Это видео недоступно.
Сожалеем об этом.
Proof The Quran Is Corrupted! Conflicting Textual Variants (Part 2).
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 26 фев 2018
- Support my videos on Patreon: / dontconvert2islam
Or you can support me on Paypal: www.paypal.com/cgi-bin/webscr...
In this video I expose and refute the claim of Quran 15:9 that it’s preserved and guarded from corruption. I compare conflicting textual variants from two different Arabic Qurans (in this case, the dominant Hafs and Warsh versions). Enjoy!
Click here for Part 1 of this video series:
• Proof The Quran Is Cor...
If you'd like to support my education in Christian Apologetics click here, thanks: www.gofundme.com/ishmael-university-studies
Don'tConvert2Islam
What’s mean naagfer lakum or yagfer lekum can you explain ? What’s mean
Thanks for your hard work to explain alot of things i really appreciate that to make us learn and become near to the truth im muslim as appear from my name but its not forbidden to me to listen to you and learn some and found the answers ibrahim prophet god bless up on him he was searching without any one helped him until he got the truth until he become on quran and bible from the nearest to god so the knowledge is important to make us search not only believe without using our mind and if you seen you will find alot of difference between many religions same as islam and christianity and Jews and Hindus or buddhism all of them if we got in searching we will need thousands of years to just found what we will follow so although im muslim and i love my religion i respect you as you are Christian searching and i hope the ultimate god to provide you and me to find the stright way to follow ( hedayah).
Hey, thank you so much for this. Do you think you could provide a source for your table at 0:44 ?
Thank you in advance! :)
Tfoooooo 💦💨💦💨💦💨💦💨💦on your face demon😈😈😈💨💦💨💦💨💦
@Ms Rana is this video of ex-moslims of North America a joke too !!! ruclips.net/video/uGQ9NoXm5J8/видео.html
By the way ! Islam is dying in the West !!
Without LIES Islam DIES
"There are holes in the standard narrative" - Shaikh Yasir Qadhi
ruclips.net/video/3BCP3hPxCfo/видео.html
There are holes in y'alls brains😭😭😭😭
@@ashley_brown6106 I know the truth hurts your feelings
@@siulong1394 The standard narrative has more holes in it than a cheese factory.
🏭 🧀
@@mo_51_married_aisha_6 indeed!
Firstly I’m a native Arabic speaker, & I couldn’t see any contradiction among all the examples you’ve brought up ☺️ you must know there were a lot of Arabic language variations according to tribes and the locations, so the Quran was revealed in 7 different ways of reading, thus every tribe can read the Quran in their own way of Arabic language.
The second thing you need to know that the Arabic language isn’t like anything amongst languages, Arabic is uniquely flexible and saturated with meanings, because of that you can’t say for instance English Quran, French Quran and so on. But you rather say “an English or French Translation of Quran” etc..
And about what you have said, all of your examples in this video were hovering around “يـ They say or do” and “تـ you say or do”. But if you are speaking Arabic you’ll understand for sure that Allah talk about the same people in each phrase, either directly talking to them like « You are saying » or as a third person as «They are saying ». Therefore you can see there’s no difference between both of the two examples.
And the 7 tongues or « ways of Arabic reading» were being read by prophet Muhammad *peace be upon him* himself.
Peace ✌🏻 and May Allah guide your heart to his true way “The Islam” ❤️
Brother I was searching for warsh & hafs Quran recitation but I don't know How I get this video.Then I listen his lecture & started laughing.He has no knowledge about Arabic language😂😂🤣🤣
@@tamimhossain4488 só you can write and read arabic?
@@tamimhossain4488 واحدة مكتوبة فدية طعام مسكين , والتانية مكنوبة فدية طعام مساكين ....طبعا فيه اختلاف واختلاف كبير جدا , لان فيه فرق بين عدد المساكين هما كتير والا شخص واحد ..لكن طبعا بدل ما تطلعوا تردوا رد منطقى بتطلعوا تهربوا من الاجابة وخلاص ....هو صح وانتوا غلط
ruclips.net/video/LzSyGjsd9jY/видео.html
@@lilykamal4824
الفرق فى الكلمات لا يغير المعنى النهائى للأيات , مشابه للمثالين الاولئل "نغفر و يغفر" و كمان " تقولون و يقولون " بالنهاية المعنى واحد
حتى المثال الى انت كتبتيه , مسكين و مساكين , التشريع يبنى على القران والسنة وليس القران فقط
لان حتى مساكين هو جمع غير محدد , يعنى اكيد ليس رقم عشوائى
بل يتم تحديده بما كان يعمل به فى هذا الوقت
وفى النهاية الاختلاف هو اختلاف كتابة وقواعد لفظية وليس فى المعنى , مفيش تضارب فى المعانى , زي حتى الانجليزية لها لهجات مختلفة و مرادفات كثيرة
I am arabic person and I'm good in arabic, and you are absolutely right about everything you've said
Quran was revealed in 7 different ways of reading by God according to Prophet Muhammad ﷺ, which in fact causing a slight different in meaning by these variations, but it does not change the true meaning and there's no contradictions in those variations. Thus, it helps in reaching the true meaning and making it more eloquent. Every variations were preserved and strengthen with the chain of narrators which goes all the way to the Prophet. These variations were approved by the Prophet himself since it was revealed to him in that way by God.
Umar ibn al-Khattaab said: “I heard Hishaam ibn Hakeem reciting Surah al-Furqaan in a manner different from that in which I used to recite it and the way in which the Messenger of God (May peace and blessings be upon him) taught me to recite it. I was about to argue with him while he was praying, but I waited until he finished his prayer, and then I tied his garment around his neck and seized him by it and brought him to the Messenger of God (May peace and blessings of be upon him) and said, "O Messenger of God, I heard this man reciting Surah al-Furqaan in a way different to the way you taught it to me." The Messenger of God (May peace and blessings be upon him) said to him, "Recite it!" and he recited it as I had heard him recite it. The Messenger of God (May peace and blessings be upon him) said, "It was revealed like this." Then he said to me, "Recite it!" so I recited it and he said, "It was revealed like this." "This Quran has been revealed in seven different ways, so recite it in the way that is easiest for you."
(Narrated by al-Bukhaari, 2287; Muslim, 818)
Syed, didn’t Uthman burn the various other Qurans that were not in the quryshi dialect? So then how were they preserved? And doesn’t that mean he went against what Muhammad said here? So how can you trust the Uthmanic recent of the Quran?
Jesse Digges
Uthman did not burn the original, instead he COPIED from the original then returned it back to Hafsa, the daughter of the Prophet (PBUH).
Here is the full hadith:
Narrated Anas bin Malik: Hudhaifa bin Al-Yaman came to Uthman at the time when the people of Sham and the people of Iraq were Waging war to conquer Arminya and Adharbijan. Hudhaifa was afraid of their (the people of Sham and Iraq) differences in the recitation of the Qur'an, so he said to 'Uthman, "O chief of the Believers! Save this nation before they differ about the Book (Quran) as Jews and the Christians did before." So 'Uthman sent a message to Hafsa saying, "Send us the manuscripts of the Qur'an so that we may compile the Qur'anic materials in perfect copies and return the manuscripts to you." Hafsa sent it to 'Uthman. 'Uthman then ordered Zaid bin Thabit, 'Abdullah bin AzZubair, Said bin Al-As and 'AbdurRahman bin Harith bin Hisham to rewrite the manuscripts in perfect copies. 'Uthman said to the three Quraishi men, "In case you disagree with Zaid bin Thabit on any point in the Qur'an, then write it in the dialect of Quraish, the Qur'an was revealed in their tongue." They did so, and when they had written many copies, 'Uthman returned the original manuscripts to Hafsa. 'Uthman sent to every Muslim province one copy of what they had copied, and ordered that all the other Qur'anic materials, whether written in fragmentary manuscripts or whole copies, be burnt. Said bin Thabit added, "A Verse from Surat Ahzab was missed by me when we copied the Qur'an and I used to hear Allah's Apostle reciting it. So we searched for it and found it with Khuzaima bin Thabit Al-Ansari. (That Verse was): 'Among the Believers are men who have been true in their covenant with Allah.' (33.23) (Sahih Bukhari, Book 61, Hadith 510)
____________________________
Meaning of this hadith
1- People of Syria and Iraq were Non-Arabs who converted to Islam, their Mother tongue was not Arabic.. so they used to Pronounce Arabic words and recite Quran differently. So they differed among each others
2- To save the situation before the differences among them arises, Uthman (the companion of the Prophet) ordered the COPYING from the ORIGINAL QURAN COPY which was compiled during the period of Abu Bakr and was kept with Hafsah (the Daughter of the Prophet)
3- Uthman ordered Zaid, the scribe of the Prophet (pbuh) who compiled Quran during period of Abu Bakr, to COPY from this ORIGINAL copy of Quran with two other men from the Tribe of Quraish (Tribe of the Prophet) in order to write it in Quraishi dialect if they differed about any word, because Quran was revealed in the dialect of Quraish
4- Zaid didn't just copy, he also acquired at least two witnesses for EACH VERSE from those who MEMORIZED the Quran. So preservation of Quran was done by COPYING FROM ORIGINAL + MEMORIZING = PERFECT PRESERVATION
5- After this PERFECT preservation was done.. Uthman ordered the copying of another 7 copies which was sent to every Muslim provenance and then ordered the burning of all fragments and copies even the copies of Syrians and Iraqis who differed among themselves to avoid confusions
6- Finally, what Uthman (the companion of the Prophet) did was A GREAT ACHIEVEMENT for the preservation of Quran !!
Syed Zaki
watch debate (the quran and the Bible in light of science) between dr Zakir Naik and dr. William Campbell
Here we are talking about changes in words and meaning - so Allah in one quran is saying if you shit facing east will give you jannah and in another he is saying if you face west. So which is true.?..Allah is confused and contradicts himself. BUT most importantly ...the Qurans are different in the words used//
Syed Zaki thanks for the information but I have a simple question: why do the other variants exist if they all originate from Hafsa's copy? And who's to say that one variant is correct and another is incorrect like the difference where in one version of 2:184 it requires feeding one poor person but in the other version many poor people? They can't both be correct in this case.
This is because Quraan was revealed to Prophet(SAL) in 7 different Ahruf (plural form for harf). For those who are unfamiliar with Arabic langauge, it basically consists of Noun which is called “Ism”, Verb which called “Fi-il” and all the rest are “Harf” . Secondly, the Arabic language does not have “Harakaat,” that is, the markers which guide the Non-Arab reader how a word should be pronounced. The original Quraan did not have diacritics(Harakaat). It was added later for easy recitation for Non-Arabs.
Coming to your particular verse, the letters of the word: مسكين (poor) are the same in both warsh and hafs. So, textually hafs and warsh do not differ. It is only recitation that differs. Not only Hafs and Warsh there are numerous other recitations. The word مسكين can be either pronounced as “Miskeen” which is singular or “Masaakeen” which is plural. Both are contextually correct. A person who can not fast can feed one poor person many times or many poor persons at one time.
Lastly, your interpretation of one poor person and many poor persons may be grammatically correct but it may miss the context. The word “poor” even in English means a group who are poor or a single person who is poor.
Iman E That is not true brother. The reading of the Quran is actually a reflection of what the text says. The reading and the text go together.
You say that only recitation change. But we see that meaning changes, one poor person is not the same as many poor persons. Now, to me this is not corruption since th overall context may be the same, but this idea that the Quran has never change even to the dot of the word is obviously false.
Tiki Taka
No, it did never change. The dots were added to make pronouncing the words and reading the quran easier. The words themselves didn't change.
Besides that the quran was given to the Prophet ( peace be upon him) in different styles. The evidence for that is the hadeeth of Ibn ‘Abbaas who narrated that the Prophet (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) said: “Jibreel taught me one style and I reviewed it until he taught me more, and I kept asking him for more and he gave me more until finally there were seven styles.”
(narrated by al-Bukhaari, 3047; Muslim, 819)
The best of the scholarly opinions concerning what is meant is that there are seven ways of reciting the Qur’aan, where the wording may differ but the meaning is the same; if there is a different meaning then it is by way of variations on a theme, not opposing and contradiction.
The difference in poor between warsh and hafs isn't significant, because it doesn't change the ruling on feeding the poor when one is not able to fast. You can choose to feed one poor person or more than one person. Both are seen as correct.
Hm, I'm not saying a difference in "poor" I'm saying the difference in "one" and "many". Feeding one and feeding many is different. Singular and plural isn't the same.
Trust me I do NOT consider this corruption since these are very small variants, it's not significant. But I don't understand why Muslims insisting that word-by-word all are the same, it's just not true.
Tiki Taka
Yes, but the difference between the plural and singular isn't in the word poor itself, but in the places of the dots and signs. If you read it without the signs and dots it can be understand as one poor person and many poor persons. The words many and one aren't in the Arabic text it's only added in the English translation. As an example in Arabic text:
Poor person(s) = مسكين
Plural = مَسَكـِينَ
Singular = مِسْكِينٍ
You see how plural and singular have dots and lines at different places, but with out the dots مسكين (poor) can be both read as plural and singular. The words are still the same.
