AHHH I AM HYPERVENTILATINNGG! It me! I'm the subscriber! We honestly just moved out of the house, but I would be happy to answer any questions I can if anyone has any. I was super well researched on the case before we moved in, we had some creepy coincidences with moving in, and then chatting to people in the area who were close to the case and knew the Birnies. It's a super wild ride of a case and Kate Moir has got the be the most INCREDIBLE woman, I am in such awe of her strength and courage.
@@talulahsafir honestly it was a really peaceful house! the owner has done renovations and kept its little 1950's cottage integrity. I loved the house so so much. Only occasionally freaked myself out!
@@cokecinderella5520 no, actually! My partner got a job 3.5 hours away and I was devastated to move. I get super attached to properties and it was my very first rental, such an emotional time haha!
Was it ever weird knowing that such awful things happened in any given room you’d walk into? Too bad everyone in the town would know the house’s history, that would be a hell of a story to tell guests! It’s so surprising that a place where such awful things happened could be so calm and charming in modern day. It’s funny how different maintenance can really make or break places like these, while the Moorhouse seems to be well maintained and anyone who didn’t know its history would be oblivious, places like Keddie Cabin are so decrepit and creepy, giving off a vibe as ominous as the events that once happened within its walls.
The police in Australia are like that. The female officers tend to be much better, but the male officers 9/10 are absolute pigs who don't believe sexual assault victims and accuse every woman of 'wanting attention'.
One of the first things my mother ever taught me: (due to the events that have happened to her) to *NEVER TRUST A WOMAN EITHER!* "Stranger danger" does NOT just apply to men. Always be aware.
Oh definitely, hell no do not trust a strange woman either. They could be working for someone else or themselves, they could be doing this out of coercion or fear or just plain being evil themselves. The end result is the same.
Look on RUclips for "The Flypaper" (tv show called Tales of the Unexpected) Man uses a woman to attract victims because the woman could gain the trust of the victim.
My husband asked why I watched videos about murders and crime so I let the video run while he was in the room and he listened to the whole thing, kept asking questions, and now we are on a binge haha great job!
That poor girl, running for her life naked, no one helping. Then the police ignoring her story! Thank god for her and that police officer, they would have kept on killing. I wonder what happened to the 7 kids she had. Imagine knowing your mother is a killer. You pronounced things very well. Well done!
Her eldest son was hit by a car and died as a young child. The other 6 were left with their father ( her first husband, Donald Mclaughlin) when she ran off with David. I never usually think a mother is doing her children a favor by abandoning them, but I think Catherine definitely gave them an advantage by doing that in this case. I wonder where they are now.
@@clod148 Oh man, that's so true, as fucked up as it sounds... But hey, this whole thing is pretty fucked up, so yeah, I think they lucked out by being abandoned by her, they dodged a bullet there.
Because it could have easily been a trap. Those who blindly trust are the biggest targets. I would have definitely called the police and told her to hid in the bushes or something, but I wouldn't have let her in on the off chance she was the decoy and working for someone else. There are plenty of stories about people pretending to be hurt so when you go to help them they rob you, kill you, abduct you. Or human traffickers who will cause a car accident (suddenly stop in front of you so you rear-end them) and when you get out that is when they take you. One youtuber posted a video of her experience and even has video evidence because she was vlogging when it happened. A man dressed as a city worker approached her and tried to lure her out of her vehicle. He had orange cones set up ( I think blocking the exit) but his behavior was off and he was alone, in a mall parking garage, at night. She ended up driving away (but I think she could only go to the higher lots since the exit was blocked) and then ran into one of the nearest shops and told an employee what happened. They called the police and they told her that what she described sounded like a trafficking attempt as his story to get her to leave her car, his mannerisms, etc. fit the profile.
I hate that people don’t want to be involved when they see something happening. Without getting into too much detail.. my ex “assaulted me” (to put it lightly) which ended w/me running out of the woods in the middle of the night with him chasing me.. I ran up to FOUR houses where the people didn’t let me in or even call the cops for me. before a passerby in a car finally called 911.. please help when someone asks for it!
That's must have been a nightmare! I wouldn't let a stranger in my house, but would definitely call 911 for them. One has to be compassionate yet wary.
Jessica Aide someone screaming at my door for help could be a woman faking to get you to come out, so you are kidnapped. Don’t let them in. Call the police. If they need help or if they’re a criminal, it’s the right thing.
Although it's messed up that they did that, I somewhat understand. There are people that pretend to be in danger, to get access to your home. I wouldn't let someone in. But I would call the cops for them.
My jaw dropped, when you said that Katie deliberately left evidence behind. It boggles my mind that she was able to pull off an escape AND leave behind proof, and I wish I could give her a high five! I wonder if the officers who doubted her faced any disciplinary action? Do you think her kidnappers got complacent, because they’d gotten away with so much?
that part reminded me of another woman who was held captive in australia i dont remember her name but once her abductor wasnt there she managed to untie herself and made sure to throw her locket under the bed before running out so when police searched the house her story could be confirmed as that locket put her at the crime scene
Absolutely AMAZING!!! There are multiple crimes that the victim is SURE to leave clues about in her kidnappers home so that police would know if she/he died or not they would be able to prove it! Actually it kept most of the ones I have seen alive!
@Loca Cola there's been many victims that have done that. Not necessarily bc they are assuming they won't be believed but just to provide irrefutable proof.
Maybe the cops there have a reputation for not taking crimes against women seriously. Leaving something at the crime scene for others to find later is smart
My Dad was actually their neighbour- David tried to hire him to do yard work or something for him but my Dad wouldn't do it bc he was creeped out by them..
I never realised that if someone went missing they didn't really look for you. Unless there is some signs of foul play they just say adults are allowed to get up and leave if they want. I'm like if im missing someone come look for me please. 😂
I’m actually crying. “She refused to dismiss someone’s story just because it sounds bizarre” the world needs more people like that woman. And Katie is such a survivor I’m in awe 🖤
I would totally love an ESCAPED series. Not just solved, or even missing persons. This gives us a major major insight looking into the predators mind. I love all the videos you post. Thank you for getting everyone’s stories out so fluently.
