Where's Noa? A forensic analysis of her kidnapping and what it says about Israel's hostage crisis
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 18 дек 2023
- NBC News foreign correspondent Raf Sanchez examines the case of 26-year-old Noa Argamani, who became one of the faces of the hostage crisis after video of her abduction from the Supernova festival spread across social media. Despite the release of more than a hundred hostages in November in a deal that included most women and children, Noa’s whereabouts-and those of nearly all of the hostages taken from the festival-remain unknown.
» Subscribe to NBC News: / nbcnews
NBC News Digital is a collection of innovative and powerful news brands that deliver compelling, diverse and engaging news stories. NBC News Digital features NBCNews.com, MSNBC.com, TODAY.com, Nightly News, Meet the Press, Dateline, and the existing apps and digital extensions of these respective properties. We deliver the best in breaking news, live video coverage, original journalism and segments from your favorite NBC News Shows.
Connect with NBC News Online!
Breaking News Alerts: link.nbcnews.com/join/5cj/bre...
Visit NBCNews.Com: www.nbcnews.com/
Find NBC News on Facebook: / nbcnews
Follow NBC News on Twitter: / nbcnews
Get more of NBC News delivered to your inbox: nbcnews.com/newsletters
Where's Noa? A forensic analysis of her kidnapping and what it says about Israel's hostage crisis
#Israel #Hamas #Gaza
The fact that anyone is still sympathetic to Hamas is unbelievable
The fact you can't tell the difference between hamas and Palestinian civilians is unbelievable
@@birdsinparadise3113Palestinians support Hamas and elected them. Wake up.
No offense. How about the Israeli father who lost his 26 year old son? At the hands of the IDF. While being half naked, unarmed, and waiving a white flag with SOS in Hebrew, waiving it in front of their faces? What HAMAS did is terrible. That was even more terrible. Imagine being held hostage, you escape your captors who haven’t killed you at this point, you see your countrymen, you do everything you can and they chase and gun you down at first sight. No chance of even a conversation. No military personnel even care to show up to that proud 26 year old Israelis funeral. That father, proud Israeli father, is living that nightmare everyday now. Who do you think he dislikes more? Who do you think he holds more accountable? To me, those 3 hostages are the faces of Israel. Those parents as well. Hope she comes home. Those 3 were gunned down by the men who swore to bring them home. Pray for the ignorant killing to stop. People are shooting their own hostages at this point! You don’t have to be sympathetic to HAMAS to be against Israel. 20,000 lives who had families affected by this are experiencing more pain and grief and Israel doesn’t mention them or the Israeli father I started with. All most Israelis talks about is HAMAS. The hostages families have been pushed to the side. They are protesting there because of it.
They voted Hamas in plus they took part in the attack. Shame on you.@@birdsinparadise3113
@@birdsinparadise3113the fact that Palestine is run by hamas is unbelievable
When hammas took israelis hostages. Muslim says they are heroes.
But when israelis fight back. Muslim says genocide.
The real problem is in islam teaching.
The real problem are your big lies and distored reasoning !
@@user-kw8lp1ei1v yeah, people think this started on October 7th... they should look at what zionist settlers and zionist terrorists have done to Palestinians long before..... 😔
@@user-kw8lp1ei1vthey can't occupy their own country...if it was only about land, then why are jews being attacked abroad?
Old Palestine maps included Jordan too, so why are they not asking Jordan to give their land back?
In any country that shares a region with Islam, there's always a civil war. Islam is hostile and incapable of coexisting with other religions. You dont witness this with Christians, Hindu, Buddhist, etc.
@@user-kw8lp1ei1v god gives you braind to think, not for accessories.
Her poor mother has brain cancer and came out, begging and pleading to see her daughter before she dies, the most heartbreaking thing ever! My heart felt like it was ripping into pieces, watching it. I couldn’t even imagine 😢😢😢
My Lord I can't imagine the pain ,i pray she is still alive...heartbreaking.
😢😢😢😢😢
What a nice daughter, her mother has brain cancer and she goes to drug parties near the Gaza front line. What a lovely Israeli youth.
@@DanieleLeone-re9cv drug partieslol ! When she was taken away, she might think Aliens took her
@ishamon7010--have we heard any updates--my word I need to know, I want to catch my breath! My ❤️ is broken.
It tells me everything about a man that hurts a woman or plays with her life. I thought it’s common sense that during wars you don’t touch woman, children and the elderly. But these monsters decide to capture the most weak and vulnerable ones and play with their lives. What a disgrace.
You're assuming the attackers are civilized. Certain cultures don't respect humanity.
People really need to learn of the values/ideologies of a culture.
Don't think everyone thinks as we do.
This is awful & I pray for her safe return but the way Israeli settlers and the IOF have tortured Palestinians for years shouldn’t be overlooked. It would never got to this if Israel wasn’t committing such terrorism.
@@donnapower2416
Get educated. Israel's home country is Israel. God had Moses lead his people to the land of milk and honey, by the Jordan.
They treat their own women,children and gays like that
Look at Bacha Bazi dancing boys
Noa’s mom’s message brought me to tears. (I’m Chinese, and my mom is also ill).
