LET'S ARGUE: The Most Overrated Albums of All Time Pt. 1
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 30 май 2024
- This batch of albums includes My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy, Die Lit, Funeral, The Money Store, Mellon Collie and the Infinite Sadness, The Cool, Metallica's black album, Tool's entire discography, Blonde, Trout Mask Replica, and Dark Side of the Moon.
===================================
Patreon: / theneedledrop
Follow your melon:
Twitter: / theneedledrop
Instagram: @afantano
FB: / theneedledrop 
Видеоклипы
let's argue: anthony fantano is actually the mustache and he took control of this poor guy's body
So who's the guy when Anthony is shaved off
@@WiezAnims actually, the mushroom is always there, it retracts at times but is still in control
No. Anthony shaved off the grinches feet and wore it.
12:06 is the man trying to regain control of his body
This actually made my laugh out loud
i think this dude knows every single album ever
.....Is what someone who hasn’t listened to enough well known music would say.
@@SeanMacadelic well said
@@SeanMacadelic what if it was purple
I bet he don’t know about sybyr
Yall insulting my boy hive over here but he's right the albums mentioned on this video really aren't that obscure
"MBDTF cuz it has too many features"
*Gorillaz has left the chat*
Lol
Gorillaz uses its features like instruments tho, Kanye does too, but the joke *too* many features is wrong imo.
Steely Dan has left the chat
Yeah but it can be a problem for them as well. In my opinion Humanz fits what Anthony was talking about perfectly, there are so many features that you lose the connection to Damon Albarn ect.
Christian Acosta except nobody overrates Humanz, really it’s kind of underrated at this point imo
“Overrated” is the most useless criticism of all time
Agreed, doesn’t mean much as far as criticism
Ikr, it's just unfair to label anything that someone dislike as "overrated" just cuz they didn't get the hype as the general public.
No one uses overrated these days now underrated is the cool new buzzword that means nothing anymore
Overrated is an overrated adjective
Not really. Sure if someone just says that “such and such is overrated” and nothing else, then sure it’s not a good criticism. But it’s normally used as the start of some sort of argument.
Let’s argue: Anthony still thinks The Weeknd is a band
69 likes
420 likes
Can’t like it’s at 420
785 likes
I thought he was a band at first when he was on that Ariana Grande song...
Let’s agree: this is not Jesus is King review
Ben Shapiro where is it
It’s gonna be a not good
Let's Agree: Jesus Is King had lots of potential but Kanye failed to express his faith in an interesting or substantial way
@@yungyamazaki9512 Doubtful. Even if he doesn't like it, he wouldn't give it a NOT GOOD, based on what he said a NOT GOOD is
@Garrett Scroggs I would give it a light 5
Just paused and listened to MBDTF start to finish just to come back and say it’s not overrated at all lol
Yeah I'll never understand why melon's so critical on it
@@dekuscrubbed1411 anthony is just jealous of kanyes melonhead
it definitely is
It's not really anything new
Yeah that's one of the best albums of all time
The guy complaining about Death Grips is essentially like going to a horror movie and not liking it because you got scared.
Plus the fact they seem to think everybody enjoys music the exact same amount like if Melon gave Lil Pump a 7 and also gave The Money Store a 10, is it not obvious that he enjoyed The Money Store a bit more than Lil Pump?
Death Grips are overrated as f imo.
@@smackthatfemale it’s fine to not enjoy Death Grips but at least have a valid reason unlike the guy in the video
@@R-H-B They're just like not that good. It's just cryptic lyrics shouted over glitchy instrumentals. Idk what Death Grips offers that somebody like Peggy doesn't do better in literally every way
@@someguy4046 it’s not all glitchy instrumentals and cryptic lyrics dude. As a DG fan, the thing that I think sets them apart from other experimental rap groups is I think they add abrasiveness really well without making it hard to listen to. The lyrics are very poetic and that endears me to a lot of songs too. A lot of the instrumentals are more like hard and industrial beats rather than glitchy ones. They’ve used glitchy beats but its not like they do it that often either
why this man's lips wearing a cowboy hat
Y E E H A W
Sam Dolan this mans mustache is a product of a sponsorship from pizza hut
That's actually look like grinch feet
Hahahahahay
My parents' fights: worst to best.
Divorced parents type beat
domestic violence ft. child abuse (prod. by abusive household)
@Jarod M lol, im happier now only having one parent, other was terrible
The Mum: Was it me?(My fault) Alt ver
Sorry, you can't get anything man. Ever try tinder? I met my GF on there and we've been together for almost 2 years now.
