If they do they´ll probably price it very Cartierisch like around 5500$ for reasons not even them self understand. And that´s why JLC are the best but Cartier the coolest..
@@YoureTerrific Do you think the Tank Must or any watch for that matter appears smaller when worn with the matching bracelet? The contrast between a stainless case and a black leather strap is pretty dramatic compared to both in stainless (or gold or any color). In other words do you think the XL watch would look more proportional on your wrist if it was all stainless?
I find myself coming back to this video many times. I have a 7 1/2 inch wrist and too can not pick between them. Totally agree with sophisticated, elegant, conservative size of watches.
Just bought my XL today! The large was just a little too small and I felt 2,750 was too much for a quartz. Settled on the XL because the 3,700 wasn’t unreasonable for the in-house movement. Thanks for your content.
@@Cortesevasive €1000 more for a movement that cost €20 more in production cost. People are so brainwashed by the word mechanical. Also - it's basically just a rebranded ETA 2892 caliber.
@@nomansland120 No,it's not a rebranded ETA.It's a fully 1847MC Cartier in house caliber .It's not the older Tank.Especially that Cartier is owned by Richemont group and not Swatch group who owns ETA.
@@nomansland120 not sure where you get €20 from, the cost of designing and assembling an in-house mechanical movement, most of which is by hand is not insignificant. I'm a quartz guy myself, mechanical watches being too expensive to maintain and too inaccurate for my professional needs, but let's not kid ourselves here!
I went in wanting the Large for my 7 inch wrist, but ended up walking out with the XL. It was that guiocche that got me. Also can’t go wrong with a solid mechanical movement. I think it’s a wonderful size for a 7 inch wrist and above, but you can’t go wrong either way.
@@YoureTerrific Seriously though, great videos! Never thought I might want a Cartier, but thinking on this. It would be out of my comfort zone but that may be a good thing.
extra large my friend, no question the large is elegant but immediately makes me think "it's a bit too small" and that reaction will never fade, whereas the XL doesn't make me think "it's a bit too big".. it's just right
I think Tank by Cartier always works better smaller size but the dial in the extra large is truly beautiful plus an in-house automatic movement is a lot of value from the price … I will but this piece for my birthday in October :)
Large looks way better on you. You know, tanks were initially designed to wear small for both men and women, watches to be worn under the radar. This gordy XL is just too flashy and too big. Also, in my honest opinion, it shouldn't matter what movement is inside a cartier tank. It's about the brand name, the design, the story and the history. Who the hell cares the large has a quartz?? with buying a Cartier in general, the movement shouldn't be something to focus on like so many people do. And remember Muhammed Ali wearing a small sized tank on his large wrist, and it works! before people are gonna attack me, it's just my opinion!
If the movement doesn't matter the size doesn't matter. Some matter more to other people. Personally I rather admire the watch than be concerned of how other people think is to big.
It’s funny, I have a 7” wrist and I own the large Santos(it was actually a very tough decision between the large and medium) but I find the Tank XL absolutely huge. It wears real bog and like you, I feel a Tank should be understated. My Santos is more of a sports watch that can be worn with a suit but the Tank really is a dress watch, IMO…especially on the strap.
While I think the more classical way of wearing a tank is to go smaller or diminutive as you pout it, I think the XL fits just as well if we're following the trend these days. And I have to say, the XL has a more attractive dial.
Finally someone reviews the new tank collection on RUclips. I have bought the XL as I want the tank watch for so long time. But spending thousands of dollars on a Quarz watch makes no sense for me and you can definitely find a more elegant Quarz watch with lower price. The XL version is combining all significant elements from Cartier watch, that is the reason it is a great watch and I buy it immediately without a second thought. I am sure the price of the watch will increase soon for this watch.
I own the large one, here the main point is the size of your hand not the wrist. Is how proportional looks the watch vs. your hand. Awesome video :D Cartier watches always right choice!
The greatest SIN Cartier has done with this watch is replacing the much more elegant ALLIGATOR strap with this cheap cow hide one, and the multiple colours they come in only make them look even cheaper! The first time I came across this watch was an Asian man in glasses, wearing a beautiful suit, crisp white shirt and shiny high end shoes. His tank had the original shiny ALLIGATOR strap. He really made an impression on me, and that's what I think how this watch should be dressed with. Cartier throws in a cheap cow hide strap while quietly increasing the price of this watch is unforgivable - and don't even think we haven't noticed, whoever came with with this wicked idea in Product Planning!
They do that to comply with certain countries/states that bans the use of such leather. Also, being environmentally friendly is in vogue now and companies see that as a plus point, or if nothing else, an excuse.
Definitely the Large for a 7in wrist. I have a 7.25 wrist and would go with the large as well. It's too bad it doesn't come in a mechanical movement. Maybe they are saving Tanks in that size with a mechanical movement solely for their Louis Cartier line of tanks? I love Cartier, but sometimes all the sizes, date/no date models (this one looks way better without the date window!), and movements confuse me a bit. There are lots of options.
