Pumping Iron - Muscles, Mythology and Masculinity - Part 1

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 4 ноя 2024

Комментарии • 111

  • @Matthew-rc1xt
    @Matthew-rc1xt Год назад +16

    Really well done video. You deserve a million subscribers. Keep it up brother

    • @carvedouttastone
      @carvedouttastone  Год назад +2

      Hey Matthew...mate I really appreciate that awesome comment. I'm aiming for 1000 subs, and if they're an amazing 1000, then it's enough. Check out the other vids if you haven't yet, because I like them just as much. Thanks for subscribing!

  • @stind1299
    @stind1299 8 месяцев назад +2

    Magnificent video essay. You knocked it out of the proverbial ballpark.

    • @carvedouttastone
      @carvedouttastone  8 месяцев назад +1

      Oh wow I had almost forgotten this first time effort on my part. Seems like it's so long ago now making it but glad you dived back into my archives for some of this earlier content mate. :-)

  • @pixiesujira6995
    @pixiesujira6995 Год назад +1

    came from reddit. your content is so good. the thumbnails are fire!!

  • @djkimvlogger9762
    @djkimvlogger9762 Год назад +4

    Now we are back at the same time before pumping iron .. bring back testosterone 💪🏻

    • @carvedouttastone
      @carvedouttastone  Год назад +1

      Full agree there Kim. Bodybuilding has crawled back under the rock that Arnold and others fought so hard to drag it out of

  • @Lawcanine
    @Lawcanine Год назад +25

    Phenomenal videos.
    The intertwined footage mixed with your commentary was very well done.
    The intro of the video touching on how the abundance of modern technology and conveniences leading to a “soft” population resonates massively today.

    • @carvedouttastone
      @carvedouttastone  Год назад +1

      Thanks for your comment Lawson. Great book on the topic of man's ever increasing softness since antiquity is the book "Manthropology" showing just far the physical degeneration has set in over the ages.

  • @Elliek920
    @Elliek920 Год назад +15

    Amazing content and fascinating video on the history of bodybuilding
    Can’t wait for part 2!

  • @craigwinter458
    @craigwinter458 Год назад +14

    Fascinating insights and information!
    As a bodybuilding purist, historian and all-round fan of the sport, I look forward to this series!
    👍👌💪👊😊

    • @carvedouttastone
      @carvedouttastone  Год назад +1

      Appreciate the feedback mate. Thanks for commenting

  • @carolmurray3185
    @carolmurray3185 Год назад +8

    Great insight into the history of Bodybuilding that most people have no idea about , loving the accompanying images 👌

    • @carvedouttastone
      @carvedouttastone  Год назад

      Thanks for watching! We gotta preserve this history of our iron game or all these wonderful stories, lessons and visuals will be lost in the tsunami of modern-day, diluted content. :-)

  • @viktorhorn7731
    @viktorhorn7731 Год назад +6

    I really like the differenciated presentation, it gives a rarely seen insight in the origins of bodybuilding

    • @carvedouttastone
      @carvedouttastone  Год назад

      Thanks for watching and commenting. Yes, I'm trying to do things a little bit different to the average bodybuilding channel. Please subscribe if you want to see more content like this to come. 💪

  • @classypotato9255
    @classypotato9255 Год назад +13

    When I was watching this video, it was so well made that I thought it came from a well estabilished essay channel. To hear it was your first video was a huge surprise! You are really good at this, keep at it

    • @carvedouttastone
      @carvedouttastone  Год назад +1

      Wow, that really means a lot as I was even unsure about releasing them as I'm not a tech whiz and am using the most basic equipment and apps to put all this together. Having a lot of fun doing it (despite losing days of work and footage on some of my earlier attempts), so please subscribe for more to come. Thanks for commenting, CP

    • @classypotato9255
      @classypotato9255 Год назад +2

      @@carvedouttastone No problem :)
      Already watched all 4 of your video essays, liked and subscribed. I really liked the Adonis Complex one. There's not a lot of content talking honestly about bodybuilder's (pro or otherwise) motivations, I found it to be conducive to my own introspection.

