Missed you, Josh. I don't normally watch poll videos along with unboxings and reaction videos (boring!) but I really enjoyed your presentation. You made it great fun, and for the most part I agreed with the results! Can't wait for Abominable Snowmen! Many thanks. XX
You made me crack the heck up when you said "The Macra do not exist!" A great callback to your missing episodes series, and the intro for this one is spot-on to the original. This was a great video. I'm only sad I didn't know about the poll, though I couldn't have voted in it, anyways. I haven't seen any of them. Thank you for the best laugh I've had in a hot minute!
Okay, if they ever make an episode showing a young version of the first Doctor (or whatever number he is if you count all the timeless children)...Josh Snares should get the job. You've already got the costume and a far better understanding of the character than most of the NuWho team.
Amazing work, as usual, and the "telesnap" reconstruction midway gave me a welcome laugh! Bring on the Myth Makers! And can we get the Daleks' Masterplan while we're at it?
My mate and I watched ‘Evil of the Daleks’ in its entirety the other night. It was a blast! Lots to spot in the backgrounds too. Although I was a Who fan before the original aired I have no memories of seeing it on TV strangely.
I rewatched Ice Warriors recently and was surprised at how much more I enjoyed the story, especially the animation. It looks quite basic, but I forgot it was animation after a while, which was a good sign.
The thing I love most about your videos is how into it you are and the quality of production. And then there's that first Doctor costume - you won me over in a double-heartbeat!
Yes, Macra Terror is absolutely my favourite animation, it's a perfect length (as you said) and the flow was just amazing, it kept to the original story while also adding tweaks to enhance the story quality. I always find myself going back to it if I need a Troughton fix (which is often, he's my favourite Doctor).
Just found this, Great video! And thanks for the kind words about Macra Terror. I work at Sun & Moon and we really tried to give that story every bit of love the director would let us.
I’m excited to see how good the Evil animation is. It’s not out in Canada until mid-November and I decided to wait. But just listening to it it was always one of my favourites despite the length (like you I usually prefer the shorter ones because there’s less filler). Great video and good to see you back!
Another great video, Josh! My two favorites are The Moonbase and Macra Terror, good stuff. Don’t feel bad about wanting Myth Makers, I have this nonsensical desire for Space Pirates to be animated, though it could just be because I love me some Bob Holmes.
Yes to "animate The Myth Makers"! I haven't watched The Evil of the Daleks yet, but I'm definitely excited now. Great video, as always. You do such a geat job balancing information and comedy; balancing poll results and your own feelings. You're so charismatic and I love this First Doctor costume for you!
I’m a huge fan of Cosgrove Hall animation. I feel that they should have been allowed to continue, would have been great Maybe a special edition with Zoe’s catsuit would be nice
Given the BBC are guaranteed money from their Mafia bully boy tactics, money for such a flagship show should’ve been an issue! But hey…gotta pay that prick Lineker!
I love the recent missing episode animations but it feels like it's getting more advertising than the upcoming series 13?? Can't wait to see what will be animated next though!
Out of the episodes that have not had the animation treatment, I would love to see Marco Polo, the Highlanders or the celestial toymaker, hopefully one day all of the missing episodes will have their animations
I absolutely agree on the Web of Fear stuff. 3D has huge potential if the work is put in: better animation, fewer cut elements (ie. stuff like the outfit changes in Macra), and a feel closer to the source material. Web's animation falls short through, I suspect, a severe lack of time and budget. Little effort has been put into properly mimicking the look of 2D animation, the likenesses look like a first draft, and several animations look like they had the bare minimum of clean-up work done on them before they were shoved out the door (wiggling arms, models sticking into one another, etc.)
It's always surprised me how highly the animated epidodes of 'The Invasion' are ranked amongst fans. I remember finding them below par, even with the DVD was first released. Nothing comes close to 'The Moonbase,' and 'The Macra Terror' for me, for lots of reasons but most importantly, they capture the likeness of Patrick Troughton perfectly, which none of the others do.
