In my opinion many people underestimate Anette singing Tarja's songs because of their different voice color. While Tarja's voice is dark, Anette's is much much brighter and since the earlier songs were written for a dark voice, most of them are sad or melancholic. When someone with bright voice sings them it's really some kind of untypical but in many cases it is interesting yet wonderful because it's not usual. And the thing with Floor is that she can fit in both because her color is somewhere in between.
While this is by no means a bad version, it's really surprising to hear how much Marko is holding back here as compared to when he is singing with Floor, especially in the duet sections. Still quite enjoyable even if not the best.
@@herlindeherrebout8111 It is because of her limitations as a singer and he doesn’t want to outshine her. It’s exactly the same, if not worse, in live performances. She was a mistake.
Actually sounds good, if you haven't heard the original and the one from Floor. Definitely could've been improved but it's a good as it gets with Anette.
see i think the best part about anette is her voice is different enough to where she pulls off Tarjs songs very well and adds its own tone to it without ruining Tarjas version.
Alguien que me de el link de cuando tarja canta esto en vivo... Me parece que nunca lo canto en vivo... Si es asi.. Mis respetos para Anette... Además excelente le sale...
For mr thats the best version of that song shes into it and i love albums with her maybe even the most ;p not everyone has oprah voice and i think she killed it
+Kristel „LyraChii“ Cenica Floor is the best! I totally love her voice! Absolutely beautiful in slow songs and powerful, very powerful in other songs! :D She's got it all!
The two studio albums with Anette are my favorites, and she sang this pretty well here, but you can tell the band are just not really feeling it with her. They never were. It’s a shame because I think she’s a great singer, just maybe not a great Nightwish singer.
One other thing... Man you can sense the tension and displeasure in the guys faces. But you're laughing now aren't you now that you got a angel in the band
Jane Crepsley Todos los seres humanos al tener voz tenemos un rango... El de Anette es soprano, que no tenga entrenamiento clásico es otra cosa. Hay muchas cantantes que no lo tienen y llegan a notas altas... Que Anette sea patetica es otra cosa
Wow not only is it like Minnie Mouse singing the song, but no emotion at all and just like reading a q card at the State of the Union Address. Now... Floor Jansen! Holyshit! I guess that's about all I can say. Other than God's probably really pissed right now because his top Angelic voice in the choir of the Angels is on loan with Nightwish now. Floor can take any Nightwish song past present or future... And improve it tenfold. Now the music, that's a given because we know they got skills and the guys are phenomenal musicians. But I had to hear a song that floor did at the 2013 wacken Festival, but by one of the prior to lesser-skilled vocalists. And I will never do that again. After hearing floor Jansen do the song, and then watching this video... It was literally like watching someone butcher Nightwish song On karaoke I just... Karaoke singer. Good God can floor improve any Nightwish song or what!? Yes tharja and Annette are good singers, just not in metal or symphonic metal. Tarja, one-dimensional old school with slow vibrato Opera singing Only that's all I can see her singing. and their last singer Annette Olson, same thing. But with a Annette you have that one dimensional genre... A top 40 pop type music vocal Style. But I will tell you... Floor Jansen, she can blaze a trail Like Pat Benatar with the rasp in the vocals, power and high of Ann Wilson of heart, the grace the melodice Celine Dion, but also classically trained and Opera. To put a long story short - ish... Floor Jansen has it all! stage presence in commanding a crowd... Check! Beauty, Grace, seductive and sensuality presents... Check check, and triple fucking check! and as far as the rest of the band and floor as well as her Angelic voice... And sorry guys but God will be wanting her back soon cuz I know he's missing that voice. But seriously other than the fact that she is actually an angel. A 6ft tall, gorgeous blue-eyed Dutch Goddess from the Netherlands... Since Seattle Washington 2012, Nightwish has hit perfection!
