Without fixing the homeless problem add another 200k. Its absolute insanity. Infrastructure is not up to standard to bring in more and more we will all suffer.
The houses will all go to free loading migrants who are given comp from the government. Most of the migrants, save a few good ones who will try to contribute, are NPCs
Tell them to work harder not slower Everything is expensive so try telling them to be independent and smart that way they can save money and buy a house Remember it's 2023 not 1993 😂
Its because they are not working hard enough and they are spending more than they are earning, why lots of migrants end up making their own homes where locals find it hard to make their homes?? its simple because migrants know the importance of not spending more than what they earn and they end up saving a lot which you don't
650.000 Migrants will vote for the Government that give them a new country to live in and the benefits as well .This is Albo's idea to help get his racist voice scam over the line and also to help him stay in Government at the next Fed election more migrants = more votes for him.
That's right it's all vote grabbing. Albanese and this government must go. Timecwe had a pm that's not scared to speak out. Send all the illegals back for starters
Asking people in the street is not a reliable form of journalism. People could be afraid that they will lose their jobs, or welfare payments if they say the wrong thing. But put a bug under their kitchen table and see what they really think...
If people from the street don't provide you adequate answer or share their opinions , mean that the government is in control and keep people in fear . Doesn't strike as a democratic country.
@@williamcrossan9333 97% of Australians come from immigration. What you want to promote is an end to negative gearing and capital gains tax concessions for buying and selling housing you don't live in. I bet you don't even understand how many properties are vacant due to this,
@@IIIIIIIIlIlIlllIlllI Hey fake name keyboard warrior it's easy to lie when there are no consequences. And you are just making it up to suit your boomer narrative.
Exactly. That is why they had to have a Life in UK test. Because of the cultural differences....hmmm. You cannot make people adopt a culture and change.
@@superlight7654 especially two cultures that are so radically different from each other and have pretty much been mortal enemies for thousands of years.
The biggest lie is that Australia is a large country so it needs more people. 70% of Australia is uninhabitable desert , if you take into accout the land that is actually habitable Australia is no larger then New zealand. Almost all immigrants move into the already overcrowded large cities and not the regional areas with lower populations. Its only big business, property developers that benefits from mass immigration , while the vast majority of the people sufffer
Family visas..so theres almost no health or employment prospect requirements. One aged care worker eg a carer can sponsor their whole family regardless of either.
You asked the wrong people, you asked mainly boomers that most likely own property. It's not a problem for them, infact it's actually a benefit for them as it will increase the price of their property, for young Australians it's not good. It will just increase rents and price us out of the housing market even more
Australia's rich= own your own home. A 3RD will never own, a 3rd owe the bank, a 3rd owns. So if you do own you are in the top 33% of the rich list. Australia's dream is almost lost completely
@@ozziecoops it is terrible to watch this happen to our younger generations as it is for them. Albo said Liberal didn't care for the future of our children yet here we are debating the voice over homelessness in cities and the violence in remote areas to children. He the biggest Hypocrite there has ever been.
Old ppl are just selfishly thinking about themselves, they get desperate and clingy as they get older because they know they'll need carers. Migrants are not interested in coming here to look after old white ppl. They're more likely to suffocate them with a pillow, than give a crap about changing their depends undergarments...
The point is that the government is not even trying to attract the 'right' skilled workers. Instead, they have granted permanent residency to those who never obtained a proper degree, never set foot in Australia, and never studied here. These individuals are a group of people who couldn't even find a job in countries like China or India, yet they have been granted permanent residency by the Australian government. Meanwhile, those with RIGHT skills who are already residing in Australia and contributing to their communities have been left out by the incompetent labor party.
Next time vote for Suatainable Australia or One Nation. They are the only parties that are willing to reduce immigration. Even the Greens want to import people from the third world, to endow them with a western living standard at the expense of Australians.
@C R The desert cities in America have the same problem that most of Australia has: _not enough fresh water_ . It was irresponsible for urban planners to build cities in places like Phoenix or Las Vegas.
Now they do. But they voted almost 30 years straight LNP. We had a million and a half permanent temp migrants and cheap labor floating around the country.continiously. Party is over.
Listen to the speech You are getting less migrants with Labor. Libs had a million and a half temporary migrants floating around the country continuously for almost two decades.. Keeping your wages low. This is why we're screwed..wake up.
as a non australian... i beg your government to get your house in order....have a proper long term 100 years plan with regards to housing, skills in demand, new industries, invstment in new communities before allowing more migrants in! I am myself looking to migrate but i dont want to be a part of an already overburdened system. Its a loss-loss for everyone. With proper strategy it can be a win-win for all. Lets not turn yourself in to Canadian housing crisis please.
Australian housing crisis is literally at the same level as Canada’s. Been in both countries. Both countries are fucked. They need to have their own people have more babies. They need to mass educate those babies in manufacturing, STEM, etc. They need to completely eradicate drugs and vapes and other things that make a population unhealthy. They need to bring family structure back.
Who are we? You do know only the 3% of the population is indigenous right? The rest are immigrants from all over the world. You need to listen to the great Australian song we are Australian by the Seekers on loop.
@@David_Beames in the eyes of the diversities, you are no different to a "bogan" your wokeness does not make you any better in their estimation, to them you are a convict racist with no culture who stole this land anyway, your woke virtue signalling earns you no respect because your disrespect for your own kind is then reflected back onto yourself. If you call your brothers bad names, those outside the family will see you the way you see your brothers.
"Not a worker shortage, more like a welfare surplus !" No it's not. The problem is that there is a refusal to train people to do jobs & the jobs in the rural areas don't have anyone to do them because those jobs have been taken up by backpackers for 20+ years, forcing locals to move out of those rural areas & in to urban population centers looking for work. It's got nothing to do with welfare & everything to do with government protectionism.
It’s simple. More people means more consumers. More consumers means more earners and more tax. It makes economy stronger. With some states now broke, it is one of the choices. Working population is needed whether local born or overseas.
@@DS-nx6zq Migrants cost. They compete with Australians for the time and attention of Australian-trained doctors, nurses and teachers. Migrants crowd up infrastructure that existed before they arrived, for which they haven't paid and will never pay for. Migrants contribute to the need for more infrastructure that everyone has to pay for, not just the newcomers that make it necessary. We have plenty of workers. All that we need. What does it matter if employers don't fill all their vacant positions? They should offer higher wages.
Once a aussie women in her thirties told that she simpley does not want to work as she gets more welfare than the paid job. Also average aussie expects to roll in range rover while fixing pipes or working as a barista. America being more richer and higher GDP/capita than australia never offers such generous welfare. Thus more industrialised and high innovation. Australia simply imports all aspects of well developed nation. Brisbane transport system including Translink card is pucca copy of oyester card in UK.
@@roydavis5613 Cheaper to bring in low paid workers via a hire company . I know a highly skilled specialist welder that trained imported workers that were listed as " Welders " before training they Could Not Weld as good as the average home handyman self taught welder, some could never do it but they got to stay in Australia doing whatever, Dole , Uber , Scamming etc.
This is ridiculous when the homeless have increased by 3x, labor/greens have to be the biggest idiots... regional areas are not in that much desperation, the homeless are in desperation
So more migrants coming to put more pressure on our water supplies. But if we do have migrants, make sure they have trade or other tertiary qualifications. And they need to make a genuine effort to assimilate.
We need to pause the intake every two years for a period of 2 years. Max 50,000 every year. None for Melbourne, Brisbane or Sydney. Exception should be for Doctors, Nurses and age care workers.
I heard a native Australian reporter asked native residents whether they want thieves and crooks from Britain in their country. The view was aggressively NOOOO.
Pollies are seriously short sighted when it comes to policy. Our unemployment rate is going to rise rapidly in the next 6 months. When America sneezes the rest of the world catches a cold? They are on their 3rd quarter of negative GDP, it's a recession. The housing market is in freefall, worse than 2008. The RBA has stopped raising rates. Rates go up pause and the go down. When the rate goes down you know your in trouble, it's happened before and it will happen again. Because of stimi-checks and lockdowns the whiplash effect is going to be massive. People are already struggling with power bills and food price increases. Now we have to compete with 600,000 more people looking for work. It's the Labour Party's (commies) way of having open boarders and buying votes. If we siphon of the best and brightest from other countries, aren't we condemning those countries to poorer outcomes. Why does the government outsource medicine production and stifled investment in manufacturing? Where are they going to get rare earth oxides from? China? Why destroy working infrastructure, coal fired power stations, when the alternatives can't fill the gap? Don't know. Why is Australia one of the biggest producers of uranium, but we only have a "medical reactor". Don't know. What are they going to do with all the broken solar panels? Don't know. Where are the going to get the magnets for wind turbines? Don't know. Why is the government so reliant on China, to the point we can't make our own stuff. Narcissistic globalists are not right in the head. What's the Australian military going to do without chips when China invades Taiwan? Where do we fit in with China's world domination plan? Is it a coincidence that Putin an XI where both WEF young leaders? And both are at war with the west. Conspiracies are mostly correct these days.
