The World is F*cked - Abhijit Chavda Geopolitics Update: ruclips.net/video/QpxWE_a9tnA/видео.html 10 CRAZY STORIES From India's History - BLOW YOUR MIND! - ruclips.net/video/uc_plE-nOAc/видео.html
@@juventus6728 They didn't walk away They were made to walk away. After INA was tried to neutralize by British. Their was a revolt which started within the army. And slowly it was started to be seen in Navy and Airforce as well. And huge reason was that INA was formed by the Indians who went to fight for British in World War 2 and were captured by Japan and Britain made no efforts to save the captured Indian Soldiers. The revolt was going on when WW2 ended and economic depression started. So British in England were weak and couldn't help the ones here in India with anything from man to commodities. They still tried to keep India as much as possible because ofc it could exploit but the revolts were so much that they couldn't afford another hit after WW2.
@@dashmeetgrover8891 it was the fear of Netaji and the passion he ignited in the youngsters of that time made the British quit India in a "peaceful manner"
**From Pakistan** This podcast was very productive and gave me a good perspective into critically analyzing my country's history and geopolitics. And YES! our textbooks lie to us too, very much!! Thank You Ranveer and Mr Abhijit!
@@siddharthdoshi1703 an utter fiasco is going on here since the corrupt leadership from all the Political Parties (Sharifs, Bhuttos, Mullahs etc.) have joined hands to overthrow Imran Khan's Government which was doing a good job. Now that Khan is out of power, the new corrupt government cannot handle the situation and hence, pushing the country into economic crisis. Everyone over here wants elections as soon as possible but the government is being stubborn, because if there are elections, Imran Khan is going to come back with almost 2/3rd majority - He is the best option we have right now.
I am a senior citizen...l used to hear this from my father who would have been over 100 years now if lived. He was very much against Gandhi and his intentions. He used to call him the biggest hypocrite in Indian Politics. But l was so confused at that time as what l was studying in History Books in school would not match with what my father would say . Now it is clear to me. Thank you for arranging this type of programme.Will look forward for many more.
I also have the same feeling. When I started to think properly after my childhood stage I also started to think that 'it is not as true as we have been thought'.
We also grew up believing that Gandhi and Nehru were God,s gift to Indians. But with age and maturity , we realize that were British stooges who are directly responsible for the ills in India.
Yess mam my father was a militant who faught in world war for britishers !!! He always use to tell all these stories abt that naval incidence and abt gandhiji and I was surprised not those things mentioned in our history !!!!
You should realise that means no one view is more true not yours not the once you are against. Its all about fact if you disagree debunk the point with proved facts or if you support then also support fact opinion doesn'/t matter in grand scale@@MDAman-bt2vi
@@soumyadiptadandapat2395 I can prove with facts that your parents raised you just because they wanted a man who can do work for them in older age Will you agree
I just gave my 10th board exam and realised humme kitni galat history padhai jaati hai. I am very interested in history to mujhe thoda knowledge hai but still my peers are unbothered by the fact ki unhe sahi facts mil bhi rahe hai ya nahi. 😐
Koe baat nahi brother.. Hum log hai nai.. We will do our best to First: get our own facts right, so we can spread the right knowledge like Chawda Sir.. 🙏
@@leo8402 and how do you know there is no god.....those who believe and don't believe in god are the same.....because they both have not experienced it
The fact that ranveer had to keep repeating and clarifying himself when it came to religion, just indirectly shows that the freedom of speech of our country is only applicable when it's in favour of what we want to here..
Absolutely agree with u.. check out Abhijit Sir’s channel he doesn’t even say mahatma or add Ji to Gandhi.. he is brave n spot on with facts.. respecting Gandhi, Nehru n Jinhah in fear of losing subscribers is what Abhijit sir will never do.. calls spade a spade.. watch his video on Gandhi n his experiments.. lakhs of people died during partition, Mohpla Hindu massacre, direct action day, Kashmir’s article 370 their sins r too many.. they were agents of Britishers.. Ranveer should learn such things from Abhijit Sir..
Brilliant episode. Too much of our brutal history is concealed and altered. We should all be honest and real with ourselves to understand our past better, and to avoid repetition of errors and blunders that occurred in history. Respect for keeping things real here. Big fan of this show and Dr Abhijit Chavda from 🇵🇰
Please don't mind , I don't mean to disrespect you but as a Pakistani didn't you feel offended from what sir said . I mean whatever sir said is true but is not taught even in India and why you liked this podcast. Just asking out of curiosity ? Love from India ❤️ 🇮🇳
@@dhruba5849 No reason to get offended here. I personally never did any of those things so why should I feel offended. The concept of patriotism towards a land mass is illogical to me, I’m more passionate about the social and cultural diversity and values our society represents.
@@ammarzaidi765 Pakistan needs more people like you, to absolve it of its identity crises. As long as Pakistan searches it's history in Arabs and Turks, it won't be at peace. It needs to accept it's Hindu heritage like Indonesia, and use those ties to form greater alliances with other nations like Indonesia does. We have the same blood, same ancestors, same history. We should be the greatest allies if only Pakistan accepts that it shares the same holy land as us, it too had the same fate due to invaders, absolve itself of it's crises.of identity. We are from.same Indus valley civilization, which infact lies in today's Pakistan along with Sun Temple of Lahore and many other places, even Takshila is in Pakistan..
@@ammarzaidi765 patriotism should be towards landmass/ geographical identity plus Civilizational identity... It should be combination of these 2 But Civilizational identity should take precedence. Cuz it's a larger entity
This takes me back to my highschool...On my first day of highschool our principal asks like who gave us freedom...we all students collectively went like "Gandhiji"...And our Principal was like who told this what about those thousand of people who sacrificed their lives for the sake of freedom and also told us about the true history of freedom struggles...He always acknowledged people like Bhagath Singh,Shivaji.. Also our school had different houses named Shivaji, Netaji,Tilak and Bhagath
Gandhi indeed had immense contribution in freedom movement Bose and bhagat singh life was shaped and inspired by senior leaders like gandhi It's true freedom movement was a big movement involving crores of people with many organisations involved in it - ghadrites, East Asian contingent of ras behari Bose,anshulan samiti and neither of them gave us freedom alone
Also take a look at 19:12 To iss hisab se to baki desh bhi WW2 ke baad Azad ho jane the ne? Bostwana, Ghana,Brunie,Fiji,Kenya in sabko 1947-1948 me kyun nhi mil gyi azadi?? 19:30 - ranveer bhai na to aap asli historian ho na chavda ji Yaa phir Aaplogo ne, dono ne kitni khud se research kitab likhti hai ki aapke opinion ko sahi maana jaaye?? 20:50 - Africa me NIC ki formation aur jo indians settled the unke rights ke liye lade, franchise bill ke khilaf (jo indians ko discriminate kar raha tha), newspaper indian opinion was run by him,Africa me Jahan natak aur Transvaal me Indians ki situation ekdum pathetic thi,wahan par bill wapas karaye - wahan par bhi Indians ke liye lade? Ye sab kam hai kya,kitne log karte hain ye sab Boer wars me medical help provide ki - usme help boers ki,boers ko white treat ni karte the,wo bhi indian community ki position strong karne ke liye He was a well know personality in Africa,he was instrumental in formation of Natal indian congress 22:57 - sir champran movement to mr jinnah shuru karne jaate haina? 1915 me gokhale ji ke amanantran se lekar congress ke kaaman sambhalane ke bich me - gandhi had already supported various causes - nadiad,kheda,bardoli, champaran,khilafat,gone against rowalalt act, strategizing swadeshi policy,pura bharat bharaman kar rahe the,full time politicaian the,aur aapke hisab se to gandhi ne kuch Kiya nhi india me parachute lekar aagye aur sidhe hi sabse bade neta ban gaye congress aur desh ke?? 24:50 - bhai ranveer ab ye mat bolio ki Caliphate aur khilafat movement bhi indian textbook me nhi hai kyunki bas aapko nhi pta iske baare me to 25:10 - sir aap to ab history hi mix kar rahe ho Khilafat movement in 1919 me shuru huwa tha,wo treaty of sevres ke through Caliph aur ottoman empire par jo sanctions place kiye the British ne,uske khilaf tha khilafat movement sirji Khilafat movement attrutk ke decision ko oppose nhi kar raha tha,infact khilafat movement 1924 me atatruk ke descion lene ke saath band ho gya totally,india me to 1922 me bhi traction khtam ho gya tha Jab atatruk ke decision lete hi khatm ho gya movement to usko oppose kaise kar rahe the? 25:45 - haan bhai British ke khilaf hi tha movement jab treaty of sevres se sanctions British ne hi daali thi,usi ke khilaf 27:45 - how did you reach this assessment? Please I request you write a research paper in it as a historian and prove(convince most of the reputed qualified historian) with proper methodology which historian use. In Africa - he lived for 21 years,made Indian community political strong there. Fought against several bills which were discriminating Indians in Africa,led for better amenities for Indians in Africa He was about to get killed by white mob in Africa at one time just because he championed cause of fellow Indians there He helped Indians there,fought against British there - is this considered service to British? What did his sevice to British Empire gave him? Him money?his kids some political throne? Plz tell the audience what did he recive in return? His grandson just recently few years back died in seculsion,many of his deacdensts are common man,middle class Bose,mn Roy,ras beahri Bose,Giani pritam singh,Raja Mahendra Singh - even never questioned the patriotism of Gandhi,even his biggest rival sarvakar and ambedkar never questioned his integrity. Please do us a favour get out this conspiracy and if no plz write a book with full methodology (you claim yourself a historian na?plz do it) This is just being ungrateful to the man,who single handlely has done more than most of us(including you) for the nations and the Indians 30:50 Gandhi has made the offer to Jinnah to be the pm of United India and form to the interim govt and he informed the same to viceroy linlithgow in 8 aug 1942, Jinnah's biographer Stanley wolpert says this too and the offer was made several times but Jinnah rejected it. In 1944 through CR formula - Gandhi proposed to achive independence jointly and then when the British leave,they can settle the issue of Pakistan with a pebliscite after the British leave but league refused this too. India was supposed to be independent in 1948 and gandhi was securing support from several leaders and parties (as many parties other than congress and league were stakeholders in this) for united India,there was a supposed fasting too but direct action happened dueti which indian independent was pre-poned to 1947,gandhi had to then move his attention towards the riots engulfed naokhali to stop the killings happening there. Chavdaji you need to update your information on this as you seem to think gandhi did not act on this,kindly read more on it. 31:35 - sir ye bhi aaphi hi assesment hai ki ye kahin likhit me proof hai ki ki congress ke kaido 5 star me rakha jata tha? All the flood relief campaigns,school built,securing rights for more political participation of Indians in governing India even when British were here, tax reduction campaigns? Who did all this? Does that amount to nothing according to you? Provincal elections, voting rights (whomever got it) - happened own its own,while sitting in 5 star hotel?? isnt this too much ungratefulness 33:00 - and plz enlighten the viewers who demanded for partition?which parties and org supported partition Sindh assembly passed the resolution in favour of pakistan,and the ruling govt of Sindh which passed the resolution was formed by the coliation of hindu mahasabha and muslim league,in Bengal again mahasabha and league formed coliation under the leadership of the guy - fazul haque which instigated the pakistan resolution. Apparently these both which supported partition and sow seeds for division are not responsible for partition?? But the parties which were forced to agree to demand of pakistan because of direct action day are responsible?? Why are you skipping direct action day which forced the partition on us and several talks,intiative to stop partition as that never happened?? is this how you see history with your own lens Also enlighten the viewers about Gandhi's plan(before assaination) to visit pak Punjab and other areas to forge better relation while reorganization of territories was happening? 36:12 - ranveer bhai,aap 1-2 hafto ki chhuti lekar saari ncert padho history ki pehle ,ye 8th class ki NCERT me cover hai - 1946 ki RIN mutiny 38:00 - chavda sir your skipping few very imp points and mixing things again. First of all gandhi didn't give any statements that - ki kya kar rahe ho?hume to non-violence se independence leni hai specifically on RIN mutiny RIN mutiny was majorly organised by 'ratings', most officers(Indians) in the royal indian Navy didn't support the mutiny Cabinet misson plan was ongoing behind the scenes as it was proposed in March 1946,RIN mutiny took place in Feb 1946.Both the events were going in parallel. Ratings were already compromised by army and royal British forces at Karachi, Calcutta only Bombay was the strong hold of the RIN. By 22 Feb the mutiny was already loosing traction as the British forces were breaking in and arresting ppl in hundreds. Sardar patel on 25 Feb made the rest of mutineers to put off the mutiny to avoid harsh consequences on them as the support and the mutiny had already was close to not succeeding. Gandhi on 3 March 1946 criticised the ratings for lack of organisation and prepared revolutionary party. Strike community was not clear about the independence in their charter of demands as most of the demands were about equal treatment in comparison to royal Navy. Leaders were watching this play out,who would the risk the proper transfer of power when it was going parallelly with these events? The major arms and big equipments were under British control,even indian officer sided with the British, without any leadership if the war breaks out between the forces,army stance still was not clear? Who would risk out losing out the war,reducing ones own bargaining power,killing the strength of our own forces when cabinet misson plan which was channelizing the transfer of power was taking place?risking this with 7-8 decades of independence struggle worth it? Chavdaji,why whitewashing events?let the audience know risk of war,losing out the war,power vaccum taking place due to this? Let the audience know about the Congo civil wars- which happened in similar fashion. Sir you particularly has something deep hatred for gandhi,as you accuse others of whitewashing facts but you do the same. 48:46 - Nehru was not the defacto PM. Those who wanted some other as PM could have simply supported the other guy and spring a leader of their own staying in India. Those who left India,they left because they believed in 2 nation theory otherwise Shah Nawaz Khan who was part of INA believed in United India moved to India itself.leaders like meer Taj mohmmed moved to India as they didn't support 2 nation theory. 49:00 - while I am optimistic about you with this on this point,par japnese occupation ka khatra?jo indian area japnese ke under the kuch weeks ke liye udhar to unhone local ka Massacre kiya tha - homfreyganj massacre to unse hume khatra nhi tha? 50:20 - uss waqt duniya ke saare leaders Hitler ko letter likh rahe the, prominent Jews Einstein ki trah Jews par ho rahe jurmo ko duniya ke saamne laa rahe the,india me hi gowalkar ne Hitler ne jaise Jews ki treatment ki uski tarif ki aur aapke hisab se duniya janti hi nhi thi?
Cross-check yourself and 2nd event is straight made up lie 51:31 - sir aapne bol diya to circumstancial evidence hogya?sir kya proof hai ye to batao.aap bolte ho ki plane crash ka koi evidence nhi hai jabki plane,pilot, hospital me jisse le jaaya gya wo sab public disclosure ke liye available hai,aapne khud crosscheck kiya ki ye info hi galat hai? 56:54 Ye neutral historian safed jhoot bol raha hai,Gandhi didn't choose pm for india,he chose congress president 1st election in India happened after death of gandhi and Patel Gandhi didn't threaten - fast untill death if Nehru is not made congress president,it's a straight lie He just pursuded Patel that Nehru is gandhi's choice as congress president to represent the interim govt and petel withdraw his name to respect Gandhi's choice He never threatened or fasted for this,which history are you studying?
@@kashutosh9132 I'm not telling that Gandhiji has not done anything...The thing is Along with the leadership of Gandhiji there were lot of people who were sacrificed their lives for the sake of freedom...So I just wanted today's generation to acknowledge other heroes along with the father of nation
@@sujaya2705 Definitely I agree with your points and I have also mentioned some less known movements and leaders which needs to more recognised. As thier contribution and movements are less known but their dedication and sincerity was unparalleled.
Towards the end when he says that even the people from the country would agree that they are not in good state… reminds me the dialogue in Gadar 2..”Agar tum apne desh ke har isaaan se poocho toh woh Khud hi Hindustan Jane ke liye tayaaar hoga”
My elder sister always said Mister Gandhi was not a Mahatma. I was confused because school taught us a completely different story and my sister said totally opposite of what was taught. But i guess she was 100% right.
Please be reminded that Nepal was never any part of India. Nepal is one of the few nations in world which is never ruled by outsiders, we are ever independent.
Chawda sir, Theoretical scientist Great Historian Geologist Anthropologist Cosmologist Theologianist Etc... Etc... Etc... Sir some time please give reference book . or otherwise you have a time machine Kya hi bolu aap dhanya hai Prabhu.
