New Ahsoka - The Mandalorian Videos are up! Ahsoka Tano Says Goodbye To The Mandalorian - ruclips.net/video/Ohko1Je7mlk/видео.html Ashoka Tano Meets The Mandalorian - ruclips.net/video/i6Q-FaEJsfw/видео.html
Look, it was cool seeing Force Ghost Luke, but imagine if Anakin was the one that caught the lightsaber and walked out of the fire. That’d be fuckin amazing
When I first saw this in theater I thought it was gonna be Anakin. I was like “Anakin” and t Amgen when Luke appeared I was like “aw not you” 😂 I still enjoyed seeing Luke as a force ghost though
@@wingedbluj1674 the emperor manipulated the midichlorian around his mother womb causing her to be pregnant So what I told was true from a certain point of view
@@MariOmor1 Hell, he gives her advice he didn't bother with in episode 6. "You must confront Palpatine" Luke confronted him by tossing his saber aside and giving up.
@@Radb707 In all fairness, he underestimated Palpatine at that point. He didn't know about Force lightning, and his refusal to fight was more of a symbolic gesture. He even says outright, "I'll never turn to the Dark Side. You've failed, Your Highness. I am a Jedi, like my father before me."
I like to think that Luke's smile when he lifted his ship out of the water was a smile and nod to the audience. A throwback to Empire. That after 40 years, he finally lifted his ship out after failing to do so when he was training with Yoda because he didn't believe.
It was also a message for us that Star Wars was still alive in a message to our enemies the people who ruined its reputation including Disney that hope lives for all sides and still pretty much a threat
I still get tears seeing the bit at the end, where Luke is just calmly lifting the X-wing up and smiles to Rey. It shows that he's finally completely at peace and has redeemed himself completely after severing his connection to the force in 8. I hate TLJ still but this scene kinda makes his "arc" in the sequels better retroactively
Yeah... it kind of better than TLJ. Thankfully, Battlefront 2, The Mandalorian an The Book of Boba Fett gave us the oportunity to meet the Luke we wanted to see
Mark Hamill has often stated how much he’s not a fan of the Disney films, and I don’t blame him, but I wonder if he got a sense of real joy finally getting to be a force ghost
godzillavkk I know he didn’t. He said that he hoped that he had a sense of joy and I said “so did I”, because I disliked the way he was presented in The Last Jedi and so did Mark, and so I hoped that he had more enjoyment filming episode 9.
@@Spectrumoe But Mark Hamill literally says: "But I was wrong" in those interviews after talking about the film all these clickbaity and very shitty videos of: "Mark Hamill hates The Last Jedi" are completely false, as they literally take the bits they want you to hear and exclude all the moments in which he literally praises Rian, obviously not in all of these videos and yes I do understand he "fundamentally disagreed" I've seen the documentary and eventually he started to understand what they did and believes that Rian was the right person for this job. They exclude those moments to fit their own agenda, just like how they claim Disney has an agenda when in fact EVERYONE has an agenda, whether in the media/politics or anything else, you'll find agendas EVERYWHERE.
THE LAST JEDI He says in interviews that he didn’t like the way Rian Portrayed his character, but says that he liked the way that he was sent off in The Last Jedi and that that’s all that he could ask for.
@@TrickyPJM752 Considering Yoda stops Luke from setting fire to the Jedi Temple before doing it himself while giggling? Maybe, maybe not. Now we'll never know.
Pastor Brian hmm, but then again he lost his connection with the force when he asked that question, and until he regained his connection that’s when he realised but just didn’t tell her.
Da-vid Cargill yeah I believe in a novel or something explaining Obi Wans transcendence into the force it says he feels all this sudden knowledge and history granted to him so yeah same thing most likely happens when to any Jedi who transcends into the force.
3:55 - I rolled my eyes many times throughout the sequels but this scene and the music as Luke’s X-Wing is lifted out of the water made me cry in the cinema 😊😊😊
Dude...I respect your opinion, but nobody really cares whether you liked them or not, what is it that gives you guys the urge to comment on every video about a scene of the sequel trilogy that you don’t like them? It’s so unnecessary
@@joshuawillis602the luke we knew in OT wouldn’t even isolate himself in the first place, he would have kept optimistic and rebuilt his order while trying to turn back ben to the light side, while he wouldn’t hesitate to come back, he would come back and fight the first order with the resistance
Luke had become very powerful in his own way, the projection in ep. 8 and here as a ghost, easily lifting the X-wing up as he did. I just wish we could've seen him use it in a more traditional sense. Being Anakin's son, but without virtually any physical damage (just the hand) I always figured he had the potential to be at Yoda and Palpatine's levels (maybe even higher) as the strongest force users.
Lucas has said that Luke became the most powerful Jedi of all time. More than yoda or any other force user. Of course Disney and rian Johnson completely ruined that and made Rey the strongest ever because of her gender
@@IMHS21 obi wan only beat anakin because at their last moment he was too Arrogant to realize the situation he was in when obi wan tried to warn him. If obi didn’t know how anakin fights then he would have lost to him a lot sooner. That’s the only reason him and anakin where on par, they knew each other’s fighting style
@@Crusty783 in response to the outcry over his original comments ala "Jake Skywalker." He was either A) trying to calm the fan base and avoid causing a huge split, or B) responding to pressure which came down from on high at Disney to retract his previous statements. Either way, if you look at his interviews it is plain as day that he doesn't agree with how the character of Luke Skywalker was treated in the sequals, especially TLJ.
A real motivational scene from this film that has aged very well. The message is at your worst days and lowest points, you must confront and overcome your fear and leave it behind, and go ahead and embrace your destiny. Waiting for this film to get a re-evaluation eventually.
You know what. Given where Luke’s character was (opinions aside), this was the best send off they could have gave him. An ode to his training with yoda with yoda’s theme worked beautifully
What makes me laugh about this scene is the fact that Luke uses his left hand and we can’t see his right hand because so many people started that whole thing where since Luke died will he still have his robotic hand LOL
Well Luke appears as a force ghost with his robes and clothes on his back, so him with his robot hand isn’t far fetched. I think if he used his robot hand it would by symbolic in a different way and not communicate the correct message. Luke in his force ghost presence is his astral projection of himself. The way he projected himself all cleaned up towards Kylo Ren is of a different appearance, more put together than what he is on the island. The force works in mysterious ways.
@@Jayman2800 It’s not a plot hole. Of course he has his real hand back. The reason why they didn’t show it was because they want to people to take the scene seriously. And not compare it to that scene from happy Gilmore when Carl’s weathers was like “shut up happy. Don’t feel bad. Look I got my hand back see?” They hate Memes.
In Return Of The Jedi, Anakin Skywalker’s ghost portrays him as his younger self; without all the tubes (which were visible on his throat), and millions of other robotic things that became part of his body. A Jedi can choose how their force ghost appears.
This was so epic. I think there could be no better send of for luke then that. Not only did he give Rey hope, but he did what he couldn't do in The Empire Strikes Back. He lifted the Pod. Im going to miss Luke but will always remember the childhood he gave me.
