Alan Jackson Challenges Karen Read Verdict Form | Killer Or Cover-Up Murder Trial
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 5 сен 2024
- Defense Attorney #AlanJackson challenges the verdict form in MA v. #KarenRead. Things got tense in the courtroom between the defendant and Judge Beverly Cannone.
#CourtTV What do YOU think?
Watch 24/7 Court TV LIVE Stream Today www.courttv.com/
Join the Investigation Newsletter www.courttv.co...
Court TV Podcast www.courttv.co...
Join the Court TV Community to get access to perks:
/ @courttv
FOLLOW THE CASE:
Facebook / courttv
Twitter/X / courttv
Instagram / courttvnetwork
TikTok / courttvlive
WATCH +140 FREE TRIALS IN THE COURT TV ARCHIVE www.courttv.co...
WHERE-TO-WATCH www.courttv.co...
#CourtTV What do YOU think?
I'm ready for a verdict and not see her on my screen anymore, to be honest.
I think his point is very fair. Without having the words yes and no you are subconsciously directing their vote towards yes
I think this judge should not make special changes for Read it's been like this for years.
This shows how desperate they are getting to ensure they send this innocent woman to prison to cover up the murder they committed.
I agree with him.
"so why are we out here, i was tired"
DO YOUR JOB
Right!!! Judge Bev it's your job, that's why you're there. ⚖️
I could not believe she would even asked that. 😮
Jackson is a fantastic example of “advocating for your client”. He’s a gem.
Jackson is a rude thuggish lawyer that threatens and berates the judge, the court and witnesses- he is way too intimate with client.
This is how a passionate defense attorney is supposed to fight for his client. This judge has pegged her as guilty from jump street.
Oh please -he’s a high paid robot to throw doubt.
That is so unfair
He and Brian Steele are savage! Going hard for their clients....as it should be.
Because she is
@@triciamuir I AGREED WITH💯💯💯💯
I’m tired is a wild excuse when someone’s freedom is on the line. The entitlement is unreal.
The world is watching Auntie Bev. I'm calling it now and saying someone called her after this despicable display from her and told her to add it to the form. Shame on you, Auntie Bev.
Yeah the world is watching The Karen sitting there laughing too.
@@Jack-bc5xg She wasn't "laughing" because she found it funny. Her face and expressions were an accurate reaction from any human being that knows another person sounds ridiculous.
Yeah, she must be guilty because she smiled. 🙄@@Jack-bc5xg
She's not your Aunt.
Agreed Beautifuldisaster. She didn't have a change of heart on her own
Tired? Good grief. Combative Auntie Bev. 🤮Rude & disrespectful to Jackson, as usual.
WTH 😮 why is she so lazy !!!
There is no word to describe how guilty this judge is being biased and one-sided. I’m flabbergasted.
Judges always want to side with law enforcement especially if the victim themselves didn't commit a crime. They rely on the police for them being elected as judges. There was the cash for kids scandal in luzerne county years ago and the one cop choke slammed his own son for testifying against judge Conahan.
Im digging the Judge.
totally inappropriate response from Bev. she totally disregarded his legitimate concern and had the nerve to scoff at Yanetti and scold Karen. then an hour later “understands Jackson’s concern” and comes out with a revised form.
she’s letting her personal vendetta of the defense team get in the way of Karen’s right to a fair trial
I think she got a phone call from someone…. Seriously 😳
@nataliedigiovanni4863 that doesn't surprise me
She has someone, and I'm not sure if that's other judges or someone that she's taking counsel with.... I think they agreed with Jackson that this would be grounds for appeal.... I think that is why she changed it..... Had this case not gotten the public spotlight that it has been getting I don't think she would have change it
It was an attachment
Why can’t Karen shake her head & “laugh” over how unbelieveable Bev is being when her lifes @ stake?! It’s the face of being continually shocked by the bias, and calling Karen out was in bad taste. Just goes to show her resentment towards KR by Bev admonishing her for having a human reaction.
He was right. She knew it. That's why she changed it.
💯
Many lesser attorneys would have worn it too.
