Mortal Kombat Trilogy (Sega Saturn vs PlayStation) Side by Side Comparison (Dual Longplay) VCDECIDE
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 15 окт 2024
- A Visual Comparison of Mortal Kombat Trilogy for Sega Saturn and PS1 (PSX/ PlayStation). The video shows a Dual Playthrough with the Kintaro character of the Mortal Kombat series on standard difficulty in order to compare the two systems side-by-side whose purpose is of study and learn.
Support my work on RUclips: / vcdecide
Technical data -
Full Game Name: Mortal Kombat Trilogy
Developer: Avalanche Software (PlayStation) Point of View (Sega Saturn)
Publisher: Midway
Comparative Region: American Version
Game Language: English
Genre: Fighting Game
Mode: 1 or 2 Players (versus)
Format: CD
Year: 1996 (PS1) 1997 (Saturn)
Dual Gameplay by VCDECIDE
#vcdecide #gameplaycomparison #visualcomparison
![Mortal Kombat Trilogy [PS1] - All Animalities](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/8ChxUvYZ4lM/mqdefault.jpg)
the voice of shao kahn when said “wins” is different, on sega saturns use the mk2 version and psx use the mk3
That's a weird change.
UMK3 also worked like this: When you play as Scorpion, the last game he appeared was MK II, so, it is exactly the same phrase "Scorpion Wins" that you hear in MK II. So, Rai(y)den, Johnny Cage, Scorpion, etc., all are announced with the MK II tone as the characters from MK 3, are announced with a different tone, as the phrase was recorded for the latest game.
In MK Trilogy for the PSX it is also the same, but for the bosses, something has changed. I have no idea why.
Played the hell out of the PC version. That was some money well spent. And yes, it IS superior to the Saturn version, because installation to the hard drive drastically shortens the load times. My only gripe with Trilogy is that some of the sprites are of mixed quality, and that the Pit II no longer has a stage fatality, but that's due to them not wanting to re-shoot a bunch of new footage of each of the MK3 characters falling.
The PC version also had larger sprites from what i remember. Closer to the arcade. But to be fair all the Saturn versions of MK were poor/lazy ports, often the same as the PSX when the Saturns hardware was capable of more. Capcom did things right on Saturn. And i completely agree with the sprite quality in Trilogy. It looked cheap with such large inconsistencies between old and new sprites/stages. Every character from the older games needed re-shooting, plus the dated and crappy looking MK1 stages badly needed updating, but they were lazy and cheap so they didn't get my money.
@@NoClipMode point of view used avalanche software ps1 source to port it to the Saturn. Very lazy what they did and avalanche software should've developed mkt to the Saturn instead of point of view.
Bought the PC version back then, and it simply would not work. I don't mean my PC was too slow and the performance was awful, it just wouldn't even start! Had to take it back. It's been a quarter century, and it still pisses me off when I think about it. I wanted to play it so bad.
@@longtallshorty5791 you could get the GoG version, it fixes everything to work without problems in any modern OS.
@@longtallshorty5791 So play it now, it was a bitch to get it to run on PC I used the dos version and was able to play it.
They look pretty even. I guess it would be more of a preference on which controller you prefer to play Mortal Kombat with. I love the Saturn controller for Street Fighter style fighters, but I actually like the PlayStation controller better for Mortal Kombat.
I swear I want to report every comment that Sega Saturn controller is better than the PS controller for fighting games LOL just kidding. But I do prefer the PlayStation controller for very fundamental foundational reasons such as the attack buttons being accessible by three fingers independently!
This makes instant hell murder in Street fighter so much easier to pull off and chain combos are also easier and more fluid because you don't have so much travel with your fingers from button press to button press...
Also I've never liked arcade sticks because the travel distance is just too much!! Although I did let a demographic of the fgc gas light me for a while until cats started winning Evo with PlayStation controllers...
BTW, I think I prefer the PlayStation version of MK trilogy because the PlayStation has a better sound processor and you can definitely hear the crunchiness in the Sega Saturn sound effects...
Oddly enough the crunchy sound doesn't bother me in Street fighter zero 3 on the Sega Saturn because the visuals are so drop dead gorgeous!! Not to mention the sound processor is definitely better utilized by Capcom than it is by Midway so I think the implementation is also a determining Factor...
