Analysis: Sky News explains Australia's migration strategy
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 9 дек 2023
- Sky News' Tom Connell breaks down the government's migration strategy, highlighting how it intends to navigate both short-term and long-term issues of migration.
We need skilled immigrants who can fit into Australian values and society, who works for our country and respect our culture 🙏🏻🇦🇺 We don’t need aggressive religious groups of people, especially the extreme Muslims.
And there you go, you just should have said you're a racist bigot and you don't want Muslim Doctors just non Muslims.
one comment already deleted ,,,, yeah free speech for you
Exactly
right on, we should pick and choose the best fit for australia, and that is not religious, west hating fanatics. too many here already.
Do we have a data on illegals and purposefully made refugees only here for welfare and benefits from the bleeding middle class and enjoy a life only to populate.
Speaking English is a major issue for many foreign graduates, they don't get through interviews or get job offers because they can't communicate in the national language.
The English assessment process needs review. Each occupation should have a minimum English level required. There is not a one-size-fits-all occupations, There should be a fifth English Componernt "Occupation Health and Safety" to ensure that applicants can work in a safe environment.
In 50 years applicants may need to be proficient in Hindi to be considered
People aren't realizing that affect that policy is going to have and already is having upon English speaking people. Immigration isn't all from obscure Countries outside of The United States and The United Kingdom or First World Countries. This will affect Everyone. This isn't being understood for how it really is or works across the board, I mean and things are left out in big handfuls like Sky News' Graphs where They're not including a number of broken down statistics like Who came but left or was asked or forced to leave and within what time period; Who was a return VISA holder waiting out the pandemic and etc.... There are a lot of people Who come in on Work VISAs as Journalists and Entertainers and leave in a matter of Days. There are people Who come in and pass away or again come in for something like a Funeral and happen to work while there briefly. There are tons of speculative scenarios that are arbitrated by large statistics that look like They're meant to just convince this argument not illustrate that the argument is valid, whole in it's convictions or reasonable for that matter. There is a scenario where people continue to come in at a higher rate than normal and things steady off over time that no One considers as well. There are considerations as well like Families Who were deported from the inception of the Pandemic until now upon premises like Families with Children Who are Down Syndrome and were seen as a cost to the premium of Health-Care in Australia.
This is like the Homelessness epidemic. Housing costs a lot for all and so that focus could be on fixing that which starving the housing market doesn't necessarily guarantee as a solution and could rise costs in a bare market. And if the Housing Lenders and Investors wanted to push their luck until They were to bust then that decision is on them and is their responsibility to take that risk. Pushing them in to a corner and scaring them doesn't necessarily mean that They'll buy that or be intimidated by that and react in any way let alone incrementally to adjustment. If people can afford to rent and buy then They will keep their prices wherever They want.
I don't doubt that there is an English speaking barrier but I also attended TAFE for Automotive Engineering and was placed in The International Class with mostly Korean and Chinese Students and all of them spoke proficient English and passed every single battery of that program on a Pass / Fail basis and so I'm speaking at least for my personal experience.
There should be a sliding scale for success and opportunity weighed or made verdict by ability over access to opportunity with which I agree but while people talk about Foreigners like They're morons and criminals; There are large populations of native Australians Who would not be able to pass a Mathematics proficiency Exam at a Junior or Year 9 Level as Adults or operate a Cash Register or Count Inventory or physically be able to unload a Truck and so if the assessment lies solely in Immigration and not on those things as issue on the whole then I would deem that an ideological absolute rather than an acceptable form of opportunity.
You're not evaluating ability; You're pre-determining worth and value which is different. Again; There is no sliding scale there. There's just a bar that keeps getting moved Week to Week that oddly seems to dictate a lot of policies.
I'm afraid genuinely for writing my opinion Online but that's what I really think. A larger system with more more more more will be just that in terms of it's data produced to a positive affect: more more more more.
I'm a Registered Republican in The United States but one thing that annoys Me and that this entire time that Liberals have been in power; Conservative movement(s) have done everything except the one and most mature thing: Just work to the adjustment of the unreasonable system that's being argued against You and in it's efficiency would be expose the flaws and inaccuracies and even wrong doing(s) that You could use to make argument(s) in the other political aisle or direction. Instead all that You've done and are doing is justifying an argument for the other side to legitimize action against and holding Everyone hostage and accountable in the middle. That's not only irrational and selfish but it's not productive and just will serve to another audit down the line at what point I worry more of that same discord will occur once again in rotation aggressively and without sight or direction or selflessness. You don't have to be a Liberal lunatic but You also don't need to go off the hinge and radically dictate, either.
English is not mai. Language in Australia anymore
Well, we all know the real reasons behind Australia's immigration rate, but no one in the media has the testicular fortitude and integrity to say so...
so say it then?
@planetoidmedia8486 OK then, lower wages, a ready-made voter supply, the elimination of the existing culture and people, and ultimately, the creation of an impoverished source of cheap commodities.
Put it this way before the pan 2.17 mill temp people were floating around the country that U never hear about.
@@brothermaynard3200 Just like China.
It began in the 70s with feminism. Sending all those housewives out to work, doubled the tax base, doubled the value of real estate portfolios, and for big business suppressed wages without decreasing consumerism.
Whitlam saw the advantages. Previously Australia had only allowed European immigrants who could speak English. He changed that to multiculturalism, so the whole third world could come. And the rest is history.
What a shambleds Australia is falling apart from bad govt policies
Universities making money from overseas students is not something Australians should pay for through higher costs, exploding house and rent prices and reduced standards of living due to the increased demand. Australia is full. The government message is just window dressing, "yeah we will cut migration after the Election"
The chart shows quite clearly that the high level degrees have little to know value to the market. As an RTO trainer I have had some 5% of those with single or double degrees from Australian universities fail a year 10 LLN test. The reality is those working in the low skilled area competing directly with our young kids seeking to enter the market regardless of their worthless degrees are only capable in working in that area.
The government needs to ensure that the universities that take taxpayer funds actually provide a valuable or fit for purpose product.
It obviously not.
Not necessarily. I think a lot of international students are fairly skilled technically but lack the English and Australian experience that employers want. The bigger problem however, is that there aren't that many vacant jobs that pay well. There are significant vacancies in trades however the international students don't study trades. I think the government needs bring more engineering and trades students to address certain gaps in the labour market. I'm Canadian and we have the same issues here. Too many international students who have no jobs and a government with no plan.
I went do a university subject online a few years ago it was $800 , ended up pulling out as when I went to sign in to start the course the system was broken. Got my money back, now that same one subject is two thousand dollars.
Hmmm ten subjects will be $20,000 .
Who can afford that?
Yep full fee paying overseas students who pay someone else to do the work for them
ABSOLUTELY DISGUSTING GOVERNMENTS.. both parties. Nowhere affordable to live, nothing affordable to rent or buy. Inflation through the roof.. roads blocked even in the suburbs, cars parked either side, five minutes to get from one end of the street to another.. no parking at the shopping centres, fuel unaffordable, energy prices ridiculous..
