Half-Life 2: MMod vs. Black Mesa - Weapons Comparison

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 18 сен 2024
  • Patreon ► / noclicksforme
    93% of the people watching this video are not subscribed.. can you bring that percentage down by subscribing to my channel? It's time to choose.
    Half-Life 2 MMod 1.3:
    www.moddb.com/...
    You can support me on Patreon: / noclick

Комментарии • 128

  • @shiba2ndworlder
    @shiba2ndworlder 4 года назад +243

    "Hey! What's Freeman doing?"
    "Ahh yes, he's shooting the sky again"
    "What a great scientist"

  • @abhaybhatt4286
    @abhaybhatt4286 4 года назад +152

    Honestly I like MMODs just a little bit more. Sound design and the HEV arms look a lot more rugged. Although BM's Tau Cannon is a lot better.

    • @troysandman552
      @troysandman552 4 года назад +16

      Think MMod uses a higher poly version of the beta Tau cannon

    • @MinorLife10
      @MinorLife10 4 года назад +10

      BM's τ-cannon is a scientific tool. In HL2 τ-cannon is made of garbage and blue duct tape. I like both, but differently

    • @hmmxyoutubechannel5576
      @hmmxyoutubechannel5576 4 года назад

      thats because its been a while since black mesa in hl2

    • @Snaking_Gamer
      @Snaking_Gamer 3 года назад

      @YayDude123 Because half life 2 doesn't have gibs

  • @eldkfwkd321
    @eldkfwkd321 4 года назад +83

    Black Mesa's weapon animation is like a father with a son's body.
    MMod's weapons animation is like a son who has a mature body as much as his father.

    • @nuclearpotato4073
      @nuclearpotato4073 4 года назад +8

      Makes sense, seeing as how Gordon is just a man out of his element in hl1/Black Mesa and not a revered supersoldier.

    • @SirAroace
      @SirAroace 4 года назад +1

      Well BM is the mark IV and MMOD is the mark V suit. One is factory new, the other was made by rebels.

  • @MauricioJara
    @MauricioJara 4 года назад +103

    It's cool to see Half-Life 2's gritty style compared to Black Mesa's close to realism style.

    • @azurevie
      @azurevie 8 месяцев назад +1

      Gritty? Like the half life 2 be- *gets fucking desintegrated*

  • @WAcrobat19
    @WAcrobat19 4 года назад +55

    Good gunplay is when you want to use the pistol again, and MMod delivers in that department greatly!

  • @weavorjjohanna5619
    @weavorjjohanna5619 4 года назад +63

    Black mesa has realism
    But mmod has the dynamic style
    The reason being is :
    In black mesa : gordon is still very new to firearm in general, even if he has gone through hazardous course, his knowledge with fire arms is still very limited
    In mmod : you are looking at a man spend half of his life running and gunning, repeat the whole process over and over angain
    Overall, i love half life and it entire modding community so both of these are very good animation

    • @dezynjikReal
      @dezynjikReal 4 года назад +8

      "New to firearms"
      *Literally destroys HECU squads*

    • @weavorjjohanna5619
      @weavorjjohanna5619 4 года назад +5

      @@dezynjikReal i mean he got trained with an mp5 in hazardous course, and watching the HECU is enough....
      -also yeah, gordon freeman literally destroyed a alien civilization so "new to firearm" is actually not that accurate, i think the word i wanted to use is : he handle weapon with care

    • @IdRatherNotHaveAHandleThankYou
      @IdRatherNotHaveAHandleThankYou 4 года назад +3

      @@dezynjikReal Gordon, I do believe we have wiped out the entire United States Military!

    • @damarvelousone
      @damarvelousone 3 года назад

      "spent half of his life running and gunning"
      Half Life 1 takes place over 3 days. Gordon is most definitely older than 6 days.