Quiet Ackshon - We buy from China so we don't have to make anything. If we don't manufacture, then we don't need to invest and train staff - and so we logically will have a skills shortage. We sell our raw mineral resources as we find that easier than making stuff, but that creates jobs for only the wealthy. The poor are limited to low paying unskilled labour or service based jobs. Most engineers and doctors are now Chinese or Indian. What goes around comes around. If we import, the Aussie Government makes a lot more money in import duties and taxes. The governments who make these dumb decisions won't be in office in a few years, so they don't need to take responsibility and wont be held accountable after they have died. They can sit on their retirement packages and tell the rest of us to "fuck off" when we complain about the future results showing themselves for what they are. It's no wonder I gave up voting years ago. Why vote for someone you have no faith in.
Actually, America is ondergoing the greatest boom in modern history. The total size of the industrial base in America will DOUBLE over the next 10 years.
@@Ozgrade3 Thanks for making us all a little dumber with your well researched assessment, based on what, Government projections? Or is it the Democrats unfulfilled economic promises, the 2 year and 10 year inversion or the stimie-check issue? Perhaps it's the continuous stream of lies coming from the White House.
My son lives in Osaka, and is having his third child in July, crazy thing is though he gets 12 months maternity leave funded by the Japanese government.
@@ritaa1359utter nonsense 😂 Americans migrate to the UK in similar numbers British migrate to America, its very balanced. It does not work if millions arrive and millions of British don't leave for the migrants countries, it causes serious problems indeed
It is illogical if they are thinking of fulfilling the demands of the labour force, such as staff for hospitals, nursing homes, and schools etc, it only adds a small supply with increased demand. The demand is always greater than the supply. We still haven't learnt the management of resources.
As someone who has lived and worked in the US and the EU, I chose to move to Australia for the weather and be closer to some friends and family here. When I arrived as a skilled migrant around 15 years ago, the housing market was still manageable and transport issues weren't as bad. Now in 2023 after a raft of transportation projects and FHB allowances and what not, things have almost hit the fan. I am particularly unimpressed with the FHB allowances, there is no point in having them since the prices get jacked up and the so-called allowance vanishes without making a dent in the amount of money one needs to cough up to own a place.
I came to Australia as an immigrant 60 years ago. It was no different. There were few jobs, and most did not last long! A lot of Australia is surplus to requirement. We refuse to accept the truth. Most people struggled to live at any time.
@@shyamchabra5355 do you see australia making the same mistakes as 60 years ago? We had the baby boom back then, now there are so many baby boomers and they require more health care and more aged care, so the government say we need an immigrant boom to care for the baby boomers. Now in another 60 years we will need another boom to take care of today’s immigrant boom that have become older. That’s how I see it.
Sounds good but doesn't work, as migrant myself I don't see Ausis getting into technical fields like engineering, tech, or medicine. That's where the issue lies, perhaps stop studying useless fields like music, arts, gender studies and focus on what matters
@@tazoman26 the sports industries is unironically the single most vital part of this country's economy, why would you learn maths when you could be a field runner or a sprinter? Not to mention most people instead of going to university, would rather do a apprenticeship in construction, because only work related to real estate development is just about the only thing worth anything as a skillset here aside from sports
That's very true, most of the local crowd is not willing to study medical, science & technology, engineering, IT, Math etc as studying and working in these sectors in general is pretty boring compared to more exciting and creative fields like Fashion, Hospitality, Retail, beauty, sports etc. Hence there is acute shortages of skilled employees.
Absolutely not!!!! Australia’s infrastructure is struggling as it is, the last thing we need is more people coming here. We need to shut down immigration for at least 10 years.
The presenter on the show with a beard is a migrant himself or his parents, yet he has the nerve to point out the migrants they interviewed from their accent.
Decentralisation is one of the considerations to alleviate urbanisation. Most of migrants settle in cities, because the rural Australian areas don't have convenience and employment opportunities.
Hiroko, If you imagine that the VAST MAJORITY of immigrants would even consider living in a regional area of Australia extols how deluded you must be. Because the reality is that, virtually every migrant is like Dick Wittington and is looking for a place where the streets are paved with gold. Apart from that, do you think that all bar the odd soul would come here to live in Dubbo or Wagga? Please, spare are this fanciful crap.
In reality tough to add millions even though Australia is so large. A huge portion of land is not as hospitable for large numbers of people. So basically millions more would make current areas higher density. Plus it would cause migration to new suburbs which would need costly infrastructure.
Rubbish. Even with most of the continent uninhabitable, there's still plenty of room along most of the lush green eastern seaboard. People from overseas (and not necessarily from just overcrowded third world countries) will rightfully laugh in your face for suggesting that Australia can't efficiently handle more. It's just that most Australians are dumb and want to huddle together in cities despite all the empty regional space. Or more like successive governments are to blame for creating an economy that more-or-less forces people to live in cities just for the work purposes. Bit of both perhaps. And another problem many of us Aussies have is the spoiled entitlement mentality of living in large cities yet still wanting to live on large property blocks (preferably with a 1-story house), causing wasteful low density urban sprawl and all the problems associated with it.
I'm a white Australian who has worked in the Hotel industry and aged care. I have found that most places will only employ there own, without being racist," Asian or Indian!" Not are white Australian who can speak 100% English! That's what I found with clients or dealing with guests is that they can understand stand my vocabulary!
maybe the old people are of that community and dont understand english being very old ? hence the preference fo someone who understands their language and culture. The old generations from the mainland are ... how do i say it ..... a different kind ...
Same in the UK, especially London! Then they say Brits are too lazy to do the job 🙄 This happened in the building trade too, advertising the jobs in Poland to unskilled workers, an🤷 Don't get me wrong, the polish are very hard working people, and they have their own highly skilled workers, but it was mostly unskilled that was getting first offers of a job, because they except the lower rates of pay. They they live 10- 15 people in a small apartment and have little overheads.
I personally know staff in QLD health departments, ranging from HR departments right into the on ground staff in hospitals. During covid was huge job layoffs, these people are doing work of 2-3 people. With next to no staff, they are crying for more staff to help. They’re management saying they trying to employ people but none apply. We know this is a lie as myself and other have applied for positions, that we are skilled, educated and more than capable of doing. We all get rejected!!! The staff ask their management about this, with responses from their management saying things like “no one has applied”. It’s all a big fat lie!
For those that don't apply for jobs - get rid of the vaccine mandates and people might rethink the job application. Its basically discrimination by having such - not about health and safety. Lots of new evidence against the vaccines being life threatening.
You would get new staff if those people thought they would find affordable decent accommodation to live in that area. No housing means the people will not risk moving even for a new job which would increase knowledge and practice. Where will the poorly paid immigrants live? Do you want to put them up in containers like Qatar workers?
Sounds like an investigation is urgently required into the characters involved in perpetuating the myth that no one applies. We could do with some grown ups taking the reigns here.... Unbelievable!!! If you don't give a sh*t, GET OUT. Enough Crap
Yes people do apply- but senior management put constraints on the staffing budget. So as a consequence, skilled, capable people are rejected because they are too expensive. Hospitals want cheap labour. Overseas migrants are cheap labour. You then see local people lose a job they could perform to a migrant.
Personally, I've seen the other side of the coin. Non qualified people hired to fill vacant positions. But most of these people resign after 6-12 months because it is too much work for them. And they can easily find another less demanding job.
The absolute core issue is being overlooked. Birth rates in free fall is a direct consequence of hyper feminism. The communities which have better birth rates might lack first world civic sense. But, their birth rates are better due to stronger emphasis on traditional gender roles and much longer lasting marriages.
G A - I love kids and would have more tomorrow, if I could find an Aussie woman that was supportive and not a gold digger in the family court - and I would be able to have a stable house and not rent. I've moved 39 times since my second divorce in 2001 and lost not one but TWO homes to my ex in court over a technicality. This meant I had to move interstate to get housing rather than stay with my 3 married kids and 3 grandsons - who don't give a fuck about their father's mortality. My mental and physical health is now failing as I get older, as would it be for any kids living with me in a transitory lifestyle. Unfortunately in this day and age if a man loves kids, he has to be a closet pedophile - not a father figure; - so what's the point !
That and more young people having to live longer with their parents due to being unable to afford a home or even find a place they can afford to rent. Can't imagine a young couple wanting to start a family out of one of their parents spare rooms.
GA Birth rates will rise if the people see a healthy and happy FUTURE. If a dystopian future is all they have to look forward to, they will avoid having families. Surely that's obvious !!!
@@kimbal1958 My thoughts exactly. The legal system and social norms have incentivized divorce and hypergamy for women. Men literally have every reason to shun the institution of marriage, having kids and raising a family. I played the dating musical chairs sham for quite a while. As my mates and acquaintances around me got married, I dodged the bullet of getting hitched. It is no coincidence that most of my mates are either divorced, or separated, or locked into a destructive marriage that is ruining their finances and peace of mind. With literally no tangible benefits in return. I am in my early forties, never married and debt free. Absolutely no regrets. Life is too short to worry about changing demographics and political gamesmanship played by the permanent political establishment.
so they will take p more Australian jobs and more homes that we dont have and poor infrastructure to cater for it all.. fk that... how many are still sacked for not being forced into the jab
And it is a false claim. We are the descendants of migrants, like everyone else on the planet. It is only the mass immigration since the Howard government, that has increased the proportion of foreigners among us. We are still mostly Australian born, though many of us have foreign parents. Last time we had so many immigrants was during the gold rushes.
