He's a man from a generation where people used to have integrity, could die for his principle, civilized and well cultured, and even he has the ability to respect his enemy. Such a loveable and admirable individual he is.
Yes the uneducated Fool Karan Thapar mistook him for Obstetrician (who deliver babies) as opposed to Gynaecologist. Nowadays in India both fields have been combined as MS Obs and gyne
Many of you Indians might not know that Mr .Sam Bahadur is also the honorary General of the oldest military organisation of Asia ie . Nepalese Army .. Salam ger. sahab 🙏
Really a legendary military figure of India by his virtue. A great gentleman cadet Lt Monekshaw. I love reading his life stories, his stories always allures me. As a now a days soldier, I wish I'd privileged to serve under his sage command.
Parsi's are such a wonderful gift to India. Proud of this small but great clan. Wish we had millions of such people around to lead and nuture our beautiful nation.
@@mincyabraham186 No mam. You misunderstood me. Very proud of you and your selfless service to our nation. My father was in AMC too. He retired a few years ago. He last worked command hospital pune. So i have seen the hardships of being a nurse and thats why i said "mallu nurse". Bcz we are mallus.
"A warrior capable of absolute carnage is the calmest of all" that holds true for this great gentleman. P.S. I don't know who said that quote but I just remember reading it somewhere😅
Rest in peace, Sam Bahadur, rest in peace. They don't make them like you anymore, neither in the eastern hemisphere nor, especially, in the western one. Rest in peace, brave man.
They do still make them like Sam, both in the Eastern and Western Hemisphere. The thing is, you need to look harder to spot them. If you stop looking hard for them, if you surrender to the notion that they are not there........well that Is Surrender right? There’s a high price to pay for it. Peace. Out.
I wish he had written his autobiography. His language and the clarity and confidence with which he recounts incidents is delightful! An older generation of men that are just lost now.
Field Marshal Maneckshaw passed away in 2008 but his noble memory remains. RIP. Before 1947 partition /independence he served with the 12th Frontier Force Regiment with great valour in World War 2 . A great uncle of mine served under his command . He deeply respected him like all soldiers who ever met Sam Maneckshaw, friends or foes. No earthly awards are equal to such a figure .
An interesting interview. For a change kudos to Karan Thapar. He did a great job here. I admire Sam to the hilt. First time I saw him in real was when he addressed the Passing Out Parade in IMA in Mar 72. Thereafter I met him a few times in Wellington when I was attending the Staff College in 1983. He was the one who presented us the MSc Degree. Later I heard him in Higher Command Course in 1994. Every time my respect and admiration went higher and higher. He was certainly a Chief who the nation is proud of. God bless his soul.
He handeled political pressure in a great way everytime and fought for the respect of man in uniform whenever any need arises, this made him a unparellel motivater for the men in last row to first. He could dare to face defence minister in Maj Gen Rank. He always fight for right and not for promotion. Promotion followed his bravery. He truly followed the word of Lord krishna"Karm kar fal ki chinta mat kar".Such leadership is missing now. Miss you daring soul. Jai Hind
My hero! It took lot f courage to tell Indira Gandhi in 71 to tell her that if her plan to attack in april is followed it will be 100% defeat !I Salute my hero
For a great personality like Field Marshall Sam Manekshaw, there are only praises and praises. The country is in debt for such a great personality who has contributed so much. If only india had more Sam Bahadurs....
@Chaudhry Vikrant ror maratha Praising other is not an inferiority complex I'm talking about this generation ,am proud we have had great ancestors who fought bravely.
