Great video. Have watched many of your videos always informative I worked for a John Deer dealerships for 22 years and they never would of given out the information that you do to inform customers the only thing that they were interested in is the dollars that they can pull out of the pocket of the next victim
Hey Neil Great video! That upper gasket you're trying to explain is called and Anti-Drain Back Valve. It keeps the oil from running out of the filter to reduce dry starts. We had problems with this in the automotive industry with engine clatter on startup. The anti drain back was added to prevent this issue. It was good that you pointed out the material difference between all these filter. Buying cheap filters is never cheap.
Excellent, eye-opening video. Thanks. I had always assumed that the size of the can pretty much corresponded to the size of the filter element inside. Putting the undersized elements inside a standard can is, at the very least, ethically bankrupt and, IMO, actually borders on fraud.
I disagree. Filter can sizes have a lot to do with the volumetric amount of oil it holds as well as the flow spec by the engine application, physical dimension of the space it lives in. This filter size is extremely common on Japanese cars engines etc. And if the filter is sufficient for the application other than Kubota then Kubota should design their own filter. Another strange arguement but possibly valid that I have not researched is that space in the bottom of the can allows room for sedimentation which only can occur if you reduce agitation. In water separation if the element touches the water it will wick up into the element.
Wow, many many more Kubota owners need to see this video. Quite informative and enlightening. As a corollary video, I would like to see a comparison of transmission fluids. UDT 2. compared to the many non OEM fluids available. Thanks very much. Messick’s. Your a real asset to the Kubota family.
I have bought from your dealership before, AND I watch Wess Pandy's You Tube channel, where he speaks highly of you guys. Good video! Thanks, Central Indiana, USA
I am not a Messick's Customer. Do not even live near one! However, I do have a mechanical background and have worked as a truck/equipment technician. Three things: One: Fleetguard filters are awesome! Two: Run OEM filters! These filters meet or exceed the design requirements of the equipment for which you require filters. Three: If you cannot run or do not have access to OEM filters (why would you not with the internet?), then run a filter such as Fleetguard or another extremely comparable brand. Running aftermarket filters is an evolving risk to failure, extensive damage and VERY expensive equipment repair or replacement! "It's Cheaper to Keep'R! (with the good stuff, of course!)
I think given the chance, and if our machines were equipped with sturdy metal spin-on filter canisters for both oil and fuel, we would chose the more substantial filter insert every time. Good and informative video, as per usual from Neil!
Microns don't mean squat if the filter has a poor beta rating. You guys need to test the engine oil by sending it to a lab and you will find out which filter is best. Run a back to back test with the NAPA platinum and OEM
I used to own a quick oil change shop. We sent oil samples to the lab to check wear. That is the only way you will know if one filter is better than another, also all oils are not the same. Compare apples to apples. You are absolutely correct.
This was nothing less than shocking to me. Thanks so much for going to that effort to put out a great vid that’s also very well presented. No fluff just facts!
Hey Neil, I remembered watching this video when it first came out and gave you a shout out in my latest video while changing the oil on my bx2370 and referred to this video you made. Left a link in my video description. Great video indeed!
I have seen so many filters unprotected, in dusty boxes, having sat for years... I know it's a brand new filter but no, I will never use it, in the trash it goes, not worth the wear to the motor.
Considering the price and that you know for sure the Kubota dealer will have it in stock, the Kubota filter is without doubt the way to go. If, however, you need a filter and there is not a Kubota dealer around any of these filters will work fine. The important thing is DO THE MAINTENANCE and dont put it off. I do not have that many hours on a tractor, but have several decades on automobiles and as an average working stiff would use the cheap oils, filters, etc. along as the parts were the correct spec or grade. Never had a maintenance related problem. Maintenance schedules exist for a reason, and if you go by the schedule for extreme use, there is not a lot that can go wrong. I plan on using Kubota filters, because of the ease of ordering "kits" online, and since I am older I have the money to do so.
Question for Messick's Equipment. From what I can tell off of your website, you list three oil filters with the same M20-1.50 thread specification as the part number specified in the video. These part numbers are: 1.) The Kubota HH150-32430, 2.) the Kubota HH-150-32094, and 3.) the Kubota HH160-32093 (arranged from smallest to largest). Would it be acceptable to run the larger HH160-32093 filter on a system that specified one of the smaller HH150 filters? Thank you for your time.
we generally would not recommend deviating from the part recommended for your model. The threading maybe the same, but we don't know if there is a difference in flow rate, filter material, etc.
Thanks for this video. I will be using Kubota filters from now on. My 2013, Kubota B-2920, has very low hours so I haven't had to change my filters very often. My tractor has less than 400 hours. Central Indiana, USA
I usually buy all my maintenance supplies from where I bought my tractor. My thought is the oil & filter I use in my truck is fine for my truck, and I put some quality stuff in my truck, but I wouldn't use it in my tractor. Kubota chose the oil & filter they use for a reason, and the price they ask isn't outrageous. I bought my oil change for my tractor last year 7.5 quarts of oil and a filter was less than $60. Not exactly breaking the bank if you bought and are paying off $20,000 worth of equipment. I just think the piece of mind of using the certified oil and filters is worth the extra money you spend.
I only used a "non-Kubota" filter once on my 6040 and didn't have an issue. The only reason I didn't use a Kubota filter this particular time was because I bought every filter for the machine and somehow ended up with 2 fuel filters and 0 oil filters and of course it was a Saturday afternoon after the dealership closed when I discovered what had happened. Now that I've got my new M5-111 I intend to keep it all Kubota even the motor oil. BTW who acutually makes Kubota motor oil?
