Alan Smith's Transfer from Leeds to Manchester United
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 30 сен 2024
- Alan Smith's Transfer from Leeds United to Manchester United
Subscribe to The Athletic at www.theathletic...
Subscribe: bit.ly/TifoSubs... | 🔔Make sure to enable all push notifications!🔔
Watch the most recent videos: • Most Recent Videos | T...
Read Phil Hay's original article on The Athletic: theathletic.co...
Two years before his transfer to Manchester United, Leeds star, Alan Smith, had said in an interview that Manchester United were incompatible with his Leeds United roots and that he could never play for them. So how then, did his transfer come about?
Subscribe to the Tifo Football Podcast: bit.ly/TifoPodC...
Follow Tifo Football:
Website: tifofootball.com
Twitter: / tifofootball_
Facebook: / tifofootball
Instagram: / tifofootball_
Listen to the Tifo Football podcast:
Acast: bit.ly/TifoAcas...
Apple Podcasts: bit.ly/TifoFootPod
Spotify: / tifo-football-podcast
Subscribe to the Tifo Football Podcast: bit.ly/TifoPodC...
Subscribe to Tifo Basketball at bit.ly/TifoBask...
Watch more Tifo Football:
Tactics Explained: • Tactics Explained | Ti...
Finances & Laws: • Finances & Laws | Tifo...
Tifo Football Podcast: • Tifo Football Podcast
Most Recent Videos: • Most Recent Videos | T...
Popular Videos: • Popular Videos | Tifo ...
Produced by Tifo Studios: Taking an illustrated look into the beautiful game.
Music sourced from epidemicsound.com
About Tifo Football:
Informative, illustrated football analysis. Home of WhiteboardFootball®.
Tifo loves football. We know there’s an appetite for thoughtful, intelligent content, for stuff that makes the complicated simple.
Our illustrated and live action RUclips videos address all aspects of the game, including tactics, history, and the business of football.
We provide analysis on the Premier League, Champions League, La Liga, Serie A, Bundesliga, World Cup and more.
Our podcasts interview some of the game’s leading figures. And our editorial covers football with depth and insight.
Tifo Football used to be uMAXit Football - we changed our name in November 2017 to better articulate who we are and what matters to us: making football accessible to its fans through story-telling and the expertise and insight of our team of writers and producers.
Tifo was nominated by the Football Supporters’ Federation for the ‘Best Online Media’ Award in 2017 and 2018.
We also make bespoke videos.
#MUFC #LUFC #AlanSmith 
Спорт
This is not the Alan Smith who commentates with Martin Tyler
Josh Cuthbert that Alan smith of Arsenal won the Golden boot twice and won the league at Anfield. This one can’t even lace his boots
@@tanmaypagar8022 exactly
@Josh Cuthbert I wouldn't call a shot from a free kick a tackle...
Thank God someone brings this up
@Josh Cuthbert you just dont know anything about football so shut up
I cant speak for all Man Utd fans, but in my experience he was a massive fan favourite for us. Really unselfish player, always gave his all and there was a recognition that he had found the move tough.
Yeah he was definitely a favourite for me too, it a shame he had that injury but I'll allways remember his quality in front of goal and his want to press the oppo no end.
Fair assessment.
Im a die hard Liverpool fan, but 1 of my best mates was a huge leeds fan growing up. Him and his dad had season tickets for Elland Road and every now and again his dad had to work so I would go with him - it was around this time - Smithy, Viduka, Batty, Milner, Fowler, Robinson etc. Some of my fondest football memories and I dont even support the club but the atmosphere and the support around the team at the time was exciting to be involved in. Hope Leeds get back into the Prem soon where they belong, but us LFC fans will be sad to see you take Milly back from us
He was yes
I was happy when he signed for united. Just a shame he never really took off. And that injury was horrible.
A lot of shade being thrown at Alan Smith. By joining Manchester United, he contributed funds to saving Leeds United financially. That's one of the best things a Leeds lad can do for the club. Anyone with bitterness to him is misguided - he left because if he didn't, Leeds United may not even exist. Especially him. He saved the club. He and Milner are as loyal good Leeds lads as they breed.
Pretty much similar to Rooney moving to United from Everton. Die hard evertonian but Rooney moving possibly saved Everton as a whole.