I love escape stories. I sae a story of a girl who was kidnapped in the night I think at 13/14 years old and she was taken to the wood and the kidnapper said they are married under the eye of God. The police I believe recognised her and saw that her heart was beating and she had teary eye and said that if she is the missing victim her family miss her and that's how she escaped. I forgot her name but it made me happy that she was able to escape and tell her story to people! I forgot her name but I ended up in tears while listening,
Thank god for that female cop and that she was not just interested in conforming and fitting in with the guys that she worked with. She was smarter than all her colleagues combined.
Its actually very common for people who have been abandoned to abandon their future families. It's very sad, but it's because that's all that they know.
Please do Jayme Closs she’s my little cousins friend and went missing here in Wisconsin after her parents were killed just last week. We’re all grasping at straws
Mimi Murdaa no one actually thinks she killed her own parents, it's just a horrible meme that some idiot created out of this tragedy... And you're not any better than them for spreading the idea.
Why did his abuse of horses not raise more suspicion. As a kid I was made to ride them, which I hated but loved giving them apple and carrots, and they are really smart gentle creatures. I myself never became a horse girl but my contact with them is appalled that anyone would want to abuse them.
That was my first thought; didn't that raise some fears or suspicion? I'm guessing that it because that was a different time? I'm not saying that every kid who looks the wrong way needs therapy, which seems to be the case these days, but good grief, that kid was screaming for help.
A lot of people don’t understand the connection of animal abuse to other violent crimes. Animal abuse (especially so young) is almost always where serial killers and domestic abusers start.
I’m pretty sure in those days studying people like David was fairly new so it probably wasn’t known to a lot of the public the correlation between the two.
My Mum had to work at a prison here in Perth as part of her registered nursing training and it just so happened to be the one David Birnie was kept at. She had to help the inmates and see to them (one being David Birnie) and she said that you'd never know what he did by talking to him. She said he came across as nice and easy going which made it all the more creepy!
Well he might be- A lot of kids who go through such trauma..have multiple personalities..They are very mentally ill usually...and they can switch from sweet kids..to evil monstrous teens...
I have observed Catherine and she honestly confuses and terrifies me (psychology bachelors. She wouldn’t do an interview but I got access to the CC). People think she followed David but honestly I think she had a much bigger role in everything that went on than what is believed. She has really really dark eyes!!! You did amazing on research btw!! Mainly on the background info, no one has covered it to this degree. Especially as you’re from the US! Can’t believe someone lives in that house and is one of your subs - such a small place lol!
Katie Moir is incredible. She hid a drawing in there? That's some really smart thinking and I would think it would be very tough to think that clearly in such a horrible situation. She saved other people's lives....
the universe saw me waiting for kendall rae’s new video and sent me this blessing of a video :’) despite all of the scary topics you cover, i swear your videos calm me in the strangest way. thank you for making these cases known and giving me something to look forward to 🖤👻
Mikaela Bauguess my friend always tells me, "you just like her voice don't you " hahaha even thou the topic is fucked up her voice is just so soothing.
It’s her voice. It’s so soothing and calming , even when she’s talking about crime and murder! She’s the only person whose videos I can watch before bed because it doesn’t give me nightmares or triggers my bouts of sleep paralysis!
It always baffles me how a mother wouldn't be capable of taking care of her own children. Like...in my head, there's no deciding in whether or not I should take care of my daughter. I have to. No ifs, ands, or buts about it. Idk I guess I just feel like whenever you have a child, you have no choice but to step up.
Unpopular opinion but when I hear stories of child abuse or parents killing their children I really wish a test could be done to see if they would be capable of being a good parent.
Def my favourite time of the year bec of these ladies : Kendall Rae, Danelle Hallan, Eleanor Neale & Georgia Marie 💕 Any other youtube channels you can recommend that has the same content as theirs??
It's so hard for me to understand how people think these insane actions are ok. Not just the murders/assaults but even a night with his brother?! Like what!?
David’s life kind of makes me sad because if it weren’t for his shitty parents he would have grown up fine but then again, it doesn’t justify his actions. On the other hand, Katherine could have lived a normal nice life. From my POV she got influenced too much by David and she decided to do these horrible acts. I don’t know why she wants parole, she has no right to do so. But what really fascinated me was the way Kathy managed to escape. I don’t think if i was ever in the same situation (god hope I won’t ever) I wouldn’t be so smart to leave evidence behind and to be a little detective while I’m held captive. Like what are the chances that Katherine forgot to chain her up. It’s just ... it’s one in a million chance. I’m extremely glad that she got away. BTW- I’m a new subscriber and i have been BINGE watching your videos all week. You are doing an amazing work, I love your videos! You put so much detail into these it helps me put perspective to everything. Keep up the good work!
in every nightmares I have where I'm abducted morbidly all I do is think "what evidence can I leave behind so investigators know I was here?" I find myself ripping out my hair and hiding it everywhere
That's very smart! I haven't had any dreams like that, the dreams I have the most are when someone is trying to capture me so I try to hide and not breath. Worst feeling ever. I think I would just go to panic mode and my brain won't function normally.
@@ThimbleFox350 Hahaha! I'm always thinking about if I get attacked, rip hair out, scratch with nails, or draw blood to collect evidence of the attacker.
Oh no...It was in her..no one can be THIS influenced..this is sick things...I have been with "bad boys"...I don't start doing what they do...I correct them and if they don't stop..I go.
This name reminded me of the Moors Murders in England … The Smiths wrote their first song about it. I'm fairly new here but if its not covered can we add that to the research list, please? Thnx!
It's because she actually matched the skin tone of her face and neck, instead of making her face orange like she usually goes. Over here usually looking like an oompa loompa
This just reminded me so much of Fred and Rosemary West and I am so glad Katie was able to get out and that the body count was so low which sounds horrible, but I know they would not have stopped and would have kept going killing more and more women. It sucks but even today we could all learn from Katie sick people are still out there and having a plan or preparing yourself as best you can is still just the smartest thing to do to keep yourself safe and possibly keep others safe as Katie did by getting out. She saved countless women and honestly is a hero.
This is insane, I’m from Perth, Australia, I attend the University of WA, Iv never felt so close to a case because of the familiarity of the suburbs and highways you stated, Wow I don’t know how I haven’t heard of this case before. Great job as always 💕
I live in perth and not too far away from where Katherine is being held! It's honestly crazy to think about because Perth is such a safe city, especially back then! She was due for parole but I think she was denied thankfully. So good to see an Australian story covered! thanks for all the time you take for your videos and research! xxx
ok so i wrote that before i had watched the entire video and omg its so crazy to hear the roads I drive down daily, the prison I've toured and just so much other stuff in my home city! thanks again for covering this xx
i'm an aussie and thought I was across at least all the big time crime stories we have but have never heard of this one! thanks for bringing it to light!
