"'Oh! Darling' was a great one of Paul's that he didn't sing too well. I always thought I could have done it better - it was more my style than his. He wrote it, so what the hell, he's going to sing it." - John .... oh john would've killed this song! 💛
paul wrote the song as a way to express his confession to john - unspeakable things he wants to say to john that can only be delivered in a song, makes it more clear and understandable why paul didnt want anybody to sing it but him
@@shutupandmakemeasandwich6991 There is a recording on Anthology where Lennon sings a couple of the verses. It sounds great and is very natural for Lennon to sing. I think Paul did a very good job on the album, but for Lennon it was effortless and sounded wonderful.
haha! 0:50 : John singing I'll never do you no harm, while Paul, at the same time is sing "I'll never let you down " They didn't even laugh about it: this kind of things happened very often in studios and alive... Oh..HOW I MISS ALL THIS....!!!!
Paul McCartney always was the first one in the studio when they were recording, "Oh Darling." He always sung it once, then he waited until the next day to sing it again because then it would not get old and he waited until the perfect take, that's how the album version was made!
If you wanna know even more about how this song was written, you should check out this article.. the website also writes quite a bit about the beatles in general, lately www.wh-cha.com/single-post/2017/05/08/The-Song-on-Abbey-Road-John-Lennon-thought-he-Should-have-Sung
I feel like I've read a lot and know a lot about them, but when I see facts like this being brought out, I feel like a newbie. Where did you learn this particular fact, can you tell me? Also, where does one find tracks like this ....anthology? I'd appreciate some direction from you guys and gals. Thank you.
@@schyevie yes! there are a lot of books, like The Complete Beatles by Mark Lewisohn for example. You can find these takes in bootlegs that were unofficialy released, and some also in the Anthology series!
Interesting an unusal take. John singing along with Paul at the beginning ...nice! Paul can change his voice in whatever style....one more talent he has
+Gata Barbieri I wonder how many other rare practice pieces are vaulted that are not heard by the public.It is very entertaining listening to them experimenting and making adjustments and changes to get their final product. Seeing how an idea develops thru constant trial and error. It is fascinating.
Paul does do many voices, but quite a few of them I don't like. He had to wear out his voice to pull off this song, but he did pull it off in the end. I think he should have stuck with his good voices and not messed around with the rest, but I guess I'll give him credit for taking chances.
Even when they were just messing around, their music always had something to keep me interested. I've spent an unconscionable amount of time listening to these guys. A hundred years from now somebody will probably be thinking the same thing!
It's not RUclips, it's the artists, themselves. YT pays a small royalty to artists that agree to the terms. Try finding studio Hendrix; His estate(mostly his sister) hardly allows anyone to use his music. They made a movie about him and the only thing they could use were his covers because his sister wanted creative control. Ridiculous.
I can't get over how I'm unable to find some of the lesser known Beatles songs. you can find Hey Jude and Yesterday with no problem. But try to access The Beatles video of Oh! Darling & it's nowhere to be found. I would think that Paul McCartney & Ringo would like fans to view their music videos. Maybe it has something to do with John's estate?
its definitely Paul McCartney, his vocal riffing is unmistakable. Remember he was really stressing his voice out on the Abbey Road album for this song. Its a Masterpiece and I for one am glad he didn't try to duplicate the exact vocal stylings of the album!!
I always thought it would have been beautiful if john and paul had traded off verses on this one. the searing quality of john's voice suits this tune well.
no soy un conocedor , pero en mi opinion paul desde muy joven demostro su talento para impostar voces , lo podemos escuchar en I SAW HER STANDING THERE y tambien en SHES A WOMAN y en I M DOWN , y en DRIVE MY CAR canciones donde aun no habia " muerto " y posterior a esta etapa lo siguio haciendo por ejemplo en BACK IN THE USSR , y en WHY DONT WE DO IT IN THE ROAD y en LADY MADONA y en OH DARLING y en su etapa de solista lo hizo en la cancion q conocemos como el monje y en CALLME BACK AGAIN
Oh! Darling, please believe me I'll never do you no harm Believe me when I tell you I'll never do you no harm Oh! Darling, if you leave me I'll never make it alone Believe me when I beg you, ooh Don't ever leave me alone When you told me You didn't need me anymore Well you know I nearly broke down and cried When you told me You didn't need me anymore Well you know I nearly broke down and died Oh! Darling, if you leave me I'll never make it alone Believe me when I tell you I'll never do you no harm Believe me darling When you told me, ooh You didn't need me anymore Well you know I nearly broke down and cried When you told me You didn't need me anymore Well you know I nearly broke down and died Oh! Darling, please believe me I'll never let you down Oh, believe me darling Believe me when I tell you, ooh I'll never do you no harm
Los Beatles en sesion de grabaciones , Paul tenía que calentar la voz para entrarle a la grabación final , pues es una canción desgarradora de cuerdas vocales. Si no reconocen la batería de Ringo , su toque fuerte y a la vez acompasado con cierto arrastre , la guitarra de George y la intervención de lennon , pues , pa que hablar más .
