"Let's get outta here" *proceeds to slowly turn around, initially going closer to the detonation instead of straightlining it forward AND UP to maximize distance*
Actually because of the momentum of the bag, because the boat it was on was moving, it would’ve moved forward so turning around and going backwards was the best idea.
@@skygge1006 actually still no because that initial momentun is lost very quickly in the water and more importantly they had also already moved several hundred meters ahead of the dropzone by the time he was finally lifted into the helicopter...
@@skygge1006 wut? Do you think before you type or were you trolling? That bag isn't a torpedo with propulsion. The second it hit the water it's forward momento went to basically zero while the boat kept moving forward a decent distance.
Love how the chopper turns and goes back over the area where the bomb was dropped in the water. Additionally, every Captain knows you don't present the side of the ship to the wave, nor did any ship have to be that close.
Call me crazy but every captain knows that you shouldn't be close to a nuclear explosion when you, your crew and your ship would do nothing there. I mean ,what they would do with the fleet? sccary the atoms?
@@warriorbug35 They, by procedure, should not have tried to turn. Naval officers, and even enlisted who pilot the ships and boats of the navy are taught to steer into the wave. Just about any sailor, even an old ex-submariner like me knows this.
I was thinking the same thing! tons of water hitting them broadside. I guess that's what happens when you pay $1203.00 for a bolt into the deck. but the salt water damage will make those F-35s just about useless for a long time.
Fair, also, the chopper was flying along with the boat. He dropped the bomb, boat keeps going. Chopper gets him inside and then turns 180 and goes back the way it just came. Where the bomb is.
Also just saying this is really unrealistic, they’d probably blow up the boat since the nuke wouldn’t explode, it needs a sequence of events to happen to actually explode.
@@naburg360 - Are you _sure_ about that sequence of events? Because I'm not so sure that the ordnance used wouldn't supercede that sequence of events.
Search up the "Devil's Sphere"... It's just a plutonium core, composed of 2 hollow graphite hemispheres, over a solid core of weapons grade plutonium... The hemispheres are kept apart so that the radioactive particles from the plutonium sphere can keep escaping from the gap between the hemispheres... There have been 2 instances where the braces keeping the 2 hemispheres were accidentally removed and the hemispheres clamped together completely... The core IMMEDIATELY went critical as the neutrons had nowhere to escape, and the chain reaction started... Fortunately they were separated both times within seconds, but still went almost super critical, and killed many people within the room... Similarly, blowing up a nuke before it explodes doesn't guarantee that it would destroy the "sequence" of events... More than likely it will just push the core to its supercritical stage in an instant... Remember the nuclear grade plutonium and uranium are both EXTREMELY sensitive to their conditions... And even just covering them with anything can start a chain reaction that may send them to supercritical stage within a couple of minutes...
@@samuelluria4744 The "sequence of events" is all of the the explosives that wrap the core of the bomb going off simultaneously. Timing is critical. Hitting it with machine gun fire, a shell, or anti-ship missile won't detonate it.
It's like someone explained an underwater nuclear explosion to the creative team over a phone call and then they wrote and shot this scene based on what they remembered and added their own spin.
Seeing how well those F-35s were secured to the deck reminded me of how well I glued the planes to the deck of my U.S.S. Enterprise model when I was a kid. 🤣
Imagine enlisting in the navy, hoping to go home to your family, being rendered a hero and then being nuked by some mop-headed edgelord for movie plot.
@@samhowe1605 Good point (That depends on jurisdictions tho). But the good news is government won't chase you up like loan sharks. Still taking my time with student loans with the government from 2 decades ago..
Its stiles stilinski after his work on the FBI and after almost of four year saving the life of the sourwolf aka derek hale and puppy scott mccall Sorry but it is Dylan Obrien and after teen wolf and yhe maze runner well its understanding
@@hotelmario510 . For all these years I thought hydrogen weapons carried by aircraft weighed millions of tons................................. How much do you think a 10kt warhead weighs? This script says 25 lbs...........
@@hamSAH713 no. water doesn’t compress so explosions underwater maintain their deadly pressure waves as they travel further. a grenade on the other side of an olympic sized swimming pool will kill anyone in the water in the pool, despite the shrapnel not going at all very far, simply due to pressure. those submarines first got sucked into the blast, and then hit with high pressure that likely cracked their hulls and did a number of other horrible things to them tl;dr, in reality, most of those ships are dead, subs are all gone, aircraft carrier is most likely thing to survive, but no planes on deck would, and many casualties would be sustained simply from being shoved around inside the ship like a ping pong ball. also that heli, yeah that thing should be dead. 30s from a nuclear blast? nah. huey should be going for a drink with no recovery possible.
obviously from a ridiculous distance then yes they would be fine, but if they were anywhere near the fleet that also mostly should be dead, no, they are gone
@@syst_m Most ships would be fine as they can withstand any form of water waves with modern technology. The aircraft carrier will definitely be the least damaged one. Can't say the same about all the f35s or frieghter ships. Destroyers will also be fine. Subs yeah they are fucked. But the humans inside any of the ships and helicopter will absolutely be decimated
The Navy actually did tests on this back in the 50s and 60s. Nuclear weapons were not found to be an effective anti-fleet tool either as an air dropped bomb or torpedo. Even dropping the bombs into the middle of a fleet did not do significant damage to more than the couple ships closest to the detention point, same was found for torpedoes.
I like it that the helicopter pilot stays around for no reason until the guy is winched in. You'd think he'd start getting the hell outta there as soon as he got hooked up.
*How* many magnitudes did this nuke scene packed again? just to be able to make a deep temporal hole in the ocean surface there?.... (or probably it didn't sunk too deeply enough. [sighed]).
Very true other than all that material that went vertical with the water column and got ejected out. That's where your fallout and radiation is going to come from. Those ships were just rained on with a lot of material.
In the 50s, they set off the first underwater blast. They anchored ships from ww2 around to monitor. Some had sheep or pigs on them. The blast sunk some of the ships considered to be safe with sailors on them. It knocked the bottoms out of all of the test ships that they thought were a safe distance away. The underwater shockwave was incredibly more than figured.
