Matt Wenning Comparing Different Squat Techniques

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 26 дек 2024

Комментарии • 100

  • @reignconsumer
    @reignconsumer 2 года назад +25

    When I first started squating for strength I used squat shoes and let my knees travel way past my toes. It was easy right away and I was able to make solid progress. Within a year, I could not squat due to knee pain. I could not even walk up a flight of stairs without being in immense pain. So much pain I didn't even want to train the squat anymore. After watching Wennings content I realized where I missed up. I started opening my hips or "taint" and sitting way back while keeping a vertical shin angle with flat shoes. Since then I've had no knee pain. Not sure if he'll ever see this, but Matt Wenning you kept me from quiting lifting. Listen to this man, he's been around long before all of us and will still be around long after we're all gone.

  • @derekwinkler7414
    @derekwinkler7414 2 года назад +19

    I’ve tried the KneesOverToes concept. It most definitely works. Also took ideas from Matt Wenning. I really truly believe. Many variations is the key. Take ideas from all of the very best. In this respective space.

  • @MousyBScrappin
    @MousyBScrappin 2 года назад +34

    Love them giving polite clarification on Ben’s stuff and not just letting that slide. Not that Wenning is necessarily incorrect but that he was unintentionally misrepresenting someone else & the convo was better for it being corrected. This is way too rare in these spaces. And this is what I wanted to see when CWS & Wenning sat down way back when but alas… anyways good stuff from Wenning, good stuff from y’all

  • @loganyates2553
    @loganyates2553 2 года назад +3

    I appreciate this clip a lot. Very professional. No unnecessary digging on either side. Opinions were addressed on both sides, challenged, and resolved very well. Great episode.

  • @godzeus777
    @godzeus777 2 года назад +3

    I love listening to these different perspectives. I see both sides and I like to have a one on one with both explaining their point more. Also the emphasis on body type and how to incorporate both styles. Huge fan of your podcast. Thanks 👍 for the great content as always.

  • @bgl500
    @bgl500 2 года назад +7

    What I appreciate the most about Mark's podcast is that he's really open-minded when it comes to training and nutrition. You've got to have an open mind to keep learning and growing in the gym and life. Cheers

  • @Mimsie
    @Mimsie 2 года назад +9

    Doing ATG movements has improved my deadlift, squat, press and bench. Has increased my ROM in my hamstrings and quads.
    1.Pepper in some of the movements
    2. Train them for strength
    3. Profit?

  • @marshallore6869
    @marshallore6869 4 месяца назад +1

    Squatting wider uses more muscles, more hamstring, more adductor etc, plus less ROM, more stretch reflex at the bottom, etc, etc

  • @johnbackos5192
    @johnbackos5192 9 месяцев назад +1

    People are built differently. I like the way Coan says it - if you’re getting stronger, not getting hurt, it’s ok.

  • @joshthiermann3989
    @joshthiermann3989 2 года назад

    Fantastic conversation gents this was great to listen to

  • @rayrod4218
    @rayrod4218 2 года назад +20

    If you want to squat to just move weight, follow what this guy says, If you play football & run track for example, you need to have your knee over toe. Ben Patrick emphasizes more for sports performance rather than just moving a barbell with weight.
    your welcome.

    • @kevivarma2759
      @kevivarma2759 2 года назад +7

      Huge difference between picking up a weight and playing an explosive sport

    • @rayrod4218
      @rayrod4218 2 года назад +3

      @@kevivarma2759 100%

    • @rayrod4218
      @rayrod4218 2 года назад +1

      @@kevivarma2759 I would like to add, if Sam Darnold were too execute the movement this man is explaining coming off the line instead of K.O.T, he'd get pancaked by the O-Line man everytime, running backs going through holes would be leveled off there feet. I believe that box squatting has benefits for sports performance because it provides safety to execute a heavy movement and or it's a good cue for breaking 90% to pop back up instead of having to go lower when not neccessary.

    • @CrashMetaReligion1996
      @CrashMetaReligion1996 2 года назад +5

      They both transition to sport. The ways that Louie trained athletes worked extremely well. Hell Ben Patrick got a lot of his ideas from Louie Simmons he even admits that. There is more then one way to skin a cat and at the end of the day it’s just up to the athlete to choose what works best for them. Yes you need strong ass quads for athletics nobody doubts that. However squatting knees over toes you are going to risk a lot of wear a fear on your knees. You also neglect your hamstrings and glutes. You need strong hips and hamstrings for sports too. Matt was an extremely explosive lifter and almost every Westside guy or even guys who squatted in a similar way like Dr Squat were extremely explosive. I think it’s extremely short sighted to act as if the way Matt trains doesn’t work for athletes is not true at all. He has trained plenty of athletes and military guys with great results. Both of them are intelligent in their training approach. It’s just different in some ways.

