Clicky Vs Tactile Vs Linear Mechanical Keyboard Switches with Sound Tests And Examples
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 2 авг 2024
- There are three main types of mechanical switches: clicky, linear, and tactile. Here are examples and sound tests of a variety of each kind.
Clicky Vs Tactile Vs Linear Mechanical Keyboard Switches with Sound Tests And Examples
Mechanical Keyboard Typing Sounds ONLY Playlist: • ASMR - Mechanical Keyb...
Our in-depth blog post regarding the difference between clicky, tactile, and linear switches with pictures: switchandclick.com/2020/02/04...
Breakdown of a Cherry MX Blue Switch: • What makes a Cherry MX...
Kailh BOX Switches Aniamtion: • Kailh BOX Switch For M...
Check out this blog post we wrote about this topic!
switchandclick.com/2020/02/04...
Try Amazon Prime for 30-days trial: geni.us/SROS7r
Check out more mechanical keyboards at mechanicalkeyboards.com/shop/... (affiliate link).
Channel donations, only if you ever want to: paypal.me/switchandclick?loca...
Switch and click is a RUclips channel all about mechanical keyboards. We enjoy reviewing keyboards and posting informative videos about building/buying your own keyboard. Please check out our channel, and subscribe if interested.
Links below have affiliate links:
Our favorite mechanical keyboards so far: kit.co/bvan1412/our-top-mecha...
Our favorite budget mechanical keyboards: kit.co/bvan1412/out-top-budge...
Our Budget Deskmats: kit.co/bvan1412/our-budget-de...
Our Budget PBT Keycap Sets: kit.co/bvan1412/budget-pbt-ke...
Everything we use to create our videos: kit.co/bvan1412/my-camera-and...
Accessories for Mechanical Keyboards: kit.co/bvan1412/mechanical-ke...
Subscribe to our channel here: / switchandclick
Blog: switchandclick.com
Facebook page: / switch-and-click-10457...
Instagram: / switch_and_click
Email us at the theswitchandclick@gmail.com (Business Inquiries Only, Thanks!)
Switch and Click is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program and the Creator Program for Mechanicalkeyboards.com, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to amazon.com and mechanicalkeyboards.com. As an Amazon Associate and a MechanicalKeyboards Creator, I earn a commission from qualifying purchases. All prices and star-ratings mentioned during the videos are at the time of purchase and what it was when we bought it, they may not be representative of the current data involving the products specified.
0:00-0:30 Intro
0:31-1:18 Clicky Switches Intro
1:18-2:23 Clicky Switches Sound Tests - Oetemu Blues, Cherry MX Blues, Razer Greens
2:24-3:46 Discussion of Clickbars and Click leaf
3:46-4:40 Tactile Switches
4:40-7:00Tactile Switches Sound Tests - Halo Clears, Cherry Mx Browns, Cherry Mx Clears, HyperX Aquas
7:05-8:05 Linear Switches
8:06-9:35 Important Tip Regarding Sounds
9:36-12:15 Linear Switches Sound Tests - Gateron Reds, Cherry MX Reds, HyperX Reds, Gateron Yellows
12:15-12:43 Outro
I like how finally we got a reviewer who do sound tests by typing like a normal person instead of smashing the keys like other. Thanks!
I only wish I were as quick as TaehaTypes.
@@SwitchandClickOfficial TaehaTypes is 100 words faster than me per second
idk... at least for reds I think if you don't bottom out then you literally cant actuate
almost
@@deletice no
@@firecracker7314 e
Lol this girl has content on like everything related to keyboard I ever search on RUclips.
That's the goal!
@@SwitchandClickOfficial Would like to see your channel grow a lot, I certainly am buying the keychron k8 after seeing your videos.
@@SwitchandClickOfficial can you try to cut a 100 percent membrane keyboard.
@@aravdundon4397 ????????????
Linear = Gaming, Tactile = Typing, Clicky = waking up neighbors
And a super important point mentioned here that other people ignore: the same switch can sound different across several keyboards due to the materials and keyboard design
This has to be one of the clearest, audible and most sound-accurate video I've come across regarding the testing of switches I'm interested in. Thanks.
Wow, thanks!
Yes!!! I learned alot. I knew absolutely nothing about this subject and now I feel well informed and didn’t even know I even had a preference.
Jesus Christ! Why did it take me so many years to finally find someone who knows what they’re talking about with mechanical Kbrds??? Jeeeeesh :-)
Hahaha thanks so much for the kind words
haha so what MK did you end up getting?
