Civil War - The Complete Story | Comicstorian
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 2 апр 2015
- Buy this Comic on TCGplayer at bit.ly/3AiTtZ6
Check us out!
▸Patreon - / comistorian
▸Twitch - / comicstorian
▸TikTok - / comicstorian
▸Twitter - / comicstorian
▸Instagram - / comicstorian
▸Facebook - / realcomicstorian
▸Merchandise - comicstorian.myspreadshop.com/
▸RUclips Premium Sub - bit.ly/comicstoriansub
Our Other Channels!
▸Absolutely Marvel & DC - bit.ly/3KxCbtH
▸Dungeons & Ale - bit.ly/3LzGBS3
▸Ben & Friends Gaming - bit.ly/3vvyHUe
Send Mail!
Eligible Monster Productions or Comicstorian
PO Box 1869
Loveland 80539
All Music Provided by Epidemic Sound
Thank you for your support!
About Comicstorian:
Comic Books dramatically read by the Eligible Monster Team. DC Comics, Marvel Comics and Indie alike, nothing is free from our dramatic readings.
Civil War - The Complete Story | Comicstorian
• Civil War - The Comple...
Comicstorian
/ comicstorian 
Развлечения
Spiderman unmasking is still one of the most iconic moments in comic history
synx but because of that "iconic moment" we got One More Day
Yes, because it was so stupid and they had no plan for it. There really is no story that goes with it. It's a stupid way to do it, too.
not like captain America being captain america
synx i
It's a big moment but it made no damn sense. He just had to reveal his identity to the GOVERNMENT. They never said anything about the public. Peter basically just put himself and all his loved ones at risk for no reason
Who's to blame for this catastrophe? Reality TV.
Yeah.
+Victor Hernandez this is why we gotta stop that kardashian show before it causes a war
+Naveed Hossain LOL
A Kardashian War
Or the bad bus driver driving at that time,near and when there is a fight,and not following safety rules,and the civilians for always overreacting,and the villains
Well of course Tony Stark and Reed Richards don't have a problem with the "Super Hero Registration Act" THEY DON'T HAVE SECRET IDENTITIES!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
batshineman
Indeed
Yes
Super Registration Act. Or SRA for short.
I don’t blame them.
Iron Man had a secret identity for forty years in the comics. It was only two years before Civil War when he revealed it because he was saving some kid's dog.
> Fights villains that stomp planets
> Gets knocked out by bottle
Just Some CoD 12yr Old With a Gun 😂😂😂
He was not using his abilities and was blindsided
Just Some CoD 12yr Old With a Gun I mean it did have water in it
@@quiltedlive3966
So that's all it takes to beat the Human Torch? Guess I'll grab a water hose then :P
that’s a good point but at the time he wasn’t on fire so it does make sense that he could get KO’d by someone with a bottle
To be honest, the MCU should've waited until they had more characters.
Also, Goliath actually stayed dead. :0
+SaberTV. Well he didn't mean to destroy Sakaar, and Hulk is pretty dangerous.
+SaberTV. Well it's irrefutable that keeping Hulk around is like keeping a cigarette in a lit match in a room full of nukes.
+Razorc Skelly I always thought this would've been a better story if it came after Infinity war. With the characters right now, Civil War will be just another Avengers movie. What can they top Infinity War with? If this storyline takes place after the events of Infinity War, it would be a massive hit.
+Ghoul Shade They'll just do Civil War 2 in a few years when they have more characters. Its already happening in the comics
Why is Spider-Man always the voice of reason? This is why he's my favorite, other than deadpool, cuz he's a badass.
He's Stan's favourite, nuff said
That and he's the most relatable. Seriously he's a teenager who experiences everyone's expectations of him as an individual, despite his young age. We all experience(d) this at a point in time; we know what it's like to have a greater feeling of importance, but whether we're able to handle the responsibility is what Spider-Man deals with in his day to day life. He is the most well-developed superhero of any franchise, thus he deserves to be the voice of reason as well as Stan Lee's favorite.
With great power, comes great responsibility fam... Lol
Dude Spider-Man eats ass deadpool would kick his ass in fact I'm the comics dead pool kills every single marvel character so ha! He blows Spider-mans brains out 😂😂😂
"The Punisher kills the Marvel universe" is better than "Deadpool kills the Marvel Universe" .. Honestly, I don't see all the hype and excitement about Deadpool.. IMO he's overrated. Yeah he's a cool and funny character, but I personally don't like rip off characters from DC.. And vice versa.. Deadpool is overrated...
i could watch a video of paint drying as long as this guy is the narrator
lol
Mrsmiley186 wow, that is exactly what I ecxpect him to say. :)
#puthiminamovie
Anthony Gronock ong
omg
Captain America stands by what's "the right decision", despite the consequences, and feels that no one's rights should be revoked. Iron Man weighs the options and tries to choose what's best for the most people, even if it's unfair to the superhuman minority.
