I don't disagree but GTA also plays like it's made for edgy teenagers. And I'd rather the game play well and know how cars work than have a story that doesn't fit the game.
Astro Bot should win this year, there has never been a platformer this good and I don’t think an RPG deserves to win again until they surpass what BG3 did
@ I’m a massive nintendo owner I’ve played mario galaxy, sunshine, 3D World, 64, odyssey, hollow knight, shovel Knight, cup head, most of the ratchet and clank series, DK country series, yoshis island, woolly world, lots of Kirby games, rayman legends. Basically a whole bunch of them and Astro Bot surpasses them all imo
im a typical fps player so i thought i woulden't like bg3, but oh my god. For me it's the best game i have ever played with no competiotion. The replayebility is amazing, the strory is amazing, every singe thing about this game is perfect for me. So it easily takes the nr1 spot for me.
Really great video, love the ranking, especially because i know how hard it must have been to rank anything above the 8th place, as all the games in the top 8 are basically perfect in their own genre.
Nice vid man, I looked at the likes and sub count and was absolutely shocked, the quality was so high I thought you’d have wayyy more subs! Hope you keep growing (and going)!
Wukong was better but oh boy if astro bot wins ı'd be way happier cuz that game could teach aaa studios some lessons about how a FUN game supposed to be
Astro bit got my GIRLFRIEND into playing video games. She’s never played a video game before, but would wanna hang out with me specifically to just game ☠️☠️
Glad to see Breath of the Wild making the list. I still prefer Ocarina of Time, but BotW has to be one of the most innovative and influential games ever.
Man God Of War 2018 was a masterpiece and it did something impossibly rare in the industry . It reinvented a beloved franchise . R2D2 may be bigger budget more advanced and detailed but the risk which Santa Monica took with GOW is an achievement in itself. Ragnarok is a great game but GOW 2018 is almost flawless storytelling.
From 2004 to 2013, my list would be: Half-Life 2; FEAR; Hitman Blood Money; Portal; GTA IV; AC II; Fallout New Vegas; Deus Ex Human Revolution; Dishonored; The Swapper. From 2014 to 2023: Transistor; The Witcher 3; Dishonored 2; Prey; Celeste; RE2make; Bugsnax; It Takes Two; Elden Ring; Baldur's Gate 3.
man overwatch should not have won goty. Dark souls 3 and doom 2016 are masterpieces. Same with 2020, final fantasy 7 remake or doom eternal deserved. I'd say 2017 should have been nier automata as well, which is imo the best game ever made
@ Zelda is goated but only one game can make me tear up just by hearing the music, and that’s automata. It’s just the best story and music of any online thing ever created imo
@@firstorderblade4432 fs, the story and music of NieR is supreme, far away better than Zelda, but in terms of just being a game, Zelda is my favorite action adventure game ever made. It's probably my favorite game ever made, actually. Also the second playthrough of NieR is pretty weak comparatively to the other two until you get to chapter 9, which drags it down a bit in my eyes. Also the final Emil quest was not fun to initiate. But the story is goated, probably my second favorite in all of gaming
@@pogethedoge I assume you did the third playthrough of automata right? And got all 5 main endings? I understand why some people might not like the second playthrough because a lot of it is repeat content, but to me I see it as just more reason to play the most enjoyable game of all time for me, so I dont mind it at all. But the entirety of route C is easily the best story content ive ever seen. Playing as A2 is absolute peak, what happens to 2b and 9s is tear inducing, and the true ending is even more so
@@500本の歯を持つ恐竜を検索 sekiro gameplay Needs pure skills Plus it gives u excitement, challenge and fun Best sword gameplay I've seen and played and I've played tons of melee games In gameplay sekiro is god teir its one of the main elements why its became game of the year of 2019 lol Its my favorite from software game too
@@500本の歯を持つ恐竜を検索 even Skyrim has better gameplay then that for me Sekiro is overkill Baldurs gate 3 don't even have full 3d gameplay Despite having good graphics
Walking Dead is one of my fav games its story is literally on of the best iv played but the other games like dishonored and assasins creed were the more deserving ones, i agree.
It’s not a crime, BG3 was just a better game at every point than every Zelda ever realized, Zelda games are great and very great sometimes, but BG3 is the essence of 30 years of gaming putting in the same licence and game with everything who can makes a game/a story/a lore unforgivable and so freaking great. I’ve played a lot of games in my life, and the atmosphere, the replayability, the story telling, the design, the possibility in terms of scenario/gameplay/narrative choice etc are just beyond compare
Bg3 is better but i think totk is underrated even with 95 metacritic. It's much better than botw even if we criticize them in their own times but botw got all the attention. I think totk above any 2022 game too.