    • @rayrod4218
      @rayrod4218 2 года назад

      @@CrashMetaReligion1996 you 100% right but what your missing to understand is that barbell bell squatting has different emphasizes in sports, there are different exercise that are used to specifically target the hamstrings in sports performance. When you squat 1k on your back, yes I would recommend this gentleman because hes an expert in executing a single movement in (competition) one time. Ben teaches how to execute movements multiple times, in multiple angles because sports is not 1rm single or a linear sport. also, having strong quads in football doesn't mean anything if you cant use them. lastly, try the shin angel method that hes talking about against any defensive line man and I promise hell knock you over with out any effort or even ask your gym buddy, all he has todo, is push forehead and you fall back

  • @tommyAndechs
    @tommyAndechs 2 года назад +25

    Some need to squat toes forward, some need to squat toes out, some need to stop around paralles, some need to squat really deep, some need to squat really wide. Some coache sunderstand squat depth and technique are based on an individuals anatomy, mobilit, injury, history and goals. Matt Wenning is not one oft hem. Good coaches don´t make statements that everyone should squat the same way because some simply can´t and shouldn´t attempt to. Good coaches understand how to analyze those factors to find the best squat for the individual while alos giving them tools to work on to enhance their lifts and find whats most optimal in the long run. This dude sitll believe that there is one size fits all, shins straight, over arched back and so on. Embarassing in the year of 2022

    • @shub9008
      @shub9008 2 года назад +10

      agree. I asked about his opinion on kneesovertoesguy and he blocked me like a little kid. on the other side he claims he hast no followers which obviously is no wonder

    • @SXLLXNBXE
      @SXLLXNBXE 2 года назад +3

      @@shub9008 stop power fantasising that knee guy

    • @Necrofinowa
      @Necrofinowa 2 месяца назад

      This is the truth. NASM actually let this guy do a lecture and he just wouldn't shut up about the straight shin thing. It was embarrassing for the sport

  • @Ethan_la
    @Ethan_la 2 года назад +6

    Hate how this guy just puts down Ben Patrick. He doesn’t understand that they both have different goals. A majority of people don’t care about lifting a ton on a barbell. He didn’t even do any research on KOT and starts saying you shouldn’t train that way, like WTF. I bet Ben would destroy all those squat variations this guy is talking about.

  • @DrDeusExMachina
    @DrDeusExMachina Год назад +2

    The reason why a low bar squat is a more powerful position than a back squat in the Amount of weight that can be moved has to do with leverages. If you’re a power lifter that’s what you care about: pure numbers.
    If you want to strength quads preferentially then it absolutely makes sense to have a larger lever occurring at the knee.

  • @TheBaitShopGuy
    @TheBaitShopGuy 2 года назад +6

    Those look like two cans of beer Wenning is drinking

    • @Yeomannn
      @Yeomannn 2 года назад

      Does he claim to not drink?

    • @IsaacMorgan98
      @IsaacMorgan98 2 года назад +1

      it's water haha, look up "liquid death".

    • @MattFlyFisher
      @MattFlyFisher 10 месяцев назад

      Mountain water from the Alps. It murders thirst💪🏽🔥💯

  • @chriscota1635
    @chriscota1635 Год назад +1

    I like Matt and Ben. But when I was in high school football I was told to avoid letting my knees go over toes. I’m not really built for low bar as I have a relatively long torso. Last 6 or 7 years I do allow more knee travel and have solid quads. Sitting back in the squat is a way to build a massive squat but my heaviest are with a mid bar, mid foot width and some knee travel. It’s not as upright as Olympic style but not bent over as power lifting. The truth is you will get strong in The position you train. If you are a powerlifter then the most weight is what matters. Otherwise balance is key lol

  • @tooxtalivai0690
    @tooxtalivai0690 2 года назад +5

    These are the videos that should be getting the views and going viral not the steroid ones it’s crazy.

  • @zachroberts6180
    @zachroberts6180 2 года назад +4

    I have a tighter squat stance with knees over toes a bit but In the same session I’m doing wide stance box squats and hitting the ham/glutes and then doing single leg lunges to focus on that knee strength. It’s worked really well for me but as Mark tends to suggest, ill throw some
    Alternative secondary leg workouts to keep athleticism on point.

  • @derekwinkler7414
    @derekwinkler7414 2 года назад +3

    I think just like anything else. The truth lyes somewhere in the middle. From what I gather from all of this. Is do many variations of it all. Kinda like what Bruce Lee said. Be #Formless. Not stuck to one idea basically. I respect the heck out of all these guy’s opinions.