The fear in this young woman's eyes is gut wrenching. I pray she and the others survive this and she's able to see her mother again
We all would be
Its crazy to think she woke up that morning happy and just like that…
They need to return Noa and all other hostages
Yes your were blind to see Plestinian babies tens on thousend turned into pieces you see only the Ocuupier losts soldiers not tens on thousands of babies killed be the occupier
@absayman well I'm not a soldier kids weren't either
Millions of us are praying for Noa's safety and the safety of the other hostsges.
No offense. How about the Israeli father who lost his 26 year old son? At the hands of the IDF. While being half naked, unarmed, and waiving a white flag with SOS in Hebrew, waiving it in front of their faces? What HAMAS did is terrible. That was even more terrible. Imagine being held hostage, you escape your captors who haven’t killed you at this point, you see your countrymen, you do everything you can and they chase and gun you down at first sight. No chance of even a conversation. No military personnel even care to show up to that proud 26 year old Israelis funeral. That father, proud Israeli father, is living that nightmare everyday now. Who do you think he dislikes more? Who do you think he holds more accountable? To me, those 3 hostages are the faces of Israel. Those parents as well. Hope she comes home. Those 3 were gunned down by the men who swore to bring them home. Pray for the ignorant killing to stop. People are shooting their own hostages at this point! You don’t have to be sympathetic to HAMAS to be against Israel. 20,000 lives who had families affected by this are experiencing more pain and grief and Israel doesn’t mention them or the Israeli father I started with. All most Israelis talks about is HAMAS. The hostages families have been pushed to the side. They are protesting there because of it.
Since when does prayer do anything?
Agreed, there seem to be too many that forget this is a War. In wars too many inconceivable things happen that should not have happened.@@insanitywolf5049
Why wasn’t their 911 call not answered? Why didn’t the IDF come sooner than 8-10 hours?
Why on earth were 3 hostages killed by their own?
I’ve been praying daily for Israel 🇮🇱 to defeat Hamas, but there have definitely been some major mistakes that need to be answered for. 😢
@@TonyFiling
CORRECT.
With 26y/o Alon Shamriz, was REDHEADED 28y/o Yotam Haim; never knew Palestinians were redheads.
More + more we see the IDF lack the most basic discipline.
Noah we haven't forgotten you we pray for your release. Please Lord help the hostages to survive 🙏
God bless palestine
God knows all about this and is okay with it. Good luck to you, Cherish.
@@krisbaker9427God Allah knows the real intention and they're now experiencing the wrath.
No offense. How about the Israeli father who lost his 26 year old son? At the hands of the IDF. While being half naked, unarmed, and waiving a white flag with SOS in Hebrew, waiving it in front of their faces? What HAMAS did is terrible. That was even more terrible. Imagine being held hostage, you escape your captors who haven’t killed you at this point, you see your countrymen, you do everything you can and they chase and gun you down at first sight. No chance of even a conversation. No military personnel even care to show up to that proud 26 year old Israelis funeral. That father, proud Israeli father, is living that nightmare everyday now. Who do you think he dislikes more? Who do you think he holds more accountable? To me, those 3 hostages are the faces of Israel. Those parents as well. Hope she comes home. Those 3 were gunned down by the men who swore to bring them home. Pray for the ignorant killing to stop. People are shooting their own hostages at this point!
@@TonyFilingNo offense, but I think that young woman forced into a Jeep with blood on her pants was the worst of all.
Thank you for sharing Noa’s story, the human face of this tragic war😔 May she be reunited with her mother soon
she will never be reuinted with her family. Her army is bombing the place where she is every single day. How do you think noa will survive
@@admastudios3700 So you think none of Hamas will survive?
@admastudios3700 😂 they having some fun with that party girl... 🥳
@@admastudios3700are you even aware of the amount of tunnels in Gaza? Probably not. Just keep blaming Israel.
ruclips.net/video/3VLe9FX9uZI/видео.htmlsi=O3pCh2A6e02TIT2t
Continuing prayers for Noa, her mother, family and friends, as well as all others affected by the Oct. 7 attack!
ruclips.net/video/3VLe9FX9uZI/видео.htmlsi=O3pCh2A6e02TIT2t
That doesn't do anything
@@DeviantDorkyour comments don't do anything either you little troll so get going! Clearly not the sharpest tool in the shed, are you?
@@DeviantDorkSTFU AND STOP BULLYING PEOPLE!!
Hamas and its supporters, are they still chanting freely on the streets of Europe, Australia and North America?
Noa sounds like a sweet sweet girl All hostages have to be saved❤
Thank you for doing this video. Noa has become the face of all hostages , in a way . Hopefully she will be home soon. As will all people in captivity. Hugs to you , Noa ! 🎈
Hopefully IDF hasn't eliminated her by now. Fingers crossed.
1
lol
@@enterthevoidIiI love how you people pretend to be about peace but all I see from free-Palestine activists online non-stop is insensitivity regarding the victims and pointing the finger at everyone else EXCEPT her actual captors and abusers. Yall pretend to care about innocent people, but show zero compassion for innocent families.