*Sigh. So tired of this idiot excuse. It wasn't his job to "save the club," and if he just felt he had to do that, he could have went elsewhere. Nobody is misguided for rightly labelling him a Judas turncoat.
@@Michael_Chandler_Keaton firstly, calm down. Secondly, Man United were the best team in England. It was a huge move for him. And would you rather he stayed and your club went under? Embarrassing.
@@bens4602 Lol come now mate, let's not be daft. This one transfer didn't save the club from going under. That's revisionist, melodramatic nonsense. Furthermore, again it was not his job to "save the club." It was admitted that the move generated at most a couple hundred thousand pounds toward club debt, inconsequential ultimately for a club millions in the hole. He knew what he meant to Leeds, and from his own mouth he'd never go scum. There were other moves available, but the Leeds board were in a rush. Smith could have slowed things down by refusing the move. Right or wrong, whatever one's opinion is, let's just drop the mad "he did it to save the club" nonsense. It's juvenile and nauseating.
@@bens4602 And Arsenal were the best club in England, not the scum.
Lol Fergie was a proper troll...Michael Owen, Alan Smith, RVP...
he even 'stole' Giggs from city 😅
Yeah he was ruthless. As much as United fans loved him and as successful as he was he was also a total bastard and pissed alot of people off along the way (not sure united fans agree)
To me, he is the embodiment of corporate football.
...and Giggs ended up winning more trophies than City :D
Benitez refused to buy back Michael Owen because his agent was a prick. so Owen could only join Manu, one of few teams who actually made an offer to buy him from Newcastle.
@TheRealist 811 By the time we sold Smith we had already been relegated. Not much to weaken there.
Don't forget Roy Keane had already told Dalgleish he would join Blackburn before Fergie persuaded him to change his mind
As a leeds fan. I had no problem with the move and didn't resent him. He knew it was the best deal for the club and this transfer essentially saved us from going totally bust. Anyone who calls him a traitor are pushing the envelope in my eyes. He always had the best interests of Leeds in his mind.
@Bootneck777man said he wanted a UCL club and United were the only UCL club going for him 😂
Another what could he have been? The injury changed him forever. He was a warrior & bull. Gegen pressing like saiyan before it was cool.
Isn’t it funny to think that there was a time when a player could just delay their unveiling at a new club in an attempt to calm supporters. That would be pointless today because the supporters would still go for you on Twitter.
Do a video on the corruption of the European cup final of Leeds v Bayern and the referee being banned for life
Great idea
@Leeds United Forever as a chelsea fan i feel that Leeds were robbed of the 1973 European cup winners cup final and 1975 European cup final
Has to happen
Yeah normally I'd say fuck Leeds but I feel sorry for them on this one. Being cheated out of the biggest game of your history is something no football fan should be happy about regardless of who they support
@@williamking1905 fair play, lad, from a Leeds fan.
Most Leeds fans in this day and age realize the sacrifice Smith made. Man U were the only club putting a good offer on the table and in turn, moving to a club he hated and said he would never move to, helped saving us. You still see a couple of fans saying Judas though...followed by a barrage of "he saved us" messages.
We all know Harry Kewell is the real Judas
@@harrisonlupton3857 Agree, burnt his bridges when he went to those Gala-C*nts in the name of "bringing the clubs together".
Man United saved you, dont get it twisted :)
@@bhew7409 Oh yeah, maybe they can work the same magic in saving themselves over the next few seasons :D
@@stevenhickenjr haha, we trying!
Alan Smith was exceptional, tenacious. I liked his game. I also thought he might be Roy Keane's illegitimate son😄
He was utter shite at Newcastle
@@JohnKobaRuddy The injury vs Liverpool finished him. It's Newcastles fault for going for him.
JUDAS MOT
He was OK, he was nothing like Keane as a footballer other than he could get stuck in. He couldn't pass for shit and you could tell he was a forward playing in midfield....apologies if I sound like an assehole but Comparing smith to Keane is an insult to Keane
Overrated as f@ck and ran about like a headless chuck kicking players is that what you mean?😂
Injuries caused Alan Smith, Owen Hargreaves, Michael Owen to underperform and end their careers.
Tee Jay don't forget Rodrigo Possebon and Ben Collett
Michael owen best goal? Vs city for sure!!!! Worth every penny we paid for that goal😅😅😑
Chris Perry Would’ve been even more regarded had United won the league that season ! But Chelsea did !
