It's underrated because it's genuinely funny and doesn't get the praise it deserves because people take Nostalgia Critic too seriously and can't handle when someone "disrespects" their little favorite bland album.
You won't believe it but when I tried to think of the most underrated album in the beginning og the video I could only think about decent albums that are given too much hate, "over... hated... albums" I thought to myself "most overhated albums; that would be a good next topic! With like a little wordplay in there as well! Kind of brilliant, let's suggest that in comment and..."... I had lost what Fantano was talking about at this point but after like five seconds he came into that very frase - M7nd a bit blown
On one side I'm like "How do you even know that it could be from so many other songs instead" but at the same time I feel like you just know it for sure.
So happy you finally talked about Fishmans. Their version of “In the Air” on that live album is my favorite song of all time, just absolutely astonishing
Yes! In the Air (live) is the greatest song I've ever heard also. The second half of the track that starts midway through the violin solo is absolutely cosmic, Shinji's vocals get me every time.
Audioslave's debut album is one of my favorite rock albums of all time, but grossly underappreciated. It's one of the rare examples of albums from which every track could be a hit.
I was so pumped when I first heard they were getting together cause they came from 2 Bands I adore but it sounded more of a "make money" project than anything else. Album is ok but I don't see why ppl should praise it unless by exclusively personal taste.
@@mrtesticles889 Because he only has 1 great solo album, and one great collab album. IMO Biggie has more great tracks then Mos, and Biggie died at 24. If Mos died at 24 no one would know who he is, outside of maybe Blackstar and a couple of lyricist lounge tracks. Having said that I would definitely put him over Em, and probably over 3 Stacks, because 3 Stacks doesn't have a solo album, unless you count the love below, but that isn't a rap/hip hop album, he only raps on like 3 songs from it.
Big problem with Ye is that almost immediately after it dropped he released Kids See Ghosts so a lot of they hype went that way instead (and Deservedly so)
Yeah, I was guilty of that too. Also the Pusha T one before was epic too so he kinda lost his own project in the shuffle. That who producing binge he went on was epic though. Ye sounds like a great album to me now and Daytona and Kids See Ghosts were straight up classic.
Seeing somebody with this level of influence talking about Fishmans makes me incredibly happy. Over the last year or so I've become a bit of a fanatic and nobody who I've ever discussed music with has even heard of them. They've definitely got some of the most underrated albums out there
Adam Flynn same, i actually found out about them quite a while ago but only listened to some songs but i recently decided to listen to their albums and im hooked,, i wondered if tnd did do a video about them so im happy he did talk about them, and yea they’re a pretty underrated band
Ye same, like obviously I wish he appreciated it like the rest of us who have discovered Fishmans, but at least he recognized them because yeah they deserve so much more
Oh man. Better late than never. And now you have a huuuuge amount of content to go thru. I'm actually kind of jelous. Between the 2 channels theres tons. And on one of his TND videos (the response to the Fader article) he linked a ton of unlisted videos from his long gone channel, thatistheplan. You have such a good time ahead of you. And your Spotify will grow 100000x over and you'll be a better person for it. Have a blast dude.
@@acak5449 It's so stupid how self-absorbed some people are,like this guy who thinks nobody gives a shit about the beatles just because they don't care. Dude,the world doesn't revolve around you.
Electric Light Orchestra’s Discovery was pretty much universally panned by critics at the time and I think a lot of people think it’s cheesy but I love every single track. It is also a huge influence on Daft Punk.
Atom Heart Mother definitely is the most underrated. Summer 68 and Fat old sun are classics, even if is really good. But it was the perfect middle ground between the early stuff and what Floyd did on Meddle.
If anything, Meddle is the most underrated album from their work. While Echoes is absolutely incredible and it carries the albums on its shoulders, the rest of the tracks, apart from Seamus imo, are utterly fantastic as well. Fearless is golden, A Pillow of Winds is one of the most relaxing songs ever made with a close 2nd being San Tropez later on, and the opener One of These Days is brilliant as well. Echoes obviously gets a lot of credit, which it 110% deserves, but it’s not the only exceptional track on the album.
@@Bighomie39 Alans psychedelic breakfast is my favourite pink floyd song :( You just dont understand the vibe of epic psycheldic piano music and breakfast noises :)
Part of me wants to have your centrist and reasonable take on Fishmans, and I definitely think overhyping is in itself a problem. But damn, this band is probably the only time I've ever legitimately agreed with any music circle's niche obsession. No other band gives me such a life affirming feeling.
@@rashotcake6945 For sure. In the Air is my personal favourite cut from the album, but just the scope of Long Season alone is insane. The way they reinvented it on the live album is so bloody impressive.
I know right! Even though I personally love the more reggae tinged tracks of their career, the psychedelic ones are king. Songs like Long Season, Nightcrusing, Oh Slime, 幸せ者, なんてったの, and In the Air hit me on an almost spiritual level.
I've just listened to it! I might be biased for already liking Yasiin for for work on various Gorillaz and Kanye projects, but I did really enjoy the album
Black On Both Sides is imo one of the few flawless hip hop albums. As someone who is most familiar with hip hop and not other genres, this was a gap in my 90s knowledge and holy is this thing amazing. I think I could name maybe 10-15 flawless hip hop albums and this would be one. Genius album
@@joeyterheide5426 MBDTF (I hate giving Kanye praise rn but this is a perfect album imo and one of the only ones), Atrocity Exhibition, TPAB, Madvillainy, IGOR, Yeezus, GKMC, Piñata, Aquemini, The Blueprint, Illmatic, and The Forever Story (if it ages well, so far it has). The only ones that are a 10 or near 10
thanks for introducing me to Mos Def! I used to only really listen to modern hip hop music, but you've introduced me to tons of old-school rappers, so now I listen to a mix of 80's, 90's, 00's, 10's, and 20's
Anthony, I didn't think you were going to rate my family's 2005 holiday party photo album as the most underrated album of all time. But honestly I'm flattered. You can definitely come thru this year bro, HMU if you're in the area!