It’s got nothing to do with Albanese, the World Economic Forum have told him what to do, and as a good boy ,he’s going to do it...... Albanese has always been a flake ; that’s why the World Economic Forum picked him for the job...
In 1984, Bob Hawke refuted the claims made by professor Blainey that, "it was an agenda by the government and big business to Asianize Australia". At that time Hawke responded with saying: "It's not my intention or, that of my government, to Asianise Australia. In fact, Asians won't even be four percent of the population by 2000." Well, when the year 2000 came around, the official ABS figures had Asiatics to be 7.6% of Australia's population. In other words DOUBLE what Hawke falsely espoused. Twenty years later in 2020, Asiatics had surged to become 18% of the population (ethnic-Chinese account for the clear majority). And now in 2023, Asiatics are over 24% of the total popultion. Included in that number are over 400,000 people in the country occupying educational institutions. In addition to that, a cabal of other non-Anglo/European ethnocultural groups accrue to being 11% of the country's population. However, the non-AE component of Sydney and Melbourne's populations have them being slight majorities of both cities. In numerous suburbs of either city, such as Burwood, Hurstville and Wolli Creek in Sydney Asiatics account for 80% of all the residents. This comes to pass, because there are close to 900,000 people in each city who aren't citizens: the largest cohort being international students. But what's so incredible is with how at, the same time Labor is pushing for a "Yes" vote for the Voice, it has an open-borders program of people from non-AE sources who have no sense of guilt for dispossessing indigenous people.
Interesting take, doesnt matter where people are from, there is just too many. And we are all paying for it. Litterally check the bottom of you tax return.
@@allong4709 Allong, you say, "it doesn't matter where people are from", which is fine so long as they aren't in such numbers that, they go from being significant in numbers to re-colonising not just a few suburbs but electorates. A galling example of re-colonisation is in the Parramatta area. Whereby, in less than two decades, Indians, and others from the Subcontinent, have gone from being less than 2 percent of the district to now being (overall) 40 percent but, in the suburbs of Harris Park, Westmead and Wentworthville, they're between 65-75 percent. Hence, because they are the absolute majority of suburbs means that they need not integrate into society and must inevitably use their numbers, which by 2034, there'll be a total of 3 million people of Indian heritage in Australia. So, if anyone deludes themselves that when Indians become such a significant part of the population, and they hold, up to a dozen seats in the federal parliament that, they won't organise against Australia live in Nania. To sustain this prediction is irrefutably proven by virtue of 20,000 fanatical Indians paying between 80 to 3,000 dollars to hear Modi address them at Olympic Park a few weeks ago. What a horror awaits us in a decades time.
I am a Mech/Aerospace Engineer, currently working at Safran Aircraft Engines at its HQ in Paris, was actually thinking of coming over to AUS to work for a while, yk to experience the aussie adventure, but have been told that the Migration process is ridculously complex and to some extent not worth it. I genuinly hope they're going to do smth to fix this
If you can read, write and speak English along with a very good chance of employment and don't have 30 welfare dependent relatives coming with you.Sorry you're over qualified
To be honest with you. Australia really need a similar race like immigrants from Euro to come over. However this priminister has shaken hands with the indian prime minister MODI already and that means that this country policy is to get south Asian immigrants only. So they make it harder for folks elsewhere to enter deliberately.
Sure but who exactly is the Australian you referring to. 30% were born outside Australia. 51% are either born overseas or their parents were born overseas. This is mostly young and effectively paying for welfare in Australia.
@@clemfandango619 So your definition is those not born in Australia, and their kids. So 51% since they or their parents are not Australian , the argument was way forward is Australians should produce next generation, the stated 51% non Australians are actually of age which can have children, since in order to immigrate you need to be below 45. So essentially u want about 10% (rough math) thrid generation Australian to reproduce to sustain population? Moreover for some reason above comment said "not Indians, Arabs or Chinese" although the largest population of migrants in Australia is from UK.
@@clemfandango619 So ur problem is not immigrants but non-whites? Let's remove the whole lot of 51% Australians and every immigrant other than whites. This will being down population to probably 12 million, of which most UK immigrant would be in older category, and most would also be unskilled since whole reason of skilled immigration is skilled labour shortage. This wipes all taxes paid by migrants, do u think Australia will sustain population and welfare with no immigration? Look at the issues Japan is facing with its extremely stringent immigration policy. Also this is one's migrating permanently, think about the one who work here temporarily and get no welfare but pay same taxes. This is the lot mostly funding Oz welfare with nothing in return in terms of welfare guarantee. The only issue I see with high immigration is Housing, which is something government should look into. As per available stats each migrant add 10% more to GDP than existing people. And by projection by 2050 they will contribute 1.6 trillion to GDP, that is almost same as Aus current total GDP.
Our own citizens cannot change jobs or move interstate to a new job because of the lack of housing, high and unregulated rents in short supply and others are forced out of work because they cannot afford urgent dental care or needed medical care let alone get on a waiting list. So many Australian citizens still do not have a home so does the government want to open new caravan parks to house the proposed new cheap labour immigrants or put them in containers as Qatar does?
Why not have them vote instead? On camera no one will speak truth afraid of being called racist. Voting is more reliable method to have opinion of Australians. In Canada we DO NOT need more immigrants.
It’s blatantly obvious we don’t have enough cities in this country if we are bringing in the population of Canberra and Darwin every year … When was the last time we built a new one ?
@@iggyblitz8739 Why do you think that it's inevitable that we take more migrants? Vote for One nation or Sustainable Australia. No use voting for the Greens. They aren't even slightly green. Migrants come here to increase their consumption of the earth's resources, their waste and their carbon emissions. That is what "seeking a better life" means.
You asked older people if Australia needs more immigrants. And they answered yes. Because they stand to benefit from increasing real estate prices. They need more nurses and care givers very soon. You asked the youth and the new immigrants and they said no because they are the ones who is suffering the most. This is going to lead to a decline in family formation and less children will be born in Australia. Meaning Australia will need more immigrants to make up for the tax revenue.
Immigrants cost. The tax revenue that they contribute is used up to pay for the extra infrastructure that they make necessary. Why does everyone assume that these latecomers will vote for politicians who will look after ageing white people? More likely, they will vote for politicians who will allow them to bring their own elderly to use infrastructure that they haven't paid for and never will pay for.
Most of we older people look on our houses as our homes not just investment value. We've been in our modest three bedroom ,one bathroom house for twenty five years ,not many nowadays would want it,
@@joycebaron672 It is the land that the building is sitting on that has value. The area of land within a reasonable commute of a CBD is fixed. So any increase in population makes every square metre of that land more valuable and more expensive. Anything that makes land more expensive, discourages family formation.
@chriswatson1698 I live no where near the CBD I live in nearly 3 hours from the nearest capital city .where I live you could probably get 3 houses for the price of one in Melbourne suburbs.
@@joycebaron672 And are jobs abundant in your area? Has the population increased in your area? Any increase in population anywhere will push up the price of land. Nobody is making any more land.
@@IIIIIIIIlIlIlllIlllI Exactly. A river takes the easiest course or route to the ocean. It's far easier to import labour (unskilled and skilled) than build complex industries and train existing citizens in difficult tasks.
I'm an Aussie who has applied for numerous MR driving positions.they don't want me.but every time I see a delivery truck drive by it has an Indian at the wheel.
I moved to Australia and lived,worked there for 10 years, in the construction industry in Melbourne,Sydney and noticed in most work sites the workers were pretty much all immigrants, in the company I worked for, most installers were from NZ , we had a few Australians start work but they all left after a few days,weeks. All the admin staff were Australian, it wasn't like it was low paid work, I just think it was more hours, physical work than they wanted to do .... I was paid pretty well but I think Australians expected to be paid management salaries for labourer jobs.....
The thing is, you came from a country with lower cost of living, so any money earned here goes further toward buying what you want in your home country... it is more appealing to "tough it out" as a labourer when you can put a year or two of earnings and buy property outright rather than Australian wage of $30/hr and paying ten or more years of wages for an average place here.
@@joebloggs6131 nz has a higher cost of living than Aust, petrol is 3.15 a litre here , grocery prices are higher, housing and rents arent significantly cheaper , the median house price in Auckland is now over 1 million.....when I left Aust 4 years ago I was on over 40 dollars an hour, I looked for the same job here and wages are 25-30. Australia will always be a better place to live based on what you can earn and what stuff costs.... In NZ everyone lives paycheck to paycheck, the extra you earn in Aust really makes a difference to your quality of life. I've been back in NZ for 4 years through no fault of my own but am planning to move back to Australia because 'things' are just better there .......
@@nix123ism So you don't live here, but just pocket any saving and take it away? So if Australia faced a bad economy and hyperinflation, you'd just desert and eke out a meagre living elsewhere? Admirable, bro...
Where exactly are 650,000 SKILLED workers coming from. How many people are homeless our structure can't cope. How embarrassing for them when they take these homes off the homeless. We always have welcomed them into society because we ourselves come from immigrants but not now. We need to fix what we got first. There also needs to be an investigation on why people are on jobseeker for longer than a year. They need to help these people get them help for jobs or these companies get fined.