The Government doesn't set Housing prices or Lending qualification(s) and / or rate(s). Why is no One angry with Banks or Realtors? These people are not your Friend. Never were. They'll keep the housing prices up as long as They want to wherever They want whyever They want. Period. And what is with this Cars on the road and in parking lots thing? You're not seriously suggesting that's a real issue or has to do with Immigration, right? I know that those are different places but I mean....Sydney and Brisbane are Worlds apart as far as congestion is concerned and that respectfully just is the nature of Cities, let alone anywhere. The War in Ukraine and other factor(s) led to oil deal(s) and inflation result of dealing(s) with China and cutting off of pipelines in The United States and again among other reason(s) and / or factor(s) and so EVERYONE is paying a lot for fuel with which I agree but that focus on Housing and that manipulation of Australian's emotion(s) in the matter largely by Media stoking fear campaigns is unfair and heinous. Some of the things that They say are true but They're leaving out a lot of detail(s) and blurring context like that a lot of these thing(s) came result of the pandemic and if You think that They didn't know that an Immigration intake surge would happen upon opening the border after the hardest and longest border closure in the entire World during the pandemic then You are fooling yourself. They knew that would happen and now They're using that affect to influence You and write policies that affect all of Australia not just Foreigners. This will impact Tourists as well as Student(s) and when You affect one department of society like that then You will WILL see an affect in your area of society in which You live your life and most likely see Gas prices stay the same along with Housing and wonder why that change never came or happened. Keep people afraid and They will consume and that idea has nothing to do with Immigration.
Please tell me how all these ills are the government's fault? Do they own shopping centres? Did the Aussie government make Russia invade Ukraine, thus pushing up fuel prices and making near everything more expensive?
Rentals are almost exclusively private property, so how can governments be blamed? If they tried regulation, imagine the screams from investors and the RMNJs on Sky.
They're distracting the population with focus in immigrants...students etc.....when they're not able to solve the real problem inflation because let's be honest students don't have money to buy houses
The data here is really focusing on the international students. The figure about % of skill levels job of graduate international work is interesting. It seems like international students are not that good. However, is it because of the student's ability or the job market is also picky that international students have a much harder time getting their first professional job after graduation. I study Environmental Science and I heard that it would take about six months to a year for me to secure a job in my field.
get rid of the level 1. Professional jobs should be for Aus graduates
Sorry to burst your bubble but the Aus graduates are not qualified
Australians not Australian graduates send them back to their countries it's all lies everything she sayssssss omgggg
Infrastructure growth before migration .......................... We need 1 million homes before we allow anyone in the country ..................
TRUE: When governments can show charts that show the increase in houses being build the number of homeless dropping, more money into our hospitals and all other areas. STOP BLAMING COVID you all did that, so that's on you all! STOP letting people inn on the short little lone long fix - you can't expect the system and tax payers to keep it all going without things becoming third world country right here! Take a leaf out of Germany, Sweden and America is now joining the movement of STOP BRINGING IMMIGRANTS INN - FIX THE COUNTRY FIRST and provide for the voting public of Australians now including those who are too young to vote WAKE UP POLITICIAN'S WAKE UP - NOT WOKE just WAKE THE HELL UP! NOT just LABOR ALL PARTIES!
Accomodation Rentals have gone sky high, Aussie’s on a standard wage are absolutely struggling to pay their rentals and have something left over for day to day living…..it’s crazy. 😢
People fail to realize that people from other Countries simply can afford their cost of living and accomodation. Putting this policy in to place merely will shut out those same people. What will that solve if You're left with those Who still can't afford what Housing now isn't being purchased and / or Rented by Foreign Students and Foreigners even Visiting? What is the "And now what?" part of that plan? If You take away a piece of the pie; You still have to fill that void of the pie with something and no One seems to have anything to say about that other than "No. This will work. We'll just lock 'em all out and over time this will balance out." but balance out how? And won't that create a deficit?@@The12thSeahorse
The universities won't want to cop much of a reduction. The international students market is like a license to print money for them. Full fee paying students vs citizens who are able to access a subsidised education. The other migration category intakes are almost irrelevant compared to the students that are here studying arts, law and similiarly useless endeavours. If there is anything to change it is to shape the student intakes towards useful directions like STEM subjects and degrees IT, engineering (and its many different disciplines).
Great comment
The main issue is not the State-run universities or established educational providers but the proliferation of dodgy providers and education agents that give bad migration advice. We have to ban the "commission payment system"Agents and lawyers should be working in the best interest of their clients. the interests. State governments need to review their recruitment strategy. A state based educational placement office for offshore students that works with agents and clients baed on the student's needs,
Refugee visas are a specialist area a law, Agents and Lawyers should be accredited and certified before they are allowed to provide advice on Refugee visas.
They're capping Student VISAs across the board by number not by field or quality of any subsequent field studied anywhere. Subject matter of course of study is irrelevant when people simply won't be coming in because They're going from X number of VISA applications to x number of VISA applications. It's a straight line and a total reduction anywhere across the board not specific to field of study and even though field of study might appear relevant to You or to Anyone; There is no bottom-line for any University but that money paid by any Student to study and so if numbers are capped overall then analyzing relevance of one field over another would be a diluted reference considering that payment would be significantly reduced making whatever data circumstantial not reflective of importance of field per application of employment in industry or Job availability. Job availability is a constantly shifting model and so money per University in Student Numbers offered by allowable VISAs granted and approved as deemed acceptable by Immigration standards is all that matters in this scenario which now has been severely reduced per the new guidelines.
English bars are still not sufficient, and should be raised further to get quality students.
Its so bloody hard to get a graduate job or internship now for Australians from the oversupply of students to entry level roles. It's so unfair
It is not an issue with oversupply of student, it is more issue with expecting 10 years working experience with fresh graduate.
7 days approval ! Wow I'm sure none of them will be criminals.
My brother in law jas been waiting nine years for a remaining family visa 🤣🍻🇦🇺
your outta line boomer, youll probably end up in a age care being taken care by a coloured migrant too
@@helenowen5408 good I know a guy who waited 12 years for US green card.
It takes on average 72 Hours for Australian Federal Police Checks to be done and 12 Hours for The FBI to screen for a full Background Report in The United States. Interpol processing times are adequately comparable to a time-frame acceptable to approximately 72 Hours for International Reports, as far as I understand.
@@nickwolfe4591 That explains how the terrorists get in.
This is the only "net zero" that we need.
100%
Definitely.
They talk so much about net zero, but think about the amount of carbon emissions it must produce to import that many people.
Surprisingly good analysis of the data etc. This is much better than just usual Government bashing that Sky generally do.
House Australian people 1st, not migrants
How do you feel about Kiwi migrants?... I've been here nearly 20 years.
I am from Pakistan, I want move Australia n fnd wife
WORK FOR IT MATE, being on Centrelink doesn’t qualify you for a house.
Been working g all my life mate
Doubt it
I know many professional students with necessary work experience., In Australia it is required that they may not have a level of English but if they want to work in their sector, why not create programs to include them?