    • @carvedouttastone
      @carvedouttastone  Год назад +1

      That's good to hear because I'm copping a lot of flack from comments saying I'm being negative -shitting on bodybuilding, shitting on Arnold; shitting on self improvement when it's exactly the opposite to what I'm saying.
      Like i mentioned in the first video, the Greeks emphasised moderation and balance, and somewhere along the way, the obsessive line we walk and sometimes NEED to walk as bodybuilders diminishes the positives and benefits that can be realised by such a cool and empowering activity.
      I'm glad some people like yourself understand the message I'm trying to deliver. If anything, I'm just encouraging some introspection, like you stated

    • @classypotato9255
      @classypotato9255 Год назад

      @@carvedouttastone yeah I took the videos as you being a fan of the sport, lamenting what it could be ideally, and disappointed at where it is at currently. Not necessarily shitting on the bodybuilders themselves, but on the state of the sport.
      You plan on doing a video on natural bodybuilding today? I feel like it is going to make a resurgence; not necessarily the shows (like the unnatural counterpart), but the culture of maximizing one's natural potential without disregarding health and longevity: the greek ideal, in a way.
      Maybe I'm biased from watching basically only Noble Natty channels (which seem to be enjoying a rise in popularity), but I'm hopeful. Who knows though, realistically, I'm probably wrong.

    • @classypotato9255
      @classypotato9255 Год назад

      @@carvedouttastone and also, there will always be haters, just make sure your message is being properly received by most people; you'll never satisfy everyone, and you shouldn't, most points worth making will have people disagreeing. After all, if everyone agreed, you wouldn't need to say it.

  • @x.highlander
    @x.highlander Год назад +2

    This was a great presentation on the documentary itself as well as on the philosophy of the ancients as it relates to the body and physical excellence. Your video does a great job in using each as a mean in discussing the other. The point in the beginning on the hylomorphic view of man, the idea that form and matter exist in an inextricable relationship remains quite profound even to this day. Consequently, they also understood of the bilateral relationship that is present. That the physical, or matter and the subjective can communicate and aid us in comprehending aspects of the (platonic) ideal, the objective or the metaphysical and that which is true, good and beautiful. It is no wonder that we often find ourselves struck by or at a minimum inspired by fitness, capacity, proportion and athleticism being embodied. Seeing well put together content in this vein is well appreciated., great work!
    Greetings from Sydney!

    • @carvedouttastone
      @carvedouttastone  Год назад

      Hey X Highlander - Really appreciate you watching and commenting on my video with such a thoughtful response. I feel the Greek connection is sometimes glossed over without a lot of in depth analysis as to why we appreciate bodybuilding at a spiritual and visceral level. Love to see fellow Aussies on here also. Again, really appreciate the support mate!

  • @mitkomarkov4375
    @mitkomarkov4375 Год назад +9

    Great job. Very stable academic quality on the subject. We needed your channel! 💪🏻

    • @carvedouttastone
      @carvedouttastone  Год назад

      Thanks for watching and commenting, Marko. Hope to make many more

  • @superhedgehog6447
    @superhedgehog6447 Год назад +5

    I remember watching Pumping iron for the first time in 2016. I was 13 around 90 lbs at the time and that movie helped me starting my muscle building Journey. Along with watching some JCVD movies.
    I'm now 19 at 176 lbs and muscular over six years later. Of course my Journey isn't over yet.
    Great video one the history of bodybuilding 👍🏾.
    Also learning about the origins of bodybuilding in the Ancient Greece times is quite fascinating.

    • @carvedouttastone
      @carvedouttastone  Год назад +1

      Hey Superhedgehog - thanks for commenting mate. Same! I was massively inspired by Van Damme growing up in the 80's and when I saw Pumping Iron for the first time in 1991, it was a total gamechanger. There's more to come in the series, but I see it as my "thank you" to the film for inspiring me all those years ago. Glad you enjoyed the stuff on Ancient Greece also as it's equally fascinating. Thanks for commenting!

  • @ColonelJohnmatrix1000
    @ColonelJohnmatrix1000 Год назад +6

    Wonderful take on the film!.

  • @MrXolaX
    @MrXolaX Год назад +5

    How did we move from such beauty to the insane freaks in today's bodybuilding???

    • @carvedouttastone
      @carvedouttastone  Год назад +2

      How indeed! I think I will make a video on it someday probing that question further. It's sad for sure .

  • @yahoshua2527
    @yahoshua2527 Год назад +3

    As a personal trainer and practices of martial arts I do feel that it is important to understand that moderation is key, so many people now in days destroy their bodies by obsession of getting results that would take someone 20-30 years and they push to get that in 5 years and forget to educate themselves in for intelligence as well, and there for you hear of these bodybuilding monsters hitting a wall of injuries to early in life, great video

    • @carvedouttastone
      @carvedouttastone  Год назад +3

      Hey Yahoshua (is that Hebrew?) I totally agree. Persistence, compliance, consistency is great - obsession...not so much. Balance and moderation in all things. Great comment. I think your clients would do well with your approach. Thanks for watching and commenting.