@@alvint4944 I backed the Keychron K3 with optical switches on Kickstarter.
Hello, I just wanted to say that this channel seems like it takes a lot of work to make happen at the level of consistency and quality content that is being produced. I admire the dedication and this channel has brought me so many good things and I have purchased keyboards feeling well informed. You really have something great here. Please please please keep up the hard work.
This is the best video I've watched so far that clearly explains the difference between the various switch types. I'm certainly better informed now, as I try to decide on a first mechanical keyboard.
Was quite literally just shopping for a keyboard and had to choose between these three different types of switches. For me working in an environment with a keyboard switch that makes a huge amount of noise is quite troublesome. So having an actual audio test is immensely beneficial
Your video is the best one ive found when it comes to showing how different switches sound. Others either just bash the keyboard or equalize the volume so everything sounds equally as loud.
You girl, really understood what people want to look for when searching mech keyboard sounds
Thank you for your dedication of making this video, I find it very helpful since all the tests were done in normal typing, and very well done explanation. Keep up the great works!
I never realized that the case material is also a factor in the feel/sound of the switches. One cool thing about my corsair k95 is the metal casing makes it sound like reloading an m1 garand from world war 2 on certain key presses, much less loud of course but still there.
I've wired in a microphone in the keyboard and that goes into my 6000W RMS 7.2.4 atmos system so when you press a key it moves pots and pans several rooms away.
@@billybobby7607 i hope what your saying is true
Bruh your channel is so good, ive been binging all your videos for the past month or two
I'm doing the exact same thing! This channel is a gold mine. It deserves more views!
"Bruh"?
So much to consider! Thanks for the great video, my favorite is still cherry MX red, something about the gritty sound as I type makes it satisfying. I never even knew a keyboard could be pulled apart and cleaned until I started watching your channel, now I have my Logitech gaming keyboard in pieces, cleaning it thoroughly and getting it in better shape.
Excellent video....I've been trying to decide between clicky and tactile and this vid has done a better job of demonstrating the differences than any other vid I've found. Good job and thank you.
Very informative. Probably the best video I've ever seen covering this topic.
I learned the hard way that linear switches are not ideal if you type a lot. I do a combination of gaming and writing, and for gaming, they did a fine job, but when I had to type anything out, I would make *TONS* of errors on linear switches.
I converted to a clicky variant of the Logitech G915 recently, and it's a totally different experience. Gaming on it feels surprisingly better for me with the clicky feedback, though I can see why the linear switches would be preferred for the most hardcore gamers. Typing on it is a night and day affair, and that's where i'm the most satisfied. I now make little to no errors when I type, and as a writer, I appreciate this a ton. I will admit, the clicky sound is very prominent, and I can definitely understand how it wouldn't be for everybody, but luckily, I do enjoy it, and I can confidently say that it is for me. If you enjoy ASMR videos of people typing on keyboards, clicky switches might be the way to go.
I've had the least amount of experience with tactile, but from what I hear, it's universally agreed that they're basically a sweet middle ground between linear and clicky. So this seems to be the one to go for if you're a centrist or a fence sitter lol.
I won't game on my keyboard so the description of the clicky keyboard you present sounds amazing but I'm doing a ton of research because I don't want to wake up my girlfriend while she sleeps and I type. Do you think typing on a clicky keyboard is loud to the point you wouldn't want your so sleeping near it?
@@JRCxyz Go for tactile if you don't want it to be very loud. Clicky switches are the modern version of typewriter noise.
True, i'm a gamer and red switch really help me spam skills faster and responsive..
but when it comes to typing or writing something long paragraphs it's lil bit uncomfortable, and tactile/clicky is the best for writing..
nice opinion. 👍
Great, thanks for posting your thoughts! It's really helpful as a membraner looking to convert :)
Glad to see a useful channel utilizing newer RUclips features making it easier to navigate, which also sort of keeps it simple for beginners :)
I suppressed by Cherry MX Blues a bit and they're great for solo use now. Hoping that my Zilent Z2s will be good for the office.
I started with the blue switches before even knowing what a switch was, It was rowdy and not too pleasant to the hears in the long run, slowly moded the keyboard, by buying dampening material, PBT keycaps, lubed stabilizers, and my 50 dollar keyboards sounds great, Thank you.
