Range Rover Autobiography vs Suzuki Jimny - 4x4 face off | Autocar
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 4 окт 2024
- Question: which car will go further off road? Subscribe now: smarturl.it/aut...
Might it be a Range Rover? The epitome of luxury SUVs, constructed by one of the most famous 4x4 manufacturers on the planet, tested here in £120,000 SVAutobiography form and reputedly capable of going almost anywhere in the world, and powered by a mammoth V8 turbodiesel engine?
Or could it be a £15,000 Suzuki Jimny, an old-fashioned little 4x4 powered by an even tinier engine, of just 1.3-litres and making just 84bhp.
We head to an old quarry - a very, very muddy old quarry - to put the pair of them to the ultimate off-road test.
New videos are uploaded to Autocar each week. Don't miss a single one. Subscribe now: smarturl.it/aut...
Visit our website at www.autocar.co.uk
Autocar, the world's leading motoring magazine and website, delivers industry-leading news, the most in-depth car reviews and opinion from our team of experts. Our presenters include some of the world's top motoring journalists who have unrivalled access to the world's fastest, rarest, most exotic and most exciting cars on some of the world's best roads and race tracks.
Follow AUTOCAR here:
LIKE Autocar on Facebook: goo.gl/mWG2I5
FOLLOW Autocar on Twitter: goo.gl/DSAnav
FOLLOW Autocar on Instagram: goo.gl/N2Id68
+1 Autocar on Google+: goo.gl/h6UHVu
Check out our full video catalog: goo.gl/xHxfRA
For car reviews you can trust, subscribe to Autocar: smarturl.it/aut...
is everyone here for the jimny too?
Anton G yes 🅂🄸🅁
No
Yes
lol... YES!!
Yep. I like reliability.
The Jimmy is far more the "proper off-roader": it has live axles, which are almost always better than independent suspension off-road, and the simplicity is preferred by the majority of off-road drivers because it means there is less to go wrong - if it does it's easy to fix too - and it is easier to modify.
I dont need proof what Jimny could do, I came here to see how much they wasted that RR.
marlboro9tibike Yeah i clicked the video for modern Landie humiliation
😂😂🔥
Hahaha!
This.
Same here, the Jimny is more of a Land Rover Defender than the new 2020 models.
Jimny is old school off roader. The design assumes that you don't need all the heavy comforts and luxury to travel on rough terrain. And that's what it is. Cheap, reliable and a bump or dent on it will not kill your wallet.
I always knew you could little Jimny!
wtfdididolastnight don't ever thought my 1999 grand Siskin
wtfdididolastnight .
nowdays new car is busheet.
Get that little thing to India
Is The Matrix just generating AI gibberish?
Almost none of the above is true.
Had my jinny for 10 years & honestly that thing could go absolutely anywhere..
Even if you rolled it in the ditch it's so light you could just flip it over & keep going 🤣
Glad Suzuki has maintained the Jimny looks. Has a personality.
The jimny is amazing off road. Can do everything the big boys can, at a fraction of the cost. Love it. Great video.
Exactly, with skilled off road drivers & suitable tyres, both cars would fare better. However as stated, the Jimny is cheaper than the options on the Rangy.
Cavush what about towing a 3500kg trailer?
That Jimny is a classic, remaining example of the Japanese manufacturing and design ethic; out-perform and better the competition, for a fraction of the price.. They do this in every single area they have tried it, electronics, motorbikes, knives, technology etc since the 50's. and something China have tried to emulate but failed immensely.
Shame the Japanese manufacturers are now trying to Eurocentric their products and economise their outlays and manufacturing. We need more of this ethic! Unsurpassed reliability and quality for the everyday person, through excellent and innovative design and quality.
My Workshop dont know of many offroaders that take 3500kg trailers into the mud
Yes, military type off roaders begining with Unimog.
All that without locking diffs and fancy off road tech... pretty cool.
