Son of Released Israeli Hostage Shares Her Experience
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 4 дек 2023
- Yafa Adar, 85, was among the first group of Israeli hostages to be released by Hamas on Nov. 24. Now her son, Moshe Adar, who survived the Oct. 7 attack on Kibbutz Nir Oz, tells The Times about his mother’s nearly 50 days spent in captivity.
Subscribe: bit.ly/U8Ys7n
More from The New York Times Video: nytimes.com/video
----------
Whether it's reporting on conflicts abroad and political divisions at home, or covering the latest style trends and scientific developments, New York Times video journalists provide a revealing and unforgettable view of the world. It's all the news that's fit to watch.
Palestinian children are “the only children in the world who are systematically prosecuted in military courts” and an estimated 10,000 have been held in the Israeli military detention system over the past 20 years.
The children were the ones throwing stones at Israeli authorities
I (an Israeli Jew) agree this is reprehensible. Yet everyone knows where they are. They are provided food and healthcare. They are not physically and sexually abused.
@@OAmusall you said just in reverse 😂😂, you get ur info from media
@@OAmusThey are not subjected to physical or sexual abuse. How merciful you are!! What a merciful occupation, stealing their childhood and innocence and putting them in prisons is the greatest evil for them. Even greater than that is stealing their homes in Sheikh al-Jarrah and the West Bank and stealing their identity and culture. Also, whoever told you that they were not beaten, all those who came out of prison said so. They were severely beaten, even the women among them. As for the sexual assault, it is sufficient that we have evidence that an Israeli soldier assaulted a 16-year-old girl, and his fellow soldiers brag about killing unarmed civilians, women and men in the village of Tantura in the movie. What a disgusting thing. They brag about their terrorism in... Movie Well, tell us, Mr. Occupation, how did you get Palestine in 1948? Was it by dancing for the Palestinians and kissing them, or by killing, displacement, and stealing lands? How disgusting you are. You justify every heinous crime you commit.
@@OAmus wtf are you kidding??
So no torture, no harrassment and definitely no sexual abuse stories unlike what Palestinians have beem going through in Israeli prison and yet they call Hamas as the terrorists...🤦♀️
agree
There are 240 stories.
From 240 people.
This is one of them and she’s old, I guess her future is not the same as 21 hot Israeli women
Meanwhile old Muslim women praying at Al Aqsa are stomped on and manhandled by their police
Thankful for the mother to have returned safely. Now let’s see the New York Times interview Palestinian children released from Israeli prison. I highly doubt that will ever happen. The bias and double standards are unreal.
If you actually cared about Palestinians then you would have checked before leaving a comment.
‘They Came in the Dark’: Settler Violence Intensifies in the West Bank
In Gaza, Filmmakers Asked Children: What Is Your Dream? | NYT Opinion
Palestinians Film War in Gaza: ‘So They Know We Existed’ | NYT
War Through the Eyes of Gaza’s Children
Empty Classrooms, Abandoned Kids: Inside The Great Teacher Resignation | NYT Opinion
How an Israeli Soldier Killed Palestinian Medic Rouzan al-Najjar | NYT - Visual Investigations
exactly
ruclips.net/video/I--AUvKnP6k/видео.html ruclips.net/video/GLgKSWonPm0/видео.html
finally someone said it
Look at a video made by NYT titled " War through the eyes of the children in Gaza".
There are no biases and double standards. Both sides deserve to be heard equally and treated with empathy.
Oh yeah. She looks healthy to me. Have you seen the Palestinian kids released by israel ? Have you seen their broken arms and deprived of any medical care for weeks?
Have you heard the israeli police report that the majority of the civilians were killed by the israeli army and not by Hamas?
Please tell me these are Russian bot comments and not actual Americans?? Then I can at least not worry to the degree I am right now...
@stephanie4200 We need to see the international media. Our media is literally a parrot that repeats what the israeli PM says. They have no credibility. It just happened that I speak 3 other languages and watch news from different sources
@@stephanie4200
everything they said was true though...
whats so wrong about being angry at human rights violation?
How come we didn’t see any of the hostage speak out about their capture
Let’s see you get kidnapped then finally released only to have nosy people like ourselves demand they speak instead of giving you time to assimilate back to life after captivity. If they do not want to speak, it is THEIR right not to! They were held against their will for Pete’s sake @hiamari1497!!! At least give them the right to decide moving forward what they want to do with their lives. Compassion and empathy are words you should look into dude.