I put the XL bracelet version on my 6-3/4" wrist and instantly decided to buy it. I have plenty of diminutive sized vintage watches. I don't need that aspect from my modern pieces. The XL on bracelet has a great modern wrist presence but references it's history with the guilloché dial, Roman numerals and the blue tipped crown.
Agreed man. I wanted to love the auto but the size was off so I went with the L Quartz. Got over my no quartz ego and it has transformed my collecting habits.
Excellent video. You really showcase the beauty of the dial in the XL, which is hard to see in most photos and other videos of this watch I've seen. Coincidentally, we have the same wrist size, so that I could see that the XL, while not traditionally diminutive, looks really great especially with that dial! Watch sizes have evolved for both men and women, and I prefer a larger size which I think is actually more masculine in appearance.
I saw these for the first time in a dealer literally yesterday and I couldn’t believe the price, particularly when there’s a 2 grand / 60% jump to move to the Santos Medium (my fave) with the same movement!! Gave me a real head wreck 😵💫
Love your reviews and love my Tank Must XL. I admit I bought mine before seeing your review but I agree with all your points. I can't wear leather and the XL was available with a nice steel bracelet (well worth the upgrade IMO). The watch looks great on my 7.5" wrist and is super comfortable and I am able to keep it on all day when I work whereas I must take my Tag off when I work as its simply too bulky. As an Architect I appreciate the timeless design and the value represented vs its nearest competitor the Reverso could not be ignored. I did consider the Reverso but I dont play Polo, prefer a center seconds and consider Art Deco a great style whose time is in the past. Anyway thanks for your work.
XL, no doubt. I can’t speak to classy, and I will take your word for what a traditional Tank size used to look like. But as to what suits your wrist better? XL.
One of the best review of the tank, thanks a lot ! I purchased the xl version because I prefer the automatic movement and my wrist is large enough, 19 cm. I can say your video has influenced me to pay more attention to this watch 😊 Just one question... what is your wrist size please ? 😂
I myself bought a large tank solo with my wrist size at 7 1/2 I figure the proportions seem right, smaller looked a bit more classy on this square watch. I figured the Quartz is cheaper to service and battery changes are not so bad with the four screws to remove from the case back.
This video has done more to convince me that this is my next watch than anything else on the internet. Just fantastic. I've got an 8 inch wrist, so the XL on bracelet is my choice.
Great video, I have a 7.25 wrist and went with the large. It is a bit of an adjustment looking down and seeing the size in comparison to my other sports models, I were day to day but once you do it’s very elegant.
I think wrist circumference size is not as important as top wrist width. You can have a 7 inch but very round, or 6.5 inch but very flat and wear the watches similarly
I'm not sure about the size either, but if didn't have the guilloche dial, I'd feel like I was missing out on something. Kind of like I got the cheaper model. :(
I prefer a small tank...like the size that's now considered a "woman's size". But Im a minority...the plate sized watches are in now. PS. What's your wrist size?
This man REALLY just 3d printed a watch case just to see the size, legend. And thanks for helping me choose between the XL and L, I have 7 inch wrist if not abit more and i chose XL
What’s your wrist circumference? Totally agree with Tanks perhaps looking smaller rather than larger. The XL looks fine on your wrist though. Tried it on my 6.5 inch wrist and was shocked at how large it was - but I do prefer the mechanical movement.
okay are you me? subbed you because you love cartier especially the tank, just like me, and the intro music, retrowave/synthwave kind of music. Love the combo. Great video!
For me a Cartier Tank should be: 1) mechanical (that rules out the smaller size, 2) small (that rules out the bigger size), 3) in a precious metal. For those reasons I wouldn't get the Tank Must (or the Solo before it). I'd wait until I could afford a Tank Louis in gold
@@lewisjones3345 I think the watch design should be small even if the person has large wrists. Look at photos of Muhamad Ali and the size of the tank on his wrist.
@@stephen9609 no I got you. But that was 55-60 years ago. To say that was what was done then as the only way to do it would be incorrect. We don’t dress like 1967. Why would our watch tastes have to stay stagnant (as a society, however you decide to dress or wear your jewelry is up to you)? So I’m following you that is how you see the Tank and you’re not alone. I’m just saying that if it has grown in size with modern incarnations, that’s just the progression of things.
Thank you so much for making this video! Exactly what I needed! While the large is more "historically" accurate in terms of how the tank should be as a dress watch, I simply can't ignore the guilloche dial and the non quartz movement. Wish they made the XL without the date though. I also didn't know the must line was available at US boutiques?
Great video, as always. I think we’re all falling back in love with Cartier via the Santos or Tank Must. Personally, I love the XL and look forward to getting one soon. We’re all torn by the concept of the Tank being, diminutive, by tradition. But, I think that’s more history than tradition. Go the XL, is the perfect size for the unwritten history.
