New footage from China congress fuels questions about why Hu Jintao was hauled out

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 24 окт 2022
  • New footage from the Chinese Communist party congress shows a series of interactions related to a file held by Hu Jintao, before the former president was hauled out of the room.
    Subscribe to Guardian News on RUclips ► bit.ly/guardianwiressub
    Outgoing politburo member Li Zhanshu can be seen pulling a file away from Hu, before Xi Jinping signals to some aides and gives them lengthy instructions. They then turn to Hu, and holding him by his arms remove him from the hall. Chinese media have reported that Hu was taken out of the Great Hall of the People in Beijing because he was feeling unwell.
    The incident came as Xi Jinping was confirmed as the leader of the party for a precedent-breaking third term. Xi replaced Hu as China's president in 2013.
    China’s leader Xi Jinping secures third term and stacks inner circle with loyalists ► www.theguardian.com/world/202...
    Hu Jintao ‘not feeling well’ when he left China congress, says state media ► www.theguardian.com/world/202...
    Who’s who in Xi Jinping’s China as leader cements power ► www.theguardian.com/world/202...
    The Guardian publishes independent journalism, made possible by supporters. Contribute to The Guardian today ► bit.ly/3uhA7zg
    Sign up to the Guardian's free new daily newsletter, First Edition ► theguardian.com/first-edition
    Website ► www.theguardian.com
    Facebook ► / theguardian
    Twitter ► / guardian
    Instagram ► / guardian
    The Guardian on RUclips:
    The Guardian ► bit.ly/guardiannewssubs
    Guardian Australia ► bit.ly/guardianaussubs
    Guardian Football ► bit.ly/gdnfootballsubs
    Guardian Sport ► bit.ly/gdnsportsubs
    Guardian Live ► bit.ly/guardianlivesubs
    #HuJintao #XiJinping #CommunistParty #Beijing #China #Politics

Комментарии • 2,9 тыс.

  • @guardiannews
    @guardiannews  Год назад +71

    China’s leader Xi Jinping secures third term and stacks inner circle with loyalists ► www.theguardian.com/world/2022/oct/23/xi-jinping-to-rule-china-for-precedent-breaking-third-term
    Hu Jintao ‘not feeling well’ when he left China congress, says state media ► www.theguardian.com/world/2022/oct/23/hu-jintao-not-feeling-well-when-he-left-china-congress-says-state-media
    Who’s who in Xi Jinping’s China as leader cements power ►
    www.theguardian.com/world/2022/oct/23/whos-who-in-xi-jinping-china-as-leader-cements-power

    • @kso8554
      @kso8554 Год назад

      This is "Election 2"( Black Society: Harmony is a Virtue) by Johnnie To Kei-fung

    • @turismoknowledgewithrealey2648
      @turismoknowledgewithrealey2648 Год назад +1

      Yoooo winer winer chiken dinner 🍽😋 east west China has best super power 🔋

    • @aopd6223
      @aopd6223 Год назад +10

      The man is 95 and clearly confused. Anybody who has ever seen or taken care of a person with dementia will recognize what is going on here. That look in the old man's face and the way of talking and gesturing from the man next to him, like he is talking with a little kid. It is so very clear. Do you really have to do this? Also, show the beginning, when he was not even able to sit down. They didn't show anything in the news not to embarass an old man who used to be the leader.

    • @irvanabidin7912
      @irvanabidin7912 Год назад +1

      delusional

    • @胡
      @胡 Год назад

      @@aopd6223 exactly, I’m very surprised not many people recognize an old man with dementia

  • @grundy333
    @grundy333 Год назад +3628

    I love how everyone in their chairs are like “nothing to see here!”
    If he wasn’t “unwell” then he sure is now.

    • @ancapeancape9829
      @ancapeancape9829 Год назад

      I like how western medias make this out of context footage like the sign of the downfall of ccp. The man's in his 80s, he's not in great health condition, he needed assistant when enter the hall, and some one had to remind him to sit down. And he appeared in the next day's meeting. But just ignore all that and you'll have a great great story about THE EVIL CCP. Great job.

    • @T.efpunkt
      @T.efpunkt Год назад +29

      @@break1722 how do you know it's wrong? Do you know something everybody else doesn't?

    • @bumpyjason
      @bumpyjason Год назад +24

      @@T.efpunkt how do you know it’s right? Do you have proof

    • @T.efpunkt
      @T.efpunkt Год назад +34

      @@bumpyjason thats not how any of this works. If you have a hypthesis, the burden of proof is on your side. I'm just pointing out that there is no such proof.

    • @lawrenceweston922
      @lawrenceweston922 Год назад

      @@break1722 Westerners are the last people who can call someone a cow herd!!

  • @comments2840
    @comments2840 Год назад +1823

    The fact that everybody around was sitting there stiff and wooden faced , shows how afraid everyone was.

    • @canto_v12
      @canto_v12 Год назад +73

      You haven’t watched many Chinese Congress videos have you 😂. They’re ALL like this and causing or contributing to a scene is frowned upon.

    • @alienalien1925
      @alienalien1925 Год назад +56

      thats politics, no game for boys

    • @nocturnalowl5867
      @nocturnalowl5867 Год назад +31

      They are not drama queens and know it’s not the right time and place to create a buzz around that scene that could have a few undesirable consequences like disturbances at an official event. Simple.

    • @CountingStars333
      @CountingStars333 Год назад

      @@nocturnalowl5867 PUTIN bots don't get a say

    • @ritang5726
      @ritang5726 Год назад +34

      Best wishes to you for having a government that jokes around and laughs while making serious political decisions.

  • @michaelsimpson945
    @michaelsimpson945 Год назад +204

    How to terrify a room full of thousands of people without even moving

  • @AmericazGotTalentYT
    @AmericazGotTalentYT 9 месяцев назад +22

    That hand was the kiss of death 😢

  • @ironmana
    @ironmana Год назад +2713

    His eyes tell everything, he was surprised that this thing could even happen on himself.

    • @RazielDeTam
      @RazielDeTam Год назад +94

      Surprised? 0:36 'he used me', absolute awareness about situation he is in

    • @casab654
      @casab654 Год назад

      Britain peoples admired at Xi ditactor , when we could have long serving leader ?