I hope South asian countries become developed and liberal. All of them. Like europe, east asia etc. Hope we all do well. And leave behind stuff like forced marriages, religious riots, corruption.
I'm feeling ashamed to write lies in my exams. Even though I scored really good but for myself I have come to realise I failed all those history tests.
Ranveeerrr..... You have my heart❤ Not everyone talks about this openly. Glad you pickup this topic..!! Be fearless..! Keep learning, growing and evolving. More power, positive vibes and love to you❤
@@ranveerallahbadia Ranveer i really wish to talk with you in person.. All the things you share here regarding spirituality as well i did experienced it in my life.....!!! I really really wish to meet you in person..!! Love and affection❤
@@ranveerallahbadia Cant i get a chance to talk to you..? Either on instagram dm..? I dont know why i feel some sort of spiritual connection with you sir..!!! So if possible for a few minutes..!
What a great convo this was. Keep it up Ranveer. It is our right to know as Indians and Pakistani's on what happened in the history. I think this will bring people from both nations a little closer. Keep doing it.
@@hariss3908 i didn't make a comparison between the two...and i humbly disagree with you. There are certain aspects and ideas of Netaji which would probably have made him a better candidate for the PM post
@@vedanthrao5879 oh. No problem. I understand where you are coming from. Patel was a good administrator and a strategist for our country. But he was weak when he had to take leadership. On the other hand Bose was a strong leader who took initiative. But he trusted the wrong people and chose the wrong allies. Both have their flaws. No one is perfect. I just feel we needed a leader like Patel back then who had a clean and clear vision for our country and had a plan. He even delegated well in areas that weren't his strong suit in terms of navigating the army and annexing princely states. He was good at giving people responsibilities and ensuring they followed suit. We had good people to take care of the day to day affairs. Patel had to oversee the entire operations which he was good at. He just wasn't great at demanding what he wanted and getting it for himself
Sir, inko firse bulake inse ek aur podcast nikalvao..inse current affairs discuss karo ...aur ye discuss karo ki abhi ki currupt politics agr hamare history k book mein pade raaja maharaja bhagwaan jaise shri raam🚩 the ....kaise raaj kar rhe hote ..kyuki hame pata hi nahi hain ki raja kaisa hona chahie... To ye janna hain ki agr aise raja shri raam jaise koi hote abhi..ya chhatrapati shivaji maharaaj jaise, maharana pratap jaise, to bhaarat varsh kaha pohcha hota ?.....iss topic ko vote kar k top pe laye jiss jiss ko ye janna hain ..👍🏻
He left India through dense forest. Before leaving he said..I will return one day. But, recently I heard that he was residing in Veitnam before got died. He his last rituals were also performed there and people from India often visit there to give him homage.
the royal indian naval mutiny is just mentioned in one line in our history books! i am a boards aspirant and i a shocked with the amount of what I have learnt! so much is missed out!
What a great podcast once again Ranveer and Abhijit Sir! I would like to request you Ranveer, that there could be an another great podcast on the Naval mutiny and the impact of INA and Subhas Chandra Bose everyone would really appreciate the podcast.🇮🇳🙏🏻
I strongly believe in what Mr. Chavada said. Got answers to lots of my questions. I'm in Canada a very proud Indian. I believe that we all should come even more stronger together & get these changes in our history, in our texts forever so that the newer gen knows the right history.
If you are a proud Indian, why are you in Canada. Go back and work in India. If you have any reasons to why you won't go back then you are not a proud Indian, and so you should learn to assimilate to your new country.
Glad people have started talking about it. These truths were never told and now when you talk about it, you'll find people labelling you with different different name and make absolutely no sense when they counter you.
It was a great podcast . Let me add an extra bit of info, that why was the ottoman sultan back then was called "The Khalifa" which means the supreme leader of Muslims around the world. It was because back then the three Holiest places(Masjids) in the Islamic world Makkah(Masjid), Madinah(Masjid)& Jerusalem(Masjid) were under the rule of the Ottoman Empire. So they were the custodians of these three Places, that's why the ottoman sultan was called the Khalifa of the Muslim world during his time. That's the reason why Saudi Arabia's king is not called the caliph(Khalifa) because he does not have control of Jerusalem (Masjid).
Physical possession of all three masjids was not a precondition to become Khalifa. Because at the time of mongol invasion of Baghdad the abbasid khalif Al mustasim didn't have possession of all 3 masjids. Khalifa was a titular position who held supreme religious and temporal power of Islam and Muslim people all across world where all islamic states and Sultans used to pay homage as tributary to the Khalifa.
Ranveer sir you are doing a great job, there is not a single podcast I have missed, and mr. chavda should be more known amongst common people. I love this Ranveer sir you're giving us a legit use of a proper usage of internet. Thankyou alot can't be more greatfull for what you have given to the audience. Iloveyou bhai alot.
There is no documented evidence to suggest that Mahatma Gandhi ever begged the British Empire to let him help in the war. Gandhi was a staunch advocate of nonviolence and actively opposed all forms of violence, including warfare. Throughout his life, Gandhi consistently promoted peaceful methods of resistance and social change, and he believed that violence only led to further suffering and destruction. While Gandhi did volunteer as a stretcher-bearer and driver of an ambulance corps during the Boer War in South Africa, his involvement was in providing humanitarian aid and medical assistance, rather than participating in combat or supporting war efforts. Gandhi's commitment to nonviolence and his belief in the power of peaceful protest remained consistent throughout his life, and there is no record of him seeking to support or participate in any armed conflicts.
I love Chavda Sir. Reading history is one thing, reading between the lines is another, and he is a master. I wish he would record his history episodes and load them as podcasts
This episode is just amazing... Can't believe this much has been hide from such... Time to re read the history. Greatest episode ever... Keep going guys... We are with you 🙏👍👍
Everything presented by him is not real history 19:12 To iss hisab se to baki desh bhi WW2 ke baad Azad ho jane the ne? Bostwana, Ghana,Brunie,Fiji,Kenya in sabko 1947-1948 me kyun nhi mil gyi azadi?? 19:30 - ranveer bhai na to aap asli historian ho na chavda ji Yaa phir Aaplogo ne, dono ne kitni khud se research kitab likhti hai ki aapke opinion ko sahi maana jaaye?? 20:50 - Africa me NIC ki formation aur jo indians settled the unke rights ke liye lade, franchise bill ke khilaf (jo indians ko discriminate kar raha tha), newspaper indian opinion was run by him,Africa me Jahan natak aur Transvaal me Indians ki situation ekdum pathetic thi,wahan par bill wapas karaye - wahan par bhi Indians ke liye lade? Ye sab kam hai kya,kitne log karte hain ye sab Boer wars me medical help provide ki - usme help boers ki,boers ko white treat ni karte the,wo bhi indian community ki position strong karne ke liye He was a well know personality in Africa,he was instrumental in formation of Natal indian congress 22:57 - sir champran movement to mr jinnah shuru karne jaate haina? 1915 me gokhale ji ke amanantran se lekar congress ke kaaman sambhalane ke bich me - gandhi had already supported various causes - nadiad,kheda,bardoli, champaran,khilafat,gone against rowalalt act, strategizing swadeshi policy,pura bharat bharaman kar rahe the,full time politicaian the,aur aapke hisab se to gandhi ne kuch Kiya nhi india me parachute lekar aagye aur sidhe hi sabse bade neta ban gaye congress aur desh ke?? 24:50 - bhai ranveer ab ye mat bolio ki Caliphate aur khilafat movement bhi indian textbook me nhi hai kyunki bas aapko nhi pta iske baare me to 25:10 - sir aap to ab history hi mix kar rahe ho Khilafat movement in 1919 me shuru huwa tha,wo treaty of sevres ke through Caliph aur ottoman empire par jo sanctions place kiye the British ne,uske khilaf tha khilafat movement sirji Khilafat movement attrutk ke decision ko oppose nhi kar raha tha,infact khilafat movement 1924 me atatruk ke descion lene ke saath band ho gya totally,india me to 1922 me bhi traction khtam ho gya tha Jab atatruk ke decision lete hi khatm ho gya movement to usko oppose kaise kar rahe the? 25:45 - haan bhai British ke khilaf hi tha movement jab treaty of sevres se sanctions British ne hi daali thi,usi ke khilaf 27:45 - how did you reach this assessment? Please I request you write a research paper in it as a historian and prove(convince most of the reputed qualified historian) with proper methodology which historian use. In Africa - he lived for 21 years,made Indian community political strong there. Fought against several bills which were discriminating Indians in Africa,led for better amenities for Indians in Africa He was about to get killed by white mob in Africa at one time just because he championed cause of fellow Indians there He helped Indians there,fought against British there - is this considered service to British? What did his sevice to British Empire gave him? Him money?his kids some political throne? Plz tell the audience what did he recive in return? His grandson just recently few years back died in seculsion,many of his deacdensts are common man,middle class Bose,mn Roy,ras beahri Bose,Giani pritam singh,Raja Mahendra Singh - even never questioned the patriotism of Gandhi,even his biggest rival sarvakar and ambedkar never questioned his integrity. Please do us a favour get out this conspiracy and if no plz write a book with full methodology (you claim yourself a historian na?plz do it) This is just being ungrateful to the man,who single handlely has done more than most of us(including you) for the nations and the Indians 30:50 Gandhi has made the offer to Jinnah to be the pm of United India and form to the interim govt and he informed the same to viceroy linlithgow in 8 aug 1942, Jinnah's biographer Stanley wolpert says this too and the offer was made several times but Jinnah rejected it. In 1944 through CR formula - Gandhi proposed to achive independence jointly and then when the British leave,they can settle the issue of Pakistan with a pebliscite after the British leave but league refused this too. India was supposed to be independent in 1948 and gandhi was securing support from several leaders and parties (as many parties other than congress and league were stakeholders in this) for united India,there was a supposed fasting too but direct action happened dueti which indian independent was pre-poned to 1947,gandhi had to then move his attention towards the riots engulfed naokhali to stop the killings happening there. Chavdaji you need to update your information on this as you seem to think gandhi did not act on this,kindly read more on it. 31:35 - sir ye bhi aaphi hi assesment hai ki ye kahin likhit me proof hai ki ki congress ke kaido 5 star me rakha jata tha? All the flood relief campaigns,school built,securing rights for more political participation of Indians in governing India even when British were here, tax reduction campaigns? Who did all this? Does that amount to nothing according to you? Provincal elections, voting rights (whomever got it) - happened own its own,while sitting in 5 star hotel?? isnt this too much ungratefulness 33:00 - and plz enlighten the viewers who demanded for partition?which parties and org supported partition Sindh assembly passed the resolution in favour of pakistan,and the ruling govt of Sindh which passed the resolution was formed by the coliation of hindu mahasabha and muslim league,in Bengal again mahasabha and league formed coliation under the leadership of the guy - fazul haque which instigated the pakistan resolution. Apparently these both which supported partition and sow seeds for division are not responsible for partition?? But the parties which were forced to agree to demand of pakistan because of direct action day are responsible?? Why are you skipping direct action day which forced the partition on us and several talks,intiative to stop partition as that never happened?? is this how you see history with your own lens Also enlighten the viewers about Gandhi's plan(before assaination) to visit pak Punjab and other areas to forge better relation while reorganization of territories was happening? 36:12 - ranveer bhai,aap 1-2 hafto ki chhuti lekar saari ncert padho history ki pehle ,ye 8th class ki NCERT me cover hai - 1946 ki RIN mutiny 38:00 - chavda sir your skipping few very imp points and mixing things again. First of all gandhi didn't give any statements that - ki kya kar rahe ho?hume to non-violence se independence leni hai specifically on RIN mutiny RIN mutiny was majorly organised by 'ratings', most officers(Indians) in the royal indian Navy didn't support the mutiny Cabinet misson plan was ongoing behind the scenes as it was proposed in March 1946,RIN mutiny took place in Feb 1946.Both the events were going in parallel. Ratings were already compromised by army and royal British forces at Karachi, Calcutta only Bombay was the strong hold of the RIN. By 22 Feb the mutiny was already loosing traction as the British forces were breaking in and arresting ppl in hundreds. Sardar patel on 25 Feb made the rest of mutineers to put off the mutiny to avoid harsh consequences on them as the support and the mutiny had already was close to not succeeding. Gandhi on 3 March 1946 criticised the ratings for lack of organisation and prepared revolutionary party. Strike community was not clear about the independence in their charter of demands as most of the demands were about equal treatment in comparison to royal Navy. Leaders were watching this play out,who would the risk the proper transfer of power when it was going parallelly with these events? The major arms and big equipments were under British control,even indian officer sided with the British, without any leadership if the war breaks out between the forces,army stance still was not clear? Who would risk out losing out the war,reducing ones own bargaining power,killing the strength of our own forces when cabinet misson plan which was channelizing the transfer of power was taking place?risking this with 7-8 decades of independence struggle worth it? Chavdaji,why whitewashing events?let the audience know risk of war,losing out the war,power vaccum taking place due to this? Let the audience know about the Congo civil wars- which happened in similar fashion. Sir you particularly has something deep hatred for gandhi,as you accuse others of whitewashing facts but you do the same. 48:46 - Nehru was not the defacto PM. Those who wanted some other as PM could have simply supported the other guy and spring a leader of their own staying in India. Those who left India,they left because they believed in 2 nation theory otherwise Shah Nawaz Khan who was part of INA believed in United India moved to India itself.leaders like meer Taj mohmmed moved to India as they didn't support 2 nation theory. 49:00 - while I am optimistic about you with this on this point,par japnese occupation ka khatra?jo indian area japnese ke under the kuch weeks ke liye udhar to unhone local ka Massacre kiya tha - homfreyganj massacre to unse hume khatra nhi tha? 50:20 - uss waqt duniya ke saare leaders Hitler ko letter likh rahe the, prominent Jews Einstein ki trah Jews par ho rahe jurmo ko duniya ke saamne laa rahe the,india me hi gowalkar ne Hitler ne jaise Jews ki treatment ki uski tarif ki aur aapke hisab se duniya janti hi nhi thi?
And please re read real history,as a lot of wrong facts are presented 51:31 - sir aapne bol diya to circumstancial evidence hogya?sir kya proof hai ye to batao.aap bolte ho ki plane crash ka koi evidence nhi hai jabki plane,pilot, hospital me jisse le jaaya gya wo sab public disclosure ke liye available hai,aapne khud crosscheck kiya ki ye info hi galat hai? 56:54 Ye neutral historian safed jhoot bol raha hai,Gandhi didn't choose pm for india,he chose congress president 1st election in India happened after death of gandhi and Patel Gandhi didn't threaten - fast untill death if Nehru is not made congress president,it's a straight lie He just pursuded Patel that Nehru is gandhi's choice as congress president to represent the interim govt and petel withdraw his name to respect Gandhi's choice He never threatened or fasted for this,which history are you studying?
Hey! I recently started watching your videos and I am hooked. I live in the USA and so, as an international supporter, I have downloaded the Level app. I am super excited to explore it. I have a request after watching this particular video. Can you ask Mr. Chavda and let know where to read Gandhiji’s original writings. I have a hard time trusting documents on the internet.
Superb episode, this episode is now my favourite episode till now, I wanted someone to tell me why and what exactly happened during partition why alot people hate gandhi, why we could never know the truth of subhash chandra bose and alot more THIS IS THE BEST episode Ranveer bhai
Mr. Ranveer, very wonderful podcasts you bring. Many things we as common man know is hard to expose publically. Abhijit sir, has given a very wonderful insight. Hope the world realize this
Thank you for this podcast. I'm student of class 12th of history and political science and your podcast is very helpful for me to develop my thoughts and thinking as well.
Hi Ranveer sir, I've gone through all of your historical podcasts and I'm very much thankful to you and the whole efforts of yours. I would request you to make a podcast along with Sir Ninand Bedekar whose a historian very well known for Maratha and ancient Indian kingdoms history. My best wishes with you for the upcoming future.
MAHATMA GANDHI IS A BRAND CREATED BY THE ALLIED POWERS, TO SHOW HOW FRIENDLY AND PEACEFUL THEY WERE, AND HOW AMICABLY THEY LIBERATED INDIANS WHOSE AMBASSADOR BEING GANDHI. That's why you wouldn't find a single country in the world where Gandhi is criticized. The opposite would have happened if Axis powers had won the war.