Indeed, Jimny doesn't have a centre or rear diff lock. But, he forgot to mention in fact it's a part time 4WD which means Jimny doesn't even have a centre diff at the first place! It runs as a RWD car in normal situation. As soon as 4WD (doesn't matter 4H or 4L) is selected, it will run both front and rear axles equally just like a full time 4WD car with centre diff locked, as Jimny has a solid drive shaft without a diff at all. In short, Jimny in 4H/4L = RR or any other full time 4WDs in 4H/4L with centre diff locked.
lovice It is a front wheel drive normally.
This model jimny have 4x4 all grip pro at low
lovice, no. the range rover still has a rear locking diff, so its not equal
Couldn't have said it better myself
I want that suzuki so much
Theyre great offroaders, but the on road ride is terrible. I had one for a few years and it was a love hate relationship. It would be great if I could afford to own 2 cars, or if I had a lot of land to play around on.
I say I would want both a Suzuki Jimmy and a Suzuki cappuccino. Would be the perfect combination of sports car and off-roader, and both of those combined would fit in a American parking spot.
Rocket Raccoon get a Samurai instead
Me too, man... 2023 is the earliest you'll see them stateside... meanwhile the rest of the world gets the far sexier new 2019 one.
Rocket Raccoon me too
I love the Jimny, and I can't wait for next generation!
Love my jimny, never want to drive anything else (and I DO go to yoga class with it as well :D )
I'm 1.92 mts tall and i sleep inside mine with my dog when i take it to the dessert...best rig i have had..!
Snobery doesn't win in the rough conditions
I think that with better tires the Range Rover could go through that mud easily, however that Suzuki Jimmy is a great offroader, never underestimate those little Japanese jeeps
Great little cars off road and the snow.
i think its the 10th time i watch this video. A year and a half i bought my jimny, same as the video and man it is a very fun car, gets me everywhere and si reliable. Done a lot of trails and difficult tracks that everytime i go offroading. it surprises me the capabilities and all that with no tc ecs or abs
over here at iceland, where we have some real experience with trucks and suv's, and truly using them in off road conditions, you wont find any range rovers in the highlands, but you cant go for 5 minutes without bumping in to a jimny, those things have a proper ladder chassis, solid front and rear axles, these things just work, you often see auto magazine guys test a range rover on some trail provided by the manufactor, but in real the RR and many other luxury upmarket suv's are not ideal for off roading, low profile tyres, fancy bumpers, vulnerable high tech equipment, puff daddy would get his fancy shoes all dirty real soon if he tried to really off road his RR
What about the Land Cruiser? G-class?
@@alfredoalfaro5000 strong ones too
Best modern classic 4x4s are land cruiser 70,80series,hilux/hilux surf,Suzuki vitara mk1 ,Suzuki jimny ,Jeep Wrangler,Nissan patrol 61,Land Rover defender,pajero mk1 and mk2 !
Great design remains relevant for a long time. The Jimny is awesome!
This is one of the most interesting face-off I've ever viewed
The best offroad vehicle is lightweight, has small wheelbase, good ground clearance and the jimny checks all of them.
Cracking video. My Jimny is fitted with a 3 inch lift, oversized mud terrains and a rear diff locker. For a lot less than the rangerover by 10s of thousands... I know what I'd choose
I have the same just no diff lock, are you using the one from jimny bits? And are they any good
What's interesting is that most people who buy the range rover would never even do that off road. Maybe some. But unlikely. So let's just conclude that the Suzuki is pretty damn good for what it is.
That was such a wonderful video ! The terrain was extremely challenging. That's exactly how off road vehicle comparisons should be made.
Opening line I would say you’re more likely to see a Range Rover at yoga than the Suzuki 🙄
Thank God for Suzuki, all these other ‘compact’ SUVs have just grown and grown and grown in size! The VW Trox is about the only other compact one left along with the awesome Jimmy.
Jimmy > city tractor
moon shine *Jimny
Noone fucking cares about your 500 euro suzuki.
180 people prove you wrong sunshine.
Mr Smith There's also fanclubs for trabant 501s, even the worst of cars have a following, what's your point.
The Jimny is a reliable car that is awesome off road. It puts £60,000 cars to shame in that respect. Range rover are unreliable, leather clad turds.
You have 'demonstrated' what all the people in the off-roading community already knew. Thanks for discovering the hot water...