"Those who would give up essential Liberty, to purchase a little temporary Safety, deserve neither Liberty nor Safety." - Benjamin Franklin
Sounds like the movie to me
I mean except for the part where cap and Bucky jump iron Man because Bucky killed iron man's parents
Mr Boerger pretty Ironman jumped Bucky 🤦♂️
@@mrboerger1620 Pretty sure the op was talking about comic Civil War. MCU Civil War was just a Captain America movie lol
Man, it would have been weird if Captain America fighting The Human Torch
MinecraftKing lol
Human Torch: You're going down, Cap!
**knocks himself out**
"Flame on!" Capt America
Lol true
By golly, you look just like me!
I side with Capt on this, if the villains know who they are under the mask(s) no one’s family is safe
Same here
SO, have you checked out Spider-Man: Back in Black? Cause that's pretty much the plot of that.
Not to mention, the number of ways they could be exploited by corrupt government officials.
Yea I’m team cap
Exactly, and that's something that Tony, Reed, and Hank will never understand since they would be willing to reveal their secret identities without thinking of the consequences.
"You aren't arresting Captain America, you're arresting Steve Rogers". WoW. I cried there
Captain America was never in prison at the end of civil war, he was killed by Crossbones on the steps of a court house when he was going to face a trial
No that is the story Death of Captain America. At the end of Civil War he was being hauled off. Two different stories, Death of Captain America is the follow up to this
Comicstorian it was titled Civil War, Epilogue. It counts as part of the Civil War storyline
ROOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAASSTED lol #akward
#InjusticeIsBetterAnyway
Chris&Josh to
Hugh Jarsole u dumb fuck
I was trying to study for my history class and I got here.
I failed my test.
How'd you fail that test this is about civil war😂😂
At least you learned about one civil war
"What did it cost?"
Life must suck did the same thing
I won... but what did it cost?
The registration act disappeared after siege back when Norman Osborn was leading the dark avengers and had control over the avengers initiative due to the previous event secret invasion
Oh I know, it vanished as a condition from Captain America. Thats in in universe reason, but it wasnt really in effect any longer after this anyway outside of the Norman and Iron man fight over it.
Oh I was talking to the fans who were unaware of that fact ^_^ keep up the good job am loving your channel
This is kinda dumb but what is siege, what event was it?
Asgard The city home to Thor in the rest of the gods fell down to Midgaard basically earth Loki the goddess of mischief at this point account Loki is a woman manipulated Norman Osborn who's currently the iron patriot and the leader of his own avengers team that he can control this includes the walking God Mod known as the The void a.k.a. sentry into attack Asgard Thor and all of the fallen gods
Comicstorian When Cap became the director of S.H.I.E.L.D. after his resurrection and Norman Osborn's defeat (Dark Reign and Siege), he used his newfound political powers to repeal the SHRA and that's why it's no longer a problem.
Iron man also deleted the databanks on the SHRA when he was forced out of being the S.H.I.E.L.D. director in favor of Osborn and being pursued by Osborn for the memory in his cyborg-like brain (which Iron Man also deleted).
This is what happens when you bring up politics at a family gathering.
Fax
The lady who spat in Tony's face is just stupid, if the Avengers weren't around she would probably been dead by now.
that lady was a liberal.
the lady was a conservative...cue her tirade about "tony funding kids to be superheroes without federal training just because it was cool" *cough cough*
no.... she was all mad because media blew up about something so she thought she should.
that bitch was stupid...I mean I don't get it. even in the MCU, it was stupid. I mean fucking Hydra was going to kill millions of people...did you want those millions to die instead!? But I suppose it's one of those "What if questions" where if to say you were on a train track. A train is coming and there is a fork in the track. One side has five people on it while the other has two. You can't save the people, but you can send the train in either direction. Which side do you let the train go on, the one with five people or two people? You know that sort of deal...it's difficult...but whatever...
@@RandomGameFun nah she a conservative. Blaming a group tht is not real threat like CONservatives do to any group tht arent arent white staright christain (a term I use lightly) males
MCU Iron Man: Has a reasonable viewpoint, acts rationally (until he finds out Bucky killed his parents), tries to keep the team together.
Comic Iron Man: HIRES A BUNCH OF VILLAINS AND TRIES TO KILL SPIDER-MAN
Wasn't that maria hill
@@charmingmagican9821 Well, yeah, kinda. But even still, he went along with it. Not to mention he and Reed made an evil cyborg clone of Thor.
@@charmingmagican9821 Also, remember those two totally innocent Atlantean ambassadors that Tony had assassinated by the Green Goblin, by nano-slaving him to do it? I mean, Tony hit the villain juice HARD in Civil War.
