The First Crusade: How The Holy War Started

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 23 ноя 2024

Комментарии • 198

  • @Nemenon
    @Nemenon 21 день назад +18

    It's incredible how well Alexios played this situation to his advantage and halted the seemingly inevitable demise of the Roman Empire by several more centuries. His dealings with the crusaders was shrewd and merciful, especially when it came to Bohemond.

  • @phann860
    @phann860 3 дня назад +18

    The Holy war started in 630 AD when Arab armies took over Roman Syria, followed by conquests in North Africa, later spreading into Spain and conquests east where the Persian Empire was destroyed. So in fact the Crusades were a reaction to Islamic Jihad.

    • @sullyx5142
      @sullyx5142 День назад

      Nice Roman/Western propaganda. A few militants attacked pilgrims and that was all. The romans did it for power. It's ok, the West is coming to an end

    • @curtisthomas2670
      @curtisthomas2670 День назад +1

      Define jihad

    • @Hilltycoon
      @Hilltycoon 14 часов назад +1

      @@curtisthomas2670 Fight in the name of Islam

    • @curtisthomas2670
      @curtisthomas2670 14 часов назад

      @Hilltycoon you're clueless af about lslam and the Quran, as your kind usually are

    • @Hilltycoon
      @Hilltycoon 13 часов назад +1

      @@curtisthomas2670 "a struggle or fight against the enemies of Islam."

  • @AltaicGigachad
    @AltaicGigachad 22 дня назад +42

    Turks indeed had a decisive role in triggering historical major events like the Migration Period, Crusades, shaping the history of Balkans, Islamization of Northern India, Age of Discovery as well as ending the Middle Ages with the conquest of Constantinople, fall of the Roman Empire.

    • @MuhsinShah-k5v
      @MuhsinShah-k5v 22 дня назад +6

      The Hunnic Empire lead to the collapse of the Western Roman Empire, while the Ottoman Empire a millennia later lead to the collapse of its Eastern counterpart.

    • @Ment2703
      @Ment2703 22 дня назад +3

      Anatolian Turks are assimilated people, you can't find any Oghuz DNA among them, just like the Azerbaijanis, they're mixed and assimilated people, they're not nomads anymore, the Seljuk Turks looks absolutely different, they were mongoloids, Seljuk Bey, Tughril bey, Chagri bey, Ahmet Sancar, Malikshah, Alp Arslan

    • @Ment2703
      @Ment2703 22 дня назад

      ​@@MuhsinShah-k5vGermanic tribes caused western Rome to disintegrate (Goths, Visigoths, Allemanni, Franks and Lombards), the Lombards invaded Rome in 476 AD, led by Flavius Odoacer

    • @abdullahfarishta
      @abdullahfarishta 21 день назад +7

      Mongols, who were Turkic themselves, were also responsible for the Sack of Baghdad, and the end of the Islamic Golden Age.

    • @Ment2703
      @Ment2703 21 день назад +1

      @@abdullahfarishta bro, where you guys learned history? Mongols and Turkic people are Altaic people, Mongols aren't turkic

  • @JPCardington
    @JPCardington 21 день назад +98

    Well you haven’t started at the beginning have you? Syria was Roman. It was Christian, though there had been Judae before hadrians wars. The Muslims were pressing further into Christian lands - Anatolia- and this was threatening what was left of the Byzantine empire. Alexis comnensus asked the pope for help DEFENDING Christian lands from Muslim AGGRESSION. Islam always came with the sword (to quote sir Steven runciman)

    • @TheRezro
      @TheRezro 21 день назад +2

      From what I recall he did said that. But the Pope spin it as reconquest of Jerozolim.

    • @JPCardington
      @JPCardington 20 дней назад +21

      Jerusalem had been taken in 636 by Islam. It had been the Roman province of Judae. I have no problem with Islam expansion of the time nor the Franks were barbarically brutal - just the assertions that the Crusades were some inexcusable act of naked Western aggression. They weren't.

