Exclusive: What happened before former Chinese President Hu Jintao was escorted out of Congress?
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 23 окт 2022
- Speculation has been swirling since former Chinese President Hu Jintao was escorted out from the closing session of China’s twice a decade Communist Party’s Congress on Saturday (Oct 22), which saw Mr Hu's successor, Xi Jinping secure an unprecedented third term at the helm.
CNA’s cameras captured the moments just prior to Mr Hu's departure, which took place soon after local and foreign media were allowed to enter the auditorium to cover proceedings around 11.15am. It came shortly after Chinese state media announced that delegates had elected a new Central Committee and Central Commission for Discipline Inspection, which media were not allowed into the hall to witness.
Current chairman of China's legislature Li Zhanshu is seen taking papers out of Mr Hu's hand, before a man comes to speak to him and escorts him out. READ: cna.asia/3TwGKK7
Following Mr Hu’s departure, proceedings continued with delegates voting on other items on the agenda including an amendment to the party’s constitution. Addressing the incident later that night, Chinese state media attributed the incident to health reasons. In a tweet written in English, Xinhua said that Mr Hu was “not feeling well” during the session and for his health, staff had accompanied to a room next to the meeting venue “for a rest”. Mr Hu's name was censored from Chinese social media.
READ MORE: cna.asia/3z7jDNS
Subscribe to our channel here: cna.asia/youtubesub
Subscribe to our news service on Telegram: cna.asia/telegram
Follow us:
CNA: cna.asia
CNA Lifestyle: www.cnalifestyle.com
Facebook: / channelnewsasia
Instagram: / channelnewsasia
Twitter: / channelnewsasia
TikTok: / channelnewsasia
Former president Hu Jintao was responsible for the economic growth of China and friendly relations with other countries. He practised collective leadership and concensus-based rule. Hu Jintao was known for technocratic competence rather than persona. Unlike Xi Jinping, he voluntarily retired from all his positions after his second term and earned praises for it. The two are worlds apart.
Delusional take which has nothing to do with reality
Xi Jinping came to office in an atmosphere of crisis. Economy slowing; straightforward Keynsianism of throwing money into the banking system yielding decreasing returns, inflationary pressures, higher debt burden; unsustainable revenue model for local governments; SOE & local government indebtedness; growing disconnect between government economic objectives and priorities of the business sector; corruption; increasingly vocal and networked dissatisfaction; chafing at PRC pretensions at the margins (Xinjiang, Tibet, Taiwan, Hong Kong); demographic issues; corruption; clear need to wean economy and employment from the easy but no longer valid export/infrastructure growth model to something more complicated; a general desire by the US, Japan, and much of the world to circumscribe the PRC’s freedom of action and its international opportunities.
Under Xi China advanced technologically (many technology successful companies in China right now), reformed & strenghtened millitary, space advances and overally he made China much much stronger ideologically and more united and patriotic. Before Xi there were GDP numbers, but they were just numbers, without facts on the ground.
Your attempts to paint Mr. Jintao as some saint is atrocious. He presided over a DICTATORSHIP, and saw literally MILLIONS of Chinese citizens be imprisoned and have their rights severely curtailed. Shame on you for gilding a Dictator as some kind of "honest" character. The ONLY person who picked Hu to be DICTATOR of China was...ANOTHER DICTATOR, one who was responsible for the Tienanmen MASSACRE, Deng Xiaoping.
China President XI is out of her mind, that CCP Doctrine is no word of honor. Only misleading for the people of China
Well... Hu Jintao was born before Mao came to power. Xi Jinping only knows the ways of Mao since he was born in Mao's time as leader of communist China. Xi is a new Mao.
Xi Jinping took his position in 2013 and just one year later the South China Sea conflict escalated.
Thank you , great work !!🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻
Thank you for the video
Your content is so touching
Thank you for this Video 🤗
Rest of the guys were like "i heard nothing, i saw nothing, i know nothing, i just want to live" Li Keqiang was like "What am i even doing here?"