Thank you so much for putting out an actual test of several different switches for typing. Makes selecting a keyboard/switch much easier.
this is the best guide ive found so far for switches wow bless
You are my favorite about everything keyboard-related. Thank you for all these useful information, you really helped a beginner like me.
Love the in-depth videos you make. Please keep em up!
This is by far the most extensive demo and explanation
Thank you for having sound tests for things that aren't modded in any way. While lubing is a good thing for the switches, it's hard to find stock content for people just starting out in the hobby.
Thanks I was ordering a keyboard and it had options for linear Tactile and clicky switches and with the help of this video i chose linear switches or MX reds
I saw the low-production background and almost didn’t give this video a chance. I’m so glad I did because she knows her stuff and does a great job explaining and displaying the key differences.
Dont judge a book by its cover xd
Your video is great! This is exactly what I was looking for. You answered most of my questions. Thank you.
Okay, this is the video I've been looking for! So educational! Thank you 🥰🥰
Hey! I just got the Durgod K320 with Cherry MX brown and I absolutely love it! Thanks for that review that gave me the info to buy it
Thank you for this! This description is what I've been looking for!
I have been looking for videos to explain more about mechanical keyboards, and this has explained so much more than most others.
Really well done 👍🏻 thank you.
9⁹⁹⁸⁹89⁹19¹1tt
My favorite sound test ever!
Keep it up!
your reviews are sooo good wish you covered more stuff! but you do what you do perfectly!
Thank you!
I love your chilled presence and very likeable persona. But at the same time you are extremely thorough and knowledgeable. Would be great to see you branch out and review other types of tech? You've got huge potential to be a tech youtuber 💪
THIS.
You were spitting
Awesome video for non-enthusiast like me. I really got the direction what to look for. Thanks!
Thanks for the videos. Mechanical keyboards are a huge learning experience and I find your videos really useful. Look forward to checking out more of your vids. 👍
Glad you like them!
Awesome video! You did a FANTASTIC job explaining the differences between the switches without using any geeky terms. You made it super simple for someone (like myself) whose just beginning to explore the impact of switches on sound and feel. You answered several of my questions perfectly! But I am still searching for a type of comparison of the discontinued VERY original Logitech diNovo (scissor switches) vs. Cherry Red Silents. Basically, after a couple of decades of replacing the DiNovos, I need to get a new keyboard and would like to keep the same sound/feel should I make the jump from scissor to switches. Of all the keyboard channels out there, I hope you would be the one to do it! Yaaaa!
Thank you!
Thanks for the demonstration, tests and all the detailed explanations! Very useful for a mechanical keyboard newbie like me :D
Thank you! I like the linear switches a lot more than the others, so I'll get those. You've been helpful with this and some other videos!
Thank you!
you dont realize how much this helps me. thank you so much!!
I have the same Hyper X reds with the White Pudding Caps I love it
I tried the Aqua switches but it just felt and sounded like a regular cheap school keyboard so I switched it out and so happy.
Very nice and informative video. I've never used a mechanical keyboard yet and I was wondering what switch was right for me. After watching this video I decided to go with red switches as I mainly use my PC for gaming and since I am so used to membrane keyboard I believe it would feel weird for me to have tactile or clicky feedback before I pressed a key fully so going with reds would mean that I would adapt to it quicker than the other type of switches. I also do not intend to spend too much money so it's very likely that I will get outemu or some other cherry mx clone
Thank you for this video. It was very helpful. I have been using Cherry MX Brown for years, but was too overwhelmed by the different options to know where to start exploring other switches. After watching your video, I reached the conclusion that linear switches would probably be better for me compared to tactile, which really narrows the options down.
Glad it was helpful!
Hey thank you for this review, I am just getting in the world of mechanical keyboards and this video was really nice to understand. Do you maybe a video in which you talk about different brands of switches other than the regular Gateron and Cherry?
I'm in love with the keyboard demonstrating the Cherry MX clears 🤤🤤🤤🤤
I think it's the Vortexgear Cypher
I know this is three years old but dang this video explains the difference very well. Thank you so much
This video is so helpful, you help me acknowledges the real sound of each type of switch, keyboard community own you alot madam. All the best for you.
My favorite is probably the mx reds. I used to like clicky switches like the blues and box jades, but I think I eased into linear switches such as the yellows and reds.
ah yes, enlightenment. i finally know which switch to go for. thank you for this!
Wow, I never knew keyboards were this in depth. Thanks.