The Macra Terror is a good one. Really good animation and a good story. I love Shada... Im not bothered how many other people like it or if people hate it. LOL. Douglas Adams just has a way of writing. I find the same with Mark Gatis, you know when its one of his episodes of Who.
I'm watching this in 2024 so it's kind of funny to hear you excited for Galaxy 4 and "the heavily rumoured Abominable Snowmen animation" because both of those are out now. I really like the Abominable Snowmen. and I love the options to watch with the surviving episodes, or the black and white animation and then the coloured animation, love this.
Josh, you are a true Whovian. Dont worry, as long as we Whovians continue to buy animated episodes of the missing stories, they will continue to make them. My Top 5 stories that i am waiting for to be animated: 5) Marco Polo. 4) The Celestial Toymaker 3) The Wheel In Space 2) The Crusade 1) Mission to the Unknown/The Daleks Masterplan
Here’s how I’d rank them even though some of them I’ve not seen in ages: 1. Evil Of The Daleks 2. Macra Terror 3. The Moonbase 4. The Invasion 5. The Faceless Ones 6. The Tenth Planet 7. Shada 8. 2020 Power 9. Fury From The Deep 10. The Ice Warriors 11. Reign Of Terror 12. 2016 Power 13. Web Of Fear
Great video! I kind of agree with your Shad’s assessment. I feel it so obsessed over because it’s a “lost” Douglas adam’s. But that era is long gone. I think people will never find what they hope to in it! But let’s see how the six part plays. Anything has to be better than that kind of dull movie version!
You dressed as the First Doctor, I can totally see him going "What are you, a cop?" I get that 2D animation takes longer, but geez, you can put a little more effort into it. You're recreating lost episodes! That's amazing, take pride in it
Been watching Classic Who for the first time and just got to season 2. Ive only seen the missing episode Reign of Terror animation but really enjoyed it. Thought the facial expressions were great :).
I just realised, when Josh did his "There are no Macra" speech, you can see what appears to be two lights reflected in both his eyes. The eyes of Macra?
Great video Josh. Nice idea with the fun facts. I haven't seen much of the animations before. I'd just wait for the Collection Boxsets to be honest. Is there any chance of a "BIG DOCTOR WHO POLLLL" for the modern era? Please.
Thanks as always, Josh, informative, exciting, world class presentation, and as ever, bags of charisma for one of the best presenters on the planet. TV companies across the globe are missing a star. Keep doing what you do. 👍😎💥
I think that these episodes deserved the animation that The Adventures of Tintin had in the 90s,that style of animation would have fit with the Doctor perfectly
Heyyyyy, Josh! We haven't seen you for a while. How's life in these times of horror? :-) How has everyone already seen Evil of the Daleks? I had to pre-order it and it's not out on DVD until next month. I have faith that, eventually, the BBC will release animated versions of all the missing episodes, but how good they are will come down to the quality of the animation itself and which studio the BBC hires for the job. Still holding out for Marco Polo, though. I really want to see those costumes in colour!
Anyone who wants The Myth Makers animated is a friend of mine! I love that one and it's got some quite funny bits too. And The Underwater Menace! My fav animation is probably The Invasion and not for sentimental reasons. I really like the quality, and it's helped by long scenes where no actor is on screen. A truck on the road, a motorcycle at night, that sort of thing. Daleks are easy to do. No expressions, rudimentary movement, everything expressive is on the soundtrack. That's easier to animate than Troughton's mercurial facial expressions, which no on can quite do. They do a good job with Jamie in The Invasion, and Zoe is precious and very acceptably done. It also matters whether you're watching the animation to be an entire animated story, or whether you're watching it to fill the gaps of the missing episodes, to watch the existing ones and the animated versions for the missing ones. It works very well in that service. Another interesting question, since most of the animations exist in both colour and B&W versions, is which is better. I love the B&W era and go into it thinking that they ought to be watched in B&W. But in my experience several of the animated stories look so much better in colour! The Macra Terror is an example, and (since I'm writing months after this vid was posted I can add) Galaxy 4.