Nobody, and I mean NOBODY does a better review.I love how you show a watch and not try to sell a watch !! That said you've sold me many including this amazing Tank .......Clever. Great Content please keep em coming
How wide is your wrist? I find that info to be more helpful for the lug to lug. I’ve seen 6.5” wrists pull off bigger watches because they had wide but flat wrists versus 7” wrists that were narrow but round. Both sizes look to work on your wrist. Now depends on your preference. For my 7” wrist that’s 2 1/4” wide, I’d get the L since it would look more elegant. Plus I don’t want a date window and I’m good with a 2 hand quartz. And I’m sure there’s a significant difference in price. Love your vids!
@@YoureTerrific i didn’t take the curve into consideration. I just measured the flesh that I saw when I looked down at my wrist like when looking at the time. So if the lug to lug is less than that, then the watch should be fine.
XL looks like the right size. I think if it curved down alittle at the lugs and got rid of the date it would be perfect. The gap between the date and 5 drives me nuts
I have a Solo and love it. It is so nice though I tend to save it for special occasions and not many of those lately. As I remember they came in small, medium and large. I got the Medium for my 6 ¾ inch wrist and it seems perfect. To me the large size would look more elegant on your wrist except for the dial. Good choice.
After trying on both the L and XL, I got myself the XL and even though I have a smaller wrist than you (yes, I remembered your wrist size 😅), I like the way it fits me.
The water resistance is rated as, "nah, bro" 😂😭😂 Edit: hands down the large. You're so right, i think square watches, especially the tank, should diminutiveive. Check out the photo of Chet baker and his cartier tank. Classic. It's what made me want to get a tank
Great video, specially for those like me in the collecting watches hobbie. What was your decision after all this time? Did you buy it XL or L? From my point of view, and also my recommendation is to go for the XL one, and this is not for the size (what looks great in your wrist) but also for the movement. During the years, I had learned that is better to have automatic watches instead of those which need battery maintenance. So, I'd go for the XL one for that reason. Question: I'm considering to buy one, but I haven't decided if it's better to buy this one with the steel bracelet rather to buy the leather one. What do you think?
Actually, the price in 2024 is 5,000 US dollars. And you know that if you go to the boutique, this price is non-negotiable. Nice watch, but expensive. Luckily we have the Longines Dolcevita.
I really think that square watches should not cover the length of the wrist. I would go for the Large or the Medium - I think you can pull off the L though.
great video! great BGM! (do you mind sharing the song name?) by the way I'm also considering both L and XL, ended up ordered the XL size. the in house movement already make it worth.
That watch looks very good on you, 7 inch wrist or not. I've been looking at this exact watch in the high-end jewelry store where I live and plan on purchasing this watch. The price here in Calgary Canada is $6,700.
My wrist is 6.25-in and I wear the Solo XL version. Some people think it’s big. But I like it on me a lot so it doesn’t matter. My watch collection ranges from 34mm up to 45mm and I wear them all.
Beautiful, I wish Cartier did this in the Large size. Also, I'm sad to see the new straps on the new Tank Musts Medium & Large look much cheaper than that of the outgoing Solo
Same feeling. Actually cartier calls the "L" as "LM" (large-medium?). Just seen the Must in boutique and there is a significant jump in size from LM to XL. The in-between size will b nice.
Something is not right with the date window. Should not it be lower? Also the negative space between V and the date is not my fave thing. Thanks for the vid, man.
I think you're right: The Tank is all about classic elegance and should therefore be on the smaller side. Even Muhammad Ali wore a tiny Tank on his tree trunk wrists, right? I also think a Tank doesn't need a date or second hand or any fancy dial decoration. It is a very pure, minimalist design, and nothing should get in the way of that. Get the "Large" model. Personally, I have tiny wrists (any round watch above 38mm looks ridiculous on me), and I'm very much drawn to the "Small".
I had the same back and forth with the large and XL, but ended up buying the XL (note: for my 6.5" wrist). It definitely pushes my line for "wearability", but ultimately looks acceptably proportionate, even on my wrist. The rounded brancards on the new Must make the watch wear smaller than the Tank Solo predecessor, and really my decision was fairly easy due to the guilloche dial, date function, and mechanical movement on the XL. Great video! (and also love the low-key roasts lol).
You said that you do this for the passion and love for watches, not for money. And I just wanted to say that you spread that passion and love for watches with the content you create- amazing stuff!
The Cartier Tank is, in my opinion, one of those watches that looks better with a smaller profile. I’d venture to say that even a small works well with men for this type of style. That said, both sizes look really good.
This is my next watch.... BTW its not so much the difference in Size that differentiates the XL from the L. Look at everything you lose by going with the large! I want that In-house movement, Date, and Guillochet pattern and I want it now!!! One final thing, what size wrist you rocking?