Bro you must read about GANDHIJI from sources you like but authentic sources you will know how great he was.. He was lawyer at that time and would have earned a lot and must have lived the life everyone dreams of today.. But he struggled not just for India but also against racism in Africa.. And wisdom is in books not in this people who are just spreading this narratives .. atleast Bhagavad Geeta padh le aur dhayn se samaj le jivan sudhar jayega...
My father was a teacher and he taught me exactly this history.. our history books must be revised to tell our next generation truth.. thank you so much for this video ❤
bt u never know harijan name given to sc by gandhiji u can hate me its ur choice bt this is so manipulating history not a factual just by dreaming and guessing ye huva hoga
@@GoForExplore u cant be m of mahatma bcz in the name of non violence u cant go in riots do u have guts tht legend went their and people listen him stopped tht many times if u want to know gandhi thn listen lacture of dr vikas divyakriti (IAS) sir's lecture. take knowledge from the well educated people don't from haters nd graduates of whatsapp university
@UCX5Qas_O9uEo9xdp6yyaMAA bro go nd tell this historian tht historian write history on base of fact real fact , papers ,not on random guys intrnet blog . just ye tha to vo hua hoga ye nhi kiya tha kyunki nahi pasand ye sab ak dreaming kehte he fact nhi . nd dnt tlk about savarkar nd godse savarkar game himself honour of veer 😂 write own biopic written by chandragupta later on people found savarkar was chandragupta 😂lol bhai koi apne aapko veer kese bol sakta and everybody knows abhijit chvda so called historian hates gandhi
Hello Ranveer, I recently watched "The Tashkent Files" movie and it depicts at what scale we have done Injustice to Lal Bahadur Shashtri. Specially the ruling Party- Indira Gandhi at that time. How we have totally ignored how Shashtriji died? October 2 is Gandhiji's Birth date but it is of Lal Bahadur Shashtri's too. I apologize if you already have covered this topic before but I think you must arrange a session with relevant person who can shade some light on Shashtri's life, patriotism and death controversy. I think "Anuj Dhar" is for sure the best person in this regards.
Most people don’t really want the truth. They just want constant reassurance that what they believe is the truth. These kind of Podcast will be the pillars for future generations to see a wide perspective of History. Awasome Ranveer keep doing these kind of Hard-hitting uncomfortable truthfull Podcasts.
My father was offered to be a histry teacher because of very gud credibly of teaching...but he refused to do do... because he was against teaching wrong histry to the pupils..
I have goosebumps, tears in my eyes, deep and painful sorrowfulness hearing the words of Abhijit sir.. Thank you sir for such an eye opening history... Love you both.. Thanks Ranveer for the important questions...
@@sampoorn6767 Not Abhijit chawda but Ranbeer for sure. Just watch Abhijit chawda's podcast/interview whatever on jaipur dialogues channel you'll find he's man of words.
Abhijit z not only a Pseudo historian but also a Pseudo physicist.....the kinda of mis-information hez spreading is dangerous and far from truth........ Jinnah was a power hungry politician who always strived for it....that's why he wanted a separate nation so that he can govern it and have all the power...... On the other hand Mohan das Gandhi was never a power hungry politician...... Jus because the current "Fake Gandhis" (Nehru's descendants) are incompetent..... doesn't mean..u ll go and downgrade Mohan das Gandhi
I'm a Pakistani but really enjoyed the podcast. Seemed very unbiased and true to the title of the podcast. Subscribing and keep up the good work on the subject!
Hey (Brother from another mother) Kya aap jinnah sir ke baare me kux bta skte that unke views ya unke baare ya unke respect me koi video suggest kr sko aap to. I'll be so thankful to you.
@@arijitsingh944 hey bro. Yes ofcourse I can. I generally read a lot about history - both medieval as well as about the subcontinent so I can tell you alot about jinnah as well which would be unbiased.
@@Ecofin89It is said that, jinnah had never followed all fundamentals of islam. He eat pork, take drinks, also do other stuffs. And near to his death, he regretted very much for partition and massacre of so many people. For only his own ambitions and desire to rule, he literally pushed laks of population in dark and blood future. What are your views on it ? bcoz atlast we have more muslims in india then Pakistan and majorly they are happy and also if you were also included then, would also enjoy majority.
@@Ecofin89 hey guys everyone who replied to our comments. I got an idea that why don't we all come together and make Twitter handle and discuss about this all ancient India and political stuff and all. Let's make a Twitter handle and we all could discuss and speak about it in space and we'll add abhijit chavda sir and some more historians with allahabadiya bro also. Comment your views on it plzz.
Maratha empire saved all Bharatiya from getting converted to islam. Because of Maratha Bharat has hindu dharma alive. Jay bhavani...jay Chatrapati Shivaji maharaj🥰
The story about Navy was not in our NCERT books, but I remember our history teacher told us the same thing that Mr. Chavda said and now I feel proud we had such a GREAT teacher who taught us what was not even in books. We need such teachers in schools.
Even we had an awesome history teacher. In class 10 we already knew what actually happened and what is brics nato everything. He is now an ias . Proud to be his student 🔥
@@lokeshchoudhary9472 book's and if they visit those certain places there are written history on stone like cravings , word of mouth , museum's , migrants and more other resources which i don't know about. Don't take them as completely truth but they are worth thinking about and relate as they sound true cause of all the evidences.
Another awesome podcast!! 49:10 Ranveer Bhaiya , please bring Anuj dhar on your podcast in regards to the death mystery of Netaji. PLEASE DO SO AND I BET ALL YOUR DOUBTS WILL BE CLEARED . Gumnami Baba being Subhas Bose is not just any random conspiracy theory anymore , there is enough evidence to prove what the truth is . You had mentioned this issue in another video as well , please do not hesitate and pursue it.
I was searching for hate comments from some people atleast but to my surprise I rarely found one even after scrolling for 15mins, that shows people are aware about the reality and are open to accept the facts. Majority of our real history was so drastically erased and kept hidden from us.
Its not the real history , this person here is just selling a narrative either he do not know or wtever ,but he did not presented the real facts.Read books which tells factual history with dates facts & reason.Read spectrum books,rajiv ahir ,ram chandra guha,bipin chandra...There were no five star jails for anyone back then....Gandhi ji did not just became the centre the of indian politics overnight & he must have done something that everyone around the world started admiring him & still respect him. He was not perfect & nor did all of his actions,but he was not god that we expect him to hv done all the superhuman things,he did things & used methods which were best known to him, all others used theirs....for example bose choosed a different path which he felt was ryt thing to do at that moment....i dont understand why todays generation & media loves to judge their contribution without doing anything real for nation ourself... In real it was a cumulative result of all the efforts & sacrifices done by all of them & we should respect it. Period Regards Dr.Amit
Then please took a look at this,how is one thing spoken by one becomes history? 19:12 To iss hisab se to baki desh bhi WW2 ke baad Azad ho jane the ne? Bostwana, Ghana,Brunie,Fiji,Kenya in sabko 1947-1948 me kyun nhi mil gyi azadi?? 19:30 - ranveer bhai na to aap asli historian ho na chavda ji Yaa phir Aaplogo ne, dono ne kitni khud se research kitab likhti hai ki aapke opinion ko sahi maana jaaye?? 20:50 - Africa me NIC ki formation aur jo indians settled the unke rights ke liye lade, franchise bill ke khilaf (jo indians ko discriminate kar raha tha), newspaper indian opinion was run by him,Africa me Jahan natak aur Transvaal me Indians ki situation ekdum pathetic thi,wahan par bill wapas karaye - wahan par bhi Indians ke liye lade? Ye sab kam hai kya,kitne log karte hain ye sab Boer wars me medical help provide ki - usme help boers ki,boers ko white treat ni karte the,wo bhi indian community ki position strong karne ke liye He was a well know personality in Africa,he was instrumental in formation of Natal indian congress 22:57 - sir champran movement to mr jinnah shuru karne jaate haina? 1915 me gokhale ji ke amanantran se lekar congress ke kaaman sambhalane ke bich me - gandhi had already supported various causes - nadiad,kheda,bardoli, champaran,khilafat,gone against rowalalt act, strategizing swadeshi policy,pura bharat bharaman kar rahe the,full time politicaian the,aur aapke hisab se to gandhi ne kuch Kiya nhi india me parachute lekar aagye aur sidhe hi sabse bade neta ban gaye congress aur desh ke?? 24:50 - bhai ranveer ab ye mat bolio ki Caliphate aur khilafat movement bhi indian textbook me nhi hai kyunki bas aapko nhi pta iske baare me to 25:10 - sir aap to ab history hi mix kar rahe ho Khilafat movement in 1919 me shuru huwa tha,wo treaty of sevres ke through Caliph aur ottoman empire par jo sanctions place kiye the British ne,uske khilaf tha khilafat movement sirji Khilafat movement attrutk ke decision ko oppose nhi kar raha tha,infact khilafat movement 1924 me atatruk ke descion lene ke saath band ho gya totally,india me to 1922 me bhi traction khtam ho gya tha Jab atatruk ke decision lete hi khatm ho gya movement to usko oppose kaise kar rahe the? 25:45 - haan bhai British ke khilaf hi tha movement jab treaty of sevres se sanctions British ne hi daali thi,usi ke khilaf 27:45 - how did you reach this assessment? Please I request you write a research paper in it as a historian and prove(convince most of the reputed qualified historian) with proper methodology which historian use. In Africa - he lived for 21 years,made Indian community political strong there. Fought against several bills which were discriminating Indians in Africa,led for better amenities for Indians in Africa He was about to get killed by white mob in Africa at one time just because he championed cause of fellow Indians there He helped Indians there,fought against British there - is this considered service to British? What did his sevice to British Empire gave him? Him money?his kids some political throne? Plz tell the audience what did he recive in return? His grandson just recently few years back died in seculsion,many of his deacdensts are common man,middle class Bose,mn Roy,ras beahri Bose,Giani pritam singh,Raja Mahendra Singh - even never questioned the patriotism of Gandhi,even his biggest rival sarvakar and ambedkar never questioned his integrity. Please do us a favour get out this conspiracy and if no plz write a book with full methodology (you claim yourself a historian na?plz do it) This is just being ungrateful to the man,who single handlely has done more than most of us(including you) for the nations and the Indians 30:50 Gandhi has made the offer to Jinnah to be the pm of United India and form to the interim govt and he informed the same to viceroy linlithgow in 8 aug 1942, Jinnah's biographer Stanley wolpert says this too and the offer was made several times but Jinnah rejected it. In 1944 through CR formula - Gandhi proposed to achive independence jointly and then when the British leave,they can settle the issue of Pakistan with a pebliscite after the British leave but league refused this too. India was supposed to be independent in 1948 and gandhi was securing support from several leaders and parties (as many parties other than congress and league were stakeholders in this) for united India,there was a supposed fasting too but direct action happened dueti which indian independent was pre-poned to 1947,gandhi had to then move his attention towards the riots engulfed naokhali to stop the killings happening there. Chavdaji you need to update your information on this as you seem to think gandhi did not act on this,kindly read more on it. 31:35 - sir ye bhi aaphi hi assesment hai ki ye kahin likhit me proof hai ki ki congress ke kaido 5 star me rakha jata tha? All the flood relief campaigns,school built,securing rights for more political participation of Indians in governing India even when British were here, tax reduction campaigns? Who did all this? Does that amount to nothing according to you? Provincal elections, voting rights (whomever got it) - happened own its own,while sitting in 5 star hotel?? isnt this too much ungratefulness 33:00 - and plz enlighten the viewers who demanded for partition?which parties and org supported partition Sindh assembly passed the resolution in favour of pakistan,and the ruling govt of Sindh which passed the resolution was formed by the coliation of hindu mahasabha and muslim league,in Bengal again mahasabha and league formed coliation under the leadership of the guy - fazul haque which instigated the pakistan resolution. Apparently these both which supported partition and sow seeds for division are not responsible for partition?? But the parties which were forced to agree to demand of pakistan because of direct action day are responsible?? Why are you skipping direct action day which forced the partition on us and several talks,intiative to stop partition as that never happened?? is this how you see history with your own lens Also enlighten the viewers about Gandhi's plan(before assaination) to visit pak Punjab and other areas to forge better relation while reorganization of territories was happening? 36:12 - ranveer bhai,aap 1-2 hafto ki chhuti lekar saari ncert padho history ki pehle ,ye 8th class ki NCERT me cover hai - 1946 ki RIN mutiny 38:00 - chavda sir your skipping few very imp points and mixing things again. First of all gandhi didn't give any statements that - ki kya kar rahe ho?hume to non-violence se independence leni hai specifically on RIN mutiny RIN mutiny was majorly organised by 'ratings', most officers(Indians) in the royal indian Navy didn't support the mutiny Cabinet misson plan was ongoing behind the scenes as it was proposed in March 1946,RIN mutiny took place in Feb 1946.Both the events were going in parallel. Ratings were already compromised by army and royal British forces at Karachi, Calcutta only Bombay was the strong hold of the RIN. By 22 Feb the mutiny was already loosing traction as the British forces were breaking in and arresting ppl in hundreds. Sardar patel on 25 Feb made the rest of mutineers to put off the mutiny to avoid harsh consequences on them as the support and the mutiny had already was close to not succeeding. Gandhi on 3 March 1946 criticised the ratings for lack of organisation and prepared revolutionary party. Strike community was not clear about the independence in their charter of demands as most of the demands were about equal treatment in comparison to royal Navy. Leaders were watching this play out,who would the risk the proper transfer of power when it was going parallelly with these events? The major arms and big equipments were under British control,even indian officer sided with the British, without any leadership if the war breaks out between the forces,army stance still was not clear? Who would risk out losing out the war,reducing ones own bargaining power,killing the strength of our own forces when cabinet misson plan which was channelizing the transfer of power was taking place?risking this with 7-8 decades of independence struggle worth it? Chavdaji,why whitewashing events?let the audience know risk of war,losing out the war,power vaccum taking place due to this? Let the audience know about the Congo civil wars- which happened in similar fashion. Sir you particularly has something deep hatred for gandhi,as you accuse others of whitewashing facts but you do the same. 48:46 - Nehru was not the defacto PM. Those who wanted some other as PM could have simply supported the other guy and spring a leader of their own staying in India. Those who left India,they left because they believed in 2 nation theory otherwise Shah Nawaz Khan who was part of INA believed in United India moved to India itself.leaders like meer Taj mohmmed moved to India as they didn't support 2 nation theory. 49:00 - while I am optimistic about you with this on this point,par japnese occupation ka khatra?jo indian area japnese ke under the kuch weeks ke liye udhar to unhone local ka Massacre kiya tha - homfreyganj massacre to unse hume khatra nhi tha? 50:20 - uss waqt duniya ke saare leaders Hitler ko letter likh rahe the, prominent Jews Einstein ki trah Jews par ho rahe jurmo ko duniya ke saamne laa rahe the,india me hi gowalkar ne Hitler ne jaise Jews ki treatment ki uski tarif ki aur aapke hisab se duniya janti hi nhi thi?
Note, Gandhi supported to give away the money that was supposed to be splited in two newly formed nations during the partition , of which patel and ambedkar both apposed, according to them money should be divided 2-3 years later, so that we can have check on jinnah and other muslim league's politician
I am 55 years now....but I ostensibly remember that I was taught that "Khilafat" movement spearheaded by Gandhi and Congress then was meant for Angrejon ki Khilaf Lada Jane vala a combined Hindu Muslim tirade.....but now the world history accounts brings out the Turkish connection of this 'Indian freedom struggle'.....i remain shocked how hypocrites have been these congressmen so far?
Don't believe these liar find truth about man who himself follow the path of truth. Mr. Jinna haven't written a single book on anything. As a Sawarite I like to tell you that daughter of Subhash Chandra Bose knows better about him than anybody else. Read her writing & then believe.
Who was your teacher? And i think you were one of the numb student of your class who never questioned their teacher? I wish you had read your book well... Jise ye nahi pata khilafat ka khalifa se kya samband hai.
👏 Bjp now using these greedy youtubers to spread their hate game, divide and rule.. ! Very clever to brain wash sheeps but few can easily see thru this kiddish game!