@Chaudhry Vikrant ror maratha Wtf is wrong with you man ?? Sam Manekshaw was Indian as well. Dont you remember he was the COAS of the Indian Army during 1971 ?? You unnecessarily replied to one Indian praising another Indian community. Parsis are Indians. Lt. Col. Ardeshir Tarapore who was Indian first and then a parsi lead the Indian tank attack against Pakistani army in Pakistan in 1965, his battalion, the one which he was commanding destroyed 60 Patton Tanks whilst losing 9 of his own, including the one in which he was present, he died in it and for that he was later awarded the PvC or Param Vir Chakra, highest war time gallantry award. Another Indian parsi Lt. Comm. Bahadur Nariman Kavina was the commanding of officer of INS Nipat (now decommissioned) during the 1971 war, he lead and planned Operation Trident which destroyed Karachi port to bits and destroyed Pakistani Navy Headquarters there. Other countless Indian parsis have served the Indian nation. You calling them non-Indians is simply wrong. They are as much Indians as you and me. Inferiority and superiority complexes are nothing but illusions. People who have no achievements of their own cling to the glories of their great ancestors to feel good today. In reality they are only coping with their internal void and failure to achieve anything worthwhile in life. All Indians were great, all our ancestors were great. But then everyone's were. Everyone in this world thinks their ancestors were great. And they should but there should be no obsession over it. Honour the heroes of the land just dont obsess over them. Otherwise it goes on to become full on Nazism. And all of us know how it ended for the Nazis, dont we ? Honouring the heroes is always fine, one shouldn't obsess over them or any "past glorious times". Its dangerous. Otherwise, superiority and inferiority complexes are both equally suicidal and perennial to survival. One must strive to become rational.
What a chief ! India will never forget you Sir, we as a nation were blessed to have a son of motherland like you. Rest in Peace Sam . Jai mahakali, aayo gorkhali !
Our Chilhood Hero....once had the privilege to see him in person at kolkata when in class VI attending a military tattoo...was just awestruck by his mere presence...what a personality. SAM BAHADUR... THE NATION SALUTES YOU.
@@Luvly2938then you must not care about us anymore fu 3k inglish. He was a britsih sepoy of cource ssrvant if ytt will speka ytt inglish rest assured wer won't many anyoner like this anymore here
The clarity of the voice and the poise in the interview is amazing. Present journalism is way too concentrated on creating controversies rather that getting information!!
When I teenager I have heard about him in the press during India Oak war, still remember his name and fame, good to listen to the interview of great personality of war.
The interviewer is simply not catching up with the great Marshal's sense of humor. Our marshal truly emanated his masculinity and was not at all shy. India is blessed to have a leader like you. Great war stories. You showed respect to both sides. Thank you sir for your service!
This kind and level of gentleness and civility is a rare commodity in the effing 21st century. Salute to the man, Field Marshal Sam Hormusji Framji Jamshedji Manekshaw!
Thank you Karan for sharing this delightful interview with Sam Bahadur .... An officer & a gentleman of valour & humility , who carried his sense of humour , character & straightforwardness till his last days .... The pride of India . !!!! ... What a man , a class apart !!!! God bless his soul.🙏
hobgoblin1216 bullshit. This man doesn't mind making jokes. But he was an excellent general. He looked after his troops. All the gorkhas,sikhs and other great soldiers were absolute fans of him. A major part of why 30000 Indian brave hearts made 100000 surrender is his bond with his soldiers
Op thank you for this classic video. It's a true pleasure! This is how interviews are to be made! Not the screaming propaganda fests that they are now worldover. What class and humor :) This is a real personality! Just a small correction : the Field Marshal's name is Sam Manekshaw. Not Monekshaw.
Now I realise why India won the 1971 war with such a bold and enamoured commander while Pakistan Army had the misfortune of being led by a drunk and loadmouth Niazi. I am from Pakistan yet I have a huge respect for General Sam Manekshaw.
Love and tears of joy is all i had after watching the satisfaction on this honourable soldier's amazing and heart warming interview. God bless this soul
Salute you Field Marshall Sam Bahadur Manekshaw. Rest in Peace Sir. Edit: Very disrespectful of the then Indian Government to not attend his funeral. As expected from the bunch of spineless
Manekshaw didn't like the Congress regime at all. In this interview it seemed like Manekshaw had good relations with Indira Gandhi, but it wasn't the case. He made her more furious day by day, he was the man who used to go by his own words, conviction and commitments adding much more to the irk of her party members.
@@prash175 he called her cooly as sweety Manekshaw then was at a prime that they thought he would take down Indira Gandhi govt with his military coup But he refused it as he said he is not interested in politics See Indira Gandhi despite being like a friend him most of the times made her bitter to him
Thanks to internet connectivity and You Tube Premium ! Only because of this we are able to see and listen wonderful videos on almost all subjects just sitting at home ! Best past time for elders and young both !