  • @EpictheEpicest
    @EpictheEpicest Год назад +4

    It frustrates me when they talk about style without addressing bone structure. Someone with very long legs may not be able to squat with anything close to vertical shins. Someone with forward facing hip sockets won't be able to push their knees out to the side. I would never propose to tell Matt Wenning how to squat, but not everyone should squat like Matt Wenning.

    • @Necrofinowa
      @Necrofinowa 2 месяца назад +1

      Correct yet Wenning keeps insisting his way is right regardless or femur length. If you have longer femurs and you squat with straight shins, your ass will be so far behind you that you'll just fall backwards.

  • @Ello769
    @Ello769 2 года назад +21

    Most power lifters come off as Aholes. He's criticizing Ben Patrick as if he's a meat head power lifter trying to break records. I will like to see him dunk a basketball. He looks like a competitive eater year round, not athletic at all

    • @PETAGRIFFIN27187
      @PETAGRIFFIN27187 2 года назад

      Competitive eaters are actually thin. Look at joey chestnut, kobiashi.. good point, bad analogy

    • @allenhu1763
      @allenhu1763 2 года назад +8

      he bashes those “athletes” then complaint that nobody is support his channel w without himself can barely moves. Those powerlifter are so caught up with the idea of strong without realising powerlifitng is not even a sport.

    • @cheeks138
      @cheeks138 2 года назад +3

      @@allenhu1763 so true

    • @godzeus777
      @godzeus777 2 года назад +1

      It is not criticism, it is his opinion. Ben cannot achieve records Matt's squad records. No need to compare and try to understand different perspectives. Also extremely different body types. We are different people.

    • @YouJustAintHearinMe
      @YouJustAintHearinMe Год назад

      I would actually like to take a stab at competitive eating. Lol.
      Breakfast would be my food of choice 😋

  • @nikdat
    @nikdat 2 года назад +5

    Ben Patrick does not train for size nor squatting but numbers. By this guys argument, why can’t he dunk like Ben?

    • @CrashMetaReligion1996
      @CrashMetaReligion1996 2 года назад +1

      He weighs like 260 pounds. But he is almost certainly more explosive then Ben.

    • @footba11fan41ife
      @footba11fan41ife 2 года назад +1

      Idk Louie Simmons produced some crazy explosive big guys. Dave Tate another big guy Louie trained could jump and touch 11’6 I believe he squatted 900+. Wouldn’t be suprised if this guy could dunk back when he was in his prime

    • @keisi1574
      @keisi1574 2 месяца назад +1

      ​@@CrashMetaReligion1996He's more explosive on the toilet- shooting out his performance enhancing drugs. 🤪

  • @jacali2737
    @jacali2737 2 года назад +4

    I appreciate this video. I’m rehabbing my legs after severe injuries. I had a goal of being able to ATG squat.
    I started with “box squats” into my chair. I did that for 6 months controlling the eccentric tension. Then I removed the chair & started pausing at the bottom ie at 90 degrees.
    Not long after I started to be able to ATG squat! I love working both ATG squats & horse stance. They are both awesome.

  • @MrBroKid
    @MrBroKid 2 года назад +4

    strong knee tendons with knee over toes

  • @MattFlyFisher
    @MattFlyFisher 10 месяцев назад

    I follow Wenning and ATG guy thoroughly. I bet if Matt sat down with the dude he would think his style is legit. But i absolutely agree with matt as far as the need for variation. Theyre both blessings to the fitness world. PERIOD

  • @vancemcnulty8242
    @vancemcnulty8242 Год назад +1

    Comparing Wenning and Ben's squat technique is the apples vs oranges comparison. Wenning's technique is specific for maximal weight to be lifted, I mean he's a world class powerlifter for a reason. Ben's ATG technique is specific for knee function as it pertains to improving the jumping movement pattern, because he cares about dunking a basketball.

    • @TheChosenOne2023
      @TheChosenOne2023 Год назад +1

      I think Wenning's Vertical Shank style is also if not more about keeping the longevity of your knee to beable to squat overtime with no injuries as opposed to knee over toes which can most definitely cause knee pain and injuries, One of my favorite quotes from Matt is "Whoever lifts the longest gets the strongest"

    • @Necrofinowa
      @Necrofinowa 2 месяца назад

      It is apples to oranges yet Wenning won't acknowledge the oranges and keeps insisting it's all apples.

