Explained: The most misunderstood twist in the charges against Donald Trump
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 28 май 2024
- The jury in Donald Trump's hush money criminal trial in New York have to ask themselves a series of questions on their way to arriving at a verdict in the case, with the final step being less prescribed than many people are accustomed to seeing, and consequently a lot of people are misunderstanding how it works. MSNBC legal correspondent Lisa Rubin and former prosecutor Duncan Levin explain why it's simpler than it sounds.
» Subscribe to MSNBC: / msnbc
Download our new MSNBC app for the latest breaking news and daily headlines at a glance: www.msnbc.com/information/dow...
Follow MSNBC Show Blogs
MaddowBlog: www.msnbc.com/maddowblog
ReidOut Blog: www.msnbc.com/reidoutblog
MSNBC delivers breaking news, in-depth analysis of politics headlines, as well as commentary and informed perspectives. Find video clips and segments from The Rachel Maddow Show, Morning Joe, The Beat with Ari Melber, Deadline: White House, The ReidOut, All In, Last Word, 11th Hour, and Alex Wagner who brings her breadth of reporting experience to MSNBC primetime. Watch “Alex Wagner Tonight” Tuesday through Friday at 9pm Eastern.
Connect with MSNBC Online
Visit msnbc.com: www.msnbc.com/
Subscribe to the MSNBC Daily Newsletter: link.msnbc.com/join/5ck/msnbc...
Find MSNBC on Facebook: / msnbc
Follow MSNBC on Twitter: / msnbc
Follow MSNBC on Instagram: / msnbc
#Trump #jury #hushmoney
trump isn't arguing he's innocent, he's arguing he has the right to be a criminal
Obviously, Donald has a limited vocabulary to argue with 😂
Well he's been at it for decades, so....
He argues both.
That TDS fever has given you hallucinations.
Nobody cares. America wants Trump. Say NO to Sloppy joe.
I find violating the tax law to be a no-brainer. Deductions of business expense need to be business expenses. Nothing deducted on the taxes was a legitimate cost of doing business. Fraud.
Just as easy to determine was violating the $2700 campaign finance contribution.
@@heemlo649The deduction was in Donald Trump’s company’s NY and Federal tax returns.
Yeah, I was surprised that commentators were talking about the tax fraud as if it was weak because Cohen was paying more tax than necessary (repayment disguised as income requires income and other taxes be paid) but legal services for a business can often be tax deductible and I would be shocked if Trump didn't claim the fees as deductible.
@@heemlo649 oh ffs, if it's claimed as an expense (which legal fees are) it's deducted. That's accounting 101 stuff.
@@heemlo649 Different crime Donald Trump has already been found guilty of (two months ago). The falsified ledgers were part of the Trump Organisation’s tax filings.
20 years ago, that's the last time a Republican presidential candidate has won the popular vote.
They steal supreme court seats too. Then their stolen court says they can steal Congress too.
joes 40 year high inflation will change that.
Yeah, without the EC the Republicans would have a hard time winning.
@@kelperdude👈
Takes his Kool-aid intravenously.
@@sassysaint3096 And probably pays Von Schitzinpants for the honor. 🤣🤣
It Does NOT matter that trump WAS A FORMER PRESIDENT IF THE UNITED STATES!!! trump IS "DEFENDANT" trump in this trial!!!
This is the proof under a conspiracy that he scammed his way into the white House or he woulda never been a president and we never woulda had the Trump or maga years infecting our government.
He is CITIZEN now.
Agree! if he's a John Doe its a slam dunk!!....if they give the ex president deference, the law could fail!!
I'd prefer that he be referred to as the un-presidented Donald Trump
@@peterwainwright5994*sigh
Be careful what you wish for...
if i were chosen for jury duty, put on a jury, went through the entire trial, and then told in deliberation i would have to just remember 53 pages of instructions in order to make a decision about someone’s freedom, i would freak out! i’m not capable of retaining that kind of information, and the whole thing just seems insane to me. how is that a thing?
poor baby.
@@davidcleveland-yv6my What a strange response. You sound like a person who is very young.
