The Chronicles of Norm #8 - The Big Engine

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 13 июл 2024
  • A Lionel TMCC S1 from the early 2000s rolls into the shop and onto the layout.
    0:00 Intro and look-over
    1:45 IR tether woes
    2:35 IR tether alignment testing
    3:36 3D printed IR tether LED housing
    4:13 Lionel second gen. Odyssey exploration
    5:00 Odyssey speed curve plotting
    5:59 eBay scope for train analysis
    7:00 CAB2 absolute speed steps
    7:50 Excel speed plots
    9:51 Loco chassis tour/more work planning
    12:06 Gearbox maintenance
    15:11 Chuff upgrade/repair
    17:16 3D printed chuff cam #1
    18:11 Final chuff cam version and chuff phasing
    19.37 Loco wiring cleanup
    23:52 Tender wiring cleanup
    26:15 Naked test run
    28:11 Tender buzz fix
    29:01 Power umbilical
    29:30 Reassembly and review
    29:52 Weigh-in
    30:04 Final test run
    34:28 3D printed ashpan screen replacements
    36:40 Final running montage
  • Авто/МотоАвто/Мото

Комментарии • 106

  • @mitchcornacchia968
    @mitchcornacchia968 2 года назад +9

    Why wouldn't the wires be nice and neat from factory? So simple to do and so much nicer , GREAT JOB!

    • @normstrains
      @normstrains  2 года назад +2

      I am probably the third owner, everything worked, just needed tidying up.

  • @Jones3DModelingClub
    @Jones3DModelingClub 2 года назад +5

    Although the PRR S1 was too big for the PPR system, it was the most exciting thing ever happened in American railroading history. Thank you for showing us your big engine!

  • @GoldStandardTrains
    @GoldStandardTrains 2 года назад +13

    I love how close the spacing is from the engine to tender on this one you got. Sets it apart from all the others just with that, let alone all the other detailing you've done. Great work, nice addition to you collection.

    • @normstrains
      @normstrains  2 года назад +1

      The previous owner put that on. It worked out nicely for my O99 curves. Don’t think I can run it any tighter.

  • @LMR78
    @LMR78 2 года назад +8

    I love the big S1 class locomotive. Especially with their dual drivers! Love the video Norm!

  • @Aatrains512
    @Aatrains512 2 года назад +4

    7:52 “i’m not trying to go off the deep end or anything”, might be a bit too late lol. Really interesting stuff though

    • @normstrains
      @normstrains  2 года назад +1

      I have since edited my TMCC speed plot report to include tabs for 128 speed steps. Couldn’t help myself! Maybe I’ll curve an EOB engine someday in all 3 modes.

  • @conrailfan6277
    @conrailfan6277 2 года назад +4

    Nice work Norm!! 3D printing has
    really opened up a whole new range
    of options for all of us Model Railroaders!!!!!

    • @normstrains
      @normstrains  2 года назад

      I love it - wish I would have got one sooner!

    • @Slideyslide
      @Slideyslide 2 года назад +1

      @@normstrains What 3D printer do you use? I would like to buy one and could use some help picking a good one.

    • @normstrains
      @normstrains  2 года назад +1

      @@Slideyslide a Creality Ender Pro 3. It's been great so far!

  • @K-Effect
    @K-Effect 2 года назад +2

    13 lbs, what a beast!

  • @Elios0000
    @Elios0000 2 года назад +7

    S1 is such a monster forget the Bigboy

  • @MetalMania3DTV-TAS-AUS
    @MetalMania3DTV-TAS-AUS 2 года назад +5

    Wow absolutely beautiful love it cheers KC Tasmania Australia 🇦🇺🇦🇺😎👍

  • @mitchcornacchia968
    @mitchcornacchia968 2 года назад +3

    BRILLIANT LAYOUT ALL MY FAVORITE LOCOS!!!!!!

  • @ajmayowskijr
    @ajmayowskijr 2 года назад +4

    Amazing engine Norm

  • @dadoodadaa6282
    @dadoodadaa6282 2 года назад +3

    Thanks Norm! Excellent video! Yes, red markers were used for standing equipment only.
    Hopefully we can stay in touch, I'm in the process of building a building for my layout, 42' X 120' and will post the progress

  • @racer248xxx
    @racer248xxx 2 года назад +3

    Love it.. that engine is huge! Was cool to see it smoking. You don’t typically have the engines smoking. Very cool

    • @normstrains
      @normstrains  2 года назад

      I meant to set up a couple of smoke 💨 shots but ran out of time. It actually works ok, but is very thirsty for smoke fluid.