    • @weavorjjohanna5619
      @weavorjjohanna5619 3 года назад

      @@damarvelousone for a war veteran, 6 day is enough to made them see their life flashing before their eye ( we talk about a war veteran here, let alone a scientist being inject morphine every 10 minutes )

  • @theimperialcombine
    @theimperialcombine 4 года назад +32

    Everyone's talking about which they like more, Yet very little is talking about the idea of MMod for Black Mesa.
    Its too perfect not to work. #BMMmod

    • @Heroheenie
      @Heroheenie 4 года назад +1

      @@forgotmyname1242 MMOD doesn't really change models though, just improves graphics, adds some extra effects, and some weapons. Really it's still pretty vanilla

    • @HappyMan0203
      @HappyMan0203 4 года назад +1

      I mean, not really. MMod works because it's taking an already older game and then spruces it up, improving the visuals and enhancing the gameplay to bring it to modern standards.
      _Black Mesa_ is a full on remake of an even older game, and already has all the bells and whistles that MMod has anyway, and looks even better. There's not really anything an MMod version of BM could bring to the table.

    • @Heroheenie
      @Heroheenie 4 года назад

      @@HappyMan0203 That is true. I mean, pretty much the only thing that could get added is maybe a few extra weapons, like dismountable guns and extra particles.

  • @BraixenKartzem
    @BraixenKartzem 4 года назад +21

    No skyboxes were harmed in the making of this video

  • @vladislav109
    @vladislav109 4 года назад +29

    Actually, this is coming from someone who played both games extensively. I really like Black Mesa, though the gunplay only got a little bit better than hl2 thanks to a few improvements. But it's still the same hitscan combat that we're already used to. MMod however really improves upon that, the gunplay is made much more dynamic and fun, to a point where even using the pistol is fun, especially when you turn on the bullet physics in the settings, which is weirdly set to disabled by default. It gets rid of the hitscan and makes bullets become real projectiles. There's something really badass about feeling the weapons having actual ballistics in a game, and it really shows how much it improves combat in a game like half-life. Black Mesa's animations might look more cleaner and desirable than MMod, but I think it's more about the actual gameplay. BM's gunplay can get tiring after a while, especially after you replay the hl2 games with MMod. The feeling of firing a shotgun is uncomparable.

    • @RIPzippyshare
      @RIPzippyshare 3 года назад +1

      I preferred HL2 mmod's gunplay better than BM

  • @ohfkgsofyes
    @ohfkgsofyes 4 года назад +11

    MMOD revolver was like BANG when Black mesa revolver was like SLAP

  • @gamingnerd1037
    @gamingnerd1037 4 года назад +6

    Black mesa has satisfying sounds and better reload animations

  • @some_european
    @some_european Год назад +2

    MMod seems to do the right thing with the revolver, as the hammer does move, but not exactly when it should.
    The MMod pistol somehow slides back its slide without being empty, which makes no sense.
    And the double fire also makes no sense, because you would need 3 "barrels"(one holds the shells) and a bigger bolt/2 bolts. Again, this is done to entertain the players.

  • @xxdrippy5522
    @xxdrippy5522 4 года назад +1

    Barney: shoorting in sky again gordon
    Gordon: ...
    Jesus: stop shoot me please

  • @mondiefromroblox2738
    @mondiefromroblox2738 4 года назад +7

    What If BM Has MMod

    • @ilovequake833
      @ilovequake833 4 года назад +2

      Nice idea.

    • @WAcrobat19
      @WAcrobat19 4 года назад

      Then playing vanilla becomes liquid dogshit

  • @rey4874
    @rey4874 4 года назад +1

    A wild underrated RUclipsr in its natural habitat appeared!

  • @ohfkgsofyes
    @ohfkgsofyes 4 года назад +3

    And mmod weapons have inspect anims, press reload when magazine is full

  • @ronanlorekeeper7226
    @ronanlorekeeper7226 4 года назад +2

    Honestly I like the normal HL2 and BM weapons over the ones from MMod.

  • @phobosthisofficial7235
    @phobosthisofficial7235 4 года назад +5

    This all weapons look good

  • @MauricioJara
    @MauricioJara 4 года назад +1

    I wish Gordon’s arms were as thinner as the ones in Half Life 2.

  • @falconsh92
    @falconsh92 4 года назад

    5:53
    🎶 There is something strange... in the neighborhood... Who you gone call? 🎶

  • @videosrus8631
    @videosrus8631 2 года назад

    "Look mummy, there's an aeroplane up in the sky"

  • @drewbrown3116
    @drewbrown3116 Год назад

    Black Mesa's matches Valve's vibes for reload animations better honestly, as much a both of these are well animated their own ways tho

  • @IdRatherNotHaveAHandleThankYou
    @IdRatherNotHaveAHandleThankYou 4 года назад +2

    Noclick, you mixed up the names for the Τau Cannon and the Gauss Gun. Great video though.