@StefunnyStrange Because they are all straight up EVIL...and not a dissent man among Islamists.
I noticed that most of the women that have not been released are young & very pretty. This is very concerning, because they are probably being kept for monstrous purposes.
They're also soldiers. Different than civilian hostages.
I didn’t want to say it but you’re right. Hopefully it’s just a coincidence.
there have been many young women who have been released... if anything there hasn't been many men that have been released. just the women and children
Typical Muslim behavior....
@@jturtle5318 Most of them are civilians and not soldiers.
Noa is someone that I watched on youtube several times. Prayers for her to return home and the several women children men and elders who are still held. Prayers for their safe and quick return.
Did you watch on RUclips what happened to Rachel Corrie in Gaza? That’s a more newsworthy story.
@@RC-qf3mpNot really
Prayers for palestine, we stand against the occupation army
Is it Israel that is in crisis? I thought 20,000 is larger than 150
@@RC-qf3mpstop talking.
So sad. But a well told story that needs to be shared and heard. This longer format...keep doing this. Context and depth are everything 😢
Why?
WHAT? Context - Hamas apologist? DEPTH - don't include her mom is dying, cut out the footage including the guns. Give me a break! NBC has not been a legitimate news source since Clinton ran for office. I always thought it was so odd NO ONE reported the weird CA fundraisers during Obama's terms - one of them Barbara Streisand was supposed to host but she backed out apparently at the last minute. Always wondered why? Russian Oligarch in attendance - his yacht was actually on the local news. But the national news just wanted to focus on Mel Gibson's troubles! Clinton we had China funding him when he ran out of money during the primaries - most of us didn't have a clue when we cast our ballot for President. Sure would have been nice for the press to do their job! And Obama we had Russians helping (and who knows how many Islamic out of country supporters). It's easy to hide money when you only have to include a sum as a gift or payment for a speaking engagement- and our laws don't make you include to WHOM you spoke and precisely who gave you the gift/sum! Makes the power of the press very important. But it all evaporates when they are sold and work to deliver propaganda not real news.
as soon as see Noa's Mum, cannot watch anymore - horrifying
One point : Noa wasn't the only one documented in an ordinary house that day. Sisters Dafna, 15,and Ela, 8, were also documented in 2 photos inside Gaza, sitting on mattresses in what seemed like an ordinary house.
I believed they, and her, were taken by civilians, and I was worried about whether they'll be released.
On the contrary to Noa, they were, thankfully, released to their mother (their father, step mother, and step brother were murdered that day).
I do hope Noa is freed in time to see her mother.
Most were in houses. There are very few reporting ever being in a tunnel, they'd moved from house to house. Something by now IDF is well aware of but keeps pushing the narrative of tunnels while they bomb houses and apartments
@@TonyFiling stop trolling
Me too !
I know by "civilians" you mean "non-Hamas". But to be clear: international law considers them combatants, even if they don't cary a gun.
I take offense with the narrator calling hostages being held as "in custody", as if the victims were judicially detained or for protection. A poor choice of words, for sure.
No accident that
Yet if it were Palestinians uncharged in a military court,. Then we can say detained in custody right?,.
@@jaleel42yeah the double standards is comical
@@jaleel42Are palestinians getting kidn@pped?
@@jaleel42It's called being held in CUSTODY and happens everywhere in the world.
There's no comparison between that and being forced out of your home in your pyjamas and put on a motorbike and held captive in a tunnel, especially when you are INNOCENT (as all the hostages are) and even more so when you're 85 years old or 10 months old.
How SICK is that??
To kidnap elderly men and women, girls, boys and BABIES???!!! 🤦🏻♀️
heartbreaking. May Noa be returned soon along with all our hostages
So heartbreaking. Please God, keep Noa safe and all hostages safe, and bring them alive and well to their loved ones.
Please God Save Gaza from the Evil IDF!!!!! Please God bring peace and free Palestine from occupation for 75 years!!!!
@@sasham3021will not happen! You're on the side of evil!
This whole situation is so heartbreaking 😔💔
Blame Israel.
ikr? 80,000 either killed. injured or missing under the rubble.....😭
@@kdmo7814that’s called karma.
@@israelizzyyarrashamiaak766its called war crimes against civilians
@@israelizzyyarrashamiaak766its called war crimes against civilians .
Heartbreaking! 💔 May God have a blanket of protection over Noa and the other hostages. I pray their all home with their friends and family very soon. 🙏🙏🙏🙏❤️.
You’re sick! What kind of God allows this to happen in the first place? Why didn’t God use his protective abilities before it even got to this? Your God is a sadist.
Amen
Amen. God, please protect these people. Let them feel your strength and your love. In Jesus name, Amen.
Praying for her protection and mental health. Praying for her to come home to the people who love her.
This is the saddest year, we love you Noa
Bring Noa back home.
Give palestine their land back, praise God brother ❤
@@generaljg4373you want the Jewish people to leave all of Israel
@@generaljg4373it s not their land, it never was. You conquered it in the past. Israel is taking it back from you.
@@generaljg4373I hope karma bites you hard.