Luke will always be the hero he was. Even stronger so he sank into depression and came out of it knowing full well he was always strong and hope. Which is such a difficult thing to do in life. If anything it’s inspiring and gives hope to others at a low point you can came back from a low point
@@GD-mp3kz In episode 5: The Empire Strikes back Luke loses his original lightsaber. (The blue one.) He crafted a new one that was green in color. Rey received the old lightsaber by an ally. Is is unknown how the ally got the lightsaber.
In the videogame SWTOR (Not canon) a character dies and becomes a force ghost and he was known to wear armor in life and although he did not need it he still wore it as that was how he would like to be remembered. That’s most likely why Anakin doesn’t look like Vader when he’s a ghost
I find it funny people say this retcons The Last Jedi when Luke in fact changed at the end of that back to something that was even more wise than the Luke Skywalker that we saw in Return of the Jedi. As much as I wanted to see more Luke in this movie, basically as a vision that haunts Kylo Ren everywhere he goes , I thought this scene was very Luke Skywalker and to see him finally do something Yoda was trying to teach him to do in Empire was nostalgic and emotional.
Luke didn’t act at all like himself at all in the whole movie. It’d be one thing if he started off that movie as the angry old hermit who wanted the Jedi to end. Then, over the course of the movie, he’d slowly rediscover hope and return to his old ways. But that never happens.
@@superjackster0165 I feel like you only watched half the movie. After Yoda talks with him, he comes and saves the Resistance. That was the best Luke we'd ever seen.
@@dill1332 LMFAO. Yeah, what a hero. Saving the remaining 10 resistance people makes up for abandoning his sister, his best friend Han, Chewie, and the entire rest of the galaxy to be blow up and die by the hands of the First Order. He really saved the day.
Introducing grogu into the canon contradicts this movie unless grogu was killed prior to ep 7, which would be one of the worst things to happen and would cause the fans to burn down the franchise.
I'm not a fan of Episode IX in general, but one thing I really love is this weird relationship between Luke and Rey. The way he asks "What are you doing?" really comes off like a teacher dealing with a pain in the ass student who they know can do better. Crotchety antisocial hermit Luke is great, I don't care what anyone says.
Luke is extremely stubborn and demanding. He is very “my way or high way” person but with good intentions. Absorbed Vader’s fatherly instincts and is the father that Anakin would have been.
When Jedi Grand Master Skywalker tells Rey that confronting fear is the destiny of a Jedi not only is he right but it's also a trial every Jedi Apprentice must face besides looking in him or herself
@@andresmolina8306 No. You couldn't be more wrong. It would've been the easiest thing for Johnson to pigeonhole Luke into the expected mentor archetype and we would've just had another stoic Jedi Master like we've already seen many times before. He actually respected this character more by taking the *one film* where he was going to get the spotlight and treating him as a main character, giving him an unexpected and truly substantial story, in a trilogy where he and the other "Legacy" characters were supposed to be in the backseat.
@@theS0UND_1 yes, making him drink green milk in a nasty way, throw away his lightsaber, give up after a mistake and leave all his friends and family for years like a coward, and try to kill his nephew is treating the character with respect. Even Mark hamill was angry with the way they wrote the character in TLJ
I kinda wish she pulled out Luke’s green saber, considering we barely saw it in the last film. Also the visual of the main Jedi colours, green and blue, deflecting palpatine’s force lighting would’ve been an interesting visual. “All the Jedi live in you”
Green saber is related to Luke fighting his father and his close contact with the dark side.That's why he did't give it to her.Besides there was Leia's saber to be taken.
People calling Luke's saber catch at retcon clearly failed to pay attention to his arc in TLJ. His saber toss at the start of TLJ represents his weary and disillusioned self following his failure to train Ben and restore the Jedi order. He was down in the dumps for the first two-thirds of the movie. He came around and reembraced his Jedi ways following a visit from Yoda who knocked sense into him. At the end of the movie when he faced off against Kylo and the First Order, he openly declared "I will NOT be the last Jedi", cementing his reembrace of the Jedi ways once again. Hence why he could come back as a Force ghost and lecture Rey about respecting a Jedi's weapon.
@@wilfredolopez9865 when someone makes an observation about the sequels, it's a reach but when someone makes ridiculous theories with the prequels, you go "ooooh that's amazing the prequels are masterpieces"
@@johnstephen4847 a lot of the decisions in the OT like Vader being Luke's father or Leia being his sister weren't planned, but they were brilliant. Luke's arc makes perfect sense but people don't even try to understand why he was like that in TLJ
well if you think about it there was no way around to fix that awful fking mess that rian johnson left in episode 8 along with kennedy making things worse in episode 9.
@@borris3768 He also voiced Hobgoblin, Sticky Beard from Codename's Kid's Next Door, Arnim Zola, Alvin the Treacherous from Dreamworks Dragons, Skips from Regular Show and Maltruant from Ben 10 Omniverse.
So this is her true identity, now that all makes sense; such great power and rage flow through her veins from her grandfather Sheev and so her parents kept her safe in hoping she could find a better path against him.
3:33 One thing I liked about this movie was the theme created for the protagonists, it’s so beautiful and really makes you feel like the end is near and everything is coming together, even tho it was all half baked. And Yoda’s theme coming RIGHT after it was just awesome
It's a super underrated theme, honestly that whole "The Rise of Skywalker" theme track is one of John Williams' best Star Wars compositions imo. It reminds me how "Across the Stars" captures the conceptual beauty and tragedy of Anakin and Padme's romance better than the actual story or performances. I can listen to "The Rise of Skywalker" and experience all the emotion of what the Star Wars saga ending should feel like even if it's not all there in the movie.
That wasn't his job, just like it wasn't Obi Wan's job to defeat Vader. Just as only Luke could defeat Vader and bring Anakin back from the dark side, it was Rey's job to defeat her grandfather Palpatine, which she did with some help from a redeemed Ben Solo. The other lightsaber was for Kylo. It's a Skywalker descendant beating Palpatine again along with his own descendant.
Treverrow’s script was better. I still hate The Last Jedi and all. But at least Treverrow tried to expand on things set up in that movie instead of retconing it all
SuperJackster01 But it didn’t expand anything. I mean, the balance thing was explored in only one or two lines, but just like in TROS the good guys win again and nothing changes at all 😕 for me TROS is more exciting.
@@brickforge12 do not frighten us with your stories lord vader, your sad devotion to this ancient religion wont help us to recover stolen datatapes-- ugkh.
Luke Skywalker(ROS): "A Jedi's weapon deserves more respect!" Luke Skywalker(TLJ): Throws his first lightsaber away and proceeds to burn the Jedi library...
@@blackorder9565 Like Nocto Ki said, it's called a character arc. Character arcs involve a character change. Every character changes in all stories. And life is all about change. But you and the rest of the toxic fandom just seem to just want to stay the same.
