I traumatized my dad when I was 3, disappering in the mall, he had a friend in the security there so they lockdown the place. Actually look like I run of to the toys section, but when I noticed dad was not behind me I just sit there waiting for him, still because of that dad don't leave me separated from him if we are shopping together and I'm in my 20s now... 😅
@@Rea_no_Kuni Same my mum and aunt was getting their hair done I was playing up so they said if I behave we’ll go to Poundland and get toys I must have been 2 years old I walked to pound land filled a basket with toys then just sat there and waited they went mentally looking for me 😂 Had a harness after that hell I half remember having it on but god did people have some words to say to my mum and dad when me and my brother had those harnesss on
Oh for sure. I was kidnapped by my bio dad at 12 for a month, whenever my daughter (3) is out of my sight I barely contain my panic. When she was about one she was behind a curtain and I couldn’t find her and the only things keeping me from a panic attack was knowing our three dogs never would have let anyone into the house without freaking out and she could not possibly open the baby gate or the deck door and certainly never would have closed it behind herself. The next time my mother in law said she was going to take her downstairs to play but I didn’t hear her over the sounds of supper. When I couldn’t find her that time I held it together long enough to race downstairs and see if my mother in law had taken her. I don’t think I let go of her for five minutes after that. The park can be a nightmare. Since there’s so much stuff she can run behind and places she can play where she’s not in sight from where I am. I try not to hover but it’s hard to tamp down the fear that she’ll be grabbed.
I knew what he meant because if you look at his facial expression, it's more like he's puzzled, if the baby had passed away you would see more sadness, consternation and possibly anger!
As someone who’s just watched a load of criminal minds, reese did exactly what they would have done. Also, she didn’t lie to a patient, she was not obligated in any way to the woman. The priority was baby first, then the woman.
The hospital lock down really give the vive of Criminal Mind episode 7 Second where a little girl was missing inside a mall and it go on lock down due to two kids already murder inside the mall
@@elysenahar223 yup...i can already tell that her own family member hide her when the gang find her doll and find out that her uncle give her a gold necklace because 1: a happy and nice children always groom their doll base of them but the fact the doll look like a mess tell that she feel like a ugly doll 2: that necklace is way to expensif to give to a child who not even your daughter. Most parents or relative just give some less of it even it was a gift
A morally grey case for the most part, but ultimately, I do agree with Reese’s deception. The Code Pink would have forced that woman to remain hidden and the longer she stayed hidden, the sicker that baby got. Better to make psychiatric care more difficult for one patient than to lose a life that could otherwise be saved.
Yeah, except she didn't have to. They found the baby in time, and it was clear dr. charles had a plan of attack to get the child back WITHOUT making the womans treatment harder, then Reese speaks up and starts making promises and ethically problematic statements, and he can't stop her because THAT would endanger the child. Not showing a unified front would destroy any chance of trust from the Subject. He did the best he could to curb her, but she blindly persisted and continued to make promises. The reality is, this could have been done right if the Subordinate had kept her emotions out of it, or at the very least recognized that she was not the most emotionally qualified in that moment to speak and let dr charles de-escalate. Instead, her approach resulted in the same outcome, the baby was saved, but at the cost of this womans ability to trust doctors. Now treating her is going to be next to impossible, and dr. Reese may well be the difference between that woman recovering in a year or two... and NEVER recovering. That its brushed off at the end as no big deal is a horrible dis-service to the woman, who turned out to be exactly what dr charles predicted, a traumatized woman who was under a tremendous amount of stress and in need of help and care. Agree or disagree, I hope you have a great day! Peace.
@Meat Box Plays the patient is not exactly in the correct mental state to judge what's right or wrong. This is why the legal system provides a lesser sentence for those claiming psychological incapacity.
I agreed about lying but not about law is law. What she did is she had to weigh the baby's and kidnapper's health as doctor, definitely she chose the baby. She was "negotiating" to get the kidnapee. But Reese really isnt for psychiatry, she sounds so stiff and unempathetic
Her case was actually shown! It was an episode were she had a few problems and Dr. Manning did everything she could but her baby was too small to survive..
I mean, if you wanna get technical, Reese could defend herself and say she meant “protect” in a medical standpoint because that’s her profession. She doesn’t have any say in terms of the law.
Her lying to the lady wasnt a big deal. If she thought shed get in trouble she might have done something. Who cares if she lied - that woman commited a crime and stole a baby. It was Reese's duty to get the baby back safely, not to the lady who stole the baby. The only people responsible for her were security and then the police.
For anyone wondering, She delivered to a premature baby and Dr Manning tried to save him but he died shorty after delivery. She was distraught and her and her husband mourned loss of their child. If you are wondering what episode she was in, it’s Season 3 episode 9.