I was sexually molested as a child. The last thing I wanted to do was speak to anyone and retell what happened. Demanding a VICTIM speak of the horrors they went through just so you and the rest of the world can sit there and judge and analyze every single word and gesture to arrive at your own conclusions is disgusting!
What’s your point..
Israel don't want them to speak about how KhaMaS tread them well, like the grandma who exposed Israel propaganda about kHamAs 🙆♀️
They will try to brainwash them for one mouth, then they will let them speak against kHamAS🥴
There was a Filipino Hostage who already spoke of their experience. Go look it up. Not every hostage is mentally capable of taking too much media attention.
@@StrygwyrBSand they were called a liar 😢
Palestinians suffering and Israeli suffering are completely two different things. All of the hostages that have been released from Hamas have all be treated well, they're all healthy, they've been all taken care of. While in the meantime, hostages that are released from Israeli army have broken limbs, they're beaten and humiliated, they're not allowed to speak to press and if they do, they will be jailed.
OMG - YOU HAVE GOT TO BE KIDDING ME??!! They were ripped out of their beds on a saturday morning by terrorists and have been dragged to Hamas tunnels and kept locked in underground terror tunnels. What sick person could possibly even write something so incredibly insensitive ignorant. All these uneducated people that have never been to either place should really stop talking and get on a plane and go hang out with hamas for a week and then you can talk about being "well treated" What a joke. I honestly thought it was a joke when people said that but if this person is serious they are sooo misinformed!!!! They were NOT beaten or broken limbs that picture of that boy was fake. Wow are americans really this stupid and easily fooled to think israeli army is bad and hamas terrorist are good. I'm seriously terrifed that anyone with a brain can say that with a straight face. What bs have you been getting fed for the last 17 years of hamas murderous reign of terror over gazans who if they speak out against them are brutally murdered. Get your facts right please bc this thinking is so irresponsible and downright dangerous for all of humanity!! This is so sad. I honestly cant believe I just read such utter lies and have to say such an obvious thing I just can't understand when did hamas take over american social media. Bc this is absolutely insanity. Hamas is far more brutal than ISIS so NO they were not treated well. And Israel is a DEMOCRACY the only one in the middle east. So all these lies about it are just absurd and I really need to know if this is innocent ignorance or you know the truth and facts and chose to lie bc your anti semantic. Not sure what is worse but America has got to educate you all better bc getting your news from tick tok has brainwashed an entire generation into thinking hamas terrorists are humane and israeli is the bad one. I cant believe I am even having to say something that out loud.
Please tell me these are Russian bot comments and not actual Americans?? Then I can at least not worry to the degree I am right now...
@@stephanie4200 1. Why are you assuming people online are either American or Russian?
2. "Russian bots" might've worked to silence leftists in 2016, it doesn't work now.
You liar!! They have massacred innocent people and children. Palestinians have shown their true colors I will never ever support them!
@@stephanie4200go to gaza and see what the terrorist group named idf is doing
I will tell you a little story. Imagine yourself living in your own house that you have owned for centuries. You and your siblings live in it in peace. Some of you are Muslims, some of you are Jews, and some of you are Christians. However, you live in a beautiful, peaceful coexistence. Then a person fleeing from World War II comes to you and you host him in your home and welcome him. You treat him well, then he turns into a psychopath who claims that the house is his. Then he takes your house by force, kills your father, rapes your mother, imprisons your brother, expels your sister from the house permanently, corners your younger brother in the bathroom, beats you every day, and deprives you of food and electricity. You are prevented from taking transportation inside the house or entering the airport. You have no right inside the house and cannot leave it if you wish. And if you raise your voice and try to demand freedom, you will die. Tell me, will you be able to live in peace like this, or will you resist to regain your home?
The truth...the Palestine history has taught me lessons... That at times kindness can lead u in problems.sad😢😢😢
@@safianamani1375 It is unfortunate when a person treats another in a beautiful way and then returns the favor with a fatal insult
@@malkirania999 exactly...no words to describe wats going on... The scenes the screams..hunger thirst... Collective punishments I avoid the fon... Coz av been crying since the war... Only prayers for them😭
Only if it was real ,Muslim have never lived peacefully with anybody since its creation.They were trouble under crusaders rule,malmuk rule and ottoman rule which lead to the great Arab revolt against the ottoman turcs Then when British won the war it was a British mandate and the British separated all the fighting parties.palestinian Arabs where fighting with everybody just like they are today and this is why none of their Arabs neighbor wants them as refugees.when Lebannon took them in ,they attacked the christian and launch Lebannon in its worst civil war,when Jordan took the Palestinians in they tried to eliminate king Hussein and look at Egypt they don't want them in either Your version of the story is pure fantasy.
