John is the best, obviously. He creates the songs, btw. But Josh sings so well either. Under The Bridge with him is spetacular. Just appreciate, guys. Just appreciate.
give "omission" from john frusciante's shadows collide with people a listen and you'll hear what josh mixed with john sounds like...SPOILER ALERT: awesome.
To the people who say Josh is awful, just stop. He is a really good singer and a good guitarist. You can't compare him with John, John's older and more experienced, plus he wrote most of RHCP's songs while he was with them, but still Josh did a pretty good job singing them. Also, because of John, Josh is into a lot of pressure. Just calm the fuck down and leave the guy in peace for a while, he knows what he's doing.
The difference is when John replaced Hillel, within one album (Mother's Milk), frusciante proved himself to be amazing and the fans started to love him. It's been an album and almost a second and people still are divided. Josh is a great musician without a doubt but I don't care what anyone says, John frusciante is a legend. Period.
Alex Pappas Did I say anything about Frusciante being bad? Frusciante is my favourite guitarist, he's absolutely magnificent, an amazing guitar player and composer and I love him!
There's no comparison between these two, they're both amazing. They have two totally different styles in guitar playing and singing (and clearly have a different approach to song writing), so I don't think I can really pick one over the other. I prefer John, as I've been used to hearing him for many years and he has influenced me a lot as a musician but I'm not going to push Josh to one side and say that John will always be better. They're two completely different musicians.
God I love this video. Not because it puts them against each other, but it shows how fucking amazing both their voices are. John’s voice is so powerful and angelic at the same time, and josh’s is similar, but in its own way
los dos muy buenos cantantes y coristas, pero para mi John posee una voz hermosa, privilegiada, extraordinaria y sublime, como recordar esos coros que hacía con RHCP y también todo su trabajo como solista... me derriten y me elevan..Frusciante es un ser con magia...
The way I see it, John has the ,,rockman" voice and Josh...he is just an alternative music singer with his unusual voice. So it's pretty hard to compare their sound.
Lucia nne yh, both hav the voices of different genres, ik johns is always full of soul and perfect, I like joshes probably just as much, it's just they're soo different it's impossible and pointless to decide
I think John's voice better compliments Anthony's for background vocals, but I think overall Josh has a better voice. I guess it all comes down to personal preference
i think john is better singer...you're right though it's subjective. john does have the larger range though...so that's something non subjective. i like that john sings much more from chest voice than josh...josh is almost all head voice with occasional falsettos and chest. very thing compared to frusciante. for me there is no competition, but like you said it's 80% subjective.
Johns vocals on Otherside at Slane Castle never fail to give me goosebumps. I'm actually pretty impressed with Josh, there's no denying he's an incredible guitarist. As much as I hate to say it, the reason the bands live shows these days aren't as great is more due to Anthony than Josh.
Anthony and Josh has a "boyish" voice. While John has an angelic-mature-Godlike voice. Which is great filling for Anthony vocal. But, both of them are great :)
Josh seems to be making a huge effort on training his vocals. And i respect that. He is on the right path, where u give everything you got for love to make music.
It was a legitimate competition until Otherside at Slane happened. John's solo stuff is better than most chili peppers stuff anyway, and John is an absolute fucking legend always, but on that particular night, he was a GOD.
0:00 by the way - josh 0:36 - john 1:07 universally speaking - john 1:40 - josh 2:08 otherside - josh 2:54 - john 3:40 right on time - john 4:16 - josh 4:47 under the bridge - josh 5:13 - john 5:39 solo john 7:06 solo josh 8:16 solo john 9:32 solo josh You're welcome
my opinion: in Frusciante's time with rhcp, his voice was matching just perfectly, but by the ages anthony gets old too, so his voice is little different, and Josh is now perfect replacement cuz he is still kinda young with powerfull voice to cover anthony
I just get chills with John's voice...(especially Otherside, one of the most amazing things I've ever heard). Josh is still incredible but I think John wins.
As the biggest John fan in the world (cried when he left lol) I have to say I like Josh's vocals better. They're super unique. John has more of a pure beautiful voice. Maybe I just like the fresh sound of Josh better.
Oh for god's sake, John can't sing worth S**t. He is a brilliant guitarist and that's more than enough. But Josh brings an actual trained voice to the group. John made my ears bleed.
pegeen1 Do not talk stupid nonsense, Josh's voice does not compare with that of John, we note that you are listening to the band again. The started listening since it was John, the glory of this RHCP with John.