There's a great program about these two on "Crimes that shook Australia" You get to see interviews with the lady officer that this was her first police report she'd ever taken, and how she had to convince the male police officers and detectives to believe what this young woman that had escaped was saying. You did a great job on covering these murders. Thanks as always!🧡
Duuuude. I am not even half way through this video and am wondering 1) how have I never heard of this 2) how has this not been made into a movie 3) these are some the craziest people I’ve heard about in a long while and I constantly watch/read/listen to true crime from all over the world. Geez now to watch the other but I’m kinda scared too.
I'm from perth and i remember my parents telling me about when this was going down and how terrifying it was. perth is known for being quite a boring place in australia and not much happens here so when this was happening it was big news and really effected the community. i dont live far from where the murders took place so its really surreal something like this happened
I've lived in Perth for 20 years and I've never heard of this case before! So cool seeing our small isolated city being mentioned by my favourite youtuber :) Really well told
My niece and I were cooking dinner earlier and she asked, “Hey! You aren’t watching that Danelle girl! Don’t you always watch her while you cook?” Thanks for giving me a little calm to my chaotic life! Your videos play in the background while I cook and clean.
i always read about people watching Danelles videos while cooking, cleaning or doing their make-up....i don`t get it because i have to be watching the video and concentrating on everything, if you`re not watching it then you miss the visuals......everyone to their own of course :-) but i would miss the half of it if i wasn`t watching.
I doubt you’ll see this, but what’s that lippie you’re wearing? I always see someone asking so Maybe you could put your makeup in the description for us true crime and beauty lovers 🤣
Smh , that's a helluva story Danielle., I'm glad to know that one of their victims was able to get away from those maniacs and after all that the cops don't believe her , Thank God for that female officer who was new on the job.... God Bless her whoever she is ! . Keep up the good work and please be safe. XOXO
So weird that you're covering a case that is so well known in perth where I live and isn't very well known anywhere else until now as you're from America! So crazy😅 this couple murdered my ophthalmologists daughter and it's so sad as he still talks about it to this day and my dad also went to the same high school as susannah
When couples commit crimes like this together its blows my mind. I can't comprehend what goes on in their minds. I'm so glad that the last victim got away alive!!!! She is the true hero in this story, without her there's no telling how long this could have went on for. Thank you for covering this story!!💖💖
I live in Perth and this story is one of the biggest and most talked about here. Me and my sister have driven past that house years ago and it gave us the creeps. Thanks for covering this case
Holy heck, I grew up near Perth and only vaguely remember hearing about the Birnies. I completely forgot about it. I usually have tunnel vision and think primarily of the Claremont & Corryn Rayney cases when it comes to Perth true crime. Thank you so much for being open to cases from outside of the US. It truly means so much.
this is one if not the creepiest case youve covered, I actually felt uncomfortable throughout and kept looking around my living room 😅 it really reminds you that tragedy could strike anytime, so we should always be cautious. You did an amazing job covering this as always~~
It’s super strange that you’ve covered this! I’m from Australia. And I think only recently the new channels covered it again. I hadn’t heard of these murders until it was brought back up. I’m from the east side of AUS, this literally terrifies me. There’s other people who acted similar then these 2. They did kill 2-3 women also, but one got away. I can’t even think of the couple that carried out the murders.
Thank you for doing such a wonderful job of speaking for these victims! I'm proud that you keep your emotions in check, but tell the whole story. Keep speaking for the victims and the missing!!
My grandmother was born and raised in Perth!!!! She met my grandfather--an US Navy soldier sent there during WW2. They got married there and had there first child there before going to live here in the states after the end of the war.
i remember when my favorite murder covered this case--i researched it for like a week after!! so insane! also thought it was so interesting how they found eachother after 10 yrs and THEN committed the murders...weird to think about if they would have become murderers if they stayed seperated, or if it was just because they were together & fed off of eachother. some twisted sort of fate?? super fascinating
I really think you should add more pictures in your videos it can really help tell the story much better rather than a full story with little or no pictures
The level how sick some people are, is really terrifying, troubling and extremely frightening! --- Thank you Danelle for explaining both of their backgrounds so detailed and perfectly well. Even back to their parents' lives/stories/circumstantial backgrounds you've done a ton of research on this one as you generally always do. Which is what makes your videos so very outstanding; I'm sure not only to me but also for your other subs. You'll reach one million subs (like Kendall Rae) in no time cause of this extraordinary quality of your channel's content/all your videos and the CAC-podcast, I'm definitely seeing this coming very, very soon!
I love your channel. I like the way you dig deep but don't place blame where its not needed, unlike another RUclips channel (won't name names). You have a beautiful soul that matches your beauty on the outside! Thank you for each and every show you take time to investigate and share with us all!
Danelle, you are such a great RUclipsr and you inspire me so much. Your dedication and hard work you put into each case you cover is amazing especially since these cases are disturbing. I love your videos, channel and especially you. Thank you for being you💜
Im an Australian and so I thought I knew everything there was to know about the Birnies but you taught me things I didnt even know! Mostly about their back stories and stuff. SO well researched xx
As a kid growing up in the 80s my mom would make me watch America's Most Wanted. We had a secret password and I was told to always be aware of my surroundings. Because of her training I'm very aware and I even notice that there are a lot of women walking around looking at their phones or just completely oblivious of their surroundings. This story is definitely an eye-opener for the unaware and oblivious
TheFox Jones my dad and I use to watch the same stuff. He was a cop and wanted his daughters to know the evil out there. He always said to keep our eyes peeled for something that doesn’t seem right. Window shades go down at night, doors locked all the time. As a child I thought it was annoying but now I see he was just doing his job and being a good dad and teaching his girls to watch out for ourselves. I’ll be forever grateful to him 💗
You do better investigating than some law enforcement!! Especially Alphabet Agencies. You’re one of my fav True Crime Channels!! I love how tell their story. You’re respectful & you can tell you put your all into it.