قال الله في سورة الشعراء : ( وَإِنَّهُ لَتَنزِيلُ رَبِّ الْعَالَمِينَ (192) نَزَلَ بِهِ الرُّوحُ الْأَمِينُ (193) عَلَىٰ قَلْبِكَ لِتَكُونَ مِنَ الْمُنذِرِينَ (194) بِلِسَانٍ عَرَبِيٍّ مُّبِينٍ (195) وَإِنَّهُ لَفِي زُبُرِ الْأَوَّلِينَ (196) أَوَلَمْ يَكُن لَّهُمْ آيَةً أَن يَعْلَمَهُ عُلَمَاءُ بَنِي إِسْرَائِيلَ (197) وَلَوْ نَزَّلْنَاهُ عَلَىٰ بَعْضِ الْأَعْجَمِينَ (198) فَقَرَأَهُ عَلَيْهِم مَّا كَانُوا بِهِ مُؤْمِنِينَ (199) كَذَٰلِكَ سَلَكْنَاهُ فِي قُلُوبِ الْمُجْرِمِينَ (200) لَا يُؤْمِنُونَ بِهِ حَتَّىٰ يَرَوُا الْعَذَابَ الْأَلِيمَ (201) فَيَأْتِيَهُم بَغْتَةً وَهُمْ لَا يَشْعُرُونَ (202) فَيَقُولُوا هَلْ نَحْنُ مُنظَرُونَ (203) أَفَبِعَذَابِنَا يَسْتَعْجِلُونَ (204) أَفَرَأَيْتَ إِن مَّتَّعْنَاهُمْ سِنِينَ (205) ثُمَّ جَاءَهُم مَّا كَانُوا يُوعَدُونَ (206)مَا أَغْنَىٰ عَنْهُم مَّا كَانُوا يُمَتَّعُونَ (207) Translation Ash-Shu'araa
Verily this is a Revelation from the Lord of the worlds:
With it came down the Spirit of Faith and Truth,
To thy heart and mind, that thou mayest admonish
In the perspicuous Arabic tongue.
Without doubt it is (announced) in the revealed Books of former peoples.
Is it not a Sign to them that the Learned of the Children of Israel knew it (as true)?
Had We revealed it to any of the non-Arabs,
And had he recited it to them, they would not have believed in it.
Thus have We caused it to enter the hearts of the Sinners.
They will not believe in it until they see the grievous Penalty;
But the (Penalty) will come to them of a sudden, while they perceive it not;
Then they will say: "Shall we be respited?"
Do they then ask for Our Penalty to be hastened on?
Seest thou? If We do let them enjoy (this life) for a few years,
Yet there comes to them at length the (Punishment) which they were promised!
It will profit them not that they enjoyed (this life)!
Lmao 😂 you really think the “dialects” or “accent” really mean it is corrupted. It’s literally like saying I am tired and I am shattered. Diff word yet it’s the same. When they say not a single word has changed it doesn’t mean the physical words rather it’s the meaning of the word. The example I gave you I am tired and shattered. When you say تقولون or يقولون you’re completely ignoring the context. I appreciate how you analysed it however in terms of Quran science you are wrong. They say and you say end of the day represents the same person. God is not like a normal person. Nor a male or female yet people say he and why’s that?
I disagree . Why allah is not able to make differences between singular and plural ? Some verses in some mushaf are in singular and in other mushaf are in plural
@@nickelbriand HAHAHAHAHHA you must study about the Basic Arabic hahahah. The man on the Video didn't know to recite properly the quran hahahahah. There so many people muslim can quran with or without Baris this man is clever Hahhahahahahhahahahha
@@nickelbriand You can read arabic??? Then try to read it from the video. If not your dumb hahahahhaha. The translation is suck hahahah
@@nickelbriand for eg if I say india is our country and india is my country . Our and my refers to the plural and singular respectively but the context of both the verses are same that india belongs to me
@@arman4304 wrong answer . "our" is a possessive pronoun , "we" is a s subject . Why allah dosn t know if he is single or plural ?
Are you joking right . There s one coran . And you can work experience. And you can invite guests two people memorized Quran one of Morocco and one of Malaysia. And you will see that you liar.
Just because the Bible is distorted. You look for like that in the Koran. But you wish
Nada, you are being deceived, brainwashed by your ustadz/ulama, See the video Nada, the proof is given side-by-side comparison of the two qurans (hafs vs Warsh). Islam is a false religion, made up by muhammad, abandon islam Nada.
Lance Gin you are big liar and am sorry for you . First, it appears that you did not read the text, and that you are transferring from Islamophobic sites that publish fraud and lies.
Abraham peace be upon him when he pray god to give him a child
(37:100) Lord, grant me a righteous son
.god inser him by two Annunciation The Bible says that at the birth of the Prophet Ishmael, the Prophet Abraham was 86 years old (Gen. 16: 16) and at the birth of the Prophet Isaac a hundred years. (Gen. 21: 5).
.the first annunciation from god That will give it the first son who was ishmail .and when god said the first annouciation he star to talk about the story of sacrifice between abraham and his first son .
And when god finish the story .then he said about the second annouciation to give him the second child wich is issac. And god also start to talk about the specific of issac
And this the verses from 100-112
(37:100) Lord, grant me a righteous son
(37:101) (In response to this prayer) We gave him the good news of a prudent boy.
(37:102) and when he was old enough to go about and work with him, (one day) Abraham said to him: “My son, I see in my dream that I am slaughtering you. So consider (and tell me) what you think.”He said: “Do as you are bidden. You will find me, if Allah so wills, among the steadfast.”
(37:103) When both surrendered (to Allah's command) and Abraham flung the son down on his forehead.
(37:104) We cried out: “O Abraham
(37:105) you have indeed fulfilled your dream.Thus do We reward the good-doers.
(37:106) This was indeed a plain trial.
(37:107) And We ransomed him with a mighty sacrifice.
(37:108) and We preserved for him a good name among posterity.
(37:109) Peace be upon Abraham.
(37:110) Thus do We reward the good-doers.
(37:111) Surely he was one of Our believing servants.
(37:112) And We gave him the good news of Isaac, a Prophet and among the righteous ones.
Do not speak before you read and learn please.
You can check the website of if you wan study verses and what is about.
www.islamicstudies.info/tafheem.php?sura=37&verse=99&to=113
Lance Gin who said that also to you . You have never read the Koran. Do not claim anything and you do not know. The Qur'an mentions Ismail in several times by name . He mentioned many stories without mentioning his name.
And this verse in the Quran about Ismail.its a verse Express gratitude Ibrahim to the one god who give him ishmael and isaac.
(14:39) All praise be to Allah Who, despite my old age, has given me Ishmael and Isaac. Surely my Lord hears all prayers.
First Read the coran after that you can make your claim.
Lance Gin first can i know your back ground ?
Lance Gin are you jewish or chritien
Very weak refutation The Qur'an has been revealed in different Qiraa'at (types of reading) which all Muslims know. The reason behind this difference was the knowledge that the islamic faith will be embraced by many different people from various countrys with different mother tounges etc.
Your main mistake: you think "the" one and only qur'an that the Vers (the quran is unchangeable) refers to is the Qira'a of Hafs and every single letter has to be the same in every Quran Copy to prove the claim the the quran has not changed. Wrong assumption: we say the Quran was revealed in all those different Qira'at so the conditions to be called "a Quran" are fullfiled. Because all this ways to read the quran with the different letters came from the prophet aleyhi as salam.
If you would argue now, that it cant be called one Qur'an we say: wrong. It is one Quran because it came from the same source.
I think you guys should ask yourself if you know your own faith good enough before youll try to refute.
Boaz Goldmeyer I don’t see how you can believe everything you just said. Islam would spread to many different peoples? How does that have anything to do with the variants he shared in this video? You’re just settling with that answer of yours even though there’s no reason different peoples would need these verses to be different for them. Why would one country need a verse to be one way and another country need it to be another way? And if you really think this to be the case, then use the variants in this video as a case study and offer some explanations.
There’s not any reasoning behind your response. I mean think about it. If that’s your explanation then there’s no limit to how far you could take that explanation. It wouldn’t matter how many differences exist between the Quran versions. You would still just chalk it up to being different qiraat that are all accepted. That is, you begin with the assumption that all variations are to be accepted, and therefore no variant could ever be viewed as a human change. That’s putting the cart before the horse. Do you have any methodology at all to judge what would be too far? It seems to me that the whole seven qiraat (even though there are actually many more) was just a cop-out invented by early Muslims to explain away the differences that existed between qurans.
No, there is not just “one” Quran just because you assume they all came from the same source. There are many qurans that are all similar but also different. And yet Muslims are taught, and they tell us, that there is only one Quran and not a single letter has been changed. Come on, we can see the differences. They are clearly different letters which create different words. It’s not a difference of dialect. It’s a difference in meaning.
You’re basically saying, the Quran can have all the hallmarks of a text that’s been changed, but it’s still unchanged anyway. That’s a nonsensical claim. Moreover, you can’t even prove the things your claiming, that all the variants that exist are all original and from God. That’s an assumption you’re making because you automatically reject the idea that the Quran could’ve changed.
And don’t you remember that Uthman burned all the qurans that differed from the version he put forth? Even he tried to get rid of all the variants, so why do we still have so many variants between different versions of the Quran? Uthman was supposed to have destroyed them in order to artificially “preserve” the Quran.
The thing is they are so insecure in their own faith they try to find flaws in a perfect one
Hitler Kun that’s a classic assumption on your part. You don’t think it’s possible for someone who is genuinely secure in their faith to point out the errors in another religion with the hopes of leading those adherents to the truth? If not, then why do muslims attack others’ beliefs? And Islam is far from perfect. It has so many problems and holes in it. If it was perfect then the Arab world wouldn’t have so many human rights abuses. 15 of the top 18 countries where it’s the most dangerous to be a Christian are all Muslim countries. So much for a “perfect” religion. Go figure.
Shin Dok yeah but the thing is, so much of the Quran and Hadith are contrary to human rights. For example, Muslims are allowed to have sex with their female captives even if the women are already married. Muslims will commonly say that the bad stuff that happens in Muslim countries is contrary to Islam, but if you read the Quran, Hadith, and sirah, they actually teach those things. But then lots of Muslims like to sugar coat it and project a manufactured context onto those unsettling verses to make them appear acceptable. But to non-Muslims who don’t feel the need to go into immediate damage control, we just don’t buy it. The verses don’t say what Muslims say they mean. They say what they say.
@@makk191 no one's insecure.He is doing what any academic should do
Assalamu Alaykum to all who reads this comment, Im just trying to say that dont listen these people that are trying to use Islam to make their faces famous also for likes and subscribers. I listen and watch it carefuly and being focused in this video it is all false, a lot of photoshop used. Islam is the True Religion and Only Religion Accepted by All-llah (s.w.t.) and surely he will guard it. The most merciful the Apsolute.. Respect for other religions. Peace
Thanks brother you increased my faith in Allah and his quran. Let me explain
There are versions of bible some of them includes some chapter while some omits. Sects have their own versions. While some has even added Gospels.
Now come to quran. In the video you were only able to show some words which changes the meaning grammatically. But if you ask any Arabic native he will tell you they have same meaning. And the difference is not something we are not aware of. It was told by prophet saaw himself that it is revealed in different dialects which you just showed us. Thank you for showing coz this proves that even our saying of prophet are well protected than your holy book Bible.
Now coming to the part where you said God told in quran he will preserve it. Now let me know which religious books is memorised by thousands of its followers?
Do you want acid test of the verse we are it's guardian??
Let's throw all the religious scriptures in the water and see which scripture comes back as it is. This what is called preserving.
Different Christian sects have different Bibles with chapter omitted or included.But shia version of the Quran and sunni version of it are identical even though they differ with each other in beliefs. Go to different countries and you will find every one following same Quran. This is what is called preserving
And the variants which you mentioned is not something we don't know. It's in the Hadith of Messanger Saaw that it was revealed in different dialects.
Still in doubt???
Just think why Quran is the only religious which is memorised by heart by thousands of its followers. See what Allah says about it in Quran.
And We have certainly made the Qur'an easy for remembrance, so is there any who will remember.
@imu70 Don't you know that we all moslem are Jesus alayhissalaam followers? We moslem believe he is the Messiah who will kill the dajjal the false messiah and he will tell the truth about Moslem. The obvious difference between us is that Our Lord doesn't have son who is called Jesus, he is mere a prophet, messenger and slave of the Lord. Nothing ever compare the Creator. We simply believe One Creator and the rest are creatures. So eventhough how much noble Muhammad sallAahu alayhi wassalaam, he is a mere prophet, messenger and a slave. His level never descent to the be divinity as put to the same level to the Divine itself. And we don't worship prophets who are mere just human being, one of creatures created by Allaah, the Creator all of exist.
imu70 cool when you don’t have anything good to say, you will just condemn people to the hellfire. Well done on you, instead of refuting what he said with some type of proof or evidence you just attacked him. How civil and peaceful of you.
That's the apocrypha, my friend. Those are late century works. I will list them and they belong to the old testament
Parts of Daniel and Esther
Sirach
Wisdom
1 & 2 Maccabees
Tobit
Baruch
Judith
These books are found in the catholic bible and are deutrocano nicel and are not considered as the main canon. While Protestants don't have that. Orthodox has much more books. The real authors are not known for these books and we're not in the Jewish torah
Different recitations of quran
ruclips.net/video/PxSbGeW5Kko/видео.html
ruclips.net/video/LzSyGjsd9jY/видео.html watch this then give proof
Thank you for this informative video. I admire your dedication to have learned Arabic; it is unfortunate, however, that you did not care to study or even read a simple explanation on Hafs and Warsh "differences".