    • @RazielDeTam
      @RazielDeTam Год назад +3

      @@casab654 that's why you are following chinese shows?😅 British people are very educated, 👏 for speaking chinese

    • @casab654
      @casab654 Год назад +6

      @@RazielDeTam well even thought the new monarch The King was well greet by all around the world, but watching an alive Emperor China episodes is much interesting.

    • @junebug8485
      @junebug8485 Год назад +19

      what I can barely see his eyes

  • @RT-or6it
    @RT-or6it Год назад +2068

    The scary thing is none of the major Chinese social media outlets talk about this. All searches for Hu Jintao either return no results or outdated results. Guy is getting erased.

    • @meegssan5716
      @meegssan5716 Год назад +41

      i hope they made it quick, may he r.i.p

    • @loljk1991
      @loljk1991 Год назад

      Chinese news media much like Russia are all controlled by the state . They are simply a better version of North Korea

    • @ajayiolaniyi2591
      @ajayiolaniyi2591 Год назад

      You can't see cause nothing happened... It just western media misinterpretation that cause widespread of the news. Just few seconds video without audio, then we started seeing different versions of story.. the media looks so desperate . do you want bad thing to happen to China already..

    • @waiu0235
      @waiu0235 Год назад

      haha, not only Hu, But everyone in the Central committee, including XI. can't be search on BaiDu-pedia
      Simply like sabotaged Wikipedia after each major election in the West.

    • @ssvegeto1610
      @ssvegeto1610 Год назад +139

      Xinnie the pooh can't allow for any comparisons or remnants of the 'legacy' leadership. Literally only the xi way or no way

  • @Miumiu0404
    @Miumiu0404 Год назад +116

    0:38 the realization in Hu Jintao's face

  • @blt4life112
    @blt4life112 Год назад +2071

    For a country that's all about pride, they didn't leave him much.

    • @eustab.anas-mann9510
      @eustab.anas-mann9510 Год назад +70

      It's about "face" and ol' Hu just lost all of it.

    • @timcasady4750
      @timcasady4750 Год назад +10

      Perfectly said

    • @AlexP-jz9sg
      @AlexP-jz9sg Год назад +110

      This is technically how Biden needs to be escorted from every one of his speeches.

    • @andreasbalaskas7292
      @andreasbalaskas7292 Год назад

      I will not surprise, if former president of China, (found dead) some time now soon. From his personal security team. We all know what is going on!!
      The way, of how they took him outside (thank you for your services, now go die like old dog!), seems clearly that Xi Jinping is the new ruler of China (law & order : in a country that does not need to obey in international laws,...however. China creates new rules of law for the rest world).
      Exactly this on happen now!!

    • @David-iu4mr
      @David-iu4mr Год назад +12

      You’re one of those who didn’t do enough research

  • @VicharB
    @VicharB Год назад +23

    He wanted to see the list which had the names of 7, which was replaced by Xi with his candidates, not that what was agreed with Hu Jintao. Having seeing the list Hu would have reacted there. Remember that Hu was backed by Shanghai Gang, the real corporates behind (Tsencnet, Alibaba, telelcoms, etc) .... and the story goes on. It's a deep political power struggle, one needs to understand, not what you see from outside.

  • @antiphonusy197
    @antiphonusy197 Год назад +257

    This is a historic moment in China's transition from collective dictatorship to individual dictatorship

    • @antiphonusy197
      @antiphonusy197 Год назад +30

      Warning, Mao Zedong is back

    • @alalalala57
      @alalalala57 Год назад +12

      All paths leads to autocracy.

    • @sovietheart3883
      @sovietheart3883 Год назад +1

      Every capitalist country is a dictatorship of the Bourgeoisie.

    • @uhohhotdog
      @uhohhotdog Год назад

      There is no dictatorship at all. China is far more democratic than the USA

    • @yingliu4616
      @yingliu4616 Год назад +2

      😭 You're right

  • @BParis-kj5qo
    @BParis-kj5qo Год назад +1430

    What a charming, open, transparent way of decision making!!!!!

    • @mickeythompson9537
      @mickeythompson9537 Год назад +33

      Come on, it's nothing like the British system of appointing a Prime Minister!

    • @mikicerise6250
      @mikicerise6250 Год назад +4

      @@mickeythompson9537 But it's something like the British system of appointing a head of state.

    • @boogiewoogie9770
      @boogiewoogie9770 Год назад +3

      @@mikicerise6250 Is it? How so?

    • @Tough_Tardigrade
      @Tough_Tardigrade Год назад +6

      Now the tankies are have the full control in China. Regional instability in East Asia can be expected.

    • @T.efpunkt
      @T.efpunkt Год назад +6

      @@Tough_Tardigrade retireing corrupt polititians leads to regional instability? Ok

  • @dayneholt4149
    @dayneholt4149 Год назад +759

    He wasn't unwell when he left, he is unwell now.

    • @Axeolli
      @Axeolli Год назад +10

      he probably needs a beverage now if he didn't before.

    • @watersportsbyjamesfitzroy5870
      @watersportsbyjamesfitzroy5870 Год назад +14

      It’s a common Chinese excuse for retirement

    • @sjhassjh3941
      @sjhassjh3941 Год назад

      you are the health expert here

    • @swisschese1323
      @swisschese1323 Год назад +2

      My theory is that he probably shat himself

    • @user-dk8hh1uk1u
      @user-dk8hh1uk1u Год назад +2

      he is too well to be sitting next to the world leader

  • @thealmighty007
    @thealmighty007 Год назад +9

    He is now with his maker.......may the two have a heart to heart....

  • @ahmedwan6528
    @ahmedwan6528 Год назад +75

    As a Chinese person I wish him rest in peace. He isn’t a perfect man but he’s doing much better than his successor

    • @pfg1659
      @pfg1659 Год назад +5

      你是真的勇

    • @AsMightyAsBread
      @AsMightyAsBread Год назад

      From America we see the oppression on you, it is unfair. I would gladly fight beside you for freedom of the people but I am far away and wouldn't understand. I believe in the Chinese people you can and will win against the dictatorship!