Idk how many people already said it but i'm gonna tell you 1 mo gen... YOUR HAIR LOOKS STUNNING💯💯💯 I usually prefer your curly hair but DAMN... LOOKIN GOOD SISTA😍😘💋😍😘💋
My mum told me that one of Catherine’s relatives was a friend of ours and she stood up for her in court. My cousins also knew the girl who escaped. The second victims dad was my aunts eye doctor and he when crazy after what happened.
Hi Danelle, If I could have added something to your warnings about not getting into cars with strangers it would have been this: Everyone should teach their children (and themselves) that if someone comes at you with a knife or a gun and tells you to get into their car or they’ll shoot them/kill them DONT GET IN THE CAR! If someone gets mad because you won’t get in, and they shoot you, or shoot at you at least you have a chance of survival. If you get into the car thinking that if you just do as he says he won’t hurt you YOUVE MADE A SERIOUS MISTAKE. Once you get into his car he owns you. I’d much rather be shot in the street with other people in the area because I’d have a chance of surviving. Once you get in the car he’s going to take you somewhere where all the odds are in his favor, and dying in the middle of nowhere with this twisted psycho is not my idea of a good way to die. I’d rather say “No way”, and be shot. Chances are if you tell him to go ahead and shoot you because you’re not getting in the car he may shoot you, but he also may just leave and find a more willing victim. Stay well.😁🙏🏼💕
The story of katie reminded me of the lifetime movie called believe me. It’s about Lisa Mcvey who was kidnapped. She was blindfolded in a car and made note of every turn the kidnapper made. She also left behind evidence in the car just like Katie! It’s amazing how their instincts save their lives
stumbled upon one of your videos a week ago and you’re all I’ve been watching! I seriously have never been more interested in a video like i have been with yours!!
AHHH I AM HYPERVENTILATINNGG! It me! I'm the subscriber!
We honestly just moved out of the house, but I would be happy to answer any questions I can if anyone has any. I was super well researched on the case before we moved in, we had some creepy coincidences with moving in, and then chatting to people in the area who were close to the case and knew the Birnies. It's a super wild ride of a case and Kate Moir has got the be the most INCREDIBLE woman, I am in such awe of her strength and courage.
How did you live there omg I would cry
did moving out have to do with the history of the house?
@@talulahsafir honestly it was a really peaceful house! the owner has done renovations and kept its little 1950's cottage integrity. I loved the house so so much. Only occasionally freaked myself out!
@@cokecinderella5520 no, actually! My partner got a job 3.5 hours away and I was devastated to move. I get super attached to properties and it was my very first rental, such an emotional time haha!
Was it ever weird knowing that such awful things happened in any given room you’d walk into? Too bad everyone in the town would know the house’s history, that would be a hell of a story to tell guests!
It’s so surprising that a place where such awful things happened could be so calm and charming in modern day. It’s funny how different maintenance can really make or break places like these, while the Moorhouse seems to be well maintained and anyone who didn’t know its history would be oblivious, places like Keddie Cabin are so decrepit and creepy, giving off a vibe as ominous as the events that once happened within its walls.
The fact that the police said to ignore her and that she was lying makes me absolutely sick.
Sadly that reaction is common:(
Very common reaction by most police. They don't care
The police in Australia are like that. The female officers tend to be much better, but the male officers 9/10 are absolute pigs who don't believe sexual assault victims and accuse every woman of 'wanting attention'.
Eff the police. 🖕🏼👮♀️
ikr! im so glad the female cop was kind and understanding
One of the first things my mother ever taught me: (due to the events that have happened to her) to *NEVER TRUST A WOMAN EITHER!* "Stranger danger" does NOT just apply to men. Always be aware.
True!
Oh definitely, hell no do not trust a strange woman either. They could be working for someone else or themselves, they could be doing this out of coercion or fear or just plain being evil themselves. The end result is the same.
Look on RUclips for "The Flypaper" (tv show called Tales of the Unexpected) Man uses a woman to attract victims because the woman could gain the trust of the victim.
Truee
@Elizendo omg... tell us more?
My husband asked why I watched videos about murders and crime so I let the video run while he was in the room and he listened to the whole thing, kept asking questions, and now we are on a binge haha great job!
Sayra Amaya lol same with me and my husband
Sayra Amaya Lucky!
My husband is not into my obsession. 😒
Saryra Amaya I am pregnant and my husband joles that so much of crime videos may turn our child psycho 😂😂
Sayra Amaya Girl yessss!! I did the exact same and it worked! It was like a spell!
@@vandanamalik1343 oh my goodness😂😂I hope that's not true cuz SAME 😂😂
It's so eerie that the priest was hesitant about marrying David's parents considering how much damage their marriage ended up causing...
Or...you know... common sense.
@@lizzychrome7630 that doesn't make it any less eerie?
Right?! Like he just had that gut feeling!
The lord
The Holy Spirit told him. These people should not be together.
That poor girl, running for her life naked, no one helping. Then the police ignoring her story! Thank god for her and that police officer, they would have kept on killing. I wonder what happened to the 7 kids she had. Imagine knowing your mother is a killer. You pronounced things very well. Well done!
Her eldest son was hit by a car and died as a young child. The other 6 were left with their father ( her first husband, Donald Mclaughlin) when she ran off with David. I never usually think a mother is doing her children a favor by abandoning them, but I think Catherine definitely gave them an advantage by doing that in this case. I wonder where they are now.
@@clod148 Oh man, that's so true, as fucked up as it sounds... But hey, this whole thing is pretty fucked up, so yeah, I think they lucked out by being abandoned by her, they dodged a bullet there.
Because it could have easily been a trap. Those who blindly trust are the biggest targets. I would have definitely called the police and told her to hid in the bushes or something, but I wouldn't have let her in on the off chance she was the decoy and working for someone else. There are plenty of stories about people pretending to be hurt so when you go to help them they rob you, kill you, abduct you. Or human traffickers who will cause a car accident (suddenly stop in front of you so you rear-end them) and when you get out that is when they take you.
One youtuber posted a video of her experience and even has video evidence because she was vlogging when it happened. A man dressed as a city worker approached her and tried to lure her out of her vehicle. He had orange cones set up ( I think blocking the exit) but his behavior was off and he was alone, in a mall parking garage, at night. She ended up driving away (but I think she could only go to the higher lots since the exit was blocked) and then ran into one of the nearest shops and told an employee what happened. They called the police and they told her that what she described sounded like a trafficking attempt as his story to get her to leave her car, his mannerisms, etc. fit the profile.