Oh wow! Glad you're back Josh and after just watching the new Web Of Fear animated episode...I also give it a Crime Against Humanity rating...its sooo bad I almost want my money back. For some reason the colour episode does seem a bit better but the animation style is still terrible and I just wish they had stayed consistant and kept it in line with the other animated episodes. I'm looking forward to the new Galaxy 4 animation and I just wish they would get the Wheel In Space out to us as I love the Cybermen!
I predicted evil would be on top, not neccesarily because it looked great, but because it just released less than a month ago. There's still some leftover hype for it
I've been going through the Patrick Troughton era of Doctor Who and when I get to the Web Of Fear I'll probably just watch the updated telesnap of episode 3 instead of the animation
@@JoshSnares Don't get me wrong, I got Marco Polo (colour and B&W) on a blank DVD disc in a case with custom artwork, but that won't stop me getting those desert splatter discs!
I’m so glad they did Evil of the Daleks justice. When I did the Troughton era during my marathon (I’m currently stuck in the 1970s), I found Evil to be a bit… meh. Good ideas, but it dragged. I did acknowledge that in general I found telesnap episodes to be less interesting, but I still didn’t enjoy it that much. Power of the Daleks, on the other hand… now that was a story I loved. The slow burn, the inexorable build-up to an inevitable bloodbath at the climax… I could look past the slightly shoddy animation because I’d found one of my favourite Who stories. I’d taken a break from my Doctor Who marathon, until recently. I’d taken a break from the show entirely for about a year - everything gets a tad stale eventually. I read somewhere that Evil of the Daleks had finally been animated, and was intrigued by the rave reviews it seemed to be getting. After haggling with the iTunes Store, I downloaded it and started watching. I watched it all in one sitting. It did not feel like nearly three hours. Not at all. Wonderful. All I needed was something to watch, something to see, a TV program instead of a slideshow. I’d still rank Power over Evil, but only just. Now Evil is comfortably one of my favourite stories of the Troughton era. I’m so glad they properly did it justice. It’s visually stunning.
I worked on the Power of the Daleks animation. I have to admit that even 6 years on, I've never watched it. The potential was there because everyone worked as hard as possible, but working 20 hours a day in the last month burnt everyone out and ultimately it got that quality control failure on it because of the desperate short cuts in the last weeks. The time where it should have been honed and fixed was instead the time in which things were rushed for the sake of the deadline. There were some bad choices in terms of some character designs early on that didn't bode well either. Ultimately it was much less than the some of its parts. Also I guess the dogged adherence to the camera script made it more complex than it needed to be. Animation is its own beast and should have been storyboarded with that in mind - it would have worked much better - and really who actually cares that it was released on its anniversary? - it could have been announced on it's anniversary and released six weeks later for Christmas and allowed the breathing room for a better product. So, yeah, I'm very (very) familiar with the story, the sets and the dialogue, but I have never sat and watched the animation because it's just not the the product I'd hoped I was working on. It has some good scenes for sure, Rob Ritchie's Dalek sequences are exemplary, but much of it is too frustrating to be bearable. Ten minutes into episode one I started skipping chapters, always to be confronted by another disappointing example of the 'it'll do' approach in the next scene. The assets were there for a considerably better effort but it just doesn't capture that atmosphere of the story - and it is one of the most important stories in Dr Who's history, it needed a realistic timeframe for completion. The team did a much better job with Macra - but changing the design of the creatures wasn't necessary in my opinion, and it's a story that looks better in B/W.
Thank you so much for the insight, Daryl! It is really upsetting when the higher ups get in the way of the creative process. I rewatched the special edition last night, funnily enough, and found it to be quite enjoyable still! It’s an impressive production on such short notice. I rarely, if ever, watch my own work, so I can relate!
Import. The Blu Rays/Steelbooks are region free. I am in the states and have been importing each one from UK as they release. I even paid for express global shipping on Evil and Amazon mailed it out before official release and I had it the day after release I was amazed at the service as others normally take quite longer.