Ed Davies Lol, calling people toxic because they have different opinions is a shitty thing to do and proves that you're also a toxic fan, I never said i want Luke to stay the same but you said so. Also, there must be certain events that happen in order for a character to change his/her point of view.Tell me which event happened that lead to Luke believing killing Kylo was the last resort, we never saw it did we, that's why people are complaining about the Jake's arc in TLJ because it was executed horribly and contradictory in its nature when you compare it to Luke's arc in the OT. Jake Skywalker in the Last Jedi abandoned his family and ran away from the war despise the fact that the first order wasn't even a thing at that time( acording to The Force Awakens, FO rose to power when Luke was absent), At the end of the last jedi, Jake force-projected himself to Crait just to Troll his nephew and didn't try to redeem Kylo (Ren straight up asked Jake whether he was there to save his soul and Jake said NO). If he was Luke Skywalker, he would never ran away from the war or abandon his family and would try to reason with Kylo to redeem him just like he did with Vader. He made the exact mistake which he has learned in the OT.
@@blackorder9565 It was briefest moment of pure instinct that made Luke believe that killing Ben was the last resort! And even that brief moment of pure instinct soon passed like a fleeting shadow as soon as he turned on his lightsaber! And the dark voices inside Ben's head was what caused him to briefly fall into that small moment of pure instinct! And the dark voices were created by Palpatine through Snoke, to manipulate Luke into thinking that his nephew has made his choice to turn to the dark-side! Finally Luke Skywalker exiled himself to Ach-To because he was so guilt ridden for having succumbed to that brief moment of instinct that caused Ben to turn to the dark-side, that he's not going to let it happen again! He even said it himself in that very clip, that he was wrong to exile himself and that it was fear that kept him in Ach-To! Also while he did trick Kylo by force-projecting onto Crait, he did it so that the last of the Resistance and his sister can escape and regain their strength so that they can fight the First Order again, so that he can apologise for what happened the night Ben turned to the dark-side, and so that he can pass the torch to Rey!
-Wait a minute. You can use the force, and hold a lightsaber after you're dead? -Yeah, why? -You're coming with me. Oh my god I can never watch this scene seriously again after watching How it Should Have Ended.
There was something I read about the sith having some sort of weapon that could trap force ghosts or something like that and that since they didn't know whether the sith did or did not have that sort of weapon, they didn't want to risk it. Well that's from what I've read.
Something I noticed. We never once see Luke's right hand - the one he lost to Vader. I think it's cause they don't wanna show Luke's failure OR create debate amongst the fans whether he should or shouldn't have it as a force ghost.
Something that's bothered me, and I've never seen anyone else have this issue, is when Luke said "you have everything you need" I thought Rey was going to use the Force to guide herself instead of needing the map. It would have been an accomplishing moment for Rey's training and also she takes Luke's X-Wing where he iconically relied on only the Force to destroy the Death Star.
A Jedi’s weapon deserves more respect? Uh, Luke, aren’t you aware that that weapon you caught was used by your dear old daddy to massacre like fifty kids?
TrueMohax there’s also Sith style lightsabers, which are created when dark siders corrupt Jedi kyber crystals simply by pouring their dark emotions into them
I'll be honest. Yoda's scene from Last Jedi and the fighter raising scene from this one is the only really good things about the last trilogy. I mean, yeah there are some other things as well. But I love how they honor Yoda's lessons to young Luke, and how even Luke now get's exhausted in the same way as Yoda when raising the ship. His journey ended where it began in some ways.
@@mattblom3990 all the trilogies are flawed. The effects in the OT have aged like milk, the dialogue in the prequels was atrocious and the sequels add nothing to the overall story. Despite all this the important thing is all the movies entertained people for decades and will continue to do so
You may not thing about it but "some things are stronger than blood" is a great theme and a part of reality because not all people find love from people of their bloodlines. That could be either because they didnt meet them either because those were just assholes. So this scene gets a 👏👏from me.
I like that theme, but I really wish they had stuck with Rian's Rey is "no one" idea. The idea that anyone in the universe can make a difference and that you don't have to be part of some bloodline is a powerful message for kids. Heck it's the entire premise of LoTR and a large part of the reason LoTR is so timeless. I also don't think Palpatine needed to come back for this movie. Ben killed Snoke and had ascended to big baddie status. The whole movie could've been Ben's redemption arc without Palpatine as a bad guy. Not resurrecting him would've also kept Vader's sacrifice in RotJ meaningful. I don't hate this movie, but some of the choices were just stupid.
"Yeah, this is my old X-wing from 30 years ago. It's been underwater for the passed, shit I don't even remember, got a little rust but, should get you from point a to point b!!" For real though, as much shit people talk about these movies, I still enjoy the scenes like this where they bring you back to where it all began or bring back the nastalgic feeling of something seen before!!
Spectrumoe the deepfake they did for rogue one was way better than even this Rise of Skywalker one! I just don’t get how no one caught how bad this looked!
Shaun Bang I don’t believe they used deep fakes in either (although I could be wrong). For the fight scene they took one of the cut scenes of Leia from Return Of The Jedi and basically stuck it on Carrie’s daughter’s face and then changed the lighting.
Episode 9 is a incoherrent clusterfuck. But this scene at least created a good feeling. Luke telling the new protagonist that it is a jedis duty to confront your greatest fear and that some things are more important than blood.
@@TheWeepingDalek Sure. But for a film called "Rise of Skywalker," being the only one that legitimately possesses the Skywalker name, you would think he would have a little more than a reshoot cameo....
![[4K] Watch SpaceX Catch A Starship Rocket From Space!!! #IFT5](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/pIKI7y3DTXk/mqdefault.jpg)
![Who Wrote a Short Story That Seriously Disturbed a Teacher? | Dirty Laundry x Smosh [Full Episode]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/bvHAy_rKoEI/mqdefault.jpg)
New Ahsoka - The Mandalorian Videos are up!
Ahsoka Tano Says Goodbye To The Mandalorian - ruclips.net/video/Ohko1Je7mlk/видео.html
Ashoka Tano Meets The Mandalorian - ruclips.net/video/i6Q-FaEJsfw/видео.html
Same
Lmao when did started editing comment 😂
@@spurrellproductions1725 rey skywalker 🧎🏾♀️🧘🏾♀️
Look, it was cool seeing Force Ghost Luke, but imagine if Anakin was the one that caught the lightsaber and walked out of the fire. That’d be fuckin amazing
Rey doesn’t know him. She’d be wondering who the fuck this is
@@ep1cgam3r11 Yet he says to her when she fights palpatine "Bring back the balance Rey, as I did"
Nah, but it should have been Anakin’s Force Ghost who spoke to Ben instead of a “memory” of Han.
@@ThatDangerousWolf I agree but it's good Ben and Han patched things up
When I first saw this in theater I thought it was gonna be Anakin. I was like “Anakin” and t Amgen when Luke appeared I was like “aw not you” 😂 I still enjoyed seeing Luke as a force ghost though
“Rey some things are stronger than blood.” And he knows that better than anyone. He’s Darth Vadar’s son!
