I think they just forgot that it’s just the first person to three in a row, and that the next person doesn’t get to actually compete their turn. You see that when Ash would put an X to complete her row Mat would go and put an O for finish his. The problem is that the game would end after ash complicated her row, and May wouldn’t get a turn. That’s the mistake they made.
@@MissCaraMint Honestly though a ruleset that works like that would be a bit more fair to the one who goes second than the current rules. For both of them to forget the rules in the same way is pretty interesting.
19:17 "This reminds me of when Stephanie and I first met. She 'forced' me to play Portal to test what my thought process was" What an interesting mating ritual 🤔
21:24 "You're right there, I mean, beep. **sad beep** Beep, come on, beep! " I love that someone who sounds exactly like JoCat is acting like an exit detector who breaks out of character when they get frustrated 😂
No, don't change the intro. Steph is still a part of the team. She may not be on cam, but she is willing to eat sawdust for you. Whether or not she knows it.
1:10:22 "The obelisk of knowledge" I love the fact you were able to bring Steph along for that rare piece of "mature content", since she often gets flustered with that kinda thing 😂
you are legit the first person to figure that stop sign puzzle out, everyone i have watched playing it has just scribbled over it (even my friends did because it made no sense)
i played the game before the new real life cutscene, so that was funny to watch, but yeah im surprised you also understood what the last puzzle was witrh the points, i did it for about 30 minutes just doing trial and error lol
I'm sure I'm not the only one who tries to figure out when they shoot GTLive and I must say, the lack of Halloween decorations in this one helps a little 😂
I'm so happy to see steph make an appearance!! I love mirror mat and ash but Matpat and Steph's chemistry always beings so much energy and it's all so nostalgic too
There was an episode of dont tell the bride in the UK where the groom had the wedding in a hedge maze. It was actually really nice as there were memories inside to help guide here through she was so emotional by the time she got to the ceremony
i have seen tons of people play this game, and none of them figured out that the shapes in the diamond puzzle was ordered by points. they all went back to the wedding area and remembered/wrote down what order they came in
This was a truly amazing episode of GTLive! Glad to see Steph back, even if just this once, and the puzzle shenanigans were truly, genuinely quite fun :D I wish you all, Matthew (and Mirror Matthew) and Steph and Ash and Oliver and of course Skeeeep, along with the rest of Team Theorist, well!
I watched the first 10 minutes of gameplay, and then I had to download the game and check it out for myself. Thanks Mat for sharing this game! I had a blast playing it and then watching you play it. Your reactions were golden
i love how in the end of the game you draw a giant p***s and then the game is understanding it, and then you understand "the looker" stands for because you looked at the thing you have just dawned
How meta is this episode beginning with the topic that Stephanie isn't in the show anymore and they need to change the intro and end the episode with Stephanie joins to show how her place in the intro is the right place
Wow Mat powered through these. The Sun-Earth thing is a nice detail if intended. Also I love the concept of Ash sitting there for 2 hours, trying not to laugh at or give away the ending that they looked up in advance!
@16:22 mat pat draws the most perfect bell curve you cannot escape the big brain neediness here. My professor was right I’m seeing stats everywhere now help lol
Steph is back! Sort of. Cool to see her again and this is certainly a great game to have her back for. Side note this is the first time I've seen anyone actually find the logic of the book in the middle of the hedge maze. Everyone else just trials and errors.
The witness will be forever one of my favorite games. I just loved everything about it, and the Looker is one of the best satire games ever made as well.
It’s hilarious to me that I was legit thinking “man they should change this intro,” and the first 20 seconds was Matt going, “we should really update that intro soon…” 😂
Sttteeeeeepppphhhhh! I'm so glad I watched Jacksepticeye play this, because it made me want to watch Matt play it, which meant I got to see a rare Steph Returns episode! 😁 And who knew I needed "Steph Helps Matt Count Corners" in my life? 😂 Quick, Ash, give them more comedic puzzle games to entice more Steph-isodes! 😁
I like how Matthew points out that the intro needs to be changed because it had been a long time since Stephanie was on the show in the episode she joins in again
I honestly wish there were more games like the witness or this, it's one of the few puzzle games i really enjoyed, especially the environmental puzzles... it was so good!
52:00 I'm not sure what's more impressive, MatPat's unforced tic tac toe error, or both of them not realizing that it wasn't a draw.
I was screaming
I was too! I was so frustrated! 😐
Right?! Literally threw my hands up haha
I had to rewind that moment to make sure I saw that correctly! How did they not see Ash’s clear win?
Me too I was so confused
So weird to think there's a whole new group of GTLive fans who haven't seen Steph
oh yeah... that's so crazy to me
I miss her contributions, the streams just aren't the same without some protip action 😂
Who is the lady in the intro?