@@Sarcasticron at heart
Those instructions seems like the jurors are righting doctorate exams😂
It definitely fits with the rest of the trial shenanigans
Let’s hope that “Bone Spurs” don’t stop him from going to jail
Doubtful but his age might earn him some sympathy by the courts. I'd hope not. breaking laws is breaking laws no matter what the law breakers station in life is. Justice matters.
I am again and again amazed how bad the US justice system is.
The jury does not have a written copy of ALL instructions and ALL evidence presented but they must remember all by memory!?
Are you joking!
You should be more amazed by how uninformed you are. Nobody said they have to "do it all by memory". That was your stupidity showing.
They can, and did, ask for a repeat for some or all the directions. It might be better that they have someone familiar with legalese read the directions to them, rather than their arguing during their deliberations about what some segment of the directions (and potentially wasting a lot of time).
@@karenferrell-white5387 that's just it. The law in New York is so any questions regarding instructions go to the judge, the person who wrote them. Versus jorurs with no legal knowledge making their own interpretation and debating amongst themselves.
People that pretend not to understand this are just making excuses and spreading lies.
@@jacobbaran Exactly.
You have been watching the wrong trials or blatantly missing the jury requests.
Thank you. Your explanation of the charges and the deliberation process is best I’ve seen so far. 💎
It’s ridiculous that they don’t get the instructions. They always get them where I live in Texas.
Well, Senior gave that story about Ted Cruz's dad to prevent ted cruz from becoming potus potential
Thank you for this clarity!
Why in the world wouldn’t the jury have those instructions in the deliberation room???
We had them for a state superior court case here in Cali… our decision was based on the EXACT wording of the instruction.
Weird quirk of NY law.
@jennaxoxox4821 some of us are auditory learners and some are visual. Time for NY to change this rule.
must be to prevent one juror coloring or parsing down evidence? maybe?
Those instructions seems like the jurors are righting doctorate exams😂
@@paulorganisation1 nah...probly wronging em....huh huh...get it huh?
One has to ask, (but knows the answer), if Trump wasn't running for President, would any of this be happening? The answer is no.
I would certainly hope so. What he engaged in was illegal activity, so whether he's running to be president or not, he should be judged by a jury of his peers.
"Sitting for 5 weeks" 😂 was actually just 17 days and less than 8 hours a day.
GUILTY & PRISON.
Not guilty and no prison.
@@jonathandnicholson Aw, that's so sweet... If your parents haven't explained what the consequences of breaking the law are, I hope, when you get to Middle School, that they do.
@@jonathandnicholson 😂 good comeback MAGA cult member. How much of your pay check are your sending to pay for Trump’s legal fees? 😂
@@sophiaestella5611 Tell me is the Donald J Trump Revocable Trust an enterprise?
I hope you never try to run a business in New York....
By the way, Trump will still win the Presidency.... even from a cell.
Orange narcissist with 🐷 👀
Still better than BUYden!
@@dianepanfil7297 In what way is trump good for anybody other than Putin, Kim Jong Un, and the filthy-rich far right movers and shakers running (or rather, preventing the running) of the US?
@@dianepanfil7297 Yer mother wasn't better than Biden....
Get rid of slow bad- en
🇺🇸 TRUMP 🇺🇸
🎉 ❤ 🎉
Better than Biden only if you’re brainwashed by Qanon Russian propaganda/Fox news. Putler helped him in 2016 because he’s a Russian asset. The antichrist.
that thumbnail of him trying to smile is horrifying and hilarious at the same time
Great show, as always, and really good guests. Thanks for explaining the Choose Your Own Adventure, and why they didn't get a copy of the instructions.
I'm shocked the guy who cheated on Eric's mom with Tiffany's mom and then cheated on her mom with the woman he cheated on in this case wasn't more warm and fuzzy.
This is the core of the guy's beliefs - he does whatever he wants without any consequence to him.
Seems like the perfect candidate for Putler. Trump is the Antichrist.
We don't know wat was unlawful it just has to be unlawful in their head?
Maybe a good night of no sleep will help Donald make sense 🖥🍿🤣
joe fell asleep at the memorial day ceremony.