@@BWIENS789 Valvoline oil is the base oil but then is shipped to either the plant in Indiana or Michigan for them to put their own additives in it. Yes Valvoline oil is good and will work. But if one cant afford the right oil and filters then they really can't afford to have the machine
I have been using the absolute largest (external dimension) filters that will fit my tractors. On my Kubota MX4800, instead of the Kubota HH164-32430 I’ll use a Wix 51515 at possibly twice the volume. I hadn’t realized that the none OEM filters use cut down elements inside their filters, but I have to believe the longer physical filters have longer elements. An additional advantage of using the larger Wix filter is that I can use the same filter on my Massey 180, and my Kubota L345. The filters are located on the side of the engine, so seem well protected from damage. If you can find fault with my logic, I would appreciate knowing your reasoning. Edit: The OEM Kubota filter measures almost 3” long, the Wix filter is almost 5” long. The element inside the Wix filter is almost 4” long, longer than the entire Kubota canister. Admittedly the 3” long Kubota filter weighs more than the 5” long Wix filter. Without pulling the Kubota canister apart, it is believable that the filter element is only 2” long, 1/2 the length of the Wix filter. The larger filters match up, spin on, don’t leak, so why not use them? Further edit: I imagine the bypass rating matters. I could not find it for Kubota, but using an oil filter cross reference chart for the OEM Kubota filter, I get 3 Wix suggested alternatives: One with a bypass rating of 8-11, one of 11, and one of 16. The oversized Wix filter that I am using has a bypass rating of 8-11.
This was an amazing video. Incredibly informative and eye opening. I get Napa filters at cost through my work and was just about to get them for my upcoming service. Thank you, keep up the great work.
Compare Baldwin filter Baldwin also makes extended length filters more filter material on them I run Baldwin on everything from the pickup to the lawn mower and sub compact tractor all the way up to the 620 quad for both trans and engine filter
I used a Wix hydraulic filter on my Kubota tractor and while running a PTO mounted rear snow blower I saw a large amount of fluid on the snow. I shut down the tractor immediately and discovered the Wix hydraulic filter was loose and the gasket was loose from the fitting on the filter. I had installed the filter in the summer and now in the winter the gasket seems to have shrunk resulting in the filter leaking. Fortunately no damage to transmission etc. I removed the Wix garbage filter and I threw away every Wix filter I had in stock. I am convinced that Kubota OEM is the best fit and best filter. I use Kubota on my Kubota and I use Toyota on my Toyota vehicles. This Wix garbage hydraulic filter failure could have cost me thousands of dollars in repairs. The cost is of OEM is very similar and the fit and quality is optimal. I am 65 years old and I finally learned my lesson. OEM all the time.
The Kubota outer air filter for my B7500 is $37. The guy at the parts counter was shocked when he looked it up. He felt so bad he gave me a 15% discount. I find the price of the oil filters to be reasonable but don't understand why the air filter is so expensive. I would have expected it to be, for what it is, more in the low $20 range.
As usual, you give accurate info. You could have included Fram filters, which I believe are the absolutely worst ones you can buy. But they sell a lot because of name familiarity.
wile interesting you did not address the micron filtration differences of the filters, and thats also what they are all about, larger pleated area is not the big issue. (ase master tech)
Kubota filters are a cellulose material which are prone to failure, as the cellulose is vegetable paper. Moisture will kill a paper filter. The NAPA Platinum is a Microglass filter which is the best of the best!!! Look up Beta ratings and you will see what efficiency looks like. Paper sucks and Microglass is the best.
Microglass has limitations as well though, particularly in fuel filter applications. The latest filter media technology out there is synthetic nanofiber media made with plastic polymer materials.
Honda tried to blame a oil filter for a o2 sensor failing. I dont know how a sensor will fail with an oil filter. Some companys will try to weasle out of anything
I often find that the cross references are also not always the best options. Often their is a larger filter with the same threads and gasket od. It takes the consumer to do their homework.
Our philosophy is that paying $4 or more for a filter that can increase the protection for a $10k engine adds to our bottom line in both equipment expense as well as staff productivity in the field. There are other ways to reduce operating costs.
Got my Kubota Z122E with 200hrs serviced from local dealer with Briggs & Stratton pn: 695396, a short yellow oil filter 2.4 in. tall. Getting mower ready for fist season cut and even though it had only been 10hrs since last oil change, decided to start fresh. Saw your video and went to Napa with B&S filter on hand, they cross referenced it to another short filter, asked if they had larger capacity and for 3/4-16 thread (3/4 stamped next to threads) got their Platinum pn: 41348 on sale for $4.99, filter height is about 3.4 in. and its as tall as Kubota filter. Its just so convenient to purchase from Napa. Have placed order from Messick's before and you guys are just amazing, mower was missing some labels and you had them all--great online source as well--appreciate your videos! ps: changed fuel filter as well, Napa pn: 3001
I would like to see a filter comparison with Fleetguard anVs Kubota filters. I use Fleetguard in my cummins Dodge truck and it now has 320,000 miles. Just curious!
thanks for video !! just bought a 2018 rtv-x900 and am coming up on 50 hours ..I was looking for a parts go to source and messick fills the bill .. I am in rural arizona and the local dealer does not ship and is 100 miles away.. good prices ...
Having worked for a manufacturer, we do not give out data on our filters to anyone, so the only ones who know the real capability are the ones we have make them for us and ourselves. Filtering media is very important. Even if they were the same size the media may not filter as well. Also it looked like the NAPA filters did not have as many pleats as the Kubota filter - and pleats add area. Lower media height, fewer pleats, and who knows what media filtering capability - recipe for disaster.
