Friends: Ross Says Rachel (Season 5 Clip) | TBS
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 4 окт 2024
- Ross accidentally says Rachel's name during his vows instead of Emily's.
#TBS #Friends #DavidSchwimmer #JenniferAniston
SUBSCRIBE: bit.ly/TBSSub
Download the TBS App: bit.ly/1qBbkMW
About Friends:
Pull up a couch and relax at Central Perk, where six Friends gather to talk about life and love. Friends tells the story of siblings Ross (David Schwimmer) and Monica (Courteney Cox) Geller, and their friends, Chandler Bing (Matthew Perry), Phoebe Buffay (Lisa Kudrow), Joey Tribbiani (Matt LeBlanc), and Rachel Green (Jennifer Aniston).
Full episodes: www.tbs.com/sh...
Get Social With Friends:
Facebook: / friends.tv
Twitter: / friendstv
Instagram: www.instagram....
About TBS:
The home of Friends, AEW, American Dad, Young Sheldon, Friday Night Vibes, The Last O.G., Rat in the Kitchen, Go Big Show, The Cube, Miracle Workers, Chad, and Wipeout.
Get more TBS:
Full Episodes: www.TBS.com/shows/
RUclips: / tbs
Twitter: / tbsnetwork
Facebook: / tbsnetwork
Instagram: / tbsnetwork
Friends: Ross Says Rachel (Season 5 Clip) | TBS
• Friends: Ross Says Rac...
TBS
/ tbs
No matter how many times i watch it , whenever he speaks "i take thee Rachel" is always a big surprise
This is definitely one of the biggest TV sitcom moments in history, I remember when this episode first aired in the 90s, everyone was talking about it for weeks after and it was all over the TV guide magazine covers the week it aired lol.
@@SophieLovesSunsets hahaha OMG
@@SophieLovesSunsets yes , this episode aired in the month of May and it was the end of the season 4 , the season 5 started in September and during the that time everyone was talking about the " i Ross take thee Rachel" , mainly because Ross and Rachel were "the dream couple" and of that time they were the most loved characters at the time.
@@henri191 bro I have just one question for you. How do you have 451 comments on this channel?😂😂
Me too 😂😂
"He could have shot her "
- Chandler 😂
🤣
Joey: "Well, that went well."
Everyone: *staring at Joey*
Chandler: "Could have been worse, he could have SHOT her."
THEY WERE ON A BREAK
🤣
After that I was surprised SHE didn’t shoot him lol!
Ross : *"I'm about to destroy Ross's whole career!"*
Lmao! 😂
Ross greatest enemy is Ross
THEY WERE ON A BREAK!
Rachel : "Then what am I supposed to do ?" 😂😂😂
😝
" take the E-M-I-L-Y"
always gets me🤣
Ross and rachel should get marry in real life bcz both the characters are touching to me...
What do you think??
@@chandancrafts yeah..no one cares wat u think 😂
@@kaushikr8133 'wat' 😂😂
haha
The only way it would've been funnier is if Ross kept messing up and saying Rachel.
I'm just surprised that they continued the ceremony.
yeah, big mistake!
As pissed as Emily is, she just keeps her cool to portray it entirely as being his issue.
Me too lmaoo
@@usul573 smart for her though probably good it wasn't her fault
That is the British do
Emily’s main mistake was not walking out right then and there.
Yeah
I think the British insist on maintaining their composure in public and handling conflict in private. As an American, I'd walk out right then and there for sure. People already saw what happened, so nothing can be hidden at this point anyway.
It's not always that easy, right?
@@manishasharma2736 not a fan of Rachel but I do like her guts to walk away from the marriage with someone whom she didn't love
@@rachel46444 yes but Emily did love Ross. And it's not always easy to act immediately. But she did realise later that she couldn't trust him.
If I were Emily I wouldn’t even considered continuing marrying someone who still loves his ex
Idk. I would be in shock and totally lost. Meanwhile, ppl would be looking at me asking what I’m gonna do. So, I’d just go on, since idk what to do, and that’s so much to think and decide what to do in so few seconds.
Poor Emily. I mean you can’t really make a scene in front of your loved ones because that’s embarrassing. But him saying another woman’s name is embarrassing anyway so yeah I’d probably just not go on at that point. That’s such a weird situation.
