Palestinian refugees: What do you know about the villages you come from?
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 22 янв 2021
- Filmed before the Covid-19 pandemic
The Ask Project is made possible by donations from viewers like you.
To donate to the project:
* www.paypal.me/coreygilshuster
* / askproject
What is this project?: Do you want to know what Israelis and Palestinians really think about the conflict? Ask a question and I will get answers. All answers are from random people and all answers are included and unedited. The questions come from you, the viewers.
Why do I do this?: See the following videos where I explain the background and goal of the project • The Ask Project interv...
This is one of best questions asked. Thank you Corey for having the courage to ask this, and this whole project and props to the person who sent this question in.
@נואה עבד אל רחמן5
Thanks to the translator
G-d bless the translator.
I think the opposite. It’s confusing. You can’t be *from* a place you weren’t born in and never lived in. Most of these people were clearly born after 1948, so they were not born in these villages referred to and never lived there. How can you be *from* a place you were not born in and didn’t live in? Your parents can be from there, but you can’t be from a place you never lived.
@@sandrad9695
Where are they from then?
@@asynchronicity Whatever town they were born in, but it’s not these towns. I’ve never lived in Arkansas. My dad was born in Arkansas, so he was from there. But I’m not. I was born in California, so I’m from California. I could never say that I’m from Arkansas just because my dad was born there.
Feeling Sober about all of this---Thank You---aloha to everyone, especially to those who are wise, kind and funny
I'm french but my grandparents were from Safed. They left in 1948. I visited Safed few years ago and it was very moving. There is no arab anymore and they turned the old mosque into an art gallery.
In 1947, the Jordanian army occupied Judea and Samaria, destroying the Jewish communities and expelling the Jews.
Jews had lived there since before Islam and Christianity.
@@Linda43 Jews before 1900 represented less than 10% of the total population
@@MehdiZanjabil
It really isn't relevant.
That fact is that Judea and Samaria were centers of Jewish life before the Jewish exile by Rome.
We have returned to our ancestral borders, facts on the ground.
Accept reality
@Mohamed Mostafa True. And I always considered that fact sufficient to make Israel illegitimate. From 5% to >70% in 100 years. Who are the occupiers ?
@ Mohammed Moustafa:
The Jewish sons( and daughters) have returned to their ancient ancestral borders. That is the reality that the Arabs need to reckon with now. 🤷♀️ Facts not propaganda
I feel sorry for these people, who've never seen the villages their parents or grandparents came from (except the old man), but what's really sad is the false hope that some day they will go back there. Of course many Jews were expelled from their homes in Jerusalem & Hebron & still can't get their property back.
palestinians will return to their towns
This is heartbreaking.
Thanks for bringing the truth..
What truth?
@@simko8665 that their land have been stolen. THE OBVIOUS TRUTH.
@@azim1833 How come? How did it happen? Two Million Arabs against hardly 600 thousand Jews with almost no weapon?
That land was also stolen by the Muslims in the 7th century, by the Romans, by the Ottomans. Not from the PA who lived there among others.
Now is the turn of Israel. Very simple.
@@simko8665 ??? israel had weapons and army and the support of Britain and america and Palestinians didn't had weapons of course the jews will win
@@VIP1G On the contrary. Britain was against Israel in the last years of the Mandate and certainly didn't supply them with weapon. America didn't care for what is going on. In the beginning of the war Israel had only one rifle for two soldiers and few ww1 canons. Egypt invaded Israel with Tanks and airplanes which bombed Tel Aviv. Syria with Tanks and so also Jordan. It was lucky for Israel to fight Arab poor soldiers who didn't have an interest in it and fled from the battle fields in many cases. Only three months later one ship had arrived with light weapon like rifles and bullets.
I suggest you to get yourself some knowledge and to stop spreading around lies in order to explain the defeat of the five Arab Armies against Israel.
Love your video So simple and easy to understand ❤️ from 🇮🇩
Are there any Jews in Indonesia? Also I wanted to ask if an Israeli can travel to Indonesia (Legally)
Because Indonesia looks absolutely stunning
@@nouhn1878 Yes you can
but you need special visa .
@@sobatjomblo2074 I only have an Israeli Visa
Poor Palestinians. I hope for all of them to return in their villages
Respect from Italy 🇮🇹🇮🇹🇮🇹
I like Marco Mengoni greetings from Indonesia
@Soia Isreal I hate you and I am secular, Let people have their opinions
@Soia Isreal I hate both zionist and hitler
@@nouhn1878 i dont hate Israelians, simply im sad to see Palestinians in this situation.
For me the best would be to see Israelians and Palestinians living together at the same level, that respect each other.
@Mohamed Mostafa Salvation* can be found in no other name under Heaven other than THE NAME of Jesus THE CHRIST/BSHEM *YESHUA* HA MASHIACH. for HE alone IS THE ONLY WAY THE ONLY TRUTH and THE ONLY WAY to Eternal life and no one gets to HASHEM/GOD ecept through HIM. so i only ask all who are here if not already to please choose this day to trust in YESHUA HA MASHIACH that HE died in your place to make atonement for your sins that was seperating you from GOD so that by believing this and trusting in HIM that HE rose from the grave that you too by believing in HIM will one day rise from the dead and have eternal life and be saved from The Terrifying Wrath of HASHEM that is to come to all who reject YESHUA as THE MESSIAH of Israel and SAVIOR of The Whole World that HE rightly, truly IS. i ask please do this so that even today will be your *Day of Salvation*
Have you ever visited the camps in Lebanon Syria or Egypt for palestinian refugees
that is how the arabs treat their brothers, in Israel, there are no camps for arabs, in Israel, they are very successful
@@avigayegos1496 yes Israel treated them very well by treating them as 3rd class citizens
@@avigayegos1496 First, we are Palestinians We live in our own homes
Thanin The Palestinian (Israeli) citizen is a second-class citizen, and there are racist and disgusting laws. Do you know that? The
Israel is a country created by refugees by creating refugees out of the locals so a random Jew from New York to Moscow can play the Land Of Israel game. A Zio will say that a Jew has the right of return after 2000 years yet a Pali can never return to the land that they were usurped from after 70 years.
@@avigayegos1496 still , not an argument to take their places !
I am also from one of the villages mentioned in the video, Dayr Aban. It's an old village, dating back thousands of years, and is present in ottoman registers and the Bible. It was a large village of the subdistrict of jerusalem. It wasn't paved over but is near Beit Shemesh and has ruins since it was struck by artillery in 1948. The name is aramiac and the population has one of the oldest Christian and semitic bloodlines. 🇵🇸
@Ant B That's actually not true since there was an Operation associated with the depopulation of most if not all depopulated villages. The operation for this village was called 'Ha'ar' and the first strike was Israeli. The village was demolished via artillery despite not being a military installment against international law.
@@ya987 The village dating back thousands of years is an old Jewish/Israelite village called Abenezer. You are talking about a territory that is a piece of Jewish history.