@@bryantnonya8704 the 6 button format is untouchable for fighting games...maybe you have a saturn now, but it seems you just grew up playing solely on ps controllers so thats your preference/soft spot...I grew up playing and having both and because of the controller i always got my multi platform fighting games on the saturn,, i never had a reason to play street fighter, dark stalkers or mk on the ps....that's one thing Saturn got right
@@starstarstar4643 no I say the PlayStation controller is superior because it is superior and even my best friend who's much better at fighting games than you are agreed with me...
@@bryantnonya8704 the reason why ppl say the 6 button format is better is because its awkward to use your fingers as main gameplay buttons unless its an fps for trigger and aim or the turbo button for nba jam/2k/live/street/hangtime me personallyi think the ps d-pad is embarrassingly terrible and 4 shouldler buttons never made since to me.....but theres always that small (very small) percentage of ppl who think otherwise so i guess ppl like you 🤷♂️......hmm just like there are ppl who prefer to use an analog stick for fighting games....go figure
@@starstarstar4643 maybe it's more difficult using the left shoulder buttons but I completely disagree with your overall assessment mainly because of what I said before regarding travel between buttons on a six button controller. Maybe you could sell me on an arcade stick although I doubt it...
The only thing I need as proof that the PlayStation controller is superior is the fact that one of my best friends growing up agreed with me and he's one of the greatest fighting game players I've ever seen! He's not just one of the greatest fighting game players. He's one of the greatest video game players ever. Rank number three in the world on EverQuest and the only player in the world who could solo kill gods. In the top 1% on the mortal Kombat leaderboards. Absolutely obliterated every local legend at the arcade! And he was so good at Warcraft 3 beta he became a permanent beta tester for blizzard... This is the one who agrees with me so I apologize if that invalidates your opinion...
Que felicidade saber que seu canal está ativo! Parabéns pelo conteúdo!
The most important things to remember about the saturn version is it doesn't have the crash bug that happens on the ps1 and the music and voices also don't glitch out and start cracking or randomly skip and start over.
I don't care about transparent effects or those other little things but I do care if a game is running without problems and the saturn does run without getting any of those problems along with having better controls.
Hell Tantrumbull 100% with you on that one..👍👍
Crash bug?
@@JakstheKid There's a chance the game will crash because of the sound glitches. if you're playing it on the ps2 the chances of the crash happening goes up because of how the system is running ps1 games.
@@HellTantrumbull Occasionally crashes for me on a PS3. Haven't played it on original hardware since the early 2000s.
@@mortenpotzdidler1998 Yeah, In the case of MK trilogy since the game was already having crash problems on the ps1 it's most likely worse when running on ps3 because of the emu.
Also you might not know this but for any ps1 game that got a digital version on the ps3 the disc version might not work properly. the emu might have some glitches or even crashes happen that were fixed for the digital versions so keep an eye out for that for any ps1 disc games you have.
Both look practically identical but yet both consoles should be capable of producing this game perfectly anyway they both look great
Feliz por essa comparação. Não encontrei sites q colocassem as diferenças em hardwares originais de PS1 vs Saturn neste jogo, e vc inovou nisto. Outra coisa q adorei é a evolução (amadurecimento) do canal, com comentários sobre cada uma das versões (não sabia q o PS1 tinha sido a plataforma escolhida para o desenvolvimento, assim como a equipe do Saturn é a msm do PC)! Esse canal está como vinho, melhor a cada ano! Uma sugestão q talvez tu possas explorar no futuro, e tem pouco conteúdo na net, é a diferença das versões iniciais de um jogo (Black Label), com suas as versões bug fixes (Greatest Hits). O próprio MK Trilogy é um exemplo disto (parece q o pessoal reclamava do tempo de transformação do Shang Tsung). Enfim, só sugestão, o canal tá excelente e melhorou mto com as tuas ponderações no vídeo! Parabéns pela evolução!
PS1 looks a little cleaner especially in the soul chamber if you look at the soulnado in the background and compare the two.
Lol. You really tried to find something. This is close to one for one. If the gameplay is identical. Then for me it would be about which controller I prefer to use.
@@roldanrosario8292 the differences are very small I do know Saturn always had an issue when it came to transparency effects if you look at the smoke around smoke it looks a lil weird due to that. It really does come down to load time and controller preference And I’ll take the PlayStation controller any day
@@Schlumped1684 Same here, for Mortal Kombat I prefer a PS controler. But, when it comes to Street Fighter it’s the Saturn controler. PS controler is closer to what I was use to on the SNES. Saturn controler is closer to the SF arcade button layout. You can’t go wrong with either one though both are responsive and playable.