Very good remaster from Anette with Marco's help. Maybe Tarja's dark vocals matches more with the song in the original version, but i like Anette's approach, too.
I have not listened to Floor's version, but I don't compare any live performance with the original studio song in which the vocals belong to Tarja. In general, in my opinion the original studio songs cannot be compared with any live performance for every song of the band.
0:56 Emppu "Que horrible canta esta mina por dios!!!". No le dan los pulmones para cantar semejante cancion. Floor se lució en el Wacken cantando este temazo!!
She’s a good singer, no doubt. But pairing her with Nightwish is just about the strangest mix up in music history. It would be like if James Hetfield left Metallica... and they replaced him with Justin Bieber 🤦🏼♂️
I'm sure Annette is a wonderful person and obviously a good singer, but I still can't get into any Nightwish song with her singing. I can listen to anything with Tarja and Floor, all day, but I just can't listen to Nightwish with Annette. To me she doesn't fit.
Eduardo Castro Much greater? How? :-D Now, this band is greater ever. With Anette was unhappy, without energy, emotions, cold...now, with Floor, is the best Nightwish by years.
Strange to hear this version after hearing Floor’s version. It’s pop versus rock. I don’t like this version at all. She is a pop singer and not a rock singer
![ROADIE REACTIONS | "Nightwish - Wishmaster (Live)" | [FIRST TIME REACTION]](/img/1.gif)
Am I the one only one absurdly in love with Emppu's guitar tone? God, so heavy and awesome
I love her version for this song. Gives an extra punch 😻
I loved this far more than I would've anticipated.
I like this version, Annete did it very well. But Floor´s version is my favorite ever
Let me say as a big fan of Tarja and Floor, it's actually good! All front womens from Nightwish are differently awesome and powerful.
there´s some songs that suites her... but others don´t. GLS is too big for her for example... Nemo, Ever Dream... Annete was not bad but...
In my opinion many people underestimate Anette singing Tarja's songs because of their different voice color. While Tarja's voice is dark, Anette's is much much brighter and since the earlier songs were written for a dark voice, most of them are sad or melancholic. When someone with bright voice sings them it's really some kind of untypical but in many cases it is interesting yet wonderful because it's not usual. And the thing with Floor is that she can fit in both because her color is somewhere in between.
While this is by no means a bad version, it's really surprising to hear how much Marko is holding back here as compared to when he is singing with Floor, especially in the duet sections. Still quite enjoyable even if not the best.
I think it's also because it's just training and not an actual performance
It’s a training session….
@@herlindeherrebout8111 It is because of her limitations as a singer and he doesn’t want to outshine her. It’s exactly the same, if not worse, in live performances. She was a mistake.
I love Annette and would have been fine with more albums with her, but I am SUPER stoked to hear the new album with Floor!
ALL albuns with Floor are sooooo bad
@@morfeuuuuuuuuuuuu bad fan
It was better then I thought. :)
Much better than I thought she would be at singing this!
Bravo Anette. Nikt nie jest niezastąpiony...NIGHTWISH and Anette ok
We love Anette!
Το Μάτι always wanted anette is good lead vocals voice
I don't
She did pretty well, I love her
There are some NW songs where Anette truly shines.
...this ain't one of them.
It is truly painful at points. She just cannot reach the notes, or hold them for any time.
Maravillosa Anette Olzon cantando con su estilo Romanticide lastima que ya no esta en Nightwish :(
She did pretty well
Actually sounds good, if you haven't heard the original and the one from Floor. Definitely could've been improved but it's a good as it gets with Anette.
Me gusta anette olzon es buena vocalista.
see i think the best part about anette is her voice is different enough to where she pulls off Tarjs songs very well and adds its own tone to it without ruining Tarjas version.
más de siete años. Y así seguirá por los siglos de los siglos ;)
I just love this woman.
Alguien que me de el link de cuando tarja canta esto en vivo... Me parece que nunca lo canto en vivo... Si es asi.. Mis respetos para Anette... Además excelente le sale...
