luke sending out a modest, choice specs, 252 sp. atk, tera dragon, mega launcher, dragon pulsing charizard against a clodsire with 10 hp: “i actually don’t know if this’ll kill”
It doesn’t really matter though, since Luke just has to say which one he wants. Knowing where they is redundant if you know the name of each one at that point.
"Can you tell me the names of all the pokemon in front of you?" Me:"yes" "So what are they?" Me: "you didn't ask what their names are, you just asked if I can tell you"
10:52 check the side of its head. Black spikes facing upwards for the dark type Single Strike Urshifu, and white spikes facing downward for the water type Rapid Strike Urshifu.
I realized that the question was "Can you please give me the names of each Pokemon?", the question is not "What are the names of each Pokemon?". This means that he could have answered with "Yes, I could, but I won't" while speaking truthfully and simply not have said the names.
Luke legit could’ve shown the feet in the last round in any order that he wanted. The question was simply to show each starter’s feet, not to do it in order. Similarly, that Galarian Slowking didn’t have to be specified. The question was about the name of each Pokémon, and the name of Galarian Slowking is just “Slowking”.
Wartortle is on the cover of Pokemon Super Mystery Dungeon riding Charizard's back, so Rich was right either way with Wartortle/Blastoise being on a game cover
I absolutely LOVED this video! The idea was super fun and I liked that it’s kinda a mix of a bunch of previous starter ideas into one! Plus, anything you upload is always a banger
That was so good! I love how it allows each creator to be so, well, creative with the question asks. And I actually really enjoyed you guys being able to ask the really OP questions like what their names were. It was super fun to watch.
Hey Luke. I have a then we fight idea. It's similar to catching mons to spell a word that you're given. However, you have to spell any 6 letter word you can think of by choosing your starters. You're given just the first letter of each starter, as your choosing your starters, you're trying to spell any word you can. If you are given letters you can't use, you have to skip and your opponent is given the chance to picker a starter in order to spell their word. First person to spell a word gets a neat little bonus like choosing any ability for one of their pokemon or something. And then you battle. For example, you're given the letters C - L - B, you choose C. The. Your next lot of Starters Are A - B - C, you can't really use B or C to spell a word beginning with C, so you choose A. You keep going, and your letters so far are C-A-R-R, but then you get to starters that are Q-X-R you can't use those, so your opponent gets the chance to take a pokemon, and they get an advantage cause they know what the pokemon are, but they can also choose to skip if they can't use a letter. You keep going till you have your word/team.
I feel like you need to add a rule called the Genie clause to this, where you answer their questions truthfully, but in whatever context you decide. For example, when asked what their names are, you up and name them on the spot.
Something cool to consider for the future if the box art question is ever asked again is that the Hisui starter base forms, Pikachu, Staraptor, Lucario, Bidoof, Rhyhorn, and Ralts are all featured on the cover of Legends Arceus (you can't see Ralts on the box itself but it is on the Switch icon, it's on Rhyhorn's back)
If you ever do this kind if vid again a few ideas for questions could be Asking for the typings of the pokemon on screen Asking for their abilities Asking what their highest base stat is Asking what the first letter is Asking if any have a regional variant Asking the generation each came out in Theres obviously more and probably better questions but these are just ones i thought of, hope it helps out in a future vid, i love your stuff ❤
Yo this concept is great, the plethera of questions you can ask makes it very unique and fun. Great stuff as always Luke and Rich was lovely guest as always.
Love the vine whip idea because it would make Vic better for play outside of grasshole teams. I think this would also discourage use of grasshole overall
I like this open-ended question setup! Maybe try where you can only ask about one of the three Pokemon. (So either "Which of the three...?" or "Tell me ___ about the Pokemon on the L/C/R")
This is a great concept, I think we need more of these! I don’t know if it was because of you and Rich being hilarious or the fact it’s all the then we fight ideas combined but it was a great one for sure
To balance out the concept you could brainstorm a set of 6 questions each that you’re allowed to ask with the same concept of once you ask a question you can’t ask again. This avoids the many questions such as “what are the names of all my options” “can you take a picture of all my options” etc. Some examples could be 1. Is there a legendary on screen and what is its location 2. What is the highest base stat total of the pokemon on screen taking into account their evolutions 3. Which option sould be the toughest for your team to fight against (these are just a few questions I thought of to show how each question would be niche and not correlated to the others, preventing asking the same question in different ways)
Speaking as someone who has had both Urshifu forms on my party at the same time and have seen them in resting mode, they both look the same in resting mode. They only take on their type's stance in battle. The same thing happens with the party sprites, which is something at least one person took advantage of in the VGC space (they brought an Urshifu with a rain team where all other mon were Water types, giving the impression of being Rapid Strike, but it was actually a Single Strike).