- Dark Side uses same chords over and over
- The Wall is more complicated
Bro, the Wall literally has 9 tracks with the same 1 2 3 2 chord progression
But at least there it fits in with the story and theme of a musical
@@radical3868 So does the Breathe Reprise. It's about the start of life and the various ways to live your life, either fast and exciting, or long and mundane. It comes back at the end of Time, a song about waiting and wasting your life, to signify the sad reality that you've wasted your life, the less desirable of the two options presented in Breathe has been realised thanks to Time
@@B---tw3kh the wall did it better
@@radical3868 animals would like a word
Wish you were here ist their best work imo
I don't care that Dark side of the Moon is so popular, I love it, 'any color you like' is an awesome instrumental. Guess what, Pink Floyd have a handful of really popular records besides Dark side, pretty soon people will start saying 'Meddle' is overrated.
Oh yes! Meddle and Obscurred By Clouds are like warm-up albums for TDSOTM.
Funny that I actually don’t listen to TDSOTM a lot ... don’t even know why. Not that it’s not good. Guess other albums bring me more emotions. I actually listen to Meddle more.
@@nurrnena7798 There isn't an album that I don't like by them. I love Animals alot to.
@@shawnbowers4836 exactly. as many may call it "overrated", they havent spotted musical goldmines like Ummagumma or Atom Heart Mother. Their discography is almost perfect and none can tell me otherwise
@@Andiama Yeah, people need to chill. An album can only be overrated if it's mega popular but in reality it's cheesy garbage.
Meddle has a killer opener, followed by a couple of bland, boring fillers that no one cares and talks about and then one of the greatest songs of all time. Extremely inconsistent album.
Let's Argue: Most these submissions are trying too hard to be controversial
Lets argue: I have never heard of 85% of anything in this video. Or anything melon ever talks about.
So are they just trying to be contrarians?
The fans are becoming smarter…
HiIm Werer listen to all of them fr
@@RealTrachta It seems like a lot is hip hop/rap and that just isnt my genre.
@@JohnSmith-kt3yy I dont know it so it must be people being contrarian hah
I can see it in melons eyes, hes thinking, “if you guys ask me for the Jesus Is King review one more time, im gonna make you all meet Jesus”
@Equality 7-2521 no
kanye got left behind in 2008
CPSPD lol what you talkin bout. He gave Kanye’s last album a 10
@@CPSPD no
Treycen Clausse Technically Kids See Ghosts is a different artist group then Kanye alone.
Can we all agree that DSOTM, WYWH, Animals, and The Wall is the greatest 4-album run of all-time? Regardless of which is your favorite, that's 4 straight masterpieces.
Damn straight!
Agreed
i never thought about it like that, that really is an incredible run
No F**ing way. DSOTM is amazing, but I would have cheered if The Wall replaced it on this overrated list, cause the Wall belongs here. As far as 4 album runs, still one of the top 4 album runs, but I'll take the Stones Big 4, The Velvets 4 original releases, Led 1-4, LCD's Four non-nike sponsored releases, over This Floyd stretch - drawing a blank if there's any other's I'd rate ahead.
Zeps 1-4 run is the greatest imo
While I agree with the take on Dark of The Moon not being as musically complex as their later albums with Roger Waters, I wholly disagree with the album being considered “overrated”
I think a better take on the album is when I heard a dude say *Dark Side of The Moon is arguably the greatest album of all time but not the greatest Pink Floyd album* and it somehow makes so much sense to me.
At the same time, it IS their best album. There's nothing else like it.
Definitely funnels back into the "If it's accessible, is it good?" argument that circles around art.
I believe Dark Side of the Moon is great BECAUSE it is accessible: it works as an elegant primer into prog that is not initially palatable.
There is a culmination to their work where you can start feeling its ruminations within Meddle, and then it continues with WYWH, Animals, and The Wall.
I like to think of Dark Side as the entrance to the Roman Coliseum: yes, it's grand, but the space opens up in ways you can scarcely imagine.
I find pink Floyd in general is vastly overrated.
@@BICfootball92 wrong
@@parker3216 respectfully it just feels like if ur not on psychedelic drugs the majority of their music is way too slow and boring to me. Maybe they're excellent technical musicians, idk I'm not a musician, but just to the ear I find them very boring and overrated. Comfortably numb is a great song, but after that I'm pretty bored by their playlists
Let's Argue: The Glasses, Nose, & Mustache are connected.
That’s a let’s agree right there
The new Groucho Marx.
it’s a mask.
Why did i laugh at this
Mustache = God
Nose = The Son
Glasses = The Holy Spirit
Thus, its the holy melonrity..
Yea because "The Great Gig in the Sky" and "Money" sound totally similar...
its a bot opinion
For that matter time and us and them and the rest of the album. I think he just doesn’t get what a concept album is or the fact that wish you were here and the wall use motifs too
I believe that The Wall is more overhyped/overrated. Dark side sounds like something made by aliens. Anything close to it would be Meddle or WYWH.