Everyone on the planet comes from immigrants. But not all immigrants have paid for our infrastructure and public services. Economic growth is ruining Australia.
Majority of people dnt know that every person who migrates to Australia has to pay $5000-8000 just for the application process, which goes to the government, so guess why they need more migrants.
@@rajveerkamra i understand ur pain. I spent $150k on (diploma+uni fees) in 7 years and also $200k+ personal expenses (rental+food+health insurance etc). Then I had to spend extras for PTE and PR fees and after getting PR again citizenship fees etc. People dnt have no knowledge how much money they make from immigrants and students. This country is surviving because of students and immigrants.
Importing skills doesnt work when those foreign skilled even if business people will not employ locally born Australians. Many hate the local aussies and only come here with idea of social displacement & replacement on their minds.
WHY isn't this put to a referendum and see what the PEOPLE of this ONCE GREAT country of AUSTRALIA really think about it ?????🤔????? I'm voting for Less migrants especially Tye ones that will not assimilate to this COUNTRY of AUSTRALIA
What do mean by australians. If you mean only white people=australians and Indian race people=not australian. I guess you are white too. You going to Australia meant, you as white going to other country of white people, but don't like when other races also have some share of it. Why do white people want to monopolise the world so much.
labor and greens say the land belongs to the Aborginies, l bet the aboriginies dont want billions of immigrants invading their land , so why doesnt labor listen the the aboriginies, l thought thats what the voice is about
Sorry i thought Albo was concerned about Climate change? if we are at 1.7 fertility rate isn't that a good thing? doesn't that place less pressure on housing , health, energy requirements and resource consumption? .. doesn't that mean we will create less emissions?.. oh sorry i started to think logically there for a second..
Big Australia is poor Australia. Wealth gets watered down, smaller piece of the pie for everyone. People say yes without knowing the consequences. Explain to them what happens when you flood the country with cheap labor. We had to lock down in Vic for 2 years because our health care system wouldn't cope and imagine what another 500k people would do to that. We are not setup for Big Australia. Want Australians to have more babies?? Stop destroying the family unit and looking down on women that want to be stay at home mums. Everyone has the right to work if they choose but don't justify the over spending of government's and their need for more to support the system with woke garbage ideology.
Need to make sure 100% of the migrants are working, contributing to society and paying tax like the rest of us. We don't want to be importing bag ladies, unskilled or unwilling to up skil,l dragging on our tax system, ie unemployment, disability or any type pension.
the tax the immigrants pay wont pay for the new infastructure needed so the goverments will have borrow the money from the international finaicial lenders australia been high immigration for 30 +years and we are now 30 trillion dollars in debt the australian goverment has been using borrowed money to expand the population through immigration
lol you do know Migrants can't claim any benefits such as job seeker and Medicare? Essentially migrants are the ones who pay for services they can't use until they attain PR
I want to know where are they going to live? Australians can’t get housing. We desperately need more affordable housing for Aussies first! People are homeless!
650,000 migrants, each in a family of 3.25 people will require 200,000 more houses.
Albanese is insane.
Amen to that.
Without fixing the homeless problem add another 200k. Its absolute insanity. Infrastructure is not up to standard to bring in more and more we will all suffer.
So why did you vote for him in last election then😅?
Philip Gibbs SOCIALISM is insane !!!
@@MrKenng123
Not me mate.
My kids who are in their 20's can't even think of buying a home. How will this improve with another 600,000 people? Absolute insanity from Labor.
should have earned more money bludger.
The houses will all go to free loading migrants who are given comp from the government. Most of the migrants, save a few good ones who will try to contribute, are NPCs
Tell them to work harder not slower Everything is expensive so try telling them to be independent and smart that way they can save money and buy a house Remember it's 2023 not 1993 😂
Its because they are not working hard enough and they are spending more than they are earning, why lots of migrants end up making their own homes where locals find it hard to make their homes?? its simple because migrants know the importance of not spending more than what they earn and they end up saving a lot which you don't
Will be fighting to keep our jobs to
650.000 Migrants will vote for the Government that give them a new country to live in and the benefits as well .This is Albo's idea to help get his racist voice scam over the line and also to help him stay in Government at the next Fed election more migrants = more votes for him.
Mick & Dean ::: Spot on . Analbese is paving the way to a U N etc job to cash in on the Corrupt Payments those grubs receive .
and a cheap source of labour if they want to work rather than turning out mini me's.
Only citizens can vote
@@johnnybgood3909 How long b4 they become citizens?? wake up!
That's right it's all vote grabbing. Albanese and this government must go. Timecwe had a pm that's not scared to speak out. Send all the illegals back for starters
Asking people in the street is not a reliable form of journalism. People could be afraid that they will lose their jobs, or welfare payments if they say the wrong thing. But put a bug under their kitchen table and see what they really think...
If people from the street don't provide you adequate answer or share their opinions , mean that the government is in control and keep people in fear .
Doesn't strike as a democratic country.
We already have a severe accommodation shortage in Australia.
Where will these people live?
They will take your home and give to them like they do in England
In your house one day, once the replacement is complete.
They will in fact, displace other Australians. It's going to be Australians on the margins, who will be displaced into makeshift accommodation.
@@williamcrossan9333 97% of Australians come from immigration.
What you want to promote is an end to negative gearing and capital gains tax concessions for buying and selling housing you don't live in. I bet you don't even understand how many properties are vacant due to this,
@@IIIIIIIIlIlIlllIlllI Hey fake name keyboard warrior it's easy to lie when there are no consequences. And you are just making it up to suit your boomer narrative.
No look what’s happening in the uk 🇬🇧 and Ireland 🇮🇪 they are running rampant
Exactly. That is why they had to have a Life in UK test. Because of the cultural differences....hmmm. You cannot make people adopt a culture and change.
Here in the USA is the same!
@@superlight7654 especially two cultures that are so radically different from each other and have pretty much been mortal enemies for thousands of years.
And look at the New Sudan crises
most of new generation teenagers doing tiktok and youtube side hussle that why G7 countries badly needed highly skilled immigrants all over the world
Labour needs more voters. That is the only reason.
The biggest lie is that Australia is a large country so it needs more people. 70% of Australia is uninhabitable desert , if you take into accout the land that is actually habitable Australia is no larger then New zealand. Almost all immigrants move into the already overcrowded large cities and not the regional areas with lower populations. Its only big business, property developers that benefits from mass immigration , while the vast majority of the people sufffer
I heard this quote recently, "import the third world, become the third world".
Profit mate! When you have both political parties with the same donors.........
Queensland is a regional área ?
The rural area infrastructures are undeveloped, no jobs are available .
@@eddyng6067 they are not there are big regional cities. Migrants don’t want to live there. Less money and less opportunity
What I got from that street interview we are all fucked!
👍😊
yes they reflect the mind set of the herd of sheep.
They would make good cargo cultists.
@@chuckh5999 touch some grass mate
LOL .
As long as it's only migrants, not the aunty's, uncles and 3/4 of the family.
😂😂😂
They will want to bring their own parents to increase the median age of our population.
Family visas..so theres almost no health or employment prospect requirements. One aged care worker eg a carer can sponsor their whole family regardless of either.
You asked the wrong people, you asked mainly boomers that most likely own property. It's not a problem for them, infact it's actually a benefit for them as it will increase the price of their property, for young Australians it's not good. It will just increase rents and price us out of the housing market even more
Lol Nope not all. Pensions are not fun and they are low income.
Australia's rich= own your own home. A 3RD will never own, a 3rd owe the bank, a 3rd owns. So if you do own you are in the top 33% of the rich list.
Australia's dream is almost lost completely
@@ozziecoops it is terrible to watch this happen to our younger generations as it is for them. Albo said Liberal didn't care for the future of our children yet here we are debating the voice over homelessness in cities and the violence in remote areas to children. He the biggest Hypocrite there has ever been.
Old ppl are just selfishly thinking about themselves, they get desperate and clingy as they get older because they know they'll need carers. Migrants are not interested in coming here to look after old white ppl. They're more likely to suffocate them with a pillow, than give a crap about changing their depends undergarments...
Didn't ask any battlers.
The point is that the government is not even trying to attract the 'right' skilled workers. Instead, they have granted permanent residency to those who never obtained a proper degree, never set foot in Australia, and never studied here. These individuals are a group of people who couldn't even find a job in countries like China or India, yet they have been granted permanent residency by the Australian government. Meanwhile, those with RIGHT skills who are already residing in Australia and contributing to their communities have been left out by the incompetent labor party.
What a disgrace this government is. Time to throw them out
Exactly the immigration minister and the labor government will ruin the country in the end.
Next time vote for Suatainable Australia or One Nation. They are the only parties that are willing to reduce immigration.
Even the Greens want to import people from the third world, to endow them with a western living standard at the expense of Australians.
why don't you go to your Europe back then? this land originally belongs to Aboriginals not you
Send the migrants to Alice Springs 👍💀
I wouldn't wish that on my worst enemy.
@C R The desert cities in America have the same problem that most of Australia has: _not enough fresh water_ . It was irresponsible for urban planners to build cities in places like Phoenix or Las Vegas.
☠️
Immigrants fear for safety in Alice Springs, lots of immigrants are ready to move and work but security and safety is a concern mate.