I hate that people don’t want to be involved when they see something happening. Without getting into too much detail.. my ex “assaulted me” (to put it lightly) which ended w/me running out of the woods in the middle of the night with him chasing me.. I ran up to FOUR houses where the people didn’t let me in or even call the cops for me. before a passerby in a car finally called 911.. please help when someone asks for it!
That's must have been a nightmare! I wouldn't let a stranger in my house, but would definitely call 911 for them. One has to be compassionate yet wary.
I couldnt imagine not helping someone if they showed up at my door saying they needed help. I am so sorry for you had to go through
I once went thru this, a cop told me I was better off screaming fire rather then help. Ppl run towards a fire
Jessica Aide someone screaming at my door for help could be a woman faking to get you to come out, so you are kidnapped. Don’t let them in. Call the police. If they need help or if they’re a criminal, it’s the right thing.
Although it's messed up that they did that, I somewhat understand. There are people that pretend to be in danger, to get access to your home. I wouldn't let someone in. But I would call the cops for them.
My jaw dropped, when you said that Katie deliberately left evidence behind.
It boggles my mind that she was able to pull off an escape AND leave behind proof, and I wish I could give her a high five! I wonder if the officers who doubted her faced any disciplinary action?
Do you think her kidnappers got complacent, because they’d gotten away with so much?
@Loca Cola so what exactly are you trying to say?....
that part reminded me of another woman who was held captive in australia i dont remember her name but once her abductor wasnt there she managed to untie herself and made sure to throw her locket under the bed before running out so when police searched the house her story could be confirmed as that locket put her at the crime scene
Absolutely AMAZING!!! There are multiple crimes that the victim is SURE to leave clues about in her kidnappers home so that police would know if she/he died or not they would be able to prove it! Actually it kept most of the ones I have seen alive!
@Loca Cola there's been many victims that have done that. Not necessarily bc they are assuming they won't be believed but just to provide irrefutable proof.
Maybe the cops there have a reputation for not taking crimes against women seriously. Leaving something at the crime scene for others to find later is smart
My Dad was actually their neighbour- David tried to hire him to do yard work or something for him but my Dad wouldn't do it bc he was creeped out by them..
Oh wow, what did he feel around them? Did he see or sense anything? Like spiritual sort of?
this makes me wonder just how many cases could be solved if police actually...did their jobs properly
I never realised that if someone went missing they didn't really look for you. Unless there is some signs of foul play they just say adults are allowed to get up and leave if they want. I'm like if im missing someone come look for me please. 😂
Good question...
yeah im noticing that in all these cases. police fail us alot
That's Australia for you. The cops over here are useless
Honey - I wish American cops were just useless. Ours are not only useless, but they’re also dangerous.
I’m actually crying. “She refused to dismiss someone’s story just because it sounds bizarre” the world needs more people like that woman. And Katie is such a survivor I’m in awe 🖤
I would totally love an ESCAPED series. Not just solved, or even missing persons. This gives us a major major insight looking into the predators mind. I love all the videos you post. Thank you for getting everyone’s stories out so fluently.
sedona Jackson Yes my favourite cases are the ones where people survive kidnapping and live to tell their story
I love escape stories. I sae a story of a girl who was kidnapped in the night I think at 13/14 years old and she was taken to the wood and the kidnapper said they are married under the eye of God.
The police I believe recognised her and saw that her heart was beating and she had teary eye and said that if she is the missing victim her family miss her and that's how she escaped. I forgot her name but it made me happy that she was able to escape and tell her story to people!
I forgot her name but I ended up in tears while listening,
@@Maya-dw5jz i think that was Elizabeth Smart
@@XYZ-kb3mm yeah Elizabeth Smart!! Thank you
“If you’re picking up what I’m throwing down” lol that made me laugh 😆
Second case I've heard recently where 'thank god for female cops' applies
Thank god for that female cop and that she was not just interested in conforming and fitting in with the guys that she worked with. She was smarter than all her colleagues combined.
She has abandonment issues, but abandons her kids and husband 🤦🏾♀️
Its actually very common for people who have been abandoned to abandon their future families. It's very sad, but it's because that's all that they know.
Mich Aguiluz I agree, was gonna say that too.
If you abandon them they can’t abandon you
Please do Jayme Closs she’s my little cousins friend and went missing here in Wisconsin after her parents were killed just last week. We’re all grasping at straws
I've seen that story on Twitter. Idk why but everyone thinks she murdered or own parents.. I have no idea.
It makes me nauseous knowing this girl is out there, god knows what is happening to her... I hope they find her quickly.
Mimi Murdaa no one actually thinks she killed her own parents, it's just a horrible meme that some idiot created out of this tragedy... And you're not any better than them for spreading the idea.
where at in Wisconsin? I'm 20 mins from Wisconsin in IL.
Logan Hensley Barron wi, it’s by Minneapolis
Why did his abuse of horses not raise more suspicion. As a kid I was made to ride them, which I hated but loved giving them apple and carrots, and they are really smart gentle creatures. I myself never became a horse girl but my contact with them is appalled that anyone would want to abuse them.
I thought the same thing. No one did anything about a dude punching horses? Who punches a horse?
That was my first thought; didn't that raise some fears or suspicion? I'm guessing that it because that was a different time? I'm not saying that every kid who looks the wrong way needs therapy, which seems to be the case these days, but good grief, that kid was screaming for help.
A lot of people don’t understand the connection of animal abuse to other violent crimes. Animal abuse (especially so young) is almost always where serial killers and domestic abusers start.
I’m pretty sure in those days studying people like David was fairly new so it probably wasn’t known to a lot of the public the correlation between the two.
Animals were not that protected or cared about much until very recently..its us darn millennials that obsess over our animals❤
My Mum had to work at a prison here in Perth as part of her registered nursing training and it just so happened to be the one David Birnie was kept at. She had to help the inmates and see to them (one being David Birnie) and she said that you'd never know what he did by talking to him. She said he came across as nice and easy going which made it all the more creepy!
I’ve worked in a maximum risk prison and it’s usually the ones who are nice and quiet that have committed the most heinous acts.
Well he might be- A lot of kids who go through such trauma..have multiple personalities..They are very mentally ill usually...and they can switch from sweet kids..to evil monstrous teens...