Dark Side deserves all the hype it had ever got. It's the best album of all time.
@@kebab_boi Hell yeah brother.
The critique of TOOL is literally what people who have never listened to TOOL say
That goes for any famous band with mass popularity that gets called trash or overrated.
I was thinking the same. That opinion and his way of writing it clearly comes from a meme. Nobody that had listened Jambi thinks of it as dull or smt like that.
As a Tool fan I can absolutely see why people see their music that way
“Trout Mask Replica” was one of THE most celebrated “underground” albums of the 60’s! It birthed an entire genre of bands in its wake.
Melon: MBDTF is overrated
People: how many times we gotta teach you this lesson old man
hahahah
Let's be real, even if you rated it a 9 it'd still be way overrated
@@withnail-and-i no
@@mhj626 Yeah man, it hasn't even aged well.
@@withnail-and-i to you
Getting a headache while listening to Die Lit is just new knowledge entering your brain
Just dumb mfs increasing their IQs too fast
No pain no gain
@@mv03dl100 On God niggas need to stop drinking that dumb bitch juice, and start sipping that Playboi Carti lean.
Nigga whitest shit i ever heard b
Dean Winchester bro look at your name ur goofy
Blond came out when I, along with my peers, were coming into taste and going through late teens to late 20s. And that age group’s presence on the social sphere might be the loudest… The emotional impact hit in a certain way. It was different than a commercial album from a pop-ish r&b artist. It just hit so heavy in the moment. I can remember exactly where I was when I first listened to it and relating to it immediately
I feel the exact same way
So basically u gotta be depressed and touchy to enjoy it got it
I'm 40, into many genres, and that album is a masterpiece and easily #1 or #2 of the 2010's. Kaputt would be my other pick there.
@@andresmcjrnot at all. Bizarre take actually. It's just soulful and beautiful. You definitely have to not be shallow to enjoy it I'll say that. Being into many genres and decades of music helps too, having done psychedelic drugs also helps.
I have a very hard time agreeing that Dark Side of the Moon is overrated, it deserves all the praise it gets. Even though my favorite PF albm is Animals, then The Wall, then Dark Side, it still never fails to affect me emotionally every single time I listen to it from start to end, it puts me in a different place.
A lot of people tend to think that because an album is so popular, it has to be overrated, this doesn't count with dsotm because it's a near perfect album
I mean sure, it's a little bit homogenous, musically speaking, and I definitely think WYWH and Animals are better, but it's not an overrated album by any stretch.
Dark side of the moon is a masterpiece! However, Animals is my favorite, amazing!
really no WYWH or Meddle in that list? Also never got the hype around Animals, i think the wall its much more hard hitting
@@john-paulsmithmcgloin190
WYWH is slightly overhyped and Meddle has Seamus on it
LET'S AGREE: Let's Argue is about arguing
Debatable
can't argue
i mean agree
Let’s Argue: Let’s Agree is about agreeing.
Legion Vision i give this take a light 4 out of 10
His mustache looks like feet for his nose.
Or The Lorax vro
How high are you?
I can't unsee it...
Jacob Acton like the grinch’s feet
please say shoes instead
Blond is a fire ass album. Frank Ocean will forever be a goat
blonde lol
lmao look at the cover art you buffoon
@@levivanveen6568 obliterated him
preach
@@levivanveen6568 the name is blonde
00:05 DUCKTALES - WOO-OO!!
Wasn't expecting to see you here
duckthony quacktano
Donthony Ducktano
Well hello there!
Scroogethony McDucktano
The guy who said die lit gives him headaches listens to logic
Sick Boy yeah but Carti is so fucking good
Hahahahahaha
Nah Logic is shite but I didn’t like Die Lit. I was especially intrigued after seeing Skepta on the tracklist..but I couldn’t get into the album.
Imma relisten though in future, but it just couldn’t click with me. Similar with Migos. I like trap and harsh abrasive rap & don’t mind a lack of lyricism..but couldn’t vibe w/ those unfortunately
I get a headache when I listen to Die Lit but I hate Logic even more and I would take die lit over a lot of Logic
Die Lit can wear you down if you listen to it excessively with the basic structure, but as an overall project I still think it works pretty good. Self-titled compensates for Die Lit’s weak points
Me: everyone should have the right to their own opini...
"every song on The Dark Side Of The Moon sounds the same"
me: *loads shotgun*
@@remaininlight9269 *Aims nuclear warhead*
@@remaininlight9269 yea bro the great gig in the sky and money sound totally similar, right??!
@@remaininlight9269 Proletarian spotted
@@blazeh And every other song in the album....