Is the 1365 the recommended filter for BX's? I thought it was the 1064. I use the Wix(Napa) 51064 about half the time and it is nearly the same size as the Kubota filter - I have cut them open and the Wix is slightly smaller, but comparable. The 1365 is a smaller filter and no surprise it is way smaller inside.
What is the micron filtering size of each filter? Just because the element is is taller doesn't mean it filters more particulates out. It will flow more but not necessarily filter more containments
Is there a difference between Stanadyne filters like the Fieldmaster 100 series and the OEM filters as Stanadyne rep said some years ago that the only difference was the part number and colour but the price difference seems huge £11 for one Stanadyne £38 for OEM £8 for the primary from Stanadyne £28 for the OEM. In this case it was Cat filters for a Cat/Perkins engine
I use nothing but OEM parts and supplies on my Kubota. It's just not worth taking chances with a fine machine over a couple dollars saved on junk parts. But you can use Callahan Filters made by Big Tom Callahan.
you should only run oem oil filters and air filters. some makers have special valves that keep the proper oil pressure. I use a aftermarket on my foreign and the engine started knocking.
It is impossible to judge the filter surface area without removing the material and measuring its area. The NAPA pleats are fewer and shorter in one dimension, but appear much deeper. Love Messick's videos but all of the points made here are likely irrelevant, excepting backflow prevention, if oil is changed at proper intervals. I would rather know which element passes largest particulates, so to avoid it. Capturing particulates is the complete and only purpose of a filter.
Agree 100% I had a Nissan Altima where we changed religiously at Firestone since new car was new. That cars engine was filled with sludge at 65k miles. Nissan Dealer told me engine burned up $5k for rebuilt motor.. I took it to another mechanic he had it running in an hr. Sludge at the oil pump caused it. Anyway point of all that I go with original al OEM in all vehicles now. I go to the dealer for oil changes and filters. They are Specifically engineered for each vehicle , and virtually no price difference.
I'm going to guess that not every size of wix filter is like this. There's been tons of filters that have been cut up from WIX and none have seemed to be this small in comparison to their competitors. Would be good to document which wix filters are undersized for their case though if this is more common.
I've had good results with the name brand Wix stuff, the private label stuff (Napa, et al) is a dice roll as the manufacturer is building to a price point prescribed by the brand owner (in this case Napa).
You don’t always get what you pay for, but you can bet on not getting anything you didn’t pay for! Cheap isn’t always worse, though it probably will be, but it’ll almost never be better.
The only problem with your comparison is that in each of the Napa filters you showed are the low capacity version of those filters for that particular application ,, in each of those there is a High capacity version for the same application which has equal to or more filter material than the Kubota filter... so you are doing a unfair comparison of filters,, not knowing if it was intentional or not ,,next time ask the sales person so that they can show you and pick the filter that is equal in size ( because those are not) and get both versions ,,Napa filters are made by WIX and are one of the highest quality filters made in the world and make Caterpillar filters , and you cant get anymore industrial use than that... not saying that the kubota filters are not a good filter but they are not any better in quality than that of a equivalent WIX / NAPA filter..
The warranty thing is they cannot *automatically* void warranties for using non-oem parts. If they void a warranty for using an aftermarket part, they must prove that this aftermarket part the cause for the malfunction. Also,
How about this compare brand name, Fram, Purolator , Wix, instead of a store brand produce by another company to the stores specs. Also who makes the Kubota filter?
The one problem I really have it is outsourcing, I hate seeing distributed by. I would also would like to know who made the product. I really bit me with my 1988 Chevy truck where they outsourced The front end parts. 10,000 all new ball joints and idler arm., 10,000 later the same thing this time instead of using GM parts they used MOOG they lasted. Most of the filters oil and air are outsourced so I guess it's kind of a crap game, but you don't if you lose until you have a failure.
Hi Neil, Great video, Sadly our Kubota Filters in Australia is 3-4 time the cost of your filters(and other parts). That is why we have to use Third Party Filters, Sometime 10x times more expensive then Kubota OEM. Pity you don't send them to Australia, It would save us farmers a lot of money and headache Could you do one on Kubota Oil and Third Party Compatible oil?
Lubricating oils are a very complex chemistry and lots of trade secrets on the mix of base oil with special additives. The best thing Messick Farm Equipment can do is explain the legal significance (in the USA) of when a non-factory oil claims to "meet" or "exceed" factory specs, yet never includes that factory spec on their container label. Also most warranty claims require lab testing of the lubricant oil in question, to prove if it was in fact an oil that meets all the factory specs.
Some oil filters, especially in the F250 trucks, the napa filters on the diesel trucks can be shorter then factory, and not close off the anti-drainback valve leaving hard starts in the hpop.
@@MessicksEquip which makes better sense and kinda apples to oranges vs wix and the others. They OE hydro filters come with the magnets as well that others don’t provide (or fit) Great video, thanks
OEM DOES make a difference!! Learned first hand using NAPA Gold hydraulic filters on my Kubota BX 25 while operating in the winter and snow blowing. Blew out two filters and gallons of hydraulic fluid. First time I thought was a fluke second time shame on me. Never had the problem again using Kubota parts and will not risk it again with any replacement parts. They couldn't stand up to the pressure and the clean up was a nightmare.
+murph372 it varies by part number and can change. I've never heard of an actual supplier mentioned before, I know fleetguard does some stuff for them.
