I've been using the American Sound in my pedalboard for a few months now. I go direct to mixer. Put a Boss Overdrive/Distortion pedal in front of it. Does everything I need it to. It replaced a Strymon Iridium (at almost 10x the price).
On the clean sound, I like the ACtone it's got more character. On the crunch tone, I like the British sound. And on the lead tone, I like the American sound because its got more bite or grit plus the tone is beautiful. Bought a Harley Benton American Sound by the way and Im loving it. Thanks for this comparison video.
very good comparison video. it's hard to find videos that compare in such detail with the different settings. exactly what i needed to decide which one to get. keep it up please! tanks for the info. and keep smiling
Many thanks one of the best comparison reviews I have seen. I have the American pedal but i think overall I liked the British but so little difference. Great playing as well
Very nice demonstration - but - I was looking forward to really cranking the gain - which is where a couple of them start to really shine, so long as you adjust the 'voice' correctly with the gain. It takes a bit of playing around, but there are some really good sounds there.
Thanks for the comment Hayt. I've made individual videos on each one of these pedals and there I play more with the gain and all settings as I could spend more time on each pedal. However, I don't really like their cranked sounds very much. I find the cleans to a light crunch are more to my taste and fit my playing style better
Fascinating! I'm enjoying using an Amplug2 Clean model into a powered speaker... but I'd like a bit more control over the sound - so I'm considering one of these pedals. I'm probably inclined towards the American version for pop and country... and the ACTone for the blues - and either for jazz; it's great to have choices!
Backing tracks, reverb... some other youtubers add even delay. But allow us hear the BARE sound of the item, for God! In this way how can some one decide for buying or not? -.- Btw, smiling and full of guitar passion guy, so i subscribe
I've had an American Sound for several months and the only thing I criticized about it is that it doesn't have an XLR output to connect directly to the console.
Had the American now for few weeks and my British just arrived yesterday, so far very happy with the American into my Blackstar amp and will be testing out the British tomorrow too. Considering a combo of each together either through line out or front input or one in both…basically I’m just looking to make a lot of noisy but beautiful tones while my guitar gently weeps 😂 great video and thanks, loved your playing and personal vibe. Between the Actone and California, which would you suggest for a hint of grit but a mellow clean crunch?
Thanks for the nice message 👍 I haven't tried the California yet, but the AC Tone is great for those Vox AC style sounds. It does nice jangly cleans and bright low to medium gain drives really well. I wouldn't call it mellow though. I also have a video on it if you want to check it out. It's also a great pedal but tbh it's my least favorite among these 3
@@TheBedroomRocker1 Ah thankyou I appreciate the reply, and likewise I wasn’t too sure I liked the overall feel of the AC but will further look into it. And I mean mellow as in got a nice chime and ring to it but without too much breakup and grrr 😁 I’m definitely more strayed towards the California but shall look again into each…btw, British/American is fantastic along with a Boss Ds-1 and bit of a knob fiddle!! I sat for about an hour in a wall of noise and LOVED it, so very pleased. Shall consider the others and value your input…ps, on looking back I meant to say fx loop not line out on amp ha. Peace in the now and happy noise making my friends
@@TheBedroomRocker1 just now watched your video on AC Tone and completely see now what you were saying in your reply. Definitely has a nice jangle to it at about 25% drive, liking how it sounded. But agreed, it loses some of its shape without the digital simulation! Will certainly have to experiment with using in the fx loop, but looking like I’m gonna get an Ac/Cali and Oxford and play around with what mix feels most fitting to myself. ThAnkyou very much, most appreciated 😁
Thanks for the reply! Yes, they're all different but they also cover a lot of ground with the powerful EQ and the voice knob. The british is also my favorite
Good comparison. Thank you. Is tha cab sim always on? In your opinion is it a problem to add an i.r. after the pedal so adding a amp sim over a cab sim? Thankx in advance!!