@@timotheeman they are both different games with very different game play mechanics and bg3 is turn based game play which is just not as good to most people the best thing about bg3 is the story but i still think totk should have won and also the zelda franchise is 38 years old and way more fleshed out and totk is a game you could play for years and not get bored me and so many people i know have been playing is still consistently for the entire time its been out and it has a lot more quests than bg3 and totk has sold 20.28 million copies and bg3 has only sold 15 Million Copies thats a 5 million difference and the combat is just way better in totk
nice video. Got to say that The Walking Dead games from Telltale are not what you are initially made to believe they are. I agree that there's a tad too much cinematics going on, and the decisions that supposedly impact many charaters'fates last for just a couple of episodes. I still have to finish Season 2 out of four but I agree that it's not a masterpiece of a game, and definitely deserves some praise but not as prestigious as a GOTY
For me is still black myth wukong. Then Elden ring DLC, the final fantasy 7 rebirth, then silent hill 2, then stellar blade, and finally Allan wake 2 or could be war hammer space marines. 🤷🏽♂️
Honestly though my list would be a lil different you can put any of these in any order and I'd respect that. the only 2 insults are Overwatch and Madden which we can all agree aren't GOTY worthy.
Elden Ring and Skyrim are in my top 5 games of all time. Lot of other phenomenal games on this list I enjoyed as well. But those 2 games I completed and replayed many times.
Shadow of the Erdtree is my favourite game this year, if it wasn’t an expansion it would be my GotY hands down, but I do have to give props to the other original titles this year like Astro Bot
I agree with your list but your takes on who should have won goty I think metal gear solid 3 should have won over san Andreas it is literally such a good story and took the top down gameplay of metal gear 2 and turned into a over the shoulder 3rd person game. I also think mario galaxy should have won in 2007 it is the best mario game and platformer I have ever played. For 2024 I would either give it to helldivers 2 for the straight thrill of playing it or to the elden ring dlc, in my opinion black myth wukong is a 8/10 most of the bosses are really easy and not very enjoyable then you get to yellow long and errlang and they suddenly skyrocket the difficulty up even though errlang and the final boss are.some banger bosses
Baldurs Gate is too low man. I get that this is all subjective, but no game on this list pushed the boundaries that BG3 did. A towering achievement that only elden ring could maybe hope to match.
GoW 2018 was a better game than RDR2. Though RDR2 is a technically better game, GoW 2018 is one of those games that you consider art... the story is beautiful, the gameplay was a banger, the bosses were amazing (Sigrun is fucking badass of a boss) and the change of tone of Kratos was interesing coming from the greek saga. Something I can't stand of RDR2 is that the missions treat you like you are retarded, although the details around this world are amazing. The story is great, but somehow it feels inconsistent, I love Arthur and Dutch tho
Exactly i dont understand the hate for that game. It was a experience like no other. The acting by Chris Judge brought tears to my eyes. Especially the blade of chaos scene. And what a Score man.
BG3 should be in the top 3 beyond Breath of the wild and The Witcher 3, but in my opinion, it’s a bigger and better rpg than these two, and its a niche game at base which managed to conquered the world of gaming with an incredible strength like no others niche games did before. My personal top 3 would have been Elden Ring, Skyrim and BG3
I tried playing it recently, but hadn’t the slightest clue what I was doing and got nowhere after 7 hours. One day I will try again, but I’ve decided I’m going to go through at least one Dark Souls first so I have some idea what I’m doing.
@@chambeetfirst 20 hrs you don't even need to understand how scaling works because standard is the best and the damage will depend almost totally on the upgrade level. So, grab whatever garbage and weapon you like the best, finish the cave of knowledge (tutorial) to get acquainted with the basics and go out into the vast beautiful world. All you need to do is: - look around more. For any possible sites of interest and for just taking in the view - listen carefully to rare NPCs you will come across. - read items descriptions. The history of the world and much of the plot is in there
WuKong should win GoTY for 2024. I loved SoTE and it’s definitely as big as a game, it’s still a DLC which means giving it to SoTE is basically just giving it to Elden Ring as a whole again cause you’re still using the same character you rushed Base game with. Maybe if you could start the DLC in the very beginning of the game I’d say otherwise. As much as I love Elden Ring, I don’t think it deserves to steal GoTY with a DLC in a year where actual quality games came out
you should pick goty games based on most awarded game each year. thats true goty. for example 2016 real goty was uncharted 4 which got 50% more awards than overwatch...
My eild take for goty stuff is that ee7 should have won 2017. Im honestly not a nintendo owner and while i can see breath of the wilds merits it just doesnt click for me. Put of all the 2017 game si think re7 is one of the best horror games i have played and one of the most passion filled games ive ever played
The most unfortunate thing to ever happen in TGA history was having both RDR2 and GoW 2018 release on the same year. Both games are absolute masterpieces and universally considered the greatest games of all time. I still prefer GoW over RDR2, having 100%'d both games (not the platinum for RDR2, screw Red Dead Online) but the gap is soooo damn narrow I have my doubts from time to time. Great vid man, keep it up!
I think they are both perfect in their own genre but I prefer RDR2 just slightly more than GoW. Getting the 100% in RDR2 is crazy work though, takes way too long imo so massive respect for the time you put into it!