Thank you for this video. Pray for our hostages to come back to their families and loved ones in good health
The Palestinians cheered and dance in the streets over the murder of these young women...we all seen this on the news.... I have no sympathy for them..... Level Gaza to the ground...... I'm so sad for this young woman...... If she is still alive she is no doubt an empty shell of the person she once was because of what they have done to her...😢😪
Psycho ,… Israel been doing this to Palestinians for 75 years ,. Read a book
👏 👏 👏 👏
That was wrong but imagine that the ones cheering had family previously killed and abducted by IDF . It no way makes their behaviour correct but you can see there will be no end to this if so called leaders don't sit down and come up with a peace deal
Not so different from Israelies celebrating the bombing of Gazan children and animals then.
you can't do that. you'll have another war in a generation and it will be ten times as destructive. half of the population of gaza is under 18 years old.
I have went down a rabbit hole with videos and stories from this sad sad day😢 I have a daughter who just turned 27 this year so I can only image what her family is going through. My love and prayers are with them all ❤ Thank you God for our country, land of the free home of the brave.
Do you not believe in heaven?
I wonder if the hostages who came back knew how the world was praying for them and searching for them? The people who have no uniform on are Gazans. They say they are all militants or gangs but we saw Gazan civilians, young and old, running into Israel when they broke the fence down and we have heard the stories of Gazan civilians even children using hatchets on innocent Israelis. I pray every day for the hostages.
@@rikailayabbir what has that got to do with anything. Loss is loss, whether someone believes in heaven or not.
And her mum is dying of cancer which makes it sadder
Solidarity with palestine in their struggle for freedom against the occupation
Absolutely heartbreaking. Praying for the release and healing of all hostages. Hamas is pure evil.
Its heartbreaking what happened to Gaza, justice for palestine
God is okay with this situation. Denny, is your praying helping? Maybe you are praying incorrectly?
@@krisbaker9427 why don't you teach me how to pray? I don't worship terrorists lol so I could use a few pointers.
@@dennyjames939 can you answer their question? it seems you are here to deflect. especially since the "but Hammas" retort is a tired deflection that is enabling a genocide. the reported number of Israelis who died keeps going down while Palestinian murders keep going up. we already know you're not going to answer the questions. because you're a coward.
@@generaljg4373 after they invaded another country and murdered and kidnapped ?? Wash your stinky towl first
I pray daily for the resolution of this whole situation. Noa is deeply in need of being able to return to her home and family.
My heart aches for her and her family. Please share this story more and make her cause known widely. May God protect her and other victims of this horrible tragedy and inhumanity of acts that began the day of Noa’s kidnapping. She is forever in my thoughts and prayers.
GOD, PLEASE BRING HER HOME.IT'S HEART BREAKONG EVERYTIME I WATCH THIS VIDEO.PLEASE,GOD,PROTECT HER OF SHE'S STILL HELD SOMEWHERE.
God please give Palestine their land back 🙏
@@generaljg4373Palestine doesn’t exist in history
@@generaljg4373if you have no humanity you do not deserve any land
@@Jerri001obviously education is not your friend
@@generaljg4373try me with education. Whole middle east owned by russian.
Our hearts still cry for these still held in the hands of evil and wicked men!!❤
It's war, you have to expect these things.
@@gambrydew2059wrong! This was a terrorist attack, not a war! You absolute fool!
Israel has the right to defend itself. And Palestine has the right to defend itself.
@@RC-qf3mp kidnapping hostages is defending?
@@shaneprince6572 taking prisoners, not kidnapping. Unless you agree Israel has been kidnapping Palestinians for decades and calling them “prisoners.” No charges, no trial, no judgment. Just another means of ethnic cleansing. Palestine is free to lock up trespassers. So called Israelis have been trespassing since 1948. Palestinians didn’t sign the Sykes Picot, or Balfour declaration, or UN resolution to pretend Israel is a state. Terrorist Zionists drove Palestinians out of their homes and massacred entire villages such as Deir Yassin. Zionists are trespassing and can be imprisoned.
I feel so helpless when i see this. This poor young girl. You can see the fear. Prayers for her and her family.
Prayers help, keep praying. And sending funds to Israel also helps.❤
Do you also feel helpless seeing what happened to civilians in Gaza?
@@insanitywolf5049 brainwashed by propaganda 👍
Maybe someday Noa will come home and see that so many people have been praying for her 🤍
ironic @@generaljg4373
How much money were these civilians paid to take these hostages? This was one of the first clips I saw when I looked on RUclips at the breaking news of the October 7th massacre, I felt sick seeing how terrified she was and I can say in my 54 years I have never seen anything quite so repulsive and heartbreaking in my entire life. My soul broke that day and I lost all faith in humanity. Unfortunatly I fear for her safety, I do not think many of these hostages are still alive, however I pray they are and for the safe return of all of them. ❤
Are they alive?
$10000 and an apartment was payment for each hostage.
From Argentina, I pray for her and the other hostages everyday. My heart hurts for her family, specially her mother, she is dying. This is just so sad, I pray for a miracle for this family.
Christians pray for Noa ✡️🙏✝️🌺
No thanks. We pray for the oppressed.
