Dumbest Movie Premise of All Time? - MOVIE FIGHTS - Last Fighter Standing!

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 3 фев 2025

Комментарии • 2 тыс.

  • @BobbieJuanKenobi
    @BobbieJuanKenobi 8 лет назад +426

    I'm a vet and kicking Joe out of that round was absolutely stupid. His pitch was hilarious and anyone who got offended needs to pull their panties up and deal with it.

    • @BobbieJuanKenobi
      @BobbieJuanKenobi 8 лет назад +6

      Sean Bowling
      Yep, I love Andy, but he was wrong.

    • @MrKylecarlson
      @MrKylecarlson 8 лет назад +36

      I'm also a vet and there was nothing offensive about his pitch. It was meant as comedy. The whole context is silly and he even quickly clarified of course he isn't demeaning service members. The movie was not a true story btw. People need to stop kissing the ass of veterans, they are assholes too just like everyone else,

    • @BobbieJuanKenobi
      @BobbieJuanKenobi 8 лет назад

      *****
      Oh, it was for sure a a bad argument even for the ridiculousness of the whole scenario. I'm sure he'd have lost the round.

    • @SP_understars
      @SP_understars 8 лет назад +11

      Also a veteran here, and I agree that it IS a ridiculous premise--at least for the military that we have now. Even if he would have lost this round, I still would have liked to hear the argument. :'/

    • @Shugabug657
      @Shugabug657 8 лет назад +2

      I also agree Andy got it wrong with kicking Joe out early.

  • @DarkPanthera
    @DarkPanthera 8 лет назад +180

    'we don't politics in movie fights it's just for fun'
    'you have to leave we love our veterans we love America'

    • @MarcosLopez-ky5yg
      @MarcosLopez-ky5yg 8 лет назад +2

      Osaro Azams merica!!!!

    • @sarahsue123
      @sarahsue123 8 лет назад +3

      Osaro Azams supporting veterans isn't politics that's just being an American

  • @amybrown1823
    @amybrown1823 8 лет назад +308

    Andy, you owe Joe Star a serious and public apology. You are supposed to judge what is said, not personal opinion. He was going to explain himself. You should have let him finish speaking and allowed him to defend himself from your anti-vet accusations.

    • @buckybarnes2026
      @buckybarnes2026 8 лет назад +12

      yeah, he did the same thing last time and it's so dumb. He's not disrespecting anyone, he's just trying to answer a question that is clearly a joke and ridiculous.

    • @amybrown1823
      @amybrown1823 8 лет назад +4

      To be honest, I wanted to hear his pitch.

    • @Kiskey
      @Kiskey 8 лет назад +27

      Ironic that Andy hates bringing up POLITICS, but only judges people based on THIER politics... What a hypocrite

    • @Beastmig3415
      @Beastmig3415 8 лет назад +1

      Relax

    • @amybrown1823
      @amybrown1823 8 лет назад +3

      To be fair, there are those who would consider a talking dog a lot more valuable than any human being (PETA, anyone? )

  • @ricardobentes
    @ricardobentes 8 лет назад +63

    Poorly poorly handled by Andy the dictator kicking out Joe. you knew the answers before hand, if you didn't like them you should have told Joe before the show or changed the question on the show. If you're going to kick him out then you should've left as well since you're as much to blame as he was.

  • @jeremylefevre9610
    @jeremylefevre9610 8 лет назад +211

    I'm kinda really upset that Joe got kicked out after winning on a religion based on not taking things seriously! He completely set us up for following his jokes to success, and Andy immediately forgot all about that from the previous question.

    • @jeremylefevre9610
      @jeremylefevre9610 8 лет назад +20

      And then that happened instead. I honestly thing Saving Private Ryan with dog would be way better than Pawcific Rim, or taken. Once again the round got caught up on Mance's weird answer and no one responded to the other movies.

    • @writingref
      @writingref 8 лет назад +12

      Jeremy Lefevre Andy really needs to apologize for that. I am
      A veteran and I am more offended that they didn't let Joe argue when this is a non serious show. There are lots of good dog soldiers. Hello! They even made a movie about one.

    • @Lucyfrmearth
      @Lucyfrmearth 8 лет назад +1

      Jeremy Lefevre seriously!!! Plus I didn't see any disrespect to veterans...

    • @jeremylefevre9610
      @jeremylefevre9610 8 лет назад +2

      Travis Hightower +Lucyfrmearth Right, all he was saying is we'd rather save the only talking dog soldier than one of many million human soldiers. Turning a movie into a talking dog movie that sounds like a great premise..

    • @Benception
      @Benception 8 лет назад

      A REAL LIFE WAR STORY replaced with a talking dog, better than a couple of blockbusters replaced with talking dogs? It is a little offensive.

  • @VeggieGamer
    @VeggieGamer 8 лет назад +557

    I sometimes find Joe a lil annoying, but I think he was completely screwed over in this, and I don't mean just in the game! He made what any rational person would realise was a JOKE and he was booted out without having any chance to clarify! Andy made him appear to be saying it was face-value! If you want to kick him out of the round, do it at the end of it, but stopping the round and getting him out of there made what was SO CLEARLY A JOKE seem serious! Which is weird as you guys were seemingly completely fine with the Nazi stuff that followed later in the show. Really odd decision imo. Not surprised he left straight after as he was completely humiliated by the other idiots saying that he was "disrespecting the troops". You completely buried the guy!

    • @bobjones3563
      @bobjones3563 8 лет назад +53

      Not to mention the fact they know what answers they guys are going to give beforehand and could have raised any concerns off air. That whole part of the show seemed contrived, almost scripted to me.

    • @VeggieGamer
      @VeggieGamer 8 лет назад +13

      This is a very good point!!