Australia needs to build roads and new citys New Cities in Central Australia Population density should be distributed
Australia may not need more migrants, but Labor does as the majority of migrants tend to vote Labor.
You vote for whoever you want
The Howard Government saw the greatest rate of immigration ever in Australia, It's a fact you can look it up.
Now they do.
But they voted almost 30 years straight LNP.
We had a million and a half permanent temp migrants and cheap labor floating around the country.continiously.
Party is over.
Listen to the speech
You are getting less migrants with Labor. Libs had a million and a half temporary migrants floating around the country continuously for almost two decades.. Keeping your wages low.
This is why we're screwed..wake up.
@@David_Beames I don't doubt you, but I'm talking about the present situation.
as a non australian... i beg your government to get your house in order....have a proper long term 100 years plan with regards to housing, skills in demand, new industries, invstment in new communities before allowing more migrants in! I am myself looking to migrate but i dont want to be a part of an already overburdened system. Its a loss-loss for everyone. With proper strategy it can be a win-win for all. Lets not turn yourself in to Canadian housing crisis please.
Australian housing crisis is literally at the same level as Canada’s. Been in both countries. Both countries are fucked. They need to have their own people have more babies. They need to mass educate those babies in manufacturing, STEM, etc. They need to completely eradicate drugs and vapes and other things that make a population unhealthy. They need to bring family structure back.
As a dual citizen i know both countries are corrupted by the greedy property development sector pushing for higher migration rates.
It all makes sense when you realize we’re being replaced.
Who are we? You do know only the 3% of the population is indigenous right? The rest are immigrants from all over the world. You need to listen to the great Australian song we are Australian by the Seekers on loop.
Same uk
@@IIIIIIIIlIlIlllIlllI Show me the stats lying keyboard warrior.
@@David_Beames in the eyes of the diversities, you are no different to a "bogan" your wokeness does not make you any better in their estimation, to them you are a convict racist with no culture who stole this land anyway, your woke virtue signalling earns you no respect because your disrespect for your own kind is then reflected back onto yourself. If you call your brothers bad names, those outside the family will see you the way you see your brothers.
@C R No people lie and say they are natives because of the perks they get
Many more Indians going broke or having their entire family living with them with 600k mortgages and 300sqm blocks
hmmn, well, I offloaded mine,to Indians, might be worth what they paid 3 years ago now! went from losing 50k, to making 100k!
There is no lack of workers.
Just an excess of bosses
No lack of workers but lack of workers who want to work for peanuts.
Get back to work please 😛 I'm your boss 😝
Joke! 😂
Not a worker shortage, more like a welfare surplus !
"Not a worker shortage, more like a welfare surplus !"
No it's not.
The problem is that there is a refusal to train people to do jobs & the jobs in the rural areas don't have anyone to do them because those jobs have been taken up by backpackers for 20+ years, forcing locals to move out of those rural areas & in to urban population centers looking for work.
It's got nothing to do with welfare & everything to do with government protectionism.
It’s simple. More people means more consumers. More consumers means more earners and more tax. It makes economy stronger. With some states now broke, it is one of the choices. Working population is needed whether local born or overseas.
Hello dear. How are you?
@@DS-nx6zq Migrants cost. They compete with Australians for the time and attention of Australian-trained doctors, nurses and teachers.
Migrants crowd up infrastructure that existed before they arrived, for which they haven't paid and will never pay for.
Migrants contribute to the need for more infrastructure that everyone has to pay for, not just the newcomers that make it necessary.
We have plenty of workers. All that we need. What does it matter if employers don't fill all their vacant positions? They should offer higher wages.
Once a aussie women in her thirties told that she simpley does not want to work as she gets more welfare than the paid job. Also average aussie expects to roll in range rover while fixing pipes or working as a barista. America being more richer and higher GDP/capita than australia never offers such generous welfare. Thus more industrialised and high innovation. Australia simply imports all aspects of well developed nation. Brisbane transport system including Translink card is pucca copy of oyester card in UK.
Train up Australians to do the skill jobs !!
thats too logical.
@@davepowelldrumz Not rocket science is it ? Trade schools and apprenticeship schemes, medical colleges etc. Just takes the will !!!
@@roydavis5613 Cheaper to bring in low paid workers via a hire company . I know a highly skilled specialist welder that trained imported workers that were listed as " Welders " before training they Could Not Weld as good as the average home handyman self taught welder, some could never do it but they got to stay in Australia doing whatever, Dole , Uber , Scamming etc.
@@crustymoto Yes. "Cheap" is expensive in the end!!
Make the dole budgets work.
Where are they supposed to live? We already have a housing shortage.
in everyones vacant bedrooms , be prepared to fight.
Aussies will have to live out in the bush
In your spare bedroom
your place, they can fit 3 families in your house
Footy stadium.
NOT HOUSING NOT EVEN FOR AUSTRALIANS WHAT ABOUT MIGRANTS
This is ridiculous when the homeless have increased by 3x, labor/greens have to be the biggest idiots... regional areas are not in that much desperation, the homeless are in desperation
The single biggest cost, is to keep a roof over our heads so ....we can't afford anything (kids) else !
How many of these people were frightened to say what they really think?
So more migrants coming to put more pressure on our water supplies. But if we do have migrants, make sure they have trade or other tertiary qualifications. And they need to make a genuine effort to assimilate.
We have so many international students..because its a permanent residency scheme. So you can see why its completely out of control.
Um, no. Many students go back home.
We need to pause the intake every two years for a period of 2 years. Max 50,000 every year. None for Melbourne, Brisbane or Sydney. Exception should be for Doctors, Nurses and age care workers.
What’s wrong with these people 🤦🏻♀️
They always do the interviews in areas where they’ve never been affected by immigrants
Dont follow the news
answer me this why should Australia be a dumping ground for the world
That's how it started...in 1788...😘😆😆😆😆
@@thinkingallowed7042 don't worry day of the rope will fix that for you
@@thinkingallowed7042go back home.
Drop the cost of living, and people will start having babies.
each of the 650,000 will bring over ten family members each
And $50000
$32 billion
True and they can bring in more as well if they wish to and if they got the money than why not
@@andytaylor-dw7pz becasue we dont want there here, ,australia is full, they can stay in their own country
We need to lower the Centrelink payouts to MAKE Australian people work.
I hope you never get laid off at your age buddy and try to get another job it’s not easy for older people employers are pretty biased and picky
@@warwick4763 I'm 68 and still working my ass off. So.... take that.
@@user-ln3jy4oc9t I agree, & if you are olderthan you have plenty of experience. If you are working as a pensioner, you shouldn't be taxed.
@@patrickjohnson8741 good for you Patrick probably pushing a pen lol
@@warwick4763 nope!!! driving a taxi AND lecturing @ TAFE.
It's good to read the comments. RUclips is a place where evereybody can be genuine and there is no need to be politically correct.
Why wouldn't they let the Australian public vote on this matter
How can people want kids right now when paying rent is such a huge expense
dont give into the plan. reassess your priorities and position in the grand scheme of things
Many don't want kids..
I heard a native Australian reporter asked native residents whether they want thieves and crooks from Britain in their country. The view was aggressively NOOOO.
They will never admit this . This people are chameleons. Just keep changing colours whenever needed
😂😂😂
So who would do all the work and organise and pay for everything? They'd be back in the stone age within a generation.
Meanwhile many young parents and children here in Australia are surviving in tents.. vile
Pollies are seriously short sighted when it comes to policy. Our unemployment rate is going to rise rapidly in the next 6 months. When America sneezes the rest of the world catches a cold? They are on their 3rd quarter of negative GDP, it's a recession. The housing market is in freefall, worse than 2008.
The RBA has stopped raising rates. Rates go up pause and the go down. When the rate goes down you know your in trouble, it's happened before and it will happen again. Because of stimi-checks and lockdowns the whiplash effect is going to be massive. People are already struggling with power bills and food price increases. Now we have to compete with 600,000 more people looking for work. It's the Labour Party's (commies) way of having open boarders and buying votes.
If we siphon of the best and brightest from other countries, aren't we condemning those countries to poorer outcomes. Why does the government outsource medicine production and stifled investment in manufacturing? Where are they going to get rare earth oxides from? China?
Why destroy working infrastructure, coal fired power stations, when the alternatives can't fill the gap? Don't know. Why is Australia one of the biggest producers of uranium, but we only have a "medical reactor". Don't know. What are they going to do with all the broken solar panels? Don't know. Where are the going to get the magnets for wind turbines? Don't know.
Why is the government so reliant on China, to the point we can't make our own stuff. Narcissistic globalists are not right in the head. What's the Australian military going to do without chips when China invades Taiwan? Where do we fit in with China's world domination plan? Is it a coincidence that Putin an XI where both WEF young leaders? And both are at war with the west.
Conspiracies are mostly correct these days.
Well said 100%
Quiet Ackshon - We buy from China so we don't have to make anything.
If we don't manufacture, then we don't need to invest and train staff - and so we logically will have a skills shortage. We sell our raw mineral resources as we find that easier than making stuff, but that creates jobs for only the wealthy. The poor are limited to low paying unskilled labour or service based jobs.
Most engineers and doctors are now Chinese or Indian. What goes around comes around.
If we import, the Aussie Government makes a lot more money in import duties and taxes.