    • @noclick
      @noclick  4 года назад +1

      That is the same thing

  • @boiled_one0
    @boiled_one0 2 года назад

    Half-Life 2 and Black Mesa Sounds Like Jacket When You Switch Weaopns

  • @Rdboun
    @Rdboun 4 года назад +1

    Considering mmod is a mod of half life 2 and black mesa the considered remake of half life there's a big difference.

  • @HPalternetive
    @HPalternetive 4 года назад +12

    This mod is amazing, Found it today, was a bit complicated to download it but its awesome. Black Mesa so far I bought it in november and played aboth 40 hours and in terms of weaponery some of them are really feel nice But not all of them and the ones that are like the shotgun and glock arent near the satisfaction that MMod brings, you can just not compare it, try to play the updated half life with this, its freaking crazy how Im not getting bored from a game that Ive played like 86 hours probably 7 times...
    Black Mesa is about recreacting a freaking 90s game in crazy way... Just look at Xen, shooting is just not the greatest there and its alright..
    What is not alright is the level design sometimes, that doesnt have excuse.
    But it have very nice weapon remakes, and style.. yes some of them are broken like the Tau cannon being a bit lame and this freaking aim interference.
    Im still not sure if they had the time to work on it when theyve being focusing on building the goddamn game!
    MMOD, is just all about gameplay and guns and shooting and balancing... Its literally the only reason it was made so of course its going to out class black mesa, When its Goal was to out class as much games as they could in a one thing, only one thing.
    Black Mesa is a freaking entire game yet suppose to remake another game was built from scratch... MMod wasnt, and it still took couple of years to devalop hint why its going to be so good.
    But if you really play black mesa its still going to be amazed, and be entertained from the bigger picture, I deffinetly recomend both

    • @vladislav109
      @vladislav109 4 года назад

      yeah, obviously. Combat in BM did get a bit of an improvement with the newer source engine, though it can still feel...boring after a while? Once you fired the shotgun a hundred times you notice it doesn't really feel that good. But MMod, man, every gun feels amazing. I think there was this option called bulelt-realtime or something which is turned off by default, it gets rid of hitscan and makes all of your bullets become actual projectiles that get affected by distance and the environment. It just adds so much juice to the combat that it never stops being fun. I hope that one day, BM will also get a mod similar to MMod.

  • @chingapu7308
    @chingapu7308 Год назад

    Crowbar is the only unchangeable weapon

  • @eco5317
    @eco5317 3 года назад +1

    Why doesn't the safety lever fly off when gordon holds the grenade in his hand in mmod? He's clearly not holding it down with his thumb or hand

  • @europeiz
    @europeiz 4 года назад +4

    4K RTX 2080RTX i9-9999K 60FPS

  • @Ghost741SC
    @Ghost741SC 4 года назад +3

    3:59 poor H.E.C.U soldier 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

    • @bottomtextgaming1864
      @bottomtextgaming1864 4 года назад +1

      He's dead, And you're laughing. He's dead. And you're LAUGHING. You're sick man. Sick.

    • @Ghost741SC
      @Ghost741SC 4 года назад

      @@bottomtextgaming1864 easy mate don't be mad it's a game

  • @boiled_one0
    @boiled_one0 2 года назад

    Poor Black Mesa, Black Mesa Grenade Is Not High

  • @zoszos5
    @zoszos5 4 года назад

    1:11 why are rifle casings coming out of an SMG?

  • @RIPzippyshare
    @RIPzippyshare 2 года назад

    i never got to play the original HL1 and 2, i played Black Mesa first then after that i installed MMod on my HL2 to feel consistent

  • @user-jo5xq7kf8z
    @user-jo5xq7kf8z 4 года назад

    mmod sound and sfx amazing!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • @Coolsub13
    @Coolsub13 3 года назад +1

    Black mesa is original animations then the mmod copy the. Black mesa Weapon animation to hl 2 to make look cool

  • @theweirddudeonline4150
    @theweirddudeonline4150 4 года назад +2

    does mmod really have a gluon gun or was that just a SWEP

    • @noclick
      @noclick  4 года назад

      It has one

    • @mrpiratefox4497
      @mrpiratefox4497 4 года назад

      No, it doesnt

    • @itsmant3
      @itsmant3 3 года назад

      It has one but there is no model so they did put the ar2 model in there

  • @theooxaramirez4752
    @theooxaramirez4752 4 года назад +1

    BLACK MESA ❤

  • @sunl4ght
    @sunl4ght 4 года назад

    Half life 1 RTX 2080 vs Half life source

  • @grapepublic6420
    @grapepublic6420 4 года назад +3

    Mod had a gluon gun???