    • @racer248xxx
      @racer248xxx 2 года назад

      @@normstrains I bet it is. I have often wondered why you typically don’t have your engines smoking..

  • @mitchcornacchia968
    @mitchcornacchia968 2 года назад +4

    I've got the same awesome engine thanks for the education! Great video

  • @billpope2111
    @billpope2111 2 года назад +4

    Amazing how much better the wiring looks!

  • @johncrowley3722
    @johncrowley3722 2 года назад +3

    Norm - Great Video. I am so glad bought this one off me. It couldn't have a better home. Cheers!

    • @normstrains
      @normstrains  2 года назад

      Awesome engine - I remember Dick Maddox demoing at Wild Bill’s. I said this was out around 2001 but I think it was closer to 2002-2003. 🤔

  • @ralphmiller2265
    @ralphmiller2265 2 года назад +2

    The uniqueness of your modeling is in the weathering of the locomotive and rolling stock as well as structure and the scenery detail as a whole. I wish I had your eye for this level of detail. This is the work of a real artist. Model railroading is a new art form for sure. And then beyond this, your confidence in working with the electronics in these locomotives. - WOW! I am not an electronic minded person even though I have upgraded a few locomotives from conventional to ERR, doing the two magnets on a tender wheel for the prototypical 4-chuffs per revolution., So far, this has worked since the tender wheels were a proper circumference to the drive wheels. I was always afraid to do what you did with placing the magnets on the actual drivers (which is better any way you look at it). I would like to learn John Will's system where the motor weight is taped and the chuff is read electronically. Legacy as a whole is way better than TMCC but I'm with you, some of these early TMCC models had fantastic sounds, only needing enhancement such as 4-chuffs and maybe rule-17 lighting. Again, I really appreciate your work, just wish I could match at least some of it.

  • @greyfoxtrains3244
    @greyfoxtrains3244 2 года назад +3

    Looking forward to the weathering. As always, your knowledge of these locos is great. Nice work!

  • @tony8074
    @tony8074 2 года назад +4

    As always Norm another great video. I love the scale of that locomotive, it looks impressive.

  • @brettmariotte5249
    @brettmariotte5249 2 года назад +2

    Great addition.

  • @bobdutka1176
    @bobdutka1176 2 года назад +1

    Great video Norm!!👌 Just goes to show great deals are to be found and can still be updated. Thanks for sharing.👍😁

  • @FLRailroaddog
    @FLRailroaddog 2 года назад +3

    Awesome 😎

  • @Porschedude8
    @Porschedude8 2 года назад +3

    Brilliant! 👏😏

  • @brenthopley874
    @brenthopley874 2 года назад +1

    Hi there again Norm. Thanks once again for sharing your work here on YT in this case reworking and modifying the PRR S1. Having converted many 3R locos (all diesels) and quite a number of rolling stock to 2R over the last 10 years, I've been frustrated with the lack of information/data there is on-line regarding 3R electronics. While I now have a reasonable stash of 3R wheels & couplers as a result of these conversions, I also have quite a number of CctBds of which I have little or absolutely no idea of what they are/do. At least from this video I have been able to identify some of the boards and worked out what they do.
    As most of our NZR locos are brass and white metal models "kits", the 3D printed parts such as the CCTBD mounts and cam followers you have produced has inspired me to pull out my 18 month old, as yet unused, 3D printer and start producing some bespoke mounting brackets, thanks once again for sharing your work.

  • @troystaten5633
    @troystaten5633 Год назад +1

    What a beast of a locomotive, it sure can fly. Thanks for showing us.

  • @dektold76
    @dektold76 2 года назад +1

    Nice job. Really fast locomotive!