    • @yahoshua2527
      @yahoshua2527 Год назад +2

      @@carvedouttastone yes is Hebrew, translates to Joshua in English

  • @molasorrosalom4846
    @molasorrosalom4846 Год назад +3

    Kennedy would lose his mind if he saw how weak we have become. Something like 81% of 18-21 year olds couldn't join the military even if they wanted to.
    75% of 21 year olds couldn't pass the POWER test to join CPD. They had to lower tbe standards

    • @carvedouttastone
      @carvedouttastone  Год назад

      Good point. Hard to conceive how far we've fallen. The devolution of man

  • @jorget6569
    @jorget6569 Год назад +3

    Excellent quality! Congratulations

    • @carvedouttastone
      @carvedouttastone  Год назад

      Jorge, thanks very much. To be honest, I sat on releasing these for months, because I didn't think they were good enough. In the end, I said "Fk it" and decided to start the channel. I figured I'll learn to get good as I go. Thanks for commenting! :-)

  • @aryeh155
    @aryeh155 Год назад +28

    You definitely should have more material. Your RUclips has been up 8 years and only has 7 videos. Hopefully you can find time to put out more material.

    • @carvedouttastone
      @carvedouttastone  Год назад +16

      Good things, sometimes take time. Keep watching, more to come. Thanks for commenting

    • @frediochweda5199
      @frediochweda5199 Год назад +5

      @Carved Outta Stone 🤣🤣noo you wont aply that here bro bring content

    • @carvedouttastone
      @carvedouttastone  Год назад +3

      More coming this weekend

    • @Perun.Tha.Unvaxxd
      @Perun.Tha.Unvaxxd Год назад +1

      @@frediochweda5199 💪💯🎯

    • @randybarnett2308
      @randybarnett2308 Год назад +3

      It's better to make few great videos, than to make a shit ton of lousy ones !!!👍💪🤠🏋️‍♂️🏃‍♂️

  • @murozman
    @murozman Год назад +3

    Excellent video. Fantastic work!

    • @carvedouttastone
      @carvedouttastone  Год назад +1

      Thanks for watching and commenting murozman. Please subscribe because I have some more golden era content coming including the new vid I posted just now.

    • @murozman
      @murozman Год назад

      @@carvedouttastone Subscribed straight away as I was watching the vid. Content is ❤‍🔥.

  • @MrXolaX
    @MrXolaX Год назад +3

    Beautiful essay!

  • @comicsandcombat11
    @comicsandcombat11 Год назад +4

    I enjoy the videos you post, great job!

    • @carvedouttastone
      @carvedouttastone  Год назад

      Hey chitown - just wanna say thanks for stopping by and leaving a comment. I hope I can continue to put out enjoyable content, because I'm having a lot of fun making these videos.

  • @DoomSlayerEythyn
    @DoomSlayerEythyn Год назад +6

    Love it mate! Absolute awesome video and what we need in today's society to preserve this great history. Keep up your great work bro. 💪

    • @carvedouttastone
      @carvedouttastone  Год назад

      Thank you Ethyn. I really appreciate the kind words and feedback

  • @ungodlyaura
    @ungodlyaura Год назад +5

    this is a really great first video, i'm not watching the next videos but at least for this one i'd say the title could be better, this only got my attention from the thumbnail
    here are some AI examples if ur interested, since this video (at least) talks about the history, it's more enticing to convey that.
    "From Ancient Greece to Modern Times: The Evolution of Bodybuilding"
    "Muscles, Mythology and Masculinity: A History of Bodybuilding"
    "Pumping Iron: The Fascinating History of Bodybuilding"
    "Bodybuilding Through the Ages: A Look at the History of Muscle Building"
    "The Rise and Fall (and Rise Again) of Bodybuilding: A Historical Perspective"
    only a suggestion, do what you think is best and hope you grow with this level of quality

    • @carvedouttastone
      @carvedouttastone  Год назад +1

      Hi ungodlyaura thanks for watching and commenting - and for the title suggestions! I'm still new to this so there's a lot to think about getting the content out there.

  • @jardo531
    @jardo531 Год назад +5

    Well done.

    • @carvedouttastone
      @carvedouttastone  Год назад

      Thanks mate. Please subscribe; plenty more to come 💪

  • @bpetey5970
    @bpetey5970 Год назад +1

    Love the insights about how fitness and physique were originally meant to be viewed and developed in a multifaceted manner. The importance of not just physical strength but moral strength and emotional and mental fortitude as a whole “fit” person. I also liked the original emphasis on moderation as well since one of the flaws of the modern fitness world is indeed vanity. However, I do think fitness and physique have a good sub-culture now despite the many flaws within the larger culture. I mean everybody knows of at least one person at their gym who has a fantastic physique but is utterly messed up in the other aspects of their lives. And we all know the person who is weak and unhealthy as all get out but they say they won’t set foot in the gym for fear of “vanity”.
    Health is wealth.
    May we all practice virtue, learn from the best books, serve our fellow man, and pump the iron. 💪

  • @bruceroberts8614
    @bruceroberts8614 Год назад +3

    Well done sir!