    • @generalbelisarius8103
      @generalbelisarius8103 20 дней назад +8

      And the muslims didnt allow pilgrims and persecuted christians trying to visit their holy land

    • @michaelthomas5433
      @michaelthomas5433 20 дней назад +7

      I think the Jewish ppl at that time would have argued there was definitely Christian AGGRESSION.

    • @joemac1293
      @joemac1293 20 дней назад +1

      Roman? They came all the from italy..it was never their land.

  • @HistoricaldHorizons
    @HistoricaldHorizons 22 дня назад +1

    Beautiful work! The quality of the maps and research is spot on

  • @nostrathomas4617
    @nostrathomas4617 20 дней назад +4

    This is a great video, HOWEVER, I wish it was longer, HOWEVER, you could do that...

  • @Roshini-q5d
    @Roshini-q5d 22 дня назад +13

    Can you make a video about 30 years war please and waited for this video❤❤❤

    • @History_Mapped_Out
      @History_Mapped_Out  22 дня назад +6

      I'm hoping to have it ready in a month

    • @beepboop204
      @beepboop204 22 дня назад

      @@History_Mapped_Out if you spend one minuter per year, thats like a 30 minute video! 😂 cant wait for your 1.6hour video on the 100 Years War 😉

  • @Nama-Montana
    @Nama-Montana 22 дня назад

    This video is well made. It’s a keeper for me ❤❤❤thanks for all the details and efforts.

  • @ReligiousReflections70
    @ReligiousReflections70 4 дня назад +1

    "This is next-level creativity! 🖌✨ Don't miss [08:55] - life-changing advice here!"

  • @danielsantiagourtado3430
    @danielsantiagourtado3430 22 дня назад +2

    LOVE your content! please consider tackling the war of austrian succession

    • @History_Mapped_Out
      @History_Mapped_Out  22 дня назад +2

      This topic is in our notes too, thanks for the suggestion

  • @americaisacontinent.
    @americaisacontinent. 5 дней назад +1

    The holy cross will always be protected. Amen..

  • @nicholasleopold3826
    @nicholasleopold3826 22 дня назад +5

    Germany (HRE) - Ancient Sparta
    England - Ancient Athens
    France - Ancient Thebes
    Spain - Ancient Corinth
    Italy - Ancient Argos
    Poland - Ancient Theassaly
    Sweden - Ancient Crete
    Russia - Ancient Macedon
    Balkans - Ancient Epirus
    Vatican - Ancient Delphi
    Greece - Ancient Elis

    • @rockstar450
      @rockstar450 20 дней назад

      @@nicholasleopold3826 what's this?

    • @ZhanetaPetroska
      @ZhanetaPetroska 20 дней назад

      Не

    • @paulocorreia7942
      @paulocorreia7942 18 дней назад

      What about Portugal?

    • @smal750
      @smal750 10 дней назад +1

      HRE was a joke 😂 absolutely nothing like sparta 😂

  • @juliank6793
    @juliank6793 21 день назад +2

    You could seriously chill with the music. A little too intense and loud most of the time.

  • @jxyzbxt2355
    @jxyzbxt2355 14 дней назад +1

    it would be nice if you didnt make the music so loud in the background... or you could just leave it out completely or at least not play it constantly. it distracts from your explanations

  • @Melka-kj4ec
    @Melka-kj4ec 18 дней назад +8

    Mesopotamia was all Christian’s as well. The indigenous peoples church was one of the first. The Assyrians church began they say 33-37ad. The whole region by the time Islam came with swords and sneaky ass tricky, there were more than 200 million members of the Ancient Church of the East alone. To China, Japan. India that whole region. It’s a shame. It really is. They slaughtered that race so much. Probably the most persecuted race. I’ve been studying the Assyrian people. They have been through genocide after genocide. I’ve read the stories about their genocide during WW1 and beyond and until. An indigenous people of that land, were every artifact found is an Assyrian one. The population in their homeland rightful land is 500,000…
    Population 3-5 million worldwide. They need attention too

  • @propilotpdx
    @propilotpdx 2 дня назад +2

    3:49 so much makes sense now

  • @Pipicrit
    @Pipicrit 19 дней назад

    Awesome stuff, you use aftereffects ?