I love Josh's voice, it's weirdly captivating, but, John is the best, his voice is just so amazing and goes perfectly with Anthony's, and he has a huge range, sounds amazing singing really high or really low haha.
Comparing Josh with John is not fair, simply because John hasn't played or sung any RHCP songs written with Josh. It's in John's favor forever like this.
When they were written is irrelevant. So since they were written during Frusciantes time that means I can't judge both of them singing back vocals for Keidis to the same track? In my opinion Johns backing vocals pair better with Kiedis.
@@batman4452 Old comment, I know, but no. When they were written is completely relevant because that determines who they were written by. John created the backing vocals for every song that Josh sang backup for here, so obviously they're going to be better suited for John's voice. John's vocals probably won't merge well with the songs Josh wrote, because they're better suited for Josh's voice.
@@featheryfemme Still irrelevant, you're saying that since whoever wrote it intended it to work for their-self means it 100% actually does? I completely disagree... there's been many songs done better by a person who covered it rather than the original singer/writer of said song.. that's proof right there. I can name dozens... just because the person wrote it doesn't mean they're the best suited to sing it.
tocan muy parecido y josh mantiene la escencia de la banda y tiene una voz espectacular es dificil decidir cual es mejor ademas los dos son muy buenos amigos y han hecho varias colaboraciones juntos
I think the solo covers showed that John is more seasoned than Josh vocally, with better ability to keep the pitch where he wants, and such. However, in the backing vocals specifically, Josh has a much more distinguishable voice that adds more to the song than John did. All of it is opinion, anyway.
While I can't say I like Josh as much as John, Josh is still very very good. TO those of you saying John can't sing worth a shit, have you heard the album By the Way? Seriously? Songs like Dosed and Tear wouldn't have even come into place without John's glorious backing vocals.
It's not that Josh isn't good, it's that John is SO perfect that it's unfair to compare them. It's completely unfair because I'm sure any band in the world would give anything to have a guitar player like Josh, and one should recognise the greatness in him. The thing with Frusciante is that he's a prodigy, he's the kind of guitarist that comes once, maybe twice in a generation, and on top of that he's just as talented singing too. It would be like comparing, I don't know, Neymar or Dybala with Pelé or Maradona.
niggas act like John is a saint guitar player. Dude, have you heard the licks that Fall of Troy make? That guitar player is a dude that does lead screemo, guitar shredding, melody breaking, kidney bursting and brain melting musical medicine. What is so good about Josh guitar playing? It's like... up to par with todays talent. Look at Fall of Troy, Incubus, Satriani... Just cause RHCP is your fav band does not mean that in fact they have a prodigy guitar player. I personally know someone who is better than him. Now if you talk about Flea being a prodigy... yes that is correct.
i want to say something about josh before getting to the point.josh is great and he is the best man for the job after the exit of john from the peppers, though, if u want to compare their backing vocals,dont, just dont put the slane castle in the game, NOTHING compares to john's vocals that night, NOTHING. peace, love and peppers!
johns voice is much more soothing than joshs voice. I like joshes voice in iwu, but his sounds a little more artificial in my opinion. Im not saying he fakes it, but i feel like his singing can be used for another genre. thats why iwu sounded a little different due to his singing and how they needed to build off of that.
La voz de John en los coros, es única e inigualable, si te pones a escuchar, no hay alguien que haga coros como John, son hermosos y sublimes, no lo puedo explicar con palabras...su voz solista también es bella, sentimental e inspiradora...la voz de Josh es muy buena y bonita, pero ya es común su estilo bastante oído y puede apreciarse en otros cantantes, en fin John es un ser muy grande en la música, ingenioso y lleno de pasión y sentimentalismo.
John has more emotion in his backing vocals. He's got this powerful voice, I can't explain it...but whatever it is, it's something Josh doesn't quite have.
Of course he does. John was there to write those songs. He was there to put that emotion into it, and on stage, he knew the emotions that were put into it. He could feel what he was feeling at the time of the songs' creations, even years later. Josh wasn't there for any of that. Whether he can understand it or not, he can't _feel_ it, because he didn't experience it.