I am from Pakistan 🇵🇰, and I love your podcast, especially on Neeta Ji, but one thing which I will add is that unfortunately, the real history was hidden by the state machinery from the people of both nations😪
Very beautifully covered all topics 1.I was unaware that Britishers didn't destroyed Mughal Empire it was Marathas 2.about Gandhi and jinna 3.the Navy struggle of 1946 which I had never heard about And the most important That the "Plane" Of 'Subhash Chandra Bose ' was not crashed
@@SudeeptoRoy10 there were Revolt in British-army , Navy & Airforce in 1946 . This caused Colonials to leave India , but before that they Partitioned India to take Revenge !
That is true ...but if u search further ...the main cause of revolt was that the INA soldiers who were captured were being tortured by the british ..thats y the indian soldiers especially the Navy started protesting
Ranveer Allahbadia... I'm from Fiji 🇫🇯 and my fore fathers brought to Fiji by the British to work. Requesting if you could do an episode or two or maybe more with Abhijit Chavda sir on how this indentured labour system came into place and so many Indians went about the World to work in other countries specially in Fiji 🇫🇯
As per my grandfather his dad was in British indian navy and every time he told me about his father's story I was really amazed and that stories I can't tell here because many people will get offended If I say it here.💯
Definitely you can read true history of India but you can't put it in your answer booklet... there's a two perspective of Indian history like hathi ke daant khane ke or dikhane k or... and that's all because of the hypocrisy of our purchasable so called historians and the brown sahebs Congress
As someone who's Pakistani by ethnicity, I found this podcast very informative and real. Also appreciate how you approached this whole subject respectfully, trying your best to not offend anyone. Can't wait for Part 2- would love to find out more about the present and possible future!
What is ethnically Pakistani? You could say that your ethnicity is, for example, Baloch, Sindhi, or Punjabi if you don't want to say that you are ethnically Indian. But yeah you are Pakistani by nationality not ethnically.
There is another perspective to it, Nehru ji was much younger than Patel ji. And if we would have lost our leader early it would have derailed our progress. Pakistan lost its leader early just after independence, we can see where they are right now. Foundation strong karne ke liye maybe Gandhi ji ne ye kiya ho!!
@@shikharlitoria6907 The Nehruvian rate of growth of India's GDP lasted till 1990 and India's GDP grew at 2% per year using Nehru Ji's idea of Fabian Socialism, search it and please then write , please don't comment on your knowledge based out of another RUclips video....read the materials from the internet and search it up!!
@@dhruba5849 Gandhi had already declared Nehru as his successor , at point 1942 when there was danger of japanese invasion Patel sidelined Nehru and Gandhi and took control of Congress and told britishers to support them in case of invasion of japanese. Many times Nehru proved his worth before becoming PM and gave some important advice like whether to support britishers or not, as a mediater between Bose and gandhi during Tripure session of Congress . Patel has also two phase earlier he was complete devotte of Gandhi later he changed after seeing failures of NCM and CDM he started to become extremist which may develop hate in Gandhi to Patel
Abhijit sir taught me more than school + college this kind of people needs to be protected and celebrated Ranveer its a humble request please invite these kind of people in place of celebrities
@@satyamjha2124 everything this Man is saying is Bitter Truth Our History books are written by the British which glorify invaders and manipulate facts Never say anything about the Brave hearts like Rani Lakshmi Bai Bhagat Singh ji etc
@@satyamjha2124 in current fast paced life if someone who has done so much reaserch nd read lots of books if someone is sharing the things which he has read and research then there should be no problem in getting information or knowledge from that particular person
Being a Bangladeshi Citizen,i also learnt a lot about the history of Indian subcontinent from this podcasts..Thanks to Ranbeer and Abhijit Sir for this great informative podcast..looking for more content like this..keep up the good work👍
I am a Pakistani. But, Being a rational person, I love to get the 360 degree angles of the geopolitical issues. Brilliant. I must appreciate the efforts you put to bring people closer. Sometimes, We may have differences but culturally we are same, same ancestors and history. One Day It may be dealt with. I do not think It must offend anyone. Keep it up Ranveer Jee
👏 Bjp now using these greedy youtubers to spread their hate game, divide and rule.. ! Very clever to brain wash sheeps but few can easily see thru this kiddish game!
I am a Pakistani and I just finished this episode. Abhijit Sir's words about current situation of Pakistan are very accurate. Love and prayers for both the countries.
In grade 12, I had 90% score in History. With this podcast, which negates a lot of things that I learnt, I feel I failed my grade , since we were taught wrong story. I want to read everything from the start now all over again. Thank you Abhijit ji, for opening our eyes. You are a legend, and thank you Ranveer for bringing it to us.
How can you believe his every word so blindly man😅😅 everyone is guided by an ideology and they present things according to that. So don't believe blindly on anyone and go search read and try to understand things on your own.
@@ratansinghbaghel3970 yeah it's true people are driven by ideology, but for everyone to become historians just to know what is the exact truth (which may even be near to impossible) it's better to follow one ideology that seems more convincing and supports your intrest. That is how strong nations are built, look at china, if there would have been transparency of the history of their nation, do you think they could have prospered the way they did, not only china but the entirety of Whiteman nations are built on pseudo historical ideologies! After all, the world politics is just a war of ideologies and the winners are able to push forward their ideology as truth.
@@descendedofrigvedicclans2216 Nehru was good at building institutions... Tht i can give credit to him... Other than tht... Zero respect to him. He was a Hinduphobic bigot who ruined indian economy
@@descendedofrigvedicclans2216 i didn't say he was a good person... I said he was good at building institutions.. thts all I exactly know how terrible and horrible Nehru was in rest of the things
Truth & Reconciliation is the need of the hour. It's important to discuss and know the truth about history and not put all the uncomfortable events under the carpet
Books to read to know the dark side of Gandhi:- Research and Study of Life of Gandhi Gandhi - Naked Ambition Great Soul Subhas Chandra Bose in Nazi Germany Truth about Gandhi's sex life Shattered Heroes: Gandhi's Dark Side 10 curious controversies about Mahatma Gandhi It's time to stop glorifying Gandhi once and for all
Truth and reconciliation have their place. The poster child would be to take legal recourse against Britain and her activities, looting India and conspiring against India and partition of India. $43 trillion dollars was looted from Bharat. The British in conducting the first census, randomly assigned Indians to a similar European system which in time became the ossefied caste system. Caste comes from the Portuguese word kasta. India has varna and jati, yet India is hung with caste. They created episode after episode of famine leading to genoicide. Churchill knowingly, transported grain out of India to other countries where it was not even needed, whilst thousands of Indians were dying. Countries like US and Australia offered aid and grain, but Churchill denied any assistance - let them die. Remember those skeletal images of Indians forever burnt into your memory? It was so bad Starving Indians were eating grass. All Churchill could say was beastly Indians, I hate Indians. Demand that Britain return $43 trillion, the kohinoor, and what's in their museums. In British history, Churchill is whitewshed as a hero. Not the supremist and racist he clearly proved himself to be.Have courage to google and read for yourself.
Aap bilkul sahi kehrahahe . We believe you 100% . Firoz khan aur iska next generation step by step jabke Muslim hain yeh jante hoye bhi Gandhi ne isko Gandhi surname diya . Jahar lal nehru se lekar moti lal ka purwaj musalman hi tha .
Hahahaha... Nehru became PM in 1952. He became secretary in Congress in 1946-47. He doesn't know the history as he doesn't complete the books as he said in one of his interviews.
Just a small correction, Jinnah wasn’t the first prime minister of Pakistan, it was liaquat Ali khan. Mohammed Ali Jinnah was the first Governor General who’s the representative of the queen to the Pakistan. And there’s another interesting story about him in which Jinnah had formerly asked Nehru to come back to Bombay as his house in Malabar hill was very dear to him.
I have shared this podcast to my parents and family to enlighten them. Most of my family members are teachers, who taught us to worship Gandhi ji. Except for one uncle. Thanks to that Uncle, I learnt to think rationally. Today, after listening to this podcast, I really appreciate way of showing us practical aspects of history.
Believe the man who follow the path of truth. Chawda don't even know that Jinna wasn't 1st wazir e azam of Pak. Jinna was 1st Governor general of Pak & Liakat Ali was the 1st PM of Pak.
Gandhi returned to India in 1915 and was insisted by Gokhale sahab to join Congress as the revolution needs more and more people and late in 1934 or so he also resigned from congress and may be again he had to join the party....Now you tell me he didnt revolutionize the whole congress party over night u moeon Chavda..it took hi time to make the 35 year old political party to a new level...the way you explained it is like it was a mere minute of his life time but it take time for a revolution😂🤣
![Yailin La Mas Viral, @kreizyk.official - Dale 2 (Remix) [Video Oficial]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/JaYHBzgqz94/mqdefault.jpg)
The World is F*cked - Abhijit Chavda Geopolitics Update: ruclips.net/video/QpxWE_a9tnA/видео.html
10 CRAZY STORIES From India's History - BLOW YOUR MIND! - ruclips.net/video/uc_plE-nOAc/видео.html
gift krdo bhai kuch
this master made claims without any sources or evidence
give your sources
he made claims on ghandhiji without proofs
Kyu re bhadwe pseudo science promote karta tha ab political propaganda bhi failane laga🤦🏻♂️
Freedom is not given ,it is taken
~Subhash Chandra Bose🇮🇳🇮🇳
@@juventus6728 They didn't walk away
They were made to walk away.
After INA was tried to neutralize by British. Their was a revolt which started within the army. And slowly it was started to be seen in Navy and Airforce as well. And huge reason was that INA was formed by the Indians who went to fight for British in World War 2 and were captured by Japan and Britain made no efforts to save the captured Indian Soldiers.
The revolt was going on when WW2 ended and economic depression started. So British in England were weak and couldn't help the ones here in India with anything from man to commodities. They still tried to keep India as much as possible because ofc it could exploit but the revolts were so much that they couldn't afford another hit after WW2.
@@saptarshipal6743 and adding to it i guess is the Bengal famine
@@dashmeetgrover8891 it was the fear of Netaji and the passion he ignited in the youngsters of that time made the British quit India in a "peaceful manner"
@@juventus6728 that's ancient Persian right? On ur name?
@@dashmeetgrover8891 we can conclude that Netaji really was the biggest enemy of the British Empire...
**From Pakistan**
This podcast was very productive and gave me a good perspective into critically analyzing my country's history and geopolitics. And YES! our textbooks lie to us too, very much!! Thank You Ranveer and Mr Abhijit!
Wow you have been an intelligent
How's the political turmoil going there? Would love to get some insights..... Who you personally feel should be in power?
Same here bro our text books lied to us
@Chappelle Then in what we should believe?
@@siddharthdoshi1703 an utter fiasco is going on here since the corrupt leadership from all the Political Parties (Sharifs, Bhuttos, Mullahs etc.) have joined hands to overthrow Imran Khan's Government which was doing a good job. Now that Khan is out of power, the new corrupt government cannot handle the situation and hence, pushing the country into economic crisis. Everyone over here wants elections as soon as possible but the government is being stubborn, because if there are elections, Imran Khan is going to come back with almost 2/3rd majority - He is the best option we have right now.
I am a senior citizen...l used to hear this from my father who would have been over 100 years now if lived. He was very much against Gandhi and his intentions. He used to call him the biggest hypocrite in Indian Politics. But l was so confused at that time as what l was studying in History Books in school would not match with what my father would say . Now it is clear to me. Thank you for arranging this type of programme.Will look forward for many more.
I have red your whole comment, I think it's a best compliment for ranveer show.
absolutely wonderful mam❤️
I also have the same feeling. When I started to think properly after my childhood stage I also started to think that 'it is not as true as we have been thought'.
We also grew up believing that Gandhi and Nehru were God,s gift to Indians. But with age and maturity , we realize that were British stooges who are directly responsible for the ills in India.
@@divyagautam2216 same here
Yess mam my father was a militant who faught in world war for britishers !!! He always use to tell all these stories abt that naval incidence and abt gandhiji and I was surprised not those things mentioned in our history !!!!
Maturity is when you realise gandhi was not mahatma 😊
It's a sign of foolishness bro you can be manipulated by anyone 😢😢
You should realise that means no one view is more true not yours not the once you are against. Its all about fact if you disagree debunk the point with proved facts or if you support then also support fact opinion doesn'/t matter in grand scale@@MDAman-bt2vi
@@MDAman-bt2vi bro or you can also be manipulated by our constitution
@@soumyadiptadandapat2395 I can prove with facts that your parents raised you just because they wanted a man who can do work for them in older age
Will you agree
@@MRIDULMITRA-ii7fk textbook taught us what could make us a good human being
I just gave my 10th board exam and realised humme kitni galat history padhai jaati hai. I am very interested in history to mujhe thoda knowledge hai but still my peers are unbothered by the fact ki unhe sahi facts mil bhi rahe hai ya nahi. 😐
Koe baat nahi brother.. Hum log hai nai.. We will do our best to First: get our own facts right, so we can spread the right knowledge like Chawda Sir.. 🙏
you should read more podcasts won't be helpful either
@@leo8402 and how do you know there is no god.....those who believe and don't believe in god are the same.....because they both have not experienced it
Hmm same case with me
You are lucky atleast itni jaldi you are aware and you will bring the change ❤️
The fact that ranveer had to keep repeating and clarifying himself when it came to religion, just indirectly shows that the freedom of speech of our country is only applicable when it's in favour of what we want to here..
exactly
Exactly!!
Hai Ram, what has happened to this Dharmic land😢😢
@@faadhilkhaled9012 he even twisted the meaning and teachings of some sanatani shlok's for his benifit
@@debosmandasgupta3940 these are the results of colonization, invasions , thousands of betrayals and a f*cked society and system..
Absolutely agree with u.. check out Abhijit Sir’s channel he doesn’t even say mahatma or add Ji to Gandhi.. he is brave n spot on with facts.. respecting Gandhi, Nehru n Jinhah in fear of losing subscribers is what Abhijit sir will never do.. calls spade a spade.. watch his video on Gandhi n his experiments..
lakhs of people died during partition, Mohpla Hindu massacre, direct action day, Kashmir’s article 370 their sins r too many.. they were agents of Britishers..
Ranveer should learn such things from Abhijit Sir..
Brilliant episode. Too much of our brutal history is concealed and altered. We should all be honest and real with ourselves to understand our past better, and to avoid repetition of errors and blunders that occurred in history. Respect for keeping things real here. Big fan of this show and Dr Abhijit Chavda from 🇵🇰
Please don't mind , I don't mean to disrespect you but as a Pakistani didn't you feel offended from what sir said . I mean whatever sir said is true but is not taught even in India and why you liked this podcast. Just asking out of curiosity ?
Love from India ❤️ 🇮🇳
@@dhruba5849 No reason to get offended here. I personally never did any of those things so why should I feel offended. The concept of patriotism towards a land mass is illogical to me, I’m more passionate about the social and cultural diversity and values our society represents.
@@ammarzaidi765 Pakistan needs more people like you, to absolve it of its identity crises. As long as Pakistan searches it's history in Arabs and Turks, it won't be at peace. It needs to accept it's Hindu heritage like Indonesia, and use those ties to form greater alliances with other nations like Indonesia does. We have the same blood, same ancestors, same history. We should be the greatest allies if only Pakistan accepts that it shares the same holy land as us, it too had the same fate due to invaders, absolve itself of it's crises.of identity. We are from.same Indus valley civilization, which infact lies in today's Pakistan along with Sun Temple of Lahore and many other places, even Takshila is in Pakistan..
@@ammarzaidi765 patriotism should be towards landmass/ geographical identity plus Civilizational identity... It should be combination of these 2
But Civilizational identity should take precedence. Cuz it's a larger entity
U r man of truth bruh 🤍🤍
This takes me back to my highschool...On my first day of highschool our principal asks like who gave us freedom...we all students collectively went like "Gandhiji"...And our Principal was like who told this what about those thousand of people who sacrificed their lives for the sake of freedom and also told us about the true history of freedom struggles...He always acknowledged people like Bhagath Singh,Shivaji..
Also our school had different houses named Shivaji, Netaji,Tilak and Bhagath
Gandhi indeed had immense contribution in freedom movement
Bose and bhagat singh life was shaped and inspired by senior leaders like gandhi
It's true freedom movement was a big movement involving crores of people with many organisations involved in it - ghadrites, East Asian contingent of ras behari Bose,anshulan samiti and neither of them gave us freedom alone
Also take a look at
19:12
To iss hisab se to baki desh bhi WW2 ke baad Azad ho jane the ne?