@@tylerbremer6696 Steph, matpats wife :)
That is _really_ strange
Matt saying their game of Tic Tac Toe ended up tied, when Ash was one move away from winning, is a travesty that I demand be rectified!
Yeah I was going to say the samething. He just said it cause he knew he had lost and didn't want to admit defeat!!
What time does this happen??
@@markusaurelius4015 at about 51:28
I know!!!!!
It's also a "complete" game, two people who know what they're doing will always end in a draw
I love how they didn’t realize that Ash was going to win tik tac toe and just called it a draw
I think they just forgot that it’s just the first person to three in a row, and that the next person doesn’t get to actually compete their turn. You see that when Ash would put an X to complete her row Mat would go and put an O for finish his. The problem is that the game would end after ash complicated her row, and May wouldn’t get a turn. That’s the mistake they made.
@@MissCaraMint Honestly though a ruleset that works like that would be a bit more fair to the one who goes second than the current rules. For both of them to forget the rules in the same way is pretty interesting.
@@AltName7 Maybe its a regional variant or something.
@@MissCaraMint doesnt ash use they/them pronouns?
@@blueandtrue3027 Oh do they? I’m sorry I didn’t know that.
19:17 "This reminds me of when Stephanie and I first met. She 'forced' me to play Portal to test what my thought process was" What an interesting mating ritual 🤔
Lot better than randomly selecting mates off an app.
It’s kinda brilliant actually.
That’s literally what GLaDOS was doing
I’m so glad they went all the way. I would’ve been devastated if they missed the masterpiece in the end!
Dont_Read_My_Name* 💀.
It'd be a shame if they missed out on the Obelisk of Knowledge.
The Obelisk of Knowledge
The Obelisk of Knowledge
The Obelisk of Knowledge
Can't believe Ash never got the satisfaction for winning that tic tac toe game, because they did indeed win
they were both one move away lmfao
No, it would have ended in a draw due to turn order.
@@RobinRhombus2 What? No. Mat put an O on the center left, then it was Ash's turn, in which they could've put an X on the center bottom and won.
Glory to Ash, winner of tik tac toe!
“Oh wait, it’s a giant co-“ never fails to make me laugh
What time stamp is that?
@@duskovolkanovski5975 1:10:41
21:24 "You're right there, I mean, beep. **sad beep** Beep, come on, beep! " I love that someone who sounds exactly like JoCat is acting like an exit detector who breaks out of character when they get frustrated 😂
How the flip is that so accurate
This video starts with MattPatt joking about his wife leaving him. And it ends with his wife leaving him. Excellent foreshadowing
Bravo Matthew!
Wait actually they broke up? And got a divorce???
@@M00NLIGHT_.yes totally yes that is definitely something that happened so true
@@EccentricDrDino oh danm
@@M00NLIGHT_.its a joke
No, don't change the intro. Steph is still a part of the team. She may not be on cam, but she is willing to eat sawdust for you. Whether or not she knows it.
I would love to see them update it but not remove steph
what do you mean she isn't on the camera... didn't you watch the video?
@@FionaPGT this would be the best outcome
It would be funny if they had a "and occasionally" with stephanie, mirror matt, etc
@@sawyer-m I commented prior to me seeing the end of the video. I actually wasn't expecting that to happen.
10:40 "It's like Mr. Hippo all over again" Which is why the rusty hint button is now one of my all-time favorite NPCs 🔴
over an hour of matpat puzzling… tysm gtlive 🙏
Dont_Read_My_Name* 💀.
1:10:22 "The obelisk of knowledge" I love the fact you were able to bring Steph along for that rare piece of "mature content", since she often gets flustered with that kinda thing 😂
I can always count on matpat to write a five hour long lore video with in the next 0.5 seconds of playing this game
Keep Steph in the intro, just add the disembodied voices of Ash(e) and Mirror Matt
THIS
That's what I've been saying.
Never startle MatPat when he's holding a shotgun. Lesson learned.
That was hilarious! 😂
I mean, he managed to entirely miss the suit of armor, so...
I love the reaction to when he pulls out the gun. He was more surprised at the gun that the ghost. Never laughed harder in my life!😆
Imagine programming the shooting gun just for one joke lmao
Timestamp?
@@dragonstar37325:26 sit back and enjoy
@@dragonstar373Around 26:00
Can’t wait for the three hour lore video on puzzles 👍
*Dont_Read_My_Name* 💀.
@@MbitaChizi okay
I'd watch that. 😅😂
1000% would watch that.
22:31 matpat's genuine fear when the music kicks in KILLED me.
you are legit the first person to figure that stop sign puzzle out, everyone i have watched playing it has just scribbled over it (even my friends did because it made no sense)
i played the game before the new real life cutscene, so that was funny to watch, but yeah im surprised you also understood what the last puzzle was witrh the points, i did it for about 30 minutes just doing trial and error lol
I think jacksepticye did that as well.