It does make me confused that Reese was so convinced that a woman without a conscience/a psychopath kidnapped the baby. Like yes it's possible, but statistically so unlikely. There's a reason there are profiles, they're made based on statistical likeliness of certain offenders.
@@warh1story563 yes I am serious, her baby died, you've got to give her some sympathy, she's going crazy with grief and quite obviously not in the right mind. She never meant hurt the baby, she was just hurting inside. Arresting her will do nothing, Make sure she's given the help she needs, that's what should have happened. If this were real I'd give the poor woman a hug and tell her things were going to be all right. I really think it wouldn't hurt you to show a bit of sympathy and understanding.
this case happened in Quebec many years ago. A woman dressed as a nurse kidnapped a baby in a hospital, faking to make some tests on him. The baby has been found in her apartment.
Dr.Chalse is the best .. I loved it , she said afterall I am my father's daughter... He said.. but u are also my intern .. everyone needs a mentor like Dr. Charles
dr reese had no obligation to be truthful to the woman, the main priority was the baby, which was extremely sick and in the hand of an unstable person who could end up hurting him. in my view, dr reese could say whatever she wanted and could make any promises she wanted to make as long as the got that baby away from that woman safely.
it creates a distrust of authority. Psychiatrists are also not meant to manipulate. It's unethical. She's going to be much less likely to respond to treatment from a psychiatrist if one has lied to her and, should a situation occur where she needs to be coaxed by authorities again, she will be much harder to convince. Dr Charles could probably have gotten her to give it up but Sarah was too impatient.
@@MsJubjubbird to0 impatient? bruh the baby was dying, time was of the essance. I know the mother was grieving but kidnapping another couples SICK baby, that just to far. i do agrree with psychiatrists are not meant to manipulate, but in this case i feel it was very nessasary. there has to be some kind of lying in those situations, I mean police do it all the time. in this moment Reese's priority was getting the baby back. sarah wouldnt know what that women wouldve or couldve done, The women couldve taken her own life and or the babies. Not allowing the baby to get treatment was also hurting him. every second that baby was in that womens arms it was closer to dying. I understand going through grief, but thinking that she shouldnt have been lied to bc thats unethical, i mean i think stealing a dying baby is a little more unethical dont u think?
@@emmawalker2277 the baby wasn't dying there and then. It was a sick baby but it was conscious and breathing. It certainly could have made it another few minutes while Charles negotiated with her. It is malpractice to lie to patients a doctor has to be above reproach. It also is going to make the situation way worse in terms of addressing the woman's behaviour. If Sarah wasn't disciplined for it she would think it's OK to lie to every patient to get what she wants
@@MsJubjubbird The women was not her patient, therego she had no obligation to tell the truth. In those cirmcumstances u dont have much time to think, they dont know what this women would do. Sarah obviously wouldnt do it again as the end of the clip it was her feeling guilty. she probably thought in the moment thats what she had to do to get the baby back. Yes in the grand scheme of things I do agree that wasnt the best choice but can you really blame someone in that moment for lying to someone who isnt really ur patient so that you can get the baby back? and The baby was sick and the more time the baby was spending in that womens arms they were getting sicker.
@@emmawalker2277 she is about to be committed as a patient and Sarah is a doctor on duty. Doctors have to be ethical with everyone, not just the people in their direct care. I do blame her because she knows it's poor conduct and has done a huge amount of damage. Psychiatrists and any doctors cannot expect their patients to act appropriately if they do not themselves
Im on Dr Reese's side, I mean come on this women stole someone's baby because hers died, mind you she could have accidentally hurt the baby even when she didn't mean to. if that was the only way to get the baby away from her then I am on Dr Reese's side
Dr Reese:"You will be fine, we are here to help you." Security:" Go,Go,Go! Arrest her!" Kidnapper:" Why? I gave you the baby. YOU LIED TO ME!!! YOU LIED TO ME!!!!!!!!" ME: U can't blame Dr Reese, because you cause the problem so she can't make any promises that you will be fine.
OMG! I think the kidnapper was the same woman from the ‘On Shaky Ground’ ep where she & her husband lost their premature child, tho I wonder WHERE her husband was in all this?
Couples don’t usually spend every single moment of every day together, and she was capable enough of hiding her intentions to convincingly pretend to be a nurse. She could just have told him she was going to work or somewhere else and he would have no idea this was happening. There’s no particular indication from this clip that they separated, although that’s quite possible given her mental state.
i wonder the morality of reese lying. im sure it was imperative to get the baby the treatment. but was it a form of manipulation? the woman is still a "patient" and I didn't see the baby in imminent physical harm.
I can see why she did it because a baby's life was at stake, but by breaking the woman's trust like that she's going to make psychiatric care very difficult.