The difference is most of what the Beatles wrote was timeless, while Madonna's efforts are dated.They didn't perform 60's standards, they created their own sound, they have such a repertoire,(their own stuff not covers) you could listen for days and not hear the same song twice. They are so diverse in their genres you can hear a song and not realize it's the Beatles, or that it was recorded fifty years ago.They in no way produced 60's standards, but they did set a standard no one else can touch.
As rough as it is it is fantastic to hear, out takes & demos are where the final product comes from but are sometimes in certain ways better than the official release. I love this, & Oh Darling is one of my favorites.
Los que no reconocen la voz de Paul Maccartney no los culpo, yo tambien la primera vez no creí la transformación de su voz sobre todo en el album Let it Be.
Beatles is famous for studio versions! Live is something like this recording ... I even like this live version and the guitar sound with Leslie effect amp ...
@beatlestoneful That is definitely Paul from the Let it Be sessions. During the month of January 1969 Paul recorded at least 10 different versions of Oh Darling. If you are familiar with the Let it Be sessions then you would recognize the sound of these endless Beatle jams. Hundreds of songs over twenty days according to the book "The unreleased Beatles" by Ritchie Unterberger. It's a great reference book, I highly recommend it for any true Beatles fan.
If Paul could help put together a collection of great outtakes with comments for posterity, that would certainly be greatly appreciated by everyone both now and in the future because the Beatles represent a high point in rock in the same way Beethoven did for symphonies, Michelangelo for sculpture, etc. and fans and musicologists will be studying them far into the future.
They're just playing, that's obvious. But even this is fantastic for me because they became real guys, just boys having fun... and being The Beatles at the same time. If you don't understand it, it's just because you didn't grow up listening them.
Everybody has experienced that nagging "Can't get this song out of my head"....It is quite often for me (5-6 times a week) and 80% of the time, it is this song!..... and I don't mind...... Proof that the Beatles became what they were reaching for......An American root blues group....
One of the many outtakes of the Abbey Road LP recordings, it's defiantly Paul singing with John on backup as is another version found on the Beatles Anthology 3 CD
All the third person narrative bull shit and here say,these two were best friends and musical brothers who created outstanding music and the best 3 part harmony ever. TY Men.
BTW, I know a lot of people say this, but I am 14 years old. I started listening to the Beatles when I was 8. I used to get terrible migraines, I found most contemporary music could bring one on, but their stuff seemed to make them better. Except for Let It Be, and Spector's "Wall of Sound", which also tended to give me a headache.
Facinante come estos sujetos aun practicando suenan muy bien. Despues se oye el producto finalizado y Wow!!!! Que talento. La series the 'The Anthology' exibe muchas de sus cancione in medio desarrollo. Los errors y cambios que hacen. Muy entretenido.
COOL.....The takes are in real time. Shows an example of prelude to the song before mastered take..New singers & listeners take HEED...Everyone makes mistakes (even the BEATLES) but this is how HITS ARE MADE...Example: Take a GREAT song , PRACTICE with FLAWS, then per-fect song & re-cord it = A HIT SONG ! ... SIMPLE RIGHT ?
guy guys guys, the song "hello goodbye" had no meaning when it was written... it was simply paul showin his friend whos name escapes me when he was asked "how can you write so many amazing songs" pauls reply was "writing a pop song is easy, ill say a word, you say the opposite" hello-goodbye, yes-no, stop-go, etc just shows how genius they were, truly masters of the art of songwriting
Ok ! si no reconocen la voz de McCartney , lennon el la Parte de "Please belive me" se mete , si no reconocen a lennon por lo menos , ponganse a escuchar mas los beatles :3
Of course,the finished version is way more sophisticated...but this is just fun time,just foolin' around...they're not taking it seriously at that moment..