I think everyone should pray for the hostages and the situation.
I'll best there are Muslims that are praying for the hostages safe returns as well.
@@factsnotfeelings3247Israel is the most oppressed nation on earth.
Israel has been proposing peaceful solutions for decades but is surrounded by countries that want the annihilation of it and the death of all Jews!
@factsnotfeelings3247 OP said "Christians". Yes, Christians are and should be praying for all involved here.
Pray for the christians in Gaza
They will only return the elderly and kids. If you're a young girl... God be with you. Bodies have been found of female hostages with crushed pelvises already. You can only imagine what they went through.
Please cite your source.
@@veramae4098Philistine 🇦🇺
@@veramae4098the world renowned forensic/pathology departments in the Israeli forensic laboratory centre, with international journalists and forensic scientists as witnesses, is that good enough for you ?
@@veramae4098Google is free and easy to use. If you choose to be ignorant, shame on you.
@@veramae4098 Simchat Greyman, which was a volunteer to help move bodies, along with her colleagues reported this to the UN. It's been covered by Ivana Kottasova and many other journalist in the area. This was also presented at the screening recently of Hamas attacks where raw body cam footage is shown. Enough sources for you?
I pray for Noa in pray she is safe. I pray she is not being harmed. I pray she is returned to her family and she will be able to see her mom again. I pray for all the hostages and their release. I pray this war ends. In Jesus name. Amen
Prayer does nothing
No offense. How about the Israeli father who lost his 26 year old son? At the hands of the IDF. While being half naked, unarmed, and waiving a white flag with SOS in Hebrew, waiving it in front of their faces? What HAMAS did is terrible. That was even more terrible. Imagine being held hostage, you escape your captors who haven’t killed you at this point, you see your countrymen, you do everything you can and they chase and gun you down at first sight. No chance of even a conversation. No military personnel even care to show up to that proud 26 year old Israelis funeral. That man, Israeli man, is living that nightmare everyday now. Who do you think he dislikes more? Who do you think he holds more accountable? To me, those 3 hostages are the faces of Israel. Those parents as well. Hope she comes home. Those 3 were gunned down by the men who swore to bring them home. I pray the senseless killing can stop. People are shooting their own hostages at this point!
@@TonyFilingwhat's the matter with you?? You seriously think those soldiers knew and deliberately shot their own people?? They're there putting their own lives at risk in order to find and bring back the hostages. The entire country lives and breathes those people for 3 months now. Unfortunately, casualties are part of war, and sadly and cruelly, these 3 were also casualties. We don't blame our soldiers for what happened to those 3 young men, but the Hamas, who dragged them to Gaza in the first place
@@TonyFilingbe quiet dude. It's not whats at issue here. There is plenty y of tragedy to go around...
@MoniqueLuzey-cf9mv are you also praying for the dead Christian mother and daughter who were murdered by an Israeli sniper inside a church?
Its weird how they ignored Noahs boyfriend
The first responders' numbers were probably overwhelmed, I mean with people calling from the kibbutzim too 😢
@@leenieledejo6849I think he means it’s weird that nbc ignored him as a missing person, as if his life doesn’t matter. Only cute missing women matter, not men. Like in the US, young blonde missing women get a lot of attention. Black women, not so much. Racist and sexist “news” coverage . It’s what they don’t cover that makes it biased.
Exactly my thoughts after finish watching the video. Anyways... this whole news segment is what they call Missing Pretty/White girl syndrome. The MEDIA is great at sensationalizing this.
She's not white. She is Asian. Her mother is Chinese from China. The Chinese government could help
@@olg06Noa is not white. She’s Jewish.
Her boyfriend is also missing. He hasnt been heard from at all since october 7.
One of the male friends being interviewed looks really like her boyfriend!?
Only God knows what these women are going through! It is very scary!
And the families of all the hostages? So helpless, in completly agony, but full of hope!
Every day I pray for them! ❤
I pray for Noa 🙏🏾 and all the other hostages still being kept, may God guide you all through these terrible times 😢
Where is NOA? Bring her back.
In gaza kiddnapped
Her face, her face, will always be remembered and is now in my mind forever
Praying for Noa everyday! Her and Naama Levy are at the top of my heart, waiting and waiting for news on these two young women. 🇺🇸❤️🇮🇱
Thank you Sara. I’m an Israeli woman and often can’t sleep at nights thinking about these girls and the rest of our people there. Non Israelis often don’t understand that also our soldiers are actually just children. We have
a mandatory army service at 18 years old!
@@ih719 I am back here 3 weeks later, still praying and thinking about Noa. So very heartbroken for these 14 women including Noa, Naama Levy, Karina Ariev, Liri Albug, Agam Berger, and Daniela Golboa and Shari Bibas and her one and four year old boys and their father and all 136 hostages. Still there in Gaza 98 days later. 🇮🇱❤️🇺🇸
God bless you sister 🙏❤️🌟
Which god?
God bless palestine amen to that
@@generaljg4373 Palestine don't exist.