Bioshock should have been in top 5 tbh though...nonetheless elden ring is definitely no 1...no doubt ...and bg3 god of war and overwatch are in the right spot
Here are my games of the year list 2011-Skyrim 2012-Darksiders 2 2013-Bioshock Infinite 2014-Dragon Age Inquisition 2015-Pillars of Eternity 2016-Final Fantasy 15 2017-Tales of Berseria 2018-God of War 2019-Fire Emblem Three Houses (haven’t played it but heard it’s really great) 2020-Ghost of Tsushima 2021-Tales of Arise 2022-God of War Ragnarok 2023- a tie between Hogwarts Legacy and Baldur’s Gate 3 2024-a tie between Dragon’s Dogma 2 and Final Fantasy 7 Rebirth
Ha ...you on coke ? You only play 1 system and your listing your best playstation game of the year ? Lol...there is a reason why god of war is shit...no one is gonna play it after 1 time....thats why elden ring win over ragnarok
What makes you put a game above Sekiro if you haven't even played it? Your opinion would look valid if only you had played the games you picked to be "The game of the year".
Makes a list of "Worst GotW to Worst" and puts the only game on the list to win EVERY award it was up for (and it went up for all of them) midway down the list and also having opinions on games they never played. Yeah. This is a bad list. Ending midway, you got your eNgAgEmEnT you wanted.
As impressive Skyrim was, the combat is so dated and pretty shtty without mod, the world design is bland and gray with all rocks too, I'll swap it with BG3 in this list. And I don't like Sekiro, I don't like the map design that you sneak around corners of just a castle, I don't like the character, and combat feel monopoly, repeatitive with parrying, enemies are 90% humanoid is boring, and it's short with only like 15 bosses. I don't like even the gears system, I don't like how it doesn't have armor and stuffs only weapons. For the game with similar fedal Japan souls-like, Nioh 2 is so good and an underrated gem compare to it. So many Yokai to fight and interesting gears and skills system
I do think that in the context and time of when it was released. There is a case to be made for ow to br game of the year. While i would not pick it (ds3 for me) the atmosphere around it was just insane. The hype and popularity it had were comparible and even surpassed prime fortnite imo. Say what you want about fortnite, it didn't singlehandedly kill every single competitor it had
Personally I don't think hype means you have a goty game as multiplayer games usually have more hype/players than single player games and you can't experience the ow that won goty anymore as it has changed so much. Meanwhile you can still play every other winner in the same way it was when it won the award which is why I think live service games shouldn't win the award.
I get so upset knowing god of war won over red dead 2. I love both games but i truly believe red dead is way better when it comes to the writing, details and replay value. I beat red dead 2 about 3 times and i only beat god of war once and i never see myself going back to it. Also till this day more people still talk more about red dead 2 over god of war.
Man GOW 2018 has one of the best story and redemption arc for a character in videogames . You feel its full depth and hype when you have played the previous trilogy. R2D2 may be a bigger game and more mature in some ways but the pressure to live up to its predecessor and redefining the character of Kratos and the child parent relationship and cycle of violence was chefs kiss. R2D2 may be more in depth and gritty and for some more impactful but GOW has its own emotional beat and subject issues. I already commented why GOW 2018 is something incredibly rare in industry because it reinvented a franchise, brought one shot camera and felt more like a movie. R2D2 is maybe more deserving for GOTY for some people but that doesnt take away anything what GOW 2018 achieved.
Small? Elden Ring is anything but, and Ragnarok was amazing but all they did was basically improved and expand upon what they already did back in 2018. 💯🙏😎😒🙄 P.S I hope Astro Bot wins GOTY 🏆 🙏 💯 😎
I disagree about the combat in Witcher 3, it’s pretty terrible imo. Don’t need to research anything to beat any of the monsters so far though I haven’t beaten the entire game yet
@@gabagool3928 I wish there was even harder difficulty than Death March, once I got hold of it it was not that difficult. But I agree that you have to use bestiary and oils
@@yannispirou101 tbh i didn't play royal yet due to playing p5 on release and consuming do much content regarding 5 before royal release, thinking it was just a rerelease i brushed it off. until last week i thought it was just a rerelease. oh boy was i wrong. but yes i agree Royal is on par. but still metaphor cuts down the time for leveling up your social links and upgrading your stats and progression in general. and imo rewards you heavily in comparison.
@@MostafaAliAce yea, Metaphor generally flows better in every way, both gameplay and story are paced better than in any Persona and I'd argue most JRPGs even lol, I think Metaphor is a good example of what Atlus should look up to for Persona 6
Sorry but the Witcher that high is crazy. I am a gamer, I like every type of game. The Witcher is probably the most boring game on the list. The combat sucks, you want to play for the story but nothing sucks you in other than the story and it’s just not worth it
I agree. Elden Ring is the best game ever made. I know a portion of the souls community likes to be pretentious and act like Elden Ring is a “C tier” souls game just because its the popular one. Like come on lol. Its the best souls game by a pretty good margin. We all know this. And the best video game of all time. Botw top 3 is a great pick as well. I will say that Baldur’s Gate 3 is just a little low, I’d have it #4 right above Skyrim.