Curious how it failed? seems to be a step backwards isn't it? If a Kubota filter failure damaged the engine you have a very black and white claim. However if a Napa or Fram fails you have to somehow convince them it was their filter that caused the problem.
Messick Farm Equipment the threads were not plum to the base plate. So the gasket on the base plate could not seal, thus oil was spraying all over. Initially I thought I cross threaded it but that was not the case after I inspected the filter.
I loss confidence with Kubota’s oil filters. I rather use Kubota’s filters but now I’m afraid too. No damage, I always inspect for leaking oil no matter what equipment it is. Tractor or automobile.
In my 40+ years of changing my own oil, the only oil filter failure I've ever had was from a Fram. Fired it up to check for leaks and watched a couple quarts of oil pour all over the driveway. Not cross threaded - just a bad filter from the factory. It can happen with any company but after looking into the construction of Fram filters, I never used them again. Grew up in a time where Fram was a quality product - sort of like Sears Craftsman. Times have changed.
Some good, some not so good. Many people aren't aware that the size of the can doesn't necessarily correspond to the size of the filtering material inside. As to the filtering media, the NAPA uses a marketing principle called good, better, best, which is self explanatory. The NAPA Silver is comparable to most other filters, the Gold goes to a silicone anti drain back and a somewhat better filtering media. The NAPA Platinum uses a synthetic filtering media which far exceeds the quality of filtering media in the OEM filter. Your OEM filter is comparable or possibly better than the Silver and Gold but not in the same league with the Platinum. You mentioned you felt the OEM filter had a thicker can, but you didn't measure it, the video was taken in a shop, surely you had easy access to a pair of calipers to detail the difference, instead of just a maybe, or possibly the difference wasn't as much as you wanted people to think it was. You do explain that they can't force the consumer to use the OEM filter, but then tell a story about people causing problems with their fuel rails by using the wrong fuel filter, which is misleading since we are talking about oil filters in this video. In this particular case your oil filter price is reasonable, while on some other brands of equipment the OEM oil filters are grossly overpriced.
OP did measure the can gauge thickness, I believe the Kubota OEM was .54 mm while the NAPA was .37, your information about filter media is mostly correct, however pleat count is absolutely relevant, though you don't mention it. The length of the filter media is SIGNIFICANT with the NAPA cut corners however and certainly does not meet the OEM for fit/finish & performance.
Retired auto mechanics teacher here. This video has sold me on Kubota filters.
almost reminded me of a 'projectfarm' video; great presentation, and demonstration!
Great video. Have watched many of your videos always informative I worked for a John Deer dealerships for 22 years and they never would of given out the information that you do to inform customers the only thing that they were interested in is the dollars that they can pull out of the pocket of the next victim
EXACTLY
It's ALL about destroying the customer
Hey Neil
Great video! That upper gasket you're trying to explain is called and Anti-Drain Back Valve.
It keeps the oil from running out of the filter to reduce dry starts. We had problems
with this in the automotive industry with engine clatter on startup. The anti drain back
was added to prevent this issue. It was good that you pointed out the material difference between all these filter. Buying cheap filters is never cheap.
Excellent, eye-opening video. Thanks. I had always assumed that the size of the can pretty much corresponded to the size of the filter element inside. Putting the undersized elements inside a standard can is, at the very least, ethically bankrupt and, IMO, actually borders on fraud.
I disagree. Filter can sizes have a lot to do with the volumetric amount of oil it holds as well as the flow spec by the engine application, physical dimension of the space it lives in.
This filter size is extremely common on Japanese cars engines etc. And if the filter is sufficient for the application other than Kubota then Kubota should design their own filter.
Another strange arguement but possibly valid that I have not researched is that space in the bottom of the can allows room for sedimentation which only can occur if you reduce agitation. In water separation if the element touches the water it will wick up into the element.
Worthless Fram Ph8a bypass valve opened up destroyed a perfect engine allowed dirt onto Conrod oil hole.
An eye-opening examination. Well done. Keep up the excellent work. I really wish your dealership was in my state!
I don't even have a tractor yet and feel the same!
Wow, many many more Kubota owners need to see this video. Quite informative and enlightening.
As a corollary video, I would like to see a comparison of transmission fluids. UDT 2. compared to the many non OEM fluids available. Thanks very much. Messick’s. Your a real asset to the Kubota family.
Wow thanks I would have never thought that there was that big of a difference, THANKS
I have bought from your dealership before, AND I watch Wess Pandy's You Tube channel, where he speaks highly of you guys. Good video! Thanks, Central Indiana, USA
Wes Pandy uses napa/wix gold
I am not a Messick's Customer. Do not even live near one! However, I do have a mechanical background and have worked as a truck/equipment technician. Three things: One: Fleetguard filters are awesome! Two: Run OEM filters! These filters meet or exceed the design requirements of the equipment for which you require filters. Three: If you cannot run or do not have access to OEM filters (why would you not with the internet?), then run a filter such as Fleetguard or another extremely comparable brand. Running aftermarket filters is an evolving risk to failure, extensive damage and VERY expensive equipment repair or replacement! "It's Cheaper to Keep'R! (with the good stuff, of course!)
Absolutely true, not all filters are alike. Wix may make Napa filters but they make them to Napa specifications.
I think given the chance, and if our machines were equipped with sturdy metal spin-on filter canisters for both oil and fuel, we would chose the more substantial filter insert every time. Good and informative video, as per usual from Neil!
Thanks for the great video and examination. As a new tractor owner I want the best for my equipment.