The governments who make these dumb decisions won't be in office in a few years, so they don't need to take responsibility and wont be held accountable after they have died.
They can sit on their retirement packages and tell the rest of us to "fuck off" when we complain about the future results showing themselves for what they are.
It's no wonder I gave up voting years ago. Why vote for someone you have no faith in.
Actually, America is ondergoing the greatest boom in modern history. The total size of the industrial base in America will DOUBLE over the next 10 years.
@@Ozgrade3
Thanks for making us all a little dumber with your well researched assessment, based on what, Government projections? Or is it the Democrats unfulfilled economic promises, the 2 year and 10 year inversion or the stimie-check issue? Perhaps it's the continuous stream of lies coming from the White House.
@@Ozgrade3 hi dear how are you doing?
My son lives in Osaka, and is having his third child in July, crazy thing is though he gets 12 months maternity leave funded by the Japanese government.
I think you mean "paternity" leave there!
No wonder Japan is a ticking debt time bomb.
And let's not forget Japan is overpopulated..
Hello dear . How are you doing?
We definitely need more dingos
🤣😂
Its the same in the uk , we have ilegals and legals , and we can barely cope just now and they want to bring people from sudan now smh
I feel bad for u Brit’s because u have a lot of Americans in London and all over Europe Europe is 99% Americans
😂😂u tried to control half of the world by sending illegal brits by boats and now ur scared, karma bych
London is a melting pot...there are many British and Europeans in New York and Washington...
They are trouble.
@@ritaa1359utter nonsense 😂
Americans migrate to the UK in similar numbers British migrate to America, its very balanced.
It does not work if millions arrive and millions of British don't leave for the migrants countries, it causes serious problems indeed
It is illogical if they are thinking of fulfilling the demands of the labour force, such as staff for hospitals, nursing homes, and schools etc, it only adds a small supply with increased demand. The demand is always greater than the supply. We still haven't learnt the management of resources.
Need to make use of technology
As someone who has lived and worked in the US and the EU, I chose to move to Australia for the weather and be closer to some friends and family here. When I arrived as a skilled migrant around 15 years ago, the housing market was still manageable and transport issues weren't as bad. Now in 2023 after a raft of transportation projects and FHB allowances and what not, things have almost hit the fan. I am particularly unimpressed with the FHB allowances, there is no point in having them since the prices get jacked up and the so-called allowance vanishes without making a dent in the amount of money one needs to cough up to own a place.
I came to Australia as an immigrant 60 years ago. It was no different. There were few jobs, and most did not last long! A lot of Australia is surplus to requirement. We refuse to accept the truth. Most people struggled to live at any time.
@@shyamchabra5355 do you see australia making the same mistakes as 60 years ago? We had the baby boom back then, now there are so many baby boomers and they require more health care and more aged care, so the government say we need an immigrant boom to care for the baby boomers. Now in another 60 years we will need another boom to take care of today’s immigrant boom that have become older. That’s how I see it.
2009 was still pretty big ..
LIfe expectancy back then was not very high .
@@xkimopye Thus went the song, Boom, boom, boom, boom!
I want you in my country...err room. Ah well never mind.
What skilled labour shortages?!?! Is she high? Train our own people for those roles first before satisfying your friends in big business first…
Sounds good but doesn't work, as migrant myself I don't see Ausis getting into technical fields like engineering, tech, or medicine. That's where the issue lies, perhaps stop studying useless fields like music, arts, gender studies and focus on what matters
@@tazoman26 I’m an engineer
@@notimeliketoday9414 they should be more like you, then there wouldn't be a shortage
@@tazoman26 the sports industries is unironically the single most vital part of this country's economy, why would you learn maths when you could be a field runner or a sprinter?
Not to mention most people instead of going to university, would rather do a apprenticeship in construction, because only work related to real estate development is just about the only thing worth anything as a skillset here aside from sports
That's very true, most of the local crowd is not willing to study medical, science & technology, engineering, IT, Math etc as studying and working in these sectors in general is pretty boring compared to more exciting and creative fields like Fashion, Hospitality, Retail, beauty, sports etc. Hence there is acute shortages of skilled employees.
Absolutely not!!!! Australia’s infrastructure is struggling as it is, the last thing we need is more people coming here. We need to shut down immigration for at least 10 years.
You want dame brixit ando collapse You country same british
What a stupid comment, you give nothing to migrants lol they bring food for you 😂😂😂😂😂
Or you can just hire skilled migrants to resolve the infrastructure issue fuckhead. If countries like Saudi Arabia and Qatar we can to
notice they do nothing and talk nothing about improving skills and training for us already here, replacement is happening.
The presenter on the show with a beard is a migrant himself or his parents, yet he has the nerve to point out the migrants they interviewed from their accent.
Decentralisation is one of the considerations to alleviate urbanisation. Most of migrants settle in cities, because the rural Australian areas don't have convenience and employment opportunities.
Hiroko,
If you imagine that the VAST MAJORITY of immigrants would even consider living in a regional area of Australia extols how deluded you must be. Because the reality is that, virtually every migrant is like Dick Wittington and is looking for a place where the streets are paved with gold.
Apart from that, do you think that all bar the odd soul would come here to live in Dubbo or Wagga? Please, spare are this fanciful crap.
Its the same in Canada. We're being replaced.
At least canadians can work in other countries.who would hire an ausi
@@AhriGamesMillions of Australians work abroad you knucklehead.
The question is when will all the Europeans leave the land call Australia.
Do a street interview lol
In reality tough to add millions even though Australia is so large. A huge portion of land is not as hospitable for large numbers of people. So basically millions more would make current areas higher density. Plus it would cause migration to new suburbs which would need costly infrastructure.
Rubbish. Even with most of the continent uninhabitable, there's still plenty of room along most of the lush green eastern seaboard. People from overseas (and not necessarily from just overcrowded third world countries) will rightfully laugh in your face for suggesting that Australia can't efficiently handle more.
It's just that most Australians are dumb and want to huddle together in cities despite all the empty regional space. Or more like successive governments are to blame for creating an economy that more-or-less forces people to live in cities just for the work purposes. Bit of both perhaps.
And another problem many of us Aussies have is the spoiled entitlement mentality of living in large cities yet still wanting to live on large property blocks (preferably with a 1-story house), causing wasteful low density urban sprawl and all the problems associated with it.
Australia probably does not have enough water in times of drought. Where will the extra drinking water come from?
Not millions mate ( although that would be insanity), even half a million more is too much.
And guess who gets to pay for the costly infrastructure?
@@iggyblitz8739 not millions? This lunatic government wants to jam pack 1 million extra migrants in the next 2 years.....
I'm a white Australian who has worked in the Hotel industry and aged care. I have found that most places will only employ there own, without being racist," Asian or Indian!" Not are white Australian who can speak 100% English! That's what I found with clients or dealing with guests is that they can understand stand my vocabulary!
The same in my dad’s nursing home mostly Nepalese staff
Indians and Nepalis speak better English than the Pakis and Arabs and Africans..
@magpyes I don't think these are immigrants they are probably temporary workers with temporary work visas or even student visas.
maybe the old people are of that community and dont understand english being very old ? hence the preference fo someone who understands their language and culture. The old generations from the mainland are ... how do i say it ..... a different kind ...
Same in the UK, especially London!
Then they say Brits are too lazy to do the job 🙄
This happened in the building trade too, advertising the jobs in Poland to unskilled workers, an🤷
Don't get me wrong, the polish are very hard working people, and they have their own highly skilled workers, but it was mostly unskilled that was getting first offers of a job, because they except the lower rates of pay. They they live 10- 15 people in a small apartment and have little overheads.
I agree with Pauline Hanson we don’t need to open our floodgates anymore to migrants during our rental crisis
if you get immigrants you don't need to educate the people in your own country
I personally know staff in QLD health departments, ranging from HR departments right into the on ground staff in hospitals.
During covid was huge job layoffs, these people are doing work of 2-3 people. With next to no staff, they are crying for more staff to help. They’re management saying they trying to employ people but none apply.
We know this is a lie as myself and other have applied for positions, that we are skilled, educated and more than capable of doing. We all get rejected!!!
The staff ask their management about this, with responses from their management saying things like “no one has applied”.
It’s all a big fat lie!
For those that don't apply for jobs - get rid of the vaccine mandates and people might rethink the job application. Its basically discrimination by having such - not about health and safety. Lots of new evidence against the vaccines being life threatening.
You would get new staff if those people thought they would find affordable decent accommodation to live in that area. No housing means the people will not risk moving even for a new job which would increase knowledge and practice. Where will the poorly paid immigrants live? Do you want to put them up in containers like Qatar workers?
Sounds like an investigation is urgently required into the characters involved in perpetuating the myth that no one applies.
We could do with some grown ups taking the reigns here....
Unbelievable!!!
If you don't give a sh*t, GET OUT.
Enough Crap
Yes people do apply- but senior management put constraints on the staffing budget. So as a consequence, skilled, capable people are rejected because they are too expensive. Hospitals want cheap labour. Overseas migrants are cheap labour. You then see local people lose a job they could perform to a migrant.
Personally, I've seen the other side of the coin. Non qualified people hired to fill vacant positions. But most of these people resign after 6-12 months because it is too much work for them. And they can easily find another less demanding job.
