I read the book for Tom Holland back in the mcu peak days and I remember wondering how the heck they were going to adapt it- I guess the answer was not very well
I did too! I got through the entire trilogy in a month and loved them but I was so confused about how they'd put the noise on screen. definitely works better as text in a book
I don’t know if it’s just me but the recent output has been awesome and consistent. I don’t even watch movies but I enjoy hearing your opinion on them as well as shows. It’s led me to some good ones like Parasite and The Farewell.
This cast was an incredible line-up. But jeez, that clip of Tom asking for direction from THE DIRECTOR and being given literally nothing... that tells you the entire shooting experience. This is actors taking a concept and doing the best they can with absolutely no help from the people behind the camera, and for that I think they did a great job. I 1000% understand why Tom did no press for this, and wish Daisy had done the same. Maybe it can be reedited into a better mini-movie.
I heard that they were never going to release this movie and it disappeared out of the blue. Then RUclips HEAVILY advertised it for like three days. I guess having the star power and hard work be wasted made them just give up and release whatever they had.
i really liked this movie cause i could relate my inner thoughts are always loud consistently talking, day dreaming and having full on conversations with myself to the point where i start murmuring and grumbling that my family can hear me in the next room so when i watched it i kept thinking how my voice would be like, i really wish in the future some one will try again and remake it maybe into a good Tv series (hopefully Netflix) so we can fully dive into this awesome story i really want to see this story just with little less kid friendly and more centered around adults and our Noise problems
The author is super talented - his books are all so original and different. ‘More Than This’ is incredible and still one of my favourites and ‘The Rest Of Us Just Live Here’ is such a unique perspective on the YA genre! Also his book always include great representation.
Part of what made the original story so special was that Todd and Viola were only meant to be around 13 years old, so even though Tom and Daisy are wonderful actors, as soon as they were cast and the characters were aged up, I lost hope for this movie.
I actually liked the movie a lot. I was not familiar with the books, and find out afterwards that they are a bit different in the execution of the story but I enjoyed the movie and was really entertained
Yeah and maybe if I’d not read the books first I’d feel the same. Really frustrating having your favourite trilogy made into a movie just for them to skip over every important detail. You’ll find that the storyline diverts about 10 minutes into the movie. Real shame imo
That's exactly it, he thought that nobody should hide their thoughts. Hiding is weakness.. you aren't brave enough to own up to your thoughts. Kind of has a point.
@@Bayard1503 the author himself literally says, “it’s not about what you say, but what you choose not to say” the whole point is having control is better than being unfiltered. Having unfiltered thoughts (Nick Jonas character for example) is a sign of weakness. That’s constantly shown in the movie and books. So nope.
A massive plot point of the book is Manchee's death. I know it was never gonna be popular, but if they were gonna tell the original story well, then unfortunately the dog has to die :( But ultimately, this film likely suffered due to its age rating. Its a book with lots of complex themes, and that was never gonna take well to a 12 rating.
Davy Jr. and Todd's somewhat brotherly relationship in the second book was nice. It forced Todd to mature and I could sympathize with Davy. Also I'm pretty sad Wilf and Mistress Coyle will never be seen.
I didn't know there were issues with production side but that definitely explains a lot. It felt straight forward and the teen stuff was a bit overdone but yeah it had potential.
To be honest, my sister and I enjoyed the movie a lot, we had a good time at the cinema (suffered with the dog thing) but of course, we haven´t read the books before...
@@sorchacarr579 you mean the dog?... if so, I think whatever I say would be a spoiler... but if you are wondering if it might be triggering, then yes, whatever happens might trigger people
to be fair though, this was already a disaster in place. it was made in a time where YA film adaptations are dwindling. The Hunger Games, The Fault In Our Stars and Twlilight really peaked the genre, while films like Divergent, The Maze Runner, and Percy Jackson had to suffer mediocre returns. Netflix would later redo the genre in a new format, but that was it.
this really should have been a show, the story was extremely condensed and didn't include important parts of the story and it added things that didn't happen, they could have made each episode about 45 minutes long and each book could be its own season that would let a story like this flow very easily because a story as complex as chaos walking should be told over a long period of time and making it a show would've let the writers include more of the events in the books.
