This is my favorite slow movement in the trio sonatas. There's something mystical about it. More chromatic than some of the others. Well done young lady.
Sarkasmusfilter ab. Das vorweg. Da kam in den Sinn dieses Amis (Mark, aufgewachsen in einem Kuhdorf in Apache Co. Arizona) ein Lied, das meine Frau (aufgewachsen in Kiel Schleswig- Holstein) unseren gemeinsamen Kindern ganz Kulturtreu vorgesungen und somit beibebracht hat. "Hänschen klein ging allein....Stock und Hut....aber Mutter weihnet sehr usw." Entschuldigung, wenn das albern klingt. Einstein aber sagte, dass Kindermärchen voller Wahrheit sind. Vielleicht hast du lieber Hans dieselben Geistesverbindungen zwischen unserm "Basti" und seinem musikalischen Liebesbrief an seinen Sohn CPE--d.h. an uns im Jahre(!) 2023. "" "" "" "" "" " It's a very intime thought. And so I codedswitch back to my mother tongue, US Cowboy English. My first organ teacher when I went away to college at the ripe age of 17.5 was J. J. Keeler. He learned the instrument from Karl Straube at the Leipzig Conservatory during the fatal years 1931-1933. Through Straube's good office "JJ" was able to leave Germany in peace and resume lessons with Sir Ernest Bullock at Westminster Abbey. There he learned what Leipzig could not teach, to wit, hymn playing alla Brit. I was one of maybe 1000 fortunate girls and boyz who learned Music and the Organ from a damned (bloody) well-equipped teacher. My point? A saying of Keeler's we all got to hear at least once: "You listen to all the rest, then you wash your ears out with Bach.". Amiright?? Cheers n bravos🙏❤️, Mark
Same! I wanted to hear if the the transcription has somehow managed to "improve" the original by adding a few extra notes. It didn't! All the rich harmonies and virtuosic passages already are present in Bach's original.
Bach would disagree with you! You dishonor everything he did with this comment! Johann Sebastian Bach would often write the initials "S. D. G." at the end of his compositions, which stands for Soli Deo Gloria or "To God alone, the glory.”
A masterpiece made visible by a master !! I have been listening to performances of this work for a good while - this is the first one in my opinion which perfectly balances the voices, is completely transparent, is RIGHT ON with the tempo and the touch of an angel level of rubato. A wonderfully subtle registration. I don't believe the work can be performed at any higher level than Ms. Juodelyte did. BRAVO !! ALLE ACHTUNG !!
I come back every week to listen this Bach' andante . Beauty of the work and of course , talent and beauty of the player Karolina. Thanks again Karolina !
Great performance! Just love that movement. I could hear it a thousand times without getting bored. Would love to hear the entire Sonata! Thanks for posting!
the great master at it again. I have been studying and admiring J.S. Bach for years now but I never heard this beautiful piece. What strikes me the most how much Mozart I hear in this piece! especially near the end. Also.. masterfully played Karolina!
I was looking for a good performance of this piece, found it! I found others that did sound a rather mechanical. This performance is really alive. Thank you.
At one time, only boys and men had the strength and stamina to learn and perform professionally on pipe organs because of the heavy mechanical keys and pedals. When electrification eliminated the male advantage decades passed before girls and women began to try their hands (and feet!) at the pipe organ. However, they have caught up and, in some case, excelled.
Such a refined, soft playing directly dissolves in the soul. It was this magical moment that Bach himself was looking for and finding... After all, it is customary to roar and scream on the organ in order to suppress the listener, just as the organist himself was suppressed in childhood. But a weightless, airy performance is such a rarity that each such success is a real discovery for me! A month ago I discovered this your greatest musical godsend and now I listen to this record every morning. I immediately have the inspiration to get up and go on refining my home organ, which is almost already working. To make every day magical, I look for magical music every morning. But lately I haven’t been looking for anything, I start the day with this recording, and the day turns out to be fabulous. Refined waving of phrases, peaceful tempo, cosmically beautiful and perfectly matched registers, soulful organ itself as soulful organist... I think it woild be better to lead right hand in the beginning on legato, or even legatissimo, then it would envelop the space and be a link connecting the footfall of the bass and middle voice soaring in the sky.
Quelle approche romantique de cette pièce ! C''est assez rare - et beau ! - pour être souligné. On écouterait volontiers l'ensemble de la sonate. Belle registration.
Magnífic piece of the giant Bach in a magnific interpretation of so nice and perfect musician. Delight for all the senses and the soul. Thanks from Argentina.
Perfect performance of a magnific work of the supreme musician ever, the "voice of God" as Wynton Marsalis once said. Congratulations from Balcarce, Argentina.
