DON’T BUY ONE OF THESE! Universal Audio Vs Focusrite

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 21 ноя 2024

Комментарии • 479

  • @EdThorne
    @EdThorne  2 года назад +9

    ➡SPECS & COMPARISON CHART: edthorne.com/exclusive-content ⬅
    🔥Get your tracks mixed by Ed: edthorne.com/mixing 🔥
    🎬 Best Interface For Mixing! This HP Amp is Insane!: ruclips.net/video/n0fyFRl2R24/видео.html
    🎬 Scarlett 4th Generation vs 3rd Gen: ruclips.net/video/_LDDzsxp1a0/видео.html

  • @Hermiel
    @Hermiel 2 года назад +461

    In 2022 sound quality is basically a wash. The preamps and converters on these things are 95% identical from a utility standpoint. Write and record great music and don't spend any energy on which sounds marginally better. Your listeners certainly won't care.

    • @EdThorne
      @EdThorne  2 года назад +112

      Can’t argue with that. Music listeners won’t but RUclips viewers definitely will 😜🤘

    • @Hermiel
      @Hermiel 2 года назад +21

      @@EdThorne Ha, fair enough.

    • @Neil-Aspinall
      @Neil-Aspinall 2 года назад +4

      Too true Hermy

    • @mangadolo
      @mangadolo 2 года назад +10

      To be honest with you…. I think music sounds better when it feels/sounds a bit antiquated.

    • @ponternal
      @ponternal 2 года назад +54

      The Focusrite is better because my favourite color is red

  • @thomashambrecht6435
    @thomashambrecht6435 2 года назад +69

    We use multiple Scarlett 2i2 for audio editing at multiple locations. We record with several 8-channel RME, Focusrite and Presonus. There isn't a big difference.

    • @juanmejiar
      @juanmejiar 2 года назад +2

      you are right, i have also tried several including rme, apollo, ssl and focusrite never failed me in terms of software and durability, it has gotten me out of trouble many times.

    • @masterr2667
      @masterr2667 2 года назад +5

      yes , i sold my apollo 8 quad , for a scarlett focusrite and i have been able to get better sound out of the scarlett than before when it works with other top interfaces on the market , i have learned through 30 years of producing career that sometimes one as a producer is it limits a lot in musical productions or in post-production for audiovisuals, when using a certain piece of equipment in an ecosystem as closed as that of apollo and I cannot exploit the full potential of a musical production, for my focusrite it has not failed me in compatibility, software , resistance to take it wherever you want without worrying about damaging it , for my focusrite very reliable.

    • @juanmusic8806
      @juanmusic8806 2 года назад +2

      Yes the scarlett focusrite is the best interface of the market

    • @IgneelS11
      @IgneelS11 2 года назад

      what about latency?

    • @davidvicars6688
      @davidvicars6688 2 года назад +1

      @@IgneelS11 I would like to know this as well.

  • @spikesguitarcamp
    @spikesguitarcamp 2 года назад +36

    I'm listening on studio monitors, and I have to say that the Scarlett "Air Mode" was my favorite, and I really couldn't hear a difference between the two "dry" modes". The "vintage" mode actually sounded a little dull. These are obviously just my opinions.

    • @dr34m-r20
      @dr34m-r20 2 года назад +2

      The air mode is just an eq. U can put it manually. It isnt equal to isa one preamp

    • @spikesguitarcamp
      @spikesguitarcamp 2 года назад +3

      @@dr34m-r20 And your point is?

    • @dominicmcmahon4798
      @dominicmcmahon4798 2 года назад +10

      @@spikesguitarcamp his point is .. if you have a daw then you can simply eq it in to sound like air for free. So it's a trashy gimmick of no real value.

  • @TractorMonkeywithJL
    @TractorMonkeywithJL 2 года назад +20

    What's with the "Don't buy one these in the title"? For click bait? Sounds like you gave them both a good review.

    • @ritchski1
      @ritchski1 18 дней назад

      I was wondering the same thing. silliness.

  • @DuaneDouglas
    @DuaneDouglas Год назад +17

    I chose to get the Volt over the Scarlett because of the MIDI jacks and on/off switch. Those extra features determined my choice.

  • @lyniseuk
    @lyniseuk 2 года назад +17

    Alot of these budget sound interfaces contain similar chip sets. The main difference is in features and build quality. My point is they are all good at this budget end.

    • @EdThorne
      @EdThorne  2 года назад +6

      Compared to 10-15 years ago, the low cost interfaces available now are unreal, especially for the price!

    • @jackedkerouac4414
      @jackedkerouac4414 2 года назад

      That being said my Scarlett Solo 3rd gen has excellent build quality. The knobs feel just as solid as my $1000 dj mixer

  • @macmovieman1
    @macmovieman1 Год назад +11

    I am a very basic user, and I love my Scarlet 2i2 and I never really did a research to see whether there were other brands for available. It seems to work really well for my vocals, guitar and speakers.

    • @O_pai_fpv
      @O_pai_fpv Год назад

      for most users, I believe the scarlett line is perfectly fine. As an audio engineer though, I've had my share of problems with their interfaces from the old sapphire to the scarletts. I actually own a scarlett 4i4 that lives in my backpack as a backup.
      There are a lot of other brands available and quite a few quality "entry level" products like the scarlett. Audient is an excellent option, in my opinion

    • @brucerain2106
      @brucerain2106 10 месяцев назад

      @@O_pai_fpvwhat kind of problems did you have with Scarlett?

  • @rebeccaschade3987
    @rebeccaschade3987 2 года назад +44

    To me, the midi-interface on the Volt makes it a much more attractive option than the Scarlett 2i2. I don't get why so many budget interfaces have dropped midi these days. There are plenty of musicians out there still using synthesizers without USB, so not having midi on the audio interface means having to spend extra money on a dedicated midi-interface. That's like a €60 added value if we go by the price of a Roland USB midi interface.

