The three singers have something that make them special. Tarja is perfect, I love her. Floor is what the band needs. Anette wasn't the most suitable for Nightwish, but she's amazing, her solo album is really fantastic, I liked more than Tarja's albums, I can't believe it.
Nightwish 1.0 (Tarja): Good Old Nightwish, my whole Childhood. Single Tarja: WTF is this? Eat Snickers plx Nightwish 2.0 (Anette): Good Nightwish 3.0 (Floor): TENSA ZANGETSU BANKAI MUGETSU AWESOME EPICNESS WATASHI NO KAMISAMA OMG WANT MORE SHARINGAN KAMEHAMEHA NO JUTSU KARYUU NO MOETE KITA ZO
totally agree with you!! there is no room for discussion about who is better, when everyone sings beautiful in its own way, this is where you meet your best nightwish fans, the best band ever
Floor is no.1 hands down. She has the best English accent, pure metal singing with the combination of both worlds (opera + rock), is a fantastic live and does the best and cutest headbanging ever! Tarja is from the original NW, but she's more technical than anything else and a bit boring to watch live.
maboleth Tarja is fucking amazing, floor is extremely boring. So what what if she doesn’t speak English well she knows 6 languages maybe a few more. Tarja is a Queen
This video is very bias. it shows Tarja with great hd sound, but the other 2 always have crapy versions to compare.. with all 3 in HD I found that Floor has the best of both worlds. She can have that warm and deep opera sound, and she can hit really high notes as well.. very well rounded for the entire Nightwish experience.
Tarja: Defined Nightwish, but she needs to drop the Diva attitude. Annette: Good but she sounds like she doesn't belong in Nightwish but her own band instead. Floor: Absolutely perfect. Nightwish made an excellent choice with her.
I have meet both tarja and flor, tarja was way more accesible than flor, i love both of them but tarja was really great she hug me and talk with me after her concert, flor was so serios and actually say no touching so....
Tarja IS unique (: I have seen Nightwish live over 9 years ago (Mera Luna), even though I was way behind the line her voice was so present that I could hear her clear and strong.
yo amo a nightwish suena excelente con cualquiera de las tres... pero insisto en esto nightwish con tarja es excepcional... si pudiera pedir un deseo seria que tarja regresara con ellos y asi podria morir tranquila!!!!
Tarja is just Tarja. No explanation needed. I like the newer songs with Anette but she can't sing the older ones. Omg, Floor is amazing, it's a pity that there are only a few high quality records with her yet.
não é so questão de qual é a melhor, e sim qual se encaixa melhor na banda, nota-se ate uma animação geral na banda com Tarja, ela e Tuomas juntos eu gosto de chamar de dinamite eletrica, se encaixam muito bem, floor e otima substituta de tarja, mais ainda acho q tarja e a cara e a alma do nightwish!!!
los temas empezaron con tarja los amamos asi,entonces va a ser un poco mas dificil escuchar otras cantantes de la banda sin comparar las voces de anette y floor.que no cantan mal pero tarja tiene una potente voz y le da "mas vida y poder a las canciones"! aguante Nightwish!!!!!!!!!!!
Floor is great she is a real metal girl, not just a classical singer, she is the winner, but if you see the people in the audience is still having a great time.. even with Anette who is an unprofessional singer so... the music is first not the vocalist the proof of that is the audience :D
I love what each of them brought to the band. I can understand people who follows the band since its inception are upset that Tarja left but Anette and Floor both have added their own mark on the band.
Regardless of the best voice. What strikes me the biggest difference is the grace that Tarja brought to the band. Her feminine styling and appearance just enhanced her voice so much.
I never thought Anette was a bad frontwoman. I just think that Nightwish's previous material was not suited to her style at all. I loved her vocals in Imaginaerum because those songs were best suited for her vocal range.