Thanks for the comment. The cab sim is indeed always no and no chance to turn it off (there are some mods for that though). There are no big problems in adding an IR after the pedals though. In fact, I do this in another video. I thought it sounded pretty good ruclips.net/video/5XQ-O-h3jUA/видео.html
Looking at the schematics of these, they are all identical with the exception of one or two resistors. i have all of them american sound is my favorite
Good video, by the way I want to add it to my pedalboard, where should I put it? I have in this order: equalizer, compressor, overdrive, dist, noise Gate, chorus, tremolo, flanger, and delay. Where should I put it? Thanks
Thanks for the comment! I would start by putting it between the chorus and the noise gate. However, the best way is for you to experiment and see what works out the best
one thing that i just recently found out about this amp sim...they also have a built in cabsim...just like you've said..but is it good to add IR in it? if it has already a cabsim in it? is it going to be redundant or are you logically putting 2 speakers in chain...how's it going to work with IR's? - i'm thinking of doing the mod - cabsim bypass - but i don't really want to de-solder one of the resistor and end up messing it badly...
Thanks for the nice comment! Yes, I usually create my own backing tracks for my videos. You can download some of them for free in my Patreon page. You can find the link in the video description 😉 keep on rocking
They have an analog cab sim. It's decent, but not great. The cab sim is also always on and cannot be switched off. I usually like to add an impulse response cabinet simulation after these pedals
Thanks for the comment. This series of pedals are the exact same with different branding (Joyo / Harley Benton) in the enclosure. It's like those Amazon products made in China (you can find the same product from the same factory under many different brands). However, both brands also offer different pedal lines that are not related to each other.
Thanks for the comment. Harley Benton is an umbrella brand from music shop Thomann. Their products are manufactured in several locations (mostly China and Vietnam) and sold under Harley Benton brand. Joyo is a Chinese brand and, in the case of these 3 pedals, they are the same Harley Benton pedals but with a different branding.
Ciao, thanks for the comment. It's of course the same guitar and the same player but there's still a substantial difference between the 3 pedals. Maybe try listening with a good set headphones or studio monitors.
Both of these brands sell the exact same pedals. If you're in North America, chances are that you'll find them under Joyo brand. Here in Europe, we have them most as Harley Benton like mine. But as I said, they're the same pedal coming from the same Chinese factory
I've been using the American Sound in my pedalboard for a few months now. I go direct to mixer. Put a Boss Overdrive/Distortion pedal in front of it. Does everything I need it to. It replaced a Strymon Iridium (at almost 10x the price).
This is the best pedal comparison video I've ever seen and your playing is excellent; thank you very much!
Wow, thanks! Glad you've liked it
British all the way! I also have the rest and for my ears the British sounds fuller & bolder on single coils, great playing & nice comparison!
Cool, thanks!
British one sounds also good to me. Thank you, was very usefull to me
I've just bought the British one and glad I did after this great comparison. Thx m8.
Thanks a lot for the comment! Glad the comparison was helpful.
On the clean sound, I like the ACtone it's got more character. On the crunch tone, I like the British sound. And on the lead tone, I like the American sound because its got more bite or grit plus the tone is beautiful. Bought a Harley Benton American Sound by the way and Im loving it. Thanks for this comparison video.
Thanks! Super glad to know it was helpful! Keep on rocking 🤟🏼
@@TheBedroomRocker1 will do, cheers!
very good comparison video. it's hard to find videos that compare in such detail with the different settings. exactly what i needed to decide which one to get. keep it up please! tanks for the info. and keep smiling
Great to hear!
The orange 🍊 is the best Joyo pedal, just don't crank them up much as you correctly said in this great video.
Many thanks one of the best comparison reviews I have seen. I have the American pedal but i think overall I liked the British but so little difference. Great playing as well
Glad it was helpful! Rock on!
You are adorable and brilliant, thanks so much for the video and stay as smiley as you are. You're a joy to watch.
Thank you so much!
Bella recensione. Bravo! Fra qualche giorno comprerò il British. :)
exellent review format
Thanks a lot for the kind comment!