If Fishmans had songs on that live album that were just straight up reggae, I’d understand finding it unimpressive. But all of the reggae influenced songs on that album have been put through a psychedelic, progressive dreamy filter and that’s what makes them stand out and interesting
@@PaulRobinsonOk Dub is rooted in reggae, and several of the tracks on the album are, by definition, reggae, or at least reggae fusion, with melodic lead bass, accented rim shot beats and one drop rhythms, and skanking rhythm guitar on the upbeats. I dont think the fact that there is a decent amount of it on the album really hurts it at all either. Fishmans, in my opinion, were the best non Jamaican reggae practitioners. They had a very idiosyncratic, experimental, and uniquely Japanese take on it.
I always thought that Neurosis as a metal band have always been underrated. I feel like their songs and albums deserve millions and millions of listeners but they don’t. Their album Through Silver in Blood is a real classic. One of the heaviest and darkest albums ever and I think, one of the best metal albums of all time. A lot of people love them, but I still think they deserve more recognition in the metal scene as they basically created post-metal single handedly
Yeeeeeee Fishmans made it to the channel. Anyway, i was like Fantano and dismissed the reggae tracks at first but the more i listened to the album (aswell as hearing their other stuff that wasn’t Long Season or Uchu Nippon Setagaya) the more the reggae or rather dub tracks started growing on me hard. There is something about the playfulness of songs like Thank You or Hikouki that just gets me going. But overall tho, i am one of those people who think 98.12.28 is the best live album of all time. Not only for it being the last performance by Fishmans but also because every song just hits a chord with you. Whether it be the dreamy tracks like Night Cruising and In the Flight or the more expansive epics like Yurameki in the Air and Long Season. This album will always hold a special place in my heart and seeing it get more recognition outside of RYM and /mu/ makes me very happy. Sorry if i was overdoing it with the gushing. I’m just so in love with this album.
Kreek Kid Productions I bought a limited pressing of the first games ost and while I enjoy it. I wish I could get my hands on silent hill 2 ost even if only for that beautiful piano (I think it’s the theme)
Joey Depp That's true, people go nuts for 'Pornography' or even 'Faith' but 'Seventeen Seconds' has a lovely, dark, homespun feel to it that really deserves more attention.
Definitely, I think cudi all around is very underrated, I don’t feel that he ever got the cred/ rep he really deserved. I also feel that Kanye could’ve been a better friend to him which I feel is also kinda why he isn’t as popular, he’s big on Spotify now because of Travis Scott which I’m not happy about but I hope it leads people to see that he really is a great artist. ( note I’m not mad that he’s big on Spotify I’m mad cause Travis Scott blew him up and travis is not good
I'm just gonna have to mention my favorite album of all time here: Honeysuckle Strange by Howlin' Maggie. It got some critical attention for a very short while after its release in 1996, and a few of the tracks got some indie and alt-rock radio play, but its themes of self-destructive behavior, industry bullshit, frustration, and mental health are well-executed and eternal. If you are reading this, there is a chance you have possibly heard either "Alcohol" or "I'm a Slut", but I'd implore anyone with even a passing interest in 90's alt-rock to give the album a full listen as it is a masterclass in cohesion of the seemingly disparate elements of grit and haunting.
Hey Anthony, just waiting to hear back from you about your request to join our D&D campaign. I think your character, Richard Strongshorts the Barbarian, would be a great addition to our party! Love to hear back from you. Thanks
Yes and no. It isn't known in the mainstream and therefore is underrated as it isn't widely known, but to the heads it is heralded as one of the greatest hip hop releases period.
Queen II is actually extremely underrated . They really dug into their heavy-ish sound . It might not be the most underrated album but it is a most definitely a masterpiece .
@@TheMACnator Side 1 has Father to Son (an epic opener) White Queen (An emotional ballad) Some Day One Day (A beautiful Brian May acoustic piece) What do you mean weak?
Indigoism- The Underachievers These guys are the most underrated duo on the face of the earth. Hard af but still kicking some positive shit. Yall sleep. This shit is a masterpiece.
Yasiin Bey aka Mo's Def definitely deserves MORE flowers while he's still with us. I do wish he'd make more hip-hop even if it was independentally. Purpose? I'd say to educate the youth. But he seems pretty far gone from music nowadays. I get it. He was never gonna play the industry game in the long run but you can do your own thing independentally and fans will always support. Another Black Star album would be insane if that ever happened.
IMO, the HIStory album by Michael Jackson is a lot better than most of the general public would have you believe. This is probably the closest the man ever came to a proper concept album and it's done expertly in my opinion. Cuts such as Stranger in Moscow, Scream, and They Don't Care About Us rank up there in terms of his most experimental songs production wise and lyric wise.
@@Hemaglox Big agree! Earth Song itself is a masterpiece, but Stranger in Moscow is an underrated gem for me. I legit discovered it via the MJ: The Experience game, and I'm glad it's in my life.
There’s a really underrated album I know about, it’s called Dark Side of the Moon by Pink Floyd. It’s super underground though, so you normies probably won’t know it
The Libertines - Up The Bracket. Easily the best indie record to come out of the UK in the last 15 years but outside of the UK it is relatively unknown
That's a weird one because it took over the UK but they were barely known elsewhere. I actually think their second album was underrated. It was so shambly and emotional, I think people found it underdone but I loved that about it. Same with first Babyshambles album.
AGREE with Chinese Democracy! I was getting into GNR during late-middle school early-high school when CD came out. I obviously expected it to be nothing like the original GNR sound, but there are some great ballads on there (Catcher In The Rye, Better, Shackler's Revenge, There was a Time). Obviously some misses and agree with some odd industrial style attempts, but it's not a "bad" album at all. Axl still sings his ass off.
Jeopardy by The Sound is a post punk masterpiece, the only reason the album and band are basically unknown by the masses is because the label never promoted their music
They're one of my most listened artists of all time. I don't think they're underrated though. They're not well known, but they get a lot of praise from those who know them.
I'm pissed that Richard Wright's album Broken China is so obscure. He was a member of Pink Floyd, the third-best-selling band of all time, for fourteen years, and then his double album collab with Sinead O"Connor is so unknown it's not even on RUclips. Fucking insanity.
Rick Wright in general is way too underrated. He doesn't get enough credit as a keyboardist and a songwriter, which I don't get because he was the backbone of PF if you ask me.
Wow, that album must incredibly obscure. I'm a huge Sinéad fan and seek out all of her collabs, and I've never heard of this album once in my life. It's not for sale on itunes and amazon has it for like $90, or $50 used. I'm glad you mentioned it, though. I'll try to hear it somehow.
