Israelis: Where are the Jews from?
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 1 окт 2024
- HOW TO HELP
▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀
The Ask Project is made possible by donations from viewers like you.
To donate to the project:
* www.paypal.me/...
* / askproject
WHAT IS THE ASK PROJECT?
▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀
Do you want to know what Israelis and Palestinians really think about the conflict? Ask a question and I will get answers. All answers are from random people and all answers are included and unedited. The questions come from you, the viewers.
WHY DO I DO THIS?
▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀
See the following videos where I explain the background and goal of the project • The Ask Project interv...
The first dude should've just been like "fuck it" and said "ETHIOPIA!" 🤣🤣🤣
That would have been hilarious 😆
😄 .....!?? "It is what it is"
Perfect Dave Chappelle skit
Almost no one understood the question, you should have asked what is the origin of the Jews and not where they are from
Correy should hire a professional local Hebrew-English translator, same as he does with Arabic, in that way Correy's lack of Hebrew language skills and his lack of knowledge of culture and history will not affect the answers he gets. The videos will become more symmetrical when done with translators of symmetrical skills.
@@ef2718 His Hebrew isn't;t terrible, but it's not great. Sometimes he is right on track and other times he messes up the questions completely. or he translates the responses into English incorrectly.
It's the right way bec the just are settlers in palastinians land
There is a systematic education problem in Israel if this many Israelis don’t know that yehudim come from yehuda.
jews today are not the real beni israel, there is today only Palestinians Samaritans who mostly live in nabuls, the real deal!. they better teach them this fact instead!.
@@lightbody232 You don't get to decide who is a "real" Jew. Learn that fact.
@@lightbody232 Bullshit!
@@lightbody232 the DNA is the proof that the jewish groups are descendants of israelites. They share many genetic ties with samaritans and lebanese people
Owner of Israel r Palestine Jews Muslim christian only
Israel is the land of my Jewish ancestors.Am Yisrael Chai.Never again.
Yeah whatever
@@ziyadamir8187 triggered? :)
@@kvzgm6316 I am an arab from Kathiri tribe which is from hamdan tribe my people are well known do you think I care about some idiots who claim to be indigenous because they just follow certain religion?
@@kvzgm6316 FYI my tribe used to follow Judaism and paganism before islam and fuck you
@@ziyadamir8187 Aside from the fact that nobody asked, yes, I do think so. Particularly because you are in almost every comment thread on this video, and you seem very passionate about your beliefs. As you have stated you are an Arab, it is true that you may be native to Arabia. And nobody denies that... But this does not grant you the authority in determining the indigenous origins of the Jews. We are talking about the Levant here, not Arabia. Salam
Judea lol what so hard
Why didn't you ask any clearly religious Jews this question?
Exactly my thought, the questions were directed to non religious jews. It is more rooted to Judaism.
It is a knowledge of history issue not a religious one.
@Methodius of Thessaloniki Nonsense. I'm an orthodox Jew myself and I put out videos on my channel. Most orthodox Jews would be happy to answer and to be filmed, though not on a Shabbat.
@Methodius of Thessaloniki Orthodox Jews are normal people who simply keep the commandments of the Torah. As I'm married, I cover my hair and that is a wig I'm actually wearing. I'm also highly educated with a PhD and I wasn't always a religious Jew. There are many observant Jews whom you would perhaps consider "modern". And actually there are many secular Jews in Israel who do keep at least some Torah commandments in their lives eg Yom Kippur in Israel is observed by the majority of Jews here and the roads and streets on that day are almost completely silent, apart from some cyclists.
He ask simple people from the streets
Jewdea.
Thank you!
Hebrew Yehuda --> Greek Iudea -->Latin Judea -->English Judeans/Jews
@@ef2718 whatever so if someone convert to Judaism they became indigenous ?
@@ziyadamir8187
If a person marries into a tribe, then, he and his descendants become part of the tribe.
@@ziyadamir8187 how many people do you know that converted to judaism? Its almost impossible.
Anyways i hope the israelis extreminate all the sand na zis a.s.a.p
I am fully shocked that people did not say “Mi-Yehuda”. That is the literal origin of the word Jew. Is it possible that when you threw in the word Geography, it confused the people answering the question? It’s as if the obvious answer was avoided to sound “smarter”. The most likely answer is that the average secular Israeli has a poor knowledge of basic Jewish and world history . In fact, this seems true all over the world. This may have also been a sampling bias of the most undereducated about basic history. Clearly, those secular Jews consider it “religious.” It’s why it’s important to learn both World and Jewish history.
Thanks for the insight Cory! I love your channel.
1:36 Didn't Abraham come from the city of Ur? The city is in lower Mesopotamia, while part of the Kurdistan area is in Upper Mesopotamia.
From The Imam of Peace: The Dome of the Rock - It is in Jerusalem. Inside it are many holy books, the holiest of them is called the Quran. Inside the Quran is a "land tile" that says this entire land belonged to the Kingdom of Solomon, Moses and their Jewish nations. I believe in that, not in the United Nations.
Ur of Chaldean in Bible didn't mean ur of sumerian btw it means modern day urfa turkey don't confused because it has a same name also majority of Kurdistan is not in mesopotamia
@@avi3860 Imam of Peace has been proven to be a fake Imam
@@omaralfar1666 Major copium.
We do not know where Ur was. There are several options. The most famous option was Urfa in Turkey. Josephus and Maimonides said it is Urfa. The islamic autorities also believe that Urfa is the correct city. But there are many other options (Urkesh in north Syria, Urmia in northwest Iran, and of course the famous Ur today in south Iraq, which was called Uria in aramaic, Urim in sumerian and Uru in akkadian. It already was a big city in the times of Abraham)
BEFORE CHRIST ERA (BC) about 1,900 it was Abraham who created the idea of One God and Laws and who meandered down from Ur (Persia) to Canaan (present day Lebanon, Syria, Jordan and Israel).
1,000 BC the land of Israel was ruled by King David who united the 12 tribes of Israel. (Read up on the kingdoms of Judea and Samaria.) still named Judea and Samaria, even though Jordan changed the name to the West Bank when they occupied the area from 1948 to 1967. NO PALESTINIAN COUNTRY OR PEOPLE.
70 AD Jews revolted against the Romans who destroyed the Jewish temple. Artifacts proving this have been found and surface every other week - the most important and intriguing proof is the Arch of Titus; if you ever visit Rome, please do pop in and see it. NO PALESTINIAN COUNTRY OR PEOPLE
Dead Sea Scrolls - NO PALESTINIAN COUNTRY OR PEOPLE
PALESTINE A GEOGRAPHICAL REGION OF THE LEVANT- named Palestine by Hadrian (117-138 CE) who was a Roman Emperor - NO PALESTINIAN COUNTY OR PEOPLE
539 BC the land was occupied by the PERSIANS; NO PALESTINIAN COUNTRY OR PEOPLE
333 BC the land was occupied by the GREEKS; NO PALESTINIAN COUNTRY OR PEOPLE
63 BC the land was occupied by the ROMANS; NO PALESTINIAN COUNTRY OR PEOPLE
638 the land was occupied by ARAB/ISLAMIC - UMAYYAD, ABBASID, FATIMID; NO PALAESTINIAN COUNTRY OR PEOPLE
1099 - 1167 the land was occupied by the CRUSADERS, NO PALESTINIAN COUNTRY OR PEOPLE
1260 - 1516 - the land was occupied by the MAMLUKS, NO PALESTINIAN COUNTRY OR PEOPLE
1515 - 1917 the land was occupied by the OTTOMAN EMPIRE (WHO WERE NOT ARABS, THEREFORE, NO PALESTINIAN COUNTRY OR PEOPLE.