  • @abdullahazzam4703
    @abdullahazzam4703 18 дней назад +3

    Holy wars in christian perspective,
    in muslim i think its only some series of invasion that saw many of that invasion fail or misdirected

    • @ducoh2093
      @ducoh2093 16 дней назад +1

      well your countries had it coming after taking iberia, see piracy, and constantly attacking byzantine empire. the crusades were not hard enough at all.

    • @phann860
      @phann860 12 часов назад

      @@ducoh2093 Upset enough people and you have it coming, Muslim loons are still wittering about Southern Spain.

  • @issith7340
    @issith7340 17 дней назад +9

    Wrong!!! The holy wars ( named: jihad), started in the 7th century, when arab tribes, “in the name of Islam, as they were excusing themselves), invaded the Christian lands of mesopotamia, levantine, Egypt, mahreb, including the holy land, destroying ancient christian holy shrines , or converting them to mosques. The crusades, were jut one stage of the Christian response, starting of the innumerable tries of eastern Roman Empire ( byzantine) to take back their territories from the muslim invaders. The wars are still continuing, to this day.

  • @dylangtech
    @dylangtech 11 дней назад +4

    0:35 Not even a minute in and you are already making false claims. The Pope did NOT promise the forgiveness of sins. He promised pardons for the temporal cleansing of one's soul after death (Purgatory), essentially making the struggles of the Crusades a pentential offering of one's own blood, sweat, and tears.

    • @user-cw1ht6vc4k
      @user-cw1ht6vc4k 6 дней назад +1

      Trying to rewrite history we see. Martin Luther would like a word with you!

    • @dylangtech
      @dylangtech День назад

      @@user-cw1ht6vc4k You need to learn what historical revisionist looks like. Usually it happens with someone with a radical agenda (Luther) and not a loyalist agenda (a modern Catholic)

  • @manojitbasak_0377
    @manojitbasak_0377 13 дней назад

    Make video on the history of East Asia, Pacific isles, African and American countries

  • @canaday2k
    @canaday2k 6 дней назад +2

    Caucasian Turks started all this madness in Jerusalem. When the indigenous Arabs were in control, you didn't have nearly as much issues, because everyone were cousins (i.e. Ishmaelites, Israelites, all Shemite, etc.). Now fast forward to 2024/2025, everyone in North Africa and Western Asia/Middle East is partly or totally Caucasian Turk, and they now call themselves Arabs. The true historical Arabs are still there in small numbers (same thing what happened in America(s), Australia, etc.). They look like modern day Somalians and Ethiopians. The whole region and the Prophets looked like that millenia ago...their identities were hijacked after they let the Caucasian Turks convert to Islam...they also took over the identity of the true Israelites as well

  • @eapoe6
    @eapoe6 11 часов назад

    Is this narrated by Tobias Funke, the Analrapist? He's an analyst and a therapist.

  • @beepboop204
    @beepboop204 22 дня назад

    they sequels could never capture the magic of the original

  • @Nama-Montana
    @Nama-Montana 22 дня назад

    This is millennial phenomenon. When years reaching every thousands, people thought the world will end. They let everything go away because kingdom of heaven will arrive in a few tens or hundreds of years. After millennium they recognise that the end is not here yet. They must do something to their world. It’s a great learning lesson. ❤❤❤😂😂😂

  • @ArrestMe-k5l
    @ArrestMe-k5l 21 день назад +1

    Have you ever thought of kinda recreating crusade march from europe to juruselum?. With kinda same uniforms and flags symbols. That would be awesome and historic 👑