GTA V story feels like it's made for edgy teenagers
GTA IV story feels like it's made for actual adults
True but Obviously they won't get it
Man whole gta v is just satire on the modern society and adults ofc understand this
I don't disagree but GTA also plays like it's made for edgy teenagers. And I'd rather the game play well and know how cars work than have a story that doesn't fit the game.
Yep GTAIV was amazing, GTA V whilst fun don’t think it makes my top 3
Love that you included the Spike awards. It just doesn't feel right stopping at 2014
Astro Bot should win this year, there has never been a platformer this good and I don’t think an RPG deserves to win again until they surpass what BG3 did
You don't play a lot of platformers, don't you?
@ I’m a massive nintendo owner I’ve played mario galaxy, sunshine, 3D World, 64, odyssey, hollow knight, shovel Knight, cup head, most of the ratchet and clank series, DK country series, yoshis island, woolly world, lots of Kirby games, rayman legends. Basically a whole bunch of them and Astro Bot surpasses them all imo
I consider Astro bot more of a colectathon than a platformer and that’s why I loved it.
Literally any nintendo platformer outclasses it hard.
@@SapphicMysterie I disagree
Nobody's talking about the sneaky loop at 6:20 when he was talking about Deathloop. Very crafty!
Small editing mistake that I didn't even realise until you pointed it out 😅Thanks for letting me know! (definitely intential)
im a typical fps player so i thought i woulden't like bg3, but oh my god. For me it's the best game i have ever played with no competiotion. The replayebility is amazing, the strory is amazing, every singe thing about this game is perfect for me. So it easily takes the nr1 spot for me.
that's dope man, it really has a lot of potential to climb on my list just because it's so replayable but nice that it's your nr1!
Really great video, love the ranking, especially because i know how hard it must have been to rank anything above the 8th place, as all the games in the top 8 are basically perfect in their own genre.
Thank you so much! It was quite challenge and did take a lot of time to figure it all out as they really all are contenders of best game ever
RDR2 deserved it 100%
Overwatch winning GOTY 2016 was nothing more than a bad joke.
Yeah, but those first couple of years of OW were really great. Uncharted should’ve been GOTY but I ain’t that mad at OW
overwatch deserved it.
@@ramen3643Deserved nothing
@@Emra.1 it absolutely deserved it. You're just looking at it's current state and judging based on that.
@ramen3643 Over Uncharted 4, Civ VI, DOOM, Dishonered 2, BF1 and Dark Souls 3? Yeah not even close there m8.
Nice vid man, I looked at the likes and sub count and was absolutely shocked, the quality was so high I thought you’d have wayyy more subs! Hope you keep growing (and going)!
Thank you so much, it really means a lot! I'm trying as much as I can to make high quality videos!
What's your 2024 GOTY???
Squirrel with a gun
wukong
Wukong was better but oh boy if astro bot wins ı'd be way happier cuz that game could teach aaa studios some lessons about how a FUN game supposed to be
FF7 Rebirth, but I'm biased as a FF fan
Astro bot
Cool video bro, i liked hearing anothers' views on GOTY winners like this, in a thorough way even including runner ups. 👍
Astro bit got my GIRLFRIEND into playing video games. She’s never played a video game before, but would wanna hang out with me specifically to just game ☠️☠️
Glad to see Breath of the Wild making the list. I still prefer Ocarina of Time, but BotW has to be one of the most innovative and influential games ever.
It was just a zelda open world game dude, calm down lol
Am surprised Lies of p is not on this list if you like Souls type games
It never won goty why wld it be on the list
God of War Ragnarok got what its predecessor did to Red Dead Redemption 2
BTW very High Quality and Detailed Content
I don't think it was as big of a robbery as RDR2 but ragnarok is still outstanding
Man God Of War 2018 was a masterpiece and it did something impossibly rare in the industry . It reinvented a beloved franchise . R2D2 may be bigger budget more advanced and detailed but the risk which Santa Monica took with GOW is an achievement in itself. Ragnarok is a great game but GOW 2018 is almost flawless storytelling.
4 open world games at the top 4. It show that what's best that games do is immersing you in their world.
From 2004 to 2013, my list would be: Half-Life 2; FEAR; Hitman Blood Money; Portal; GTA IV; AC II; Fallout New Vegas; Deus Ex Human Revolution; Dishonored; The Swapper.
From 2014 to 2023: Transistor; The Witcher 3; Dishonored 2; Prey; Celeste; RE2make; Bugsnax; It Takes Two; Elden Ring; Baldur's Gate 3.
man overwatch should not have won goty. Dark souls 3 and doom 2016 are masterpieces. Same with 2020, final fantasy 7 remake or doom eternal deserved. I'd say 2017 should have been nier automata as well, which is imo the best game ever made
I don't think NieR deserved to win, but it absolutely should've been nominated. My second favorite game of that year, and definitely in my top 10 oat.