    • @CrashTestSkater
      @CrashTestSkater 2 года назад +2

      Oh waow, thanks for the tip man! My particular situation actually would have required that anyhow, so much appreciated ❤️

    • @gaetanobruno5889
      @gaetanobruno5889 2 года назад +3

      nowadays, you can buy a MIDI-USB cable for 5 bucks only. its very easy, plug and play and same latency. but i get your point.

    • @LTPottenger
      @LTPottenger Год назад

      Yes and my synth cost 600 bucks so I don't want to bin it or buy a new one that's twice the price and half as good, which is the other option.

    • @iainmcguire7190
      @iainmcguire7190 Год назад +1

      @@LTPottenger why would you bin it, when a USB to midi adapter is a very cheap purchase?

  • @gazzyb85
    @gazzyb85 9 месяцев назад +4

    Volt is better, and my opinion is better than most😜

  • @ManWatchingtheStars
    @ManWatchingtheStars 2 года назад +35

    I have both and I noticed right away that the Line Out from the Volt 2 to my Neumann KH120 monitors had a different sound. Mostly rounder, with the highs less crispy than what I heard from the Scarlett. I also really love the premium feel to the Volt 2 knobs and the lights that indicate the audio output peaking/loudness.

    • @PNWGuitar
      @PNWGuitar Год назад

      Any differences between the volt 2 and volt 276?

    • @EdThorne
      @EdThorne  Год назад +3

      @PNWGuitar The compressor…

  • @glennusher4160
    @glennusher4160 2 года назад +51

    All Interfacers are great.. I've been in many studios and seen the top and best Producers use the cheapest interfaces and make hits.. It's mostly about the Mics, the Plugin and the hardware they have connected to it. i use the Presonus Studio One and also the Apollo..

    • @koltonjacobs6584
      @koltonjacobs6584 2 года назад +3

      Also speakers

    • @andysixxlett2632
      @andysixxlett2632 2 года назад +8

      The song matters most…..a bad song is bad regardless of how it’s recorded

    • @taylorcliff6609
      @taylorcliff6609 2 года назад +15

      @@andysixxlett2632 not entirely true. ive been in sessions where the artist has layed down some terrible songs come back the next day and somehow the engineer made it into a banger. people dont give engineers anywhere near enough credit for what comes out today. 90% of the top artists have fairly terrible vocals, the amount of live performances ive been to that just sound so bad compared to the studio mix is crazy. its almost like all the talent these days is in the mix and mastering side not the actual performance of it.

    • @taylorcliff6609
      @taylorcliff6609 2 года назад +5

      @@JohannesLabusch dont ever think that being part of an older generation means there is no merit to your wisdom. there is no such thing as a grumpy old man, only ignorant young people have made that a term. as a fresh 30 yr old i see it from both sides and can say with confidence that i want someone older sitting in my sessions. not only for their expertise but also their life wisdom. ive been in recording sessions with a lot of dudes coming into their 50s and 60s and its such a good experience. they are patient and genuinely show more love for the art no matter what. ive sat there with young producers and engineers who refused to do what i want/ask because they have this weird chip on their shoulder. the older guys didnt care, they listened to my bulshit for 8 hours and a complete album was the bi product of being made comfortable.
      much love to you.
      sorry for the tangent.

    • @PendelSteven
      @PendelSteven 2 года назад

      Actually, the features on the interface are the most important: do you need SP/DIF? MIDI? Amp out? ADAT? And for some: software that comes with it.

  • @fred4664
    @fred4664 2 года назад +23

    The volt has a separate power supply which is necessary when connecting to an I pad since the I pad doesn’t have enough power to run the Volt 2. That was the deciding factor for me in purchasing another brand. Being a novice recorder I’m starting with Garage Band as a DAW.

    • @EdThorne
      @EdThorne  2 года назад +1

      Good shout. This is a detail to forgot to mention in the video. I believe the iPad Pro is powerful enough to power both devices though.

    • @gkiss2030
      @gkiss2030 2 года назад

      That sucks.
      UA put out bus-powered interfaces in the past (Arrow, Apollo Solo).

    • @EdThorne
      @EdThorne  2 года назад

      @@gkiss2030 This is bus powered….

    • @raulgarcia1718
      @raulgarcia1718 2 года назад +6

      You can use a powered usb hub to power both the iPad and audio interface

  • @ISOwav
    @ISOwav 2 года назад +12

    Great video, but this comment section is gold in terms of thoughts on the interfaces, really informative

  • @sonofnothing
    @sonofnothing Год назад +6

    As expected, extremely close.
    What matters more?
    1. PERFORMANCE
    2. Mic choice
    3. Mic placement
    4. Room

    • @EdThorne
      @EdThorne  Год назад

      Very true. Plus: 5. Instrument. 6. Player. 7. Gain Structure. 8. Mixing. 9. The Song. 10. Mastering

  • @juliussharrock8943
    @juliussharrock8943 2 года назад +15

    As the owner of a 16i20. Cannot say enough good things about Focusrite. Record rappers, drum
    Kits, full bands and use outboard mixer in conjunction. Great company. Great piece of kit - it never leaves my top rack mount on the desk itself!

  • @hostilekeldon
    @hostilekeldon 2 года назад +23

    It depends on the use, for portability, a USB powered interface seems better to me, and the converters nowadays are much less the weak link in your chain than a decade or two ago, plus all of them come with nice software. and External DSP importance is falling two with the newer Ryzen and M1 chips anyway, depending on the price difference I can really relate on buying a UAD device, so for low budget I'd go for Focusrite, for mid a UAD Volt, for small device but better budget, an RME most likely.

  • @hamricmike8
    @hamricmike8 Год назад +5

    For me, the only negative about the Volt 2 is that it doesn't have line inputs, it's only mic/instrument inputs. So if I want to connect my outboard tube preamp and compressor, I would have to route it in some way that changes those line-level outputs into mic or instrument-level signals going into the interface which I don't really want to do. It's cool that the Volt has MIDI in/out but most MIDI stuff these days are USB so I probably wouldn't use them. Both seem like great choices but I'm leaning slightly toward the Scarlett for what I need.