@@Oscar-os7fj i would have to disagree with you there, for example us and them and eclipse sound alike in terms of its structure.
Anybody who doesn’t appreciate Tool is completely unaware of how talented Danny Carey is.
Someone can be technically talented and still not make very enjoyable music.
@@finitesound definitely not the case with tool though, they're an excellent prog band through and through
@@finitesound true, but not tool. Thats Dream Theater
When i saw DSOTM in the thumbnail i thought "well, i think someone didn't listened to it paying attention" i was right when he said that "most of the songs sound similiar" yeah, cuz Brain Damage its a copy of Breathe
"most of"
Most overrated reviewer: Anthony Fantano
uninspired
Jamison C Wow. Sick burn, buddy.
tom stevens He is though
Shawn Dimery who is he overrated by?
Ninja FEESE “Overrated” doesn’t exist. People that whine that others like something they don’t are fucking morons.
Your mustache looks like the grinch’s feet
Too far bro...
LAWD
Wow
W
stolen
We should all respect each other opinio-“dark side if the moon is overrated”
*Sir allow me to holy slap you into the 16th dimension*
@Ben Talbot You're just a dumbass. 💯
@Ivor Biggun You took all that
time out your day to write something
out this long but I'm triggered...?
Alright buddy.
album sucks
@@XD-ly7fp fuck off it's one of the best, how about you try making music? Hm? It's not easy, and they are one of the most famous bands in rock out there so stfu
FOR REAL THOUGH
The TOOL reception is quite weird, People will Die on the the Hill of how good it is or how much they hate it. There is no inbetween, Personally I think their music is genuinly some of the greatest works of art ever
You will never convince me that The Dark Side of The Moon is not a masterpiece
Agreed. Even though Animals is their best album, DSOTM is still a masterpiece.
@@skatterpro wholeheartedly agree. Animals is hands down their best album
Anne-Gabrielle Berthaud wish you were here imo
ocrow365 agreed.
GurktheBrutal I love Animals, but I’ve never understood people who say it’s their absolute best, I always have thought Dark Side was but recently Wish You Were Here has been my favorite, Animals being a close 3rd
Should be titled “Let’s Argue: Albums I hold a grudge for”
Loooool
He disagreed with basically all of them though
Any logic album
@@ThePacemaker45 I was shocked he said Dark Side was one of their better records ...
@@millfred123 Out of 15 studio albums it certainly is one of their better ones.
I like this video for two main reasons. One is that it’s full of records I recognize and remember easily. Secondly Anthony’s defense of these classics is a representation of how he loves music in general, and any good album is worth liking. I like that positivity, even if it’s founded on the negativity of others.
Dark side of the moon is the greatest album of all time, but it isn’t even the best Pink Floyd album
That's because WYWH takes the cake
@@interrogatorchaplain9552 yes
@@interrogatorchaplain9552 also animals
@@interrogatorchaplain9552
Eh. DSOTM is better, WYWH is overhyped.
Somehow this makes sense.
Let's agree: melon needs to make a pink Floyd worst to best before he dies
No
I...
Agree
Yes please
Piper at the gates of dawn
@@hetornhetorn I
The MBDTF guy went for one of the easiest "I Agree"s ever and Melon still picked his sister up from day care
Mulch Man “picked his sister up from day care” is a burn that really makes one wonder, what it means
@@NotDingse no one knows what it means but it's provocative
@@IamSuperEffective it gets the people going!
@@NotDingse i hope you know what you did there
Craig Shaw I really don’t, thank you
There is almost a cult following of And Justice For All
Objectivly yes, the production is a step back BUT the same way you enjoy harshness of Death Grips, many people enjoy the sound of AJFA
It sounds rough, brutal, every song is so technical, there are a lot of things to love about AJFA
Also James sounds fucking demonic, his best vocal performance by far
he didnt say its bad he just said the production is shit
Yeah man, I really love AJFA. I view it as a grief album and I like the roughness. I don't dislike the black album but it definitely is more accessible and for lots of metal elitists I think its easy to shit on.
@@matthewaxe6647metal elitists can suck my big d
Oooh dissing DSOTM found the kid who couldn't find friends to trip with in high school
Dude who said Blonde has never been sad in his life
@sponeg the Infinity Gauntlet Whoa there.
Treefingers imagine ur opinion being that shit
Treefingers literally the worst take.
I love how he called it intimate. Totally.
Treefingers I don’t feel rejected just alone and i don’t play fortnite sooooo 🤷♂️
"Calling recurring elements a 'motif'"
That's....literally what a motif is.
Apply hice on the burn.
Haha, jk, dsotm us my favorite album
Yeah, the criticism was dumb, but Dark Side does have a lot of fat.