Idk what stark and shield were thinking with the Thunderbolts
This shows a much darker side to Marvel, I like it.
If you like dark Marvel stuff you should try Old Man Logan.
@@geekmangacomic5281 marvel is more darker than DC
Just mcu screwed it up
@@michaeljosephjackson2364 debatable
@@michaeljosephjackson2364 winter soldier, black panther, infinity war,
@@thomaspanditfan2435 blackest night, metal universe, injustice, injustice 2, jason todd, new 52 joker, dceased, and flashpoint paradox
I liked the part where the woman spit on Tony,cause it kinda sparks the entire event. That woman most probably lost her kid and she reacted how any parent would.
yeah, like the civil war movie
And tony should have punched her face in then and there..
Really, I think you liked it because it breaks up the boring monotony of this lame storyline with some sexiness.
there is no way they could have made this into a movie too many heroes to develop this would have had to be a 3-4 hour movie . the way they did it was smart
It was too rushed and too gimmicky
true
+Aneruddha Yadav
The rush was the point.
The politicans are just rushing things trying to put the Avengers under control ASAP to have as low amount of issues to deal with as possible.
Zemo is also not letting anyone have a moment to think by putting event after event into motion.
Tony Stark is already at the brink of emotional breakdown because of his guilt and feeling of responsibility, then all this crap happens.
Steve had to attend to Peggy's funeral, then had to go get Bucky, having no time to talk over his point with Tony.
The spine of Zemo's plan is to divide the Avengers by exploiting Bucky and Steve's connection, and put events into motion at such a fast pace that no one have time to reasonably talk over the issues.
In the end Zemo believes that he have succeded, and don't even realize that he actually failed to dismember the Avengers since he can not comprehend the motivation of the superheroes for doing their job.
It was a three hour movie
+Matthew Carlson it was 2 and a half hours
It's a shame the cinematic version of Civil War won't come close to being as big as the comic version.
It's hard to put that many superheroes and flesh them all out in movies
+Phil Adams They're probably gonna take out the kids dying because it's too dark. A lot of things as well most likely
There's way too much stuff. especially build ups
+Phil Adams My brother is predicting they might do something in Agents of SHEILD.
@@stevenkollin4409 That comment did not age well. They showed with their Thanos-Plotline spread out over multiple movies how you can actually do it... if only they had done that for this movie....
The Black guy always dies first...
+WellNowWhat
lol Hood References AF
Technically, Namorita died first.
England is my GodChurch with the new warriors and a town of people.
I thought those people at that school bus died first?
WellNowWhat 7:37 BROTHA DOWN!
I can't believe everyone got mad at the Avengers and Fantastic Four! They've literally saved the entire planet dozens of times! Even if they had been directly involved with the school explosion, the school along with the planet would've been dust ten times over if not for the Avengers!
Zen Brown Thing is, the heroes to actually blame we’re all dead or imprisoned
It's the media dude. In real life they always stretch things out and make fake narratives just to get more clout and money
Vincent 2099
True
True. That's something that always annoys me. Like there isn't any way that the Avengers could have handled the situation that would result in there not being damage and if they hadn't gotten involved the world would've ended. The army sure as hell couldn't handle anything the hero's fought
And I thought it was just the X-Men🤔
Dude your storytelling skills... wow!!
Yelu C. Hello
Your face is.. wow!!
Look at all these thirsty people.
@@asl1218 simpsy people*
@@jayy_lalive2343 ikr, if only u and the dickhead that replied before u were capable of talking to women irl rather than thirsting over girls on the internet who wouldn’t even give you the time of day
"That Thor died in a earlier event!"
Brushing it off like that wasnt interesting information.
Had me laughing hard
Let me just reveal my identity so all the villains know where I live
man Spider-Man can't catch a break
SIAKA KROMAHZONE That's the life of being a youngunexperieneced superhero when their not running with the Big Boys.
@@greenlightcomics7602 Wasn't Spidey an adult here so I think he was experienced.
@@da5hainy556 he was the person above has no clue
@@greenlightcomics7602 spider Man was married here
@@greenlightcomics7602 they're*
10:08
iron Man has sentry
game over
Ikr i was like that fight should've ended sooner than it did
@@twizzlerlemonpie3083 yeah Sentry is quite overpowered
He literally did nothing.
That sentry might be a cyborg
To think that a big part of this plot could have been avoided if the heroes were not forced to reveal their identities in public... Honestly, wasn't it just enough to register into shield without also having their identities exposed?
That's probably what they'll do in the film
***** But 1 of the conditions that the movement required, was to reveal the identities of the heroes to the citizens in public...