I used to love to find rare recordings of the Beatles here in RUclips and have returned countless times to this recording of "oh darling" which I feel is a more relaxed and less performative version, It's a pity that I'll never again be able to find a rare recording of the Beatles without suspecting it being made or enhanced with artificial intelligence (like the song Now & Then which gives me an uncanny feeling)
Do you realize there is something special with The Beatles? Find out what it is: go to TruthContest° com and read +The Present+. The chapter about The Beatles starts page 59, but read at least the first 3 pages before.
this song touches me in many ways and after reading these comments i am beggining to realize that the shorthand i use may not be good at all. I am a 13 year making a full transformation into a 63 year old :)
It would be great if we could get a collection of outtakes put together with Paul's stamp of approval so we could see how the Beatles evolved songs towards their final cuts. But when you get them from underground sources you can't trust what you are getting and you may be obfuscating the matter and confusing yourself more than gaining illumination.
I can't believe you just said that Madonna wrote like these guys. I have studied music for a while now. I can tell you that the Beatles' music is some of the most complex and genius music ever written. Maybe even more genius than Mozart or Beethoven. The Beatles did so much in the few years they were together that you can teach a whole class about their music. Madonna only wrote catchy, pop songs. Pop songs are made to be catchy for more sells. Pop songs die out. The Beatles don't.
@cynmeneguel The significance and soul of "Hello Goodbye", to me, is an invitation to the sunny side of things. With upbeat tempo and lyrics, the song spreads smiles by saying "Hello" to ALL people in a way that is friendly but not so nerdy or weird. It ought to be noticed that the Beatles played their instruments and wrote their songs in addition to singing them. Do not spread such false information about the Beatles. You will regret it.
En 1980, John Lennon hizo la siguiente declaración: " Oh! Darling fue una gran canción que Paul no cantó muy bien. Siempre pensé que yo podría haberlo hecho mejor, pero él la escribió y, por norma general, quien escribe la canción la canta, que le vamos a hacer".
Si es cierto paul hacia los altos...pero de seguro que lennon no pensaba cantarlo al estilo de paul si no mas o menos como se ve en el demo...o tal vez al estilo rasgado de twist a saw
Pero el resultado final de Paul fue increíble que pena que no se volvió a ejecutar en vivo esta canción ...lo mas cercano a escuchar a paul cantar en vivo esta canción es en el grupo the fab four...
Two thirds through this recording it stops sounding like them at all. What's the source of these audio tapes? The backup voice in particular does not sound like John in the least. How can you verify it's them?
This clip may not be at proper speed, but this is indeed them. One of the many messing around takes from the Let It Be sessions. The confusion lies in Paul's voice, but for the actual take, Paul arrived early and proceeded to blow out his voice so he could achieve that gravelly grumbling blues effect which if you noticed, he has rarely ever used since, except for Monkberry Moon Delight. It is not a natural voice for him so on this light hearted rehearsal sounds weak at that range. My 2 cents.
We ( my mom and me) try not to use medicine too much. They stopped mostly once I became a teenager, now I only get them if I get dehydrated or forget to eat. Loud noises will make them worse, but techno or euro brings them on for me. I don't go to school dances because of headaches - they play the worse music.
Estuvo ensayando mucho porque no lo lograba a su gusto. Pienso que al final forzó mucho su voz, porque él era consciente del interés de John en cantarla, y sabía que John lo haría muy bien también pero su orgullo, bien entendido, le impidió cedersela para cantarla, y más teniendo en cuenta que era su canción. Yo siempre fantasee con que los dos la contasen juntos, e intercambiasen frases de la misma y creo que por ahí hay una versión fantástica de los dos (la 3 creo), que no está nada mal.
John tries to add harmony. he wanted to sing this song so bad
The “genious”.
"'Oh! Darling' was a great one of Paul's that he didn't sing too well. I always thought I could have done it better - it was more my style than his. He wrote it, so what the hell, he's going to sing it." - John .... oh john would've killed this song! 💛
paul wrote the song as a way to express his confession to john - unspeakable things he wants to say to john that can only be delivered in a song, makes it more clear and understandable why paul didnt want anybody to sing it but him
@@tetusooooo It would be very interesting to hear a Lennon version of this song. I think it would have been more emotional.
