@@cbyam1300 We've played it a bunch, but I would have to see if it was ever recorded. I'll see if I can find it. I have around 10 songs on youtube we've done as our CSNY Tribute.
The first time I see you and hope not the last time. Such a great performance.this is one of the best song I heard years ago watching Woodstock movie and still love that song and csny .thanks guys .
Very good rendition, id even say great! Had I just been listnin and not watchin Id a probably been fooled into thinkin it was them! I do believe THAT is the intent or purpose to play it like the original so... Excellent Job!!
Estupenda Interpretación,gran armonía...y musicalidad... sentí que viajaba en el tiempo... mis 15 años grandes recuerdos...te recuerdo Abelardo mi querido hermano Qué Dios te tenga en su Gloria
What a beautiful things love can do ...This song has been wrote by Stephen Stills to his love "Judy" . He offert her the song and the guitar he played with the day of her birthday ... Isn't it lovely ??? From Tangier , we salute you ❤❤❤❤
Very nice...... appreciation from Nova Scotia, Canada! Takes me back to the 'Golden Age of Music' - late 60s-early 70s. Loving the shade top D-35 and the cool room.
First of all nice job by 'Carry On' on this song! Well done. Regarding the 27 year-old comment ... we have a phenomenal CSNY tribute band here in St. Louis that routinely packs (nearly) a good sized arena in neighboring St. Charles, MO. The band is called '4 & 20'. They typically play twice a year or so as 4 & 20-though they are starting to do more festivals and concerts in the park. If you go ... be prepared for vocals that are spot on ... and a mindblowingly-talented gun slinger of a guitarist who nails Stephen Stills' leads (not easy) and then always wows the crowds with putting his own touches & riffs on leads. I've seen most of the pros in my life -- Stills, Santana, Page, Beck and this guy--John Mondun (sp?) will wow your ears and take your heart to that level of playing! Sorry ... I ramble. The crowds at 4 & 20 gigs are filled with fans of every age. Good music is good music.
You.... guys.....are great ...This is one one of the things I'd like to do in my life . But I guess I'll never be able to do . At least you have made this for us to enjoy .
Hey Stephen, we just had a show on the 4th. Did Ohio and Woodstock but not Southern Cross. Here's a snippet of Find The Cost of Freedom and Ohio. I'll have to look for Woodstock. facebook.com/tjtony.prisciandaro/videos/10157840733560138/UzpfSTg2ODg0OTU5OTgzNTE0NzoyNTYyNzAxMDAwNDQ5OTkw/?epa=SEARCH_BOX
@@kmacdc4 Where do you guys play? Love to see you up in the Seattle area. You guys are one of the very few who do CSNY justice. Nicely done. Southern Cross would be a great addition for you all.
Nice job! I expect the guy playing lead has tuned the way Stills did on the recording. Are all three using alternate tunings? If not, are the tabs and chords available?
Well I subscribed put a thumbs upthen I rolled up my sleeves and did the real high falsetto Harmony along with you guys and of course I had to tie my underwear in a knot first 😄💓!!!!
Bob, the one in the middle is playing bass:) We overdubbed it after we realized it was needed. If you watch the video to the end there a few shots of him playing it.
Sounds great but, lose the "AND" before the "I am sorry" and " I am lonely" parts. Keep rockin' guys! Just loosen up a little, and you'll be perfect. You're the best I've heard, and I've been listening to CSNY since 1980.
Hmmm, we did it a few years ago. I'm not positive but I'm sure one of us may have doubled/ thrown in an extra harmony. When we do it live we will use 5 voices.
+cure969 Bob, the one in the middle plays the bass. After listening to the playback we realized that is needed a little more low end so he overdubbed the bass. He's in the video playing the bass but it's a little later in the song:)
Did you watch until the end? The song was pre recorded then we shot the vid. Here's a live version of us doing it. Bass player and all. ruclips.net/video/ZPRyFbFpAGw/видео.html
Hola Paul, here's a video of us doing this live if you want to check it out. Just a bit more passion:) Have a great 2019! ruclips.net/video/ZPRyFbFpAGw/видео.html
How so? We recorded the song in a studio and this is the video we made for it. If you would like to see us cover this song live you can watch it here ruclips.net/video/ZPRyFbFpAGw/видео.html
excellent job on one of my favorite csny pieces...keep up the good work...
Thank you!
Great cover. Watching from Ontario Canada 🎉
Thanks a bunch Sean!
AWSOME! Remember this from my youth. They don't make lyrics like this any more! Favorite of CSNY!
Superb hearing this played live by 3 excellent guitarists and singers. A beautiful copy of the original.
Thank you so much!!
From the opening chord, I knew this was going to be good. I wasn't proved wrong... hats off to you guys.
Thank you Chris, there's a version of us doing this live as well. Great song with great harmonies.
@@kmacdc4 Found it. Yep, really enjoyed it. It is such a great song & not one which is easy, I would imagine. Ever recorded Southern Cross ?