    • @EdThorne
      @EdThorne  Год назад +2

      So get the Volt 4 👌

    • @TheTimidPimp
      @TheTimidPimp Год назад +2

      According to this video, you can use line level inputs. Basically, just turn off the INST and 48V buttons.
      ruclips.net/video/0D0sp3gnYRM/видео.html

  • @mikesmith1290
    @mikesmith1290 2 года назад +13

    The biggest difference for me when I upgraded my 2i2 1st gen to the Apollo X Twin was the mic pre. My scarlet couldn’t really preamp my sm57 that well. Then I’d have to run it thru an eq and compressor, etc
    With the Apollo, I run the compressor on the unison preamp, eq to the mix and done.

    • @EdThorne
      @EdThorne  2 года назад

      Yeh man. The Apollos are so powerful if you use them like you are!

    • @thomasaudio8585
      @thomasaudio8585 2 года назад

      Use mine the same way, absolutely love it. Won't be looking back for sure.

    • @AB-wy7dr
      @AB-wy7dr Год назад

      Sorry can someone explain more what makes the Apollo X Twin so much better for 5x the price? Thanks!

  • @apg91
    @apg91 Год назад +2

    I'm buying the Volt 1 because all I need is a DAC with volume control and balance output. Having a separate power then the USB is a big advantage if you are using it in a USBSwitch

  • @RogerZoul
    @RogerZoul 2 года назад +5

    What amazes me is how good everything in this video sounds on my iPhone 11 Pro at 4 inches from my face! I have the Scarlett and am happy with it for my simple needs. Nice vid!

    • @larryvaughn5843
      @larryvaughn5843 2 года назад +2

      I use some Yamaha studio monitors and the sound is much better than when it comes from a tiny speaker.

  • @ROCKNROLLMODS
    @ROCKNROLLMODS 2 года назад +4

    I just purchased a volt interface on a whim. I figured "I can finally afford a universal audio product" seems like it might have been a good choice. Hopefully when the Sweetwater delivery gets here I'll have a similar experience

    • @ItsTheMajorScalebro
      @ItsTheMajorScalebro 2 года назад

      How is it?

    • @ROCKNROLLMODS
      @ROCKNROLLMODS 2 года назад

      @@ItsTheMajorScalebro works great I use a 16 ch tascam for tracking. For some reason it seems like overdubs periodically get out of sync. I think the 16 channels has just got the processor too busy. So I use the UA for overdubs, and it sounds better than the tascam's pre's. Definitely the best mic preamps I have used aboard an inexpensive interface.

  • @jitterbugzombies6441
    @jitterbugzombies6441 2 года назад +3

    I recorded my album using a cheap m-audio from 2005 and published in 2017 in vinyl, everybody was amazed by the sound. Get a cheap sound card, but just don't buy the cheapest and don't go too crazy about it. Focus on making good music.

  • @lolilollolilol7773
    @lolilollolilol7773 2 года назад +12

    I have always read very good feedback on the Roland audio interfaces, in particular the Quad and Octa-Capture. It would be nice to have a review of them.

    • @juanmejiar
      @juanmejiar 2 года назад +2

      I have used the octa-capture it is very good, it has a very balanced sound with good definition, but after a while the buttons began to fail, I ended up selling it

    • @juanmusic8806
      @juanmusic8806 2 года назад +1

      I did not like it, and it is true the buttons are of poor quality

  • @ORACLEBALL
    @ORACLEBALL 2 года назад +9

    I've owned the scarlett 2i2 for 10 years now, 1st gen. Believe me, I've ran that thing through its paces, gotten to know if very well, and beat this crap out of it, taking it everywhere with me. It still works perfectly fine, and I still use it from time to time in a crunch and as a traveling interface. That thing is reliable.
    On the contrary a few years ago I upgraded to the Audient ID44. I now run my home studio with that hooked up to 2 asp800's. I remember the day I swapped out the scarlett for that interface, my jaw dropped. My speakers sounded better (I still have my speakers, krk gen 3 rokit 5's, I know them like the scarlett), the inputs are insanely clean, noise floor super low, headphones sound better, and my sub pac went from feeling fluffy to tight like a sub woofer.
    As nice as those things are, I can still work with the scarlett anywhere and feel confident working.
    Universal Audio is a great company and I love their products, but I thought there was some value to be said about the longevity of those scarlett's.

    • @Pavelkozhin
      @Pavelkozhin 2 года назад

      As for your words, the difference in sound, it looks very
      contrived

    • @ORACLEBALL
      @ORACLEBALL 2 года назад

      @@Pavelkozhin yes I'm sponsored by focusrite 😂

    • @Pavelkozhin
      @Pavelkozhin 2 года назад

      @@ORACLEBALL I get your joke, yes. I think marketing is doing its job, just

    • @ORACLEBALL
      @ORACLEBALL 2 года назад +2

      @@Pavelkozhin By no means do I live or die by any company, just sharing my experience. I'm not familiar with any of these companies making durability a main marketing tool of their products - which was my main point.

    • @Pavelkozhin
      @Pavelkozhin 2 года назад

      @@ORACLEBALL I mean, our perception of the sound of any equipment is influenced by too many parameters - design, price, even the name, which can be more pleasant or more harsh. All this deceives our senses. If you test the audio paths of your sound cards, the frequency response will be plus or minus 1 dB or less at the ends of the range, which our ears almost never hear.

  • @LEGEND.408
    @LEGEND.408 Год назад +3

    Switched from focustite to volt hella better now I got no problems at all

  • @keithbutler2222
    @keithbutler2222 Год назад +5

    I got the volt 2 and it sounded great, but after a while drop outs and outages would creep in. I exchanged it for another model, thinking it faulty...same problem. I've swapped it for the Focusrite which I've worked to death for the last two days...no issues

    • @TurtlesWithAutism
      @TurtlesWithAutism Год назад

      Did you try updating firmware and driver?