Also if you want real story you can look at Arab Israel stories that describe how it was the Arabs neighbors(Syria, Lebanon,Egypt and Jordan)that told the Palestinians Arabs to sell their lands to the Jews to fund their war promising to recuperate the house once they won,except they lost so those who sold their house didn't get it back.This explains why there are still a seizable Arab Israeli population along with druze , Samaritan and other minorities.there is proof of those transaction.
Good! Please also interview Palestinian hostages released from Israeli prisons, most of them are women and children without any charges!
The Palestinians are not allowed to say or show anything in fear of the IDF taking the rest of the family to prison!
Same with the Israeli prisoners most of them have other family
Members in captivity still so they wouldn’t speak on it. Dont try and just act like one side is doing the only immoral things now.
@@lauralondon3312 How about you stop acting like there is symmetry here. Israel is a nuclear state armed to the teeth by US who are running an occupation of 6 million Palestinian refugees who barely had clean drinking water to begin with!
why you dont bother yourself and send correspondents to Gaza or even to West Bank like the imprisoned children in Israeli jails don't have families nor emotion no fear , Hypocricuty,, your mom didnt sleep for a month because they gather them what about millions haven't ceiling to sleep under it
Didn't sleep because of the IOF CARBET BOMBING. Can he be such a sympathizer with the Palestinians because no one in Gaza has slept in 2 months now
Preempting some comments here: Palestinian suffering and Israeli suffering are not mutually exclusive.
Israel is an occupation it’s the land of Palestine
No, they can just go back to Europe
ruclips.net/video/lhNGimPNygs/видео.html
But the Palestinian suffering continued for the last 75+ years starting with the brutal occupation of Palestine by the Zionists and the massacrers they committed, or the massacrers committed by the British before that.
@@hiamomari1497 there’s no such thing as Palestine cry more 😂
@@Alayossy'all keep using genocidal speech like Israel isn't about to appear at the ICJ accused of genocide.
let hostages speak for them selves.... why can’t they ?! oh they r not allowed 👀👂🏻lol i Wonder why 🧠🤔
They did. But the israeli government doesn't want them to praise Hamas
So glad she made it home safely. I'm wishing for the other hostages to be returned safely as well. I'm also wishing that Israel stops its practice of kidnapping mass amounts of Palestinians and holding them without charge for days, weeks, months, or years. We truly have to stop all of this suffering across the globe. My prayers go to Congo as well!
After the Battle of Badr, Prophet Mohammed peace be upon him gave the prisoners 2 choices:
1- Teach 10 muslims how to read or write.
2- Have a relative pay thier ransom.
William Muir states in his book The Life of Mahomet :
“In pursuance of Mahomet's commands, the citizens of Medîna, and such of the Refugees as possessed houses, received the prisoners, and treated them with much consideration. "Blessings be on the men of Medina!" said one of these prisoners in later days; "they made us ride, while they themselves walked: they gave us wheaten bread to eat when there was little of it, contenting themselves with dates. It is not surprising that when, some time afterwards, their friends came to ransom them, several of the prisoners who had been thus received declared themselves adherents of Islam...Their kindly treatment was thus prolonged, and left a favourable impression on the minds even of those who did not at once go over to Islam"
The first batch of hostages released by Hamas said they were well treated, fed well, and ate the same food as Hamas, were visited by doctors, and given any medication they needed. They waved goodbye to the Hamas members and smiled at them. Why is this story so different. Coercion from Israel?
You’re joking right?? They said they found evidence of being drugged to appear happy, others said they were scared they wouldn’t be let go unless they agreed to pretend they were well taken care of. Let’s see how you would do with terrorists demanding you play nice with a gun to your head. Before you are freed. Many of them had awful stories. But ignorant people only would look
At one side and neglect to research the other.
@@lauralondon3312 Just have a look at this video about the whole history of this conflict. It takes a look at all Zionist stories and researched their origins. It’s really well put together!
Я очень переживала за жту женщину❤❤ так рада что она дома❤❤❤❤❤
Interesting when almost all other hostages have said they were together with others, were playing games, had conversations with others, got as much food and medication as israel allows into gaza (which is almost nothing already - you can thank your israeli government for the lack of food :). let's hear from her now, see if she tells the same stories or if they are different
She appears to have all her fingernails and limbs intact. Can’t say the same for Palestinian prisoners/hostages.