@ Zelda is goated but only one game can make me tear up just by hearing the music, and that’s automata. It’s just the best story and music of any online thing ever created imo
@@firstorderblade4432 fs, the story and music of NieR is supreme, far away better than Zelda, but in terms of just being a game, Zelda is my favorite action adventure game ever made. It's probably my favorite game ever made, actually. Also the second playthrough of NieR is pretty weak comparatively to the other two until you get to chapter 9, which drags it down a bit in my eyes. Also the final Emil quest was not fun to initiate. But the story is goated, probably my second favorite in all of gaming
@@pogethedoge I assume you did the third playthrough of automata right? And got all 5 main endings? I understand why some people might not like the second playthrough because a lot of it is repeat content, but to me I see it as just more reason to play the most enjoyable game of all time for me, so I dont mind it at all.
But the entirety of route C is easily the best story content ive ever seen. Playing as A2 is absolute peak, what happens to 2b and 9s is tear inducing, and the true ending is even more so
Personally
2016 You should also include titanfall 2
2020 Replace FF7R for Hades
Amazing list, only change I would make is switch Sekiro with Baldurs Gate 3
In gameplay sekiro negs
@@yashmehta4087 BG3 gameplay has way more variety and depth in it compared to rhythmically pressing buttons
@@500本の歯を持つ恐竜を検索 sekiro gameplay
Needs pure skills
Plus it gives u excitement, challenge and fun
Best sword gameplay I've seen and played and I've played tons of melee games
In gameplay sekiro is god teir its one of the main elements why its became game of the year of 2019 lol
Its my favorite from software game too
@@500本の歯を持つ恐竜を検索 even Skyrim has better gameplay then that for me
Sekiro is overkill
Baldurs gate 3 don't even have full 3d gameplay
Despite having good graphics
My Top 3 would be:
1 Elden Ring
2 Skyrim
3 Witcher 3
Walking Dead is one of my fav games its story is literally on of the best iv played but the other games like dishonored and assasins creed were the more deserving ones, i agree.
honestly, the games in the top 8 are all just so incredibly good that it just comes down to personal preference at that point
Best story telling imo but as a game I prefer the other games
Great list! My ranking is mostly similar but with bg3 higher.
For Madden 04 winning gane of the uear is absolutely crazy to me when Halo 2 came out that year.
i legitimately cannot understand anyone ranking BOTW over BG 3 when it simply does everything better.
totk not winning over baulders gate 3 is a crime among man and super mario galaxy not winning is just so damn sad
It’s not a crime, BG3 was just a better game at every point than every Zelda ever realized, Zelda games are great and very great sometimes, but BG3 is the essence of 30 years of gaming putting in the same licence and game with everything who can makes a game/a story/a lore unforgivable and so freaking great. I’ve played a lot of games in my life, and the atmosphere, the replayability, the story telling, the design, the possibility in terms of scenario/gameplay/narrative choice etc are just beyond compare
Bg3 is better but i think totk is underrated even with 95 metacritic. It's much better than botw even if we criticize them in their own times but botw got all the attention. I think totk above any 2022 game too.
@@timotheeman they are both different games with very different game play mechanics and bg3 is turn based game play which is just not as good to most people the best thing about bg3 is the story but i still think totk should have won and also the zelda franchise is 38 years old and way more fleshed out and totk is a game you could play for years and not get bored me and so many people i know have been playing is still consistently for the entire time its been out and it has a lot more quests than bg3 and totk has sold 20.28 million copies and bg3 has only sold 15 Million Copies thats a 5 million difference and the combat is just way better in totk
Dont say that, gatekeeping BG3 fanboys will attack you like its a crime. Its a great game but also way to overhyped by social media.
bro predicted the future 😭😭
Great video mate!
I love your ranking here 🗿 awesome job
Thank you so much, really means a lot!
nice video. Got to say that The Walking Dead games from Telltale are not what you are initially made to believe they are. I agree that there's a tad too much cinematics going on, and the decisions that supposedly impact many charaters'fates last for just a couple of episodes. I still have to finish Season 2 out of four but I agree that it's not a masterpiece of a game, and definitely deserves some praise but not as prestigious as a GOTY
For me is still black myth wukong. Then Elden ring DLC, the final fantasy 7 rebirth, then silent hill 2, then stellar blade, and finally Allan wake 2 or could be war hammer space marines. 🤷🏽♂️
great list. keep it up 💪
Mgs3 not winning 2004 game of the year is a joke. It was way ahead of it's time.
Man just seeing all these games brings back such good memories, also Alien Isolation(2014) is a horror masterpiece and still looks fantastic in 2024.
Good list overall.
My top 3 would be reversed actually.
Botw, Witcher and Elden.
Btw, 2006 goty was twilight princess no?
Totally valid opinion, in 2006 oblivion won
Honestly though my list would be a lil different you can put any of these in any order and I'd respect that. the only 2 insults are Overwatch and Madden which we can all agree aren't GOTY worthy.