Go Jimny go , cost 1/6 or less than the Range Rover and it wins , luxury Range Rover , bare bones Jimny but who cares off road , except you don't want to scratch or damage the Range Rover after paying all that money :-)
Stephen Kite more like 1/12
😮
Whats the point of getting an off road car if you're afraid to scratch it. And also, who brings their range rovers off road. Its built for stupid rich milfs
On a narrow mountain road a small car like the Jimny is about the only thing that can get through to the top to carry supplies (that or a donkey maybe), the only weakness is really deep mud because the clearance is not as high compared to bigger offroaders , but I don't think that's an usual situation.
The new Jimny looks AWESOME!! Perfect modern update for the little charmer. I may even get one!
One of them is off-roader.
Other is SUV (sub-urban vehicle)
The Jimny, my favourite rental car.
That's funny because we have one at my rental company. The thing has seen some beating but it's the perfect example of less equals more.
Jimny’s are legendary offroad. Every weekend these little warriors. One of our local magazines had one for a long termer and even turbocharged it so day to day the Jimny the Little Samurai is a daily
I've had a Jimny since 2008 (new) and it has done 82 000km . Some suspension problems and a new gearbox. It will go anywhere but it is quite uncomfortable. Just the way I like it!
No comparison both are awesome and legend
You call the RR legend? Its not the old RR anymore
luxury,comfort, effortless?
that's not offroading!!
Jimnys are brill. Such fun in snow.
The problem is not the Range Rover, the problem is the "driver".
Range Rover is trash
@union310 you probably never driven one so how do u no
@union310 unlikely but if you have then you'd know that it would rinse any Jimmy off road my 2015 v8 goes just fine done 100k in it never had any problems goes off road all the time
union310 where I got the car from in Ipswich they all used them as farm cars, tbh I don’t know how they can afford it but if you had to chose 1 for free which one would you have?
@union310 I do know what you mean when it comes to bigger cars sinking, unfortunately that's the laws of physics the heavier the car the further it goes down,sometimes it helps sometimes it doesn't, in terms of making mess it doesn't 😂
It's like watching an unreliable lumbering buffalo with a chandeleur on it's head take on a billy goat.😅
Man O War very well put 🤣
lolololololololol hahahahahahah!!!!!!!!!!!!!1
Man O War well played sir 👏
Billy goat too eazy mate, just been there with Jimny this summer.
100% Man O War!
Range Rover is good for getting on a sidewalk and parking there. It's also off-road, right?
theonechocolatechips rocky mode may handle this task :))
Too dangerous for their hand crafted, ingraved, gold coated delicate suspensions.
They are seriously good offroad tho, they are just never used
The jimmy never seems to disappoint!
Please do Lada Niva (4x4) vs Jimny.
It has been already done.
MrPaukann in Autocar? Don't think so.
Djordjeblrs, in the same format.
Lada Niva vs Mahindra THAR and Suzuki Jimny.
Niva has IFS so I think Jimny will ace it
2019 jimny is so beautiful now and yes, jimny inst a SUV, is a real old style 4x4 like jeep wrangler or mercedes g class.
That was a really enjoyable video, extremely well presented by two calm and collected professional journalists.
Make it right, make it light. Here in the Austrian mountains lot's of Jimnys with the forest workers. Dacia Dusters, too.
Imagine if the Suzuki had 3 locking diffs😍
I’ve just bought an 05 Jimny, can’t wait to pick it up next week
Suzuki Jimny will beat Range Rover Expensive ass anytime anywhere. No Assumptions there.
Range Rover is king. Jimmy is a kids car.
The Jimmy beat the range rover but the is better then the little Jimmy.
@union310 Did the Jimmy beat the Range Rover on luxury, comfort, space and practically?
Replace that fairy driving the Rover with someone that has some simple commonsense like yourself I'd assume who would most likely remove those stupid road tyres and replace them with MT Tyres that is suited to the job and actually put some effort into driving instead of prancing around like a fairy that has no idea of what it's doing... Then you'd get a better result than the pansy Autocar driver who failed to put in any effort into the task of driving. Paid to play the fool I think... Both vehicles are very good at off road driving if driven by someone who knows what they are doing ..