@@sofiaguerrero0969 RIGHT 😳
Poor girl I feel terrible for her 😓
I also wouldn't marry someone that I had known for like 3 months
Joey was always so loving towards Phoebe, he gave up meat for her during her pregnancy, he held up the phone for her so she could listen in on the wedding, and in later years he even proposed to her when he thought she was going to be a single mother ... and threatened to kick the father's ass lol. They were platonic soulmates ❤️
So true! I love joey the most 😊 such a cutie
They were gonna get together if the show had more episodes, they said so
He also gave her the perfect kiss , comforted her after David went back to Minsk (both in season 7), and in the last season he acted like a father to her at her wedding. Their friendship is so underrated
I always wanted her and Joey to end up together. Too bad she picked Mike.
"I will destroy all of you!"
* looks at Joey *
"Except for you Joey"
- Phoebe -
This is worse than when he married the lesbian 😂
I love Judy Geller. She is such a bitch, but in a good way.
@@bigdog3628 not a good mother to Monica
@@bigdog3628 I would've agreed if she wasn't the world's most toxic mother to Monica.
i could see this happening on dawson creek if they did a wedding.
Way way worse
“This is worse than when he married the lesbian” this line makes me laugh all the time.
in today's world that joke would not pass.....
@@hugokloeppel3596 yes it would moron
I had to laugh when Judy said that.
@@hugokloeppel3596 yeah, because everyone needs a trigger warning in today's world
@@hugokloeppel3596 Yeah, because today's world sucks and is full to the brim with crybabies who act being "offended" per proxy.
I wish we would still have the internet before 2007 where all retards came in with facebook and their stupid mobile phones.
My father and I watched this together. He said that if I was in the position as Emily, he would get up on the alter and announce, “Ladies and gentlemen, let’s all gather to the reception hall to celebrate the fact my daughter didn’t make the biggest mistake of her life.”
what a great father :)
🔥🔥🔥
@@fairlyflyyyi.6415 idk about that. if my daughter would look to me then id do something but if not then im not taking the choice out of her hands altho i pray she does the right thing on her own
@@rksworld4405 well you're not wrong. A father might sense it but he should make sure she wants that too. But I was focussing on the aspect that he would stay behind her and support her no matter what.
Your dad is awesome!
Rachel:”he said Rachel right? Do you think I should go up there?” I imagine Rachel just telling Emily “excuse me” and then shoved her away lol
Now you made me imagine the whole scene😂 there could have been a great fight btw Emily and rachel
I hated that the writers kept Ross and Rachel apart until the last episode. Especially when Emma came along. It would been great to see them get married and watching them deal with Rachel’s family. Wish Joey fell for Rachel’s sister Amy (Christina Applegate) too. That would have been comedy gold.
@@justinreckers161 yess anything would have been better than Rachel and joe, it's just too cringe and painful to watch
@@justinreckers161 I hated Ross and Rachel together. They were such a toxic couple.
@@freddiemercury4880 I don't even consider them a couple as they were together 1 year out of 10. They could have been a great couple though IMO
He’s been in love with Rachel since 9th grade and he’s definitely been dreaming that “Take thee Rachel” since then 😭🤣🤣🤣
exactly, and since the subconscious mind is programmed thru repetition+emotion, repeating something since 9th grade that’s laced with a strong emotion it’s no wonder he messed up
@@FruityHachi 👍
If then why didn't he say Rachel's name for his first wedding.with Carol
@@mj1947 well he hadn’t been dating her then. He may have still had a crush on her but she wasn’t on the forefront of his mind like she more likely was here
Then he should stop marrying everybody else
Priest: Ross, repeat after me. I, Ross
Ross, I, Ross
Priest: Take thee EMILY.
lol
hahaha
And the look of Ross. 🤣
@@СнежанаНешић I like the little sound he makes when Emily angrily puts the ring on Ross’s finger.
Emily: 😠
Sick in bed laughing 🤣🤣
Red is Monica's colour 💅💁♀️👗
Black too! 🖤
Ita definately Black@@oisheemitra7200
Definitely. It brings out the promiscuity in her.
And Ross' :)
People are still hating on Emily even when she gets it the worst , and Ross is just ' Oh so much in love with Rachel '. I love Emily for the punch in his guts. Had I been in her shoes , it would not have been just a punch.