    • @voktam5517
      @voktam5517 4 года назад

      I never saw it in the game

  • @MinorLife10
    @MinorLife10 4 года назад

    Why in HL 2 gloves are gray? In HL 1 they were black. Hmm... Mb, Kleiner changed gloves?

    • @jbom
      @jbom 4 года назад +2

      Yes, new Mark V suit has black gloves.

    • @xxfalconarasxx5659
      @xxfalconarasxx5659 4 года назад +1

      Because it's not the same suit. The one in Half Life 1 is the Mark IV, while the one in Half Life 2 is the Mark V.

  • @animationkidsanimationshow1388
    @animationkidsanimationshow1388 4 года назад +1

    Lags hard in both

  • @Ghost741SC
    @Ghost741SC 4 года назад +1

    For me both 😁😁😁😁😁😁😁😁

    • @Vultonized7
      @Vultonized7 4 года назад +1

      How did we even get here

    • @Ghost741SC
      @Ghost741SC 4 года назад

      @@Vultonized7 whut? What do you mean

  • @jiraffe9600
    @jiraffe9600 4 года назад

    I would love to play mmod but It just doesn't run well. And i know its not my computer being weak because i have played a lot more taxing games.

  • @dwayne1625
    @dwayne1625 4 года назад

    Anyone else think the Shotgun in Black Mesa looks like shit.

    • @noclick
      @noclick  4 года назад +1

      That's your opinion! :)

    • @dwayne1625
      @dwayne1625 4 года назад

      Yea but, i mean don’t deny it.

    • @noclick
      @noclick  4 года назад +1

      @@dwayne1625 I think it looks alright, I wouldn't call it shit.

    • @peppermillers8361
      @peppermillers8361 4 года назад

      I like it, it looks mean and powerful. Also resembles the original shotgun pretty well.

    • @dwayne1625
      @dwayne1625 4 года назад

      Idk maybe i just have poor choice in weapon designs.

  • @bigbosssmiling7135
    @bigbosssmiling7135 4 года назад

    now do hl2 vs hl1

  • @phobosthisofficial7235
    @phobosthisofficial7235 4 года назад +2

    I already subed lol

  • @HPalternetive
    @HPalternetive 4 года назад

    also why does your black mesa has low fps, you dont have to play in max settings ypu knpw

    • @noclick
      @noclick  4 года назад

      It has low fps? I didn't notice that, I recorded the clips in 60FPS, I don't know what happened there, the game runs smooth while I record it.

    • @HPalternetive
      @HPalternetive 4 года назад

      noclick weird....
      I noticed a bit of a drop

    • @peppermillers8361
      @peppermillers8361 4 года назад

      it's lag since BM isn't super well optimized.

  • @DOOMSLAYER-h9p
    @DOOMSLAYER-h9p Месяц назад

    MMod is better

  • @roblox_talon_gaming1309
    @roblox_talon_gaming1309 Год назад

    mmod redux is better

    • @SheffMarkGmod
      @SheffMarkGmod Месяц назад

      bro thats the same thing as mmod exept with diffrent textures

  • @SamplrDesigns
    @SamplrDesigns 4 года назад +1

    Black mesa looks like a copycat)

    • @itsmant3
      @itsmant3 3 года назад

      Black mesa was made back in 2012

    • @DaisesTmrw
      @DaisesTmrw 3 года назад

      @@itsmant3 but half life 2 was made in 2008

    • @mrnooblol5163
      @mrnooblol5163 3 года назад

      @@DaisesTmrw what HL2 was made in 2004

    • @DaisesTmrw
      @DaisesTmrw 3 года назад

      @@mrnooblol5163 oh wait you’re right lol

  • @shiba2ndworlder
    @shiba2ndworlder 4 года назад

    Nice