I like a lot of Leeds fans never blamed him, at the end of the day Peter Ridsdale is the only one to blame for the fire sale which saw a local hero go to a bitter rival. i would say all the players sold suffered from it too, i doubt it feels great to be bought because you where going cheap.
Viduka was never the same. I say that as an Australian and he's a hero of mine (and anyone who follows the sport in our country)
Was always a fan of this guy at United... his hardwork, his determination, eye for goal. He was just great.
Until he left for scum
Yeah totes!
As a Leeds fan its really hard purely because it was Man United, Leeds were a financial basket case and we all knew player sales were incoming. Its just that its to them.
I don't blame him
Do you think Leeds fans would have preferred him to have gone to another club but for less money?
Leeds united sucks lol..petty with a small club mentality..poor beggars 😂😂😂
@@H1vey I think at the time he was made the victim because of the timing - after losing Robo, Rio, Fowler, Milner etc and not replacing them it was too much of a loss for the team. I think when Rio and Milner left it was very much an expected loss, the fans new they couldn't keep that team for long but they didnt expect to loose as many stars as they did. At the time I remember and equal amount of anger at the club and at Smithy...
Just another bullit in the long list of reasons why everybody hates man united.
I think he was convinced by the board that going to United was the best thing for Leeds since they offered the most money. If they'd have taken less for him Leeds might not have existed. So even though it was probably tough for him, he was doing what he thought was the best thing for Leeds at the time.
@@keytostart7053 they got a hefty fee for rio and reasonably enough for smith.
The only other player not on your list is kewell. Its a criminal leeds let him go for a paltry amount of fee.
Gutted for smith...
We was delighted when fergie got this deal done. He was a massive favourite at Old Trafford, I reckon he could have gone on to be one of the best ever...
I was at the league Cup final against Wigan, think it was 2006??
We sang Alan Smith Alan Smith Alan Smith all the way through...
I remember all the utd players had Alan Smith t shirts on through the warm up and again at the end when collecting the trophy...
Never forgot that he put his body on the line for his club...
Hello everyone. I'm Martin Tyler, this is Alan Smith
Though not the same Alan Smith.
Clive Tidesly here.
different Alan Smith
I'm just joking guys
This is a different Alan Smith
Moral of the story: NEVER SAY NEVER
You just said it twice
Do one about Torres' transfer to Chelsea from Liverpool
Jamie Carragher recently said that selling him was a perfect decision. He was already waning down.
@@AdarshKumar-nj7rp didn't fucking ask u did I ....I am talking about how the move developed, the whole story... not Jamie carra version of it...
He betrayed Liverpool, moved to chelski for 50 million, flopped big time, Liverpool signed Suarez with less than half that! The end!
@@fernandoiniesta0081 I never objected to your demand. Also it's a comment section. I can write whatever I want.
@@davidrowan3853 I think ull find that Suarez was bought in to partner Torres up front......the replacement was Carroll, who well and truly failed....this was one of the biggest transfer headlines in the previous decade, and a lot of the details are still blurry....it would therefore be nice to see an objective report on the transfer that tells both sides of the story, rather that the club's narrative, which paints Torres as the traitor, when infact, as people inside melwood know, there was a lot more to it....
This is Martyn Tyler, along with Alan Smith
Not the same lad
different Alan Smith
@@antonisantoniou1436 yep I know just kidding
@@yusdrum91 I know the commentator one was an Arsenal player
L
Ah yes Alan Smith. I recall you scored a few headers playing for Arsenal, right Alan?
3 of the best he’s made them pau
It's not that Alan Smith
That’s a different Alan Smith
james fisher Oh ReALY
Nuri Volkoff we know
Leeds fan here. I loved him at the club, like others have said, he had everything to endear him to the public. He was a good finisher, good in the air, hardworker, relentless presser.
He may have said that he isn't going to play for them and he did. But with the club desperately needing him to go and only 1 club bidding for him, what else could he have done?
Wayne Rooney, Alan Smith, Van Persie, Cantona.... Manchester United sure know how to piss off fans of the former clubs of the players they bought.