    • @ImperialVader
      @ImperialVader 21 день назад

      That would be insane. To what would the Israelis and Palestinians say about it? H what would the warring regions of the Middle East have to say? The thought of such a prospect is laughable to the papacy today, and other religious institutions.😊

    • @ArrestMe-k5l
      @ArrestMe-k5l 21 день назад

      @ImperialVader I understand that, first question is, would even turkey let that march enter into their territory knowing historical background of it and there is Syria, Lebanon and Jordan. If Israel agrees to this then there is a chance through the Mediterranean sea from Greece or Italy directly to Israel but challenges are still there like the security threat of that march, considering current status we never know what if half group attack local Jews there, what about global opinion, budget, planning ....
      I guess, it's just a fantasy for me.

    • @ImperialVader
      @ImperialVader 21 день назад

      @@ArrestMe-k5l Turkey and other Muslim states would consider it an attack and violation of religious respect and an attack on the dignity of Islam in their state. A zealous march by Christian’s meant to emulate the religious wars of the old past is definitely not gonna ever be permissible.

  • @ianblake815
    @ianblake815 13 дней назад +1

    Love the Crusades

  • @saifsaad201286
    @saifsaad201286 18 дней назад +2

    Why do both Crusaders and Muslims have Arabic names? lol

  • @iwannisbalaouras1687
    @iwannisbalaouras1687 10 дней назад

    you have alexios komnenos in your video in secondary role, your scope is very western. alexios started the crusades

  • @TheRezro
    @TheRezro 21 день назад +2

    Lol, Evangelion reference. I laughed hard

  • @piedmontatl
    @piedmontatl 14 дней назад +1

    There was no such thing as the Byzantine Empire. The term "Byzantine Empire" was only coined following the empire's demise; its citizens referred to the polity as the "Roman Empire" and to themselves as "Romans".

    • @phann860
      @phann860 11 часов назад

      Probably true, but in later periods it was referred to as Byzantine to differentiate from the "Roman" ie. Western Empire. It doesn't really matter because it is understood the Roman Empire didn't finally fall until 1453.

  • @ElBandito
    @ElBandito 22 дня назад

    Cult of personality makes madmen out of us all.

  • @davidcross701
    @davidcross701 День назад

    What really happen was that the Muslims imposed a halt to Christian pilgrimage in the Early 1090s AD. to the Holy Land, which was the name in Europe for the region, not Palestine. Using this name, is mere politics bias, in this channel.

  • @magma9000
    @magma9000 21 день назад +9

    Feels bad for Palestine.😢

  • @smal750
    @smal750 10 дней назад +2

    funny how the crusades were french 😂
    the french carrying the useless eurogays as always 😂

    • @rustyshackleford4761
      @rustyshackleford4761 3 дня назад

      You’re literally coping in a European language that’s how hard you’ve been colonized

  • @JIdjadi
    @JIdjadi День назад

    Why is it called Palestine?

  • @Colonel_Blimp
    @Colonel_Blimp 20 дней назад +4

    The holy wars began when the Arabs came boiling out of the desert in the early 600’s.

  • @curtisthomas2670
    @curtisthomas2670 День назад

    The use of the name Palestine seems to have triggered a certain type, they're bitching all over the comments 😅

  • @cyberblunt
    @cyberblunt 21 день назад

    I guess GOD willed all those wars.

  • @GeorgiosLeo
    @GeorgiosLeo 21 день назад +3

    There are a lot of inaccuracies in this to be called a historical documentary.

    • @TheRezro
      @TheRezro 21 день назад

      And you of course not elaborate.

    • @waqarsaleem8611
      @waqarsaleem8611 21 день назад

      why don't YOU make a video with a lot of accuracies then?

    • @TheRezro
      @TheRezro 21 день назад

      @@waqarsaleem8611 Because people like him lack of arguments.

  • @rockstar450
    @rockstar450 22 дня назад +21

    The constant Palestine references makes me feel you're anti-israel. Continually referring to Arab ownership but ignoring the Christian and Jewish control prior.