What a charming personality. Really rare gem of a person. If I get even 10 percent of Sir Sam's personality, I would consider myself lucky. Amazing to see such brave men
Interestingly, Manekshaw had a poor opinion of Karan Thapar's father, Gen. P.N. Thapar, who, accoring to him, lacked the courage to stand up to the political establishment, which led to India's defeat in 1962.
You are one of kind Mr. Field Marshal !! No other Sam Manekshaw will ever ever take birth on this earth. Mother India so privileged to have son like you.
A very informative interview. The interviewer was really good. And what can you say about the guest? A true legend. Everyone from the Indian Subcontinent should watch this interview.
The Late Field Marshal Sam Manekshaw, was a very Honourable, Knowledgeable & Great man! ... Moreover, He too reminds me of my Grandfather... As he also highlighted 'Moral Courage' as one's duty...God Bless✌
he was 85 during this interview, yet he speaks so eloqunetly and coherently. Plus he is sitting without any discomfort. He is looking at least 10 years younger.
Watching this interview after watching his movie SAM BAHADUR. Love respect ❤️ Also great to see people comments those who know him before this movie was released
GREATEST GENERAL INDIA EVER HAD A PROUD FIELD MARSHAL.HIS BROTHER WAS A DOCTOR IN AIR FORCE OF INDIA AIR COMMODORE MANEKSAW AND WAS COMMANDER OF MY BROTHER WING COMMANDER MOHAN MURALI TOGETHER THEY IMPROVED INDIAN INSTITUTE OF AVIATION MEDICINE IN BANGALORE
He is probably the best person i have ever came across in my life. Jai hind sir ji 🇮🇳🇮🇳. You will live in our hearts, true hero never dies 🙏🙏. I wish i could have met u but 😭😭
What a man!!! What a personality!!! Way of talking way of seeing in the eyes...!!! Just too much Impressed whenever i saw this man's video...love from Bangladesh
It is a very lovely interview. for once, I'm seeing Karan Thapar being an attentive and respectful listener. FM Manekshaw comes across as a bright, very civil and refined man. Also very articulate.
He's a man from a generation where people used to have integrity, could die for his principle, civilized and well cultured, and even he has the ability to respect his enemy. Such a loveable and admirable individual he is.
Agreed.
Absolutely
He was
Hope the present political leadership understands what he says!
You mean before India got independent, Becoz he is from that era only
Dear Field Marshal Sam this nation & bangladesh are forever indebted to you.
ranjit bal Jai hind
Well said and quite true.
Jai hind
@o h 😂😂😂😂 thats the best joke i heard in ages
india fuck sikh community hahahahahah
The twinkle in his eyes when he said "I wanted to become a Gynaecologist". Oh such a naughty charmer he was!! 😄😄😍
Respect for him.A through gentleman.
Yeah!! 😄😄
Yes the uneducated Fool Karan Thapar mistook him for Obstetrician (who deliver babies) as opposed to Gynaecologist.
Nowadays in India both fields have been combined as MS Obs and gyne
Many of you Indians might not know that Mr .Sam Bahadur is also the honorary General of the oldest military organisation of Asia ie . Nepalese Army .. Salam ger. sahab 🙏
Wow its a honour
We proud of gorakh regiment
I actually didn't know that. Thank you for this information :)
Really a legendary military figure of India by his virtue. A great gentleman cadet Lt Monekshaw. I love reading his life stories, his stories always allures me. As a now a days soldier, I wish I'd privileged to serve under his sage command.
Respect
Inspiration for me, even he fought against us but he deserved the victory.
Truth. We all should be a great human being and soldier. Great.
💪💪💪😤jai hind 🙏😎😎😎😎
@@riyasinha8921 Long Live Motherland India!!!!
@@riyasinha8921 what a befitting reply to pakistani who want to come in goodbook
❤️
Parsi's are such a wonderful gift to India. Proud of this small but great clan. Wish we had millions of such people around to lead and nuture our beautiful nation.
U echoed my words...I always call them the Best Indians.
I had the previlage to lookafter him in 1989 when he was admitted in command hospital Bangalore
Great luck
Mincy are u physiotherapist
mallu nurse
Vinod Nair Ys, I am an exArmy officer. Is there any prob””mallu nurse””
@@mincyabraham186 No mam. You misunderstood me. Very proud of you and your selfless service to our nation.
My father was in AMC too. He retired a few years ago. He last worked command hospital pune. So i have seen the hardships of being a nurse and thats why i said "mallu nurse". Bcz we are mallus.