Went to try the XL on the wrist in an AD today. Holy Moly was it huge… I mean like genuinely enormous, it’s hard to believe based on the numbers. I’ve got the same wrist size of just under 18 cm. It really is a bit of a shame, as all the specs and pricing seem so attractive!
I can fit both the large and XL in my collection. I find that the large looks kinda weird when wearing tshirts and the XL looks bad when wearing anything with long sleeves.
The XL is more versatile IMO. They look a bit more suitable with casual style outfit. The large on the other hand is perfect on your wrist for more formal outfit .
I own the Reverso Classic Medium Thin which is much smaller than this watch yet JLC have put a manual wind movement inside. Cartier missed a trick by not making a choice of mechanical or quartz movements in at least the L or XL sizes. The L would probably suit me best but I'm going to buy the XL. As you say even with recently diminished Rolex grey prices the XL still looks a steal. I bought the JLC way before recent price hikes. Cartier are offering very good value relatively at entry level luxury. Will it last??
It is likely that you want a steel bracelet some day in the future as leather strap is so quickly worn out. I have the exact Cartier must with steel bracelet. It looks much larger than the same size with a leather strap. So get the large.
Hey! Love the video, i intend to buy the Large model for my birthday but I got a question for you. I would love to get the same strap as the XL model but I feel like it's not possible because the size is probably different, what do you think ?
Still liking the XL? The email interest is the in-house mechanical movement vs quartz. For me, personally, that is a big factor. I do agree with comments about it being extravert but that also means that it can be a dress watch and casual. So, the flexibility is good to have IMO. For me, I'd go gold but wouldn't we all if we could!
I think it also depends on your character. The large looks introverted and humble. The Extra large is for more extroverted outgoing. I might not explain very well as English isn’t my mother tongue.
I have a similar size wrist to you, the tank must XL feels a bit too big with the strap yet it felt a tad better on the wrist with the bracelet. However, after trying, I think i prefer the balanced case design of the tank americaine or the santos, perhaps a reverso.
XL is right for you. The iconic and classic design of the Cartier Must with a modern size is a winner, IMO. Plus, I hate when a man wears a watch that looks petite. Ick.
If Cartier would release an automatic movement/guilloche dial size Large, then that would genuinely be perfect. I hope they do it.
I think they save that for the more expensive Tank Louis.
If they do they´ll probably price it very Cartierisch like around 5500$ for reasons not even them self understand. And that´s why JLC are the best but Cartier the coolest..
on an elegant timeless watch it's manual wind for the win
@@YoureTerrific Do you think the Tank Must or any watch for that matter appears smaller when worn with the matching bracelet? The contrast between a stainless case and a black leather strap is pretty dramatic compared to both in stainless (or gold or any color). In other words do you think the XL watch would look more proportional on your wrist if it was all stainless?
@@dantimber Bracelets make watches look larger. That’s why I bought the Large and wear it on a bracelet. See my Instagram.
“As date-less as they were in high school” this man is on fire 😂
Glad you caught that.
I find myself coming back to this video many times. I have a 7 1/2 inch wrist and too can not pick between them. Totally agree with sophisticated, elegant, conservative size of watches.
Just bought my XL today! The large was just a little too small and I felt 2,750 was too much for a quartz. Settled on the XL because the 3,700 wasn’t unreasonable for the in-house movement. Thanks for your content.
Excellent choice. You can’t really beat the XL price.
Yeah but that means you are throwing 1000 just for a movement which is less accurate and the maintenance is much more expensive...
@@Cortesevasive €1000 more for a movement that cost €20 more in production cost. People are so brainwashed by the word mechanical. Also - it's basically just a rebranded ETA 2892 caliber.
@@nomansland120 No,it's not a rebranded ETA.It's a fully 1847MC Cartier in house caliber .It's not the older Tank.Especially that Cartier is owned by Richemont group and not Swatch group who owns ETA.
@@nomansland120 not sure where you get €20 from, the cost of designing and assembling an in-house mechanical movement, most of which is by hand is not insignificant.
I'm a quartz guy myself, mechanical watches being too expensive to maintain and too inaccurate for my professional needs, but let's not kid ourselves here!
I went in wanting the Large for my 7 inch wrist, but ended up walking out with the XL. It was that guiocche that got me. Also can’t go wrong with a solid mechanical movement. I think it’s a wonderful size for a 7 inch wrist and above, but you can’t go wrong either way.
Nice pickup! I like the watch for all the same reasons.
I always feel like I am in a 80's movie when watching your videos, and I love it.
Also--go for the large. It's more elegant and understated
Something about that music really works for me.
Yes, great music! Video would have been better if he showed the watch while holding his boombox over his head.
I’m not paying Peter Gabriel for his music, though.
@@YoureTerrific Seriously though, great videos! Never thought I might want a Cartier, but thinking on this. It would be out of my comfort zone but that may be a good thing.