He's right. He was trying to tell Rey that just because she is Darth Sidious's grand daughter it doesn't mean she's going to turn to the dark side
Yeah because luke is also the emperor grandson 😂
@@scottishcookie8198 no, what made you say that?
@@wingedbluj1674 the emperor manipulated the midichlorian around his mother womb causing her to be pregnant
So what I told was true from a certain point of view
@@scottishcookie8198 From a certain point of view?
0:52 Luke succeeding where his father failed
There are too many of them, what are we going to do?
🤣🤣🤣
3:55 Luke succeeding where he failed in Episode 5
@@MariOmor1 Hell, he gives her advice he didn't bother with in episode 6. "You must confront Palpatine" Luke confronted him by tossing his saber aside and giving up.
@@Radb707 In all fairness, he underestimated Palpatine at that point. He didn't know about Force lightning, and his refusal to fight was more of a symbolic gesture. He even says outright, "I'll never turn to the Dark Side. You've failed, Your Highness. I am a Jedi, like my father before me."
I like to think that Luke's smile when he lifted his ship out of the water was a smile and nod to the audience. A throwback to Empire. That after 40 years, he finally lifted his ship out after failing to do so when he was training with Yoda because he didn't believe.
It was also a message for us that Star Wars was still alive in a message to our enemies the people who ruined its reputation including Disney that hope lives for all sides and still pretty much a threat
Mark Hamill must have been so happy to finally be able to lift the X-wing.
me too buddy XD
Agreed entirely! This was like a big f*** you Rian Johnson, I am still Luke!
Based on the look on his face, in our house it's known as the "Smug Luke" scene.
I still get tears seeing the bit at the end, where Luke is just calmly lifting the X-wing up and smiles to Rey. It shows that he's finally completely at peace and has redeemed himself completely after severing his connection to the force in 8. I hate TLJ still but this scene kinda makes his "arc" in the sequels better retroactively
Yeah... it kind of better than TLJ. Thankfully, Battlefront 2, The Mandalorian an The Book of Boba Fett gave us the oportunity to meet the Luke we wanted to see
Yes I 100% with this statement.
so do I.
I agree. This scene totally tracks with the Luke we saw at the end of TLJ.
Luke should’ve revealed his original hand since he’s force ghost
Mark Hamill has often stated how much he’s not a fan of the Disney films, and I don’t blame him, but I wonder if he got a sense of real joy finally getting to be a force ghost
Hopefully he did. I can't stand how they presented his character in The Last Jedi though.
godzillavkk What?
godzillavkk I know he didn’t. He said that he hoped that he had a sense of joy and I said “so did I”, because I disliked the way he was presented in The Last Jedi and so did Mark, and so I hoped that he had more enjoyment filming episode 9.
@@Spectrumoe But Mark Hamill literally says: "But I was wrong" in those interviews after talking about the film all these clickbaity and very shitty videos of: "Mark Hamill hates The Last Jedi" are completely false, as they literally take the bits they want you to hear and exclude all the moments in which he literally praises Rian, obviously not in all of these videos and yes I do understand he "fundamentally disagreed" I've seen the documentary and eventually he started to understand what they did and believes that Rian was the right person for this job.
They exclude those moments to fit their own agenda, just like how they claim Disney has an agenda when in fact EVERYONE has an agenda, whether in the media/politics or anything else, you'll find agendas EVERYWHERE.
THE LAST JEDI He says in interviews that he didn’t like the way Rian Portrayed his character, but says that he liked the way that he was sent off in The Last Jedi and that that’s all that he could ask for.
I was half expecting a funny comment after he lifted the X Wing, or yoda appearing and hitting him with his cane saying "Long enough, it took you!"
Luke: Well how long did it take you!
Yoda: Learned as an infant, I did!
That would’ve been funny as heck but would also kind of ruin the scene
@@TrickyPJM752 naa that would have been cool cos they could both turn and watch her fly off. Foreshadow later the battle of the force ghosts.
After watching the last episode of Kenobi, this makes me smile
@@TrickyPJM752 Considering Yoda stops Luke from setting fire to the Jedi Temple before doing it himself while giggling? Maybe, maybe not. Now we'll never know.
Luke:...because you’re a Palpatine. Luke in Last Jedi: Who are you?
Pastor Brian hmm, but then again he lost his connection with the force when he asked that question, and until he regained his connection that’s when he realised but just didn’t tell her.
@@Spectrumoe plus he is a force ghost that exist in the past present and future
Da-vid Cargill yeah I believe in a novel or something explaining Obi Wans transcendence into the force it says he feels all this sudden knowledge and history granted to him so yeah same thing most likely happens when to any Jedi who transcends into the force.
@@kidofsteel0362 hopefully the same for us in the afterlife
Spectrumoe Define cutting yourself to the force he been the force in last Jedi plus their was no plan for Rey being a palpatine.
3:55 - I rolled my eyes many times throughout the sequels but this scene and the music as Luke’s X-Wing is lifted out of the water made me cry in the cinema 😊😊😊
true i liked this part cause it showed how luke became stronger in the force since episode 5
Would have better though if he were NOT a force ghost doing it, but yes.
Talk about perfect nostalgia to OG real star wars
Mee too.
Luke: "A Jedi's weapon deserves more respect." Rey: "You literally threw the fricking thing of a cliff."
0:54 this was me throughout the entire movie.
same
except this scene
worst star wars movie but this
this is good, this is pure star wars
I don't like the sequels but little scenes like this I do genuinely enjoy
Yeah I feel like JJ Abrams really needed to put something like this in for Luke’s part to make up for the mess he was in TLJ
No. Skywalker admits that he was wrong? And Rey Space Jesus always Mary Sue right? No.
Dude...I respect your opinion, but nobody really cares whether you liked them or not, what is it that gives you guys the urge to comment on every video about a scene of the sequel trilogy that you don’t like them? It’s so unnecessary
TheCatLover Lord Ok
InfiniteGG ツ Just saying, it looks just dumb to see all the comments saying “sequels bad” over and over again, very original lol
It's great to see Luke take the role of Yoda in the episode 9
More so obi wan tbh
This was more of an Obi-Wan role
Why Luke Skywalker still speak with American accent even he is old
@@muhammadfawwazabhinaya3131 When you’re part of the force, the English in that realm is American English according to George Lucas
@@NinjaBuddha503 you know his actor's nationality
After all these years since the empire strikes back when Luke couldn’t lift his X-Wing,
Luke finally lifts his X-Wing!
After he dies 😐😐
They even played the same music when yoda had to lift it for him
@@Kage_Yurei That was awesome! Got me all in my feels!
@@richardpierce4908 ikr
Satisfying
The sequels may have been divisive but one thing is for sure and that's John William's always kills it with the beautiful scores
This is the Luke Skywalker I wanted to see in The Last Jedi
That would make his isolation completely pointless. You kids are seriously delusional
@@joshuawillis602he shouldn’t have isolated himself in the first place.