And no, the first strike wasn't Israeli. It looks like you can read and understand the concept of "dates" so, just take a look yourself, the internet is free and full of information. Your leaders back in 48' thought it is a good idea, after they rejected any form of peace and negotiations, to blockade Jewish settlements with about 100,000 civilians in the very same area of Jerusalem and other parts of Judea and Samaria, and also Jewish settlements in the south of Israel. All Israeli operations where Arabs were displaced, took place well after that blockade and were a direct response to that act of war. Blockading 100,000 civilians is a universally accepted casus beli, a legitimate cause to go to war, defensively. The person you need to thank for starting this whole conflict, war and displacement is Al-Hussayni and the Arab League that made the foolish mistake of going to a war they ended up losing. Your leaders made the mistake, and the common people paid the price.
The arab denial of the partition plan (as well as any negotiations) was in November 29th 1947.
The blockade started in December 31st 1947.
The displacements occured in:
Operation Ha-Har started in October 1948.
Operation Dalet March 10th 1948.
Corey should show us how the camps look like
Camps? Those were fortified, bustling cities.
@@TheRanaro
you want them to live in tents for 80 years
@@nashmi-8609 actually, I'd love for them to live as full-fledged and proud Jordanian citizens throughout their native land in Jordan. It's a crying shame that both Abdullah and his father Hussein have gotten away with too much.
@@TheRanaro
why dont you back to poland
isnt that better
becaue trust me when we come you will regret you didnt flee
@@nashmi-8609 no reason to. Israel is mine. Not Poland. Who the fk would want to live there in the first place?
My grandparents were from jaffa, they didn't told where exactly, but i really want to see it back
But that makes your grandpa a reffugee, not you. If the PLO wants to call you a reffugee that isn't Israels problem
Have you been there ever?
@@simko8665 No i wasn't
@@Whatever4867 Why not? What kept you doing it till now. I'm sure that you'd be well received in Israel.
@@simko8665 i am not going to be well received in israel if i protested against bibi, that would cause me arresting, or if i didn't have israeli nationality, i won't be able to live like the israelis does
Corey how do you feel when you had the right to come from Canada and live in this land with no right to do so on expense of these people ?
Law of Return enacted by the legitimate government of Israel in 1950 gives him the right.
@@Linda43 Israel itself is illegitimate
@@rayyanabualia4500 No it is completely legitimate whether you like it or not
@@rayyanabualia4500 I say that as an Israeli Arab
@@nouhn1878 im Palestinian and if i said it’s legitimate doesn’t make any difference, if you consider yourself as an Israeli Arab i really feel sorry for you, poor guy
Next week Corey Gil-Schuster is headed to Germany to ask the descendants of Sudeten and Silesian and Danzig and East Prussian refugees what they know about the towns and farm villages they "came from". ....We mustn't let bygones be bygones for the sake of peace! Yes, let's start a campaign among former Volksdeutsch to recall the places they were expelled from as a result of Germany's wars of aggression against their neighbors! Maybe they should campaign for a "right of return" to their former residences and farmland.
After he is done in Germany, Gil-Schuster will then head to France and meet with some former Pied-Noir and their descendants to ask THEM what they know about the towns and farms they were ethnically cleansed from, fifty to sixty years ago, after Algerian independence. Many of them had lived for generations in Algeria and Tunisia and had developed commercial farms and towns there.
800,000 Jews were living in peace (and at peace with most of their neighbors) in Yemen, Iraq, Iran, Algeria, Tunisia, Morocco, etc. until the 1940s and '50s when they were DRIVEN out by the Arab and Muslim fanatics that Mr. Gil-Schuster currently serves. Will he ask any of them if they remember the life they had there, after having lived centuries there? Will he ask THEM if they wish THEIR plight to be mentioned every time people mention the Arab so-called "refugees"?
I'm an American, so can those of you who live there -- and speak either Hebrew or Arabic -- please tell me if their is a Hebrew word (or an Arabic word) for CONTEXT?!? (As in, historical context for the way things are now?)
If you wish to live in peace with your neighbors, try not killing them (or plotting with others to kill them)! ....People can only live in peace with others if they agree that religion and state (and general education and state, as well) are SEPARATED; if they learn that the SOLE PURPOSE of a civil state is to keep the peace -- and NOT to foster culture, religion, art, "morals", or even the economic welfare of the people (those matters are PRIVATE concerns to be handled by VOLUNTARY cooperative efforts.); but simply to keep the peace and adjudicate disputes that arise even among honest men, THEN peace can be had among Sunni, Shiites, Jews, Christians, Druze, Buddhists, atheists, everyone!
People must accept that public government is, in its essence, FORCE. And that force should only be wielded against those who initiate force or fraud (which is an indirect form of force) against others (including matters of contractual dispute and "tort" injury). If you want peace among men, learn to live and let live and forego any endeavor to FORCE the "improvement" of others' lives -- whether morally or materially.
How do you know this?
@@nouhn1878 , are you referring to?What, specifically
@@MrJm323 How do you know Corey is going to Germany?
@@nouhn1878 I was being sarcastic; of course he isn't going to Germany or France.
my origin from Umm az-Zinat (أم الزينات), I know everything because one of my uncles who lived there wrote a whole book (like a bio) about it even the map haha, and how Jews and Druze conquer it, then he passed to his son everything he knows about it and the son still doing vids about it and similar topics
I still go there and steal olives.
just sayin.
The Druze?
@@nouhn1878 Yes
@@user-co8uf1mj6c The Druze don't conquer and neither do the Jews
@@user-co8uf1mj6c RUclips keeps deleting my comments for no reason
@@nouhn1878 ki ho ben zouna
Coary can you make a video Palestinians who are US citizens living in US
How can you help solve the conflict
Hi, thank you for your comment.
There are whole villages where the people all have US citizenships, and it would be interesting to go there, but mot easy. Maybe we'll try to go and see.
Please donate to help us get there :)
fyi corey habibi, zechariah is not a new testament prophet but a well known jewish prophet mentioned in the old testament.
No, there is another Zechariah, or Zachary, the father of John the Baptist in later times.
@@woopert7 oh i see. but was john the baptist's father a prophet? i dont think so.
I am from a village called hajjah next to Nablus
How to send question ?
Hi, to the email at the end.
Beautiful
How is someone “from” somewhere if they were not born there and never lived there? The people who were born in the village and left when they were small could say they are from that village. But some of these people, the ones clearly born after 1948, are not *from* the village their parents left. You could say their parents were from a specific village, but you can’t be *from* somewhere you’ve never been. The question is confusing.
Palestinians have strong connection to their land. That’s because they are indigenous people. If you’re indigenous to the land you live in, you will understand.
@@geegeeh.6118 Having a strong connection to the land, which I don’t believe Palestinian Arabs have in the first place, still doesn’t change the fact that you can’t be from a town or village that you’ve never been to. You have to have lived somewhere and moved away in order to be “from” that place. That’s the very definition of being *from* somewhere. You were there and then you left. So if they’ve never been to the village their parents lived in, they can’t be from that village. They can say that’s the village their parents are from, but that’s it.