强子：麻了
胡春华甚至两手抱胸，开始摆烂了
Li Keqiang is a special one in the spotlight. He was part of the Communist Youth League, the faction which Hu Jintao started which opposed Jiang Zeming's Shanghai Gang. That's why Hu patted Li's shoulder as he was forced out, they were old buddies. Of course, Xi destroyed both those factions in the end and Li is now replaced as Premier. A shame really, Li seemed to actually care about how the Chinese economy was doing and even stated that the numbers published were 'man-made'
😂 not long ago they were making fun of the political systems in US. Now, they have become the joke of the new world. They are doing US’s job for him by destroying themselves within
What rubbish, Hu was clearly unwell and everyone were trying not to be dramatic nor add to his embarrassment.
One moment it’s president Xi being arrested and now Hu was arrested, gee, you all fell for all the crap flung all around.
Thank u CHA
Heart breaking
Thank you CNA for helping Chinese people to document this piece of history ! Well done
Well Done CNA 25Oct22
@Poo Too 能理解你心情
@@LivingLonger can you share the link? It was removed.
@@Med Literally no sign that Hu is disoriented, besides Li and Xi are not doctors, they can not diagnose Hu on the scene, more importantly, this all bullshit has nothing to do with the focus of this scene, the paperwork.
If you can't get it, you must suffer form some mental sickness like dementia, God bless you.
@@Med 是啊，他病了，前几年就手抖的厉害，现在可能也有点认知上的问题
Thanx for sharing this video with us all. Gd morning everybody here.. 🙏🙏🙏👌👌👌
So why does CNA cut out part of the video - at circa 1:26. I distinctly remember there was a first attempt to lift him out of the chair which hu resisted ,and they failed to lead him away. Then there was a second attempt, which we now see here and it's sucessful.
Chilling; absolutely chilling. When so little says so much.
What are you talking about?
An old man needed help.
Whatever you're reading into this speaks only of your own prejudice.
Thank you very much. This is an historic moment.
I thank this news channel
Poor guy. Hope he is fine
@Beluga, I wonder if any of his family members disappeared also.
You are poor
Afzal Roomy - Don't worry, he is fine..
U are right
They're ALL crooks. I'm not shedding any tears when criminals become victims of other criminals.
Why cut some part of the video at around 1:26, where it missed out how the escorting person walked to the other side of Hu Jintao.
Very shocking. In addition, they call this a meeting but notice the only guy with microphones is the guy in the center.
The true meeting has already taken place behind closed doors with no media. This grand convention is just a big show to rubber stamp what has already been decided in private. It's not up for debate. It's a glorified announcement of policy and the new team of leaders.
Only the front row are the ministers and emperor. The rest are either eunuchs or palace maids given nice sounding titles.
Please, can you see everyone in US congress has microphone?
Chinese people love to yell out loud so no need for microphones
@@CaseyTianJ 👍👍👍
Great respect got CNA for recording and sharing this video
respect for what? for filming and publicly embarrassing via tv&other media an obviously dementia stricken great man? what is good about it?
@@ThePolishTraveller You just copying your comment on all of these? Are you blind and stupid?
@@ThePolishTraveller It is the account of the Chinese comment corps that is saying respect right now. Just ignore it.
@@ThePolishTraveller nope. For showing how tyrannical Xi Jinping is.
why do CNA you just cut and play half vedio, there are more clips in advance, he want to stay although felt uncomfortable, that just what i saw
After cna posted this, is Olivia gonna be ok?
Why is this clipped, what about before this?!?
thank you to share full version. Truth is valuable. well done
its not full. its edited.
你发现这是完整版了，那么之前谁发送的剪辑版？是
The former president Hu appeared reluctant to leave; that part is pretty clear regardless the context.
These are facts the regime apologists cannot deny
He was afraid of the reptilians he was about to meet.
to me he was more confused than anything... makes me think about dementia, hopefully I am wrong
he is more like confused, like Biden lost its way to go down the stage sometimes
A man so sick he couldn't stay in the room, but his body language screamed he didn't want to leave....
CNA should be highly praised for recording such a major incident in modern Chinese history.
Edited out video is not true. CNA is low in ethics. Lowest professional level.
@@kapogin9360 No, you guys should thanks CNA for editing out the most ugly part!
@@mic5391 CNA edited out part of the video which Hu stretch his hand to take Xi's document while his document is on the other side. CNA has the evil intention to portray Xi in a bad light and you told us to thank CNA for editing out video which show Hu is in his normal self. You don't have any ethics or conscience.