Animals is better as a whole.
there's an argument to be made that DSOTM is not as good as some of their other albums, but to say that the songs and chord progressions on dark side sound "the same" is absolutely fucking absurd. the reprise of breathe sounds like breathe (gee ya think?) and other than that none of the songs sound "the same" as each other in any way at all.
@@HollowGolem Of all the unwarranted criticisms I've ever heard about DSOTM, saying the album has "fat" has got to be the most ridiculous ones. The Dark Side of the Moon is 42 minutes and 32 seconds of perfection. There isn't one filler moment on the entire record.
lmao, a saucerful of secrets is better than anything else even piper
Tool and Floyd are two of the best progressive rock bands to ever grace this planet
No
yes
Hard facts
@@cheekymonkey7734 note the use of the word “of”
King crimson> tool
Imagine calling Mellon Collie overrated smh
Ikr, lame criticism. Just say you're lazy to listen to a 2 hour long double album. smh
fantano has no idea what he's talking about.
I personally can't stand Billy Corgan's singing and can't get into the smashing pumpkins because of his voice. 1979 is a good song though.
@@arthurias7693 I hate smashing pumpkins after he started doing those terrible banshee noises. Because of this, Mellon Collie had a lot of songs I don't like. Gish and Siamese Dream are brilliant imo.
so ridiculous - my fav album
LET’S ARGUE: Let’s argue doesn’t even create discussions
*lets agree
smartass
Bulleheaded discussions
I.... Agree
This
Ironically I think that Dark Side of the Moon is underrated by the RUclips music community that thinks it’s overrated
I whole heatedly agree
How can it be underrated when it's #2 after OK Computer
@@p0werfu11 There's no way it's behind OK computer surely?
@@p0werfu11 Pretty sure the RUclips sphere and RYM sphere aren't exactly the same my dude lmao
@@p0werfu11 I didn't mean in terms of ranking, just people's general perception of it
Things that are considered overrated: anything good
Well overrated doesn't mean bad lol
Blond is a revolutionary album. The weak points julesnnz identifies are in fact some of its strongest and what makes it so groundbreaking. It introduced many structural and sonic innovations in the context of pop music that, I reckon, will continue to exert influence over other musical artists for a long time.
i’ve listened to it like 18 times in a row, its just impeccable
even after 7 years of blonde's release, it still stands at #1 for me
For a lot of people who love blonde, the lack of percussion is part of what's impressive; the songs are emotionally heavy and carry themselves with so few elements. Complaining that those songs feel unfinished because they have "0 drums" is like complaining that Picasso painted faces with the eyes "in the wrong place".
Yes 0 drums indeed 😐 ruclips.net/video/uzS3WG6__G4/видео.html
@@M0urnfulD3solation Yeah, it doesn't apply to every song. I think it's like half the songs don't have drums
Absolutely perfectly stated good sir
@@dog5893 thank you Dog
Yes exactly, it’s my favorite album and I absolutely acknowledge that it’s a little minimalistic, but the emotion is what I love about it
Let's argue: Fantano has 20/20 vision and those glasses are actually just to weigh down his nose to keep his moustache from growing up to his eyebrows.
I.... Agree
How would a heavier nose keep that from happening? I know you're trying to be funny, but you need to make sense to do that.
@@Amateur0Visionary I don't think your tedious & mundane "analysis" of a month-old random YT comment qualifies you as an expert on humor.
@@Cryogenik_1 I'm not an expert on anything except failure. I've done that a lot, so i know it when i see it.
@@Amateur0Visionary oh ok, well they say failure is the only path to success, so welcome to the winners club.
One word to describe Mellon collie and the infinite sadness=BEAUTIFUL!
Yes, very melodic and emotional album. Hipsters don't understand melody and emotions though, they only understand snark.
Everytime I listen to it, it becomes my favourite album of all time, and i've listened to Dark side of the moon
Your channel is something I wish I'd discovered earlier. I live in a small place with small friends circle, but you're the only person I've listened to is a genuine critic without pandering to your prejudices; you're honest, and know your shit. Love hearing when you don't know it too.
Everyone: “Do Jesus is king review”
Melon: *no I don’t think I will*
it is not going to get more than a 4/10
@@lcs-1 idk, it definitly isnt below avrage album, it is not a masterpiece but it is decent enough imho
Who Cares I agree with that but it’s definitely his worst album and there’s no stand out tracks like new workout plan, roses, heartless or power but it does have a very cohesive structure
It's an 8/10 easy
Got3mcoach21 something is wrong with your cerebrum
I think the greatest mistake made is: overhyped =//= overrated. Lateralus is absolutely a rolling banger from begining to ending. Dark Side of the Moon remained a high bar for the genre for years after its released. Do the fans treat the band as living gods and overhype the shit out of them? Absolutely. Does this make the albums overrated? Not a chance. The two are mutually exclusive.