But then it'd be a command, not a question, which isn't legal either. "Can you tell me ____?" "Tell me ____." Gotta start with a who/what/when/where/which/how/why
Supposedly the direction the floaty parts of Urshifu's headband visually differentiate which form it is. Rapid strikes they float back and the tips float upward, on single strike the tips face downward. Even knowing that difference, it's pretty subtle
Luke's team reminded me of the mono grass run I'm currently doing on radical red. I have Mega Sceptile, Rillaboom, Meowscaratta and Chestnaught on my E4 team. Closing it with Amoongoos and Ogerpon.
Ritchie you gotta start trying to make some predictions and/or think ahead of the battle and what's gonna happen next. You always go to what seems the best/safest option at that specific time and a LOT of times it costs you the entire battle.
Fun fact. Frostlass is based on the yuki-onna (i think) a female frost spirit that freezes people to death. Much like what frostlass does when she finds someone she likes she freezes them and stores them in her cave.
A unique question that could've been asked might be "what ability would you give the pokemon in front of you (excluding wonder guard, huge power, pure power, and beast boost)... This would make the opponent think a little bit... (Mons shown in other s/v vids) Like Regenerator could be on a bulky Mon like garganacl... Desolate land on walking wake (access to flamethrower and hydro steam)... Or even skill link on maushold with kings rock population bomb
Luke was fine at the end lol 252 SpA Choice Specs Mega Launcher Tera Dragon Charizard Dragon Pulse vs. 252 HP / 252+ SpD Tera Water Clodsire: 103-123 (43.4 - 51.8%) -- 10.5% chance to 2HKO
So funny thing about the "can you tell me the names" question believe it or not I would say that is a fair question cus technically Luke made the same mistake twice which was asking without knowing the location (but was told the positions on accident)
Luke, I would unironically pick a charmander line pokemon over ANY other mon in ANY situation. He is not capping. We've been brainwashed to love charizard.
Would have been great if when asked "tell me the names" or "show me the feets", the other told them or show them not in order. It would make this whole idea even more trickier.
If you do another version of this, a question I thought of is “What pokeball do each of the options match with . Example can be pikachu=Ultra ball, as those colors best match each other
I always love when you posts videos! They are always SO entertaining to watch and always laugh during them! Hope you keep doing the amazing things you do! 😄
What 3 pokemon are in front of you? What's the pokemon on the left? " " middle " " right Which would you choose? (Said already) Which has the highest BST?
If possible, you should do every starter has multiple forms, 2 truths 1 lie, and you must change its form. Say if there's a Landorus Therian on your opponent's screen, you have to bring Incarnate to the battle.
I feel like a lot of the guys who do these "then we battle"-style videos have collaborated enough times that they know each other fairly well and have good chemistry built up with each other, and can joke around while still being competitive with each other. I think it makes for fun content!
I think in the future if someone asks about 1 Pokémon they get to know the location (e.g. Which Pokémon is shiny? Left.) but for questions about all the Pokémon you *don’t have to answer in order / reveal location* (E.g. What are the BSTs of each Pokémon? A: -not necessarily in order- 530, 500, 480.)
5:54 I think it's a far question BUT the person chooses what to name without giving the location like they could say left, right, middle, middle right, left, etc
I just realize, when he asked for the names, you didn't have to go in order, you could have said any order but no location, so that question wasn't as broken as you maybe thought, unless hes a stickler for going left to right.
I'm yet to see a dark type Urshifu since I started paying attention (is it only one form in the randomiser?) but I believe the two tells are his headband and his knee fur There will always be two black spikes pointing up on his headband, but the other 80% of it will either be white pointing down for water, or black pointing up for dark Similar for his knee fur too, it will either be pointing down and Gray for water, or fiercely up and black for dark Hope it helps
What is each of their names in [different language]? What is each of their species? (I.E Vaporeon as the Bubble Jet pokemon) Which if any are [type]? What is the [position] pokemon? So many ways to go about it?
