To be fair, it's not really the cameramen's fault... for one, you really have to give the faults to the editing team. I may be wrong on this one though.
The cameraman probably did great but the editor had Parkinson’s, ADD and an alcohol-tremor since 32 years and getting worse. Vengerov did great though 😂
Playing: Absolute perfection Camera work: Way too close at times, out of focus and jumping from one frame to the next. Maxim Vengerov's performances deserve much better camera work.
This is a far less pyrotechnic performance, but Vengerov's technique is as fine as it ever was and this performance is simply more mature than the legendary one from 20 years ago. I think I like it.
Don't get me wrong, he is an amazing musician far ahead of myself. That being said, I noticed that this version is somewhat slower and has some small mistakes like accidently hitting a string. Still amazing but just is different
lol the editor went nuts, especially toward the end of the piece! XD Guess he was taken away, like all of us, by the maestro's exquisite performance! ;)
Y'all talking about the cameraman... I'm just sitting here in bliss, listening to this fantastically hard piece, played with perfection by the most wonderful soloist. I hope to one day be able to play this piece a quarter as well as him.
Wow! amazing, just beautifully played. in another version. how he feels the music is amazing - strong, but with a sort of Russian passion. i don’t know if he’s Russian or not, but it’s there. amazing phrasing - just beautifully played. my god one composition with four interpretations. holy cow! 🌷✨
@@feralbluee lol i was about to say "hmmmm, is 'vengerov' russian? let's see....." well, i probably would've actually ended up saying it nicer than that, but still that was my first thought lol. glad to see you caught it yourself though
This very piece among great others I find it very special in many aspects,,It is vey underrated,, for me it is the best solo violin piece ever written.
Wow good catch. Only Vengerov can miss a note and play that note at the same moment in time haha. You can literally see his finger miss the fingerboard then go back on ... and the melody still flows beautifully!
Splendid performance with disgusting video editing especially around 05:46 . Couldn't have been edited worse. it should be calm and smooth. it made me dizzy, not an action movie.
Ayşe Önder - Ümit Önder you mustn’t see it that way. “Even the videographers was in the spirit of the piece!” Because without the video, you wouldn’t be able to see anything, without the mic, you wouldn’t be able to hear anything. Everyone has their part to play.
@@FrenHorn14 Terrible argument. Just because there is a video does not mean the low quality camera work is acceptable for such an exceptional performance. Just like because movies exist does not mean there are excuse to produce bad movies. Undermining the work of a great artist with bad camera work is nothing short of an insult to the artist himself.
Calm and smooth? I can't find any other less accurate adjectives for that part. I would suggest, hectic, electric, epic, atrong and fast paced. The video editing depicts that specially.
@@germangarciamartinez4097 @Germán García Martínez Mr. Vengerov depicts himself so incredibly on the stage that nobody needs any other "hectic, Electric, atrong???, epic, and fast-paced" tryings.
I have never seen such irritating camera editing in my life. You'd swear they were shooting a multi-cam assassination scene. This is how you do NOT pay attention to the music, and it's not Vengerov's fault.
Shame about the cameraman. Why??? It's not a fiction movie.. no need for chaotic and illogical camera moves and angles. The performance is incredible . Technique, phrasing are sublime.
AMAZING videography! Even they were in the spirit of the musical piece. 😀😃😃👍🏽👍🏽👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽 That was wonderful video work! It shows not only the violist is important, because without the video, you wouldn’t be able to see, without the mic, you wouldn’t be able to hear. Everyone was contributing their gift to the wonderful performance of this great master player! “THE VIDEOGRAPHERS WAS IN THE SPIRIT OF THE PERFORMER, THE PERFORMER WAS IN THE SPIRIT OF THE COMPOSER” 👌🏾😇
Great performance!!Actually I used to prefer Repin's performance than his specially when they're in young age by 20s, but now prefer to listen to Vengerov(depends on piece but mostly) rather than Repin, and I'm definitely sure that he is the best in the world.
By far from his best, maybe he had a bad day, excellent tecnique as usual and musicianship but I notice that he was out of himself... I follow him very closely and this is not his real or best version.