Brilliantly said! I love DSotM and I agree.
Exactly, and people often regarded Overhyped with Overrated.
Fuck that record.
@@int0the3p1t32 go back to the basement contrarian.
Ya I would agree with that, and a lot of time I see that pendulum swing back and forth. For me, that's like Nirvana, the hype was so big, all I ever heard was Nirvana is the greatest band, or greatest 90s band, etc. when personally I didn't even think they were the best grunge band from Seattle. But then the hype gets so big that it becomes "uncool", so then I would hear how overrated they were or how they're not even a very good band, and I thought the same thing they're not really overrated just overhyped, and now I see it swinging back the other way, especially with the younger generation discovering them
I'm a simple man, I see dark side of moon is overrated, I clicked dislike.
It’s an honor to read your comment sir ✊
Why does disagreement correlate with dislike? I don't get it.
Si si, ya los vimos
Noah May lol that’s literally how RUclips works and basically what the dislike is for
It is
I think DSOTM is the best album of all time, it's just my opinion but... It's not about the band that made it, each song that is in it, that single guitar solo in Time or the instrumentals, for me, that album is a life lesson as a whole. You could listen to it 20, 30 years in the future and still have goosebumps in Great Gig, or On The Run. It's a timeless album, and beside of that, it's musically a masterpiece as well, full of emotion, passion, heart and soul. Ignoring what I said before and focusing on each songs, Torry's voice performance in Great Gig, that guitar solo in Time that was made in the first try and improvised, the emergency of On The Run, or the loneliness and soul of Us and Them. I would hate Pink Floyd and even Rock in general, but if I gave that album a try, oh boy, wouldn't regret a single second.
I personally disagree. There are at least 15 albums better than DSOTM
Edit: I no longer disagree lol
Funeral is the best album of all time imo
DSOTM is very boring
@@sambt123 changed my mind about it being the best album (as it's fucking dumb to give this title to any piece of art), but I'll have to disagree with ya on that
guy: criticises money store
Melon: I'm boutta end this mans career
Let’s Agree: Life is like a hurricane
Here in, Duckberg
I thought the same!!
I HATE FUCKING
@@Tanikaze2 they're all poor like obama
Thought It was a highway and I wanna ride it all night long
@@henrg fuck mishull obama
I dont see how MDBTF having a lot of features would be a bad thing, it doesnt make it any less listenable
Ikr
Mellon Collie is my favorite album I don’t care how big it was
So nobody is gonna talk about how he just knows every single artist ever? It could be any genre or time period and he’ll still know.
Hes the internets busiest music nerd for a reason. We should kick his ass and take his melon money
He probably has a degree in music study or something
@@papiuniverse1583 BRO LOL IMAGEINE THAT
@@papiuniverse1583 MusIC ThEOrY
He trasends space and time
Let's Agree: Melon is the reason of my cat's erectile dysfunction
I.........
AGREE
How do you know your cat had erectile dysfunction
@@deadchannel2876 Shane Dawson told him
Agree
I’m sorry you’re not getting satisfied 😔
Trout Mask Replica was so fucking infinitely important in so many ways. Thank fuck for the Magic band, Captain Beefheart, and Frank Zappa.
the dark side of the moon to me is 2, 5 part songs that tell a story in a really cool psychedelic way that still holds up today and that alone is worthy of being one of the best albums of all time
LET'S AGREE: That bass intro was the best of all time
I thought it was Ducktales for a second
Hall and oates vibes
Nah the one in that video about Greta van fleet was way better
@@henriktheonly3874 it's not?
Davie504 has entered the chat
his mustache looks like the head of the lorax
Oh shit
Oh shit
I agree that basically most of the chord progressions on DSOTM are the same, (i IV) I feel like that progression never gets old. There is so much soul in it, and is so easy to space out to. The tension and release is also neat. It is so much less repetitive that (I V vi V)
Oh dang, these were special to me. I've gotta come back around to these.
Dude that Chris Rock feature was the best part of MBDTF clearly yeezy didnt taught you.
After listening to that album 20+ times I can say for a fact it is not the best part
Mario i skip the skit every time, the skit made blame game mu least favorite track on that album
I genuinely find that skit really funny and iconic.
not necessarily the best, but truly made it more relatable. many have a chris rock they, at one time, resented.
Best part has to be the black balls part of Gorgeous.
Melon what should I think about JIK my friends have been asking and I don’t know how to respond help
HahHHahahhaahHHa
Review Jesus is king so I can have an opinion on it already, Anthony
think for yourself jeez...
sos s first time around these parts or is it just hard for you to spot satire?