Bostwana, Ghana,Brunie,Fiji,Kenya in sabko 1947-1948 me kyun nhi mil gyi azadi??
19:30 - ranveer bhai na to aap asli historian ho na chavda ji
Yaa phir Aaplogo ne, dono ne kitni khud se research kitab likhti hai ki aapke opinion ko sahi maana jaaye??
20:50 - Africa me NIC ki formation aur jo indians settled the unke rights ke liye lade, franchise bill ke khilaf (jo indians ko discriminate kar raha tha), newspaper indian opinion was run by him,Africa me Jahan natak aur Transvaal me Indians ki situation ekdum pathetic thi,wahan par bill wapas karaye - wahan par bhi Indians ke liye lade? Ye sab kam hai kya,kitne log karte hain ye sab
Boer wars me medical help provide ki - usme help boers ki,boers ko white treat ni karte the,wo bhi indian community ki position strong karne ke liye
He was a well know personality in Africa,he was instrumental in formation of Natal indian congress
22:57 - sir champran movement to mr jinnah shuru karne jaate haina?
1915 me gokhale ji ke amanantran se lekar congress ke kaaman sambhalane ke bich me - gandhi had already supported various causes - nadiad,kheda,bardoli, champaran,khilafat,gone against rowalalt act, strategizing swadeshi policy,pura bharat bharaman kar rahe the,full time politicaian the,aur aapke hisab se to gandhi ne kuch Kiya nhi india me parachute lekar aagye aur sidhe hi sabse bade neta ban gaye congress aur desh ke??
24:50 - bhai ranveer ab ye mat bolio ki Caliphate aur khilafat movement bhi indian textbook me nhi hai kyunki bas aapko nhi pta iske baare me to
25:10 - sir aap to ab history hi mix kar rahe ho
Khilafat movement in 1919 me shuru huwa tha,wo treaty of sevres ke through Caliph aur ottoman empire par jo sanctions place kiye the British ne,uske khilaf tha khilafat movement sirji
Khilafat movement attrutk ke decision ko oppose nhi kar raha tha,infact khilafat movement 1924 me atatruk ke descion lene ke saath band ho gya totally,india me to 1922 me bhi traction khtam ho gya tha
Jab atatruk ke decision lete hi khatm ho gya movement to usko oppose kaise kar rahe the? 25:45 - haan bhai British ke khilaf hi tha movement jab treaty of sevres se sanctions British ne hi daali thi,usi ke khilaf
27:45 - how did you reach this assessment? Please I request you write a research paper in it as a historian and prove(convince most of the reputed qualified historian) with proper methodology which historian use.
In Africa - he lived for 21 years,made Indian community political strong there. Fought against several bills which were discriminating Indians in Africa,led for better amenities for Indians in Africa
He was about to get killed by white mob in Africa at one time just because he championed cause of fellow Indians there
He helped Indians there,fought against British there - is this considered service to British?
What did his sevice to British Empire gave him? Him money?his kids some political throne? Plz tell the audience what did he recive in return?
His grandson just recently few years back died in seculsion,many of his deacdensts are common man,middle class
Bose,mn Roy,ras beahri Bose,Giani pritam singh,Raja Mahendra Singh - even never questioned the patriotism of Gandhi,even his biggest rival sarvakar and ambedkar never questioned his integrity.
Please do us a favour get out this conspiracy and if no plz write a book with full methodology (you claim yourself a historian na?plz do it)
This is just being ungrateful to the man,who single handlely has done more than most of us(including you) for the nations and the Indians
30:50
Gandhi has made the offer to Jinnah to be the pm of United India and form to the interim govt and he informed the same to viceroy linlithgow in 8 aug 1942, Jinnah's biographer Stanley wolpert says this too and the offer was made several times but Jinnah rejected it.
In 1944 through CR formula - Gandhi proposed to achive independence jointly and then when the British leave,they can settle the issue of Pakistan with a pebliscite after the British leave but league refused this too. India was supposed to be independent in 1948 and gandhi was securing support from several leaders and parties (as many parties other than congress and league were stakeholders in this) for united India,there was a supposed fasting too but direct action happened dueti which indian independent was pre-poned to 1947,gandhi had to then move his attention towards the riots engulfed naokhali to stop the killings happening there.
Chavdaji you need to update your information on this as you seem to think gandhi did not act on this,kindly read more on it.
31:35 - sir ye bhi aaphi hi assesment hai ki ye kahin likhit me proof hai ki ki congress ke kaido 5 star me rakha jata tha?
All the flood relief campaigns,school built,securing rights for more political participation of Indians in governing India even when British were here, tax reduction campaigns? Who did all this? Does that amount to nothing according to you? Provincal elections, voting rights (whomever got it) - happened own its own,while sitting in 5 star hotel??
isnt this too much ungratefulness
33:00 - and plz enlighten the viewers who demanded for partition?which parties and org supported partition
Sindh assembly passed the resolution in favour of pakistan,and the ruling govt of Sindh which passed the resolution was formed by the coliation of hindu mahasabha and muslim league,in Bengal again mahasabha and league formed coliation under the leadership of the guy - fazul haque which instigated the pakistan resolution.
Apparently these both which supported partition and sow seeds for division are not responsible for partition??
But the parties which were forced to agree to demand of pakistan because of direct action day are responsible??
Why are you skipping direct action day which forced the partition on us and several talks,intiative to stop partition as that never happened??
is this how you see history with your own lens
Also enlighten the viewers about Gandhi's plan(before assaination) to visit pak Punjab and other areas to forge better relation while reorganization of territories was happening?
36:12 - ranveer bhai,aap 1-2 hafto ki chhuti lekar saari ncert padho history ki pehle ,ye 8th class ki NCERT me cover hai - 1946 ki RIN mutiny
38:00 - chavda sir your skipping few very imp points and mixing things again.
First of all gandhi didn't give any statements that - ki kya kar rahe ho?hume to non-violence se independence leni hai specifically on RIN mutiny
RIN mutiny was majorly organised by 'ratings', most officers(Indians) in the royal indian Navy didn't support the mutiny
Cabinet misson plan was ongoing behind the scenes as it was proposed in March 1946,RIN mutiny took place in Feb 1946.Both the events were going in parallel.
Ratings were already compromised by army and royal British forces at Karachi, Calcutta only Bombay was the strong hold of the RIN. By 22 Feb the mutiny was already loosing traction as the British forces were breaking in and arresting ppl in hundreds. Sardar patel on 25 Feb made the rest of mutineers to put off the mutiny to avoid harsh consequences on them as the support and the mutiny had already was close to not succeeding.
Gandhi on 3 March 1946 criticised the ratings for lack of organisation and prepared revolutionary party.
Strike community was not clear about the independence in their charter of demands as most of the demands were about equal treatment in comparison to royal Navy. Leaders were watching this play out,who would the risk the proper transfer of power when it was going parallelly with these events?
The major arms and big equipments were under British control,even indian officer sided with the British, without any leadership if the war breaks out between the forces,army stance still was not clear?
Who would risk out losing out the war,reducing ones own bargaining power,killing the strength of our own forces when cabinet misson plan which was channelizing the transfer of power was taking place?risking this with 7-8 decades of independence struggle worth it?
Chavdaji,why whitewashing events?let the audience know risk of war,losing out the war,power vaccum taking place due to this?
Let the audience know about the Congo civil wars- which happened in similar fashion.
Sir you particularly has something deep hatred for gandhi,as you accuse others of whitewashing facts but you do the same.
48:46 - Nehru was not the defacto PM. Those who wanted some other as PM could have simply supported the other guy and spring a leader of their own staying in India.
Those who left India,they left because they believed in 2 nation theory otherwise Shah Nawaz Khan who was part of INA believed in United India moved to India itself.leaders like meer Taj mohmmed moved to India as they didn't support 2 nation theory.
49:00 - while I am optimistic about you with this on this point,par japnese occupation ka khatra?jo indian area japnese ke under the kuch weeks ke liye udhar to unhone local ka Massacre kiya tha - homfreyganj massacre to unse hume khatra nhi tha?
50:20 - uss waqt duniya ke saare leaders Hitler ko letter likh rahe the, prominent Jews Einstein ki trah Jews par ho rahe jurmo ko duniya ke saamne laa rahe the,india me hi gowalkar ne Hitler ne jaise Jews ki treatment ki uski tarif ki aur aapke hisab se duniya janti hi nhi thi?
Cross-check yourself and 2nd event is straight made up lie
51:31 - sir aapne bol diya to circumstancial evidence hogya?sir kya proof hai ye to batao.aap bolte ho ki plane crash ka koi evidence nhi hai jabki plane,pilot, hospital me jisse le jaaya gya wo sab public disclosure ke liye available hai,aapne khud crosscheck kiya ki ye info hi galat hai?
56:54
Ye neutral historian safed jhoot bol raha hai,Gandhi didn't choose pm for india,he chose congress president
1st election in India happened after death of gandhi and Patel
Gandhi didn't threaten - fast untill death if Nehru is not made congress president,it's a straight lie
He just pursuded Patel that Nehru is gandhi's choice as congress president to represent the interim govt and petel withdraw his name to respect Gandhi's choice
He never threatened or fasted for this,which history are you studying?
@@kashutosh9132 I'm not telling that Gandhiji has not done anything...The thing is Along with the leadership of Gandhiji there were lot of people who were sacrificed their lives for the sake of freedom...So I just wanted today's generation to acknowledge other heroes along with the father of nation
@@sujaya2705
Definitely I agree with your points and I have also mentioned some less known movements and leaders which needs to more recognised. As thier contribution and movements are less known but their dedication and sincerity was unparalleled.
Towards the end when he says that even the people from the country would agree that they are not in good state… reminds me the dialogue in Gadar 2..”Agar tum apne desh ke har isaaan se poocho toh woh Khud hi Hindustan Jane ke liye tayaaar hoga”
My elder sister always said Mister Gandhi was not a Mahatma. I was confused because school taught us a completely different story and my sister said totally opposite of what was taught. But i guess she was 100% right.
Please be reminded that Nepal was never any part of India.
Nepal is one of the few nations in world which is never ruled by outsiders, we are ever independent.
Chawda sir, Theoretical scientist
Great Historian
Geologist
Anthropologist
Cosmologist
Theologianist
Etc...
Etc...
Etc...
Sir some time please give reference book . or otherwise you have a time machine
Kya hi bolu aap dhanya hai Prabhu.
Wow, what a thrilling video!!
Respect from Australia 🇦🇺 for sharing this perspective 🙏🙏🙏
Nothing but respect for such a candid discussion.
Grew up with some awesome Indian friends in Dubai.
Love from Pakistan.
Me also from dubai... But jhoot bahut bolte hai Pakistani punjabi... They are bluffmaster... Agree
Respect is OK, as discussion is always good to bring clarity. But swallow these arguments with a grain of salt. Vested interests are playing.
@@vmk9299 Congress supporter?
I hope South asian countries become developed and liberal. All of them. Like europe, east asia etc. Hope we all do well. And leave behind stuff like forced marriages, religious riots, corruption.
Abhi bhi kuch Indian confused hai ke unke sath gaddari kisne Kia...kon political party ne kia...hai na??
😂😂😂😂bilkul
I am too intrigued about our history specially the pre independence one.. thanks for putting this out 🙏❣️
An hour of truth.
@@sanatani_003 yes bro
you should follow more credible sources rather than fiction storyteller Chavda.
@@prabhakart1 He is more credible than any other historian
@@audacity4 that may be your opinion.
I'm feeling ashamed to write lies in my exams. Even though I scored really good but for myself I have come to realise I failed all those history tests.
Ranveeerrr.....
You have my heart❤
Not everyone talks about this openly.
Glad you pickup this topic..!!
Be fearless..!
Keep learning, growing and evolving.
More power, positive vibes and love to you❤
Fr
Keep supporting ❤️❤️
@@ranveerallahbadia Ranveer i really wish to talk with you in person.. All the things you share here regarding spirituality as well i did experienced it in my life.....!!!
I really really wish to meet you in person..!!
Love and affection❤
@@ranveerallahbadia Cant i get a chance to talk to you..? Either on instagram dm..?
I dont know why i feel some sort of spiritual connection with you sir..!!! So if possible for a few minutes..!
@@apoorvashrivastava8019 simping horri bhot bhayankarr 🙄😏
What a great convo this was. Keep it up Ranveer. It is our right to know as Indians and Pakistani's on what happened in the history. I think this will bring people from both nations a little closer. Keep doing it.
Wow, what an insightful human being he is
Thank you so much Ranveer for this one the Truth must prevail ...lots of love ❤❤
Honestly typing ...right now i'm crying little bit...
the situations they created and my country faced it. Thank..u...so much
How unfortunate we are that we didn't get a leader like Netaji as our first PM!
More than Bose we needed Sardar Vallabhai Patel. Much more than Bose as PM
@@hariss3908 i didn't make a comparison between the two...and i humbly disagree with you. There are certain aspects and ideas of Netaji which would probably have made him a better candidate for the PM post
@@vedanthrao5879 oh. No problem. I understand where you are coming from. Patel was a good administrator and a strategist for our country. But he was weak when he had to take leadership.
On the other hand Bose was a strong leader who took initiative. But he trusted the wrong people and chose the wrong allies.
Both have their flaws. No one is perfect.
I just feel we needed a leader like Patel back then who had a clean and clear vision for our country and had a plan. He even delegated well in areas that weren't his strong suit in terms of navigating the army and annexing princely states. He was good at giving people responsibilities and ensuring they followed suit. We had good people to take care of the day to day affairs. Patel had to oversee the entire operations which he was good at. He just wasn't great at demanding what he wanted and getting it for himself
@@hariss3908 patel was good as home minister as he didn't had the global exposure which Bose got
Sir, inko firse bulake inse ek aur podcast nikalvao..inse current affairs discuss karo ...aur ye discuss karo ki abhi ki currupt politics agr hamare history k book mein pade raaja maharaja bhagwaan jaise shri raam🚩 the ....kaise raaj kar rhe hote ..kyuki hame pata hi nahi hain ki raja kaisa hona chahie... To ye janna hain ki agr aise raja shri raam jaise koi hote abhi..ya chhatrapati shivaji maharaaj jaise, maharana pratap jaise, to bhaarat varsh kaha pohcha hota ?.....iss topic ko vote kar k top pe laye jiss jiss ko ye janna hain ..👍🏻
He left India through dense forest. Before leaving he said..I will return one day. But, recently I heard that he was residing in Veitnam before got died. He his last rituals were also performed there and people from India often visit there to give him homage.
the royal indian naval mutiny is just mentioned in one line in our history books! i am a boards aspirant and i a shocked with the amount of what I have learnt! so much is missed out!
28:40 Maybe because Gandhi was pro-muslim and anti-hindu
Brilliant topic covered!! Truly an eye-opener for young India! I wish, every young Indian listens to this podcast!!
What a great podcast once again Ranveer and Abhijit Sir! I would like to request you Ranveer, that there could be an another great podcast on the Naval mutiny and the impact of INA and Subhas Chandra Bose everyone would really appreciate the podcast.🇮🇳🙏🏻
I strongly believe in what Mr. Chavada said. Got answers to lots of my questions. I'm in Canada a very proud Indian.
I believe that we all should come even more stronger together & get these changes in our history, in our texts forever so that the newer gen knows the right history.
If you are a proud Indian, why are you in Canada. Go back and work in India. If you have any reasons to why you won't go back then you are not a proud Indian, and so you should learn to assimilate to your new country.
Glad people have started talking about it. These truths were never told and now when you talk about it, you'll find people labelling you with different different name and make absolutely no sense when they counter you.
Being a history enthusiast 🦚... This podcast is ice upon cake ❤
It was a great podcast . Let me add an extra bit of info, that why was the ottoman sultan back then was called "The Khalifa" which means the supreme leader of Muslims around the world. It was because back then the three Holiest places(Masjids) in the Islamic world Makkah(Masjid), Madinah(Masjid)& Jerusalem(Masjid) were under the rule of the Ottoman Empire. So they were the custodians of these three Places, that's why the ottoman sultan was called the Khalifa of the Muslim world during his time. That's the reason why Saudi Arabia's king is not called the caliph(Khalifa) because he does not have control of Jerusalem (Masjid).