Elden Ring and Skyrim are in my top 5 games of all time. Lot of other phenomenal games on this list I enjoyed as well. But those 2 games I completed and replayed many times.
Shadow of the Erdtree is my favourite game this year, if it wasn’t an expansion it would be my GotY hands down, but I do have to give props to the other original titles this year like Astro Bot
METAPHOR REFANTAZIO GOTY CALLING IT NOW
I agree with your list but your takes on who should have won goty I think metal gear solid 3 should have won over san Andreas it is literally such a good story and took the top down gameplay of metal gear 2 and turned into a over the shoulder 3rd person game. I also think mario galaxy should have won in 2007 it is the best mario game and platformer I have ever played. For 2024 I would either give it to helldivers 2 for the straight thrill of playing it or to the elden ring dlc, in my opinion black myth wukong is a 8/10 most of the bosses are really easy and not very enjoyable then you get to yellow long and errlang and they suddenly skyrocket the difficulty up even though errlang and the final boss are.some banger bosses
Outer Wilds is game of the year, every year.
"I'll be only talking about original RE4"
Proceeds to use remake gameplay as broll. Yeah that makes sense.
Baldurs Gate is too low man. I get that this is all subjective, but no game on this list pushed the boundaries that BG3 did. A towering achievement that only elden ring could maybe hope to match.
Solid list
Ghost of Tsushima should have won 2020
Nah Hades and Doom Eternal were way better
Indeed
Nah ghost of Tsushima won player choice aka gamers picked that game only reason TLOU part 2 won GOTY was because it was pushing a woke agenda
GoW 2018 was a better game than RDR2. Though RDR2 is a technically better game, GoW 2018 is one of those games that you consider art... the story is beautiful, the gameplay was a banger, the bosses were amazing (Sigrun is fucking badass of a boss) and the change of tone of Kratos was interesing coming from the greek saga. Something I can't stand of RDR2 is that the missions treat you like you are retarded, although the details around this world are amazing. The story is great, but somehow it feels inconsistent, I love Arthur and Dutch tho
Exactly i dont understand the hate for that game. It was a experience like no other. The acting by Chris Judge brought tears to my eyes. Especially the blade of chaos scene. And what a Score man.
BG3 should be in the top 3 beyond Breath of the wild and The Witcher 3, but in my opinion, it’s a bigger and better rpg than these two, and its a niche game at base which managed to conquered the world of gaming with an incredible strength like no others niche games did before.
My personal top 3 would have been Elden Ring, Skyrim and BG3
The Witcher 3 is the last time my ouch for goty ever won also that game and Skyrim are my top 2
Elden ring and the Witcher 3 top 1&2 = goated list, gg.
BG3 is way too low
well it IS a really niche game, but all these games are pretty much perfect in their own genre
If you think it's higher that's dope but I think it's at a good spot and still one of the greatest games of all time
@@theultimatep1e40 skyrim and oblivion are nowhere near perfect in rpgs
@@500本の歯を持つ恐竜を検索in my opinion
3.bg3
2.sekiro
1.elden ring
As it should be
great List, but i would put Witcher 3 over Elder Ring
Respectable, witcher is soo good
Witcher is the king.
Elden ring is a god.
Oblivion at the place it deserves, enough for me to like this video
DLCs should never be considered for GOTY. that just doesnt make any sense. that not a individual game but part of another game.
Props for putting Elden Ring at #1. I used to hate on the game (because I was a little salty tbf), but it's so magnificent that it deserves number 1.
Elden ring truly comes as close as you can get to perfection in my opinion
I tried playing it recently, but hadn’t the slightest clue what I was doing and got nowhere after 7 hours.
One day I will try again, but I’ve decided I’m going to go through at least one Dark Souls first so I have some idea what I’m doing.
@@Dalto_ It still has a lot of flaws though...
@@benthehen-uy7fj it does but nothing beats the first playthrough
@@chambeetfirst 20 hrs you don't even need to understand how scaling works because standard is the best and the damage will depend almost totally on the upgrade level.
So, grab whatever garbage and weapon you like the best, finish the cave of knowledge (tutorial) to get acquainted with the basics and go out into the vast beautiful world. All you need to do is:
- look around more. For any possible sites of interest and for just taking in the view
- listen carefully to rare NPCs you will come across.
- read items descriptions. The history of the world and much of the plot is in there
WuKong should win GoTY for 2024. I loved SoTE and it’s definitely as big as a game, it’s still a DLC which means giving it to SoTE is basically just giving it to Elden Ring as a whole again cause you’re still using the same character you rushed Base game with. Maybe if you could start the DLC in the very beginning of the game I’d say otherwise. As much as I love Elden Ring, I don’t think it deserves to steal GoTY with a DLC in a year where actual quality games came out
It’s probably the worst game on the list unfortunately
Wither 3 and Mass Effect Legendary Edition is the best ever but i did not play Elder Ring
I don't know how rdr2 didn't win
Sony bias. Same reason TLOU 2 won
@@justadictatorridingonanuke3714 Ghost of Tsushima, which many people wanted it to win, was a Sony game as well
@yannispirou101 the Sony bias between GoT and TLOU 2 cancel each other out. I'm ngl GoT also didn't deserve to win that year either
Because God of war is the better game?