I don't agree, she said she'll protect not stop the police from arresting her. she thought protect from being arrested but you kidnapped a baby there was no way they weren't going to. Reese can still protect her by going to court and testifying that she wasn't in her right mind and shouldn't go to jail.
See the parking spot for motorbike and cycle paths? There are specifically for certain two-wheeler, but you can see cars or lorries park on the designated parking spot, and people jogging on these paths. I'd agree with Dr. Charles... although you've promised, no one keeps them and would still trample over the rapport you've build, like a raging bulldozer. Do you still want to guilt over what someone else did?
She is the same women who gave birth in ER that Dr. Manning gave her false hope about her extremely preterm baby. Why has board not revoked Manning’s license yet, this is the consequence if you do medical practice unethically.
I understand that Reese had to do that for the safety of the child, but that lady will never trust a medical professional again. The morals here are so blurred, and I dont think that either are fully in the wrong. Reese saved a life, and scared a traumatised woman.
That woman was already traumatized and needed serious psychiatric help. She had to be taken into custody or she would be a risk to herself and other babies. Reese did help her. But the priority was keeping her away from children and protecting the baby.
@Mikej212 Exactly ... Taking a baby, despite her own subconscious telling her it is wrong, shows the level of desperation she is in ... ... yet, by staying in the hospital, she also wanted her to be found. Added on top that the complex mental support she needs is likely outside her medical insurance, and you have the perfect mental storm: a woman in desperate need; psychiatry and psychology, whose hands are tied behind their back, due to limitations placed by medical insurance companies; and medical insurance companies & brokers, whom effectively practice medicine with out a license, by effectively telling a doctor, or even surgeon, what procedure/s they _can't_ perform due to that not being covered, to say nothing about being able to deny important drug/prescription treatment ... I swear it is the price gouging by medical insurance companies that result in insane costs, due to what ever methods used to squeeze as much out of hospitals, and administration driving up prices, so that the hospital remains financially viable ...
Doctor: the baby never made it there. Me, an engineering student obsessed with med shows in the middle of python class: CODE PINK YALL CODE FUCKING HIPPO MILK.
Dr. Reese had a correct assessment, I think. Doesn't mean that Dr. Charles was wrong, but in the end, that woman WAS psychotic. She was too afraid of the consequences of her actions to consider the baby's health. She cared more about the baby being hers. She had a traumatic experience, she definitely acted on that, but it lead to a psychosis and that's why Dr. Reese got to her better than Dr. Charles did. Would be great if the lady got some help though...
I'm glad all turned out well at the end. The lie wasn't a issue to me but there is better ways to deal with the aftermath. Clearly emotionally and mentally she was struggling. Ask her willingly to walk with you to a ward where she could get tests related to the issues. Get her the support she needed. If she doesn't cooperate then cuff her and take her to where needed. Yes medically she wasn't helping the baby but the baby was in minimal danger at the end aside from it. We sometimes have to give to get things back.
a case of kidnap is still a case of kidnap regardless of what happens to the hostage. Moreover, the baby had pneumonia, delaying treatment would mean endangering the baby's life, although she wasn't "physically harming" the baby. She still has to face some sort of repercussions though.
The various codes have different meanings between different hospitals - the ones in the Australia are: Black - Internal/Personal threat Brown - External emergency (Natural Disaster etc) Blue - Medical Emergency Red - Fire Yellow - Internal Emergency Purple - Bomb Threat Orange - Evacuation Grey - Aggressive person, not armed
I am really against lying, I always state wishes/ hopes, hypotheticals and possibilities to patients to avoid accidentally lying. But I also respect people that can lie in an impossible situation. I likely would've been very hesitant talking at all, who knows how long it would've taken to convince her of the right thing to do. The babies needs in this case are more important than an adults trust.
Resse's deception was morally justifiable. The baby was sick and his life was in danger, his abductors life wasn't though. My compassion for her is basically zero. She carefully planned this, and she only handed him over when she felt sure she wouldn't be punished. If he died because he went without treatment for too long, no one would have compassion for her. Certainly not his mother and father.
This reminds me about a case in Argentina, the kidnap of Eliana Garelli. A woman fake her pregnancy, later enter in a hospital disgise as a nurse and kidnap a newborn to make it pass as her own. She even use the same excuse in this episode. Sadly, she comited suicide when she was caught.
The babies well being should come first in situations like that you gotta assume that the person holding the baby could be either a sociopath or a woman with trauma. Sometimes you gotta lie to save the person in most of these shows they do that to protect the person in danger and honestly the baby comes first hurting the woman's feelings shouldn't be first priority the baby should be
I've only watched this show through these videos, but everytime I see Reese, she's defensive about her father and accusing people of being psychopaths. Issues much?