XL looks best.
extra large my friend, no question
the large is elegant but immediately makes me think "it's a bit too small" and that reaction will never fade, whereas the XL doesn't make me think "it's a bit too big".. it's just right
Thanks
I think Tank by Cartier always works better smaller size but the dial in the extra large is truly beautiful plus an in-house automatic movement is a lot of value from the price …
I will but this piece for my birthday in October :)
Large looks way better on you. You know, tanks were initially designed to wear small for both men and women, watches to be worn under the radar. This gordy XL is just too flashy and too big. Also, in my honest opinion, it shouldn't matter what movement is inside a cartier tank. It's about the brand name, the design, the story and the history. Who the hell cares the large has a quartz?? with buying a Cartier in general, the movement shouldn't be something to focus on like so many people do. And remember Muhammed Ali wearing a small sized tank on his large wrist, and it works! before people are gonna attack me, it's just my opinion!
If the movement doesn't matter the size doesn't matter. Some matter more to other people. Personally I rather admire the watch than be concerned of how other people think is to big.
It’s funny, I have a 7” wrist and I own the large Santos(it was actually a very tough decision between the large and medium) but I find the Tank XL absolutely huge. It wears real bog and like you, I feel a Tank should be understated. My Santos is more of a sports watch that can be worn with a suit but the Tank really is a dress watch, IMO…especially on the strap.
While I think the more classical way of wearing a tank is to go smaller or diminutive as you pout it, I think the XL fits just as well if we're following the trend these days. And I have to say, the XL has a more attractive dial.
Finally someone reviews the new tank collection on RUclips. I have bought the XL as I want the tank watch for so long time. But spending thousands of dollars on a Quarz watch makes no sense for me and you can definitely find a more elegant Quarz watch with lower price. The XL version is combining all significant elements from Cartier watch, that is the reason it is a great watch and I buy it immediately without a second thought. I am sure the price of the watch will increase soon for this watch.
What do you think are more elegant quartz watches?
@@YoureTerrific fashion watch like Hermès and Chanel. Longines is also a good replacement for Cartier. I have a watch from Zeppelin and love it.
“WR is nah, bro.” Haha! I like this XL size on your…….7 inch wrist.
Thanks
The XL is too large. The large one suits you perfectly. Classic Tank is Even smaller than the large
A truer word has never been spoken.
Also, a date doesn't really belong on a Tank anyway.
Whats your wrist size?
😂
I own the large one, here the main point is the size of your hand not the wrist. Is how proportional looks the watch vs. your hand. Awesome video :D Cartier watches always right choice!
The greatest SIN Cartier has done with this watch is replacing the much more elegant ALLIGATOR strap with this cheap cow hide one, and the multiple colours they come in only make them look even cheaper! The first time I came across this watch was an Asian man in glasses, wearing a beautiful suit, crisp white shirt and shiny high end shoes. His tank had the original shiny ALLIGATOR strap. He really made an impression on me, and that's what I think how this watch should be dressed with. Cartier throws in a cheap cow hide strap while quietly increasing the price of this watch is unforgivable - and don't even think we haven't noticed, whoever came with with this wicked idea in Product Planning!
They do that to comply with certain countries/states that bans the use of such leather. Also, being environmentally friendly is in vogue now and companies see that as a plus point, or if nothing else, an excuse.
Thank you for getting into this hobby, such a joy to watch everytime.
Definitely the Large for a 7in wrist. I have a 7.25 wrist and would go with the large as well. It's too bad it doesn't come in a mechanical movement. Maybe they are saving Tanks in that size with a mechanical movement solely for their Louis Cartier line of tanks? I love Cartier, but sometimes all the sizes, date/no date models (this one looks way better without the date window!), and movements confuse me a bit. There are lots of options.
I put the XL bracelet version on my 6-3/4" wrist and instantly decided to buy it. I have plenty of diminutive sized vintage watches. I don't need that aspect from my modern pieces. The XL on bracelet has a great modern wrist presence but references it's history with the guilloché dial, Roman numerals and the blue tipped crown.
Agreed man. I wanted to love the auto but the size was off so I went with the L Quartz. Got over my no quartz ego and it has transformed my collecting habits.
The production of your videos is just breathtaking.