Execução muito boa técnica e expressivamente. É o Bach de sempre. Perfeito em sua intenção expressiva emergindo naturalmente da construção técnica deste gênio inigualável.
If ever Hans Zimmer is about to search for a well-talented organist, to record a new OST, just as with Interstellar: I would love to hear Ms. Joudelyte playing for him. I listened to a couple of her recordings now, and she is one of few subscribed. It is a pleasure to hear her playing Bach.
But listen to the pedals! Piano transcriptions of Bach don't work. Too much is added by the transcriber when the harmonic structure defies anything more than Bach intended us to hear. (sadly as i love have a go at transcribing him)
Eu sou um organista brasileiro que conhece a particularidade de cada uma das 6 trio-sonatas (ou sonatas em forma de trio) de Johann Sebastian Bach: elas são em seu gênero o que há de mais aprimorado, nenhum compositor anterior nem sucessor igualou nem muito menos superou o grande mestre alemão, até mesmo o seu predileto aluno Johann Ludwig Krebs. Só me recordo das palavras do saudoso colega Calimério Soares: "Para mim um organista é completo se souber tocar as trio-sonatas de Bach respeitando tudo o que está escrito na pauta, isto é, durações, articulações, ornamentos, andamentos e repetições, além de registrações diferenciadas e equilibradas em todas as três partes mutuamente. Um que fez isso foi Carl Weinrich."
Mind-blowing how one performer can play 3 voices simultaneously. It's hard enough to play Bach on a guitar, I can't imagine with 2 manuals AND footpedals! How long did you have to rehearse this piece before mastering it?
![J.S. Bach-Organ Sonata No.4 BWV.528: II. Andante [Adagio] 바흐 오르간 소나타 4번 2악장](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/prqSDo3Wugw/mqdefault.jpg)
![J.S. Bach-Organ Sonata No.4 BWV.528: II. Andante [Adagio] 바흐 오르간 소나타 4번 2악장](/img/tr.png)
![Oscar Maydon x Fuerza Regida - Tu Boda [Official Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/_ymicn0_GYc/mqdefault.jpg)
![Chino Pacas - Modo Capone (with Drake & Fuerza Regida) [Video Oficial]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/zjv8TQ0gBkg/mqdefault.jpg)
![Víkingur Ólafsson - Bach: Organ Sonata No. 4, BWV 528: II. Andante [Adagio] (Transcr. Stradal)](/img/1.gif)
One of the most relaxing pieces in the history of music.
So true, but it is, paradoxically, strangely invigorating too. Bach's magic.
Ditto.
❤❤❤BWV 528
@@ericiverson3441
This is my favorite slow movement in the trio sonatas. There's something mystical about it. More chromatic than some of the others. Well done young lady.
Great playing! Good to see Bach played by the young generation. Thumbs-up also to the composer.
Sarkasmusfilter ab. Das vorweg.
Da kam in den Sinn dieses Amis (Mark, aufgewachsen in einem Kuhdorf in Apache Co. Arizona) ein Lied, das meine Frau (aufgewachsen in Kiel Schleswig- Holstein) unseren gemeinsamen Kindern ganz Kulturtreu vorgesungen und somit beibebracht hat.
"Hänschen klein ging allein....Stock und Hut....aber Mutter weihnet sehr usw."
Entschuldigung, wenn das albern klingt. Einstein aber sagte, dass Kindermärchen voller Wahrheit sind. Vielleicht hast du lieber Hans dieselben Geistesverbindungen zwischen unserm "Basti" und seinem musikalischen Liebesbrief an seinen Sohn CPE--d.h. an uns im Jahre(!) 2023.
"" "" "" "" "" "
It's a very intime thought. And so I codedswitch back to my mother tongue, US Cowboy English.
My first organ teacher when I went away to college at the ripe age of 17.5 was J. J. Keeler. He learned the instrument from Karl Straube at the Leipzig Conservatory during the fatal years 1931-1933. Through Straube's good office "JJ" was able to leave Germany in peace and resume lessons with Sir Ernest Bullock at Westminster Abbey. There he learned what Leipzig could not teach, to wit, hymn playing alla Brit. I was one of maybe 1000 fortunate girls and boyz who learned Music and the Organ from a damned (bloody) well-equipped teacher.
My point? A saying of Keeler's we all got to hear at least once:
"You listen to all the rest, then you wash your ears out with Bach.". Amiright??
Cheers n bravos🙏❤️,
Mark
Every pianist or organist MUST have J.S.Bach's music in own daily study!!
Every single person on this earth needs Bach in their lives! Even the deaf!
@@JohannSebastianWainwright Holy words, holy words. Many musical critics consider Bach's music the earth mean for the man to grew up toward God!