    • @qingmingshiren
      @qingmingshiren 7 месяцев назад +3

      他还没死就rip干什么

    • @mergat2970
      @mergat2970 5 месяцев назад +7

      -500 social credit 😢😢😢😢

    • @priyanshuraturi5987
      @priyanshuraturi5987 4 месяца назад +5

      -10000social credit

  • @dokacokequak
    @dokacokequak Год назад +484

    one possibility is that Hu found out the list was not identical to what they agreed on in advanced and he showed some kind of frustration, which made Xi decide to "get him out of the meeting".

    • @anabelpineda9976
      @anabelpineda9976 Год назад +12

      I don’t make any sense because why they have a extra chair that was a disrespect but they did

    • @orbitalpotato9940
      @orbitalpotato9940 Год назад

      Or that he's simply feeling unwell. He's 79, same age as Biden. Occam's razor says he's just unwell.

    • @yanaya713
      @yanaya713 Год назад

      There is no list in the paper. They didn't vote for anyone afterwards by agenda.

    • @rdiddyspace1708
      @rdiddyspace1708 Год назад +16

      I like this theory better than the Chinese govt. story. "He just wasn't feeling well, everybody else was feeling OK". he got kicked out!

    • @attilamarics3374
      @attilamarics3374 Год назад +2

      @@rdiddyspace1708 He was escorted in also.

  • @joei8236
    @joei8236 Год назад +272

    The “finalized” list shown to Hu was different to the actual list presented in the congress, Hu realized and wanted to see the list, Li Zhan shu (third highest political power) denied him doing it. Although Hu have no political power and health was declining for years, he is still one of the most respected person in China. If he was truly unwell… and escorted out due to consideration of his well-being, there would been reports on Chinese social media and news outlet regarding the issue. Unfortunately, there’s zero coverage. Jiang ze min unfortunately didn’t make to the congress this year, but I sincerely hope both Hu and Jiang have a long peaceful life.

    • @allansh828
      @allansh828 Год назад +8

      @Joei That "nearby aid" is Hu's grandson. Hu has very poor health due to overwork, in recent years, one of his family member is always with him. You can see in video, Hu's grandson came to talk to Xi, not called by Xi.

    • @MrJ0lly
      @MrJ0lly Год назад

      what was it a list of?

    • @mark-jf5ik
      @mark-jf5ik Год назад +11

      @@allansh828 source?

    • @kunaiwithchain5278
      @kunaiwithchain5278 Год назад

      @@MrJ0lly they think it’s a list of people who will be in the standing comittee

    • @vkvk7113
      @vkvk7113 Год назад +17

      @@allansh828 Yep and the "mysterious file" that was taken from him was given to his aide so it was not like they were taking it away from him. They just wanted him to lie down because he was clearly unwell and they gave the aide the file so he could read it on his own time. Bunch of drama queens here

  • @lautuckwai4465
    @lautuckwai4465 Год назад +76

    How someone treat his benefictor tells a lot about the person in him

    • @aglis_
      @aglis_ Год назад

      @Howard Christophen Guy has pretty much retired, you know nothing.

    • @nohopeequalsnofear3242
      @nohopeequalsnofear3242 Год назад +4

      @@aglis_ then why take him out and humiliate him?.... I will assume your a Chinese minder

    • @Danie678
      @Danie678 10 месяцев назад

      ​@@nohopeequalsnofear3242because he has trouble sitting there due to health issue. So they help him to get out earlier.

    • @ajz2436
      @ajz2436 9 месяцев назад +1

      Bros been reading too many wuxia novels.

    • @lautuckwai4465
      @lautuckwai4465 9 месяцев назад

      @@ajz2436 Neh! This applicable to real life, you and me or anyone as a human being

  • @golinlim2221
    @golinlim2221 Год назад +26

    > *better than the Sudden Resignation of Boris Johson* or cough cough *Donald DucK Triumphy* ^^!

  • @davidharrison7030
    @davidharrison7030 Год назад +10

    Beyond chilling.

    • @samoak123
      @samoak123 Год назад +1

      so is Biden looking around the room for a dead woman

    • @DwightEisenhower34
      @DwightEisenhower34 5 месяцев назад +1

      bing chilling

  • @randomthoughts6625
    @randomthoughts6625 Год назад +12

    We are all really just speculating. I think he actually might really just felt unwell, it might be something entirely different too.

  • @Cursed_Mark
    @Cursed_Mark Год назад +64

    "Tom can you get me off the hook? For old times sake?"
    "Can't do it, Sally."

    • @PatrickFitzgerald..
      @PatrickFitzgerald.. Год назад +8

      LOL just like in the movie these guys acted like it had to be done no hard feelings

    • @TR4R
      @TR4R Год назад +1

      To me, it reminds me more that scene of The Godfather when Tessio knows he's sentenced to death and he asks Tom Hagen, former don Vito's consiglieri for a last favour and he tells him "can't do it, Tessio".

    • @ianmangham4570
      @ianmangham4570 2 месяца назад

      😅

  • @distrologic2925
    @distrologic2925 Год назад +5

    Unbelievable how nobody sees anything wrong with this and just plays along.

  • @worldbfree9321
    @worldbfree9321 3 месяца назад +1

    He was looking at Xi like “For old times sake, ah Tom?” 😅

  • @1398go
    @1398go Год назад +502

    It was odd the guy to his left slide the folder away from him as you can see he didn’t want him doing that. You know for a fact he’ll never be able to tell his side publicly. Saying he is unwell doesn’t necessarily mean he’s unable to speak.

    • @msblue1003
      @msblue1003 Год назад +33

      It was not on the agenda for Hu to do any speaking at that stage of proceedings... The guy looks mentally confused in a big way. It looks like dementia to me

    • @durgeshshah3734
      @durgeshshah3734 Год назад +3

      @@msblue1003 😅

    • @qzz3514
      @qzz3514 Год назад

      没有吧??

    • @qzz3514
      @qzz3514 Год назад

      你在歪曲什么事实

    • @qzz3514
      @qzz3514 Год назад +1

      胡根本就不是这样想的,你心真细啊

  • @farahrizvi6634
    @farahrizvi6634 Год назад +416

    Removing him like that and while everyone watches is scary, and a message to everyone to create further fear.