@@shutupandmakemeasandwich6991 There is a recording on Anthology where Lennon sings a couple of the verses. It sounds great and is very natural for Lennon to sing. I think Paul did a very good job on the album, but for Lennon it was effortless and sounded wonderful.
Paul's voice range is unbelievable.. wow!
haha! 0:50 : John singing I'll never do you no harm, while Paul, at the same time is sing "I'll never let you down "
They didn't even laugh about it: this kind of things happened very often in studios and alive...
Oh..HOW I MISS ALL THIS....!!!!
thus boy!
Paul McCartney always was the first one in the studio when they were recording, "Oh Darling." He always sung it once, then he waited until the next day to sing it again because then it would not get old and he waited until the perfect take, that's how the album version was made!
GamePlayWithNolan nice thanks for the info.
No problem!
If you wanna know even more about how this song was written, you should check out this article.. the website also writes quite a bit about the beatles in general, lately
www.wh-cha.com/single-post/2017/05/08/The-Song-on-Abbey-Road-John-Lennon-thought-he-Should-have-Sung
I feel like I've read a lot and know a lot about them, but when I see facts like this being brought out, I feel like a newbie. Where did you learn this particular fact, can you tell me? Also, where does one find tracks like this ....anthology? I'd appreciate some direction from you guys and gals. Thank you.
@@schyevie yes! there are a lot of books, like The Complete Beatles by Mark Lewisohn for example. You can find these takes in bootlegs that were unofficialy released, and some also in the Anthology series!
Interesting an unusal take.
John singing along with Paul at the beginning ...nice!
Paul can change his voice in whatever style....one more talent he has
+Gata Barbieri I wonder how many other rare practice pieces are vaulted that are not heard by the public.It is very entertaining listening to them experimenting and making adjustments and changes to get their final product. Seeing how an idea develops thru constant trial and error. It is fascinating.
+Javier Gonzalez
totally!!
Paul does do many voices, but quite a few of them I don't like. He had to wear out his voice to pull off this song, but he did pull it off in the end. I think he should have stuck with his good voices and not messed around with the rest, but I guess I'll give him credit for taking chances.
Even when they were just messing around, their music always had something to keep me interested. I've spent an unconscionable amount of time listening to these guys. A hundred years from now somebody will probably be thinking the same thing!
why is youtube taking down all the Beatles songs? RUclips is getting worse and worse
YES IT IS. working for the government..
It's not RUclips, it's the artists, themselves. YT pays a small royalty to artists that agree to the terms. Try finding studio Hendrix; His estate(mostly his sister) hardly allows anyone to use his music. They made a movie about him and the only thing they could use were his covers because his sister wanted creative control. Ridiculous.
TheMonsterRain
SAD Very SAD
bob dylan too
I can't get over how I'm unable to find some of the lesser known Beatles songs.
you can find Hey Jude and Yesterday with no problem. But try to access The Beatles video of Oh! Darling & it's nowhere to be found.
I would think that Paul McCartney & Ringo would like fans to view their music videos.
Maybe it has something to do with John's estate?
its definitely Paul McCartney, his vocal riffing is unmistakable. Remember he was really stressing his voice out on the Abbey Road album for this song. Its a Masterpiece and I for one am glad he didn't try to duplicate the exact vocal stylings of the album!!
MrMonkeyfarmer1 anthology 3, let it be sessions i think.
Whoa. I actually LOVE this version as much as the one used. It's got a great feel, so heartfelt.
"My fiance named Paul"- lol!
Greatest Bromance in music hustory!
is it just me or does it sound like Paul is singing Oh Johnny sometimes?
He is. This song was written about John
Absolutely!!! Written for John... Paul in the end did make it alone..... Happy Birthday Sir Paul 6\18
2020
When?
"My fiance named Paul"- lol!
Greatest Bromance in music hustory!
What an awesome demo! Paul said he was kinda trying a 50's style and this demo pulls it off.
I always thought it would have been beautiful if john and paul had traded off verses on this one. the searing quality of john's voice suits this tune well.