    • @keithbutler2222
      @keithbutler2222 Год назад

      @@TurtlesWithAutism yes all of those...I replaced the unit too

    • @black_deus
      @black_deus Год назад

      @@keithbutler2222funny, I’m having this issue but with w a focus rite

    • @keithbutler2222
      @keithbutler2222 Год назад

      @@black_deus oh that's a shame...clicks pops and dropouts?

  • @LeeLimerick
    @LeeLimerick 2 года назад +3

    Cheers Ed, finally sat down and had a watch. I gotta do something about that double-chin! Nice to catch up and hang out mate :)

    • @EdThorne
      @EdThorne  2 года назад +1

      Ha. I didn’t even notice, I was too mesmerised by your playing 😘 Thanks again for playing in the video!

  • @mawo1096
    @mawo1096 2 года назад +8

    Scarlett sounded clearer and more musical for me.

  • @nejih1323
    @nejih1323 2 года назад +10

    A comparison like this between the volt 2 and the audient or the SSL 2 would be awesome. I can't decide between those as a guitarist/vocalist and the volt seems quite complete with all the midi stuff added

    • @EdThorne
      @EdThorne  2 года назад +3

      This video is in production, featuring those interfaces and the M2. Be out next Tuesday hopefully.

    • @Lovingdeadboy
      @Lovingdeadboy 2 года назад +4

      Due to the A Class Preamp in Audient's Interfaces you should expect a better/ sweeter/ preciser amplification on your microphones with their id series

    • @gkiss2030
      @gkiss2030 2 года назад +1

      @@Lovingdeadboy
      I really like m iD4 MKII.
      Even though I have UA Twin X next to it (the converters are more precise on that one, but the sound is more sterile).

    • @Lovingdeadboy
      @Lovingdeadboy 2 года назад

      @@gkiss2030 absolutely agree, i got an ApolloX8 to get clear daad through my externals RVBs and stuff. Absolutely in love with their DAC applied on my Monitor output and their unisson technology on my inputs

    • @gkiss2030
      @gkiss2030 2 года назад

      @@Lovingdeadboy They a price for it, but it shows.

  • @Ixiom64
    @Ixiom64 2 года назад +8

    All depends on how you use what you got. I've been using a 1st gen Scarlett solo for almost 10 years and still can get the sound I need

    • @leonardodicaprio5676
      @leonardodicaprio5676 2 года назад

      do you use it for electric guitar? if so, is it a good audio interface?

  • @mudi2000a
    @mudi2000a 2 года назад +4

    In this comparison the Arturia Minifuse is missing. I have it and it is cheaper than the other 2 plus it has a mixer for direct monitoring as well as an integrated USB hub. It also works fine on the iPad Air without the need of an additional power supply.

    • @EdThorne
      @EdThorne  2 года назад +2

      I reached to Arturia but never heard back.

  • @saplouie
    @saplouie Год назад +5

    If you need the Midi then definitely go with the Volt. I already have multiple usb midi controllers, but I know many people with electric pianos that only have the midi out option. Price wise, I've always found that the Focusrite was a bit cheaper. For example, Amazon has the 2i2 for 148 and the Volt 2 for 163 right now.

  • @allendean9807
    @allendean9807 2 года назад +3

    Love my 4i4. Though i did have a 2i2 through about 3 generations. Very good interfaces.

  • @johnwinslow8841
    @johnwinslow8841 Год назад +2

    Using budget studio headphones, I turned my head to not know which of the two were being used under a dry signal. The volt sounded better to my ears.

  • @mdsoulsounds
    @mdsoulsounds Год назад +2

    Thanks for your clear direct and honest review. You ran it down very well. Only Focusrite set back for me was the old usb female input which has finally completely stopped working. Even with Focusrite changing to gen 3 usb c input , I want to try the Volt now .

  • @maxborbass
    @maxborbass Год назад +4

    Thank you very much for this great review: not only I was able to hear a clear demo comparison, like the guitar one you did, but also the technical comparison was very clear and informative. This and other reviews help me choosing between the two (I got a Volt).

    • @EdThorne
      @EdThorne  Год назад +3

      Oh, wow! You’re my first Super Like donator - THANK YOU very much!! I’m glad the video helped 🙂🤘

    • @Geoswich
      @Geoswich Год назад +1

      ​@@EdThorne which is better for vocals , please I need to know?

    • @EdThorne
      @EdThorne  Год назад +1

      As with all audio products, it’s how you use. An interface doesn’t discriminate against different instruments. However, the compressor on the Volt 276 and Vintage mode on this model do enhance vocals nicely.

  • @rikyriky966
    @rikyriky966 Год назад +1

    Instead of these two, I just bought a MOTU M2 (v2 - after 2021 version) and I am SOOOO HAPPPYY with it

  • @siquierostreaming5620
    @siquierostreaming5620 2 года назад +4

    I just buy a unite of Universal Audio Volt 476 and his sound is amazing! on the headphones sounds clear and louder than previos Focusritte i had (clarett 8 pre).

    • @gibson2623
      @gibson2623 2 года назад +1

      The carett 8 pre is much better, on another league.....Ignorant

  • @justinbouchard
    @justinbouchard 2 года назад +6

    I used a scarlet solo for years, the headphone monitor out wasn't working for about a year and I just replaced it with a behringer umc204hd. The difference in sound quality was shocking to me. The behringer was so much clearer and seemed to be more dynamic as well, guitar and mic. Also the amount of i/o and options on this compared to any other brand at the same price is not even comparable.

    • @justinbouchard
      @justinbouchard 2 года назад +2

      something that I thought after using it for about a week or so is that focusrite is the "apple" of interfaces and behringer is the android, i have no idea where UA fits in but it's too expensive for me anyways lol

    • @Boysoundtechniques
      @Boysoundtechniques 2 года назад +2

      @@justinbouchard I disagree, i believe M-Track Duo sounds way better than the UMC absolutely

    • @Boysoundtechniques
      @Boysoundtechniques 2 года назад

      @@justinbouchard It does not only record a little bit clearer but also improves a lot on the low end.