Transparency effect on health bars is different. Only thing I spotted
Longarms sega Saturn original
Voices are better set than in Psx version
@@alexmatos2659 perfeito...
Longarms
Don’t forget the shadows.
@@ThatOldSchoolMagic not sure how I saw the health bars and not that 😄
En televisión crt es donde está la magia, ahí se nota como se aprovecha el no tener transparencia.
Besides the transparency effect, the only thing i noticed is the voice sounds during the endurance matches. In the PSX version, all male characters share the same voice clips (i don't remember if this applies to Sheeva and females), while in the Saturn version, Baraka and Jhonny Cage have separate voice sets (at least, it shows in this video). Dunno if this had something to do with RAM limitation in the PSX or was just laziness. My only grip about the Saturn is that they could have taken advantage of the RAM expansion carts to reduce loading times, add Shang Tsung as a possible enemy on the towers (morphing means loading times), and maybe include these changes to the PC version. Still, great video!
There's no way they would have made the game compatible with the RAM cartridge since it wasn't even released in the U.S.
@@SEGAHEADDY I'm pretty sure it was. I swear I've seen it with an ESRB rating.
@@casualvanilla I meant the RAM cart wasn't released in the U.S. The game WAS.
@@SEGAHEADDY Oh, you're right, my bad. It definitely didn't use the RAM cart. Most the effort for Trilogy went to the PlayStation and N64 versions. The Saturn and PC versions just weren't given as much focus. I mean, they released the next year whereas the previous two released in 1996.
Actually, when it comes to sound memory the PS1 has the same amount of RAM as the Saturn. In fact, it’s actually easier to store more sound effects on the PS1 because of its built-in sound compression
I never would've thought that this version is better on the Saturn!!
How?!?
Saturn vence, controle 6 botões prático como todo jogo de luta dele. Loading's rápidos, vozes, cenários e personagens fiéis, mesmo sem o detalhe da transparência da barra de vida. Parabéns!
e nas sombras
O loading no Saturn não é rápido.
The PS1 version received a few revisions and the latest revision is considered the best by competitive UMKIII players.
I think the revisions primarily fixed the gravity and little stuff like that to make it play more like Ultimate Mortal Kombat 3. However, I'm pretty sure the Saturn version got those fixes upon launch along with the PC version. I know for a fact that the N64 version didn't.
It's interesting to see how close these ports are when you compare that with how the SNES versus Genesis MK titles had much larger differences between them. Although people complain about the dithering effect developers used on Saturn, I have a feeling most people would barely notice it on a CRT. It would be interesting to see a test for both either with a simulated CRT or real-life CRT with high-quality capture. I think if I had to re-do my choice for that generation (I was an N64 evangelist), I'd pick PlayStation, but I'm coming around to the idea that Saturn was actually a decent system that suffered from the erosion of consumer confidence (from 32X and Saturn) and SOA and SOJ's constant battles.
Damn you owned a N64? I'm Sorry to hear that😢
that's because both display the same resolution and number of colors here. Snes and Genesis didn't. Genesis had higher resolution and Snes 3 to 4 times more colors on screen at once, so games rarely if ever looked identical.
And no, even if the effect isn't nearly as bad on a CRT screen, dithering is very noticeable. On cartoonish games like Street Fighter is fine, even the Arcades use it, but on more realistic ones like MK it looks atrocious. On Saturn's UMK3 port you can barely see it as shadows are black and other colors are solid, but with MKT they just copy pasted the PS1 game to Saturn and changed the real transparency to dithering. There's a lot of it througout the game and it's very noticeable.
Joguei bastante a versão do polistation' desse game, bom mk!
Não joguei no Sega flop'Saturn, mas pelo video se vê bem a versao do console da Sega, diversão garantida em ambas plataformas. 👍
On this, I have the Saturn winning. The reason for this is because, the loading times were shorter than the psx. In the cemetery stage, I noticed that, the clouds appeared more often on the Saturn than the psx. The colors were more vibrant on Satarn than, the psx (look at Kintaro's color scheme a little closer)
Lembro muito bem desse loading do Saturn... Era o maior tédio, até pegar a versão de PC que aí sim, poderia usar Shang Tsung e suas transformações, sem contar o loading que não existia.