***** The Problem with that is, the Government is always being hacked and had their secrets leaked, which is why having regular heroes registering would also mean signing their own death certificate if or when they cross paths with villains that hold a grudge, the SHRA also alludes that the Registered heroes will be used as Government Resources, which means some would play bodyguard to a politician, while others would be used to wage wars with other nations to protect the government's interests. In a separate issue, Uatu showed both Tony two other possible outcomes of the SHRA, one is which the Heroes are strictly controlled by the government and used as "Peacekeeping Weapons of Mass Destruction", while the other had the SHRA used in a different way, with only Captain America having the knowledge of each Heroes' identity and establishing a training facility for up-and-coming would-be-heroes not unlike Avenger's Academy.
The public’s argument was that the heroes could be anybody and that they needed to be held responsible, much like how a public official would. If just the government/SHIELD knew their identities, they’d still be upset and wouldn’t have solved the core issue
Really feel like Civil War movie should've been done during Phase 4, or even Phase 5.
Yeah.Just because of the lack of heroes/villains in the MCU
Honestly I think it's fine when it happens yeah we want a lot of heroes but the mcu just cant go hiring a bunch if people to play heroes that alot of pay checks plus civil war happens to build the plot for infinity war and endgame
@The King Channel yeah your right but yk the movie still didn't disappoint
My favorite thing about captain America is that he isn’t just America’s poster boy like everyone thinks he has his own agendas and his own ideals and is willing to go against the government for the greater good
Iron Man actually wants to talk before fighting for once, but NOOO Cap has to EMP him. If that never happened, the rest probably would've been avoided with a good negotiation.
But, there would have been no compromise it would be, unmask yourself and make your families vulnerable to attack.
Samara Habyarimana yeah but Cap is a good negotiator and the rest of Iron Man's team would have listened at least. They could have found a compromise.
Samara Habyarimana doesn’t the world know caps identity
Kent Pham there's actually a what if story showing if he hadn't started the fight, shit would have worked out
"to talk" woud have been Tony and Maria Hill telling them "do it our way, or do it our way" talking would have been surrender
This video sky-rocketed in views recently, i wonder why....
+dragonofdarknes4 You know why baby.... CA:CW Trailer!!!
Which was unbelievably great.
+Captain Rodgers Yeah but the movie will never live up to the comics
+Larry Jake You mean it could be worse than that dreck? I hope not.
+Larry Jake i don't think they would ever film a scene in which a school blows up
punklover99 except in a drama or historical movie
Civil War is pretty much satisfying. The whole storyline and tie-ins are equally interesting. The tie-ins here a must-read. I love the Young Avengers & Runaways, Frontline, Choosing Sides, Wolverine and Thunderbolts. I love the stories of Penance (once Speedball), Hulkling & Wiccan and even Deadpool & Cable fooling around the conflict.
when spiderman said tony i thought you said you had this under control an captain america civil war ad popped up
I actually shed a tear hearing this story. All of the superheros we love and look up to, they are battling and killing each other. It's horrible because this can actually be true in our real world and I hope we never come to that catastrophic realization
In all honesty, this entire situation could've been resolved in one session if everyone just put their egos aside and talked this out like adults. You'd think they'd do that too considering the circumstances that led up to the Super Hero Registration Act.
TechoXero isnt every war in human history started by egos instead of talking things out tho
didn't Tony ask Cap for a 5 minute talk but Cap just attacked Tony anyway
What did Tony planned?what did that lil thirsty hoe for thor plan and do when a hero's were fighting,does marvel know wht to do with shield,are they the bad guys or the annoying lil critters
TechoXero all this could have been avoided if
1) Maria hill didn’t try to have Cap shot BEFORE the bill passed
2) Mariam Sharp wasn’t a total bitch
3) Tony Stark wasn’t an asshole
4) Everyone just shut up, sit down, and talk
Grimdarkwolf Plus the enforcement of the law was totally wrong. When a real law passed people have time to comply to it and it passes by a certain date, not immediately afterwards. Starting a fight with the Cap’n before the law even passed was stupid af
For the final battle... how did Cap beat Iron man to the ground when Iron man was programmed to know Cap's every move?
ItaliaeHellas It's like Captain America knew that and attacked Iron Man without thinking about his attacks, don't know how that would work but it did OR, ...nvm idk
Lol.
ItaliaeHellas well in the civil war comics, vision disabled iron man's suit in the final battle that's why cap had the edge on tony
I felt he should of included that in. Think that was such an important fact behind Iron Man's loss against Captain America, only because Cap is pretty hopeless without anyone's help.
