No... no, no, no! people hating on this performance, read this- you guys (and, as a violin student who wouldn't dare attempt this piece for another decade or so, I) have NO IDEA how hard this piece is. All I can say is it looks immensely difficult. To get everything perfectly in tune, resonating, up to speed- and then to handle all the artistic elements- it sounds like a nightmare! This performance is far from perfect- but it's significantly better than ANYTHING you or I could whip up. Kang is a fantastic violinist to even attempt this piece! And she is so brave to play it in front of an audience! I have trouble playing suzuki pieces in front of my teacher!!!!!! No, its not as precise as Hahn or as fast as Vengerov, but why should that make it a bad perfomance? There are still many parts of this piece where she excels. Some parts I enjoy more than any other interpretation. She has excellent use of vibrato and of accents. She brings quiet splendor to parts where some violinists just pound through to show off. There's sincerity and maturity here- maybe not technical perfection, but that's not what classical music is about. Kang is an amazing violinist- check out her recording of Hubay's Carmen Fantasy, or her Sibelius Violin Concerto, or her Saint-Saens Introduction and Rondo Capriccioso. And how many violinists actually play Ernst's Last Rose Of Summer or Milstein's Paganiniana? Not a ton. She does. Why does EVERY single piece she plays have to be perfect? So you can be sure it won't be 9 minutes of "coulda clicked on that other interpretation..." If that's what you're saying to yourself, that's YOUR problem, not hers. I understand wishing it was better in the knowledge that she is a great violinist and maybe could done better, but there are all sorts of reasons people make mistakes and it's nothing worth commenting "OMG so cringy" about. It's a GOOD PERFORMANCE. We are lucky to be able to witness astronomically virtuosic performances from the comfort of our homes, lets not abuse that power. This is why so many classical musicians burn out- because of the expectation you have to always be "better" than the youtube video you'll land next to. And I bet, if she were to revisit this piece, invest a little more time into it, it would be JUST as good as Vengerov or Hahn, Still different. But just as good. Anyway, sorry for the rant, this is just something that bugs me a lot :(
예전엔 별로 좋아하지 않았던 연주자였는데 깜짝 놀랬습니다 지금은 음악에 몰입하게 만들어주는 연주자입니다 자신만의 해석과 표현 그리고 다양한시도에 두려움없이 힘차게 마주보는 그 배짱에 압도됩니다 요근래 남녀 통틀어 가장 듬직하고 힘있는 멋진 바이올리니스트👍사운드가 초창기에비해 화려하고 깊고 강인합니다 멋져요진짜👍
Beautiful! A more feminine interpretation than Maxim's, but equally powerful and passionate. And clearer, I have to say. There are phrases in this piece which I never noticed until I heard you play it.
There's a lot of room for personal interpretation in Ysaye 3... Vengerov's performance has become iconic, but this kind of slower, rubato performance is also perfectly fine. Unless there's something I'm missing? Her intonation sounds fine to me...
She is a human, not a robot :), and this is still one of the most clear performance ( full of clear phrasings, delicacy and musical intentions) here on youtube.
![[양인모 Inmo Yang] 이자이: 무반주 바이올린 소나타 6번 Ysaye: Sonata No. 6 for solo violin, Op. 27](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/K9nMd-Db42U/mqdefault.jpg)
No... no, no, no! people hating on this performance, read this- you guys (and, as a violin student who wouldn't dare attempt this piece for another decade or so, I) have NO IDEA how hard this piece is. All I can say is it looks immensely difficult. To get everything perfectly in tune, resonating, up to speed- and then to handle all the artistic elements- it sounds like a nightmare! This performance is far from perfect- but it's significantly better than ANYTHING you or I could whip up. Kang is a fantastic violinist to even attempt this piece! And she is so brave to play it in front of an audience! I have trouble playing suzuki pieces in front of my teacher!!!!!!
No, its not as precise as Hahn or as fast as Vengerov, but why should that make it a bad perfomance? There are still many parts of this piece where she excels. Some parts I enjoy more than any other interpretation. She has excellent use of vibrato and of accents. She brings quiet splendor to parts where some violinists just pound through to show off. There's sincerity and maturity here- maybe not technical perfection, but that's not what classical music is about. Kang is an amazing violinist- check out her recording of Hubay's Carmen Fantasy, or her Sibelius Violin Concerto, or her Saint-Saens Introduction and Rondo Capriccioso. And how many violinists actually play Ernst's Last Rose Of Summer or Milstein's Paganiniana? Not a ton. She does. Why does EVERY single piece she plays have to be perfect? So you can be sure it won't be 9 minutes of "coulda clicked on that other interpretation..." If that's what you're saying to yourself, that's YOUR problem, not hers.
I understand wishing it was better in the knowledge that she is a great violinist and maybe could done better, but there are all sorts of reasons people make mistakes and it's nothing worth commenting "OMG so cringy" about. It's a GOOD PERFORMANCE. We are lucky to be able to witness astronomically virtuosic performances from the comfort of our homes, lets not abuse that power. This is why so many classical musicians burn out- because of the expectation you have to always be "better" than the youtube video you'll land next to. And I bet, if she were to revisit this piece, invest a little more time into it, it would be JUST as good as Vengerov or Hahn, Still different. But just as good.
Anyway, sorry for the rant, this is just something that bugs me a lot :(
la mas completa violinista de esta generacion
진정한 바이올린 천재, 천부적인 재능은 이런 분을 두고서야 말을 할 수 있는 것 같다
The cleanest, brightest, not crushing, clearest and impossible to achieve tenth I've heard on 8:16
예전엔 별로 좋아하지 않았던 연주자였는데 깜짝 놀랬습니다 지금은 음악에 몰입하게 만들어주는 연주자입니다 자신만의 해석과 표현 그리고 다양한시도에 두려움없이 힘차게 마주보는 그 배짱에 압도됩니다 요근래 남녀 통틀어 가장 듬직하고 힘있는 멋진 바이올리니스트👍사운드가 초창기에비해 화려하고 깊고 강인합니다 멋져요진짜👍
uh holy shit
클주강 바이올린 넘사벽급으로 겁나게 잘 킴!
Beautiful! A more feminine interpretation than Maxim's, but equally powerful and passionate. And clearer, I have to say. There are phrases in this piece which I never noticed until I heard you play it.
예쁨
Bravo !!!
oh no..... there were moments I physically cringed.
it's sad, because I love sooooo many of her other pieces. like her grieg sonata
What do you mean?
There's a lot of room for personal interpretation in Ysaye 3... Vengerov's performance has become iconic, but this kind of slower, rubato performance is also perfectly fine.
Unless there's something I'm missing? Her intonation sounds fine to me...
Very disappointing. Not up to her usual excellence.
She is a human, not a robot :), and this is still one of the most clear performance ( full of clear phrasings, delicacy and musical intentions) here on youtube.