I am from India. I watched all your episodes with Shahzabia. I am very interested in geopolitics. I must say, your facts aren’t opinion-based. I like the way he puts things and tells a whole narrative around them. The way he accepts what's wrong and what's right is commendable. The last 5 minutes of the video were all about making me believe that people in Pakistan do talk about facts other than hypothetical stories. Thank you for sharing the knowledge. 🙏🏻
I'm sorry but you as a host should have been more aware about the topic. Its sad that you don't know who mullah bradar is and we're not aware of how kabul fell. It was all over the news. You should have researched.
I do admit the frankness but they have deliberately not stated the following facts: 1. A highly educated and well meaning MBA, Ashraf Ghani, who was living in US for many years was posted as the chief administrator in Afghanistan for seven years 2014 till 21 st August 2021. He did huge construction work for which all ( most) construction agencies were Indians. He however was no experience of war and best choice for him was to run away rather than fighting. Biden’n choice to quit Afganistan suddenly was the worst decision any individual could take. Indians did construction work in those few years of American rule worth over a billion of Indian money that included all the infrastructure that exists in Afghan today. Even Talibani’s have been requesting India to continue that work after Occupation. Pakistani military rulers were very happy when they got the control of Afghanistan on the platter. But Pakistan as a country has been suffering for such stupid decisions.
One thing you didn't ask which was equally important that How Afghan government run their business as their state money frozen by USA besides they have no resources
Even if the Taliban wish to court modern industrial world, he can’t. Having been content staying idle for centuries, the rustic mind of the Taliban wouldn’t function. Modern industrial world is a very demanding world. A highly educated and skilled labor force in America didn’t just pop up out of nowhere. It has taken centuries of hard work and play of mind. At least they haven’t sunk to the level of Jihadi state of Pakistan. They are too proud to be the recipient of borrowed dollars from I.M.F.
I disagree with your analytical review that Pakistan chose the people who are winning. No Pakistan chose people who were extremist and who will take over the world after they finish with the Russians. Indian cashmere was the next target. that’s why CIA did not trust ISI when they were told to give weapons to Masoud. ISI was siphoning so much money and whatever left was given to the most extreme elements.
Stop spreading your own wrong thoughts.Actualy they gave a safe passage to the US Forces to leave Afghanistan and that was the part of the deal.The whole world knows, who has been defeated but as you are Hazara and you were also a part of the community of Northern Alliance who got defeated, not accepting it.
America ko ek islamic mercenaries army chahiye is khitte mein take wo Iran aur dusre mubaliko pe nazar rakh sake, 100% agree with Shahzaib, ki inko America le ke aya hai inhe, taki abb inke saath business kar sake, asal mein Pakistan ko becha gaya hay.
How did it impact pakistan ? war against terrorism khatam , drone khatam , operation khatam , coalition support fund khatam , hon ke kariye ? Air Bases doh , drone humlay karo , mulk may deshat gardi karwao , Taliban say jung karo or dollars lo , yeah hai pakistan ke foreign or economic policy .
Come out from your stupid foolish naratives like covid vaccines ke andar chip hai opinions. Pak has no benefit from Afghanistan since 1947. Afghanistan is a headache for Pakistan as since 1947 they started attacking pak and doing proxies and eventually pak had to respond and create the influence to balance that which is the right. Ye fund yeh operation yeh chawale bhai foolish majority truck ki bati hai. Jitna nuksan pak ko Afghanistan ki war se hua ha fund uska 1% hai. Pak k lye Afghanistan sir dard ha aur pak ka koi interest ni Afghanistan me na wo koi productive society h war lord society h Afghanistan agar pak ke andar ye durand line or pashtun card na khele to pak ko koi shoq ni Afghanistan pe dehan dene ka bhi. 1970 tak pak ne koi respond ni kia Afghanistan ki karwaiyon ko Majbori me phr apna influence banaya jab agle baz ni atay.
![Noob To Max With DRAGON REWORK In Blox Fruits [FULL MOVIE]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/LnBMOinoOvA/mqdefault.jpg)
I am from India. I watched all your episodes with Shahzabia. I am very interested in geopolitics. I must say, your facts aren’t opinion-based. I like the way he puts things and tells a whole narrative around them. The way he accepts what's wrong and what's right is commendable. The last 5 minutes of the video were all about making me believe that people in Pakistan do talk about facts other than hypothetical stories. Thank you for sharing the knowledge. 🙏🏻
An illuminating sessions... brilliant
🙏
This podcast couldn't be more informative...much appreciated
🙏🙏
Shahzad Sahib I’m hazara afghan I spent my childhood in Peshawar, great conversation thank you both
Learned a lot from this conversation!
Great podcast , brilliant journalist shahzaib wahla
Excellent podcast. Thanks for providing first hand information based on real facts!!
Ghani did great for leaving the country and saved afghanistan from another Civil war
really nice perspective
Very genuine person 🎉🎉🎉
Very thoughtful, dunya main log kese kese under pressure zindagi guzaar rhe hotay hain or un ka faida uthaya ja skta hai 🥺
Fantastic presentation n discussion
Good good purposeful information. Wishes from India ❤
American agent or any anty Muslim will never like Taliban.
Extremely balanced account but conclusions are speculative
I'm sorry but you as a host should have been more aware about the topic. Its sad that you don't know who mullah bradar is and we're not aware of how kabul fell. It was all over the news. You should have researched.