@@cbyam1300 We've played it a bunch, but I would have to see if it was ever recorded. I'll see if I can find it. I have around 10 songs on youtube we've done as our CSNY Tribute.
@@kmacdc4 excellent Ken. I'll subscribe & look up the other songs you've done. Thanks for your replies...
Absolutely beautiful rendition!
Thank you!!
The first time I see you and hope not the last time. Such a great performance.this is one of the best song I heard years ago watching Woodstock movie and still love that song and csny .thanks guys .
Damn! You fellas killed it! Bravo!!!
Thank you!!
Man! I have listened to this song about a dozen times and still not tired of it!
Very good rendition, id even say great! Had I just been listnin and not watchin Id a probably been fooled into thinkin it was them! I do believe THAT is the intent or purpose to play it like the original so... Excellent Job!!
Thanks Clamshell:) Yep, we were just covering the original as close as possible.
Estupenda Interpretación,gran armonía...y musicalidad... sentí que viajaba en el tiempo... mis 15 años grandes recuerdos...te recuerdo Abelardo mi querido hermano Qué Dios te tenga en su Gloria
You guys are great love singing along to my favourite CNS songs…🙏😊✌️
Thank you Terri!! Appreciate you stumbling upon us.
it is awesome dude
So awesome that you're keeping this great music alive! ❤️
Thank you so much!! Have lots of other CSNY covers on my page:)
What a beautiful things love can do ...This song has been wrote by Stephen Stills to his love "Judy" . He offert her the song and the guitar he played with the day of her birthday ...
Isn't it lovely ???
From Tangier , we salute you ❤❤❤❤
Very very good. Ambitious!
Thanks so much Steve!
Loved it!
Very nice...... appreciation from Nova Scotia, Canada! Takes me back to the 'Golden Age of Music' - late 60s-early 70s. Loving the shade top D-35 and the cool room.
Appreciate that Glen, yes, I believe Bob's D35 is a 75.
@@kmacdc4 hi dad
Amazing how a song can transport me to my adolescence! Thank you for mastering such a challenging piece. You guys are awesome!
Thank you:) Yep, this music is timeless.
Outstanding!!!
Just soooo good... I was singing along at the top of my voice, towards the end. Bravo!
Awesome, thank you, just a great song.
LOVELY! The all the acustics are great! Thank You Brothers! DaveyJO in Pennsylvania
Thank you my friend!
Hi dad
This is awesome guys!! 😀😎
Excellent 👏👍✌
Very cool and very good
Thank you:)
just wow...if you ever come to Orlando to perform I will surely pay to watch you.
great job..greetings from switzerland.
Hello from Michigan USA.
Is it weird that a 27 year old is in love with this wonderful music?
Mark vaars i would think it odd that a 27 year old wasn’t. It’s timeless and amongst the best music ever created. 😊
First of all nice job by 'Carry On' on this song! Well done. Regarding the 27 year-old comment ... we have a phenomenal CSNY tribute band here in St. Louis that routinely packs (nearly) a good sized arena in neighboring St. Charles, MO. The band is called '4 & 20'. They typically play twice a year or so as 4 & 20-though they are starting to do more festivals and concerts in the park. If you go ... be prepared for vocals that are spot on ... and a mindblowingly-talented gun slinger of a guitarist who nails Stephen Stills' leads (not easy) and then always wows the crowds with putting his own touches & riffs on leads. I've seen most of the pros in my life -- Stills, Santana, Page, Beck and this guy--John Mondun (sp?) will wow your ears and take your heart to that level of playing!
Sorry ... I ramble. The crowds at 4 & 20 gigs are filled with fans of every age. Good music is good music.
Fantastic cover!
Thank you. Appreciate taking time to listen.
@@kmacdc4
You deserve!!
SWEET !
Hey hey, thanks Joseph!
Very nice. Great job. Only in the last twi minutes you here the difference.
Thank you Erik!
Woah. Awesome harmonies.
Great work! Love it.
amazing ! sounds great - and what a mix !
Gracias:)
A breath of youth I've felt listening to this excellent cover. ¡Many thanks for this rejuvenating effect...!
Thank you Maria!!
You.... guys.....are great ...This is one one of the things I'd like to do in my life . But I guess I'll never be able to do . At least you have made this for us to enjoy .
Thank you so much Marco!
Very good the best
Super good.
I would give anything to play drums/percussion for these guys...and do it right. Respect.
ruclips.net/video/ZPRyFbFpAGw/видео.html
Let's see some links to more of your CSN music!
Hey Bob, just click on my name and look through my videos. We’re also on Facebook, Carry On CSNY Tribute.
@@kmacdc4 Hi Ken. I did just that. I saw CSN live 3 times. You guys are 100% excellent! Thank you!
Fantastic
You guys are wonderful! Lovin' it!!! Like to hear your take on Ohio, Woodstock and Southern Cross.