Я читал немного другие выводы о операции Перекрёсток. Типа подводный ядерный взрыв не так страшен кораблям, особенно если бы там были экипажи, занимавшиеся борьбой за живучесть (кого на испытуемых кораблях не было конечно же).
@@nickkozak4763🤣🤣 просто ваши авианосцы ещё реально никто не пытался потопить. Но, русский посейдон способен потопить не только авианосец, а всю группировку целиком😂. А в кино согласен американские корабли не тонут.😂
I was on a US Navy Destroyer Escort in the ‘70’s. We purposefully went into a storm in the North Sea. The waves were absolutely unimaginable! At times the ship felt like it was a sub. The bridge was underwater wave after wave! Looking out the front glass at the bow all you could see was water! As the water cleared away all you could see was clouds in the sky. The whole ship would shudder as it slammed into the next wave. As the ship crested each wave the prop would cavitate… meaning the prop was out of the water because the ship was balanced on the top of a huge wave about to “surf” down the rear face of that wave. The prop was spinning but not grabbing any water. It always made a gut wrenching vibration. As you tried to walk down the gangway the ship would roll to unbelievable angles. You could literally have one foot on the deck and the other on the bulkhead (wall). Then it would roll back the other way. The worst of the storm lasted 4-5 days. There was no cooking of food on board for those days. They rationed out dry grub and liquids to stay hydrated. The mess decks were empty. Trays wouldn’t stay on tables. There were a lot of sea sick sailors for those days. We had to tie ourselves into our racks(beds) so as not to get thrown out as the ship rolled. Every item, large or small had to be secured down otherwise they became a flying projectile. Very scary at the time. But as the seas calmed down… what an adventure!! Thanks to our US Navy. God bless them all. What a job.
I was a marine in the Swiss navy in the 2030s and we purposefully went into a storm in the Alps. The waves were absolutely unimaginable! After we crushed with a mountain we ate some cheese. Then i woke up.
If there's one thing this movie gets right it's how the Naval Warships handle large waves or even Tsunamis They were built to survive the worst weather conditions or sea conditions that might occur whilst deployed. Most ships would've gotten toppled and sank but due to the Design of Navy Warships they made it out with relative low damage
I have seen a Hollywood movie where an iceberg destroyed a ship, now here is one where a nuke can't destroy a ship. Hollywood blowing hot and cold on this subject. Now that the iceberg concept is incontrovertible, we need someone to offer up their ship for a hot trial run. Perhaps US politicians would line up for the star roles???
Manuel Camelo IM SORRY FELLOW REDITOR!! *uwu* HERES YOUR REDDIT GOLD FOR GIVVING REDDIT GOLD TO THE PERSON WHO GAVE REDDIT GOLD TO ME!!! *uwu* 🏅🏅🏅 gfycat.com/descriptiveobedientborzoi
People on boats in movies: “Sir, we’ve been hit! The impact damaged all of the spark machines and the corks on the water holes fell out! Now we can’t stand up straight!!”
I didn’t know a 30 megaton nuclear warhead could fit inside a duffel bag. Scientists must’ve done a lot of work to make a 30,000 pound device turn into a 30 pound device. Edit: I’m aware of the fact that those numbers have no correlation nor am I suggesting yield and weight are connected. I’m just referring to old bombs. The largest weapon detonated by the United States was castle bravo and the nuclear device weighed 23,500 pounds. Today you could get the same yield from a device that weighs around 2,000 pounds (again a rough estimate) or even smaller, we are talking about a 15 megaton device so it’s hard to say really. Most modern bombs don’t produce a yield that high at least on the American/NATO spectrum.
I am fairly certain it cannot . Also the wave produced by the blast is disappointing for disaster groupies.There is one but much of the energy goes into turning water into steam.
The fact that you think the “megaton” part of a nuclear bomb refers to its mass and the fact that you think 30 megatons would be 30,000 pounds if that was how it worked. A ton is 2,000 pounds, by your logic, the bomb would weight 60k lbs., but that’s not how it works anyway.
Well, realistically wouldn't it instantly flash billions of gallons of water to steam in the initial blast? And in doing so, create an enormous tsunami hundreds of feet high!!
In general, solids are denser than liquids, which are denser than gases. So yep you're correct, there wouldn't be a period of cavitation where there was a suddenly a big 'hole' in the water, so there wouldn't also be the following tsunami also. What there would be is a massive amount of displaced radioactive water, coating all those navy vessels and marines.
Maybe, maybe not. Tsutomu Yamaguchi survived both atomic bombs in Japan and was less than a mile from each when they exploded just before they hit the ground. He died in his 90's about 10 years ago in Nagasaki.
Not really... the radiation from nuclear fallout would only exist if the blast was in the lower or higher atmosphere, or the ground. No radiation hazard would exist if the blast was in the ocean, because all the energy from the blast would be compressed into water.
@@WokerThanThou Yeah, I don't think one example or a few that made it through in an ok shape from thousands who died from radiation and get deformed because of it, is too much of a proof that they may survive.
@@blaze_4280 the water would be hot, but it would be mostly converted into steam. Radiation is blocked heavily by water, so while some water would be radioactive, it would be mostly diluted in the vast ocean.
honestly the sequence of events is QUALITATIVELY very similar to that recorded in real underwater blasts, the only problem is Hollywood pushed the slider on each effect up to 11
Yeah, it matches what I've heard about the Navy practices in the event of a nuclear attack (this clip cuts off the sprinklers popping out to soak every ship and prevent radiologicals from settling), but the initial hole in the water and some of the blast effects are just ludicrous even to the completely uninformed. They almost did it right (and it would have looked even better because they did so), then did it wrong apparently just because.
I love how a 25 megaton nuke fits in a duffle bag. Those waves that "dufflebag" nuke produced were absolutely massive, for a bomb fitting in that volume.