If the aim of this is to calm house price increases and make more rentals available IT DOESNT GO ANYWHERE NEAR FAR ENOUGH...!!! its been a long standing oddity that people from all ASEAN countries along with China can buy and own property here in Australia.... yet in nearly all ASEAN countries except Malaysia and Singapore.... why doesnt Australia enforce the same reciprocal rules it has to apply by to own property in Asia to ALL foreigners... lease it yes but NEVER own it.. same same !!!
Asian. A foreigner can correct you on your own language. I'd start looking a bit more inwards if I was Australia.
Exactly they're just distracting the population from the real problems....students don't have money to buy proprieties usually they're helping landlords pay the mortgages
@@TommasoCauNo, he means ASEAN. They're a group of countries in Asia. Look it up. You tried to be smart but look stupid.
The original poster is right. ASEAN is the correct reference, the ASEAN region does not encompass all Asian countries. I'm not a foreigner and understand the language perfectly, it's good to see you try though.@@TommasoCau
@@larstorders9695 you never stop learning
As for the regions we don't want them.
TRUE: When governments can show charts that show the increase in houses being build the number of homeless dropping, more money into our hospitals and all other areas. STOP BLAMING COVID you all did that, so that's on you all! STOP letting people inn on the short little lone long fix - you can't expect the system and tax payers to keep it all going without things becoming third world country right here! Take a leaf out of Germany, Sweden and America is now joining the movement of STOP BRINGING IMMIGRANTS INN - FIX THE COUNTRY FIRST and provide for the voting public of Australians now including those who are too young to vote WAKE UP POLITICIAN'S WAKE UP - NOT WOKE just WAKE THE HELL UP! NOT just LABOR ALL PARTIES!
That’s perfect. But the question is who will take up aged care jobs to wipe the bottom of baby boomers!!!!!
@@TheTinku90 Japanese robots?
May I ask why the regions don’t want them? What are the issues they have caused ?
@@vishsola5174 I imagine many of the same reasons cities don't. We have housing issues and our medical services and schools are already under strain. We already have jobseekers we don't need more.
I've also heard feedback from migrants who have come on regional visas and they don't like it either. One family was upset because the churches were all Christian, the locals drank beer, which was against their religion, and they had to speak English outside of their own home. What they expected in a rural Australian town I don't know. But they disappeared as soon as the international border opened after covid. Another family went back to China because they missed the CCP. There's a few Filipino workers, they don't mind the lifestyle but they're thinking of going home because the cost of living is too high here.
There is a huge blowout in Visa processing. The Peth Child 445 Dependent Family visa had a 90% performance indicator of 8 months in August this has pushed out to 15 months. H=We have FOIed the department seeking details of processing times and they are actively seeking to avoid publishing them The Perth office is one of the worst. Family visas were meant to be given the highest priority. Families are under stress. Dubious RFI and a lack of accountability, the problem is management or the lack of it. Yes, there is a major issue The system needs shaking up.
I think also the approval of protection visa need to be reviewed I think lots of people from non war countries have applied for this visa as I have seen in my work
There should be NO protection visas. Our humanitarian effort should be devoted to supplying education and contraception services to the women in the refugee camps and in undeveloped countries.
the housing prob isn't just mainly more migrates, it is more so on offshores/onshores investors - ie investors who own multiple real estates, skewed up the real estate medium price, and make it really difficult for middle class to afford homes. It is not the migration strategy that need fixing, it's the real estate artificial pricing.
Put restrictions on foreign investors and local investors on their real estate portfolio, ie put a cap on how many real estates they can invest in;
also, cross ref how many % of migrates can afford a house in Aus?? how many are renting in-voluntarily because the house price is just so out of reach, ie the imbalance between real wage and house price.
Think.
Do You think that's a distortion between selectively targeting a specific group of people financially stimulating a market versus Anyone stimulating a market? Would it make a difference if You split say 10 investments up and gave 2 to one person and then split the rest up as individual investments with taxes paid equally either way whether that were 10 investments to 1 person or divided equally? And do You not think that there is a massive issue with delegating how Anyone exercises their legal and rightful success and why? Be specific. This sounds like Socialism or even Communism where there's a scrutiny upon owning a certain number of Cars or a number of Houses and there's a correlation being made between that type of large scale investment again being paid to it's requested demand of tax(es) upon a dictation of how much Someone can have on a spectrum versus a scale of worth per ownership. Foreign or Native Australian I think that's a flawed idea and I think that a lot of people are just acting out of pure fear right now which is sad but also doesn't make an emotional response a justified or rational application.
counter question, firstly, do you think we really have democracy in Australia? think Covid19, mandatory jabs or I lose my job. I took the jab involuntarily so that I could put food on the table.
I do concur that at the moment lots of ppl are FOMO'ing into the real estate market. FOMO is a no no in investing world.
AUS goverment is not helping to ease the inflated house pricing. Do you know about the Help-to-Buy Scheme by the Federal goverment?
See how the gov is self conflicting??@@nickwolfe4591
Do you really think Australia exercises democracy? Think Covid19. Mandatory jabs or I lose my job. I took 2 jabs involuntarily so I could put food on my table.
Do you know about the Help to Buy Scheme by the Federal gov? a shared equity scheme. so tell me how is that not socialism/communism?
I do concur with you view on ppl are FOMO'ing into the real estate market. But being an acute investor, FOMO is a no no. @@nickwolfe4591
@@jordanting705 😂 Good job you seemed have owned him. I have no problem with your suggestions either especially when its wealthy foreigner property investors whinging about it.
I thought the strategy was just let everyone in who wanted to come?
That seems to be labors usual policy
OMG this is the first time I’ve seen anyone look at the details. Great work Sky. How is it I have new immigrants picking up and delivering my parcels? All u need is a drivers license, we don’t have enough people in Aust that can do that?
They're blurring a lot of information and leaving out a lot of details like how many people already were VISA holders returning to Australia apart from new intake or Temporary Workers there for sometimes Days or a Month. There's a lot to unpack in numbers to just put up a few columns and call it a Day.
The issue is they don't wanna do that.
Someone has to do jobs that the local Aussies don't want to do.
I agree although I have a slightly different take, we are an employer who needs to hire people. We are competing with other companies for good workers, now we are competing with the government for the same people. They want to pay them to do nothing, I want them to work hard for a little extra money. It’s not an easy competition to win.
""we don’t have enough people in Aust that can do that?" - We don't have CHEAP people to do that, that's all.
No. They are undercutting existing Australian businesses and some don't carry any insurance.@@danielmuigai5465
Truth be told: Australian universities are way subpar and the students taken in and the workforce is quite inefficient and nowhere in the competition. The immigration system is designed for people of low caliber to sneak in with dubious degrees and work in unrelated fields.