@@sl4yer134 why? Because you say so? That’s not how story telling works you fool
The only problem is: he’s not showing his right hand. Since he’s a force ghost, he should no longer have that cybernetic hand
@@joshuawillis602the luke we knew in OT wouldn’t even isolate himself in the first place, he would have kept optimistic and rebuilt his order while trying to turn back ben to the light side, while he wouldn’t hesitate to come back, he would come back and fight the first order with the resistance
Luke had become very powerful in his own way, the projection in ep. 8 and here as a ghost, easily lifting the X-wing up as he did. I just wish we could've seen him use it in a more traditional sense. Being Anakin's son, but without virtually any physical damage (just the hand) I always figured he had the potential to be at Yoda and Palpatine's levels (maybe even higher) as the strongest force users.
Lucas has said that Luke became the most powerful Jedi of all time. More than yoda or any other force user. Of course Disney and rian Johnson completely ruined that and made Rey the strongest ever because of her gender
@@seahawkman50 no one said she was , only u deluded ppl
Anakin was supposed to be better than Yoda and Palpatine.
@@musicaldooder20 his potential was higher, but he never actually was. Even obi wan beated him
@@IMHS21 obi wan only beat anakin because at their last moment he was too Arrogant to realize the situation he was in when obi wan tried to warn him. If obi didn’t know how anakin fights then he would have lost to him a lot sooner. That’s the only reason him and anakin where on par, they knew each other’s fighting style
“What’re you doing?”
~ Mark Hamil upon reading the RoS script
Correction: Mark Hamill upon reading TLJ script
@@Tubanapoleon he called TLJ an "all time great" movie but okay
@@Crusty783 in response to the outcry over his original comments ala "Jake Skywalker." He was either A) trying to calm the fan base and avoid causing a huge split, or B) responding to pressure which came down from on high at Disney to retract his previous statements. Either way, if you look at his interviews it is plain as day that he doesn't agree with how the character of Luke Skywalker was treated in the sequals, especially TLJ.
@@Tubanapoleon
"All time great movie"
"I was wrong"
Imply otherwise but okayyyyy
@@Crusty783 David makes a perfectly valid point. Mark has openly criticised the direction of Luke's character in TLJ, in interviews again and again.
I love when he lifts the X-wing. His smug face.
Luke: Yep, still got it.
😂😂
"So this is how that felt" - Luke thinking about Yoda
Yoda should’ve appeared next to him when Rey left and said “hmm long enough it took you”
I know that Luke & Yoda are technically dead, but I bet Yoda would've been very Proud...😌
*Luke finally lifts his X Wing*
Yoda: ABOUT DAMN TIME, IT IS
A real motivational scene from this film that has aged very well. The message is at your worst days and lowest points, you must confront and overcome your fear and leave it behind, and go ahead and embrace your destiny. Waiting for this film to get a re-evaluation eventually.
Same
If it weren't for Qui Gon learning to become on with the force. Jedi would become extinct. And for the power bloodline of Rey to keep the Jedi alive
Finally someone says something positive about the sequels
Qui Gon is a key to all this. Because he’s a funnier character than we’ve had before.
the Jedi were never about bloodline and Skywalker bloodline was way stronger than Palpatines and he openly stated it
@@yoneighbor9449 they're honestly way better then the originals. Big shiny graphics and big booms that go BANG. 👶
What about Revan?
She was just about to do the same mistakes Luke did
Both out of fear remorse guilt and a broken will
Ramzeh X And then Luke himself stopped her from that! Pure poetry!
@@otinad2008 Exactly
@@otinad2008 Rise of Skywalker fan for liveee
Ramzeh X Me too bro!!! Such an amazing and underrated movie!!!
@@otinad2008 Underrated? More like a hated movie by toxic people
It used to be Yoda’s theme. Now its the “pulling tie fighter out of water” theme
Hi
You mean x wing
No it not his it the sad
Wait what
Yes
I totally love the reference scene. Yodas theme... when luke could not raise his x wing and yoda did... now luke could... this scene was epic
Yoda: Learn he did
You know what. Given where Luke’s character was (opinions aside), this was the best send off they could have gave him. An ode to his training with yoda with yoda’s theme worked beautifully
I tried to watch this again and not get tears in my eyes when Luke lifted his X Wing....I failed.
Shut up eric butts
@@mywario damn
@@mywario No need to be rude now, come on
What makes me laugh about this scene is the fact that Luke uses his left hand and we can’t see his right hand because so many people started that whole thing where since Luke died will he still have his robotic hand LOL
Well Luke appears as a force ghost with his robes and clothes on his back, so him with his robot hand isn’t far fetched. I think if he used his robot hand it would by symbolic in a different way and not communicate the correct message. Luke in his force ghost presence is his astral projection of himself. The way he projected himself all cleaned up towards Kylo Ren is of a different appearance, more put together than what he is on the island. The force works in mysterious ways.
It's a huge plot hole though. In ROTJ, Anakin Skywalker had all his limbs back as a force ghost, so by that logic, Luke should have his hand too
@@Jayman2800 It’s not a plot hole. Of course he has his real hand back. The reason why they didn’t show it was because they want to people to take the scene seriously. And not compare it to that scene from happy Gilmore when Carl’s weathers was like “shut up happy. Don’t feel bad. Look I got my hand back see?” They hate Memes.
In Return Of The Jedi, Anakin Skywalker’s ghost portrays him as his younger self; without all the tubes (which were visible on his throat), and millions of other robotic things that became part of his body.
A Jedi can choose how their force ghost appears.
It is the mental projection of his digital self
This was so epic. I think there could be no better send of for luke then that. Not only did he give Rey hope, but he did what he couldn't do in The Empire Strikes Back. He lifted the Pod. Im going to miss Luke but will always remember the childhood he gave me.
Luke will always be the hero he was. Even stronger so he sank into depression and came out of it knowing full well he was always strong and hope. Which is such a difficult thing to do in life. If anything it’s inspiring and gives hope to others at a low point you can came back from a low point
both sables are blue? why in the raining luke sable is green but then his sable is blue just like her sister
@@GD-mp3kz In episode 5: The Empire Strikes back Luke loses his original lightsaber. (The blue one.) He crafted a new one that was green in color. Rey received the old lightsaber by an ally. Is is unknown how the ally got the lightsaber.
@@sea1865 thank you
@@GD-mp3kz np
I love that he learned that lesson and lifted the xwing. I almost cried it was that sweet.
I cried like a baby when I saw Luke come out of that fire as a force ghost
thats sad! you like bad writing
@@ShadowDashh bro you're probably like 12 years old. Log off
@@bigfloppa9594 bro that is like the most original comment ever bro I mean bro you really got this bro
@@ShadowDashh case and point
@@bigfloppa9594 you have no case bro you just dumb bro don't be upset bro
You know, I realized that we never see Luke’s right hand in this film.
You mean right hand
Weird, because by that logic, Anakin would only get to keep his head and torso.