Hey Stephen, we just had a show on the 4th. Did Ohio and Woodstock but not Southern Cross. Here's a snippet of Find The Cost of Freedom and Ohio. I'll have to look for Woodstock. facebook.com/tjtony.prisciandaro/videos/10157840733560138/UzpfSTg2ODg0OTU5OTgzNTE0NzoyNTYyNzAxMDAwNDQ5OTkw/?epa=SEARCH_BOX
@@kmacdc4 Where do you guys play? Love to see you up in the Seattle area. You guys are one of the very few who do CSNY justice. Nicely done. Southern Cross would be a great addition for you all.
@@stephenjohn823 Thank you Stephen. We're out of the Detroit area. We do Southern Cross, just don't think I have a video of us doing it.
Excellent 👍
Thank you:)
awesomness.
Fine guitar playing and nice vocals...well done...
You're amazing ! thanx for this great musical moment ! And kisses from France :)
NAILED IT!
Thank you Avery!
....well done guys. Standard and Bruce Palmer tuning. Beautiful backdrop as well.
Thank you Set Ter:) Very kind words. There is a version of us doing this live as well:)
well done !
Thank you:)
Well done guys. Lovely playing and harmonies ✌️
Thank you Larry!
Nice job! I expect the guy playing lead has tuned the way Stills did on the recording. Are all three using alternate tunings? If not, are the tabs and chords available?
Thank you:)
Yes, I’m (far right) tuned in EBEEE, the others are standard.
nicely done guys
WOW!!!!
Awesome. Thank you :)
Good Job!!!
No easy feat, great job!
Hi, Thanks Avery!!
Well I subscribed put a thumbs upthen I rolled up my sleeves and did the real high falsetto Harmony along with you guys and of course I had to tie my underwear in a knot first 😄💓!!!!
Ha, it is up there:) Stills gets up there on "It's my heart that's suffering, it's a-dying".
Well done, hats off! What model are the Taylors
?
Hey Rob, that's a circa 2000 Taylor 314 KCE. One of my favorites to play out with. Not really sure which Taylor Matt on the far left is using.
Everyone is strumming! But there's a plucked bass line?
A bass part was edited in. Bob, the guy on the far left is also playing bass. There's shots of him playing it towards the end of the video:)
Here's version of us doing it live. ruclips.net/video/ZPRyFbFpAGw/видео.html
Nice
Middle guy looks almost like Stephen Stills actually :)
I think you are thinking of David Crosby
Cept the guy in the middle is 50 years younger than the originals! 😂. . . .
good cover
Out Standing Cover...........New Sub Here............Very Well Done...........
Please subscribe:)
who's playing the bass
Bob, the one in the middle is playing bass:) We overdubbed it after we realized it was needed. If you watch the video to the end there a few shots of him playing it.
Sounds great but, lose the "AND" before the "I am sorry" and " I am lonely" parts. Keep rockin' guys! Just loosen up a little, and you'll be perfect. You're the best I've heard, and I've been listening to CSNY since 1980.
Gracias, but watch a few videos of Stills singing this song, he often adds the "And" in before the "I am sorry" and "I am lonely".
Am I mistaken that I hear a 4th part of harmony?
Hmmm, we did it a few years ago. I'm not positive but I'm sure one of us may have doubled/ thrown in an extra harmony. When we do it live we will use 5 voices.
ruclips.net/video/ZPRyFbFpAGw/видео.html
Ken McCauley both versions are really nice! Great job.
😘Love ye dad
Who plays the Bass? Playback?
+cure969 Bob, the one in the middle plays the bass. After listening to the playback we realized that is needed a little more low end so he overdubbed the bass. He's in the video playing the bass but it's a little later in the song:)
Fantastic stuff! He missed a bit on the Spanish lyrics, there was no "oh va, OH VA!"
All depends on what version you're talking about and that specific individuals pronunciation and accent.
nice rendition, should also credit the bass player
Thank you:) Bob, the one in the middle, also did the bass track.
That bass guitar, though.
Hey Cliff. We sneak the bass guitar in at the end. We have a live version on RUclips as well.
Where's the bass player?
Did you watch until the end? The song was pre recorded then we shot the vid. Here's a live version of us doing it. Bass player and all. ruclips.net/video/ZPRyFbFpAGw/видео.html
Awesome you guys keep practicing you almost got it.......breaking balls, you nailed it hat song
Ken is my dad I’m cash McCauley
Hey Buddy, love ya!!
Love you too!
Nice job, Who needs Neil Young
Good guitar and harmonies.but you gotta step up the energy,guys. More passion please!
Hola Paul, here's a video of us doing this live if you want to check it out. Just a bit more passion:) Have a great 2019!
ruclips.net/video/ZPRyFbFpAGw/видео.html
um..... F&F
how fake
How so? We recorded the song in a studio and this is the video we made for it. If you would like to see us cover this song live you can watch it here ruclips.net/video/ZPRyFbFpAGw/видео.html
Nice