Microns don't mean squat if the filter has a poor beta rating. You guys need to test the engine oil by sending it to a lab and you will find out which filter is best. Run a back to back test with the NAPA platinum and OEM
I used to own a quick oil change shop. We sent oil samples to the lab to check wear. That is the only way you will know if one filter is better than another, also all oils are not the same. Compare apples to apples. You are absolutely correct.
As FRAM used to say, "You can pay me now or you can pay me later!" Thanks Neal!
This was nothing less than shocking to me. Thanks so much for going to that effort to put out a great vid that’s also very well presented. No fluff just facts!
Great video I do tend to run hem for all the reasons mentioned and hav never had problem with any of my machines thanks
Hey Neil, I remembered watching this video when it first came out and gave you a shout out in my latest video while changing the oil on my bx2370 and referred to this video you made. Left a link in my video description. Great video indeed!
Good video. I like that Kubota has plastic seals on all the filters to keep them clean in the box. I wish everyone did this.
I have seen so many filters unprotected, in dusty boxes, having sat for years... I know it's a brand new filter but no, I will never use it, in the trash it goes, not worth the wear to the motor.
Great video, thank you for taking the time to dissect these filters. It was a real eye opener.
Hello,
How about the filtering potential in "microns"
And the flow capacity?
Cheers from Belgium.
Considering the price and that you know for sure the Kubota dealer will have it in stock, the Kubota filter is without doubt the way to go. If, however, you need a filter and there is not a Kubota dealer around any of these filters will work fine. The important thing is DO THE MAINTENANCE and dont put it off. I do not have that many hours on a tractor, but have several decades on automobiles and as an average working stiff would use the cheap oils, filters, etc. along as the parts were the correct spec or grade. Never had a maintenance related problem. Maintenance schedules exist for a reason, and if you go by the schedule for extreme use, there is not a lot that can go wrong. I plan on using Kubota filters, because of the ease of ordering "kits" online, and since I am older I have the money to do so.
Wow, I will be doing some more research and likely changing my maintenance decisions.
Question for Messick's Equipment.
From what I can tell off of your website, you list three oil filters with the same M20-1.50 thread specification as the part number specified in the video. These part numbers are: 1.) The Kubota HH150-32430, 2.) the Kubota HH-150-32094, and 3.) the Kubota HH160-32093 (arranged from smallest to largest). Would it be acceptable to run the larger HH160-32093 filter on a system that specified one of the smaller HH150 filters?
Thank you for your time.
we generally would not recommend deviating from the part recommended for your model. The threading maybe the same, but we don't know if there is a difference in flow rate, filter material, etc.
Phenomenal analysis! I always wondered the difference. Thanks so much.
Thanks for this video. I will be using Kubota filters from now on. My 2013, Kubota B-2920, has very low hours so I haven't had to change my filters very often. My tractor has less than 400 hours. Central Indiana, USA
I usually buy all my maintenance supplies from where I bought my tractor. My thought is the oil & filter I use in my truck is fine for my truck, and I put some quality stuff in my truck, but I wouldn't use it in my tractor.
Kubota chose the oil & filter they use for a reason, and the price they ask isn't outrageous. I bought my oil change for my tractor last year 7.5 quarts of oil and a filter was less than $60. Not exactly breaking the bank if you bought and are paying off $20,000 worth of equipment. I just think the piece of mind of using the certified oil and filters is worth the extra money you spend.
Good video. I will say though, I worked in the field for many years for many years and the most popular after market filter is Baldwin.
I only used a "non-Kubota" filter once on my 6040 and didn't have an issue. The only reason I didn't use a Kubota filter this particular time was because I bought every filter for the machine and somehow ended up with 2 fuel filters and 0 oil filters and of course it was a Saturday afternoon after the dealership closed when I discovered what had happened. Now that I've got my new M5-111 I intend to keep it all Kubota even the motor oil. BTW who acutually makes Kubota motor oil?
Valvoline made to Kubota specifications
@@BWIENS789 Valvoline oil is the base oil but then is shipped to either the plant in Indiana or Michigan for them to put their own additives in it. Yes Valvoline oil is good and will work. But if one cant afford the right oil and filters then they really can't afford to have the machine
I have been using the absolute largest (external dimension) filters that will fit my tractors. On my Kubota MX4800, instead of the Kubota HH164-32430 I’ll use a Wix 51515 at possibly twice the volume. I hadn’t realized that the none OEM filters use cut down elements inside their filters, but I have to believe the longer physical filters have longer elements. An additional advantage of using the larger Wix filter is that I can use the same filter on my Massey 180, and my Kubota L345. The filters are located on the side of the engine, so seem well protected from damage. If you can find fault with my logic, I would appreciate knowing your reasoning.
Edit: The OEM Kubota filter measures almost 3” long, the Wix filter is almost 5” long. The element inside the Wix filter is almost 4” long, longer than the entire Kubota canister. Admittedly the 3” long Kubota filter weighs more than the 5” long Wix filter. Without pulling the Kubota canister apart, it is believable that the filter element is only 2” long, 1/2 the length of the Wix filter. The larger filters match up, spin on, don’t leak, so why not use them?
Further edit: I imagine the bypass rating matters. I could not find it for Kubota, but using an oil filter cross reference chart for the OEM Kubota filter, I get 3 Wix suggested alternatives: One with a bypass rating of 8-11, one of 11, and one of 16. The oversized Wix filter that I am using has a bypass rating of 8-11.
FYI.. Wix makes Napa’s Gold line filters..they have for many years..