@Hk Ps Well said!
@@mic5391 you are just an idiot without conscience . See the full video before you comment . CNA =CNN=BBC fake media who only do propaganda. I urge CNA put up the real news where XI show respect to Hu before the meeting start . Use your brain to think why Xi want to do this in front of world media . He can just disallow the senior leader to attend the meeting . Stop your stupid anti humanity campaign
Why did they do that?
Thank you CNA!
There 3 levels of power been displayed here: the guys who has a seat in the hall, the guys who not need to wear a mask, and the only guy who has mics before him.
And an extra teacup.
U mad that Xi is styling on u
It’s giving squid game energy
wow, what an observation
good observation!
why was part of the footage edited out?
How does this explain what happened ? Why was he removed ?
Thanks you so much for sharing this video, it can clear much things in people's mind. 谢谢新加坡的CNA！
Clearly XJP and his gang didn't want Hu to know the true details in the papers before the voting begin shortly.
Only thing it proved was that Xi wanted to humiliate Mr Hu infront of the bigwigs of communist party. If Mr Hu was sick then why not stop him from attending the meeting before? Why only infront of everyone? If Hu was able to walk up and sit on the meeting table besides xi easily then he definitely could be able to attend the whole meeting
Clearly Hu wanted to make a comment and objected the 3rd term of Xi, but he was ushered out.
There's a new procedure being implemented that only newly elected or re-elected officials are allowed to sit in the "long" table where the President is seated.
ruclips.net/video/EEz3a6fUdtY/видео.html
Great piece of work
Why?
@@virchandrakumar8186 以你的智慧，好难讲得你明喔
@@virchandrakumar8186 getting the footage out
what? filming and publicly embarrassing via tv&other media an obviously dementia stricken great man? what is good about it?
@@ThePolishTraveller getting the footage and showing the world about the reality of the CCP relationship with its former champion is a great risk. The great work I mean receiving the clip.
Hu was the gentleman who rules 10 years and stepped down with dignity in 2012. He is the one who shaped good China. No loan traps just development and global business he did.
"Slightly less bad China", maybe. You still had all the persecutions going on back then. The CCP is the World's biggest crime syndicate, and has been throughout it's existence.
apparently this is missing the part at 1:26 where he refuses to leave and holds on to the table
Thank you CNA, the history will remember everything, one day this documentary piece will become one of many evidences.
Let the United States take care of its leaders and its history. And China and the Chinese will decide for themselves how to live and what to do
Evidence for what…😂
thanks for what? for filming and publicly embarrassing via tv&other media an obviously dementia stricken great man? what is good about it?
This video makes it pretty obvious that this was not a planned incident at all but an health issue.
why do CNA you just cut and play half vedio, there are more clips in advance, he want to stay although felt uncomfortable, that just what i saw
Seems like everyone in the front row knows what is coming
Like what?
Only one guy there didn’t know the switch
Yes, old age. That is what's coming to us
@@lawless5037 they are all "retired" now.
Yup. Because thats what they do. Conspire, lie and keep secrets. Then boom, you are out. This guy will be watched and probably go to prison. They will make up charges against him.
President Hu: "But I'm trying to look at the menu to see what I'd like to eat, preferably pancakes."
From the audio, it seems Hu is not supposed to see the list of candidates standing for election. Looks like his supporters are not in the list.
Thank you CNA! My greatest respect to your work and this piece.
Check out Brian Berletic’s channel for the truth
Jai Hinduja. Seems from now on, CNA may even exceed the Indian rhetoric on Xi
@@zeissiez that is bullshit
@@entertainmentlobbyist you watched?
@@tedchandran For spreading lies.
Sad.
1.27 footage seems cut. Where is the full footage
Learn to respect each other. Life in this world is short. Always respect each other.
how did you find your point in this video？
1:26 they cut the little part when they try to force to lift him and he resisted.
@Tech "Americans" and "trust" two words that will never go hand in hand
@Tech That is a racist thing to say. I think you are a CCP bot trying to make America look bad.