    • @justinbouchard
      @justinbouchard 2 года назад +2

      @@Boysoundtechniques how bored are you? This video was comparing Scarlett to UA audio volt, my comment compared my Scarlett to my umc 204. I have no idea what m track duo is, nor how you somehow took my comment and created this scenario in your head where I compared anything to an m track audio.

    • @justinbouchard
      @justinbouchard 2 года назад

      @@Boysoundtechniques I had to look it up. I cannot believe you're coming here out of fucking nowhere comparing an Amazon interface to Behringer.
      Clean your house or something if your this bored.

  • @666thsense
    @666thsense 2 года назад +3

    the scarlett is a stellar dac though, even outshining some of the actual dedicated dacs in the audiophile world, how does the volt hold up as a dac when just listening to music through it? because quality out will let you also have quality in.

    • @macseigel7295
      @macseigel7295 2 года назад +1

      The Scarlett uses the same mass produced converter chips as every other budget interface in the world. Those are every bit as good as most top-of-the-line DACs from 20 years ago, so it's nothing to complain about, but I wouldn't call it a meaningful difference.

  • @ReinQuest
    @ReinQuest 2 года назад +2

    Your really selling the Volt for me. I’m coming from a Yeti looking to upgrade so I might be able to break into VO work. The yeti is great for its intended use but it falls short when you start wishing your budget could fit a 416. 🤣

  • @luciano.armani
    @luciano.armani 2 года назад +2

    ive found the scarlett to work great on mac but be HORRIBLE on windows. all sorts of artifacts and bs. i wonder how the UA is regarding that.

  • @davidfabien7220
    @davidfabien7220 Год назад +4

    In my opinion, the UA VOLT sounds slightly more musical than the Focusrite Scarlett.

  • @Bashanvibe
    @Bashanvibe 2 года назад +2

    Ok so I was debating on these two beast interface for live performance using AL after watching this I think I’m going to stick with Focusrite I already have a twin as my main set up!!!

  • @trentfranks4507
    @trentfranks4507 2 года назад +12

    I feel like the volt having midi capabilities also is a solid for it. The new Scarlett 2i2 does not.

  •  2 года назад +8

    Why does the caption say "don't buy" them?

  • @jcm5888
    @jcm5888 2 года назад +4

    Great information source. I'm a novice and I independently narrowed my choices to the Volt and Focusrite but wanted an expert opinion...........this is where ED came in. Do you have a more detailed video of either?

    • @EdThorne
      @EdThorne  2 года назад +1

      Thanks, Jorge. I’m glad the video was helpful. I have a whole playlist of interface reviews and comparisons, including many videos featuring these two: ruclips.net/p/PLPGp5cq-hMjzcuVrYrnbZUbZ39nqFWpeb

  • @seabreeze2792
    @seabreeze2792 2 года назад +3

    Focusrite is used by every you tuber you watch. They have become THE industry standard. Good build quality. throw it in your lap top case and travel the world. 2i2 will never leave you with your Richard in your hand.

    • @EdThorne
      @EdThorne  2 года назад

      Love this comment!

    • @edgardometal
      @edgardometal 2 года назад +1

      Scarlett sound really... mmm artificial for me... Volt wins

  • @lojibaybee
    @lojibaybee 10 месяцев назад +1

    Just bought the scarlet sound is bomb air mode is cool but i always prefer a low down dirty heavy thick old school vocal that’s volt provides

  • @Dante-qf9yd
    @Dante-qf9yd 2 года назад +6

    I would like to see the Volt compared to the more expensive Apogee Symphony Desktop in quality of sound. I have an older Apogee that might not be compatible with the MacBook M1 Max I’m getting, so I’m interested in a really good interface.

    • @EdThorne
      @EdThorne  2 года назад +4

      They’re in very different price leagues. An Apogee/Apollo might be a fairer comparison. I’ve reached out to Apogee’s distributors a few times about reviews to no avail…

    • @Dante-qf9yd
      @Dante-qf9yd 2 года назад +2

      @@EdThorne They know that you will tell the truth about their products. That Volt might be good in sound as my older Apogee interface. I’ll be able to find out this summer. I already heard the Scarlet 2i2 yesterday. My Apogee sounds better, but not $1,000.00 better. Good mixing skills would make them equal. My Apogee just sounds bigger in frequency.

  • @doremind1
    @doremind1 2 года назад +3

    i bought the Steinberg one...perfect.

  • @Gretsch0997
    @Gretsch0997 Год назад +4

    I don’t get the title of the video.

  • @rolo8436
    @rolo8436 2 года назад +2

    I have been very happy with my behringer U-PHORIA UMC204HD which cost half as much money as these 2 and so quiet and much better than the Presonas Firestudio which I had before - it was very noisy

  • @judsonchristudas
    @judsonchristudas 29 дней назад

    Which of these have good preamps for Electric Guitar for recording Heavy Metal?

  • @kanaille7485
    @kanaille7485 9 месяцев назад +1

    hi , i've just purchased the volt176 and it's for me the best choice for the budget , Ed thx for the cool contents .

    • @EdThorne
      @EdThorne  9 месяцев назад

      That’s great! Glad you’re enjoying it!

  • @mikerammel8731
    @mikerammel8731 2 года назад +1

    The focusrite solo third gen, is awesome I love it.

  • @mitchdodgemusic
    @mitchdodgemusic 2 года назад +2

    I personally had a weird experience with the Volt - and it’s intermittent… but my tempo when playing back various audio through either Spotify, Music (iTunes), or even Ableton. The interface will actually slow the tempo down when playing back audio as normal… I had never actually had this problem before // haven’t seen anyone else post about it with the Volt - previously had the Motu M4 and never had an issue like this.