    • @DarkKnight95sm
      @DarkKnight95sm 8 лет назад +1

      I disagree, I think jokes can go too far (just ask anyone who has been verbally bullied) and in the past, they might have felt they were walking a little too close to that line. At first glance, it might seem innocent which is why it was accepted as an answer, to begin with, but the response from the other contestants and the fan cam kind of showed that maybe the answer inherently wasn't going too far but there was a good chance that it would in the argument, maybe not by Joe himself either. Joe might have thought it through and came up with an argument that would not be offensive but there is no predicting what the other contestants might say or come up with on the spot and what knee jerk comeback might come from it. On the flip side, the other contestants might also feel like they have to be more cautious with the way they fight him in that battle.

    • @bobjones3563
      @bobjones3563 8 лет назад +28

      Even given that argument though, the way in which he was ejected as if he had done something heinous was way over the top, the way Andy phrased it suggested he was being thrown out for "disrespecting the troops". He wasn't given the chance to think of another or come back in another round, he was disqualified from the tournament. Still completely unfair and OTT

    • @Noble_Savage
      @Noble_Savage 8 лет назад +3

      A lot of people I know love Saving Private Ryan for its realism of war.
      Many WWII vets say that the film illustrated d-day perfectly, and Joe
      saying that the movie is unrealistic and the story-line would never
      happen in real-life was going to tick someone off.
      his pick was in bad taste but he shouldn't have been kicked out of there and insulted by the others.

  • @kingofwakanda6899
    @kingofwakanda6899 8 лет назад +42

    The Parr Family (The Incredibles) would be a pretty cool family to be part of. Or maybe Vin Diesel's Furious Family, since he doesn't have friends, they're all family.

    • @NCBCSPRINGRETREAT
      @NCBCSPRINGRETREAT 8 лет назад

      She does yell a lot though.

    • @Borat69able
      @Borat69able 8 лет назад +3

      Mrs. Parr is also really hot so that's a plus.

    • @mbanerjee5889
      @mbanerjee5889 8 лет назад

      I'm surprised no one said the Weasleys.

  • @TheRichardson711
    @TheRichardson711 8 лет назад +118

    military and police dogs are considered actual members of those forces. I think it was offensive to military dogs to kick out joe star. I'm so offended!

  • @darthiraecorpus
    @darthiraecorpus 8 лет назад +44

    I was US Infantry for six years, fought both in Iraq and Afghanistan. Nothing Joe said offended me or was insulting to veterans. I understand that Saving Private Ryan was based on a true story, but that was a congressman using one soldiers situation for their political agenda. Sending a unit in to pull one soldier out is not the norm and is unrealistic. They would not send him if he was a last survivor, they would pull him out at the earliest opportunity if he was a last survivor, but would not typically send a unit to go retrieve him. If a soldier in a K9 unit tells his dog "We'll get through this buddy," and the Golden Retriever turned to his handler and spoke "Acutally, I think we're screwed this time," Then sending a unit in to retrieve a talking dog is more believable than pretending like the original premise of the film is a normal event. It was a bizarre one fueled by political gain rather than army doctrine.

  • @juansalva_
    @juansalva_ 8 лет назад +90

    Kicking Joe out was pure BS. They were replacing Matt Damon, not a real veteran. They took it too personal. Kicking him out was way too stupid.

    • @Bruno3605
      @Bruno3605 8 лет назад +8

      Juan Salvador Valverde Also, thinking about the movie itself: Matt Damon's role would not suffer if it was played by a dog. That show judge guy is shit.

  • @krustomer
    @krustomer 8 лет назад +286

    Joe is too lovable for this

    • @michaelbass3456
      @michaelbass3456 8 лет назад +45

      Seriously it's like they were LOOKING for something to be offended by :(

    • @poontang3zizo
      @poontang3zizo 8 лет назад +5

      Welcome to 2016

  • @SkatKat
    @SkatKat 8 лет назад +182

    What was the issue with the saving private ryan dog replacement? In the movie they were aware of how all of the efforts put into returning one person home in the midst of a war was ridiculous. It was for a publicity stunt. For a talking dog, however, maybe it would be less ridiculous. Either way, how did war veterans come into all of that? And how did they come up to such a worrying extent that they had to send someone off for it? It was an argument for a talking dog in a war movie.

    • @flixerdk7947
      @flixerdk7947 8 лет назад +9

      I don't get it either.

    • @SkatKat
      @SkatKat 8 лет назад

      I'm happy I'm not the only one confused by this.

    • @kingplunger1
      @kingplunger1 8 лет назад +1

      y, I didn't even think andy was serious because it seemed so ridiculous

    • @edwardv1255
      @edwardv1255 8 лет назад +2

      Really weird to bring "liberal ideologies" in here, Grailsarvas, as the idea of glorifying anything done by American troops and past, present and future is an extremely conservative concept.

  • @JunkYardDog175
    @JunkYardDog175 8 лет назад +741

    I feel awful for Joe, it was a silly question that everyone was giving joke answers for and everyone there implied he was insulting veterans. That goes beyond a game, if I were him I'd never go on the show again.

    • @werion10
      @werion10 8 лет назад +1

      JunkYardDog175 Agree

    • @KingGumpers
      @KingGumpers 8 лет назад +17

      I think it was a smart move on Andy's part. he could see how the arguments were going to go after Joe said They wouldn't save him just cause hes some lady's last son. he was up against the 2 worst people for that as well, Andreyko and Spencer have no qualms about going heel to make you look like a shit person.

    • @lesc9532
      @lesc9532 8 лет назад +15

      I feel bad for Joe but I think Andy did the right thing as a moderator. Their audience is fairly large. They have to be careful because of that. While Joe gave a joke answer, it was already a little too close to the "Uh oh" line that Andy did what he thought was best to make sure it didn't go way too far by the time the fight was over.

    • @werion10
      @werion10 8 лет назад +25

      I think it was wrong, he kick him off because he misunderstood the situation. He shouldn't have play the "Respect the veterans" card to avoid the criticism of the U.S. War Economy.

    • @shadowfragment
      @shadowfragment 8 лет назад +95

      What can you do, Americans are weird about their super intense patriotism and militarism. People giving up their lives for others is something to be respected, but the idea that it can't be criticised or parodied is kind of a dangerous way of thinking. And yet, it didn't surprise me at all. Just disappointing.