The more i watch these short clips, the more i become convinced that Reese is a loose cannon who is too emotionally driven to be working in such big cases
In season 9, we all now that jay and hailey are togheter but can Erin come back? She is one of my favorite acters!! She is the best acter in Chicago pd!! Please the creaters? Season 9 or 10?
Dont steele a child here. My husband would slap that person. He has no mercy. He says dont steal a child or you will pay. He also has no compession for such people. Neither have I. Keep your hand from other persons and their children. If you cant have children go to a adoption bureau. There are a lot of children that need a good and loving home.
That baby is never going to be able to leave the house without all eyes on him, because the parents would be traumatized by that situation.
I traumatized my dad when I was 3, disappering in the mall, he had a friend in the security there so they lockdown the place.
Actually look like I run of to the toys section, but when I noticed dad was not behind me I just sit there waiting for him, still because of that dad don't leave me separated from him if we are shopping together and I'm in my 20s now... 😅
@@Rea_no_Kuni Same my mum and aunt was getting their hair done I was playing up so they said if I behave we’ll go to Poundland and get toys I must have been 2 years old
I walked to pound land filled a basket with toys then just sat there and waited they went mentally looking for me 😂
Had a harness after that hell I half remember having it on but god did people have some words to say to my mum and dad when me and my brother had those harnesss on
Oh for sure. I was kidnapped by my bio dad at 12 for a month, whenever my daughter (3) is out of my sight I barely contain my panic.
When she was about one she was behind a curtain and I couldn’t find her and the only things keeping me from a panic attack was knowing our three dogs never would have let anyone into the house without freaking out and she could not possibly open the baby gate or the deck door and certainly never would have closed it behind herself.
The next time my mother in law said she was going to take her downstairs to play but I didn’t hear her over the sounds of supper. When I couldn’t find her that time I held it together long enough to race downstairs and see if my mother in law had taken her. I don’t think I let go of her for five minutes after that.
The park can be a nightmare. Since there’s so much stuff she can run behind and places she can play where she’s not in sight from where I am. I try not to hover but it’s hard to tamp down the fear that she’ll be grabbed.
@@abysswalker2594 lol u saying poundland ik u from uk
@@naomiakande5731 i bet she is. Im pretty sure only we have a pound land
When Halstead said he didn’t make it there, I thought he was saying the baby died.
Same
I knew what he meant because if you look at his facial expression, it's more like he's puzzled, if the baby had passed away you would see more sadness, consternation and possibly anger!
Same
@@jordanabeaulieu2530 of course you could understand, but everything happened quick so I bet you wouldn’t get that so quick! (: but great explanation
@pandapigs ME to
As someone who’s just watched a load of criminal minds, reese did exactly what they would have done. Also, she didn’t lie to a patient, she was not obligated in any way to the woman. The priority was baby first, then the woman.
I also thought of Criminal Minds.
The hospital lock down really give the vive of Criminal Mind episode 7 Second where a little girl was missing inside a mall and it go on lock down due to two kids already murder inside the mall
Same
@@syabilaazri7834 oh yeah i remember that one, was it the one where it ended up being the aunt and uncle??
@@elysenahar223 yup...i can already tell that her own family member hide her when the gang find her doll and find out that her uncle give her a gold necklace because
1: a happy and nice children always groom their doll base of them but the fact the doll look like a mess tell that she feel like a ugly doll
2: that necklace is way to expensif to give to a child who not even your daughter. Most parents or relative just give some less of it even it was a gift
i could have sworne Reese was Charles' daughter their relationship is beautiful
Ya same😁
I thought the same, the only thing that threw me off was the surname
Unfortunately their relationship has fractured permanently and Reese has left the show.
Didn’t we all? 😂
Way did lied to her
Dr reese : I am my fathers daughter
Dr Charles : you’re also my resident
What I heard : you are actually my child
This comment would be fine if it wasn’t for the emoji
Controversial opinion but I don’t think they’re related
@@rainandhail67 that doesn't mean he can't be a father figure
A morally grey case for the most part, but ultimately, I do agree with Reese’s deception. The Code Pink would have forced that woman to remain hidden and the longer she stayed hidden, the sicker that baby got. Better to make psychiatric care more difficult for one patient than to lose a life that could otherwise be saved.
Yeah, except she didn't have to. They found the baby in time, and it was clear dr. charles had a plan of attack to get the child back WITHOUT making the womans treatment harder, then Reese speaks up and starts making promises and ethically problematic statements, and he can't stop her because THAT would endanger the child. Not showing a unified front would destroy any chance of trust from the Subject. He did the best he could to curb her, but she blindly persisted and continued to make promises.