There is also the California one that is Mesa
Very good and well done video. Grande Albero 👍🏼👍🏼👍🏼
Obrigado e um forte abraço!
Very nice demonstration - but - I was looking forward to really cranking the gain - which is where a couple of them start to really shine, so long as you adjust the 'voice' correctly with the gain. It takes a bit of playing around, but there are some really good sounds there.
Thanks for the comment Hayt. I've made individual videos on each one of these pedals and there I play more with the gain and all settings as I could spend more time on each pedal. However, I don't really like their cranked sounds very much. I find the cleans to a light crunch are more to my taste and fit my playing style better
Fascinating! I'm enjoying using an Amplug2 Clean model into a powered speaker... but I'd like a bit more control over the sound - so I'm considering one of these pedals. I'm probably inclined towards the American version for pop and country... and the ACTone for the blues - and either for jazz; it's great to have choices!
Thanks for the comment! Yeah, these are really great pedals and do a lot for the money
British to my ears. Good comparison.
Thanks for the kind comment! British is also my favorite and I think it recorded the best in these clips
nice video man
Thanks for the visit, glad you've liked it! :-)
Pour ma part je me sert de la British et de l'American ensemble , la British en sortie de guitare , ensuite l'American , un Delay et l'ampli . Top .
Great video love it
Glad you enjoyed it
Backing tracks, reverb... some other youtubers add even delay. But allow us hear the BARE sound of the item, for God! In this way how can some one decide for buying or not? -.- Btw, smiling and full of guitar passion guy, so i subscribe
Thanks for the very nice comment and sub! Glad to know the videos are useful!
I subscribed with immense pleasure and Wish you a rapid growth of the Channel :)
I've had an American Sound for several months and the only thing I criticized about it is that it doesn't have an XLR output to connect directly to the console.
Had the American now for few weeks and my British just arrived yesterday, so far very happy with the American into my Blackstar amp and will be testing out the British tomorrow too. Considering a combo of each together either through line out or front input or one in both…basically I’m just looking to make a lot of noisy but beautiful tones while my guitar gently weeps 😂 great video and thanks, loved your playing and personal vibe. Between the Actone and California, which would you suggest for a hint of grit but a mellow clean crunch?
Thanks for the nice message 👍 I haven't tried the California yet, but the AC Tone is great for those Vox AC style sounds. It does nice jangly cleans and bright low to medium gain drives really well. I wouldn't call it mellow though. I also have a video on it if you want to check it out. It's also a great pedal but tbh it's my least favorite among these 3
@@TheBedroomRocker1 Ah thankyou I appreciate the reply, and likewise I wasn’t too sure I liked the overall feel of the AC but will further look into it. And I mean mellow as in got a nice chime and ring to it but without too much breakup and grrr 😁 I’m definitely more strayed towards the California but shall look again into each…btw, British/American is fantastic along with a Boss Ds-1 and bit of a knob fiddle!! I sat for about an hour in a wall of noise and LOVED it, so very pleased. Shall consider the others and value your input…ps, on looking back I meant to say fx loop not line out on amp ha. Peace in the now and happy noise making my friends
@@TheBedroomRocker1 just now watched your video on AC Tone and completely see now what you were saying in your reply. Definitely has a nice jangle to it at about 25% drive, liking how it sounded. But agreed, it loses some of its shape without the digital simulation! Will certainly have to experiment with using in the fx loop, but looking like I’m gonna get an Ac/Cali and Oxford and play around with what mix feels most fitting to myself. ThAnkyou very much, most appreciated 😁
Excellent video. Thank you
Glad you liked it! Thanks
Nice vid. Subbed
Thanks for the nice comment and sub!
top pedal, top video and top playing!
Thanks a lot! Keep on rockin'!