@@sandrad9695then u don’t understand arab culture at all. I was born in my village in Yemen. I haven’t been since I was 1 for safety and economic reasons. We speak the Arabic of that village and still are completely connected to the village. Just because u don’t understand what it means to be a villager, it doesn’t mean u should push ur views on others
@@amoolakhanshali2972 If you were born there, you’re officially from there. This is not the case for most of these Arabs in this video. The majority of them were not only not born in the village they say they’re from, but they’ve never even visited. Their parents lived there and can say they’re from that village. But no one can be from somewhere they’ve never been.
Lol so in that logic, jews, who claim they lived there 3000 years ago, can't tell they own the land.
Do you think he did something... I don't.. they just like to abuse the owners of the land.. can't you feel it 😪
@Starhopper the old man 👴 who couldn't go back to his own house.. he is refused from interning his home town by the Israeli authority .. imagine how abusing is that feeling.. take care
@Starhopper
ruclips.net/video/LTfMiZ4WCg4/видео.html
This is the real picture.. and I thank them and respect them they are the amazing 👏 ❤
5:36 i think I see what you mean.. he's kinda have black like he was abused in the eye. 👁️
@Starhopper Do you know the guy that you can claim he didn't do anything?
2:22 Prophet Zechariah is not from the new testament. He's a Jewish Prophet he's first mentioned in the old testament.
Are you sure you are not confusing this one with Zephaniah, who is indeed one of the 12 minor prophets in the Tanakh.
I imagine Zechariah was quite a common name (given its meaning) but the one most widely known, and most likely to have a tomb is the Zechariah who was the father of John the Baptist.
@@marksimons8861 Yes you’re right. My mistake. In Islamic theology Zechariah is the one mentioned in the New Testament which he’s also the father of John the Baptist. Also, Prophet Zechariah’s wife is the sister of the Virgin Mary. So Jesus and John and cousins.
@Soia Isreal 😱🤯 You didn't call him an IslamNazi!
@@7164227 hence the confusion of the Koran getting facts straight and Jesus is Moses nephew 🥴🕋
@@GigiAbbi-cu9qn they’re not nephews Jesus is a descendant of Moses?!
People relocate or forced from their land all the time. Now, in the past and probably in the future. Why would these people expect something different from the fate of others?
Why do israelis expect that, lets say they lived their 3000 years ago (which they haven't, it's hard to believe the polish white netanyahu comes from the middle east) why do they expect to return?
Palestinians are not going to give up on their rights, if you see whats happening as normal ,that's up to you, but you can't take them their right to return
@@feisalajaj7954 actually that is exactly what has happened in many other places around the world. Just in the Middle East the Hittites dislocated the locals, then came the Romans and what about the Ottoman Empire. One nation conquers and another is dislocated.
@@mirabrown2271
So you are saying they have now been conquered by Israelis and have to leave?
@asynchronicity No because we were willing to share it but Islam needs to save face and have it all from the river to the sea which we allow for a jewish state in the equation. That is not going to happen.
@@mirabrown2271
Well, you have to admit that most Israelis ultimately see West Bank territory as Judea and Samaria, and therefore part of “historical Israel.” Even Gaza is seen by many in the same way. What is left?
looks like summer
To all the brothers and sisters in Palestine 🇵🇸, show the world what you can achieve. Show the world, despite the hardship, the occupation, the constant destruction and bombing, you as Palestinians will not be defeated. You will rise up stronger and better and deal with everyday life as best as possible. All the best from Tunisia 🇹🇳🌹Peace ☮️
I am not sure that the lives of Tunsians are so much better because of your disputes.
Not that Israel is ok for the refugees they expelled.
But is the only thing important to them is to go to the home where their grand grand parents lived? Do they really have any feelings or relation to that place they never have been in?
Will their life all of a sudden turn great because they live there?
In my opinion they should put more effort in making the today life better, and not all of the effort to go back to go live as in 1948
@DragonLady XD as I said in the beginning
*Not that Israel is ok*
You yet didn't answer me
Why is this the only thing important to them in life?
@@alonsol8989 not where their grand grand parents lived, where their fathers and mothers lived. For many of them it is important, because those towns are tied to their families and their ancestry.
Whats currently going on in Palestinians regions about the vaccines? Is it guaranteed for everyone or are Israelis prioritized? It would be interesting to know what Palestinian think in current situation because Israel is No. 1 in German News for example for their fast vaccinations. Today there was an article that most Palestinians are still waiting.
The Palestinians will recieve the Russian Vaccine supposedly
The Russian one is alot worse than the American one (Pfizer or Moderna)
Is there a roll out plan for Gaza and WB? It's certainly far too dangerous for Israeli health care workers to go there.
@@marksimons8861 I doubt it,I'm not really sure I haven't done that much research
Also canadians and belgians are still waiting for israeli vaccines!!!! Why dont israel vaccinate them?!?!?!?!?!
Unfortunately, as long the Palestinian people still consider the Jewish population in the '48 land as settlements, no compromise can be reached.
Most "Palestinians pre 48 are now Israeli Arabs.. conveniently people forget that fact. There's only 1.7 million of them after all
@@da3v1ls93 What about the refugees?
everyone consider them as settlements because they are , you cant deny the truth like cowards everyone knows it now , 'if i dont steal your house someone else will' -yacoub from broklyn
@@omnipresente6958 I don't know what you're quoting, but even the Palestinians have recognized the '48 lands as Israeli.
@@exx8eran Nope they didnt everyone call them settlements , because england gave you the land and you took all of it. You send jews from all over the world to colonize the land.
Here a video of yacoub claiming that he has to steal the house or someone else will, enjoy seing your compatriots stealing houses
ruclips.net/video/KNqozQ8uaV8/видео.html
2:27 Zacharya is in the Old Testament. Please give Jews some credit for writing the Old Testament hundreds of years before Jesus :-)
Jews wrote most of the New Testament too.
@@DougWinfield shh... did you know that in medieval Europe you'd get into trouble discussing the Jewishness of Christianity
@@makpazon11 Strangely enough I read an article about that earlier today.
Jesus emerged at a time when many jews were expecting the Messiah and many folks stepped up then and at other times to claim that role.
Muslims view Jesus as more than a man but less than a god. Christians range from believing him to be a prophet, messiah, son of God to God incarnate. And as you can see in Corey's videos, Israelis see Jesus as everything from the son of a whore to the one and true messiah. I myself am a fan of Depeche Mode's Personal Jesus:
Someone to hear your prayers
Someone who cares
Someone who's there
works for me
@@DougWinfield Now that's what I call serendipity. The interconnectedness of the universe is beyond Moses, Jesus or Mohammad.
"around hebron" and "around jerusalem" aren't terribly specific
are there any palestinian or ex palestinian or arab living well in israel? or are they being discriminated?