I agree with brother LOL
Would love to have the Jimny in the U.S. Thoroughly enjoyed them while living in Japan, and I know it wouldnt sell well, here but still it's a fantastic runabout and offroader!
Why do so called reviewers always try to ‘test’ cars off road when they haven’t got a clue what they’re doing?! It’s like getting an anorexic to host a cookery programme.
Hear hear, he literally says that at the one minute mark! Unfortunately, this is content tailored for RUclips, made to get into your feed like it does in yours & mine.
I think It's pretty obvious really. Not everyone that buys these cars will take them off road and if they do, most will not have a clue how to drive through muddy & rough terrain. It would also be pointless having professional off roaders driving them because they know all the tricks to always get them through (regardless of what they are driving)
The Jimmy is far more reliable, and if you do break something it's easy to fix, but the range rover when it goes wrong and they do all the time ,you just have to scrap it because it costs to much to put it right, and that doesn't eve factor in the depreciation that's horrendous.
This guy has his stereotypes all mixed up. Yoga Pants are literally the dress code for RR drivers.
Do they even sell RRs to men?
I've had Jimny, Mitrubishi Parejo, and the Sport, and LC200 5.7 over the past several years. In terms of overland capability, Jimny is definitely the master, no doubt about it. It beats anything you can think of.
When the range brakes down so will your bank account.
Really cool clip, guys. Well done!
There are so many Jimny's down here in rural Cornwall. Small size for the narrow lanes, they can handle mud and such. They hold their price well, just about the only thing they are no good for is towing.. You can tell if it's a city Jimny or a country one, back seat up then it's city, back seats down all the time for a bail of hay or a couple of feed sacks.
I will say we tow with a Jimny. With a 1035kg 4/5 berth caravan behind it. The sail effect of it upsets it much more then weight. Yes it’s not exactly quick. But it drags us 120 miles each way to santa pod and back to watch events. Will sit at 57 ish with the lorries happily and does a bit more when the time comes to push past. Everything just requires a good look ahead and some planning. It’s ridiculous how adequately the jimny handles what’s thrown at it even when really it shouldn’t be thrown at it.
Yep same here in the wild west of Ireland, my back seat is always down 😂
I own a 2009 Range Rover AND a 1992 Suzuki Samurai. Both are awesome in their own way
No surprises here. Japanese SUVs are the real off-road tools for people who demand such. Range Rovers are best on tarmac, outside the country club, doing the school run and on the back of a flat bed truck.
You can't afford a Range Rover
You serious? If you think the Range Rover is like any other posh SUV then you're totally, completely wrong.
best luxury off-roader is Cayenne!
Lol they dont use range rover in real off road. They use toyota amazon etc.
khurramsultan2012 but it is one of the most capable off roader despite being driven by posh people.
That Landrover only just managed to drag its belly over that hump, the little Jimny walked over that bit.
The wading depth is also easy to improve on the Jimny by fitting a snorkel and doing some minor improvements on sealing off a few bits a bit better.
From the closeup video, it appeared that the LR had the tires aired down, while the Jimny's were fully inflated, giving the LR a big advantage. Seems a bit of a cheat.
Great video. Thanks for not making it shorter. I enjoyed it.
Driving one myself I'd say the only thing to improve would be the 17 seconds 0-60 :)
I think the RR driver was not using the car the way he should.. I mean, this is why Jeremy Clarkson is the best, he would send it hard on the RR
That Jimny will wade a lot higher than you think.
Hoo GOD,,,This one is Extreme Challenging of,,Range Rover & Suzuki Jimmy.....👌👌👌
Forgot to say ,the RR guy couldn't drive sheep !.
My 2008 Jimny has done 90 000km. At guess I'd say about 50% on gravel roads. Yes, we have a lot of them in South America. Lots of potholes and volcano dust. The car has a rather bumpy ride and the short wheelbase makes for rather challenging handling over the bumpy stuff if you are in a hurry. I had to replace the gearbox but other than that it has been reliable.
jimny is a legend
" I don't know the first thing about off-road, but let me tell which is the best 4x4" Sounds legit.