Joguei muito pouco a versão de ps1.
Obrigado pelo vídeo :)
E na versão n64 tbm
Sim, infelizmente a versão de Pc tinha os gráficos inferiores, como por exemplo a arena Deadpool, na versão de Pc o ácido no fundo não possui as animações, já nas demais versões possui, embora tenha como consertar isso instalando o Kommunity Patch usando as versões de Sega ou Ps como base.
A principal diferença está nas sombras e efeitos de fumaça do Smoke que parecem mais apagadas na versão do Saturno do que no PS1, porem a versão do Saturno ganha em loading mais rápidos e um joystick melhor para games de luta em geral, a melhor versão talvez seja a de PC pois não tem loading, o problema é que ela não roda bem no Windows 10.
No saturno so parece mais granulado igual symphony o efeito de fumaça dependendo do caso eu prefiro o controle base do saturno mais o meu favorito e o dualshock
Os gráficos da versão PS estão um pouco melhores também, dá pra notar pelas arenas The Pit 3 (que as lanternas no fundo parecem mais vívidas no PS) e naquela arena que tem o rio (onde se você observar direitinho, os prédios no fundo tem a coloração mais acurada no PS, já no Sega está bem forte o tom de roxo).
Em contrapartida, os loading do Sega parecem um pouco mais rápidos, e os sons parecem melhores nele, embora em volume bem mais baixo.
A versão de Pc realmente não possui os malditos loadings, porém muitas arenas eles optaram porcamente por remover as animações delas, tipo a Deadpool, que o ácido no fundo não borbulha, simplesmente fica estático, em contra partida os sprites estão mais acurado nessa versão.
Player shadows, health bar, and colour toning is better on the Playstation. Much less dithering. The Saturn has better load times.
I can't get over the transparencies and the better presentation. PS1 wins. Love the Saturn tho
Unless ur using a arcade stick and setup, the saturn version is usually better with alot of fighting games because of the 6 button layout and better D pad. I have both versions, and the saturn version is better to learn combos on then the ps1 controller.
There is loading in endurance match though when the next character comes.
The Saturn version, though 6 months late to the scene, had slightly quicker loading times. For some reason, the developers used crosshatch for smoke and shadows even though the Saturn can shade in 2D like the PS1. Parallax dithering occurs in both, so the differences are minimal. I guess it depends upon the controller you use and the system you have.
@@toejamandearl8110 apparently the reason a lot of developers used checkerboard transparency is because you couldn’t go transparent between the 2 VDP boards. I wouldn’t be surprised if this wasn’t in the documentation and tripped up developers late into their game production cycle.
Cara a versão PC praticamente nao contem loadings,o saturn falta alguns efeitos sonoros e tem slowdows e travamentos em alguns momentos,a versão PC e praticamente a versão definitiva pq como nao tem loadings,se jogar com shang tsung pode transformar em qualquer personagem que ele vai aparecer sem travar ou espera para carregar o sprite
Concordo, a versão do PC praticamente não tem Loadins, no demais é bem parecida com essas apresentadas (não prestei atenção a transparência) por isso na minha opinião a melhor versão é a do PC.
@@bmwisetta300 O problema da versão de PC é que no Win 10 fica sem musica, no Win 7 parece não haver esse problema.
The game plays significantly better with the Saturn pad personally. Can't go wrong with any of these two versions!
The sound is cleaner on the Saturn. The parts that were "muffled" on PSX were filtered on the Saturn and a hint lesser loading time. BTW I own 2 original copies of this for Saturn. I got a hot cop of this for my PSX - But that loading at times can put someone to sleep
@@cantstopbeeboo2055 the PlayStation has superior audio then the Saturn, especially in this game, and some of the audio clips are missing on the Saturn, like when u use the run button, and on the Saturn they actually use the announcer from mk 2 with certain characters. The PlayStation is definitely the superior version. And that’s that this is a 2D game.
saturn version have problems with transparency and shadow
@Terra Firma Sana Same.
All that loading the ps1 had to do at the beginning and covered it up with flashy fmv for the logos 😂
Saturn version loads significantly faster
significantly?
@@ClevertonHeusner Yes, significantly. Look at all the times he has to pause the Saturn side to let the PS catch up.
But the Saturn version has crappy dithered shadows, because it can't handle transparencies very well.