@@thatDamnAusWhoFan In US we get totally shafted. Not only do we not get the steelbook we don't even get the regular blurays for animation release just the DVDs which normally takes 6 to 9 months after UK. This led me to try importing and been doing it since.
Do they announce when the broadcast the animations on BBC America or have I just not been paying attention?. You get the latest series announcements all the time but I don't remember them ever saying "Time To Watch The Animation, Kids!"
![How Doctor Who's Missing Episodes Came Back [Part 1]](/img/1.gif)
Missed you, Josh. I don't normally watch poll videos along with unboxings and reaction videos (boring!) but I really enjoyed your presentation. You made it great fun, and for the most part I agreed with the results! Can't wait for Abominable Snowmen! Many thanks. XX
Josh: Anything over 4 parts and it's not going to be my favourite.
*cough* Dalek Master Plan *cough*
Just goes to show I make it up as I go along! 😂
@@JoshSnares Btw, I loved that you had to do a reconstruction yourself to this, even if it was by accident, I think you handled it brilliantly
😂😂 thanks
You made me crack the heck up when you said "The Macra do not exist!"
A great callback to your missing episodes series, and the intro for this one is spot-on to the original.
This was a great video. I'm only sad I didn't know about the poll, though I couldn't have voted in it, anyways. I haven't seen any of them.
Thank you for the best laugh I've had in a hot minute!
Thanks for watching! I only kept the poll up for 24 hours, sorry! 😂
@@JoshSnares That's fine! Like I said, I wouldn't have been able to vote anyways!
Okay, if they ever make an episode showing a young version of the first Doctor (or whatever number he is if you count all the timeless children)...Josh Snares should get the job. You've already got the costume and a far better understanding of the character than most of the NuWho team.
i am always available to play the First Doctor. My acting abilities are limited, but the love is there! 😂😂
@@JoshSnares LOVE! PRIDE! HATE! FEAR!
Amazing work, as usual, and the "telesnap" reconstruction midway gave me a welcome laugh! Bring on the Myth Makers! And can we get the Daleks' Masterplan while we're at it?
My mate and I watched ‘Evil of the Daleks’ in its entirety the other night. It was a blast! Lots to spot in the backgrounds too. Although I was a Who fan before the original aired I have no memories of seeing it on TV strangely.
I rewatched Ice Warriors recently and was surprised at how much more I enjoyed the story, especially the animation. It looks quite basic, but I forgot it was animation after a while, which was a good sign.
The thing I love most about your videos is how into it you are and the quality of production. And then there's that first Doctor costume - you won me over in a double-heartbeat!
Loving the videos as always. Hopefully we get more frequent uploads because two months is a long wait for more quality Josh Snares content.
No promises! 😂
Should be making something on The Edge of Reality, and Maze Theories Doctor Who games when it comes out
@@JoshSnares I’ll keep my eye out for it.
Yes, Macra Terror is absolutely my favourite animation, it's a perfect length (as you said) and the flow was just amazing, it kept to the original story while also adding tweaks to enhance the story quality. I always find myself going back to it if I need a Troughton fix (which is often, he's my favourite Doctor).
So great to get more josh snares content
I agree
Just found this, Great video! And thanks for the kind words about Macra Terror. I work at Sun & Moon and we really tried to give that story every bit of love the director would let us.
Thank you for all your hard work! Even after all these years, it’s my favourite of all the Doctor who animations! 💕
I’m excited to see how good the Evil animation is. It’s not out in Canada until mid-November and I decided to wait. But just listening to it it was always one of my favourites despite the length (like you I usually prefer the shorter ones because there’s less filler). Great video and good to see you back!
Good thing about Evil is that it changes locations every few episodes so it doesn’t feel so long! 😂
Another great video, Josh! My two favorites are The Moonbase and Macra Terror, good stuff. Don’t feel bad about wanting Myth Makers, I have this nonsensical desire for Space Pirates to be animated, though it could just be because I love me some Bob Holmes.