Tarja nunca cantou essa ao vivo nem Tutankhamen que seria tudo se ela cantasse mas a Anette e a Floor arrasaram em Romanticide ao vivo
For mr thats the best version of that song shes into it and i love albums with her maybe even the most ;p not everyone has oprah voice and i think she killed it
As much as I like Anette, I'm Curious. Soooo for people that dislikes Anette, what do you think of the new sing Floor Jansen????
+Kristel „LyraChii“ Cenica Floor is the best! I totally love her voice! Absolutely beautiful in slow songs and powerful, very powerful in other songs! :D She's got it all!
Niki \m/ I was able to see them live in Toronto last week. I must say, she has impressed me. She's probably one of the best singers I've seen live.
Good version, really good
HAHAHA! Emppu at 00:57 XD
Never knew this was an Anette era song..
The two studio albums with Anette are my favorites, and she sang this pretty well here, but you can tell the band are just not really feeling it with her. They never were. It’s a shame because I think she’s a great singer, just maybe not a great Nightwish singer.
Прекрасный вокал!
не тянет
@@nighthunter28 Тянет,это живое исполнение и практически идеальное)Это говорит о том что Анетт прекрасная певица)
One other thing... Man you can sense the tension and displeasure in the guys faces. But you're laughing now aren't you now that you got a angel in the band
No you can’t ....wtf?
wtf no you cant
Wonderful voice)
Ouhmm Anette 🥰
So so beautiful, miss her
I didn't expect to see pyros in that environment.
Anybody watching this after seeing Wacken 2013 performance? :S
Lol
Stop please! What a headshake.
no te preocupes por que anette ya no esta en nightwish =)
ademas si amas a nightwish amas la escencia
exacto...cada etapa con cada cantante n.n/
Sinceramente, Anette nunca fue apta para esta gran banda... Se escucha mucho mejor en su nueva rola...
si es verdad tiene una voz demasiado angelical suave,,, no llegaba a las mas altas notas de Tarja
Manuel Arce Tal vez porque...no es soprano, duh
Jane Crepsley Todos los seres humanos al tener voz tenemos un rango... El de Anette es soprano, que no tenga entrenamiento clásico es otra cosa. Hay muchas cantantes que no lo tienen y llegan a notas altas... Que Anette sea patetica es otra cosa
Claro que sí, cariño. Claro que sí.
Jane Crepsley seeeee jajajaja
Excellens!!!
casi siete años y se sigue hablando de tarja
2:42 Marco doesn't love this :))
5:22-5:38 hahahahahahahaha haciendo un comercial de agua ¡¡¡por que hacen como castores ? XD que tierna la cara de Tuomas
5:08 the best part. Thank you Anette
Floor does this better than both Tarja and Anette in my opinion.
And you opinion is right. :D
fake
Sí, sí lo es, pero Anette también lo es.