This is indeed the best performance of BWV 528 II. Andante I have heard.
Alternatively, you might also hear my recommendation: Vikungur Ólafsson, BWV 528: II.Andante (Adagio), Transcr. Stradal
Came here from Ólafsson's Stradel piano transcription. Awesome xx
Same! I wanted to hear if the the transcription has somehow managed to "improve" the original by adding a few extra notes. It didn't! All the rich harmonies and virtuosic passages already are present in Bach's original.
As someone wrote: without Bach, God would have no reason to exist. Beautiful 🎵🎶 Greetings from Costa Rica 🇨🇷
What nonsens, without Hashem there is no BACH! Greetings from the Black Forest, Germany
Heresy!
Vice versa ..... otherwise it's heresy !
He would
Bach would disagree with you! You dishonor everything he did with this comment! Johann Sebastian Bach would often write the initials "S. D. G." at the end of his compositions, which stands for Soli Deo Gloria or "To God alone, the glory.”
Vielen Dank diese wunderschöne Musik für uns gespiellt zu haben.
A masterpiece made visible by a master !! I have been listening to performances of this work for a good while - this is the first one in my opinion which perfectly balances the voices, is completely transparent, is RIGHT ON with the tempo and the touch of an angel level of rubato. A wonderfully subtle registration. I don't believe the work can be performed at any higher level than Ms. Juodelyte did. BRAVO !! ALLE ACHTUNG !!
Totally agree Calvin.
Dear Karolina, your play in my heart and in my soul. Thank you very much for your amazing playing!
I love this piece! I love Bach! ❤️🎹🎹🎹
What a timless piece . Like following the sun surounding the center of our galaxy on a musical level .
Karolina Joudelyle Thank you for sharing you Art with J.S.Bach. Greetings from Venezuela land.
I come back every week to listen this Bach' andante . Beauty of the work and of course , talent and beauty of the player Karolina. Thanks again Karolina !
I am so glad to hear this! Greetings from Berlin 🎶
Absolutamente glorioso. Una de mis piezas preferidas tocada maravillosamente, de verdad muchas gracias por esta interpretación!!!!!
Great performance! Just love that movement. I could hear it a thousand times without getting bored. Would love to hear the entire Sonata! Thanks for posting!
Bach would be proud of you, your phrasing is brilliant!
My favourite rendition of this piece on RUclips, thank you for making this video. Such an amazing performance of this extraordinary music.
the great master at it again. I have been studying and admiring J.S. Bach for years now but I never heard this beautiful piece. What strikes me the most how much Mozart I hear in this piece! especially near the end. Also.. masterfully played Karolina!
I was looking for a good performance of this piece, found it! I found others that did sound a rather mechanical. This performance is really alive. Thank you.
Healing - as any piece created by the Genius! The interpretation is beautiful - the female delicacy resounds! Thank you!
At one time, only boys and men had the strength and stamina to learn and perform professionally on pipe organs because of the heavy mechanical keys and pedals. When electrification eliminated the male advantage decades passed before girls and women began to try their hands (and feet!) at the pipe organ. However, they have caught up and, in some case, excelled.
Bach con questa musica ci conduce per mano ai confini del cosmo.
This is heavenly, thank you!
Karolina, this is simply amazing, thank you for your interpretation, it sounds speciaL .
This song brings me happiness. Very refreshing for the soul.
Toda a genialidade de Bach em cinco minutos. Parabéns, Karolina.
Registration, tempo, and expression (and the organ!) are all lovely. I've saved your performance for when I want to hear this movement.
Danke!
Berührt mich.
Thank you for your videos, this one is my favourite❤️ Your beautiful pedal touch, and soft legato takes my mind out of sadness🤗🤗🤗
Such a refined, soft playing directly dissolves in the soul. It was this magical moment that Bach himself was looking for and finding... After all, it is customary to roar and scream on the organ in order to suppress the listener, just as the organist himself was suppressed in childhood. But a weightless, airy performance is such a rarity that each such success is a real discovery for me! A month ago I discovered this your greatest musical godsend and now I listen to this record every morning. I immediately have the inspiration to get up and go on refining my home organ, which is almost already working.
To make every day magical, I look for magical music every morning. But lately I haven’t been looking for anything, I start the day with this recording, and the day turns out to be fabulous. Refined waving of phrases, peaceful tempo, cosmically beautiful and perfectly matched registers, soulful organ itself as soulful organist...
I think it woild be better to lead right hand in the beginning on legato, or even legatissimo, then it would envelop the space and be a link connecting the footfall of the bass and middle voice soaring in the sky.
Amazing. You're very talented, great ear and such grace. Kindest regards!