Thanks be to God Almighty from whom All good things come Amen. We are very joyful to see her back here in Nigeria. Love you Grandma. Long shall you live in joy, peace and love Amen 💕💯🙏
🤡
You didn't thank ha.mas
@@user-pr3uj6mu9f With the hostile attacks still ongoing, it’s hard to calculate the cost of what Israel might need from the international community. As the United States and the international community rallies to Israel’s side, the House Budget Committee will continue an analysis and cost breakdowns of specific defense and humanitarian assistance programs and will support other Committees in finding sustainable and efficient ways to offer Israel the resources they need to defeat the enemy.
The Bottom Line:
The Biden Administration’s foreign policy has been an abject failure. This weakness and lack of leadership creates a dangerous political and economic environment around the world that undermines our interests. Reckless policies have a chain reaction that leads to American consumers facing higher prices and our government scrambling for resources.
I remember this lady from the attack on Oct. 7. Glad she's back home with her loved ones. She looks like she has lot of weight when compared to her kidnapping video. She was so calm and peaceful, even as the hooligans were taking her to Gaza.
Yafa Adar was one of the founding members of Kibbutz Nir Oz and had lived there for 60 years.
She's one of the reasons Palestenians were kiked out from those territories.
I hope people don't forget she's a settler who funded the genocide of Palestenians.
@@fatimaezzahrarifla3024
Nir Oz was recognized as a Kibbutz in December 1955 or thereabouts. She is said to be 85. So she must have been 30 years old when she began her residence at Nir Oz. If she lived there for 60 years, she would be 90 years old now. Can you provide a reference as to her funding the genocide of Palestinians? How so? Gaza was under military occupation by the Israeli governate after the 1967 Arab-Israeli/Israeli Arab war. In any case, she appeared to be patient and forbearing during the time of her capture. Was she part of the Nahal force? Probably, right?
@@e.t.ethics1771 If she's not Palestinian.
Simply she was an invader when the British colony were still occupying Palestine
There is not enough food! Why don't you ask your government. Despite all the atrocities committed against people of GAZA, she was treated as a human being, as opposed to the Palestinians.
Is the message clear?
This is like listening to the experience of Germans during WW2 . I
It's amazing how non of the released hostages were able to speak????
Isreal needs to maintain that the hostages were not mistreated 😂
EXACTLY !!!
its wired & it have reasons
I prayed deeply for her to be freed. Praise The Lord
🤔😭😭😭😭😭
So Sad....
Prayer's For Your Mother 💗💗💗💗💗💗💗💗💗
You & Your Family....
How bad it feels for this mother who was away for 50 days..
Just imagine how many thousands of people in Palestine is being kept or murdered away from life by Israel.
And when they revault you call them terrorist?
Amin 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
❤❤❤❤dady i love you ❤🙏
Cant she speak??
They addressed this if you bothered to watch the video
Can't you watch the video?
@@DefenseOnTitan Israili government ordered them not to speak to the media because they would say the truth about the soldiers of Hamas(politeness-respect-generosity)which other hostages revealed when they come back home.
seems to have been pretty well treated considering she was released from a 'terrorist' organisation. Funny how we don't get to hear her side lol
Are you really say it's terrorist after all this?? Shame on you !!! Now its very clear who's the terrorist netniaho & his terrorist boys
She’s 85, ffs!
@@KohalaLover so what?? Is this woman the only hostage?
@@Islam.isthetruth. “Don’t tell me about your religion, show me by how you treat others”. - Corey Booker
No doubt the freed hostages were asked to keep quiet in order for any remaining hostages, if any, to be treated well. Both sides are horribly wrong. Terribly wrong. Anything related to any religion equals discord.
@@KohalaLover Oh my God, my dear, what's wrong? Are you okay? Iam talking about the fact that the hostage was as if she was in a five-star hotel while the Palestinians are being tortured and most of them have been in captivity for forty years. Your words are wrong. You are completely illogical. Palestine is a country for the Palestinians and it is a very natural thing for citizens to appear and defend. About their homeland, while Israel's conspiracy, which is pure terrorism and wants to occupy something that does not belong to it...
Why are you lying that’s not true, maybe you’re talking your way of treating Palestinian prisoners
May Allah keep you safe , if you think same as me ! Ameen and your family but what about my brothers and sisters what about my childrens what about my elders you never even care to see that your army was killing my people from last 75 year may be you never had time may be !