Gp watch videos of this channel about israeli arabs
My grandparents had a land with an old house in Ein Karem
My grandparents had a home in Poland. 🤷♀️
Wars come and populations shift. 🤷♀️
@@Linda43 Then you should go back to Poland
@@Linda43 Poland is safe now,You can return
@@Linda43 Have fun with you're bigos stew
@@nouhn1878 Have fun with your Islamic refugees!
Wow I’m early
Early bird, yada yada yada
The last guy's mindset looks christian to me
Is he?
Reminds me of my uncle (fathers mothers side) from Jerusalem
My Dads side were from Nazareth but my Dad was born in Jerusalem - the Christian Quarter
Where were you born
Zakariya is quit far from Bet Shaemesh, more close to
kfar-Etzion where all the the Jewish male executed defending their homes untill their last breath, they wouldn't be refugees anymore.
However, the femely living in Zakariya are very nice, I've been their when I was in highschool.
Those from Haifa and Akko - why do they say that they are refugees. There are thousands of Arabs living there now. And btw nice landcruiser in a poor refugee camp
because many were forcibly removed
@@TheAwesomeGingerGuy if that's true, doesn't seem like they have it too bad. Where I am from, "being forcibly removed" and given a home and job is a BLESS compared to forced human trafficking..
@Soia Isreal Doesn't the term "arabs" (in reference to original comment) communicate ethnocentrism as opposed to religious mysticism?
@@auahsuleikan9277 Salvation* can be found in no other name under Heaven other than THE NAME of Jesus THE CHRIST/BSHEM *YESHUA* HA MASHIACH. for HE alone IS THE ONLY WAY THE ONLY TRUTH and THE ONLY WAY to Eternal life and no one gets to HASHEM/GOD ecept through HIM. so i only ask all who are here if not already to please choose this day to trust in YESHUA HA MASHIACH that HE died in your place to make atonement for your sins that was seperating you from GOD so that by believing this and trusting in HIM that HE rose from the grave that you too by believing in HIM will one day rise from the dead and have eternal life and be saved from The Terrifying Wrath of HASHEM that is to come to all who reject YESHUA as THE MESSIAH of Israel and SAVIOR of The Whole World that HE rightly, truly IS. i ask please do this so that even today will be your *Day of Salvation*
@@skellingtonmeteoryballoon thats what they called themseleves for decades before balastinians became the more financially benficial term in the 1990s
Tu'Beshvat, Chag Sameach to all Am Yisroel wherever you are... The Chag starts on Wednesday Jan 27 at night to Thurs Jan 28 at night
Rosh Hashana for Trees.
Traditionally it is the end of winter and trees begin to bloom.
Plant a tree and reclaim the land of Israel.
Enjoy the Seven Species of Israel plus other symbolic foods at a Seudah.
Fun fact: It is a favorite chag in Kibbutz, secular and religious.
How does that work?
Are you on some sort of Drugs?
Probably PTSD
Or maybe Crack who knows
I am sorry for any sorrow anyone feels. I also cannot believe that this issue is being re -debated at the UN today while 79.5 million refugees who might like to resettle anywhere safe and clean , wait. This issue is like beating a dead horse. The quartet will make the leaders talk again only to find there is nothing they can talk about. This while 79.5 million other refugees from other conflicts like Syria wait. Palestinians are not included in this figure of 79.5 m because they and only they have a special agency called UNHRA dedicated to them for the past 75 years, Is that fair? I wish everyone equanimity and justice ,but not on the backs of others.Peace
UNRWA has turned the Arabs into professional refugees, therefore perpetuating their delusions of " statehood "
@@Linda43 EVIL ISLAMNAZISM
@@nouhn1878 Noah I going to make you shut up forever where you live?
@@nouhn1878 I can not stand to IslamNazi five minute🤮🤮🤮
@@nouhn1878
Did you read Soia new post?
After the British empire left the area in the 1940s, the UN divided the land into two states, but the Arabs attacked the Jews and wanted to take over all the land, with the help of the armies of the neighboring Arab states, that attacked the Jews from all directions. After a bloody war, the Jews managed to repel them and won. The Arab leadership ordered the Arabs to leave, and assured them that they would return and take over the land, so some went to Gaza and other places, and others remain and today are equal citizens of the State of Israel.
I'm afraid it is not quite so simple as this.
In 1948 the Arab armies were besieging Jerusalem and the nascent state was desperate to relieve the Jewish inhabitants of the city from starvation. This involved clearing some of the villages which had been used as bases to attack the convoys.
All the Jewish inhabitants of the part of Jerusalem held by the Arabs were expelled from their homes. This gave birth to the idea of an "Arab" East Jerusalem.
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_for_Jerusalem
@@marksimons8861 exactly and we will never let Islamist have a foot hold in our midst again
@@GigiAbbi-cu9qn There are 2 million citizens of Israel who are Arab.
@George Wannabee Pure ignorance from a clown!
@George Wannabee did ben gurion declare a genocidal war on day 1?
Nah........
It was the people of peace. And 7 peacefull states of peace.
Thank you for showing the truth about the stolen land, indeed it will be free again.
#Free_Palestine
🟥⬛⬛⬛⬛⬛⬛⬛⬛⬛⬛⬛
🟥🟥⬛⬛⬛⬛⬛⬛⬛⬛⬛⬛
🟥🟥🟥⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜
🟥🟥🟥🟥⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜
🟥🟥🟥⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜
🟥🟥🟩🟩🟩🟩🟩🟩🟩🟩🟩🟩
🟥🟩🟩🟩🟩🟩🟩🟩🟩🟩🟩🟩
You can't free what doesn't exist....
You can't steal your own country......
💙💙AM YISROEL CHAI LE'NETZACH
ISRAEL LIVES FOREVER FROM THE JORDAN RIVER TO THE MEDITERRANEAN SEA 💙💙
@@Linda43 lol ok keep dreaming 😂🤦♂️just see how miserably your government wants to be recognized by arab countries 🤦♂️
🟥⬛⬛⬛⬛⬛⬛⬛⬛⬛⬛⬛
🟥🟥⬛⬛⬛⬛⬛⬛⬛⬛⬛⬛
🟥🟥🟥⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜
🟥🟥🟥🟥⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜
🟥🟥🟥⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜
🟥🟥🟩🟩🟩🟩🟩🟩🟩🟩🟩🟩
🟥🟩🟩🟩🟩🟩🟩🟩🟩🟩🟩🟩
@@azim1833
The Abraham Accords have removed any strategic advantages that the Arabs in Israel ever had in the past.
Israel has moved on and so has the Arab world.
If you find this amusing, I congratulate your response to failure.
@@Linda43 lol thank you for confessing that israel the occupier is an apartheid state, nothing new to me. Thr world knows it and you know it. Period. 🇵🇸
@Danny Smith lol ok kiddo.
🟥⬛⬛⬛⬛⬛⬛⬛⬛⬛⬛⬛
🟥🟥⬛⬛⬛⬛⬛⬛⬛⬛⬛⬛
🟥🟥🟥⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜
🟥🟥🟥🟥⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜
🟥🟥🟥⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜
🟥🟥🟩🟩🟩🟩🟩🟩🟩🟩🟩🟩
🟥🟩🟩🟩🟩🟩🟩🟩🟩🟩🟩🟩
The same people who aspired so much to go back to the holy land after two millenia will now tell you that Palestinians after generations cannot go back after 100 years.