Hmm interesting because from what I remember I saw displacement in the air. Didn’t we just see a massive nuclear water column shoot up in the air? Oh we did? Then there is still what you would wanna call a shockwave in play however it is not nearly as powerful and likely not enough take down the helicopter but enough to cause major turbulence
@@williamchastain9510 Ok. Water isnt compressible; air is. That means that oxygen is a great shock absorber, and the only oxygen displaced from the explosion came from the water ejected from the explosion, which means no shock wave formed above water. Minimum turbulence.
and what happened to the vacuum created by the blast and what happened to the air rushing back in to fill the vacuum - no amount of special effects will ever beat a well written story...........
Mik Moen actually when you detonate a nuclear bomb there is a plasma ball Hotter than the sun for a split second disintegrating everything in that area
@@fossilfountain Europe yeah? not China or North Korea or most countries in the the Middle East, or Russia or AMERICA no no, Europe is where all the problems are at?...wow
id worry more about the emp effect than anything. the ships would probably be fine due to how well their shielded but that chopper? probably not. at least it crashes.
Nah electro magnetic waves don't travel well in water . You only have to worry if the bast is at or above the surface. Now if that fleet had a submarine.... That sub would be dead.
2:30 - Escape the explosion by making a turn towards the bag with the bomb. 3:35 - Avoid the effects of the explosion by not reducing the impact area, standing with your side to the epicenter to avoid the shock wave and the resulting water waves.
Desending at 1.5- 2 meters per second and then sinking more than a kilometer, then detonating with such force to be seen from low orbit, it had to be massive. I've never see the movie, so I'd estimate it being in the Megaton range.
congrats you got your self a one way trip to prision and oh by they way here is a bill for over $100 billion dollars for the damages to the US Navy fleet
So I'm a simple soldier not a sailor so they can correct me if needed. But 1- the navy wouldn't have ships that closely packed together 2- the planes would either be flown off the carrier or stored in the hangers if this was likely to happen. 3- the navy has Weapon systems that would let them fire on the boat without being that close 4- the navy wouldn't send a whole carrier strike group after a speed boat even if it did have a nuke on it. One destroyer would be fine. 5- 30 mega ton warhead is a big and heavy Weapon. Make more sense if it was 3 kilo tons maybe. That is all
This is Hollywood. They don't sail that close together unless they're doing refueling or during an exercise or photo op. Other than that they're almost always out of visible sight of each other. I know this because I have served aboard 4 different aircraft carriers.
Yeet Yeet Much of the battle group pictures we see are photo ops. Normally they are quite spaced out. It’s Hollywood that usually them in tight formations, but that’s also so the ships all fit in the frame. But, if the group had just left port they might not have had the time to spread out yet.
the helicopter pilot was like bro, it's a miracle we survived! and the other said we have the 2 main stars here. We were safe. Not necessarily, said the other. The chopper might've crashed, killing us but giving them mere scratches.
@@ClosedEyeVisualisations Well, back in time. Today you do it in studios in India or somewhere else, good rendering pipelines are today much cheaper as back in the days and know how you can watch even on youtube...
Fun Fact: During the nuclear tests on Warships at Bikini Atol, a bomb that was tested underwater had similar effect to the warships. So despite this being a ridiculous scene, it's actually plausible.
Not really. There was no mega wave like what was depicted - nearby ships got rained on by radioactive foam, but nothing as intense as seen here. The main damage to boats irl is from the underwater shockwave causing sections of the hull to collapse and then causing the ship to capsize.
@@BigBrotherMars The Baker shot at Bikini Atoll: ruclips.net/video/gy6-ZKWCoH0/видео.html However, the nuke in the movie is more similar to something like this: ruclips.net/video/ydWLkyMRfaU/видео.html Note the crazy amount of spray, but no wave. Or mysterious water sinkhole.
yea so after watching this I think the unplausable part of this scene is the massive tsunami that rocks the fleet. That shot of the radio tower flying off and the aircraft carrier getting lifted up by the wave misses the mark
It's just a movie, so we'll overlook how tightly the ships are grouped together (that only occurs for "team picture") or that the aircraft carrier is not the the middle of its escorts, or why the carrier group is chasing the speed boat when it has, you know, aircraft.
2:34 wait, they're turning back instead of flying further away? They do it in plane because its more safe (bc bomb droped still have same direction as the plane) 5:43 yes, opening your safety gear after nuclear explosion...
@@Mrbimmer11 lol you lost your fucking mind , even though Michael Keaton and Dylan O'Brien are the actors who carried the movie everyone did a great job
How lucky for us to apparently have a bunch of Oscar-winning movie producers and nuclear physicists chiming in with informed critiques. This is a kick-ass movie start-to-finish unless you hate action thrillers and Barbie is more your jam.
boat right is going straight. he drops bomb overboard at back. ok so then when he is winched up to helicopter, the chopper turns and back back. That chopper had been parallel to the boat. So to fly back meant he was going to fly right over the nuke. ha ha
I bet when you were born your mum had been shocked and horrified after being told you were her child. See I’m sure she probably thought you were some turd or something as she’d looked down at you.
Кино
The physics of that blast made every scientist in the world cry uncontrollably for hours.
True_So true
I’m like 10 but even stil I was crying
@@neoblox6753 Yeah same dude I am like 3 and still i am crying
Apex legend same dude I’m am like 1 and still crying
Starfruit Tasty Yeah dude I haven’t even been born and still I was crying.
"Let's get outta here"
*proceeds to slowly turn around, initially going closer to the detonation instead of straightlining it forward AND UP to maximize distance*
That's what I thought. But hey, it's a movie! Get lost, physics.
Actually because of the momentum of the bag, because the boat it was on was moving, it would’ve moved forward so turning around and going backwards was the best idea.
@@skygge1006 actually still no because that initial momentun is lost very quickly in the water and more importantly they had also already moved several hundred meters ahead of the dropzone by the time he was finally lifted into the helicopter...
He meant "out" as in out of this world and away from this mortal coil.
@@skygge1006 wut? Do you think before you type or were you trolling? That bag isn't a torpedo with propulsion. The second it hit the water it's forward momento went to basically zero while the boat kept moving forward a decent distance.
If you missed the chance of watching this movie on the big screen you have a second chance of missing it and you're not missing anything
😂 этот комент я искал! Спасибо!))
🤣
lmao .. my thoughts exactly
So, you're saying that the movie is not worth watching?