Australian Universities are quality and that quality is not the issue. A lot of field of work and industry in Australia are strictly regulated to extremely specific Degrees and / or Certification(s) that only can be attained in Australia for work specific to Australia with few exception(s) abroad which is I think what sets Australia apart as far as demands for success based upon ability learned per Skillset. The Immigration system isn't designed for people of "Low Caliber" and They don't for the majority "Sneak in" and everything that You said is what is convinced about that idea that every Foreigner is an idiot with nothing to offer which I can't imagine how that must make a Foreigner feel Day to Day trying to stay motivated in Australia to make a genuine effort and beyond that even if Someone was attending School just to get in to Australia and Work; As long as They're paying their due(s) and aren't a Criminal; How is that person or their being there affecting You? That just sounds like a projection and a subjective and very judgmental opinionated statement to presume that there isn't a ladder system to Immigration to offer the most wide span of opportunity just a line of lackluster losers Who are being allowed in because no One else can make the cut. What does that say for Countries like The United States Who would let those people in? I wonder what your opinion of The United States would be for that. Success should be up to the individual but it also should function on a sliding scale intuitive to that fact that not all people are perfect and perhaps some people are trying to build a life in Australia as a second start and in order to better themselves. Once You presume that people either are good enough to provide something or that They're worthless then You lose all objectivity of what freedom and opportunity are all about and that's my problem with a lot of people's perspective's on Immigration in Australia, as if doing away with Immigration if not halting it completely is going to fix all of the World's problems. It's not and it won't but people will have to learn that on their own, I guess.
I'm very certain you are part of that very immigrantion system that brought you here or your previous generation to settle in Australia, don't forget that almost everyone was an immigrant at some point of time entering this country.
In term in the jobs these interntional students are getting after graduation, the problem is there isn't enough quality jobs where there are a lot of jobs in the level 4,5 that most Australians want to do and that where they filled in the gap. It's like the UK as well, there are many educated graduates but for different reasons they can't get the jobs they are qualified for so they, to survive, they have to work in what they can find
How about 188visa backlog?we are waiting more than 2 years
Nice sense of entitlement. Back log reasons are obvious thats why they are having this discussion.
"We need more immigration because Australians aren't having kids"... WE'RE NOT HAVING BLOODY KIDS BECAUSE IT'S TOO DAMN EXPENSIVE. House prices are through the roof because, you guessed it, too much migration. The state and federal governments love the bigger tax base from a bigger population and from higher house prices, but they refuse to spend money on the critical infrastructure required for a bigger population.
We need net migration of NO MORE than 200,000 per year.
The current system (too expensive to have kids) means that it will be a spiral of increasing migration for the next 50-years as the children of those migrants come to the same realization young Australians have now. This is also known as a ponzi scheme.
You are talking crap. The Lebs have heaps of kids here, if they can do it why can't you?
a load of BS mate, truth is family life like rest of the western civilisation is in ruins, yall arent man enough to take responsibility to raise children, youd rather adopt a dog
Stats are 5 immigrants to 1 natural population increase, we can see where this is headed
@@thekingspin9846 What difference does that make?
The correlation between Immigration and Housing cost(s) is disjointed. One is not directly reflective of another. People also weren't buying Homes during COVID I'm sure and no data in that time is being considered just the balloon of intake of Immigration. You'll stagnate GDP and inflate RBA more by keeping out Tourists and Students and furthering that difficulty for those Students Who do make that cut to come in and study in Australia. This will do a lot of damage.
International student visa rort.....
Work full time "cash" in their communities....
Damage is done, cant wind back the clock...
As an immigrant (Canadian Citizen), here is what i think.
You need to properly vet immigrants and refuse illegal immigration.
Australia is not that bad to immigrants but just looking at the percentage of foreign born nationals is not the right way to determine how friendly or effective a country is when it comes to immigration policies.
The issue is a lot of immigrants in Australia are allowed entry but face discrimination in society and in the job market. I personally don't face it as much since I'm a native English speaker and come from a western country, but I've seen other new immigrants face much more discrimination.
A lot of these international students and immigrants have the technical skills but lack the English and Australian experience to enter the labour market. There are doctors and engineers in Australia that drive Uber. The government needs to modify work equivalency and support these people so they can integrate into society faster.
Also, I've noticed that racism and anti-immigrant sentiment is more prevalent here than back home in Canada. This doesn't help the new immigrants either.
I also do think immigrants need to work harder to integrate into Australian culture and society without having to give up their own completely.
There is work on both sides to do. Just my opinion and observation from a North American perspective.
Lol subcontinent migrant classing himself as 'north american' , get british independence then only want to live in nice commonwealth countries
@@thekingspin9846 You made 0 sense. Maybe learn some English first pal.
@@sartajaziz5930 Never had to speak any other language Aziz, keep telling yourself your a Canadian mate, most Aussies will mistake you for a 3rd world uber driver. Learn some history while you're at it.
@@thekingspin9846 Most Aussies are great to me and I'm doing very well as a software engineer here. You on the other hand are a trailer trash loser who's mad immigrants are doing better than him 😂😂. Cope harder pussy
As an immigrant of color myself, I can back this up
There's a skills shortage, but 56% of them with a degree end up as waiters and cleaners. Yeah ok.
A degree is not a skill. It's proof you need to be spoon-fed until your early 20s.
Australia. The only thing they produce is household debt.
No. It's an education. Are You anti-education? What type of education would You prefer and why?@@robotnoir5299
Who is "them"? Be specific.
@@nickwolfe4591 Watch the video.
If you are thinking that migration is the key factor for housing then I would like to say only migrate people can fill realestate pockets and their greediness.
And give easy permission to buy houses and businesses to temporarily visa holders and then see how many migrate population look for lease houses… Barley you can see after complete their study.
Any updage about 476 visa?
I don't believe that 6% of International students ending up as 'Level 3' @ 3 years after completing their degree is arrived at. Firstly, motor mechanic & electrician are both trades that take a 4 year apprenticeship. Secondly, I seriously doubt that almost 1 in 10 graduates would ever elect to jump straight into doing a trade after bothering completing a degree.
Can you skip years of apprenticeship if you show the knowledge or am I missing something?
@@chickenbroski99 You are somewhat correct. You can get credit for a few of the 'theory' modules (generally there's about 2-3 years of theory) by proving you have attained it elsewhere, but the length of the 'practical' component of an apprenticeship usually doesn't change.... unless your employer takes responsibility to to 'sign-off' an apprentice early by certifying they have attained a suitable level of practical experience. This happens but is not common because it means the employer now also has to pay tradesman wage instead of the lower 4th year apprentice wage.
It just sounds like You don't want International Students there if 6% is unbelievable to You and 1 in 10 seems far fetched. I wonder why that perception of International Students is so low and poor of one.@@philnelson940
I have seldom seen international students going into trades because they want white collar jobs. In their country of origin, trades are for the lowest of the low in their society.
@@tunglam8210 What is your point though and what is wrong with International Students learning a Trade for any reason? That's their business and doesn't affect Anyone else.
The plan sounds reasonable, let's see if Labour actually do it. As soon as they see house prices start to come down or the wait times for Uber drivers increases a few minutes they'll want to pump it up again.
Goes nowhere near to addressing the root cause of the problem! This is a big problem that needs to be clamped down on hard!!
I don't know if people understand that without a PR, we are getting underpaid (it's simple supply and demand). Which means no one looking for a PR has high enough income to be successful.
How is this well thought out?
We should be pro-active anticipating issues and making policies accordingly, but lastly we are on the right path.