Thanks for this info bro
Physical possession of all three masjids was not a precondition to become Khalifa. Because at the time of mongol invasion of Baghdad the abbasid khalif Al mustasim didn't have possession of all 3 masjids. Khalifa was a titular position who held supreme religious and temporal power of Islam and Muslim people all across world where all islamic states and Sultans used to pay homage as tributary to the Khalifa.
Mr. Abhijit n Mr. Ranveer need to learn History Geography Literature and they would be a good Podcast.
You need to learn how to write English. So who needs to learn what is secondary as when you yourself are so much incompetent.
I just remember ambedkar when he says i dont belive that gandhi is great
Do u know that Ambedkar had written a Book about Brahmin which tells that they were fond of beef 😂
Always get so much to learn about everything after every podcast. After this I really feel like to throw out my old history books.
Ranveer sir you are doing a great job, there is not a single podcast I have missed, and mr. chavda should be more known amongst common people. I love this Ranveer sir you're giving us a legit use of a proper usage of internet. Thankyou alot can't be more greatfull for what you have given to the audience. Iloveyou bhai alot.
There is no documented evidence to suggest that Mahatma Gandhi ever begged the British Empire to let him help in the war. Gandhi was a staunch advocate of nonviolence and actively opposed all forms of violence, including warfare. Throughout his life, Gandhi consistently promoted peaceful methods of resistance and social change, and he believed that violence only led to further suffering and destruction.
While Gandhi did volunteer as a stretcher-bearer and driver of an ambulance corps during the Boer War in South Africa, his involvement was in providing humanitarian aid and medical assistance, rather than participating in combat or supporting war efforts. Gandhi's commitment to nonviolence and his belief in the power of peaceful protest remained consistent throughout his life, and there is no record of him seeking to support or participate in any armed conflicts.
I love Chavda Sir. Reading history is one thing, reading between the lines is another, and he is a master. I wish he would record his history episodes and load them as podcasts
he already has a podcast channel-ruclips.net/user/AbhijitChavda
I can listen to Mr Abhijit sir and his way of telling stories all day long.
Please let them coming.
🤗
So true
Completely engrossing discussion. But effect of Netaji and INA should be discussed too.
This episode is just amazing... Can't believe this much has been hide from such... Time to re read the history. Greatest episode ever... Keep going guys... We are with you 🙏👍👍
Everything presented by him is not real history
19:12
To iss hisab se to baki desh bhi WW2 ke baad Azad ho jane the ne?
Bostwana, Ghana,Brunie,Fiji,Kenya in sabko 1947-1948 me kyun nhi mil gyi azadi??
19:30 - ranveer bhai na to aap asli historian ho na chavda ji
Yaa phir Aaplogo ne, dono ne kitni khud se research kitab likhti hai ki aapke opinion ko sahi maana jaaye??
20:50 - Africa me NIC ki formation aur jo indians settled the unke rights ke liye lade, franchise bill ke khilaf (jo indians ko discriminate kar raha tha), newspaper indian opinion was run by him,Africa me Jahan natak aur Transvaal me Indians ki situation ekdum pathetic thi,wahan par bill wapas karaye - wahan par bhi Indians ke liye lade? Ye sab kam hai kya,kitne log karte hain ye sab
Boer wars me medical help provide ki - usme help boers ki,boers ko white treat ni karte the,wo bhi indian community ki position strong karne ke liye
He was a well know personality in Africa,he was instrumental in formation of Natal indian congress
22:57 - sir champran movement to mr jinnah shuru karne jaate haina?
1915 me gokhale ji ke amanantran se lekar congress ke kaaman sambhalane ke bich me - gandhi had already supported various causes - nadiad,kheda,bardoli, champaran,khilafat,gone against rowalalt act, strategizing swadeshi policy,pura bharat bharaman kar rahe the,full time politicaian the,aur aapke hisab se to gandhi ne kuch Kiya nhi india me parachute lekar aagye aur sidhe hi sabse bade neta ban gaye congress aur desh ke??
24:50 - bhai ranveer ab ye mat bolio ki Caliphate aur khilafat movement bhi indian textbook me nhi hai kyunki bas aapko nhi pta iske baare me to
25:10 - sir aap to ab history hi mix kar rahe ho
Khilafat movement in 1919 me shuru huwa tha,wo treaty of sevres ke through Caliph aur ottoman empire par jo sanctions place kiye the British ne,uske khilaf tha khilafat movement sirji
Khilafat movement attrutk ke decision ko oppose nhi kar raha tha,infact khilafat movement 1924 me atatruk ke descion lene ke saath band ho gya totally,india me to 1922 me bhi traction khtam ho gya tha
Jab atatruk ke decision lete hi khatm ho gya movement to usko oppose kaise kar rahe the? 25:45 - haan bhai British ke khilaf hi tha movement jab treaty of sevres se sanctions British ne hi daali thi,usi ke khilaf
27:45 - how did you reach this assessment? Please I request you write a research paper in it as a historian and prove(convince most of the reputed qualified historian) with proper methodology which historian use.
In Africa - he lived for 21 years,made Indian community political strong there. Fought against several bills which were discriminating Indians in Africa,led for better amenities for Indians in Africa
He was about to get killed by white mob in Africa at one time just because he championed cause of fellow Indians there
He helped Indians there,fought against British there - is this considered service to British?
What did his sevice to British Empire gave him? Him money?his kids some political throne? Plz tell the audience what did he recive in return?
His grandson just recently few years back died in seculsion,many of his deacdensts are common man,middle class
Bose,mn Roy,ras beahri Bose,Giani pritam singh,Raja Mahendra Singh - even never questioned the patriotism of Gandhi,even his biggest rival sarvakar and ambedkar never questioned his integrity.
Please do us a favour get out this conspiracy and if no plz write a book with full methodology (you claim yourself a historian na?plz do it)
This is just being ungrateful to the man,who single handlely has done more than most of us(including you) for the nations and the Indians
30:50
Gandhi has made the offer to Jinnah to be the pm of United India and form to the interim govt and he informed the same to viceroy linlithgow in 8 aug 1942, Jinnah's biographer Stanley wolpert says this too and the offer was made several times but Jinnah rejected it.
In 1944 through CR formula - Gandhi proposed to achive independence jointly and then when the British leave,they can settle the issue of Pakistan with a pebliscite after the British leave but league refused this too. India was supposed to be independent in 1948 and gandhi was securing support from several leaders and parties (as many parties other than congress and league were stakeholders in this) for united India,there was a supposed fasting too but direct action happened dueti which indian independent was pre-poned to 1947,gandhi had to then move his attention towards the riots engulfed naokhali to stop the killings happening there.
Chavdaji you need to update your information on this as you seem to think gandhi did not act on this,kindly read more on it.
31:35 - sir ye bhi aaphi hi assesment hai ki ye kahin likhit me proof hai ki ki congress ke kaido 5 star me rakha jata tha?
All the flood relief campaigns,school built,securing rights for more political participation of Indians in governing India even when British were here, tax reduction campaigns? Who did all this? Does that amount to nothing according to you? Provincal elections, voting rights (whomever got it) - happened own its own,while sitting in 5 star hotel??
isnt this too much ungratefulness
33:00 - and plz enlighten the viewers who demanded for partition?which parties and org supported partition
Sindh assembly passed the resolution in favour of pakistan,and the ruling govt of Sindh which passed the resolution was formed by the coliation of hindu mahasabha and muslim league,in Bengal again mahasabha and league formed coliation under the leadership of the guy - fazul haque which instigated the pakistan resolution.
Apparently these both which supported partition and sow seeds for division are not responsible for partition??
But the parties which were forced to agree to demand of pakistan because of direct action day are responsible??
Why are you skipping direct action day which forced the partition on us and several talks,intiative to stop partition as that never happened??
is this how you see history with your own lens
Also enlighten the viewers about Gandhi's plan(before assaination) to visit pak Punjab and other areas to forge better relation while reorganization of territories was happening?
36:12 - ranveer bhai,aap 1-2 hafto ki chhuti lekar saari ncert padho history ki pehle ,ye 8th class ki NCERT me cover hai - 1946 ki RIN mutiny
38:00 - chavda sir your skipping few very imp points and mixing things again.
First of all gandhi didn't give any statements that - ki kya kar rahe ho?hume to non-violence se independence leni hai specifically on RIN mutiny
RIN mutiny was majorly organised by 'ratings', most officers(Indians) in the royal indian Navy didn't support the mutiny
Cabinet misson plan was ongoing behind the scenes as it was proposed in March 1946,RIN mutiny took place in Feb 1946.Both the events were going in parallel.
Ratings were already compromised by army and royal British forces at Karachi, Calcutta only Bombay was the strong hold of the RIN. By 22 Feb the mutiny was already loosing traction as the British forces were breaking in and arresting ppl in hundreds. Sardar patel on 25 Feb made the rest of mutineers to put off the mutiny to avoid harsh consequences on them as the support and the mutiny had already was close to not succeeding.
Gandhi on 3 March 1946 criticised the ratings for lack of organisation and prepared revolutionary party.
Strike community was not clear about the independence in their charter of demands as most of the demands were about equal treatment in comparison to royal Navy. Leaders were watching this play out,who would the risk the proper transfer of power when it was going parallelly with these events?
The major arms and big equipments were under British control,even indian officer sided with the British, without any leadership if the war breaks out between the forces,army stance still was not clear?
Who would risk out losing out the war,reducing ones own bargaining power,killing the strength of our own forces when cabinet misson plan which was channelizing the transfer of power was taking place?risking this with 7-8 decades of independence struggle worth it?
Chavdaji,why whitewashing events?let the audience know risk of war,losing out the war,power vaccum taking place due to this?
Let the audience know about the Congo civil wars- which happened in similar fashion.
Sir you particularly has something deep hatred for gandhi,as you accuse others of whitewashing facts but you do the same.
48:46 - Nehru was not the defacto PM. Those who wanted some other as PM could have simply supported the other guy and spring a leader of their own staying in India.
Those who left India,they left because they believed in 2 nation theory otherwise Shah Nawaz Khan who was part of INA believed in United India moved to India itself.leaders like meer Taj mohmmed moved to India as they didn't support 2 nation theory.
49:00 - while I am optimistic about you with this on this point,par japnese occupation ka khatra?jo indian area japnese ke under the kuch weeks ke liye udhar to unhone local ka Massacre kiya tha - homfreyganj massacre to unse hume khatra nhi tha?
50:20 - uss waqt duniya ke saare leaders Hitler ko letter likh rahe the, prominent Jews Einstein ki trah Jews par ho rahe jurmo ko duniya ke saamne laa rahe the,india me hi gowalkar ne Hitler ne jaise Jews ki treatment ki uski tarif ki aur aapke hisab se duniya janti hi nhi thi?
And please re read real history,as a lot of wrong facts are presented
51:31 - sir aapne bol diya to circumstancial evidence hogya?sir kya proof hai ye to batao.aap bolte ho ki plane crash ka koi evidence nhi hai jabki plane,pilot, hospital me jisse le jaaya gya wo sab public disclosure ke liye available hai,aapne khud crosscheck kiya ki ye info hi galat hai?
56:54
Ye neutral historian safed jhoot bol raha hai,Gandhi didn't choose pm for india,he chose congress president
1st election in India happened after death of gandhi and Patel
Gandhi didn't threaten - fast untill death if Nehru is not made congress president,it's a straight lie
He just pursuded Patel that Nehru is gandhi's choice as congress president to represent the interim govt and petel withdraw his name to respect Gandhi's choice
He never threatened or fasted for this,which history are you studying?
This man never fails to amaze me idk how he has soo much knowledge wish I was taught all of this during my 10th
Hey! I recently started watching your videos and I am hooked. I live in the USA and so, as an international supporter, I have downloaded the Level app. I am super excited to explore it. I have a request after watching this particular video. Can you ask Mr. Chavda and let know where to read Gandhiji’s original writings. I have a hard time trusting documents on the internet.
Man u are doing so good job
Keep glowing and abhijit sir is fantastic like always .
BTW coming here after consuming ur English podcast
Superb episode, this episode is now my favourite episode till now, I wanted someone to tell me why and what exactly happened during partition why alot people hate gandhi, why we could never know the truth of subhash chandra bose and alot more THIS IS THE BEST episode Ranveer bhai
Mr. Sharad pokshe ke sath bhi podcast shoot karo he have great knowledge about स्वातंत्र्यवीर सावरकर and Hinduism
I am 34 years old and I never met any one who loves Gandhi
Mr. Ranveer, very wonderful podcasts you bring. Many things we as common man know is hard to expose publically. Abhijit sir, has given a very wonderful insight. Hope the world realize this
Loving The Podcasts ❤️
Thank you for this podcast.
I'm student of class 12th of history and political science and your podcast is very helpful for me to develop my thoughts and thinking as well.
Hi Ranveer sir, I've gone through all of your historical podcasts and I'm very much thankful to you and the whole efforts of yours. I would request you to make a podcast along with Sir Ninand Bedekar whose a historian very well known for Maratha and ancient Indian kingdoms history. My best wishes with you for the upcoming future.
MAHATMA GANDHI IS A BRAND CREATED BY THE ALLIED POWERS, TO SHOW HOW FRIENDLY AND PEACEFUL THEY WERE, AND HOW AMICABLY THEY LIBERATED INDIANS WHOSE AMBASSADOR BEING GANDHI. That's why you wouldn't find a single country in the world where Gandhi is criticized. The opposite would have happened if Axis powers had won the war.
Frontier Gandhi told gandhi ... That he has thrown them in front of dogs and not wolf ....for the correction
As a Pakistani 🇵🇰.. I completely agree with that real history from Abhijit Chavda💯
Kabhi DIRECT ACTION DAY search karna. Pata chalega HINDU ki maut par bana hai pakistan. totega agle 30 sal me
I disagree only 25% maybe right,the rest is like a spin Doctor.
@@mohammedmir777 look at the condition of your country. Do you seriously think there’ll be a Pakistan in the next 100 years? I don’t think so.
@@Bruhh2002 No need to wait for 100yrs.. Our Raw Agent Immu is on a mission..Hell definitely do it in few yrs🤪
@@Bruhh2002 100 years is being super optimistic. 5-10 years and this pakistan is history. They're drying up. Way faster.
The way Abhijit sir uses term Mister not “mahatma” for gandhi is appreciable. He’s a gem.
Please do not use 'sir' or 'mam' after a name. It is wrong grammar.
Instead usse 'mr' or 'ms' before the name.
@@kingscross4233 bhag chutiya kon pucha ha tereko
@@kingscross4233 would you like to explaine the grammer related to it?
Abhijit Chavda is a BJP fascist propagandist.
That's why he hates gandhi.
Bro you must read about GANDHIJI from sources you like but authentic sources you will know how great he was.. He was lawyer at that time and would have earned a lot and must have lived the life everyone dreams of today.. But he struggled not just for India but also against racism in Africa.. And wisdom is in books not in this people who are just spreading this narratives .. atleast Bhagavad Geeta padh le aur dhayn se samaj le jivan sudhar jayega...
My father was a teacher and he taught me exactly this history.. our history books must be revised to tell our next generation truth.. thank you so much for this video ❤
So koi to teacher he jo sahi history jante hai so proud
😂
Tere ko kaise pata ye sahi history hai.....appang dimag ho kya@@VjVerma-rh4yo
🙏👍😍Ambedkar said, “Gandhi was never a Mahatma; I refuse to call him a Mahatma.”