The Qur'an, before the main points of these "differences" are summarized, was not revealed as "text" (book), rather as "recitation". This is why we read the Prophet (saw) say, "Gabriel read the Qur’an to me in one way (i.e. dialect) and I continued asking him to read it in different ways till he read it in seven different ways." Now, to the main points:
1. As you have affirmed, 95% of the recitation is the same in the Muslim world with other variants permitted (no issues here, as per the hadith of the Prophet (saw)).
2. The meanings have not been changed, that is, the overall message remains the same.
3. Whole words are not changed. A single word is not substituted by another.
4. Difference in a single letter or diacritical mark does not mean that the whole word is changed.
5. Differences in recitations also do not mean that the words or the meanings are changed.
6. Lastly, the chain of narrators is mutawatir (known and authentic).
All in all, there are differences in 38 letters (maximum) from 300,000 (minimum) letters which is less than 0.01% variation and most importantly, these differences are within the margins of preservation with no change in actual meanings, whole words or actual verb.
Those “seven versions” are a fake late creation. They DO differ in actual meaning and have real impact in multiple place. Before the number of approved texts was cut down to 7, there were many, many more variants. Some early texts are here, proving.this.
info.qurangateway.org/
Gen Li It was read in 7 ways, that doesn’t mean that there are only 7 allowed. As he said, different ways of recitation are allowed, as Gibriel read it in different ways. If the scholars of Islam agree that the Quran and it’s message is preserved and the chain of narration is preserved, it is allowed.
refutation let see if stays up ruclips.net/video/PxSbGeW5Kko/видео.html
@@genli5603 As you are not familiar with Arabic language it is difficult to explain to an arrogant person. basically the rasm al-Othmany still allows some "linguistic interpretation" as at the time the Arabic language didn't consist of 29/30 letters and most of that amount was of letters which looked the same (as I stated in my answer of the Question about qira'aat)... but let's start with the example given from surat al-Humazah 104 سورة الهمزة:
Basically the difference between yahsibu and yahsabu is in the diacritics it is a common difference between two linguistic schools which applies for any incident of this verb in the whole Quran:
Let's say the rasm al-'Othmany is this:
يحسب
Now the reading of 'Asim عاصم (from al-Kufa) the teacher of Hafs حفص and Sho'aba شعبة , ibn 'Amir ابن عامر (from a-Shaam) and Hamzah حمزة (from al-Kufa) is yahsabu:
يَحْسَبُ
While the rest of the seven quraa' like Nafi' نافع (Medina) teacher of Warsh ورش and Qalun قالون, Abu Amr (from Basra), al-Kissa'iy الكسائي (from al-Kufa) and ibn Kathir ابن كثير (from Mekka) were reading it yahsibu:
يَحْسِبُ
This also applies to other present conjugations of the verb hasiba حسب:
يحسبهم, يحسبون, يحسبه ...
Other differences in surat al-Humazah:
Note: If I say instead of "x" I mean that "x" is the reading followed by the majority among the 7 qiraa't!
Ibn 'Amir, Hamzah and al-Kissa-iy read in (102:2) with an emphasized "m":
جَمَّعَ (jamma'a) instead of جَمَعَ (jama'a)
Hafs the student of 'Asim (only), Abu 'Amr and Hamzah read here and in (90:20)
مُؤْصَدَة (mo'sada) with an extra hamzah (ء) instead of مُوصَدَة (moosada).
Note that these kinds of hamzah were "too heavy" for most Arabic tribes so Quraish never used to pronounce it while Hudhail used to taht's why they primiraly appear in most Kufi-qiraa't as they were following the reading of the hudhali sahabi Abudullah ibn Masu'd for a long time before accepting the rasm al-'Othmany.
Al-Kufa readers ('Asim, al-Kissa'iy and Hamzah and their students) except for Hafs read (104:9):
عُمُدٍ ('omodin) instead of عَمَدٍ ('amadin)
None of these differences has an impact of the meaning! It is like a word that can be spelled or pronounced in different ways.
This is a link to audio files of the Egyptian Sheikh of qiraa't Ahmad al-Ma'srawy أحمد المعصراوي were you may find the 10 different qiraat of the Quran to compare surat al-Humazah is apparently always present, normally all 20 riwayas (narrations) should be available, but on this link some are not (Hafs is the most striking absent one!). Maybe you can find the missing ones on an other rather salafi site called islamway.com.
Examples of general rulings in the seven qiraa't
Be aware that some difference come from "technical" tajweed details such as how and when to prolong a letter etc.:
For example the reading of Hamzah is well known for their special diacritic for example were ever you may read "عليهم" ('alayhim), "إِليهم" (ilayhim) and "لَديهم" (ladayhim) he reads it "عليهُم" (alayhom), "إِليهُم" (ilayhom) and "لَديهُم" (ladayhom) which in standard and spoken Arabic sounds rather strange!Ibn Kathir and Warsh are adding the diacritic "dama" to the "m" of plural if a neutral diacritic is following in the next word like "عليهم" ('alayhim) which they read "عليهمُ" (alayhimoo) ...Hamzah and Hisham (the student of ibn 'Amir) use to do a slight pause on each hamzah (ء) following some special rulings.I could go more in details, but I'm afraid that wouldn't be helpful. A last example: If you went to Morocco or Algeria or any country where the reading of Warsh is prevalent you may notice in the adhan that the "L" of as-salat الصلاة in "Hayya a'la as-salat" is emphasized and sounds like "as-soloh" or "as-soloht". This is a kind of impact of the reading in the local Arabic "dialect". So Warsh is known to emphasize some "lam's"
Great work as always brother I’m going to share this far and wide👍
God bless you my brother in Jesus mighty name ♥️♥️♥️✝️♥️♥️♥️
I can see islam crumbling bit by bit, its lies are being exposed one by one.....thanks brother
You realise there's as many holes in the holy bible too don't you?
@@GGTBOTD yes crumbling bit my bit as it becomes almost the most practiced religion in the world. Good stuff Mr. Statistics
Christian.By.Choice Muslims responded
ruclips.net/video/XDL1yy4iqiU/видео.html
The Bible is worse lmao all religion does is separate people and create problems.
Please watch this video The SEVEN Ahrof & the TEN Qira'aat of Quran - EXPLAINED! - Arabic101 ruclips.net/video/8hj7u0F3yEg/видео.html
In this video it answers the following TEN questions:
1- What does harf mean? What are the seven ahrof of Quran?
2- Why do we even have seven ahrof for the Holy Quran?
3- What kind of changes/ examples are we talking about when it comes to variations of the Quran?
4- What are Qira’at (modes of recitation)? And is it linked to Ahrof of Quran?
5- What is riwayah (narration) of the quran?
6- What is tareeiq (method) of the quran?
7- Can you have your own method of reading Quran?
8- If ahorf is a similar word to dialect, can we use today’s dialects to read the Quran?
9- Indispensable sources for those who are interested in Qira’at.
10- I am an absolute beginner in the Holy Quran, do I have to know this?
Eye opening! Please keep the good work going!
This is called Qira'at and it doesn't mean corruption.Quran is kept word by word and this is a recitation which means the same thing and the prophet accepted them on time, because of difference of dialects. You failed!! Why because we all knew this and it's a treasure preserved. Not corruption. These are small allowed syllables.
Atomizer Did you check the differences in meaning of the textual variations or just simply haven’t? For example one aya from Hafs version and other one from Warsh version:
- Yukathibuna al lathina (they say those people lied)
- Kathibu al lathina (They lied who say)
Is this the same meaning, *The Answer is: No* it is DIFFERENT meaning!!
Stop listening to lies of imams! This has NOTHING to do with DIALECTS. Either you are ignorant or a just a liar. I think you are just ignorant and it is NOT your fault brother, you have been told a lie by your sheiks.....
Atomizer Atomizer Did you check the differences in meaning of the textual variations or just simply haven’t? For example one aya from Hafs version and other one from Warsh version:
- Yukathibuna al lathina (they say those people lied)
- Kathibu al lathina (They lied who say)
Is this the same meaning, *The Answer is: No* it is DIFFERENT meaning!!
Stop listening to lies of imams! This has NOTHING to do with DIALECTS. Either you are ignorant or a just a liar. I think you are just ignorant and it is NOT your fault brother, you have been told a lie by your sheiks.....
He never came with something new, but he is shaking his knees for different recitations we had all time, since the time of Muhammed and he fools the christian irrationals who believe his non-sense. If there was a problem with one recitation or other, we wouldn't pray in on single prayer in 2 or more different recitations. The syllables you mentioned has no effect and even certain word alterations but with same meaning are allowed in one or two cases, because some communities couldn't pronounce a sequence of some syllables. This was known. And we admire, meditate and listen to quran for it's different kinds of recitations. Why does he get mad? Because he didn't know before hand
Atomizer now you are lying, there is BIG differences
Quran is not like your Bible, which is changed, omitted and has no original language of revelation. The oldest is the king James version. No one knows who Paul, peter, John and Mark are, but they made into bible without knowing who they were. No aramaic or original hebrew bible until now. So, cry for wishing muslims to have the same mess you have with your thousands of different bibles, which verses and interpretations added each year. An worst of all, is that they are contradicting each other. Unlike quran which is kept both in Oral recitation and written. Am i lying? Are you so impulsive and ready to accuse me that easy and call me a liar? Learn arabic, if you are serious or die with your rage, if you are a hater. Quran and arabic are living, while the language of the bible are dead and no longer used. Quran has 10 recitations which is our historic treasure and they are all known and they all have some minor vocal or consonant differences, but not something you can call corruption as your friend claims here.
Keep up the great work brother.
May God bless you!
Ran fer ruclips.net/video/3ye8WXeFlm4/видео.html 😀
What great work? This video was an embarrasment for him😭😭😭
@@ashley_brown6106 wrong. He proved that the Quran is not perfectly preserved.
@@electro639 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣lol😒
And if you are in doubt about what We have sent down upon Our Servant [Muhammad], then produce a surah the like thereof and call upon your witnesses other than Allah, if you should be truthful.
Al quran 2: 23
Brother, Instead of wasting your efforts on making vids etc and trying to find errors in the quran by explaining it in the way 'you' understand it.....why not just take up the challenge of the Quran and produce a chapter or something like it??
Wouldnt that be alot more productive for you in achieving your goal...!
I guess verse 24 explains why you dont attempt it.
As a non muslim, who was raised in a an Islamic country and and a native speaker of Arabic. I don't need anyone to tell me what Islam is. I know Islam very well and understand the Islamic mentality that hates the non muslims and suppress women. My people suffered from racism, violence, and even killing. Churches were attacked and burned. Thank God I have immigrated to Western country, I see muslims here enjoy freedom of religion and worship. What people don't understand that they're multiplying like rabbots, and aim one day to rule the Western countries. I wish my kids won't see what we saw in the future, this is my nightmare.
Don't rely on you government as it will do NOTHING, you people need to urgently wake and make an action and protest before it's too late, otherwise and your kids will pay the price!!!
ربنا يرحمنا ويرحمكم
Good to see you my brother in Christ! Keep up the great work! God bless you!
sldeyo Christanity is just a laughable as Islam lmao.. oh when will you idiots ever learn
@ Tyrion Lannister
"Christanity is just a laughable as Islam lmao.. oh when will you idiots ever learn"
You've never read either the Bible nor the Quran, much less done a study comparing the two.
It's also hilarious to me when illiterate people who can't spell or punctuate call others "idiot." Thanks for the laugh! Now, anything to say on the content of this video?
Yesica1993 Ahhhh yes the assumptions.... typical! I was actually a Muslim for 18yrs lol, and yes I've read the Holy Babble and the Quran, multiple times. Laugh harder everytime
tyrion... you sure? you don't have bad childhood memories that makes you do that? If I am right... you think God is not real because your life was a mess...
Tyrion Lannister - being a muslim for 18 years doesnt mean you have read the quran. We know many muslims dont read it
Thank you for strengthening my imaan(faith..).As Allah the All-Wise,the All-knowing says in His Glorious Quran :
وَقَالَت طَّائِفَةٌ مِّنْ أَهْلِ الْكِتَابِ آمِنُوا بِالَّذِي أُنزِلَ عَلَى الَّذِينَ آمَنُوا وَجْهَ النَّهَارِ وَاكْفُرُوا آخِرَهُ لَعَلَّهُمْ يَرْجِعُونَ (72)
English Translation - Sahih international
And a faction of the People of the Scripture say [to each other], "Believe in that which was revealed to the believers at the beginning of the day and reject it at its end that perhaps they will abandon their religion (3-72)
Btw,you may (may not) want to know that all your silly allegations had been crushed centuries and centuries ago..so,it's just some nerds here and there who keep trying to force it as much as they can,changing their strategies,faces,tongues,..and even their own identities over and over (as long as their master satan is still breithing) fooling the fools and cooking the rules...Yet,The light stand shinning high for all who see,while your corruption stay unchanged bringing darkness and confusion upon those who have never seen a light for they already blind.
Even your own bible expose your wickedness.Let's see a hint..:
BIBLE'S TESTIMONY TOWARD THE SCRIBES
------------------------------------
[Jer. 8:8]
How can you say we are wise and the law of the Lord is with us. Behold,
THE FALSE PEN OF THE SCRIBES TURNED IT INTO A LIE.
[Jer. 6:10]
Behold, the word of the Lord is unto them a reproach, they have no delight
in it.. From the least of them even unto the greatest of them, every one is
given to covetousness, and FROM THE PROPHET EVENT UNTO THE PRIEST, EVERY ONE
DEALS FALSELY.