Nishanth Ashok it's called buying the league utd have been doing it for years, the only reason their dominance stopped is cos other teams started doing it
@@StoutProper Oh yeah. How else do you propose to keep improving the squad? By using the same players? United have a long list of home-grown players who have become solid players for the club with some becoming legends of the game. You can't just say United bought the league and ignore the perseverance, the determination and the hard work the staff of the club (from the players to the manager and the coaches to say the least) put in to stay at the top.
If it is so easy to buy the league, then why haven't Chelsea or Arsenal done the same. They have the money power to do it too. To blindly say it's because United bought the league is disrespectful to the club.
As for the current situation at Manchester United, it's due to the lack of a clear path/plan that the club has suffered. The board of directors, the transfers, the fans, the poor recruitment (both with managers and the players), all have contributed to the failures that United is facing right now. You just can't say it's down to the money the club has spent over the years.
j d tick tock...just a matter of time before United challenge again.
Vilifying a player for moving to another club always seemed pathetic to me. Shall we remember all the great things he did for us? NO!! He moved to the F-in scum!!
Just calm down a bit. It's not your wife moving in with your best mate, its your mate moving to another company.
there's a difference between moving to a different team and saying "I'll never play for X team" and the next year moving to that team, specially if that team is a main rival. Just ask Mauro Zárate
@@applehack97
Lazio and Inter are not bitter rivals, they kinda "worked together" to stop Juventus in late 90's and early 2000's even though they weren't very successful in doing that. Even their fans get along as they both hated Juventus.
Also, Zarate's move from Lazio to Inter was just a loan deal and Inter was really low on cash at that time, very unlikely for Inter to properly buy Zarate.
Do you know any Leeds fans? Their level of hate for Man Utd has to be seen to be believed
@@HonestFarmerLigue1Fan I'm not talking about Inter and Lazio...
Smith was my childhood idol when he signed for United, I always tried to emulate his playing style of sliding tackle to unsettle defenses and he was probably the only striker in the world that does that. His endeavor and passion was always admirable. Thank you for this video TifoFootball.
It's a sad story. He loved this club and had its best interests in his heart, and his hand was forced. I'll never hold a grudge against him.
as a United fan I of course love him... he was member of my favourite squad of 06/07 ...and part of that most legendary match when we beat AS Roma 7-1 in Champions league quarter finals...
he was injured for so long people just stopped caring. i even forgot how good he once was.
Was never the same after the leg break
A video on Arsenal’s Alan Smith would be nice too most people know him as the commentator in FIFA video games but he was once a deadly striker. A video on his playing career and subsequently his commentary career would be nice :)
I think most fans realise that the Man Utd offer was indeed the only genuine one and money up front and not like most fees which are staggered. To think Smudge waived a signing on fee when Harry Kewell and his agent "stole" half of the transfer money shows that he did what he could. It wasn't his fault the club was mismanaged so badly. Any bitterness from fans should be reserved for Peter Ridsdale and the club's directors and so called accountants who allowed this to happen in the first place. "Living the dream".......
Alan Smith, the man who have guts to stop John Arne Riise's freekick
Who broke his leg
we loved him at united. what a good player he was for us
Shame about leeds. They were a good team but but were run so poorly. At there peak, smith, viduka, kewell and Bowyer were class
Yeah that leeds team was class
what about the life and crimes of the mighty Lee Cattermole
We'd need an entire Netflix documentary for that one mate!
1 day u may
🤣
As a Leeds fan, I loved Alan Smith. I was angry he left for our biggest rivals, but I know now that he took a bullet for our team. It didn’t help we went down that year, he was a good kid.
He would have been perfect for Bielsa's Leeds of today
likes 1,652, dislikes 10.... if you want to be a rebel, this is your chance!
Absolutely loved smudger, his style and tenacity was what was needed at that time, was truly gutted when he had his leg broke
It's such a shame thay Alan Smith had the misfortune he did with injuries, i think the leg break was the turning point. He was such an exciting player to watch and you always felt like something was going to happen when he was on the ball. I think that he could have been world class had the stars aligned for him.
Arsenal under arteta please tifo
Another great video as always! Would it be possible to do a video on the last time Leeds won the league title in 1991-92? Feel like its forgotten as it just missed the Premier League Era.