😂
Love how the chopper turns and goes back over the area where the bomb was dropped in the water. Additionally, every Captain knows you don't present the side of the ship to the wave, nor did any ship have to be that close.
Call me crazy but every captain knows that you shouldn't be close to a nuclear explosion when you, your crew and your ship would do nothing there. I mean ,what they would do with the fleet? sccary the atoms?
They clearly didn't have the time to turn
@@warriorbug35 They, by procedure, should not have tried to turn. Naval officers, and even enlisted who pilot the ships and boats of the navy are taught to steer into the wave. Just about any sailor, even an old ex-submariner like me knows this.
They were somewhat side on to attack the boat. Apparently they all forgot to spend the 30 second sthey had turning as much as possible.
my thoughts exactly!
everybody on that chopper must be stupid.
Those are some well secured F-35s.
I was thinking the same thing! tons of water hitting them broadside. I guess that's what happens when you pay $1203.00 for a bolt into the deck. but the salt water damage will make those F-35s just about useless for a long time.
@@AffordBindEquipment I thought the same thing
Im crying and feeling the pain when i see f35s destroyed
CV emerges from wave, nothing on deck anymore.
Ought to be considering their cost
A nuke is about to detonate. Ok navy, let's just keep sailing parallel to it. No need to turn away.
WOOOW!!! Navy Ships quickly turning from Bomb radius in less than 30seconds must be a sight to see 😮😮😮. This is the smartest comment I've seen today 😊
and lets stay in tight formation so we can all be taken out in one shot.
Fair, also, the chopper was flying along with the boat. He dropped the bomb, boat keeps going.
Chopper gets him inside and then turns 180 and goes back the way it just came. Where the bomb is.
@@boydsinclair7606 😂
@@rrrmediodia8383 You do realize that he was most likely being sarcastic, right?
There is a significant part of me that is thankful I missed this movie.
whoever is in charge of making those glass panels should get a promotion, bro made something that withstood a nuclear shockwave.
Also just saying this is really unrealistic, they’d probably blow up the boat since the nuke wouldn’t explode, it needs a sequence of events to happen to actually explode.
@@naburg360 - Are you _sure_ about that sequence of events? Because I'm not so sure that the ordnance used wouldn't supercede that sequence of events.
Well they are made to withstand hurricane force winds as well as shrapnel. It’s a fucking military ship
Search up the "Devil's Sphere"... It's just a plutonium core, composed of 2 hollow graphite hemispheres, over a solid core of weapons grade plutonium... The hemispheres are kept apart so that the radioactive particles from the plutonium sphere can keep escaping from the gap between the hemispheres...
There have been 2 instances where the braces keeping the 2 hemispheres were accidentally removed and the hemispheres clamped together completely...
The core IMMEDIATELY went critical as the neutrons had nowhere to escape, and the chain reaction started... Fortunately they were separated both times within seconds, but still went almost super critical, and killed many people within the room...
Similarly, blowing up a nuke before it explodes doesn't guarantee that it would destroy the "sequence" of events... More than likely it will just push the core to its supercritical stage in an instant...
Remember the nuclear grade plutonium and uranium are both EXTREMELY sensitive to their conditions... And even just covering them with anything can start a chain reaction that may send them to supercritical stage within a couple of minutes...
@@samuelluria4744 The "sequence of events" is all of the the explosives that wrap the core of the bomb going off simultaneously. Timing is critical. Hitting it with machine gun fire, a shell, or anti-ship missile won't detonate it.
That awkward moment your aircraft carrier becomes a submarine
I-400:but I'm meant for that!
@@Shawa_Skibidi ye that thing was big
That awkward moment Beetlejuice becomes a Navy Seal.
Hate when that happens
hahahaha
And that's how you wake up Godzilla
Wrong movie sir
Underrated comment lol
@KOLA RUCHITH yeah ik
@@dotaultimate6607 Thats the joke- but ok
@@cxrpsie but in godzilla movie it is true
It's like someone explained an underwater nuclear explosion to the creative team over a phone call and then they wrote and shot this scene based on what they remembered and added their own spin.
Seeing how well those F-35s were secured to the deck reminded me of how well I glued the planes to the deck of my U.S.S. Enterprise model when I was a kid. 🤣
The Tamiya 1/350 kit? For what that damn thing cost, those planes had BETTER be secure! 😁
Imagine enlisting in the navy, hoping to go home to your family, being rendered a hero and then being nuked by some mop-headed edgelord for movie plot.
Lmfao
Pearl Harbor script
@@miranda9691 i agree
You didn’t see the movie he didn’t set off the nuke
Always called *those* people “dredgelords” - as in they run river dredges…
The government later sent him a bill for 2.8 trillion dollars for damages which he promptly paid.
Imagine you see a bill of trillion dollar in your mailbox
@@natgenesis5038 Wouldn't do much, just file for bankruptcy. A Billion or a trillion don't matter.
@@cloudygor8948 can't go bankrupt on government debts
@@samhowe1605 Good point (That depends on jurisdictions tho).
But the good news is government won't chase you up like loan sharks.
Still taking my time with student loans with the government from 2 decades ago..
ppppppppppppp
Just by the mere description of movies like this one, I am convinced that my intellect has saved me from many hours of needless suffering.
Now I know why I never heard of this movie. Thanks.
Dude casually tosses a several kilo-ton warhead off the boat like he's tossing a lobster trap.
Hes very strong.
Its stiles stilinski after his work on the FBI and after almost of four year saving the life of the sourwolf aka derek hale and puppy scott mccall
Sorry but it is Dylan Obrien and after teen wolf and yhe maze runner well its understanding
That looked more in the low Megaton yeld.
You do know that "kiloton" refers to explosive yield rather than actual weight, don't you?
@@hotelmario510 Who you replying to?
@@hotelmario510 . For all these years I thought hydrogen weapons carried by aircraft weighed millions of tons.................................
How much do you think a 10kt warhead weighs? This script says 25 lbs...........
Sixth Fleet: *"We're Okay!"*
Sixth Fleet Submarine escort: *"Are we a joke to you?"*
arent submarines resilient to nuclear blasts from a certain distance?