In the videogame SWTOR (Not canon) a character dies and becomes a force ghost and he was known to wear armor in life and although he did not need it he still wore it as that was how he would like to be remembered. That’s most likely why Anakin doesn’t look like Vader when he’s a ghost
@@minozZzZ Darth Marr
He is hiding his hand whole time? Lol
I find it funny people say this retcons The Last Jedi when Luke in fact changed at the end of that back to something that was even more wise than the Luke Skywalker that we saw in Return of the Jedi. As much as I wanted to see more Luke in this movie, basically as a vision that haunts Kylo Ren everywhere he goes , I thought this scene was very Luke Skywalker and to see him finally do something Yoda was trying to teach him to do in Empire was nostalgic and emotional.
Luke didn’t act at all like himself at all in the whole movie. It’d be one thing if he started off that movie as the angry old hermit who wanted the Jedi to end. Then, over the course of the movie, he’d slowly rediscover hope and return to his old ways. But that never happens.
SuperJackster01 Bro,that Jake Skywalker guy straight up saying he wasn't there to save Kylo's soul. He just came there to troll his nephew and died.
@@superjackster0165 I feel like you only watched half the movie. After Yoda talks with him, he comes and saves the Resistance. That was the best Luke we'd ever seen.
@@dill1332 LMFAO. Yeah, what a hero. Saving the remaining 10 resistance people makes up for abandoning his sister, his best friend Han, Chewie, and the entire rest of the galaxy to be blow up and die by the hands of the First Order. He really saved the day.
Well said sir
I don’t know why but I love the annoyance in Luke’s voice when he says “what are you doing?”
Who's here after Luke showed up in the Mandalorian season 2 finale?!
Look at this trash
looking at it cuz of how trash this one was compared to the mandalorian
hahah me
Introducing grogu into the canon contradicts this movie unless grogu was killed prior to ep 7, which would be one of the worst things to happen and would cause the fans to burn down the franchise.
Me
I'm not a fan of Episode IX in general, but one thing I really love is this weird relationship between Luke and Rey. The way he asks "What are you doing?" really comes off like a teacher dealing with a pain in the ass student who they know can do better. Crotchety antisocial hermit Luke is great, I don't care what anyone says.
Luke is extremely stubborn and demanding. He is very “my way or high way” person but with good intentions. Absorbed Vader’s fatherly instincts and is the father that Anakin would have been.
Apart from the alien milk. Lets just leave that part out, shall we?
You do care. Otherwise you literally wouldn’t have posted this.
When Jedi Grand Master Skywalker tells Rey that confronting fear is the destiny of a Jedi not only is he right but it's also a trial every Jedi Apprentice must face besides looking in him or herself
Mark Hamill seems happy to play this scene unlike in SW VIII
That's because we don't have Rian Johnson ruining this movie
Yes. This movie wasn't perfect but it treated Luke better than TLJ
@@andresmolina8306 No. You couldn't be more wrong. It would've been the easiest thing for Johnson to pigeonhole Luke into the expected mentor archetype and we would've just had another stoic Jedi Master like we've already seen many times before. He actually respected this character more by taking the *one film* where he was going to get the spotlight and treating him as a main character, giving him an unexpected and truly substantial story, in a trilogy where he and the other "Legacy" characters were supposed to be in the backseat.
@@theS0UND_1 yes, making him drink green milk in a nasty way, throw away his lightsaber, give up after a mistake and leave all his friends and family for years like a coward, and try to kill his nephew is treating the character with respect. Even Mark hamill was angry with the way they wrote the character in TLJ
Luke: Rey, something are stronger than blood
Rey: what is it?
Luke: “Plot Armor”
"It would be picked up again by someone finish your journey"
-Luke Skywalker
0:47 General Grievous: A fine addition of my collection deserves more respect👏
“A Jedi’s weapon deserves more respect” and “I was wrong” made me laugh in the cinema because of how much of a blatant shot against TLJ it was.
not really. I think its showing how much he changed since then despite becoming one with the force. its a continuation of his arc from TLJ
In TLJ ITSELF Luke accepted he was wrong, rose up and re-aligned himself with the Jedi you moron 😂
Proof that TLJ was to intelligent for a lot of Star Wars fans
Nocto Ki disgusting
Nocto Ki Nah it was stupid for "reinventing" the characters we knew and love.
I remember the audience screaming and cheering seeing Force Ghost Luke
I kinda wish she pulled out Luke’s green saber, considering we barely saw it in the last film. Also the visual of the main Jedi colours, green and blue, deflecting palpatine’s force lighting would’ve been an interesting visual.
“All the Jedi live in you”
Let’s be honest, we were all a little mad Rey didn’t get Luke’s green saber.
Green saber is related to Luke fighting his father and his close contact with the dark side.That's why he did't give it to her.Besides there was Leia's saber to be taken.
What are you talking about my saber no it my
I mean.. yeeaaah. And Rey doesn’t rlly deserve the chosen one’s light saber
Yeah
@@YesNO-bn3pq you right but rey still a jedi so I support all sw movies
People calling Luke's saber catch at retcon clearly failed to pay attention to his arc in TLJ. His saber toss at the start of TLJ represents his weary and disillusioned self following his failure to train Ben and restore the Jedi order. He was down in the dumps for the first two-thirds of the movie. He came around and reembraced his Jedi ways following a visit from Yoda who knocked sense into him. At the end of the movie when he faced off against Kylo and the First Order, he openly declared "I will NOT be the last Jedi", cementing his reembrace of the Jedi ways once again. Hence why he could come back as a Force ghost and lecture Rey about respecting a Jedi's weapon.
Whatever makes it you feel better bub
@@wilfredolopez9865 that actually makes sense tho. Way more than the stupid theories trying to disprove that Padme didn't die of sadness
@@wilfredolopez9865 when someone makes an observation about the sequels, it's a reach but when someone makes ridiculous theories with the prequels, you go "ooooh that's amazing the prequels are masterpieces"
@@cucumberwater6 It would be plausible except for the director admitting that they didn’t have a plan
@@johnstephen4847 a lot of the decisions in the OT like Vader being Luke's father or Leia being his sister weren't planned, but they were brilliant. Luke's arc makes perfect sense but people don't even try to understand why he was like that in TLJ
0:54 Hamill to the directors of The Last Jedi.
“you’re a palpatine”
*AHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA*
How J.J. Abrams fixed the problems of episode 8: “I was wrong” lmao
Luke was indeed wrong. He's now much wiser despite being dead. Luke in this movie is the one we deserved in episode 8.
well if you think about it there was no way around to fix that awful fking mess that rian johnson left in episode 8 along with kennedy making things worse in episode 9.
*insert J Jonah Jamison laugh meme.
I’m pretty sure Luke already admitted he was wrong at the end of Episode 8.
did you even pay attention? luke came back to being his optimistic self at the end of TLJ.
I like Mark Hamill as Luke Skywalker more than I like his voice as the Joker and Chucky.
Trickster and master eraqus
Red skrull and chthon
Now he voices Skeletor on the new He Man cartoon series on Net Flix
He is the joker. Nails that character
@@borris3768 He also voiced Hobgoblin, Sticky Beard from Codename's Kid's Next Door, Arnim Zola, Alvin the Treacherous from Dreamworks Dragons, Skips from Regular Show and Maltruant from Ben 10 Omniverse.