Quelle approche romantique de cette pièce ! C''est assez rare - et beau ! - pour être souligné. On écouterait volontiers l'ensemble de la sonate. Belle registration.
This is so gorgeous in every way. Thank you Karolina.
Perfect. Thank you!
Absolutely beautiful. Thank you, Mrs. Karolina.
Magnífic piece of the giant Bach in a magnific interpretation of so nice and perfect musician.
Delight for all the senses and the soul.
Thanks from Argentina.
Splendid interpretation. Bravo !
Great job Karoline, congratulations!
I need a woman like her in my life.
I would listen her play organ from morning till dawn.
Beautiful interpretation. Thank you and good luck.
So beautiful
Wonderful! Thanks for sharing.
Magnifique !!!
She is one of my best organ players.
Bravo! very nice and inspiring to listen to :)
My very favorite organ piece by Bach.
Beautiful!
Perfect performance of a magnific work of the supreme musician ever, the "voice of God" as Wynton Marsalis once said.
Congratulations from Balcarce, Argentina.
Wonderful piece ❤ i Like This very much / i subscribed ❤
incredible, I love this.
Makes me feel warm and fuzzy inside when i hear this.
Это пожалуй самое лучшее исполнение данного произведения! Спасибо!
Great performance rich of phatos ! My compliments!!
Thank you!!!!!
Absolutely wonderfoul sounds 🎹🎶
Beautiful - Congratulations
Ausgezeichnet. ❤️
Beautifully played.
Many thanks, God bless you.
Только это исполнение и слушаю, очень хорошо.
This makes me calm and happy.
Wonderfull!! 👏👏👏
When the angels sing to God , they sing J S Bach music. Soli Deo Gloria
mesmerising, thank you
La mejor versión que he escuchado.
Execução muito boa técnica e expressivamente.
É o Bach de sempre.
Perfeito em sua intenção expressiva emergindo naturalmente da construção técnica deste gênio inigualável.
Завораживает!!! ))
Комментарии излишни)
Beautifully played!
If ever Hans Zimmer is about to search for a well-talented organist, to record a new OST, just as with Interstellar: I would love to hear Ms. Joudelyte playing for him. I listened to a couple of her recordings now, and she is one of few subscribed. It is a pleasure to hear her playing Bach.
4:10 I love this part
Браво 👍🏻
Une magnifique registration, Bravo.
Beautiful playing!
Magnificent 🙏🏼
Fabulous playing 👏👏👏👏
just see how she just glide across those pedal notes oww.Thanks Karolina love the speed and regisration.Please do entire work???
A very good sound of a organ.
C'est magnifique
Holy cross, batman! That's awesome!
Obigado! Grazie mille!
OMG 😱 4:17 that D# got me ❤️❤️❤️ amazing
Maravilhoso!!!
Very Pleasant - Thank you for this Work now played by a great pianist disk D.Gramophone
But listen to the pedals! Piano transcriptions of Bach don't work. Too much is added by the transcriber when the harmonic structure defies anything more than Bach intended us to hear. (sadly as i love have a go at transcribing him)
Exquisite!
Brava!!!
All Bach is Sacred music.
Magic.
i like it. great performance
Moça, você é muito boa! Esta peça de Bach ficou ainda melhor com sua interpretação! Parabéns!
Eu sou um organista brasileiro que conhece a particularidade de cada uma das 6 trio-sonatas (ou sonatas em forma de trio) de Johann Sebastian Bach: elas são em seu gênero o que há de mais aprimorado, nenhum compositor anterior nem sucessor igualou nem muito menos superou o grande mestre alemão, até mesmo o seu predileto aluno Johann Ludwig Krebs. Só me recordo das palavras do saudoso colega Calimério Soares: "Para mim um organista é completo se souber tocar as trio-sonatas de Bach respeitando tudo o que está escrito na pauta, isto é, durações, articulações, ornamentos, andamentos e repetições, além de registrações diferenciadas e equilibradas em todas as três partes mutuamente. Um que fez isso foi Carl Weinrich."
Diese Performance hat mir wohl gefallen. Grüße aus Brasilien!
Bravo!
素晴らしい!!!
Bravo !!!
Love it!
Mind-blowing how one performer can play 3 voices simultaneously. It's hard enough to play Bach on a guitar, I can't imagine with 2 manuals AND footpedals! How long did you have to rehearse this piece before mastering it?
I've tried the instrument maybe 40 times, ameteur player, yeah the "3" voices really gives you a headache but amazing feel when you finally manage
Fantastisch.
Puikus atlikimas, bravo!
❤️💕💕
Nice and soft.
The organ is a crazy instrument. Where do you start practicing that
At church obviously
Un vrai dialogue amoureux entre les deux mains...
great