This is why Kathrine and Grant stepped away from the new Animorphs movie. They are gonna water down the war, genocides, PTSD and ableism the series is really about to make it fit what the ratings say is fit for pg 13. Crazy considering the age range the book series was originally written for.
Didn't really like the movie... I tried to get into it... Kept waiting for it to get better.. for something crazy to actually happen but nahhhh... And then they killed off the goodest doggo and that was the last straw for me...
They definitely should have stuck more with the books its sad they give whats his face some good character development then to have his father kill him sad
I really enjoyed the movie. But i knew nothing about the book, so I can appreciate it. Cool concept. Totally realistic ala hand maiden's. Thoroughly enjoyed it
Honestly I watched this movie in theaters bc I like Tom and Daisy. It was a fine movie and the world is super interesting so I might just pick up the books
i didn't see this movie and i probably never will but every time i look at the scenes it just feels like they made this movie just to see how people would react to Tom Holland doing jungle based adventure stuff in prep for uncharted...lol
YA dystopian sci-fi/fantasy are rarely done right. Would have like your take on the Shadow and Bones series cause I was expecting a dumb-fun watch, but got swooped over by the series instead.
I've seen comments from book fans saying that it's the best book adaptation they've seen. I really enjoyed it but I'm biased to anything with Ben Barnes lol
I hope they just dont do a sequel. The end of the movie was literally the end of the trilogy I would love for them to do what they did with His Dark Materials and save it but after waiting ten years for this movie just for it come out like this Im not very hopeful
I imagined preacher looking more like mayor Preston when I read the series. With a huge gash from that gator creature. 115 million ? They could have gave me 5 million and I’d do it better
I have not read the books and i 90% enjoyed the movie cause of the interesting main concept and i truly believe it had the opportunity of being a really good one.It just mostly never works to give a 3 book series just one movie or even making 4 movies with the final having a part 1 and part 2.
This was an excellent concept. I loved the story that was brewing. But it should've been a series.I could see this compared to "See" or "Raised By Wolves". They botched the ending trying to keep it under movie time formats.
Personally i think the industry has shifted to the point that there isn't as much of a place for ya adaptions as films, rather that they're finding more of a place as tv shows. Like you have his dark materials and shadow and bone which are fairy recent that i would say have been pretty successful. I haven't seen a successful film adaptation in a long time.
I knew the film wasn’t going to be good because it had many reshoots and it’s been done like three years ago. The cast is amazing and love the premise of it but it ultimately failed. Still haven’t seen it yet but will someday.
anyone else not watch the movies and just watch these
Yes but I'll watch em on my lazy day
thankfully the studio gave us a screener link and never bothered to watch it again
It be like that some times
Sometimes! Lol especially older stuff I didnt want to watch anyways
Same
They screwed this masterpiece over, you have no idea how bad they ruined it. Such a great book!
IKR!!!
Right! The ending of the book and what led you to this is developed so well but this feels dumb down for kids. Sorta like a Disney movie
I know every single book was incredible but they destroyed it
No point even relating this to the book unfortunately. Leaves out so many important aspects
YES IK!!
I just want to know who thought it was a good idea to give Nick Jonas a southern accent.
Southern where?
@@matthewmclean9012 in his voice
@@matthewmclean9012 in his voice
I’ve not read the book, but my sympathy goes out to the book fans. I feel your pain.
me neither but I could tell something was missing and the ending was disappointing
I think this would have been great as a TV series ... Much more character development...
True but I would like them to do 3 movies instead
@@cassiusfelix2805 I don’t think a movie could do the trilogy justice. Way too many relevant details for it to not be hours long
Yes. This story needs time to breathe, movies are too rushed.
@@ronandoyle1306 they did good on the Maze Runner Trilogy IMO! I liked them!