Rachel was to blame here clearly! She went there last minute to ruin the wedding and I can only imagine how that was like to ross
Oh yes , because assault or spousal abuse is always the solution to the problem
@@gurll8784 but she didn't do anything. Ross was the one who ruin the wedding. He invited her and even got mad at her for not wanting to go to the wedding.
Ross was the one who married someone when he was still in love with his ex.
@@gurll8784 Rachel could litterly stand just breath air and people would say she ruins everything for Ross.
@@GoldenRose116 Well, she went to the wedding to RUIN it. Let's be honest here... that was her purpose. To go to the wedding and tell ross she loved him! And even if she didn't end up telling him, her sudden and unexpected appearance led to Ross's mistake, so yes, it was clearly Rachel's fault.
And yes, Rachel has sabotaged pretty much every relationship ross ever had. She convinced bonnie to shave her head so that ross wouldn't date her, she lied to ross about girls not wanting sex so that ross wouldn't sleep with julie and so on.
I don't hate Rachel. In fact, I love her but facts are facts. People don't blame her for no reason.
“It could have been worse , he could have SHOT her” 😭 Chanler is top 2👌🏽
No but she “shot” him.
Social media would've exploded if there was social media back then
Your right it would be all over RUclips
@@Padwarner4452 like it's not now :)
@@Free.Palestine505 he means if this happened in real life social media would’ve exploded because someone would’ve been filming it
These days, sit-coms are not that bold, so I doubt a show that the F.R.I.E.N.D.S would exist.
A lot of memes as well
Honestly it's kinda of both Ross and Emily's fault....
When Ross said Rachel's name
Emily should have called off the wedding instead of marrying him and divorcing.... It's pointless
well she did this for maintaining her and ross image in front of all these guests!!
@@anujgoyal2414 she shouldn't have, Ross never really loved her or anyone else except for rachel. In his wedding the whole time he was thinking about rachel and said her name.
@@ambika4631 well I think Ross never loved Rachel too and how will she get to know that Ross didn't loved him he was the one who asked her for marriage
Exactly
@@sharjeelwani8066 Umm definitely was Ross' fault. Like how in the hell could it be Rachel's? Ross invited her to the wedding
"I Ross take thee Rachel" iconic 😂😂
This line is funny but also traumatizing 😂😂😂
Take the “ Emmmmmmily “. That death stare from ross 😂😂
Omg I can’t I can’t… take the E M I L Y….
Emily still married him, left everything behind, decided to move to America with Ross to start a family & Ross in return couldn't sacrifice some bits for the sake of marriage. It's universal truth that compromise is the key to marriage. Ross couldn't really move past Rachel, made a blunder & how couldn't he do something in return?
Emily deserved whatever she asked for as a wife. And it would have been better had she broken off the wedding at the first place when Ross uttered Rachel's name.
Marrying in a haste was the biggest mistake here.
They married way too fast.
@B They were having dinner in Monica and Rachel's apartment! Rachel LIVES THERE!
@@卩丨尺卂卂-d8u Their whole relationship seemed rushed.
Emily was a bad act for the show . Ross loved Rachel since like middle school. So
Phoebe’s expression just made it even more hilarious
It would have been better if she was there at the wedding, but I know, Phoebe was pregnant until episode 3 of season 5 when she give birth.
No you should watch Joey's 😂😂😂
@@khangphamchannel016 she's probably glad that she wasn't. 😅
Honestly Emily was nice, Ross couldn’t move on after Rachel. And her being there made it worse
She was nice until after this, then she became a manipulative bitch.
@@timelordrock2954 i agree she was not only cruel to ross or rachel but to all 5 of them. She kind of broke their group by making ross move too far and leave the apartment which was too precious to him as his son took his first steps there. This marriage could never work.
@@timelordrock2954 bad writing i guess?
@@ambika4631 Imagine your to-be husaband said another woman's name while getting married...Emily had every right to be mad, most esp she knew about the past of Rachel and Ross. But yes, she totally lost her trust in him and drove her paranoid.
@@francina8508 then she shouldnt marry him if she doesnt trust him smh
And to think, just a few short years later there would be another Geller wedding, involving Chandler Muriel Bing ❤️
@Zach Pfeiffer it's *MISS Chanandler Bong
so... chandler marries ross?