So this is her true identity, now that all makes sense;
such great power and rage flow through her veins from her grandfather Sheev and so her parents kept her safe in hoping she could find a better path against him.
3:33 One thing I liked about this movie was the theme created for the protagonists, it’s so beautiful and really makes you feel like the end is near and everything is coming together, even tho it was all half baked. And Yoda’s theme coming RIGHT after it was just awesome
It's a super underrated theme, honestly that whole "The Rise of Skywalker" theme track is one of John Williams' best Star Wars compositions imo. It reminds me how "Across the Stars" captures the conceptual beauty and tragedy of Anakin and Padme's romance better than the actual story or performances. I can listen to "The Rise of Skywalker" and experience all the emotion of what the Star Wars saga ending should feel like even if it's not all there in the movie.
This is the Luke we should’ve had in episode 8
So right
My brother actually cried seeing this in theaters when Luke lifted the X-Wing like how Yoda did in his favorite movie of the original trilogy.
If Luke can grab his lightsaber, then just go fight Palpatine.
HISHE did just that
Luke could grab things because ach-to is strongly connected to the force
Exactly. These movies are written by overpaid con artist hacks.
If there's 1 thing the sequel trilogy has taught me, it's that death for a Jedi means absolutely nothing
That wasn't his job, just like it wasn't Obi Wan's job to defeat Vader. Just as only Luke could defeat Vader and bring Anakin back from the dark side, it was Rey's job to defeat her grandfather Palpatine, which she did with some help from a redeemed Ben Solo. The other lightsaber was for Kylo. It's a Skywalker descendant beating Palpatine again along with his own descendant.
I still liked this movie even though I know some of trevvorow’s script
I agree. I’ve read a bit of Trevvorow’s script and while it’s good, I’m happy with what we got
I mean, Trevorrow script wasn’t that good. Kylo’s motivation was basically his face 😂 I really prefer what we got with The Rise of Skywalker
Treverrow’s script was better. I still hate The Last Jedi and all. But at least Treverrow tried to expand on things set up in that movie instead of retconing it all
SuperJackster01 But it didn’t expand anything. I mean, the balance thing was explored in only one or two lines, but just like in TROS the good guys win again and nothing changes at all 😕 for me TROS is more exciting.
This is the Luke we should've gotten in TLJ. This is the Luke we expected.
I will say that luke getting a final arc of redemption and reconciliation before this was rather fulfilling
Rian Johnson just had to screw him up, luckily JJ Abrams fixed that
@@MariOmor1 Learned nothing, have you.
@@cerebrophage7709 Miss the part where that's my problem, I have.
@@MariOmor1 A true Star Wars fan, you are not.
If force ghosts can handle physical objects then they should have had the rest of the Jedi kicking ass at the end of the movie
I'm angry that Luke's voice lacked the spiritual echo when speaking as a Force ghost.
To be fair, Yoda's voice didn't echo in the previous film either.
@@Mac14329 Yes, I know. And I was angry at that, too. They made Qui-Gon and Obi-Wan's voices echo as Force ghosts.
@@kryptonianpowers It didn't make me angry. It didn't really matter to me.
"It was fear that kept me here..."
"Fear of this battle station."
Loved it.
No shit you (jake skywalker )goddamn hypocrite.
Impressive... most impressive
Don't be too proud of this technological terror you constructed, the ability to destroy a planet is insignificant next to the power of the force.
@@brickforge12 do not frighten us with your stories lord vader, your sad devotion to this ancient religion wont help us to recover stolen datatapes-- ugkh.
Luke: a Jedi's weapon deserves more respect.
"Proceeds to throw away lightsaber away in the last Jedi"
Uhm no. He doesn't proceed because this is follow up movie, where he even admits that he was wrong
Congrats. You’ve just learned what character progression is
You appear to be confused about which direction time goes
Luke Skywalker(ROS): "A Jedi's weapon deserves more respect!"
Luke Skywalker(TLJ): Throws his first lightsaber away and proceeds to burn the Jedi library...
It’s called an arc... lol y’all don’t get shit
Nocto Ki You mean this is Luke Skywalker and the hermit guy in The Last Jedi was Jake Skywalker.
@@blackorder9565 Like Nocto Ki said, it's called a character arc. Character arcs involve a character change. Every character changes in all stories. And life is all about change. But you and the rest of the toxic fandom just seem to just want to stay the same.
Ed Davies Lol, calling people toxic because they have different opinions is a shitty thing to do and proves that you're also a toxic fan, I never said i want Luke
to stay the same but you said so. Also, there must be certain events that happen in order for a character to change his/her point of view.Tell me which event happened that lead to Luke believing killing Kylo was the last resort, we never saw it did we, that's why people are complaining about the Jake's arc in TLJ because it was executed horribly and contradictory in its nature when you compare it to Luke's arc in the OT. Jake Skywalker in the Last Jedi abandoned his family and ran away from the war despise the fact that the first order wasn't even a thing at that time( acording to The Force Awakens, FO rose to power when Luke was absent), At the end of the last jedi, Jake force-projected himself to Crait just to Troll his nephew and didn't try to redeem Kylo (Ren straight up asked Jake whether he was there to save his soul and Jake said NO). If he was Luke Skywalker, he would never ran away from the war or abandon his family and would try to reason with Kylo to redeem him just like he did with Vader. He made the exact mistake which he has learned in the OT.
@@blackorder9565 It was briefest moment of pure instinct that made Luke believe that killing Ben was the last resort! And even that brief moment of pure instinct soon passed like a fleeting shadow as soon as he turned on his lightsaber! And the dark voices inside Ben's head was what caused him to briefly fall into that small moment of pure instinct! And the dark voices were created by Palpatine through Snoke, to manipulate Luke into thinking that his nephew has made his choice to turn to the dark-side! Finally Luke Skywalker exiled himself to Ach-To because he was so guilt ridden for having succumbed to that brief moment of instinct that caused Ben to turn to the dark-side, that he's not going to let it happen again! He even said it himself in that very clip, that he was wrong to exile himself and that it was fear that kept him in Ach-To!
Also while he did trick Kylo by force-projecting onto Crait, he did it so that the last of the Resistance and his sister can escape and regain their strength so that they can fight the First Order again, so that he can apologise for what happened the night Ben turned to the dark-side, and so that he can pass the torch to Rey!
The scene with Luke and Leia was beautiful. Especially since we got to see a young Carrie and a young Mark in Star Wars again.
Another retcon to the Last Jedi, and I'm all for it.
This is one of the few moments that makes me kinda like Ep. 9.
I still remember people in the theater legitimately cheering when Like raised his X-Wing from the water, one of the few good parts of this movie
4:03 witnessing that scene in the big screen was favorite moment in movie history.
One of the best scenes in the movie. I love how TROS corrected the wrongs of TLJ
The sequels felt off but this scene .... man did it feel right at home with the Star Wars I grew up with
Luke X-Wing : Why I always under water :/
He finally lifted his X-Wing!