1922 the land was occupied by the BRITISH UNDER THEIR MANDATE. - PALESTINE WAS A GEOGRAPHICAL REGION IN THE LEVANT AND NOT A SOVEREIGN PALESTINIAN COUNTRY.
- JEWS AND ARABS WERE KNOWN AS PALESTINIAN.
1947 - the land was legally and rightfully partitioned to JEWS who accepted the United Nations Partition Plan and to the ARABS - there were no Palestinians to give it to in 1947 - the Arabs rejected their own homeland. - NO PALESTINIAN COUNTRY OR PEOPLE.
The Arabs who fled to Gaza and Judea and Samaria (named the West Bank) called themselves Palestinians only AFTER they were invented by Arafat in 1964.
Please define a Palestinian land at any time in history ruled, governed or occupied by PALESTINIANS FOR PALESTINIANS WITH JERUSALEM AS ITS CAPITAL CITY.
Isn't this all a bit semantics? Somehow these people wound up in these lands, whether there was ever a Palestinian king or whatever or not. They have a basic human right to live as well as any jew.
The girl at 3:50 and couple at the end probably explained it best. Geographically, sure you would say the Mesopotamian area where Abraham is from, culturally though Jews are form Israel because that is where their identity and culture was formed
Not accurate! Abraham came to Canaan by himself! He didn't bring the ancient Jews with him to that land from Mesopotamia! The ancient Jews (Hebrews) were already living in Canaan, as part of the many Canaanite tribes who lived there at the time of his arrival. He just led them in the new way of monotheism.
@@GPBKM If you’re using Hebrew as synonymous with Jews, then that is impossible since Abraham is the father of the Jews… but I suspect your answer is politically motivated
@@arjealis97 , Politically motivated??? What are you on about? LOL!!! It's a historical fact! The ancient Hebrews are what the Jews were called before they became Jews! They were also used to be called Israelites. Regardless, what's that has anything to do with politics? 😂
@@GPBKM some people in Israel will say anything to legitimise their claim against Palestine, even though it isn’t necessary. I don’t see any other reason why you’d claim Abraham arrived when the Jews were already there since that makes no sense at all
@@arjealis97 , Who said anything against Palestine here??? We're talking historical facts about the origin of Jews, which is the Levant, NOT Mesopotamia, and you're the only one who's pushing politics and Palestine into the conversation... Absolutely ridiculous... 🙄
According to DNA tests and according to the thousands of years of history, the origin of the Jews is from the Levant region, the Middle East, the Land of Israel. According to genetic studies done in order to map common Jewish genetic diseases, they found an identical Middle Eastern gene in all Jews, whether those who lived in the Ashkenaz region or in Jews who lived in the region of Arab countries and North Africa.
Besides history, the Bible and genetics, archeology also proves that the Jews know their origin very well, tremendous archaeological findings, such as verses from the Torah engraved on stones, ancient synagogues, coins with Hebrew inscriptions, mikvehs, Jewish symbols such as engraved lamps, ancient names that pass thousands of years Among Jews, testimonies from ancient peoples that describe the Jews, etc., etc.
this is a lie. There were many converts throughout jewish history, some of them, mostly very recent ones, do not have any middle eastern ancestry. Unless you think that converting to judaism changes your DNA. Moreover, that fact that there were torah followers in Judea 2000 years ago does not mean that every torah follower today was born there. Again, there are plenty of converted jews who believe and follow the torah but have no jewish ancestors. This was already discussed in early rabbinic and medieval times.
@@meownyan3925s..but do you understand that this is something like
000.0001%?
It’s extremely hard to convert and hardly any do.
Way are you referring to the minimum of the people and not the Majority?
Do you think that is the way of truth?
And then call the facts a lie?
Lol
This is 100% fact. I have read (and saved) the DNA test results for Jewish populations as analyzed by the Albert Einstein College of Medicine in NYC. Ashkenazi DNA is 100% Middle Eastern in origin. When compared to their neighbors, Ashkenazi, Sephardi, and Mizrahi DNA did not match. When compared to one another their DNA matched. The oldest historical texts from the land of Israel as well as the oldest archeological artifacts show Jewish origin. However, no matter how many facts are presented by the most credible sources, Jew haters will continue to remain ignorant and deny our existence. Their sources are the anti-Semites on social media comment sections who literally just make things up.
The land of Palestine.
@@theonecounttheonecount8477 There is no country or people called "palestine"
Jews doesn't have a basic land or place lived in until they occupied Palestine.....
,,, p.s ,,,, I do respect the Jews who doesn't steal Palestinians houses.
Jews are from Israel. Countless times they were driven out & scattered but thank GD we are back in our original home.
Search for kingdom of kazar its interesting
Historical evidence is that Yahweh was a god that was borrowed from other people. It was not originally a Hebrew God. It was a war god of other people.
@@cinnaminson0653 you’re an idiot.
aren't most jews ashkenazi, and aren't they from turkey?
"I'm Palestinian. From 1921 until 1948 I carried a Palestinian passport! "
~golda mier~
BRITISH MANDATE Palestine, was a mandate area not a country (and if it had been one, it would have been a British one). “I was born a Jordanian. After the 1967 war, people started calling me Palestinian.” - Walid Shoebat, former PLO member
@@starhopper1706
Question for Correy:
Had the legislative assembly of the state of Israel in 1948 chose to retain the British Mandate title "Palestine Land of Israel", what would then be the identity title appropriated by local Arabs starting in 1966, or what identity title would have the Egyptian and KGB intelligence services come up with in July 1964?
@@ef2718 Good question. Canaanitians?
@@starhopper1706
It's too elaborative question for Corey's style.
@@starhopper1706
Per the bible ,the Israelis married Canaanites , per archeologists the Israelis were Canaanites who became monotheists, so appropriating Canaanite title by Arabs AKA Palestinians is not the best choice.
Natufians predated Canaanites by 9000 years hence a better choice.
Kebaranians predate Natufians by 6000 years so even better.
Timeline of events for ELI5:
Akkadian exodus > K'naan > Egypt > K'naan became Israel > Israel divided (Israel and Judea kingdoms) > Two exiles of northern and southern kingdom > Exiles return to Israelite land > multiple subjugations from foreign polytheistic powers > Judean-Samarian revolt fails against Roman Empire > Major exile > Some came back or never left > Around the world escape > Back to Israel again
The last dude is correct from a strict originary point of view, but Elohism (and subsequently Judaism) didn't really start until the land of Israel united with the confederation of the twelve tribes.
The man who had it on point was Akkim. Origination is Israel, then exiled people returned. End of.
Wow, very fascinating variety of answers. Not what I expected !
In history JEWS are before Arabs by almost 1000 years.
Jews originally from " YEMEN" to IRAQ to Phalasteen to Egypt then return " kingdom of David.
Why yemen? Why not japan? If you lie as your "taqyia" religious duty then at least lie big lol
@@dogbert52
They are from YEMEN because they are " SEMETIC" nation " Shemyot" & all SEMETIC race are from YEMEN Arab & Jews.