  • @haleemulhassan9158
    @haleemulhassan9158 8 лет назад +121

    #SavingPoorJoe What a horrible decision to kick him out on his awesome premise, and even worse, what a horrible horrible way to humiliate your own colleague in front of the whole world like that. GTFO Andy, this show deserves a better judge

    • @MrAustyn88
      @MrAustyn88 8 лет назад +15

      Haleem ul Hassan That is the biggest slap to the face that more people need to notice; Andy publicly humiliated Joe. Up until this point Ive actually been one of the people who enjoy Andy. That is no longer the case because he is a damn asshat

  • @uberchemist
    @uberchemist 8 лет назад +41

    I have to chime in and echo what so many others have already commented: kicking off Joe Starr before he could argue his choice was misguided and tasteless. Just because the others started tearing into his argument, Andy just had to jump on that wagon and take it to such a serious level. If you did your homework and his pick bothered you that much, nix it before the show goes live. The show should be fun.

  • @r0kus
    @r0kus 8 лет назад +63

    I can understand why Joe left. It can't feel good to be accused of taking an anti-vet stance. OTOH, I thought he should have been eliminated the round before with his really dumb Ace Ventura religion thing.

    • @RavenGlenn
      @RavenGlenn 8 лет назад +8

      Huh...and here I thought my girlfriend went to Afghanistan as a medic to help heal people. Good to know she was shooting at brown people for oil. You've changed my entire view on life!

    • @user-lm6db2pw3n
      @user-lm6db2pw3n 8 лет назад +4

      Ned Malcom, how the hell did 24 low-life people agree with you. You are a disgrace for believing this.

  • @targaryenbatman5728
    @targaryenbatman5728 8 лет назад +384

    Kicking joestar out was bs, it would have been an awesome fight!

    • @ttm77777
      @ttm77777 8 лет назад +21

      he would have won

    • @yang-geenam9793
      @yang-geenam9793 8 лет назад +12

      Would not have minded the ruling if he kicked out other fighters immediately after bringing up the Holocaust or bestiality.

    • @PurpleBadger
      @PurpleBadger 8 лет назад +1

      Yeah that seemed... outta nowhere?

    • @Xizura
      @Xizura 8 лет назад

      That was fucking garbage I agree.

    • @PurpleBadger
      @PurpleBadger 8 лет назад +13

      Yang-Gee Nam Yeah. There's been a tonne of answers regarding WW2 movies, and jokes about Schindler's List & that one Nazi-baby movie pitch w/ the pregnant Nazi woman running away but Oh God, someone suggested saving an army dog? & the reaction was so OTT & I'm not shocked he left. That was... really odd.

  • @OpenMind3000
    @OpenMind3000 8 лет назад +37

    Usually I don´t agee with all the dislikes, but I don´t agree with the disqualification in the dog round

  • @BruceWayne-wh4of
    @BruceWayne-wh4of 8 лет назад +300

    Really? Kicking Joe out, just because he replaced Private Ryan with the dog? He's right, the movie is unrealistic and not very good, and just because its "based on true events" (which isnt really right) its not a good reason to kick him out. Thats not objective enough, and to patriotic for me. It ruined the whole fight. I'm out of this.

    • @BruceWayne-wh4of
      @BruceWayne-wh4of 8 лет назад

      Matt Lewis yeah sorry

    • @BruceWayne-wh4of
      @BruceWayne-wh4of 8 лет назад

      TOKAGERO1 Why? Just because I think its ridiculous to kick him out because of that reason?

    • @BruceWayne-wh4of
      @BruceWayne-wh4of 8 лет назад

      TOKAGERO1 Oh. Sorry for blaming you.

    • @8035568045
      @8035568045 8 лет назад

      Multiple cases in US military history, where brass has tried to save the last of blood lines during war.
      also, I say he got cheated out, but the events that taken place have actually happen a decent amount.

    • @BruceWayne-wh4of
      @BruceWayne-wh4of 8 лет назад +3

      DCv1 Gaming Yeah, but its unrealistic that they would go that far, to save ONE person. And this just because, his mother wanted that.

  • @redxix88
    @redxix88 8 лет назад +323

    You should have multiple judges on this show. Andy can be really unfair and biased.
    Kicking Joe out like that was incredibly embarrassing...

    • @mikehiebert6227
      @mikehiebert6227 8 лет назад +19

      redxix88 I know, it's really unfortunate. I watch other screen junkies shows plus shows with Andy in them predominantly and he's a really nice, a-dork-able type of guy who's genuinely funny, but he so frequently misunderstands things and states the questions improperly, putting the fighters at a disadvantage... Dan (as grumpy as he gets) and Spencer are the only clear sighted level headed guys on staff

    • @SvartePeter
      @SvartePeter 8 лет назад

      Agreed.

    • @gasparxciv
      @gasparxciv 8 лет назад

      What disability?

  • @BenDPB
    @BenDPB 8 лет назад +44

    You guys were harsh as hell about a talking damn dog, it's a comedy show and he ain't insulting veterans in the slightest. Poor showing Andy

  • @fsyeah
    @fsyeah 8 лет назад +53

    55:52 A joke that compares talking out of your ass to Catholicism (1 billion followers/worshipers), doesn't get you kicked out.
    1:03:00 A joke answer to a joke question, revolving around a fictional story about WWII soldiers, gets you kicked out.

  • @cocaloca5402
    @cocaloca5402 8 лет назад +153

    Major BS Andy...Joe did not deserve this, you are getting too sensitive for a comedy show

    • @blusafe1
      @blusafe1 8 лет назад

      I saw why he did that, the veteran thing would have spiraled out of control quickly. But he could have done other things like force him to choose another movie or dismiss that round.

    • @cocaloca5402
      @cocaloca5402 8 лет назад +1

      blusafe1 You are right, it was a hot potato issue, and I agree, he should have handled it a bit more diplomatic fashion, perhaps he was caught off guard

    • @angryreaper9336
      @angryreaper9336 8 лет назад

      blusafe1 yeah, I'm going to agree with this. It's a very touchy subject and could have easily gotten out of hand, but should have been handled very very differently instead of the shit show Andy created. Don't they email in their answers before the show? They didn't see this coming?