14:37
Josh: anything over four parts is too long and won’t be my favourite
Also Josh: DALEKSMASTERPLAN!!!!!1!!1!1!!1
I love being inconsistent 😂
@@JoshSnares Yep. Look who's talking.
Yes to "animate The Myth Makers"!
I haven't watched The Evil of the Daleks yet, but I'm definitely excited now.
Great video, as always. You do such a geat job balancing information and comedy; balancing poll results and your own feelings. You're so charismatic and I love this First Doctor costume for you!
Oh thank you, Derek! I try really hard to find the right balance, so I really appreciate that 💕
The first objectively correct ranking in the history of forever! You have done what many academics believed to be impossible! The Nimon be praised!!
I’m a huge fan of Cosgrove Hall animation. I feel that they should have been allowed to continue, would have been great Maybe a special edition with Zoe’s catsuit would be nice
I read that they were too expensive.
They got the feel of the era perfectly & animated 2 episodes. There really shouldn’t be a price on quality
Given the BBC are guaranteed money from their Mafia bully boy tactics, money for such a flagship show should’ve been an issue! But hey…gotta pay that prick Lineker!
I literally justed finished rewatching your animation prediction video perfect timing 😍
I love the recent missing episode animations but it feels like it's getting more advertising than the upcoming series 13?? Can't wait to see what will be animated next though!
Gotta love his videos, especially the poll videos! You should do more of these more often!
Out of the episodes that have not had the animation treatment, I would love to see Marco Polo, the Highlanders or the celestial toymaker, hopefully one day all of the missing episodes will have their animations
👍👍 for your BBC America comments Josh! For my part, I buy the DVD’s hoping I’m supporting further animations …and of course because I *love* them!
I buy them too, and hope I have a small contribution to it!
And as costs per minute animation continue to fall (while quality rises) the business justification should become ever easier!
I absolutely agree on the Web of Fear stuff. 3D has huge potential if the work is put in: better animation, fewer cut elements (ie. stuff like the outfit changes in Macra), and a feel closer to the source material. Web's animation falls short through, I suspect, a severe lack of time and budget. Little effort has been put into properly mimicking the look of 2D animation, the likenesses look like a first draft, and several animations look like they had the bare minimum of clean-up work done on them before they were shoved out the door (wiggling arms, models sticking into one another, etc.)
It's always surprised me how highly the animated epidodes of 'The Invasion' are ranked amongst fans. I remember finding them below par, even with the DVD was first released.
Nothing comes close to 'The Moonbase,' and 'The Macra Terror' for me, for lots of reasons but most importantly, they capture the likeness of Patrick Troughton perfectly, which none of the others do.
The Macra Terror is a good one. Really good animation and a good story.
I love Shada... Im not bothered how many other people like it or if people hate it. LOL.
Douglas Adams just has a way of writing. I find the same with Mark Gatis, you know when its one of his episodes of Who.
I'm watching this in 2024 so it's kind of funny to hear you excited for Galaxy 4 and "the heavily rumoured Abominable Snowmen animation" because both of those are out now. I really like the Abominable Snowmen. and I love the options to watch with the surviving episodes, or the black and white animation and then the coloured animation, love this.
Josh, you are a true Whovian. Dont worry, as long as we Whovians continue to buy animated episodes of the missing stories, they will continue to make them.
My Top 5 stories that i am waiting for to be animated:
5) Marco Polo.
4) The Celestial Toymaker
3) The Wheel In Space
2) The Crusade
1) Mission to the Unknown/The Daleks Masterplan
One thing about The Tenth Planet, is how they rotoscoped the surviving footage - particularly "It's far from being all over"
Happy to do my part as a BBC America viewer!
Nice Video! Thanks for info about BBC America
The Big Doctor Who Poll! Great to see it back, even if only for a one-off episode!
Here’s how I’d rank them even though some of them I’ve not seen in ages:
1. Evil Of The Daleks
2. Macra Terror
3. The Moonbase
4. The Invasion
5. The Faceless Ones
6. The Tenth Planet
7. Shada
8. 2020 Power
9. Fury From The Deep
10. The Ice Warriors
11. Reign Of Terror
12. 2016 Power
13. Web Of Fear
This channel is considerable consolation for the missing episodes.