Camera movement and zooms are completely unnecessary add on (and dilution/ distraction / mutation) to music like this, when the performer is telling the entire story himself
@@konstantinSE не обладаю такими широкими познаниями, но по мне, так Третьяков и Венгеров совершенно похожи, остальные звучат слишком академично, и только Ойстрах оказался между этими крайностями.
IM CRYING WHO EDITED THIS VIDEO AT 5:40 AND SAID IT GOOD 💀💀💀💀
🤩
When you lie on your resume but still get the job as the cameraman.
To be fair, it's not really the cameramen's fault... for one, you really have to give the faults to the editing team. I may be wrong on this one though.
@@rarufu2368 i see
The cameraman probably did great but the editor had Parkinson’s, ADD and an alcohol-tremor since 32 years and getting worse.
Vengerov did great though 😂
Hahahaha exactly right, my God. Such great playing! Such a shame when incompetent people think they also have to be artistic…. Instead of profesional!
Playing: Absolute perfection
Camera work: Way too close at times, out of focus and jumping from one frame to the next.
Maxim Vengerov's performances deserve much better camera work.
I found it really nice to be able to see his hands from that close, really enjoyed it
He was totally out of tune. This was not good at all. I hope he just had a bad day 😭
Happy Bee you must be a violist. He played amazingly.
@@brunorecalde7048 a giant I'll avt
why are we moving so fast 😭😭😭
One of the great Violonists in our days;;;;;;;;;;;;;;; GREAT VENGEROV !!!! Hope to hear you one day live !
I have and it was an amazing experience...a lovely memory to have......
For me generally the greatest violinist
Loved the master class with Brett. It's why I found this to listen. Bravo!
This is very different from his older performances of this piece. Interesting to see how an artist evolves!
comparing the iconic recording when he was younger, you can hear that he is older and more mature now.
most satisfying part is around 5:24. you can just hear that D ring in the hall and then the colour just changes
*Perfect pitch gang*
Just wow
Bravo. What a unique performance 🤎
This is a far less pyrotechnic performance, but Vengerov's technique is as fine as it ever was and this performance is simply more mature than the legendary one from 20 years ago. I think I like it.
Don't get me wrong, he is an amazing musician far ahead of myself.
That being said, I noticed that this version is somewhat slower and has some small mistakes like accidently hitting a string. Still amazing but just is different
@@AlexGrom The original performance wasn't perfect either; the tempo just covered for him more!
Such a privilege it is to be able to behold it without having to practice for 20 years
lol the editor went nuts, especially toward the end of the piece! XD Guess he was taken away, like all of us, by the maestro's exquisite performance! ;)
5:40 WHO told you that changing frames like that during the epic finale would be a good idea?
lol, it is quite funny and had me burst out laughing😂
there is something schizophrenic in this music (not performed)
It’s funny, makes vengerov look like he’s in a cowboy gun duel lol
HATING the camera...
The camera man's aim was to make a show out of Maxim's perfomace. Incredibly awful.
Maxim himself was JUST trying to make a show out the piece. Incredibly awful.
Sergio Marrini Thanks God, Sergio Marrini is not Maxim Vengerov;)
JUST stop talking bullshit.
It IS a showpiece...
I want the full video of this festival.
I can't decide what instrument I like best, it is all beautiful. I love classical music. Great.
Absolutely amazing...
Brasileiro?
Claro que é brasileiro, já pensou um americano com esse nome 🤣🤣🤣
Irreal . Demasiado increíble ! Gracias Dios por este tremendo prodigio.
Супер!!! 👍👍👍
Я удивляюсь откуда у маленькой, лиричной скрипки СТОЛЬКО страсти и мощи!!!
Спасибо 🙏🙏🙏
Y'all talking about the cameraman... I'm just sitting here in bliss, listening to this fantastically hard piece, played with perfection by the most wonderful soloist. I hope to one day be able to play this piece a quarter as well as him.
“Bro and as he’s playing vigorously at the end, we’ll use the footage from all our 7 cameras and then spam it all over the screen”
I am completely awe-stricken, stupefied and dumbfounded. I would say he is THE finest in our time in playing this piece and many other.