    • @louispaxeco6931
      @louispaxeco6931 Год назад +11

      Exact; besides removing an opponent, showing everyone what happens to those who dare question anything;

    • @ricksantinni6836
      @ricksantinni6836 Год назад +10

      Its another culture, another laws, respect.

    • @shabz4772
      @shabz4772 Год назад

      Scary was it; dont be so absurd Farah.

    • @farahrizvi6634
      @farahrizvi6634 Год назад +1

      @@louispaxeco6931 absolutely agree with you.

    • @farahrizvi6634
      @farahrizvi6634 Год назад +1

      @@shabz4772 very funny

  • @RolandPihlakas
    @RolandPihlakas Год назад +1

    This video is cut significantly. There were more notable gestures by all parties involved in between the scenes visible here.

  • @magnusnotcarlsen3241
    @magnusnotcarlsen3241 Год назад +1

    We need unedited videos

  • @aristhotle
    @aristhotle Год назад +203

    Interesting that Hu’s closest allies looked uncomfortably stiff and didn’t turn to look at him when he was being hauled out. Definitely not the reaction you’d expect if he were really unwell. Can’t see this as anything other than a political show of force by Pooh as he filled the top ranks solely with individuals that have no loyalties to any former president.

    • @JackJack-vi9uk
      @JackJack-vi9uk Год назад +5

      Hu has been retired for 10 years. If Xi wants to mess with Hu, will his thoughts be broadcast by global reporters? Xi has been the president of China for 10 years. What can't be changed in 10 years? Hu Du is already so old, what should I do to him? Wouldn't it be better if you really did not let him come out for the meeting? When he came in again, Xi helped Hu to sit down.

    • @isarainie4ever
      @isarainie4ever Год назад +3

      @@JackJack-vi9uk they could not even acknowledge his health condition before inviting him to the congress? Is it that hard?

    • @JackJack-vi9uk
      @JackJack-vi9uk Год назад +1

      @@isarainie4ever And what if he insisted on participating in the 20th National Congress?

  • @tommitchell4579
    @tommitchell4579 Год назад +381

    Does he look well? Not 100%
    Do we all know that China is a sketchy place to exist? 100%

    • @imprisonedone8054
      @imprisonedone8054 Год назад +13

      Bro this indeed is scary. Will this ever come to the west?

    • @emiriebois2428
      @emiriebois2428 Год назад +21

      All societies are sketchy!

    • @null7936
      @null7936 Год назад +1

      @@imprisonedone8054 Clearly you don't know how things tic here.

    • @danwelterweight4137
      @danwelterweight4137 Год назад

      At least they don't go around invading and bombing other countries in the other side kd the world and killing hundreds of thousands of people in other countries in the other side of the world like the West does.
      They use their wealth to build up their infrastructure, eradicate extreme poverty and improve the standards of living of their people.
      China just surpassed the US in life expectancy last month for the first time in recorded history.
      Not bad for a country that had a meager life expectancy of just 35 years of age in 1949.

    • @JDBBB
      @JDBBB Год назад +2

      It’s just politics lol

  • @atul58
    @atul58 Год назад +4

    Most surprising fact is how this clip escaped for the world to see.

    • @luka3174
      @luka3174 Год назад

      Escaped? It was intentionally filmed, if Xi wanted to keep it quiet he could’ve done it latter behind closed doors

  • @tray3120
    @tray3120 Год назад +2

    I think he doodled a pic on Winnie the Pooh in his note book 😂

  • @golinlim2221
    @golinlim2221 Год назад +29

    > *Muchhh much better than the Sudden Resignation of Boris Johnson & Donald DucK Triump LOSES* ^^ !!!!

    • @ellycham621
      @ellycham621 Год назад +2

      You have my RESPECT....NO nooo NO NO! You DESERVED my Respect😍🥰❤

    • @crimsonsbarvwin3393
      @crimsonsbarvwin3393 Год назад

      ❤❤❤❤‍🔥❣

  • @TheStoicApe
    @TheStoicApe Год назад +40

    "Respect your elders,.." only when it suits the narrative

    • @nightrunner1456
      @nightrunner1456 Год назад +1

      Why do some have on mask on, and some don't need to abide.

    • @smikkelbeer7890
      @smikkelbeer7890 Год назад

      Is that really what you took away from this video?

  • @mlislife5458
    @mlislife5458 Год назад +324

    I think it is also a message to everyone on that room. If anyone against us this will happen to you no matter where you at even in the most respected place.

    • @jumpinggoldagatito9153
      @jumpinggoldagatito9153 Год назад +7

      Only everyone in the room?
      Everyone on earth is what he means.

    • @viccozhang5299
      @viccozhang5299 Год назад +5

      Well imagined. I tell you that it's all because Hu is unwell, and they're afraid of any unsuitable behaviors. Why you think so much, he is an old man, can't you see?

    • @joseph1016you
      @joseph1016you Год назад +1

      @@jumpinggoldagatito9153 whole universe

    • @JackJack-vi9uk
      @JackJack-vi9uk Год назад +2

      Why don't you go to the original video? This video was intercepted. Before leaving, President Hu also greeted General Secretary Xi and Premier Li, didn't you see it? And when President Hu stood up, his feet were already unsteady. Can't you see it? In the opening video, General Secretary Xi helps President Hu to sit down, which already shows that President Hu is not feeling well! ! !

    • @lowiey6585
      @lowiey6585 Год назад

      朝君主专制中央集权迈进......😔

  • @yagotamamesdevis2638
    @yagotamamesdevis2638 Год назад +4

    The level of ignorance of this comment section is hardly believable

  • @pepsicherry6389
    @pepsicherry6389 Год назад +2

    When i watch european Parlament i See everyone playing with their smartphone

  • @avpr1574
    @avpr1574 Год назад +8

    Serious dementia going on there.

    • @shaoouhai3532
      @shaoouhai3532 Год назад +1

      五毛

    • @taxitaxi922
      @taxitaxi922 Год назад +1

      EXACLTY 100%.!!!
      ~ making him LEAVE is the BEST Choice.!!!

    • @gabrielmak371
      @gabrielmak371 Год назад

      @@shaoouhai3532 SO.??????????!!!!!!!!!!!!