@@kenneth465 I agree! Just wish they had taken the same approach here. One movie which covers 3 books vaguely doesn’t do the story justice imo
"Peter Parker Pecker" is the name of my new garage band.
this film is so bad Tom Holland tries to escape every questions about the film during his Cherry press tour
"peter parker pecker"
Jesus wtf that caught me offguard 😁😄
Me too! “Spidey cheeks” also got a laugh out of me
Guess this is the first major miss for Tom Holland , I think we can all admit it was eventually gonna happen .
and then Cherry came too
Uh, Cherry?
@@deprimada3560 Tom holland's new movie about a guy with ptsd from the army turning to drugs
@@heavenlygamer2390 is it bad? that movie is on my list
@@defenderofminorities3056 Well the beginning is ok but it kinda goes downhill from there
They really wasted tom, daisy, and mads like that
I read the book for Tom Holland back in the mcu peak days and I remember wondering how the heck they were going to adapt it- I guess the answer was not very well
I did too! I got through the entire trilogy in a month and loved them but I was so confused about how they'd put the noise on screen. definitely works better as text in a book
I don’t know if it’s just me but the recent output has been awesome and consistent. I don’t even watch movies but I enjoy hearing your opinion on them as well as shows. It’s led me to some good ones like Parasite and The Farewell.
cant wait for this movie to be rebooted as a tv show and actually give a shit about the books
Same. From what I’ve learned about the books it could make a really good TV show.
my god that cast, why can’t studios not continue to mess everything up, make this a tv series, god DAMN.
Holy hell I WISH I had watched the interviews for this AHA
This cast was an incredible line-up. But jeez, that clip of Tom asking for direction from THE DIRECTOR and being given literally nothing... that tells you the entire shooting experience. This is actors taking a concept and doing the best they can with absolutely no help from the people behind the camera, and for that I think they did a great job. I 1000% understand why Tom did no press for this, and wish Daisy had done the same. Maybe it can be reedited into a better mini-movie.
I heard that they were never going to release this movie and it disappeared out of the blue. Then RUclips HEAVILY advertised it for like three days. I guess having the star power and hard work be wasted made them just give up and release whatever they had.
i really liked this movie cause i could relate my inner thoughts are always loud consistently talking, day dreaming and having full on conversations with myself to the point where i start murmuring and grumbling that my family can hear me in the next room so when i watched it i kept thinking how my voice would be like, i really wish in the future some one will try again and remake it maybe into a good Tv series (hopefully Netflix) so we can fully dive into this awesome story i really want to see this story just with little less kid friendly and more centered around adults and our Noise problems
I think amazon or HBO would do a great adaptation in a series format.
Best line “no Peter piper pecker “ lmao
*Peter Parker, but yeah that was hilarious lol
The author is super talented - his books are all so original and different. ‘More Than This’ is incredible and still one of my favourites and ‘The Rest Of Us Just Live Here’ is such a unique perspective on the YA genre! Also his book always include great representation.
Part of what made the original story so special was that Todd and Viola were only meant to be around 13 years old, so even though Tom and Daisy are wonderful actors, as soon as they were cast and the characters were aged up, I lost hope for this movie.
I'm so sick of them changing the movie so much from the books. If the book was a huge success, why change it so drastically?
"nick jonas plays... nick jonas" got me 💀😂
I actually liked the movie a lot. I was not familiar with the books, and find out afterwards that they are a bit different in the execution of the story but I enjoyed the movie and was really entertained
I never read the books either so I actually liked it but now I have the books so I can read them.
@Greg Williams that's your opinion. I like the movie and that's what matters
@Greg Williams wow and you are just plane rude... but do you
Me too
Yeah and maybe if I’d not read the books first I’d feel the same. Really frustrating having your favourite trilogy made into a movie just for them to skip over every important detail. You’ll find that the storyline diverts about 10 minutes into the movie. Real shame imo
Loving that year 3000 reference 🤣
Poor unfortunate soul was also a jonas brothers reference
The book was actually really good. If you don’t like reading, chaos walking is a great novel to start on
“Weak like a woman” yet men are the ones who can’t control their thoughts. Yea ok preacher man.
That's exactly it, he thought that nobody should hide their thoughts. Hiding is weakness.. you aren't brave enough to own up to your thoughts. Kind of has a point.