I am a Jew and I agree with you. I wish there could be a homeland in Israel/Palestine for us all. Meanwhile, for what reason haven't the Arab countries absorbed the Palestinian refugees instead of keeping them in camps?
@@aaronrudner3934 The Arab countries (Most) have made peace with Israel so if they helped Palestine that would worsen relations
@@aaronrudner3934 And relations between them are at the best they have been
@@aaronrudner3934
In 1950, the Arab countries voted to NOT to offer citizenship to the Arab refugees. Instead they allowed them to languish in refugee camps, putting more fuel on the fire.
@@nouhn1878 thats why they dont absorb their felloq arabs for 70 years? Dosnt make sense.
I have question that please video later about how the people’s think for israel ethiopian jew’s
Thank you
From USA
Corey did a video on this subject. Look at his archives.
Interesting facts:
1-The majority of Ethiopian Jews are modern Orthodox or traditional.
1-Most Ethiopian Jews vote Likud, which is a secular,center right to right wing party. The Likud coalition traditionally includes Ultra Orthodox parties.
There is Ethiopian Knesset member from Likud.
3- 162 Ethiopian Jews recently arrived in Israel.
Most Israelis don't hate the Ethiopian Jews but some of the Orthodox Jews do (The Orthodox are the people who run around in crowds without wearing masks) Oh and they also don't like the Gentiles (It doesn't matter who,they just like themselves)
@Mohamed Mostafa
Google Likud
@Mohamed Mostafa Likud ain't the religious right, that's for sure.
On its official website, Likud stands for the National Liberal Movement.
Liberalism is associated with secularism.
“What did they farm” What is this police interrogation? Don’t they feel uncomfortable?
Incredible ! Refugee is passed from father to son like a legacy
@Mohamed Mostafa The Jews didn't just claim the right, they actually took back the land and created a country, unlike the Palestinians who have absolutely zero chances of getting back the land for themselves, yet continue whining and complaining and living off foreign aid in refugee camps for the past 72 years, it is time for them to face reality and move on.
@Mohamed Mostafa I'm very calm, yourself?
@@sunshine6522 Don't forget to mention the millions and millions of foreign aid that Israel gets.
@Eti Bronx
And adopted children 🙄
@Eti Bronx
The absolute truth!!
The fact that these people have never visited their own villages and land and only heard about them from their parents really breaks my heart, not to mention the Palestinian refugees who died before fulfilling their lifelong wish to return to their OWN country and live there. #FreePalestine
Wouldn't the same logic apply to the Jews who used to live in these areas thousands of years ago? The only solution is to move on and find a way to live together.
@@ShpanMan How about the Jews that lived in the West Bank and Jerusalem untill they were forced out by Palestinian combatants and the Jordanian army in 1948? How about the vast majority of Jews during the very same time that were refugees of war and were forced to leave their homes?
Somehow the narrative only allows sympathy for one people's suffering and not the other.
שבוע טוב לכולם😊
שבוע טוב ומבורך☺
*Speak English, not coin grabber*
@@user-up1ny oh I don’t write in caravan robber seven Sentry Arabian megalomaniac
@pros tras2 Arabs are also semites arent they?
I have Palestinian friends who are right now live in Hebron but both of their Parents actually live in Beersheba for generations until they being expelled in 1948. I heard their stories on how did their Parents being expelled. They said one day in the morning, their Parents had a breakfast & suddenly a family of Ukrainian Jewish refugees came accompanied by 5 Israeli soldiers & give them two words which are either leave or die. And then they asked them why are they want to steal their own house, guess what the Ukrainian Jewish refugees answered? “God said this house are ours & he allowed me to steal it!”
sorry about the question but where is palestine ? i dont know realy
It is a (Disputed) country in the Middle East, I recognize it as a territory but not as a country
@@nouhn1878 what do you think about this territory? And what are you prefer to live in israel or palestine territory?
@@nouhn1878 your answer is very good for me thank you
@@gilkatsir4052 I prefer to live in the Israeli territory since it's more secular than the Palestinian one
@@gilkatsir4052 Btw I'm a Secular Muslim
2:17 بية مختار؟
سلام عليكم من ليبيا 😂
ههههه
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
مختار القرية يمكن القصد
مش عيلة المختار 😅
الله يفرجها على ليبيا الغاليه
@Danny Smith I disagree. You say that Sonic is better than Mario and this is outrageously stupid. Mario has big mushrooms and Sonic has what? Some rings, that's it. It's not worth it. And you can't even kill the enemies in this stupid game. Nah, Mario wins.
Free Palestine 🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸❤️❤️❤️❤️ good times will come inşAllah, don't be desperate! 👍
@Yoav DanyalYou mean just for you
@Yoav Danyal good time will come and it will end the current Fascism. Remember this flag very will, it's your host flag.
🟥⬛⬛⬛⬛⬛⬛⬛⬛⬛⬛⬛
🟥🟥⬛⬛⬛⬛⬛⬛⬛⬛⬛⬛
🟥🟥🟥⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜
🟥🟥🟥🟥⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜
🟥🟥🟥⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜⬜
🟥🟥🟩🟩🟩🟩🟩🟩🟩🟩🟩🟩
🟥🟩🟩🟩🟩🟩🟩🟩🟩🟩🟩🟩
@Danny Smith ruclips.net/video/zBrNyFJXrTY/видео.html
@Danny Smith where are u from
They aren't reffugees, their grandparents are
Neither do their parents.
Israel has declared independence. The Arabs attacked. Israel defeated them. They have to bear the consequences of their aggression.
Stfu
@@patriotsforisrael3610 haha love the twisted historical views. as someone once said "the best tactic is to lie and lie until you yourself believe your own lies"
I hope all of my Israeli Brothers and Sisters well from the UAE
We are well. Thank you.
We welcome the normalization treaty with your country.
All the best..
@Mohamed Mostafa Troll
@Mohamed Mostafa Prove it
@Mohamed Mostafa
How is that clear? Momo
@Mohamed Mostafa دبي
Surely the religion in the Providence of Allah is Islam. Ali 'Imran [3: 19]
Your life your choice. @נואה עבד אל רחמן5
@נואה עבד אל רחמן5 I mean it. But we are not able to convert anyone, as humans. We can just give a hand. Just like religious Jews do in New York subway for non religious Jews.... But in our faith, everyone can be welcomed.
@נואה עבד אל רחמן5 Peace 🤝
@נואה עבד אל רחמן5 Athiesm is the opposite of a belief, you can't say I follow Athiesm.
@נואה עבד אל רחמן5 lol no
"We are not refugees from 1948, but from 1967" The third time is now for some of them?