I cracked up so much when Luke went to get a closer look at Urshifu and the character just bends down and stares at its crotch, then literally choked on my oatmeal when he talked to it and it ZOOMED IN! LMFAOOOOOOO DEAD.
I think its way better that luke gets mons he has to think outside the box with, makes for a good battles. Instead of getting like mewtwo or something really busted.
I love how they ask the number or the names of the pokemons, yet they also tells their locations on the screen... I mean, you dont have to tell them in order, right? I would tell them in random order.
"what position of pokemon are you most afraid of me getting" "What position of pokemon would you pick for a competitive team." How were these or anything like these not asked?
You guys are really nice to each other. Tell me the base stat total of all the pokemon could have easily just been a single number (all the bst's combined)
tbf the names question didnt say he has to tell you where each one is, its still random chance, you just get an idea of what youre picking ahead of time, i dont think its that broken of a question unless you add on their locations
luke sending out a modest, choice specs, 252 sp. atk, tera dragon, mega launcher, dragon pulsing charizard against a clodsire with 10 hp:
“i actually don’t know if this’ll kill”
Not only that but the clodsire was already down below half lol.
@@stephenreilly2334usually 10 hp implies that it’s below half
@@Abhishek-ue6tjnah he just has the strongest shedinja ever.
💀
@@jasonbarry3301but its a clodsire
I love how this concept became a combination of almost every "Then we fight!" videos together into 1 video
And they choose how to go with that so it's more interesting then there's a preset rule
Shouldnt of told him where the pokemon were when Luke asked what each one was. Fumbled that chance for shenanigans
My immediate thought as well, he asked what bit not where
He could’ve also just said slowking instead of specifying that it was galarian
I came down here to say that same thing.
It's 2024, stop saying "shouldn't of" and learn how to speak correctly.
It doesn’t really matter though, since Luke just has to say which one he wants. Knowing where they is redundant if you know the name of each one at that point.
"Can you tell me the names of all the pokemon in front of you?"
Me:"yes"
"So what are they?"
Me: "you didn't ask what their names are, you just asked if I can tell you"
"Now I'm not asking, I'm TELLING you to tell me the names of the Pokemon in front of you." :p
@@MunchKING that's not how you play the game. You have to ask it as a question :)
@@TheCompanyRepresentative Well yeah, but he asked a question, so now he's demanding a real answer. ;p
@@MunchKING Yes
But then the previous answer is a lie then😅😅
10:52 check the side of its head. Black spikes facing upwards for the dark type Single Strike Urshifu, and white spikes facing downward for the water type Rapid Strike Urshifu.
There's something so poetic about Charizard getting the final hit there.
5:58 He asked for their names, not for their name and location 😂
Rich is just a nice lad 😂
@@MasterAbeer101 Rich is the type of guy to reveal his IP address when asked about his nationality.
I literally was thinking the same thing!
I would've said them in a random order and not given their location of where they were just to fuck over Luke
Only reveal the names but you pick randomly would be brutal, imagine there's a broken one but you don't know where is it lol
I realized that the question was "Can you please give me the names of each Pokemon?", the question is not "What are the names of each Pokemon?". This means that he could have answered with "Yes, I could, but I won't" while speaking truthfully and simply not have said the names.
When he asked 'can you tell me the name of the Pokemon in front of you?', they could have just answered 'yes' 😂
I would’ve said the names but not positions😂
@@Cdiggidydog especially out of order
Luke legit could’ve shown the feet in the last round in any order that he wanted. The question was simply to show each starter’s feet, not to do it in order.
Similarly, that Galarian Slowking didn’t have to be specified. The question was about the name of each Pokémon, and the name of Galarian Slowking is just “Slowking”.
Wartortle is on the cover of Pokemon Super Mystery Dungeon riding Charizard's back, so Rich was right either way with Wartortle/Blastoise being on a game cover
And on Trozei cover
Chesnaught's sacrifice saved the day! Such a good battle and a very entertaining concept.
Btw, I hope you're having a great time at EUIC!! ⚡️
I was gonna like, but the likes are 69
In Rich's defense, he did get an ice type right before that fire type, so yeah, I think Charizard over a genie is a good choice.
Yeah, Luke didn’t ask “which is the strongest?” He simply asked what one Rich would choose, which could be for any reason as long as it’s honest.