@@generaljg4373allah is not god. Allah is our president slave
@@generaljg4373God condemn Hamas pure evil no palastine person would live freely with Jess they said it themselves
Thank you for sharing Noa's story. I am praying for her like so many others, and now will pray for her Mother as well. The whole story is tragic. Noa is so well loved and so beautiful. May God watch over her and bring her back.
Praying for your release Noa. May God protect you and bring you home. ♥️🕊️
We all know exactly why they don't want specific women to be released.
Think for 5 seconds, and then realise why they didn't release some specific WOMEN.
People are so stupid to think that
Why
I want to know
@@angelamclaughlin2170Are you really that obtuse?? R@pe and torture, 👌??
Praying for Noa and all the other hostages safe return.💫🙏💜
I hope Noa is found healthy. I hope all the hostages return asap! There are a bunch of them I think about everyday since they got kidnapped. The young girls they kidnapped for a reason, n we all know why. So sad😔
Ok well i know one of the girls out of the original group won't be turned over. Her death was all over the news. And it was graphic. They didn't show how it happned but showed the end result. She was from Germany. Her mother was talking on tv. She died the day the attack happned and parts of her skull have been found.
The video of this girl has haunted me. On 07.10, unedited videos appeared on IG. I prayed and hoped for her survival plus the other girl with " greased" pyjamas. It was so tragic when her death was confirmed. There is no comparison between this positive and happy dancing girl and the torture she went through. May The Almighty comfort her family.
@@themercy234her name is Shani Louk. It still bothers me about how that young lady must have suffered. Now she's at peace and dancing with the angels. 🕎✝️🛐
@@themercy234 yeah the video was burned I my mind for a week. I feel so bad for her mother because I read her mother found out about what happned to her daughter by seeing her on tv first. The video we have seen apparently is how the mother found out what happned.
Oddly I remember people hoping she was still alive. I'm not a Dr, but I could tell the girl was either dead or dying when it was recorded. Terrible.
@@themercy234 greased pajamas?
@@whitneymiller3809I think she means Naama Levy, who's pants are soaked with blood in the video where an African militant is pulling her out of the back of a jeep and putting her in the back seat.
And hamas broke the deal...Israel got back children ,women, the elderly while hamas and the PA got back terrorists 😢
Of course, Israel would say Hamas broke the deal.
Yes young children sent to prison for 15 plus years for throwing rocks!
@@Nike2030That is a lie, and you know it.
@@halimaali798
Just because Hamas LIES (part of their belief), doesn't mean everyone lies.
My heart is broken for all the victims of Hamas !!!!!!!💔💔💔💔💔💔💔💔💔💔💔💔
Heartbreaking! 😪
Praying for Noa Release May Almighty Father God Help all the captives especially Noahs Mother is critically ill❤❤❤ my heart is so breaking for her mother not to see her daughter💝🙏💖♥️👏👏👏
Amen.
No offense. How about the Israeli father who lost his 26 year old son? At the hands of the IDF. While being half naked, unarmed, and waiving a white flag with SOS in Hebrew, waiving it in front of their faces? What HAMAS did is terrible. That was even more terrible. Imagine being held hostage, you escape your captors who haven’t killed you at this point, you see your countrymen, you do everything you can and they chase and gun you down at first sight. No chance of even a conversation. No military personnel even care to show up to that proud 26 year old Israelis funeral. That father, proud Israeli father, is living that nightmare everyday now. Who do you think he dislikes more? Who do you think he holds more accountable? To me, those 3 hostages are the faces of Israel. Those parents as well. Hope she comes home. Those 3 were gunned down by the men who swore to bring them home. Pray for the ignorant killing to stop. People are shooting their own hostages at this point!
Praying for her safe return 🙏🏻
Did you see that bloody child's bed? Just imagine that that was YOUR child's bed, It will be very soon if you keep silent
This is heart breaking praying for Noa's and the remaining hostages return. Sickened by the barbaric attack of October 7, 2023
So heartbreaking. Senseless violence😢
Thank you for this report. My heart breaks for the hostages, their family and friends.
My heart also breaks for the Palestinian people who have also lost their family and friends.
I am sending love, support in the hopes that hostages will be released and Peace can be restored.
this is what happend in africa every days and no one is talking about those Hama,jihads, MUSLIM ;; Always kidnap WOMEN ..
Still you are not going to get the Israeli visa
same in pakistan, kashmir and bangladesh
I really wish they have the humanity to bring Noa home asap, her mother is seriously ill and doesn't have much more time. Please don let her mother pass away before seeing her daughter again and letting her know that her only child is safe and back home with her and her father. Give Noa the chance to see her mother before she passes please.
What about thousands of Palestinians women who are being held hostage in Israeli Jails without charges for years? Noa was at party on stolen land
No offense. How about the Israeli father who lost his 26 year old son? At the hands of the IDF. While being half naked, unarmed, and waiving a white flag with SOS in Hebrew, waiving it in front of their faces? What HAMAS did is terrible. That was even more terrible. Imagine being held hostage, you escape your captors who haven’t killed you at this point, you see your countrymen, you do everything you can and they chase and gun you down at first sight. No chance of even a conversation. No military personnel even care to show up to that proud 26 year old Israelis funeral. That father, proud Israeli father, is living that nightmare everyday now. Who do you think he dislikes more? Who do you think he holds more accountable? To me, those 3 hostages are the faces of Israel. Those parents as well. Hope she comes home. Those 3 were gunned down by the men who swore to bring them home.