He knew the hypocrisy of Gandhi back in 40s and 50s
Ambedkar or gandhi may fark hi kay dono battareen insaan thay
bt u never know harijan name given to sc by gandhiji u can hate me its ur choice bt this is so manipulating history not a factual just by dreaming and guessing ye huva hoga
@@GoForExplore u cant be m of mahatma bcz in the name of non violence u cant go in riots do u have guts tht legend went their and people listen him stopped tht many times if u want to know gandhi thn listen lacture of dr vikas divyakriti (IAS) sir's lecture. take knowledge from the well educated people don't from haters nd graduates of whatsapp university
@UCX5Qas_O9uEo9xdp6yyaMAA bro go nd tell this historian tht historian write history on base of fact real fact , papers ,not on random guys intrnet blog . just ye tha to vo hua hoga ye nhi kiya tha kyunki nahi pasand ye sab ak dreaming kehte he fact nhi . nd dnt tlk about savarkar nd godse savarkar game himself honour of veer 😂 write own biopic written by chandragupta later on people found savarkar was chandragupta 😂lol bhai koi apne aapko veer kese bol sakta and everybody knows abhijit chvda so called historian hates gandhi
Hello Ranveer, I recently watched "The Tashkent Files" movie and it depicts at what scale we have done Injustice to Lal Bahadur Shashtri. Specially the ruling Party- Indira Gandhi at that time. How we have totally ignored how Shashtriji died? October 2 is Gandhiji's Birth date but it is of Lal Bahadur Shashtri's too. I apologize if you already have covered this topic before but I think you must arrange a session with relevant person who can shade some light on Shashtri's life, patriotism and death controversy. I think "Anuj Dhar" is for sure the best person in this regards.
He had already covered this topic on a podcast with Anuj Dhar. Check it in on RUclips
@@rajraut3583 and also Netaji's mystery too
@@debosmandasgupta3940 Yes I remember about the discussion about Netaji's mysteries. Thank U and Raj Raut.
Do watch the movie gumnami.
@@jaymungra563 watch the Jaipur Dialogues, there you'll see Shastri ji's family member telling truth about Shatri jis death
Who knew that Indian textbooks were the original "WhatsApp University" 😂
😂😂🤣
😂
Lol for 70 yrs we were taught from WhatsApp University..
What a waste of time...i realise. Putting so much effort to learn lies and score the highest in class 🤦
news, movies, and our syllabus everything seems to be source of spreading propaganda and brainwashing. The trick is to triangulate different sources
Most people don’t really want the truth. They just want constant reassurance that what they believe is the truth. These kind of Podcast will be the pillars for future generations to see a wide perspective of History. Awasome Ranveer keep doing these kind of Hard-hitting uncomfortable truthfull Podcasts.
Cognitive dissonance is what they suffer from .
Did you just describe yourself?
Truth is china evading India in ladhakh
This is slightly better than shitposting. A few facts here and there with wide ranging speculations. That too from a wannabe historian.
@@rishabh7589 chill
My father was offered to be a histry teacher because of very gud credibly of teaching...but he refused to do do... because he was against teaching wrong histry to the pupils..
,👏👏👏
🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
Great
Grand salute to him. He is the true son of India.
Proud of your father
22:05 😂😂 I can't imagine Gandhiji Driving Ambulance. Imagine karne se hi hasi a raha hai yarr.
@Jatin 😂😂
munnabhai driver
it is matter of your intelligence , that you can imagine , perhaps PseudoHindutva has something to do with it
Just imagine him using charkha on wheels😂
I have goosebumps, tears in my eyes, deep and painful sorrowfulness hearing the words of Abhijit sir.. Thank you sir for such an eye opening history... Love you both.. Thanks Ranveer for the important questions...
follow him on his u tube channel. u will be amazed.
Ro kyu raha bhai, mere taraf se chocolate kha le :D
Aree bhai bhai bhai😂😂
Bhai itna kyu over exaggerate kar raha hai
Everything will be keep in mind & avenged at the right time.
Ranveer ki itni fati padi hai, itna neutralize kar raha hai cheezo ko. Bhai audience ko sach sunne do jab bulaya hai itne qabil insaan ko .
@KRISHNA : The father of both Jesus and Allah correct
I felt the same
@@abhaymaurya1116 Bhai, these people are just opportunists. What do you say?
@@sampoorn6767 Not Abhijit chawda but Ranbeer for sure.
Just watch Abhijit chawda's podcast/interview whatever on jaipur dialogues channel you'll find he's man of words.
Love his podcasts. He's not just a physicist but also a good history expert.
Only dumb and who don't know anything about history watch Physicist for history lacture.
because he is really educated
There was one theoretical physicist, probably the best ever, had absolutely different view of Gandhi……. This guy is rather ill- informed.
@@kolipnkj2003 these are not opinion these are facts , can u disprove any fact about Gandhi given in this video
Abhijit z not only a Pseudo historian but also a Pseudo physicist.....the kinda of mis-information hez spreading is dangerous and far from truth........
Jinnah was a power hungry politician who always strived for it....that's why he wanted a separate nation so that he can govern it and have all the power......
On the other hand Mohan das Gandhi was never a power hungry politician......
Jus because the current "Fake Gandhis" (Nehru's descendants) are incompetent..... doesn't mean..u ll go and downgrade Mohan das Gandhi
In bengali, there is a proverb that "Alpo bidya bhayankari" means little knowledge is dangerous. It perfectly sits with our history text book.
ekdom
duto desher history book same kaj kore , ind nijer dosh dhake , ar pakistan anti hindu brain washing kore
Thik...
কি খবর 😜
@@IDOIT_GAMER_2000 খবর কলকাতা 🤣🤣🤣
Un divided india first Prime Minister was Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose ki jai Jai Hind Bharat Matta Ki Jai
Shouldn't it be called "The Ranveer-Abhijeet Show" whenever Abhijit sir comes? It's such a pleasure to watch him in podcasts.
True
True
Yeah the TARShow.
No
I'm a Pakistani but really enjoyed the podcast. Seemed very unbiased and true to the title of the podcast. Subscribing and keep up the good work on the subject!
Hey (Brother from another mother)
Kya aap jinnah sir ke baare me kux bta skte that unke views ya unke baare ya unke respect me koi video suggest kr sko aap to. I'll be so thankful to you.
@@arijitsingh944 hey bro. Yes ofcourse I can. I generally read a lot about history - both medieval as well as about the subcontinent so I can tell you alot about jinnah as well which would be unbiased.
Hi, do people in Pakistan regret partition? Because I have seen in India, people regret partition....😅
@@Ecofin89It is said that, jinnah had never followed all fundamentals of islam. He eat pork, take drinks, also do other stuffs. And near to his death, he regretted very much for partition and massacre of so many people.
For only his own ambitions and desire to rule, he literally pushed laks of population in dark and blood future.
What are your views on it ?
bcoz atlast we have more muslims in india then Pakistan and majorly they are happy and also if you were also included then, would also enjoy majority.
@@Ecofin89 hey guys everyone who replied to our comments. I got an idea that why don't we all come together and make Twitter handle and discuss about this all ancient India and political stuff and all.
Let's make a Twitter handle and we all could discuss and speak about it in space and we'll add abhijit chavda sir and some more historians with allahabadiya bro also.
Comment your views on it plzz.
Maratha empire saved all Bharatiya from getting converted to islam. Because of Maratha Bharat has hindu dharma alive. Jay bhavani...jay Chatrapati Shivaji maharaj🥰
The story about Navy was not in our NCERT books, but I remember our history teacher told us the same thing that Mr. Chavda said and now I feel proud we had such a GREAT teacher who taught us what was not even in books. We need such teachers in schools.
Even we had an awesome history teacher. In class 10 we already knew what actually happened and what is brics nato everything. He is now an ias . Proud to be his student 🔥
Xii history me h...a bit of info
Ye log kaha se padte h
@@lokeshchoudhary9472 book's and if they visit those certain places there are written history on stone like cravings , word of mouth , museum's , migrants and more other resources which i don't know about. Don't take them as completely truth but they are worth thinking about and relate as they sound true cause of all the evidences.
WHY NOT 2.0
ruclips.net/video/rAtMZHkIPDU/видео.html
Another awesome podcast!!
49:10 Ranveer Bhaiya , please bring Anuj dhar on your podcast in regards to the death mystery of Netaji. PLEASE DO SO AND I BET ALL YOUR DOUBTS WILL BE CLEARED . Gumnami Baba being Subhas Bose is not just any random conspiracy theory anymore , there is enough evidence to prove what the truth is .
You had mentioned this issue in another video as well , please do not hesitate and pursue it.
Abhijith sir did a podcast with Anuj Dhar.
I was searching for hate comments from some people atleast but to my surprise I rarely found one even after scrolling for 15mins, that shows people are aware about the reality and are open to accept the facts. Majority of our real history was so drastically erased and kept hidden from us.
Sorry brother, but now there are a lot of hate comments, i just found them😅
@@debosmandasgupta3940 😂😂
Wht h8 comments ? If ur ideology cannot take criticizm that means there's some problem . Esp islam as much of a terrorist cult it is
Its not the real history , this person here is just selling a narrative either he do not know or wtever ,but he did not presented the real facts.Read books which tells factual history with dates facts & reason.Read spectrum books,rajiv ahir ,ram chandra guha,bipin chandra...There were no five star jails for anyone back then....Gandhi ji did not just became the centre the of indian politics overnight & he must have done something that everyone around the world started admiring him & still respect him. He was not perfect & nor did all of his actions,but he was not god that we expect him to hv done all the superhuman things,he did things & used methods which were best known to him, all others used theirs....for example bose choosed a different path which he felt was ryt thing to do at that moment....i dont understand why todays generation & media loves to judge their contribution without doing anything real for nation ourself... In real it was a cumulative result of all the efforts & sacrifices done by all of them & we should respect it. Period
Regards
Dr.Amit
Then please took a look at this,how is one thing spoken by one becomes history?
19:12
To iss hisab se to baki desh bhi WW2 ke baad Azad ho jane the ne?
Bostwana, Ghana,Brunie,Fiji,Kenya in sabko 1947-1948 me kyun nhi mil gyi azadi??
19:30 - ranveer bhai na to aap asli historian ho na chavda ji
Yaa phir Aaplogo ne, dono ne kitni khud se research kitab likhti hai ki aapke opinion ko sahi maana jaaye??
20:50 - Africa me NIC ki formation aur jo indians settled the unke rights ke liye lade, franchise bill ke khilaf (jo indians ko discriminate kar raha tha), newspaper indian opinion was run by him,Africa me Jahan natak aur Transvaal me Indians ki situation ekdum pathetic thi,wahan par bill wapas karaye - wahan par bhi Indians ke liye lade? Ye sab kam hai kya,kitne log karte hain ye sab
Boer wars me medical help provide ki - usme help boers ki,boers ko white treat ni karte the,wo bhi indian community ki position strong karne ke liye
He was a well know personality in Africa,he was instrumental in formation of Natal indian congress
22:57 - sir champran movement to mr jinnah shuru karne jaate haina?
1915 me gokhale ji ke amanantran se lekar congress ke kaaman sambhalane ke bich me - gandhi had already supported various causes - nadiad,kheda,bardoli, champaran,khilafat,gone against rowalalt act, strategizing swadeshi policy,pura bharat bharaman kar rahe the,full time politicaian the,aur aapke hisab se to gandhi ne kuch Kiya nhi india me parachute lekar aagye aur sidhe hi sabse bade neta ban gaye congress aur desh ke??
24:50 - bhai ranveer ab ye mat bolio ki Caliphate aur khilafat movement bhi indian textbook me nhi hai kyunki bas aapko nhi pta iske baare me to
25:10 - sir aap to ab history hi mix kar rahe ho
Khilafat movement in 1919 me shuru huwa tha,wo treaty of sevres ke through Caliph aur ottoman empire par jo sanctions place kiye the British ne,uske khilaf tha khilafat movement sirji
Khilafat movement attrutk ke decision ko oppose nhi kar raha tha,infact khilafat movement 1924 me atatruk ke descion lene ke saath band ho gya totally,india me to 1922 me bhi traction khtam ho gya tha
Jab atatruk ke decision lete hi khatm ho gya movement to usko oppose kaise kar rahe the? 25:45 - haan bhai British ke khilaf hi tha movement jab treaty of sevres se sanctions British ne hi daali thi,usi ke khilaf
27:45 - how did you reach this assessment? Please I request you write a research paper in it as a historian and prove(convince most of the reputed qualified historian) with proper methodology which historian use.
In Africa - he lived for 21 years,made Indian community political strong there. Fought against several bills which were discriminating Indians in Africa,led for better amenities for Indians in Africa
He was about to get killed by white mob in Africa at one time just because he championed cause of fellow Indians there
He helped Indians there,fought against British there - is this considered service to British?
What did his sevice to British Empire gave him? Him money?his kids some political throne? Plz tell the audience what did he recive in return?
His grandson just recently few years back died in seculsion,many of his deacdensts are common man,middle class
Bose,mn Roy,ras beahri Bose,Giani pritam singh,Raja Mahendra Singh - even never questioned the patriotism of Gandhi,even his biggest rival sarvakar and ambedkar never questioned his integrity.
Please do us a favour get out this conspiracy and if no plz write a book with full methodology (you claim yourself a historian na?plz do it)
This is just being ungrateful to the man,who single handlely has done more than most of us(including you) for the nations and the Indians
30:50
Gandhi has made the offer to Jinnah to be the pm of United India and form to the interim govt and he informed the same to viceroy linlithgow in 8 aug 1942, Jinnah's biographer Stanley wolpert says this too and the offer was made several times but Jinnah rejected it.
In 1944 through CR formula - Gandhi proposed to achive independence jointly and then when the British leave,they can settle the issue of Pakistan with a pebliscite after the British leave but league refused this too. India was supposed to be independent in 1948 and gandhi was securing support from several leaders and parties (as many parties other than congress and league were stakeholders in this) for united India,there was a supposed fasting too but direct action happened dueti which indian independent was pre-poned to 1947,gandhi had to then move his attention towards the riots engulfed naokhali to stop the killings happening there.
Chavdaji you need to update your information on this as you seem to think gandhi did not act on this,kindly read more on it.
31:35 - sir ye bhi aaphi hi assesment hai ki ye kahin likhit me proof hai ki ki congress ke kaido 5 star me rakha jata tha?
All the flood relief campaigns,school built,securing rights for more political participation of Indians in governing India even when British were here, tax reduction campaigns? Who did all this? Does that amount to nothing according to you? Provincal elections, voting rights (whomever got it) - happened own its own,while sitting in 5 star hotel??
isnt this too much ungratefulness
33:00 - and plz enlighten the viewers who demanded for partition?which parties and org supported partition
Sindh assembly passed the resolution in favour of pakistan,and the ruling govt of Sindh which passed the resolution was formed by the coliation of hindu mahasabha and muslim league,in Bengal again mahasabha and league formed coliation under the leadership of the guy - fazul haque which instigated the pakistan resolution.
Apparently these both which supported partition and sow seeds for division are not responsible for partition??
But the parties which were forced to agree to demand of pakistan because of direct action day are responsible??
Why are you skipping direct action day which forced the partition on us and several talks,intiative to stop partition as that never happened??
is this how you see history with your own lens
Also enlighten the viewers about Gandhi's plan(before assaination) to visit pak Punjab and other areas to forge better relation while reorganization of territories was happening?
36:12 - ranveer bhai,aap 1-2 hafto ki chhuti lekar saari ncert padho history ki pehle ,ye 8th class ki NCERT me cover hai - 1946 ki RIN mutiny
38:00 - chavda sir your skipping few very imp points and mixing things again.
First of all gandhi didn't give any statements that - ki kya kar rahe ho?hume to non-violence se independence leni hai specifically on RIN mutiny
RIN mutiny was majorly organised by 'ratings', most officers(Indians) in the royal indian Navy didn't support the mutiny
Cabinet misson plan was ongoing behind the scenes as it was proposed in March 1946,RIN mutiny took place in Feb 1946.Both the events were going in parallel.
Ratings were already compromised by army and royal British forces at Karachi, Calcutta only Bombay was the strong hold of the RIN. By 22 Feb the mutiny was already loosing traction as the British forces were breaking in and arresting ppl in hundreds. Sardar patel on 25 Feb made the rest of mutineers to put off the mutiny to avoid harsh consequences on them as the support and the mutiny had already was close to not succeeding.
Gandhi on 3 March 1946 criticised the ratings for lack of organisation and prepared revolutionary party.
Strike community was not clear about the independence in their charter of demands as most of the demands were about equal treatment in comparison to royal Navy. Leaders were watching this play out,who would the risk the proper transfer of power when it was going parallelly with these events?
The major arms and big equipments were under British control,even indian officer sided with the British, without any leadership if the war breaks out between the forces,army stance still was not clear?
Who would risk out losing out the war,reducing ones own bargaining power,killing the strength of our own forces when cabinet misson plan which was channelizing the transfer of power was taking place?risking this with 7-8 decades of independence struggle worth it?