@@jerry89753 bro🥶💀
So.. itsn't uncut
@Tech you pink people are the one to talk. 😂
I don't know what is going on here but the old man deserve respect
Xi Jinping kidnapped his former leader Hu Jintao
respect what?? are you blind? you didnt see xi jinping give him a respect. he need to rest not to join coneference
No he has to earn your respect first
He seemed to be disoriented. Some said he has Parkinson's disease. Don't jump to conclusion. 😂
Because the list of the governing body for the next term does not have any of his people. The current China premier Li (on Xi’s right side) is not in the list. Li was Hu’s (old man) appointed vice premier. Hu pat Li’s shoulder on the way leaving the congress as a gesture saying farewell or take care.
2:25 this scene is heartbreaking
Whats heartbreaking about it? He w0rks for 3lites, hes trait0r of Ch!nese people. Zero c0vid rule is his too.
Why?
If it happened in India, surely the body was thrown into the river. What happened to the old man in India?
It's like "Severus... please."
@@nads5907 he basically represents the modern and friendly China. He basically is founder of modern China if you study about the economic gains and history of China under his rule.
Imagine doing everything that for your country only to be removed within the Congress by fools who is hungry for power and status. Basically he and Xi are world's apart.
A very monumental footage .
There was something in that file that the leader didn’t like.
I want to see uncut version
Not sure what this is about? Please someone explain
As the former president of China, Mr. Hu carries historical weight in the minds of the whole country and represents public opinion. To remove Mr. Hu from the meeting against his personal will is totally unjustifiable in terms of the law, the CCP Party Constitution, the principle of human relations, ethical standards and public opinion.
Reminder: Communism = gansterism
Sounds a lot like cops and their unions 🤔
Yeah really, when you're a criminal enterprise like the CCP, you're not worthy of decorum. He's very fortunate that's all they did.
Thank you, CNA!
The CCP under Xi clearly wants China to return back into isolation. Can anybody give me a good reason why the rest of the world should not accommodate this policy ?
It's all over BBC, CNN, Al Jazeera, Reuters, AFP....
@UCryRvQugxrQCse8phtQf9dw First 60 seconds is new disclosure, which clearly refutes Xinhua's latest editorial that this escort was just for Hu's health.
@@CarlWilliamGTM The 1st 60+s shows more signs of Hu being afflicted with some mild form of mental sickness like dementia. This was not disclosed earlier by western media as it goes again their narrative that Hu appeared "normal" or not unwell which is clearly not the case. Watch Hu from 1:00 to 1:15 with that blank stare into the distance and looking lost. That's a symptom of dementia.
Jai Hinduja. Neoliberals are thankful and grateful for CNA's attempts in throwing shits at Xi's blemishes to all like-minded democracies.
It's informative and instructive to watch the action on a frame by frame basis. With the video first paused, you can frame-step forward and backward using the '.' and ',' (period and comma keys), respectively.
Underrated comment, needs more thumbs up.
I found no new information this way. What did you imagine you saw?
some important part of this video was edited out
Does anyone know what was being said and what were in the red binders?
I respect channel news asia for this important video in most original and complete recording!
Thank you !!
Did you stay in India too long? Everyone in the region knows what CNA is like and the channel is given away freely overseas.
Could anyone provide lip reading of those without a mask as to what was said?
Can anyone read lips? What they were talking about before he was escorted?
Good on you CNA.
Good on them for what exactly? Hu was once, as party secretary of Tibet, nicknamed the “Butcher of Lhasa” for his brutal repression of the Tibetans. So don't feel too sorry for him.
"Hu is especially despised by Tibetan masses as the ‘Butcher of Lhasa’. As the governor of Tibet, Hu used army tanks and armoured vehicles to effectively crush the Tibetan uprising in Lhasa in 1989. Three months later, it was the same ‘Lhasa Model’ that was used by his seniors in Tiananmen Square in Beijing to crush the Chinese youth’s uprising against the Communist system."
@@kiickinballistics But,he is better than Xi
@@frankzhou933 only the Chinese can answer that, if allowed. Hu was no saint.
@@kiickinballistics
US Presidents and government are the biggest butchers. They have been butchering people around the world since the founding of the US Imperial Empire.
@@kiickinballistics I am Chinese,although Hu is not good,but he is better than Xi.
Almost everyone pretending nothing was going on. Full of fear.