@@TonyFiling I am going to take offense that you are engaging in a tragic level of whataboutism in multiple comments when the reality is that they never should've been taken hostage to begin with and to sweep that under the rug is not necessary when you can criticize Israel's response without forsaking those ripped from their homes and lives by extremists.
I cant stop thinking about her,she was terrified...please God bring her home...I have 16 grandchildren and 4 great grandchildren.. 8 granddaughters and 8 grandsons....she is my heart as are all the hostages...I pray and pray for them...
Pray, but she is not a hostage, she is a soldier, so she is a *war prisonner* .
There were 2 distinct groups that streamed into Israel on October 7, the Hamas group and the Gazan civilian group. At the end of the day Hamas had an accurate assessment of the number hostages they had in their possession. At the same time Hamas had no idea of how many Israeli females were abducted by the Gazan civilians, for let's say 'personal use'. And yes, if any of these females are still alive, Hamas and Gaza certainly do not want these females returned to Israel to tell the World of what has happened to them while in captivity.
Says a lot about Palestinian civilians.
When anyone asks why Gaza is being turned into a parking lot, have em look at this video. No ceasefire, no negotiation until Hamas surrenders and the hostages return. Period.
Sending prayers for Noa's safe return.
It's very sad to see innocent people dying because of the guilty
I blame the occupation for this tragedy
You’re right. It makes me sad, too. This endless fighting instigated by the MIC and it’s spiritually stunted leaders is terrible and unnecessary and, probably unbeknownst to them, is damaging their own consciousness. The Abrahamics specifically fighting endlessly with one another is childish. But that’s to be expected from supremacists. I’m sure this reply to you will be censored. I’ll be surprised if it’s not. Aloha. 🤙🏽
yep. apartheid states shouldn't exist. @@generaljg4373
She definitely isn't innocent.
@@DeviantDorkhuh?
Really deep, excellent light-handling of a painfully sensitive topic and ongoing, maybe even worsening situation. Stay strong Raf, blessings 💛🙏🏼
This is horrible. I cannot sleep nor eat anymore. War is terrible. I am so worried for the toddlers who are still captive, the women also and all the others.
Yes I feel the Same…. 💔 They are always on my mind, praying every day
You forget to mention that the Israelis women and children taken hostage did not do anything. But the women and children from Israelis prison did crimes attacking, stabing or even bombing attacks ...
Great job in Geo-locating the point Noa was taken from, now all they need to do is find the two guys on the motorbike! Prayers for Noa and her family.
Please keep in mind the rest of the hostages who did not receivet video coverage . .😢.. They are ALL in need of prayers 🙏🏿🙏🏿🙏🏿🇮🇱❤️🇮🇱
so hamas get their criminals back at the cost of all the lives lost in gaza? this seems fair to these nutters
Stop dehumanizing Palestinians.
@@rikailayabbirHamas is dehumanizing their own people! Swopping criminals and paying with the deaths of kids, you sick in the head to support this
@@rikailayabbirIt's HAMAS and wicked Palestinians who dehumanize Palestinians!
They kidnapped the young Israeli soldier Gilad Shalit between 2006 and 2011 and only released him when Israel agreed to release *1,027* Palestinian prisoners!!
It's the same this time. We see THREE Palestinian prisoners released for every ONE hostage.
We see young men on serious terrorism charges being swapped for little children like the 9 year old Israeli/Irish girl.
I mean, Hamas do not care about lives. Period.
They take most of the aid for themselves and spend it on rockets, weapons and building tunnels.
That's their priority: death and destruction.
Not life.
Using people as human shields is ANOTHER example of their pure wickedness and how they DO NOT CARE about their own people.
And by the way, Israeli soldiers have NEVER paraded a dead Palestinian girl stripped naked through the streets of Jerusalem as Hamas terrorists did with Shani Louk, with excited bystanders taking photos and SPITTING on her body.
Since then, a piece of her skull is all that's been found.
What threat did she pose exactly?????!
What threat did 10 month old Kfir Bibas pose????!
Hamas/Palestinians treat Israelis worse than animals.
There's nothing more dehumanizing than desecrating bodies.
Israel has a specific group of volunteers called Zaka who take care of bodies, even those of dead Palestinians.
The reality is that it would be impossible even to imagine Palestinians doing that for Israelis.
Desecrating a body is the LOWEST OF THE LOW.
Some verses from their book about dehumanizing the "enemy" 👇
the 4th sura (what it says about women)
The following verses from the Qur'an about dealing with non Muslims: 9,5, 9,29, 9,73.
Also 👇
"So when you meet them who don't believe, smite their necks till you have killed and wounded many of them" (Qur'an 47:4)
"And fight them (the unbelievers) until there is no more unbelief (fitnah) and the religion will all be for Allah alone" (Qur'an 8:39)
And:
Surah 3, 151
2,191
9, 5
And: Sahih al bukhari 2926
what is ur thought about Israel actions who did since last 2 decade lots of noa like woman's & childeren, recently more than 4 to 500 of Palestinian live buried by Israel they are the Champion of Human Rights.