    • @gabrielmak371
      @gabrielmak371 Год назад

      @@shaoouhai3532 SO.!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • @SB-lp7yj
    @SB-lp7yj Год назад +271

    It seems like the quarrel was about the list of names in that sheet of paper that Hi tried to grab several times and that was taken away from him each time. Current hypotheses: he had a list with different names that other members (they don’t approve each name but just the list) or he had the same list as the other but did not like the names in the list (his son for instance wasn’t in it…). So he was removed. Quite unbelievable anyway.

    • @klab3895
      @klab3895 Год назад +5

      Seems plausible he didn’t like what he was seeing in the paper and it was upsetting him I think he was about to throw a tantrum he’s obviously unwell so they had to remove him

    • @pooi-hoongchan8680
      @pooi-hoongchan8680 Год назад +6

      How do you know it is a list of names. We’re you there to look? Do up know Chinese ? Stop spinning .

    • @qzz3514
      @qzz3514 Год назад +1

      你在瞎扯什么啊?拜托搞清楚事情再来评论好吗???你想的太多余了吧!

    • @qzz3514
      @qzz3514 Год назад

      @@klab3895 有道理个屁

    • @user-gf5gg9bv2t
      @user-gf5gg9bv2t Год назад +4

      @@qzz3514 收嗲啦

  • @gongli1996
    @gongli1996 Год назад +16

    He must be a man of integrity to be hauled like that.

  • @ds3930
    @ds3930 Год назад +1

    “And he was never seen again. The End”

  • @golinlim2221
    @golinlim2221 Год назад +26

    > *Muchhh better than the sudden Resignation of Boris Johson* !!!

    • @tigerheinskein5346
      @tigerheinskein5346 Год назад +3

      ikr! the western elections (politics) are just too much of Freedom and DemoCrazy!!! Just too complicated!

    • @estheryau8611
      @estheryau8611 Год назад +1

      Tell me about it. AMEN🙏

  • @nisupply
    @nisupply Год назад +356

    Hu was massively embarrassed on a world stage and there is no doubt that wasn’t unplanned. The intent was to show who is in control…

    • @tofuyam7361
      @tofuyam7361 Год назад

      um, everyone knows Xi has been control since 10 years ago. Hu gave up all his govt posts and has not been seem much in public since

    • @Max-px5ym
      @Max-px5ym Год назад +41

      "there is no doubt that wasn't unplanned" took me a bit of maths to figure out the positive /negative outcome

    • @midnightwolfee2128
      @midnightwolfee2128 Год назад

      Don't know about that theory mate. Xi control is absolute and has been for some time. Zero need against an old frail out of power man to 'show who is in control'.

    • @night4shadow435
      @night4shadow435 Год назад +1

      @@Max-px5ym positive/negative outcome?

    • @Max-px5ym
      @Max-px5ym Год назад +17

      @@night4shadow435 no doubt that was planned is simpler than no doubt that wasn't unplanned. Just jokingly compared to an equation like -2x2=-2x(-1)x(-2)

  • @Relentless_Games
    @Relentless_Games Год назад +384

    He looked confused, but it's probably because they were confusing him.

    • @darth.severuss
      @darth.severuss Год назад +35

      So is Biden, who finished his speech but couldn't find the way out.

    • @Asoka-great
      @Asoka-great Год назад +27

      @@darth.severuss or Trump sliding on his toilet paper...

    • @ClaraFlater_than_surface_board
      @ClaraFlater_than_surface_board Год назад +1

      Cuz that's how ccp works

    • @giawou6615
      @giawou6615 Год назад +2

      He is over 90 ear old lol... he ask where is ice cream lolllllllllllllllllll

    • @yuanruichen2564
      @yuanruichen2564 Год назад

      @@giawou6615 no he's only 80

  • @golinlim2221
    @golinlim2221 Год назад +27

    > *much MUCH better than the sudden Resignation of Boris Johnnson & the phase(s) OUT of Donald DucK Triumphy* ^^ !!!!

    • @estheryau8611
      @estheryau8611 Год назад +2

      @@wallysmet5076 his "Sillyness" got him 21 Likes👍 and you -👎 (0). Who's the silly one now🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣😂😅

    • @estheryau8611
      @estheryau8611 Год назад

      @@wallysmet5076 his "sillyness" got him 21 Likes👍 but you.....???!
      Who's the silly one now🤭🤭🤭🤣😂😇

    • @gabrielmak371
      @gabrielmak371 Год назад

      Applaused

    • @ellycham621
      @ellycham621 Год назад +2

      You Deserved my Respect👍👍👏

    • @crimsonsbarvwin3393
      @crimsonsbarvwin3393 Год назад

      @@wallysmet5076bwuahahahahaHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA...................

  • @paullynn8953
    @paullynn8953 Год назад +1

    Why don’t you show the whole footage? This edited version make things appear totally differently

  • @afordcsy
    @afordcsy Год назад +43

    As a Chinese, this is an absolutely disgrace to see. What a joke government.

    • @christyl1663
      @christyl1663 Год назад

      @Libuše Xi is a disaster

    • @sergeikorolev922
      @sergeikorolev922 Год назад +3

      更难看的是西方媒体吧,你也很搞笑,反思怪是吧

    • @afordcsy
      @afordcsy Год назад +7

      @@sergeikorolev922 我评价的只是我看到事实,跟什么媒体没关系。视频里的这种行为你看着不难过吗?

    • @PureWhiteWolf
      @PureWhiteWolf Год назад

      For me, it looks like show of power, Xi do what ever he needs. To keep power, I'm not surprised if we hear that he is dead.

    • @jz6219
      @jz6219 Год назад +6

      @@afordcsy 可以那么说,不过另一方面天下乌鸦一般黑。西方政府也好不到哪去,只是表面形式不同

  • @Shadowless_Kick
    @Shadowless_Kick Год назад +635

    (1) Xi asked the two men to pressure Hu to leave without first asking Hu if he wanted to leave or not
    (2) We can see in the video that Hu *did not* want to leave even after the aides came to pressure him to leave.
    (3) Hu tired hard to get the white paper out of the red folder but the guys around him just did not let him get it. Xi knew why Hu insist on getting the paper so he ordered to escort Hu out immediately to prevent Hu from continuing challenging him
    (4) Eventually Hu had to give up, but before he moved, he patted the shoulder of the Prime Minister Li Keqiang, who was just removed from the Central Committee, to express his sympathy, Li appeared to be moved and very grateful.
    Hu should be Ok, he will still be respected, but his influence on China’s politics will likely be reduced to none.