This was an amazing video. Incredibly informative and eye opening. I get Napa filters at cost through my work and was just about to get them for my upcoming service. Thank you, keep up the great work.
geez, a clear, uncomplicated and Honest ... Honest presentation. A new phase of capitalism with a conscientious frame. thank you!
Compare Baldwin filter Baldwin also makes extended length filters more filter material on them I run Baldwin on everything from the pickup to the lawn mower and sub compact tractor all the way up to the 620 quad for both trans and engine filter
Good for you, only factory filters for me.
Just bought a BX 2380 thanks for the info.
I used a Wix hydraulic filter on my Kubota tractor and while running a PTO mounted rear snow blower I saw a large amount of fluid on the snow. I shut down the tractor immediately and discovered the Wix hydraulic filter was loose and the gasket was loose from the fitting on the filter. I had installed the filter in the summer and now in the winter the gasket seems to have shrunk resulting in the filter leaking. Fortunately no damage to transmission etc. I removed the Wix garbage filter and I threw away every Wix filter I had in stock. I am convinced that Kubota OEM is the best fit and best filter. I use Kubota on my Kubota and I use Toyota on my Toyota vehicles. This Wix garbage hydraulic filter failure could have cost me thousands of dollars in repairs. The cost is of OEM is very similar and the fit and quality is optimal. I am 65 years old and I finally learned my lesson. OEM all the time.
The Kubota outer air filter for my B7500 is $37. The guy at the parts counter was shocked when he looked it up. He felt so bad he gave me a 15% discount. I find the price of the oil filters to be reasonable but don't understand why the air filter is so expensive. I would have expected it to be, for what it is, more in the low $20 range.
$20 from us.
www.messicks.com/part/6c060-99410/outer-filter
So True, I've purchased OEM in Automotive usually cheaper than aftermarket and found similar. Crazy world.
As usual, you give accurate info.
You could have included Fram filters, which I believe are the absolutely worst ones you can buy. But they sell a lot because of name familiarity.
Robert Fakler yup there base filters are junk. The synthetic is ok
wile interesting you did not address the micron filtration differences of the filters, and thats also what they are all about, larger pleated area is not the big issue. (ase master tech)
no arguments here. The problem is that information is really hard to come by.
The Microns are usually listed on the packaging.
Usually, tighter pleating has a better filtration rating like k&n
Kubota filters are a cellulose material which are prone to failure, as the cellulose is vegetable paper. Moisture will kill a paper filter. The NAPA Platinum is a Microglass filter which is the best of the best!!! Look up Beta ratings and you will see what efficiency looks like. Paper sucks and Microglass is the best.
If you have water in your oil, you're in some serious trouble.
There’s moisture inside of your engine. It comes in the form of condensate.
What’s the price difference
Microglass has limitations as well though, particularly in fuel filter applications. The latest filter media technology out there is synthetic nanofiber media made with plastic polymer materials.
You my friend are correct
Honda tried to blame a oil filter for a o2 sensor failing. I dont know how a sensor will fail with an oil filter. Some companys will try to weasle out of anything
I've seen a lot of RUclips videos of cutting open a Napa filter and I've never seen one as small as the one you're showing on this video
I often find that the cross references are also not always the best options. Often their is a larger filter with the same threads and gasket od. It takes the consumer to do their homework.
Our philosophy is that paying $4 or more for a filter that can increase the protection for a $10k engine adds to our bottom line in both equipment expense as well as staff productivity in the field.
There are other ways to reduce operating costs.
Got my Kubota Z122E with 200hrs serviced from local dealer with Briggs & Stratton pn: 695396, a short yellow oil filter 2.4 in. tall. Getting mower ready for fist season cut and even though it had only been 10hrs since last oil change, decided to start fresh. Saw your video and went to Napa with B&S filter on hand, they cross referenced it to another short filter, asked if they had larger capacity and for 3/4-16 thread (3/4 stamped next to threads) got their Platinum pn: 41348 on sale for $4.99, filter height is about 3.4 in. and its as tall as Kubota filter. Its just so convenient to purchase from Napa. Have placed order from Messick's before and you guys are just amazing, mower was missing some labels and you had them all--great online source as well--appreciate your videos!
ps: changed fuel filter as well, Napa pn: 3001
I would like to see a filter comparison with Fleetguard anVs Kubota filters. I use Fleetguard in my cummins Dodge truck and it now has 320,000 miles. Just curious!
There's a good chance Cummins is making those filters for Kubota!
Cummins does many in this industry, we sell fleetguard also. Not these though.
@@MessicksEquip Donaldson keeps my Cummins clacking !
Project Farm RUclips Channel
thanks for video !! just bought a 2018 rtv-x900 and am coming up on 50 hours ..I was looking for a parts go to source and messick fills the bill .. I am in rural arizona and the local dealer does not ship and is 100 miles away.. good prices ...
Great video. I think the biggest reason you see none OE filters is they can get it local.
We always use Kubota filters on our B2650. Saving a coupe bucks just is not worth the risk.
Terry
Having worked for a manufacturer, we do not give out data on our filters to anyone, so the only ones who know the real capability are the ones we have make them for us and ourselves. Filtering media is very important. Even if they were the same size the media may not filter as well. Also it looked like the NAPA filters did not have as many pleats as the Kubota filter - and pleats add area. Lower media height, fewer pleats, and who knows what media filtering capability - recipe for disaster.
I have also worked for a filter manufacturer and agree with your points 100% - spot on!