    • @Shaheen164
      @Shaheen164 22 дня назад +20

      It was called Palestine. That's literally what they called it back then. Education is key

    • @Shaheen164
      @Shaheen164 22 дня назад +4

      And ps, Arabs have been there just as long. There has never been a point in history where both groups didn't occupy it at the same time.

    • @paul1780
      @paul1780 22 дня назад +13

      Arabs weren't a significant people in the area until the 8th century. Babylonians, Sumerians, Assyrians, Phoeniacians (?), Cannonites (?), Israelites, Hitties, Hurrians, Persians, Medians were in western Asia before the Islamic arrival. Many of these people were Arabized partially or wholly, also North Africa with the native Berber & Egyptian. Egyptian Coptics face discrimination, young girls kidnapped & married to old Men. The same with the Christian population in Iraq. Saying the region was always Arab is erasing these people, people facing extinction. Aramaic is still spoken in Syrian & Iraqi Churches, sad it isn't the vernacular of the Levant since it is native to the region & Arabic came from the Arabian Peninsula. Modern supporters of Hamas try to or don't do enough to look into the past of the region before Islam or even Byzantine Empire. North Africa & the Levant were Arabized. I support the Arabs of the Holy Land, they just need secular rule even moderate Islamist can lead to eventual radicalism. The same fanaticism that led some to what happened in Jordan with the Black September. Many have a habit of being welcomed as "guests" to than repay that hospitality with a separate state like what has been happening in Lebanon, once a thriving country & Hezbollah has to drag Lebanon & the Lebanese into another war with Israel. And the Muslim Brotherhood in Egypt. The 1st US Iraq War where Palestinians welcome Saddam's army. Not really grateful & a bad track record. Golda Meir said it best,"...Peace will come when the Arabs will love their children more than they hate us."

    • @mikep9690
      @mikep9690 21 день назад +6

      ​@@Shaheen164 the reason it was called Palestine goes back to the year 70. There was a Hebrew revolt against Rome the general Titus put it down. Titus burnt the temple and declared that there would no longer be self governing in Jewish lands . So their lands were said to be without palace. There are third century maps with many small Palestines in Spain France and Italy. Palestine literally means "land of the Jews"

    • @Shaheen164
      @Shaheen164 21 день назад +5

      @mikep9690 so thank you for proving my point. That at the time of the crusades, it would've been called Palestine. Since the crusades happened in 1096 AD WELL AFTER the year 70 AD. Therefore, this channel is being historically correct. Not antisemitic like the above comment was implying.

  • @zanchiso1934
    @zanchiso1934 21 день назад

    I cant beleive peaple want to change hisotry for political issue historically it was called Palestine and for muslim Pahlestine it's history not political and from the Roman empire, Jerusalem was just used as most important city there

    • @TheRezro
      @TheRezro 21 день назад

      Yeh. Political Correctness is a cancer. History is absolute! Politics F off!
      For example US Democrats are actual fallow up to good old Republican party. Not this weird mixture of Wigs and Libertarians, who call itself Republican now. History!

  • @Conway-ol8gh
    @Conway-ol8gh 3 дня назад +1

    Always the pesky muslims

  • @natheriver8910
    @natheriver8910 20 дней назад +1

    Deus vult ⚜️⚜️⚜️⚜️

  • @zztopwildman9104
    @zztopwildman9104 10 дней назад

    Crusade again!!! 😂

  • @survivemoto
    @survivemoto 19 дней назад +1

    You glazed over the part where the crusaders' pogroms gave birth to antisemititic movements in Europe.

  • @franksalz9114
    @franksalz9114 20 дней назад +1

    Why isnt Sicily crisscrossed with green...in 1095 muslims were 45-50% of sicily population....thought this was the channel 'History mapped out' u remember to put red stripes in egypt and levant...

    • @phann860
      @phann860 11 часов назад

      Really, most of the population were certainly not Muslim.