Indeed. The decisions made by Nightwish to kick out Tarja, Anette leaving the group, now Floor being the singer, we can only respect that. Yes, I loved Tarjas voice, as I did when Anette sang. I only saw Nightwish with Anette live, but I also have their cd's with Tarja. I only heard and saw Floor on youtube, but I love them all. I love Nightwish as a group. They write lovely songs and I hope they keep doing that for a long time. Respect for all who have ever been and will be in Nightwish!
Тарья-великолепна в своих песнях. Флор-не тянет то что пела Тарья, но вокал у неё отличный и Анетт она заменила на все 500% Анетт - ХЗ, что она столько лет делала в группе.
conoci a nightwish con tarja... y ellos sin duda seran siempre nightwish asi surgieron... pero anette me enamoro ... y floor ps es floor ... tarja no kiere volver.. y anette o la amas o la odias ..y yo la ame...
Nightwish será Nightwish para siempre, no se los demás fans, pero por mi parte adoraré esa banda y a las vocalistas que se presenten con ella; no voy a compararlas, porque no me parece algo justo, simplemente amaré a Nightwish hasta el final de mis días ya sea con Tarja, Anette, o Floor ( o la que vaya ser la tercera vocalista). Un saludo para todos
Truth be told I don't think we'll ever know for sure unless they were to make an album with Floor. I've yet to find the greatest audio quality on any of these concert videos, although I do appreciate the upload :)
I can't deny that this was made by a Tarja enthusiast, but most of us who followed Nightwish from the beginning ARE Tarja enthusiasts. Nightwish was, and is, one of the biggest names in the operatic metal genre. It became famous for a particular sound that was equal parts Tuomas' genius at writing orchestral metal, a band made up of musicians who were 110% on board with his vision, and Tarja's operatic voice. Tuomas wrote most of those early songs with Tarja's voice and vocal style in mind. They're quite literally HER songs. When they replaced her, they replaced her with a singer with a completely different style. Anette has a beautiful sweet voice, but she does not have the same kind of vocal power that Tarja did. This made it very difficult for her to sing songs that were written with Tarja's power in mind. The band had to change how they played, to accommodate her vocals, and it drastically changed how the entire band sounded. So Tuomas, started writing songs with Anette's voice in mind, and Dark Passion Play was what we got. It's not ONCE or Wishmaster, but it's still a great album. If you judge it on it's own merits, instead of comparing it to what amounted to a different band, performing a different style of music, you'll realize it was a great album. Floor, on the other hand, has the power to match Tarja's. The video in this seem to be taken during the first tour, when she took over mid stream, and hadn't really meshed with the band yet. I know, I was at their Phx, AZ concert, just 6 days after she took over for Anette. She was great, but she hadn't meshed well yet. Listen to some of the videos from Wacken 2013. She has really gotten in tune with the band, and they're back to the symphonic operatic powerhouse that got my attention in the first place. They're playing the old songs again, in their original operatic style, at full power. But she also has a rock vibe that Tarja just didn't, which makes her..different. Not better, just different. Trying to compare them is silly. All 3 are great singers, just with different styles. Enjoy each for themselves, not for whether they are better than each other.
Floor is nightwish she is a perfect fit tarja started it but floor took it and flew with it imo I love both of them. You should watch floor and tarja sing over the hills together it's amazing
Adoro Nightwish, não existe outra banda igual, a musicalidade tudo é único, fiquei e fico muito triste com a saída de Tarja, pois para mim ela era e é a parte que completa essa banda maravilhosa. Fora que a saída dela foi muito trágico e desnecessário, poderia ser feito de maneira mais correta, acredito que todos presentes tinham sentimentos e que esses geram amor e ódio, nada que uma boa conversa não resolveria, mas cada um faz o que acha certo! infelizmente nesse aspecto, o talentoso Tuomas não pensou nos fãs quando despediu de forma tão horrenda a Tarja!
+Ariana Carvalho Assim como parece que ele não pensou muito ao contratar a Anette, que não tem nada a ver com o Nightwish. Foi um alívio a Floor vir para o Nightwish. Mas fato é que essa banda nunca será tão boa quanto era com Tarja. É bom saber que hoje a Tarja parece ser muito mais feliz.