I've had experience with Suzuki machines and mostly, the 2009 Grand Vitara with the 2.7L V6. They're extremely great offroaders.
My friends and I were taking a few offroaders up Cameron Highlands in Malaysia and that hilly terrain is known to be extremely wet and muddy due to all those soil used by rice, corn and tea plantations littered across the whole highlands. I got the Suzuki Grand Vitara while we have a Discovery 4 TDV6, a rented J80 Land Cruiser by an Australian friend who visited us and followed us on the roadtrip, a Toyota Hilux driven by a Malaysian friend (He opens a garage and that Hilux was his work vehicle which, is also modded) and a Land Rover Series III. We were driving into ankle deep mud and sometimes even higher than that and incline that's almost 35 degrees steep and every car got past except the Discovery. The Grand Vitara being the only ones out of the bunch that doesn't have a pure offroad gearing set up was being dogged on even by the Discovery driver (My friend also) but he was the one that was constantly stuck while the rest of us had no issues at all. I really love the Grand Vitara.
I've got a standard 2005 55 reg jimmy with road tyres and when it snowed in the UK before Christmas it went everywhere without any issues! Also the jimny is my first car.
Do you still have it?
The driver in the range rover pretty much sums up what a range rover is. It's an overhyped off-roader with arrogant drivers. You can barely modify one. If you want to go rock crawling you take a JEEP. And if you want to drive across continents without breaking down, you take a Land Cruiser.
Nope, it's a bargain luxury car, has been for the best part of 30 years. None of the cars you mention come close to it's remit. No other car on sale does to be fair.. £80 grand starting price for something that rivals a rolls royce more than it does a jeep. And on top of that, it's a superb offroader, as good as anything on similar tyres.
Any other view is just silly. Like comparing a single seater to a GT3.
Yeah these new ones are shite, the 80s rangies, and (shock horror!) even the P38s are much better as offroad machines. Nowadays if you want a proper offroad land rover you're fucked, as the defender isn't being made anymore and everything else is for mums to look cool outside the school gates.
Range Rovers have always been properly good off-road. Maybe the new ones not as much as previous models, but they're highly competent nonetheless. Better than American crap anyway. And why the fuck would you want to take a brand new Range Rover rock crawling?
No mention of what tyres were on the RR and what was on the Suzuki. I'm sure the Rangey would do much better if it were on some really chunky off-road tyres.
Furthermore, you wouldn't' want to go 4-up with luggage down to the Italian Alps in the Suzuki. The Range Rover is far more capable in other areas than the Suzuki.
Nope. Your Range rover will break down. And it will take a Land Cruiser to come and rescue you.
Had a little F20 in Australia, got to cape york without any probs. With water in the car, wheels in the air it went on and on.
One flat tire all the way.
Toyota land cruiser sitting on the side laughing at this cow and goat trying to off road .. but to be honest im totally impressed with the Jimmny , what a machine ..
Surely makes you wonder is all the gadgetry and hefty prices under the name of technological marvel really required to make cars great! Wonderful video!
Suzuki: lose some weight fatty!
Range Rover: *cries*
Everyday I get my transit up a mud slope like that! It's my driveway!!
Didn't know range rover still do off roading since I seen so many white girls driving around with them
Dexter Sullen 'TRUTH' white girls? Lol are you black man? ;)
Miłosz L don't get me wrong here, I have nothing against white girls but that's the stereotype around where I live. Like if I had a nickel for every time sent that combo, hell this the only time ive seen a new land Rover off roading
never seen a black guy offroad either
Dexter Sullen 'TRUTH' ok, so I'm sorry for my misunderstanding ;)
Rude Dogg lol you never seen African people, doing them tour guides, national geographic
You guys are reminding me of the sorrow I felt when Suzuki withdrew from the Canadian market
Sad day 😭
Keep your thumbs out of the steering wheel, who are you, James May?
This video is absolutely amazing!! I really enjoy it. I really love those two SUVs, and you've made a nice video about them doing that off-road! Thank you very much.