Interesting. My mom was a prison sergeant for over 20 years. I will have to ask her if she has any interesting stories!
Hold up..... one of your subscribers live in this house!?! OH HELL NO TIME TO GO!
I really wish I could post a photo of it here in the comments!!
You're one of my favs @Pageanteen
Pageanteen okay!! Hell no to the nah nah nah.
I juat looked. It is back on the rental market, if anyone's interested?
@@clod148 $390 is bloody steep lmao. It's pretty small, despite how lovely it is.
Wow! Katie is a hero. So brilliant how her instincts kicked in.
Ugh I hope the police who wouldn’t believe the poor woman are ashamed of themselves
I have observed Catherine and she honestly confuses and terrifies me (psychology bachelors. She wouldn’t do an interview but I got access to the CC). People think she followed David but honestly I think she had a much bigger role in everything that went on than what is believed. She has really really dark eyes!!!
You did amazing on research btw!! Mainly on the background info, no one has covered it to this degree. Especially as you’re from the US!
Can’t believe someone lives in that house and is one of your subs - such a small place lol!
Katie Moir is incredible. She hid a drawing in there? That's some really smart thinking and I would think it would be very tough to think that clearly in such a horrible situation. She saved other people's lives....
the universe saw me waiting for kendall rae’s new video and sent me this blessing of a video :’) despite all of the scary topics you cover, i swear your videos calm me in the strangest way. thank you for making these cases known and giving me something to look forward to 🖤👻
Mikaela Bauguess my friend always tells me, "you just like her voice don't you " hahaha even thou the topic is fucked up her voice is just so soothing.
It’s her voice. It’s so soothing and calming , even when she’s talking about crime and murder!
She’s the only person whose videos I can watch before bed because it doesn’t give me nightmares or triggers my bouts of sleep paralysis!
Yep she has a calming voice but the content is interesting enough to not get bored (vs an asmr video or something) I watch these videos to go to sleep
"He wasn't good looking...he had a hunch back " 😂😂😂 lmao
It always baffles me how a mother wouldn't be capable of taking care of her own children. Like...in my head, there's no deciding in whether or not I should take care of my daughter. I have to. No ifs, ands, or buts about it. Idk I guess I just feel like whenever you have a child, you have no choice but to step up.
I feel the same way. But, I have met a couple women who could make a baby....but, have no maternal feelings/instincts. ☹
Unpopular opinion but when I hear stories of child abuse or parents killing their children I really wish a test could be done to see if they would be capable of being a good parent.
Besides people being crazy like Kathryn, there is such thing as postpartum depression which is out of the mother's control.
Britney Jade this wouldn’t work
@@cokecinderella5520 of course it wouldn't, it's not that simple but if only it was
Def my favourite time of the year bec of these ladies : Kendall Rae, Danelle Hallan, Eleanor Neale & Georgia Marie 💕
Any other youtube channels you can recommend that has the same content as theirs??
I think it's called Amber loves mystery. It's a little bit different. But, she respects everyone she reports on.
Shauna Rae!
Bella Fiori, lordanARTS, Rob Dyke, Caitlin Rose
K Schiffer legit every RUclipsr you listed I watched as well 😂😂
K Schiffer cayleigh elise!!! ❤️
I’m loving HALLOWEEK so far, got me some snacks and cant wait to watch this 😀😀💜
It's so hard for me to understand how people think these insane actions are ok. Not just the murders/assaults but even a night with his brother?! Like what!?
David’s life kind of makes me sad because if it weren’t for his shitty parents he would have grown up fine but then again, it doesn’t justify his actions. On the other hand, Katherine could have lived a normal nice life. From my POV she got influenced too much by David and she decided to do these horrible acts. I don’t know why she wants parole, she has no right to do so. But what really fascinated me was the way Kathy managed to escape. I don’t think if i was ever in the same situation (god hope I won’t ever) I wouldn’t be so smart to leave evidence behind and to be a little detective while I’m held captive. Like what are the chances that Katherine forgot to chain her up. It’s just ... it’s one in a million chance. I’m extremely glad that she got away.
BTW- I’m a new subscriber and i have been BINGE watching your videos all week. You are doing an amazing work, I love your videos! You put so much detail into these it helps me put perspective to everything. Keep up the good work!
in every nightmares I have where I'm abducted morbidly all I do is think "what evidence can I leave behind so investigators know I was here?" I find myself ripping out my hair and hiding it everywhere
That's very smart! I haven't had any dreams like that, the dreams I have the most are when someone is trying to capture me so I try to hide and not breath. Worst feeling ever. I think I would just go to panic mode and my brain won't function normally.
Katherine is a lot more evil than a lot see her. She could very well be a malignant narcissist.
@@ThimbleFox350 Hahaha! I'm always thinking about if I get attacked, rip hair out, scratch with nails, or draw blood to collect evidence of the attacker.
Oh no...It was in her..no one can be THIS influenced..this is sick things...I have been with "bad boys"...I don't start doing what they do...I correct them and if they don't stop..I go.
This name reminded me of the Moors Murders in England … The Smiths wrote their first song about it. I'm fairly new here but if its not covered can we add that to the research list, please? Thnx!
I'm surprised they didn't burn that house to the ground, imagine the horrific energy in it let alone unsettled spirits.
You look extra pretty in this video Danelle! 😍 loving halloweek, great video as always xx
It's because she actually matched the skin tone of her face and neck, instead of making her face orange like she usually goes. Over here usually looking like an oompa loompa
Joey pinkpants30 I wish she would do a make up Tutorial, I love her eye make up.
@@francinestone girl there's a 1000 eye makeup tutorials better than she could do. Just look them up.
@@samhowl1152 Why exactly are you so extra about her looks? This is a crime video. If you can't say anything nice, move tf on
Forreal, why do you care so much Sam? She’s pretty all around. No need to be jealous and hateful.
This just reminded me so much of Fred and Rosemary West and I am so glad Katie was able to get out and that the body count was so low which sounds horrible, but I know they would not have stopped and would have kept going killing more and more women. It sucks but even today we could all learn from Katie sick people are still out there and having a plan or preparing yourself as best you can is still just the smartest thing to do to keep yourself safe and possibly keep others safe as Katie did by getting out. She saved countless women and honestly is a hero.