@@TheWatcher802 lol.....
@@TheWatcher802 duh! You're _obviously_ not a *F·R·I·E·N·D·S* fan if you even have to ask that!
And Monica Felula Geller...
You know what, it's so sad, imagine what Emily felt when he said this
Got a feeling this isn't the first time he say that. But she wants him to marry her just didn't expect him to do that to her in public at their wedding. That's way she say keep smiling while they walk out the aisle when she clearly wasn't happy
it's a gut punch, and tough to react in a moment like that
Annoyed I guess.
"This is worse than when he married the lesbian" 😅😅🤣🤣🤣😄😄 Gets me every single time!
0:41 - haha I love how quickly those cameras jump from Ross to Emily to Rachel to Monica to Joey to Phoebe then back to Ross.
Great acting from all of them too.
2:33 Best line of the episode.
This isnt romantic. It is traumatizing.
I would die 😭
@@samanthastephens9720 prove it
@@ExoShadow you want me to find a man who’s still in love with his ex and marry him? I better not
Its a comedy show, just laugh dude
@@YellowFlash34 This isn't comedic
Still iconic after 25 years
Yep
his mom's comment after the wedding ceremony was the ONLY time she acknowledged a mistake made by her son, all the other times it was always Monica...Monica...Monica...the poor girl could not catch a break with her mom...
I remember watching this when it first aired, back in May of 1998. One of the most classic moments in modern television.
For those who don't know, the season ended at 1:05, just after the registrar asked, "Shall I go on?" (The video here has been edited to include the beginning of the next season, when Emily tells him to continue.) As soon as it ended, a friend of mine called me up and exclaimed, "No WAY! They CANNOT leave us hanging like that!" LOL!
Haha very interesting I was 2 years old back then 😅
Yes, season 4 ended at 1:05 as you said. But no, this youtube video is not edited. Season 5 began by repeating the end-scene of season 4.
Really! OMG! I worked 4pm to midnight back then, so I never saw this show. I am just now watching it all for the first time.
What a cliff hanger! 🙀
Thx for that info.
U r a lucky man...
Wish i was born by 98 to see d iconic moment...🥰😅
It was my junior year of high school when this aired. I never watched it myself, but I knew all about this moment because EVERY GIRL IN EVERY CLASS WAS TALKING ABOUT THIS SCENE NON STOP for a solid WEEK after it aired. It's still amazing how much of a grip this show had on society back in its day.
everything emily did was justifiable. Emily didnt deserve this. Ross used emily to see if he had been able to get over rachel or not. But aha.. emily gets all the hate
No.... Emily turned into a control freak who wanted ross to cut people out of his life, move out his apartment and sell his furniture. Then, had the audacity to call ross months later the night before she was getting married again.
Nothing is ever Rosses fault.
Imagine almost 20 years ago and ppl still debating this...
@@kaprio551 😁👍
@orangecucumber of course Rachel had to stop being friends with him. In real life that would have been a perfectly reasonable demand. Don’t hang out with your ex , who you obviously still have feelings for, if you want to marry me
I love Joey's horror in the background the whole time. 😂
Probably this is the reason now in weddings people only say “I do” instead of repeating the names in case of mistakes... XD
😂😂😂
I wouldn't be at all surprised if that was true
FOR REAL?! 🤣🤣🤣🤣
@CymricEuphoricx no, they're joking. Some ceremonies they say the name, some they dont-same as it's been forever.
Lmao the priest handled the situation pretty well,I wouldn't even what to do in this type of awkward situation.
No he is being sarcastic about it
no matter how many times i watched this but everytime he says take thee rachel,,I get goosebumps
Every single time I still hope against hope he wont.
1:24 Ross's withering glance is priceless. What a terrific actor Schwimmer is.
So TBS is uploading the whole show in small clips. I got it. Brilliant.
And that too in sequence
Right views💷💵💴💰
David Schwimmer is such a great actor. perfect timing, facial expressions and the akwardness after the "take thee Rachel" part.So fun to watch
His body and facial expressions are tbe best 😂.he can make you laugh without uttering a word
1:22 When the priest saya E-M-I-L-Y and then Ross' face after that had me in tears!!
I understand that this was very hurtful for Emily but I can't help but appreciate the brilliant writing of this. I mean, this can easily be one of those "well remembered" scenes on tv.