This is one of the best definition of The Beatles I have ever read, RESPECT!
no soy un conocedor , pero en mi opinion paul desde muy joven demostro su talento para impostar voces , lo podemos escuchar en I SAW HER STANDING THERE y tambien en SHES A WOMAN y en I M DOWN , y en DRIVE MY CAR canciones donde aun no habia " muerto " y posterior a esta etapa lo siguio haciendo por ejemplo en BACK IN THE USSR , y en WHY DONT WE DO IT IN THE ROAD y en LADY MADONA y en OH DARLING y en su etapa de solista lo hizo en la cancion q conocemos como el monje y en CALLME BACK AGAIN
I like this version very much. Paul is Nice & John is Good. and when someone going to sing this, he can sing like Paul's does.
Oh! Darling, please believe me
I'll never do you no harm
Believe me when I tell you
I'll never do you no harm
Oh! Darling, if you leave me
I'll never make it alone
Believe me when I beg you, ooh
Don't ever leave me alone
When you told me
You didn't need me anymore
Well you know I nearly broke down and cried
When you told me
You didn't need me anymore
Well you know I nearly broke down and died
Oh! Darling, if you leave me
I'll never make it alone
Believe me when I tell you
I'll never do you no harm
Believe me darling
When you told me, ooh
You didn't need me anymore
Well you know I nearly broke down and cried
When you told me
You didn't need me anymore
Well you know I nearly broke down and died
Oh! Darling, please believe me
I'll never let you down
Oh, believe me darling
Believe me when I tell you, ooh
I'll never do you no harm
Los Beatles en sesion de grabaciones , Paul tenía que calentar la voz para entrarle a la grabación final , pues es una canción desgarradora de cuerdas vocales. Si no reconocen la batería de Ringo , su toque fuerte y a la vez acompasado con cierto arrastre , la guitarra de George y la intervención de lennon , pues , pa que hablar más .
OSCAR DANIEL ARIAS MARTINEZ siii siii en resumen THE BEATLES
Yes warm up hard difficult song been trying for years but before I died ill do it right lol
wow thanks for sharing this rendition...they probably were super stoned while working on this version!
The difference is most of what the Beatles wrote was timeless, while Madonna's efforts are dated.They didn't perform 60's standards, they created their own sound, they have such a repertoire,(their own stuff not covers) you could listen for days and not hear the same song twice. They are so diverse in their genres you can hear a song and not realize it's the Beatles, or that it was recorded fifty years ago.They in no way produced 60's standards, but they did set a standard no one else can touch.
Mclennon is true 😂😂😂
"My fiance named Paul"- lol!
Greatest Bromance in music hustory!
As rough as it is it is fantastic to hear, out takes & demos are where the final product comes from but are sometimes in certain ways better than the official release. I love this, & Oh Darling is one of my favorites.
Oh Darling was one of my favs as a young teen
Realmente the Beathes não morreu.Que linda 👏 bateria perfeita e a voz perfeita.
"Please believe me darling I want you to so bad" omg I fucking will
Los que no reconocen la voz de Paul Maccartney no los culpo, yo tambien la primera vez no creí la transformación de su voz sobre todo en el album Let it Be.
Una maravilla esta version... piel de gallina carajo... vale un trago... fuerza los beatles for ever
Glad they didn't use this arrangement
It's a run through of the song, was never meant to be the final album version.
Beatles is famous for studio versions! Live is something like this recording ... I even like this live version and the guitar sound with Leslie effect amp ...
@beatlestoneful That is definitely Paul from the Let it Be sessions. During the month of January 1969 Paul recorded at least 10 different versions of Oh Darling. If you are familiar with the Let it Be sessions then you would recognize the sound of these endless Beatle jams. Hundreds of songs over twenty days according to the book "The unreleased Beatles" by Ritchie Unterberger. It's a great reference book, I highly recommend it for any true Beatles fan.
I like it. Simple. Clear voice. Thanks.
When you told me
You didn't need me anymore
Well you know I nearly broke down and died
Mccartney el voz camaleon
Porque camaleón?
@@miguelharrison6742 creo que por cambiante
Thank you, made my night!
If Paul could help put together a collection of great outtakes with comments for posterity, that would certainly be greatly appreciated by everyone both now and in the future because the Beatles represent a high point in rock in the same way Beethoven did for symphonies, Michelangelo for sculpture, etc. and fans and musicologists will be studying them far into the future.
I was brought up on music like this my mom actually seen the Beatles at the Hollywood Bowl I was just a little girl I remember well
Oh my this is just amazing
I just love this vibe,Thanks for posting::
Still love this rare beauty :) peace and love ✌
It is so rare that only half a million people have seen it.
Shut the fuck up
Congratulations Karl. You are officially a troll.