Who will cut my hair when you’re gone- The Unicorns, is a gem waiting to be uncovered and glorified by anyone who has not heard it yet. Fantano has discussed it before with high praise. It’s a quirky and glorious monument.
Probably got a higher chance of getting a Classic review than favourites like Sufjan Stevens esp. with Fantano exploring relatively more obscure cult favourites outside of /mu/ cores.
@@fiftyclown Strongly implied. The Unicorns are given a 9 on Fantano's RYM account but The Postal Service's 'Give Up' is another 9 which he eventually gives a Classic review to with the description saying that it's one of the best records in the 2000s. Given how opinions on albums can change especially with Fantano, it's likely that WWCOHWWG is a solid 10. For citation purpose: ruclips.net/video/SM579Up7yC0/видео.html
As much as people loved to hate Limp Bizkit, their debut album is insane and immensely underrated. The riffs by Wes Borland, the funky basslines of a then teen Sam Rivers along with his cousin John Otto with some tight drumming. Sam & John studied jazz in college and you can really tell, the groove, tightness and allround instrumental prowess is really something most people haven't discovered since they hate the band solely because of Fred Durst and the fact that they've only heard Rollin' and Nookie.
man that album had some really solid tracks Counterfeit, the trio of Sour/Stalemate/Clunk I will admit some moments of it have not aged gracefully (need I bring up the cover of George Michael's Faith?) but it's got some highlights for sure. Nowhere near as bad as it gets a reputation for being.
Humbug by Arctic monkeys is my favourite of theirs and I think criminally underrated for me. The musicianship, trippy concepts and as a drummer. The best drumming from them.
Mcabre Brothers - Tell A Friend is one of the best hip hip albums I've ever heard. Lee Scott and Milkavelli have an unmatched chemistry, it's unbelievable
Jellyfish Spilt Milk is the most overlooked, underrated pop record of all time. It deserves a full review, by you. A band that imploded before they had a chance. This album needs some love.
Deceit by This Heat: it's noisy and abrasive as hell but as a soundtrack for nuclear armageddon (and any other sort of armageddon) it really works. SPQR, Cenotaph, and New Kind of Water all are awesome in very different way.
![Blox Fruits Dragon Rework Update [Full Stream]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/EqDAp8udhm0/mqdefault.jpg)
It’s a bit early to make a list of the most underrated albums of all time. Shouldn’t you wait until time is over first?
is it just me or is the end of time underrated?😅😅😅
@@stg_tmc thats just you
Not Josiniffy ruclips.net/video/mm0hWgCDNSI/видео.html most underrated show love^ ☝️
Hey a humorous comment that ain't a meme about Fantwan saying something awful
I'm the 1000th liker okaybye.
My grandma has that same shirt. Now that I think about it... I've never seen her or Fantano in the same room...
wait..
You should confront "them"
Grandthony Matano
Yourthany Grantano
Granthony nantano
There’s a reason he reviews music and not graphic t shirts
damn
@@vVincent. 7/10
@@blujxy444 true
@@vVincent. 8/10 fight me
EDIT: I changed my mind it's a light 9 GOD. and LOYALTY. grew on me
@@shoreZ nah
i like how people with names like "charlie xcx uwu xoxoxo" show out with the most esoteric, noisy, jazz influenced hiphop reccomendations
...but do you really?
@@dripofu haha
@@dripofu yea
@@hi-ve1cw Okay, but UWU?
Im here after brat got a 10 from melon
Realistically the most underrated album of all time wouldn't even be rated enough to get on a video like this
enormous brain take
No it was Lil Pumps self titled album
Incorrect. The correct answer is Saul Williams self-titled album. Saul Williams self-titled album is the answer we were looking for.
Most unknown good album? I'd rather think of an album that a lot of people are aware enough about to form some kind of prejudice or vague perception.
Crimson by Edge of Sanity. I will never understand why nobody talks about it
I think you should make a video about: Most Overhated Albums
confessions of a dangerous mind isn’t as bad as people say. imo it’s a 6 or 7
Bleach (Nirvana) and Chocolate Starfish and the Hotdog Flavored Water (Limp Bizkit)
Revival. It was not near Eminem's full potential but it was still pretty great AND was 10x better than most rap is right now...
Birds in the trap
@@cartoonchaos2594 Idk man, I'm a big Bizkit fan but I'd day Results May Vary is the underrated misunderstood album.
"I hate being Biracial its awesome" -Logic, 2069
@youtube comment sections were a mistake wait what happened? I don’t keep up on logic
@youtube comment sections were a mistake dude he just dropped music lol
"Kanye" - Kanye, Kanye
“I hate being biracial, nigga”-melon
@@joekerr9150 “Frank” - Frank, Frank
16:34 渋さ知らズ ⭐️
18:06 フィッシュマンズ 🐟
How to talk like that
ありがとうございます
prior to this video, both of these albums i had given a 100/100 on album of the year, funny to see.
fax
I disagree
okay but this is literally the first time i hear Anthony saying anything about Guns'n'Roses ever
Matylda Deadass same. I rlly want a worst to best or a classic review of AFD
@ECCO This
@ECCO but they're extremely popular
ECCO he spittin facts
ECCO false
I know nostalgia critic’s The Wall is criminally underrated, but calling it the most underrated album of the decade?
Crow Reputable it’s a horrible album
It ain’t underrated
It underhated
Nostalgia Critic's The Wall is underrated because no one listens to such bad music
It's underrated because it's genuinely funny and doesn't get the praise it deserves because people take Nostalgia Critic too seriously and can't handle when someone "disrespects" their little favorite bland album.
@@pudge5174 is this an unironic comment haha
@@gabeh1839 it's a joke
"Not Underated, but Overhated" is a t-shirt slogan if I ever heard one.
Sounds like a similar line from Melon’s favourite album MBDTF...
You won't believe it but when I tried to think of the most underrated album in the beginning og the video I could only think about decent albums that are given too much hate, "over... hated... albums" I thought to myself "most overhated albums; that would be a good next topic! With like a little wordplay in there as well! Kind of brilliant, let's suggest that in comment and..."... I had lost what Fantano was talking about at this point but after like five seconds he came into that very frase - M7nd a bit blown
0:11 Radiohead: Planet Telex
On one side I'm like "How do you even know that it could be from so many other songs instead" but at the same time I feel like you just know it for sure.