    • @jacc4928
      @jacc4928 Год назад

      Super old comment but I have this issue with my Scarlet all the time! It slows it down to almost comedic lengths so I have to restart spotify

  • @drewb9022
    @drewb9022 2 года назад +4

    I have the Scarlett 2i2, and honestly considering switching to the UA Volt 2, I'm dealing with a ground loop buzz issue with the Scarlett going into my THR30ii amp, I'm hoping with the Volt 2, having its own 5vDC power port, ordered a Ground Loop Noise Isolator, but I'm worried it'll some how color the audio some how so I'm thinking about being sure and just making the switch, that is, if having a power source that isn't through the same cable the audio source is coming through, would fix that.

    • @alldayhiphop6537
      @alldayhiphop6537 Год назад

      Did it ever work?

    • @drewb9022
      @drewb9022 Год назад

      @@alldayhiphop6537 Yes, the BESIGN Ground Loop Noise Isolator, surprisingly worked.

  • @stuartewoldt1513
    @stuartewoldt1513 Год назад +1

    The volt 2 sounds better I've owned both but I screwed up. When you put those together it sounded great

  • @KordTaylor
    @KordTaylor 2 года назад +1

    Nice video. Thank you. It was great hearing the Air circuit on acoustic. Really nice. And also the Austrian mic was mmmmmm. 🔥

  • @Rowe4900candymachine
    @Rowe4900candymachine 2 года назад +1

    Another bonus is if the volt's cable breaks you can actually find usb-c cables easily.
    edit:Nevermind I was thinking about an older version of it.

    • @adainjarrio
      @adainjarrio 2 года назад

      They're both USB-C though.

    • @Rowe4900candymachine
      @Rowe4900candymachine 2 года назад +1

      @@adainjarrio I was thinking about the older version I own thanks for pointing that out.

  • @kaivrock
    @kaivrock 2 года назад +2

    I’d add that all these little boxes in this price range are the same. Scarlett, MOTU, Volt, Presonus, Behringer, just take your pick. You’re not going to get anything noticeably better without going into the 7-800 dollar range.

    • @EdThorne
      @EdThorne  2 года назад

      For the most part, yes. Whatever UA have done with the Volt though does give it the edge sonically.

  • @TuMalditaMadre
    @TuMalditaMadre 2 года назад

    The monitor outs on the Volt interfaces are also CV gates.

  • @Gratomiccom
    @Gratomiccom 2 года назад +2

    I need high loudness
    What sound card do you suggest for very high loudness??
    I do not need sound card for record!!
    And I mostly need a sound card that is good for mixing and mastering
    Especially for loudness
    Please guide me to buy a suitable sound card
    thank you❤❤

    • @EdThorne
      @EdThorne  2 года назад +1

      For mastering you probably want the best conversion possible. Loudness isn’t really an issue, all interfaces have loud line-outputs. It’s the dynamic range of the converters that’s important. The Black Lion Audio Revolution and Antelope Zen series have great converters. Or go for a specialist DAC unit.

    • @Gratomiccom
      @Gratomiccom 2 года назад +1

      @@EdThorne thank you
      Now I know what to look for
      Thank you so much

  • @psychoslingers8732
    @psychoslingers8732 2 года назад +5

    I’ve used both, for whatever reason I just stuck with my Scarlett, it’s a pretty solid work-horse considering. I do run the Beringher headphone amplifier with it cause it def lacks control/volume but for the most part and price considered, they’ll get it done. (Especially if you know how to mix/master well).

    • @Geoswich
      @Geoswich Год назад

      Which do you prefer for vocals recording quality?

  • @BlakeMlungisi
    @BlakeMlungisi 2 года назад +2

    Hi. I think you mistakenly sais iOS instead of macOS. There are devices supported on iOS and that can be quite confusing.

    • @EdThorne
      @EdThorne  2 года назад +2

      Volt is supported on iOS iPhones and iPads 👌

  • @MikaelKonradsson
    @MikaelKonradsson Год назад +1

    I bought a Scarlett 2i4 First gen back when I wanted to get into making music maybe 6-7 years ago, but I have not really started yet since other life stuff got in the way. Now I feel very excited and motivated to finally learn about music production et.c. In todays standards, does my old 2i4 1st gen "hold up" to todays interfaces or do I need to upgrade to something like these ones? Its obviously for budget home studio use and mostly used to record D.I guitars+bass and some vocals I suppose.

    • @EdThorne
      @EdThorne  Год назад

      You probably wouldn’t notice a difference. The converters are slightly better on these newer models but you’d be hard pushed to hear it. Good luck with your new music journey.

    • @MikaelKonradsson
      @MikaelKonradsson Год назад +1

      @@EdThorne Thank you so much for your reply! I really appreciate it :)

  • @earlitymeproductionz
    @earlitymeproductionz Год назад +1

    Will the Scarlett solo be able to drive the Beyerdynamic DT 770 80ohms well?

  • @alldayhiphop6537
    @alldayhiphop6537 Год назад

    I had a question i recently bought the volt audio interface 1, but the the usb cable is to short. Do you have any other recommendation on which usb could go good with the interface any usb c to a?.

  • @caiocarvalhotube442
    @caiocarvalhotube442 Год назад +1

    Between Volt and Minifuse (Minifuse being cheaper) wich one do you recomend for a mixing and mastering work/>?

    • @EdThorne
      @EdThorne  Год назад +1

      Hi there. I haven’t tried the Arturia interface so I can’t reliably comment. What I would say if you’re looking at mastering is get a device with the best converters you can afford. The Focusrite Clarett+ or Apollo Twin Xs have great converters.

  • @alienz1494
    @alienz1494 11 месяцев назад +1

    I've heard some people had problems with the volt 2 glitching/popping/cracking. Is this a common problem? I'm considering to buy one, but it's holding me back.

    • @EdThorne
      @EdThorne  11 месяцев назад +1

      The likely cause for this is A) PC drivers, and/or B) un-synced sample rates between computer and device (again, usually only on PCs). I’ve not had a problem on my MAC.