Proud to be a Muslim..Hope my comment doesn't get removed (that'll only make it clearer than ever )..And,see you soon.Pity !
Jamal Gharib mashallah
But Can u refute his assumptions ?
Alhamdulilah ❤️
@@algerianatheist5854
YES WE CAN REFUTE THEM AND VERY EASILY. SEE MY POST
ALHAMDULILLAH! Good post ahki!
The meaning is exactly same arabic is very rich language.
The Arabic language is then so rich that anything then can mean anything, as suits there best for your situation.
If the Quran was really dictated by Allah then I would not expect any variation but the exact words that Allah said.
ruclips.net/video/LzSyGjsd9jY/видео.html watch then give proof
Thank you for your research, through this video I noticed how big the contradiction and gaps in the Bible books are compared to Quran.
In all the mentioned differences you found in the narrative books of the Quran , the meaning of the verse don't change, but realy they complement each other.
The Quran is supposed to be the perfect uncreated word of God that is completely preserved down to every dot and letter.
The problem is you muslims, pressume Quaran is "perfect" with these clues given by the brother is just confirming that Islam is another false relgion.You should be worried. Christians believe in what Jesus did on the cross,you believe in a man that supposely was illuminated by an "angel" and following a book that clearly is a man made.May God guide you to the Light of Jesus.Amen
@@nando1968can what is the no perfect points that you find in Quran ! do you speak and know arabic ? what we belive is that God is my god and your god (Allahe - Allohem), the One the powerful nothing compared to him the god of Adem created from no mother and father god of Jesus created from no father and Muhamed from father and mother and all creations. you have all messages and you are free to decide by your selfs and searche by your selfs not to folow what the preachers ,you have quran and you have bible and both have the same messages God is one and Jesus is the messenger. as well as more messenger befor him and mohamed after him
Very funny, so "has fought" and "has killed" are the same. Allah has clearly not protected his word from corruption and Islam is false
@@kth66 yes both are correct the vese said whith Mohammed some peopel has fought and has killed , tho one who fought has killed , or he one killed was fighting....not even an extra word ....thus where did you read Allah has protected his word ? Allah in quran said he will protect the Dhikr. the remembred verses not the readable verses go study arabic maybe you can see well other to follow thos lie
Awesome Literary exegesis of the failed book of Islam. All of us who study Islam and love our dear Muslim friends and families are deeply encouraged by your hard work of exposing the truth about the Quran. Thank You Brother!!! I can literally see Jesus Christ in your eyes as you bring your excellent scholarship to the debate between The Truth and The Deception. God bless you and protect you from the works of darkness Always!! In the Mighty Name of Christ Jesus, Amen!!
Craig Nelson. Amen.
Wow isn't it rude to say my religion is fake?
Your religion, has mistakes
Examples
-holy ghost
-his son was older than his father
So much more stop being mean!
@@glitchmaster5548 Islam is fake and it's a threat for humanity.
@@electro639 (Deuteronomy 20:14)
(14 As for the women, the children, the livestock and everything else in the city, you may take these as plunder for yourselves. And you may use the plunder the Lord your God gives you from your enemies.)
(Samuel 15:3)
(Now go, attack the Amalekites and totally destroy[a] all that belongs to them. Do not spare them; put to death men and women, children and infants, cattle and sheep, camels and donkeys)
yeah as in your bible killing child is ok damn look who are threat for humanity
Always wait for your video, and as usual great video, well done 👍
May Allah grant you to Jannah for your magnificent works that you have done....Amen🤲🏼💟
He died? 😳
@@Debater1 no
Surah Al-Hijr, Verse 9:
إِنَّا نَحْنُ نَزَّلْنَا الذِّكْرَ وَإِنَّا لَهُ لَحَافِظُونَ
Surely We have revealed the Reminder (Quraan) and We will most surely be its guardian.
via iQuran
The entire Quran was memorized verbatim (word for word) by many of the Prophet’s Companions (males and females). Among them were Zaid ibn Thabit, Ubayy ibn Ka’b, Muadh ibn Jabal, and Abu Zaid.
Abu Bakr decided to appoint Zaid ibn Thabit to compile all of the written verses of the Qur’an into one collection, using only those verses which had been written in the presence of the Prophet ﷺ himself. These manuscripts would then be verified by those who had memorised the entire Qur’an at the hands of the Prophet himself. This was where the important concept of tawatur, or multiply attested sources, came into play. In order to be 100% sure that a verse of the Quran was in fact a verse of the Quran, it needed to have multiple independent chains of transmissions from different memorisers of the Quran. In this way, any verse that came to Zaid could be corroborated through both written and oral means, essentially guaranteeing that every single verse put in the final book was conveyed by the Prophet ﷺ. Once this had been completed by Zaid, he penned the completed text which became known as the Suhuf, and gave it to Abu Bakr. This was now the official text of the Qur’an.
Narrated Ibn `Abbas: The Prophet (peace be upon him) was the most generous amongst the people, and he used to be more so in the month of Ramadan when Gabriel visited him, and Gabriel used to meet him on every night of Ramadan till the end of the month. The Prophet (peace be upon him) used to recite the Holy Qur'an to Gabriel, and when Gabriel met him, he used to be more generous than a fast wind (which causes rain and welfare).
(Sahih al-Bukhari, Book 30, Hadith 12)
No other religious scripture was compiled with such accuracy...
Other Arabic Quraans available today are translations into different local arabic dialects, or different editions/fonts/tafsers etc...
ruclips.net/video/kyzLXIKkpXA/видео.html
ruclips.net/video/K8Ck9ITtIQM/видео.html
Quraan Preservation;
ruclips.net/video/n281Zyywyn4/видео.html
ruclips.net/user/shortstSBk0d-OCUY?feature=share
www.letmeturnthetables.com/2012/10/ibn-umar-irreparable-much-quran-loss.html?m=1 Hu
@@Shahid-if4ws quran was not preserved and was corrupted, Sunan Ibn Majah 1944, Mishkat al-Masabih 2221, Sahih Bukhari 4987, Sahih al-Bukhari 4993, Sahih al-Bukhari 5038, Sahih al-Bukhari 5039, Sahih al-Bukhari 5669, Sahih al-Bukhari 4679, Sahih al-Bukhari 4986, Sahih Muslim 1050, Sahih al-Bukhari 4090, Sahih al-Bukhari 6830, Sahih al-Bukhari 5037b, Sahih al-Bukhari 5005, Sahih al-Bukhari 4788. (Q2:106) and (16:101) why would allah cause a verse to be forgotten, and why would he need to send something similar or better and how could a send something better from the original verse he had already revealed, (allah changes his mind and makes new quran) yet his words can't be changed and are eternal hmm allah words are not perfect. allah words can't be changed verses (Q 6:115) (Q 10:64) (Q18:27)
@@Sancho.
Seems like you are confused. Allah is God and has the right to reveal and abrogate Verses if He wishes;
ruclips.net/video/b-jUNj1nego/видео.html
Thank you so much brother your research helped me alot but ur recitation of quran I feel ur getting it from english translation mashallah my imaan is getting stronger 🤗 love u bro
Those are not different 'versions'! The Quran was revealed to the Prophet PUBH in 7 different narrations or styles (Ahruf) and he recited those 7 different narrations. The full explanation can be found here: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ahruf
@@Planet_XplorerUthman burned all but 1 ahruf. No one even knows what the Ahruf are
@@vierbrandon All those Ahurf and Quraat were approved by the Prophet himself and had the same context but slightly different styles to make it easier for those from very far areas to recite Quran in the style they are familiar with. The English language is similar to this concept. There's American English, British English, Irish English, Australian English, etc...they are different styles that don't contradict each other so burning them doesn't make difference. Uthman burnt them because the Islamic empire became extremely large in a very short time and many of the Prophet's companions who are Quran experts and were used as a reference since they heard it from the Prophet himself were dying so he wanted to make sure that future generations have an accurate, well presrved Quran which is the case till today, 1500 years later.
@@Planet_Xplorer the hafs Quran says in 2:10 "they lie" but in the doori Quran in 2:9 it says "they accuse others of lying", which is correct?
@@Planet_Xplorer they literally contradict each other. Dont forget your pedophile said the sun sets in a pool Dawud 4002
I'm Arab i know the language well,i did see what you are calling differences or contradiction and my conclusion is i believe in Quran better than before and that makes me thinking about reading all the recitations to know more about Islam, trust me I'm happy to know this
word for word, letter for letter? There is no doubt that Allah lied to you when he said that. He is gonna protect the Quran, And no one will ever be able to touch it. Enternal WORD of Allah?
Come to the true God, don't find excuses. Look for the TRUTH. May God bless you and your Family.
@@Snoopdog8888 QS. Al-Hijr Ayat 9
Verily, it is We who sent down the Qur'an, and surely We (also) will preserve it.
The Quran claims to guard it, doesn't it word for word, letter for letter as you say
@@Snoopdog8888 Those are not different 'versions'! The Quran was revealed to the Prophet PUBH in 7 different narrations or styles (Ahruf) and he recited those 7 different narrations. The full explanation can be found here: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ahruf
@@Snoopdog8888 Nonsense, and both the Bible & the Qur’an say that God (ﷻ) is One, not Three!
הַתַּנַ"ךְְ: הַתּוֹרָה:
דְּבָרִים ו: שְׁמַע, יִשְׂרָאֵל: יְהוָה אֱלֹהֵינוּ, יְהוָה אֶחָד. ﴿ד﴾
ٱَلۡـقُـرۡأٓنَ، سُـوۡرَةُ ٱلۡإِخۡـلَاصِ
قُلْ هُوَ اللهُ أَحَدٌ ﴿١﴾ اللهُ الصَّمَدُ ﴿٢﴾ لَمْ يَلِدْ وَلَمْ يُولَدْ ﴿٣﴾ وَلَمْ يَكُن لَّهُ كُفُوًا أَحَدٌ ﴿٤﴾
So who invented the concept of Trinity,
when Muhammad, Jesus, John the Baptist, Zechariah, Job, Jonah, Elisha, Elijah, Solomon, David, Samuel, Aaron, Moses, Shu‘ayb, Joseph, Jacob, Isaac, Ishmael, Lot, Abraham, Salih, Hud, Noah, Enoch, Adam and other Prophets (عَـلَـيۡـہِـمُ ٱلـصَّـلَاةُ وَٱلـسَّـلَامُ) preached Monotheism, not Trinitarianism?
@@ramizparkar4199 how many names has allah?
trinitarianisem is not tritheisem
Dear brothers and sisters, I have done research of my own and believe this will answer some of your doubts regarding Islam,
This very important verse(refer to video=1:26), however, have been misunderstood by millions of Muslims. The misinformation was spread by some of the Muslim scholars who did not grasp the meaning or purpose behind this verse.
For centuries the Muslim scholars have been teaching the Muslim masses that by verse 15:9, God means He will protect the Mus-haf of any distortion or changes. The mus-haf is the Arabic name for the book in which the Quran is collected. Many Muslims refer to the Mus-haf as the Quran for short and both words have been used interchangeably. However the promise in 15:9, as we will see, has nothing to do with what the people write down as the Quran but rather it refers to the actual Quran placed into prophet Muhammad's heart, 26:194, and preserved in master tablets at God Almighty.
This is just a misunderstanding, you will be forgiven by Allah if you truly seek forgiveness as he is the most merciful
Just try doing more research before you claim something is wrong
And I believe this comment clears most of the doubt of the whole video
wikiislam.net/wiki/Main_Page
Omg this is the truth. May allah bless you sir
@@panis4952
You know this is just lies?
@@octavioust.talium9110 how???
Am arabic native and i didnt see any thing changing ..bro. go n study arabic first
@Tsürong IMC speaking and reading are two different things. this so-called ishmael can only read.
ruclips.net/video/LzSyGjsd9jY/видео.html
he knows Arabic more than you if you didn't see anything changing😂😂😂 I'm Turkish and reading Arabic and know the different
@@serkanorhan6270 lol. He know Arabic more than us? Biggest joke of the century.
Well explained with arabi. Hope Muslims should begin to study koran critically and teach the innocent mass
damn my man. I remember years ago you sound just like bin Laden.
congrats for leaving this cult. much love
Leonard Wattimena same lol
woww..serious conflict !!!!😂😂😂. The cover and colour also different.😂😂😂
😂😂😂🤣🤣
lol doesn't really change the meaning. lmao dude. do you know what textual change really means
😄😄😄
@FEAR KCP the cover and color changes the meaning????????? Lmaooo i cant believe this 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😭😂😭
None of you people payed any attention to the video did you…
I know a REAL christian would not do these videos INSTEAD a REAL christian would respect other religions including ISLAM. Just remember Don’tconvert2Islam it’s not sincere to do this.
Just some letters in a word that are different due to different narrations , now do comparison of two main versions of bible let's see if the bible can hold
The claim was that the Quran was perfectly transmitted until today. You again forget what the purpose of this video is.
@@Sp3ll633 i did my research and found out that meaning does not change when specefic letters change , there something in arabic called al-IRAAB basicly it's syntax of the arabic language , this dude has just critisied the quran without having the knowledge of arabic syntax
@@Sp3ll633 Why are there different books in Protestant and Catholic Bible? Why do Mormons and JW have completely different books? I know Christians who also claim the Bible is the words of god. I didn’t know YHWH can’t make up his mind on how many books.
Thank you for your courage, bravery and example.
This person is telling lie it is types of reading quran which is called Qirat....Quran is only one.....