John Frusciante is better than Josh Klinghoffer on all aspects: guitar playing, singing, composing! End of story😛 Sorry, but there’s no comparison! Josh has a lot to learn; he’s still young so he can get to John’s level eventually.
I love how for John's you only use Slane Castle... not much can compare to that night! Listen to Dot Hacker if you want to hear how good Josh is, because he's incredible vocally, also with Guitar, Drums and Keys!
From both of their singing and guitar playing, I see John as more of a clean and sophisticated musician, where as Josh is more of a teenager, having fun playing on stage
All of the songs compared are vocalized by john on the records. so i think we're more inclined to pick john cause its sounds exactly like the record. while in josh's case, its good but doesn't sound quite right. Nonetheless josh's voice is beautiful.
Claramente es mejor John... las canciones son originalmente suyas.. Josh canta bien bien pero o sea, no se compara al original, al que todos acostumbran oír con el reemplazo. Mi voto es para Frusciante, sin dejar de lado el gran trabajo de Josh
Downtown and also - the sound that John produces with his guitar is way better than Josh's one. I was in a performance of RHCP with Josh, and he used such a bad tone that it sounded as though his guitar was choking. John got a cool guitar tone - the one he used with his Telecaster in Slane Castle 2003 was so funky and good!
to be honest theyre both good yes its sad that john left but at least they didnt break up flea said that if john left he would leave but he didnt due to the love for the band and their art that the have created the good part is that they didnt split and red hot chili peppers are still together and making amazing music :D
La voz de Josh en "Right on time" pero el Meadows Festival 2017 estuvo espectacularmente hermosa ❤❤ Su voz estuvo genial, hasta podría decir que en todo el concierto
Really hard to pick one, because both are great musicians. Josh has a really nice voice and really lovely backing vocals man but... John Frusciante it's from another planet. Check "By the way" live at chorzow and listen to the chorus, you'll agree with me.
Josh has got a very beautiful studio voice but quite often to me, his live vocals are weak and not well controlled. John has a very powerful voice and his backing vocals are, without question, some of the best in the business. His vocal range is also much better than Josh's too. BUT John and Josh's voices harmonise together so well, better than either of them with Keidis IMO.
i agree. but i will say john in keidis is like a match made in heaven. really the awesome part about that duo is really that together they create a super voice. they really become one. but like you said john and josh do harmonize amazingly. the song Omission off of Johns shadows collide with people is one of the first songs i show people we they want to hear johns solo stuff
Josh has the more natural singing voice while John's is more forced, also, Josh's voice compliments Anthony's much better than John's in general... On the other hand, John is able to do both lead and backing vocals and still sound great doing both, while Josh is more of your typical backing vocalist... That's not to say Josh can't do lead vocals, but his unique vocal style is better suited for backing vocals. Either way, both are great musicians in general, neither is better than the other...
John utiliza el llamado falsette que le sale bastante bien, y que no cualquier hombre lo domina, y es un corista bastante bueno bueno...excelente!!!...puedo decir que es muy bueno cantando, mucho sentimiento a la hora de cantar y transmite demasiado, pero creo que es mejor haciendo coros, si te pones a escuchar sus coros son tremendamente hermosos, diferentes y perfectos!!!, la voz de Josh sí es mas natural, pero tiene una voz bastante común que no impresiona mucho, ya que he escuchado su estilo en otros cantantes, en pocas palabras no es una voz innovadora....es muy buena...pero muy repetible...
How can you say that someone with a more unique voice is more suited to backing vocals? The more generic you sound the more suited to backing vocals you are. That being said this new dude sound way less unique to me than john. Also his style is an almost carbon copy of john circa BSSM
From a technique point of view, John wins it easily. His control, especially while singing falsetto, is very good. He is also great at jumping between head and chest voice. He also has a greater vocal range: compare his solo songs, 'One more of me' and 'Walls' for example. Listening to Otherside and By the Way, John's chest highs are far more powerful and clear. I see the appeal of Josh's voice, and I've known of him way before he joined the peps. He sounds great on 'Omission'. But technically, he isn't a great singer at all.
It’s so unfortunate for Josh to have to be compared with John. Josh is great and all. But John is debatably the greatest guitarist of the late 20th and early 21st century. Plus his backing backing vocals are A1. Hard to compete with a living legend.