IsraelTV channel say otherwise who to believe. Certainly not your Chanel and most definitely NOT any spokesperson from the Israeli government.
Kazakhstan has many monopolists, Kleptocrats, Authoritarianism, etc.
Why are you talking she is the one who was there
In Israel time the translation is being manipulated 😂
Free Palestine
Go get your mom and say same thing in front of her, unless you are her son too
Where are the testimonies of Palestinians? Tgey are inside of the rumbles no one can hear their suffering.
I am glad for your mom.
But there is a tragedy in Gaza and in the occupied territories.
This tragedy is ongoing, and the tragedy is not called Hamas. It is called the occupation and settlement of Palestinian land.
~~~
The problem in the occupied territories is that Israeli settlers do not see themselves as settlers. They claim that God promised them the land from the river to the sea.
Only the Palestinians see them as settlers.
Settlers see themselves as God's chosen people, and they see whoever opposes them as a terrorist.
~~
Solution?
The solution must come from the Israeli state government and not from the settlers. The Israeli government must come to understand that illegal settlements block the peace and must be dealt with. In spite of the fact that it is painful to let go of the settlements, it is a must. Peace has a price. We cannot achieve peace without serious compromise.
~~
Problem?
The Israeli state government wants to settle Palestinian land and gives weapons to the settlers and uses the IDF to defend them and oppress the Palestinian population.
~~
Therefore?
More killings, more acts of terror, more fear, more instability for everyone, more $$$ for the military and military industrial complex. Misery and inhumanity wins the day.
This is what nightmares are made of.
😮
The reason she had little food and no medication was because Netanyahu stopped those supplies and fuel! 😢😢😢
Let her talk mate lol
She look like a bada@@ going off with that smirk on her face. Like you got me but you dont know what your in for! So happy shes home.
well, palestinians in gaza don't have much food or medicine either..
Hamas just wanted to show these people what is it like to be terrorised, abducted, killed for no reason out of thc blue one day. It's been happening to them for 75 years
Hmmm
Пентагон заявил, что Укpаина может испoльзовать aмериканские ракеты ATACMS для ударов по Крыму. Россия имеет полное право нанесение ракетных ударов по Пентагону.
almost every other israeli hostage is saying the same thing. They were treated with respect and the women were honored by Hamas.
Bet it hates some people to hear they was treated well. Doesn’t fit their narrative.
So sad 😂😂😂😂😂
He probably also wished that she was dead instead of taken hostage... what crazy echo chamber
a big liar
why are you hiding and lying
LEAVE PALESTINE‼️🇵🇸
🤮
Free Palestine 🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸
And kidnapping grandmas and toddlers helps free palestine how exactly?
His experience. Free Palestine!
Please. This guy was lucky his own government didn’t Hannibal him. Millions of us would rather hear from the Palestinians and can you please report on the children murdered? Perhaps a story on the 1000’s of hostages isrl is holding?
As a candidate for office in 2020, President Joe Biden vowed to seek a quick return to the 2015 Iran nuclear deal, formally known as the Joint Comprehensive Plan of Action (JCPOA), and to end the Trump administration’s maximum pressure campaign. During his transition, Iran launched its first salvo of nuclear escalation to test the incoming president’s resolve, beginning production of highly enriched uranium to 20 percent purity level - a provocation Tehran had avoided even at the height of the Trump administration’s maximum pressure campaign.2 Indeed, most of Iran’s nuclear expansion occurred after President Biden’s election.
Despite Iran’s escalation and warnings from policy experts that pursuing a return to a flawed and already expiring nuclear deal would prove disastrous, President Biden shifted American policy from pressure to accommodation in hopes of facilitating the restoration of the JCPOA.4 Biden removed the Iran-backed Houthis from the State Department’s list of foreign terrorist organizations, rescinded the American snapback of UN sanctions at the Security Council, relaxed
sanctions to free up cash for Iran to pay some debts and allow for increased oil exports to China, pulled European allies back from censuring Iran at the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) in Vienna, and allowed Iran’s proxies in Iraq and Syria to attack U.S. forces with near impunity.5 In the hopes of brokering a deal quickly, Biden appointed Robert Malley to be his special envoy - a Washington insider well known for an ideology sympathetic to the mullahs in Tehran and their terror proxies like Hezbollah and Hamas.6 Maximum pressure had been replaced by maximum deference.
🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱
God bless this woman and her family.. what she must of endured . I support Israel and the IDF 🇺🇸❤️🇮🇱💙💪
Praying for Yafa and her family 🇮🇱🙏🏽🇺🇸