ItaliaeHellas yeah that's one detail that he forgot to mention here, and to be honest some info on this video is wrong.. great vid though
A very underrated moment in Civil War: Tony Stark has arrested Daredevil and takes him to the Negative Zone, all the while babbling about his reasoning for siding with the government and trying to convince Daredevil that his actions were for the greater good, and asking for both forgiveness and asking Daredevil to talk, who's completely silent. One of the guards tells Tony that Daredevil has a Silver Dollar to give him, and when Tony is confused by this, Daredevil just says: "Guess that's 31 pieces of silver you've got now, huh? Sleep well, Judas"
That wasn't Matt Murdock as Daredevil
I’ll quote 69% of the citizens
“You, the person that wasn’t involved killed me son. You ever monster”
I know it took us forever, but I did it out of respect for Comics Explained since thats one of his largest video series, check it out at ruclips.net/user/fluidicbeats Also, for those of you who asked if I didnt like the story, my complaint about it is all the good stuff happens outside of it. Captain America wasnt shot until the Epilogue and Spider-man got his Suit before it, and Thor comes back after it...
I was looking forward to this complete story and it was great like always
Hey man I got a random question maybe you can answer. Its not anything to do with this video but its been bugging me for a while. Why has the hulk not been contacted by a red ring? Or has he?
Nicholas Perry you know(IF you Arent kidding) that red lanterns IF you are talking about them is from DC Comics while the hulk is from Marvel Comics.
because the red rings exist in the dc universe not the marvel universe.
See I'm not a comic book guy. ( even though I love this channel) I would never have known that.
I think the MCU will do a good job of the story with what they have. Getting Spiderman in is a huge boost not only to the story but for the rest of phase 3.
+Crandy Slags have you been living under a rock?
+Aryan Sharma lmao
+Crandy Slags dude are you an idiot, sony and marvel made a deal. they got a new actor and everything he's going to be in civil war.
+Mike Morris By not telling you could have left him for the biggest surprise ever for the movie.
+Crandy Slags this dumbass said spiderman isnt in the MCU
Dude you are so good at narrating this stuff, I feel like im watching an actual movie
I like how the civilians here are crying over their city being destroyed when this is caused by them being selfish about the hero who litterally face death everyday not wanting to put everyone they know in danger. The ACT was basically on the same level as broadcasting every secret agent identities on the internet. It'll only make hero want to be hero alot less.
You can say that, but you can't deny the superheroes are just as selfish. They don't wanna be held accountable by exposing themselves.
@@zyonthelickman I mean, I get the sentiment but remember that literally not long after this, Spiderman's grandmother was sniped and was going to die over this.
You can understand why people who fight villains with powers that can blow up a building don't want any chance of their love ones being held hostage or murdered. Or them to be murdered in their sleep.
@@DarkChocolateGamer grandmother? You mean aunt right?
That is why Batman did what he did in JLA: Doom.
+unclelink great story
+unclelink Yeas contingency plans
have you read injustice? it is so good and it's fantastic. if you wanted a full out war with nearly EVERY DC character that is the comic book series to read.
Adler Charles i will admit year 3 lacked a lot of things but year 4 semi picked up. Can't wait to see year 5 though.
Adler Charles not in my opinion. I believe it was not to bad
I personally think Captain America is right... I would never trust a gov. that can control super humans. And if it weren't for the heroes intervening in the first place more people would have died. I agree that there has to be consequences but giving gov. the control is going in the wrong direction. For every non-moral super-villian there will be a superhero that will oppose them. "the best hands are still there own." You don't get to label superhumans as all non-moral because a few people died..
Exactly, if they killed a few humans. We kill each other all the time. Attempting genocide to name one. Normal people are more of a threat to people than super humans. So what would happen if normal humans took control of the super humans? See capt Americas point? Done and done, no need to argue any further. I just completely murdered this argument. Cheers 🍻
kwang-won Chung Tony was right at first but then he went freakin crazy
Same
@Jay Talents Someone doesn't understand the concept of natural rights. Government does not give rights it only takes them away
I supported Captain America in the Civil War
I think this plot line makes a lot more sense than the Civil War movie, however the movie is still good.
+Elliot Ormson Well, they couldn't have done the same story in the movie, because most of the heroes' identities were known.
The plot from the comics makes no sense at all.
Why do they still fight in downtown New York?
@@user-iy7jo7bq4f what kind of stupid point is that? Um, because they do? Like what?
@@KIN1311
Kid, why do they fight in a populated area instead of taking the fight to somewhere remote???
Like the complaint for Man of Steel...