Videos like this highlight why some football fans are just bellends (and I can say that being a football fan myself)
All you have here is a guy who left one job/employer to join another, any hatred shown towards him is just childish and immature
It's like me hating Tesco employees just because I used to work at Sainsbury's 🤷♂️
Make a video on what happened to Fabio Coentrao please
Always tough to sign a player from the rivals! 💥
Remember when Riise broke his leg with the football
Another good video. Sol Campbells transfer to arsenal would be good one.
My English Teacher was a Leeds fan had Smith on a news paper clipping on his cupboard door... it vanished after the united transfer
Wolves fan here. I always really liked Alan Smith, reckon he would have gone a lot further in the game if it wasnt for THAT injury
The Flag Of Sodor At The Start
The best no.14 at united after Lord Lingard
I like him. Still have the Man Utd kit with his name & number at the back.
A very good story nice content I wish Harry Kewell had joined too 💯
Wait...WHAT?! Some Leeds players were making fucking how much back then?! £100,000 a week? Wages weren't that high in 2004 where they? What were Man Utds highest earners earning in that time? I remember in 2001 I think, Keane was the first ever player to earn over £50,000. What Leeds players were on £100,000 a week in 2004?
Make a video about away goals rules. It should be interesting
Judas. "He was trying to help the club!" Bugger off. Judas traitor could have went anywhere else to "help the club," but he wasn't the financial officer anyway, not his job to help the club.
@3.20 why does it show the Football League Championship Trophy and the Premier League Trophy? Leeds never won the former whilst Smith played for them, and they never won the latter, period
Reminds of when RVP signed for United. The anger that reverberated around the Arsenal fanbase was pretty strong!
I'm a Gooner and tbh, I didn't blame him and we got a good price. It said more about the club at the time than his character. He went and won the league when we had no chance so was the right move. Plus he was prone to injuries so there was always the possibility he could break down again.
@@alfredthegreat9543 I was more annoyed than angry - I fully understood his reasons but was just annoyed we couldn't hold onto him at his peak but certainly don't hold it against him and thank god it wasn't to City unlike some other players I could talk about
Stuck with him through countless injuries and left us in his prime as our captain when we were still competing for silverware. Gave me a lot of good memories but that one is still hard to get over. The fact it was to United made it hurt so much more. At least go overseas, the prick
Good morning everyone!:)
The blame lies with Ridsdale, 100%. Smith gave everything while he was at Leeds and was forced to leave. Can’t blame him for wanting CL football. Yes, I hate that he went to Man U of all clubs, but his heart was still in Leeds. I’d like to see him involved with the club again, for sure
Dear TIFO Football, can you make a video on why Manchester United and Leeds hated each other. from United overseas fan.
Tifo, you are wrong! Alan Smith served the public and himself by signing with Manchester United. Everyone did well in that deal. Leeds United F.C. got the monies they needed in the form of the transfer fee, and Smith's waived signing on bonus Alan Smith got a good chance to further his career, Manchester United fans had yet another chance to gloat, and Leeds supporters got the opportunity to feel sorry for themselves. Everyone's a winner.
I thought he was superb as a striker...No idea why he then became a midfielder...
Would never have happened had Leeds not collapsed. The fact it did, pure unbridled destiny. After that pretty much anything goes.
He scored 7 goals in 61 league games for Manchester United. Not really that good for a striker.
I will never know why SAF played this guy in midfield. He was an awesome striker and that along with his injuries killed his career.
He tried to convert him into a midfielder because he lost alot of pace after his ankle dislocation/break against Liverpool...
@@WayneCatlin I'm not convinced. Smith never had pace. It was his movement and finishing that made him a good striker.
saf envisioned his tenacity as the new Roy Keane
@@paddymcdougle
He was never a striker that got in behind defenders, he dropped deep and linked up play, he was very good at passing, never chose the wrong pass. I think he could have been a midfielder anyway - with or without that injury. But he definitely lost movement after that injury, he never looked as fast or as agile...
@@WayneCatlin
SAF tried to convert him before the injury though. He should have stayed up front.
Alan Smith would have called nurse F***king Hell when he was getting born 😂
Reality is that Man United offered money Leeds were in no position to turn down. For Smith, being the player who helped bury the club would have been a fate far worse than Old Trafford.
Leeds is a rugby town. It's no surprise that their football team is basically a feeder club for United.