My sister recently got a apex 5 keyboard and I just love the way it sounds and feels
It sucks it sucks it sucks it sucks
Isn't it membrane??
The apex 7 and pro is so expensive lmao
Great video, super interesting to watch and hear the differences, it looks like you were typing the same text with different keyboards, was it part of a novel? The translucent, super bright keys would distract me but the sound doesn't, cherry MX blue are one of my favorites, but then I have several keyboards with different types of keys to suit my mood, task and environment. Good job!
really appreciate this detailed yet clear professional video
Girl where have you been? I’ve been looking for you all this time you are now one of my favorite ytubers
well ... that was pretty down to earth and honest. And it saved me a lot of time and trouble.
thank you so much for making this video it really helped me decide what switch i wanted to get for my first mechanical keyboard!
Glad I could help!
That last keyboard with the gateron red switches...I want that. Sounded beautiful and I really like the layout.
Thank you very much. I have needed a new keyboard for a while now but I'm so use to my current one. I didn't know why I can't stand other keyboards. It turns out they used different type of switch.
Amazing and very thorough explanations. This was very helpful!!
Thank you for the videos! Keep em coming!
Thanks for making this video. I have the Razer huntsman v2 tkl with linear switches. It also has sound dampeners. I love it and this video helped me figure out why i like it so much.I also use a razer tartarus v2 for mmorpg play and It's more clicky.
Thank you for actually letting me hear what the different types sound like!
No problem!!
Tactile switches (browns) are probably best for most people the feel good to type because of the tactile bump and less noise and it’s also good for gaming
@@muCephei_ 😂😂😂... that was funny. Not all browns are created equal. Some are definitely more tactile than others.
I like the sounds of Cherry MX Blues but I LOVE THE SOUNDS OF RAZER GREEN SWITCHES
I repeat what I read in another video of you: this channel is underrated. Thanks!
Wow, thank you!
Seriously.... Well done and simply explained...loved it.
I've had a TTC Blue switch keyboard (cherry clone) for about a month now and I love it for typing, especially as a high school graduate / college student! This is a really helpful video though! I'm considering getting a tactile switch keyboard for my next one, since I'll probably have a roommate and I'd rather not be an annoyance
@@SwitchandClickOfficial the Rii K61C you reviewed a few months ago (the video that convinced me to get it) has TTC switches (either red or blue, I got the blues) :)
But yeah I'm definitely considering a tactile one, I'm not much a fan of the linear ones, too smooth for my taste
Ahhh I'm a noob to mechs and your vid has given so much great information to digest! I'm thoroughly overwhelmed of course, and don't know where to start.
This is such a personal preference decision that ultimately can only be made with IRL compare contrast use, but your clear explanation and samples helped tremendously.
I'm not a gamer but I work with software that uses highly customizable shortcuts, multi-key combos, and its own set of WASD areas of the keyboard (F5-F8, P colon brackets, and frequent numeric kypd use) and ofc regular typing.
Anyway, if anyone happens to read this I'd love a recommendation based on:
- I don't need rapid fire speed
- Unintentional mis-presses are not good so i probably want a feel where I have to be deliberate or "learn" where the actuation point is rather than it being a random surprise. Having trouble deciding between linear and tactile!
- I like warm, almost dull, clacks. Not sharp and snappy clicks.
- Colored grouping would be great
- I like to be able to feel that certain keys are larger than others (like CTRL, ALT, MODIFIER each being different sizes)
- numeric kypd is necessary
- compact as possible w kypd
- wired + Bluetooth (don't care about 2.4ghz)
- programmable
- PBT keycaps
- rugged as it needs to go where i go.
Any experienced guidance in a direction to start would be much appreciated! Thanks in advance for any tips.
Cheers
Super comprehensive. Thanks a ton!
Thank you for explaining this topic so clearly.
Great quality video as usual. So the conclusion is: 1. Choose the "clicky" one if you love that sharp metallic sound along with normal keystroke sound. 2. Choose the "tactile" one if you love that physical feedback (the bump) on your fingers and choose the "linear" one if you prefer a "smooth" (meaning no bump) pressing. Is it right? Question: Does the word "linear" imply the force required from pressing a key to bottom-out "grows linearly", vs the other two types that seem to have different force curves? And what impact does this force change have on typing (and gaming lol) experience? Thanks :)
no with linear the force is the same from press to bottom out =)
@@AbothGaming Got it. Thanks for help :)
The force in all switches will grow linearly, it's how springs work (F = kx). The reason i guess why it's named linear is because there are no obstructions such as tactility and a smooth press all the way.