@@user-iy7jo7bq4f Coz Cloak transferred them there dipshit, they didn't go "oh hey lets battle this out in New York"
7:08 was it around the event of Thor, God Killer that you guys covered
It's funny, this comic is hailed by so many people as a magnificent story, but to me... I dunno, the whole thing seems kinda weak. Tony Stark essentially turning into Stalin, locking away all dissidents in a parallel-dimension-gulag, the entire world turning against the entire metahuman community over a single (Admitedly horrific) accident, all these superheroes seemingly having no qualms whatsoever in trying to kill eachother (then again, superheroes fighting eachother as much as fighting villains is par for the course in the Marvel Universe), the whole story leading into One More Day Spiderman story(And the less said about that atrocity, the better), and the pro-registration side being portrayed as being in the right, when metahuman registration is pretty much the exact thing that the X-men have been battling against since their inception!
Watch Comics Explained's videos on Civil War (main issues and tie-ins), they will clear-up most of what you seem to not like about the story
It's true, everyone was grossly out of character and though the story had a good theme, it just kind of fell flat. It's not that good, but it is one of the most memorable.
Michael Welsh its dumb to me too bro, after years of fighting together all of a sudden because of a simple disagreement lets kill each other now lol
Jay Williams Well, no heroes had killed one another aside from Reed's RoboThor goin' out of control and impaling Goliath.
Jay Williams Simple disagreement? This was their lives and the lives of their families and loved ones, that is no simple disagreement. The fact that Captain America, a man who's only motivation is his love for America and his willingness to do anything to be able to fight for it, goes against America, you should probably start looking at what you are doing.
I'm so glad that you were able to clarify as to how the world doesn't know Spidey is Peter anymore.
I'm a little lost in the marvel arks and it's really nice to have channels like these to explain them with captivating narrations.
I'm trying to get through the Runaway's Civil War arc and I needed a refresher on the main story. You guys are amazing, keep doing awesome stuff like this.
Bro the part where you tell how affected both sides are from Goliath's death and the music in the background omgosh amazing
2:16
Knocking him out cold...
Human Torch? Out *cold*?
I see what you did there.
This trend of making comic books story lines into movies but only using some aspects of the source material is kind of ruining the comic book. The comic book adaptation deserves a complete use of the story on screen instead of just having the name of the comic and a few of the stories details. I read that old man Logan is to be the story premise for the 3rd wolverine film, however for obvious reasons the full story isn't possible as marvel owns rights to characters that fox does not. The only possible out come then is again a story with only some of the original stories plots details and then the rest made up by script writers to fill the blanks.
I'm not saying these movies will be bad, but rather I believe these stories deserve to be adapted to screen in their entirety rather then half made.
Animated movies of both civil war and Old man Logan would be a welcome compromise.
My heart goes out the all the children in that school and the rest of the victims 🕊
Why is peter parker SO GOOD LOOKING IN COMICS BOY HE PERFECT
ive read the comics, and ive listened to comics explained(love it) but i really enjoyed how well you told the story in 13 min. Fantastic, New Subscriber
I have been waiting so long for this. Thank You. This is my favorite Marvel story arc. Really thanks for this.
this made me cry. great work with the music. you have such an emotional voice.
the instrumental at the end of this video nailed the weight of the story. i appreciated this summary of the story, good on ya!
Thank you. I read comic books up until ~1977. Cap, Thor, and Avengers comic-books were my favorites. I was so glad that they started making these movies about my childhood heroes, but I quit reading them before all of this happened and I was really curious as to what caused all of this. I can't wait to see what other videos you have to offer. Thanks again, oh, and I did subscribe!
I had these comics back in the day. I have to say, the way you describe it (plus the slide show) make it even more exciting than it was actually reading the comics lol
Lol true its more exciting hearing him than me reading it
So happy the MCU adapted this story so amazingly, at the perfect time in the MCU as well
They really didn't. The only thing similar is Cap vs Iron Man and the whole hero vs hero thing. They should've waited til they got more characters like the X-Men and fantastic 4 in the MCU and then make the movie because it's supposed to be this huge war between every hero and villain there is. They can probably still do it but just title it civil war instead of captain America civil war
I mean don't get me wrong it's a good movie but it doesn't feel Civil War level conflict considering they only fought one day and then it was over, but at the time they didn't have a lot to work with but they could've just waited instead of trying to use what they got
But if they make another Civil War Movie, There would be more Differences.
Examples:
In the Comic Spider-Man was the one to Reveal his Identity Spider-Man: Far From Home, Mysterio Revealed Spider-Man’s Secret Identity.
The MCU Contracts for Actors and Actresses like Chris Evans, Mark Ruffalo, Chris Hemsworth, Scarlet Johansson, and maybe even Jeremy Renner will already Expire.
And the last one for now being the Moment where Frank Castle saves Peter Parker, will they be able to use The Punisher in the Movie? I ask this because There had been some Controversy with the Character Earlier this Year.
@@Tae200. it was like 2 years left for infinity war. When else were they supposed to do it? 2017 would have been way too close.
@@thomaspanditfan2435 What I mean was that they could've made a actual big civil war event in the future after they've introduced more characters. They could've titled this something else.