  • @davevan8864
    @davevan8864 2 года назад +1

    I'm a conventional runner so much of your electrical stuff is above my pay grade.....but never hurts to learn!! I own a 3rd Rail S-1. She is pretty simple with a QSI board in here. But I like her and is among my favorites. My father in law's brother was in charge of the PRR S-1 display at the 1939 World's Fair......so while a S-1 is kinda over the top......I had to own one with the faimly connection!!! Thanks

    • @normstrains
      @normstrains  2 года назад +1

      I would not mind getting the unskirted S1 that 3rd Rail made!

  • @danny117hd
    @danny117hd 2 года назад +1

    I aways enjoy the 3d prints just magically appearing.

  • @timothymclaughlin6860
    @timothymclaughlin6860 2 года назад +1

    Your work is so impressive. Thanks for the peek into your shop . Absolutely beautiful engine . Looks amazing on those long straightaways .

  • @joneades1364
    @joneades1364 2 года назад +3

    19:30 We've always called those twist-ties. Nowhere near the quality of Zipties but for stuff like holding larger wires together and opened bread bags.

    • @normstrains
      @normstrains  2 года назад +1

      No haha, they were just bits of wire. I’ve done worse, especially when I really wanted to get something running. Now I’m a little more patient.

  • @CWFTrains
    @CWFTrains 2 года назад +1

    What a great look at that S1. I’d also like to say your weathering skills are top notch and your layout is fantastic!

  • @notcooper339
    @notcooper339 2 года назад +1

    The way the it looks clean and unweathered running through lived in scenery definitely fits the vibe of s1

  • @hmsjr0154
    @hmsjr0154 2 года назад +1

    Excellent work Norm!

  • @DynamicDuo795
    @DynamicDuo795 2 года назад +4

    Excellent video and engine! I have the MTH Premier version in PS3. I'm thinking about looking for the newer Legacy version that came out recently. Glad you found one and picked it up. It's a massive steam engine.

  • @eagleroute3241
    @eagleroute3241 2 года назад +1

    Excellent engine for your collection, good topic on going over a pre bought model/cleaning also. Also love how you add to you collect of Pennsy engines of the time era. I pretty much do the same as for as engine collections that I model. Looking forward to up-and-coming video's

  • @UlyssesGrant1869
    @UlyssesGrant1869 Год назад +2

    Looks awesome 😎👍

  • @Winworld6
    @Winworld6 Год назад +1

    Beautiful Train
    Train Engine Beautiful
    Very Glamorous Engine

  • @nate7046
    @nate7046 2 года назад +4

    I have one of these and have a stock draw bar but, the guy before ran it on to tight of cures and bend the draw bar all up and it’s got ir tether problems too seems to be kinda common for these

  • @KPen3750
    @KPen3750 2 года назад +1

    Now you own the longest engine ever, coupler to coupler. No engine could match the S1 for length

  • @blairterry9435
    @blairterry9435 2 года назад +1

    Not bad Norm! I wish I had an S1.

  • @sergeselr1687
    @sergeselr1687 Год назад +2

    Great videos Norm We can learn a lot. Im Steve from the club

  • @Geo3Rail
    @Geo3Rail 2 года назад +1

    Every video a master class 😔👏🏻

  • @mitchcornacchia968
    @mitchcornacchia968 2 года назад +2

    GENIUS!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • @railchief74
    @railchief74 2 года назад +2

    I wish my layout looked as realistic as yours norm

  • @gusshadleythelunaticfromar7125
    @gusshadleythelunaticfromar7125 2 года назад +1

    Norm, this is funny, iam watching this while iam Running Lionel Nation on the DVD, your in both places.lol. nice engine.

  • @jasonanderson6583
    @jasonanderson6583 Месяц назад +1

    Cleanest of the fleet lol

  • @EtonieE25
    @EtonieE25 7 месяцев назад +1

    Norm that baby cost more then my car man 😳🤣
    Love it tho 👍

  • @northpennvalleysteamrailroad
    @northpennvalleysteamrailroad 2 года назад +9

    Hi Norm! Excellent engine!! Are you going to do a full video of the S1 being weather or are they going to be separate videos?

    • @normstrains
      @normstrains  2 года назад +10

      I did not film the weathering on this one! This was supposed to be a quick project and vid, but as usual I wandered down into a couple rabbit holes. I am hoping to find a classier passenger set for it at York.