    • @carvedouttastone
      @carvedouttastone  Год назад

      Thanks for watching and commenting Bruce. More to come soon. 🙂

  • @Exodus26.13Pi
    @Exodus26.13Pi Год назад +3

    Great content, new sub

    • @carvedouttastone
      @carvedouttastone  Год назад +1

      Thank you for that feedback Hoytvfx. Love that you took the time to watch and comment. Check out the rest in the series too! Thanks for subscribing! 😊

  • @TriariusWarGaming
    @TriariusWarGaming Год назад +3

    Just found your channel, keep it up bro awesome stuff!

    • @carvedouttastone
      @carvedouttastone  Год назад

      Cheers for watching and thanks even more for commenting. Means a lot to get that positive feedback Triarius.

  • @eastfightersboxing-kickbox2034
    @eastfightersboxing-kickbox2034 3 месяца назад +1

    Nice work bro!!

    • @carvedouttastone
      @carvedouttastone  2 месяца назад +1

      Thank you mate. The video that started it all. I can't watch that again - my production values were too cringe back then 😂, but hopefully the message resonates

  • @thorstormlord
    @thorstormlord Год назад +3

    Great video as a Greek and a bodybuilder i fond your whole approach very good explaining things that never crossed my mind i was raised up to think men should be strong and the fact that bodybuilding was considered g@y and why that was never crossed my mind. Different places different minds i guess. Overall enjoyed the video, you got one more sub.

    • @carvedouttastone
      @carvedouttastone  Год назад +1

      That means a lot of you to say, particularly because you're Greek and I respect your culture and heritage so much. Thank you very much for subbing to the channel. I hope we can have more conversations in the future

    • @thorstormlord
      @thorstormlord Год назад +3

      @@carvedouttastone Thank you , our culture is been slandered by many these days by those that wish to use it as a stepping stone to promote their perverse ideas or gets appropriated by people that have nothing to do with it and its nice to find people admiring its essence . Thank you for the respect and advertisement of the values of ancient Greeks.

  • @josephmiller9424
    @josephmiller9424 Год назад +1

    I think if Lou had the same training core as Arnold he may have done better but look at where he trained and who was in his gym , then Arnolds core but Arnold from down sizing for a movie to 210 wasnt not at his best.

    • @carvedouttastone
      @carvedouttastone  Год назад

      Lou was training with Steve Michalik before Butler intervened and said the father son connection would be more interesting for the movie. Apparently Lou never trained full time at that gym featured in the film

  • @BlakbunnyxD
    @BlakbunnyxD Год назад +1

    I would disagree with the statement that the acient greeks depicted women as less beautiful than men. For example the venus of milo shows a very beautiful woman.
    I would say they had a feminine ideal for women and a masculine for men.

    • @carvedouttastone
      @carvedouttastone  Год назад

      Hi blackbunny - yes and no. While there's numerous examples of clearly identifiable statues of male Greek statues, it would be a reach to identify any more beyond the Venus. Also, the Venus di Milo is representative of the goddess of love, Aphrodite - not a common. representation or example to which the average Greek woman was meant to aspire to. The Doryphoros and many others were statues designed to inspire and motivate the average man towards a standard of physical excellence. Women weren't allowed to train in most Greek states, so they weren't held to the same expectations of achievable beauty. Thanks for commenting

    • @BlakbunnyxD
      @BlakbunnyxD Год назад +1

      @@carvedouttastone
      Well, I think that's true. Women did not train in most greek states, I think.
      But still I think the greeks had a beautiful ideal of women's bodys. This you can see in all greek statues of goddesses (Artemis, Athene and so on).

  • @reddnacpil4420
    @reddnacpil4420 Год назад +1

    great vid!

    • @carvedouttastone
      @carvedouttastone  Год назад

      Thanks for taking the time to watch and comment Redd! Please subscribe for more to come.

  • @ovens88
    @ovens88 Год назад

    Any one know who the two guys are moving the car?
    Is that John Grimek, closest to the camera?

  • @craig4867
    @craig4867 Год назад

    PUMPING ARNOLD

  • @stoyanyotsov4185
    @stoyanyotsov4185 Год назад

    Аrnold is the best .....EVER !!!!