@@christopherwalkinalloverya5824 But the saturn has literally the best 2d controller, the 6 button layout+D pad is superior. Unless ur using some arcade setup the saturn is better.
but the saturn cant do 3d well
Difference in loading times (Saturn seems to be faster most of the times), Smoke's smoke is fully transparent in PSX while in Saturn they do the old-school trick, the announcer's voice is different for each version, at least in the "Kintaro wins" bit. No more relevant differences IMO. It's pretty much a draw for me.
Also, alot of people forget to realize, the saturn's 6 button controller and better D pad is literally THE best 2d controller. Unless ur using a arcade setup with a joystick, nothing really comes close. I have both versions and the saturn controller is what gives the nod to the saturn for me.
@@profo4544 Indeed. Even today, I still only use controllers that mimic the 6-button arcade/Sega layout instead of the more conventional "diamond" layout - you know, unless it's an old game for DOS, maybe, in which case it's down to just 4 buttons.
6 button controller => the way I play classics MK
shadows, lifebars and chameleon dithering vs 6 button pad.
We need to see the game on composite, but well. Saturn wins, I bet that the dithering did the good job in that scenario. It was implemented for it.
On RGB.. 6 buttons still being 6 buttons. R1 and R2 aren't the same. I'll pick saturn. I can live with the dithering shown here.
Good video!
This is something nobody wants to address. Thats how you can tell the majority of these people havent played this or have only played 1 version.
Saturn port came 8 months after the psx one,the developers was biased towards the psx console,there is no excuse for dithering effects on the Saturn port, there are many Saturn games the display transparency,they didn't use the VDP2
WHO cares ? Better sound......and a hint better loading.
Other than failing at most semi transparent approaches, it is a very neat port!
I never liked the borders on the health bars on the Saturn version. Also, the sounds are somewhat degraded in the Saturn version. Picture is slightly bigger on the PS1 version, no music when moving to the next opponent on Saturn. Load times differentiate between the two.
The best ports of the Mortal Kombat games that I would recommend are:
1. Mortal Kombat 1 (Sega CD/MS-DOS).
2. Mortal Kombat 2 (Sega 32X/Super Nintendo/Saturn/PS1/MS-DOS).
3. Mortal Kombat Trilogy (Saturn/Nintendo 64/PS1/PC/MS-DOS).
4. Mortal Kombat Gold (Dreamcast).
5. Mortal Kombat: Deadly Alliance (Xbox/PS2/GameCube).
6. Mortal Kombat: Deception/Mortal Kombat: Unchained (Xbox/PS2/GameCube/PSP).
7. Mortal Kombat: Armageddon (PS2/Xbox/Wii).
8. Mortal Kombat vs DC Universe (PS3/Xbox 360).
9. Mortal Kombat: Komplete Edition (PS3/Xbox 360/PC).
10. Mortal Kombat XL (PS4/Xbox One/PC).
And 11. Mortal Kombat 11 (PS4/Switch/Xbox One/PC).
Mortal Kombat Gold(Version 2, after they bug fixed the game) is grossly underrated. They didn't do Mocap on MK4/Gold, they keyframed all of those animations, by hand, and it still looked as good as mocap!
That isn't a recommendation, you just made a list.
:(
really? MK2 on ps1? that version is barely playable.
Mortal Kombat 4 on N64 is pretty good.
MKT pra mim é como se fosse um MUGEN licenciado. KKK
Muggem pra mim sao os crossovers que a capcom fez com a snk e marvel
*Both fail in that MK3 music showdown...*
NOT true Saturn sounded better...."clarity"
For the audio side of things the ps1 has a higher sample rate when it says "Kintaro wins" compared to the saturn. But the saturn character voices & grunts, sound effects are a bit clearer then the ps1 which sound a bit muffed if you ask me.
I totally agree
Como tu mesma explicou no Vídeo aos 4:32 a Falta de Transparência na versão Saturn, só nessa que o Mito PSX Leva Vantagem no resto tá tudo igual mesmo.Excelente Vídeo como sempre Marotinha ::)
Always better on Saturn
I suppose having a CRT television helped the presentation of mesh transparencies back in 1995, but on LCD monitors it doesn't fare so well. It's not as if they couldn't throw in some transparencies into the Saturn version, at least just for the shadows - VDP1 transparencies "ate" anything behind them that was also rendered by VDP1, but as shadows are usually an element behind the main sprites, they could have been safely rendered.