![Red Hot Chili Peppers - Rock And Roll Hall of Fame Induction [HD]](/img/1.gif)
John is the best, obviously. He creates the songs, btw. But Josh sings so well either. Under The Bridge with him is spetacular. Just appreciate, guys. Just appreciate.
give "omission" from john frusciante's shadows collide with people a listen and you'll hear what josh mixed with john sounds like...SPOILER ALERT: awesome.
Chrispfe4800 yh haha, they work so well together
Chrispfe4800 my absolute favourite. divine.
Chrispfe4800 give a chance to "Surrogate People" From The Johns and Josh album
Been on repeat... Such a beautiful song!
REALLY AWESOME
they both are awesome stop comparing them
Agree
John and Anthony on otherside can not be replicated
Never fucking ever. NEVER.
Thats not what josh wanted to do, he wanted to give his thing to the song
To the people who say Josh is awful, just stop. He is a really good singer and a good guitarist. You can't compare him with John, John's older and more experienced, plus he wrote most of RHCP's songs while he was with them, but still Josh did a pretty good job singing them. Also, because of John, Josh is into a lot of pressure. Just calm the fuck down and leave the guy in peace for a while, he knows what he's doing.
It's like when John replaced Hillel people were talking shit bout John even though there all talented
two super accurate comments right here. I wish people can see that
The difference is when John replaced Hillel, within one album (Mother's Milk), frusciante proved himself to be amazing and the fans started to love him. It's been an album and almost a second and people still are divided. Josh is a great musician without a doubt but I don't care what anyone says, John frusciante is a legend. Period.
Alex Pappas
Did I say anything about Frusciante being bad? Frusciante is my favourite guitarist, he's absolutely magnificent, an amazing guitar player and composer and I love him!
who is that, i love josh voice
Otherside, Slane Castle version, Frusciante, Best backing vocal ever.
ignacio silva aguirre when John hits that note at "slide" oh my goddddd
I have that on my paste so I can look at it whenever I want
Otherside, Pink Pop 2006, Frusciante, Beautiful too.
Agree 100%
Venice Queen in Slane Castle too
Don't forget that JOHN created most of the backing vocals we're listening. Anyway, i think they're both great singers
I like that Josh gives more "youthful" backing vocals, he gives younger energy to the band. while john has more experienced vocals. I LOVE BOTH
There's no comparison between these two, they're both amazing.
They have two totally different styles in guitar playing and singing (and clearly have a different approach to song writing), so I don't think I can really pick one over the other. I prefer John, as I've been used to hearing him for many years and he has influenced me a lot as a musician but I'm not going to push Josh to one side and say that John will always be better.
They're two completely different musicians.
You cant put Josh up against John's Slane vocals. Thats not fair
Man was in his prime during that show lol, fair
Flea is best singer. End of the discussion.
You said everything!😂
LOL
Through brass pipes, yeah that is accurate. Kid can toot like nobody's business
Pea is the greatest vocal performance of all time
To be honest i prefer Josh's vocals. He has a very special and interesting voice. He sounds like an angel
I prefer Josh too, except in otherside, john does an amazing job in this one
PERO QUE COÑO??? JAJAJAJA
Hahahah Josh's vocals better than John's? Omg ;x
omg an opinion opposed to the john frusciante worshipping? jokes aside, totally agree! I love how his vocals on the By The Way performances.. golden.
Rickard Livbom You mean as opposed to the josh Klinghoffer worshipping?
God I love this video. Not because it puts them against each other, but it shows how fucking amazing both their voices are. John’s voice is so powerful and angelic at the same time, and josh’s is similar, but in its own way
john or Josh sing much better than Anthony LOL
i lol'd cause its true but you gotta love it
Davi Bernardo but they can't rap that good
Anthony is the voice of RHCP, you can't change this
Anthony is the one that gives flavor to the band
Davi Bernardo true
los dos muy buenos cantantes y coristas, pero para mi John posee una voz hermosa, privilegiada, extraordinaria y sublime, como recordar esos coros que hacía con RHCP y también todo su trabajo como solista... me derriten y me elevan..Frusciante es un ser con magia...
love josh's voice :)
The way I see it, John has the ,,rockman" voice and Josh...he is just an alternative music singer with his unusual voice. So it's pretty hard to compare their sound.