Thanks
Excellent video. You really showcase the beauty of the dial in the XL, which is hard to see in most photos and other videos of this watch I've seen. Coincidentally, we have the same wrist size, so that I could see that the XL, while not traditionally diminutive, looks really great especially with that dial! Watch sizes have evolved for both men and women, and I prefer a larger size which I think is actually more masculine in appearance.
masculine in design is overrated
I saw these for the first time in a dealer literally yesterday and I couldn’t believe the price, particularly when there’s a 2 grand / 60% jump to move to the Santos Medium (my fave) with the same movement!! Gave me a real head wreck 😵💫
Love your reviews and love my Tank Must XL. I admit I bought mine before seeing your review but I agree with all your points. I can't wear leather and the XL was available with a nice steel bracelet (well worth the upgrade IMO). The watch looks great on my 7.5" wrist and is super comfortable and I am able to keep it on all day when I work whereas I must take my Tag off when I work as its simply too bulky. As an Architect I appreciate the timeless design and the value represented vs its nearest competitor the Reverso could not be ignored. I did consider the Reverso but I dont play Polo, prefer a center seconds and consider Art Deco a great style whose time is in the past. Anyway thanks for your work.
XL, no doubt. I can’t speak to classy, and I will take your word for what a traditional Tank size used to look like. But as to what suits your wrist better? XL.
One of the best review of the tank, thanks a lot ! I purchased the xl version because I prefer the automatic movement and my wrist is large enough, 19 cm. I can say your video has influenced me to pay more attention to this watch 😊 Just one question... what is your wrist size please ? 😂
I myself bought a large tank solo with my wrist size at 7 1/2 I figure the proportions seem right, smaller looked a bit more classy on this square watch. I figured the Quartz is cheaper to service and battery changes are not so bad with the four screws to remove from the case back.
This video has done more to convince me that this is my next watch than anything else on the internet. Just fantastic. I've got an 8 inch wrist, so the XL on bracelet is my choice.
Great video, I have a 7.25 wrist and went with the large. It is a bit of an adjustment looking down and seeing the size in comparison to my other sports models, I were day to day but once you do it’s very elegant.
That’s my experience too. A short adjustment period and that’s all.
I think wrist circumference size is not as important as top wrist width. You can have a 7 inch but very round, or 6.5 inch but very flat and wear the watches similarly
I'm not sure about the size either, but if didn't have the guilloche dial, I'd feel like I was missing out on something. Kind of like I got the cheaper model. :(
I prefer a small tank...like the size that's now considered a "woman's size". But Im a minority...the plate sized watches are in now.
PS. What's your wrist size?
I have huge wrists and I prefer a small tank.
Did he mention his wrist size yet?
This man REALLY just 3d printed a watch case just to see the size, legend. And thanks for helping me choose between the XL and L, I have 7 inch wrist if not abit more and i chose XL
I just want to say that i love the synth music you use in this video and a few others. Bring it back!!! Great work, love the channel!
What’s your wrist circumference? Totally agree with Tanks perhaps looking smaller rather than larger. The XL looks fine on your wrist though. Tried it on my 6.5 inch wrist and was shocked at how large it was - but I do prefer the mechanical movement.
okay are you me? subbed you because you love cartier especially the tank, just like me, and the intro music, retrowave/synthwave kind of music. Love the combo. Great video!
For me a Cartier Tank should be: 1) mechanical (that rules out the smaller size, 2) small (that rules out the bigger size), 3) in a precious metal. For those reasons I wouldn't get the Tank Must (or the Solo before it). I'd wait until I could afford a Tank Louis in gold
Wait… Doesn’t the Tank Solo XL come in automatic (same movement I believe) with a 18k rose gold option?
@@lewisjones3345 yes I believe that one comes in automatic, but its way too big for a Tank watch
@@stephen9609 that’s fair… for you. Some folks with bigger wrist might find this right on target.
@@lewisjones3345 I think the watch design should be small even if the person has large wrists. Look at photos of Muhamad Ali and the size of the tank on his wrist.
@@stephen9609 no I got you. But that was 55-60 years ago. To say that was what was done then as the only way to do it would be incorrect. We don’t dress like 1967. Why would our watch tastes have to stay stagnant (as a society, however you decide to dress or wear your jewelry is up to you)? So I’m following you that is how you see the Tank and you’re not alone. I’m just saying that if it has grown in size with modern incarnations, that’s just the progression of things.
Thank you so much for making this video! Exactly what I needed!
While the large is more "historically" accurate in terms of how the tank should be as a dress watch, I simply can't ignore the guilloche dial and the non quartz movement. Wish they made the XL without the date though.
I also didn't know the must line was available at US boutiques?
The XL and standard Large are available here. The Solar and colored dials are not yet.
@@YoureTerrific isn’t the large a quartz and the XL automatic? That’s a game changer if true - for me
I will say at the 4:00 minute of the video the watch looks fantastic on your wrist. I think you made the right choice.
Great video, as always. I think we’re all falling back in love with Cartier via the Santos or Tank Must. Personally, I love the XL and look forward to getting one soon. We’re all torn by the concept of the Tank being, diminutive, by tradition. But, I think that’s more history than tradition. Go the XL, is the perfect size for the unwritten history.
You chose well. XL looks great on you. And it’s the better watch anyway.