    • @antoniodevido678
      @antoniodevido678 Год назад +93

      Li Keqiang was term limited, but the fact that he wasn’t kept in some other position is a big disappointment to the economy-focused factions within the party.
      Hu Jintao’s removal is especially shocking, as he has kept his promise to not meddle in the leadership of Xi Jinping despite Xi dismantling the collective leadership that Hu sought to strengthen.
      Hu Jintao may be old, but it’s incredibly heavy handed to have done this. Xi may have wanted to send a message that “the old days are gone, and the future is here” but I think it was a major miscalculation. Even with Xi having successfully removed all dissent from the central committee, dissatisfaction with Zero COVID, economic stagnation, and continued expansionist language towards Taiwan will undermine the popularity of the central government as lower level bureaucrats feel ignored.

    • @Shadowless_Kick
      @Shadowless_Kick Год назад +36

      @Antonio De Vido, I agree with you, but Xi didn’t do this to make a statement, he was just afraid that things might get out of control if Hu continued to voice his objection to (most likely) the result of the election. Although Hu has retired for 10 years, his objection would cause huge damage to Xi’s image. Well, Xi probably was not aware that journalists were just allowed to enter the Great Hall at that moment….

    • @yoleedance5136
      @yoleedance5136 Год назад

      Did not expect was the hired paper with thrown member out meeting.

    • @lagrangewei
      @lagrangewei Год назад +17

      watch the entire meeting and you will see, Hu was dazed, he could not continue, the guy that came for him his actually his family, u can tell because it was the same guy that enter the hall with him. Xi actually had to help Hu take his seat earlier. what we are seeing is basically an old man, there is nothing political about it. also the paper doesn't contain anything, this isn't a deliberative meeting, it is simply a statement by Xi to serve as the summary of the term, in US term, this would be a "state of the union" address, except that it addresses the party and not congress.

    • @SD-tn9ce
      @SD-tn9ce Год назад +6

      his family is rewarded economically for his sacrifice. and his grandson will rise to power 40 yrs later. so don't feel bad for him. 😉😉

  • @renijohn5111
    @renijohn5111 Год назад

    Scary!

  • @shuuushkiddo
    @shuuushkiddo Год назад +1

    Ain’t jintao the bad guy from one of the rush hour movies? I can almost imagine agent carter buss in there and start dancing while singing Michael Jackson classics

  • @JuiceMyRandomness
    @JuiceMyRandomness Год назад +18

    Not sure what doing this to him was about but it didn’t make you look powerful… the total opposite.

  • @krollpeter
    @krollpeter Год назад +1

    If an old person is frail does not mean he can not think.

    • @aglis_
      @aglis_ Год назад

      What do you know of Hu Jintao random youtube comment person.

  • @golinlim2221
    @golinlim2221 Год назад +27

    > *muchhh much better than the Sudden Resignation of Boris Johnnson & the LOSES of Donald duck Triumpy* :D !!!

    • @sanchurros6030
      @sanchurros6030 Год назад

      😅🤣😂👍🤝

    • @tigerheinskein5346
      @tigerheinskein5346 Год назад +1

      Couldn't agreed more. the Western elections (politics) are full of shockness. Too much demoCrazy!

    • @brendanburrows3217
      @brendanburrows3217 Год назад +1

      how can you compared with Democrazy where everything is Free. Freedom of speech, Free to protest. Freedom of Killing.. Free from Prisons & Free from Jails. !!!

    • @gabrielmak371
      @gabrielmak371 Год назад

      Appluased😘😘😘😘

    • @ellycham621
      @ellycham621 Год назад

      You have my Respect❤

  • @candidaprout560
    @candidaprout560 Год назад

    What a Shame. I would like to know where this man is and if he is well.

  • @Daijobustory
    @Daijobustory Год назад +128

    We all know Mr. Hu is well and happy in his farm upstate

    • @lemon1657
      @lemon1657 Год назад +15

      Love your comment lol. I hope he meets my childhood dog who also had business upstate. What kind of business? None of yours 😅

    • @rage8kage
      @rage8kage Год назад

      With a trainset in his den and a hydro electric dam in 1/3000000 scale

    • @amandacollyer645
      @amandacollyer645 Год назад +4

      🤣

    • @SelfProclaimedEmperor
      @SelfProclaimedEmperor Год назад +4

      Sure, as fertilizer for the farm

    • @Nighthawk-8050
      @Nighthawk-8050 Год назад

      Yeah ok anything you say

  • @titteryenot4524
    @titteryenot4524 Год назад +260

    Xi Jingping: “We’ve been expecting you, Mr Hu.”
    Hu Jintao: “Do you expect me to talk?”
    Xi Xinping: “No, Mr Hu, I expect you to die.” 🐈

  • @postal24
    @postal24 Год назад

    Why you still have to make cuts in new footage. Annoying.

  • @rogerzhang1228
    @rogerzhang1228 Год назад +1

    THIS IS NOT THE FULL CLIP.

  • @isaacdagwom2464
    @isaacdagwom2464 Год назад +80

    How does pulling his file away from him says about him being unwell?

    • @ravisalunke677
      @ravisalunke677 Год назад +6

      As per shang shung science if he sees the names in file, the named persons also goes unwell

    • @bobbyhill5067
      @bobbyhill5067 Год назад

      bro its chinese censor media; he wasn’t unwell it was a show of political force; instill fear in others that having thoughts of disposing Xi will end up being taken away … with your family and friends

    • @isaacdagwom2464
      @isaacdagwom2464 Год назад

      @@bobbyhill5067 very 💯%

    • @jashibopo2275
      @jashibopo2275 Год назад +1

      what are you guys guessing..?
      plz stop

  • @bindurao3463
    @bindurao3463 Год назад +323

    Elmer Yuan has explained why, the agreed to list of committee members was changed by Xi and hu jintao wanted to see changes, but Xi did not allow and instead had hu jintao removed unceremoniously

    • @MADBADBRAD
      @MADBADBRAD Год назад +22

      Lots of Chinese citizens were saying how the guy was suffering from cognitive decline. He’s too old to even figure out what’s going on around him. Like Potus for example.