One of the reasons it's well remembered is because after the priest said "Shall I go on?" we had to wait six months to find out what happened next!
Priest: Shall I go on?
Emily: Yes
Me: I would have already been ten feet out the door by the time it took for him to say that.
I can’t even begin to imagine the hot waves of prickly shame and humiliation that Emily endured. She should have left him right then and there.
Or she could have laughed it off
David Schwimmer's acting is so good here. When he uttered the name "Rachel," it really made me feel he said the name accidentally (not acting at all).
The worst thing is that Ross doesn`t really feel guilty(
What the hell are you talking about, he felt guilty. I don’t know what show you watched
Time for a rewatch mate! You couldnt be more wrong.
What's there to feel guilty about?
It was just a slip of the tongue. I forget names all the time.
That’s his personality when he feels guilty he acts nervous in the most scared manner
2:04-2:07 I have forgotten how Many times i replayed that part, just class acting!!!
i heard “see you again” and started balling. this friendship is everlasting in our hearts. Rest in peace Matthew, you will continue to help so many people.
Ross @2:05 showing off the ring gets me everytime 😂😂
Ross took the saying your biggest enemy is yourself to the next level.
Honestly I love Emily, her voice so sweet
The way Emily places that ring on Ross🤣😂😂😂 and rose whimpers in pain
She was fuming 😂
Jack and Judy always have the best lines on the show lol
I just love Swimmers facial reactions, just so adds to the comedy of it all!!!
Emily had every right to be angry
Emily overreacted.
I love how he says that it shows deep down he still loved her even then he always saying marrying her and that’s why he said it
This scene just proves to illustrate how crucial it is to always follow your heart and live your life authentically. You can lie to yourself and others but the truth ALWAYS outs. Just save yourself and others the pain and BE HONEST FROM THE START.
This is sort of unrelated, but at 0:46 you can see Joey turning to Chandler, and at 0:48 you can see his head in the background whipping backwards to look at him.
Punching won't help. Ross had Rachel in his mind, Emily should've walked out. I would respect that.
I watched this clip after not having seen it for many years. My memory of how Ross says it was slightly different.
My memory was that he had said the name Rachel & realized immediately as the word was leaving his mouth. “Take thee Ra…chel…..no Emily!….Emily.”
But that’s not how he says it. He says with a sincere smile a strong “Take thee Rachel,” no hesitation & takes the longest relative time to realize it.
I think the writers & directors did it that way because for the character Ross, it wasn’t actually the wrong name.
So subconsciously he's still love with Rachel right?
Obviously he was imagining marrying her the whole time
Ross had a fantasy of marrying Rachel since like high school. Maybe when he married his first wife, she was out of sight, out of mind but when he married Emily, it was what like less than a year after they had dated for like a year & they were very much still in love so......yes lol.
@@PrettyGirl-zl7th exactly
Maybe that's what the writers wanted viewers to assume...In real life...If Monica was the one who just showed up in the last minute, then he might have just said Monica...
@@CuttyKitty1 uh.. thats his sister.
The real IRONY HERE is that the actress Helen who played "Emily" on Friends was also playing another character on British sitcom and her name there was "RACHEL" so technically Ross didn't Fck up !!!!
Ross has always loved Rachel and he will always love her only❤️❤️❤️❤️
“This is worse than when he married the lesbian!”
I laughed my ass off! 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
The registrar said "take thee, Emily" literally 1 and half seconds before! I know Rachel's a huge part of Ross's life but... how does he make that catastrophic error?
Such a classic scene.
I couldn't understand that either.
I was not surprised when Ross say's "I Ross take thee Rachel."
Hugh Laurie demolishes Rachel on the flight in to London. Best cameo...also despite the British accent it felt like House deconstructing a patient's motives!
Yes 👌
I still remember the first time I ever watched this episode and I was in so much shock that 4 years later I still remember the feeling.
The poor Vicar, "shall we go on?" 🤣
List of victims of the "Ross and Rachel thing / toxic relationship " :
- Julie
- Russ
- Mark
- Tommy
- Bonnie
- Joshua
- Emily
Who is the next victim ? 😂😂
Chandler, Joey, Monica, Phoebe duh
@@lustrals1273 poor guys , the four endured for 10 years two toxic and annoying characters with a more toxic and annoying relationship for 10 years / 10 seasons , i feel sorry for you guys Chandler , Joey , Phoebe and Monica 😂😂😁
@@luiz3459 Booring
Mona ?