The reality is, this could have been done right if the Subordinate had kept her emotions out of it, or at the very least recognized that she was not the most emotionally qualified in that moment to speak and let dr charles de-escalate. Instead, her approach resulted in the same outcome, the baby was saved, but at the cost of this womans ability to trust doctors. Now treating her is going to be next to impossible, and dr. Reese may well be the difference between that woman recovering in a year or two... and NEVER recovering. That its brushed off at the end as no big deal is a horrible dis-service to the woman, who turned out to be exactly what dr charles predicted, a traumatized woman who was under a tremendous amount of stress and in need of help and care.
Agree or disagree, I hope you have a great day! Peace.
@Meat Box Plays if everything was white and black, justice would be easily achievable
@Meat Box Plays the patient is not exactly in the correct mental state to judge what's right or wrong. This is why the legal system provides a lesser sentence for those claiming psychological incapacity.
@Meat Box Plays yes it is but every person has a right to be treated as one!
Yeah but imagine she’d have left the hospital with the baby, which would’ve been substantially worse,
Ok but can we acknowledge how cute that baby was in the first scene with the X-ray like,🥹🥹🥹🥹
I would have lied by omission too.
Nothing bad happened to the kidnapper from a medical point of view. Can’t help that the law is the law.
Yep the law is the law. Totally agree👍
And she is a medical profession her statement cant be used she was not a cop doing barter
The law isn't wrong. It's bullshit
@Bobo The Monkey how? The baby isn't hers. She was sick and desperate but she endangered the baby's life.
I agreed about lying but not about law is law. What she did is she had to weigh the baby's and kidnapper's health as doctor, definitely she chose the baby. She was "negotiating" to get the kidnapee. But Reese really isnt for psychiatry, she sounds so stiff and unempathetic
Her case was actually shown! It was an episode were she had a few problems and Dr. Manning did everything she could but her baby was too small to survive..
Wait yeah i remember that
i thought that was the episode! i knew i recognised her from somewhere and my mind went to that episode, but i never confirmed it for myself.
No way it's the same woman!!
How the hell did I not know remember that?!
Nah sis you did right, i would have lied my heart out as long as i could that baby out of harm way
I mean, if you wanna get technical, Reese could defend herself and say she meant “protect” in a medical standpoint because that’s her profession. She doesn’t have any say in terms of the law.
Along the same lines, the hospital would not have punished her. As well as the security we’re concerned for the baby.
Her lying to the lady wasnt a big deal. If she thought shed get in trouble she might have done something. Who cares if she lied - that woman commited a crime and stole a baby. It was Reese's duty to get the baby back safely, not to the lady who stole the baby. The only people responsible for her were security and then the police.
She the same lady that had a child too early
Doctor Charles is always calm no matter the circumstances
For anyone wondering,
She delivered to a premature baby and Dr Manning tried to save him but he died shorty after delivery. She was distraught and her and her husband mourned loss of their child. If you are wondering what episode she was in, it’s Season 3 episode 9.
It does make me confused that Reese was so convinced that a woman without a conscience/a psychopath kidnapped the baby. Like yes it's possible, but statistically so unlikely. There's a reason there are profiles, they're made based on statistical likeliness of certain offenders.
it was because at the time reese found out her dad was psychopathic so she had a bit of a bias
Who knows? Unlikely doesn't mean not happening.
Well done Reese. Lie whatever to get the baby from the kidnapper. Yes kidnapper ins not in her right mind. But stealing a baby! No free pass.
How are you doing today!?
Well done Dr. Reese👍🤗
She shouldn't have lied, it's clear the lady was not in the right mind, she is filled with grief. She needs help not arrested.
@@amburrelizabeth1572 kidnapping a baby?? Seriously??
@@warh1story563 yes I am serious, her baby died, you've got to give her some sympathy, she's going crazy with grief and quite obviously not in the right mind. She never meant hurt the baby, she was just hurting inside. Arresting her will do nothing, Make sure she's given the help she needs, that's what should have happened. If this were real I'd give the poor woman a hug and tell her things were going to be all right. I really think it wouldn't hurt you to show a bit of sympathy and understanding.
I feel so bad for the woman, I saw the previous episode and her baby died because it was developed and it made me so sad this is a moring mother's
I knew I saw her before.
i think it’s underdeveloped and instead of moring it’s mourning x
@@mialoubou yes sorry I have dyslexia
@@x_rinaruy_x3464 it’s absolutely fine! just pointing it out
was the the one who had the real small baby in the incubator?
this case happened in Quebec many years ago. A woman dressed as a nurse kidnapped a baby in a hospital, faking to make some tests on him. The baby has been found in her apartment.
Did the baby live?