@@hamSAH713 no. water doesn’t compress so explosions underwater maintain their deadly pressure waves as they travel further. a grenade on the other side of an olympic sized swimming pool will kill anyone in the water in the pool, despite the shrapnel not going at all very far, simply due to pressure. those submarines first got sucked into the blast, and then hit with high pressure that likely cracked their hulls and did a number of other horrible things to them
tl;dr, in reality, most of those ships are dead, subs are all gone, aircraft carrier is most likely thing to survive, but no planes on deck would, and many casualties would be sustained simply from being shoved around inside the ship like a ping pong ball. also that heli, yeah that thing should be dead. 30s from a nuclear blast? nah. huey should be going for a drink with no recovery possible.
obviously from a ridiculous distance then yes they would be fine, but if they were anywhere near the fleet that also mostly should be dead, no, they are gone
@@syst_m Most ships would be fine as they can withstand any form of water waves with modern technology. The aircraft carrier will definitely be the least damaged one. Can't say the same about all the f35s or frieghter ships. Destroyers will also be fine. Subs yeah they are fucked. But the humans inside any of the ships and helicopter will absolutely be decimated
The Navy actually did tests on this back in the 50s and 60s. Nuclear weapons were not found to be an effective anti-fleet tool either as an air dropped bomb or torpedo. Even dropping the bombs into the middle of a fleet did not do significant damage to more than the couple ships closest to the detention point, same was found for torpedoes.
now that ladies and gentlemen is how you make a completely unrealistic movie ending.
I like it that the helicopter pilot stays around for no reason until the guy is winched in. You'd think he'd start getting the hell outta there as soon as he got hooked up.
lol ye. I was looking for this comment, should be the main thing people mention. he just stays around idle; like he's a uber driver.
No glass were harmed during filming this scene.
They should've used that same glass on their hulls.
@@menuly trying to make sense of that stupidity
The glass Navy ships use is remarkably strong
@@MrCurlyBill Very! indeed, they are extremely strong ^_^
The damn mast of the arleigh burke got ripped off but glass didn't bruh
it's made of transparent aluminum
5:48
"Low levels."
To be fair, water is one of the best radiation blockers known to man.
*How* many magnitudes did this nuke scene packed again? just to be able to make a deep temporal hole in the ocean surface there?....
(or probably it didn't sunk too deeply enough. [sighed]).
Very true other than all that material that went vertical with the water column and got ejected out. That's where your fallout and radiation is going to come from. Those ships were just rained on with a lot of material.
it seems that 'plot' doesn't care enough to show those effects afterwards.
also, huh. look that that. 2 players of the main [Flower Game] franchise and the Halo [Flower] franchise here.
(all needs now is a player who plays heavily back on the Marathon [Flower] franchise).
Blows masts off ships but the F-35 on deck sits there like it's a gentle wind
In the 50s, they set off the first underwater blast. They anchored ships from ww2 around to monitor. Some had sheep or pigs on them. The blast sunk some of the ships considered to be safe with sailors on them. It knocked the bottoms out of all of the test ships that they thought were a safe distance away. The underwater shockwave was incredibly more than figured.
Poor animals
Я читал немного другие выводы о операции Перекрёсток. Типа подводный ядерный взрыв не так страшен кораблям, особенно если бы там были экипажи, занимавшиеся борьбой за живучесть (кого на испытуемых кораблях не было конечно же).
Which is why our carriers are so damn incredibly hard to sink.
m.ruclips.net/video/DT1D3fh40Nk/видео.html&pp=ygULZHJhY2hpbmlmZWw%3D
Operation Crossroads.
@@nickkozak4763🤣🤣 просто ваши авианосцы ещё реально никто не пытался потопить. Но, русский посейдон способен потопить не только авианосец, а всю группировку целиком😂. А в кино согласен американские корабли не тонут.😂
I like how it blows the radio system off the ship but like a minute later the f35 on 3 chains is still holding up
No it blew of the whole mast of a arleigh burke destroyer and the glass on the ships didn't break and the f 35 chain links must have been expensive e
@@Symphinitystug_III ahh thats what it is
Good brakes 😆
those f35 didnt have drag... so the blast didnt bother with it :D
It's more expensive
2:27
to the pilot: "go, get outta here"
the pilot: *flies towards the nuclear bomb*
😂😂😂
Exactly!
@@RazvanMihaeanu I’m glad I’m not the only one that noticed 😂
"Uh guys the bomb isn't on the boat anymore..."
@@annehaight9963 He just forgot to tell THAT to the pilot! This could perfectly explain his "inappropriate" behavior.
I went to high school with Dylan O'Brian. We were in the same English class Freshman year. Great guy.
One of the best comedies I've seen in a while. 🤣
I was on a US Navy Destroyer Escort in the ‘70’s. We purposefully went into a storm in the North Sea. The waves were absolutely unimaginable! At times the ship felt like it was a sub. The bridge was underwater wave after wave! Looking out the front glass at the bow all you could see was water! As the water cleared away all you could see was clouds in the sky. The whole ship would shudder as it slammed into the next wave. As the ship crested each wave the prop would cavitate… meaning the prop was out of the water because the ship was balanced on the top of a huge wave about to “surf” down the rear face of that wave. The prop was spinning but not grabbing any water. It always made a gut wrenching vibration. As you tried to walk down the gangway the ship would roll to unbelievable angles. You could literally have one foot on the deck and the other on the bulkhead (wall). Then it would roll back the other way. The worst of the storm lasted 4-5 days. There was no cooking of food on board for those days. They rationed out dry grub and liquids to stay hydrated. The mess decks were empty. Trays wouldn’t stay on tables. There were a lot of sea sick sailors for those days. We had to tie ourselves into our racks(beds) so as not to get thrown out as the ship rolled. Every item, large or small had to be secured down otherwise they became a flying projectile. Very scary at the time. But as the seas calmed down… what an adventure!! Thanks to our US Navy. God bless them all. What a job.
OMG glad I didn't join up
Thanks for sharing that. Love stories like this from people who actually did stuff with their lives.
Damn.. and I thought jumping out a perfectly good airplane was scary!