Me gustaria que alguien subiera un video en condiciones de igualdad de calidad de sonido de las tres, para mi gusto Floor es buenisima, si si, Tarja canta muy bien pero ya paso su tiempo y Floor tiene la expresividad que le faltaba a ella y canta como los angeles tambien, lo siento por Anette pero es mejor que se dedique al pop que es para lo que en mi opinion tiene voz.
nightwish llego ah ser lo que es por tarja, mas alla que los musicos son buenos la realidad es que sin tarja dudo que hubieran llegado hasta donde llegaron...
iloved tarja, loved anette and love floor, its nightwish no matter what Thoumas is the band he is so talented that he writes for her singers and makes master pieces
There is, and always will ever be, one Tarja
The three singers have something that make them special. Tarja is perfect, I love her. Floor is what the band needs. Anette wasn't the most suitable for Nightwish, but she's amazing, her solo album is really fantastic, I liked more than Tarja's albums, I can't believe it.
Nightwish + Tarja: Excellent
Nightwish + Anette: Good
Nightwish + Floor: PERFECT EPICNESS!!!!!
é isto ai amigo
Tarja: Forever S2!!!
Anette: What???
Floor: Amazing!!!
Nightwish 1.0 (Tarja): Good Old Nightwish, my whole Childhood.
Single Tarja: WTF is this? Eat Snickers plx
Nightwish 2.0 (Anette): Good
Nightwish 3.0 (Floor): TENSA ZANGETSU BANKAI MUGETSU AWESOME EPICNESS WATASHI NO KAMISAMA OMG WANT MORE SHARINGAN KAMEHAMEHA NO JUTSU KARYUU NO MOETE KITA ZO
Camus Altamirano Tarja perfeita 😍
Floor es la mejor!!!!!!
Sin duda Tarja es la mejor
Gracias a ella la banda creció
Tiene una voz inigualable
I'm a true fan of Nightwish and I love all them, Tarja, Anette, Floor
Totally agree. Three talented ladies 🎸🎤🥁👯♀️🎧👯♀️🎻🎹🎼
totally agree with you!!
there is no room for discussion about who is better, when everyone sings beautiful in its own way, this is where you meet your best nightwish fans, the best band ever
Floor is no.1 hands down. She has the best English accent, pure metal singing with the combination of both worlds (opera + rock), is a fantastic live and does the best and cutest headbanging ever!
Tarja is from the original NW, but she's more technical than anything else and a bit boring to watch live.
Tarja is awesome to watch floor so boring and sounds so weird thats why jukka left nightwish
Loud Silence no you are dumb Jukka left cause of insomnia and Floor is far better live than Tarja in every single way.
maboleth Tarja is fucking amazing, floor is extremely boring. So what what if she doesn’t speak English well she knows 6 languages maybe a few more. Tarja is a Queen
Junkstapozicija Muve Delusional ass, Tarja is far better than that man you call a woman
@@junkstapozicijamuve1071 So true! He is a really dumb!
This video is very bias. it shows Tarja with great hd sound, but the other 2 always have crapy versions to compare.. with all 3 in HD I found that Floor has the best of both worlds. She can have that warm and deep opera sound, and she can hit really high notes as well.. very well rounded for the entire Nightwish experience.
Zach Pilling not opera like Tarja...
tarja is the best!!!!
Tarja: Defined Nightwish, but she needs to drop the Diva attitude.
Annette: Good but she sounds like she doesn't belong in Nightwish but her own band instead.
Floor: Absolutely perfect. Nightwish made an excellent choice with her.
+lisa miller
but plaque is an indivisible part of nightwish
+lisa miller Your know floor is a an cold hearted arrogant irevelant bitch
I have meet both tarja and flor, tarja was way more accesible than flor, i love both of them but tarja was really great she hug me and talk with me after her concert, flor was so serios and actually say no touching so....
Loud Silence exactly why she is perfect for them... I love her singing but yes, its a diva
Tarja had and has no diva attitude.
Tarja IS unique (: I have seen Nightwish live over 9 years ago (Mera Luna), even though I was way behind the line her voice was so present that I could hear her clear and strong.