  • @PeteBetter
    @PeteBetter Год назад +3

    You've convinced me. I am definitely not buying either of these.

    • @EdThorne
      @EdThorne  Год назад +1

      Fair enough. I’m happy the video aided your decision making process. What do you think you’ll get instead?

    • @PeteBetter
      @PeteBetter Год назад +1

      @@EdThorne I am just thinking of the clickbait title. They are both good and I bought a 4i4.

  • @johndivy
    @johndivy 2 года назад +2

    Both links to Volt2 (Sweetwater and Thomann) link to the Volt276 rather than Volt2, just heads-up

    • @EdThorne
      @EdThorne  2 года назад

      My apologies. I shall amend. Thanks for the comment.

  • @ZDDNK
    @ZDDNK Год назад +1

    I think 3(ish)ms difference is the big factor for me, i would instantly chose Scarlett for that ;)

  • @AD-ou7si
    @AD-ou7si Год назад +1

    NIce comparison video, thanks. Have enjoyed my Audient ID 14 which suddenly stopped registering on my MacBook Air M1. Despite updating firmware, etc. and troubleshooting with tech support, I suspect it is and internal or hardware issue in the unit and not worth fixing. I'm on the hunt for a replacement. My travel rig for Voice Over made by CEntrance is amazing!! It even has a built in limiter. It's my main right now and super easy to use - flawless - , but might go with the Focusrite due to the 'air' mode for my home studio. Hoping it won't amplify pesky sibilants, however.

    • @EdThorne
      @EdThorne  Год назад

      This maybe an obvious question but did you try a different USB cable/USB port? Occasionally on my M1 I have had to restart the computer because it’s stopped recognising the USB ports.

  • @pgkofficiel3992
    @pgkofficiel3992 2 года назад +1

    Hello would you advise me the volt 2 or SSL 2 t? res objectively according to your feedback and experience which is the best thank you in advance for your answer

    • @EdThorne
      @EdThorne  2 года назад

      Watch this space for a comparison of these, and two other very popular interfaces coming soon!

  • @zenemij
    @zenemij Год назад +1

    I just bought the Focusrite 2i2 3 gen , and I see this 😭💀, but I love the interface , I been using the Apollo twin and it’s almost the same thing , the Apollo just dont have any latenci and that’s it

    • @EdThorne
      @EdThorne  Год назад

      I mean the features on the Apollo are vastly superior to a Scarlett but the best interface is always the one you when inspiration strikes!

  • @lastlightgaming6271
    @lastlightgaming6271 Год назад +1

    scarlett without the Air mode was the most cleanest and realistic.

  • @donteroberts5467
    @donteroberts5467 2 года назад

    Say Less you made it all better for me to really to buy the Volt 2 because it should be perfect for me recording in mpc beats and fl studio.

  • @poinguan
    @poinguan 2 года назад +2

    Sorry if my question is a bit silly as I'm new to these stuff. How do I test if my computer audio output is clipping before fed to the speakers? Is there a way to test it?

    • @EdThorne
      @EdThorne  2 года назад

      If you’re on a Mac you can view the output display in Preferences/Sound.

    • @poinguan
      @poinguan 2 года назад

      @@EdThorne I'm on Windows.

    • @AT-wl9yq
      @AT-wl9yq 2 года назад

      The first thing you have to do is look at all the "volume" controls in the signal chain and determine which ones are really volume controls, and which ones are gain controls. Volume controls are on output side of a component and gain controls are on the inputs. Once you have that figured out, any problems you have with regards to distortion/clipping have to be dealt with using the gain controls. Volume controls can't distort the signal, only gains can. Reduce gain until the distortion/clipping goes away, then use volume controls to achieve the desired loudness.

  • @tonezou3918
    @tonezou3918 Год назад +1

    Does the Volt come with a DC adapter? I'm asking, because I'm using my Focusrite on a USB hub and it makes issues sometimes, because the Focusrite is only USB powered, while I noticed the Volt has a DC input. Can the Volt be USB powered only, without external DC adapter?

    • @EdThorne
      @EdThorne  Год назад +1

      Yes, it comes with a power supply so you can use the USB-C port to connect to an iPad/phone for iOS recording. It is also bud powered via the USB-C port if needed.

    • @tonezou3918
      @tonezou3918 Год назад

      @@EdThorne But I guess I can use the power adapter on PC as well?

  • @poulwinther
    @poulwinther 2 года назад +1

    What never seems to earn a mention are the drivers. I always perfect stability and zero problems with Focusrite - which I can't say about any other interface I tried.

    • @EdThorne
      @EdThorne  2 года назад

      I’m a Mac guy, so all interfaces are class complaint and work without drivers - so I can’t comment on PC drivers. I’ve only ever had monitor software issues with one brand (neither of these).

    • @poulwinther
      @poulwinther 2 года назад

      @@EdThorne Class compliant is only a fancy name for the equivalent to Windows standard drivers. I doesn't mean they work which a quick search will reveal.

    • @EdThorne
      @EdThorne  2 года назад +1

      @@poulwinther I’ve never had a problem with an audio interface on my Mac - and I’ve used A LOT. They ALL just work. Literally, the only people I hear complaints from about comparability are PC users. Which interface are you considering anyway?

    • @poulwinther
      @poulwinther 2 года назад

      @@EdThorne I know you test a lot but it's not the same as heavy use. I had M-audio in the past and it was the worst junk ever to get connected to my system. I've been using Scarlett 2i2 since gen. 2 and never had a glitch. Since it now in a suitcase that the airline cannot even register after three days I need a new one. I was starting to lean strongly towards Audient iD4 or iD14 because of all the positive reviews but just found on Reddit that a lot of people have terrible problems with them. So the slight advantages over the Focusrite are not worth the issues and I think I will stick with them. The UA is fine too but it's unknown territory for me and they are well known for terrible software support. Besides I find it almost criminal that the interface doesn't allow use of UA plug-ins.