Words cannot describe how much I love that song
Damn you’re right
after all the negativity he’s said about that album… smh
The New CALassic is a criminally underrated mixtape and should’ve gone at least triple platinum
I... agree!
At least
Anthony: tell me the most underrated albums of all time
r/PinkFloydCircleJerk: I was born to do this
Kek at the profile picture
Greeze exactly, ahaha Animals go
s t o n e
S T O N E
Yeah,but Floyd pre- Darkside is total trash. Only Saucerful and Pipers are good. And my favorite PF album is also Animals
Bernardo Carneiro sir they wrote their best song pre darkside,Seamus and Echoes
Trick question, the most underrated albums of all time wouldn't actually make the list of most underrated albums of all time
That's why it's giving birth to a stone
Hany M.Gamal asking what the most underrated albums were WAS the trick question...
Only if you assume that there is an objective answer, but there isn't, because the question is inherently subjective.
Idk that random Japanese one is probably in with a shout
That's why my tweet about American Football LP2 didn't end up on the video.
velocity: design: comfort by sweet trip is so fucking underated and the album cover is amazing
My favorite album
I think since it's /mu/ it's getting enough recognition
wdym its top album in rym and constantly talked about in /mu/. not that underrated in the underground
@@justanotherfishinbikinibot6060 this comment is 7 moths old, it was much less popular back then
a friend of mine on discord just recommended me this project so imma see how it goes but judging by the genres alone, I'm pretty hyped for it
Let’s argue: Melon’s head shines like a thousand suns
His head shines brighter than my future.
Brighter than*
*LET'S AGREE*
No one understands his head is the only source of light in the whole universe
I love that book
shawn cee’s unreleased album doesn’t count wtf
Shawn Cee’s obscure sample identification skills are underrated
Melon had a private listening party thats why
if u buy a physical copy of his album it comes with a leg reveal dont tell anyone i told u tho
is he making music?
Dusty Computer it’s a meme between the fan base
So happy you finally talked about Fishmans. Their version of “In the Air” on that live album is my favorite song of all time, just absolutely astonishing
The whole thing is probably the beast live album ever made
He's only 10 years or something late to the party lol
they're not underrated whatsoever tho
Yes! In the Air (live) is the greatest song I've ever heard also. The second half of the track that starts midway through the violin solo is absolutely cosmic, Shinji's vocals get me every time.
I had to click on this video once I saw that 98.12.28 cover
Audioslave's debut album is one of my favorite rock albums of all time, but grossly underappreciated. It's one of the rare examples of albums from which every track could be a hit.
Literally one of the most beloved rock groups and albums from the early 2000s
@@namijmi8179 at the time their albums were kinda panned.
I was so pumped when I first heard they were getting together cause they came from 2
Bands I adore but it sounded more of a "make money" project than anything else. Album is ok but I don't see why ppl should praise it unless by exclusively personal taste.
Second time I've read this so I'll listen and hope not disappointed. Check out supergroup Handsome from 1997. Heavy melodic 90s
PREAAACH!!
If any Kid Cudi album is underrated, It’s Satellite Flight.
I second this
EpicJake35 idk man half of it’s like instrumentals and rest is just ok imo
Aryansh Chauhan true still great though
Hell Yeah
I thought it was j strange. Kinda good but mostly strange
We all know that the most underrated album is Neutral Milk Hotel's "To Pimp A Butterfly"
I still think they were better on Wish You Were Here.
Neutral Lamar “To Milk A Butterfly”
Kendrick Milk, "Lamar the Butterfly"
It's actually Neutral Lamar Radio Milk Head Kendrick Hotel's "To the aeroplane Computer a OK Pimp in the Butterfly over the sea"
"not as epic as late reg or college dropout..."
say it, say it...
"..or even mbdtf"
hell yeah dude
@@cbrad_edits 66/6*
6/5
6/6
@nobrimsame bro
That pained him to say
"Scott 4" by Scott Walker. HOW is it not more famous? Genius album that sounds like it came out yesterday (I think it's from 1969).
I personally think Scott 3 is better, but they are both incredible, and have aged well
Nite Flights by the Walker Brothers is another album that just blew my mind.
@@daveysaturn7232 I like two of the Scott songs off nite flights but other than that I can't get into it
NOBODY that really knows hip hop underrates The Mighty Mos Def.
He doesn’t get top 10 status for most people. I never see him up there with Nas Big Pac Em Jay even 3 stacks.
@@mrtesticles889 Because he only has 1 great solo album, and one great collab album. IMO Biggie has more great tracks then Mos, and Biggie died at 24. If Mos died at 24 no one would know who he is, outside of maybe Blackstar and a couple of lyricist lounge tracks.
Having said that I would definitely put him over Em, and probably over 3 Stacks, because 3 Stacks doesn't have a solo album, unless you count the love below, but that isn't a rap/hip hop album, he only raps on like 3 songs from it.
3lancer Officialmaybe The Ecstatic is a great album as well
Totally agree
Wish he did more though.
Big problem with Ye is that almost immediately after it dropped he released Kids See Ghosts so a lot of they hype went that way instead (and Deservedly so)
*Undeservedly
Nah they both around the same in rate
I think both projects are very good however I prefer ye personally tho it's really neck and neck
Yeah, I was guilty of that too. Also the Pusha T one before was epic too so he kinda lost his own project in the shuffle. That who producing binge he went on was epic though. Ye sounds like a great album to me now and Daytona and Kids See Ghosts were straight up classic.
@@DumbBaby daytona isn't a classic, ksg is though
Seeing somebody with this level of influence talking about Fishmans makes me incredibly happy. Over the last year or so I've become a bit of a fanatic and nobody who I've ever discussed music with has even heard of them. They've definitely got some of the most underrated albums out there
Adam Flynn same, i actually found out about them quite a while ago but only listened to some songs but i recently decided to listen to their albums and im hooked,, i wondered if tnd did do a video about them so im happy he did talk about them, and yea they’re a pretty underrated band
Ye same, like obviously I wish he appreciated it like the rest of us who have discovered Fishmans, but at least he recognized them because yeah they deserve so much more
Friend showed me them last week and I'm also hooked. Really dig King Master George
Aren't they like the top rated on rym? Also, deep cuts has a video on them
@@featherycoffee1401 Their live album is #17 on RYM for best albums of all time. Like fantano said - overrated on RYM and underrated everywhere else
How has it taken me so long to find this guy, he seems super thoughtful.