Anette is so sweet, I love her voice and feel her very much. She is very versatile, I love her voice in Scaretale.
1, FLOOR 2. FLOOR 3. FLOOR
yo amo a nightwish suena excelente con cualquiera de las tres... pero insisto en esto nightwish con tarja es excepcional... si pudiera pedir un deseo seria que tarja regresara con ellos y asi podria morir tranquila!!!!
this is the best trio comparison ive found on youtube, thanks for uploading your the best
1. Floor
2. Floor
3. Floor
Nightwish + Tarja: The best
Nightwish + Anette: ... unf
Nightwish + Floor: good
Floor. No way around that.
tarja le saca la cresta a sus remplazos o imitaciones, ademas desde que se fue tarja murió nightwish
Tarja is just Tarja. No explanation needed.
I like the newer songs with Anette but she can't sing the older ones.
Omg, Floor is amazing, it's a pity that there are only a few high quality records with her yet.
Brace yourself Live DVD is coming at end of month! :)
.... tarja sigue y seguira siendo la mejor...
tarja is better..!!!!Her voice is amazing...!!!!!
não é so questão de qual é a melhor, e sim qual se encaixa melhor na banda, nota-se ate uma animação geral na banda com Tarja, ela e Tuomas juntos eu gosto de chamar de dinamite eletrica, se encaixam muito bem, floor e otima substituta de tarja, mais ainda acho q tarja e a cara e a alma do nightwish!!!
Definitivamente tarja es la mejor, me gusta mucho Floor y canta hermoso, pero PARA MI Tarja simplemente tiene la voz mas potente
Floor ♥
TARJA was never out of tune. SHE IS AND WILL BE THE BEST FOR EVER
los temas empezaron con tarja los amamos asi,entonces va a ser un poco mas dificil escuchar otras cantantes de la banda sin comparar las voces de anette y floor.que no cantan mal pero tarja tiene una potente voz y le da "mas vida y poder a las canciones"! aguante Nightwish!!!!!!!!!!!
Floor is by far the best ! DEAL WITH IT !
no tarja is deal with that
Tarja is far better deal with it 😌
@@FluffyLaDooDoo 😂😂 you wish but you know that is not the truth!
Winter Sun Tarja Is such a god, what do you see in that man you call woman floor with her pop voice 🤮
@@FluffyLaDooDoo You have no idea! Pop voice 🤦♂️!
Was this a singer comparison or a video quality comparison?
Lul
Tarja :'C Te extrañamos , aunque las otras no cantan mal ella era el alma de nigthwish :(
As much as i started off first hearing Floor and was a first time Floor fan, TARJA SOUNDS THE BEST OUT OF ALL OF THEM STILL, BIG TIME!!!!!😀👍
Angels first, oceanborn, wishmaster, century child, once are albums that's just for Tarja
To me tarja is the best
But floor has a good voice too
But tarja is the best
Floor is great she is a real metal girl, not just a classical singer, she is the winner, but if you see the people in the audience is still having a great time.. even with Anette who is an unprofessional singer so... the music is first not the vocalist the proof of that is the audience :D
Tarja is the BEST ! She´s got the POWER , THE ENERGY to make EMOTIONS spring up .!!
Lejos... Tarja la mejor
Anette es la mejor
all are beautiful and awesome !!!!!
I love what each of them brought to the band. I can understand people who follows the band since its inception are upset that Tarja left but Anette and Floor both have added their own mark on the band.
Anette sounds like a cat in pain. Tarja's voice is beautiful, maybe a little forced, but Floor's sounds like a metal goddess!!!
Tarja es la mejor🥰
TARJA FOREVER
nadie podra remplazar a tarja,pero annete hizo un buen trabajo en nightwish y el estilo de floor le queda muy bien a nightwish :)
floor its more attractive and the combination opera-rock its more powerful...
tarja tarja always tarja nadie como ella
Yeah he is amazing, I love his: The Islander and also his sense of humor:)
Tarja is the identity of Nightwish.