Nobody, and I mean NOBODY does a better review.I love how you show a watch and not try to sell a watch !! That said you've sold me many including this amazing Tank .......Clever. Great Content please keep em coming
How wide is your wrist? I find that info to be more helpful for the lug to lug. I’ve seen 6.5” wrists pull off bigger watches because they had wide but flat wrists versus 7” wrists that were narrow but round.
Both sizes look to work on your wrist. Now depends on your preference.
For my 7” wrist that’s 2 1/4” wide, I’d get the L since it would look more elegant. Plus I don’t want a date window and I’m good with a 2 hand quartz. And I’m sure there’s a significant difference in price.
Love your vids!
I'm not sure how to measure my wrist's width. At what point in the curve do I say, "this is now the side"?
@@YoureTerrific i didn’t take the curve into consideration. I just measured the flesh that I saw when I looked down at my wrist like when looking at the time. So if the lug to lug is less than that, then the watch should be fine.
XL looks like the right size. I think if it curved down alittle at the lugs and got rid of the date it would be perfect. The gap between the date and 5 drives me nuts
I'm more for smaller Tanks too, but I think the extra large looks great on you man
Thanks
Large. The extra large looks like a smart watch upon first glance.
I have a Solo and love it. It is so nice though I tend to save it for special occasions and not many of those lately. As I remember they came in small, medium and large. I got the Medium for my 6 ¾ inch wrist and it seems perfect. To me the large size would look more elegant on your wrist except for the dial. Good choice.
Great looking classic. What’s your wrist size?
I think it's a tough one because of the dial finish on the XL! In terms of size I think the Large looks good on your wrist
After trying on both the L and XL, I got myself the XL and even though I have a smaller wrist than you (yes, I remembered your wrist size 😅), I like the way it fits me.
Hmm.. I think they both work but I lean towards the x-large on you. Keep up the great vids man!!
Thanks and thanks
The water resistance is rated as, "nah, bro" 😂😭😂
Edit: hands down the large. You're so right, i think square watches, especially the tank, should diminutiveive. Check out the photo of Chet baker and his cartier tank. Classic. It's what made me want to get a tank
“The water is resistant is rated as ‘nah, bro.’”
Lines like these are why I keep coming back.
Ha, thanks
Great video, specially for those like me in the collecting watches hobbie. What was your decision after all this time? Did you buy it XL or L? From my point of view, and also my recommendation is to go for the XL one, and this is not for the size (what looks great in your wrist) but also for the movement. During the years, I had learned that is better to have automatic watches instead of those which need battery maintenance. So, I'd go for the XL one for that reason. Question: I'm considering to buy one, but I haven't decided if it's better to buy this one with the steel bracelet rather to buy the leather one. What do you think?
This is exactly the video I needed as I’m interested in a Tank Must. Definitely go with XL on your wrist (similar to mine). Thanks for this!
I think a croc strap will improve the look even more.
Actually, the price in 2024 is 5,000 US dollars. And you know that if you go to the boutique, this price is non-negotiable. Nice watch, but expensive. Luckily we have the Longines Dolcevita.
I really think that square watches should not cover the length of the wrist. I would go for the Large or the Medium - I think you can pull off the L though.
Thanks!
Love everything about this new watch except for the strap. Do they offer it on any other options?
great video! great BGM! (do you mind sharing the song name?) by the way I'm also considering both L and XL, ended up ordered the XL size. the in house movement already make it worth.
That watch looks very good on you, 7 inch wrist or not. I've been looking at this exact watch in the high-end jewelry store where I live and plan on purchasing this watch. The price here in Calgary Canada is $6,700.
100% Large is the perfect size. Thanks for making this vid, I’ll go for the Large myself
XL looks perfect!
My wrist is 6.25-in and I wear the Solo XL version. Some people think it’s big. But I like it on me a lot so it doesn’t matter. My watch collection ranges from 34mm up to 45mm and I wear them all.
I was hoping to try my hand at 3d printing it too, but unfortunately it looks like Thingiverse took your link down 😢
Beautiful, I wish Cartier did this in the Large size. Also, I'm sad to see the new straps on the new Tank Musts Medium & Large look much cheaper than that of the outgoing Solo
Same feeling. Actually cartier calls the "L" as "LM" (large-medium?). Just seen the Must in boutique and there is a significant jump in size from LM to XL. The in-between size will b nice.
XL looks much better on your wrist, plus there's no way I'm spending thousands on a Quartz watch.
Hey great video! Where were you able to find the watch for 3.7 k ? Looks like it may have gone up in cost :(
Something is not right with the date window. Should not it be lower? Also the negative space between V and the date is not my fave thing. Thanks for the vid, man.
im torn between L and XL … movement matters to me so im leaning towards XL.
I think you're right: The Tank is all about classic elegance and should therefore be on the smaller side. Even Muhammad Ali wore a tiny Tank on his tree trunk wrists, right? I also think a Tank doesn't need a date or second hand or any fancy dial decoration. It is a very pure, minimalist design, and nothing should get in the way of that. Get the "Large" model. Personally, I have tiny wrists (any round watch above 38mm looks ridiculous on me), and I'm very much drawn to the "Small".