Don't forget the VDP2 could also be used for transparency effects, without "eating" the sprites behind.
Para mim não tem diferenças, a única coisa que eu optei em pegar Game, na versão do Saturn, foi por causa dos controles da Sega. Eu Tinha os dois vide games na época, mas sempre em questão de games de lutas eu sempre buscava versão do Saturn.
PS1 version wins based on transparencies, availability and affordability! The Saturn version, on average, is worth 10x more than the PS1 release...
Para mi mas allá de algún menor detalle, ambas son idénticas.
5:11 tem a fase do cemitério. É impressao minha ou essa frase roda num framerate melhor? Tenho essa impressao desde a versao de mk3 do psx. Comenctem.
Um ano depois primeiro a comenctar...que ninguém ligou pras suas deliberações
@@vitormlb É muito triste a vida na grande rede mundial de computadores , A INTERNET
@@CassioQueixudo na Likelândia é muito dura a vida de quem não é carismático 😔
@@vitormlb foi uma deliberação importante
Gostei de ambas as versões, mesmo tendo jogado mais a versão do PS1
Pretty much identical -- not even a significant difference in the load times. Speaking of, I never understood why the 32-bit editions of Mortal Kombat had such abysmally long load times. Street Fighter Alpha 2 looked twice as good as MK Trilogy on the Saturn, but I swear it loaded in half the time.
I wish mortal kombat games had ram carts compatibility on the Saturn.
SS has transparencies if you play on a CRT with composite cables. It’s called “dithering.”
It’s crazy that Saturn was the system you wanted for 2D fighters, but they Midway made inferior versions of MK for it. It’s like the Saturn version was an afterthought and nothing was done to optimize it for the hardware.
You see a difference?! Please explain. The Saturn MK Trilogy is a port of the PS1 version from my understanding.
This shows you how ahead of time the Saturn was it's just as good as the playstation no different
bom, tirando alguns efeitos de som que são inexistentes no Saturno, eles são praticamente o mesmo jogo, portanto acho que deu empate. po Marota, eu não sabia que VC era fã do Kintaro assim como eu !! acho ele o MELHOR sub chefe pois além de ter quatro braços igual o Goro, tem as ombreiras iguais as do Shao Khan, fora que tem lindas listras de tigre e gospe fogo !! é um dos personagens MAIS originais de toda a franquia !! o Motaro é apenas uma cópia de um centauro que NÃO tem a metade do carisma dos subs antecessores !! Melhor MK já feito, obrgado por este FANTÁSTICO vídeo, abraço !!!
Concordo em tudo. Principalmente que Kintaro é o melhor sub-chefe. Até hoje não consigo vencer esse infeliz no MK2 sem o macete do soco baixo.
The two ports shown in this video look and sound pretty much identical. The PS1 port sounds slightly better than Saturn version to my ears. I have the PS1 version of this game and love it. Great comparison video.
I'd be lying if I didn't say the screams Jade let out as the was stomped sounded a lot better on the Saturn
The PSX has just a hair bit better of pixelization in the stages but the Saturn loads faster.... The characters look identical and the speed is the same. The health bars about the two biggest differences. I think the PSX's text looks better.
I noticed that most textures that are solid on the ps1, are dotted, or hazy. Same as castlevania SOTN, but it also seems like they cut out some sounds. I have ultimate mk3 on the saturn and trilogy on ps1 (I know, not the same.) But they recycled a lot of the same sounds from other versions. And it's weird the small but noticeable differences
Todo meguista se sente em casa aqui.😀
Detalhe no n64, salvo engano os chefes tem final, no ps e saturn nao! mta coisa capada das versões 32 bit
Gráficos, sons e gameplay exatamente iguais. Loading times um pouco mais rápidos no saturn do que no psx e transparência melhor no psx.
Acho o empate extremamente justo!
Acho que tu quieto é um poeta. *Tô brincando man, joguei muito a versão de psone, vivia dentro do video game esse cd* kkkk muy bueno
Concordo plenamente.
Embora tenha votado na versao do ps, em casa tenho a versao do saturn e nao deve em nada alem das transparencias e algum pequeno detalhe aqui e ali.
Ambas sao superiores ao n64
But in my headphones the sound for the Saturn version is coming out of the right ear instead of left ear as you mentioned 🤔
Had no idea that Saturn released MKT. I had UMK3 and was jealous
Não consegui identificar nada de diferença que seja signivatica, exceto os loadings, o que é o efeito de transparência?