Oh man. Better late than never. And now you have a huuuuge amount of content to go thru. I'm actually kind of jelous. Between the 2 channels theres tons. And on one of his TND videos (the response to the Fader article) he linked a ton of unlisted videos from his long gone channel, thatistheplan. You have such a good time ahead of you. And your Spotify will grow 100000x over and you'll be a better person for it. Have a blast dude.
Your life will chance
Yea his reviews are insightful
@@SwedePotato314 I love your passion
He's a ball
LET’S ARGUE: Anthony’s tiger shirt is the hottest thing ever
prod. h a r m 0 n y *let‘s agree
LET’S AGREE: Anthony’s tiger shirt is the hottest thing ever
cant argue with facts
ruclips.net/video/mm0hWgCDNSI/видео.html we might rap bout tiger shirts? You’ll never know☝️
“Overhated”
Everybody knows Abbey Road Anthony, stop calling it underrated
maybe in 70 s nobody gives a shit about beatles
Magical Mystery Tour - best Beatles release
@@acak5449 It's so stupid how self-absorbed some people are,like this guy who thinks nobody gives a shit about the beatles just because they don't care. Dude,the world doesn't revolve around you.
I heard AR last week for the first time, I am 17 though
@@x99ribs hmmmmm nah
The takes be sounding like that Huey Lewis American Psycho scene
Nicolás MB underrated comment
“Hey Paul?!”
Their early work was a little too new wave for my taste
Let’s hear Paul Allen’s take
Cool it with the anti semitic remarks
Electric Light Orchestra’s Discovery was pretty much universally panned by critics at the time and I think a lot of people think it’s cheesy but I love every single track. It is also a huge influence on Daft Punk.
Give a man a melon, and you feed him for a day. Teach a man to melon, and you feed him for a lifetime.
Let's........ Agree!
I unironically agree
7
Lmao
Plot twist: you can't teach a man to melon. He has to it on his own terms on his own time.
it seems like it hurts Melon to even day "My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy"
That album is not underrated.
Max Smart who said it was?
@@diegoflores8764 it seems like jack was inplying that.
Max Smart not really bud
Max Smart i never said or implied that it was underrated
Melon, I don’t think every Kendrick Lamar album is the most underrated
@ECCO Nah
uu is
Atom Heart Mother definitely is the most underrated. Summer 68 and Fat old sun are classics, even if is really good. But it was the perfect middle ground between the early stuff and what Floyd did on Meddle.
If anything, Meddle is the most underrated album from their work. While Echoes is absolutely incredible and it carries the albums on its shoulders, the rest of the tracks, apart from Seamus imo, are utterly fantastic as well. Fearless is golden, A Pillow of Winds is one of the most relaxing songs ever made with a close 2nd being San Tropez later on, and the opener One of These Days is brilliant as well. Echoes obviously gets a lot of credit, which it 110% deserves, but it’s not the only exceptional track on the album.
jsmarty1 meddle really doesn't get the praise it deserves
Fuck yes, I adore that album
I think the reason why AHM is rated the way that it is is just because Alan's Psychedelic Breakfast is just that awful of a track.
@@Bighomie39 Alans psychedelic breakfast is my favourite pink floyd song :( You just dont understand the vibe of epic psycheldic piano music and breakfast noises :)
Let’s argue: Melon kinda looks like light skinned bald juice wrld
Let’s agree*
Wait Anthony’s White?
Fantano is birracial
It’s his friendly face
Very intriguing, valid observation king. However, in my humble opinion, he looks more like a Thicc Moby.
Part of me wants to have your centrist and reasonable take on Fishmans, and I definitely think overhyping is in itself a problem. But damn, this band is probably the only time I've ever legitimately agreed with any music circle's niche obsession. No other band gives me such a life affirming feeling.
Tom Williams it’s really hard to think of a song with a climax as great as the one from the live version of long season
@@rashotcake6945 For sure. In the Air is my personal favourite cut from the album, but just the scope of Long Season alone is insane. The way they reinvented it on the live album is so bloody impressive.
I know right! Even though I personally love the more reggae tinged tracks of their career, the psychedelic ones are king. Songs like Long Season, Nightcrusing, Oh Slime, 幸せ者,
なんてったの, and In the Air hit me on an almost spiritual level.
I've never in my life heard someone speak ill of Black on Both Sides.
Your Name Here on god
Your Name Here I haven’t gotten to that point in the video but I can’t trust someone’s music taste if they dislike BOBS. Every song on it is great.
my friend made fun of me for liking "Mr. Nigga" but fuck that guy he likes lil peep
@@Rohit-jv7nl cmon why u hadda drag peep into this
Yeah right. Now the Ecstatic, maybe.
Most underrated albums:
*Kanye*
Smh
Yeah but compared to his other albums, Ye is definitely underrated
@@brown-eyedcheese5440 Ye is garbage lol it’s easily my least favorite Kanye album, there’s only 2 good songs imo
@@coastercraziness no
KanYE
@@coastercraziness ye is fye
Anthony’s saving that yellow flannel for NAV’s “Good Intentions” next week😤👌🔥
Karthik Tiruv on god
i’m holding out hope that he’ll give it like a 5 because he liked leaders and turks
He is going to give It a 6
If It has a Gunna feature
Let’s agree: Anthony looks like he’s auditioning to be Joe Exotic’s next husband
Nah too many teeth
First listened to Black on Both Sides this year. It was my first exposure to Mos Def and it's already become a top 10 if not top 5 hip hop record
It’s phenomenal along with Black Star’s self titled album.
I've just listened to it! I might be biased for already liking Yasiin for for work on various Gorillaz and Kanye projects, but I did really enjoy the album
Black On Both Sides is imo one of the few flawless hip hop albums. As someone who is most familiar with hip hop and not other genres, this was a gap in my 90s knowledge and holy is this thing amazing. I think I could name maybe 10-15 flawless hip hop albums and this would be one. Genius album
which albums would you call flawless?