Chavdaji,why whitewashing events?let the audience know risk of war,losing out the war,power vaccum taking place due to this?
Let the audience know about the Congo civil wars- which happened in similar fashion.
Sir you particularly has something deep hatred for gandhi,as you accuse others of whitewashing facts but you do the same.
48:46 - Nehru was not the defacto PM. Those who wanted some other as PM could have simply supported the other guy and spring a leader of their own staying in India.
Those who left India,they left because they believed in 2 nation theory otherwise Shah Nawaz Khan who was part of INA believed in United India moved to India itself.leaders like meer Taj mohmmed moved to India as they didn't support 2 nation theory.
49:00 - while I am optimistic about you with this on this point,par japnese occupation ka khatra?jo indian area japnese ke under the kuch weeks ke liye udhar to unhone local ka Massacre kiya tha - homfreyganj massacre to unse hume khatra nhi tha?
50:20 - uss waqt duniya ke saare leaders Hitler ko letter likh rahe the, prominent Jews Einstein ki trah Jews par ho rahe jurmo ko duniya ke saamne laa rahe the,india me hi gowalkar ne Hitler ne jaise Jews ki treatment ki uski tarif ki aur aapke hisab se duniya janti hi nhi thi?
Note, Gandhi supported to give away the money that was supposed to be splited in two newly formed nations during the partition , of which patel and ambedkar both apposed, according to them money should be divided 2-3 years later, so that we can have check on jinnah and other muslim league's politician
correct! and they used that crores of money to attack us in 1947 itself. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Indo-Pakistani_War_of_1947%E2%80%931948
Patel, Ambedkar and Nehru
It was international agreement if pakistan would have gone to international Court india would have surely lost case
I am 55 years now....but I ostensibly remember that I was taught that "Khilafat" movement spearheaded by Gandhi and Congress then was meant for Angrejon ki Khilaf Lada Jane vala a combined Hindu Muslim tirade.....but now the world history accounts brings out the Turkish connection of this 'Indian freedom struggle'.....i remain shocked how hypocrites have been these congressmen so far?
Don't believe these liar find truth about man who himself follow the path of truth. Mr. Jinna haven't written a single book on anything. As a Sawarite I like to tell you that daughter of Subhash Chandra Bose knows better about him than anybody else. Read her writing & then believe.
@SarangPani why brother do you really think gandhi has done khilafat movements..
That coward never done anything for country
Who was your teacher? And i think you were one of the numb student of your class who never questioned their teacher? I wish you had read your book well... Jise ye nahi pata khilafat ka khalifa se kya samband hai.
Khilafat in Malabar was anti Hindu...who will tell the truth....that is the truth.
👏 Bjp now using these greedy youtubers to spread their hate game, divide and rule.. ! Very clever to brain wash sheeps but few can easily see thru this kiddish game!
Again abhijit sir and ranveer bhai nailed it...Thanks a lot for this fabulous podcast..... Keep it on...
I am from Pakistan 🇵🇰, and I love your podcast, especially on Neeta Ji, but one thing which I will add is that unfortunately, the real history was hidden by the state machinery from the people of both nations😪
You are absolutely Right ! Real HISTORY is hidden , what we read is STORY by white colonials .
Jo peace
Pakistan will be destroyed like afghanistan
Absolutely so.
Yes
Ismail khan ...
Sab thik hai lekin Pakistan terrorism activity kyu kar raha hai ??
Aur Sab Pakistanis log desh ke government ko kyu nahi poochte
Very beautifully covered all topics
1.I was unaware that Britishers didn't destroyed Mughal Empire it was Marathas
2.about Gandhi and jinna
3.the Navy struggle of 1946 which I had never heard about
And the most important
That the "Plane" Of 'Subhash Chandra Bose ' was not crashed
I suggest you watch the bengali movie 'Gumnami' if you are interested in the story of Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose.
Plz clarify i thought the revolt of 1946 by army was because of the INA soldiers prosecution?
@@SudeeptoRoy10 there were Revolt in British-army , Navy & Airforce in 1946 . This caused Colonials to leave India , but before that they Partitioned India to take Revenge !
That is true ...but if u search further ...the main cause of revolt was that the INA soldiers who were captured were being tortured by the british ..thats y the indian soldiers especially the Navy started protesting
Our education ministry has all along conspired to fool all Indians especially the schoolgoing ones.
Ranveer Allahbadia... I'm from Fiji 🇫🇯 and my fore fathers brought to Fiji by the British to work. Requesting if you could do an episode or two or maybe more with Abhijit Chavda sir on how this indentured labour system came into place and so many Indians went about the World to work in other countries specially in Fiji 🇫🇯
Brilliant topic. I also want to know
We all want this topic ranveer
many people were forcibly taken as slaves by british during that time.
Yes right
Brother your ancestors are from Bihar, Uttar pradesh, Bengal etc. We have the same culture
As per my grandfather his dad was in British indian navy and every time he told me about his father's story I was really amazed and that stories I can't tell here because many people will get offended If I say it here.💯
Please say it bro would like to hear about it
Bolde bhaaai
Bolde de
Bhai poora podcast h upar offend hone ko
Pls tell in the replies
God bless Godse
He real freedom fighter but show as Anti Indian
I'm in 10th class and I wanna study this kind of history and gain more knowledge like this...
But our education system 🙄🙄
Beta lekin sach likhoge toh fail hojaoge boards me
@@Akankshasingh-ci7nd correct 🙏
all the best for ur exams. Be careful not to write this in the exam or u may fail!!
Definitely you can read true history of India but you can't put it in your answer booklet... there's a two perspective of Indian history like hathi ke daant khane ke or dikhane k or... and that's all because of the hypocrisy of our purchasable so called historians and the brown sahebs Congress
Read capt Ajit vadakayil
As someone who's Pakistani by ethnicity, I found this podcast very informative and real. Also appreciate how you approached this whole subject respectfully, trying your best to not offend anyone. Can't wait for Part 2- would love to find out more about the present and possible future!
ethnically you are Indian, by nationality you are pakistani. we are the same people. religion and politics came between us.
@@narutohenaruto who asked?
What is ethnically Pakistani?
You could say that your ethnicity is, for example, Baloch, Sindhi, or Punjabi if you don't want to say that you are ethnically Indian.
But yeah you are Pakistani by nationality not ethnically.
What is ethnically pakistani , either you can be a Sindhi or a Punjabi or a baloch
That's how civilized people behave
"I think the British liked Nehru more than Mr. Patel"
Gave chills down my spine!!!
That's why agent gandhi did his job making him the pm
There is another perspective to it, Nehru ji was much younger than Patel ji. And if we would have lost our leader early it would have derailed our progress. Pakistan lost its leader early just after independence, we can see where they are right now. Foundation strong karne ke liye maybe Gandhi ji ne ye kiya ho!!
@@shikharlitoria6907 The Nehruvian rate of growth of India's GDP lasted till 1990 and India's GDP grew at 2% per year using Nehru Ji's idea of Fabian Socialism, search it and please then write , please don't comment on your knowledge based out of another RUclips video....read the materials from the internet and search it up!!
@@dhruba5849 Gandhi had already declared Nehru as his successor , at point 1942 when there was danger of japanese invasion Patel sidelined Nehru and Gandhi and took control of Congress and told britishers to support them in case of invasion of japanese.
Many times Nehru proved his worth before becoming PM and gave some important advice like whether to support britishers or not, as a mediater between Bose and gandhi during Tripure session of Congress .
Patel has also two phase earlier he was complete devotte of Gandhi later he changed after seeing failures of NCM and CDM he started to become extremist which may develop hate in Gandhi to Patel
@@shikharlitoria6907 R u suggesting that Gandhiji knew in 1946 that Sardar Patel was going to die in 1950? 🙂
Read a book by veer sawarkar -6 golden pages of indian history - सहा सोनेरी पाने
Abhijit sir taught me more than school + college this kind of people needs to be protected and celebrated Ranveer its a humble request please invite these kind of people in place of celebrities
This is the only problem that people like you learn more from these kind of people instead of learning from different books.
@@satyamjha2124 everything this Man is saying is Bitter Truth Our History books are written by the British which glorify invaders and manipulate facts Never say anything about the Brave hearts like Rani Lakshmi Bai Bhagat Singh ji etc
@@satyamjha2124 in current fast paced life if someone who has done so much reaserch nd read lots of books if someone is sharing the things which he has read and research then there should be no problem in getting information or knowledge from that particular person
these people do not read themselves. these are godi historians.
@@elliotalderson2007 ok then just disagree him with facts . Are there any facts he have told everything with facts don't be so white washed .
Being a Bangladeshi Citizen,i also learnt a lot about the history of Indian subcontinent from this podcasts..Thanks to Ranbeer and Abhijit Sir for this great informative podcast..looking for more content like this..keep up the good work👍
Do u understand hindi???
stay safe bro
@@matkachhap6159 it might be strange, apart from our mother tongue we understand and speak Hindi and Urdu well
@@Omniman300 is it quite common there to know hindi and urdu along with your mother tongue????
Be safe bro bangaleshi hindus are decreasing due to extremist jihadi Muslims
I am a Pakistani. But, Being a rational person, I love to get the 360 degree angles of the geopolitical issues.
Brilliant. I must appreciate the efforts you put to bring people closer.
Sometimes, We may have differences but culturally we are same, same ancestors and history.
One Day It may be dealt with.
I do not think It must offend anyone.
Keep it up Ranveer Jee
Do you really believe such wrong narrative of BJP?
Don't you see what BJP is doing against indian muslims and kashmiris?
@@Wanderer975 You are the real Kafir.
@@Wanderer975 bjp spread hate
Bjp cong and all political parties making money, and spread hate
👏 Bjp now using these greedy youtubers to spread their hate game, divide and rule.. ! Very clever to brain wash sheeps but few can easily see thru this kiddish game!
*Seriously 😳 ye Aadmi Soft Hindutva promote krta Hai & Soft Hindutva is Thousands Times More Dangerous than Hard Core Hindutva*
I am a Pakistani and I just finished this episode. Abhijit Sir's words about current situation of Pakistan are very accurate. Love and prayers for both the countries.
Aji lan* mera aata chahiye jinnah ko bula
You're a good soul
@@naraendrareddy273 no, you are a good soul that you said this.
im also from Pakistan i hope hum is current situation se nikal kar ache halaat mei jaenge Insha Allah Pray for us PAK+IND ❤❤❤
@@zubairmemon akhand bharat kya kahte ho 👏👍
Mr.Nehru said, tum mujhe pandit bnao aur mai tumhe mahatma bnaunga.😁
My SST teacher in 9th class told me this truth about our Navy, and how our books whitewash us.. Thank you sir and Ranveer !
Your city?
In grade 12, I had 90% score in History. With this podcast, which negates a lot of things that I learnt, I feel I failed my grade , since we were taught wrong story. I want to read everything from the start now all over again. Thank you Abhijit ji, for opening our eyes. You are a legend, and thank you Ranveer for bringing it to us.
Cute dp
How can you believe his every word so blindly man😅😅 everyone is guided by an ideology and they present things according to that. So don't believe blindly on anyone and go search read and try to understand things on your own.
@@ratansinghbaghel3970 yeah it's true people are driven by ideology, but for everyone to become historians just to know what is the exact truth (which may even be near to impossible) it's better to follow one ideology that seems more convincing and supports your intrest. That is how strong nations are built, look at china, if there would have been transparency of the history of their nation, do you think they could have prospered the way they did, not only china but the entirety of Whiteman nations are built on pseudo historical ideologies! After all, the world politics is just a war of ideologies and the winners are able to push forward their ideology as truth.
Lgta h Bhai ne Nakal mar ke 90% liye the... 😂
We are taught wrong History in our books . I N A & it's NETAJI WERE INSTRUMENTAL IN GETTING FREEDOM OF INDIA !
Thanks for giving such great content... From my point of view it needs very strong guts to speak on these sensitive topic🇮🇳🇮🇳
Ppl would have got arrested. If we spoke about this 30 years ago
@@descendedofrigvedicclans2216 Nehru was good at building institutions... Tht i can give credit to him... Other than tht... Zero respect to him. He was a Hinduphobic bigot who ruined indian economy
@@descendedofrigvedicclans2216 i didn't say he was a good person... I said he was good at building institutions.. thts all
I exactly know how terrible and horrible Nehru was in rest of the things
Truth & Reconciliation is the need of the hour. It's important to discuss and know the truth about history and not put all the uncomfortable events under the carpet
Books to read to know the dark side of Gandhi:-
Research and Study of Life of Gandhi
Gandhi - Naked Ambition
Great Soul
Subhas Chandra Bose in Nazi Germany
Truth about Gandhi's sex life
Shattered Heroes: Gandhi's Dark Side
10 curious controversies about Mahatma Gandhi
It's time to stop glorifying Gandhi once and for all
Exactly!
here your 1OOth like
Truth and reconciliation have their place. The poster child would be to take legal recourse against Britain and her activities, looting India and conspiring against India and partition of India. $43 trillion dollars was looted from Bharat. The British in conducting the first census, randomly assigned Indians to a similar European system which in time became the ossefied caste system. Caste comes from the Portuguese word kasta. India has varna and jati, yet India is hung with caste. They created episode after episode of famine leading to genoicide. Churchill knowingly, transported grain out of India to other countries where it was not even needed, whilst thousands of Indians were dying. Countries like US and Australia offered aid and grain, but Churchill denied any assistance - let them die. Remember those skeletal images of Indians forever burnt into your memory? It was so bad Starving Indians were eating grass. All Churchill could say was beastly Indians, I hate Indians. Demand that Britain return $43 trillion, the kohinoor, and what's in their museums. In British history, Churchill is whitewshed as a hero. Not the supremist and racist he clearly proved himself to be.Have courage to google and read for yourself.
Bravoo!@@sushagni1933 .. i couldn't have said it better..
@@ska4666 Thank you
Aap bilkul sahi kehrahahe . We believe you 100% . Firoz khan aur iska next generation step by step jabke Muslim hain yeh jante hoye bhi Gandhi ne isko Gandhi surname diya . Jahar lal nehru se lekar moti lal ka purwaj musalman hi tha .
Nahi bhai. Firoz ghandy the wo. Parsi the. Gandhi naam ke saath align karne ke liye wo gandhi ban gaye. Kyuki wo gandhi ko bahut mante the.
@@rahulbhandari9396 😂😂
Abe chutiye Jews tha wo
Parsi tha wo
WhatsApp University😂
Hahahaha... Nehru became PM in 1952. He became secretary in Congress in 1946-47. He doesn't know the history as he doesn't complete the books as he said in one of his interviews.
Just a small correction, Jinnah wasn’t the first prime minister of Pakistan, it was liaquat Ali khan. Mohammed Ali Jinnah was the first Governor General who’s the representative of the queen to the Pakistan. And there’s another interesting story about him in which Jinnah had formerly asked Nehru to come back to Bombay as his house in Malabar hill was very dear to him.
Desh ko todke vapas ussi desh may aane ki request kidda hypocrite
@@LIGHT-1999 That hypocrite(Jinnah) died a natural death.By the way how your patriotic leader (Gandhi) died 🤣🤣🤣
Then what happened after that nehru granted or not
@@jyotiradityachoudhury2241 Nehru simply laughed it off.
@@Avimalik13 lol 😂😂
I have shared this podcast to my parents and family to enlighten them. Most of my family members are teachers, who taught us to worship Gandhi ji. Except for one uncle. Thanks to that Uncle, I learnt to think rationally. Today, after listening to this podcast, I really appreciate way of showing us practical aspects of history.
Remember the lines, everyone in the spot light of world has grey areas in their life. Those which have effected common man.
Believe the man who follow the path of truth. Chawda don't even know that Jinna wasn't 1st wazir e azam of Pak. Jinna was 1st Governor general of Pak & Liakat Ali was the 1st PM of Pak.
True
@@sarangpani8637 abhijeet chawda is discussing about personality and perspective of gandhi and jinna, he is not participating in prelims exam of PSC.
Gandhi returned to India in 1915 and was insisted by Gokhale sahab to join Congress as the revolution needs more and more people and late in 1934 or so he also resigned from congress and may be again he had to join the party....Now you tell me he didnt revolutionize the whole congress party over night u moeon Chavda..it took hi time to make the 35 year old political party to a new level...the way you explained it is like it was a mere minute of his life time but it take time for a revolution😂🤣