@@tomgu2285 it wasn't though
you should pick goty games based on most awarded game each year. thats true goty. for example 2016 real goty was uncharted 4 which got 50% more awards than overwatch...
My eild take for goty stuff is that ee7 should have won 2017. Im honestly not a nintendo owner and while i can see breath of the wilds merits it just doesnt click for me. Put of all the 2017 game si think re7 is one of the best horror games i have played and one of the most passion filled games ive ever played
I wouldnt even put Witcher 3 or Elden Ring in my top 20 lol. Overrated slop all the normies love so much. Sekiro can maybe go at like 18th place.
Walking Dead is my favorite.
The most unfortunate thing to ever happen in TGA history was having both RDR2 and GoW 2018 release on the same year. Both games are absolute masterpieces and universally considered the greatest games of all time. I still prefer GoW over RDR2, having 100%'d both games (not the platinum for RDR2, screw Red Dead Online) but the gap is soooo damn narrow I have my doubts from time to time.
Great vid man, keep it up!
I think they are both perfect in their own genre but I prefer RDR2 just slightly more than GoW. Getting the 100% in RDR2 is crazy work though, takes way too long imo so massive respect for the time you put into it!
Putting San Andreas so low on the ranking feels criminal but hey man it’s your opinion
Personally I would've loved Bloodborne to win, but Witcher 3 is good too
the camera in sekiro is dredful
Wukong is the lowest rated game on MC ever nominated for GOTY. It doesn't have a chance.
Bioshock should have been in top 5 tbh though...nonetheless elden ring is definitely no 1...no doubt ...and bg3 god of war and overwatch are in the right spot
Here are my games of the year list
2011-Skyrim
2012-Darksiders 2
2013-Bioshock Infinite
2014-Dragon Age Inquisition
2015-Pillars of Eternity
2016-Final Fantasy 15
2017-Tales of Berseria
2018-God of War
2019-Fire Emblem Three Houses (haven’t played it but heard it’s really great)
2020-Ghost of Tsushima
2021-Tales of Arise
2022-God of War Ragnarok
2023- a tie between Hogwarts Legacy and Baldur’s Gate 3
2024-a tie between Dragon’s Dogma 2 and Final Fantasy 7 Rebirth
From yr list I'm sure you have only played games on the playstation
@ True. Even games like Skyrim, God of War and Ragnarok and Baldur’s Gate 3 are considered the greatest games of those years.
Ha ...you on coke ? You only play 1 system and your listing your best playstation game of the year ? Lol...there is a reason why god of war is shit...no one is gonna play it after 1 time....thats why elden ring win over ragnarok
Hard to put almost on the same lvl Hogwart Legacy and BG3
What makes you put a game above Sekiro if you haven't even played it? Your opinion would look valid if only you had played the games you picked to be "The game of the year".
I love Zelda Breath of wild now in 2022🤩
Last of us 2 hate till i end
What about the S.T.A.L.K.E.R. 2 that will release 20 of November???
I dont know why but imo uncharted 2>>uncharted 4
MGS3 and HL2 are so much better than San Andreas. San Andreas is great but HL2 and MGS3 20 years later are still top 20 games of all time easily
Baldur's Gate 3
Unfortunately I never played Bg3 I just know that you can have sex with a bear in the game so 10 out of 10
BG3 lower than sekiro? Average fromsoft fan take lmao. I'm not surprised.
I have to say, I am EXTREMELY satisfied with your list and this year predictions.
Insta subscribe, fellow shieldbearer 😅
Baldur's Gate 3 is easily my number 1, followed by Breath of the Wild and Elden Ring too
Makes a list of "Worst GotW to Worst" and puts the only game on the list to win EVERY award it was up for (and it went up for all of them) midway down the list and also having opinions on games they never played.
Yeah. This is a bad list. Ending midway, you got your eNgAgEmEnT you wanted.
6:47 no top 3
As impressive Skyrim was, the combat is so dated and pretty shtty without mod, the world design is bland and gray with all rocks too, I'll swap it with BG3 in this list.
And I don't like Sekiro, I don't like the map design that you sneak around corners of just a castle, I don't like the character, and combat feel monopoly, repeatitive with parrying, enemies are 90% humanoid is boring, and it's short with only like 15 bosses. I don't like even the gears system, I don't like how it doesn't have armor and stuffs only weapons.
For the game with similar fedal Japan souls-like, Nioh 2 is so good and an underrated gem compare to it. So many Yokai to fight and interesting gears and skills system
I do think that in the context and time of when it was released. There is a case to be made for ow to br game of the year. While i would not pick it (ds3 for me) the atmosphere around it was just insane. The hype and popularity it had were comparible and even surpassed prime fortnite imo. Say what you want about fortnite, it didn't singlehandedly kill every single competitor it had
Personally I don't think hype means you have a goty game as multiplayer games usually have more hype/players than single player games and you can't experience the ow that won goty anymore as it has changed so much. Meanwhile you can still play every other winner in the same way it was when it won the award which is why I think live service games shouldn't win the award.