@@Eclipsed6she admitted he lied in another video 😂😂😂
I absolutely LOVED this video! The idea was super fun and I liked that it’s kinda a mix of a bunch of previous starter ideas into one!
Plus, anything you upload is always a banger
Next time you do one of these you can still ask what the 3 are but don’t say in order from left to right.
That was so good! I love how it allows each creator to be so, well, creative with the question asks. And I actually really enjoyed you guys being able to ask the really OP questions like what their names were. It was super fun to watch.
Omfg when he got the hydrapple, I had a Crunchyroll ad interrupt while he was yelling and the ad was Goku, also yelling. I about died. 😂
Hey Luke. I have a then we fight idea. It's similar to catching mons to spell a word that you're given. However, you have to spell any 6 letter word you can think of by choosing your starters. You're given just the first letter of each starter, as your choosing your starters, you're trying to spell any word you can. If you are given letters you can't use, you have to skip and your opponent is given the chance to picker a starter in order to spell their word. First person to spell a word gets a neat little bonus like choosing any ability for one of their pokemon or something. And then you battle. For example, you're given the letters C - L - B, you choose C. The. Your next lot of Starters Are A - B - C, you can't really use B or C to spell a word beginning with C, so you choose A. You keep going, and your letters so far are C-A-R-R, but then you get to starters that are Q-X-R you can't use those, so your opponent gets the chance to take a pokemon, and they get an advantage cause they know what the pokemon are, but they can also choose to skip if they can't use a letter. You keep going till you have your word/team.
I feel like you need to add a rule called the Genie clause to this, where you answer their questions truthfully, but in whatever context you decide. For example, when asked what their names are, you up and name them on the spot.
We have: George, Bob, and Magdalena
Something cool to consider for the future if the box art question is ever asked again is that the Hisui starter base forms, Pikachu, Staraptor, Lucario, Bidoof, Rhyhorn, and Ralts are all featured on the cover of Legends Arceus (you can't see Ralts on the box itself but it is on the Switch icon, it's on Rhyhorn's back)
Luke is single handedly the best person i “know” at guessing Pokémon cries lmao
He gave you a Charizard and lost to it. Poetic.
5:55 i wish he would answer like ok you didn't say wich language 😂
Pokemon are named in Japanese so technically the Japanese names was the correct way to interpret that question
He just said the name not where there are, so just said the name without there position
If you ever do this kind if vid again a few ideas for questions could be
Asking for the typings of the pokemon on screen
Asking for their abilities
Asking what their highest base stat is
Asking what the first letter is
Asking if any have a regional variant
Asking the generation each came out in
Theres obviously more and probably better questions but these are just ones i thought of, hope it helps out in a future vid, i love your stuff ❤
Yo this concept is great, the plethera of questions you can ask makes it very unique and fun. Great stuff as always Luke and Rich was lovely guest as always.
5:20 Rich: I am a gen 4 stan.
Me and Rich: *realization
Rich: That has nothing to do with anything here.
Luke: Almost chokes on his drink laughing.
vinny was DISRESPECTED 😭
Love the vine whip idea because it would make Vic better for play outside of grasshole teams. I think this would also discourage use of grasshole overall
That was the most badass I have ever seen someone look whilst saying "I'm fluffy"
I like this open-ended question setup! Maybe try where you can only ask about one of the three Pokemon. (So either "Which of the three...?" or "Tell me ___ about the Pokemon on the L/C/R")
Absolutely loved this format, Luke! Please bring this one back.
"can you give me the names of each pokemon?"
the answer is just "yes"
when played dirty, play dirty
This is a great concept, I think we need more of these! I don’t know if it was because of you and Rich being hilarious or the fact it’s all the then we fight ideas combined but it was a great one for sure
To balance out the concept you could brainstorm a set of 6 questions each that you’re allowed to ask with the same concept of once you ask a question you can’t ask again. This avoids the many questions such as “what are the names of all my options” “can you take a picture of all my options” etc. Some examples could be 1. Is there a legendary on screen and what is its location 2. What is the highest base stat total of the pokemon on screen taking into account their evolutions 3. Which option sould be the toughest for your team to fight against (these are just a few questions I thought of to show how each question would be niche and not correlated to the others, preventing asking the same question in different ways)
next time if someone asks what the names are, you look at the names in Japanese and save them that way.