When Anthony was talking about the TOOL comment and how math is inherent to music(and not just western music either) I immediately thought of Music is Math by Boards of Canada.
Fantastic group, definitely worth your time if you like warm, ambient electronic music with an emphasis on melody and analogue synthesis.
The paaaast inside the present...
I saw this while looking up Mellon Collie and readied my pitchforks, only to put them down in relief when he defended it. And then he talked about dark side of the moon
"The Chris Rock feature was useless", this tells me everything I need to know about Melon.
yup
Imagine being this moronic
Can someone explain the point of it though? I just went back and listened and I'm confused, it seems like a jarring detour for the song
Edit: grammar
word when he said that i knew what type of person he was
John C Points for _FACES_ as your pfp
My man better not do MBDTF dirty again 😤
Edit: wtf bro
The reason why I think blonde is one of the best albums of our generation is because of the way frank introduces his emotions. For its time the style of prediction and use of effects was very unique for the major art world. The way the songs sound and the almost liquid texture I believe really capture what it feels like to be In a period of existential dread. I am also a fan of the points and slight references he makes on the album. He talks about relationships struggles, drug addiction, technology addiction, loneliness and isolation, the fear of losing people and learning to let go, I also have the feeling that he was inspired by 2pacs message about helping others and making sure that everyone has a fighting chance. At the end of the album frank talks about trying to let go of all his worries because he realizes that he can’t fix everything. “ I’m just a guy not a god “
I think that just bc an album or piece of music was revolutionary but isn’t now doesn’t mean it’s overrated. For example; Stravinsky’s The Rite of Spring isn’t as revolutionary as it was (there’s been a piece written specifically for each member of a string quartet to be in a different separate helicopter or smth), but is nevertheless respected and enjoyed for its status. It’s also just really fucking good
Also just Beethoven
Let's agree: No one out-pizzas the Hut.
Lemon MacButtons girl what
Pizza Hut pizza is disgusttttiinngg. Papa johns and dominoes top it by far
HotdogTango I agree
Everyone out-pizzas the hut.
YESSS! You won my internet today Lemon! Thank you
Lateralus and Aenima are masterpieces.
Undertow and Opiate are too, more visceral tho.
Lateralus and Aenima are better. More math is always better.
Whisky Warlord undertow is the worst album other than that new pile of garbage
@@dalekay9ine just because you say it? Fuck you hating piece of shit
Dale Kay eww guys look a bitch with lame ass music taste
"No one cares that you put math in your music."
*Bygones intensifies*
That Metallica take isn’t a hot take. That’s the general consensus that the Black album was their last good one for a very long time and was a step down in terms of technical ability from literally everything before.
DSOTM is an undisputed transcendental masterpiece
THE BEST ALBUM MANKIND WILL EVER PRODUCE PERIOD.
@@AvanRoyOfficial not at all.
That would be To Be Kind
@@bobsbigboy_ dsotm is tbk if tbk was waaaaay better
I love it. But it's not even my favorite pf album.
what does that stand for
I don’t get the guys argument about Tool. Tool never tried to push the whole Fibonacci thing in your face. The fans are the ones that pushed it in your face. I’m a huge Tool fan and even I didn’t really care about the whole math thing and that was never really the point of Tool.
i feel like maynard finds it funny how deep some of the fans read into the music, similar to the king gizzard fanbase. Also lateralus sounds fucking incredible i feel like that guy has mostly just read about tool on reddit rather than actually listening to the music himself
anybody who thinks that "all the songs sound the same" on dsotm hasn't listened to it properly, im sorry. the truth is its suppose to be listened to AS AN ALBUM! thats why so many people think its overrated, bc the sequencing has been ruined for them by hitting shuffle. thank you for coming to my rant, yall know im right
I'm super picky when it comes to music and no way is dark side of the Moon overrated. I don't even really like the wall but dark side of the Moon is a masterpiece
@@XxxXxx-br7eq exactly
blond is such a different and influential album, one of the best
"math belongs on paper" has to be one of the most ignorant sentiments of all time.
rocks.
yeah like bro its 2019, use LaTeX
Music is also mathematical by nature. What a dummy.
No
hetornhetorn i like how you just see these comments out of no where of people just randomly saying “no” or “yes”
My man really pushing the agenda against MBDTF lmaoo
he’s just doing it to be a contrarian
His MBTF and Mac Miller reviews are my biggest points where I straight up just feel like he’s trying to hate things that are well received
Jacob Ballance still don’t know why yall love it so much tbh but whatever floats ur goat
@@amedding you do know this is just his opinion. Right??
grape conqs I don’t even love it that much, there’s Kanye records I like more than MBDTF but to give it a 6 and still stick by it is just absurd. there’s no way that album is a 6 lmao.