Different recitations of quran
ruclips.net/video/PxSbGeW5Kko/видео.html
@@ibwttindwtbwbaaibwtmihsam3947 OMG WE KNOW IT HAS DIFFERENT RECITATIONS, THATS THE BEAUTY OF IT, U can recite it in different ways!
@@agcollection6299 There is a difference in the meanings, and because Arabic is my mother tongue, so I confirm what he said in the video. There is a big difference in the meanings and letters, such as the example mentioned in the video: Feeding a poor person (singular) or poor people (plural). This is a difference in meaning. So stop defending your religion with lies and accept the truth
@@drk7971
bro your disscussion with no knowldge has no meaning you dont know any things about qiraat and follow a book that tells you to kill cheildren and womens
(Samuel 15:3)
(Now go, attack the Amalekites and totally destroy[a] all that belongs to them. Do not spare them; put to death men and women, children and infants, cattle and sheep, camels and donkeys) learn before talk bro learn before talk
How educated you are, brother! You are a beacon of truth in this confused world.
There are dozens of videos refuting him, unfortunately.
@@user-nu7fo3tc4b yes, and they all arrive at the pre determined conclusion using the question begging fallacy.
@@tracybeckett4107 Um no but okay. We don’t have to lie and be dishonest with ourselves now.
@@tracybeckett4107 As you are not familiar with Arabic language it is difficult to explain to an arrogant person. basically the rasm al-Othmany still allows some "linguistic interpretation" as at the time the Arabic language didn't consist of 29/30 letters and most of that amount was of letters which looked the same (as I stated in my answer of the Question about qira'aat)... but let's start with the example given from surat al-Humazah 104 سورة الهمزة:
Basically the difference between yahsibu and yahsabu is in the diacritics it is a common difference between two linguistic schools which applies for any incident of this verb in the whole Quran:
Let's say the rasm al-'Othmany is this:
يحسب
Now the reading of 'Asim عاصم (from al-Kufa) the teacher of Hafs حفص and Sho'aba شعبة , ibn 'Amir ابن عامر (from a-Shaam) and Hamzah حمزة (from al-Kufa) is yahsabu:
يَحْسَبُ
While the rest of the seven quraa' like Nafi' نافع (Medina) teacher of Warsh ورش and Qalun قالون, Abu Amr (from Basra), al-Kissa'iy الكسائي (from al-Kufa) and ibn Kathir ابن كثير (from Mekka) were reading it yahsibu:
يَحْسِبُ
This also applies to other present conjugations of the verb hasiba حسب:
يحسبهم, يحسبون, يحسبه ...
Other differences in surat al-Humazah:
Note: If I say instead of "x" I mean that "x" is the reading followed by the majority among the 7 qiraa't!
Ibn 'Amir, Hamzah and al-Kissa-iy read in (102:2) with an emphasized "m":
جَمَّعَ (jamma'a) instead of جَمَعَ (jama'a)
Hafs the student of 'Asim (only), Abu 'Amr and Hamzah read here and in (90:20)
مُؤْصَدَة (mo'sada) with an extra hamzah (ء) instead of مُوصَدَة (moosada).
Note that these kinds of hamzah were "too heavy" for most Arabic tribes so Quraish never used to pronounce it while Hudhail used to taht's why they primiraly appear in most Kufi-qiraa't as they were following the reading of the hudhali sahabi Abudullah ibn Masu'd for a long time before accepting the rasm al-'Othmany.
Al-Kufa readers ('Asim, al-Kissa'iy and Hamzah and their students) except for Hafs read (104:9):
عُمُدٍ ('omodin) instead of عَمَدٍ ('amadin)
None of these differences has an impact of the meaning! It is like a word that can be spelled or pronounced in different ways.
This is a link to audio files of the Egyptian Sheikh of qiraa't Ahmad al-Ma'srawy أحمد المعصراوي were you may find the 10 different qiraat of the Quran to compare surat al-Humazah is apparently always present, normally all 20 riwayas (narrations) should be available, but on this link some are not (Hafs is the most striking absent one!). Maybe you can find the missing ones on an other rather salafi site called islamway.com.
Examples of general rulings in the seven qiraa't
Be aware that some difference come from "technical" tajweed details such as how and when to prolong a letter etc.:
For example the reading of Hamzah is well known for their special diacritic for example were ever you may read "عليهم" ('alayhim), "إِليهم" (ilayhim) and "لَديهم" (ladayhim) he reads it "عليهُم" (alayhom), "إِليهُم" (ilayhom) and "لَديهُم" (ladayhom) which in standard and spoken Arabic sounds rather strange!Ibn Kathir and Warsh are adding the diacritic "dama" to the "m" of plural if a neutral diacritic is following in the next word like "عليهم" ('alayhim) which they read "عليهمُ" (alayhimoo) ...Hamzah and Hisham (the student of ibn 'Amir) use to do a slight pause on each hamzah (ء) following some special rulings.I could go more in details, but I'm afraid that wouldn't be helpful. A last example: If you went to Morocco or Algeria or any country where the reading of Warsh is prevalent you may notice in the adhan that the "L" of as-salat الصلاة in "Hayya a'la as-salat" is emphasized and sounds like "as-soloh" or "as-soloht". This is a kind of impact of the reading in the local Arabic "dialect". So Warsh is known to emphasize some "lam's"
@@user-ws3sw8vp3x Muslims will go to any lengths to defend their false religion, now I guess that includes you. If the Arabic language was incomplete and could be misinterpreted, then Allah was a fool to send it to the illiterate self proclaimed desert prophet. He could have sent it to China which had a thriving culture and an advanced language established, but he didn’t, because it’s all a myth that Jay Smith utterly proves in his lectures on RUclips. He proves that mohammed and the rightly guided caliphs never even existed! You need to watch his latest CIRA international channel, then you will leave Islam and regret all the time wasted, believing such falsehood.
Thank you for your studies. While hearing your presentation, I noticed other verses were the same between the two Korans. So that all the differences that you show compared to the around 6000 verses of the Koran are very few. And if we pay attention, to these different words, if the harakat and dots are removed, they will have the same written form. This is what is meant by the 7 recitations (7 Ahruf) where Umar and Hisham once argued in front of the prophet and the prophet justified them both. So, the difference in recitations is not a problem. Impact theologically? There isn't any. It will not change the Muslim faith in Allah and other pillars of faith. I thought why the Islamic world allows this difference to this day? Don't the scholars know? Of course! But they have studied it and let these differences become the treasury of the cultural riches of the Koran. As it has been read and memorized since ancient times in each Islamic region.
it has been 1400 years dude , never said quran is corrupted , it is your heart broken ...
Sorry, but this is a very pathetic argument
99% of the verses barely differ in meaning and they are methods of RECITING the Quran only changing the orthography. If a person follows the warsh version say for example, but 90% of the people follow the hafs version, it is said that the hafs version is correct. "As the Quran's propagation was en masse from the time of the Prophet, it has continued its propagation in the same manner. Therefore, only such a majority recitation as the one recited today in 95% of the Muslim world would be reconcilable with verse 15:9 which confirms God's own protection of the message." With that being said anyone after the time of when the Quran was revealed may change, add or modify by MAKING new version of the Quran, this does NOT mean that the ORIGINAL Quran is 'corrupted' and that GOD fulfilled his promise. Also the Prophet (peace and blessings upon him) said to stick with the majority.
If you were to spend half the time analysing Christianity, you would not have became a Christian at all, mark my words (no I am not exaggerating). Christianity is the source of corruption, but for some reason you don't look at the different versions of the bible, yet love to criticize Islam. Something seems fishy, but I will give you the benefit of the doubt.
Please reply
May ALLAH guide you
when we start making counter-arguments to uninformed, ignorant arguments you either:
1) Block us (as shown by David Wood)
2) Change the topic
3) insult us
4) do 3 & 4 and once again throw pathetic childish arguments
On top of that, you people love talking so much about IQ and intellect but instead you people are very pretentious and condescending. It is up to you to either follow him and be happy the way you live or the harder approach is actually finding the truth about Islam from Islam itself, quite frankly I am done with your type of people
My brother he is a shytaan in human form
Ace M
1) you can’t block at youtube
2) that’s what you are doing right now lol
3) you just did that in the last paragraph
4) sounds familiar
+Ace M : Why don’t you take your own advice and study Christianity for yourself then compare. Look at the facts in your own sources and compare them to the examples being cited in these videos. Not listening to scholars, but use the sense God gave you. Is what is being demonstrated the same thing you discover when you look yourself?
Why do you think the Bible has been corrupted? Where’s your evidence? I’m not going to accept Islamic evidence (because Islam denies historical facts). Produce for me a non-theological source that demonstrates incontrovertible evidence that the Bible has been changed or ‘corrupted’ over time.
You can’t make baseless accusations without proof. You have to use the same methodology for criticizing Islam as you do for criticizing Christianity. See how your own beliefs pass that level of criticism. Will it succeed? Of course not.
So be fair or stop prattling on about nonsense. No one is going to adopt your hateful attitude or accept your beliefs. Why? Because we have peace and joy. Who on earth would want to trade that in for the hate, anger and rage all Muslims seem to suffer from.
You see... the difference between you and me? I love you and don’t want to see you in Hell. I want you to share in the same comfort and joy I have the honor to live with because of Christ. I want for you only good things.
Like most Muslims, you believe that Christians are out to “corrupt” you or challenging your beliefs out of hatred for Muslims and Islam. That is not the case. Christians try to lead you to the truth with your own sources as evidence, because we don’t want anything bad to happen to you. We want you to be safe and secure as a child of God. We don’t want you to lose your soul, we want you to have the gift of Salvation!
Perhaps you should take a moment and do a quick search on RUclips. There’s a video with several different Muslims who died (temporarily) and went to Hell. They ultimately met Jesus (who allowed them to return to earth, so they could warn others that Hell is real and Jesus is the only way to Jannah). They were devout Muslims and ended up in Hell... think about that a moment.
This is not a game. This is our one shot in life and we have to be right. We can’t change our minds once we’ve died - our destination is set.
Seek God honesty and humbly. If you’re truly wanting to please God, you won’t worry about what ‘religion’ you have to be... you will ask HIM to guide you to the Truth. Honestly ask Him!!!! Ask Him, just tell Him you want to know if the Christians are right or if you are doing right in Islam. If you’re doing this with sincerity and humbleness - He _will_ reveal it to you. I am _positive_ of it! Most Muslims who end up Christians have had some supernatural encounter. I don’t know if you will or not, I can’t say. I know some have had dreams, others have literally been taken to Hell and shown what would await them, some have had first-hand visions. Then there’s some who haven’t been able to get Jesus out of their minds. One thing is sure... God always honors the prayer of someone sincerely, humbly and with an open heart seeking Him. If you’re approaching Him with anger, distrust, doubt or any other issue of pride, etc.; He won’t honor your prayer. Why? Because He doesn’t hear the prayers of sinners, only a prayer of repentance.
If you wanted to, the first thing you could do is ask God for forgiveness and admit to Him that you’re a sinner and you are seeking to know the Truth and to know Him for Who He is and on His terms. Then allow HIM to guide you!
You can use the term “God” versus “Allah” (unless you’re praying in Arabic, then I am sure you could say Allah as long as you’re not appealing to the deity Islam defines as ‘Allah’). Which is why I recommend English, because they are distinct (YHWY and Allah).
Give Him a chance. In Islam you will never have a relationship with Him, because your Allah is a father to no one. God isn’t like that. He truly loves you. The only thing He wants is for you to love and seek Him.
Seriously, please ask for guidance. I am positive that you will find out the truth.
Peace to you.
ruclips.net/video/nfZBfuDMV_g/видео.html
God bless you. Muslims claim that everything they do is for God, when in reality they're just putting words into God's mouth.
BINGO
SirLangsalot
watch debate (the quran and the Bible in light of science) between dr Zakir Naik and dr. William Campbell
SirLangsalot how DARE you say that about islam you know NOTHING so dont say what you dont know
Youre pretty wrong muslims pray 5times a day for themselves to go to heaven
There are many different tribes and different places, and it is known that different habits and habits vary in different environments. This is the language as well. Each environment has certain words that may not be based on the dialects of other environments. It was the companions of the Arabs, however, that the difference of their tribes and their citizens led to the individualization of each tribe with some words that may not be known by the other tribes, although all Arabs, and the Holy Quran came to address everyone, so the Quran took care of this, , The facilitation of the nation, and the emergence N it is the cause of the multiplicity of readings.
And the frequent conversations about the descent of the Quran on seven characters
The seven letters are seven aspects of which there is no difference in the readings:
1- The names differ from individuals, Deuteronomy, collection, remembrance, and femininity.
2 - different conduct of acts of past and present and ordered.
3 - different expressions of expression.
4 - difference in the shortage and increase.
5. Difference in presentation and delay.
6- Difference in substitution.
7 - different languages - any dialects - such as openness and tilt, and exaggeration, and lamentation, and show and diction
I love you man! just found this channel and really need more of these videos!
I have been together with a Muslim girl for two years and we just now broke up because I simply could not convert. I really studied the Quran but it is so full of verses, which simply do not align with my moral standards.
still I feel really bad and guilty for breaking up over such reasons, but I just wouldn't want to teach my kids a book of hatred and fear.
so thoroughly researched videos like these might finally help me find clarity!
Which book you been reading my brother?
Hatred and fear?
If everyone follows Quran this world would be perfect!
Hope you get the truth before your end!