    • @joerionis5902
      @joerionis5902 Год назад +50

      @@MADBADBRAD Thank you for your unnecessary segue, I guess

    • @briankim151
      @briankim151 Год назад +26

      Ccp xi Dictatorship had to be completed with xi's seven royalty dogs. Hu jintao would decline for sure. So, they eliminated him. Such a low and poor quality of chinese political development.

    • @tofuyam7361
      @tofuyam7361 Год назад +3

      doesn't make sense since the paper work is given to everyone

    • @vampiregamingyt8754
      @vampiregamingyt8754 Год назад

      What does that mean?

  • @mortuus4601
    @mortuus4601 Год назад

    hes like i took your candy and u will never get it back lol..

  • @g.bafrika
    @g.bafrika Год назад

    Just shocking .

  • @hannespeters1055
    @hannespeters1055 Год назад +287

    Imagine being forcibly removed from your own funeral.

    • @Jon.Morimoto
      @Jon.Morimoto Год назад +67

      @@darth.severuss Reported as a death threat. Your lack of decency and responsibility is noted.

    • @shimzk40
      @shimzk40 Год назад +7

      @@Jon.Morimoto true that

    • @darth.severuss
      @darth.severuss Год назад

      @@trendingsearchtoday thanks for the compliment and demonstrated you're a lowlife.

    • @lauriebarton9836
      @lauriebarton9836 Год назад

      Wahhh boo hoo shut up you lose scun

    • @DrRudy-em5nw
      @DrRudy-em5nw Год назад +6

      @@darth.severuss id like to see you try

  • @LittleMissRollerCoaster
    @LittleMissRollerCoaster Год назад +35

    I like the way everyone sitting so straight, praying 'oh no, he is unwell, please dun lockdown the whole room!'...

  • @akeemdobson8511
    @akeemdobson8511 Год назад +1

    He was not hauled out. Why are you reporting this in such clandestine manner?

  • @QueenOfArabianSea
    @QueenOfArabianSea Год назад +16

    He was promised his son's name on the roster. His health is failing. He doesn't think he will be around for the next meeting in five years. He won't get another chance and he was seriously upset when he found out he got cheated out of the deal.

  • @arnauddechristiani741
    @arnauddechristiani741 Год назад +48

    Well, Hu Jintao was simply drawing Winnie the Pooh on this paper, and then...

    • @citizenx7585
      @citizenx7585 Год назад +1

      Imagine if it was literally like that 😂

  • @rebikaroka913
    @rebikaroka913 Год назад +8

    This is what you get, for serving your country. Your service, dedication and loyalty to your party and country is measured in the way they treat you like this...

    • @nanjiang1953
      @nanjiang1953 Год назад

      Still better than Trump’s home was searched by FBI just less 2 years he was out of office

    • @yaedo6035
      @yaedo6035 Год назад +1

      Maybe the party wants incondicional fear above dedication and loyalty.

    • @salsaproductions5859
      @salsaproductions5859 3 месяца назад

      Thats what happends when you pick the wrong succesors

  • @entertainmentjoke2871
    @entertainmentjoke2871 Год назад +1

    Why keep cutting the video? Learn from CNA to be reliable news reporting. Show us uncut video!

  • @mohdaziz1242
    @mohdaziz1242 Год назад +1

    his eyes saying..."ooo man am i fxxx-ed"...

  • @user-jd9nq5jm8z
    @user-jd9nq5jm8z Год назад +104

    This is a historical moment

    • @arboghast8505
      @arboghast8505 Год назад +10

      10 years later people would watch this footage repeatedly and recognise this is the signature moment when China switches from World Factory to 100x DPRK

    • @jonimaar__2023
      @jonimaar__2023 Год назад +3

      @@arboghast8505 yes

    • @booomer180
      @booomer180 Год назад +1

      The moment Xi showed his hand as Q.
      Ncswic.
      Nothing.

  • @clankb2o5
    @clankb2o5 Год назад +11

    But if it's a health issue, Xi's body language is so odd...

  • @uriels4097
    @uriels4097 Год назад

    looks like my uncle who don't want to leave even after too much drink

  • @skyheart9245
    @skyheart9245 Год назад +2

    Wow, but we don’t know the whole story.

  • @Justmyopinionlol
    @Justmyopinionlol Год назад +142

    Hu lost more than face. His entire clan is doomed. 😢

    • @Sam-nb8ev
      @Sam-nb8ev Год назад +13

      Not only his clan; his friends, associates, partners, acquaintances are all doomed.

    • @bspiderm
      @bspiderm Год назад

      Who is Hu?

    • @qzz3514
      @qzz3514 Год назад

      What's there to lose face about? What's wrong with national leaders stepping down normally when they reach retirement age? ? ? What ignorance! It's hopeless! I'm from China. I know what's going on, okay?

    • @qzz3514
      @qzz3514 Год назад

      What's there to lose face about? What's wrong with national leaders stepping down normally when they reach retirement age? ? ? What ignorance! It's hopeless! I'm from China. I know what's going on, okay?

    • @qzz3514
      @qzz3514 Год назад

      @@bspiderm一位非常伟大的国家领导人

  • @mostlyshorts7462
    @mostlyshorts7462 Год назад +17

    Has to remove anyone that might stand in the way of his intentions..

  • @chenzhang19
    @chenzhang19 Год назад

    This is not even the original video, the major conflict part is cut, shameless

  • @jitan1972
    @jitan1972 Год назад +5

    一个身体不舒服,🤐让你扭曲的解读了。那么大岁数 坐了那么长时间,肯定会感到不适。【大惊小怪 小题大做】

    • @shaoouhai3532
      @shaoouhai3532 Год назад

      五毛

    • @TimeKiller.No1
      @TimeKiller.No1 Год назад

      你这是什么意思? 你上次不是说你不会忘记天安门而且必定找回民主主义吗。

  • @JackKemet
    @JackKemet Год назад +3

    "Xi, are you sure they won't chop off my head when I leave the building?"
    Xi: Don't worry...