  • @MIRAAJMUHAMMAD_666
    @MIRAAJMUHAMMAD_666 20 дней назад +3

    Palestine

  • @samuelferrell9257
    @samuelferrell9257 3 дня назад

    Do better homework next time. Also, please learn how to pronounce names.

  • @hsusyehsh
    @hsusyehsh 2 дня назад

    None of u internet nerds know what realy hapeend all jus make sh up, tryna sound intelligent

  • @withalexmoto
    @withalexmoto 22 дня назад +2

    Using Palestine name for all the reaction is wrong mate. Big error

    • @zanchiso1934
      @zanchiso1934 21 день назад +4

      What is wrong historically it was called Palestine for Muslim Pahlestine it's history not political and from the Roman empire Jerusalem was just used as most important city there

    • @ImperialVader
      @ImperialVader 21 день назад +4

      Please, enlighten us on what you would call the region they were invading at the time. It was called Palestine at the time.

    • @curtisthomas2670
      @curtisthomas2670 День назад

      Triggered z

  • @JordiSalvadoBuque-gs1he
    @JordiSalvadoBuque-gs1he 18 дней назад

    Cruzaders are so crazy 😊😊😊😊!!!

  • @marcosvazquez3984
    @marcosvazquez3984 21 день назад +1

    Palestine? Where is that?

    • @ZhanetaPetroska
      @ZhanetaPetroska 20 дней назад

      Sykes picot secret treaty or first secret London trity and demarcation of middle eastern borders

    • @ZhanetaPetroska
      @ZhanetaPetroska 20 дней назад

      There no exist no philistines or Palestine nor so called Israel zio state that was a totally different place captured by zio Jewesh askhe nazzies from Europe escaping sephradick Spanish revolution Armenian genocide vulgar seldjuk djihad nazie genocide SSSR pogrom or Holodomor France revolution British civil war and oliwer Cromwell ect ect

    • @ihaveachihuahau
      @ihaveachihuahau 20 дней назад +1

      Judea, Syria-Palestina. The Romans never called it Palestine, lol. They even split it up and called it "Palestine prima" "Palestine segunda" etc. but it was literally never just "Palestine".

    • @dans.o.s.d.s6971
      @dans.o.s.d.s6971 10 дней назад +3

      ​​"It was never carolina but only N. and S. carolina " this literally what you imply...
      be honest with yourself, you just don't like the word "Paelestina", and by all means attempting to force us to believe that it didn't exist or whatever... but the fact that modern israeli historian scholars, like the rest of the world, are unanimously referring to this Region, south of Levant, as Palestine, says a lot and makes your comments weird.... (the north of Levant is Syria)
      bro, plz leave ur politics away, it's history time, if you don't like how Christians used to call it, it's your problem... ​@@ihaveachihuahau

    • @dans.o.s.d.s6971
      @dans.o.s.d.s6971 10 дней назад +1

      ​​​​@@ihaveachihuahauthe word Palestine refers to a region, like the word Syria, it refers to a region( before it became a country) , goes the same with Italy, india and Germany, to say the least....
      Israel however doesn't refer to a region but a specific political entity that existed there for a certain period of time.
      and before you jump typing saying it's AntiS or whatever... There are sets of political entities (states or tribal confederacies like judea and Izra, el) that does indeed follow this rule...
      for instance, Lombardei was a german kingdom that occupied the whole region of italy but never used interchangeably with the word Italy (only a small region inside italy).
      History is not what you like..... Accept it as it is, my Izra, eli friend, we don't need ur dictations , thanks.

  • @markbeckens
    @markbeckens 2 дня назад

    The Holy Grail of "Killing in the name of a God"!

  • @bilals8188
    @bilals8188 4 дня назад

    Free Palestine 🇵🇸

    • @Jrock44
      @Jrock44 3 дня назад

      No nation in history has carried that name

    • @curtisthomas2670
      @curtisthomas2670 День назад

      ​@@Jrock44no nation was called lsraeI until 1948