  • @psychospexss
    @psychospexss 2 года назад

    Good topic

  • @kevivarma2759
    @kevivarma2759 2 года назад

    Jeffrey Wolf aka the Flexibull is going to have a field day with this one

  • @DrDeusExMachina
    @DrDeusExMachina Год назад +6

    Why does Tom Platz have bigger quads than Matt nobody is the better question
    Him bragging about his thigh size while he has 40% body fat is fucking hilarious.

  • @zenmindgreenthumbful
    @zenmindgreenthumbful 2 года назад +11

    Matt Wenning is a dinosaur stuck in 2006

    • @jerroldhyman1337
      @jerroldhyman1337 2 года назад +4

      Please, explain how that claim holds water?

    • @mac5917
      @mac5917 7 месяцев назад +1

      A strong, injury free dinosaur 😂

  • @s.woberts6576
    @s.woberts6576 2 года назад +6

    This guy admittedly says he hasn't done much research into Ben Patrick, yet has very strong opinions of him. That's the definition of ignorance.

  • @anthonymagnotta3428
    @anthonymagnotta3428 Год назад +1

    Here’s the thing
    Matt Wenning and Ben Patrick are both correct.
    Just do both…

  • @TheBaitShopGuy
    @TheBaitShopGuy 2 года назад +1

    Box Squats 4Life!

  • @briefcasemanx
    @briefcasemanx 2 месяца назад

    Kneesovertoes is about building stronger joints and connective tissue, its not a protocol yo lift the most weight possible. Its not a powerlifting thing. Trying to critique it through a powerlifting lens makes no sense.

  • @user-fb9pp6nz1v
    @user-fb9pp6nz1v 6 месяцев назад

    Why are they standing

  • @rupakshk
    @rupakshk 2 года назад +17

    guys, this guy is for behind. don´t make the mistake and sign up for his patreon. you will get nothing

    • @shub9008
      @shub9008 2 года назад +8

      agree 100%, not worth a penny

    • @jerroldhyman1337
      @jerroldhyman1337 2 года назад +1

      Please articulate what you're trying to say here...it is unclear...thanks.

  • @connellmacquisten6631
    @connellmacquisten6631 2 года назад +4

    He has solid points but using Ben Patrick (who I don't particularly like) as an example by saying he hasn't got big legs compared to him is silly. Ben Patrick' goals are v different. He also don't take steroids, or if he does, he needs a refund and he likely doesn't eat a great deal and has never truly 'bulked'.
    I prefer Matt Wenning and Matt Wenning has far better content than ATG imo.

    • @Necrofinowa
      @Necrofinowa 2 месяца назад +1

      You must not be familiar with Wenning. This is a guy who compares himself to non-roid lifters and feels good about it.

  • @reallymakesyouthink
    @reallymakesyouthink Месяц назад

    Matt uses hamstring and glutes to avoid going knees over toes.
    Ben uses hamstring and glutes to absorb force as he goes knees over toes.
    I'm not sure Matt really gets what Ben's goal is. Its not high level powerlifting.

  • @danielcartwright8868
    @danielcartwright8868 Год назад +2

    He's not thinking this through. Of course people who squat knees over toes will end up with knee pain if they HAVEN'T STRENGTHENER THEIR KNEES IN THOSE POSITIONS, whch is what Ben's training is all about!

  • @tooxtalivai0690
    @tooxtalivai0690 2 года назад

    Pushing weight v sport’s performance how about implementing both. Or do we choose one over another and become biased, you pigeon hole yourself just saying.

  • @mateogodeaux1556
    @mateogodeaux1556 Год назад +1

    Louie Simmons said close squat will do nothing for wide but wide squat will help your close squat

  • @emZee1994
    @emZee1994 2 года назад +36

    L take. Possibly the worst possible opinion on the matter. And saying Ben Patrick has small legs and trying to put him down was very slimy of him

    • @johnsambo9379
      @johnsambo9379 Год назад

      @emZee1994 What the fuck have you done again? Oh nothing. Lol

    • @johnsambo9379
      @johnsambo9379 Год назад

      @Whyohwhyno They are everywhere. Are you lying or stupid? Tons of professional and Olympic lifters have knee and back problems.

    • @firaselachkar4159
      @firaselachkar4159 6 месяцев назад +3

      It's this type of shit that hinders Matt's prominence. He's just so fucking slimy sometimes.

    • @Swoooooooon
      @Swoooooooon 5 месяцев назад +1

      Hard disagree. Ben Patrick DOES have small legs, he's not exceptionally strong and his methods are not special, but for some reason he's still glazed hard by the fitness industry. It's refreshing to hear Matt call a duck a duck when nobody else wants to.