Lucia nne yh, both hav the voices of different genres, ik johns is always full of soul and perfect, I like joshes probably just as much, it's just they're soo different it's impossible and pointless to decide
How tf do we even compare this the music is all that should matter, does it sound good or not ya know. Both of them are talented and sound amazing
hear the john's backing vocal in venice queen at slane castle
I think that's my favorite John backing vocal song, especially in the Slane Castle gig, it's just beautiful.
exactly
Josh K is another version of John Frusciante... younger xD
noooooooo!!!!!! there's no another John Frusciante..!!!!
la forma de tocar hasta se la copió!!! :P..
es lo que yo percibo claro, quizá solo es mi imaginación...
Alter Bandai Josh fue alumno de Frusciante si no me equivoco, además de amigo y ambos estuvieron juntos en Ataxia.
Mark360core Encima Josh les hacia de guitarra de apoyo en vivo cuando aun estaba John.
si concuerdo, Josh es como un Frusciante de joven gritando afinadamente, pero obvio no se compara con Frusciante.
John is God, Josh is Goddess.
+蔡東翰 hahahaha very nice
Yeah souds very high but i Like his part in dark necessities
@@yyzei6297 XD
I love Johns backing vocals but I enjoy Joshs even more. I love the adolescent touch he brought in there
I think John's voice better compliments Anthony's for background vocals, but I think overall Josh has a better voice. I guess it all comes down to personal preference
+Deryck Gebe have you ever listened to john's solo album? "inside of emptiness" and "curtains" expecially, but also check out "Empyrean"
Check out John's live cover of Emily or tiny dancer. He's a great singer josh is good too. I seen him live a few weeks ago with them and they're great
i think john is better singer...you're right though it's subjective. john does have the larger range though...so that's something non subjective. i like that john sings much more from chest voice than josh...josh is almost all head voice with occasional falsettos and chest. very thing compared to frusciante. for me there is no competition, but like you said it's 80% subjective.
Johns vocals on Otherside at Slane Castle never fail to give me goosebumps. I'm actually pretty impressed with Josh, there's no denying he's an incredible guitarist. As much as I hate to say it, the reason the bands live shows these days aren't as great is more due to Anthony than Josh.
THRILL606 exactly my thoughts
Anthony and Josh has a "boyish" voice. While John has an angelic-mature-Godlike voice. Which is great filling for Anthony vocal. But, both of them are great :)
Josh seems to be making a huge effort on training his vocals. And i respect that.
He is on the right path, where u give everything you got for love to make music.
It was a legitimate competition until Otherside at Slane happened. John's solo stuff is better than most chili peppers stuff anyway, and John is an absolute fucking legend always, but on that particular night, he was a GOD.
john girardi I coudnt have said it better
i love josh
Josh it’s so talented
Josh has a good voice, but the mix of John's and Anthony's voices sound better
On otherside, i would personally take in the live in Sao Paolo in 2002.. Just amazing.. Nice video!
Conclusion: Listen the song ''Omission'' by John and Josh.
Come on, no SNL 92 for John’s Under The Bridge? Hahaha for real tho, wicked video, two dope musicians
0:00 by the way - josh
0:36 - john
1:07 universally speaking - john
1:40 - josh
2:08 otherside - josh
2:54 - john
3:40 right on time - john
4:16 - josh
4:47 under the bridge - josh
5:13 - john
5:39 solo john
7:06 solo josh
8:16 solo john
9:32 solo josh
You're welcome
Both have beautiful voices.
my opinion: in Frusciante's time with rhcp, his voice was matching just perfectly, but by the ages anthony gets old too, so his voice is little different, and Josh is now perfect replacement cuz he is still kinda young with powerfull voice to cover anthony
I just get chills with John's voice...(especially Otherside, one of the most amazing things I've ever heard). Josh is still incredible but I think John wins.
As the biggest John fan in the world (cried when he left lol) I have to say I like Josh's vocals better. They're super unique. John has more of a pure beautiful voice. Maybe I just like the fresh sound of Josh better.
Oh for god's sake, John can't sing worth S**t. He is a brilliant guitarist and that's more than enough. But Josh brings an actual trained voice to the group. John made my ears bleed.
pegeen1 Do not talk stupid nonsense, Josh's voice does not compare with that of John, we note that you are listening to the band again. The started listening since it was John, the glory of this RHCP with John.
pegeen1 John is a fantastic singer, don't be a moron. Josh's voice is more unique yet not as strong. The whole comparison seems silly really anyway
pegeen1 wow you really are clueless, John has a really powerful and melodic voice. He genuinely wipes the floor with Josh.