Another Great video from Josh ! I loved planet 55 animations . Wish they did more !! 😢
Great review. Very fair comments on the animations.
Gotta say again your videos are amazing. So well produced and edited and your presentation is so fun. Keep it up!
Damn, I love your 1st Doctor cosplay so much!
Great video! I kind of agree with your Shad’s assessment. I feel it so obsessed over because it’s a “lost” Douglas adam’s. But that era is long gone. I think people will never find what they hope to in it! But let’s see how the six part plays. Anything has to be better than that kind of dull movie version!
Awesome Josh. They should consider you for the next Doctor x
I’m a really awful actor, so that would be a terrible decision! 😂
@@JoshSnares Didn't stop CB getting the part. 😂
Thank you!
American fan waiting for Evil Of The Daleks here..
You dressed as the First Doctor, I can totally see him going "What are you, a cop?"
I get that 2D animation takes longer, but geez, you can put a little more effort into it. You're recreating lost episodes! That's amazing, take pride in it
Good to see another video from you. Always enjoyable.
glad you did this one! love this topic.
your hair is just amazing here , almost as good as the video itself
Been watching Classic Who for the first time and just got to season 2. Ive only seen the missing episode Reign of Terror animation but really enjoyed it. Thought the facial expressions were great :).
I just realised, when Josh did his "There are no Macra" speech, you can see what appears to be two lights reflected in both his eyes. The eyes of Macra?
I really agree with you on Evil of The Daleks its so beautiful I love it The Animation on the emperor Dalek is outstanding
Great video Josh. Nice idea with the fun facts. I haven't seen much of the animations before. I'd just wait for the Collection Boxsets to be honest.
Is there any chance of a "BIG DOCTOR WHO POLLLL" for the modern era? Please.
This was very entertaining and well done
I LOVE these animations. As an american, I will make the sacrifice to watch all animations as they come out. :D Missed you Josh.
Love the Macra impersonation! can you also do the crawling all over you bit? hahah! nice video!
😂
Good fun as always! I agree with most of your rankings.
Great video as usual Josh. Love the humour.
I forgot to record this part so here a telesnap reconstruction that was kinda funny.
1:35 i think the colonel looks more like those early grand theft auto character arts you would see on boxart and loading screens.
Thanks as always, Josh, informative, exciting, world class presentation, and as ever, bags of charisma for one of the best presenters on the planet. TV companies across the globe are missing a star. Keep doing what you do. 👍😎💥
JOSH YOUR HAIR IS SOOOOOOOOOOO FABULOUS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Ahhhhhh _Josh Snares_ ...... I needed this. :)
"what are you, a cop?" MASSIVE LOL 😛. awesome video as always
💕💕
HOW ON EARTH DID I MISS THIS
The special edition of Power of the Daleks still hasn’t been released in the US
Finally you are back!!
I was having such a bad morning but he's back, he's back, he's f***ing back!!!! I never knew how much I'd get excited over a return.
💕💕💕
I think that these episodes deserved the animation that The Adventures of Tintin had in the 90s,that style of animation would have fit with the Doctor perfectly
I will continue my effort to be the only one demanding for the Highlanders animated
It is sad to think Jamie's first story is missing. Yet The Web Planet exists in it's entirety.
From what I heard they were going to do Highlanders instead of Macra but animating tartan was too difficult
Your not the only one
THA MACRA DO NOT EXIST!!!
Great vid.
Heyyyyy, Josh! We haven't seen you for a while. How's life in these times of horror? :-) How has everyone already seen Evil of the Daleks? I had to pre-order it and it's not out on DVD until next month. I have faith that, eventually, the BBC will release animated versions of all the missing episodes, but how good they are will come down to the quality of the animation itself and which studio the BBC hires for the job. Still holding out for Marco Polo, though. I really want to see those costumes in colour!
Would LOVE to see Marco Polo!