    • @lambertotimoteojuarezlopez2220
      @lambertotimoteojuarezlopez2220 Год назад

      Lá0

    • @PedroDiaz-ki6ti
      @PedroDiaz-ki6ti Год назад

      ​@@normstrains b😢 hola cariño: 66🎉 😅

  • @sbrunner69
    @sbrunner69 Год назад

    Norm is the Steve MRE of model trains.

  • @patstrains7185
    @patstrains7185 2 года назад +3

    Hey Norm
    I have the same engine, so I’d be interested in the chuff fix.
    Also look for a video on the buildings and sidewalks I’ve been printing on my channel. If you are looking for a good large format printer (400x400x400), look at eBay, they have returned Anycubic Chiron for $219 with free shipping. They need a little love but work very well. I have 2 now, I also got a CR10 S5 on the way, a massive 500x500x500.

    • @normstrains
      @normstrains  2 года назад +1

      I really want a printer with finer resolution. When I made those frames for the ash pan vents, it took a couple tries to get the horizontal strip to stand out clean. Right now, the Ender is working great for my purposes.

    • @patstrains7185
      @patstrains7185 2 года назад

      @@normstrains Then you want a resin printer. I printed out a PRR doghouse for my N3s. It’s a 3rd rail N1 s with a H class tender I got for like $350. Now that I have a 3rd rail N1s that’s correct, I’m making my own sub class. I wish I could find a N2sa though…..

    • @Slideyslide
      @Slideyslide 2 года назад +1

      @@patstrains7185 What printer would you recommend for somebody who wants to make detailed buildings and parts for model railroading?

    • @patstrains7185
      @patstrains7185 2 года назад +1

      @@Slideyslide The SLA or liquid resin has the most detail, but you are limited by print size and post processing is a pain. Also messy.
      A good FDM (filament) will give you larger print volume and less messy, but you will see layer lines. Not a big deal though and if you paint them, using a filler primer will do a good job too.

  • @Mr.Funk92
    @Mr.Funk92 2 года назад +1

    Love the results! I wish Lionel would go back to a warm light for there headlight. Not a fan of the modern “white” leds.

  • @3dartistguy
    @3dartistguy Год назад +1

    bEAUTIFUL ENGINE!

  • @huntercoleman460
    @huntercoleman460 Год назад +1

    Nice engine Norm. Who’d say makes the best O scale figures? I’d say Woodland Scenics.

  • @kevinoconnor4502
    @kevinoconnor4502 2 года назад +1

    Hi Norm, any chance you will post a vid of how you paint these prepainted models, do you ever dabble in 2-rail O? any projects? pretty much everything you've done here is so over the top of anything I've seen, your work is beautiful and certainly sets the bar in so many areas.

    • @normstrains
      @normstrains  2 года назад

      Thanks for the kind words Kevin. I've covered a bit of locomotive weathering in some of my vids. Never really messed around with 2 rail O scale.

  • @durgaprasadprasad5327
    @durgaprasadprasad5327 Год назад +1

    Mall gaadi ka enjan hai very nice

  • @ConnecticutRailFilms
    @ConnecticutRailFilms 2 года назад

    Great job once again Norm! If you don’t mind me asking do you have a file for the 3D printed chuff switch? I would like to upgrade my 4-8-2’s two chuff to a four chuff but I’m not sure of the dimensions. Any help is greatly appreciated!

  • @texaseagletrains
    @texaseagletrains 2 года назад +1

    Awesome video! You make the insides make sense to me. Can you do a chuff cam for a JLC UP 4-12-2 to do 6 chuffs?

    • @normstrains
      @normstrains  2 года назад

      I don’t see why not. I think it doesn’t trigger evenly from what I’ve heard. Might be better to trigger with my magnetic chuff cam like I used in my Q2 project. I just used the full version in my M1b: ogrforum.ogaugerr.com/topic/3d-printed-chuff-magnet-cam-my-first-foray-into-3d-printing?reply=161208612986232920#161208612986232920

  • @BLWorks1982
    @BLWorks1982 Год назад +1

    Question. Are these sound upgrades fair simple to do? I have two Williams brass engines I’d like to do something similar to.

    • @normstrains
      @normstrains  Год назад

      I would recommend looking into Electric RR products if you want to go with TMCC. Lionel just stopped selling most of their OEM TMCC parts just a couple weeks ago.