    • @dritanvarfi5274
      @dritanvarfi5274 5 месяцев назад

      Matt is plainly being humble in his opinion...don't think he is purposely abasing anyone.

  • @519blackpanther
    @519blackpanther 2 года назад

    Love this channel ......until they hit you with the ads. Wtf bro?

    • @christofferuden7680
      @christofferuden7680 2 года назад +2

      how do you expect this show to continue without some sort of monetary support?

  • @allenhu1763
    @allenhu1763 2 года назад +1

    I remember when people aksed Matts opinion about carnivore diet,he replied never seen any carnivore benched over 500. With that being said,Matts diet is pure shit because we never seen any vertical diet people dunk from free throw line or play in NBA or is the Highest level of athlete. LMAO. He is so into powerlifting lol.

    • @benjaminshoultz9657
      @benjaminshoultz9657 2 года назад

      To be fair, diet and nutrition is talked about more with power lifters. The two questions people ask are "what's your program?" and "what's your diet?"
      Nutrition isn't as visible in basketball. Everybody knows that Larry Bird shot 100 free throws after practice and that Kobe Bryant practiced 4 hours more than everyone else. But no one was asking what they ate.
      The most visible nutrition person I can think of in sports is Tom Brady. The main idea around his diet is to be antiinflammatory, which is a big component of vertical diet.

  • @kevin-ep3bp
    @kevin-ep3bp 4 месяца назад

    Ego is a bit much 😮 it's always I or I'm. I'm noticing, and I have heard matt say he has never had injuries repeatedly yet he says both his legs were broke, anyway how is occasional like every 6 weeks a balance doesn't seem like a balance to me, I don't think ben favours anything I think he says not to ignore things 🤔

  • @ajthefitnessgod9636
    @ajthefitnessgod9636 2 года назад

    I kinda agree with matt

  • @K4R3N
    @K4R3N 7 месяцев назад

    Yeah but Ben can dunk, Wenning will never dunk.

  • @keithnone6860
    @keithnone6860 2 года назад

    Very deceptive box squat. Box squats will defentely wean people off squats and lunges like nicorete gum!! Lool. I'm sticking with squats

  • @keithnone6860
    @keithnone6860 2 года назад

    Get analytical with it sound like an over educated devil. But I'm not falling for it!!! Loool

  • @YouJustAintHearinMe
    @YouJustAintHearinMe Год назад +3

    I understand being open minded about different training styles. Is Ben Patrick sponsoring this podcast? Give me a break. All of his followers, more power to you. Commercial gyms are overcrowded with this type of stigma. I'll stick with Matt Wenning and Dave Tate for my training direction. Kudos Matt. I have always been a fan of Mark Bell as well. This other guy,....pfff, go lift at Bally's with all the other douchebags.

    • @AM-dd6gk
      @AM-dd6gk Год назад

      Agreed! I'm a huge Wenning fan. His perspective on squating made me realize how weak my hamstrings were/are by widening my squat stance. It's a rough transition, but the proof is in the pudding...all of these guys you see squating a 1000+ lbs have vertical shins.

  • @axleochidae2853
    @axleochidae2853 Год назад +1

    Matt is correct, hip dominant squatting recruits far more muscle (front to back). Knee dominant squatting is ONLY optimal for long torso/ short legged lifters. You must learn basic physics to understand what Matt is saying. Gents, your hips are far far more explosive and powerful than your legs. Just watch how the NFL guys perform the vertical jump in the Combine- you will never see them load into their knees with torso upright (like a high bar knee dominant squat).....Rather they always load their hips back like a low bar squat (with just a little shin lean). These are the best athletes on earth- so if you don't see this pattern you are not understanding athletic power. Also, "Power Lifting" is a misnomer- Olympic lifters generate far more 'power' with less weight due to the explosive nature of the lifts. If you don't believe it- pull out a physics book and study the equations of: Work, Energy, and Power, then apply them to the barbell (heavy squat / deadlift vs clean/ snatch). You will be shocked how much more powerful the Olympic lifts are.
    If you want the quick and dirty explanation- look up the 'Force vs Velocity curve' and locate 1RM squatting vs cleans.
    Note: Power = Force (times) Velocity

    • @Necrofinowa
      @Necrofinowa 2 месяца назад

      Bahaha buddy you have walked yourself in a hundred circles here. How would knees forward be for someone with short femurs? They can squat however they want because they have the shortest lever arm. Someone with long femurs needs to be pitched forward more to offset how far back their ass will be because the femur is so long.
      Honestly where do you make this stuff up?

  • @nikdat
    @nikdat 2 года назад +7

    Ben Patrick does not train for size nor squatting big numbers. By this guys argument, why can’t he dunk like Ben?