And the western media and people like you are pretending there's something sinister going on, full of anti-China hate. Much ado about nothing only for China.
he has dementia
One can never be safe in a communist dictatorship.
When the US president drinks, other would hold the cup too. This is polical stage you always need behave carefully. This is normal. When your boss is sitting with you at the same table, would you do whatever you want? Fking grow up and stop dreaming your own theory
@@sed9406 dementia is what scared them to stare into the front and not dare look at Hu? Look, I can make up a better excuse than that. I would broadcast that Hu soiled his pants, and that's why Xi remove him and nobody wanted to look at him. See! The government propaganda bureau should hire me instead.
Where is he now
For those confused by this...he isn't ill...this was a choreographed display to show all who is in power now. By comparative standards, Hu was a reformer and more open leader. This is a message that such an era is categorically over.
Exactly, and it's pretty obvious they want everyone to see it otherwise they would seize the footage.
Mini Me ejected to make room for Evil Scott.. someone can't read the room
@J P - thank you. Yours was the most credible explanation. I'm so glad that I live in the states and that Dumbo Don and his herd of dictatorial Neanderthals got voted out of office. Otherwise, we'd be the next China!
Brainwashed 😂😂😂
Bullshit.
Yes, give us the full version.
This link does appear to clarify the situation. It shows an earlier scene where Hu Jintao is being (gently) guided into the auditorium and to his seat. He looks quite frail and uncertain. He is definitely being shown care, including by Xi Jinping. This video clarifies.
@@dicksiedean I am so glad you saw the truth from the link... unlike so many who jumped to a "China bad" conclusion after seeing the CNA video. We should be aware of the agenda of the Western and some Asian media .
@@chew5461 Hi. I'm familiar with Western media and how some editors will go for the dramatic story which sells. Bit more examination shows the truth which is usually quite 'hum drum' (like normal life) and doesn't sell a story.
@@dicksiedean I don't think Western media just want to sensationalise stories/news. I think their intention is a more wicked one. They are China bashing, to spread lies about China, everything about China is "bad". The West is imperialistic and/or racist?
That’s scary.
any follow up?
This is not a complete version. Some critical part had been cut off.
Do you have that version？
Thank you ，we all need truth
The spirit of Levrenty Beria has returned 70 years later.
Next month’s news: Hu Jintao suffered an undisclosed health emergency and passed quietly in his sleep in November 2022. His contributions to the glorious State are appreciated.
At least someone can combine the two videos
Mr Hu Jintao deserves respect. He was a great leader in his time and is an elder
Xi the current president of China, helped Hu to sit down next to him at the beginning. Go watch the full video
Of course he deserves, but with all my respect... his era has done.
This time is for Xi and his royalist.
why do CNA you just cut and play half vedio, there are more clips in advance, he want to stay although felt uncomfortable, that just what i saw
@@hcjet This make me curious. Can you provide us the Iink of that full video?
He looks obviously dazed and unwell, but is reluctant not to participate in this important occasion.
Looks to me like there’s a disagreement about the document he received and does not agree with it.
So, what really happened?
XJP's face be like : you guys know I can hear you right?
Thankfully, Chinese don't have your mind.
Can anyone tell what Li said to Hu
Another great historical moment captured in photo frames......
Thank you CNA!!
The joke is, when Xi ask publicly to raise hands for support, He ignored the empty seat next to him and annouced 100% support !!! 😂🤣😂
why do CNA you just cut and play half vedio, there are more clips in advance, he want to stay although felt uncomfortable, that just what i saw
do you know relationship between Xi & HU? Hu was boss who actually promoted Xi
@@hcjet Xi is not Hu first choice for President
@@hcjetno. Jiang pointed Xi. Hu was supposed to name xi's successor this year.
Why after 1:27 part of the video is cut out? I want to know the full process.
I would like an analysis. Why is he escorted out. What could they be saying? What will likely happen to him?
this is not a full video,some are cut in the middle
@@chew5461 this is not even the full video but a commentary on it
This is the first time seeing in full version.
lol you didnt even know it is not a full version.
@@kuokhunglim7914 NO none of us know the absolute truth but this version enlightened us more. As usual staged with CCP drama.
Pl is one russland one uk ?