That was the first thing that popped into my head! Eerily similair cases... so sad
This is insane, I’m from Perth, Australia, I attend the University of WA, Iv never felt so close to a case because of the familiarity of the suburbs and highways you stated, Wow I don’t know how I haven’t heard of this case before. Great job as always 💕
I'm from Perth as well! It's ready creepy hearing a case so close to home isn't it? Especially one this disturbing!
Yeah I agree! I honestly don’t think I can drive on canning/Stirling Highway without thinking of this case!
yea i live 2 streets away from this house and walk past it regularly, pretty fkn creepy
@@rubyh696 oh wow! Even living near Moorehouse St would freak me out!
Yeah because Perth is usually so isolated from these things it’s extra creepy
I live in perth and not too far away from where Katherine is being held! It's honestly crazy to think about because Perth is such a safe city, especially back then! She was due for parole but I think she was denied thankfully. So good to see an Australian story covered! thanks for all the time you take for your videos and research! xxx
ok so i wrote that before i had watched the entire video and omg its so crazy to hear the roads I drive down daily, the prison I've toured and just so much other stuff in my home city! thanks again for covering this xx
i'm an aussie and thought I was across at least all the big time crime stories we have but have never heard of this one! thanks for bringing it to light!
"I've got the munchies"?!?!?! BARF!!!!!
might regret watching this at night BUT let’s get this started.
There's a great program about these two on "Crimes that shook Australia" You get to see interviews with the lady officer that this was her first police report she'd ever taken, and how she had to convince the male police officers and detectives to believe what this young woman that had escaped was saying.
You did a great job on covering these murders. Thanks as always!🧡
i live 2 streets over from moorhouse street. when i’m walking my dog he acts really strange out the front of their house.
I love your videos and how you tell the story with such sympathy. Prayers for the victims and their families. Thank you for sharing this story.
She really does!😊
Amen, prayers for justice for all the family members friends of victims needing justice for their deaths and abuses.
Duuuude. I am not even half way through this video and am wondering 1) how have I never heard of this 2) how has this not been made into a movie 3) these are some the craziest people I’ve heard about in a long while and I constantly watch/read/listen to true crime from all over the world. Geez now to watch the other but I’m kinda scared too.
Melissa there is actually a movie based on this case it’s on Hulu it’s called “ Hounds Of Love “ very interesting and will give you so much anxiety
I love halloweek. Can it be a week out of every month? Lol
I'm from perth and i remember my parents telling me about when this was going down and how terrifying it was. perth is known for being quite a boring place in australia and not much happens here so when this was happening it was big news and really effected the community. i dont live far from where the murders took place so its really surreal something like this happened
This is the EPITOME of a codependent, toxic relationship
Thank you for all the hard work you put into your videos and into giving a voice to those who cant express their own! Your amazing
This relationship, this continuous coming together, this sick “bond”, is the work of Satan himself!! I’m so sorry for these families and victims....
Honey, WHAT? Perth, Australia? I live here!!!!! What the hell?! HOW DID I NOT KNOW ABOUT THIS BEFORE?!?!?!?!
how can people dislike your videos??? ive never heard this case and it’s absolutely insane! thank you for doing what you do 💜
I've lived in Perth for 20 years and I've never heard of this case before! So cool seeing our small isolated city being mentioned by my favourite youtuber :) Really well told
My niece and I were cooking dinner earlier and she asked, “Hey! You aren’t watching that Danelle girl! Don’t you always watch her while you cook?”
Thanks for giving me a little calm to my chaotic life! Your videos play in the background while I cook and clean.
lilnappy yesss, this is my reward for cooking and cleaning. It makes it not be a chore 🤣
i always read about people watching Danelles videos while cooking, cleaning or doing their make-up....i don`t get it because i have to be watching the video and concentrating on everything, if you`re not watching it then you miss the visuals......everyone to their own of course :-) but i would miss the half of it if i wasn`t watching.
I love this channel!! You don’t cuss every second and you’re super sweet. It’s nice to sit and watch your videos ☺️☺️☺️
When a priest do not want to marry you......*warning signs!*
I doubt you’ll see this, but what’s that lippie you’re wearing? I always see someone asking so Maybe you could put your makeup in the description for us true crime and beauty lovers 🤣
You can use Nyx- birthday suit , looks a lil bit like the lipstick she is wearing
It's strange how this is called the moorhouse murders because it reminds me so strongly of the moors murders in so many ways.
Someone accidentally disliked lol
Eyeshadow 👌🏻 in ur profile pic
My toddler came by and started pressing on my phone and accidentally hit dislike! I was like no no no! We like this. 😂
Smh , that's a helluva story Danielle., I'm glad to know that one of their victims was able to get away from those maniacs and after all that the cops don't believe her , Thank God for that female officer who was new on the job.... God Bless her whoever she is ! . Keep up the good work and please be safe. XOXO
I just wanna say I prefer your videos because of your calm and genuine mannerisms and ability to tell the story.
Don't change a thing!
Your amazing!
So weird that you're covering a case that is so well known in perth where I live and isn't very well known anywhere else until now as you're from America! So crazy😅 this couple murdered my ophthalmologists daughter and it's so sad as he still talks about it to this day and my dad also went to the same high school as susannah
I hate when the innocent family members are attacked/harassed. That poor boy had monsters as parents and deserves our support not anger
When couples commit crimes like this together its blows my mind. I can't comprehend what goes on in their minds. I'm so glad that the last victim got away alive!!!! She is the true hero in this story, without her there's no telling how long this could have went on for. Thank you for covering this story!!💖💖
I watched the movie “Hounds of love”, it’s sad how sick and corrupt some people’s minds are.
Steph Rogers yep. That was so scary!
I live in Perth and this story is one of the biggest and most talked about here. Me and my sister have driven past that house years ago and it gave us the creeps. Thanks for covering this case
Wow that was terrifying, how can two people even admit to each other they enjoy doing these horrible things let alone commit them together :(
I’m watching this while alone with my newborn . Makes me sooo scared because I spend a lot of my time alone. Thank you for covering this case!
Absolutely loving halloweek🎃
Holy heck, I grew up near Perth and only vaguely remember hearing about the Birnies. I completely forgot about it. I usually have tunnel vision and think primarily of the Claremont & Corryn Rayney cases when it comes to Perth true crime. Thank you so much for being open to cases from outside of the US. It truly means so much.