It’s been out in the Uk for a few weeks now, north america gets it next month
Marco Polo would be on my list of finding the original episodes.
@@BobaTennant that explains it. Australia is always the last to get anything, sadly. 😔
@@ksaunders4362 actually nah, australia gets collection sets before north america
Anyone who wants The Myth Makers animated is a friend of mine! I love that one and it's got some quite funny bits too. And The Underwater Menace!
My fav animation is probably The Invasion and not for sentimental reasons. I really like the quality, and it's helped by long scenes where no actor is on screen. A truck on the road, a motorcycle at night, that sort of thing. Daleks are easy to do. No expressions, rudimentary movement, everything expressive is on the soundtrack. That's easier to animate than Troughton's mercurial facial expressions, which no on can quite do. They do a good job with Jamie in The Invasion, and Zoe is precious and very acceptably done. It also matters whether you're watching the animation to be an entire animated story, or whether you're watching it to fill the gaps of the missing episodes, to watch the existing ones and the animated versions for the missing ones. It works very well in that service.
Another interesting question, since most of the animations exist in both colour and B&W versions, is which is better. I love the B&W era and go into it thinking that they ought to be watched in B&W. But in my experience several of the animated stories look so much better in colour! The Macra Terror is an example, and (since I'm writing months after this vid was posted I can add) Galaxy 4.
The Web of Fear dont even give the characters eyes!!!
The world needs a Tobias Vaughn and PACKER!!!! animated series.
Looking forward to getting the Evil of the Daleks DVD
9:00 oh no i’ve been exposed as a GallifreyBase user
Great video as always
😂😂
Oh wow! Glad you're back Josh and after just watching the new Web Of Fear animated episode...I also give it a Crime Against Humanity rating...its sooo bad I almost want my money back. For some reason the colour episode does seem a bit better but the animation style is still terrible and I just wish they had stayed consistant and kept it in line with the other animated episodes. I'm looking forward to the new Galaxy 4 animation and I just wish they would get the Wheel In Space out to us as I love the Cybermen!
14:37 I thought that the Dalek’s Master Plan was your favourite story? 😜
I am constantly changing my mind, I am inconsistent, I am flawed!! 😂
I predicted evil would be on top, not neccesarily because it looked great, but because it just released less than a month ago. There's still some leftover hype for it
The Daleks Master Plan would be impressive!
I've been going through the Patrick Troughton era of Doctor Who and when I get to the Web Of Fear I'll probably just watch the updated telesnap of episode 3 instead of the animation
Did you get The Myth Makers on vinyl? It was actually the best £26 I ever spent just as the actual day it dropped came at midnight
Nah I didn’t get it, I prefer recons over audio!
@@JoshSnares Don't get me wrong, I got Marco Polo (colour and B&W) on a blank DVD disc in a case with custom artwork, but that won't stop me getting those desert splatter discs!
I’m so glad they did Evil of the Daleks justice. When I did the Troughton era during my marathon (I’m currently stuck in the 1970s), I found Evil to be a bit… meh. Good ideas, but it dragged. I did acknowledge that in general I found telesnap episodes to be less interesting, but I still didn’t enjoy it that much. Power of the Daleks, on the other hand… now that was a story I loved. The slow burn, the inexorable build-up to an inevitable bloodbath at the climax… I could look past the slightly shoddy animation because I’d found one of my favourite Who stories.
I’d taken a break from my Doctor Who marathon, until recently. I’d taken a break from the show entirely for about a year - everything gets a tad stale eventually. I read somewhere that Evil of the Daleks had finally been animated, and was intrigued by the rave reviews it seemed to be getting. After haggling with the iTunes Store, I downloaded it and started watching. I watched it all in one sitting. It did not feel like nearly three hours. Not at all. Wonderful. All I needed was something to watch, something to see, a TV program instead of a slideshow. I’d still rank Power over Evil, but only just. Now Evil is comfortably one of my favourite stories of the Troughton era. I’m so glad they properly did it justice. It’s visually stunning.