@@mohamadahmad9896 they are from japan because japan and judea both start with a J!!!!
@@dogbert52
That's so funny 🤣🤣🤣
Georaphy jews came from Ejypt because they are canianies קנעאן. Which means the indigenous. But when they were force to leave they lived all over the world, Europe, Morocco, Russia and maby countries. Until they came here.
Jews have always lived in Eretz Yisroel
I hope they find your clan and deport them back to ar abia. After taking revenge for your lies of course. Reciprocity.
Not true . Ashkenazi Jews came from the khazar kingdom. They are originally Turkic people.
They have nothing to do with the middle east
There was no and never was Kurdistan. It was ASSYRIA. The Jews from Assyria are Assyrian Jews or Jewish Assyrians!
Kurdish from kurdistan.
The Jews preserved tradition and history in exile for thousands of generations and precisely here in Israel after several decades they do not know their own history! It's sad where the Israeli education system has brought us, a basic question they don't know how to answer, I wonder what will happen in 30 years...
Glad the israeli "educational system" (brainwashing) is failing here
If you asked this question to a random guy on the shtetl in the 17th century, you'd probably get a similar answer. Some of us learn the history, some don't.
Most of the Jews are not Semites, only a few, and a few of the Children of Israel, but their religion is not their different races, but they are racists, so some believe that they are Semites
Jews are called Jews because they are from Judea. Their DNA is Levantine with some ibtermixing mostly with ancient Greco-Roman DNA,
The Jewish people are *indigenous* to Judea - Land of Israel. 🕎🙌
After over 2 millennia of forced exile, persecution, and genocide, the *(re)establishment* of *Jewish sovereignty* in our *ancestral homeland* is a remarkable story of *national liberation.* Jewish claims to the land are far more than biblical accounts. Our *religion, language, culture, holidays, rituals, liturgy, history,* and even the words Jew and Jewish are all inseparable from *historical Judea* and our collective longing to *return to the Land of Israel.*
The land of Israel is where Jews became *a people* and the *oldest monotheistic faith.* It is where Jews *achieved sovereignty* before losing it and regaining it several times until much of the *indigenous Jewish population* was either killed or forced into exile following the *Roman Empire’s* brutal suppression of the heroic *Jewish revolt* in the second century of the Common Era. Though the Romans subsequently *renamed the land* Syria Palaestina, the Jewish people *never left* our homeland physically or spiritually. *Archaeological evidence* of Jewish life can be found in more than *30,000 sites* in Israel with antiquities dating back centuries. Even when we were massacred and persecuted by Christian Crusaders, Arab and Ottoman *invaders,* the British-led Jordanian Arab Legion, or more recently Hamas suicide bombers and rockets, our attachment *never* wavered.
It is in this same land where Jews miraculously *revitalized* the Hebrew language, *rebuilt* the institutions necessary for independence, *re-engaged* in rituals that are uniquely observed in the land of Israel, *redeveloped* the land and the economy so that by several magnitudes the Jewish and non-Jewish populations grew, and offered refuge not just to the remnant which survived the Holocaust, but also millions of Jews fleeing persecution from the Muslim Middle East, Ethiopia, and the former Soviet Union. Today, Israel is a *rich tapestry of diverse citizens,* including over half of Jewish Israelis who identify as Jews of color and 20% of whom are Arab citizens.
*Peace Not Hate!* 🇮🇱💙
I hate to be that guy, but the oldest monotheistic faith is Zoroastrianism (and technically, both Zoroastrianism and Judaism are Henotheistic).
Abraham is from Irak , but most Jews are turk
Most of them are just so confused or uneducated... LOL!!! Abraham didn't bring the Jewish people with him from Iraq to Canaan! The ancient Jews (Hebrews/Israelites) were part of the many tribes of Canaan and already lived in that land when Abraham arrived and started the belief in one God with them. So yeah, the origin of the Jewish people is in the land of Israel.
Nope, the Jews developed out of the descendants of Jacob. They were in the land.,Abraham did not prosletyse and just bring people into the group, others joined by marraige.
@@rachelsamuel3328 , So where exactly are you disagreeing with me here??? lol
🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱
Thanks. I just needed that to wipe my @ss ; )
@@freeradical_v You belong in the toilet with your BS
@@1995yuda stfu and hand me that toilet paper now.
@@freeradical_v oh, you anti semite, yes?
@@cinnaminson0653 not at all. I don’t dislike Arabs.
Happy New Year
We are from Israel. The only reason we ever lived anywhere else is because of Roman colonization of our lands. Our origins are here. And it's not a matter of opinion either.
If u tell a lie enough it becomes truth.
@@6689wonderfullyblessed lol
@Rose Toran cope harder Rose.
All humans came from Africa and jews are not an etnicity
so your bible says that the romans kicked the jews out of Jerusalem?
I'm mizrahi I know
I think it depends what point in time you want to pick.
We all come from the same couple. Period. Shalom.
Arabs and jews are LITERALLY BROTHERS who haven't stoped fighting for thousands of years. GROW UP ALREADY LITTLE BRATS.
I bet the problem is in your phrasing of the question, everyone knows were originally from Yehuda but you should've mentioned what era.
Because we are tought a lot about the Holocaust and the country having easterns and ashkenazis we automatically relate the answer to "EU & Eastern Countries"
Ask the Palestinians the same question .
they don't even know where they are from originally then they claim that Palestine is their land lmfao bruh
and arabs who claim of being "canaanites" even though this land was jewish majority till the 3rd century c.e.according to virtually all western historians,they make more sense...
@@netanelzion you still depend on the western historians to decide ur history ? Makes sense
@@RUclipsDZCherif_Hamrani if i was orthodox jew i would believe everything told in the bible,but then i would just slightly better than islamists who believes everything told in quran and follows every pip of his cleric. i prefer to follow history backed by archeological evidence or extensive historical recrod preserved by many nations-hence scientific history(western history,not what they teach in madrassas. western in that sense is also japanese and korean and chinese and russian and indian and any other place where religious clerics dont decide about the curriculim like in al azhar ).
@@RUclipsDZCherif_Hamrani facts dont matter to ji hadi imperialists. The ji hadi invaders are afraid one day they will all be returned to their ar abic is lamic lands
To you I only can sayיחי ישראלי🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱
Ashkenazi are from caucus
Really? Show the genetic proof!! The Canaanites have Caucuses DNA, clown
best video everrrrr, none of them know why he is in palestian, and all admit that they are from anywhere, but not this land!!!!! bloody hell Israhell
I guess you didn't watch the video???
@@shainazion4073 I guess you need to watch and try to understand, if not read comments and zip up your lips
@@77mrmohd who is the founder of pastaline?
@@dogbert52 existing people there since 4000 years, us arab canaanist
@@77mrmohd name a name. Why are you avoiding habibi?
Thats an easy question, Jews came from Judeah which is the origin of the name
we r Jews we came from Morocco ,Ethiopia ,Yemen ,Iraq Tunisia ,Russia ,Egypt
not all the Jews r white like all the black n saying
Now go ask that question to the Arabs, but like MSM you dare not ask such a relevant question.
Saudi Arabia and the Gulf States. What's so hard about the question and why wouldn't he dare ask it?
@@omarakram99you are totally right, but "the pastalini" clans are afraid they will be returned to their homes in ar abia.... so they invent lovely funny stories.