@@joeyterheide5426 MBDTF (I hate giving Kanye praise rn but this is a perfect album imo and one of the only ones), Atrocity Exhibition, TPAB, Madvillainy, IGOR, Yeezus, GKMC, Piñata, Aquemini, The Blueprint, Illmatic, and The Forever Story (if it ages well, so far it has). The only ones that are a 10 or near 10
@@coastercraziness respect for including piñata
@@franchise5527 Freddie and Madlib are one of my all time favorite duos
@@coastercraziness I already strongly disagreed with MBDTF but calling Yeezus a perfect album is insane to me.
The guy with the Weezer take has likely been in a coma since 1996. Literally no one thinks Pinkerton is underrated.
also why do i feel like every time Melon does a let's argue some idiot throws in their stale Weezer takes. There's other goddman music out there!
I was just going to comment the exact same thing! It the only reason they could think this!!
weezer fans are worse than tool fans
Jacob Parsons Thats a stretch man. Tools fans are something else sometimes.
Yeah I agree. Pinkerton is my favourite album of all time, and even I agree it's far from underrated
The bass intros are underrated
This one was pretty cool.
Yes
Morphine’s entire discography is criminally underrated when compared to the rising stars and one-hit wonders of the early 90s.
You're speakin' my language.
thanks for introducing me to Mos Def! I used to only really listen to modern hip hop music, but you've introduced me to tons of old-school rappers, so now I listen to a mix of 80's, 90's, 00's, 10's, and 20's
Anthony, I didn't think you were going to rate my family's 2005 holiday party photo album as the most underrated album of all time. But honestly I'm flattered. You can definitely come thru this year bro, HMU if you're in the area!
If Fishmans had songs on that live album that were just straight up reggae, I’d understand finding it unimpressive. But all of the reggae influenced songs on that album have been put through a psychedelic, progressive dreamy filter and that’s what makes them stand out and interesting
Even "Airplane", the straight up unfiltered rocksteady song on the album is a banger!
It isn't even accurate to call it reggae either. It's dub music
@@PaulRobinsonOk Dub is rooted in reggae, and several of the tracks on the album are, by definition, reggae, or at least reggae fusion, with melodic lead bass, accented rim shot beats and one drop rhythms, and skanking rhythm guitar on the upbeats. I dont think the fact that there is a decent amount of it on the album really hurts it at all either. Fishmans, in my opinion, were the best non Jamaican reggae practitioners. They had a very idiosyncratic, experimental, and uniquely Japanese take on it.
I honestly think Anthony has really boring taste and of course he wouldn’t find their dub influenced songs appealing.
I didn't even realize its influenced by reggae when I listened to that album every night haha
Mos Def's "The Ecstatic" is also such an amazing album. Especially the track "Auditorium". A real legend of Hip-Hop.
I just discovered the album and I was looking for ANYONE talking about it. What a masterpiece man. Lisstening ot Revelationss as I type this
I always thought that Neurosis as a metal band have always been underrated. I feel like their songs and albums deserve millions and millions of listeners but they don’t. Their album Through Silver in Blood is a real classic. One of the heaviest and darkest albums ever and I think, one of the best metal albums of all time. A lot of people love them, but I still think they deserve more recognition in the metal scene as they basically created post-metal single handedly
Through Silver In Blood is probably my favorite metal album period
Literally one of the only metal bands I like
I just got into fishmans like a few weeks ago!! They should be more popular in the West
For anyone wondering what Melon was singing at the Patreon section, the track is Kiss Me, Son of God by They Might Be Giants.
Thanks a lot
Was really surprised when i heard him singing TMBG
I'm surprised that he's only reviewed them once.
@@joseferrada4999 in RYM he gave Lincon a 10/10, wich I disagree because is perfect/10
Him singing that was/is the Most Underrated Album of All Time
i didn’t expect miley cyrus and her dead petz to be on here and you agreeing on it being underrated but i understand
Melon needs to review fishmans
Yeeeeeee Fishmans made it to the channel. Anyway, i was like Fantano and dismissed the reggae tracks at first but the more i listened to the album (aswell as hearing their other stuff that wasn’t Long Season or Uchu Nippon Setagaya) the more the reggae or rather dub tracks started growing on me hard. There is something about the playfulness of songs like Thank You or Hikouki that just gets me going.
But overall tho, i am one of those people who think 98.12.28 is the best live album of all time. Not only for it being the last performance by Fishmans but also because every song just hits a chord with you. Whether it be the dreamy tracks like Night Cruising and In the Flight or the more expansive epics like Yurameki in the Air and Long Season. This album will always hold a special place in my heart and seeing it get more recognition outside of RYM and /mu/ makes me very happy.
Sorry if i was overdoing it with the gushing. I’m just so in love with this album.
I guess I can say that I love this album too.
I found Long Season to be pretty average to be honest.
98.12.28(live) is the best album of all time imo
it's a titanic masterpiece. i think every human being should hear yurameki in the air...
can someone tell ne what /mu/ is? I've seen it a lot but still don't know what it is
The silent hill 2 OST is incredibly underrated. One of the best ambient records and videogame soundtracks of all time
Kreek Kid Productions I bought a limited pressing of the first games ost and while I enjoy it. I wish I could get my hands on silent hill 2 ost even if only for that beautiful piano (I think it’s the theme)
Check out Jakey’s vid on Silent Hill 2. He gives it due credit 👌
Cole? Haha i’ve seen it, Nakeyjakey is the best man
I would add the "Beyond Good and evil" soundtracks to the list of underappreciated videogame OSTs
Ilenia Yessssss
Sufjan Stevens’ Seven Swans doesn’t get the praise it deserves
YES YES YES
The Age of Adz doesn't either
FlaviusBelisarius let’s just say his entire discography, he’s the one true goat
As much as I love Illinoise and Carrie and Lowell I agree, Swans and Adz are fantastic records that get overlooked all too often
Calum Anthony does not appreciate sad banjo man unfortunately :(
Your commentary re: Mos Def was so painfully on point. I saw BOBS on this list & thought "CAN'T be underrated." I'm 42. Now I get how that's a Thing.
Criminally underrated album: The Cure - Seventeen Seconds
Joey Depp That's true, people go nuts for 'Pornography' or even 'Faith' but 'Seventeen Seconds' has a lovely, dark, homespun feel to it that really deserves more attention.
At Night is da fuckin' bomb, son!
this is so valid
Ohhh good call.
True!