The English assessment process needs review. Each occupation should have a minimum English level required. There is not a one-size-fits-all all occupational There should be a fifth English Componernt "Occupation Health and Safety" to ensure that applicants can work in a safe environment.
Immigration regulations, Schedule 6D needs review. The current requirements to discriminate against Australian Employment This issue was raised back in 2019 .
I agree with the Minister that the system is in urgent need of reform. However, I am concerned that they have not addressed the main issues. The problem is with the Department's Management They fail to adhere to the law, regulation, and policy. and make decisions according to the law and in a timely fashion. Overseas Missions more so.
Spoke to Phillip Ruddock and several past Immigration Ministers and they all expressed concern with management. A law unto themselves.
Good initiative
At the same time, there's not enough investment in infrustracture
Im from Lithuania and after living in UK for 7 years, got bit enough and want new experience and Australia is one of countries id give a fresh go. Couple co-workers leaving UK to go to there, makes me think would be nice. Problem - Visa. With still quite confusing to understand those 'sponsors' it makes me go only for traveling but you cant work without breaking law. And 4.5 grand on gambling that area will pick you on skills without seeing you in reality is bit ridiculous. Ill still give a go to somehow appear there haha
aus is going to have rishi sunak as pm based on what i saw on public transports
Rishi is on the plane on his way here as we speak.
this will happen until the government puts a cap on Indian students, let the south east asians and chinese come instead
could use some latinas in aussie aswell
@@3142KhurasanWhy bcz we have brown skins, right?
Wow, i listened to SKY for two whole minutes before i felt i was being lied to and i logged out. It is record for me and SKY.
‘Profound impact’: How Australia’s immigration boom could reshape how the nation votes.’
The ALP is purposely flooding Australia with Laor voters and ruining our way of life forever.
Analysts have broken down why the soaring cost of living isn’t the only major change Australia will see after the unprecedented immigration boom.
Australia’s rapid immigration rates could have a significant impact on politics Down Under in the coming years, with new research heralding a hard slog for the Liberal Party.
Australia has just experienced a record influx of overseas migrants that has both boosted the economy and made it harder on first homebuyers, mainly in the capital cities, boosting the population by 2.4 per cent almost overnight.
Separate annual data released by the ABS for the 2022-23 financial year showed that Australia’s capital cities grew by an unprecedented 517,000 in the year to 30 June 2023.
Melbourne (167,500) led the nation’s population growth last year, followed by Sydney (146,700).
The economic reality of half a million new residents has now set in, and pundits on both sides of the fence are calling for a solution as Australia’s next generation faces a roadblock amid crippling rent rises.
Economists have been sounding the alarm about Australia’s world-beating immigration levels for months now, with population numbers “soaring out of control” at the same time the housing construction industry faces a crisis.
But Kos Samaras, Director at Red Bridge Group Australia, says the impact is more complex than solely the cost of living.
“They’re having quite a profound impact on the way this country is going to be shaped over the next 10 years,” Mr Samaras, who previously worked as Labor’s Victorian Deputy Campaign Director, told 3AW today.
“We have already got, in Melbourne alone, over 60 per cent of the population have a parent who was born overseas.”
Mr Samaras said the lion’s share of new arrivals in Australia are coming from China, India and the Asia-Pacific. The recent spike in permanent residents has now seen that group make up one seventh of the Aussie population.
Citing research conducted by RedBridge, Mr Samaras said 80 per cent of the Indian diaspora in Victoria were more likely to vote Labor.
“That could change over time, as we saw with the post second World War European migrants,” he said.
“Their parents were very, very clear Labor voters. I would argue their offspring are now, very much like every other Australian, largely swinging voters, but most of them actually vote Liberal.”
The economic reality of half a million new residents has now set in. But the many changes it will bring to Australia will take years to develop.
“That could change over time, but in the next 10 years, that’s going to be a very difficult problem for the Coalition to be confronting.
“These migrants are very into private house insurance, independent schools, but they do value health and education. They come to this country for those two attributes in particular. That’s a side of politics Labor ‘owns’ quite comfortably, I would say, in the two major states of NSW and Victoria.
“That’s the attraction, but that could change over time.”
Mr Samaras claimed the “look of the major political parties will need to change” as Australia becomes more and more multicultural.
“If you look at Victoria, at the state level, it’s overwhelmingly monocultural. Not many Indian Australians or those from the Asia Pacific in Parliament. That over time will need to change.
“We know that particularly younger voters within these new communities are very aware of who represents them.
“So if the Labor Party -- who are the ones benefitting from this -- keep farming up people from a particular background, it could create some problems,” Mr Samaras said.
The “look of the major political parties will need to change” as Australia becomes more and more multicultural.
The recent election of Vietnamese-born Independent Dai Le in Sydney’s Fowler electorate is proof attitudes are beginning to change, according to Mr Samaras.
“It’s largely a Vietnamese and Arabic community, and that’s where Labor put up Kristina Keneally as their candidate, and she lost a super safe seat.”
Typically, it takes a new migrant “about four years” before they become Australian citizens and enrol to vote, with those from Indian backgrounds more likely to enrol over Chinese-born citizens, who “tend to wait a bit longer”.
Data released last month showed a net increase of 55,330 migrants in January, the highest January intake ever recorded and more than double the 21,000 recorded last year.
“We smashed that out of the water and all it tells you is net overseas migration surged higher than its peak from mid last year and this 375,000 target is going to be absolutely obliterated,” economist Leith van Onselen told 2GB radio on Saturday.
“It’s just another sign that population numbers are out of control and it’s coming at the same time as housing construction is collapsing.”
Former NSW Premier Bob Carr also slammed Australia for running the highest rate of immigration in the world.
“I’ve been trying to get Australians to understand that we do not need to have the highest rate of immigration, in proportion to our population, in the world,” Mr Carr told Sky News.
Data released last month showed a net increase of 55,330 migrants in January, the highest January intake ever recorded and more than double the 21,000 recorded last year.
“There’s no other country doing this. We’ve got third-world rates of immigration and we don’t need it. I just wonder why this is the only economic model we’ve got - to force feed population growth, to run the highest imaginable immigration intake, and to condemn our big cities to a relentless chase to keep up in terms of infrastructure. We don’t have to do it to guarantee Australia’s prosperity. In fact, it’s a pretty lazy way of running an economy.”
The former Labor Premier, who famously declared in 2000 that Sydney was “full”, said studies of mass migration into the UK showed there was “no economic benefit conferred on the existing population”.
“You could say that those who moved to the UK and found jobs did well, but there was no benefit to the UK itself, there was no benefit to the existing population,” he said.
“And I suspect that similar studies would show that to be true here. If you run remorselessly high immigration decreed by bureaucrats in Canberra year on year, you’re just making it harder for existing people, many of them migrants themselves, to get into home ownership or decent rentals. You’re producing a housing crisis.”
But during covid, borders were closed and a lot of people weren't allowed in the country, right? So what's the overseas migration statistic during covid (2020/21)? It just shows the year before (2018/19) and now (2022/23). Doesn't it make sense that the year after covid would be double since during covid was almost 0? Maybe I'm wrong here but?