Thanks for the video! Clearly I don't need all three, ordered the British before I saw the video RULE BRITTANIA
Thanks for the reply! Yes, they're all different but they also cover a lot of ground with the powerful EQ and the voice knob. The british is also my favorite
Good comparison. Thank you. Is tha cab sim always on? In your opinion is it a problem to add an i.r. after the pedal so adding a amp sim over a cab sim? Thankx in advance!!
Thanks for the comment. The cab sim is indeed always no and no chance to turn it off (there are some mods for that though). There are no big problems in adding an IR after the pedals though. In fact, I do this in another video. I thought it sounded pretty good
ruclips.net/video/5XQ-O-h3jUA/видео.html
Looking at the schematics of these, they are all identical with the exception of one or two resistors. i have all of them american sound is my favorite
Thanks for the comment and input! Glad to know this
did you do one for bass?
Thank you for the comment. I am not aware about a similar pedal for bass in this Joyo / Harley Benton series.
Good video, by the way I want to add it to my pedalboard, where should I put it? I have in this order: equalizer, compressor, overdrive, dist, noise Gate, chorus, tremolo, flanger, and delay. Where should I put it? Thanks
Thanks for the comment! I would start by putting it between the chorus and the noise gate. However, the best way is for you to experiment and see what works out the best
@@TheBedroomRocker1 this the answer i've been searching for hours
Interesting comparison, one thing are they battery or main powered only. Great playing btw
Thank you for the comment! They can also be battery powered
one thing that i just recently found out about this amp sim...they also have a built in cabsim...just like you've said..but is it good to add IR in it? if it has already a cabsim in it? is it going to be redundant or are you logically putting 2 speakers in chain...how's it going to work with IR's? - i'm thinking of doing the mod - cabsim bypass - but i don't really want to de-solder one of the resistor and end up messing it badly...
The so-called Cab Sim is just a high-pass filter (EQ shaping at best) Adding an Impulse Response has no detrimental effect
a big thank you @@quiksilver78, cleared my mind now
Yeah, that is correct. In theory you're adding two cab sims in series, but if it works it works 😅
Hi, good comparison video!! Are these backing tracks your creation?
Thanks for the nice comment! Yes, I usually create my own backing tracks for my videos. You can download some of them for free in my Patreon page. You can find the link in the video description 😉 keep on rocking
A blind test would prove them to be pretty much similar
They have also a cab SIM ?
They have an analog cab sim. It's decent, but not great. The cab sim is also always on and cannot be switched off. I usually like to add an impulse response cabinet simulation after these pedals
British or oxford?
Sorry, but I don't really understand your question?
@@TheBedroomRocker1 british or oxford..which one is better?
Is Joyo exactly the same as Harley Benton?
Thanks for the comment. This series of pedals are the exact same with different branding (Joyo / Harley Benton) in the enclosure. It's like those Amazon products made in China (you can find the same product from the same factory under many different brands). However, both brands also offer different pedal lines that are not related to each other.
American Sound !!
British 👍
pedals sound pretty close?
Thanks for the comment, but I actually feel like they each have quite individual voicings
Vc é brasileiro?
Fala Alexandre, sou brasuca mesmo hahaha boa percepção! Um abraço
british ya love it
Are Harley Benton products made from China? Germany? London?
What about JOYO products?
Thanks for the comment. Harley Benton is an umbrella brand from music shop Thomann. Their products are manufactured in several locations (mostly China and Vietnam) and sold under Harley Benton brand. Joyo is a Chinese brand and, in the case of these 3 pedals, they are the same Harley Benton pedals but with a different branding.
Ma solo a, me sembra che suonino tutti uguali....? Boh
Ciao, thanks for the comment. It's of course the same guitar and the same player but there's still a substantial difference between the 3 pedals. Maybe try listening with a good set headphones or studio monitors.
Plis, make up your mind: Is it Joyo or Harley Benton?!:-7
Both of these brands sell the exact same pedals. If you're in North America, chances are that you'll find them under Joyo brand. Here in Europe, we have them most as Harley Benton like mine. But as I said, they're the same pedal coming from the same Chinese factory