As a mufc fan, he should never have signed for us, he was a hardworking good player, no doubt. But he was Leeds and I hated him, in my opinion he disrespected the rivalry, local lads going to rivals shouldn't be done in my opinion.
Unlike the other vulture clubs that hovered around Leeds at the time only Man U we willing to pay cash and not spread the deal over years. When the club made it known that they wanted cash other clubs weren't interested. Newcastle took Woodgate and Milner on the never, never. Spurs got Robinson for a cut fee and payment over time. Liverpool got Kewell and Kewell and his agent got most of the fee that should have been paid to us. We didn't get much for Viduka because Risdale had signed him on a lease agreement and most of the lease had not been paid so the lease company got most of the fee.
Apart from Kewell most of the players had little or no choice because of the financial incompetence of Risdale who in my opinion should be told he is banned for life from ever attending Elland Road again.
"And subsequently sold everyone out" isnt a fair thing to say. They were desperate for money and sold him to Man United. If Leeds were doing ok and he handed in a transfer request to go to United or ran his contract down like Sol Campbell then ok you could say that but it was a good deal for everyone concerned. It even helped Leeds not to actually end up being liquidated so the supporters wouldn't even have a club anymore and that was a genuine threat at the time. I just think its harsh that he was painted as a villain
United gave us the money and we need needed it....I have nothing against Smudger, he’s still my favourite ever player
Also the tears at full time were against Bolton not charlton
but Alan Smith joined Arsenal from Leicester
Different one
massively overrated player, Viduka was the real deal, and Keane was also much better
As a little girl I loved Alan Smith and as a leeds fan I was born to hate scum!! Smith leaving was heartbreaker and signing on my birthday just tops it, I get why he did it but still find it hard to watch.
why do leeds fans hate man utd ? do utd fans hate leeds? they never really had a rivalry on the pitch except maybe early 90's briefly, but if you win the league you're gonna have a rival, aston villa were good around that time for example, is it just cos they are sort of in the same part of the country? or is it about cantona?
Im embarrassed as football fan by some so called fans who can only think of "their" club. Anyone in his position would move on to a bigger club given the chance. If a waiter gets a better job offer they go and no one thinks anything of it 😅
One of my favourite ever utd players 🇾🇪
As a player he was amazing and he’s an even better commentator with Martin Tyler!
I was thinking earlier. Was Alan Smith better for man utd than Jesse Lingard has been throughout his united career? What do ye think
He definitely put his career before the club but we needed money fast and Man Utd were the only ones willing to cough up. The fact they paid in full rather than installments says it all. So he saved the club through his betrayal
Me getting ready to here Alan Smith and Martin Tyler
Narrator: nah g this is just the b tech Alan Smith here
Me being disappointed
Fuck me this broke my city. Properly hurt us all, as a young kid of 9 at the time I was distraught
One thing we must learn as a football fan is that never ever believe what a footballer says. It's their career and money is involved. Just enjoy them while they are at your club. If they ever join a rival club, have to be subjective and see what is the reason. No hard feelings at the end of the day.
I love him but you cant escape the fact that Alan Smith looked like the douche guy in every American movie ever.
Good player. Riise fucking killed him.
was his united career what was expected? or was he a high potential player back then when he was bought? like a grealish right now? or did he have a lesser potential?
Rio is a bigger Judas than Smith
smith was my fav, i was a leeds fan before i became a newcastle fan. am happy both of my teams smith played for them. though he was finished by the time he played for nufc
No deal is worth doing that for Smithy lad. Crying into the shirt then signs for the rivals. Poor form.
That sale could of basically saved use but kissing the badge smithy shameless on you!
When he joined Utd he was my favourite, along with Park and Solskjear. Great player!
Why are you gay?
Tifo Tifo Tifo !!!! And the fans are in uproar and delirium!!!
He was never the same after breaking his leg
Is any club more hated than Leeds? I bet he couldn’t wait to leave Leeds.
My uncle got scouted with alan Smith for Leeds and they were in the same class
Alan Smith is overrated. Change my mind.
Only one Alan Smith . Gunners goalscorer in thec 80ts .
MOT ALAW NORWAY 💙💛
Arsenal fans check out my recent to see more about more about your transfer target edouard
Since Allan smith left I have always hated players they have no loyalty it’s only the fans that stay
CF to CM to Notts County