Someone who went through the bloodiest war in history talked so sweetly and professionally. He is unbelievably likeable.
"A warrior capable of absolute carnage is the calmest of all" that holds true for this great gentleman.
P.S. I don't know who said that quote but I just remember reading it somewhere😅
Wow I’m very impressed by the integrity of this man. Respect from Pakistan .
How rare. A man with integrity! We Pakistanis really appreciate your honest account of 1971 war.
You all should be!
Rest in peace, Sam Bahadur, rest in peace. They don't make them like you anymore, neither in the eastern hemisphere nor, especially, in the western one.
Rest in peace, brave man.
Bastard general , burning in hell
@@sarfm266 surprise, there is hell or heaven for real. Only on paper. But what he is done is not just on paper but a damn fact.
@@sarfm266 there is no heaven or hell
They do still make them like Sam, both in the Eastern and Western Hemisphere. The thing is, you need to look harder to spot them. If you stop looking hard for them, if you surrender to the notion that they are not there........well that Is Surrender right? There’s a high price to pay for it. Peace. Out.
@@actionflower6706 on point ..there are some raw material to need to be nurtured and trained
A very hearty,warm interview. The best thing in this world is to see an old man full of joy, happiness and satisfaction.
War hero inspiration to many army ppl
@mojo162 they say, "That man is mad who didn't cry in his youth and laugh in his old age."
I can only hope that I have a sense of humor and wit as alive as this man when I'm 85. What a phenomenal personality! Hats off, Field Marshal! 🙌
I wish he had written his autobiography. His language and the clarity and confidence with which he recounts incidents is delightful! An older generation of men that are just lost now.
He was an Army Man. His book would have brought many dead Skeleton alive. Army Men never does that. He did everything as his duty commanded.
This guy deserve Bharat Ratna
He is a ratna of Bharat.
Bharat Ratna is for Civilians.
Highest Military award during wartime, is Param Vir Chakra and during peacetime, is Ashok Chakra.
Whoto Indiranay churaliya
Bharat Ratna deserves him.
Bharat ratna is for civilians... He got the highest military award.
Field Marshal Maneckshaw passed away in 2008 but his noble memory remains. RIP. Before 1947 partition /independence he served with the 12th Frontier Force Regiment with great valour in World War 2 . A great uncle of mine served under his command . He deeply respected him like all soldiers who ever met Sam Maneckshaw, friends or foes. No earthly awards are equal to such a figure .
Gorkhas rifels
An interesting interview. For a change kudos to Karan Thapar. He did a great job here.
I admire Sam to the hilt. First time I saw him in real was when he addressed the Passing Out Parade in IMA in Mar 72. Thereafter I met him a few times in Wellington when I was attending the Staff College in 1983. He was the one who presented us the MSc Degree. Later I heard him in Higher Command Course in 1994. Every time my respect and admiration went higher and higher. He was certainly a Chief who the nation is proud of. God bless his soul.
He we'll deserve the honorific BAHADUR !!! 🌹🌹🌹🙏🙏🙏
He handeled political pressure in a great way everytime and fought for the respect of man in uniform whenever any need arises, this made him a unparellel motivater for the men in last row to first. He could dare to face defence minister in Maj Gen Rank. He always fight for right and not for promotion. Promotion followed his bravery. He truly followed the word of Lord krishna"Karm kar fal ki chinta mat kar".Such leadership is missing now. Miss you daring soul. Jai Hind
Undoubtedly the most dignified man of India.Forever Indebted to you Sir .
silpa pugalia
Shilps Pagli-a
My hero! It took lot f courage to tell Indira Gandhi in 71 to tell her that if her plan to attack in april is followed it will be 100% defeat !I Salute my hero
That shows Indira have 0 knowledge of war and insurgency
That's why she did operation bluestar
Which leads to blunder in delhi and punjab..
It takes 0 courage to tell the truth
@@sbp1747Because of Indira we are independent in Bangladesh. 😊
That sense of humour is to die for..... What a legend.....
'I had superiority 50 to 1. They just had no chance, but they fought very gallantly.' Huge respect for you sir!
For a great personality like Field Marshall Sam Manekshaw, there are only praises and praises. The country is in debt for such a great personality who has contributed so much. If only india had more Sam Bahadurs....
jafar zaheer, very right zafferji
India does. They just don't appear on TV.