  • @lassorb4752
    @lassorb4752 2 года назад +1

    Focusrite 8i6 3rd gen is a fanfuggingtastic product! Nowadays its more about the users skills than the interface

  • @seantatalovich9760
    @seantatalovich9760 Год назад +1

    why does the volt have a electric input? I thought it ran on USB-C? I notice 2 cables come in the box?

    • @EdThorne
      @EdThorne  Год назад

      So you can power the device whilst using the USB-C connection to record to an iOS device.

  • @thehomerecordingstudiozone1868
    @thehomerecordingstudiozone1868 2 года назад +2

    Really useful comparison Ed for these entry level contenders . Btw looking well Holiday? also love the Piano backing track you used on this great choice..

    • @EdThorne
      @EdThorne  2 года назад

      Thanks, Ricky. Yeh, had a break from YT and a trip to the Caribbean🔥 The background music is from Epidemic Sounds 👌

    • @TyKingsSon
      @TyKingsSon 2 года назад

      @@EdThorne Hi Ed thx for sharing w us.
      I know have 3 interfaces and need to sell one which should I get rid of? SSL2+, FOCUSRITE CLARIET USB W AIR MODE, APOGGEE ELEMENT 46

    • @EdThorne
      @EdThorne  2 года назад +1

      @@TyKingsSon Oooh, tough show down. I’d keep the Clarett and decide between the other two on a resale value vs functionality decision based on what features you need.

    • @TyKingsSon
      @TyKingsSon 2 года назад

      Now have typo...

    • @TyKingsSon
      @TyKingsSon 2 года назад +1

      @@EdThorne Sweet what island? I grew up in Antigua 🇦🇬

  • @The1Koz
    @The1Koz 2 года назад

    Hello, I've got a question.
    I have a PreSonus Audiobox iTwo and I'm consideting upgrading (I feel like the mic preamp is not ok, other people have reported problems too).
    Do you think I should go to either of those two interfaces, or should I check something else?

    • @EdThorne
      @EdThorne  2 года назад

      Check out one of these: ruclips.net/video/W8JFMyJKHfY/видео.html
      Or I always suggest the Apollo Twins if you can stretch your budget.

  • @Underhills
    @Underhills Год назад +1

    So, what's best for voice over work of these two?

    • @EdThorne
      @EdThorne  Год назад

      Whichever one sounds better to you. I prefer Vintage mode over Air mode for voice overs.

    • @Underhills
      @Underhills Год назад

      @@EdThorne Agree. Too bad it only has USB-C and not USB-2. Just discovered it. I can't afford a new PC and don't wanna mess around with cable format converters. Seems impracticable and potentially degrading to audio quality.

  • @glouglouglouglou1
    @glouglouglouglou1 2 года назад

    I have a line 6 tone port UX2. do you think it's interesting to use a Universal Audio Volt 2 ?

  • @CaptainPlanetMoo
    @CaptainPlanetMoo 2 года назад +1

    Respectfully. The Scarlett will not provide enough clean gain for suitable recording levels on the Shure Sm7b. The next Gen Clarett lineup doesn’t even provide enough clean gain.
    In comparison the UA products from the Volt to the Apollo series will provide enough clean gain without the use of a cloud lifter
    And no “learn how to project” is not a valid response.

  • @gregfabb869
    @gregfabb869 Год назад +1

    Interesting video. Absolute beginner. Hoping to use to record demo ideas to take to the band. Using a dynamic mic. Going for a refurb scarlet simply on cost. Dont need high quality

  • @DisruptedSinner
    @DisruptedSinner 2 года назад +1

    Where did you get the metal shelving in the background?

    • @EdThorne
      @EdThorne  2 года назад

      I don’t know, I didn’t install them.

  • @maladamedialabs4214
    @maladamedialabs4214 2 года назад +2

    I know we're a minority but how about Linux compatibility? I use Ubuntu Studio which does most of what I need but I lack a good interface for recording. Otherwise, a very thoughtful review. Thank you.

    • @EdThorne
      @EdThorne  2 года назад

      I don’t know (m)any brands that create drivers for Linux. M1 Macs are defo the way forward for music production.

  • @johnwinslow8841
    @johnwinslow8841 Год назад +1

    does the volt 1 have the same preamps as the volt 2?

    • @EdThorne
      @EdThorne  Год назад

      Yes. And the Volt 276, 4, 476, 476p… the whole range is identical.

  • @guyb7005
    @guyb7005 9 месяцев назад

    need to make a more thorough comparison and see if this ranking holds:
    Motu M2, Volt 2, SSL-2, Scarlett 2i2, Behringer UMC202HD, Macki Onyx 2x2, Arturia Minifuse 2, M-Audio Air 192, NI Komplete Audio 2 & RME Babyface Pro 2

  • @alcibiademinel
    @alcibiademinel Год назад

    Since I changed my PC, I have terrible ground loop issues with my current Focusrite Scarlett (I hear PC activity, especially GPU ; even at 0 volume). I'm considering buying a self-powered interface, as the Volt 1 or 2, but I don't know if the direct powering (with a 5V transformer) reduces PC ground loops, compared to the USB bus powering, on those specific interfaces (the manual seems to talk about direct powering as very situational). Any idea?

  • @Христосович-ц1ф
    @Христосович-ц1ф 7 месяцев назад

    What is better for an electric guitar recording?

  • @mangadolo
    @mangadolo Год назад

    Im trying to talk into my Pioneer DDJ-FLX 4 controller (with external microphone of course) while I DJ. Is that sound card good enough or would you guys recommend one of these two interfaces as discussed?

  • @Faahlew16
    @Faahlew16 2 года назад +1

    Thank you for your great presentation. I learned a lot just in 11mins. 👍🏽

  • @Kaizen2013v
    @Kaizen2013v 2 года назад

    Hi, if one had a higher budget for home interface use. Which would you recommend ?

    • @EdThorne
      @EdThorne  2 года назад +1

      UA Apollo all the way.