@@pegeen1 wtf?!?!
josh's backup vocals on under the bridge is very cool
John basically nails every time. Goose bump inducing brilliance every time.
John voice can touch your heart easy
All the albums John has sang and played on stand out! John gives the RHCP that extra soul
I love Josh's voice, it's weirdly captivating, but, John is the best, his voice is just so amazing and goes perfectly with Anthony's, and he has a huge range, sounds amazing singing really high or really low haha.
Comparing Josh with John is not fair, simply because John hasn't played or sung any RHCP songs written with Josh. It's in John's favor forever like this.
Those songs were written in the times of Frusciante, but let John back vocaling a song from I'm With You or The Getaway, and see who wins.
True
When they were written is irrelevant. So since they were written during Frusciantes time that means I can't judge both of them singing back vocals for Keidis to the same track? In my opinion Johns backing vocals pair better with Kiedis.
Maybe we get this opportunity
@@batman4452 Old comment, I know, but no. When they were written is completely relevant because that determines who they were written by. John created the backing vocals for every song that Josh sang backup for here, so obviously they're going to be better suited for John's voice. John's vocals probably won't merge well with the songs Josh wrote, because they're better suited for Josh's voice.
@@featheryfemme Still irrelevant, you're saying that since whoever wrote it intended it to work for their-self means it 100% actually does?
I completely disagree... there's been many songs done better by a person who covered it rather than the original singer/writer of said song.. that's proof right there. I can name dozens... just because the person wrote it doesn't mean they're the best suited to sing it.
tocan muy parecido y josh mantiene la escencia de la banda y tiene una voz espectacular es dificil decidir cual es mejor ademas los dos son muy buenos amigos y han hecho varias colaboraciones juntos
i love all the videos comparing them both because double pleasure
I think the solo covers showed that John is more seasoned than Josh vocally, with better ability to keep the pitch where he wants, and such. However, in the backing vocals specifically, Josh has a much more distinguishable voice that adds more to the song than John did. All of it is opinion, anyway.
John Frusciante ❤
they clearly have diferent styles of singing, as much john as john have a great voice, I particularly love both
ofcourse John best vocal and best guitar.... !! 100% sure
While I can't say I like Josh as much as John, Josh is still very very good. TO those of you saying John can't sing worth a shit, have you heard the album By the Way? Seriously? Songs like Dosed and Tear wouldn't have even come into place without John's glorious backing vocals.
Otherside and Right on time Josh's great.. gives another feel.. But still, John's clean, deep and worked voice gives u chills..! Fact. ;)
It's not that Josh isn't good, it's that John is SO perfect that it's unfair to compare them. It's completely unfair because I'm sure any band in the world would give anything to have a guitar player like Josh, and one should recognise the greatness in him. The thing with Frusciante is that he's a prodigy, he's the kind of guitarist that comes once, maybe twice in a generation, and on top of that he's just as talented singing too.
It would be like comparing, I don't know, Neymar or Dybala with Pelé or Maradona.
niggas act like John is a saint guitar player. Dude, have you heard the licks that Fall of Troy make? That guitar player is a dude that does lead screemo, guitar shredding, melody breaking, kidney bursting and brain melting musical medicine. What is so good about Josh guitar playing? It's like... up to par with todays talent. Look at Fall of Troy, Incubus, Satriani... Just cause RHCP is your fav band does not mean that in fact they have a prodigy guitar player. I personally know someone who is better than him. Now if you talk about Flea being a prodigy... yes that is correct.
@@cjtrouble nah it’s cuz u don’t know John like the fans do;)
I love how everyone ignores the fact that Dave Navaro was in the band 😂😂
Yeah, but he rarely sang. Backups were done by other touring members, I don't know their names.
i want to say something about josh before getting to the point.josh is great and he is the best man for the job after the exit of john from the peppers, though, if u want to compare their backing vocals,dont, just dont put the slane castle in the game, NOTHING compares to john's vocals that night, NOTHING.
peace, love and peppers!