Emma.
Was a excelent scene
1:24 , “the thee EMMM-ILLY”
The way the reverend scratched his head while telling 'you can kiss the bride' (with a silent 'meh') is pure art...🤪🤪
I still find it hilarious that the whole episode Rachel was a hot mess and Ross was cool, until the very end where Ross immediately turns into a complete dumpster fire.
If i were Emily, i’ll call Rachel to come forward and marry Ross instead 😅🤣
I won’t marry a guy who name another woman 😢
That would have been classic
It should have been Rachel
“HAPPY TO” always gets me!!😂😂
No matter where I go, I still end up with you. What's missing never changes. The scenery may change but to me you never.
2:11 Ross's head moves according to the priest. 🤣
This moment was the biggest WOW moment watching TV shows in my entire life. I was absolutely blown away by this.
For those of you who do not understand humor….this was a COMEDY show, a sit-com, on Television, back in the 90’s. This was meant to be funny. As in HA HA. And people laughed then. And you should too. Stop being so angry about everything, particularly some fictional characters acting out some fictional scene!
I remember the first time I sae this scene and that was the moment I knew he could never be over Rachel
Ross father reaction is priceless 😂
Saying another woman's name at the alter, trying to hook up with his cousin, getting so hammered he marries his ex and forgets about it, losing his job over a sandwich, and of course the break, nobody in TV history screws up like this man.
this is pretty random but did anyone else realize that the marriage officiant’s mouth wasn’t even speaking when he said “take thee Ross” in 0:18
Ross and Rachel are forever ❤️❤️ nobody can replace them❤️❤️
Ross obviously mess up but Emily should have put this wedding on pause as soon as he said that, the priest even asked if he should go on. They should have at least had a private talk *immediately* to sort everything out.
I know that would be really awkward with everyone waiting in the pews but you wanna know what even more awkward? Marrying the wrong person and then getting divorced.
Ross exemplifies the obnoxious habit of grinning and laughing his ass off when he's screwed up in hopes that it'll "lighten the mood". No, it just makes everyone want to knock your teeth in.
Ya know, watching it for the second time decades from then, I actually thought he was going to get it right this time. 😂
After watch friends reunion... ross expression in this scene is very make sense.
Emily not allowing Ross to be friends with Rachel after this was completely justified. It's a shame that no one in the gang was actually level headed to understand this. At that time everyone just had a hard on for Rachel. Imagine if Chandler said Janice's name.
Emily made things worse by doing that. She should have made it clear that Rachel can be Ross's side piece but Emily is his main girl.
Ross and Rachel forever
Phoebe's reaction while on the phone was priceless. 😂
This is still one of the best moments in friends
One of the most iconic moments in television history!!
I don't know why but, I've always wanted to watch Ross and Carol's wedding, even though they get divorced later, it is the only marriage of Ross that lasts for more than a few moments.
More like lasts for more than a DAY 😂😂😂
Can I just add because Judy said when Emily Married Ross “ this is worse then when he married the lesbian “ . I literally am wondering what she would have said.
I really love their love story, even if sometimes it is kind of tiring, because they always loved each other, even when they weren't aware of that. Ross, in this part of the series, thinks that he is over her, when in reality subconsciously he never stops to.
If I were Emily, I would have just accepted that he was in love with Rachel. And walked away from the situation altogether. At least she found out how he really felt about Rachel ahead of time. You just got to know when to cut your losses. It may hurt initially, but you will be alright.
But he isn’t in love with Rachel, why can’t people understand it’s a mistake. The actor David schwimmer was the one who said Rachel and it wasn’t in the script. It doesn’t mean David is in love with Jennifer
@@Josama0214 it wasn't a mistake in the final cut, it was during a rehearsal when he says "I have the cab waiting downstairs, Rachel" instead of Emily.
@@Josama0214The hell are you taking about? It wasn't a mistake! Have you been churning out new theories about old sitcoms or what?
This is one of the most hilarious moment of all time 🤣🤣🤣🤣
Even before he says “Rachel,” you can tell by his expression that he’s staring right through Emily.