That was awesomely epic!!! Well done Benny hell of a job as always Brotha! Comicstorian's the GREATEST EVER!!!!
2016 the year superheroes clash ! I'm war ready
Are you?
Better question is: Whose side are YOU on?
+Honey Badger even better question is : Who let the dogs out?
#TEAMIRONMAN
#TEAMCAPTAINAMERICA
🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸Pro-Registration🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸
Best storytelling I'd seen so far keep it up!
Omg this video was amazing.. The format was amazing and kept me entertained from point one. Thank you for this.
The comic book world is a fked up place
Lanksey Welcome to to the comic book world, son.
The real world is equally f--ked up
Depends on the ones you read
That was awesome story telling!!! Great job!
I'm not a reader, but my friend told me civil war would be a good place to hop in. MY GOD it was even more emotional and carried a lot more weight than the MCU's Civil War. It had me crying and laughing OUT LOUD.
I love this channel, I never read Civil War but now it is one of the comic storylines that is on my list to read besides both Secret Wars, Magneto Testament, all Superman Rebirth and Infinite Frontier, Dark Nights Metal and Death Metal and 52 so I am caught up to speed on both Marvel and DC
Captain America being shot and killed after being arrested and Tony Stark saying it wasn't worth it to lose cap feels worth a mention.
WHY?!!!!WHY!!!???WHY!!??? IS IT ALWAYS NEW YORK
cause that's where most of them live lol
Now that you mentioned it, I noticed that most superheroes lives in New York, and even if it's not in New York, it would take place at least in a fictional version of New York.
nega-venom They just like to have an excuse to destroy famous buildings I guess lol Or maybe it's cause New York is a very big city with lots of different businesses and types of people that make it easy for heroes to blend in.
Roxanne Anders I see your point. After reading that comment, it made me inspired to create a superhero cartoon show that takes place in LA.
+nega-venom what about other countries???? What do they get???
when it comes to the comic (for the beginning anyways) I'm team iron man. he just wanted to talk and captain hit him with an emp than start beating him
Bruh Iron Man destroyed Cap so hard that Cap couldn't even land a single hit on him. That's why he had to get Vision to somehow disable Iron Man's suit from the back in that final fight so Cap could have a chance
Bruh its kinda like that in the movie too
It’s dumb
@@twizzlerlemonpie3083 facts. Iron man was beating Cap and Buckys ass, and it was a 2v1 💀
Except Maria started the war by turning against Cap for refusing to support arresting heroes
Actually, there is a comic that does explain how and why the registration act was removed. This comic event is called 'Siege'.
11:02 the way he narrated this scene is so awesome
I love your work you put into this. It allows me to get info on Marvel and DC Universe events without the need to pick up comic books, which you also provide in entertaining way or when I just need to check some informations quickly. Thx for this.
BTW out of curiosity - Do you only tell the stories from Marvel / DC Universe only ? I think it would be interesting to learn some new things from stuff like Spawn, Hellboy, Thorgal, Asterix & Obelix (why not ? :D) and some other comic worlds.
Hello Comicstorian, I had the misfortune of not being able to follow this story arc as a young adult - so I just want to thank you for putting this together to help people like me (who love comics but lost the time and resources to buy them) understand the story! Keep it up :-)
You bring this comic to life. I enjoy listening.
I will forever stand by Captain America on this one. If superheroes are forced to become federal employees, then they have to go where the government tells them to go. But what if there is a crisis in some other country that needs their help, but the superheroes can't help them because they would be violating orders from their government. And what if the government was just as corrupt as the villains they fight? There could be a crisis somewhere in Europe that needs help, but the US government forces the heroes to stop an amateur terrorist group from attacking an oil field in Texas that is crucial to gas prices in the US. And Peter's part on revealing secret identities is a very real issue that Tony, Reed, and Hank don't understand since they are more than willing to reveal their identities.
By signing the Act, superheroes are practically signing away their rights to be superheroes and endangering the lives of those they know and love.
You totaly forget to take the other side into account.
Standing with Cap means, that superpowered Individuals are allowed to break any law they want, as long as they are strong enough to not be overpowered by other superpowered individuals.
He literally even supports murderers and villains, because they want what he wants xD
@@truckwarrior5944 true, and that's what makes this story so good. There are rational reasons and faults on both sides that it can be a topic of discussion for ant debate. Unlike Civil War 2, which was just Captain Marvel being a moron.
@@benjaminkern6450 I'd disagree on that tbh. One side has the "MAH FREEDOOM!" argument, pretending that superpowers give you the right to infringe on other peoples rights, because you are stronger now.
Civil War 2 at least had the discussion about precognition, which has been a philosophical debate for decades for a reason.