Answer in NO.
I dont owe migrants my culture or freedoms
Kerry Barnes ::: They will take it .
And what is your culture or freedoms?
Your culture is a mixture of different cultures ya dkhead..
The world is for everybody. Nobody owns it. Get used to sharing
Dude smoking meth and getting flat out drunk isn’t something to be proud of Kerry.
The absolute core issue is being overlooked. Birth rates in free fall is a direct consequence of hyper feminism. The communities which have better birth rates might lack first world civic sense. But, their birth rates are better due to stronger emphasis on traditional gender roles and much longer lasting marriages.
oh dear
G A - I love kids and would have more tomorrow, if I could find an Aussie woman that was supportive and not a gold digger in the family court - and I would be able to have a stable house and not rent. I've moved 39 times since my second divorce in 2001 and lost not one but TWO homes to my ex in court over a technicality. This meant I had to move interstate to get housing rather than stay with my 3 married kids and 3 grandsons - who don't give a fuck about their father's mortality.
My mental and physical health is now failing as I get older, as would it be for any kids living with me in a transitory lifestyle. Unfortunately in this day and age if a man loves kids, he has to be a closet pedophile - not a father figure; - so what's the point !
That and more young people having to live longer with their parents due to being unable to afford a home or even find a place they can afford to rent. Can't imagine a young couple wanting to start a family out of one of their parents spare rooms.
GA Birth rates will rise if the people see a healthy and happy FUTURE. If a dystopian future is all they have to look forward to, they will avoid having families. Surely that's obvious !!!
@@kimbal1958 My thoughts exactly. The legal system and social norms have incentivized divorce and hypergamy for women. Men literally have every reason to shun the institution of marriage, having kids and raising a family.
I played the dating musical chairs sham for quite a while. As my mates and acquaintances around me got married, I dodged the bullet of getting hitched. It is no coincidence that most of my mates are either divorced, or separated, or locked into a destructive marriage that is ruining their finances and peace of mind. With literally no tangible benefits in return. I am in my early forties, never married and debt free. Absolutely no regrets.
Life is too short to worry about changing demographics and political gamesmanship played by the permanent political establishment.
Yes, Me, bring a Scottish family over pls as our government is as corrupt as it gets, and also woke!
only chinese and indians are allowed in these days
@James.P Already dead. Grog & Meth.
Scotland is woke af and a corrupt basketcase with the SNP in charge
so they will take p more Australian jobs and more homes that we dont have and poor infrastructure to cater for it all.. fk that... how many are still sacked for not being forced into the jab
People will claim that ''we are a nation of immigrants'' in order to justify this all.
The reality is a lot more complicated than such simple notions.
And it is a false claim. We are the descendants of migrants, like everyone else on the planet.
It is only the mass immigration since the Howard government, that has increased the proportion of foreigners among us. We are still mostly Australian born, though many of us have foreign parents.
Last time we had so many immigrants was during the gold rushes.
It’s got nothing to do with Albanese, the World Economic Forum have told him what to do, and as a good boy ,he’s going to do it...... Albanese has always been a flake ; that’s why the World Economic Forum picked him for the job...
In 1984, Bob Hawke refuted the claims made by professor Blainey that, "it was an agenda by the government and big business to Asianize Australia". At that time Hawke responded with saying:
"It's not my intention or, that of my government, to Asianise Australia. In fact, Asians won't even be four percent of the population by 2000."
Well, when the year 2000 came around, the official ABS figures had Asiatics to be 7.6% of Australia's population. In other words DOUBLE what Hawke falsely espoused.
Twenty years later in 2020, Asiatics had surged to become 18% of the population (ethnic-Chinese account for the clear majority). And now in 2023, Asiatics are over 24% of the total popultion. Included in that number are over 400,000 people in the country occupying educational institutions.
In addition to that, a cabal of other non-Anglo/European ethnocultural groups accrue to being 11% of the country's population.
However, the non-AE component of Sydney and Melbourne's populations have them being slight majorities of both cities. In numerous suburbs of either city, such as Burwood, Hurstville and Wolli Creek in Sydney Asiatics account for 80% of all the residents. This comes to pass, because there are close to 900,000 people in each city who aren't citizens: the largest cohort being international students.
But what's so incredible is with how at, the same time Labor is pushing for a "Yes" vote for the Voice, it has an open-borders program of people from non-AE sources who have no sense of guilt for dispossessing indigenous people.
One thing for sure .. many of the Asians are already Europeanised.. I'd rather have more Asians instead of Africans..
Interesting take, doesnt matter where people are from, there is just too many. And we are all paying for it. Litterally check the bottom of you tax return.
@@allong4709 Allong, you say, "it doesn't matter where people are from", which is fine so long as they aren't in such numbers that, they go from being significant in numbers to re-colonising not just a few suburbs but electorates.
A galling example of re-colonisation is in the Parramatta area. Whereby, in less than two decades, Indians, and others from the Subcontinent, have gone from being less than 2 percent of the district to now being (overall) 40 percent but, in the suburbs of Harris Park, Westmead and Wentworthville, they're between 65-75 percent. Hence, because they are the absolute majority of suburbs means that they need not integrate into society and must inevitably use their numbers, which by 2034, there'll be a total of 3 million people of Indian heritage in Australia. So, if anyone deludes themselves that when Indians become such a significant part of the population, and they hold, up to a dozen seats in the federal parliament that, they won't organise against Australia live in Nania.
To sustain this prediction is irrefutably proven by virtue of 20,000 fanatical Indians paying between 80 to 3,000 dollars to hear Modi address them at Olympic Park a few weeks ago.
What a horror awaits us in a decades time.
@markferguson7563 be thankful they are not russian speaking migrants. Old poop-tin would hold a referendum then annex whole cities 😅😅😅
I am a Mech/Aerospace Engineer, currently working at Safran Aircraft Engines at its HQ in Paris, was actually thinking of coming over to AUS to work for a while, yk to experience the aussie adventure, but have been told that the Migration process is ridculously complex and to some extent not worth it. I genuinly hope they're going to do smth to fix this
Stay in France. Wise decision.
If you can read, write and speak English along with a very good chance of employment and don't have 30 welfare dependent relatives coming with you.Sorry you're over qualified
As a French citizen you can travel within Europe easily...
@@joelc9439 Also many other countries.
To be honest with you. Australia really need a similar race like immigrants from Euro to come over. However this priminister has shaken hands with the indian prime minister MODI already and that means that this country policy is to get south Asian immigrants only. So they make it harder for folks elsewhere to enter deliberately.
The woman in green is right. Australians should produce the next generation of Australians, not important Indians, Arabs and Chinese.
Sure but who exactly is the Australian you referring to. 30% were born outside Australia. 51% are either born overseas or their parents were born overseas. This is mostly young and effectively paying for welfare in Australia.
@@jijogeorge5792 those 30% born overseas are obviously foreigners, aren't they. Take a look at the latest census to see who Australians are.
@@clemfandango619 So your definition is those not born in Australia, and their kids. So 51% since they or their parents are not Australian , the argument was way forward is Australians should produce next generation, the stated 51% non Australians are actually of age which can have children, since in order to immigrate you need to be below 45. So essentially u want about 10% (rough math) thrid generation Australian to reproduce to sustain population?
Moreover for some reason above comment said "not Indians, Arabs or Chinese" although the largest population of migrants in Australia is from UK.
@@jijogeorge5792 yes, British origin is the typical Australian bloodline. The rest are racial strangers.
@@clemfandango619 So ur problem is not immigrants but non-whites? Let's remove the whole lot of 51% Australians and every immigrant other than whites. This will being down population to probably 12 million, of which most UK immigrant would be in older category, and most would also be unskilled since whole reason of skilled immigration is skilled labour shortage. This wipes all taxes paid by migrants, do u think Australia will sustain population and welfare with no immigration? Look at the issues Japan is facing with its extremely stringent immigration policy.
Also this is one's migrating permanently, think about the one who work here temporarily and get no welfare but pay same taxes. This is the lot mostly funding Oz welfare with nothing in return in terms of welfare guarantee.
The only issue I see with high immigration is Housing, which is something government should look into. As per available stats each migrant add 10% more to GDP than existing people. And by projection by 2050 they will contribute 1.6 trillion to GDP, that is almost same as Aus current total GDP.
If an alien landed on Earth, I'm sure they would have great respect for the kind of debates we spend our time on :D
Self Destruction.
Our own citizens cannot change jobs or move interstate to a new job because of the lack of housing, high and unregulated rents in short supply and others are forced out of work because they cannot afford urgent dental care or needed medical care let alone get on a waiting list. So many Australian citizens still do not have a home so does the government want to open new caravan parks to house the proposed new cheap labour immigrants or put them in containers as Qatar does?
Houses are being held for all the immigrants
Qatar is an absolute monarchy hell bent on abusing women and people from other religions and foreigners...
It is estimated that over 10 Billion dollars are remitted from Australia to overseas countries every year!
Many Australians who work in other countries also send money back to Australia..
Lab government is crazy
It's Done by Design by the Government.
Why not have them vote instead? On camera no one will speak truth afraid of being called racist. Voting is more reliable method to have opinion of Australians.
In Canada we DO NOT need more immigrants.
FFS there's no jobs in regional towns now for the population that lives in them.