If you dont believe in something are you just trying to please her then?
Wait fear and hatred, where?
Brother go open your eyes and look up on the right sources, your here on RUclips listening to someone who is always trying to make a video trying to prove the Quran is wrong and what not. I recommend you to read the Quran and other scriptures then only you will come to know the truth and do you research.
@@onlyinrebeltube7692 i have read them. it's not for me. all of this made me realize i'm an agnostic.
thank you and all the best
With all due respect, the gentleman in these videos has a modest knowledge and understanding of the Arabic language. He only takes it at face value . I Suggest to the Bother to learn much more about pure Arabic, not just a few words (which I must admit his pronunciation is fairly good). It took me more than 20 years to have some kind of deeper understanding of the language has much more than meets the eyes; were one word has many meaning depending on the context. That being said, I truly believe the gentleman is seeking the truth and looking for it, I really hope he will find it one day no matter what that truth to him is and give him peace of mind,heart and soul. Bless you all.
Humbly Your’s
Brother In Humanity.
Alhamdulillah..
Thank you my brother..
You show me that there is no different with those two Quran..
All the differences you mention just because "harakat" system..
The old texts of Quran doesn't have any harakat..
The one, two or three dot and slash ot comma sign in upper and lower letter to make vocal and differentiate letter..
So, if you remove all of the harakat from both version.. it will be EXACTLY THE SAME..
The letter Noon and Ya' are the same without dot system..
Thank you brother..
You make my faith getting stronger..🔥🔥🔥
May Allah bless you with your good work..!
Greeting from Java, Indonesia
☕🙏🏻😄🇮🇩
The Hafs version is a 2nd form verb, while the Warsh version has an extra alif to make a 4th form verb. This intensifies the meaning of the verb. The two words are recited differently but have the same meaning. They are two different examples of the 8th form jussive verb. Even Google claims that they are the same. Nice Try Buddy But Never happening😂. DONTCONVERT2CHRISTIANITY
Great post! Just to add. These variants were *acknowledged by the prophet himself* . *Even the word order is the same* in the examples he gave. Exact same order.
You are great sir Esmail, i see ur videos from morroco, but we need a translatin text in arabic and frensh language. Thank u sir
Sara Eloua
Assalama alaikoem, Why?
Zack Smith hi please can you tell why the difference between the two books
ruclips.net/video/LzSyGjsd9jY/видео.html
also the son of omar ibn khattab son said no one can indefinitely say they have the whole quran.
Sir, the differences mentioned are from dotting differences, or addition or omitting the "madda", a.k.a "A" letter from the basic form of words. There will be Muslims who would cite the Hadith where the prophet of Islam said it has been revealed in 7 reading by God. Have you come by additions or substractions of letters or words by any chance?
I speak Arabic and I'm laughing now hilarious.
Cuz what you just said didn't change any meaning..
Nothing...
It's the same.. As you claim serious conflict 😂
But, nice try brother. I pray this effort you put in some much you put into some serious good arguments. Peace
Let him be happy in his world...akhi😅
This video is one of the best on RUclips regarding differences in the multitude of different Arabic Qurans. Very clearly explained. Thank you Don'tConvert2Islam.
Good work! Not so incorruptible it seems!
It is a well-known fact that there are seven different ahrûf in which the Quran was revealed. This was because different Arabs spoke Arabic a bit differently. The errors pointed out here are not errors as these differences were caused by the same ahrûf factor BUT the way it was written in each type of Arabic differed in alphabets because the words were pronounced differently yet meant the same. The errors indicated here in the translation is caused because of being translated [ignoring ahrûf] in the same type of Arabic rather than in the one that it actually was. Therefore it is the mistake in translation rather than the Quran which is still well preserved. By the way unintentionally this video is in a way helping save the Quran from being corrupted by showing how it might get corrupt in future even when it will not.
Tmw someone brings a different font of Arabic and says it's textually different. This was akin to having something in Times new Roman and Calibri. The skeletal Arabic is the same and the meaning doesn't change
Please my friend can you put a link to dowload these pages so that I can show them to my muslim friends who pretend the bible is corrupted and not the quran?
Sincere congratulations to you.Some convert to mormonism, others to Jehova's witnesses, some others to the adventist church, others to buddhaism,hindouism, not mentionning judaism and christianity.Everyone needs to believe in something but that doesn't mean that what you feel in your bosom is true.Never mind you chosed to take a pedophile as a role model I wish you will not follow his example ;)
show them this hadith also:
Malik Ibn Anas reported that the second Rashidun Caliph Umar Ibn al-Khattab said: "I heard Hisham Ibn Hakim Ibn Hizam reading Surat Al-Furqan in a different way from the one I used to read it, and the Prophet himself had read out this surah to me. Consequently, as soon as I heard him, I wanted to get hold of him. However, I gave him respite until he had finished the prayer. Then I got hold of his cloak and dragged him to the Prophet. I said to him: “I have heard this person [Hisham Ibn Hakim Ibn Hizam] reading Surah Al Furqan in a different way from the one you had read it out to me.” The Prophet said: “Leave him alone [O ‘Umar].” Then he said to Hisham: “Read [it].” [Umar said:] “He read it out in the same way as he had done before me.” [At this,] the Prophet said: “It was revealed thus.” Then the Prophet asked me to read it out. So I read it out. [At this], he said: “It was revealed thus; this Quran has been revealed in seven Ahruf. You can read it in any of them you find easy from among them."
Funny how you translate Diker (ذكرة) To quran (قران)
Read the verse on any Islamic website it just says Quran
If you look at the countries that use warsh, using their dialect, the hafs words would not retain meaning in these nations. This isnt a corruption, but more like a translation.
www.free-minds.org/which-quran
Different recitations of quran
ruclips.net/video/PxSbGeW5Kko/видео.html
I am converting to Islam and I am so happy and I am 100% sure the Islam is the true religion there is no god except Allah and Jesus is the messenger of Allah
I swear by allah if you understand arabic you will found it more miraculously to know the wisdom In those deference Its not changing after the prophet.
as you mentioned its from the prophet's time Its a wisdom to have such a quran And I am asking allah to guide all of you who is seeking the truth Amen This is not a new idea for us as a muslim Because it itself is a miracle subhanallah Do learn it and try to look especially for this and it will let you more closely to quran I am happy to be a Muslim having such a book Thank you for your video bro
Actually you are wrong. If you learn Arabic and really know Arabic, the mistakes, contradictions, and fabrications are MORE ABUNDANT because all the errors are covered up by the translators to hide those mistakes, contradictions and silly things about this sham of a cult's prophet's utterances IF he actually did contribute the material to you for your fake prophet stole the writings in some parts from other cults he happened upon and incorporated the other cult's writings to put himself in the place of the other people who had visions. Case in point the night journey your prophet said he made, well that is confiscated from the Persian writings and besides his wife Aisha said 'he never left his bed'. Your prophet is a liar like his father the devil who spoke out of his mouth by YOUR prophet's OWN ADMISSION...
NO I know arabic its my mother language ... this things he said is nothing but misunderstanding ... for example in my prayers Sometimes I read by hafs Sometimes warsh ... and its a miracle itself to have this in the quran its deeply help to give you the great meaning of what allah said
If you look how you read quran with tajweed you will understand that this is how the prophet salla lahu alayhi wasallam recite it exactly look to the modod and the ghounnah wallahi you will just be sure that is the word of god
Well we do study it and like this man above he learned Arabic and found the errors and we did too. Weren't you commanded that IF you find errors and contradictions in the quran and sunnah you must DISCARD IT so in actuality the man above and we who see the errors have done that but you are still not finding the errors? That just shows you never really study it and when people show you the errors, contradictions and silliness you are too busy defending the mistakes.. Hafs was called a liar.
@@TheLionessjudah The Quran is the highest form of Arabic literature so you must have some strong heavy backing to claim that, because you have a lot of Arabic scholars, Muslim and non-Muslim, who also say it’s a very sophisticated form of literature. I as a Arab Christian when learning Arabic here, we use it and read from it.
@@user-nu7fo3tc4b The Quran is the highest form of Arabic literature? The word "Quran" isnt even Arabic. Its a transliteration from the Aramaic language as well as many other words just like the word Allah is a transliterated word from Eloha in Aramaic. Arabic is just an of shoot form of cursive from Aramaic. Arabic grammar in the Quran borrows heavily from Aramaic, Hebrew and Persian words. Just like English is a hybrid language and borrows from French, German and Latin etc. etc.. C'mon man....
He knows you dont speak Arabic and thats what he is depending on. The Quran was releaved on 7 different readings. One may differ from another just by changing one word or even one letter in the verse. But even with the change the meaning is still the same. What he didnt tell you was that those 7 ways of reading Quran was revealed by God too
exactly!
and he also pick and choose and leave out the whole meaning of what allah is saying, just like the jews doing with their torah.
what if i tell you that the way Muhammad received the revelation is a well known state in sanskritic scriptures?
@@imranragimov7781 all prophets received revelation the same way
@@abdulrhmana.elshiekh383the excuses is hilarious you didn’t watch the vid did you? How can Allah speak on 2 different ways with the same topic 💀
Nice work 👍
These variants were *acknowledged by the prophet himself* . I expected you was going to uncover the "great secret"! For example, misplaced words/misplaced verses/mixed up Sourates. *Even the word order is the same* in the examples you gave. Exact same order.
Try again!
john: i and he father are one
later in the bible: i can do nothing
so god cant do anything according to the bible
You say: Quran is corrupted because you found 8 examples of plural singular difference.
Can we talk about Bible, from A to Z you can't even find ONE word that can be traced back to the eyewitness, who can claim that they heard this word from the beautyful lips of Jesus Christ ?
If there indeed a such word in Bible, I love to see it.
Muslims critic of Bible enrage you, while Bible critic of her own self, consistent of 30,000 variation in it's text, seem like no problem for you the Bible believers, with nerve of finding errors in Quran.
God forbid if I were you guys, I would be the last person throwing rocks on my neighbors while living in the glass house.
Keep on trying Ismail, i can vision your next move to take refuge in Atheism lol.
The Quran on earth is supposed to be exactly the same as the one in heaven. Which one of all different Qurans is that please? Maybe it was burnt along with the others.
Remember Quran is nothing like Bible, where no one knows what were the words of god to base the faith upon ?
Quran words are indeed the same words which are in heaven .
When a Surah from heaven was revealed by the God of Universe, through Angel Gabriel, on Prophet Muhammad (pbuh), many eye witness would hear it, memorize it, and would write it down, what was burn was the additional copies of surah, if there were more than one, for the purpose that later down the road someone should not come up with the claim, that this is all of the Quran. Now let alone any corruption in A word of Quran, even as little as the pronunciation of each word of Quran is safe guarded.
I assume you are a Christian, and most likely believe, Jesus is (god forbid me saying that) son of your god, can you please tell me how did that happen ? Thanks
still not answered my question which is typical. oh and why did every other prophet hear the words from God himself and Mohammed did not? it was never said that it was Gabriel that came to Mohammed, and even Mohammed told his first wife what happened he himself thought he was going mad and wanted to kill himself. He only started to think he was hearing things from God, through an angel, because his first wife told him so. loooool. so if yr wife said this to you you would believe this? how come since a woman only is worth half of a man he believed her, surely it must have been a lie for a woman to have said this. lol. No other prophet felt this way. also, the angel sent by God did not know he could not read or write. come on. pull the other leg. Surely you can think outside the box and away from being brainwashed.
Is this is your most best answer to my comment ? I suggest you to re-read it and make some correction, after you get some basic knowledge of islam, coz you are refuting your own self in your comment.
keep being blind deaf and dumb, Keep in the dark. I do not try to gain brownie points ,, or beat someone, but if you cannot even see how your religion began, or should I say want to see the truth. so be it.
Sir, with all due respect to your efforts. I think you've missed out a key factor here. That being that the "garantee" of "guarding" the Qur'an was more a promise of preservation of the original text, rather than a promise that no variations would come about.
What completely baffles me is that an intelligent seeming man like yourself has completely missed that fact..
What also baffles me is that how can you consider this man intelligent? He comments on Quranic variant dialects and leaves out the corrupted bible and completely different versions of it?
What an idiotic argument... that defeats the whole purpose of preserving... you greek philosophy is unacceptable reply
I can say the same for you
I real love Quran I do not now what that you talk about
@@dssssa100 I am not sure what the Bible has to do with it ?
Firstly this Is a video about the Koran, which claims to be perfectly preserved but aparently isn’t.
Secondly this is not a video about the Bible, which does not claim to be perfectly preserved, and is not.
O God ! Please forgive the lady Allah and her servant muhammad.
Different versions dont matter, i am a muslim by choice, out of a comparison of all different religions i found this to be the most truthful, fair, and i dare say the best religion, the versions of the boom you mentioned may differ, when you put your hand out, if you look from each side you have a different view of the same thing, but we are required to look from up, think on it this way
2:47 but it doesn’t change the meaning of the sentence 😌👌🏻
Islam is a made up religion. MBS has gone public and said muhammad hadiths are pure BS. That be the case the quran is no better. Its all made up.
I think you don't know what words mean bruh. Quraan claimed no word was changed for 1400 years which makes it the truth. Well here it is proven quraan has words changed making it a contradiction of itself. Thus quraan is a lie. If you still defend Qur'an, I'm sure you will defend bigger problems with islam as well since you guys have no understanding of the word consistency. There's no hope for you.