*****
Congratulations Alexander. You have officially joined the Trolls.
out of over 7 billion humans? Yes extremely rare
I'm pretty sure the joke was that the Beatles usually get way over this already high amount of views on their songs. But that's just me.
En una de sus tantos ensayos e improvisaciones que tenian estos genios. Parece en plan de joda.
how awesome to hear this version! love it! thanks for posting.
This is simply exquisite.❤️❤️❤️
They're just playing, that's obvious. But even this is fantastic for me because they became real guys, just boys having fun... and being The Beatles at the same time.
If you don't understand it, it's just because you didn't grow up listening them.
omg this is magnificent!
Love this just as much as the original ❤
The creativeness and the body of work they did in five years or so is incredible.
The Album version is one of Paul's greatest vocal works!
Wow The guitar is so much better in this than it is in the original!!!
Everybody has experienced that nagging "Can't get this song out of my head"....It is quite often for me (5-6 times a week) and 80% of the time, it is this song!..... and I don't mind...... Proof that the Beatles became what they were reaching for......An American root blues group....
One of the many outtakes of the Abbey Road LP recordings, it's defiantly Paul singing with John on backup as is another version found on the Beatles Anthology 3 CD
We really did not need a reprise of Paul’s Cleveland Brown vocal style from Get Back. John’s harmonies would’ve been a nice touch though.
AWESOME!!!!!!!!
All the third person narrative bull shit and here say,these two were best friends and musical brothers who created outstanding music and the best 3 part harmony ever. TY Men.
BTW, I know a lot of people say this, but I am 14 years old. I started listening to the Beatles when I was 8. I used to get terrible migraines, I found most contemporary music could bring one on, but their stuff seemed to make them better. Except for Let It Be, and Spector's "Wall of Sound", which also tended to give me a headache.
Facinante come estos sujetos aun practicando suenan muy bien. Despues se oye el producto finalizado y Wow!!!! Que talento. La series the 'The Anthology' exibe muchas de sus cancione in medio desarrollo. Los errors y cambios que hacen. Muy entretenido.
Ellos son Los Beatles en las sessiones de let it be
+geronimo ferreiro Es en las sessiones de let it be
COOL.....The takes are in real time. Shows an example of prelude to the song before mastered take..New singers & listeners take HEED...Everyone makes mistakes (even the BEATLES) but this is how HITS ARE MADE...Example: Take a GREAT song , PRACTICE with FLAWS, then per-fect song & re-cord it = A HIT SONG ! ... SIMPLE RIGHT ?
guy guys guys, the song "hello goodbye" had no meaning when it was written... it was simply paul showin his friend whos name escapes me when he was asked "how can you write so many amazing songs" pauls reply was "writing a pop song is easy, ill say a word, you say the opposite" hello-goodbye, yes-no, stop-go, etc just shows how genius they were, truly masters of the art of songwriting
Ok ! si no reconocen la voz de McCartney , lennon el la Parte de "Please belive me" se mete , si no reconocen a lennon por lo menos , ponganse a escuchar mas los beatles :3
How many people think that John could have sung it better, cause he thought he should have sung it. Just wanna see
i hope this music comes back again pleaseeeee oh darling come back we all love u old timeing music come back
Very good version- Thanx.
uno de los tantos ensayos de estos genios!
Of course,the finished version is way more sophisticated...but this is just fun time,just foolin' around...they're not taking it seriously at that moment..
Oh, darling, darling, darling, help these people understand that the Beatles are the best, please dont let me dowwn.
Really rare... thanks... It's a jewell... really a jewell...
I used to love to find rare recordings of the Beatles here in RUclips and have returned countless times to this recording of "oh darling" which I feel is a more relaxed and less performative version, It's a pity that I'll never again be able to find a rare recording of the Beatles without suspecting it being made or enhanced with artificial intelligence (like the song Now & Then which gives me an uncanny feeling)
@hiimln won't argue, but to me it just doesn't sound like paul. it is supposed to be paul right?
Joe ghetto ur a moran all music starts somewhere glad u could enlighten the world.
Do you realize there is something special with The Beatles? Find out what it is: go to TruthContest° com and read +The Present+. The chapter about The Beatles starts page 59, but read at least the first 3 pages before.