She sounds so annoyed to be in Court. Judge Bev 👩⚖️ it's your job. 😆
Yes and it pissed her off
That is so unfair of judge to do that .That is wrong
So the judge chuckles when the second attorney corrects her, saying “he hasn’t seen a slip like this”.
But then Karen laughs and the judge becomes disgruntled and ends the conversation?
Image you went into voting booth and leaving blank spot counted as a vote, absolutely ridiculous.
She has made that slip so confusing they won't even know how to vote not guilty! Unbelievable
They don't have too. She is guilty.
The jury will decide. IMO the Commonwealth has not met it's burden. ⚖️
@@izabela1961how does a normal working brain come to that conclusion, dear lord, facts and science PROVE IT.
@@Charliepatch1978 exactly what she intended and exactly what she got! Nevermind the fact the jury did EXACTLY AS SHE INSTRUCTED THEM TO by not touching the verdict sheet until they were unanimous on ALL charges
I hate this judge. She should be removed!
I don’t agree with this judge and can’t stand her condescending “only fans” breathy voice.
I agree with Jackson but also gad judge voiced her disapproval of Karen's smug smirk -
Yu ppl can be just ugly and mean with your comments! Good grief..
This judge's impartiality is questionable. Her handling of objections. Her disrespect for the defendant. And the verdict slip needs to be appropriate to this specific case, not just standard wording.
She should be reprimanded for her comment towards the defendant !
I am sure Karen did not find it funny; it was mostly, jeez, you are something else.
Nope - Karen's smirks very disrespectful to the judge and court -
Especially after judge just herself laughed!
Exactly she was mocking Jackson minutes before. This is a disgrace judge and should be removed yesterday.
100% - the judge was out of order and should be reprimanded
Bev is and has been part of the problem.
She should have never taken this case because of her brother.
Agreed she's friends of cops.
@@mariaskouras1175 They must-have secrets amongst them.
Don't call 911 when you need help phone a friend instead.
@@MotherOfVincentLePew Bevs brother was Chris Albert's attorney for a DUI
@@MotherOfVincentLePewit was more than a DUI…it was a hit & run in which a man was killed. Info is online, occurred in 1994
I'd be fighting for that not guilty checkbox as well..that judge is making a big error in not making that simple addition
She changed it.
Hate this judge shes flippant
Aunty Bev is soooooo unprofessional and incompetent!!
Wow! This Judge has a very real problem!
Worst judge ever!
So true
Good judge
No, that would be Glanville rn.
Smh
@@Jack-bc5xg Dude you're an older guy who's subscribed to family vlog channels. Of course someone who partakes in watching children being filmed all day thinks that Corrupt Cannone is a good judge.
She’s unreasonable
So when she’s annoyed of one lawyer she asks the other. She’s so petty.
Even the commonwealth agreed with the defense, at that point she should had just changed it.
@@kellygarcia5577 exactly. This happened a few times during the trial in different instances as well
Oh it really p o'd her when Karen laughed because this judge does not like to be belittled in her mind😂
I’ve been saying this overly exaggerated judge is extremely bias towards Ms Read and takes shots at the defense every chance she got to do so! Horrible this woman is clearly not guilty. And WTH do u mean not guilty isn’t an option she needs to be under investigation as a poor unjustifiable excuse of a judge
Judge needs to get on her broom and go home for good
🤣🤣🤣🤣
Awful judge. In bed with law enforcement. Overruled or sustained many objections favoring ridiculous state. Embarrassing honestly.
Wow Jackson is ballsy
love it. he stands up for his client’s rights even if it means admonishing a judge
I read the actual document, it was confusing. Jackson and Yanetti were right. 🤨
He’s an attorney with integrity.
Jackson.... top notch goat.... BANG BANG
Naw, HE ain't... That Bad Azz
(shut yo' mouth) Atty,
is 3,000 miles from home, sponsored by other defense atty
(2 different law firms working, togther)
*Jackson is Hollywood Heavy Hitter*
That's why everybody was making a big deal about Read, having two law firms working on her case & then there is lally~gag solo, having to do everything by his lonesome...
boo~hoo boo~hoo 😢
oh, welp...he shouldn't have ever brought this, case in the first place, lally~gag has bitten off way much more than he could never chew...