I'm curious how does the 'is there a legendary on the screen?' question even affect the selection?
Spoiler shield 🛡
No spoiler shields pls
Why are you everywhere?
Spoiler sword ⚔️
Based
Appreciate you soldier
Speaking as someone who has had both Urshifu forms on my party at the same time and have seen them in resting mode, they both look the same in resting mode. They only take on their type's stance in battle.
The same thing happens with the party sprites, which is something at least one person took advantage of in the VGC space (they brought an Urshifu with a rain team where all other mon were Water types, giving the impression of being Rapid Strike, but it was actually a Single Strike).
6:40 should have added the bsts up with that phrasing!
5:00
This could go like:
"Yes, i can"
....
"So tell me"
"You asked if i could tell, you didnt ask me to tell"
True💀
Crazy minds games
But then it'd be a command, not a question, which isn't legal either.
"Can you tell me ____?"
"Tell me ____."
Gotta start with a who/what/when/where/which/how/why
Yo the first question asked was hilarious. "Can you tell me if there is a legendary on your screen?" I would have answered "yes i can" 🤣
I love when the trainer picks the Urshifu he continues to look at it's feet HAHAHA
I seriously think you are a great duo! Would love to see more with both of you together!
10:25 Man really pulled the “Domain Expansion: Feet Finder!” 😂
Luke's reaction to Rich picking Charmander over Thunderous is priceless 😂😂😂
Supposedly the direction the floaty parts of Urshifu's headband visually differentiate which form it is. Rapid strikes they float back and the tips float upward, on single strike the tips face downward. Even knowing that difference, it's pretty subtle
Luke's team reminded me of the mono grass run I'm currently doing on radical red. I have Mega Sceptile, Rillaboom, Meowscaratta and Chestnaught on my E4 team. Closing it with Amoongoos and Ogerpon.
Ritchie you gotta start trying to make some predictions and/or think ahead of the battle and what's gonna happen next. You always go to what seems the best/safest option at that specific time and a LOT of times it costs you the entire battle.
Definitely do this concept again, it was really fun
Fun fact.
Frostlass is based on the yuki-onna (i think) a female frost spirit that freezes people to death.
Much like what frostlass does when she finds someone she likes she freezes them and stores them in her cave.
Really love that Rich has started pokemon content. Such a good addition to the videos.
That was super enjoyable to watch, you guys should do more content like this
5:18 took a drink, got confused and nearly did a spit take then realized Luke was doing the exact same thing as me. Why you copying me mate
Questions to ban :
“Can you give me the names of the starters?”
“Can you show me the starters?”
And probably more
agreed, I feel like they can ask who ONE of the starters is but not all of them
A unique question that could've been asked might be "what ability would you give the pokemon in front of you (excluding wonder guard, huge power, pure power, and beast boost)... This would make the opponent think a little bit... (Mons shown in other s/v vids) Like Regenerator could be on a bulky Mon like garganacl... Desolate land on walking wake (access to flamethrower and hydro steam)... Or even skill link on maushold with kings rock population bomb
11:45 3rd Raidaway plus feature or video in a row with a Plusle sighting since he started calling his fans plusers.
Plusle is the mascot
Luke was fine at the end lol
252 SpA Choice Specs Mega Launcher Tera Dragon Charizard Dragon Pulse vs. 252 HP / 252+ SpD Tera Water Clodsire: 103-123 (43.4 - 51.8%) -- 10.5% chance to 2HKO
So funny thing about the "can you tell me the names" question believe it or not I would say that is a fair question cus technically Luke made the same mistake twice which was asking without knowing the location (but was told the positions on accident)
Luke, I would unironically pick a charmander line pokemon over ANY other mon in ANY situation. He is not capping. We've been brainwashed to love charizard.
No chance Luke and Raid got me smiling and giggling like I'm 12 at 10 am!! Funny video today.
Just FYI Quark drive and Protosynthesis do not give a + 1 in any stat other than speed, they increase the stat X 1.3
The wartortle is on the box art of mystery dungeon I believe
It's squirtle
Would have been great if when asked "tell me the names" or "show me the feets", the other told them or show them not in order. It would make this whole idea even more trickier.
For Urshifu... if the head band tail are high its Single, of the head band tails are level/down its Rapid.