That's not true. Geneticists and historians have shown that Palestinians have largely indigenous roots and only intermixed with other groups that came to Palestine over time who were assimilated into the overwhelming majority of indigenous peoples-some/many of whom also had some Jewish roots who converted to Christianity and then Islam (some directly to Islam). Palestinians, like most modern Arabs were culturally and linguistically "Arabized" but genetically a separate group-though both Jews and all the Arabs of Arabia and the Levant have shared ancestry back to "Abraham" (whether or not one believes the specific religious story, genetics show the shared ancestry). Interestingly, one genetic market that seems to be the best indicator of Abrahamic roots is the "Cohen" gene (which supposedly goes back to Aaron). Funny enough, this gene is more common among Arabs than Jews! Though, interestingly, it is more common among Saudi Arabians than any other group-which does seem to verify Islamic history regarding the ancestry of the Prophet Muhammad (which has also been shown to have the Cohen gene-as shown in confirmed descendents of the Prophet).
@The Palestinian Leftist thank you for clarifying but I don't know if it's any good. The dude is a troll and replied to my other comment saying I'm a jihadi... classic racist and extreme right-wing behavior.
And I fully agree with you on what you wrote. As an Egyptian, I'm only considered 17% of Arab descent so the phrase you used as being Arabized and not being the Arabs of Arabia ourselves is accurate. I feel bad for people who disregard their own country's history and identify themselves as hardcore Arabs...
@@omarakram99 I Actually like the fact that Islam was so successful to the point where almost the entire Middle East is considered "Arabs" by many foreigners. This is a testament to the effectiveness of this religion in bringing people together
Historically Jews are group of Proto-Caucassian people,have their Family tree from Iraq crossed the River Euphrates, Tigris( Ivrit) by the Assyrian King to the native land of Cannanites and Sumerians( by replacing them)or even mixed with thy inhabitants.. Thats the truth
Interesting...✌💯
Now ask the Palestinians where they are from. What year, who was their founder?
why? what would you expect their response to be?
"Pastaline existed before the dinosaurs!!!!!"
"The zionistic meteor came from europe!!!!"
Etc etc
@@gerri577A comedy show.
He already did! Now what is the excuse for your chosen people not to know? This is a real comedy show and the jews are known to be good comedians
@@annri8248Give me the name of the Palestinians founder?
The lady in yellow on the couch is very wise.
A Blessed Shavuah Tov To All Am Yisroel And Friends Of Zion From Judea and Samaria: The Biblical Heartland of The Nation State of The Jewish People, Israel 🇮🇱 ✡️🇮🇱✡️🇮🇱✡️🇮🇱✡️
You are going to be charged fully and completely for all your lies. Every single one. And I'm going to ensure you get the maximum. I have no respect for vile liars.
@@bmr4566
Please stand in line with the rest of lunatics.
I actually thought that our young people would have learned about their history and origins. How disgraceful that they are not taught our history.
@@avi3860
Twitter, TikTok and other rubbish has taken the place of real knowledge.
Steckel you nazi troll
Many original jews became christians, and mixed with others
Many original jews and christians became Muslims, mixed well with arabs and arabised
few original jews remained as jews and survived in middle east, and arab world
Some jews migrated/escaped to parts of world and mixed with non jews.
Jewish population of Isreal is made up of few original jews and many mixed jews
The overwhelming majority of Kurds believe that the prophet Abraham was a Kurd. My late father often said that we were descended from Jacob, son of Abraham.The names of my three brothers are Abraham, David and Yakub.
We the Jews also believe this..we believe Abraham was a Kurd
Abraham was a Chaldean from Babylon modern Iraq what does a nomad kurd have to do with Abraham
@@Al-Shaheedi 99% i'm sure that you're an Assyrian , arn't you ? 🤣😂🤣
Assyrians are the only people who speak contemptuously about the Kurds.Tell the truth ; are you a Syriac ??? Yes we are mountain , we are nomad and we are Aryan . And of course, we are proud to be Kurd.🤣😂🤣
@@zaragan9157 Abraham wasn’t Aryan!
@@Zeyede_Seyum Most of what is known about ancient times is not certain... Civilizations and societies have always mixed and influenced each other. Today, I know dozens of families living as Muslim Kurds but of Jewish origin. Best regards from savage Kurdistan 👋👋👋
What is your ethnic background, miss Israeli? "My parents are from Yugoslavia" .... another place that does not exist, how far in the past yall livin in?
It’s sad how many Jews do not even know their own identity, even those living in Israel. The girl and the two gentlemen in the middle of the video were spot on. It’s truly bewildering that so many Jews are confused when asked of their origins and are unaware that they originate from the land of Israel. The young man and the old woman who speculated on the birthplace of Abraham are not entirely inaccurate, however Abraham settled in the land of Israel and his descendants (the tribes of Israel) were born in Israel. Israel is our ancestral homeland. It is so sad what the diaspora has done to the Jews’ perception of self-identity.
Lol you believe the rubbish that you are taught but have no proof ? 😂 typical Jew
Life is too expensive for most Israelis to be able to care about such things unforunately.
Can you name people who would know better?
@@solvingpolitics3172 satan
Why sad??? They tell the truth!!! They are from everywhere but not this land!!!!! The land of the promise?? And 60% of them don't even believe in GOD!!!!!!! FO
lol the ones in the holy land now have came from germany and poland but they are from the four corners of the earth, even a black man can be a jew or even a chinese man in china but Titus3:9 says, But avoid foolish questions, and genealogies, and contentions, and strivings about the mosaic law; for they are unprofitable and vain... and 1Timothy1:4 says, Neither give heed to fables and endless genealogies, which minister questions, rather than godly edifying which is in faith,, and those scriptures were written by REAL JEWS! EX- High priest, scribes and pharasiees... Acts17:30 God commands ALL MEN EVERYWHERE to Repent, because he has appointed a day in which he will judge the world in RIGHTEOUSNESS!!! God isnt going to judge the world in superstitions and rituals that mean nothing unto a holy and righteous God but he is going to judge the world in RIGHTEOUSNESS!! and if you get drunk lie smoke cigarettes bible says you will not inherit the kingdom of God 1Corinthians6:9-10 and !Corinthians3:17 if you destroy the Holy Temple(your body)"with cigarettes" God will destroy you in hell fire... dont be decieved by the anti christ turn to the King of the Jews the Jew of Jews the Jewish MA-SHIACH YESHUA!!!! Jesus gives the power to GO AND SIN NO MORE!! John8:11, John5:14.. Praise God!
Egyptian guy with sefardic grandma, very happy to see others from the 1492 exile from Spain!
the ones Ottomans helped protect you meant?
@@mostafa_abbasi true
Worst decision my people ever make to allow these bastards live among us
egyptain were african new egyptans are arabs who invaded why they knew 0 about egypt
@@eclark3849 😂
No... The first Jews were Syrian-Jews and Palestinian-Jews...
Proud to be Israeli jew, finally im in the place i belong , ans not the diaspora
You are wild squatter and immigrant
Go back to poland where you came from
@@ziyadamir8187 im not from poland, and I won't go back to Europe, it was our Diaspora place, now we're back to Israel, polish people killed jews, together with russians Ukrainians germans and romanians
@@bogumilaskowron2680 i was born here and im going to stay here forever ♾️
@@ultimatedark5969 maybe you was born in Palestine but many if you had nothing to do with Palestine before and they steal homes indigenous Palestinian people
What a shame
So so lost our children are
They don't even know
Their own roots. Shameful
It's a fucking DisGrace.