NOT GUILTY 👩⚖️
So true not guilty
@@user-rx8tw9vn9m I'm still confused on why this even made it to trial. Given the fact that all the evidence points toward the Albert's and Mccabe's families.😂
Not guilty for me. Hate this judge . So Bias . This is not a fair trial. I really hope she is found not guilty and all those horrible people pay for what they did and i hope lally never has a good nights sleep for a long long time .
You’re supposed to decide a case based on the evidence not whether or not you like the judge. How odd…..
@@jamba622not guilty here based on burden of proof I have more proof of a police cover up than I do that Karen did anything.
@jamba622 I did base my opinion on evidence and the lack of proof from the prosecution. I also don't like the judge .
This judge just as corrupt as Alberts and mccabes
I have watched the Judge and anytime the defense objects she immediately overrules them. When the Prosecutor objects she sustains them.
It seems like she has really tied the defense hands by not allowing the attorney or their witness to testify. They basically are only allowed half of what they would have said.
Definitely seems fishy.
Perhaps the prosecution understands the law so only objects when appropriate while the defense is not so well trained.
@@jamba622 🤣 Lally makes one hundred thousand a year. Jackson makes more than that per case.
@jamba622 perhaps? Oh stop lying to yourself
This judge abuses her immunity privileges…
She cuts off Mr Jackson to admonish ms read for laughing even though she herself laughed just a few seconds before. She then threw a fit and left her own courtroom without hearing Mr Jackson further
That is why she is a judge. Guess what.. she’s in charge like it or not. It’s her court room. And Miss smirky face KR finally got called out on it.
@jesusmora6336 THIS JUDGE HAS ABUSED HER IMMUNITY PRIVILEGES THROUGHOUT THIS TRIAL
This judge is a DISGRACE !!!
Karen freedom is on the line and the judge DONT CARE AT ALL.
Awful!
Dishonorable Judge Bev.
They have railroaded this woman
More grounds for appeal 🤷♂️
Not Guilty , greetings and ❤ from the Netherlands
and Switzerland!
@@yvasification…and Australia!
IMO Judges Bev is biased towards the prosecution and she wants the jury to return with all guilty verdicts. Bev has a poor attitude, she's dismissive, rude, corrupt, and she should be removed from the bench.
I'm not sure that I have ever seen a judge this blatantly disrespectful of the rules. She seems to be making them up as she goes along.
TIP for everyone:
NEVER go to Canton, dont drive through there, dont visit. Drive completely AROUND that state if you are travelling!
Most corrupt BS I've ever seen. If you drive through that town and get stopped by one of their corrupt cops you'll go in front of "judge Beverage" and be thrown in jail for murder! 😂😂
Exactly like the movies of corrupt cops from the 60’ nothing has changed in that state. Scary 😱
Miss Read has spent $1,000,000 because of this funny joke of an indictment.
That’s right! I wonder if this “Judge” thinks that’s funny…
Oh she will write a book and make millions she has so many cult followers
Cult followers. 😂😂😂 Ok
She backed into her bf and killed him? This is no joke. I know her"fans" ,and herself think this is a joke? But a good man died? At her expense. If the jury doesn't sentence her? God will. Believe that.
@@user-pj5lf6mf5u ok🤡
Massachusetts showing how Judiciary system is flawed left to right and top to bottom
God’s watching
Not guilty.
So true not guilty
No evidence by CW of SUV contact w/ OJO. D had evidence of no contact.
Regarding the timeline: the Albert home was unsecured and unguarded as a crime scene over the weeks evidence was found by CERT. ALSO, BETWEEN4:16 PICKUP OF HER SUV AND ARRIVAL MANY MILES AWAY AT CANTON PD, TROOPER PROCTOR COULD HAVE DONE ANYTHING HE WANTED TO THE TAILLIGHT, WHICH IS POSSIBLY WHY THE VIDEO OF ITS CONDITION AND THE VIDEO OF ITS ARRIVAL HAVE GONE MISSING AND WHY THE TAPE WAS INVERTED. The tow driver could have stopped along the way, even just a block away from Karen's parents' house and done whatever he wanted, palmed it off to someone who went to 43 Fairview and tried to stage a debris field. Trooper Paul was incoherent on what the location of the pieces could mean.