I've been watching your vids for a while but finally subscribed just because you used Ain't Nothing Like A Funky Beat in this video
If you do another version of this, a question I thought of is “What pokeball do each of the options match with . Example can be pikachu=Ultra ball, as those colors best match each other
Yo I've never seen inteleon's shiny. It's cool asf
Very excited for future videos in this format
I always love when you posts videos! They are always SO entertaining to watch and always laugh during them! Hope you keep doing the amazing things you do! 😄
What 3 pokemon are in front of you?
What's the pokemon on the left?
" " middle
" " right
Which would you choose? (Said already)
Which has the highest BST?
Been watching awhile but this is my favourite concept you've done, worth a sub
If possible, you should do every starter has multiple forms, 2 truths 1 lie, and you must change its form. Say if there's a Landorus Therian on your opponent's screen, you have to bring Incarnate to the battle.
11:10 urshifu climbing on Luke is insane!
Is it weird I watch these videos more for the interaction between friends then the actual battles?
I feel like a lot of the guys who do these "then we battle"-style videos have collaborated enough times that they know each other fairly well and have good chemistry built up with each other, and can joke around while still being competitive with each other. I think it makes for fun content!
Amazing video concept + THE RaidAway+? Perfection.
One of my favorite video ideas, hopefully more of these
I think in the future if someone asks about 1 Pokémon they get to know the location (e.g. Which Pokémon is shiny? Left.) but for questions about all the Pokémon you *don’t have to answer in order / reveal location* (E.g. What are the BSTs of each Pokémon? A: -not necessarily in order- 530, 500, 480.)
5:54 I think it's a far question BUT the person chooses what to name without giving the location like they could say left, right, middle, middle right, left, etc
I just realize, when he asked for the names, you didn't have to go in order, you could have said any order but no location, so that question wasn't as broken as you maybe thought, unless hes a stickler for going left to right.
What should have happened
"can you pleas give me the names of each pokemon"
"yes, but i won't"
I'm yet to see a dark type Urshifu since I started paying attention (is it only one form in the randomiser?) but I believe the two tells are his headband and his knee fur
There will always be two black spikes pointing up on his headband, but the other 80% of it will either be white pointing down for water, or black pointing up for dark
Similar for his knee fur too, it will either be pointing down and Gray for water, or fiercely up and black for dark
Hope it helps
Surprised there wasn’t a “What are the type combinations for each Pokémon?”
Loved this format! Would love to see this again with more subjective questions. 🤣
1:30 immidiate bullshit answer, love it
11:09 now that moment was just crawzy bro
6:11 should have told him the pokemon names without the order. 😂
What is each of their names in [different language]?
What is each of their species? (I.E Vaporeon as the Bubble Jet pokemon)
Which if any are [type]?
What is the [position] pokemon?
So many ways to go about it?
Luke loves getting into his opponents head especially Rich's 😂
0:24 “I want head”
I can relate
@@kai_3788what
I cracked up so much when Luke went to get a closer look at Urshifu and the character just bends down and stares at its crotch, then literally choked on my oatmeal when he talked to it and it ZOOMED IN! LMFAOOOOOOO DEAD.
Cool question in the future - what item would you equip with each pokemon
I think its way better that luke gets mons he has to think outside the box with, makes for a good battles. Instead of getting like mewtwo or something really busted.
hearing the glb outro making me crave a 4 person cross channel series again, it's been so long
I love how they ask the number or the names of the pokemons, yet they also tells their locations on the screen... I mean, you dont have to tell them in order, right? I would tell them in random order.
"what position of pokemon are you most afraid of me getting"
"What position of pokemon would you pick for a competitive team."
How were these or anything like these not asked?
You guys are really nice to each other. Tell me the base stat total of all the pokemon could have easily just been a single number (all the bst's combined)
Please do another one of these, this is so funny 😂
First thing I thought was "Can you tell me the Bulbapedia page of my pokemon?" Just full cheats haha.
(Also that shiny question fumble hurt man...)
"can you tell me the pokedex numbers of each pokemon?"
"can you tell me the names of each of the Pokémon in front of you?"
... "Yes"
Luki! Hear me out, do a challenge when you randomly pick a starter but all of your Pokémon have a chance to ignore your orders
tbf the names question didnt say he has to tell you where each one is, its still random chance, you just get an idea of what youre picking ahead of time, i dont think its that broken of a question unless you add on their locations