@@Bayard1503 the author himself literally says, “it’s not about what you say, but what you choose not to say” the whole point is having control is better than being unfiltered. Having unfiltered thoughts (Nick Jonas character for example) is a sign of weakness. That’s constantly shown in the movie and books. So nope.
A massive plot point of the book is Manchee's death. I know it was never gonna be popular, but if they were gonna tell the original story well, then unfortunately the dog has to die :(
But ultimately, this film likely suffered due to its age rating. Its a book with lots of complex themes, and that was never gonna take well to a 12 rating.
Davy Jr. and Todd's somewhat brotherly relationship in the second book was nice. It forced Todd to mature and I could sympathize with Davy.
Also I'm pretty sad Wilf and Mistress Coyle will never be seen.
I didn't know there were issues with production side but that definitely explains a lot. It felt straight forward and the teen stuff was a bit overdone but yeah it had potential.
To be honest, my sister and I enjoyed the movie a lot, we had a good time at the cinema (suffered with the dog thing) but of course, we haven´t read the books before...
Does the god die???
@@sorchacarr579 you mean the dog?... if so, I think whatever I say would be a spoiler... but if you are wondering if it might be triggering, then yes, whatever happens might trigger people
never clicked on a video so fast in my life!
The books are so good, but sometimes an adaptation is not enough to express the complexity.
Sometimes a book should just stay a book.
5:50 you lying, gurl
AND YOU KNOW IT!
XD
"'Raw' thoughts were more 'Delirious' than Eddie Murphy" is such a good joke!
"The Martha trick work even in a galaxy far away" DAMN!
I’m really curious to see what happens to Daisy Ridley’s career
If you read the books, you should have been very disappointed with how the characters were written
The story of every YA novel that gets a movie, you guys get shafted way too damn much.
It was both characters though, this it need to be a tv show
@@ubermaster1 such potential with actors and story to work with, was def crammed, wish it could have been expanded more rather than rushed :(
@@suzanne1995 exactly, or a trilogy of movies at least
to be fair though, this was already a disaster in place. it was made in a time where YA film adaptations are dwindling. The Hunger Games, The Fault In Our Stars and Twlilight really peaked the genre, while films like Divergent, The Maze Runner, and Percy Jackson had to suffer mediocre returns. Netflix would later redo the genre in a new format, but that was it.
The author of the books is very well spoken. Hollywood screws up adaptation, surprise.....not.
The editing, thank you it was very intriguing. Wow thanks LME and cast
this really should have been a show, the story was extremely condensed and didn't include important parts of the story and it added things that didn't happen, they could have made each episode about 45 minutes long and each book could be its own season that would let a story like this flow very easily because a story as complex as chaos walking should be told over a long period of time and making it a show would've let the writers include more of the events in the books.
an insane amount of indepth jokes in this one. respect lmao
Has never touched ground but can ride a dirtbike?!?!
It was absolutely diabolical on every single level.
This is why Kathrine and Grant stepped away from the new Animorphs movie. They are gonna water down the war, genocides, PTSD and ableism the series is really about to make it fit what the ratings say is fit for pg 13. Crazy considering the age range the book series was originally written for.
Didn't really like the movie... I tried to get into it... Kept waiting for it to get better.. for something crazy to actually happen but nahhhh... And then they killed off the goodest doggo and that was the last straw for me...
I'm early for once, didn't know all this back story about chao's walking though
1:56 what passive psychic telepaths would be like!
An interpretation, at least
Imagine a Deaf/mute person that ALWAYS UNDERSTANDS EVERYONE
the author sounds really nice and I like his ideas, may give books a chance (a bit later as I am now in Grisha verse)
6:38 okay, did not expect THAT
XD
The books are absolute masterpieces, I’m so upset with how they adapted it :(
Listen, when you have a best selling novel at your fingertips you have no excuse not to make a good adaption. The books are really amazing so.