    • @bravosix64
      @bravosix64 8 лет назад +1

      It is touchy lol idk if you guys watch the other videos but Joe doesn't take his fights seriously. He jokes a lot in his fights (which is not a bad thing) but I think he would've said some cringeworthy things.

  • @prodbypoetics
    @prodbypoetics 8 лет назад +50

    Can't joke about saving private Ryan.
    But can make several jokes bout beastiality.
    Well okay then..

  • @12345eternal
    @12345eternal 8 лет назад +85

    Hi Screenjunkies.
    I'm a huge fan, and I watch every episode. I don't comment much though, since I keep my opinions to myself mostly. But kicking Joe out due to his pitch was unfair and he was treated extremely poorly. Respecting veterans is important, but the question is about a talking dog, and its supposed to be taken in the way the question is phrased - lightly and casually. He didn't mean any disrespect to the vets, and I'm sure that Saving the Golden Retriever Ryan would have made for a fun and interesting topic to debate on. I know that the judge is the final decision, but this decision was absolutely unfair and my support goes out wholeheartedly to Joe. On a very instinctive level, this move hurt me and I hope you guys don't end up losing fans over unfair judgments.
    Thanks.

    • @starrypanda1394
      @starrypanda1394 8 лет назад +3

      ill still watch but hate that call, it was total shit

    • @kingplunger1
      @kingplunger1 8 лет назад

      12345eternal y, at first i thought that he is just joking. really ridiculous...

  • @chrish7472
    @chrish7472 8 лет назад +76

    That transphobic comment was really misguided

    • @Nicholasryan17
      @Nicholasryan17 8 лет назад +26

      It was out of place, not said in the argument, not mentioned by anyone at all, wasn't relevant, and is someone bringing conflict that was obviously never intended in the first place. Any movie pre like the last 5 years is obviously going to be "transphobic" since it wasn't something tackled by our society yet

  • @feverishyak
    @feverishyak 8 лет назад +41

    Joe star did not deserve to be kicked off the panel wtf Andy? You guys completely threw him under the bus there, poor guy.

  • @jadenfragoso6746
    @jadenfragoso6746 8 лет назад +154

    The fact that Andy kicked Joe off of the show is ridiculous. Andy is literally the worst part of this show and I hope he lets someone else judge in future episodes.

    • @cheezyria
      @cheezyria 8 лет назад +1

      yes

    • @MirrorAshes
      @MirrorAshes 8 лет назад +2

      Jaden Fragoso truth

    • @Hrvo182
      @Hrvo182 8 лет назад +3

      Yes. Please!

    • @DaniZam41
      @DaniZam41 8 лет назад +5

      Agree we need a new judge please, or maybe a judging panel.

    • @_UPRC
      @_UPRC 6 лет назад +6

      Hal is doing way better as the host these days.

  • @Fangs1978
    @Fangs1978 8 лет назад +57

    Kicking Joe was fucked up. Would have been easy enough to boot him based on the argument at the end of the fight since "last survivor" was an actual policy in the US army at the time, but no, you have to go all righteous and shut down debate and comedy on a show that is supposed to be about both. Buuuuhhhh Andy, buuuuhhhh. Thumbs way down.

  • @ahydra3242
    @ahydra3242 8 лет назад +478

    Poor Joe. I actually liked his the most. Too bad everyone gets offended so easily.

    • @GnashingOvTeeth
      @GnashingOvTeeth 8 лет назад +21

      Dada Loompa I know right. I mean I love Scott but joe didn't deserve to get kicked off.

    • @ilStefanoable
      @ilStefanoable 8 лет назад +12

      savage humor is looked down upon in movie fights which is why spencer lost the last one ( the harry potter one)

    • @domingomonjarassalazar2039
      @domingomonjarassalazar2039 8 лет назад +1

      I completely disagree. I respect what you're trying to say but when Joe said that he couldn't understand why the military would send a group of soldiers to save one of their own because he was her last son, that was out of line. Not just bc it was an actual regulation of the military during the darkest times in history but bc it was an actual true story and he disregarded the bond and loyalty soldiers have for one another. i didn't think it was enough to get him kicked out but I thought it was enough to have him lose the round.

    • @bloodstarkidlander9159
      @bloodstarkidlander9159 8 лет назад +3

      Yup. Humor, at its core, IS offensive. IT WAS A JOKE QUESTION. PC is damaging the way people think and to see the nervousness and groupthinking we all need to avoid rear its ugly head in a show I enjoy is disheartening. You f'ed up, Andy Signore. Quit being such a fuddy duddy.

    • @jamesfranco1997
      @jamesfranco1997 8 лет назад +3

      yeah. i love america, but he shouldnt have gotten kicked off

  • @bryanb97
    @bryanb97 8 лет назад +426

    What I don't get is, don't they give their answers in advance to make sure that the other players don't have the same answer.... so why didn't they tell Joe when he gave his answer before the show "Hey that might offend our veteran how about pick a different one.".... instead of getting butt-hurt about it on a internet show and looking like a massive prick

    • @SirMasterRattington
      @SirMasterRattington 8 лет назад

      Agreed.

    • @ritzda8988
      @ritzda8988 8 лет назад +3

      I don't think it was his pick as much as what he said to support it afterward that did it, but I'm new to this so I have no idea the particular nuances that go on with this show.

    • @SirBlackjack010
      @SirBlackjack010 8 лет назад +58

      Andy really looks like a prick, it was Joes answer and it was good enough. That "we do not disrespect our veterans" bullcrap only shows how blind he is regarding dumb patriotism. Disappointing, ruined a otherwise funny episode.

    • @bradwright9477
      @bradwright9477 8 лет назад +18

      KTK Don't be so simple minded. They treated Joe like shit. No debate there

    • @Iva744
      @Iva744 8 лет назад +1

      Grailsarvas, Pretty sure she made that argument because a lot of movies contain extreme violence. Not penis mutilation, no, but violence is not unusual in movies at all. She was going for a more psychological sort of torture (though I still think her whole choice of movie and argument sucked). Maybe I'm wrong, but I don't think she was going for a "torture all the dicks!"-argument.