Dr.Chalse is the best .. I loved it , she said afterall I am my father's daughter... He said.. but u are also my intern .. everyone needs a mentor like Dr. Charles
dr reese had no obligation to be truthful to the woman, the main priority was the baby, which was extremely sick and in the hand of an unstable person who could end up hurting him. in my view, dr reese could say whatever she wanted and could make any promises she wanted to make as long as the got that baby away from that woman safely.
it creates a distrust of authority. Psychiatrists are also not meant to manipulate. It's unethical. She's going to be much less likely to respond to treatment from a psychiatrist if one has lied to her and, should a situation occur where she needs to be coaxed by authorities again, she will be much harder to convince. Dr Charles could probably have gotten her to give it up but Sarah was too impatient.
@@MsJubjubbird to0 impatient? bruh the baby was dying, time was of the essance. I know the mother was grieving but kidnapping another couples SICK baby, that just to far. i do agrree with psychiatrists are not meant to manipulate, but in this case i feel it was very nessasary. there has to be some kind of lying in those situations, I mean police do it all the time. in this moment Reese's priority was getting the baby back. sarah wouldnt know what that women wouldve or couldve done, The women couldve taken her own life and or the babies. Not allowing the baby to get treatment was also hurting him. every second that baby was in that womens arms it was closer to dying. I understand going through grief, but thinking that she shouldnt have been lied to bc thats unethical, i mean i think stealing a dying baby is a little more unethical dont u think?
@@emmawalker2277 the baby wasn't dying there and then. It was a sick baby but it was conscious and breathing. It certainly could have made it another few minutes while Charles negotiated with her. It is malpractice to lie to patients a doctor has to be above reproach. It also is going to make the situation way worse in terms of addressing the woman's behaviour. If Sarah wasn't disciplined for it she would think it's OK to lie to every patient to get what she wants
@@MsJubjubbird The women was not her patient, therego she had no obligation to tell the truth. In those cirmcumstances u dont have much time to think, they dont know what this women would do. Sarah obviously wouldnt do it again as the end of the clip it was her feeling guilty. she probably thought in the moment thats what she had to do to get the baby back. Yes in the grand scheme of things I do agree that wasnt the best choice but can you really blame someone in that moment for lying to someone who isnt really ur patient so that you can get the baby back? and The baby was sick and the more time the baby was spending in that womens arms they were getting sicker.
@@emmawalker2277 she is about to be committed as a patient and Sarah is a doctor on duty. Doctors have to be ethical with everyone, not just the people in their direct care. I do blame her because she knows it's poor conduct and has done a huge amount of damage. Psychiatrists and any doctors cannot expect their patients to act appropriately if they do not themselves
I wish this was on Netflix!
me too '^'
it’s on prime video
just get Sky
Same
@@rhapsodyes4609 not all the seasons
what Dr. Charles said to reese is right... she's not a psychopath, since she's aware of all she's going thru
'' Hey I just met you
And this is crazy!
But give me the kid
I won't eat the baby''
So funny 😑
@@kajusjacky575 u think I'm kidding?
Extremely funny😂😂😂😂
@@laspeedyboi3388there are old stories that feature mothers being framed for eating their own babies
1:06 I thought dr Halstead meant the baby passed away at first.
7:31 that stare🙀
Ya exactly. I thought the same thing👍
"When Kidnapping A Baby Was Her Last Resort" - this is about the last show I would expect to reprise Raising Arizona.
Medical shows
Lol love how dr Charles just keep looking at Reese every time she said her opingin
She had to lie! That woman does need some serious help though and I am sympathetic. But she also kidnapped, so.
she gave him DABABY LETS GOOO
Im on Dr Reese's side, I mean come on this women stole someone's baby because hers died, mind you she could have accidentally hurt the baby even when she didn't mean to. if that was the only way to get the baby away from her then I am on Dr Reese's side
Dr Reese:"You will be fine, we are here to help you."
Security:" Go,Go,Go! Arrest her!"
Kidnapper:" Why? I gave you the baby. YOU LIED TO ME!!! YOU LIED TO ME!!!!!!!!"
ME: U can't blame Dr Reese, because you cause the problem so she can't make any promises that you will be fine.
OMG! I think the kidnapper was the same woman from the ‘On Shaky Ground’ ep where she & her husband lost their premature child, tho I wonder WHERE her husband was in all this?
It is the same woman. Maybe they separated after losing their son?
Couples don’t usually spend every single moment of every day together, and she was capable enough of hiding her intentions to convincingly pretend to be a nurse. She could just have told him she was going to work or somewhere else and he would have no idea this was happening. There’s no particular indication from this clip that they separated, although that’s quite possible given her mental state.
Joanna: You lied to me
Too bad, so sad, lady! You're a kidnapper!
DOC DON'T FEEL GUILTY YOU'RE ONLY A HUMAN TOO YOU KNOW OMG TOUCHING BASE RESPECT TO ALL
i wonder the morality of reese lying. im sure it was imperative to get the baby the treatment. but was it a form of manipulation? the woman is still a "patient" and I didn't see the baby in imminent physical harm.