very good.. !!^^
tarja eres lo maximo
ohhhh ahora me di cuenta por que XD
Me gusta más la versión de Floor, tiene mucha más potencia
karladaniela cjuro aica verdad y casi casi tirandole al rango vocal de tarja
karladaniela cjuro aica annette su voz es como mas poperona
Mmmm Anette is better here
they should perform that instead of Wishmaster
Wow not only is it like Minnie Mouse singing the song, but no emotion at all and just like reading a q card at the State of the Union Address. Now... Floor Jansen! Holyshit! I guess that's about all I can say. Other than God's probably really pissed right now because his top Angelic voice in the choir of the Angels is on loan with Nightwish now. Floor can take any Nightwish song past present or future... And improve it tenfold. Now the music, that's a given because we know they got skills and the guys are phenomenal musicians. But I had to hear a song that floor did at the 2013 wacken Festival, but by one of the prior to lesser-skilled vocalists. And I will never do that again. After hearing floor Jansen do the song, and then watching this video... It was literally like watching someone butcher Nightwish song On karaoke I just... Karaoke singer. Good God can floor improve any Nightwish song or what!? Yes tharja and Annette are good singers, just not in metal or symphonic metal. Tarja, one-dimensional old school with slow vibrato Opera singing Only that's all I can see her singing. and their last singer Annette Olson, same thing. But with a Annette you have that one dimensional genre... A top 40 pop type music vocal Style. But I will tell you... Floor Jansen, she can blaze a trail Like Pat Benatar with the rasp in the vocals, power and high of Ann Wilson of heart, the grace the melodice Celine Dion, but also classically trained and Opera. To put a long story short - ish... Floor Jansen has it all! stage presence in commanding a crowd... Check! Beauty, Grace, seductive and sensuality presents... Check check, and triple fucking check! and as far as the rest of the band and floor as well as her Angelic voice... And sorry guys but God will be wanting her back soon cuz I know he's missing that voice. But seriously other than the fact that she is actually an angel. A 6ft tall, gorgeous blue-eyed Dutch Goddess from the Netherlands... Since Seattle Washington 2012, Nightwish has hit perfection!
Minnie Mouse hahahaha
@@ShebangsPrP That's an insult to Minnie.
The lat moment that cap
Te amo Anette mas essa música não é pra você!
Very good remaster from Anette with Marco's help. Maybe Tarja's dark vocals matches more with the song in the original version, but i like Anette's approach, too.
No man, Floor version is the best than 2!
I have not listened to Floor's version, but I don't compare any live performance with the original studio song in which the vocals belong to Tarja. In general, in my opinion the original studio songs cannot be compared with any live performance for every song of the band.
She's got a very good voice.Not better than Tarja but she's not bad.As her tatoo sais "Leave Me Alone".
4:26 - 5:09 EPIC
0:56 Emppu "Que horrible canta esta mina por dios!!!".
No le dan los pulmones para cantar semejante cancion.
Floor se lució en el Wacken cantando este temazo!!
She’s a good singer, no doubt. But pairing her with Nightwish is just about the strangest mix up in music history.
It would be like if James Hetfield left Metallica... and they replaced him with Justin Bieber 🤦🏼♂️
1:06/1:14... Make it stop!!!
You don’t like chipmunks?
It's achievable for her notes. Nice try. Pleasant alternative version.
I'm sure Annette is a wonderful person and obviously a good singer, but I still can't get into any Nightwish song with her singing. I can listen to anything with Tarja and Floor, all day, but I just can't listen to Nightwish with Annette. To me she doesn't fit.
So painful to listen to the chipmunk….
What a fuck? Annette is like ... like ... I don't even find the words :O A drunk karaoke singer perhaps?
Ok...thats it, Anette is very good singer, I like she, but for Nightwish she was much of pop voice. Floor is better for her voice...
what is the problem with a pop voice?....I think when Anette was with Nithwish the band becomes much greater!
Eduardo Castro
Much greater? How? :-D Now, this band is greater ever. With Anette was unhappy, without energy, emotions, cold...now, with Floor, is the best Nightwish by years.
1984seky with tarja* is better !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! much better i think i dont know ^^
Tarja, Tarja, Tarja...Tarja is not Nightwish by much of years, Tarja is cold to her fans, Tarja is good singer, but not much better than Floor.
Now you say something....I dont like Tarja personality with her fans too.
Now this is just awful =(
Nope. Tarja all the way..like if you agree!!\m/
Strange to hear this version after hearing Floor’s version. It’s pop versus rock. I don’t like this version at all. She is a pop singer and not a rock singer
Pop singer? Sorry but The pop singers are very different.
Exactly!
Horrivel....
kkkkkkkkkkkk
Why
AWFUL
Holy shit, i almost threw up after the first sentence, this was awful.
I’m always trying to be nice when Anette sings, but thanks for saying that…