Dont worry brother, when time comes you will see more ppl like them.
Sure we were lucky to have him but so is he who was given the right atmosphere and support to apply his skills by this great country
What is their in Parsi blood don't know they outshines every field ,they live very happily and they live life to the fullest.sam mankeshow jai hind 🇮🇳
Yes, this is something that even I have noticed. Same is with Jews
Interesting. They are more focused on their task and don't allow distractions to lead them astray!
@Chaudhry Vikrant ror maratha Praising other is not an inferiority complex I'm talking about this generation ,am proud we have had great ancestors who fought bravely.
@Chaudhry Vikrant ror maratha Wtf is wrong with you man ?? Sam Manekshaw was Indian as well. Dont you remember he was the COAS of the Indian Army during 1971 ?? You unnecessarily replied to one Indian praising another Indian community. Parsis are Indians. Lt. Col. Ardeshir Tarapore who was Indian first and then a parsi lead the Indian tank attack against Pakistani army in Pakistan in 1965, his battalion, the one which he was commanding destroyed 60 Patton Tanks whilst losing 9 of his own, including the one in which he was present, he died in it and for that he was later awarded the PvC or Param Vir Chakra, highest war time gallantry award. Another Indian parsi Lt. Comm. Bahadur Nariman Kavina was the commanding of officer of INS Nipat (now decommissioned) during the 1971 war, he lead and planned Operation Trident which destroyed Karachi port to bits and destroyed Pakistani Navy Headquarters there. Other countless Indian parsis have served the Indian nation. You calling them non-Indians is simply wrong. They are as much Indians as you and me.
Inferiority and superiority complexes are nothing but illusions. People who have no achievements of their own cling to the glories of their great ancestors to feel good today. In reality they are only coping with their internal void and failure to achieve anything worthwhile in life. All Indians were great, all our ancestors were great. But then everyone's were. Everyone in this world thinks their ancestors were great. And they should but there should be no obsession over it.
Honour the heroes of the land just dont obsess over them. Otherwise it goes on to become full on Nazism. And all of us know how it ended for the Nazis, dont we ? Honouring the heroes is always fine, one shouldn't obsess over them or any "past glorious times". Its dangerous. Otherwise, superiority and inferiority complexes are both equally suicidal and perennial to survival. One must strive to become rational.
Yup they are too godd and i love parsis, 🙏🙌
what an interview.love to watch it many times..regards from PAK..
What a chief ! India will never forget you Sir, we as a nation were blessed to have a son of motherland like you. Rest in Peace Sam . Jai mahakali, aayo gorkhali !
rest in peace, respect from Bangladesh ...
My brother is also called sam manekshaw. This guy is my great grandad
Wow
Very lucky you!
Our Chilhood Hero....once had the privilege to see him in person at kolkata when in class VI attending a military tattoo...was just awestruck by his mere presence...what a personality. SAM BAHADUR...
THE NATION SALUTES YOU.
the great INDIAN HERO, we all INDIANS love you with respect-----JAI JAWAAN JAI KISSAN
Mohamed ali great Ali saab
A big salute to you dear FIELD MARSHALL
The command of English by both gentlemen is pure joy to hear and watch. God bless India for diversity!!
lol thats all you care about?
@@gava9313 yes that’s all i care about.
@@Luvly2938then you must not care about us anymore fu 3k inglish. He was a britsih sepoy of cource ssrvant if ytt will speka ytt inglish rest assured wer won't many anyoner like this anymore here
All Bangladeshis are in debt to this man.
I had a smile throughout the Interview ! thats what keeps you young !
After 1947,, he is the most successful military man in the subcontinent.
The clarity of the voice and the poise in the interview is amazing. Present journalism is way too concentrated on creating controversies rather that getting information!!
When I teenager I have heard about him in the press during India Oak war, still remember his name and fame, good to listen to the interview of great personality of war.
The interviewer is simply not catching up with the great Marshal's sense of humor. Our marshal truly emanated his masculinity and was not at all shy. India is blessed to have a leader like you. Great war stories. You showed respect to both sides. Thank you sir for your service!
This kind and level of gentleness and civility is a rare commodity in the effing 21st century. Salute to the man, Field Marshal Sam Hormusji Framji Jamshedji Manekshaw!