The North Sea can be brutal, it is shallow and therefore there can be very large wave heights of 30 meters plus
@@vjreimedia 😂😂😂 man what a situation. You would die though. I am yet to hear about someone dying of sea sickness lol
"Who lives in a pineapple under the sea?!!"
SPONGEB....
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Not anymore
Bikini Bottom is said to be below Bikini Atoll, where the Castle Bravo bomb was detonated, so they're probably used to it by now.
Underrated comment...
Scientificaly accurate, anyone?
I was a marine in the Swiss navy in the 2030s and we purposefully went into a storm in the Alps. The waves were absolutely unimaginable! After we crushed with a mountain we ate some cheese. Then i woke up.
I love clips like this of movies I've never heard of...might have to pick this one up.
I'm just over here thinking about all the corrosion treatment that is going to needed to those F-35s after that saltwater bath.
No need. The carrier sank.
@@GabsARV uh.. No. It didn't.
Average Internet Musician r u dumb?
Average Internet Musician no u dumbass the carrier didnt sink
@@tsarbombawithinternetconne875 "no u dumbass the carrier didnt SUNK"
Its so amazing that the camera man survived this till the end
Yep
Cameraman always survives! :)
Movie name
@@thedarkworld1902 The Flinstones
@@v1nedakpa605 🤣😆🤣😆🤣😆🤣😆🤣😆
Cool video, thanks for posting! 👍
If there's one thing this movie gets right it's how the Naval Warships handle large waves or even Tsunamis
They were built to survive the worst weather conditions or sea conditions that might occur whilst deployed.
Most ships would've gotten toppled and sank but due to the Design of Navy Warships they made it out with relative low damage
I have seen a Hollywood movie where an iceberg destroyed a ship, now here is one where a nuke can't destroy a ship. Hollywood blowing hot and cold on this subject. Now that the iceberg concept is incontrovertible, we need someone to offer up their ship for a hot trial run. Perhaps US politicians would line up for the star roles???
Everybody: no the sailors!
Me: no the F 35s!
Goverment: MY ADVANCED JETS WHY JUST WHY
I cried for those as well
Its now a vtol submarine
imagine your the taxes that people pay for their entire life gets blown into the sea by a nuke
@@mmgaming-pu7zt confusing
That aircraft carrier would be fine, we had ww1-ww2 era battleships is that survived 2 nuclear bomb tests
except those ships where so contaminated by radiation that they had to be sunk
Then again, those nukes weren’t as powerful as today. Plus I think the radiation is in the water now, so the ships would be infected.
@@swimfeared today we can clean that much easier, nuclear is very safe
@@deancain1841 what are you talking about? How would they decontaminate the ships? They can't use water because it is radioactive.
@@swimfeared www.remm.nlm.gov/ext_contamination.htm
fas.org/nuke/guide/usa/doctrine/dod/5100-52m/chap10.pdf
What a great piece of pure comedy!..
I loved the engraving, so detailed
Everybody: Yo! I hope all those sailors are ok
me:That's another 2 billion dead sea animals
Wow your so unique and original! Here’s your Reddit gold 🏅
@Manuel Camelo Heres your medal for giving a medal to him because he gave a medal to him
@Manuel Camelo Bruh
Manuel Camelo
IM SORRY FELLOW REDITOR!! *uwu*
HERES YOUR REDDIT GOLD FOR GIVVING REDDIT GOLD TO THE PERSON WHO GAVE REDDIT GOLD TO ME!!! *uwu* 🏅🏅🏅 gfycat.com/descriptiveobedientborzoi
@@John_DustyThis fella really waited 4 days😳
People on boats in movies:
“Sir, we’ve been hit! The impact damaged all of the spark machines and the corks on the water holes fell out! Now we can’t stand up straight!!”
Also; 'Sir, we've been hit - the camera operator has gone all wobbly while we just stand about like normal'
Sir we’re about to be hit by a mega wave from a nuclear blast.
Don’t you dare put a lifejacket on son.
YES! This is the nuclear scene I've been looking for. I watched this movie ages ago, I have been scouring RUclips trying to find it. 😂
Glutton for punishment.
"Get out of here!" Turns in direction of bomb.
5:50 is the best part of this scene
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
You mean ending
@@uthpalakodithuwakku5092 🤦
Yes indeed
lmao
I didn’t know a 30 megaton nuclear warhead could fit inside a duffel bag. Scientists must’ve done a lot of work to make a 30,000 pound device turn into a 30 pound device.
Edit: I’m aware of the fact that those numbers have no correlation nor am I suggesting yield and weight are connected. I’m just referring to old bombs. The largest weapon detonated by the United States was castle bravo and the nuclear device weighed 23,500 pounds. Today you could get the same yield from a device that weighs around 2,000 pounds (again a rough estimate) or even smaller, we are talking about a 15 megaton device so it’s hard to say really. Most modern bombs don’t produce a yield that high at least on the American/NATO spectrum.
I am fairly certain it cannot .
Also the wave produced by the blast is disappointing for disaster groupies.There is one but much of the energy goes into turning water into steam.
If its anti matter with ying yang containtemeint. Maybe
The fact that you think the “megaton” part of a nuclear bomb refers to its mass and the fact that you think 30 megatons would be 30,000 pounds if that was how it worked. A ton is 2,000 pounds, by your logic, the bomb would weight 60k lbs., but that’s not how it works anyway.
@@JordanBlue1 I think he knows, that 30 Megatons refer to the yield equivaleance of 30 million tons of TNT.
Yeah Tsar bomb was 50 megatons and. weighed 27 tons.
Oh Hollywood. Your ignorance in this movie has to be one of the funniest films ive ever seen
All that water hitting those ships is radioactive btw.
Plus, the glass was apparently stronger than the ships' hulls lol
Who knew a massive nuclear explosion actually would make several billion gallons of water disappear, but just for a moment
Well, realistically wouldn't it instantly flash billions of gallons of water to steam in the initial blast? And in doing so, create an enormous tsunami hundreds of feet high!!