  • @Deritsuku2010
    @Deritsuku2010 2 года назад +1

    Ok, serious question: How in the world does your equipment looks so proportional? Do you do conversion kits? Every time I look up O scale trains, they look way out of proportions unless I look at the layouts from the UK or Europe

    • @normstrains
      @normstrains  2 года назад

      I only run scale equipment if that’s what you mean. I still have to modify some of it for proper ride height and closer coupling on occasion.

    • @Deritsuku2010
      @Deritsuku2010 2 года назад

      @@normstrains I know this sounds a silly question, but which companies do the scale equipment?

    • @normstrains
      @normstrains  2 года назад +1

      @@Deritsuku2010 they all do really. You just have to be selective. Many decent scale models have been built in 3 rail in the past 20 years.

  • @skiiipawbs
    @skiiipawbs 2 года назад +2

    Question norm, does the diameter/ radius for the chuff cam vary by locomotive? Or does it not matter? Also, where might I be able to find a chuff cam to upgrade chuffs? Thingaverse?

    • @normstrains
      @normstrains  2 года назад +1

      The most important thing about the cam size is that it has to be large enough diagonally to actuate the microswitch and also fit inside the space allocated for it in the frame. I can share the simple design on Tinkercad if you want to check it out. Maybe I should get a Thingiverse account. 🤔 The Tinkercad sharing is nice if you want to tweak the design if you have your own printer.

    • @skiiipawbs
      @skiiipawbs 2 года назад

      @@normstrains That would be cool. I’m looking at a Union Pacific y-3 and I was told it has a chuff cam with switch. Im not exactly sure how wide it is, but assuming it’s too wide latitudinally, I might just be able to file it down just a bit, to fit the frames edges. Also where might I find the design on tinkercad

    • @normstrains
      @normstrains  2 года назад

      @@skiiipawbs try this: www.tinkercad.com/things/0EgesCKY6m6

    • @skiiipawbs
      @skiiipawbs 2 года назад +1

      @@normstrains thanks so much! Do you think 00-80 screws would work?

    • @normstrains
      @normstrains  2 года назад

      @@skiiipawbs yes, or 1.4mm. Also could be CAed together

  • @ryantaylor3278
    @ryantaylor3278 Год назад +1

    What was your method for the weathering? Dry brushing? Airbrush?

    • @normstrains
      @normstrains  Год назад

      A little bit of both - I tried to do a mild job on this one. There are a few photos of the real thing showing a respectable coat of grime.

  • @dadoodadaa6282
    @dadoodadaa6282 2 года назад +1

    Oh...by the way, that small scope is badass!! I've got an old dual trace scope I usually use, but it's a big bulky rascal! Kinda a pain to use
    Where'd you get that one? Wouldn't mind having one.

    • @normstrains
      @normstrains  2 года назад +1

      eBay, usually sold under different names. I would love a bench scope but this one has been ok, just heed my warning about the input voltage!

    • @dadoodadaa6282
      @dadoodadaa6282 2 года назад

      Oh yeah! I Heard that on the input voltage ⚡

  • @ThunderboltSirenStudios
    @ThunderboltSirenStudios Год назад

    Though being 13% more powerful than big boy, would 6100 beat 4014 in a tug of war?

  • @Nathan93Baker
    @Nathan93Baker 2 года назад +1

    It has a whistle on top?

    • @normstrains
      @normstrains  2 года назад

      No just a group of pop valves.

  • @markkessler3863
    @markkessler3863 2 года назад

    Love all your videos. I was a three rail o scale hobbyist. I have a reading rs3 weaver engine for sale if your interested. I was thinking for $125

  • @rysiekwisniewski2550
    @rysiekwisniewski2550 Год назад +1

    Parowy pocisk rakietowy na torach. Nie,mylić z Rakietą G. Stephensona.

  • @sarojkumarnandagoswami7603
    @sarojkumarnandagoswami7603 Год назад +1

    অপরিয়াপ্ত। টাকার। আগমন। লক্ষ্য। করা। যায়। ,চলার। পথকে। খুবই। সহজ। ও। সরল। করা। বিশেষ। প্রয়োজন ।