-Wait a minute. You can use the force, and hold a lightsaber after you're dead?
-Yeah, why?
-You're coming with me.
Oh my god I can never watch this scene seriously again after watching How it Should Have Ended.
You could say the same thing in return of the Jedi
@@afish3976 how?
That's the Luke Skywalker I remember.
And I loved the way he redeemed himself when he said to Rey about never leaving the island: "I was wrong, it was fear that kept me here."
Love the smile clearly aimed at the audience as if to say, Yep, finally lifted the damn ship!
0:33 Anakin would be proud of his son catching his lightsaber when Rey threw it
Alright not gonna lie, this whole entire scene kinda hit me in the feels and was worth watching in theaters just for this one damn scene.
I feel like these movies wouldn't have been so terrible if they weren't a tug of war between JJ and Rian
That x-wing scene always gives me the feels.
Luke lifting up the X-Wing like Yoda did was a nice touch
If Luke could hold the lightsaber why didn’t he face the emperor he would be invincible ahahahahj
I’mtoxiclol Force ghosts were incapable of being on Exogul.
There was something I read about the sith having some sort of weapon that could trap force ghosts or something like that and that since they didn't know whether the sith did or did not have that sort of weapon, they didn't want to risk it. Well that's from what I've read.
Jedi Ghosts must not interfere
Otinad for all nerds responding it’s a joke
@@felings4u544 LMAO like Ghostbusters? 😂😂
Notice we don't see Luke's right hand since it was cut off by vader... What's left remains hidden under his robe during this whole scene
he may have gotten it back in the afterlife
Notice how anakin isn't a crisp head and torso in rotj. You get limbs back in the afterlife
Something I noticed. We never once see Luke's right hand - the one he lost to Vader. I think it's cause they don't wanna show Luke's failure OR create debate amongst the fans whether he should or shouldn't have it as a force ghost.
4:22 - Thank you for everything, Mark.
Something that's bothered me, and I've never seen anyone else have this issue, is when Luke said "you have everything you need" I thought Rey was going to use the Force to guide herself instead of needing the map. It would have been an accomplishing moment for Rey's training and also she takes Luke's X-Wing where he iconically relied on only the Force to destroy the Death Star.
A Jedi’s weapon deserves more respect? Uh, Luke, aren’t you aware that that weapon you caught was used by your dear old daddy to massacre like fifty kids?
A lightsaber is a sacred tool used by the Jedi. It has no feelings or opinions, only the wielder may choose how to use it.
TrueMohax there’s also Sith style lightsabers, which are created when dark siders corrupt Jedi kyber crystals simply by pouring their dark emotions into them
@@eddiejmartinez8631 Luke also threw it away in the last movie like it was completely useless. Even better.
This is the Luke I wanted to see in the Last Jedi, or at least develop into by the end of the film.
I'll be honest. Yoda's scene from Last Jedi and the fighter raising scene from this one is the only really good things about the last trilogy. I mean, yeah there are some other things as well. But I love how they honor Yoda's lessons to young Luke, and how even Luke now get's exhausted in the same way as Yoda when raising the ship. His journey ended where it began in some ways.
Yes, it was a perfect scene. Perhaps the sequels (at least 1 and 3) will be remembered as flawed classics, as the prequels now are.
Agreed
Matt Blom You’re so right! I mean they’re flawed, but they have amazing and epic scenes, and they’re really enjoyable!!!
@@mattblom3990 all the trilogies are flawed. The effects in the OT have aged like milk, the dialogue in the prequels was atrocious and the sequels add nothing to the overall story. Despite all this the important thing is all the movies entertained people for decades and will continue to do so
These movies are VISUALLY amazing. I'll leave it at that.
"A Jedi's weapon deserves more respect" says the guy who chucked his light sabre over his shoulder in the previous film.
You may not thing about it but "some things are stronger than blood" is a great theme and a part of reality because not all people find love from people of their bloodlines. That could be either because they didnt meet them either because those were just assholes. So this scene gets a 👏👏from me.
I like that theme, but I really wish they had stuck with Rian's Rey is "no one" idea. The idea that anyone in the universe can make a difference and that you don't have to be part of some bloodline is a powerful message for kids. Heck it's the entire premise of LoTR and a large part of the reason LoTR is so timeless. I also don't think Palpatine needed to come back for this movie. Ben killed Snoke and had ascended to big baddie status. The whole movie could've been Ben's redemption arc without Palpatine as a bad guy. Not resurrecting him would've also kept Vader's sacrifice in RotJ meaningful. I don't hate this movie, but some of the choices were just stupid.
"Yeah, this is my old X-wing from 30 years ago. It's been underwater for the passed, shit I don't even remember, got a little rust but, should get you from point a to point b!!"
For real though, as much shit people talk about these movies, I still enjoy the scenes like this where they bring you back to where it all began or bring back the nastalgic feeling of something seen before!!
Best scene of the movie in my opinion.
My favorite scene was Han Solo's cameo, but this is one of the highlights too.
Luke uses the force by lifting up the old X-Wing
Just like Yoda did for him back in 1980
Can’t lie when Luke lifted that xwing, just straight tears of happy nostalgia
I don’t understand how they got young luke so perfectly but continue to mess up young Leia!
Shaun Bang Ikr. I feel like they should have just used deep fake technology it would have looked a lot better and more realistic.
Shaun Bang ruclips.net/video/A91P2qtPT54/видео.html
Spectrumoe the deepfake they did for rogue one was way better than even this Rise of Skywalker one! I just don’t get how no one caught how bad this looked!
Shaun Bang I don’t believe they used deep fakes in either (although I could be wrong). For the fight scene they took one of the cut scenes of Leia from Return Of The Jedi and basically stuck it on Carrie’s daughter’s face and then changed the lighting.
Shaun Bang Here is what they did for rise of skywalker: ruclips.net/video/Z9d1bkRC0Hs/видео.html
It’s cool how Luke can still do things.
Episode 9 is a incoherrent clusterfuck. But this scene at least created a good feeling. Luke telling the new protagonist that it is a jedis duty to confront your greatest fear and that some things are more important than blood.
I bet you have no reason why you think this movie sucks 😂😂😂
The luke and Leia training made me so happy and knowing I always wanted to see Leia train.
"I was hoping for kenobi, why are you here?"
How sad that Mark Hamill/luke in disney's sequel trilogy is basically treated like an afterthought...
How was he. He is literally the reason the resistance still exists. He saved everyone.
@@TheWeepingDalek Sure. But for a film called "Rise of Skywalker," being the only one that legitimately possesses the Skywalker name, you would think he would have a little more than a reshoot cameo....
@@cpt.dr.hawkeye1740 a movie called attack of the clones had like 10 minutes of clones.
Luke and Kylo Ren were the best characters in the ST.
@@TheWeepingDalek kid, stop trying to defend the sequel trilogy lol
Just like vader luke's theme is always there when he appears