@deanlawson6880 it wouldn't make a massive tsunami. Go look at footage of underwater to get an idea of the effects
In general, solids are denser than liquids, which are denser than gases. So yep you're correct, there wouldn't be a period of cavitation where there was a suddenly a big 'hole' in the water, so there wouldn't also be the following tsunami also. What there would be is a massive amount of displaced radioactive water, coating all those navy vessels and marines.
“Go, get outa here”
Turns helicopter back towards where the nuke was dropped overboard.
The biggest and deadly dynamite fishing I had ever seen in a movie
And then they died by radiation.
The end
Maybe, maybe not. Tsutomu Yamaguchi survived both atomic bombs in Japan and was less than a mile from each when they exploded just before they hit the ground.
He died in his 90's about 10 years ago in Nagasaki.
Not really... the radiation from nuclear fallout would only exist if the blast was in the lower or higher atmosphere, or the ground.
No radiation hazard would exist if the blast was in the ocean, because all the energy from the blast would be compressed into water.
@@WokerThanThou Yeah, I don't think one example or a few that made it through in an ok shape from thousands who died from radiation and get deformed because of it, is too much of a proof that they may survive.
@@Monarch_Prime uhm that water pretty radioactive for a little bit and hots af
@@blaze_4280 the water would be hot, but it would be mostly converted into steam.
Radiation is blocked heavily by water, so while some water would be radioactive, it would be mostly diluted in the vast ocean.
honestly the sequence of events is QUALITATIVELY very similar to that recorded in real underwater blasts, the only problem is Hollywood pushed the slider on each effect up to 11
Yeah, it matches what I've heard about the Navy practices in the event of a nuclear attack (this clip cuts off the sprinklers popping out to soak every ship and prevent radiologicals from settling), but the initial hole in the water and some of the blast effects are just ludicrous even to the completely uninformed. They almost did it right (and it would have looked even better because they did so), then did it wrong apparently just because.
Ooooo, Qualitatively in all caps, guess that means you know what you’re talking about huh
@@Nikp117 Because the sequence is basically a very heavily dramatized CGI movie version of the Baker test from Operation Crossroads.
Man thats crazy it's almost like it's a movie or something.
In this universe, if that bomb managed to almost throw a Nimitz, god forbid we know what happened to the Bikini Atoll ships
I'm back after 3 years and I'm still crying!
These guys probably flunked physics in High School.
Rest in Peace Fishes
The fishes: NANI
@@Matz175
OMAIWA MOU SHINDEIRU_
The fishes who stuck around from the commotion 💀
2:34 the funny scene when they back to the nuke drop location 😂🤣
Yeah I was like what the fuck??
I had never heard of this movie before and I completely understand why.
how many times has this video been recommended to you
I love how a 25 megaton nuke fits in a duffle bag. Those waves that "dufflebag" nuke produced were absolutely massive, for a bomb fitting in that volume.
And that one guy was able to pick it up and throw it overboard... hahaha.
Well, it was a special kind of nuclear device... a plot device.
You don't know anything. That wasn't a Plutonium bomb. That was a PLOTonium bomb. Get it right, man :)
when you realize that the shockwave would have been absorbed by the water, and no helicopter would have been blown out of the sky...
So true tho tf
Hmm interesting because from what I remember I saw displacement in the air. Didn’t we just see a massive nuclear water column shoot up in the air? Oh we did? Then there is still what you would wanna call a shockwave in play however it is not nearly as powerful and likely not enough take down the helicopter but enough to cause major turbulence
@@williamchastain9510 Ok. Water isnt compressible; air is. That means that oxygen is a great shock absorber, and the only oxygen displaced from the explosion came from the water ejected from the explosion, which means no shock wave formed above water. Minimum turbulence.
have you ever seen the nuclear explosions tested by the us military in water... its way worse than this was
@@williamchastain9510 we're talking real life logic numbnut.
and what happened to the vacuum created by the blast and what happened to the air rushing back in to fill the vacuum - no amount of special effects will ever beat a well written story...........
I'm concerned about all the fish that were traumatized while filming this scene.
The power of the atom is frightening but beautiful...
It's basically creating a small Star for a split second. Our sun is a massive, constant nuclear explosion.
Mik Moen actually when you detonate a nuclear bomb there is a plasma ball Hotter than the sun for a split second disintegrating everything in that area
Nuclear bombs might be the thing keeping the problematic leaders of Europe from starting another world war for maybe another century
@@fossilfountain Europe yeah? not China or North Korea or most countries in the the Middle East, or Russia or AMERICA no no, Europe is where all the problems are at?...wow
This ain't a nuke lol
id worry more about the emp effect than anything. the ships would probably be fine due to how well their shielded but that chopper? probably not. at least it crashes.
Nah electro magnetic waves don't travel well in water . You only have to worry if the bast is at or above the surface.
Now if that fleet had a submarine.... That sub would be dead.
Underwater detonated nuclear weapons dont carry any EMP potential. That's only exclusively high altitude detonated weapons
Their military tech is emp proof.
And for a nuke to have an emp effect, it needs to be detonated in space.
No emp from underwater detonation.
@@swimfeared sub would be fucked lol. the pressure wave alone would move everyone back 5 feet near instantly aka your atoms go OOF.
2:30 - Escape the explosion by making a turn towards the bag with the bomb.
3:35 - Avoid the effects of the explosion by not reducing the impact area, standing with your side to the epicenter to avoid the shock wave and the resulting water waves.
Disregarding the fact that physics was thrown out the window, this was probably pretty cool to see in theaters.
Anyone who has been on any decent sized boat would have known to turn the boat towards the wave. Especially a naval officer.
"Let's sail so close to eachotger that our fragments will hit eachother" sailor " GOOD IDEA SIRR!!"
Hollywood:- I ask weebs for knowledge instead of the actual Navy
"Lets sail a trillion dollar fleet into serious harm when a coastguard cutter could do this job"
One of the best scenes ever
Desending at 1.5- 2 meters per second and then sinking more than a kilometer, then detonating with such force to be seen from low orbit, it had to be massive. I've never see the movie, so I'd estimate it being in the Megaton range.
When godzilla ate taco kaiju unleashing the wrath of its deadliest atomic farts.
if they know its gonna explode, then why did they still follows him?