Kid Cudi's "Passion Pain & Demon Slayin'" is severely underrated
Surfin is so fire
Fax. It’s like a 7/10
If he called it MOTM3 it would have blown up. Definitely fits the MOTM vibes
Definitely, I think cudi all around is very underrated, I don’t feel that he ever got the cred/ rep he really deserved. I also feel that Kanye could’ve been a better friend to him which I feel is also kinda why he isn’t as popular, he’s big on Spotify now because of Travis Scott which I’m not happy about but I hope it leads people to see that he really is a great artist. ( note I’m not mad that he’s big on Spotify I’m mad cause Travis Scott blew him up and travis is not good
Kid Cudi's - The Journey to Mother Moon
Never thought I'd see melon talk about Fishmans.
I'm just gonna have to mention my favorite album of all time here: Honeysuckle Strange by Howlin' Maggie. It got some critical attention for a very short while after its release in 1996, and a few of the tracks got some indie and alt-rock radio play, but its themes of self-destructive behavior, industry bullshit, frustration, and mental health are well-executed and eternal. If you are reading this, there is a chance you have possibly heard either "Alcohol" or "I'm a Slut", but I'd implore anyone with even a passing interest in 90's alt-rock to give the album a full listen as it is a masterclass in cohesion of the seemingly disparate elements of grit and haunting.
Hey Anthony, just waiting to hear back from you about your request to join our D&D campaign. I think your character, Richard Strongshorts the Barbarian, would be a great addition to our party! Love to hear back from you.
Thanks
Anthony would be labeled a Cudi hater if he didn’t give KSG a 10.
Y D honestly 😂
he still is tho
lmao true
@@alexcornuelle2483 Gives an album a 10/10>
Is a "hater">
LOL
Blu & Exile - Below The Heavens: most underrated rap album of all time.
correct
I... Agree
Yes and no. It isn't known in the mainstream and therefore is underrated as it isn't widely known, but to the heads it is heralded as one of the greatest hip hop releases period.
@productfromthe00s tyhat album is nuts. just heard it alst week and coudlnt stop listening...so weird yet so good
People need to know about it, it is mastercraft
Red Medicine by Fugazi definitely seems to get less love for an inexplicable reason. One of their best in my opinion.
Absolute masterpiece, definitely my favorite from them
Queen II is actually extremely underrated . They really dug into their heavy-ish sound . It might not be the most underrated album but it is a most definitely a masterpiece .
Side 2 is absolutely amazing, side 1 feels kinda weak
@@TheMACnator Side 1 has
Father to Son (an epic opener)
White Queen (An emotional ballad)
Some Day One Day (A beautiful Brian May acoustic piece)
What do you mean weak?
@@biddleeewho4181 feels a little flat compared to side 2, just my personal opinion
congratulations, your underestimation of the Queen killed her...
Let's Argue: That was one of your better bass intros
Zach Adams I...Agree
The one on 'Lets Argue: Good Kid MAAD City didn't age well' happens to be my favorite Melon bass intro
Indigoism- The Underachievers
These guys are the most underrated duo on the face of the earth. Hard af but still kicking some positive shit. Yall sleep. This shit is a masterpiece.
Pretty much their whole discography is slept on
Very much agree. The mahdi still gives me chills to this day.
The instrumentals on that are insane
I agree
FVXKING AMEN. I love that album, actually thought it was a mixtape. Stunning beats and bars, didn't sound like anything else at the time or even now.
Yasiin Bey aka Mo's Def definitely deserves MORE flowers while he's still with us. I do wish he'd make more hip-hop even if it was independentally. Purpose? I'd say to educate the youth. But he seems pretty far gone from music nowadays. I get it. He was never gonna play the industry game in the long run but you can do your own thing independentally and fans will always support. Another Black Star album would be insane if that ever happened.
Bro did Melon just acknowledge the existence of Guns N' Roses?
Sadly he did
Yes, Reddit edgelords are very upset that a popular music critic spoke about a popular band.
@@awesometruth6 Because humour is ok only when you do it, ok
IMO, the HIStory album by Michael Jackson is a lot better than most of the general public would have you believe. This is probably the closest the man ever came to a proper concept album and it's done expertly in my opinion. Cuts such as Stranger in Moscow, Scream, and They Don't Care About Us rank up there in terms of his most experimental songs production wise and lyric wise.
Stranger in Moscow is incredible
Is this a serious comment. I cant tell cuz i havent seen one here in years
rhrhrhrh123 winnie pretty sad if you think about it, every comment is a meme
@@Hemaglox Big agree! Earth Song itself is a masterpiece, but Stranger in Moscow is an underrated gem for me. I legit discovered it via the MJ: The Experience game, and I'm glad it's in my life.
I think Townes Van Zandt’s ‘Live at the Old Quarter’ is the best live singer/songwriter album, maybe even the best live album ever.
Roadsongs is really good too
Good lord I can’t like this comment enough. As good as a man and a guitar can get
Hey I found people in Anthony's comment section that like actual music.
Rex’s Blues might be my favorite song of all time.
His album 'Rear View Mirror' is even better if you ask me. Townes is like 70% of all I listen to.
The Mollusk by Ween (the guys that did Ocean Man), that album is fantastic but it doesn’t get talked about nearly as much as it deserves
Anyone who doesn't know Weens catalogue front to back has a huge hole in their game
True
Quebec as well. Ween’s catalog is great overall, but those two are definitely a step above the others.
@@jacobneylon647chocolate and cheese??
@@bert7109 Great album but not their best work
There’s a really underrated album I know about, it’s called Dark Side of the Moon by Pink Floyd. It’s super underground though, so you normies probably won’t know it
Who the hell is Pink Floyd? Disco is dead man.
Just gave it a listen. That guy Pink has a pretty good voice
lol thats like the most normie dad rock album in the world.
Ronas Dembowski Pog
Ronas Dembowski it’s sarcasm. I understand if you’re on the spectrum or if English isn’t your first language, sarcasm doesn’t always translate.
The Libertines - Up The Bracket. Easily the best indie record to come out of the UK in the last 15 years but outside of the UK it is relatively unknown
One of the few albums I could listen to over and over again without getting bored
That's a weird one because it took over the UK but they were barely known elsewhere. I actually think their second album was underrated. It was so shambly and emotional, I think people found it underdone but I loved that about it. Same with first Babyshambles album.
Ka - Honor Killed The Samurai is easily one of if not the most underrated album of all time.