Bev is buddies with the Alberts/McCabes!
Id of already voted not guilty. The head juror would not be keeping me there, stalling amd rehashing all the bs the prosecutor claims.
This will be used if he needs to appeal her guilty verdict!
You think it's funny ms read? Like wtf it's her life on the line. She allowed to have emotions. At this point and being railroaded in the first place. I'd laugh too. Like come on judge...ms bev.
She laughed at what the judge said. She should have been reprimanded. You don’t do that in a court of law.
@@ringring6618 I did not hear her laughter. Did you? Karen probably had a grin like saying you are such a meanie, Bev!!!!
@@md8465 no I wasn’t there. But apparently the judge was 🤦🏻♀️
@@ringring6618I do those kinds of laughs when I deal with preposterous behavior, it’s more of a scoff. And if my life was on the line for it I am sure I would have some very strong emotions that would be hard to hide. Especially since being a 3rd party watching this case I feel this judge has been biased since the beginning. I came into this case not knowing anything about it. Never even saw a headline.
Verdict slip needs to be completely straightforward and crystal clear. The answer choices should be consistent throughout. It doesn't matter if that's what is or what has been used.
Who designed that form? Why not just have "NOT GUILTY" options to go with "GUILTY", that way both options are treated equally by the form & nobody could argue that the form is leading jurors to either finding.
@vonkruel.. the form should reflect that EVERYTHING was considered…
Best defense team
She is CRAZY!!! Judge, STEP DOWN!!
And the way the judge said, you find this funny Mrs. Read. She has no clue what Mrs. Read is smiling about and to say that is pretty rude.
She knew Karen was (rightfully) laughing at her poor excuse (that's the way it's always been). You could either laugh or throw a chair at her I guess. Fortunately the old dragon finally came to her senses.
Not guilty 💯
Jackson is 100% correct and that form could direct them to choose GUILTY. This judge gives the jury too much credit - they aren’t lawyers!
Lally proved Reasonable Doubt! lol 🤣 Karen Read is innocent!
I always knew she was not only incompetent but BIAS as well
Bev mocking Yannetti with smirking and laughing at him FIRST and then scolding Karen who was laughing in disbelief of Bev’s unprofessionalism. 🤌🤌 This judge thinks people are blind. Not just Karen..whole world is watching and laughing 😂😂🎉
God is watching most important The True Judge
When Jackson came he figured out the other courtroom doesn’t allow for the defendant to look at the witnesses! The witness box is in a peculiar place, no air conditioning, there was no Wi-Fi 🤦🏻♀️and they are still doing in-proper jury forms ! Please get up to date Court house it’s embarrassing! Thank you Attorney Alan Jackson for speaking out ! 🩷🩷🤟🏼🤟🏼Free Karen Read !
Is this how judges play with a life of a human who is on trial ?
No wonder Karen Reed laughed, she realizes the fix is in, lol. It's not just one little thing here or there, it's the unsurmountable amount of "little things" the judge does to tip the scales that's already tipped against KR on top of that by the prosecutor, state witnesses, AND the corrupt police department. I'd be laughing too after hearing the judge stack the deck against her YET AGAIN!
Problem is Karen has shown inappropriate behavior through the whole trial. This isn't a laughing matter when u are being charged with murder but obviously Karen finds the court proceedings amusing??😮😮
@lizdahl847 No, she's not amused. Her life is on the line. The judge knew it was wrong. If I was Karen I'd let that judge know exactly how I feel.
@@lizdahl847 so your upset with her smiling, after hearing the police went through her phone looking for nude photos of here, selling her a @unt, and all sort of bad names. Why blame her?
@@amandamartin2777 Exactly!
@@amandamartin2777 Not good advice!
The judge needs to be removed… and charged later. Bad sued.
The judge is cohorts with the police. She asked one lawyer if he's seen sheets like that and he said no then she said I disagree with you. So she knows what this man doesn't know about himself? If you assume someone is lying it's cause that's what u do
I am never going to that part of the world. Too scary!.