I thought you had to scribble out "not".
I'm sure I'm not the only one who tries to figure out when they shoot GTLive and I must say, the lack of Halloween decorations in this one helps a little 😂
They played this game shortly after Sean played the looker most likely
No they just took so long to edit in confetti that this video was delayed by month /j
i want to see MatPat play Professor Layton, a puzzle game that can get really challenging as well as tell a really good story in every game
Those games were tremendous!
I'm in for that. I LOVE Professor Layton!!!
I still play them.
Yes, he should!
I have been asking this FOR YEARS
Steph being in this episode is so 🥹🥹 missed her
If Charlie Slimecicle can do this, you can too. We believe in you Matt.
Charlie's playthrough of it is still the most hilarious thing
True
So true XD
factsssss
But man he solved the puzzles so much faster I was annoyed that he missed most of the jokes
I'm so happy to see steph make an appearance!! I love mirror mat and ash but Matpat and Steph's chemistry always beings so much energy and it's all so nostalgic too
This has got to be one of my favourite GTLive episodes ever, I have really missed seeing Steph on the couch!
There was an episode of dont tell the bride in the UK where the groom had the wedding in a hedge maze. It was actually really nice as there were memories inside to help guide here through she was so emotional by the time she got to the ceremony
I missed steph so much😭. Time for the best puzzle dou I know to shine once again
32:55
Mat: "no bad ideas in brain storming"
Literally 10 seconds later
"Ahh. Oh god why did I do that?"
😂😂😂
It always makes my heart so happy to see Steph!!!
57:47 Proof that Steph and Matpat always have puzzles on the brain.
I love Ash's set up for the ending joke; I've finished this game and know what "greatest joke of all time" they're talking about.... oh ash....... smh
56:24 Steph's face is noughts hempty for a good ten seconds and I love it
i have seen tons of people play this game, and none of them figured out that the shapes in the diamond puzzle was ordered by points. they all went back to the wedding area and remembered/wrote down what order they came in
When the world needed her, she appeared. It's so great to see Steph again!
The part where the ghost walks across and you just whip out a gun kills me EVERY TIME
I'd love to see you guys play The Upturned, it's pretty spooky but mostly hilarious as has some mysterious LORE
I miss Steph!!! I've seen Sean's playthrough so I'm glad you've also played it XD the ending is a pleasant surprise.
46:12 Yes, Ponytail is a reference to Braid (since Braid and The Witness were made by the same dev, Jonathan Blow)
I want a formal apology from Matpat to Ash in the next GTLive video. She would've won that tic tac toe game!!!
So happy to see you two on the couch again! A couple that actually seems like they enjoy eachothers company and are a great team. Relationship goals!
This was a truly amazing episode of GTLive! Glad to see Steph back, even if just this once, and the puzzle shenanigans were truly, genuinely quite fun :D I wish you all, Matthew (and Mirror Matthew) and Steph and Ash and Oliver and of course Skeeeep, along with the rest of Team Theorist, well!
Insert traumatic marital problem here
...even though I'm not married yet
That sounds like what happened in your non existent marriage is terrible I hope you get though it
I can't believe MatPat first tried Snake, that took me like 10 tries
I watched the first 10 minutes of gameplay, and then I had to download the game and check it out for myself. Thanks Mat for sharing this game! I had a blast playing it and then watching you play it. Your reactions were golden
WHAT A FANTASTIC START TO MY WEEKEND
Dont_Read_My_Name* 💀.
i love how in the end of the game you draw a giant p***s and then the game is understanding it, and then you understand "the looker" stands for because you looked at the thing you have just dawned
I miss her in the not live, and live live streams. Although this is like a gift to see her play a bit, and I love their commentary as a duo.
I saw Steph and immediately started crying from happiness (Love you Steph)
3 seconds into Steph being back and things get right back to weird convos
Matt getting so bummed the game was over & he couldn’t hang out with Steph all morning was so sweet
I love Mat and I always enjoy watching him, but I just love it so much when Stephanie shows up. She makes the video extra special.
Fully completing the witness was once of my favorite gaming experiences, but I truly wouldn’t recommend it to anyone. Thanks Joseph Anderson!
love the fact that this game was made because of how pretentious the guy who made the witness is
Well I would recommend it.
@@handtomouth4690You’re a monster
Matt's reaction to the sudden fps section was absolutely incredible
YOU HAVE FREAKED ME OUT.
I literally just thought about the intro being old with Steph not being here in a while, *and then MatPat talked about it*
Such a moving ending, I completed it myself before finishing the video and it was even more amazing experiencing it first hand.
How meta is this episode beginning with the topic that Stephanie isn't in the show anymore and they need to change the intro and end the episode with Stephanie joins to show how her place in the intro is the right place
Ooooh. I love this game. Looking forward to seeing your reaction to some of these puzzles.