They definitely should have stuck more with the books its sad they give whats his face some good character development then to have his father kill him sad
I really enjoyed the movie. But i knew nothing about the book, so I can appreciate it. Cool concept. Totally realistic ala hand maiden's. Thoroughly enjoyed it
I saw the final trailer after I read the first book, and that was enough for me to completely ignore the existence of this movie
Honestly I watched this movie in theaters bc I like Tom and Daisy. It was a fine movie and the world is super interesting so I might just pick up the books
i didn't see this movie and i probably never will but every time i look at the scenes it just feels like they made this movie just to see how people would react to Tom Holland doing jungle based adventure stuff in prep for uncharted...lol
So what I'm hearing the movie got Percy Jackson'ed
I literally haven’t seen a movie in years because of these channels
He is typecast as spiderman now it's a wrap.
Thanks for your time and effort.
YA dystopian sci-fi/fantasy are rarely done right. Would have like your take on the Shadow and Bones series cause I was expecting a dumb-fun watch, but got swooped over by the series instead.
I've seen comments from book fans saying that it's the best book adaptation they've seen. I really enjoyed it but I'm biased to anything with Ben Barnes lol
I hope they just dont do a sequel. The end of the movie was literally the end of the trilogy
I would love for them to do what they did with His Dark Materials and save it but after waiting ten years for this movie just for it come out like this Im not very hopeful
I needed a trigger warning for that dog drowning scene. That was uncalled for.
Grow up
These books got me into reading and I love them so much. I recommend them 100%
Yooo said SPIDEY CHEEKS 🤣😂 PETER PARKER PECKER 😂🤣☠
I imagined preacher looking more like mayor Preston when I read the series. With a huge gash from that gator creature. 115 million ? They could have gave me 5 million and I’d do it better
Love your vids 😁
I want to watch this now seems to have fan edit potential
After watching this movie, I realized that the planet is a giant trolltrace towards men.
Doug Liman ...love him or hate him...but you gotta admit ..he is one of the ballsiest film makers in the game !
I have not read the books and i 90% enjoyed the movie cause of the interesting main concept and i truly believe it had the opportunity of being a really good one.It just mostly never works to give a 3 book series just one movie or even making 4 movies with the final having a part 1 and part 2.
Charlie kaufman would've easily made this a masterpiece. The concept is already up his alley
This was an excellent concept. I loved the story that was brewing. But it should've been a series.I could see this compared to "See" or "Raised By Wolves". They botched the ending trying to keep it under movie time formats.
I didn't even know this movie was based on the Patrick Ness series...
Sjwhdjejw I read these books back when I was like 14 and I completely forgot about it.. damn
Poor Daisy, always being part of scripts being written last minute.
“There is no Peter Parker pecker” 😂😂
The books were masterpieces and I knew that they were going to do them dirty right from the start
The synder cut of Chaos Walking is much better. Release it!!!!
i love this book series so let me go into the producers room and let me rewrite it... right now
All the people there are from the first wave daisy is from the second wave or am I wrong? That’s why she could us the bike and stuff so well
That's an idea I had...a comic I'm writing...when...was this made...
I’m not a fan but I want more movies to be more loyal to their books
Personally i think the industry has shifted to the point that there isn't as much of a place for ya adaptions as films, rather that they're finding more of a place as tv shows. Like you have his dark materials and shadow and bone which are fairy recent that i would say have been pretty successful. I haven't seen a successful film adaptation in a long time.
thanks for the warning. i refuse to see movies where the dog dies
I've read the books, and the fact that they cut Wilf makes me angry. They did my boy dirty.
would love to hear your thoughts on “the bonfire of destiny” it’s on netflix and a really interesting interpretation of the actual fire in 1897.
Talking of kurt sutter sons of anarchy let me explain?
Let HBO take it
Pulling a Katniss omg.
3:57
XD
I knew the film wasn’t going to be good because it had many reshoots and it’s been done like three years ago. The cast is amazing and love the premise of it but it ultimately failed. Still haven’t seen it yet but will someday.
You should do the raid
I liked it overall. just had a few moments where I was like, why. 🤦🏾♂️
It's like they learned nothing from Percy Jackson.
What happened to the A to Z show?
Makes me want to read the books.
I forgot about this movie. I remember I was upset with the casting when first heard it was being made. I'd rather have another book
The jokes in this video.