Hollywood:- my logic has no common sense
Because they are idiots😉
@@mihir1700 fuck y'all don't even know the meaning of entertainment
Wow!! It's awesome, they always win in movies only...
4:21 *How it feels to chew five gum*
Few weeks later I still haven't got over this
congrats you got your self a one way trip to prision and oh by they way here is a bill for over $100 billion dollars for the damages to the US Navy fleet
So I'm a simple soldier not a sailor so they can correct me if needed. But
1- the navy wouldn't have ships that closely packed together
2- the planes would either be flown off the carrier or stored in the hangers if this was likely to happen.
3- the navy has Weapon systems that would let them fire on the boat without being that close
4- the navy wouldn't send a whole carrier strike group after a speed boat even if it did have a nuke on it. One destroyer would be fine.
5- 30 mega ton warhead is a big and heavy Weapon. Make more sense if it was 3 kilo tons maybe.
That is all
This really was: Damn my friends. Thanks.
A nuclear bomb of that magnitude stuffed in a duffle bag he effortlessly threw overboard??
Sounds normal to me.
He’s a time traveler from 2500!
USN should update how close they sail their ships together after this experience
If they sail to far apart then subs and faster boats and patrol boats can get in between and just knock their legs from down under
This is Hollywood. They don't sail that close together unless they're doing refueling or during an exercise or photo op. Other than that they're almost always out of visible sight of each other. I know this because I have served aboard 4 different aircraft carriers.
Yeet Yeet
Much of the battle group pictures we see are photo ops. Normally they are quite spaced out. It’s Hollywood that usually them in tight formations, but that’s also so the ships all fit in the frame.
But, if the group had just left port they might not have had the time to spread out yet.
@@macc68 thank you for your service sailor
@@axolotl9522 if they sail to close a kamikaze would just drop a bomb in the middle 😂🖕
the helicopter pilot was like
bro, it's a miracle we survived!
and the other said we have the 2 main stars here. We were safe.
Not necessarily, said the other. The chopper might've crashed, killing us but giving them mere scratches.
Never seen the movie but loved the actors I saw on this video
I love he just casually tosses a nuclear bomb in the ocean like it’s a crab cage
Everybody else: "You saved lives, good job."
Environmentalists: "You killed the fishes! Murderer!"
Me: *your rusted those f35s to hell! Noo!*
and millions of scientists :- You are a heresy to science itself.
Navy nukes and RCTs: we're going to be deconing the hull for the rest of the year....
Submariner: you killed us all, you f@ck
Pilots: MY F35!!!
Cartoons have gotten so realistic over the past decade.
И ни один самолетик не упал и не смыло. «Сдается мне, джентльмены, это была комедия!»
Ik this is a clip from he movie but they probably used millions of dollar of this cgi
Why
No shit, all cgi that good costs millions.
@@ClosedEyeVisualisations Well, back in time. Today you do it in studios in India or somewhere else, good rendering pipelines are today much cheaper as back in the days and know how you can watch even on youtube...
No
@@Gameferret16191 why
The World: And that was when all life underwater di-
America: And that was when the fishing industry died.
Ocean is vast fuckin dumb ass. Unfuckinbelieveable. 🤣
Should i r/wooooosh or no?
Aaron Sanceda yes
@@aaronsanceda4085 yes
R/wooooooooosh
Crumbs - that's either sank several Destroyers, certainly heavily damaged others and damaged the Aircraft Carrier. Quite a bang!
The fact they had him tie a bowline with the hoist cable was next level.
Actually, he saved Gotham from the bomb, not Batman. This is the hidden truth...
Well, his boss is retired Batman anyway…
Fun Fact: During the nuclear tests on Warships at Bikini Atol, a bomb that was tested underwater had similar effect to the warships. So despite this being a ridiculous scene, it's actually plausible.
Proof please
Not really. There was no mega wave like what was depicted - nearby ships got rained on by radioactive foam, but nothing as intense as seen here. The main damage to boats irl is from the underwater shockwave causing sections of the hull to collapse and then causing the ship to capsize.
@@BigBrotherMars The Baker shot at Bikini Atoll: ruclips.net/video/gy6-ZKWCoH0/видео.html
However, the nuke in the movie is more similar to something like this: ruclips.net/video/ydWLkyMRfaU/видео.html
Note the crazy amount of spray, but no wave. Or mysterious water sinkhole.
@@NukeMyHouse sweet, thanks bud
yea so after watching this I think the unplausable part of this scene is the massive tsunami that rocks the fleet. That shot of the radio tower flying off and the aircraft carrier getting lifted up by the wave misses the mark
It's just a movie, so we'll overlook how tightly the ships are grouped together (that only occurs for "team picture") or that the aircraft carrier is not the the middle of its escorts, or why the carrier group is chasing the speed boat when it has, you know, aircraft.
Air craft Carriers dont chase speed boats? lol
@@keithpalmer4547 It has people for that. 😅
2:34 wait, they're turning back instead of flying further away? They do it in plane because its more safe (bc bomb droped still have same direction as the plane)
5:43 yes, opening your safety gear after nuclear explosion...
I feel sorry for all the editors for doing such a good job rendering these good scenes with such bad actors.
Bad actors?
@@macklenk8888 They are worse than bad lool
Lmao
@@Mrbimmer11 lol you lost your fucking mind , even though Michael Keaton and Dylan O'Brien are the actors who carried the movie everyone did a great job
Good job super gluing those F 35 tires to the deck! 😁
How lucky for us to apparently have a bunch of Oscar-winning movie producers and nuclear physicists chiming in with informed critiques. This is a kick-ass movie start-to-finish unless you hate action thrillers and Barbie is more your jam.
boat right is going straight. he drops bomb overboard at back. ok so then when he is winched up to helicopter, the chopper turns and back back. That chopper had been parallel to the boat. So to fly back meant he was going to fly right over the nuke. ha ha
You have a point
I bet when you were born your mum had been shocked and horrified after being told you were her child. See I’m sure she probably thought you were some turd or something as she’d looked down at you.
This makes me question how did Batman survive in the dark knight rises?
By living
Autopilot they mention it
Because he’s BATMAN
He didn't it was in Alfred's head