I can see why she did it because a baby's life was at stake, but by breaking the woman's trust like that she's going to make psychiatric care very difficult.
I don't agree, she said she'll protect not stop the police from arresting her. she thought protect from being arrested but you kidnapped a baby there was no way they weren't going to. Reese can still protect her by going to court and testifying that she wasn't in her right mind and shouldn't go to jail.
See the parking spot for motorbike and cycle paths? There are specifically for certain two-wheeler, but you can see cars or lorries park on the designated parking spot, and people jogging on these paths.
I'd agree with Dr. Charles... although you've promised, no one keeps them and would still trample over the rapport you've build, like a raging bulldozer.
Do you still want to guilt over what someone else did?
So what did you expect her to do? Leave the infant in the arms of an unbalanced woman?
@@jordanabeaulieu2530 She could've found another way tbh but i'm not going to judge her for choosing to do that. The baby's life was the priority.
I love dr. Reese's poker face
The funny thing is that 5 different people said they were first....
She is the same women who gave birth in ER that Dr. Manning gave her false hope about her extremely preterm baby. Why has board not revoked Manning’s license yet, this is the consequence if you do medical practice unethically.
His giving her false hope forced her to kidnap someone else's baby?! Do you hear what you're saying?
I understand that Reese had to do that for the safety of the child, but that lady will never trust a medical professional again. The morals here are so blurred, and I dont think that either are fully in the wrong. Reese saved a life, and scared a traumatised woman.
Her priority was saving the baby, she had no obligation to be truthful to the woman.
That woman was already traumatized and needed serious psychiatric help. She had to be taken into custody or she would be a risk to herself and other babies. Reese did help her. But the priority was keeping her away from children and protecting the baby.
@Mikej212
Exactly ...
Taking a baby, despite her own subconscious telling her it is wrong, shows the level of desperation she is in ...
... yet, by staying in the hospital, she also wanted her to be found. Added on top that the complex mental support she needs is likely outside her medical insurance, and you have the perfect mental storm: a woman in desperate need; psychiatry and psychology, whose hands are tied behind their back, due to limitations placed by medical insurance companies; and medical insurance companies & brokers, whom effectively practice medicine with out a license, by effectively telling a doctor, or even surgeon, what procedure/s they _can't_ perform due to that not being covered, to say nothing about being able to deny important drug/prescription treatment ...
I swear it is the price gouging by medical insurance companies that result in insane costs, due to what ever methods used to squeeze as much out of hospitals, and administration driving up prices, so that the hospital remains financially viable ...
That's her problem Dr.Reese did the right thing.
the safety of the baby mattered more
I love watching Chicago med ❤️❤️
Lovre your upload always❤️❤️❤️
I have 4 kids, and in The hospital when I delivered I asked that The baby was always by my side. So afraid of this
Doctor: the baby never made it there.
Me, an engineering student obsessed with med shows in the middle of python class: CODE PINK YALL CODE FUCKING HIPPO MILK.
Dr. Reese had a correct assessment, I think. Doesn't mean that Dr. Charles was wrong, but in the end, that woman WAS psychotic. She was too afraid of the consequences of her actions to consider the baby's health. She cared more about the baby being hers. She had a traumatic experience, she definitely acted on that, but it lead to a psychosis and that's why Dr. Reese got to her better than Dr. Charles did. Would be great if the lady got some help though...
I'm glad all turned out well at the end.
The lie wasn't a issue to me but there is better ways to deal with the aftermath.
Clearly emotionally and mentally she was struggling. Ask her willingly to walk with you to a ward where she could get tests related to the issues. Get her the support she needed.
If she doesn't cooperate then cuff her and take her to where needed.
Yes medically she wasn't helping the baby but the baby was in minimal danger at the end aside from it.
We sometimes have to give to get things back.
a case of kidnap is still a case of kidnap regardless of what happens to the hostage. Moreover, the baby had pneumonia, delaying treatment would mean endangering the baby's life, although she wasn't "physically harming" the baby. She still has to face some sort of repercussions though.
La cara y la voz al mentir fueron espeluznantes. Gran actriz. Y el personaje de la residente.....demasiado perverso. Hay medicos asi.
Good 👍🏻 I’m really glad 😃 was telling him that you moved out
Give it up for today!
The first code (that I've realised) that wasn't blue!
The various codes have different meanings between different hospitals - the ones in the Australia are:
Black - Internal/Personal threat
Brown - External emergency (Natural Disaster etc)
Blue - Medical Emergency
Red - Fire
Yellow - Internal Emergency
Purple - Bomb Threat
Orange - Evacuation
Grey - Aggressive person, not armed
I am really against lying, I always state wishes/ hopes, hypotheticals and possibilities to patients to avoid accidentally lying. But I also respect people that can lie in an impossible situation.