Definition of a refugee according to UNRWA - “persons whose normal place of residence was Palestine (which was ONLY a geographical region and not a sovereign state) during lst June 1946 to 15th May 1948; and who lost homes and livelihoods because of the 1948 conflict WHICH WAS STARTED BY SIX ARAB ARMIES WHO CHOSE TO ATTACK ISRAEL IN 1948.
UNRWA: “A person IS NOT A REFUGEE if he or she has acquired a new nationality” for instance, these “refugees” are citizens under the Palestinian Authority, under Hamas in Gaza, or are citizens of any country in Europe, Middle East, USA, Africa, Asia and so on…..
The greatest damage the world is doing to the Palestinians is accepting the lie about their ancient and historic homeland which never existed in any recorded history as a sovereign Palestinian state, country, or nation.
Arab refugees who escaped to the West Bank of Jordan (in reality JUDEA AND SAMARIA) and Gaza were approximately 800,000 in 1948 and 1967.
Please don’t talk about ethnic cleansing and genocide of the Arabs aka 1964 Palestinians; numbers don’t lie; people do…..
Palestinian census: 4.7 million in West Bank and Gaza ...
www.timesofisrael.com/palestinian-census- 2020
The number of Palestinians in the West Bank and Gaza Strip has risen from 2,895,683 in 1997 to 4,780,978 in 2017, the Palestinian Central Bureau of Statistics said Wednesday.
Many places in the world were just geographical regions before being colonized.
Is it possible to be a citizen of a country that does not exist?
One might well argue that Palestinians have a stronger cultural identity now than they did back in 1948. Admittedly, it is still hard to draw a distinction between them and citizens of the surrounding Arab states. The refugee status is probably the most defining national characteristic.
I don't know from where you took this info about not considered a refugee if getting nationality , but here are some quotations from the official UNRWA website!
"Today, some 5 million Palestine refugees are eligible for UNRWA services."
"More than 2 million registered Palestine refugees live in Jordan. Most Palestine refugees in Jordan, but not all, have full citizenship. "
www.unrwa.org/where-we-work/jordan
RAMALLAH, May 13 (Xinhua) -- Palestinian Central Bureau of Statistics (PCBS) Monday said in a report ahead of the 71st anniversary of the 1948 war that the number of Palestinians has increased by nine times since 1948.
Yea! 9 times!!!!
*FACTS MATTER!* ✊
The problem here is the UN has to different refugee agencies. One dealing with refugees from all over the world and another one specifically for the Palestinians.
LORD JESUS IS ETERNAL WORD OF GOD In Flesh (Isaiah 9 : 6-7) , (Micah 5 : 2) !
i don't understand , how can you be a refugee in your own land??
You can't. That is just propaganda.
they ain't living in haifa right now right?
also before israel got built, most palestinian were linked more to their own city, than their "palestinian identity"
some weren't even part of specific clan/family.
they still aspire to come back to their land they got expulsed from, those why they won't accept the nakbah, I believe you can understand that if you were expelled from your home, you would not accept it if it was because of a war. its their right to not accept it.
some did move on, but its hard for them as they are not in a recognized state (west bank) so they have no reason to remove their refugee status.(even if they do, they will still be under occupation in an unrecognized state.)
You cannot. You would be a displaced person.
However, for many years the West Bank was part of the Jordanian state and at that time a different country. The moniker stuck.
@Hispot Mesopotamia
All Jews belong in their ancestral homeland Israel.
BTW: 55% of Jews in Israel are descendants of Jews from Arab countries.
Then there are Indian Jews, Conversos from South/Central America and Ethiopian Jews.
Oh, by the by, 162 Ethiopian Jews arrived last week. ☺
@Hispot Mesopotamia
Nah.
The Jewish people are the indigenous people of the Southern Levant with a continuous presence of more than 4000 years.
The Arabs are descendants of 19th century migrants, Arabized Bedouin and European converts who were brought to the land of Israel during the Arab Conquests to populate the land.
The Arabs are the colonists.
אני לא בטוח שהייתי רוצה לגור בטיסהאוילאק או בטיאצובה. אני לא בטוח גם שהייתי אמור לדעת שגירשו את משפחתי משם
No blacksmiths, merchants, landlords among their ancestors? I think this might be why Corey pushed the farming question. If people are living in camps in Israel this is not right. I don't know the reason why some seem to live reasonably well in the West Bank and others are stuck in camps, but there should be a solution. Will the Palestinians still want all the lands back? Surely, but it doesn't mean you shouldn't take humanitarian actions and give them the best conditions you can.
YESHUA IS MESSIAH ❤️ (Isaiah 53) !
freepalestine
Arabs calling themselves by the name of Greek Philistines and claiming being native to Judea.
You can't make that shit up.
@Mohamed Mostafa they were called foreigners and semites by locals.
Should be pretty simple to deduce why. 🙄 But hey, never let that inconvenience stand in the way of your weak attempt of delegitimization.
@Mohamed Mostafa and Arab country? Which never had a sovereignty? An appointed leader? A currency? A flag?
Who are you telling these lies? Yourself? Because I'm not feeling it 🤥
Israel and Palestine are the exact same place. When the Zios invaded from Poland they did not have a name to call Palestine. All the first Zios used the historical name "Palestine". The mandate was named after Palestine because the Zios had not invented the name "Israel" yet. They did not know what to call the new state they were trying to steal from the Palestinians. They could not call Palestine by the old Roman name of "Judea" because then the local non-jews would be called "Jews". They could not call Palestine the "Land Of Zion" which would make the locals "Zionists". The Zios had no choice but to use the ahistorical term "Israel" found in Jewish mythology. Many Zios are totally unaware how the "Land Of Israel" game materialized .The Zios are clueless.
@Starhopper You are as stupid as stupid gets. All the first Zios used Palestine from Herzl to Bn Gurion. . When the Zios were having a discussion whether to build a Jewish state in Uganda, Argentina or Palestine, the ones which supported Palestine were called "paleocentric". Plus the Mandate was named after Palestine you idiot. Your "Land Of Israel" game had not been invented until the mid 1940s
My grandparents didn't survive WW2. I know next to nothing about the towns they came from in Central Europe. They lost many belongings along with their lives.
My parents and myself never considered going back to reclaim the family possessions. History has moved on but Israel-Palestine is stuck in a time-loop.
maybe give us rights and stop treating us like dogs and we'll move on?
there are filed lawsuits for returning properties to the jews. there's even consideration to demand compensation from Arab countries who expelled jews. not everything is forgiven nor forgotten. it is still on the table.
@وادي الذئاب maybe you should talk to the Palestinian authorities and Hamas
@@user-gu4tw2uf6s Nock off your cry bullying. You were created by the KGB. Palestinians are as real as Santa Claus!
@@user-gu4tw2uf6s "rights" lol
Lets not tell the westerners what your folks mean exactly by "rights".....
Or how many rights you get in the places your clans came to israel fron ;-)
"Rights" 🤣🤣🤣🤣
These are very sad stories. Now the Palestinians want to create millions of new sad stories. Let's each stay where they are and achieve peace.