Prophet Abraham was neither a Jew nor a Christian
He was a Christian. All prophets of God are Christian. It is written.
@@cinnaminson0653 The word "Christian & Christianity" do not appear in any manuscript !! where did you get it from ??
Even Jesus himself never heard of it !!!
Avraham was born as Avram, after divine intervention by God he was renamed to Avraham and Became the first Hebrew, later on his great grandson Yosef became no.2 in the Egyptian Empire which later on lad to the Hebrews being enslaved by the Egyptiant. After Exodus, Hebrews divided to the 12 tribes named by the 12 sons of Jacob, the first son is called Yehuda (Judea) and he is the Royal sector and more religious tribe of the 12. The Jews are the later generations of the Judeans who lived in ANCIENT Israel and later got colonised and Exiled 2 times, first by the Assyrian empire and secondly by the Roman Empire. After the 2nd exile the Jews were scattered throughout North Africa and whole of Europe. After the independence of Israel many of those Jews returned home, in a rare act of decolonisation. Does that answer your question?
You know they are not the original of the land you see them saying from many countries.
Shut the F up you arab clown, we know where we are from. We've been here thousands of years before your false prophet was touching little girls.
Returned to the ancestral Jewish homeland from many countries*
Many Mizrahi Jews are Arabs. And before the advent of Zionism, there were Palestinians who were Jews.
It's like asking Ethiopians where Ethiopians come from.
Ethiopia doesn't have a large returning diaspora, but yes.
Liberia is a better comparison. Americo-Liberians moved to their countries from different US states, but nobody claims that they are not African
@Alexander E. Liberia is of course a complete dump. The state doesn't function at all.
Yemen is origin place of all Semitics and homeplace of genetic marker J1 haplogroup
Where are the Palestinians from? When was there ever a sovereign Palestinian state, country, nation or people?
well, as what golda mier said in her fanous tv interview back then : "I'm Palestinian. From 1921 until 1948 I carried a Palestinian passport! "
Souverain states is a relative New thing in the World and more so in the middle east.
Ar abs = from ar abia
@@lightbody232 You missed the word "sovereign." From 1921 to 1948, the only sovereign in the land was the British monarch. But nice attempt to twist Golda's words.
@@lightbody232 You left out out the part where she said there were no such thing as palestinian and that there were just Jevvs and Arabs.
Hello my name is Sam I’m from the United States of America. I wish to marry Christian Arab or Israeli girl.
The land of Israel. Next question.
there was no land of Israel in the bible days. Israel was a person and the ppl who followed him were Israelites. The ppl who inhabit Isreal, biblically known as Jerusalem, are Israeli's.
@@gerri577 There were Jewish kingdoms in roughly the same area as modern Israel. Jerusalem is a city & the Jewish capital, historically and now. And Jewish is a nation of people, but it's also a political nation, also historically and now.
@@starhopper1706 I've always known that the Abrahamic religions are more about politics than spirituality.
@@gerri577 That would depend on the individual, but level of observance/religiosity doesn't determine if you are part of the Jewish nation of people.
@@gerri577 bro, you’re an idiot😂😂😂
You ain’t from that land fasure🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Surprised by the ignorance within my people.
Yes Abraham was from Iraq, but he moved to Israel and started his family here. Then his kids went to egypt for few generations (210 years), became a people, and came and concqured the land of Israel.
Jew is a religion not a race or ethnic group. Jews are Canaanite people that lived in Levant, Syria, Israel & Transjordan. Part of Canaan, known historically as Phoenicia is Palestine. The Arabs, Iraqis etc also live here. Jews cannot claim that Israel belongs to them, as though no other ethnic groups live in Palestine.
@@jimmylee1776 not all nations are "races",but judaism sure an ethnic group,more than "palestinians"are an ethnic group(afro palestinians,bosniaks of keisaria and turkamen of abu zurayk all "palestinians"?). no one claimed jews are " a race",but the main ethnic jewish groups(sephardi,mizrahi and ashkenasi)share strong genetic connection and come from people who were jewish for centuries and derive from hebrew migrants from judea and some converts(very few as it take few years to convert to judaism and under islamic and christian regimes it was punishable by death to convert out of the dominating religion).we share historical and linguistical(hebrew) and linguistical connection originating in this land where the kingdoms of israel,judea and maccabim existed. we are a nation,and thanks to the arabs and islamists removing us from their countries we were not assimilated
@@jimmylee1776
Jews are in fact an ethnic group (I've added the definition from Wikipedia at the end of my comment for you).
now, the Jewish people source is from one family (this fact has been established by a number of DNA researches and validated from a few historical documents and findings). they have been conquered the land of Canaan from 7 rivaling ethnic groups who lived here and each controlled a small section of the land of Canaan, then, the Jews (or should I said the Hebrews) controlled the land for another 1,250 years with a some foreign empires briefly taking control, and losing it back to Jewish hands. until the Romans Exiled most of the Jews (some Jewish communities remained mainly in Hebron, Jerusalem and the Galilee), renamed the place from Province Iudaea to Province Syria-Palaestina, and after the Romans fall the Arab conquest during this times people (who today call themselves "Palestinian") started to Immigrate to the area from near lands. despite, the immigration most of the land was not inhibited - and became a waste land during the following generations (as described in some visitors journals). that mean that during the time "Palestine" was free from "occupation" - they did not really care about the land - their interest in the land started only after the Zionists showed interest of bringing back the Jewish people to Israel around 1880AD, and they start to self identify as Palestinians...
just to let you know, in 1929 (before the modern state of Israel existed, during the British mandate), the first ever leader of the Palestinians - Haj Amin El Huseyni (and a close friend of Adolf Hitler), promised his followers a place in heaven to whomever who kill a Jew. few hours later, a massacre started against the old Jewish communities in Hebron, Jerusalem and Tzfat (who have been there since the old kingdom of Israel). The worst massacre happend in Hebron where Arabs raped young girls and mothers, killed and dismembered the bodies of Men, Women and kids {{{ ***VERY GRAPHIC STORY*** one survivor was at the time 11yo and he survived to tell that he managed to hide, but he saw the horror of his Arab "good" neighbor - laughing while raping his tied up Mother with his dead youngest brother severed feet, before another Arab cut her head off. and the survivor had to keep shut, to not be found}}}.
Here is the definition of Ethnic group from Wikipedia: "An ethnic group or an ethnicity is a grouping of people who identify with each other on the basis of shared attributes that distinguish them from other groups. Those attributes can include common sets of traditions, ancestry, language, history, society, culture, nation, religion, or social treatment within their residing area. The term ethnicity is often times used interchangeably with the term nation, particularly in cases of ethnic nationalism, and is separate from the related concept of races."
אתה צודק גם אני נורא התפלאתי, איזה בורות יש פה בארץ..פשוט מזעזע
and when Abraham came it was already called Palestine according to the bible "Genesis 21:34, NLT: And Abraham lived as a foreigner in Philistine country for a long time."
Do Jewish Ethiopians believe the original Jews were black?
Guy at 7 minutes is the most educated and correct. It’s crazy to think that Israeli schools don’t teach this.
they do, students just don't pay attention in school lol.
The "Pashtuns" are a lost Israelite tribe living in Afghanistan?...