Of course Tarja is best, because the songs were written for her....
Floor rocks!!
-Tarja sempre !!!! A Rainha Deusa sempre !!!
-Floor !!!! A Princesa do DNA da rainha Deusa !
-Anette !!! Lindíssima !!
Regardless of the best voice. What strikes me the biggest difference is the grace that Tarja brought to the band. Her feminine styling and appearance just enhanced her voice so much.
Tarja forever .
I never thought Anette was a bad frontwoman. I just think that Nightwish's previous material was not suited to her style at all. I loved her vocals in Imaginaerum because those songs were best suited for her vocal range.
vaya alguien que no se cierra, son 3 estilos muy diferentes y cada 1 con excelente voz!!
Floor, sin dudarlo.
Indeed. The decisions made by Nightwish to kick out Tarja, Anette leaving the group, now Floor being the singer, we can only respect that. Yes, I loved Tarjas voice, as I did when Anette sang. I only saw Nightwish with Anette live, but I also have their cd's with Tarja. I only heard and saw Floor on youtube, but I love them all. I love Nightwish as a group. They write lovely songs and I hope they keep doing that for a long time. Respect for all who have ever been and will be in Nightwish!
Tarja of course!!!
Tarja es la mejor !!!!!
Тарья-великолепна в своих песнях.
Флор-не тянет то что пела Тарья, но вокал у неё отличный и Анетт она заменила на все 500%
Анетт - ХЗ, что она столько лет делала в группе.
Floor Jansen превосходит всех.
ruclips.net/video/4V_eoR6r1Tw/видео.html
conoci a nightwish con tarja... y ellos sin duda seran siempre nightwish asi surgieron... pero anette me enamoro ... y floor ps es floor ... tarja no kiere volver.. y anette o la amas o la odias ..y yo la ame...
Nightwish será Nightwish para siempre, no se los demás fans, pero por mi parte adoraré esa banda y a las vocalistas que se presenten con ella; no voy a compararlas, porque no me parece algo justo, simplemente amaré a Nightwish hasta el final de mis días ya sea con Tarja, Anette, o Floor ( o la que vaya ser la tercera vocalista).
Un saludo para todos
1) Tarja
2) Anette
45) Floor sorry 145)
Floor, Anette, Tarja. Floor and Anette can sing live without false sounds. Tarja sings like crying wolf. That's my opinion.
I love the "crying wolf " !
Truth be told I don't think we'll ever know for sure unless they were to make an album with Floor. I've yet to find the greatest audio quality on any of these concert videos, although I do appreciate the upload :)
Three amazing women :)
Tarja is the best.
The acoustic version of Nemo is awesome! :)
I can't deny that this was made by a Tarja enthusiast, but most of us who followed Nightwish from the beginning ARE Tarja enthusiasts.
Nightwish was, and is, one of the biggest names in the operatic metal genre. It became famous for a particular sound that was equal parts Tuomas' genius at writing orchestral metal, a band made up of musicians who were 110% on board with his vision, and Tarja's operatic voice. Tuomas wrote most of those early songs with Tarja's voice and vocal style in mind. They're quite literally HER songs.
When they replaced her, they replaced her with a singer with a completely different style. Anette has a beautiful sweet voice, but she does not have the same kind of vocal power that Tarja did. This made it very difficult for her to sing songs that were written with Tarja's power in mind. The band had to change how they played, to accommodate her vocals, and it drastically changed how the entire band sounded.
So Tuomas, started writing songs with Anette's voice in mind, and Dark Passion Play was what we got. It's not ONCE or Wishmaster, but it's still a great album. If you judge it on it's own merits, instead of comparing it to what amounted to a different band, performing a different style of music, you'll realize it was a great album.