It was negative 80,000 during covid
We dont have the houses. An Australian-born couple in Brisbane on the DSP, will be homeless if the owner sells their basic old villa! They worked until they were medically unfit - now with the cost of living they get groceries from Rescue Food organisations! Why aren’t they on the government’s aid list???
The DSP isn't help from the government? Doesn't it come with phone bonus, reduced council rates, discounted medical and dental, cheaper car rego, discounted rail fares, etc?
@@indiathylane2158 they pay rent quite high in a rough suburb - they get subsidy for meds & ambo.
@@loulouedmo Everyone pays high rents now. The well off, the under-employed, the unemployed and struggling age pensioners.
If they're on the DSP, they get the discounts I listed. I'm not begrudging them, I'd be happy to pay another $10 a week in tax if it went to those on pensions.
The only discount they may not get is council rates. They apply in about 4 states.
There are Houses and there are plenty of people foreign Who can afford them.
@@nickwolfe4591 Same as everywhere, Aussies owning houses in Singapore, Thailand and Bali. In the latter two, we're helping price the locals out of the market.
Here's the strategy, Albo is talking himself up to try and salvage his poor opinion polls while ignoring the main issues of the country which needs to be fixed first.
Exactly let's distract the population with the same topic over and over again immigrants ...student visa....etc while we do not solve the real problem, more houses, inflation etc
@@katchreinberger679 he is about as credible as a trap door on a surfboard
@@Genesis-007 👍 true
Don't need them here in the regions take Gold Coast and Hobart of the list please, they are dangerous drivers
Who is "They"? Be specific.
We do want to part of your systems and we do have some plans to have future and better in this country, and why the goverment make this so difficult? so please dont make this so hard
The one thing I liked is the AWARENESS by the government.
Labor's excessive Immigration has caused homeless rates to skyrocket.
Accomodation Rentals have gone sky high, Aussie’s on a standard wage are absolutely struggling to pay their rentals and have something left over for day to day living…..it’s crazy. 😢
Keep electing labor greens and liberal and it will never change….
been going on longer than this labor government
How does Immigration put people out of work?
@@nickwolfe4591 It doesn't. What it does do is increase the competition for housing rentals or ownership. Starting in the late 2000's, the amount of immigrants has been increased significantly as well as favouring those with lots of money which has not helped the situation.
So if an Australian knows what they're worth and asks for it for a high demand job, the company can just reject them and get someone over from another country wihtin a week? Fantastic development there hey...
Their own data is saying that plenty of taxi drivers are qualified enough to be the "cyber expert" so why do we need more to come in? If it really takes 10 years to train to the level required, let's set that as the end date for "skilled migration" and do a much better job planning for the future. Companies that want to bring these people in can let them sleep in the office.
Not much change
Does Australia not have more people of European immigrant descent (especially the UK) and their descendants than of Aboriginal descent?
It's time to close down these nasty degree factories, so many IRRELEVANT courses that open up ZERO doors.
And generate heaps of cash.
@@libatalklieb5793 Cash is useless in a country where people earning over $100,000 cannot find basic shelter
@@cookiesoftware925 If 2 people are earning a hundred grand each and can't save to buy a home they don't deserve one. How about if they start by buying a unit first? At least they will have a roof over their head that they can call home.
@@libatalklieb5793 ok boomer.
@@robotnoir5299 No problem peasant
Alot of CEO's play book is to break something that is working, fix it and then tout it as their achievement.
they missed out cab drivers LOL
That’s a shit load of extra Camery’s on the roads…..
Lmao!
On the students English requirement- we teach in the English language so students already speak and understand enough English to follow the studies (correct me if I am wrong). Degree graduates in minor jobs. A big percentage is their choice so they don’t earn enough to pay the hex debt back. And they know employers tend to employ these graduates in minor roles because to them, it shows commitment. Granting visa s to skilled workers is fine but only if there is a job in that skill available for them to immediately go into. How many come on a particular skill visa and do something else. More homework to be done before implementing these ideals. Theory is one thing , reality is another.
Who will work ?
Not you
They have answered many people's questions about why immigration has been excessively high for the last five to six years.
Getting Australian born people to train in the fields needed by offering good incentives and reasonably priced courses is a must.
Bringing people into the country because of skill shortages is like a dog chasing it's tail with no end to the vicious circle in sight.
And obviously the huge amount of money universities and the economy in general make from international students is showing in the figures for the last ten years.
Hard to find a beneficial balance for everybody by the sounds of it.
😎🇦🇺
we need more psychologists.....labour must be intending to stay in power for 3 or 4 terms....must be the reason.
NO! A bachelors degree is not a valid qualification for being an IT Manager. If you haven't spent at least 10 years professionally writing code, you can't manage IT. Your uni-degree is irrelivant. End of story.
As a programmer, my main job used to be writing code, designing specs, and negotiating with clients. Now I spend most of my time helping my 12-year-old diversity-hire manager hide their moronic screw-ups and lies from the client, and building status-reports for my manager to pretend they created, all whilte the project sits idle and waits. I'm lucky to spend two hours a day writing actual code, and that's if I work a 10 hour day. It's an industry-wide problem.
This is what I mean about the standards in Australia. It's just way different anywhere else and that's part of the context missing in a lot of the anger that people have that's easy to place on Foreigners coming in as "Not providing good quality of people for Australia" as those qualification standard(s) not existing elsewhere doesn't really change just because that's what Australia wants at least not everywhere. The United States for example has a far more sweeping guideline for Certification when it comes to Automotive Work or Personal Training both of which I have personal experience working in as studied Fields for instance as You can be working as a Personal Trainer in The United States Full-Time fully certified from an Online Certification program in less than 8 Month(s) from start to employment but that certification wouldn't serve as bathroom tissue in Australia as the Health and Safety regulation(s) that serve respective to specific Certification(s) are non-existent in the practiced manuals and lectured course material in The United States or if They are mentioned; They're not dictated in that same and preferred way and so You have to start from scratch educating at TAFE to be a Personal Trainer as if You never did it or educated to do that before and You can go to a board for review I'm sure but even if You made it on to a Workplace Floor in a Gym; The scrutiny that You would be under daily would be insane and a mistake would not only mean your Job but also your VISA and so that only true way to do that is to go through the Australian Education and Trades system through a School like TAFE or a University like QUT and so starts that process which now is an issue for Student VISAs being capped across the board total number allowed to be applied for and approved as well as the forthcoming Student Tax increase recently added in addition to passing all of the other increased and additional criteria that now is being demanded in addition to the previous criteria and / or with that window of qualification shrinking to those Who are 'more deserving' of being there. It makes for a scenario that just is exhausting to even consider and respectfully as it can be whatever it is. I'm just trying to make that point about qualification(s) as it I worry is different than a lot of people understand for Foreigners to fly over and just be settled and off in to a Career in Australia.
It doesn't matter where they are from.
But they have to for fill one critical requirement....
And that is.
They have to want to become Australians..
The big question mark for me is: Why are skilled people ending up getting low qualification jobs? English, lack of opportunities, network? This is something to be considered and addressed.