I worked on the Power of the Daleks animation. I have to admit that even 6 years on, I've never watched it. The potential was there because everyone worked as hard as possible, but working 20 hours a day in the last month burnt everyone out and ultimately it got that quality control failure on it because of the desperate short cuts in the last weeks. The time where it should have been honed and fixed was instead the time in which things were rushed for the sake of the deadline. There were some bad choices in terms of some character designs early on that didn't bode well either. Ultimately it was much less than the some of its parts. Also I guess the dogged adherence to the camera script made it more complex than it needed to be. Animation is its own beast and should have been storyboarded with that in mind - it would have worked much better - and really who actually cares that it was released on its anniversary? - it could have been announced on it's anniversary and released six weeks later for Christmas and allowed the breathing room for a better product.
So, yeah, I'm very (very) familiar with the story, the sets and the dialogue, but I have never sat and watched the animation because it's just not the the product I'd hoped I was working on. It has some good scenes for sure, Rob Ritchie's Dalek sequences are exemplary, but much of it is too frustrating to be bearable. Ten minutes into episode one I started skipping chapters, always to be confronted by another disappointing example of the 'it'll do' approach in the next scene.
The assets were there for a considerably better effort but it just doesn't capture that atmosphere of the story - and it is one of the most important stories in Dr Who's history, it needed a realistic timeframe for completion. The team did a much better job with Macra - but changing the design of the creatures wasn't necessary in my opinion, and it's a story that looks better in B/W.
Thank you so much for the insight, Daryl! It is really upsetting when the higher ups get in the way of the creative process.
I rewatched the special edition last night, funnily enough, and found it to be quite enjoyable still! It’s an impressive production on such short notice.
I rarely, if ever, watch my own work, so I can relate!
john you are a dear and i want to hug you
I was disappointed with the final release of Fury from the Deep and hope it gets a Special Release Revamp like Power of the Daleks.
They should televise these on the ABC!
Imagine thinking Macra exist lmao
Macra don't exist
I want the daleks master plan to be reanimated
has the evil of the daleks come out where you live? i live in victoria and it isnt avalable yet :/
Not out here yet! I think it comes out Nov/Dec here?? don't remember.
Yeah- I'm just waiting for the collection box set for all these
Love this! Do u think you would make more comparing animations with the telesnaps
The BBC have requested I don't make anymore of those for copyright reasons.
@@JoshSnares didnt know that! But fair enough.
Would love to see the Myth Makers animated honestly
I’m terrified at the idea there may be more Shapeshifter releases.
I highly doubt we will get more from them…
How did you see evil of the daleks? Its not out in Australia yet and I can't find a torrent for it anywhere
Import. The Blu Rays/Steelbooks are region free. I am in the states and have been importing each one from UK as they release. I even paid for express global shipping on Evil and Amazon mailed it out before official release and I had it the day after release I was amazed at the service as others normally take quite longer.
@@Euphoria35 i really should have thought of that. I assumed they would be regioned. Thanks. Maybe I can get the steel book before it comes out here
@@thatDamnAusWhoFan In US we get totally shafted. Not only do we not get the steelbook we don't even get the regular blurays for animation release just the DVDs which normally takes 6 to 9 months after UK. This led me to try importing and been doing it since.
look at 8:18 where josh jsut pretends if his shada ranking was from the bbc and lost but he reconstructed it XD :D
Nice job
I wonder where Galaxy Four and The Abominable Snowmen would fit on this ranking, if it were to be updated
The Return of the King.
I missed you, Josh!
Do they announce when the broadcast the animations on BBC America or have I just not been paying attention?. You get the latest series announcements all the time but I don't remember them ever saying "Time To Watch The Animation, Kids!"
No idea, I live in Australia! 😂
What’s the website that Charles Norton talks about power of the daleks production?
Gallifrey Base, it’s a forum! :)
good stuff josh do you rate scream of the sharker
I have never gotten past episode 2! 😂
I love this
Good to see you back Josh! Spot on with your list WOF ep 3 was terrible! Keep up the good work mate!