Labour Party wants more migrants to vote for them
Do you have a problem with that?
The liberal party also wanted a lot of immigrants.
Say it, it's cheap labour shortage. Aussies are homeless and jobless while govt handing out free work visa
It’s blatantly obvious we don’t have enough cities in this country if we are bringing in the population of Canberra and Darwin every year … When was the last time we built a new one ?
Where would you suggest building them? What food producing land would you git red of for them?
I really wish that many weren't coming, it's a ridiculous amount, but if it's inevitable then they have to go to remote places as much as possible.
@@iggyblitz8739 Why do you think that it's inevitable that we take more migrants? Vote for One nation or Sustainable Australia. No use voting for the Greens. They aren't even slightly green. Migrants come here to increase their consumption of the earth's resources, their waste and their carbon emissions. That is what "seeking a better life" means.
You asked older people if Australia needs more immigrants. And they answered yes. Because they stand to benefit from increasing real estate prices. They need more nurses and care givers very soon.
You asked the youth and the new immigrants and they said no because they are the ones who is suffering the most.
This is going to lead to a decline in family formation and less children will be born in Australia.
Meaning Australia will need more immigrants to make up for the tax revenue.
Immigrants cost. The tax revenue that they contribute is used up to pay for the extra infrastructure that they make necessary.
Why does everyone assume that these latecomers will vote for politicians who will look after ageing white people? More likely, they will vote for politicians who will allow them to bring their own elderly to use infrastructure that they haven't paid for and never will pay for.
Most of we older people look on our houses as our homes not just investment value. We've been in our modest three bedroom ,one bathroom house for twenty five years ,not many nowadays would want it,
@@joycebaron672 It is the land that the building is sitting on that has value.
The area of land within a reasonable commute of a CBD is fixed. So any increase in population makes every square metre of that land more valuable and more expensive.
Anything that makes land more expensive, discourages family formation.
@chriswatson1698 I live no where near the CBD I live in nearly 3 hours from the nearest capital city .where I live you could probably get 3 houses for the price of one in Melbourne suburbs.
@@joycebaron672 And are jobs abundant in your area? Has the population increased in your area?
Any increase in population anywhere will push up the price of land. Nobody is making any more land.
Governments only income
@@IIIIIIIIlIlIlllIlllI Exactly. A river takes the easiest course or route to the ocean. It's far easier to import labour (unskilled and skilled) than build complex industries and train existing citizens in difficult tasks.
@C R who’s going to work in those manufacturing that you mentioned sir.
WE DONT NEED THEM, HOUSING IS ALREADY EXPENSIVE AND FULL!!!!
I've received a job offer in Australia but from what I've researched online I don't believe I will be welcome, Could I have some opinions?
I'm an Aussie who has applied for numerous MR driving positions.they don't want me.but every time I see a delivery truck drive by it has an Indian at the wheel.
And they're really shit drivers, I've nearly been taken out by them many times. Not to mention they have really bad road rage
I moved to Australia and lived,worked there for 10 years, in the construction industry in Melbourne,Sydney and noticed in most work sites the workers were pretty much all immigrants, in the company I worked for, most installers were from NZ , we had a few Australians start work but they all left after a few days,weeks. All the admin staff were Australian, it wasn't like it was low paid work, I just think it was more hours, physical work than they wanted to do .... I was paid pretty well but I think Australians expected to be paid management salaries for labourer jobs.....
Facts
@@sirx9566and people like you bring price down
The thing is, you came from a country with lower cost of living, so any money earned here goes further toward buying what you want in your home country... it is more appealing to "tough it out" as a labourer when you can put a year or two of earnings and buy property outright rather than Australian wage of $30/hr and paying ten or more years of wages for an average place here.
@@joebloggs6131 nz has a higher cost of living than Aust, petrol is 3.15 a litre here , grocery prices are higher, housing and rents arent significantly cheaper , the median house price in Auckland is now over 1 million.....when I left Aust 4 years ago I was on over 40 dollars an hour, I looked for the same job here and wages are 25-30. Australia will always be a better place to live based on what you can earn and what stuff costs.... In NZ everyone lives paycheck to paycheck, the extra you earn in Aust really makes a difference to your quality of life. I've been back in NZ for 4 years through no fault of my own but am planning to move back to Australia because 'things' are just better there .......
@@nix123ism
So you don't live here, but just pocket any saving and take it away?
So if Australia faced a bad economy and hyperinflation, you'd just desert and eke out a meagre living elsewhere? Admirable, bro...
Albo should be dismissed for this reckless policy, where is the governor general??
Australia has NO MANUFACTURING !!! What jobs ????
Asking city dreamers, who dont live in real world, Melbourne?
Where exactly are 650,000 SKILLED workers coming from. How many people are homeless our structure can't cope. How embarrassing for them when they take these homes off the homeless.
We always have welcomed them into society because we ourselves come from immigrants but not now. We need to fix what we got first.
There also needs to be an investigation on why people are on jobseeker for longer than a year. They need to help these people get them help for jobs or these companies get fined.
Everyone on the planet comes from immigrants. But not all immigrants have paid for our infrastructure and public services.
Economic growth is ruining Australia.
Many wanted to be on the dole for a long time.
@@joelc9439 a minority compared to those who rip off ATO.
@@ausjo8352 But still a significant minority..
Majority of people dnt know that every person who migrates to Australia has to pay $5000-8000 just for the application process, which goes to the government, so guess why they need more migrants.
Almost 400k in 6 years . Still not eligible
@@rajveerkamra i understand ur pain. I spent $150k on (diploma+uni fees) in 7 years and also $200k+ personal expenses (rental+food+health insurance etc). Then I had to spend extras for PTE and PR fees and after getting PR again citizenship fees etc. People dnt have no knowledge how much money they make from immigrants and students. This country is surviving because of students and immigrants.
City suburbs are already spreading out as far as the satellite cities, how much more do they want?
Hello dear. Sorry for coming to your message box. I got attracted through your comment. I think I love you.
Importing skills doesnt work when those foreign skilled even if business people will not employ locally born Australians. Many hate the local aussies and only come here with idea of social displacement & replacement on their minds.
WHY isn't this put to a referendum and see what the PEOPLE of this ONCE GREAT country of AUSTRALIA really think about it ?????🤔?????
I'm voting for Less migrants especially Tye ones that will not assimilate to this COUNTRY of AUSTRALIA
Ssshhhh! 🤫🤐
Stop being so sensible and logical will you!
It's politically incorrect..........and waysist!!!
Give international students pr after they finish their studies 😊 that’s the only way to deal with this issue
okay Indian! we hear you...
They do that now
They already give PR foolish person! If you study certain degrees you get PR.
I taught Indian students in an "International College" that offered VET courses. I have never met so many liars, frauds and cheats in one place.
nah, baljeets gotta go back
i didnt come to india i came to australia ...i see more indians than australians its really an issue they dont realise yet
Canada needs more Indians.
What do mean by australians. If you mean only white people=australians and Indian race people=not australian. I guess you are white too. You going to Australia meant, you as white going to other country of white people, but don't like when other races also have some share of it. Why do white people want to monopolise the world so much.
Punjabis mostly
@@drg598 other day another indian student hit my car no insurance
labor and greens say the land belongs to the Aborginies, l bet the aboriginies dont want billions of immigrants invading their land , so why doesnt labor listen the the aboriginies, l thought thats what the voice is about
Sorry i thought Albo was concerned about Climate change? if we are at 1.7 fertility rate isn't that a good thing? doesn't that place less pressure on housing , health, energy requirements and resource consumption? .. doesn't that mean we will create less emissions?.. oh sorry i started to think logically there for a second..
Big Australia is poor Australia. Wealth gets watered down, smaller piece of the pie for everyone. People say yes without knowing the consequences. Explain to them what happens when you flood the country with cheap labor. We had to lock down in Vic for 2 years because our health care system wouldn't cope and imagine what another 500k people would do to that. We are not setup for Big Australia. Want Australians to have more babies?? Stop destroying the family unit and looking down on women that want to be stay at home mums. Everyone has the right to work if they choose but don't justify the over spending of government's and their need for more to support the system with woke garbage ideology.
IS BULLSHEET AUSTRALIA NOT COPING WELL EVERYTHING IS TO DEAR
Same happening in UK & America
Americans r moving out of America to live in aus idk why
Need to make sure 100% of the migrants are working, contributing to society and paying tax like the rest of us.
We don't want to be importing bag ladies, unskilled or unwilling to up skil,l dragging on our tax system, ie unemployment, disability or any type pension.
the tax the immigrants pay wont pay for the new infastructure needed so the goverments will have borrow the money from the international finaicial lenders australia been high immigration for 30 +years and we are now 30 trillion dollars in debt the australian goverment has been using borrowed money to expand the population through immigration
We need to use technology more
lol you do know Migrants can't claim any benefits such as job seeker and Medicare? Essentially migrants are the ones who pay for services they can't use until they attain PR
@robertfoster7807 30 trillion dollars, Really? Australia doesn't own that much! 🙄
Even the UK debt is less than 5 trillion (Aussie dollars) 🤷
Owe*
I want to know where are they going to live? Australians can’t get housing. We desperately need more affordable housing for Aussies first! People are homeless!