Floor, on the other hand, has the power to match Tarja's. The video in this seem to be taken during the first tour, when she took over mid stream, and hadn't really meshed with the band yet. I know, I was at their Phx, AZ concert, just 6 days after she took over for Anette. She was great, but she hadn't meshed well yet. Listen to some of the videos from Wacken 2013. She has really gotten in tune with the band, and they're back to the symphonic operatic powerhouse that got my attention in the first place. They're playing the old songs again, in their original operatic style, at full power. But she also has a rock vibe that Tarja just didn't, which makes her..different. Not better, just different.
Trying to compare them is silly. All 3 are great singers, just with different styles. Enjoy each for themselves, not for whether they are better than each other.
tarja tiene la voz ideal para el estilo metal!! oscura y sombria... mas las otras son buena cantantes para hacer pop!! y nada mas......
floor!!!!!!!! the best
imo tarja will always be nightwish, Annette was like a momentary lapse of judgment, but flor seems to be right up there with tarja.
Floor is nightwish she is a perfect fit tarja started it but floor took it and flew with it imo I love both of them. You should watch floor and tarja sing over the hills together it's amazing
Tarja 4ever
Tarjа FOREVER
Its true, Tarja is my fovourite!! Nightwish = Tarja :D
1) Tarja
2) Floor
3)-
4)-
.....
100) Anette
Tarja Turunen ❤️
Tarja FOREVER!!!! TARJA IS PERFECT, AMAZING VOICE !!!
Adoro Nightwish, não existe outra banda igual, a musicalidade tudo é único, fiquei e fico muito triste com a saída de Tarja, pois para mim ela era e é a parte que completa essa banda maravilhosa. Fora que a saída dela foi muito trágico e desnecessário, poderia ser feito de maneira mais correta, acredito que todos presentes tinham sentimentos e que esses geram amor e ódio, nada que uma boa conversa não resolveria, mas cada um faz o que acha certo! infelizmente nesse aspecto, o talentoso Tuomas não pensou nos fãs quando despediu de forma tão horrenda a Tarja!
+Ariana Carvalho Assim como parece que ele não pensou muito ao contratar a Anette, que não tem nada a ver com o Nightwish. Foi um alívio a Floor vir para o Nightwish. Mas fato é que essa banda nunca será tão boa quanto era com Tarja. É bom saber que hoje a Tarja parece ser muito mais feliz.
Me gustaria que alguien subiera un video en condiciones de igualdad de calidad de sonido de las tres, para mi gusto Floor es buenisima, si si, Tarja canta muy bien pero ya paso su tiempo y Floor tiene la expresividad que le faltaba a ella y canta como los angeles tambien, lo siento por Anette pero es mejor que se dedique al pop que es para lo que en mi opinion tiene voz.
voto por Floor!!!
I like them all, but Anette is the best for me...
tarja es la mejor
Anette la supera
@@jorgeedsoncastellon5865 Mejor dicho las dos son las mejores por su forma de expresarse al público y también por su voz.
Floor's the best!!!!!
Tarja... we miss you so much :(
I like all 3, but I'm just stunned on how Floor sounds with Nightwish. I hope she stays ;w;
let tell us each other. Anette was terrible. Now with Floor their are finally smiling during concert!!!
No way to compare. Tarja is billion times better. And this is it !
Se nota la superioridad de tarja, tubo quimica con la banda. Veremos como le va a floor y el tiempo lo dirá.
She is just amazing.
Have a nice day:)
Tarja tiene una voz espectacular pero prefiero a Floor, es una mujer imponente y canta muy bien, con una agresividad que me encanta.
Tarja = noble lady from operaAnette = 13teen schoolgirl in school choirFloor = resolute warrior and singer
Tarja Turunen
nightwish llego ah ser lo que es por tarja, mas alla que los musicos son buenos la realidad es que sin tarja dudo que hubieran llegado hasta donde llegaron...
my queen Tarja
Floor amazing...
Tarja the best. That's all what can I say :)
FLOOR! Zdecydowanie :)
Tarja is the best I miss her in nightwish
So.... Best ist Tarja....
Tarja forever!!
1. Floor - 2.Tarja - 3. Anette
iloved tarja, loved anette and love floor, its nightwish no matter what Thoumas is the band he is so talented that he writes for her singers and makes master pieces