Jews, Hebrew, Aramaics, Arameans, Assyrians, Syrians, Phonecians, Druze, Sumerians, Akkadians, Persians, Kurds, Iranians, Turks, Armenians, Yazidis, And Azidis all Natives to The Middle East yeah.
Aramaic is a language, druze is religion some druze actually came from arab tribe 😂😂😂 also jews are not an etnicity
@@ziyadamir8187 the original jews were semitic. As were the palestinians.
@@gerri577 original jews? Wdym?
@@gerri577 and not all Palestinians are semitic
@Real2nd Exodus whatever don't care
I love so much Greek Jews !!! You are my brothers and sisters !!!
The Jews are from Miami, Florida.
Yes Specifically Aventura
Lmao
The question is deceiving. Geographically the Jews originated in Israel. The kingdom of Judea was established here.
The people if Israel (israelites/herbrews) however, probably came from the Ur Qasdim region - mesopotamia.
But most of the people got it right
They know they didn’t come from the lands of Palestine.
We come from the land of Israel and most of the said it.
Archeology disagrees with you. What you won't find is anything "Palestinian".
Roman or british "lands of pastaline"?
@@starhopper1706 Jews used to live in Palestine too. Jewish history is part of _Palestinian_ history
@@rxtr664 Jewish is not an etnicity
All these people gave different answers lol. They have no clue where they came from.
would a dna test help? I bet they have mixed ancestory like most americans do
Exceptional video, keep up the good work. Non biased information. Thank you Corey.
No biased information?
More then half of them didn't even k ow their own roots
How the fuck is that not biased ?
Where are the Jews From?
Khazaria Empire
@@bumingokturk7870 , The Khazar theory had already been debunked by scientists and historians many years ago. Go educate yourself better and stop spreading brainless antisemitic conspiracy theories!
Their ancestors were the Scythians originally from Iran.
@@athenaemmanouilidis1291 with all do respect sir, you are aware that Jews returning back to Israel after more than 2,000 years from many different nations all over the world is in fulfillment of biblical prophecy such as Ezekiel chapter 37:12-14; you are aware of this correct ?
As Moshe Rabeinu said "if there's 2 Jews there's 3 opinions". The origin of Jewish Nation is the Land of Israel with capital city of Golden Jerusalem. Once its territories reached till Babylonian borders. Now days Iraq.
Abraham’s birthday 1,948
Israel re-established 1948
Global academic consensus in terms of the archaeological evidence found everywhere across the region - the Jewish people (Israelites) originated in the Samarian hills of the land of Israel. The nation of Israel was Levantine pagan religion, then "henotheistic", for most of the early history. Monotheism as mainstream adherence only occurred in the 2nd Temple era. Our nation and culture is much more ancient than our religion.
This is why we have to call ourselves Hebrews/Canaanites because it was the same people that the monotheistic propaganda artificially separated and seeing these grown up people talking about "God gave the land to Abraham" nonsense is so annoying. We should be proud of our past and not this stupid religion.
@@lostinstrumentalsproject7343 I agree.
@@interestingyoutubechannel1 i am glad. By the way druze are hebrews too and some palestinians and lebanese genetics proved that.
@@lostinstrumentalsproject7343 I agreed with your perspective of a stupid religion masked on top of a nation, monotheistic propaganda as you said.
But labeling ourselves 'Hebrews/Canaanites' is problematic - the term Jews, nation of Israel, has cultural and historic meaning that accounts for the developments we had in history.
Labeling Druze or others in this way is even more problematic - e.g. the most 'Canaanite' of all Levantine people, other than Jews, are Lebanese but there is very little that connects them to their Phoenician roots. Maybe a few ancient sites of the old way to harvest salt, and some of the food preservation methods. It would be great if they re-energized their Phoenician heritage but fact is, many/most still see themselves as Arab.
@@interestingyoutubechannel1 i don't agree that Judaism was a natural phenomena thay happened to our people and nation but rather was developed through a henotheistic cult in Judah and then later became monotheistic in the babylonian captivity. The hebrew people were polytheistic and then some hebrews changed that and took the god yhwh of the midianite hebrews to their monotheistic propganda and forced it on their entire nation. Judaism is a lie, a deformity. We should not embrace it but rather fight it ideologically. If you will read the new testament you will see that for example, Saul called himself A hebrew of the hebrews and the religious affiliation he said that he was a pharicee not a jew. The term "jew" only stuck with us during the exile. Returning to our true historical culture and values is not only feasible but necessary beacuse if we don't we would end up fighting a stupid religious war and use wrong terminology forever and we will never have true peace.
You ask only the pepole that are far from the tora you know that if you ask pepole who close the tora thay have a god qustion
There is a part of the Palestinian Muslims and even a small part of the non-Armenian Christians who were part of the ancient people of Israel, then they worshiped idols and converted to religions and left their religion and allied with the Canaanites and others. The biggest example is the Samaritans in Nablus. Their number was millions before Islam and after Islam their number shrank because the majority converted to Islam By the way, they are from the dynasty of Ephraim Ibn Joseph, peace be upon him
The Samaritans are not indigenous. At the same time the Assyrians transported away many upper class Jews, to Babylon, they brought in people, from other lands, to take the Jewish homes.
@@deborahfreedman333
😂😂😂
Samaritans are a mixture of indigenous Israelites from the Kingdom of Israel and North Mesopotamians/Anatolian colonists. This is clearly the definition of a Samaritan.
@@mr.x653 just because Samaritans are Hebrews who intermarried with Assyrians does not mean they are not Hebrews.
Jews spread out over the world and intermarried with other peoples.
Most Jews who spread out over the world had multiple identities when in diaspora. Their ancient Hebrew identity(if they studied some Hebrew, celebrated Israelite festivals, used the Hebrew calendar, etc.... ), and the culture/cultures of wherever they grew up.
A good example of this would be the ancient Iraqi Jewish community who before they returned to Israel after Israeli independence Iraqi male Jews of the elite Jews of Baghdad were literate in Hebrew. They had a Hebrew newspaper in Baghdad that was called 'Hado Ver' but at the same time the Iraqi Jews contributed to the overall modern Iraqi culture.
Many Jewish poets from Yemen, Iraq and Egypt who wrote Hebrew poetry and songs also wrote and sung in Arabic as well.
@@christofferraby4712 where did I say they are not Hebrew because they mixed? That's what literally almost every Jew did. They lashed out against the Samaritans for doing it and did it themselves later. Their whole religion is a joke and has nothing to do with the Mosaic law.
Kurdistan mountains.🤨🤨🤨🤨🤷🤷 Surely not Israel. 🤫🤫🤫
But abraham was also the father of ishmael.... so ar ab muz are kurds? Or ar abs come from ar abia and lie to conquer lands?
Abraham came to Canaan by order of God. They didnt go to Kurdistan.
jewish origin as i was taught(without religious narrative i find less convincing) - the jewish religion was formulated and cannonized in the land of israel/judea,and so does the hebrew language(considered canaanite language) and the first jewish kingdoms(israel,judea and judean maccabin kingdom).
since byzanthine time most hebrews fled the land of israel and by the 3rd century c.e jews ceased being najority in the land,and after a samaritan rebellion the samaritan population dwindled as well. the jewish hebrew migrants around the world(especially the "old world"- middle east,north africa and europe) creared communities there and there was some intermarriage with converts(though limited in the last centuries - under islam and christianity converting outside the dominant religion was punishable by death).
most ethnic jews(ashkenasi,sephardi,levantine and babyonian,north african) share strong genetic and cultural ties,while others came as converts or groups who had mass adoption of judaism. of course there is still limited conversion to judaism to this day but its a very long process for conversion to orthodox judaism (up to few years).
btw -writer of this long commsnt is assyriac and yemenite jew.