  • @gaylecheung3087
    @gaylecheung3087 Год назад +1

    Now it’s a freak show!

    • @carvedouttastone
      @carvedouttastone  Год назад +1

      It's strange times indeed. Back in the day, we could look at guys like Arnold and Zane and think, "yeah, if I train hard enough, maybe I can look somewhat like he does"
      These days, 99 per cent of people look at today's bodybuilders and don't want anything to do with it, let alone emulate their look or lifestyle. Bodybuilding was once becoming mainstream and now it's hidden itself under a rock again.
      Thanks for commenting Gayle! :-)

  • @stevegrady5134
    @stevegrady5134 Год назад +29

    Great first video! Pumping Iron is truly a groundbreaking film even it must now be looked upon as such in a 'warts and all' kind of way. Despite its flaws, it is a fascinating document. One thing that I remember reading in a book about Arnold is that, despite the fact that the group of bodybuilders featured in Pumping Iron came together in the late-60's in California and had known one another for several years at the time that the film was made; they were all decidedly more conservative than the average young male in California during that period.
    Gold's Gym and Vince's Gym both had an unspoken "Hippies Need Not Apply" policy. The bodybuilders of that period had little patience for the 'tie-dyed t-shirts and tabs of LSD' crowd even though this was the crowd that surrounded them. Their gyms were like their islands within Los Angeles and the noisy, turbulent currents outside were of little interest to them. It is such a stark contrast to our world today in which everyone has to hold forth about politics even if they clearly know next to nothing about it. This Age of Social Media has taken the noisy currents outside and both brought them inside as well as made them deafening. The fact that these guys were able to live essentially in a vacuum of their own making while still being in a major city has caused me to envy them a bit. This is an excellent start to your channel!

    • @carvedouttastone
      @carvedouttastone  Год назад +4

      Steve, thank you so much for your thoughtful and insightful comment. I made this series firstly as an homage to the film responsible for drawing me into bodybuilding 35 years ago; and also to get some conversation going from other like minded fans.
      That's some really interesting backstory so thanks for sharing. And yes, I'm definitely envious of the era and the bubble those guys created.
      For all his fame and fortune, I think even Schwarzenegger looks back on those times with the fondest of memories.
      Thanks again for watching and commenting 😊

    • @tc59932
      @tc59932 Год назад +1

      Awesome insight, thanks so much for sharing.

    • @WalkerChristopher11
      @WalkerChristopher11 Год назад +4

      They were walking tall and didn't give into the social group think. I would have love to live even for a week during that time and lift with them.

    • @stevepace-first8617
      @stevepace-first8617 Год назад +1

      I think there is a deep streak of right wing ideology in this subculture. In many ways it is not a subculture, not "having beliefs or interests at variance with those of the larger culture" I rarely hear views expressed that I would subscribe to by this "community".

    • @stevegrady5134
      @stevegrady5134 Год назад +4

      @@WalkerChristopher11 If I was there for a week, I'd probably never want to come back. Can you imagine someone walking into Gold's Gym in, say, 1973 and trying to talk to those guys about 'toxic masculinity'? 🤣

  • @orthocatsr.8723
    @orthocatsr.8723 Год назад +1

    About male beauty...
    It's not difficult to attain.
    I've known short fools who played that card.
    Don't have money?
    Try having looks and some other status...
    in an economical/secular context, I guess it's very unfortunate/ expensive that I'm not gay but I found that women all "done up" with makeup and all with artificial lights on is a very pornographic or superficial high but it was far better when the woman was self conscious, unconfident, and oblivious to her natural beauty because they were i.e waking up in alcoholic vomit, none to smeared makeup, and only clean from not eating anything but vodka on an "F it all" binge for weeks, when it was a rare time that I was in shape and doing well.
    Observe nature, the male is the centerpiece with a maine.
    The lore-ish book of Enoch claims where postmodern inversion comes from

    • @carvedouttastone
      @carvedouttastone  Год назад

      "observe nature, the male is a centrepiece with a maine"
      I love that and am stealing. 😊 Thanks for watching and commenting mate

  • @littleflor2975
    @littleflor2975 Год назад

    Is this a high school essay?

    • @carvedouttastone
      @carvedouttastone  Год назад +2

      Nope, just some interesting history I wanted to share with curious minds out there. Thanks for commenting. 😊

  • @jprp999
    @jprp999 Год назад

    11.36 :)

  • @screwhammer3696
    @screwhammer3696 Год назад

    W video

  • @MrXolaX
    @MrXolaX Год назад +2

    Beautiful essay!