  • @80VersuS
    @80VersuS 8 лет назад +96

    Most ridiculous thing ever to happen on ANY SJ production. Political correctness of mega idiocy. The hypocrisy sometimes is like a tsunami of turds. Andy you have the ego of a Michael Bay movie.

    • @ThatTriniGamer
      @ThatTriniGamer 8 лет назад +8

      LOLZ love your comment!!! Andy really gets me mad sometimes, he comes across a bit douchie. When he makes a ruling that I don't like I just exit the video.

    • @earam88
      @earam88 8 лет назад +1

      andy is always the worst part of the show, hes so annoying

  • @heikkijhautanen4576
    @heikkijhautanen4576 3 года назад +3

    That Hair Spray on loop would be True torture :D

  • @Slaphappy1975
    @Slaphappy1975 8 лет назад +47

    This is probably the first time I agreed with the majority opinion in the comments section. It's OK to make fun of global religions but not US soldiers? Total BS.

    • @daraghokane4236
      @daraghokane4236 8 лет назад +1

      luckystriker yes because people should ridicule beliefs even there own

  • @sillyskeleton
    @sillyskeleton 8 лет назад +34

    Man, these guys need to lighten up. I wanted to hear the pitch for Saving Pooch Ryan.

  • @ragingfiip
    @ragingfiip 8 лет назад +4

    Haha, I love how you can hear Coy's distinctive laugh from the couch in the background at 54:37.

  • @joen0411
    @joen0411 8 лет назад +24

    Replace Keanu Reeves with a talking dog in John Wick. I think that would be hilarious

    • @TrueSnolk
      @TrueSnolk 8 лет назад +34

      joen0411 "They killed his Keanu Reeves!"

    • @Exarathas
      @Exarathas 8 лет назад +1

      Yeah because then it would be a dog going on a killing spree for revenge of his dog friend

  • @kexmi8706
    @kexmi8706 8 лет назад +216

    Andy is easily the WORST part of Movie Fights. He doesn't even follow his own rules.

    • @Kiskey
      @Kiskey 8 лет назад +11

      They need to let LON host and tell ANDY "BYE, BYE"

    • @tigerija
      @tigerija 8 лет назад +5

      The biggest problem with their "judging on arguments" is that they judge it from their point of view. Andy has his own point of view while everyone else there has own point of view. Makes all the difference.
      And you can notice this very well with that speed round bargen bin twist. I think that guy said that he would give that "fat wedding something movie" to his family BECAUSE THEY LIKE THOSE KIND OF MOVIES. So that is a GOOD GIFT. Other members there see that movie as bad movie personally and they see this as bad gift. Its two different personal opinion on same thing. Then again, sometimes people ignore arguments and just choose based on what they think would go with as if they are answering.
      I agree with Dan's point of view there for example. But most were other way around.
      Ofc you will get people who do not agree with judgment because if its about taste, its almost impossible to have 100% of people being on same side.
      And I feel like its hard to judge those things xD. Its what Andy THINKS is best argument and also probably one he THINKS most people would agree with.

    • @iheartsleep
      @iheartsleep 8 лет назад +2

      10thplague Entertainment seriously....it's frustrating to watch this channel sometimes specifically because he can't follow his own rules of "based on the arguments" he just picks what he likes. also, as soon as JTE corrected him on how the genre relates to the premise, I knew he was a goner lol.

    • @kexmi8706
      @kexmi8706 8 лет назад +2

      deadsexy1985 lol exactly!

    • @JackDManheim
      @JackDManheim 7 лет назад +5

      the worst part of movie fights is the comment section

  • @OptimusGPrime
    @OptimusGPrime 7 лет назад +10

    I know this episode happened a while ago, but I only just watched it now. I have to say that I'm very disappointed in the treatment Joe received. His answer was never fully explained, and to be honest, I think it got completely misconstrued. We're talking about a very silly question; replacing the main character in a movie, with a talking dog. How can you ask such a question, and not take the answers lightly? It was completely unfair. Lighten up guys!

  • @Saldo30
    @Saldo30 8 лет назад +8

    "Can I get out of the shot while he demeans our veterans" hilarious.

    • @DarkPanthera
      @DarkPanthera 8 лет назад +5

      yet Spencer had no problem making fun of Luna Lovegood bring bullied

    • @dylancaleb4169
      @dylancaleb4169 8 лет назад +1

      Vansmackable I like Spencer, I think he was just carrying on with the joke, and wasnt actually offended. I cant believe that they kicked Joe off for that

  • @Shmotivated
    @Shmotivated 8 лет назад +5

    I genuinely like every single fighter on this episode. Best way to spend my Saturday afternoon!

  • @ConspiracyTheatre
    @ConspiracyTheatre 8 лет назад +19

    Legitimately disappointed that Joe was kicked out for the Saving Private Ryan pick. It was a ridiculous question, and his answer was the most amusing. This shows best moments derive from those sorts of things

  • @matthewwhite2155
    @matthewwhite2155 8 лет назад +15

    Thumbs down for Joe being kicked out mid-round for what is clearly a joke. Joe is owed an apology for how he was treated, especially when you know what the answer is going to be before they say it!

  • @chazzyloveee
    @chazzyloveee 8 лет назад +24

    Why kick Joe out? Joe clearly said that he respected the vets but believe at as a FILM saving private ryan would be better with a talking dog. So what? Film is art and it's allowed to be critiqued and reinterpreted however anyone pleases and that's what joe did. Andy clearly let his personal bias get in the way of his judgement and humiliated Joe (I felt embarrassed for him so imagine how he must've felt). Andy didn't even give Joe an opportunity to justify his answer. A very low moment in movie fights, I honestly had to stop watching for a while after seeing that because it was that bad to me.

  • @superstreet7
    @superstreet7 8 лет назад +13

    Is it just me who really doesn't enjoy listening to any of Scott's arguments...?
    Replacing Joe for Scott was ridiculous as well. Don't take yourself so seriously guys!