And us palestinians live outside in diaspra like in jordan
The nice way of saying "I don't care what happened to You, but just deal with it and stay wherever you are now"
@@joka4387 Are you referring to what Palestinian are telling Jews when they say "go back to Europe"?
@@prinpi yes go back to Europe, there's no Hitler anymore, you guys are the only remaining Hitler in the world!!
@@prinpi No reasonable person says that and the Palestinians also didn't cause the atrocities jews faced. Imagine a German saying this to a jew.
💙🤍💙A blessed Shavuah Tov to all my Jewish sisters and brothers, and friends of Zion. 💙🤍💙
Chag Sameach ! Tu'Beshvat, the Rosh Hashana of Trees is this Thursday 🌳🌲🌴
Plant a tree in Eretz Yisroel, reclaim our ancestral homeland of Israel
@Starhopper
☺Hi back 💙🤍
@Jacob Ezra
If I was a convert to Judaism, I would be proud of it.
I would speak about it to anyone.
You are no Jew because you lack midot and a Jewish soul. Sorry 🤷♀️
@@Linda43 Shalom Linda and Star - Chag Sameach ! Tu'Beshvat - Linda I left a message for you on your page.
@@avirose194 חג שמח
@Danyal
Shalom and Shavuah Tov
LORD JESUS (YESHUA) Is The KING 👑 Of The JEWS (Isaiah 53) , (Psalms 22) and (Zechariah 12 : 10) !
Zachariah???? Didn't his name come up earlier?
Palestine will always live forever!
AM YISROEL CHAI 🌳💙LE'NETZACH
ISRAEL LIVES FOREVER FROM THE JORDAN RIVER TO THE MEDITERRANEAN SEA 💙
@@Linda43 NO Palestine does but not Israel
@Starhopper I exist idiot
@Starhopper I exist as a Palestinian
@Starhopper My blood is Palestinian
BH, The sons and daughters of Israel have returned to their ancient ancestral borders in Israel.
💙AM YISROEL CHAI LE'NETZACH
ISRAEL LIVES FOREVER FROM THE JORDAN RIVER TO THE MEDITERRANEAN SEA💙
@Mohamed Mostafa
From all places of their extended exile, the Jewish people have returned to their ancient ancestral borders in Israel. AMEN
@@Linda43 Linda why you not hate the IslamNazim
@@Linda43 you have two face
This is one reason why I support a two state confederation arrangement. These people could live in their villages or the areas where their villages used to be as residents of Israel while having Palestinian citizenship.
True, That's probably the best solution to the conflict
But currently, I don't imagine that happening
Its unrealistic.
People have established themselves in other places.
@@nouhn1878 there’s a lot of work to be done, but I’ve heard from a group of Israelis and Palestinians who are working on that.
@@Linda43 but giving Palestinians the option to live in Israel proper would go a long way to peace.
Corey Gil-Shuster. can you ask israelis. if they consider chiristians as a friends but not muslims. surah 5:51 says to muslims do not take jews and christians as friends they are [friends one to anather].
Email Corey
Who told you that Muslims aren't friends of Jews and Christians?
@@nouhn1878
Reread the post 🤦♀️
@נואה עבד אל רחמן2
I have read this same passage but the point is he isn't saying it personally. He is quoting it from its source.
@נואה עבד אל רחמן2
There are many people who are experts in Islam that are not Muslim.
The point is the quote.
hi everyone I dont use my phone sense yesterday and I saw someone writein in my account and broke it I am sorry linda and dogbert to what this person said from my account I really dont know and I think it is IslamNazim that do that we all know the dont like me and I dont like them
@Mohamed Mostafa it was me
@Mohamed Mostafa you right
@Mohamed Mostafa because she not hate IslamNazim
@Mohamed Mostafa no she not
You fool nobody Momo
I am unsinkable
Jihad under a just Imam = ONLY way. Ab-frigging-solutely no other way.
imam mahdi will come and lead muslims dont worry
trust in allah he will never let us alone
@Tamar Nelson Yes, peace, as long as you don't attack them first both verbally and physically
@Soia Isreal Allah and Elohim / Hashem is the same God, but different name, that can't be described as anything in this world, and both Muslims and Jews thought their religion are superior than the others
💙💙 עם ישראל חי לנצח 💙💙
So false everyone went voluntarily or with the promise to come back in 2 weeks
Everyone in my grandmas village was massacred and her and her siblings lived in a tend at a refugee camp separated from their parent for months. Nobody ever told them they could go back after two weeks. Her mother never left the village in the first place and got gunned down by IDF. You're literally minimizing other peoples trauma to make yourself feel better about benefiting from the human rights abuses that went down in 1948.
@Jokolo saying 'just move on' to justify the occupation means that if say North Korea occupies South Korea by wiping and kicking the south koreans, it is also justified.
You good with that?
@Jokolo go back to ukraine
Hola que tal? Los muslmanes no aceptaron la división y fueron a la guerra, la perdieron la culpa la tuvo gamal nasser . Ya no hay vuelta atras lo mismo que U.s.a. con mejico,nasser y sus antecesores como Alhusseini 😷🙋♂️
Hola senior abla english?
No abla english senior?
La división en 1948 tuvo lugar unos años antes del ascenso al poder de Nasser en Egipto. Es cierto que no aceptó la existencia del estado de Israel y amenazó al estado como lo hace hoy Irán. En aquel entonces, la situación era muy peligrosa para el joven estado.
@@marksimons8861 Hola que tal? De donde eres? 😷🙋♂️
@@jorgewolfenson2748 De Yorkshire, pero ahora vivo en Londres.
FREE PALESTINE
@Starhopper badass stupid
Freed since 1948 :)
@@mohdhazim8532 Badass doesn't mean what you think it means but the compliment is probably appreciated
Free the world from Islamic terrorism
@@adam_1144 nahhhhh...kind this matter dont drive into a joke or its just a mock...free from dajjal hanukkah
Anti-dajjal has been revealed... And claims to be refugee needing a home.
May Allah Protect us from the evil people of the trials and tribulations of dajjal.
@Yv Dnl the antichrist or dajjal
@Soia Isreal anybody can do a fake video about this.
The translators do a good job translating the answers but not the questions; you should choose an audience with a higher intellect to respond to questions like right of return and Israel apologising as a political term same as Germans apology to Israel because in the question it sound like just saying (sorry) its ridiculous translation of questions and audience.
PS: the average American can not name a country the starts with the letter U.
I saw a map of Palestine of Ptolemy there is no any village of Arabs there. Palestine has never associated with Arabs to me. I had no idea Arabs lived there.
Moshe Dayan: ""Jewish villages were built in the place of Arab villages. You do not even know the names of these Arab villages, and I do not blame you because geography books no longer exist. Not only do the books not exist, the Arab villages are not there either."
@@rolandboerhof9391 so why doesnt Palestine show any Arab villages then if they existed then?
There's no difference between nazi and zionist , change my mind ?
Why bother?
You are obviously a antisemite. So continue to wallow in your ignorance and hate.