Trump slept through his entire trial. They’re both older men. DT is 77? Biden 81.
It's indicative of how joe feels about vets.
@@kelperdude; Donald fell asleep again in the court room today ! AGAIN, DONSHITZINPANTS HAS TO HAVE AID from his buddy Valty !
@@kelperdudeCompletely false...
This is my only criticism of Judge Merchan. I believe he could allow a copy of the jury instructions in the deliberating room.
I believe he's just following a pre-existing law.
Omg...he can't break the law , it could cause a mistrial!!!!!
If the jury has a question about the instructions, it's better for them to ask the judge for clarification rather than try to puzzle it out themselves in a 55 page document.
@@Sarcasticron You are correct. I have discovered since the reason for his decision.
@@jend.1069 You are wicked.🤣
They're expected to memorize 55 pages of instructions? Why don't they get a copy, that makes no sense.
Sounds like “Guilty!” To moi.
Meanwhile, at compensation- for- mushroom-stump-tower, Waltine Nauta is changing the diapers again!!! Toooo much McDonald's!!! Stinky don!! Sleepy don. Nap time
Diapers Don, biggest looser !!
What on earth did he do to get skin like that?! For someone who claims to be teetotal he sure looks like a heavy drinker!
Pig eyes.
Bronzer they say
A lifetime of fast food and zero physical exertion. He thinks riding in a golf cart is exercise.
Trump apparently has some pretty wacky ideas about how the human body works. For example, that everyone has a finite store of "energy" as if we're all some kind of walking battery.
Decades of drug use, will do that to you.
Remember him and Ronnie Jackson turned the WH into a pill mill. Some amphetamines were dispensed by the thousands along with opioids and pain killers.
Dear Lisa Rubin, I wish you could draw us the diagram of the crime! 🙋♀️😁❤
she could put it into pictures for you if that would help. emojis perhaps?
No one can figure out what the supposed "crime" is.
This is what it must have been like trying to convict capone or gotti
The biggest twist is how they took a misdemeanor that the statute of limitations has run out on and morphed it into a federal crime.
Cope harder, incel
Obviously the New York legal system needs to make some sensible changes such as allowing copies of the jury instructions be provided to the jury.
Lisa rubin really working overtime
If trump is found guilty he should be held in jail until he can post bail for an appeal ... bail set at 500 million after all he is a billionaire
I am sure New Yorkers would appreciate the violent criminals and all the thieves running around the city without bail....oh wait. They vote for that type of corruption. This is why New York is finished unless TRUMP wins in November. Then even though they may not deserve it...he will fix the sh*$ show New York has become.
Y’all really hate this man so much you’re willing to forgo the constitution 😂
Who is confused ?
"O our God, will You not judge them? For we are powerless against this great multitude which is coming against us. We do not know what to do, but our eyes are on You.”
(So you'd know Who is actually in control).
This really does not do a good job explaining it...
While they weren't allowed to keep a copy of the instructions, aren't they allowed to use their own pen and paper to make notes for themselves? I ask this as someone who's been on grand jury duty (local county only) and not on trial jury duty.
🤔 so is trumps lawyers arguing the 152 ?
😆
What I'm getting out of this is it would be very difficult to argue that Trump was innocent.
RICO...IRS...
He compared this to a murder case.. that is insane
I'm just as confused as when I got here
Well explained. Looking forward to Trump losing, again
Donald Trump has already won the election 😊
If he gets any looser his diapers won't hold it...
Soo what was he convicted of?
This just made me leave the democratic party. I am now republican
Why do you assume we're morons? And why do you assume these jurors are morons? Life is complicated. These laws aren't.
you tell 'em ronny !!
True...and why all the shouting?
The jury did have a lot of info thrown at them over the course of the last few weeks. Yet, they only now are getting to know what laws are at play here. I am gad that the jury has two lawyers/attorneys as members because it may allow the jury to have more independence and encourage them all to come to the right just verdict.
They should have had cameras. I would have liked to see the trial
In my state, juries always get a copy of the instructions to take to the room during deliberations. Crazy to think people absorb unfamiliar things after just one reading of the content of the instructions.