  • @tyreliverson7841
    @tyreliverson7841 8 лет назад +36

    Wow... Just wow that was so uncalled for, joe honestly did not deserve that boot

  • @LakierosJordy
    @LakierosJordy 8 лет назад +512

    I hope you guys apologise to Joe after this, that was awful. Trying to make him look bad and literally kicking him out for making a joke on a comedy show - shameful display really.

    • @JordanArthur14
      @JordanArthur14 8 лет назад +17

      Yeah, I thought it was a very funny idea. Veterans aren't bad I don't think that was what he was saying. He was only trying to hype a silly talking dog movie. That was a real bummer. I wanted to hear him fight for that. Joe is always so great. I imagine the trailers for this being the most dramatic thing ever and then there is a dog with a slightly askew helmet and a cigar sticking out of his mouth XD

    • @Thetruthiscosmic
      @Thetruthiscosmic 8 лет назад +64

      Yeah I'm still trying to understand why Andy did that. It's true that logistically speaking, it isn't realistic for an entire team of soldiers to all risk their lives just to save one. Anyone who knows a thing about WW2 knows that (and the movie is very loosely based on a true story, loosely).
      Regardless, switching Private Ryan with a talking dog isn't in any way disrespectful to veterans and I think Joe didn't deserve to get kicked out for ANSWERING THE QUESTION.

    • @tigerija
      @tigerija 8 лет назад +2

      I think it was not personal at all. It was just a show. At least I hope that's what it was. Otherwise it would be very stupid move by Andy. There are many other ways to resolve this issue - since it was pointed out and seen as issue by Andy. But it doesnt really matter one or other. Quite sure they wont become enemies or something now, lol. Its not like they are two kids...

    • @ericstaples7220
      @ericstaples7220 8 лет назад +1

      @ Mary Lohe There is plenty of logic behind it. It boosts morale having soldiers know that they won't be left behind and that their country and government actually cares about each of them. Soldiers with a high morale are many times better fighters than soldiers with low morale. It's not as simple as saying 5 lives are worth more than 1 life. And if we are talking a numbers game, the characters in SPR killed way more Nazi's than lives lost themselves.

    • @Thetruthiscosmic
      @Thetruthiscosmic 8 лет назад +5

      Eric Staples Look, special snowflake, that all sounds really nice and sweet, morale boosts and candy canes. But that's Hollywood. The reality of war is much, much harsher than that. In WW2, soldiers' morale was Commanders and Generals' last concern.
      SPR is very loosely based on a true story, but the person on who it's based, Edward Niland, was a prisoner in a Japanese POW camp and was liberated towards the end of the war. There was never a special mission, to rescue a special soldier, to boost morale and all that bullshit.And since I don't feel like typing anymore, here are some links for you.
      mentalfloss.com/article/65611/15-fascinating-facts-about-saving-private-ryan
      en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Niland_brothers
      www.buffalo.edu/ubreporter/archive/vol30/vol30n2/n3.html
      Notices the terms LOOSELY BASED always being used.
      Last but not least, it's Nazis not Nazi's. Learn how apostrophes work.

  • @kcsoup3
    @kcsoup3 8 лет назад +2

    Mike is so effortlessly funny, it's amazing. Please come back more regularly!!

  • @dylancaleb4169
    @dylancaleb4169 8 лет назад +47

    Disliking for Joe, I hope the channel actually voices a public apology, that was horrible enough to watch, i cant imagine how bad it would have been for poor Joe.
    Does anyone know what happened, a few comments said stuff about him leaving the show after? Whats that about?

    • @TimmahYoung
      @TimmahYoung 8 лет назад +17

      ROBOTRIPPIN ROBOT He probably walked out to stop himself from publicly calling out Andy on his B.S., or to prove a point. Either way, good for Joe.

    • @Bruno3605
      @Bruno3605 8 лет назад +10

      ROBOTRIPPIN ROBOT Yeah, f what they did to joe, pricks

  • @madviolentchicken
    @madviolentchicken 8 лет назад +45

    Joe Starr got screwed! That was set for a fantastic pick and I wanted to see that properly fought - it sounded hilarious.

  • @TheBlond49
    @TheBlond49 8 лет назад +123

    Worst torture movie: *Son of The Mask*, it's so insufferable.

    • @TundraCH
      @TundraCH 8 лет назад +1

      That movie is a mess! it is so damn bad lol

    • @billys2736
      @billys2736 8 лет назад +2

      Kal-El fan 49 norm of the north... There shall be no fights today.

    • @lisaibitayo9048
      @lisaibitayo9048 8 лет назад +1

      Ah, the horror that is Son of the Mask.

    • @waltermcdonough
      @waltermcdonough 8 лет назад +1

      birdemic

    • @daegan_ftw
      @daegan_ftw 8 лет назад +2

      The real worst movie to watch on repeat would be Human Centipede 2.

  • @Calzaki
    @Calzaki 8 лет назад +4

    The Ben Affleck Armaggedon audio commentary would win round 2 by itself. its hilarious

  • @chris-cg3rg
    @chris-cg3rg 8 лет назад +1

    Manz is probably one of my favorite fighters, every time he's in the room he brings good energy.

  • @SeekingFilm
    @SeekingFilm 8 лет назад +2

    I love how Mike is always so quick on his feet to think outside the box!

  • @metalincamelot1965
    @metalincamelot1965 8 лет назад +14

    Taking Joe out was stupid

  • @MCMonsterbuilder
    @MCMonsterbuilder 8 лет назад +96

    If I'd want to torture someone, I'd make him watch that girls "sing" that stupid song 24/7. It was annoying af even for 30 seconds.

    • @Graybat12
      @Graybat12 8 лет назад

      If I wanted to torture someone I would find an alt ending of the Babadook that ends in murder suicide. That would actually ruin someone.

    • @Graybat12
      @Graybat12 8 лет назад

      Most movies will bore the hell out of you and you'll just tune out, so you have to pick something that won't let you tune out or fall asleep in peace.