Hm bhot khosh han hram zado
What an informative podcast 👍🏻
🙏🙏
Your channnel is really very hardworking , every single member of this channel contributes together for channel
🙏
Back ground music is too loud
वक्त वक्त की बात है कल की बात कल की थी आज़ की बात कुछ और है बात बदल जाती है वक्त के साथ, पाकिस्तान -तालिबान का संबंध ऐसा ही है।
Zabardast
If you could share a perspective on the ISIS history and how it failed?
Information video bro love from India ❤️
I do admit the frankness but they have deliberately not stated the following facts:
1. A highly educated and well meaning MBA, Ashraf Ghani, who was living in US for many years was posted as the chief administrator in Afghanistan for seven years 2014 till 21 st August 2021. He did huge construction work for which all ( most) construction agencies were Indians. He however was no experience of war and best choice for him was to run away rather than fighting. Biden’n choice to quit Afganistan suddenly was the worst decision any individual could take.
Indians did construction work in those few years of American rule worth over a billion of Indian money that included all the infrastructure that exists in Afghan today. Even Talibani’s have been requesting India to continue that work after Occupation.
Pakistani military rulers were very happy when they got the control of Afghanistan on the platter. But Pakistan as a country has been suffering for such stupid decisions.
Tutn ariynd us a natter of time. Oatience is called for. Highe 17:31 sr number ifwomen education is in Iran.
Finances
One thing you didn't ask which was equally important that How Afghan government run their business as their state money frozen by USA besides they have no resources
Even if the Taliban wish to court modern industrial world, he can’t. Having been content staying idle for centuries, the rustic mind of the Taliban wouldn’t function. Modern industrial world is a very demanding world. A highly educated and skilled labor force in America didn’t just pop up out of nowhere. It has taken centuries of hard work and play of mind. At least they haven’t sunk to the level of Jihadi state of Pakistan. They are too proud to be the recipient of borrowed dollars from I.M.F.
When you interview in Urdu why you interduce in English
America itne araam se ni nikla, wo apne trained logon ko handover kr k gya hoga. Jese wo hr jgah inner hold rkhta hai.
Much of them hv pak ID cards
I disagree with your analytical review that Pakistan chose the people who are winning. No Pakistan chose people who were extremist and who will take over the world after they finish with the Russians. Indian cashmere was the next target. that’s why CIA did not trust ISI when they were told to give weapons to Masoud. ISI was siphoning so much money and whatever left was given to the most extreme elements.
Host should be changed.he has no knowledge about topic.
😮😮
ان تمام باتوں کا سلوشن میں پاس ہے پہلے بھی میں نے اپنے ملک کو مصیبتوں بچایا اب بھی کچھ کرنا پڑے گا
Stop spreading your own wrong thoughts.Actualy they gave a safe passage to the US Forces to leave Afghanistan and that was the part of the deal.The whole world knows, who has been defeated but as you are Hazara and you were also a part of the community of Northern Alliance who got defeated, not accepting it.
Germet ?
Talubsb should now tue up with india, to open schools providing modern education
Tlibaan k sath Allah ki madad thi
Elie are angrezi taliban?
پاکستان نے بندے غلط چنے اور پالیسی کا تاثر بھی غلط دیا یعنی پالیسی غلط طریقے سے چلائی
Taliban brnegited by afghanistan peoples ferlung jniwn devil us better than unknown angels
taliban refusal to be used against india causing sorrow among pak punjabis.
America ko ek islamic mercenaries army chahiye is khitte mein take wo Iran aur dusre mubaliko pe nazar rakh sake, 100% agree with Shahzaib, ki inko America le ke aya hai inhe, taki abb inke saath business kar sake, asal mein Pakistan ko becha gaya hay.
Afganistan is making what for the trade and money? Is it drugs?
Sounds like another foreign implant?
How did it impact pakistan ? war against terrorism khatam , drone khatam , operation khatam , coalition support fund khatam , hon ke kariye ? Air Bases doh , drone humlay karo , mulk may deshat gardi karwao , Taliban say jung karo or dollars lo , yeah hai pakistan ke foreign or economic policy .
Come out from your stupid foolish naratives like covid vaccines ke andar chip hai opinions.
Pak has no benefit from Afghanistan since 1947.
Afghanistan is a headache for Pakistan as since 1947 they started attacking pak and doing proxies and eventually pak had to respond and create the influence to balance that which is the right.
Ye fund yeh operation yeh chawale bhai foolish majority truck ki bati hai.
Jitna nuksan pak ko Afghanistan ki war se hua ha fund uska 1% hai.
Pak k lye Afghanistan sir dard ha aur pak ka koi interest ni Afghanistan me na wo koi productive society h war lord society h
Afghanistan agar pak ke andar ye durand line or pashtun card na khele to pak ko koi shoq ni Afghanistan pe dehan dene ka bhi.
1970 tak pak ne koi respond ni kia Afghanistan ki karwaiyon ko
Majbori me phr apna influence banaya jab agle baz ni atay.
Judicious comments and narration
look who is talking 290 rs dollar wala 😅
Our attitude was wrong with talbanwhat will u sow so u willreep
Mera jism ,meri marzi group uncle
Is ProPakistani owned by Fauji foundation.
International border 😂
How did it impact Pakistan tumhara Afghanistan ke naam par jo paisa milta tga woh ruk gaaya 😂😂