Sega Saturn !!
Saturn sucks at shadows and health bar. Saturn version does have a better color contrast and a better frame rate it seems. I'll give Saturn this WIN.
Se vuelven a ver en las sombras de los personajes los problemas de Saturn con las transparencias.
Casi imperceptible
Problema arrastrado desde el Génesis.
I'm here because I purchased the GOG (PC) version. It seems the port is from the PSX.
Kintaro's Shokan stomp makes everyone cry.
colors is a bit better on the Saturn also the loading times are faster, but the ps1 looks a bit updated as the life bars fire and shadows effects looked way much better on the ps1.
the Saturn always have problems on rendering shadows as it always have this Sega Genesis style of pixelated shadows.
There are many Saturn games where shadows are a blending effect, it's just that MK trilogy developers didn't use Saturn blending capabilities.
Prácticamente las dos versiones son iguales, salvó algunos pequeños detalles. Pero las dos versiones son muy buenas.
Does anyone see a difference here?
MK Trilogy is by far the best one
Parece obvio q a versão n64 é superior, vejam q kintaro sequer tem um final!
That's funny the Saturn slightly has better sounds than the playstation go figure
I got the game on the N64 day one and still have it. And still enjoy it from time to time. But now I'm looking to get it on either the Saturn or the PS1. Just don't know which one to get.
The PlayStation is the superior port especially the audio.
Tuve la de ps1, quiero la de pc o saturn.
Either one is much more preferable to the utter travesty that is the N64 port.
Baita trampo 💟
PS1👊👍
Audio seems to be a little better on the PlayStation, although they’re almost identical. It’s a little louder on the PSX, the announcer has a little bit more reverb, and it actually plays music during the tower screen (weird that the Saturn left that out). Graphically, they’re almost identical. The energy bars were the only slight difference I noticed. It seems like the Saturn loads faster. Finally, I know from experience, the controls are a lot better on the Saturn for pulling off special moves and combos. Dare I say it, I call this one a draw. The benefits of each version offset the drawbacks of the other.
Jeff YOU need to clean your ears out BADLY and whoever gave you the thumbs up do too. I worked in QC at Williams and Playstation doesn't win the sound quality on this. I had the Saturn 1 first and 2 copies at that. Then I got the Playstation version later, but played it when it came out - THAT MUFFLED B S Bothered me then and now. At least if I put my UMK 3 and Trilogy Saturn games in my CD Player - I'd enjoy the sound quality like Bone Thugs did.
A versão de PC desse jogo tem esses loads extremamente demorados?1
Não.
a versão de PC é um port windows 95 ou ms-dos beeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeem zoado (mesmo pra época), é um saco fazer rodar direito num pc moderno, mto mais prático jogar num emulador de PS1
A do PC é exatamente igual, só que sem loadings...
the transparency effects are not a limitation of the machine but of the team that converted this game, ultimate mortal kombat 3 has perfect transparent effect.. many do not remember this detail it's, not the sega saturn's fault but the people's fault
does it? i have both, but my Saturn is broken for a long time so i can't check.
I do know shadows are black on UMK3 and dithered on MKT, Smoke's smoke is dithered in both. The agressor bar shadows are obviously not present on UMK3.
I don't remember if there is any transparency on UMK3.
it is in fact a limitation of the machine. the saturn can do transparency on 3d objects but if it's a 2d element then the saturn can't, so they have to use checkerboarding. ultimate mortal kombat 3 barely have any transparency. in umk3, the shadows are just black no matter in what system, and smoke's smoke effects doesn't have transparency. the thing that is supposed to be transparent in umk3 is the health bar, when the bule decreases, the red is supposed to be transparent but the saturn can't do it, so it is still checkerboarding.
Playstation came out 1st. We got that
Saturn came out 2nd. We got that
I own both but liked Saturn better and as you see the loading is a hint faster and sound quality is much better. Playstation had 1st dibs and much more distribution.
Thanks E B - I own 2 Saturn Trilogies
who in the hell would downvote this?
@bee boo U mom gay
@bee boo Killer Instict? It was made by RARE lmao
@bee boo
Nice, what kind of work did you perform?
The MK Trilogy Saturn version is more EXPENSIVE than the MK Trilogy Playstation version !!!