    • @youseemerolan
      @youseemerolan 8 лет назад +6

      MoFBox maybe, just maybe! that was the entire point of her singing? to be annoying? but idk

    • @MCMonsterbuilder
      @MCMonsterbuilder 8 лет назад +1

      youseemerolan Yeah pretty sure that this was her whole point, she would have gotten the point if I was judging just to make her Stop

  • @mikhaeldaoudi795
    @mikhaeldaoudi795 8 лет назад +30

    Kicking out Joe Starr was a disgusting move by Andy

  • @JacobHG1234
    @JacobHG1234 8 лет назад +55

    Thumbs up for a new judge.. Andy.. your time has come to move on buddy.

    • @JacobHG1234
      @JacobHG1234 8 лет назад

      and come on.. The Good, the Bad and the Ugly... 6 words or more

    • @MarMotorbiker
      @MarMotorbiker 8 лет назад +5

      what happened to joe was BS

    • @420simpson
      @420simpson 7 лет назад +2

      lol andy is literally the creator of screen junkies. He employs all of these people, so you cannot simply leave a comment asking for him to be removed.

    • @projectbelmont7177
      @projectbelmont7177 6 лет назад +1

      Wish granted. Thank god.

  • @ragingfiip
    @ragingfiip 8 лет назад +2

    This was a really fun episode of Movie Fights. What a great group of people!

  • @hellotybeeren
    @hellotybeeren 8 лет назад +28

    There is a difference between being "offended"/"triggered" and being open to the idea that the plot to a much beloved film might be objectively insensitive. I actually thought Joe had the strongest argument, believe it or not.
    That said, if I had gotten in there, I'd have replaced Mark Wahlberg's character in Boogie Nights with a Golden Retriever. #whatagoodboy #averyverygoodboy

  • @dontedoestuff
    @dontedoestuff 8 лет назад +13

    I'm trying to wrap my head around the fact that Joe got eliminated for being "disrespectful" but Mike was fine for saying he wants to be in a family trying to escape Nazi Germany is just jokey enough...

  • @AndromedaDreams1
    @AndromedaDreams1 8 лет назад +18

    man you his destroyed Joe. Its one thing to disagree with him but that dude was so embarrassed and you guys just fed him to the wolves. i love this group of people but i would never return if i was Joe.

  • @ShelbyBaby27
    @ShelbyBaby27 8 лет назад +1

    Batman: "WHY DO BARK THAT NAME!!!!!!" LMAO

  • @linkinparkthebest250
    @linkinparkthebest250 8 лет назад +21

    I think a public apology to Joe is in order.

  • @thepancakesman
    @thepancakesman 8 лет назад +27

    Taking out Joe because of the dog question was stupid, if it is offensive to substitute a soldier with an animal, it would be equally as offensive to substitute any other person, wether he or she is a veteran or not. If that´s the matter, the whole question should be changed.

  • @ArtPopTv
    @ArtPopTv 8 лет назад +18

    by eliminating Joe, Andy made his argument evil and anti-veterens. I think thats bull@#$%.
    Andy again ruins a great episode by making a bad call.

  • @cjolwebdesign
    @cjolwebdesign 8 лет назад +5

    Actually, the worst movie to torture someone with is 'Minions'. At the end of your torture session, you'll end up brain-dead only able to say "Banana!" for the rest of your life.

  • @WDESJ3
    @WDESJ3 8 лет назад +20

    COMEDY SHOULD NOT BE RESTRICTED!
    GO JOE!

  • @georgiemetallica
    @georgiemetallica 8 лет назад

    Joe Starr turning heel, I love it. "Get out of here Joe Starr, Nobody disrespects our veterans" had me cracking up

  • @Ronfost89
    @Ronfost89 8 лет назад +6

    Yeah as a Vet I have to say none of us were insulted. 1. Saving Private Ryan was very very very slightly based on a true story but was 90% fictional. Its not like he said Flags of our Fathers or Black Hawk Down or any other war movies actually telling a true story.

  • @TheDirtyDancer100
    @TheDirtyDancer100 8 лет назад +18

    They shouldn't have taken Joe out.

  • @hollysmith3262
    @hollysmith3262 8 лет назад +20

    I can't get over how stupid their reasoning for kicking out Joe was.

  • @Wisp100
    @Wisp100 8 лет назад +12

    Just wanted to throw in my hate for having kicked Joe out.

  • @16THESAINT
    @16THESAINT 8 лет назад +21

    I love the amount of offensive things they said after Joe left

  • @abbyherrera1317
    @abbyherrera1317 8 лет назад +4

    kicking Joe out was uncalled for, he was just trying to have fun with the fight.
    Side-note: Spencer is so adorable

  • @thebeatles170
    @thebeatles170 8 лет назад +17

    Okay Joe was robbed....

  • @KiwiImperialist
    @KiwiImperialist 8 лет назад +12

    This is the first Movie Fights video I have watched in several months. It was my hope that Andy would improve in his role as host of the show, but this has clearly not happened. His decision to eliminate Joe was clumsy and misguided, to the point where his respect for veterans appears feigned.

  • @NCBCSPRINGRETREAT
    @NCBCSPRINGRETREAT 8 лет назад +21

    Andy this was ridiculous. You owe Joe a public apology.
    It's your show, but you would serve better as a producer. You're not enjoyable as a 'fighter'. Just be a producer and keep your feels out of it.

  • @ocallaghandesign
    @ocallaghandesign 8 лет назад +4

    Lead to replace with talking Dog: Jar Jar Binks. You can still do all the gags, and the goofiness is more forgivable from a little dog.

  • @JuliaSilva-og6pp
    @JuliaSilva-og6pp 8 лет назад +7

    I got super excited about trying out for Fan Fights, until I realized that I have exams on January.

  • @MikesGamingNtw
    @MikesGamingNtw 8 лет назад +24

    Honest Trailers: Andy's poor decision making by kicking guests off

  • @henk3782
    @henk3782 8 лет назад +26

    Its funny how they screwed Joe, but he still had the best argument lol. It was total BS. Never seen people put words in someones mouth like that. I like this show, but damn..