So can someone explain to me "what happened" *before* he was escorted out? I see NOTHING that would indicate why he was escorted out.
Please provide an uncut version, people deserves to know the whole truth. Thank you CNA!
This is the uncut version.
@@rhena229 There's clearly a cut in the video
He looks so confused, wonder how he arrived at the meeting, any footage?
Truth is usually found somewhere between the Western and the Communist narrative. The communist narrative being the former president was feeling ill and had therefore to be escorted out is clearly debunked by any of these videos no matter how cut. So it is clear his removal was of political reasons. But will he be let to live is the question? What about the peaceful protester on Xitong bridge, will he and his parents be allowed to stay alive after raising a bloody banner?
clearly cut @ 1:26
Very worried about him now
Is anyone able to translate what Xi, Hu, and the other party members are saying?
I like how he places his hands on Li Keqiang’s shoulder as if he’s saying “good luck bro, hope that you’re not the next”
This is heartbreaking. They shouldve respected an old leader. This is hard to watch if your Mr Hu's family.
Hu's son was sitting right there in the same room. Those animals are not human beings
@@ianwong1711 They look humans to me though.
@@ianwong1711 animals would not do that
@@44jwong The worst demons are those disguised in a caring human form.
Those who believe them are pitiful.
Not only Hu's but the rest of the influential families connected to him.
So why did they kick him out
这个比较全，感谢分享！
Good job.The big moment in history.
??
Thank you CNA for showing the facts!
Ermmm. It was everywhere on other news media. Not the first to the party.
@@devatheshmirra8176 He means that this proof that beloved Hu Jintao is in bad cognitive health due to age. They still take care of him out of respect. This clip shows he was probably confused and not following protocol, so they ended up helping him out for a moment (he then returned for voting and end ceremony)
@@devatheshmirra8176 he didn’t say CNA was the first
@@iberico8174 that’s not correct at all, Hu didn’t come back, the voting procedures were actually before he was got evicted. Fake twitter accounts first published this news for the first place, do not get misleading.
@@iberico8174 I call bullshit
the mental is the weird stuff, it happens out of nowhere but random
I'm more interested in what happened AFTER Hu Jintao was escorted out of Congress....
The fact that its public..says alot
The Congress is public... It really doesnt say a lot.
It means he's an 80 year old sick man with Parkinson's disease. Why don't you watch the WHOLE video where he had to be helped into the ceremony which shows he couldn't even sit by himself? You fo-0ls keep believing all these western media fffaaaking narrative and demonization against China 24/7. While your countries can't solve any of your own problems.
A lot
@@PRubin-rh4sr That's what Rodd means, the congress is public to all Chinese, and this is being done potentially as a display of power from Xi. It's being done publicly because this is what they want the public to see. That's why it says a lot.
Dumb things always think they know everything
This is how he gets treated after 10 years of loyalty! Truth tellers always get treated this way by LIARS.
People like Jinping only care about how useful people are to him, once they are not he gets rid of them.
Clearly there was something in that file they didn’t want being said,
Hu’s protégé was sweating bullets.
Can you release the full-full version, i.e. without cutting the middle portion? Thanks and great work!
Hi, the cameraman paused filming briefly to adjust his position. This is the full version of the footage captured.
The middle portion showed the guard tried to pull Hu out of his chair. Hardly a good way to treat an "unwell" or "ill" elder.
@@channelnewsasia Who is the cameraman? He is a hero, he should be awarded, and let the public know who he is so that the public can admire him.
@@xiphoid2011 ????
@@channelnewsasia 移机位就移呗，非要把摄像机关了才能移嗎？在这种关键时刻移机位？被剪掉的是習近平親自出手按住胡錦濤想翻閱的文件夾以及胡被警衛強行拽離的鏡頭。我懷疑這段視頻是中共剪輯之后讓你們發的，如果是你們自己拍的肯定會如獲至寶第一時間就發佈了。結論：中共的公關視頻。
Guess who took the video?
And not a single person in the presidium stood up to greet the ex-leader at least. What a shame.
Ya ain't that crazy to think that someone would do that.
You must greet only the new leader, not old one/s. It's a basic well-known rule.
Great job, CNA! True journalism!
Really?
Did someone read on the lips ? we see clearly conversation between Hu and the neighbour to his left.