Πολύ Κακός absolutely right
Right lol
John kinda coached josh to be a chili pepper. Josh is basically john 2.0
+Michael Chowanec yup you right
Josh is a John 0.9 right?
Josh went from a bellpepper, to a chili pepper.
I'd say Josh is a beta version, hahaha.
That's why he's a better replacement for John than Dave Navarro.
1:02 John fell off the stage
The fact that people actually take the time to argue about this crap, is pretty lame. They both have their own skills, highs and lows.
johns voice is much more soothing than joshs voice. I like joshes voice in iwu, but his sounds a little more artificial in my opinion. Im not saying he fakes it, but i feel like his singing can be used for another genre. thats why iwu sounded a little different due to his singing and how they needed to build off of that.
La voz de John en los coros, es única e inigualable, si te pones a escuchar, no hay alguien que haga coros como John, son hermosos y sublimes, no lo puedo explicar con palabras...su voz solista también es bella, sentimental e inspiradora...la voz de Josh es muy buena y bonita, pero ya es común su estilo bastante oído y puede apreciarse en otros cantantes, en fin John es un ser muy grande en la música, ingenioso y lleno de pasión y sentimentalismo.
How could you not put Johns performance of tiny dancer from rock am ring in this ???
***** there were not only background vocals in this video, but some solo performances, haven't u seen the whole video?
The John's voice on Otherside is just perfect..
somebody know the name of the song what sing john frusciante at the minute 8:17, i need to know please¡
This video uploaded on my birthday!! WOW
they are both such talented vocalists AND guitarists, and they are both my role models. Hell, the whole band is.
Dispite not knowing a single word from that last remnition from john, I have been doused in the pain coming from josh's vocals. Beautiful
John forever.
John has more emotion in his backing vocals. He's got this powerful voice, I can't explain it...but whatever it is, it's something Josh doesn't quite have.
I think he will sing till the day he dies, and then after he dies.
Of course he does. John was there to write those songs. He was there to put that emotion into it, and on stage, he knew the emotions that were put into it. He could feel what he was feeling at the time of the songs' creations, even years later. Josh wasn't there for any of that. Whether he can understand it or not, he can't _feel_ it, because he didn't experience it.
John Frusciante is better than Josh Klinghoffer on all aspects: guitar playing, singing, composing! End of story😛 Sorry, but there’s no comparison! Josh has a lot to learn; he’s still young so he can get to John’s level eventually.
thank you! it's a beautiful song!
I love how for John's you only use Slane Castle... not much can compare to that night! Listen to Dot Hacker if you want to hear how good Josh is, because he's incredible vocally, also with Guitar, Drums and Keys!
From both of their singing and guitar playing, I see John as more of a clean and sophisticated musician, where as Josh is more of a teenager, having fun playing on stage
never compare to anybody against john.
Josh Klinghoffer & John Frusciante For the RHCP only had to win with you 2 incrives guitarists on stage
No words to describe the 2
The best !!!!!
Backing vocal do John é o melhor
Im sorry, I know how otherside at slane castle sounds but 2:15 gives me bigger chills..
josh will always be john's shadow. John frusciante= guitar god
josh is an amazong guitarist. writer and singer but john is a god, hes a plain out god in everything
All of the songs compared are vocalized by john on the records. so i think we're more inclined to pick john cause its sounds exactly like the record. while in josh's case, its good but doesn't sound quite right. Nonetheless josh's voice is beautiful.
Claramente es mejor John... las canciones son originalmente suyas.. Josh canta bien bien pero o sea, no se compara al original, al que todos acostumbran oír con el reemplazo.
Mi voto es para Frusciante, sin dejar de lado el gran trabajo de Josh
John is better. Nothing to do about it. He just has such a great voice, and the combination between John's voice and Anthony's voice was just divine.
Downtown and also - the sound that John produces with his guitar is way better than Josh's one. I was in a performance of RHCP with Josh, and he used such a bad tone that it sounded as though his guitar was choking. John got a cool guitar tone - the one he used with his Telecaster in Slane Castle 2003 was so funky and good!
Yeah... Right now RHCP are just three old guys out of tune and a 40 years old guitarist who isn't familiar with true music.
yeah :(
Ariking777 They no longer have 30 years, no longer be the same. Stop bitching and enjoy :)
Emmanuel Medina I'm certainly not bitching. Anyways, what I'm saying is that I DO enjoy RHCP now, but much less without John. But that's life.