MBDTF’s features are some of the best verses of all time
In 1974, I went to a record store for the very first time by myself. The records I purchased were, King Crimson's in the court of the crimson king and lark's tounges in aspic, Isao Tomita's the bermuda triangle, Captain Beefheart's trout mask replica, the first Velvet Underground album, Tangerine Dream's zeit, and Klause Schulze cyborg topped off with the first Pink Floyd album and meddle finishing up with Kraftwerk's radioactivity. Don't ask me where I got such an eclectic taste in music for a 14 year old.
Quite a lineup you got there
@@dragosandronic8003 Thanks and the really crazy part is that the bill for those 10 records was 64 dollars and some change. Today 10 newly released CD's would be almost 200 dollars.
lmao you were born in 1960 and you’re watching fantano
respect bro 👌👌👌
Damn ,hearing Lark's ,Zeit, Cyborg and Radioactivity in 1974 must've been a real mindfuck
Did you buy them all in the same visit?
The Money Store is actually the catchiest Death Grips record, strange that people pick on that one.
Idk, No Love is super catchy, but I agree, you could complain about some of their other releases a lot more.
I’m no death grips fan but that’s the one I hear about the most so of course it’s going to have people pick on it
Ex military is more Catchy for me tbh, or at least more accessible on first listen
@@shady8045 Yeah I get what you mean. There's a lot more of a punky vibe to that mixtape and as most people get the idea of what punk rock is, it's a lot more easily digestible, as heavy as it is. As far as instrumentals are concerned, songs like Beware and I Want It I Need It would almost sound normal if not for the lyrics/charles manson sampling
@@shady8045 how do you guys find it accessible..? it’s kinda too much chaos for me and I’m predominantly into heavy music. The vocals are so ear blasting in the mix. The instrumental is so messy. Their first commercial album still holds these characteristics but not as harsh.
BLOND is a dark-night-of-the-soul record and it requires something from the listener. It's the best album i've heard in 10 yrs and takes me to places no other record has.
I like BLOND but it didn't hit me like that. I think it fits in the same place as Channel Orange in songs I liked from it.
This
I’ve been waiting for this album to take me somewhere but it never has and I think it’s because I listen to other Rn’B. I tried to like it since I like Rn’B but it really just for me is an ok album.
Just curious, how much music do have you listenened to, both in amount and variety?
I like Blonde, but I really struggle to understand how so many see it as "top 3 of the decade" material or some transcendent work of art. Top 50 of the decade sure, my rating is pretty much in line with Fantano's.
Blond is amazing until you realize that there is actually a shit ton of filler between Nikes and Nights and everything after that is absolute wash. Futura Free is pretty good, kinda haunting now that his brother passed away
one of the best intro basslines ive heard from him personally
Meddle, The Dark Side of the Moon, Shine on you crazy diamond, Animals, The Wall are equally fascinating to me. No better than the other, they are different moods but you still get that Pink Floyd goodness through all of them.
I love that you confused wish you were here with SOYCD since i do it all the time🙏
@@idunnoman1342 haha I didn't even noticed, that's true.
1:48-2:06 “literally EVERY Dj Khaled album”:
isaiah cervantes I immediately thought of DJ Khaled when he said that
"LET'S ARGUE: Melon Selects Freezing Cold Takes And Then Disagrees With Them"
Siamese Dream was way better than Mellon Collie, however, it was still a damn great album. The Smashing Pumpkins just couldn’t write a bad song from 1991 to 1998
Imagine not considering MBDTF a complete masterpiece...No matter what you think of Kanye it’s clearly one of the best hip hop albums ever made at the very least.
It’s one of the (if not) best albums of the 2010s and maybe the 21st century
Let him have an opinion
The general concept of that album is one for the ages. Infusing the extravagancy and sonic diversity of an old rock album into hip hop was a stroke of genius on Kanye's part. Not to mention the guy's lyrics are for once on par with his production, and the feature list is utterly insane. I understand Anthony's gripes that the album is very inconsistent and struggles on the back half, but I feel like on all accounts, the overall merits of MBDTF makes up for that. Should be at least an 8
I think its understated how important MBDTF was for rap. Until then you had collections of good rap songs that you'd listen to at a cookout, maybe the occasional underground MF Doom/CYNE stuff on the side. This was the first real mainstream attempt at making an album meant for art. I also think Kanye has a magical ability of elevating artists he's with, perhaps because the artist is showing up for Ye who knows. Pusha, Rick Ross' godly verse, Elton John and John Legend having a duet in a song about being a criminal, Nicki Minaj's verse that basically pushed her career and women rap in general, etc. Everything about this album was so well done.
it’s so funny how largely loved rap is, like everyone is a rap fan lmao, funeral is the very best album on this video