Look at the integrity and professionalism of this man, the way he honestly praising his enemy. Politicians need to learn.
I often feel unlucky that I learned about him much later after his death , an outstanding person with great and witty sense . RIP Sam
Salutes to Field Marshal.
Bharat Mata ki jai.
Thank you Karan for sharing this delightful interview with Sam Bahadur .... An officer & a gentleman of valour & humility , who carried his sense of humour , character & straightforwardness till his last days .... The pride of India . !!!! ... What a man , a class apart !!!! God bless his soul.🙏
A true son of India, and a real worrier
hobgoblin1216 bullshit. This man doesn't mind making jokes. But he was an excellent general. He looked after his troops. All the gorkhas,sikhs and other great soldiers were absolute fans of him. A major part of why 30000 Indian brave hearts made 100000 surrender is his bond with his soldiers
hobgoblin1216 He is merely describing a historical event.
Warrior, you mean!
Respect for Sam Bahadur. Truly one of the greatest Indian. Salute to the brave and hearty soul. Wish to emulate his attitude and temperament.
Op thank you for this classic video. It's a true pleasure! This is how interviews are to be made! Not the screaming propaganda fests that they are now worldover. What class and humor :) This is a real personality! Just a small correction : the Field Marshal's name is Sam Manekshaw. Not Monekshaw.
Now I realise why India won the 1971 war with such a bold and enamoured commander while Pakistan Army had the misfortune of being led by a drunk and loadmouth Niazi. I am from Pakistan yet I have a huge respect for General Sam Manekshaw.
The gem of India. ❤️🇮🇳
He also has a wonderful sense of humor!
A legacy the present dispensation will never fathom... A Legend that still lives on ❤❤ Sam Bahadur.
Love and tears of joy is all i had after watching the satisfaction on this honourable soldier's amazing and heart warming interview. God bless this soul
Man he got everything attitude, ability, capability, humor, generosity and humbleness. I had a great respect for the man even being a from Pakistan.
This has to be my favourite interview ever. He was so elegant and charming at that age. Truly inspiring for youngsters like us to look upto.
FELD MARTIAL SAM BAHADUR
REST IN PEACE IN HEAVEN
SIR WE STILL REMEMBER YOU
WITH ALL LOVE HONOR VALOR
EVRY THING POSIBEL🙌🙌💪💓💝💘👌
Rare combination of gentle and naughty, our hero forever Mr. Sam
Manekshaw.
am in love with this old man ... long live the legacy of Sam bahadur
Good evening sir. I had dinner with you in 101 mess in 1065. God bless u healthy life and future.
A very accomplished General & Field Marshall ,A great human being and a source of inspirations to many
Salute you Field Marshall Sam Bahadur Manekshaw. Rest in Peace Sir.
Edit: Very disrespectful of the then Indian Government to not attend his funeral. As expected from the bunch of spineless
Indeed. the only politicians at the funeral were from the BJP, I think LK Advani was in attendance.
Manekshaw didn't like the Congress regime at all. In this interview it seemed like Manekshaw had good relations with Indira Gandhi, but it wasn't the case. He made her more furious day by day, he was the man who used to go by his own words, conviction and commitments adding much more to the irk of her party members.
@@prash175 he called her cooly as sweety
Manekshaw then was at a prime that they thought he would take down Indira Gandhi govt with his military coup
But he refused it as he said he is not interested in politics
See Indira Gandhi despite being like a friend him most of the times made her bitter to him
what a man! they seriously dnt make them like tht anymore!!
I don't know why, It feels irritating when Thapar speaks and it feels so soothing when the former chief speaks
" I've one wife who looks after me or at least pretends to " - witty leader.
Sam bahadur Manekshaw, a person not born everyday. The greatest general of Indian Army. Respect, honour,valour here it is. Jai hind.
my idol ..greatest indian army general
Field Marshall
Manekshaw : So I bent her over and thrashed her bottom...
I love how straightforward our field marshall was. No wonder, we won. No double thoughts.
Thanks to internet connectivity and You Tube Premium ! Only because of this we are able to see and listen wonderful videos on almost all subjects just sitting at home ! Best past time for elders and young both !