Omg this case is so interesting!! The fact she left evidence was so amazing! I wanna give her a high five 💕
this is one if not the creepiest case youve covered, I actually felt uncomfortable throughout and kept looking around my living room 😅 it really reminds you that tragedy could strike anytime, so we should always be cautious. You did an amazing job covering this as always~~
You hair looks so full and pretty
wow definition of soulmates from hell
It’s super strange that you’ve covered this! I’m from Australia. And I think only recently the new channels covered it again. I hadn’t heard of these murders until it was brought back up. I’m from the east side of AUS, this literally terrifies me. There’s other people who acted similar then these 2. They did kill 2-3 women also, but one got away. I can’t even think of the couple that carried out the murders.
Thank you for doing such a wonderful job of speaking for these victims! I'm proud that you keep your emotions in check, but tell the whole story.
Keep speaking for the victims and the missing!!
They sound like the Australian version of Paul Bernardo and Karla Homolka 😧
My grandmother was born and raised in Perth!!!! She met my grandfather--an US Navy soldier sent there during WW2. They got married there and had there first child there before going to live here in the states after the end of the war.
i remember when my favorite murder covered this case--i researched it for like a week after!! so insane! also thought it was so interesting how they found eachother after 10 yrs and THEN committed the murders...weird to think about if they would have become murderers if they stayed seperated, or if it was just because they were together & fed off of eachother. some twisted sort of fate?? super fascinating
As horrible as this case was, I can’t even begin to explain how awesome it is the hear you talk about Perth. Us Perth kids are used to been forgotten.
I really think you should add more pictures in your videos it can really help tell the story much better rather than a full story with little or no pictures
Pics and videos*
The level how sick some people are, is really terrifying, troubling and extremely frightening! --- Thank you Danelle for explaining both of their backgrounds so detailed and perfectly well. Even back to their parents' lives/stories/circumstantial backgrounds you've done a ton of research on this one as you generally always do. Which is what makes your videos so very outstanding; I'm sure not only to me but also for your other subs. You'll reach one million subs (like Kendall Rae) in no time cause of this extraordinary quality of your channel's content/all your videos and the CAC-podcast, I'm definitely seeing this coming very, very soon!
I grew up in this neighbourhood and my grandmothers brother used to play cards with David
I love your channel. I like the way you dig deep but don't place blame where its not needed, unlike another RUclips channel (won't name names). You have a beautiful soul that matches your beauty on the outside! Thank you for each and every show you take time to investigate and share with us all!
Danelle, you are such a great RUclipsr and you inspire me so much. Your dedication and hard work you put into each case you cover is amazing especially since these cases are disturbing. I love your videos, channel and especially you. Thank you for being you💜
Im an Australian and so I thought I knew everything there was to know about the Birnies but you taught me things I didnt even know! Mostly about their back stories and stuff. SO well researched xx
As a kid growing up in the 80s my mom would make me watch America's Most Wanted. We had a secret password and I was told to always be aware of my surroundings. Because of her training I'm very aware and I even notice that there are a lot of women walking around looking at their phones or just completely oblivious of their surroundings. This story is definitely an eye-opener for the unaware and oblivious
TheFox Jones my dad and I use to watch the same stuff. He was a cop and wanted his daughters to know the evil out there. He always said to keep our eyes peeled for something that doesn’t seem right. Window shades go down at night, doors locked all the time. As a child I thought it was annoying but now I see he was just doing his job and being a good dad and teaching his girls to watch out for ourselves. I’ll be forever grateful to him 💗
You do better investigating than some law enforcement!! Especially Alphabet Agencies. You’re one of my fav True Crime Channels!! I love how tell their story. You’re respectful & you can tell you put your all into it.
Idk how many people already said it but i'm gonna tell you 1 mo gen... YOUR HAIR LOOKS STUNNING💯💯💯 I usually prefer your curly hair but DAMN... LOOKIN GOOD SISTA😍😘💋😍😘💋
My mum told me that one of Catherine’s relatives was a friend of ours and she stood up for her in court. My cousins also knew the girl who escaped. The second victims dad was my aunts eye doctor and he when crazy after what happened.
Day 4 and I don't want this week to end!!
Hi Danelle,
If I could have added something to your warnings about not getting into cars with strangers it would have been this: Everyone should teach their children (and themselves) that if someone comes at you with a knife or a gun and tells you to get into their car or they’ll shoot them/kill them DONT GET IN THE CAR! If someone gets mad because you won’t get in, and they shoot you, or shoot at you at least you have a chance of survival. If you get into the car thinking that if you just do as he says he won’t hurt you YOUVE MADE A SERIOUS MISTAKE. Once you get into his car he owns you. I’d much rather be shot in the street with other people in the area because I’d have a chance of surviving. Once you get in the car he’s going to take you somewhere where all the odds are in his favor, and dying in the middle of nowhere with this twisted psycho is not my idea of a good way to die. I’d rather say “No way”, and be shot. Chances are if you tell him to go ahead and shoot you because you’re not getting in the car he may shoot you, but he also may just leave and find a more willing victim. Stay well.😁🙏🏼💕
I'm never this early! I love your channel danelle you put in so much work to bring awareness to these cases. Your awesome
Thank you so much!
The story of katie reminded me of the lifetime movie called believe me. It’s about Lisa Mcvey who was kidnapped. She was blindfolded in a car and made note of every turn the kidnapper made. She also left behind evidence in the car just like Katie!
It’s amazing how their instincts save their lives
My uncle was the arresting officer of Katherine and she actually spat at him
@@polynesian_tingz906 not sure if you realize Katherine is one of the killers and Katie is one of the victims.
Sounds very similar to Myra Hindly and Ian Brady. The took photos of of each other over their victims graves. Loathsome.
Yes very myra and Ian
BACK AT IT AGAIN FOR 11PM❤️
Fellow UK lass!
Omg this story is absolutely haunting *shivers*. So happy that Katie escaped!!
Danelle, thank you so much for all the effort you put into every single video - you are truly amazing. Much love from England xxx
girl, these videos are incredible. i sure am gonna miss them.
Youre amazing Danelle
Literally wait up til 11:00pm for this 😂😂 love ur vids and all the effort you put into them... deffo worth the late night ❤️❤️😂
stumbled upon one of your videos a week ago and you’re all I’ve been watching! I seriously have never been more interested in a video like i have been with yours!!