I love your vids mannnnnnn!!!!!! Keep em coming, very enjoyable!!!!!! If i may i would like to know about Decimation. That story got my interest!
Quick question but why the hell did they need to publicly reveal their identities? I mean Spider-man made a good point in that all their loved ones were gonna be placed in danger once they unmask themselves (Though to be fair pretty much all major heroes already have a few villains that know their identity). Was there gonna be like a website or public document so that anyone thinking "Hey I want to know this guys secret identity" can just go find out? I mean you can't just publicly look up active government agents can you? Can you? Especially if their in a situation or mission where their identity could put lives at risk
They don't have to publicly reveal, just sign up with the government. Spiderman publicly revealed because Iron Man asked him to do it to prove a point. The problem here is that like Cap said, there are a bunch of crazy smart super villains that can easily hacking into government files and find the entire list of identifies
9:08 seeing my 2 favorite heroes fighting each other killed me big time
Although I love the Captain America: Civil War movie and it's probably the best MCU movie so far, I kinda wish they held off on this and did a two part movie just titled Civil War where they have expanded heroes and stick more to the original script, if they pulled it off well it could've been every superhero fans dream
This comic book miniseries recieved extremely polarizing reviews.
Comicstorian is amazing with his charismatic storytelling
If only the movie would turn out like this, because this would be so emotional and epic.
I love the story so much I constantly find myself rereading it
Idk what Peter was smoking when he decided to unmask himself
I hate civil war so much
its just so much stupidity piled on top of stupidity, and from what I looked up, iron man is the one who is supposed to be in the right, according to some of the writers/editors
which is DUUUUMB
all the shit he pulls during this is downright villainous,.
He was trying to prevent the inevitable. He was trying to make the best of the situation by convincing the government to offer Superheroes a chance. He wasn't corrupt, just the lesser of two evils.
kai robb as they say, "the road to hell is paved with good intentions"
just because he had a good goal in mind that does not stop him from being a bastard and a villain, many of the best villains are those who believe they are doing what is right
and he does lots of bad shit
seriously, how can anyone defend him nearly killing spiderman for questioning his methods?
the prison in the negative zone?
hunting down heroes and such
no matter how much people try to defend him, Iron man was the villain there
it might have been supposed to have been two equal sides (but then again, I've read around that captain america was the one the writers/execs considered to be in the wrong all along) but they failed at it
badly
I never saw it that way. I guess he srarted out doing what was best, but became corrupt. I haven't reached the bit about spiderman changing sides yet, so I could only assume that 42 was the worst part. What did he do to Spider-Man? Did he just attack him?
Maioly i guess thats way you see it doesnt mean your right i see iron man as being in the right
Thank you! This is the most overrated comic ever.
10:13 TONY HAS SENTRY HE SHOUTCAST WIN, HOW COME THIS NEVER COMES UP
Douche Bag No idea, but I do remember that sentry is supposed to be godlike so they probs removed him because he is too op. Well I did not read it but that is what I think what happened :)
That Sentry's a cyborg
wow with the music in the background it just makes the comic much more depression and sad
Comic storian you sir are truly excellent at queing the sad music when it is needed
Do Death of Captian America.
+Andrew Panetta I reeeeally would like to see this!
+I'mAlex
i would like it to prove permanent :)
+I'mAlex i'm a bit confused is that means you love Cap or you don't like him
+john neil Cap is but a mantle, falcon and Bucky also become cap
I would like to see some good Spidey stories, like the Clone Saga or One More Day
Seriously ?
Gr8 b8 m8
more like the worst stories
Orik Muzaffarli I know, I was just joking
JustDenzell The Spider-man clone saga is what made me stop reading comic books.
This is by far the best comic I have read
Hello, why wasn't Bucky in the Civil War comics?
+Balta Bueno Because the comics had nothing to do with the Winter Soldier. That was made for the movie
Comicstorian Thanks, does the comic explain that? Or did he only appear in the Captain America comics?
Wait, but didn't Captain America die directly after Civil War, and former Winter Soldier Bucky became the new Captain America, at least until Steve Rogers was resurrected (like superheroes always are)?
+LittleZbot yes
+Deshun Campbell funny
I think I love this narration better than any other I've watched. Thanks for the emotion put forth and actually showing the comic text unlike another video I just finished watching.
Also.. why did they simply write out the fact EVERYONE knew who Peter Parker really is. Or the fact Tony Stark is the reason behind the superhero registration act? That reminds me of "Who watches the Watchmen?"
Also didn't a civilian assassinate Captain America on the way to prison? (Seen that in the video by ComicIsland)
I love this story and you telling it makes it much better Benny.
Keep doing your thing bro!
OMG THE MOVIE WAS JUST 😍, TOTALLY LOVED IT