I get so upset knowing god of war won over red dead 2. I love both games but i truly believe red dead is way better when it comes to the writing, details and replay value. I beat red dead 2 about 3 times and i only beat god of war once and i never see myself going back to it. Also till this day more people still talk more about red dead 2 over god of war.
Man GOW 2018 has one of the best story and redemption arc for a character in videogames . You feel its full depth and hype when you have played the previous trilogy. R2D2 may be a bigger game and more mature in some ways but the pressure to live up to its predecessor and redefining the character of Kratos and the child parent relationship and cycle of violence was chefs kiss. R2D2 may be more in depth and gritty and for some more impactful but GOW has its own emotional beat and subject issues. I already commented why GOW 2018 is something incredibly rare in industry because it reinvented a franchise, brought one shot camera and felt more like a movie. R2D2 is maybe more deserving for GOTY for some people but that doesnt take away anything what GOW 2018 achieved.
Replay value has been a problem with modern cinematic games especially Sony games. I dont think these games are made with replayability in mind.
Small? Elden Ring is anything but, and Ragnarok was amazing but all they did was basically improved and expand upon what they already did back in 2018. 💯🙏😎😒🙄 P.S I hope Astro Bot wins GOTY 🏆 🙏 💯 😎
Peak video
the last of us won the goty of 2013, not gta 5
Rebirth is gonna win 🏆 10/10
It takes 2 too low
Madden 04 is great
God war best one
I disagree about the combat in Witcher 3, it’s pretty terrible imo. Don’t need to research anything to beat any of the monsters so far though I haven’t beaten the entire game yet
Play on deathmarch, makes you take combat more seriously and use your bestiary, oils and potions
@@gabagool3928 I wish there was even harder difficulty than Death March, once I got hold of it it was not that difficult. But I agree that you have to use bestiary and oils
Why do uusegameplay of the remakes of the games when ur talking about the originals? That doesn't make any sense at all
Gow 2018 is the worst goty imo
you missed metaphor refantazio :3
I didn't play it so I didn't include it but I'm definitely going to check it out!
@@Dalto_ brooo you musttt, if you find persona 5 a contender to GOTY. metaphor is steps higher than persona 5 in terms of quality
@@MostafaAliAce Ehhh it didn't feel steps higher in quality imo, it felt pretty much on par with Royal for me
@@yannispirou101 tbh i didn't play royal yet due to playing p5 on release and consuming do much content regarding 5 before royal release, thinking it was just a rerelease i brushed it off. until last week i thought it was just a rerelease. oh boy was i wrong. but yes i agree Royal is on par. but still metaphor cuts down the time for leveling up your social links and upgrading your stats and progression in general. and imo rewards you heavily in comparison.
@@MostafaAliAce yea, Metaphor generally flows better in every way, both gameplay and story are paced better than in any Persona and I'd argue most JRPGs even lol, I think Metaphor is a good example of what Atlus should look up to for Persona 6
what game is this 0:05?
i think black myth wukong.
Sorry but the Witcher that high is crazy. I am a gamer, I like every type of game. The Witcher is probably the most boring game on the list. The combat sucks, you want to play for the story but nothing sucks you in other than the story and it’s just not worth it
That's your shitty opinion
Crazy to have objectively wrong opinion
@ it literally has the worst combat and menu system out of any game on the list.
@sergiodiaz2886 it can have the worst combat and menu (that's your shit opinion) and it's still better than your favorite game
Respect the list , l would put uncharted 2 a bit higher and loz botw second under witcher and elder ring third
Dope, it's really just a tossup of which games you prefer!
I agree. Elden Ring is the best game ever made. I know a portion of the souls community likes to be pretentious and act like Elden Ring is a “C tier” souls game just because its the popular one. Like come on lol. Its the best souls game by a pretty good margin. We all know this. And the best video game of all time.
Botw top 3 is a great pick as well. I will say that Baldur’s Gate 3 is just a little low, I’d have it #4 right above Skyrim.
People put their personal bias into the equation. Elden Ring is not my personal favorite Souls game, but I realize it is the best.
@Childofbhaal thank you man. If only there were more people like you
Elden Ring is great but it's not as great as bloodborne
@nerdyjawsh BB is overrated af by its zealous fans. It's a great game but it has its flaws, and Elden Ring is just ... greater.
played spacemarine 2 yet?
Hell yeah goated game
This is one of the reasons why awards are decided by industry professionals, not fans. Fortunately.
Hot take: Arkham Asylum is way better than Uncharted 2
Those Batman games got snubbed all the time, probably the best series to never win an award
Yeah I played the Arkham games last year for the first time and they are all amazing
Hecks no it isn’t
@andrewbryant1388 It is better by a mile away!