Alguien se despertó un día, eligió el camino de la violencia y subió este video jajajajaj
Io sono quel qui sono e valgo quel che valgo
però io ti amo
come nessuno t' ha mai amato... Josh!! ♥♥♥
what's the name of the song Josh sings at 7:14?
Josh, great guy nice artist, John, genious!
WHEN WAS THE 'OTHERSIDE' WITH JOHN RECORDED?! IT SOUNDS INCREDIBLE
they're both are great singers and guitarists but john, john is just GOD
I Love Josh Klinghoffer❤
John's voice is very different to Anthony's, so his backing vocals fill in Anthony's. I don't really know how to explain it.
to be honest theyre both good yes its sad that john left but at least they didnt break up flea said that if john left he would leave but he didnt due to the love for the band and their art that the have created the good part is that they didnt split and red hot chili peppers are still together and making amazing music :D
La voz de Josh en "Right on time" pero el Meadows Festival 2017 estuvo espectacularmente hermosa ❤❤
Su voz estuvo genial, hasta podría decir que en todo el concierto
John always will be THE GUITARIST in the chilis
Really hard to pick one, because both are great musicians. Josh has a really nice voice and really lovely backing vocals man but... John Frusciante it's from another planet. Check "By the way" live at chorzow and listen to the chorus, you'll agree with me.
John toda la vida :')
both of them is good musician... i miss john
Josh has got a very beautiful studio voice but quite often to me, his live vocals are weak and not well controlled. John has a very powerful voice and his backing vocals are, without question, some of the best in the business. His vocal range is also much better than Josh's too. BUT John and Josh's voices harmonise together so well, better than either of them with Keidis IMO.
i agree. but i will say john in keidis is like a match made in heaven. really the awesome part about that duo is really that together they create a super voice. they really become one. but like you said john and josh do harmonize amazingly. the song Omission off of Johns shadows collide with people is one of the first songs i show people we they want to hear johns solo stuff
okyoulot hear their newest album's lives. josh sounds amazing
Josh has the more natural singing voice while John's is more forced, also, Josh's voice compliments Anthony's much better than John's in general... On the other hand, John is able to do both lead and backing vocals and still sound great doing both, while Josh is more of your typical backing vocalist... That's not to say Josh can't do lead vocals, but his unique vocal style is better suited for backing vocals. Either way, both are great musicians in general, neither is better than the other...
LMAO . u crazy. its like john is jesus . and josh is the alter boy serving john at church.
John utiliza el llamado falsette que le sale bastante bien, y que no cualquier hombre lo domina, y es un corista bastante bueno bueno...excelente!!!...puedo decir que es muy bueno cantando, mucho sentimiento a la hora de cantar y transmite demasiado, pero creo que es mejor haciendo coros, si te pones a escuchar sus coros son tremendamente hermosos, diferentes y perfectos!!!, la voz de Josh sí es mas natural, pero tiene una voz bastante común que no impresiona mucho, ya que he escuchado su estilo en otros cantantes, en pocas palabras no es una voz innovadora....es muy buena...pero muy repetible...
How can you say that someone with a more unique voice is more suited to backing vocals? The more generic you sound the more suited to backing vocals you are. That being said this new dude sound way less unique to me than john. Also his style is an almost carbon copy of john circa BSSM
name of the song at 7:10 ?
Don't dream its over
From a technique point of view, John wins it easily. His control, especially while singing falsetto, is very good. He is also great at jumping between head and chest voice.
He also has a greater vocal range: compare his solo songs, 'One more of me' and 'Walls' for example.
Listening to Otherside and By the Way, John's chest highs are far more powerful and clear. I see the appeal of Josh's voice, and I've known of him way before he joined the peps. He sounds great on 'Omission'. But technically, he isn't a great singer at all.
If you want some really good recorded vocals by josh look up omission by john frusciante. Josh sings backup in that song and its really good.
Otherside with john and by the way with josh are my favourite
BTW, I fucking love Josh, but I have to admit that John give me chills everytime..
It’s so unfortunate for Josh to have to be compared with John. Josh is great and all. But John is debatably the greatest guitarist of the late 20th and early 21st century. Plus his backing backing vocals are A1. Hard to compete with a living legend.