  • @door-to-doorhentaisalesman2978
    @door-to-doorhentaisalesman2978 Год назад +2

    1:02 He's like: "Mr. Pooh pls save me :( "
    Xi Jing Ping: "haha lol no 😂🖕"

  • @ThobiasMarandu
    @ThobiasMarandu 20 дней назад +1

    I think He was Having Health Problems

  • @Solitude47152
    @Solitude47152 Год назад +5

    You don’t mess with Xi, he will mess with you

    • @jasoncampbell1464
      @jasoncampbell1464 Год назад +1

      He can't even stand being compared to Winnie the Pooh. He has the temperament of a 2 year old. You telling me this guy is running a nation? 🤣

    • @Solitude47152
      @Solitude47152 Год назад

      @@jasoncampbell1464 He is Ruthless

    • @crystalvoo8458
      @crystalvoo8458 Год назад +2

      @@jasoncampbell1464 How's *Triumphy* Is George FL0yd still......... *BREATHING* 😅🤣😂😂😂😂

    • @crystalvoo8458
      @crystalvoo8458 Год назад +2

      @@jasoncampbell1464 How's Donald *Triumphy* .........Is GFL0yd still........ *Breathinnnnng* !!!!

    • @crystalvoo8458
      @crystalvoo8458 Год назад

      @@jasoncampbell1464 At Least he's N0T the *Princesss & the Frog* ^^ !!!!!!

  • @adahbafa22
    @adahbafa22 Год назад +3

    Nobody's talking about this, but do you know why we have footage, and very precise footage of this? Becaude they want us to know. This is Xi showing that he can go after his predecessor if he wants.

  • @mokhtar_One_u_Key
    @mokhtar_One_u_Key Год назад +1

    It reminds me the scene when michael corleone orders the "accompaniment" of Sal tessio.

  • @kwokholuk8723
    @kwokholuk8723 Год назад +1

    At 0:36, Hu's eyes looked surprised!!!

  • @herrylalaland
    @herrylalaland Год назад +4

    He is no longer healthy clearly

    • @shaoouhai3532
      @shaoouhai3532 Год назад

      五毛

    • @taxitaxi922
      @taxitaxi922 Год назад

      EXACTLY 100% !!! that's the BEST way to him making him Leave.

    • @taxitaxi922
      @taxitaxi922 Год назад

      EXACTLY 100%.!!!
      ~ making him LEAVE is the BEST Choice.!!!

    • @shaoouhai3532
      @shaoouhai3532 Год назад

      @@taxitaxi922 五毛

    • @anastasiaana1583
      @anastasiaana1583 Год назад

      @@shaoouhai3532 *SO.* ????????????????????!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • @tammystewart10
    @tammystewart10 Год назад +6

    They probably didn't want Hu to see the list of Xi Jinping's new advisors to continue his term term with unlimited power. Hu probably apposed the new agendas with Xi Jinping's unprecedented 3rd term.

  • @Jose0421
    @Jose0421 3 месяца назад +1

    A lot of Chinese may not agree with this fact, but I think China did pretty well under Hu’s Leadership than it’s currently doing under Xi. That’s just my opinion.

  • @virtual-viking
    @virtual-viking 10 месяцев назад

    Everyone on the first row: "Hu Jin who?"

  • @sherinjohn001
    @sherinjohn001 Год назад +40

    "Don't worry, they are gonna take you to sleep.... Forever"

    • @warzone7905
      @warzone7905 Год назад

      Lol

    • @David-iu4mr
      @David-iu4mr Год назад +3

      Why did he came back later?

    • @sachi20ful
      @sachi20ful Год назад +2

      He doesn't seem like a threat. Plus he is 79 or 89 something. I guess he has some age related issue.

    • @Zieft2011
      @Zieft2011 Год назад +1

      @@David-iu4mr do you have a video link for his coming back?

    • @attilamarics3374
      @attilamarics3374 Год назад

      @@Zieft2011 You cna search it. He was even escorted in. Then when he was unwell they escorted him to the doctor.

  • @flitzipower9370
    @flitzipower9370 Год назад +39

    It's a shame for everyone sitting there!😞 Hu Jintao is not demented. "Often he does injustice who does nothing. He who does not forbid injustice, if he can, commands it."

    • @JA-ru3il
      @JA-ru3il Год назад +1

      Not dementia, he looked like he was going to pass out, the guy talking to him started and then stopped to look at him further and that's when they decide he needs medical attention so they escort him out

  • @joacimjohnsson
    @joacimjohnsson Год назад +1

    I guess the only thing to stop the madness is by using your money somewhere else

  • @selfiekroos1777
    @selfiekroos1777 Год назад

    "He was feeling unwell"

  • @wassdepp1
    @wassdepp1 Год назад +40

    Rest in peace. He lived a joyful life.

    • @SpeedyWings2323
      @SpeedyWings2323 Год назад +6

      He’s still alive it was the other one who died

    • @Irishlad92
      @Irishlad92 10 месяцев назад +1

      Which one died?

  • @clayvanalstyne7805
    @clayvanalstyne7805 Год назад +5

    Well, that wasn’t awkward. I’m guessing he’s buried behind the woodshed

  • @sanghoonlee5171
    @sanghoonlee5171 Год назад +2

    And that, Guardian, is why socialism is a bad idea.

  • @sayantanbose1093
    @sayantanbose1093 Год назад

    Scary

  • @matty1214
    @matty1214 Год назад +5

    Escort: Hu Jintao, they found your "homework" folder.
    Hu: Ain't no way man, I had that on maximum security
    Li Zhanshu: Bruh the file on the table is your "homework" folder
    Xi: Old man's beginning to act like Joe from the US, we can't have that!

    • @MunTheOddity
      @MunTheOddity Год назад

      I laughed at this harder than I should.

  • @Karl-by6ub
    @Karl-by6ub Год назад +4

    Look at all those Sheeppeople (people who are docile, compliant, or easily influenced) just sitting there, scared shi*less to do anything ‼️
    Reminds me of the citizens of Russia ⁉️🤔

  • @kckfen
    @kckfen Год назад +2

    I wonder why Guardian didn't show how he enter the hall. In the begining when enter the hall he already look confused. Leading to this footage which they actually initial had but didn't release till now. What the agenda?