What a charming personality. Really rare gem of a person. If I get even 10 percent of Sir Sam's personality, I would consider myself lucky. Amazing to see such brave men
Interestingly, Manekshaw had a poor opinion of Karan Thapar's father, Gen. P.N. Thapar, who, accoring to him, lacked the courage to stand up to the political establishment, which led to India's defeat in 1962.
Do you have proof of what you say?
@@rscsingh7848 yes, he gave a speech at st. Xaviers Bombay... it's a video on RUclips abt 51 min long
@@ShailendraSingh-pk1gf ok. Great.
@@rscsingh7848 he said that the general didnt have the guts to say that army was not ready in 1962
Thaper not good
sir u r the role model of new generation army
You are one of kind Mr. Field Marshal !! No other Sam Manekshaw will ever ever take birth on this earth. Mother India so privileged to have son like you.
Eternal legend... May this land be blessed again with this soul..!
Ommani padme hum.
This legend doesn't deserve bharat ratna.... Actually bharat ratna deserves him😎🤘
A very informative interview. The interviewer was really good. And what can you say about the guest? A true legend. Everyone from the Indian Subcontinent should watch this interview.
The Late Field Marshal Sam Manekshaw, was a very Honourable, Knowledgeable & Great man! ... Moreover, He too reminds me of my Grandfather... As he also highlighted 'Moral Courage' as one's duty...God Bless✌
Thank God I saw this ...blessed to have such a soul grace India !!
he was 85 during this interview, yet he speaks so eloqunetly and coherently. Plus he is sitting without any discomfort. He is looking at least 10 years younger.
Legend from another era..!!
A great soldier, a great man, and the greatest general that the sub-continent has ever produced.
I have never seen Karan so happy in my life. Probably the Field Marshal reminds him of his own dad who was the 4th Army Chief of India.
What a man!Respect to you Field Marshall
what a gentleman.. respect sir..
I love to hear every moment every word of F M Sir Sam Manek Saw... thanks to Mr. Thapar for this wonderful interview...
Watching this interview after watching his movie SAM BAHADUR. Love respect ❤️
Also great to see people comments those who know him before this movie was released
Great energy and personality, such an inspiration to the youth. I admire you Field Marshal Sam Bahadur....salute
my salutes to this great army chief.
sir thank you and may you rest in peace
Listening to him will change the perspective of life.. Such a gem
Moment of silence for anchor at 15:45. What a thorough gentleman this soldier is. Bravo.
GREATEST GENERAL INDIA EVER HAD A PROUD FIELD MARSHAL.HIS BROTHER WAS A DOCTOR IN AIR FORCE OF INDIA AIR COMMODORE MANEKSAW AND WAS COMMANDER OF MY BROTHER WING COMMANDER MOHAN MURALI TOGETHER THEY IMPROVED INDIAN INSTITUTE OF AVIATION MEDICINE IN BANGALORE
SALUTE TO FIELD MARSHALL SAM MANEKSHAW 🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳. ONE OF MY INSPIRATION FOR DEFENSE 🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳. JAI HIND🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
This man right there stands above all other Indian Freedom Fighters. Such a successful yet such a modest person.
I can't get enough of this great Man!!!
He is probably the best person i have ever came across in my life.
Jai hind sir ji 🇮🇳🇮🇳.
You will live in our hearts, true hero never dies 🙏🙏.
I wish i could have met u but 😭😭
He man if words and India’s luck to have a military leader like Sam Manekshaw.
What a man!!! What a personality!!! Way of talking way of seeing in the eyes...!!! Just too much Impressed whenever i saw this man's video...love from Bangladesh
a classy true gentleman ... a man of discipline and principle's... and such confidence...
God he's highly likeable isn't he lol. Adore him
@jack back happens when they breed within the family 😂😂
Such a gentleman
Great soldier
Great Citizen
Salute
Always forever in our heart.. interviewer is soooo lucky to see and talk to him
Still living in the heart of indians. Thank u sir ❤️🙏🇮🇳
But I respect and appreciate highly FM Menakshaw. He is real hero and perfect Military Leader. Long live him.
Legend! Good Indian Parsi. Jai Hind
Such an amazing interview... RESPECT !!!!!
It is a very lovely interview. for once, I'm seeing Karan Thapar being an attentive and respectful listener. FM Manekshaw comes across as a bright, very civil and refined man. Also very articulate.