Because every employer wants 10yrs experience freshgraduate.
@weihaotan148 I agreed that this could be one of the reasons, but I'd also say that some people who hold experience don't feel confident to apply for some positions. Maybe because of their English level or they don't think it is possible to succeed in their job overseas. Maybe some people are coming from a developing country and are satisfied with low qualification jobs. I think the authorities should broaden their perspective and analyse the various reasons properly in order to address it.
@pedrogouveia9884 from my conversation with these group of people, it's usually lack of opportunities. Employers always ask for Australian experience and discount most if not all overseas experience. Even myself been 15yrs working here, they still discount my experience as insufficient despite all the local recommendations and qualifications received over the years.
É uma junção de fatores, mas os dos principais são: inglês e experiência.
Muitos contratantes australianos querem pessoas com experiência, porém não overseas, querem gente com experiência aqui na Austrália. Segundo é o nível de inglês. Muita gente vem pra cá sem o inglês, sem saber falar, e apesar de ser muito bom no que fazia no Brasil, não consegue aplicar o mesmo aqui por questão de não ter um bom nível de inglês.
Países como filipinas e Índia que tem o inglês como língua oficial também, acabam tendo mais facilidade de conseguir algo melhor, mas mesmo assim você vê gente em “sub empregos”.
Tem outro fator que pode considerar também é que muitos imigrantes vieram de países subdesenvolvidos e de 3 mundo, e por isso aceitam trabalhos abaixo do nível de conhecimento deles (veja quantos engenheiros, jornalistas, biomédicos e etc que trabalham como uber no Brasil… estamos acostumados a fazer um trabalho que não tem nada a ver com nossa formação pra fazer mais grana, e isso também tá acontecendo aqui com os imigrantes).
All good points however these the same corporations that claim they want foreign candidates because of their said qualifications or skills, one would assume experience means all experience anywhere so seems these corporations keep changing the goal posts.
Why immigrate here to be led on by these lying organsations most have zero ethics their ethics is a whim the market.😅
I will add from local citizen candidates point of view they say all the above and make similar excuses to the above about local citizen candidates for jobs from average class positions ofcause its not the language in my case or thoses cases. Maybe they only want those from private schools in Australia😅 Monopoly capitalism is a scam.
Take in 600,000 a year to get 1,000 plumbers! 🤣
As long as Australia is full of property investors tradies and building industry lobbies they will pressure governments for high immigration because its their main interest and Australia has plenty of both groups.
I'm a tradie and I hate immigration.
I'm not convinced with how that guy presented those statistics...I personally felt like he just cherry-picked information and put some context behind them to justify whatever ideology he wanted to show to the viewers. It would be good if they had provided another layer of the graph comparing 2000 v 2023, what jobs were available, and why there was an increase? Perhaps because the Australian industry sector has expanded hence the bigger intake, etc.? Just wasn't too convincing how he interpreted the numbers.
What’s the impact to Australian tradies when you import trader migrants? I hear allot of new buildings falling apart lately and Australian tradies are going bankrupt cause immigrants are under-cuttin them all.
That's capitalism my friend. Competition wins. The problem is Australia has a short supply of trades workers and therefore they are forced to bring in immigrants.
Send them all to Queensland, as Australians cannot enter the Republic of Queensland. Great more Kiwis on the dole!!!
I'm for that. I don't live in Queensland.
all we need is more friggin "hey bro" , kiwis
Nah mate. We're the redneck Texans of Australia. We don't take kindly to you third world ragheads from Sydney and Melbourne.
I cant believe everyones short memory, Labour/Albanese increase immigration to record levels in September last year and were trying to streamline the visa system earlier this year, it was one his election promises. Now theres a mjaor sudden backflip to reduce immigration
The problem is in the rootstocks!!!! Now AAT cases will start increasing and getting clogged in the system where all these temporary migrants will get another 2 years of time to live by the time Tribunal Judge gives them a date to hear their appeal 😂😂😂😂!!!! Problem is not happened with labour or liberal government , it happened with bureaucracy.
Give respect, take respect! These policies and reforms don’t seem to have any respect.
University Students have been taxed additionally recently, which is widely available in mainstream resources if You're curious and ironically Australians pay far more in taxes for Native Australians especially with the induction of PM Albanese's "Fee-Free TAFE" program about which no One seems to be speaking or interested in which is incredibly unfortunate as that is where the Skillsets are for people to Work in Australia Native or from abroad in to Australia as an International Student to bridge to being a Full-Time Skilled Worker.
The Graph(s) don't show how many people are people Who already were active VISA holders returning to Australia or mention the period when The Department of Home Affairs began receiving application(s) for both returning VISA holders as well as new VISA holders. That also doesn't explain why, if Migration is the issue that the economy wasn't better during COVID, if that indeed is the case with this theory that removing, capping and restricting Immigration now will solve anything.
Cutting Migration would be a humoring of the people for what They're screaming for knowing that it will fail, I feel and as soon as it does and it will; You will have handed back to those same people "assessment(s) to be made to clarify our mis-reading of data and mishandling of mitigating our previous Immigration Policies. Numbers will go back up as We're forced to avoid further bubbles in the future of Immigration especially that of Tourism and Student Stream(s) until a further resolution is met.".
I see this going to a long drawn out dragging out of the economy; less Students and Tourists coming in which will lead to more Economic hole(s) that probably just were starting to fill back up and You will do a dance of feeling like You went 8 steps forward when You really went 2 steps forward and 20 steps back and then what?
There is no "And then what?" part of this plan. I feel that PM Albanese just is tired of fighting the Immigration issue as such for the meantime and so will allow for what the people scream for in halting it almost completely and letting that swell to a point of begging to let off of the gas pedal and then back to where You were at Stage 1 and if that is the case then have at it but it will only add to the cost and time of repairing the damage caused by the pandemic and only will lead to more political schism and discord that will lead to more argument(s) over abstract policies and then finally an admittance that the intake of Foreigners is being distorted for it's content in number(s); timing and a lot of context apart from demographics and even personal situation(s) that are left out of big graph(s) with single digit statistics. That's a "Two things can be true at the same time." scenario.
Their graph(s) that They're showing You very well might be in-fact true but the message is more accurate than the content of those graph(s) that I'm sure Someone intelligent could break down and question if not come to further conclusion(s) than "Here are some numbers in a certain proceeding of one another and so....there Ya' go. I'm right. The end.".
There's way more to it than that. There were Working VISAs entering Australia throughout the pandemic that aren't being accounted for; deportation(s) that aren't being accounted for as again: You could count when people were entering Australia but not mention that They left or were forced to leave, right? Well, that is part of my point.