Cause it's a little better
And Saturn games are harder to come by
o saturno nao tem os gritos n corrida 😢
Color looks richer on the Saturn. First time for me seeing the Saturn version.
Sound is waaaaaaaaay better on Saturn. It's like they filtered all the muffled sounds.
Trilogy é o que em Minas a gente chama de Mexidão. Há a empolgação de se jogar com muitos personagens, incluindo os chefes. Mas o jogo não tem equilibrio e identidade própria.
Muito obrigado pelo seu trabalho, Marota.
Both versions are ok.
Resolution and colors on PlayStation are much better. You can compare the definition of the backgrounds to see that.
If you already MKT for the Saturn don't get it for the Playstation and visa versa.
One difference is several of the classic characters, MK1 Kano for example, had their fatalities cut in the Saturn version (And the PC version) due to time constraints. It was something of a rushed port sadly.
I thought they said that the Saturn handles 2D games better than the PS? I should've known that was a lie after I played SF Alpha 3.
Only if you had that special 4MB expansion cartridge.
Always comes down to the developer in the end.
Não é possível fazer uma comparação se não colocar em evidência os defeitos de cada versão, se ver. Saturno falta efeito de transparência (oque não muda em nada) a versão psx tem o defeito dos morfhs do shang tsung, e isso atrapalha muito a jogatina.
Quando jogava a ver. Psx nunca pegava o shang e olha que na versão snes era meu preferido devido a poder fazer um kombo fantástico com ele, a versão Saturno flui melhor em fps.
Saturno vence essa.
Ambos possuem o defeito de Loading com Shang Tsung, joguei mais a versão do Saturn na infância e esse era o maior problema...
BattleTanx would be a good one to compare. It came out on the N64 and PSX. If you like games where you can just shut your brain off and blow stuff up, its a good time.
Baita comparação tmj ai....Tenho os 2,prefiro a de PlayStation...
How did I miss this comparison for 2 years? Anywho, PS1 takes it with better shadows and alpha/transparency effects. The Saturn appears to have slightly faster loading and sound overall, but I can't get over the mesh transparencies. I had this on Saturn and loved it, but would have appreciated better shadows.
PS1 looks better visually, due to some transparency issues on Saturn. Not too often you see a 2D victory on PS1.
I’m guessing PS1 was lead platform, since Saturn is way easier with transparencies in true 2D, with PS1 games using the 3D engine for 2D games.
I’d say the biggest difference is Tyra the ps1 version resales for 30$ and the Saturn for 200$
For me it's Pc/Saturn
If I buy a Saturn, I will get this game even if im terrible at this game.
Saturn is the same version !?? Pc have no loading!!!! 😎😎
Vocês são brasileiros ou gringos
As sombras no Playstation são melhores. A fumaça do Smoke também. As cores do Kintaro no Saturn parecem um pouco mais vivas.
Parecem estouradas, isso sim.
Whoaaaaa. I had the n64 version. Didn't have Kintaro.
The N64 version is dogshit. Frankly, I don't know why they even bothered.
Without any doubt PC version is very very superior in many aspects, starting with NO loading times, higher fps, no compressed sound effects, customizable music. There are just few details that PC lacks to make it 1000% perfect, in example the moving MK logo at the intro which is exclusive of PS1 version, or the "attract" intro with flashes of many characters fighting exclusive from N64 version. Also idk why they didnt bother on giving those moving sparkles of glitter effect on the surface of the acid in Dead Pool and the water in Wastelands, and the movement effect of the red hot steel in The Armory. Those absent graphical details are a dissapoint, but PC version still rules.
So, basically, the only difference is:
"Kintaro... winnnnns."
"Kintaro... ...wince."
Regardless, both versions are infinitely superior to the catastrophic N64 port.
I think SS sounds better than psx. Shadows in SS are dots, while in psx shadows are full blacked. Those dots all over heath bar in SS are no good. Ligh reflection in SS are worse than in PSX, you can see that in the Soul Chamber stage 1:50. Also the smoke effect on Smoke is dotted in SS. Backgrounds in 7:30 are different. Chameleon is also dotted. I think SS can't show translucent objetcs.
Saturn can do transparencies, but whoever handled this port either didn't know how or didn't care to put in the effort.
It is very difficult to get transparency effects working properly on Saturn.
The only difference I see are the character shadows. Saturn seems to struggle but I prefer the Saturn version.