That's what you get with 'states rights', just the same as it is when it comes to women's healthcare in pregnancy.
Guilty...
I'm still really confused on what he did. He settled with Stormy out of court and what? Embezzled? What was the lie? I'm not being funny
Crickets….nobody knows.
@@jzbman Yeah no one knows what he did.
And this is what America has become!!
As much as I want to see Trump held accountable, it seems this case is really threading a needle. I will be surprised if he's found guilty.
Concern troll is obvious.
Not a wise analogy used by Duncan Levin. The murder weapon is the means of a murder.
The Judge will be getting Jury Instructions everyday. 55 pages wont be allowed in the Jury Room. Whats up with that. I heard it takes over 1 hr just to read them.
Weird quirk of NY law. Something about not overly burdening the jury.
@@jennaxoxox4821 One of those rules that probably made good sense for whatever reason it was created, but then we come to a case like this and it seems totally counterproductive. I agree with the original poster, they're probably going to need it read to them repeatedly, and there will probably still be disagreements among the jurors each time over what they just heard. Human nature is inescapable! 😃
they will probably only want to revue certain portions not the whole thing.
Glad to see TLev up there. He's my ideal of a Music Man player. ❤️
The idea of decision matrix is not new with me. I have seen these used by a couple of public utility commissions. It is very helpful for complex cases.
Good explanation
It seems to have been missed that a guilty verdict in this case doesn't demand a jail sentence. The Judge said it himself when admonishing Todd Whatisname.
I just luv Ur smiling faces...😅😊New Chump NFTS [ Ending scene ♥️ of The Untouchables *** with : Mr Kevin Costner and Mr Robert Dinero ♥️...Capone dragged away...kicking and Screaming 😱 ♥️ ❤️ 💖 💙 Aaaaah
JUST GIVE THEM A COPY, it’s 2024 & that’s the most ridiculous WASTE OF TIME EVER.
and wait for 18? people to read 55 pages. that will go quick.
When they are confused about something in the instructions, do you want them to try and figure it out themselves from the document or just ask the judge? People can disagree on which way is better but it isn't an obvious choice.
What's up with the Orange tie (worn ever since the Red Tie Brigade showed up)? "Better to match my Orange skin, my dear." (With apologies to the wolf in Red Riding Hood).
Those instructions seems like the jurors are righting doctorate exams😂
Trump is such a divisive and polarizing figure that he long ago lost the ability to unite the nation under any circumstances and for any cause.
That’s pretty big words/thinking for MAGA to comprehend. . 😆. Bravo 👏
Bull💩
@@FieldBlaser Trump loves money, TV, pretty boys, his hairdresser, and one of his kids.
It's even simpler than it seems. Pretend for a moment that this was about hiring a hitman. Falsifying the document is you wanting to hide that you solicited a murder (whether or not the murder ever ended up happening.) Whether your solicited that murder because your hated the victim or to cash in on an insurance policy or to get an inheritance isn't something the jury needs to unanimously agree on as long as they unanimously agree that you falsified documents to cover up that you solicited murder for any of those three reasons. One guy thinks you hated the victim, 2 think you wanted that life insurance policy, 9 think you were gunning for an early inheritance--12 jurors think you are guilty and that's that.
But what does hush money have to do with any of this
The most misunderstood twist in Donald
Just how hard has Melania Renegotiated..!
After. He was, "speaking in tongues"
Effing banana republic.
Thanks for explaining about the menu of possible crimes. That makes the juries job much less of a wide open decision than one might conclude based on earlier reporting. Nice job.
While you're all doing this you forgot to charge him with a crime!!! 🤦🏾♂️
Joined Jul 22, 2023 Isn’t a crime, but IS an indicator on the Obvious🐿Chipmunk Checklist.
So it's like pick a crime any crime?
It's so easy to be guilty these days
55 pages of jury instruction which I take to contain decision points and they read them to the jurists??? They should give them a decision matrix and access to the transcripts and evidence so they can set up a process. It seems od that the press can get copies of the transcripts but the jurists can't???