Gyles Meng not really, he did many mistakes here.. slipped notes etc... you need to watch Augustin Haedlich version much better...
goo that he is back been a fan since i was 9 :)
Editors/ director having too much fun.. just one shot straight on is all we need.
Camera operator: How many angles do you want?
Editor: Yes.
Bravissimo. Grazie ❤
I'm crying, omg
It's impossible to stay cool l when it's Vengerov-Ysaye on the scene.
He did some mistakes,,, you need to watch Augustin Haedlich version,, much better, more dynamics and better accuracy
@@xichang5092 he played it too soft and slow . Even he made no mistake but i still perfer this version.
Wow! amazing, just beautifully played. in another version. how he feels the music is amazing - strong, but with a sort of Russian passion. i don’t know if he’s Russian or not, but it’s there. amazing phrasing - just beautifully played. my god one composition with four interpretations. holy cow! 🌷✨
Maxim Vengerov - yes, i guess you could say he’s Russian. :) 🥀
@@feralbluee lol i was about to say
"hmmmm, is 'vengerov' russian? let's see....."
well, i probably would've actually ended up saying it nicer than that, but still that was my first thought lol. glad to see you caught it yourself though
I wonder if Ysaÿe would’ve liked Vengerov’s interpretation of this piece. 🤔
Yes.
My name
This very piece among great others I find it very special in many aspects,,It is vey underrated,, for me it is the best solo violin piece ever written.
seif bashandy He did some mistakes,,, you need to watch Augustin Haedlich version,, much better, more dynamics and better accuracy
Watch his Masterclass for Brett Yang and you will understand what it means to him, how he portrays the feelings of this masterpiece over the violin.
The modern day master of the violin
Wow there was a slip at 4:11 but he covered up super smoothly. Now I believe he is human.
He did it on purpose so you will think he is a human being aswell. He is not.
Wow good catch. Only Vengerov can miss a note and play that note at the same moment in time haha. You can literally see his finger miss the fingerboard then go back on ... and the melody still flows beautifully!
@@liamnevilleviolist1809 Definitely agreed.
😂😂😂
Bravoooooooooo!!!!!!!! Fantastique!!!!!!!!! ❤❤❤
こうたん He did some mistakes,,, you need to watch Augustin Haedlich version,, much better, more dynamics and better accuracy
@@xichang5092 it depends....augustins's interpretation is more sober and vengerov's is more powerfull.
since music is subjective you can't say that
Splendid performance with disgusting video editing especially around 05:46 . Couldn't have been edited worse. it should be calm and smooth. it made me dizzy, not an action movie.
Ayşe Önder - Ümit Önder you mustn’t see it that way.
“Even the videographers was in the spirit of the piece!” Because without the video, you wouldn’t be able to see anything, without the mic, you wouldn’t be able to hear anything. Everyone has their part to play.
@@FrenHorn14 Terrible argument. Just because there is a video does not mean the low quality camera work is acceptable for such an exceptional performance. Just like because movies exist does not mean there are excuse to produce bad movies. Undermining the work of a great artist with bad camera work is nothing short of an insult to the artist himself.
Calm and smooth?
I can't find any other less accurate adjectives for that part.
I would suggest, hectic, electric, epic, atrong and fast paced.
The video editing depicts that specially.
@@germangarciamartinez4097 @Germán García Martínez Mr. Vengerov depicts himself so incredibly on the stage that nobody needs any other "hectic, Electric, atrong???, epic, and fast-paced" tryings.
It's hilarious but fits very well
estou maravilhado com tamanha performance
One if the most difficult unaccompanied works for the violin virtuoso! Oh to play like that!!
Восторг!!!
Feels like im watching John Wick with that camera work bruh
How can someone dislike this?
Bc of the camera angles LOL
They are jealous they can't play like him
By clicking the dislike button
camera
I have never seen such irritating camera editing in my life. You'd swear they were shooting a multi-cam assassination scene. This is how you do NOT pay attention to the music, and it's not Vengerov's fault.
god bless you
Shame about the cameraman. Why??? It's not a fiction movie.. no need for chaotic and illogical camera moves and angles.
The performance is incredible . Technique, phrasing are sublime.
I love you Vibrato so much!!!! Love you Vengerov
Que fenomeno este tipo....