  • @lawrenceperry957
    @lawrenceperry957 8 лет назад +2

    Fun episode. Scott Mantz is becoming my favorite person ever, lol.

  • @hellradiolives
    @hellradiolives 8 лет назад

    Oh my goodness, the Cage/Travolta switch are argument is one of my all time favorites. I laughed through it the whole time! XD

  • @collincorbean6357
    @collincorbean6357 8 лет назад +34

    More Kevin smith and max landis. Please!

    • @bloodhexesillustration1977
      @bloodhexesillustration1977 8 лет назад

      Please

    • @Batgirl219
      @Batgirl219 8 лет назад +2

      Yes to Smith. A long and loud "Please God no!" to Landis.

    • @Nebuchadnezzar31
      @Nebuchadnezzar31 8 лет назад

      MrValderviche I love his movie pitches but he's so opinionated.

    • @collincorbean6357
      @collincorbean6357 8 лет назад

      Edgar Allan Poe his movie pitches are amazing. And we happen to have similar opinions so that's probably why I like him

    • @Beastmig3415
      @Beastmig3415 8 лет назад

      Why aren't ppl allowed to be opinionated?

  • @zyygis
    @zyygis 8 лет назад +13

    My veteran father made fun out of war to the day he died. Andy that was insulting to all what he stand for

  • @MetaBoo110
    @MetaBoo110 8 лет назад +76

    Movie with the dumbest premise? Sharkboy and Lavagirl.

    • @angeljax2053
      @angeljax2053 8 лет назад +13

      MetaBoo110 That movie is perfection

    • @simongarcia6386
      @simongarcia6386 8 лет назад

      +Angel Jax the it never shows them going on any other adventure then to dreamland

    • @FreakieFan
      @FreakieFan 8 лет назад

      are those big hollywood releases? I dont think so

    • @MetaBoo110
      @MetaBoo110 8 лет назад +1

      Lt. Col. Frank Slade Not a blockbuster but it was released internationally by Columbia Pictures.

    • @JohnCruz811
      @JohnCruz811 8 лет назад +30

      HE RUINED MY DREAM JOURNAL

  • @brandondoyle9573
    @brandondoyle9573 8 лет назад +2

    Disqualifying Joe was utterly ridiculous. You owe him an apology. Not a good look screen junkies, particularly on Andy's part.

  • @sarahnadespeaks5047
    @sarahnadespeaks5047 8 лет назад

    This is the funniest movie fights I've seen you guys do in a long time! Nicely done Screen Junkies!

  • @MultiNecroz
    @MultiNecroz 8 лет назад +15

    Idk why you guys kicked joe. all the answers in that round sucked. and saving the only talking dog sounds pretty good to me. at no point he disrespected the vets and you guys accused him of it.

  • @janetdavison6506
    @janetdavison6506 8 лет назад +15

    I wish people weren't triggered so easily because I would have loved to see Joe Starr argue his point. I still enjoyed this though.

  • @TheNetrunner888
    @TheNetrunner888 8 лет назад +27

    I would totally build a religion around The Dude.

    • @laxdefender23
      @laxdefender23 8 лет назад

      TheNetrunner888 Was my first thought

  • @ReignOfZero
    @ReignOfZero 8 лет назад

    These ensemble episodes are by far the best, I have way too many favorite fighters to wait months to see them go at it.. Joes saving private ryan argument may have been the funniest thing I've ever seen.

  • @divout6688
    @divout6688 6 лет назад

    Mantz having Cage v Cage as identical twins in face off but still forcing them to change faces is hillarious! :-P

  • @luisfinol93
    @luisfinol93 8 лет назад +39

    Andy kicking out Joe is the worst thing I've ever seen on the internet.

  • @TheMrtrollguy
    @TheMrtrollguy 8 лет назад +30

    Fight 1: Son of the mask
    Fight 2: The Happening
    Fight 3: The Punisher
    Fight 4: The dude
    Fight 5: Cars 2 (Idk, it was a piece of shit)
    Fight 6: The incredibles

    • @justinriley
      @justinriley 8 лет назад

      Constantine Jack Are you hoping somebody laughs at The Happening until they plead for it to stop?

    • @keithn9253
      @keithn9253 8 лет назад

      Constantine Jack I would've change Mark Walhberg in The Happening

    • @MCMonsterbuilder
      @MCMonsterbuilder 8 лет назад

      Dudeism already exists so I don't know if that was a valuable answer but if so I would have taken that answer for sure

    • @DoubleGoon
      @DoubleGoon 8 лет назад

      Fight 1: Minions

    • @yggdrasil1972
      @yggdrasil1972 8 лет назад +1

      Fight 1 : highschool musical 1 (love but that would torture anyone)

  • @Rebel0nAMission
    @Rebel0nAMission 8 лет назад +49

    For question one, just play "A Serbian Film" on loop.

    • @FreakieFan
      @FreakieFan 8 лет назад

      my pick too, but Antichrist seems the same kind of terrible

    • @alialmuhanna4938
      @alialmuhanna4938 8 лет назад +3

      Rebel0nAMission
      Oh God ! I only read the story from Wikipedia & felt upset ! I can't imagine what would watching it do !

    • @majinjuw4953
      @majinjuw4953 8 лет назад

      thats what i was going to say.

    • @Anda_Da_SI
      @Anda_Da_SI 8 лет назад

      Lt. Col. Frank Slade In Serbian film guy gets stabed in the eye with a penis.Antichrist is nothing to that.

    • @inne_rzeczy
      @inne_rzeczy 8 лет назад

      no, it's not that bad!

  • @dirkwalker9686
    @dirkwalker9686 8 лет назад +1

    That Movie Fights poster behind Dan is awesome. They really captured the essence of the show.

  • @yavrielsechelle7431
    @yavrielsechelle7431 8 лет назад +15

    That was shitty how you treated Joe, Andy. Really shitty.

  • @cobb541
    @cobb541 8 лет назад +5

    Scott Mantz is the happiest man I've ever seen