It may says... The most expensive Off-roader vs The cheapest Off-roader!
LOL... Hahaha.
The dude in the range is just a bad driver off road
No he's not. Despite the fact his car has basically 22" rims with bog standard road tyres he did absolutely amazing. He drove it nearly perfectly. What let him down were his tyres. Low profile tyres do not perform off road.
i cannot see me with that landie conquer that trail. and i'm sure i can do with my cheap ssangyong. that thing have 2 lockers. but look.
Mernerner there wasn't a ladies anywhere near this
Mike B ,well , neither could I see any studded tyre on the jimny ! The jimny also had normal car wheels ! You guys can do anything to make an exotic look great ,I suppose! - from a defender owner!
Suzuki is arguably the king of cheap and supremely capable fourbies.
I remember I used to have a "long wheelbase" Sierra ute (about half the size of my old man's Y60 Nissan Patrol) that was an absolute monster on the beach and the dunes thanks to it weighing only about 800kg. This is despite it having only about 40hp at best as well.
Does the new Range Rover come with a "bumper to bumper" warranty?
Asking for a friend.
Neo VeNoM haha 😂 I know your friend 😂😂
Reminds me of an off-road test by one of the magazines, in about 1993... of the 6 or 7 4-door SUV's that were in the challenge, the only one that went everywhere that the Range Rover did was the Suzuki Sidekick! Automobile Magazine, iirc...
the old gypsy can do even better 😀
Harisankar Sony or how about the Austin champ!! 😂
A few accessories like big mud tyres lift kit lockers etc won't cost a whole lot but will make the little Suzuki unstoppable
Jimny is so much better than the Rover, m definitely taking it to my next red carpet event. Wait! what? no!!!!
Range Rover can look like that, with all that luxury packed in, and still do hardcore offroading. Jimny is a hill goat, Range Rover is the king of the Jungle. You don't complain when a Lion can't climb hills like a goat? It's a Lion after all. Period.
Range rover is bullshit...
...if by "lion" you mean bloated station wagon - queen of the parking lot.
We used to have the sierra's in Australia and they were just a bloody awesome little ( I emphasise LITTLE) 4x4... just like the Jimny almost unstoppable.
Lighter that’s all, the RR always going to struggle....🤔
"What mud?". That killed me. The title of this video should rather say, "Jimny vs RR"
Cute test... still take the Range, obviously!
"obviously"
Have fun walking mate
Caleb harris I could buy what 5 or more Zuki's for the price? Have fun walking after those low pro's pop 5 minutes down the trail
Anthony Dayspring99 to sell and buy 10 Jimmy's?
The problem the RR has when off roading is the fool behind the controls. I have a L322 Autobiography and love it, one of the best 4x4 I have ever owned.
I dont mind saying that the Jimmy is a good little offroad car.
But the muddy hill climb was flawed.
The landrover look like it was going as slow as possible to make sure it didnt have mometum to go up the small hill.
The Jimmy was at its first attempt going a lot faster, but it failed its first try.
- and allmost failed its sekond try
And the last LandRover try wasnt much faster than its first try.. it would make the hill with a bit more speed and a bit more heavy foot, and some tires for something else than pavement.
But all we need to go offroad is.. low gearing, diff lock on all 4, and a light car with ground clearence, its not science.
jerk ! ;)
Your correct.
Your right! And He said it "i'm not an off roader" then why the hell he need to ride and test a range rover on offeroad!
And one more thing for sure he did not lower the tires pressure which will make a big big different in the proformance!
I noticed that as well!
Simplicity its the best!!
*What 🤔I'm Having Both of Them Fok-it Yea👀*
where can i get that Suzuki Jimmy? i genuinely really liked it
Since when range rovers are off road cars again ?
Since the late 70s?
Since they had low range and more than 300 mm of ground clearance and lockers? Fit a decent set of tires and the Jimny won't stand a chance.
My friend's Jimny got stuck on the soft sand at the beach. So 5 of us + 2 surf fishermen just lifted the entire car and rescued. If it was a Range Rover, it would be totalled. Sunk like Titanic in the high tide.