@@chikoopandya Make sense. Thanks for your kind help. :)
You have no idea how grateful I am for this sound comparison. I’m so weird about sounds and this really helped me decide I probably can’t do any of them. 😂😂😂
haha your'e welcome!
Thank you, very nice video, straight to the point!
YOU are so great by doing a bunch of amazing well explained videos
Best video I've seen on the differences. Thank you!
Glad you enjoyed it!
Great video, I recently switched from the Logitech G910 to a Asus ROG STRIX keyboard with cherry MX Reds, and I'm still undecided if I want browns or blues, or keep the reds, but because of our current situation the world's still going thru, they don't have all the different varieties on display in stores anymore! Who would of thought a keyboard would be so sophisticated.
It's quite a complicated product :P
This was very helpful and well structured. May I ask what the keyboard at 11:55 was? I'm new to the mechanical scene and seemed like a modded K2 maybe? Been looking for a good 75%. :)
Really helpful when buying online, thank you!
This video was what I was searching for. Thank you.
you're welcome!
Hi, great channel.. super useful and easy to follow! I had a noob question seeing new switches such as cherry mx speed silver. Looking at the actuation points it seems they are comparable to gateron low profile switches. I am looking for a laptop style mech and was considering keychron k1 as it has gateron LP switches but i am wondering if any other keyboard which simply supports cheery speed are going to have similar experience too (such as Durgod Taurus k320 TKL). Thanks in advance!
Fantastic video! If you could rate the tactile switches from most tactile to least, that would be very helpful. I'm currently deciding on what switches to get for gaming (currently use an old k70 with mx browns, and want something more tactile). Can't afford the zealios V2s, so Im currently stuck between the GMMK switch selection on their site (gateron browns, kaihl browns, kaihl speed copper/bronze etc) and halo clears from drop.
This video is exactly what I was looking for. Thank you!
Glad it was helpful!
I needed something for typing and couldn't decide what to get. Then I found a company called Unicomp that's still making IBM style keyboards in Kentucky. Got one for myself last Christmas and it's been a pleasure to use.
Thank you for this comparison! So well done!
Glad you liked it!
clickies are my favorite kind of switch (I use Varmilo Ivy v2) but for the ivies if you press the hard enough they sound a little more like tactiles and the spacebar on my keyboard sounds quite deep and linear considering it uses a clicky switch
Thank you very much, finally i got my doubt cleared!!!
I forget all the time, this video is golden!
Love your videos, sharing the love ❤
Finally someone who helped me out with switches , thanks a lot I really appreciate it ur the best !
what are ur guys's thoughts whats ur best switch type
For me its the linear red switch since i really dont like the loud sound of the blue switches
I nearly had to get a divorce on account of the volume of Razer Green switches. In the end we decided it was better that I just get a new keyboard!
😂😂😂😂😂
Martin Challis Nah mate the keyboard is more important
literally why I'm getting my bf a keyboard for his birthday 😂 I can't hear the game when we play together
DAMN SON
@@KenzLaw what keyboard and switch did you give him?
damn this is high quality af
Thanks for the demos, just what I needed. I just ordered my first mech keyboard from Drop, $160, with Gateron Blue switches, it looks like the same keyboard that you used here for your Gateron Red demo, very handsome keyboard, so excited to get it & put it together!! So many switch choices, but I think I'll like Clicky, hope I like Gateron Blue. I really want to reproduce the feel & sound from my way back in the day when my dad had IBM Selectric typewriters. As a kid I used to love typing anything on them! You had the key click feel & sound and you also had the sound when the ball whacks the paper, so nice! *Any switch choice advise that you might have to achieve this old IBM Selectric feel & sound would be greatly appreciated.* Just talking about the feel & sound of the keystroke, not the ball whacking the paper. lol
Maybe Box Whites? Or Boba U4Ts
@@SwitchandClickOfficial OK great, thanks for the recommendation, will check these out!
best switches explanation video fr
thanks for this! just subscribed!
I enjoyed listening to you talk. You have a very pleasant personality.
Thanks so much, I get that a lot
Best kb switch review ever, exactly what i was looking for, thanks.
Best channel for keyboard reviews... Thank you so much...
Wow, thanks!