Dont_Read_My_Name* 💀.
@@MbitaChizi You got it! 👍
OMIGOSH I'VE PLAYED THIS!!!! Such a fun little game, so glad you got some fun out of it too
Wow Mat powered through these. The Sun-Earth thing is a nice detail if intended. Also I love the concept of Ash sitting there for 2 hours, trying not to laugh at or give away the ending that they looked up in advance!
@16:22 mat pat draws the most perfect bell curve you cannot escape the big brain neediness here. My professor was right I’m seeing stats everywhere now help lol
I was not expecting the return of the co-host... Tears were she's today...
Steph is back! Sort of. Cool to see her again and this is certainly a great game to have her back for.
Side note this is the first time I've seen anyone actually find the logic of the book in the middle of the hedge maze. Everyone else just trials and errors.
I feel like the puzzle around 17:00 deserves a clap and a half.
How!?!?!? If I played this game, I would have scribbled EVERYWHERE until I finished the game. You actually finished the game and solved the puzzles!
Your content makes me so happy! Love all of the theory family :)
THE OBELISK OF KNOWLEDGE, THE OBELISK OF KNOWLEDGE, THE OBELISK OF--oh wait it‘s a giant co--
You should definitely play the witness next
Great game, makes you feel stupid, but still a great game
He did...
@@lemonp3r50n7 Perfect description lmao.
Dont_Read_My_Name* 💀.
r/whoosh
Please play “I Expect You to Die” it’s a VR James Bond puzzle game. I think you would really like it
My now-husband and I were reunited after college by playing Portal 2 co-op together!
The witness will be forever one of my favorite games. I just loved everything about it, and the Looker is one of the best satire games ever made as well.
Darn. This showed me how much i missed Steph being here. The chemistry is amazing.
"do you wanna come film on the couch" - matt to stephanie, 2022
It’s hilarious to me that I was legit thinking “man they should change this intro,” and the first 20 seconds was Matt going, “we should really update that intro soon…” 😂
"We should probably change that intro at some point." They never changed it and MatPat is also leaving :'(
Honestly Steph made things intresting. Honestly miss her on the show.
It is now 2024, Matt has retired from the other four channels and that intro still has yet to be changed
Sttteeeeeepppphhhhh! I'm so glad I watched Jacksepticeye play this, because it made me want to watch Matt play it, which meant I got to see a rare Steph Returns episode! 😁 And who knew I needed "Steph Helps Matt Count Corners" in my life? 😂 Quick, Ash, give them more comedic puzzle games to entice more Steph-isodes! 😁
I mean... You fed her sawdust snuck into cookies and she's still with you so... I'd say that marriage is pretty strong
Long may Steph reign!
I love how “she can now mighty point” 1:13:57 implies that in complementing the Power of Stephanie’s Pointing, she has unlocked a new level of Point
It was so nice to see steph on the couch.
*Flashes photos of you just playing games in general with the theme song in the background then at the end just put R.I.P stef*
Stephane has left, this is old news, but keep the intro, I will miss this intro, PLEASE KEEP THIS INTRO!!!!!
The joy Matt felt about this game, was the same joy we felt seeing Stephanie join him on the couch.
Mat I highly recommend looking at the Rusty Lake series because it has a lot of interesting lore and I believe it is an underrated mobile game series
PLEASE. He would have a field day with all the theories
@@klaudiso I really want him to do a series on that, or The Room by Fireproof games cause that series is also very interesting
“Ooh spooky ghost!”
*Whips out shotgun* 😂
51:55 Mat placed his third O in a spot that let Ash get a win but they instead left :|
"Ur right there right i mean beep!" Your personal human end tracker.
Now we just gotta vet him to play the game. We are half way there!
I love the idea of humble pie being made out of crows, it gives new meaning to the nursery rhyme line "four and twenty blackbirds baked in a pie"
This game is so funny, more youtubers need to play it
i fr was listening to the intro thinking like man this intro is nice just to end it and mat say that is old and they should change it lol
mat vs puzzles, best combo 🥰
I like how Matthew points out that the intro needs to be changed because it had been a long time since Stephanie was on the show in the episode she joins in again
I honestly wish there were more games like the witness or this, it's one of the few puzzle games i really enjoyed, especially the environmental puzzles... it was so good!
I recommend a very new puzzle game called Taiji. It's basically a spiritual successor to The Witness, but in 2D instead of 3D.
@@zmaj12321 o
I looked at it and I seems like I'd like it. Might Check it out
Seeing Steph return for this episode was a very welcome surprise. Miss her. I love seeing her in the intro too, keep her there! : )
My wife shot me in the head.
1:10:01 I can’t believe they didn’t notice
😂 😂😂😂😂😂😂