😂😂😂 your Videos really enforce my believe in Islam and Quraan. after all you efforts you came up with these silly notes, which if you told to any Arabic child he will just smile at you. in the first comment a piece of quraan talking about quraan and a link to the reading
ruclips.net/video/ghoNVjV5tVs/видео.html
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂🤭🤭🤭🤭🤭🤭🤭🤭🤭🤭😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😁😁😁😁😁
The point is that the Quran is not perfectly preserved.
Get the original copy from Mecca not from publishers! Publishers change words for copy right reasons!
marco hanse ... why would they do that?
Anybody who has actually read and listened to the Quran with a good intention can not deny its truthfulness
You are like all muslim.brain washed
SALVATION
SALVATION IS A GIFT AND NOT OF WORKS, FOR ALL HAVE SINNED isaiah 64:6 KJV
But we are all as an unclean thing, and our righteousnesses are as filthy rags; and we all do fade as a leaf, our iniquities, like the wind, have taken us away.
Romans 3:23-24 KJV
For all have sinned, and come short of the glory of God; [24] Being justified freely by his grace through the redemption that is in Christ Jesus:
Romans 5:12 KJV
Wherefore, as by one man sin entered into the world, and death by sin; and so death passed upon all men, for that all have sinned:
Romans 6:23 KJV
For the wages of sin is death; but the gift of God is eternal life through Jesus Christ our Lord.
Ephesians 2:8-9 KJV
For by grace are ye saved through faith; and that not of yourselves: it is the gift of God: [9] Not of works, lest any man should boast.
Titus 3:5 KJV
Not by works of righteousness which we have done, but according to his mercy he saved us, by the washing of regeneration, and renewing of the Holy Ghost;
John 1:29 KJV
The next day John seeth Jesus coming unto him, and saith, Behold the Lamb of God, which taketh away the sin of the world.
Isaiah 53:4-6 KJV
Surely he hath borne our griefs, and carried our sorrows: yet we did esteem him stricken, smitten of God, and afflicted. [5] But he was wounded for our transgressions, he was bruised for our iniquities: the chastisement of our peace was upon him; and with his stripes we are healed. [6] All we like sheep have gone astray; we have turned every one to his own way; and the Lord hath laid on him the iniquity of us all.
John 3:3,5-7 KJV
Jesus answered and said unto him, Verily, verily, I say unto thee, Except a man be born again, he cannot see the kingdom of God. [5] Jesus answered, Verily, verily, I say unto thee, Except a man be born of water and of the Spirit, he cannot enter into the kingdom of God. [6] That which is born of the flesh is flesh; and that which is born of the Spirit is spirit. [7] Marvel not that I said unto thee, Ye must be born again.
John 6:51,53-54 KJV
I am the living bread which came down from heaven: if any man eat of this bread, he shall live for ever: and the bread that I will give is my flesh, which I will give for the life of the world.
John 8:24 KJV
I said therefore unto you, that ye shall die in your sins: for if ye believe not that I am he, ye shall die in your sins.
John 10:11 KJV
I am the good shepherd: the good shepherd giveth his life for the sheep.
John 14:6 KJV
Jesus saith unto him, I am the way, the truth, and the life: no man cometh unto the Father, but by me.
Acts 2:21 KJV
And it shall come to pass, that whosoever shall call on the name of the Lord shall be saved.
Romans 10:9 KJV
Romans 10:3-4 KJV
For they being ignorant of God's righteousness, and going about to establish their own righteousness, have not submitted themselves unto the righteousness of God. [4] For Christ is the end of the law for righteousness to every one that believeth.
ROM 10v9
That if thou shalt confess with thy mouth the Lord Jesus, and shalt believe in thine heart that God hath raised him from the dead, thou shalt be saved.
Acts 4:12 KJV
Neither is there salvation in any other: for there is none other name under heaven given among men, whereby we must be saved.
I have read the hafs quran and some of the hadiths and found the following:
- Islam teaches that child marriage is OK which implies child rape (Surah 65:4) which is evil. And Mohammed of course led by example when he raped a 9 year old little girl.
- Islam teaches that it is OK for a husband to beat his wife (Surah 4:34) which is evil.
- Islam teaches that it is OK to use women captured in war to be used and sold as sex slaves (Surah 33:50) which evil.
- Islam teaches that Christians and Jews must be fought until they have been killed (murdered) unless they submit to Islam and agree to be oppressed second class citizens in the own country (Surah 9:29) which is evil.
- And the witness of a women is worth only half of that of a man. (Surah 2:282). That is an insult to all women.
Lets see what Jesus said:
- Jesus teaches in John 14:6 English Standard Version » 6 Jesus said to him, “I am the way, and the truth, and the life. No one comes to the Father except through me. «
So who needs Mohammed and his allah? Logically no-one, especially as Mohammed does not explain how anyone gets to heaven following what he recited or how he lived.
@@johnzuma4688 how old are you
@@iknowthatiknownot Examine the issues he presented in your own eternal interest, rather than asking for his age.
perfect work. keep it up
La ilaha illAllah
With the certainty you once had that Islam is true, does it lead you to question your new certainty that Christianity is true? Do you feel you could only move on from Islam once you found something to replace it, and perhaps you now only believe in Christianity because you haven't found something else to move on to?
The word حفظ means generally “to take care”. In 15;9, the parentheses “(from corruption)” is not in the Arabic to the right. It’s not even embedded with حفظ. In other words, حفظ doesn’t generally mean “to take care from corruption”, but just “to take care”. One of the many specified usages of حفظ is “to take care from corruption”, but this usage, like the other specified usages, are highly dependent on context. So, the question is: does the context surrounding 15;9 give support for the usage of حفظ as “to take care from corruption”?
If someone said to you write colour, one of you writes "Color" and another one writes "colour", despite having different spellings, both person delivering the same message, similar logic applies to Quran, Quran has 7 different Qirat (Pronunciation and Spellings) bcz of the multiple Arabic variations like English such as British English, American English or indian English.
"They say" and "you say" are completely different things. "Colour" and "color" are different spellings of the same thing. So your example doesn't work.
Why would Allah allow his Word to be split into 7 different dialects of the same language in the first place, even different pronunciations? If it was so important to be preserved, unlike the Bible and Torah.
Some of the differences are simply due to dialect, but sometimes they completely change the words. This is just false. The Quran is a human book like any other, not different than the Bible or the Torah at all.
@@adrummingdog2782 there were 7 different tribe in arab with their different dialect that's why Allah revealed the book in 7 different dialect si that every one could read an understand but when islam spreaded out of the arab in the tim of third caliph Usman ibn Affan (RA) these seven dialects start to cause confusion so the caliph collected the original Quraishi dialect and sent it out to the world with a qari(master of quran recitation) for every region
@@dtrez3866 .... sometimes the word "you" not only refers to one person. For example, when a mother calls their children she says will you eat? Referring to both her children. Will you come? Referring to both people.
@@adrummingdog2782 the Torah is half of the Bible, you mean the Tanakh
Thanks for your honesty, truth is universally accepted but not in Islamic traditions
refutation let see if stays up ruclips.net/video/PxSbGeW5Kko/видео.html
ruclips.net/video/LzSyGjsd9jY/видео.html
You didn't prove anything hhh oh my goodness you are so funny . late me explain to you the Qur'an is one but the reading is not the same in some countries . Reading I meant the tarteal which means the worlds stay the same I hope you get it
Lance Gin 😂😂😂 you are hilarious😂👌
If you complete verses you know
قوله تعالى "سحران وقالوا إنا بكل كافرون " so you mean by hafis magic speak and magic say we not believe ? When continue verses the same meaning 🌹
Don’tconvert2Islam: I’d like to ask a question that’s always bugged me, and since you’ve sat both sides of the fence I’d value your opinion.
Many years ago I went on a sort of ‘search for God’ and I began reading any theological texts I could lay my hands on and eventually came across the infamous ‘Gnostic’ gospels.
Years later I was then approached by Muslims who provided me with a Quran and the usual “Muhammad is so fantastic” speech.
I then Read the Quran, it was much like reading a phone book to be honest, and I eventually started reading all these stories of ‘Isa’ that I recognised as being from Gnostic forgeries.
It became very obvious, very quickly, that this book was nothing but the inane ramblings of a madman and I then presented this to the Muslims with the backing evidence, needless to say I never heard from them again.
So my question is this: how, as a Muslim, can you be made aware of something like this but still ignore it?
Kym Moore Id love to hear a more detailed answer on your main points.
@Moneyxl00 YOU mean that one has to be a scholar to read and understand the qur'an? You know what? yes , because is SO confusing the book
I am Christian, and I have a qur'an. To be the word of allah is not at clear AT all. Keep listening to this man, at least questions are going to arise in YOU, ABOUT islam. A and by the way most of MUSLIMS don't like to read your book because they are not scholars too. They know is not the truth.
@@marz6588 millions of Muslims have memorized the Qur'an word for word. one can't pray without reciting the Qur'an. if possible table your prove and let's discuss
Its clear your not coherent enough to be a judge or for anyone to take seriously.
Keep up the Great videos my brothers!
Please can I ask if you would supply me with these details in a written format.
Don't be confused
Quaran is revealed in 7 mod to Mohammad pbuh
.
Both are correct
You can take anyone of these two copy
.
.
.
He is confusing you
.
Now you can say
He showed
In one version one is mentioned he say
( another saying ( we said)
.
How cannot be this two word contradict each other?
?
?
No bro . here also these two word not contradict each other
.
Rather both are indicating same thing
.
(That's one of beauty of quran 'two opposit meaning word are indicating same inner meaning
.
.
Watch this in response to him
ruclips.net/video/PxSbGeW5Kko/видео.html
@@abdulalam114 ... hahaha ... that VILE excuse for a book ... THE UNHOLY quran of EVIL, the word of SATAN. No thank you. I read it twice, and it made me angry, and the bile that oozes from it is sickening. JESUS CHRIST IS THE ONLY WAY! HE IS THE TRUTH AND THE LIFE. HE IS THE ONLY BEGOTTEN SON OF GOD/YHWH. ... GOD humbled Himself to become man to prove His Love for us. Accept TRUTH for a change, and turn from that dark path you are on. I shall not respond again, as I bind the evil you follow in the Name of The Holy Spirit. And I place your soul in the Hands of the REAL GOD, with prayers that your heart be softened, the scales be removed from your eyes, and your mind accept expansion to SEE TRUTH, instead of the lie you stumble after now.
@@MysteStorm i am inviting u to come in faith of jesuq chirst pbub
.
We muslim are in faith of jesus ( peace be upon on him)
Not you
.
Liying is also sin in christianity
.
So don't commit that
@@MysteStorm And Jesus is Satan. Isaiah 14:12 KJV, Lucifer is called the son of the morning star. Jesus also calls himself the offspring of the morning star in Revelation 22:16. Also, 2 Corinthians 4:4 NLT says satan is god.
@@user-nu7fo3tc4b ... yes you sadly are a fool ... begone servant of the evil one! You refuse to see CONTEXT!
I'm not an Arabic speaker but I know the Arabic alphabet and you're literally comparing the exact same letters lmao. There was nothing to say, and I was even confused looking at pairs of identical words. Do you think the pronunciation punctuation is quran? None of these are found in early manuscripts, and there are seven readings of the Qur'an.
A person who hates Islam so much can only come up with this little thing to attack. I can't even convince myself that the Quran has not been preserved.
Is the quran eternal? Also if there are many readings then which reading did muhammed recite?
@@Nox-mb7iu Yes, there are seven Quranic dialects, and the dominant one now is the Quraysh dialect.
@@yekeryeker4166 So if the quran is eternal then how many eternals are there? 2 or 1? Is the quran the same as allah? Is allah made of the quran or the other way around or neither? How can allah be the only uncreated being if the quran is also eternal?
@@Nox-mb7iu Laughing bro, this is the funniest logic I have ever heard. Heaven is eternal, and the world after death is eternal. Are these gods in the eyes of Christians?
Allah is the only one who needs no maintenance. Everything needs Allah to exist.
@@yekeryeker4166 You should know very well the difference between eternal in the future and eternal before creation. Let me phrase it in a way that you should understand. How many uncreated things are there? One or two? If the quran is uncreated then how many uncreated beings are there?
Brother I was searching for warsh & hafs Quran recitation but I don't know How I get this video.Then I listen his lecture & started laughing.He has no knowledge about Arabic language😂😂🤣🤣
Please explain...
@@DocRealTalk 7 differents way how to recite the quran from what the shahaba hear to Prophet Muhammad ( Pbh ).
@@mohammadalaiyabassir569
They have different words...which "by definition" makes it more than one.
If I wrote a book, then I wrote it again but change 2-3 words, the two books are not identical. They are similar but not the same.
@@DocRealTalk Hahaahahhaha You Baris??? You didn't about it? I'm a Filipino Muslim I'm not But I can read a Arabic so I know what word it is. So if you to study about quran You should also study arabic 1st so can conclude how to read, the translation is totally not 100% word to word translate , A translation is a choice of word. It's so funny about this Vlog Even my little brother know how to read it Hahahhahahahha...
It's so Funny this man didn't know how to read a quran ahhahahahah.
This man didn't know how Tasjweed to pronounce but are not Hahahhahhahaha there is no point to you to clarify . Ahhahahaah Lmao this didn't know the basic Arabic ahahhahah
@@DocRealTalk You know if this Book are not identical then You must First know the History About How Quran revealed it form Prophet Muhammad then How it published.
Go on search it. HAHAHHAHHAHAH.