There is a difference
@@Linda43 sorry miss I'm not a antisemite i love palestinian . search for Shulamit Aloni on "Anti-Semitism ...
@@nouhn1878 Tell me i'm waiting
@@algreen9592 You are the most anti semitic person on this thread
Understanding Israel's Nation State Law by Mitchell Bard
Jewish Virtual Library
Corey, I think I speak for everyone when I say just be safe mate. Not every Palestinian likes a camera pointed in their face
ruclips.net/video/DgFCLzGzKpA/видео.html
I think he need to be safe from these fascists...
Yeah sure, everyone was growing wheat🤣🤣🤣 on rocky hills of Jerusalem. What a bunch of lies.
We can teach you how if you want
What a banker like you knows about farming
@@Darksoil4555 Not much, just grew up in a village, work the land....you could have figure that out even from my profile avatar.
@@olegvolman4842 oleg??? Is that a scandanavian name??
I watched it till about 8:00 and it was enough for me. 1. No body of them are a refugee. A refugee is one who were expelled from his land by force. They are too young to be refugees. Their parents certainly are. In that way I'm also a refugee since my ancestors were expelled by force from their land.
2. The guy at 8:00 was asked where his parents were born and he answered - deir Rafat. He also was asked where is it and answered that it is located north of Jerusalem. Well, this village is located South-West to Jerusalem. Further more, it still exists till today and its Arab citizens still live there. They and many other Arabs were convinced by Israel in 1948 not to leave among many other Arabs who still live peacefully in their original towns and villages.
That's the reason that I stopped watching the rest of it. Enough lies for 8 minutes.
Or you got tired of hearing the truth after 8 minutes. And yes, if their parents were displaced then they most definitely suffered by being deprived of the land they would have inherited (not to mention the loss of livelihood due to their parents literally needing to rebuild their lives in a new city from the ground up).
Also this is just one generation of separation from the displaced. Don’t you know that zionists believe the land is rightfully theirs due to a displacement that occurred over 200 generations in the past? Do you think they remembered the city their ancestors grew up in let alone the geographical location? The hypocrisy is laughable man.
@@samiabe8686 I would like to tell one fact. Since the beginning of mankind there were wars. Nations appeared on history stage taking over former nations, going down after another nation came up, till the modern time.
Every time it had happened many died and many turned to be refugees. This is also the case. Now is the time of Israel. Why others and not Israel? Why USA, Russia, GB, Spain, France and many others and not Israel?
Even now days Russia took Crimea from Ukraine and wants to take over entire Ukraine.
That's the way of this world. You can calm down now.
@@simko8665 So what you are basically saying is “everyone else is committing injustices around the world and throughout history so Why Can’t Israel!!”
Well. Because they are all wrong. And were wrong in the past. The difference is we live in an age where we can stop this from occurring in its tracks. Same with Russia and Ukraine. Same with Uyghurs in China.
I know Israel just wants history to look over one last bit of colonization… but unfortunately the world gained a little more humanity by the era that they decided Palestine was theirs.
@@samiabe8686 1. Can you define please, Colonialism? 2. Who are "they decided Palestine was theirs"?
The Palis come from Palestine
The Zios come from everywhere else
@Starhopper The Zios invented you in a lab in Europe less than 100 years ago to replace the old model Jews who they despised. They were called the Yiddish speaking people and they lived in Eastern Europe. There were millions of them, 80% of world Jewry originate from the old Russian, Hungarian & Austrian empires in Eastern Europe. That is why Bibi looks like Putin. Unlike you, the Palis are like any other national group. The land is who they are, LITERALLY, which is why they are called Palestinians and not Russians, Polish, American, Moroccan, etc like your Jews. Corey did a whole bunch of videos on the ethnicities of Israel which explains the ethnic origins of your Jews. They literally come from everywhere, mainly Slavic and Germanic areas of East Europe like you . Ask your granddaddy. Read a book...... history is not your friend.
@Mohamed Mostafa Zionism is white, not "Jewish" supremacy. Defining Israeli apartheid as "Jewish supremacy" is a coup not only for Zionists, but for anti-Semites and white supremacists everywhere. Erroneously labelling of zionist white-supremacism as "Jewish supremacism" by JVP and B'Tselem puts wind in the sails of white supremacists like David Duke. The ZZZ = KKK
@Starhopper Hey Vancier wannabe.... the first Euro Zios knew that the Palis are indigenous to Palestine. They also knew that there was no exile by the Romans or Babylonians. The Polish father of the Jewish State said that the locals are the original Jews from Judea and that they never left Palestine, all they did was convert to Christianity and later Islam. That is a fact that the Zios ignore. In fact, the Zios have to ignore about 99.99% of the history of Palestine. The first Hebrew occupation of Palestine was only a minute episode in the history of a Arab country and the current Euro/Khazarian occupation does not even count. . Your history is in the Land Of The Yids and the Jews even created the POLIN Museum of the History of Polish Jews which documents over 1000 years of actual Jewish history.....unlike the fairytales the Zios regurgitate, which are only metaphors found in Jewish mythology , not anthropological history. The Zios have to use biology instead of the historical account to create a history in a test tube .......since you have no real history, not one iota, in Palestine. I bet you can't find one historical document, map or artifact which shows a geopolitical area with defined borders called the 'Land Of Israel", not one. There are countless for Palestine. History is not your friend.
@@chugalongway01
Rubbish
Professional refugees.
Corey you're biased.
Biased against what and whom?
Racist*
i just wanna know why cant isreals just say the truth
this is not their land it was palestine it is palestine it will remain palestine
simple
We do say the truth. It is our land. It always was the land of Israel, it is the land of Israel and it always wiil remain the land of Israel. Neither the Roman colonizers and their successors who stole this land from the Jewish people and sent the Jewish people into long exile, nor their historical subjects that came after can change it. It will remain the homland of the Jewish people till the end of history.
Simple.
@@rubilisof3908 i never said it’s not a land of jewish people jews lived and the have every right to keep living in it but muslims also lived in it why don’t allow them to live in it christians also lived in it why don’t you allow christmas to live in it i want all three of us to live peacefully togethet why are muslims opressed and btw jews are fine but i’m talking about isreal before 1948 it wasn’t isreal inly 6% were jews where did the others came from the people who came after 1948 should go back from where they cam from
@@mohammedrida8990 by your own analogy, the same can be said about Muslims and Christians. why not Muslims and Christians return to the places they came from? you admitted it's "a land of jewish people". thus Muslims and Christians occupying Jewish land. Jews returning to their place. not to someone else.
@@yigalgurevitch2936 can i talk to you in dm
do you have instagram
@@yigalgurevitch2936 i have soo much to say
My Grandpa Julius and his family lived in little village in Lithuania. Should I plan to move there? Nope. My parents visited my grandpa's village and my family mass grave.
@Golden Crown Exactly. Who cares? Jewish people read our ancient text, called the Tanach; in it our ancient ones shepherded, make love, argue, make-love & talk to God in ISREAL.
did someone throw you out if the village and they made you a refugee