Neil. we need you here in Ontario! 😉
No you need a mechanic that knows what he is doing
Is the 1365 the recommended filter for BX's? I thought it was the 1064. I use the Wix(Napa) 51064 about half the time and it is nearly the same size as the Kubota filter - I have cut them open and the Wix is slightly smaller, but comparable. The 1365 is a smaller filter and no surprise it is way smaller inside.
+lindnova no idea. I punched the part number into the Napa website and this is the cross reference it gave me.
I guess that's another reason to go use Kubota filters since the aftermarket can't give correct equivalent cross references.
W I X ( Napa Gold ) the most superior filtration parts PERIOD.
No junk bypass valves etc etc etc etc.
However, this lesson learned
What is the micron filtering size of each filter? Just because the element is is taller doesn't mean it filters more particulates out. It will flow more but not necessarily filter more containments
Is there a difference between Stanadyne filters like the Fieldmaster 100 series and the OEM filters as Stanadyne rep said some years ago that the only difference was the part number and colour but the price difference seems huge £11 for one Stanadyne £38 for OEM £8 for the primary from Stanadyne £28 for the OEM. In this case it was Cat filters for a Cat/Perkins engine
I use nothing but OEM parts and supplies on my Kubota. It's just not worth taking chances with a fine machine over a couple dollars saved on junk parts.
But you can use Callahan Filters made by Big Tom Callahan.
I always buy the next larger filter and check the micron rating of the OEM and go a few points lower
Great video, OEM all the way.
ok ase master tech and shop owner, 1st I am not an engineer I change parts and when it comes to filters more volume of filtration is always better
you should only run oem oil filters and air filters. some makers have special valves that keep the proper oil pressure. I use a aftermarket on my foreign and the engine started knocking.
How do you feel about Baldwin vs oe
It is impossible to judge the filter surface area without removing the material and measuring its area. The NAPA pleats are fewer and shorter in one dimension, but appear much deeper. Love Messick's videos but all of the points made here are likely irrelevant, excepting backflow prevention, if oil is changed at proper intervals. I would rather know which element passes largest particulates, so to avoid it. Capturing particulates is the complete and only purpose of a filter.
And fleetguard only for me. Ive seen the design of cheaper filters
Why not cut open a Donaldson filter along with a Kubota one? These are really interesting....
...or a Hastings....since its the same as the Kubota one.
Agree 100% I had a Nissan Altima where we changed religiously at Firestone since new car was new. That cars engine was filled with sludge at 65k miles. Nissan Dealer told me engine burned up $5k for rebuilt motor.. I took it to another mechanic he had it running in an hr. Sludge at the oil pump caused it. Anyway point of all that I go with original al OEM in all vehicles now. I go to the dealer for oil changes and filters. They are Specifically engineered for each vehicle , and virtually no price difference.
Knowing how Firestone operates, they probably weren't even changing your oil when they charged you.
You sold me on the Kubota filters hands down, you have to protect your investment.
magnisen moss act allows you to use other filters
I'm going to guess that not every size of wix filter is like this. There's been tons of filters that have been cut up from WIX and none have seemed to be this small in comparison to their competitors.
Would be good to document which wix filters are undersized for their case though if this is more common.
I've had good results with the name brand Wix stuff, the private label stuff (Napa, et al) is a dice roll as the manufacturer is building to a price point prescribed by the brand owner (in this case Napa).
You don’t always get what you pay for, but you can bet on not getting anything you didn’t pay for!
Cheap isn’t always worse, though it probably will be, but it’ll almost never be better.
The only problem with your comparison is that in each of the Napa filters you showed are the low capacity version of those filters for that particular application ,, in each of those there is a High capacity version for the same application which has equal to or more filter material than the Kubota filter... so you are doing a unfair comparison of filters,, not knowing if it was intentional or not ,,next time ask the sales person so that they can show you and pick the filter that is equal in size ( because those are not) and get both versions ,,Napa filters are made by WIX and are one of the highest quality filters made in the world and make Caterpillar filters , and you cant get anymore industrial use than that... not saying that the kubota filters are not a good filter but they are not any better in quality than that of a equivalent WIX / NAPA filter..
is there a oil that is subatute to the OEM for the trans oil
Like the side by side comparison. Would be nice to see the prices listed for each.
He showed prices in the beginning
Great advice Neil
The warranty thing is they cannot *automatically* void warranties for using non-oem parts. If they void a warranty for using an aftermarket part, they must prove that this aftermarket part the cause for the malfunction.
Also,
How about this compare brand name, Fram, Purolator , Wix, instead of a store brand produce by another company to the stores specs. Also who makes the Kubota filter?
Charles Kettering napa brand filters are made by wix
The one problem I really have it is outsourcing, I hate seeing distributed by. I would also would like to know who made the product. I really bit me with my 1988 Chevy truck where they outsourced The front end parts. 10,000 all new ball joints and idler arm., 10,000 later the same thing this time instead of using GM parts they used MOOG they lasted.
Most of the filters oil and air are outsourced so I guess it's kind of a crap game, but you don't if you lose until you have a failure.
Do they make different sizes or do all units have the same size filter
Great video. Very informative. Thanks
Are you comparing to a Kubota HH150-32094?
ABSOLUTELY x9 ';-) OEM/Genuine Filters always better as a 40 year+ GM/Honda Parts Manager, Thanks!
good stuff brother! I always use kubota products not worth the risk to me.
Hi Neil,
Great video, Sadly our Kubota Filters in Australia is 3-4 time the cost of your filters(and other parts). That is why we have to use Third Party Filters, Sometime 10x times more expensive then Kubota OEM. Pity you don't send them to Australia, It would save us farmers a lot of money and headache
Could you do one on Kubota Oil and Third Party Compatible oil?