THIS CHANNEL IS CLEVER hahahhahahahha
Great job brother.
Oh I see....
Check the verse number in both Qurans!
Is there any difference?
Do you know about accent?
Which spelling is right? Color or Colour?
To all those Muslims who say these are minor variants Perfect Preservation means 0 variants. Besides which version is up there in heaven with Allah?
Surah Al-Hijr, Verse 9:
إِنَّا نَحْنُ نَزَّلْنَا الذِّكْرَ وَإِنَّا لَهُ لَحَافِظُونَ
Surely We have revealed the Reminder (Quraan) and We will most surely be its guardian.
via iQuran
The entire Quran was memorized verbatim (word for word) by many of the Prophet’s Companions (males and females). Among them were Zaid ibn Thabit, Ubayy ibn Ka’b, Muadh ibn Jabal, and Abu Zaid.
Abu Bakr decided to appoint Zaid ibn Thabit to compile all of the written verses of the Qur’an into one collection, using only those verses which had been written in the presence of the Prophet ﷺ himself. These manuscripts would then be verified by those who had memorised the entire Qur’an at the hands of the Prophet himself. This was where the important concept of tawatur, or multiply attested sources, came into play. In order to be 100% sure that a verse of the Quran was in fact a verse of the Quran, it needed to have multiple independent chains of transmissions from different memorisers of the Quran. In this way, any verse that came to Zaid could be corroborated through both written and oral means, essentially guaranteeing that every single verse put in the final book was conveyed by the Prophet ﷺ. Once this had been completed by Zaid, he penned the completed text which became known as the Suhuf, and gave it to Abu Bakr. This was now the official text of the Qur’an.
Narrated Ibn `Abbas: The Prophet (peace be upon him) was the most generous amongst the people, and he used to be more so in the month of Ramadan when Gabriel visited him, and Gabriel used to meet him on every night of Ramadan till the end of the month. The Prophet (peace be upon him) used to recite the Holy Qur'an to Gabriel, and when Gabriel met him, he used to be more generous than a fast wind (which causes rain and welfare).
(Sahih al-Bukhari, Book 30, Hadith 12)
No other religious scripture was compiled with such accuracy...
Other Arabic Quraans available today are translations into different local arabic dialects, or different editions/fonts/tafsers etc...
ruclips.net/video/kyzLXIKkpXA/видео.html
ruclips.net/video/K8Ck9ITtIQM/видео.html
Quraan Preservation;
ruclips.net/video/n281Zyywyn4/видео.html
ruclips.net/user/shortstSBk0d-OCUY?feature=share
www.letmeturnthetables.com/2012/10/ibn-umar-irreparable-much-quran-loss.html?m=1 Hu
Looks like Uthman did a sub standard job of artificially preserving Quran.
No one can write quran with this big logical and scientific sense except Allah. I think you should wake up and chek yourself well. First, the quran original version is set down by allah to the earth and didnt change from 1400 years ago and no one can change it . Second point, the quran said that the moon is divided into two verses and i think usmaan did not went up to the moon and NASA discovered that truth little years ago. I am waiting for you all to wake up.
@@bahaaarja69 Don't be confused
Quaran is revealed in 7 mod to Mohammad pbuh
.
Both are correct
You can take anyone of these two copy
.
.
.
He is confusing Muslim
.
Now you can say
He showed
In one version one is mentioned he say
( another saying ( we said)
.
How cannot be this two word contradict each other?
?
?
No bro . here also these two word not contradict each other
.
Rather both are indicating same thing
.
(That's one of beauty of quran 'two opposit meaning word are indicating same inner meaning
.
.
Watch this in response to him
ruclips.net/video/PxSbGeW5Kko/видео.html
@@abdulalam114 thank you so much for giving me this information. جزاك الله خيرا ❤❤
The quran was sent down in 7 ahrof and 10 qiraat masters chose some out of the 7 and made 10 different ways to read the Quran although I'm sure there are more because of their students
I’m Algerian, your video has nothing to it. It’s all dialects and styles. The meaning doesn’t change and it is as always, intact in its meaning from corruption. In any case you won’t care about that since you have a specific agenda planned
Your Quran is the greatest fraud perpetrated upon innocent Arabs then contaminating people around the world turning them into micro anti-Christ demons. Wake up, you’ve been lied to all your life.
@ThorGT we're not anti-christ. As Muslims we cannot be Muslims without believing in Jesus as a prophet. As Muslims we follow the teachings of christ more than Christians do.
According to you Christians, God(jesus) died on the cross for your sins. How can God possibly die?
Your entire trinity concept is nonsensical.
@@santaclause1988ify Don't argue,they know Jesus will come but we know the later story and who will this So called jesus be and how christian and jews will call him God and follow him and how will we suffer but at the end of the day Allah will bless us and he'll destroy all falsehood, sigh,we and our scholar tried our best to show them light but they try to cover truth with falsehood Everytime , even went as far as to say that we r antichrist sect,so after that whatever will happen to them they will deserve it.Inshallah if Allah will let everyone see if we were in the right path or they were.
كذبت! كذبت في كل شيء! اختراع كلمة قرات ظهرت في القرن التاسع و العاشر الميلادي و لم تذكر من قبل، و ان كانت لهجات كما كذبت علي الله للدفاع الاعمي، فاخبرنا اذن هل الملائكة هم عباد الحمن ام عند الرحمن، انا مصري دارس فقه و شريعة و لغة عربية و اقول لك كذبت علي الله في قولك
@@ragazarmani2019 wtf,r u saying dude?If u can please write in english. And if u say Qirat didn’t came before 9-10 century AD then go and read hadith,also its funny how human come to conclusion in everything,1st ur no powerful being,2nd u r no powerful being to know past or future,3rd,unless people r capable enough to invent a time machine u have no right to reject islamic history,4th u dont see if qirat existed before 9-10 century, but dude before 9-10 century Islam wasnt even popular so how can u expect to find evidence of Qirat before that time?moreover Abbasid and Umayyad war was a dark time for muslims, so how people will freely write about Islam at that time? u know after 200 year ur own Existence will become myth?oh,it Won't be even a myth cause u r not popular enough to become a myth,as we r human without a time machine we can't say any thing absolute, so if anyone say it didn’t exist so It's his own opinion, no absolute thing and if I entertain some one opinion than I would be a fool.What is evidence? Is evidence anything reliable?Now even in Modern time people r suffering injustice in court with so called lack of evidence or some people entire life become hell cause even without doing anything the so called evidence point at him of being guilty though he didn’t do the crime, according to human,Jesus who at least 2.38 billion people worship as God, no historical record can be found of his existence even after his death of 200 year,so according to human, r christian worshipping some one who is only a legend or a fairytale figure?There is no record of Muses in the time of pharaoh nor there is any historical record of any pharaoh died from drowning,there is no historical record of a large number of jews were imprisoned at the time of Muses and were tortured by paharaoh, There is no historical record of Abraham and Namrud, No record of king David and Solomon.So if for lack of historical evidence Islam, Quran,Qirat,and Muhammad(pubh) r becoming myth in eyes of people than that should applied for Jew,christian and hindu as well.So if u judge every religion based on so called historical or archeological evidence , for the lack evidence they will become myth,so It's ur choice if u will believe a history or archeology that u Have noway to verify if It's true or false(u will never be sure cause u r not eye witness of past and archeology is only something that someone try to find out of nothing and not reliable enough ) or a religion which is believed by people to be true .As for Qirat, many Qirat was invented later as language is moving, but most of the Qirat is not popular or practised cause Muhammad(pubh) only give us permission to read Quran in 7 dialect/Qirat,but some people who r not knowledgeable enough about Qirat become confused with those 7 Qirat/ dialect, that's why Uthman approved 1dialect of Quran to avoid conflict and maintain unity among Muslim and burned Qurans that r written with different Qirat/dialect, but it didnt mean he banned other dialects,they were practiced orally in Arabia but they become less popular,those 7 Qira existed before but they r less popular,and about other Qirat, those which r invented later, we Muslims dont follow those cause they r invented later and some scholar read those only for educational purpose, in hadith we obviously see that 7 Qirat existed even at the time of Muhammad,Again its ur choice if u will believe them or reject,but u can't say that evidence doesn’t exist, It's only u rejected the evidence. Also we know Islam become popular in 9-10 century, a religion can't suddenly be invented and become popular over night,at least it takes 100-300 year to make a religion spread and make it well known,so if the religion it self was not well known enough than how the Qirat will be well known?Its funny how people speculate that in 9 CE Mecca suddenly come to existence , Islam invented, Quran invented than mecca become trade route overnight and they directly reject hadith cause its written in 9CE.But they forget that for people to adopt a new religion , it takes time and if a religion isn’t popular and influence a vast group of people of their religion,they won’t bother to take a historical record of it.
Hafsh and warsh are two different riding and isnt 2 books there is only one books of coran all Muslim use it in the world and riding by heart ❤️ when the imam make a pray and riding wrong. Or mistake all people behind him will correct him because it’s riding by hearts thank you the more they fight Islam the more peoples will converts to Islam every week I saw people convert to Islam last week an Italian convert to Islam
Congrats you found 2-3 words of differences, does this justify your kufr? Go back to whatever you were Doing before, Allah swt is free from need of you.
I'm from Morocco and I read both Hafs and Warsh 😂😂😂 I don't even check what reading it is because it is the same. Quran was revealed with slight different wordings. It is something the prophet himself taught and we are well aware of. Some verses were revealed in two ways and there were also different recitations because different tribes had different dialects. By the way. All the "conflicts" are not conflicts. If you're really curious, it's 60 poor people per day missed in fasting. Clearly these don't change anything man... You really tried hard but just humiliated yourself 😅😅
@Tsürong IMC It was preserved word by word. We have some scriptures dating to the early time of Islam.
One day you'll realise you have lived in lies
@@faza4023 At least I'm not afraid of questioning my beliefs. Can't say the same about some people
@@osumanaaa9982 that's great man, how deep have you questioned?
Quran Is a BOOK of Allah
Any evidence that the Quran comes from Allah? Which version is the correct one?
My brother read Bhagavat Geeta
yeah allah=devil
Reasoned Answers apologetics videos
Look at version from sunah wal jamaah! There published in Malaysia and Indonesia!
Quran is book of satan
Merry Christmas 2020
Balderdash. Arabic itself is a miracle. as ana arabi native speaker, thoses changes make no difference.
ruclips.net/video/3BCP3hPxCfo/видео.html
Narrated `Umar bin Al-Khattab:
I heard Hisham bin Hakim reciting Surat Al-Furqan during the lifetime of Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) and I listened to his recitation and noticed that he recited in several different ways which Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) had not taught me. I was about to jump over him during his prayer, but I controlled my temper, and when he had completed his prayer, I put his upper garment around his neck and seized him by it and said, "Who taught you this Sura which I heard you reciting?" He replied, "Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) taught it to me." I said, "You have told a lie, for Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) has taught it to me in a different way from yours." So I dragged him to Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) and said (to Allah's Messenger (ﷺ)), "I heard this person reciting Surat Al-Furqan in a way which you haven't taught me!" On that Allah's Apostle said, "Release him, (O `Umar!) Recite, O Hisham!" Then he recited in the same way as I heard him reciting. Then Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) said, "It was revealed in this way," and added, "Recite, O `Umar!" I recited it as he had taught me. Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) then said, "It was revealed in this way. This Qur'an has been revealed to be recited in seven different ways, so recite of it whichever (way) is easier for you (or read as much of it as may be easy for you).
thank u!could you pls quote the hadith number and refrence!
Yes but let me tell you he meant different ways of saying it I know them it meant pronunciation not different words
@@trueman6152 it meant pronunciation
The Quran was revealed by word of mouth. May Allah guide you.
It wasn't though
@@James-cs2dz Please read the Quran and judge it for yourself.
The Quran has been challenging mankind for more than 1400years to produce something the like thereof.
@@Expatnema I have, and it didn't change me. Bible gives me enlightmrnt it brings peace and love for me.
@@Expatnema how has it been challenging mankind? Explains
@@James-cs2dz Do you know about hafiz in muslim community? There are millions of them worlwide who memorized the Quran in toto word by word and Hafiz are not even native arab speakers. I have tens of relatives who memorized the Quran at the very young age. I could have been one of them but too bad i focused too much in my "western" studies. I memorized some parts of the Quran and im not even a native arabic speaker. I can still recite the verses. Thats why some of us are not worried everytime non muslims attempt to destroy the physical copies of the Quran because we can always produce it.
"And indeed, We have eased the Qur'an in your tongue that they might be reminded." (Quran)
Hey, Arabic is my first language, and I am sorry but I have got to tell you that the pieces of evidence for corruption are actually baseless, well Arabic is my first language, and the differences that you're pointing at are well-known and clear to everyone who has any kind of interest in Quran, and they are all minor literal changes, however they change nothing in the meaning at all. Let me tell you, that even the most prominent Quran Reciters, know these changes by heart, and recite them openly without any fear that they change a meaning.
Honestly, I wouldn't be criticising any holy scripture without being fully aware of the language it's originally revealed in, and especially when it comes to Quran, as one of its upsides is the use of words and rhyme in a strong fashion.
Can someone explain please. In the examples of words in the 2 versions of the Quran, the words look identical to me with the exception of dashes and dot above and below the word. Now Dr Shabir Ally saws that these symbols above and below the word just to do with accents and how vowels are pronounced but didn't exist in the original text (same as the Hebrew language), so are not important. What is the truth?