I had the same back and forth with the large and XL, but ended up buying the XL (note: for my 6.5" wrist). It definitely pushes my line for "wearability", but ultimately looks acceptably proportionate, even on my wrist. The rounded brancards on the new Must make the watch wear smaller than the Tank Solo predecessor, and really my decision was fairly easy due to the guilloche dial, date function, and mechanical movement on the XL. Great video! (and also love the low-key roasts lol).
I’m thinking the same - I wouldn’t want a quartz version.
Can you post pictures on your wrist I have the same wrist size as yours!
You said that you do this for the passion and love for watches, not for money. And I just wanted to say that you spread that passion and love for watches with the content you create- amazing stuff!
Thanks so much. I’m glad my love for this silly stuff comes through.
The Cartier Tank is, in my opinion, one of those watches that looks better with a smaller profile. I’d venture to say that even a small works well with men for this type of style. That said, both sizes look really good.
This is my next watch.... BTW its not so much the difference in Size that differentiates the XL from the L. Look at everything you lose by going with the large! I want that In-house movement, Date, and Guillochet pattern and I want it now!!! One final thing, what size wrist you rocking?
That last edit done to the beat of that music!! oh man! so nicely done!
Aside of the guilloche, are the color of the dials different between the L and XL? XL looks metallic.
The large, definitely! I think smaller watches will make a huge comeback in the next few years.
Quite possible. Thanks.
what's the music used in this video? I love it!!!! ANd of course I've seen this video more thsn a dozen times.
Went to try the XL on the wrist in an AD today. Holy Moly was it huge… I mean like genuinely enormous, it’s hard to believe based on the numbers. I’ve got the same wrist size of just under 18 cm.
It really is a bit of a shame, as all the specs and pricing seem so attractive!
I can fit both the large and XL in my collection. I find that the large looks kinda weird when wearing tshirts and the XL looks bad when wearing anything with long sleeves.
The XL is more versatile IMO.
They look a bit more suitable with casual style outfit.
The large on the other hand is perfect on your wrist for more formal outfit
.
That dateless line. 😂😂 Large definitely looks best size-wise BUT if you’ll miss the guilloche then there is only one answer (at least for now).
do note, not all MUST DE Cartier vintage are Quartz, some are handwinding (or auto - probably not)
I own the Reverso Classic Medium Thin which is much smaller than this watch yet JLC have put a manual wind movement inside. Cartier missed a trick by not making a choice of mechanical or quartz movements in at least the L or XL sizes. The L would probably suit me best but I'm going to buy the XL. As you say even with recently diminished Rolex grey prices the XL still looks a steal. I bought the JLC way before recent price hikes. Cartier are offering very good value relatively at entry level luxury. Will it last??
Nice video. In my opinion I think the lodge is a little too big for your wrist. What size is your wrist?..Just joking. I have a 7 inch wrist as well
It is likely that you want a steel bracelet some day in the future as leather strap is so quickly worn out. I have the exact Cartier must with steel bracelet. It looks much larger than the same size with a leather strap. So get the large.
I got the L Tank Must for my 6.3 inch wrist. I think the XL could be too large for most wrists.
Great video! Though maybe next time consider letting us know your wrist size so we have a reference for how the watch fits? ;)
Hey! Love the video, i intend to buy the Large model for my birthday but I got a question for you.
I would love to get the same strap as the XL model but I feel like it's not possible because the size is probably different, what do you think ?
Tried on both, definitely prefer the XL personally (same wrist size as you).
Got this one today. XL for me and loving it
Love you’re videos… just one quick question, how big is your wrist? :)
Beautiful video 👍, Which size of cartier tank is perfect for my 6 and 3/4 wrist .
???
XL mate, i saw this in person, I am drawn to this watch. Just got the sbgm221, but this may be the next buy for me.
Still liking the XL? The email interest is the in-house mechanical movement vs quartz. For me, personally, that is a big factor. I do agree with comments about it being extravert but that also means that it can be a dress watch and casual. So, the flexibility is good to have IMO. For me, I'd go gold but wouldn't we all if we could!
Great video. Just one question in order to guage its size do you have large rists?
I think it also depends on your character. The large looks introverted and humble. The Extra large is for more extroverted outgoing. I might not explain very well as English isn’t my mother tongue.
Your English is great! Good points.
I have a similar size wrist to you, the tank must XL feels a bit too big with the strap yet it felt a tad better on the wrist with the bracelet. However, after trying, I think i prefer the balanced case design of the tank americaine or the santos, perhaps a reverso.
XL is right for you. The iconic and classic design of the Cartier Must with a modern size is a winner, IMO. Plus, I hate when a man wears a watch that looks petite. Ick.