The5Head Agreed, love that album
I kind of feel like Orpheus vs The Sirens is slightly better but ka is super underrated considering how beautiful and consistent his discography is.
Also he's a fire chief and thats cool as fuck.
The5Head it’s not really underrated, most people love it, it’s just that not that many people have heard it
A lot of these people clearly don’t know what “underrated” means.
AGREE with Chinese Democracy! I was getting into GNR during late-middle school early-high school when CD came out. I obviously expected it to be nothing like the original GNR sound, but there are some great ballads on there (Catcher In The Rye, Better, Shackler's Revenge, There was a Time). Obviously some misses and agree with some odd industrial style attempts, but it's not a "bad" album at all. Axl still sings his ass off.
I freakin love Catcher in the Rye I don't know what it is about that slow chugging groove but its addicting
Brian Krosky There Was a Time -> one of the best rock songs of the past decade, and it has one of the best solos of the past decade too.
Jeopardy by The Sound is a post punk masterpiece, the only reason the album and band are basically unknown by the masses is because the label never promoted their music
just looked them up, they sound great. like a bit more pop version of unknown pleasures.
They're one of my most listened artists of all time. I don't think they're underrated though. They're not well known, but they get a lot of praise from those who know them.
Also bc they’re a pretty standard new wave band with not too much originality
Dude, From the Lions mouth is incredible.
@@eightytwo8282 totally not true
LET'S ARGUE: Anthony could make every guy gay.
by force
Sarmad yu *agree
Sarmad yu lets agree*
Zack Martin James Charles type beat
i would fuck his soul out of him
3:03 AGREED.
THERE WAS A TIME
in particularly is in their top 5 songs written at ANY era.
I'm pissed that Richard Wright's album Broken China is so obscure. He was a member of Pink Floyd, the third-best-selling band of all time, for fourteen years, and then his double album collab with Sinead O"Connor is so unknown it's not even on RUclips.
Fucking insanity.
Rick Wright in general is way too underrated. He doesn't get enough credit as a keyboardist and a songwriter, which I don't get because he was the backbone of PF if you ask me.
Wow, that album must incredibly obscure. I'm a huge Sinéad fan and seek out all of her collabs, and I've never heard of this album once in my life. It's not for sale on itunes and amazon has it for like $90, or $50 used. I'm glad you mentioned it, though. I'll try to hear it somehow.
Where's Corey Feldman's project, that album got me off the streets of Jerusalem
Who will cut my hair when you’re gone- The Unicorns, is a gem waiting to be uncovered and glorified by anyone who has not heard it yet. Fantano has discussed it before with high praise. It’s a quirky and glorious monument.
Anthony himself said its a 10
Probably got a higher chance of getting a Classic review than favourites like Sufjan Stevens esp. with Fantano exploring relatively more obscure cult favourites outside of /mu/ cores.
Mobilefize Did he actually omfg
it is an incredible album it sparked my interest in discovering more alternative music, found it from a casey neistat video lmfao
@@fiftyclown Strongly implied. The Unicorns are given a 9 on Fantano's RYM account but The Postal Service's 'Give Up' is another 9 which he eventually gives a Classic review to with the description saying that it's one of the best records in the 2000s. Given how opinions on albums can change especially with Fantano, it's likely that WWCOHWWG is a solid 10.
For citation purpose: ruclips.net/video/SM579Up7yC0/видео.html
Who else wants a Pink Floyd tear list?
Fantano crying over Pink Floyd? I’m in.
rip this comment
Roger Waters tear is the best
He wrote it down but then David Gilmour's guitar solos made him weep all over it and it washed away, forever to be unknown. Truly a tear list 😔
😢
Honestly not sure how you can miss Drake The dark demo tapes in this, easily the most underrated album from the past 20 years.
bro we all know scorpion is the most underrated album of the past millennium
coochie crumbs NA-UHHHH HAVE YOU HEARD THE CARE PACKAGE MASTERPIECE?
Easily Melons easiest 10 given.
The most underrates album EVER has to be This is Spinal Tap. Easily an 11/10 album, no one can argue.
100% Legit a great album.
Listened to it the other day and was bawling the while time! Shark Sandwich is probably their most underrated tho
LET’S ARGUE: You skipped March YUNOREVIEW because you didn’t want to review Blueface
Yea aight
I mean who would
As much as people loved to hate Limp Bizkit, their debut album is insane and immensely underrated. The riffs by Wes Borland, the funky basslines of a then teen Sam Rivers along with his cousin John Otto with some tight drumming. Sam & John studied jazz in college and you can really tell, the groove, tightness and allround instrumental prowess is really something most people haven't discovered since they hate the band solely because of Fred Durst and the fact that they've only heard Rollin' and Nookie.
man that album had some really solid tracks
Counterfeit, the trio of Sour/Stalemate/Clunk
I will admit some moments of it have not aged gracefully (need I bring up the cover of George Michael's Faith?) but it's got some highlights for sure. Nowhere near as bad as it gets a reputation for being.
Love a good dead genre bargain bin rake. Hedpe 1997 8/10 incubus 1999 8/10 Taproot 2005 8/10 vanilla ice 2002 lol 7/10
Humbug by Arctic monkeys is my favourite of theirs and I think criminally underrated for me. The musicianship, trippy concepts and as a drummer. The best drumming from them.
Nomeansno - Wrong is a criminally underrated punk album with basslines that would kick your teeth in
DID YOU HEAR THE NEWS?
Mcabre Brothers - Tell A Friend is one of the best hip hip albums I've ever heard. Lee Scott and Milkavelli have an unmatched chemistry, it's unbelievable
Milk is a scumbag
Jellyfish Spilt Milk is the most overlooked, underrated pop record of all time. It deserves a full review, by you. A band that imploded before they had a chance. This album needs some love.
Saying “it’s cr crazy frog!” for 20 minutes was a bold choice
Deceit by This Heat: it's noisy and abrasive as hell but as a soundtrack for nuclear armageddon (and any other sort of armageddon) it really works. SPQR, Cenotaph, and New Kind of Water all are awesome in very different way.
Critics love that record. So not underrated.
I came here to say SOVIET KITSCH and I'm so glad somebody beat me to it. One of the most perfect front to back albums ever made.
I've been
Listening to Soviet kitsch and I really enjoy Regina's sonic complements to the lyrics.