God bless you!
Amo esta pieza y más con Maxim me gusta igual donde toca sibelius y está de ancord
The best ever
Was this the Michael Bay cut?
Ohh, it is same cameraman and editor.
Excelente
AMAZING videography! Even they were in the spirit of the musical piece. 😀😃😃👍🏽👍🏽👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽
That was wonderful video work! It shows not only the violist is important, because without the video, you wouldn’t be able to see, without the mic, you wouldn’t be able to hear. Everyone was contributing their gift to the wonderful performance of this great master player!
“THE VIDEOGRAPHERS WAS IN THE SPIRIT OF THE PERFORMER, THE PERFORMER WAS IN THE SPIRIT OF THE COMPOSER” 👌🏾😇
Великий!
The edit just had me stroke
他本人另外一个版本的演奏(6分08秒)更好，是他更年轻时的巅峰之作，只可惜在youtube上不能下载。
推墙alex贵在 ruclips.net/video/Bg1NUBLK1tk/видео.html is this you are referring to? I think so too.
you can tell he was mad
same audience who cheered too early
Too spooky I like his earlier version. hahah
La cosa più rock che ho mai sentito.
beauty
When I grow up, I'd like to be able just to play one note of this piece like he does. That would make me happy.
The images are quite distracting from the musical quality. Give it a listen while closing your eyes, and you wouldn't believe your eyes.
wait what?
maestro¡¡¡¡
☆☆☆☆☆
集中力が高い
Hate the camera work but the playing is out of this world
Maximus finally came back.
TwoSet- “AMAZING!” 😂
💚👍🤗
Great performance!!Actually I used to prefer Repin's performance than his specially when they're in young age by 20s, but now prefer to listen to Vengerov(depends on piece but mostly) rather than Repin, and I'm definitely sure that he is the best in the world.
Gi Jung you need to watch Augustin Haedlich version,, much better, more dynamics and better accuracy
♥♥♥
Please cameraman might it not be to allow the movement to the composer and interepreter ?
What can i say
4:10 the proof he is also a human
Yeah, he made a mistake.
Editing was as good or better than the piece!
A VERY POOR CHOICE OF CAMERAMAN FOR ALL THE RECORDINGS OF THIS EVENING WITH VENGEROV
I don't think the heel of his bow has enough rosin XD
Does anyone think his violin loos much larger?
By far from his best, maybe he had a bad day, excellent tecnique as usual and musicianship but I notice that he was out of himself... I follow him very closely and this is not his real or best version.
the performans that you think is his "best one" is from 2007... he is older and more mature now....that obviously effects the interpretation
great performance but i also noticed that he was slightly off
Yes it was a very bad day for him. Maybe he was sick. Out of tune 80 percent of the time
I am of the opinion that not even Paganini could sing as well as you
everyone is complaining about the camera.. put your phone down and just listen.
french cameramen... >_>
Camera movement and zooms are completely unnecessary add on (and dilution/ distraction / mutation) to music like this, when the performer is telling the entire story himself
Oh my god this camera work is even worse than his pag 24 and that says a lot.
04:54
Too much vodka in this performance.
This camera work is absolutely terrible.
Augustin Haedlich performed this piece much better, more accurate and sublime dynamics... you guys need to watch him!
Венгеров великий , Августин хорош
no
I couldn't even truly enjoy the performance because the constant changing of the camera angles makes it impossible to do so. Horrible camera work!
These fast camera cuts are bull shit.
Венгеров страдает вкусовщщиной, очень жаль, без этого было бы неплохо, а так отврат ((
А вам кто больше нравится?
@@АртурХромушин-г3ы из ныне живущихСтадлер, Репин, Перельман, Гитлис, Третьяков, не живущих Гримо,, Франческатти, Шеринг, Ойстрах Давид, Коган, Мирон Полякин молодой Хейфиц, молодой Менухин, Крейслер, Ричи, Исаак Стерн молодой, Изаи
@@konstantinSE не обладаю такими широкими познаниями, но по мне, так Третьяков и Венгеров совершенно похожи, остальные звучат слишком академично, и только Ойстрах оказался между этими крайностями.
made many mistakes