Please show me where i may investigate these facts, ive seen none @ghazanfarali9879
A correction needs to be made... When you talk about the exchange of women and children between Israel and the Palestinians, there is a BIG difference: first of all, Israeli children are real children 9 months, 3, 9, 12 years old.. etc... ordinary children and women are civilians whom Hamas simply stole from their homes. These Palestinian "children" are life-threatening teenage criminals, and the women are just female criminals too, imprisoned by the LAW!
I am praying for Noa and her family 🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻
Those who took her looks more like gazan civilians,so they took her for their own pleasure.
people who did those kidnappings were promised of $$$$ and apartments, thats why they brought even dead bodies in gaza.
Muslim men
@@sumiben5211servants of mohammad
One of the dead hostages, a young woman, was examined in Israel. Hamass said she was killed in a bombing but the autopsies showed she was shot. Now we know that she was killed by a doctor in al shifa hospital
War is ugly . I feel so bad for what they are going through. Prayers going forth
If we ever needed the power of psychics (if the power is real), it is now. Let them all organize together and help us locate these hostages!
That’s so terrible, hope she is found. 😢
US/Israel propaganda at its finest. “Hamas has never provided evidence that hostages have been killed by Israeli strikes” literally cuts to an entire city block of apartment buildings being brought down by one idf missle 😂😂😂
I can't get her face out of my mind....
I hope she is okay 🙏🏿 That's all the other hostages prayers❤❤❤
Ich bete für Dich Noa das Du wieder nach Hause kommst. Es ist unvorstellbar grausam was geschehen ist 😢
amen
I‘m praying for Noa every day.
What becomes very clear again in this video, there were cilivilians taking place in the atrocities…To me that‘s really shocking news but yet not suprising in any way.
what about her boyfriend? His life doesn't matter? This report didn't care to tell anything about his whereabouts.
Maybe his parents opted out of this televised report
Because propaganda works better when it's a woman.
Because men aren't being even discussed in the exchange of hostages.
@@ixmini2561
Your life must be in 2D if you think is such a simplistic way.
@deepk91
I am sure that his life matters as much as anyone else's.
We can hope for the best, but be prepared for the worst.
Praying that justice will be done.
Her kidnapping has broken me……I’m praying she reunites with her mother Liora…..I have never been so devastated in hearing something as this!
Would you be devastated if she was a man?
It’s clear why they are not being released. Heathens.
Yes, you could see the on the faces of the Hamas terrorist men who sandwiched her on that motorcycle. We know. Shame on the supporters of Hamas.
I fear for these young ladies that are being held hostage. Because i'm pretty sure that they have had to endure unimaginable horrors on a daily basis at the hands of those fiends. Doubtful that Hamas would allow them to return to their people when they had to endure and witnesse what they have.
No one in Gaza is innocent. No one.
Poor Noa and all the other captives.. I hope they all are alive but somehow I have my doubts 🙏😢
🙏🏼💔for Noa and her Mother 🙏🏼❤️🇦🇺
Let noa and any other hostages go. Pls😢 devastating not knowing may they all be free and safe soon. I seriously don’t watch stuff like this but this one got me. 💔
The way media is over using and abusing her distressed face and emotion is beyond me. Imagine this being your child, niece, sister, aunt etc and this footage being thrown at your face repeatedly and you dont know if you are seeing her last moments alive.
I understand what you’re saying. But if that’s what’s needed for people to keep talking about the hostages, if that’s what’s needed to make sure no one will forget that they are still there, held by the monsters of Hamas - that’s the right thing to do. Especially when it seems that the world never really cared about them to begin with, let alone now, 7 months later.
I can't get her face out of my head, pure fear in her eyes...
THANK YOU NBC for doing this story !!! Where's Noa is the one question I keep asking over and over again !!! 4 ever Noa
noa is never coming back. she is probably under the rubble in many pieces
@@admastudios3700There never was Palestine land !!! HaShem gave the Land deed to Israel. 😅
I was wondering about Noa since the day I saw that video . I was speaking to some one in the family . He told me , they would never release Noa because she is a beautiful young girl .
I couldn’t sleep for nearly a week after that .
More than 20,000 Palestinian people have been killed, more than 50,000 people are already injured or disappeared, but question, where is Noe?Netanyahu is the only one who should be held accountable.
No to ceasefire unless all hostages are home. It's insane for Hamas to demand a ceasefire when they refuse to release the hostages.
Hippocrate u and ur nation r u blind did not seen facts in past or present who r responsible of all this mascare
I believe Noah's boyfriend is the nephew of my Aunts ex husband. He decided to follow her with the terror group, saying he needs to protect her. He could have walked away a free man because they didn't even take him at first.
Really? So you're saying he wouldn't have been taken to Gaza but he wanted to be with her.
This part of the story needs to be told. Did Avinatan know any Arabic?
@luv2travel2000 I don't know if he knows Arabic, but ye basically he wanted to be there to protect his girl.