+Han Shiong Siah oil is on my list. Harder to look at hard differences.
Lubricating oils are a very complex chemistry and lots of trade secrets on the mix of base oil with special additives. The best thing Messick Farm Equipment can do is explain the legal significance (in the USA) of when a non-factory oil claims to "meet" or "exceed" factory specs, yet never includes that factory spec on their container label. Also most warranty claims require lab testing of the lubricant oil in question, to prove if it was in fact an oil that meets all the factory specs.
@@KCautodoctor Very interesting 🤔 Can you elaborate?
Some oil filters, especially in the F250 trucks, the napa filters on the diesel trucks can be shorter then factory, and not close off the anti-drainback valve leaving hard starts in the hpop.
What about Fram?
Fram is absolute junk.
I assume you got a web site to order parts from?
+Farmall Fanatic www.messicks.com
Messick Farm Equipment ok thanks, ill give you my business. Filters are a big deal, along with the fluid you add. Go cheap on either and you will pay!
Great advice!
I'm going to cut open an extra K&N oil filter I have for a Ford to see if it is worth the money.
K&N's are made in the same facility as Mobil1 and Royal Purple and some others I believe.
i have been ordering parts from Messicks for years did you change your shipping charge because it has always been 10 dollars minimum.
+Trevor Melton it depends on weight and size of what your ordering. Our shipping algorithm is pretty complex.
Who makes kubota filters?
The only ones that you can track back to an actual filter company would be Cummins\FleetGuard.
@@MessicksEquip which makes better sense and kinda apples to oranges vs wix and the others.
They OE hydro filters come with the magnets as well that others don’t provide (or fit)
Great video, thanks
Love watching your videos.Have a L3901..
Thanks 👍
also I paid more for a aftermarket paper air filter , than a oem foam like material that was exactly cheaper.
Very good info. I will be ordering the Kubota filter for sure. Thanks for the information.
How many miles do you change the oil on a tractor
Hours, not miles. Check the owner's manual, they are not consistent.
The Kubota filter is it made by Donaldson?
Not totally sure in this case, some are. They also get stuff from FleetGuard.
OEM DOES make a difference!! Learned first hand using NAPA Gold hydraulic filters on my Kubota BX 25 while operating in the winter and snow blowing. Blew out two filters and gallons of hydraulic fluid. First time I thought was a fluke second time shame on me. Never had the problem again using Kubota parts and will not risk it again with any replacement parts. They couldn't stand up to the pressure and the clean up was a nightmare.
Who makes Kubota filters?
+murph372 it varies by part number and can change. I've never heard of an actual supplier mentioned before, I know fleetguard does some stuff for them.
Napa!
Nice video Neil…. Ty
I had a Kubota BX oil filter fail on me. I lost a quart or two before I turned off the tractor. Since then I’ve been using either Napa or Fram Ultra.
Curious how it failed?
seems to be a step backwards isn't it? If a Kubota filter failure damaged the engine you have a very black and white claim. However if a Napa or Fram fails you have to somehow convince them it was their filter that caused the problem.
Messick Farm Equipment the threads were not plum to the base plate. So the gasket on the base plate could not seal, thus oil was spraying all over. Initially I thought I cross threaded it but that was not the case after I inspected the filter.
I loss confidence with Kubota’s oil filters. I rather use Kubota’s filters but now I’m afraid too. No damage, I always inspect for leaking oil no matter what equipment it is. Tractor or automobile.
Well that's the part he left out, Bet that Wix Filter has a assembled in USA on it while Kubota uses "Made In China" junk
In my 40+ years of changing my own oil, the only oil filter failure I've ever had was from a Fram. Fired it up to check for leaks and watched a couple quarts of oil pour all over the driveway. Not cross threaded - just a bad filter from the factory. It can happen with any company but after looking into the construction of Fram filters, I never used them again. Grew up in a time where Fram was a quality product - sort of like Sears Craftsman. Times have changed.
Some good, some not so good. Many people aren't aware that the size of the can doesn't necessarily correspond to the size of the filtering material inside. As to the filtering media, the NAPA uses a marketing principle called good, better, best, which is self explanatory. The NAPA Silver is comparable to most other filters, the Gold goes to a silicone anti drain back and a somewhat better filtering media. The NAPA Platinum uses a synthetic filtering media which far exceeds the quality of filtering media in the OEM filter. Your OEM filter is comparable or possibly better than the Silver and Gold but not in the same league with the Platinum. You mentioned you felt the OEM filter had a thicker can, but you didn't measure it, the video was taken in a shop, surely you had easy access to a pair of calipers to detail the difference, instead of just a maybe, or possibly the difference wasn't as much as you wanted people to think it was. You do explain that they can't force the consumer to use the OEM filter, but then tell a story about people causing problems with their fuel rails by using the wrong fuel filter, which is misleading since we are talking about oil filters in this video. In this particular case your oil filter price is reasonable, while on some other brands of equipment the OEM oil filters are grossly overpriced.
OP did measure the can gauge thickness, I believe the Kubota OEM was .54 mm while the NAPA was .37, your information about filter media is mostly correct, however pleat count is absolutely relevant, though you don't mention it. The length of the filter media is SIGNIFICANT with the NAPA cut corners however and certainly does not meet the OEM for fit/finish & performance.
Do you sell an remote for M7060? $$?
Yes, call. 8002223373
Great review.. Thanks.