Thanks buddy! this is a must read for all beatles fans!
this song touches me in many ways and after reading these comments i am beggining to realize that the shorthand i use may not be good at all. I am a 13 year making a full transformation into a 63 year old :)
Good thing that they changed the key. Paul would have hurt himself had they not.
It would be great if we could get a collection of outtakes put together with Paul's stamp of approval so we could see how the Beatles evolved songs towards their final cuts. But when you get them from underground sources you can't trust what you are getting and you may be obfuscating the matter and confusing yourself more than gaining illumination.
great great good song / great band.
Great, a Beatles run through is better than any master take a band today can come up with.
I can't believe you just said that Madonna wrote like these guys. I have studied music for a while now. I can tell you that the Beatles' music is some of the most complex and genius music ever written. Maybe even more genius than Mozart or Beethoven. The Beatles did so much in the few years they were together that you can teach a whole class about their music. Madonna only wrote catchy, pop songs. Pop songs are made to be catchy for more sells. Pop songs die out. The Beatles don't.
Good job!
simplemente hermoso, increible preciosa version, muchas gracias
@cynmeneguel
The significance and soul of "Hello Goodbye", to me, is an invitation to the sunny side of things. With upbeat tempo and lyrics, the song spreads smiles by saying "Hello" to ALL people in a way that is friendly but not so nerdy or weird. It ought to be noticed that the Beatles played their instruments and wrote their songs in addition to singing them.
Do not spread such false information about the Beatles. You will regret it.
Hugs from Brazil
Great classic track...
@XxBrodyNDJustinxX The Let it Be sessions were before the Abbey Road sessions
de que sesion o disco es?, suena muy bien
En 1980, John Lennon hizo la siguiente declaración: " Oh! Darling fue una gran canción que Paul no cantó muy bien. Siempre pensé que yo podría haberlo hecho mejor, pero él la escribió y, por norma general, quien escribe la canción la canta, que le vamos a hacer".
Si es cierto paul hacia los altos...pero de seguro que lennon no pensaba cantarlo al estilo de paul si no mas o menos como se ve en el demo...o tal vez al estilo rasgado de twist a saw
Pero el resultado final de Paul fue increíble que pena que no se volvió a ejecutar en vivo esta canción ...lo mas cercano a escuchar a paul cantar en vivo esta canción es en el grupo the fab four...
a McCartney le quedó increible
Masterpiece
Two thirds through this recording it stops sounding like them at all. What's the source of these audio tapes? The backup voice in particular does not sound like John in the least. How can you verify it's them?
I like this kinda thing a lot! Great!
Es mi cancion preferida en vivo gracias
great version love it ! ! ! damn beep during the song
Awesome. This is the version they record during the filming of the Let It Be film which gets cut off at the start of the song, am I right?
Definitivamente mi preferida!!!!, Lennon y su divorcio... ja
I LOVE IT AAAAAAAAAAH
8 People didn't "believe" Paul when he "told them".
What in the world is going on here? But it´s The Beatles and so I love it.
This clip may not be at proper speed, but this is indeed them. One of the many messing around takes from the Let It Be sessions. The confusion lies in Paul's voice, but for the actual take, Paul arrived early and proceeded to blow out his voice so he could achieve that gravelly grumbling blues effect which if you noticed, he has rarely ever used since, except for Monkberry Moon Delight. It is not a natural voice for him so on this light hearted rehearsal sounds weak at that range. My 2 cents.
Let It Be Sessions.
@theanimalrocks
do not underestimate vocal range. you'd be surprised.
Raro...e muito, muito belo, bela versão
Hapy...happy
We ( my mom and me) try not to use medicine too much. They stopped mostly once I became a teenager, now I only get them if I get dehydrated or forget to eat. Loud noises will make them worse, but techno or euro brings them on for me. I don't go to school dances because of headaches - they play the worse music.
La versatilidad que tiene Paul de hacer su voz como el quiera!!!
Estuvo ensayando mucho porque no lo lograba a su gusto. Pienso que al final forzó mucho su voz, porque él era consciente del interés de John en cantarla, y sabía que John lo haría muy bien también pero su orgullo, bien entendido, le impidió cedersela para cantarla, y más teniendo en cuenta que era su canción. Yo siempre fantasee con que los dos la contasen juntos, e intercambiasen frases de la misma y creo que por ahí hay una versión fantástica de los dos (la 3 creo), que no está nada mal.
O- U- Darling ,love that lmao 💖
outstanding!