Let the Moroccan know that he will go back, it's obvious.
Answer: From the Levant. They got dispersed in different periods into the Diaspora, to different countries and nations for about 2,000 years, then came back. DNA analysis and genetics have proven that. But because in Jews, since some communities admixed w/ more distant populations, people think they are not ultimately indigenous tot he land.
But even if you see most if not all 'Arab' populations, they don't all look alike, and you see quite a bit of phenotipical variation, and genetic also show they ar not single origin either. Depending on their position they have different phenotypes and admixtures, as a whole, Syrias, Jordanians, Lebanese, Saudis, Egyptians, etc...you see simliarities because by now there's been more inbreeding and they became more homogeneous but still, they don't look all alike.
Having said that, unfortunately Jews get all the flack especially coz of Ashkenazim who have South European Admixture from the times of Roman Empire and Greece, so no surprised they are genetically and phenotypical the most Euro shifted, but genetics don't lie, under the skin there's proof of their Neolithic/Chalcolithic/Bronze Age Levant enthogenesis.
That's because Arab is more of a linguistical possibility cultural group today rather than an ethnic group. When the Arabs arrived in Egypt, they didn't find Arabs there and they certainly didn't find Arabs in the rest of North Africa. They didn't ethnically cleans the population and there was a degree of migration and mixing but ultimately they aren't Arabs in the way that people from Yemen or modern day Saudi are Arab.
@@colbomagazine Where are you from? What's you 'Edah'? What countries did your ancestors inhabit during The Diaspora?
@@colbomagazine Ashkenazim by and large have paternal roots in the Levant. They ashore the same Y DNA haplogroups as Sephardim and Mizrahim, simply they are a different subset of the same Late/Neolithic/Chalcolithic/Bronze Age Levantine population that around 1,500 BCE emerged as an ethic group that refers to it self as 'Israelites'. The reason why you mistakenly called the 'fakes' is simply because of their pigmentation due to admixture w/ Euro converts. But genetics don't lie. Most Ashkenazim have Y DNA haplougroups of West Asian, SW Asian , Middle Eastern origin: J1, J2, E3b-Z830/M123/M34, G-M201, T-M70. The same as Sephardim and Mizrahim. That is an indication of common Levantine origin. Abraham was from north Mesopotamia, Eastern Anatolia, Ararat region yes, but him and his south Caucasus folk intermarried w/ some of the Ancient Canaanites who were the speakers of Proto Hebrew and who were the descendants of the Natufians - the original proto Semitic inhabitants of the Levant. Fact. Meaning Jews at their origin were a mix of South Caucus/North Mesopotamians, Anatolians , Levantine Natufians and also Chalcolithic Ancient Iranians from the Zagros. The South Caucasus/North Mesopotamian neolithic 'Abrahamic' element is the one you refer as 'Kurd.' but to call it Kurd is a bit anachronistic, since ethnic Kurd as such did not exist around 2,000 BCE just yet. 2,000-1,500 BCE is the date when the 'Abrahamic' (i.e. North Mesopotamian) kin moved from he Eastern Anatolian/Ararat/North Mesopotamian region and settled in ancient Canaanite Levant. Yes, it is safe to say that the 'Abrahamic' kin and the later North Mesopotamian population that provides the basis for modern Kurd, all decent from a common group of neolithic farmers who inhabited the area encompassing Eastern Anatolia, North Mesopotamia/NW Iran.
@@colbomagazine if you want to get into the 'looks and appearance' topic, Some of the Palestinian Arabs that appear on Corey's videos can, in my humble opinion, easily pass for Jews, it makes me think the might be descendants of Israelites who were forced to convert to Islam some 1,200 years ago or who willingly converted to Christianity some 2,000 yeas ago.
@@AliShah-er7iu Correct, they were forced to adopt Arab language, culture, religion (Islam), they were originally Amazigh, Coptic Christians, Phoenicians , etc... I know many modern Lebanese who resent the 'Arab' label and seems themselves as descendants of sedentary, Levantine, Phoenicians, and rightfully so because Phoenician language, like Hebrew, are both Semitic languages, both they are quite different from Arab, another Semitic language yes, but one that is much younger, much more difficult and complex.
I am interested to know
what Israeli people think about right of return for Palestinian refugees displaced from their homeland due to war after creation of israel?
If jews can return to Germany why can't Palestinians?
Given that Israel could afford it, same as Germany can,
Which depends on the immigrant's mindset toward the state,
And the amount of people interested to do that,
It can be possible, yes.
But, just like in Germany,
Not if it suppose to cause a demographic ambush,
Or if it is a continuation of the 48 war,
as it is currently.
Jews do not feel they own Germany,
They don't want to convert it from christianity into a Jewish state,
They are neglible demographicaly,
And never had an armed effort to take Germany down.
Nor do they allow the blood of today's Germans.
Also the Germans are clearly ashamed of what they did to the Jews,
But the Jews feel the opposite: abused by the Arabs which initiated the war.
Not to mention that Germany let in complete foreigners too,
It's not like they gift Jews lands where there were Jewish vilages or something.
So why see this as a "return"?
To sum it all up, currently it isn't possible, even if the locals were wishful about it,
Which they don't, so long as there is an on going conflict,
In my opinion, that's why.
I tried not to be mean or anything,
But it is an hard topic.
I can imagine that the kind of Palestinians who left during the war,
were the more peacfull individuals who had less to do with it -
which is a shame, and also bad for the Jewish state of today.
What about you?
Are you yourself from the Palestinian diaspora?
Originally from North Africa, mainly Egypt. What I don't understand is how the zionist movement was started by European jews and when I say something against the politics and the making of the state, I get stamped as antisemitic. I, as an Egyptian, am the semit, not the ones with European descendants. And the Zionism movement is nothing but an oppressive political movement.
Religion isn't an ethnicity, your DNA and family roots are what factors to someone's ethnicity.
It's nothing but an occupation just like the German Reich, the British empire, the Ottoman empire, etc. And if someone uses the argument that they're occupying a place because their beliefs tell them they should, then they don't differ much from ISIS and the Taliban. They are also forcing their own beliefs on other people ...
"Originally from japan. Because je ws and japanese both start with a J"
Random ji hadi rambeling online
What a load of rubbish!
God bless you, Omar.
1)zionism was started by european jews because they had euqal rights in the western world,unlike us mizrahi jews who were dhimmis by law till tanzimat and dhimmis in practice till we moved to israel.
2)i agree,no need to call every anti jewish or anti israeli activity antisemitic.
you can call it anti judaism or anti jewishness. the term wasnt popularized by jews. some jewish persecution was on religious grounds only and once jews converted to other religion they were accepted in,some of it was on ethnic background like in germany where if you were mizrahi,sephardi or ashkenasi you were condemned to death regardless of your religion. some of the modern opposition to israel comes from people who are totally ignorant of the history of the region and they aint anti semitic at all,just ignorant. as a mizrahi jew living in jerusalem i have no control over the way american politicains phrase things.