I agree with him
Horribly handled by this judge!
They sure are taking a long time. I'm starting to think it's gonna be a hung jury😢
Certainly a protracted decision but as others have pointed out they are most likely just carefully going over everything.
9 hours is nothing, especially given the length of the trial and the seriousness of the charges. just need to be patient. they have to do their due diligence regardless if they all agreed at the onset
It is that stupid form delaying things.
@@md8465 I wouldn't be surprised.
Judge is off her rocker
Karen Read is innocent.
First off why didn’t Jackson see the form before it went to the jury? Second why didn’t the judge go over the form after closing arguments? Third Bev came in hot and was pissed to be called out, she should of not talked to Karen like that on the record
Such disrespect. I’m beyond horrified.
Flabbers are Gasted! This judge!
Is this judge related to Proctor?
WOW !!! Aunty Bev had steam coming out of her ears 😂😂😂
AS SOMEONE WHO HAS WATCHED THIS WHOLE TRIAL, JUDGE HAS BEEN BIAS FROM THE START. ITS MORE THAN EVIDENT.
This hole system is crooked
The Meredith Baxter wannabe judge is shady.
This makes. My day 😂
Judge is condescending. There’s a ton of people in Massachusetts like that, I couldn’t tell you how many doctors I encountered with that same dismissive attitude when I lived there…
Massholes
I believe you.
She gets mad that Read is laughing at her, trying to fix the verdict to favor the DA. Read knows already that they couldn't prove their case, and now the judge is making it so that the jury make the mistake to find Read guilty.
She was not laughing; she was probably saying you just want to f...me.
Never a good or smart idea to laugh after a judge's remark -
This judge is so crooked!
This judge is the worse. She needs to be fired. Me. Jackson is the best defense so I have ever seen and she doesn’t like that.
I hope someone challenges her “that’s how we do things” on her decisions. That Jury slip was basically, Is she guilty or is she guilty. She takes the defense for fools and her jealousy seems to show when it comes to Karen Read.
She is simply stating that this verdict form has used for EVERY other case. Why change it for THIS case.
I will say, however, that Jackson does seem to have a point.
I feel sorry for the good people that live in MA.
Who does the judge know in this case? Can anyone pls tell me why some say Bev should have recused herself from this trial and seems biased?
Alan Jackson for president! This guy is goooood!
I’d heard people say she was pro prosecution/anti defense but it wasn’t until I saw this mess that it was very clear. I remember my mouth dropping when I heard about the verdict form. Wth is her problem?
JACKSON 2024 🤣
When a lawyer catches a dirty judge. This in its self will make a great documentary.
Love that dirty water
Netflix series coming
BEV IS SO INCOMPETENT
She’s not incompetent, she’s negligent and knows exactly what she’s doing. Jackson is calling her out in front of a global audience.
I think the Judge is too fast to say no to something that seems like the way things should be... Exactly how it always is in Massachusetts, lol ... think we have seen in this case how things are in Massachusetts.
LOOK THE OTHER WAY
Not guilty. If you notice it. Albert son had a cuts on his hands
Weeks BEFORE he had those scrapes..... learn the facts!!!
@@Fee212 I been watching it .
Why didn't Mr. Jackson bring Colin up in closing arguments? Brian Albert was squirming in his seat.
@@md8465 don't know
She knew she was wrong
I've never heard of anything so ridiculous. No option of Not Guilty for all charges? How is that legal? If there isn't a not guilty option, the only option is guilty of one of the charges. That's madness.
Never mind a jury slip that sounds like it's been written up by a hungover student. What the actual ... is going on in this court??
Not guilty was simply if the jury chose neither of the options. Don’t overthink it.
@gerttopmuller that's not how it appeared on the jury slip. It looked like the Not Guilty option related only to the Murder charge. The other guilty charges were indented underneath the Murder charge and if I were on the jury seeing that, that's what I would think. Remember, the jury don't see and don't hear what we do, only what's put in front of them.
Mr Jackson is incredible and incredibly intelligent
Just wondering how "I'm tired" would fly as an excuse with my boss. Heck, on Below Deck they get hate for the rest of the season if they say that.
This judge is awful