I likely would've been very hesitant talking at all, who knows how long it would've taken to convince her of the right thing to do.
The babies needs in this case are more important than an adults trust.
Resse's deception was morally justifiable. The baby was sick and his life was in danger, his abductors life wasn't though. My compassion for her is basically zero. She carefully planned this, and she only handed him over when she felt sure she wouldn't be punished. If he died because he went without treatment for too long, no one would have compassion for her. Certainly not his mother and father.
Reese: "I am my father's daughter."
Charles: "No, actually you're mine now."
Reese: "What?"
Charles: "Finders keepers."
This reminds me about a case in Argentina, the kidnap of Eliana Garelli. A woman fake her pregnancy, later enter in a hospital disgise as a nurse and kidnap a newborn to make it pass as her own. She even use the same excuse in this episode. Sadly, she comited suicide when she was caught.
Good riddance.
That's awful.
Reese did the right thing. baby comes first
WAIT is that the mom from the episode where Dr. Manning and Dr. Halstead tried to keep the super premature baby alive?
This is my first and faviroute video out of all of them
Oh my gosh awwww🥺
Bruh kid alert
The babies well being should come first in situations like that you gotta assume that the person holding the baby could be either a sociopath or a woman with trauma. Sometimes you gotta lie to save the person in most of these shows they do that to protect the person in danger and honestly the baby comes first hurting the woman's feelings shouldn't be first priority the baby should be
I want Reese back so bad😂😂😂
Put this on Netflix pleasssss
Love. One Chicago ❤️💖❤️💖💖❤️
those wheezing from these little lungs drive me crazy, poor baby
I've only watched this show through these videos, but everytime I see Reese, she's defensive about her father and accusing people of being psychopaths. Issues much?
Crazy this stuff happens
Guys watch out she is mother miranda!!!
Love you guys
Cool bring back Reese
That's what I'm saying let her be with Dr charles
do people just like forget that Adoption and fostering is an OPTION
Adoption and fostering isn't as simple as people make it out to be. It is a very long process and is expensive.
Cutest initial 2 seconds of anything ever omg
Awe poor baby xx
"I mean I have no real friends
No significant romantic attachment
I think I have an emotions
But maybe they aren't real"
That baby is so cute 🥰
The more i watch these short clips, the more i become convinced that Reese is a loose cannon who is too emotionally driven to be working in such big cases
I can't stop looking at her hair😍
Dr Reese seems to be a person who just never got a hug from anyone. Dr Charles could've hug her.
Bro I wish chicago fire and chicago med was on netflix so bad
wouldn;t there be other doctors taking him to the place ad they wldnt of recognised or made sore that it was a real test and doctor????
7:32 You still did kidnapped a baby tho
Wowwwwww i love the story good job
Oh this is the woman who was delivered her baby with the help from Dr Manning and Dr Hasltead
If Dr. Manning only complied with DNR and didn’t give that woman any signs of hope, there is a chance that she didnt turn like that.
I watch this because the main characters are on point in their acting but the patients... Not so much hahaha
It's always the case on long running series, the main characters are more seasoned actors, the extras are usually far less experienced.
yaass u go girl
Yes!
Wow I just watch Trust me( episode highlight) video posted 3 years ago and this come posted 45 minutes ago
She negotiated not lied
That's the same way a criminal mind will think
any person / woman who would steal someone else's baby deserves the worst
edit: reese did the right thing
Fav show
I never liked Reece but I never knew why still don’t there’s just something about her
Hi Sierra
Dr Charles giving some side eye in this one lol
6:39 👀 🤨
6:51 ☝️🤓
7:07 👁👄👁
I would have flat out told Joanna "He's gonna die of pneumonia if you don't hand him over."
7:32 flash back to detriot become human 1st mission
Rachel Dipillo should have a Golden Globe
This one is sad
Kids when they are doing X-ray they put them in a tube right?
In season 9, we all now that jay and hailey are togheter but can Erin come back? She is one of my favorite acters!! She is the best acter in Chicago pd!! Please the creaters? Season 9 or 10?
Double duty baby...I just came from the episode with the "too calm" mom.
Was the kidnapper the mother of the baby that was still in a sac that dr manning and halstead cut into?
Yea
If this woman was willing to steal a baby to replace what she lost, then why did she not adopt and orphan?
why didn't she just adopt a baby , why steal somebody's else baby?
Dont steele a child here. My husband would slap that person. He has no mercy. He says dont steal a child or you will pay. He also has no compession for such people. Neither have I. Keep your hand from other persons and their children. If you cant have children go to a adoption bureau. There are a lot of children that need a good and loving home.
Edge lord