3)jews were banished from across the arab world in series of attacks and pogroms since the early 20th century,including 1945 cairo and alexandria riots and 1956 banishment of jews(and assyriacs,greco egyptians,lebanese,italians and europeans)from egypt,was on cultural basis. if someone agreed to convert to islam,he was alllowed to remain.
jews were banished as a whole from the arab and muslim world,wether they were educated and secular or poor and seeply religious in some remote village,but sure it wasnt on racial grounds(mostly)...
4)arab media and many islamic scholars have used tropes by christian anti jewish clerics(religiously based hatered) against jews and even nazi imagery and conspiracy theories against world jews(racially based hatered that arabs adopt in any way possible). that includes tv shows in egyot and syria depicting jews drinking blood of christian or non jewish kids,it includes publications by the likes of sayyid qutb and amin el husseini who incited against all world jews,especially jews of the muslim world(not just against "zionists" as some islamists try to claim) and endorsement of books like "the protocols of the elders of zion" by formal govs in the arab and muslim world...so when an arabs march and say"khaybar khaybar ya yahood" or when muslim demonstrators in europe chant"oh jew,you a woman,quit hiding",i think its quite safe to say its anti jewishness(wether on ethnic or religious background),its not anti zionism like that of noam chomsky who is just an ignorant entitled american jew...
You don't need a video for this. If Abraham is really the father of Jews, Jews are from Iraq. Abraham (and his family) was (were) from Sumer/Iraq.
Only Abraham and Sarah were from ur, they moved to Canaan and Isaac, Jacob and the Israelites were born in Israel/Canaan.
Jews aren't a race, it's a religion that's why you have many racial backgrounds. Don't know why gheu instead on Palestine
Over 80% of them come from Eastern Europe…… the demographic weight of Jews was so great in Eastern Europe after the Khazars converted in the 8th Century CE that created the Land Of The Yids. It was the first time in history that Jews had a distinct secular culture. The Yiddish speaking people was the only time Jews had a secular culture that was distinct from other peoples and cultures. It drives Zios crazy
Where did you get 80% from ? Almost half of them are Mizrahi or Sephardic
Eighty percent of them were born IN ISRAEL, you can't even help yourself. Lying is your nature,
The Khazars were only a people for 300 years, the Jews were already a people for over 2500 years when the Khazars became a people. There is no proof that the Khazars Ever became Jews,
Totally agree with lady @1:29 and man @5:31
2:18 מי שרוצח מישהו בגלל דת לא נחשב לבן אדם בשבילי
Get more views by adding a history lesson that goes along with video so people know the correct answer. so add more content in 2023
Jewish people are from Ethiopia 🇪🇹
Keep up the good work. Hopefully one day the Arabs and Jews will recognize that they are one. All from the same surrounding areas
We share the same common ancestors and language. Jewish DNA is Levantine just as the Syrians, Jordanians, and Lebanese. Hopefully one day we can live in peace. We have very much in common.
Jews and arabs? So stupid jews are not an etnicity also majority of Palestinians are not arab
@@yonikatz3513 how come ? So idiot wdym by Levantine DNA anyway?
@@ziyadamir8187 I see you failed grade school. Maybe you can go back and ask for a refund
@@johnnygucci9 whatever jews are not an etnicity also Jordan is arab not Levantine
Maybe Abraham was Kurdish
Chaldean there was no Kurd in that time
nah he was kurdish. hating is bad.@@Al-Shaheedi
The only one that knew the answer 3:50 its a shame that was alot of stupid answers
The best time of the jews was in the Islamic world. Al Andalus. Safety, nice they were free to practice their religion and held high positions. In the time of Bani Abbas the same. Same in Otoman Empire. I went to Bosnia and in a small street there was a small old synago. Which stated that when Andalus had already fallen into the hands of the Christians, the Muslims from the Ottoman Empire had taken pity on them and protected them. King Mohammed V from Morocco protect them also against the Nazi France in WW2.
Would you want you and your family to be held as dhimmi slaves? Would you enjoy being treated as dhimmi? And your wife /sister etc?
Both jews and arabs have the same father,Abraham who came from Iraq, for jews Israel its the promised land by Hashem, and to muslims its "Waqf lands" so both religions reclaim the right for this land , both people deserve this land and to live peaecfully with equal rights, because both think the other religion is wrong so there won't be any solution for the dilemma 😅 unless both people accept the truth that this holy land is a god gift and to live together in peace and harmony ✡️✝️☪️
How so all Arabs are Jews ❓
@@TheHoodVoice2024 both ismael and ittzhak are brother from different mothers.. one of them is the father of jews and the other is the father of arabs who became muslims 🤗
@@ihaapexgames6710
Father of 1.6 billion Muslims?
@@ihaapexgames6710 Not Muslims, you can be a Muslim from anywhere, it is a religion, nit an ethnicity.
@@shainazion4073 meant most arabs became muslims after the expansion of relgions, and palestine population is a mixture of all people who lived on this land for over 3000 years and many are jews who converted to christianity and then to Islam , so ethnicity science is not accurate because no race pure, which doesn't make any sense 🤔
Shame
The Jews of today are decendants of Judeans/Israelites who were exiled & migrated all over the planet thousands of years ago & mixed with local populations. I'm part Ashkenazy & it said on my 23&me that Ashkenazy are genetically close to Southern Europeans & West Asian populations with limited Eastern European ancestry in their gene pool. So Ashkenazy are like half Southern European & half West Asian. It just doesn't break down the admixture on that test.
The Jews today are descended from the Jews of the past? What a novel idea. Kind of shocking how many people deny it.
*Genome-Wide Diversity in the Levant Reveals Recent Structuring by Culture*
Prof. Haber et.al. Beirut, Lebanon.
" In particular, conversion of the region's populations to Islam appears to have introduced major rearrangements in populations' relations through admixture with culturally similar but geographically remote populations, leading to genetic similarities between remarkably distant populations like Jordanians, Moroccans, and Yemenis. Conversely, other populations, like Christians and Druze, became genetically isolated in the new cultural environment.
*We reconstructed the genetic structure of the Levantines and found that a pre-Islamic expansion Levant was more genetically similar to Europeans than to Middle Easterners."*
Those tests are phony.
@@ef2718 According to their own scriptures, the Jews are descended form Abraham, who came from the city of Ur, which was then a part of Mesopotamia; Ur was located in *southern Iraq.* There were many patriotic American Jews around the time of 9/11 and the Iraq war who were calling for Iraq to be wiped off the face of the Earth. I remember this distinctly. Only later did I realize the irony...
Thus, the *essence* of the Jewish people, according to their own history, does not emanate from the Levant and never did. Their essential characteristics are derived from *Iraq,* and can be further understood in the context of their kinship with the Arabs (also explicitly declared in the Bible). The genetic structure of the Levantines you speak of, therefore, says little about the origins of the Jews and almost nothing about the parts that they themselves say are important in their holiest scriptures. At most, the Levantine gene-pool served as the substrate for the followers and descendents of Abraham. And, in a way, this was almost an uncanny foreshadowing of what the Levantinized Jews would do when they left for Ashkenaz and other parts of Europe ~1500 years later and founded their distinct pedigrees there.
Except you don't have any evidence for this
Your Questions are INTERESTING and you have GOod PoinTS ! , although It's very difficult to get your way of THInkING .