Yeah, I find that really odd. Took me a while to track down the written jury instructions, I'd find it far more sensible to have a copy in the jury room.
The jury has a laptop.
If you can find a copy of the instructions, so can they....
@@alfredgeorge3186 Presumably the laptop is customized to jury use. No internet access, and just the tools and information they need to review the allowed testimony and evidence. Oh, and Minesweeper. Gotta have that.
it is a new york law. i doubt they can access it on line.
@@alfredgeorge3186 their laptop is loaded up with trial documents/exhibits and isn't connected to the Internet.
"Conspiracy to prevent election" you say..... ??? What is happening to Trump in this moment right now?
Not Guilty.
I served on the jury of a civil damages case and volunteered to be foreperson because I had a lot of experience facilitating meetings and finding consensus solutions to problems. My guess is that in this case one of the two lawyers on the jury was elected foreperson and will be able to lead the jury to a consensus agreement on verdicts on the 34 counts.
All this “first time an American President…”, I haven’t thought once during this trial that he was a president bc he is so unpresidential.
So , whats hard about that ? The people listen to the the trial , look at the evidence etc. Why are yall trying to make it Harder than what it is ! Please !
Corruption at its best
Everything leads to a guilty verdict. How can it be any other way. He admitted his guilt in so many different ways publicly. Every tactics to prevent this case from happening shows his guilt. He cant prove his Innocence hes definitely not Mother Teresa....shameful he even uses her name
🐷 👀
Making sure Trump doesn’t get reelected will also make sure he finally faces the rest of his criminal trials! Vote for justice. VOTE BLUE
Word! 👏
Seriously so dumb to make a big deal of this
irrelevant that he’s an ex-president-he’s a citizen.
d'ooooh
Very complicated jury instructions.
The photo for this video, looks like he is trying to pass a peach seed.
Hey all. Just found a fly in the ointment. ALL of the underlying "crimes" in the trial were ALSO OUTSIDE OF THEIR STATUTE OF LIMITATIONS. So legally they cannot be used to elevate the alleged misdemeanors to felonies. And the misdemeanors are time barred SO the WHOLE CASE IS MOOT!
Thumbnail looks like he's living up to those rumors.
Trump loves money, TV, pretty boys, his hairdresser, and one of his kids.
...and big macs c'mon.
Liberal crazies will cry in November.
Nice try, Traitor! Is your name Vladimir?
@@user-kn7hm5kd2q Hold your horses its not yet November! MAGA TRUMP 2024 A woman is an adult female lol
Get some mental gymnastics alone that the Democrats had to use just to bring these charges with no one actually knowing actually what he's actually being charged with it's just pathetic and if you don't think the people see it you're blind..... What happens if he's convicted..... I'll tell you what happens .... Straight to the White House
too easy.....big house.
@@davidcleveland-yv6my the White House if you think Trump does 30 seconds in a jail cell you need to get some help with your TDS that'll never happen
Lock up Drumph up now.
Typical Trumpian: confusing so much that everybody gives up.
The thumbnail shows when Diaper Don had an accident in his diaper.
Hey, Americans - YOU guys voted him into the oval office, so now prove to the World that you're truly repentant for causing all of this UTTER CRAP as a result of your decision - and LOCK HIM UP.
RESEARCH &: EDUCATE YOURSELF ❗
He only needs one MAGA person on that jury.😂😂😂😂
Guilty as charged, lock him up.
If 17-152 is being brought into play….why isn’t the ENTIRE democrats party up in the dock…..???😂 ah double standards…love em. Trump will still win
trump Testimony is during morning break at 9am and lunch at 12pm, listen to the words coming out of his BIG MOUTH$.
Jail for trumpy
ALWAYS A TWIST !! TUMP 2024
Another stable genius was heard from. Who's Tump?
@@thepaulusmaximus AND WHATS GREAT UNDER JOE .. WAITING ..
Trump the GLOAT, master projector...
biggest liar of all time.....bloat.
Sociopath!
Defendant trump whinning he is a victim and did nothing wrong but refused to take the stand? Give me a break!