Break these number(s) down and I guarantee that They're parsing language and skewing data to fit a normative narrative to convince an argument which is fair on it's merits but vastly one sided and doesn't speak to how You plan to solve any of the issue(s) associative to the Australian Economy outside of just Immigration. Immigration isn't everything and as I said above; PM Albanese announced and put in to action his "Fee-Free TAFE Program" of which many people already are seeing great results and by people I mean BOTH native Australians and those from abroad about which I wish that PM Albanese would speak more to as and again context to things that are rising in terms of improvement would help to define voided area(s) of confusion that people merk in far too often filled with nothing but the negative or downside to all that is wrong without light of any type of solution or positive area(s) which again is a matter of optics. People are drowning in optics of situation(s) where data and information are tools more than They are actually supplemental to determining anything of material worth in a lot of cases and this convincing of the people that They didn't know that Immigration was eating Australia's lunch or that is in-fact destroying Australia were issues. There is no Government on Earth that doesn't work in laws of finance and statistics.
You're rooting for more problem(s) and these people, Sky News Australia included, have You acting purely on your emotions and that is wrong. There is more information than is being given and if You don't believe Me then read the exclusion of American and British Passports from eligibility for an eVISA or "ETA" VISA on The Department of Home Affairs Website. That is the most basic and bare bones VISA required for a minimum 90 Day Stay in Australia as a Tourist with no other access to School or Work. Every other Country in the World is recognized as being eligible on that list except for Americans and Brits. You tell Me that's normal and I'll let that go but I know that isn't at least right or that something at least is out of place on that issue. No One expects Anyone native to Australia to read through The VISA summary sheets. You only are hearing that your Country is at risk and that You're a naive fool if You don't stand up and act when that's already Someone else's job and by that I mean; Do You really think that Anyone meaning any Politician on Earth would do anything that directly and knowingly risked their Job imminently? No.
You can't enter a lot of sectors of Australia's workforce in a number of different Industries without Australian equivalency in whatever chosen Field per Australian regulation(s) required to work that Job and You can't educate without being labeled "Sneaking in under dubious intention(s)...." or "Just going to School to make a good Show of their VISA to stay in the Country...." and now International Students have been taxed on top of their Tuition Due(s) now required to be paid in Full prior to starting their Semester and so where is their crime, exactly? You set rules and people follow them and so You invent a new and more demanding standard that Foreigners then meet and so You find a way to question that and stress it which goes to fruition for both parties successfully and so You now are claiming that just being there is the issue. That looks like You just don't want people there, is my point. It really does and like International Students or not but a lot of International Students without a hair out of place with clean Criminal Records and good intentions and Who have paid every cent of their tuition and taxes and work Jobs like Everyone else are starting to feel incredibly burned out and wondering if long-term that it's worth it. Think about that. You have the most famous beaches in the World and some of the best food and Art and Culture that money can buy and a clean and well Policed safe atmosphere with a diverse population and They're thinking about how They can get out of there. Who's the bad person in that scenario? It's easy to draw a line from point A to point B and convince yourself of easy arguments on big and difficult solutions and when I read "No more Foreigners!" and "We're full!" and "Leave!" I mean I just wonder where the power of the argument actually is other than a largely hostile and opinionated rhetoric constructed upon a handful of fragile statistics thinly veiled behind contempt and an inability to accept that the pandemic happened and an even bigger inability to accept that You might have to do things or allow for things to happen that You might not care for in order to be back up on to your feet faster than You're choosing to be. Everything can't be immigrants fault just like everything isn't Government's fault just like the pandemic did happen but without some foresight to see beyond things that You want to hold on to like I've never seen in my life You will walk in a circle and no One should apologize for that.
Feeling in control and taking ownership of something doesn't make pride. Vulnerability and success do and that's what seems to have successfully been avoided which is sad. It feels like You really don't want Anyone else there and that's really sad.
Agreed. The issue is a lot of people in Australia and around the world are facing a cost of living crisis and are frustrated. They're taking out this frustration on international students and immigrants thinking if we stop them from coming, that'll solve all our problems. The thing they don't understand is that there are holes in the economy and that we need immigrants to address them. But it's the same thing here in Canada. I'm Canadian and the public here is also upset at students and new immigrants thinking they are the root of all their problems.
Amen and God Bless. That's refreshing to hear Someone else echo what I've been thinking and absolutely nail that issue square on the head. This isn't hate back at Australians which I wish that They understood as We ALL lose in that equation including Tourists and Who would imagine an American Tourist being denied a Visitor VISA with a completely clean Criminal Record? It sounds made up or at least fictional.@@sartajaziz5930
Do not worry we do not need our home, we can sleep in tents on road. 😂😂
Instead of getting tough on legal immigrant, why not get tough on illegal immigrant and refugees.
Because there’s bugger all illegals coming in since we implemented offshore processing. The majority of remaining illegal immigrants are visa overstayers, with Europeans being the primary culprits.
As for refugees, legal refugees make up a tiny minority of immigrants. The majority are either legal immigrants or students.
Bingo. Nailed it.
Nope. This new policy is affecting and will affect Tourists as well as Students as I read even includes doing away with 'Care VISAs' where Someone wishes to come in to care for an elderly relative. This policy only will hurt other people trying to come in, believe that or not.@@chrisdoulou8149
This might be confusing for the viewer here on Sky...
You would appear to be one of them.
Mechanical Engineer from overseas can only get job new car sales here in oz..
Yep. Your education might not meet their qualification(s) and / or standard(s) as I tell people from personal experience. It's a lot more to unpack than people think.
Strategy? Where we are going we don’t need a strategy.
lol.
They’ve got a strategy have they 🙄well someone has got their numbers wrong you’ve only have to go down to the shops in perth these days it’s absolutely mayhem bloody clowns couldn’t run a lemonade stand
One we taxpayers build the new schools, hospitals, desalination plants, roads and provide welfare and suffer a reduction in standard of living how does this benefit the community?
Yep, we pay for the construction of roads, that the government sell 51% to the toll operator and then we pay the tolls so the toll operator can re coup their money… Crony Economics 101
You asked for a capitalist society, enjoy
This is going to destroy the education system since international students are the major income for the school and also for the government.
We will also be lack of retail staff, bartenders, hospitality, nurses, delivery guy and many more…because simply we don’t want these jobs while they are doing it at the moment.
Wages will increase, a lot of small businesses will suffer and this will be a major issue for all of us.
I would prefer we let the people who want to work to be in Australia than this immigrants who doesn’t want to work and use the government incentives.
What is the point to give a refugees but they don’t want to do anything
Another dopey Indian
I don't think that the Refugee thing matters much as long as You let people in like prior to the pandemic under Morrison to educate and / or Work as the Refugee / Migrant System is an entity that always will exist and isn't as encroaching as long as You have a pipeline of people coming in Who want to study and / or work but not under such high level of standards to meet a VISA to even visit Australia. That won't hurt Refugees which is my point in any of my post(s) on here. That only will hurt Student(s); Tourist(s) and native Australian(s), period.
Huge migration without tbe infrastructure to support it is bloody madness , Abonese one term No more
In Perth, half of our drinking water is expensively desalinated.
Increasing our population means that more of our water will be more expensive. We will all be charged more for water, not just the latecomers that make it more expensive.
Snapper is a delicious fish. This year the government put a 6 month ban on fishing snapper or dhufish so stock could recover. Immigration will ensure that the fishing bans will have to be more frequent and longer, until eventually, fishing for snapper will be one day a year.
Why not blame the people who over-fish, instead of immigrants who may never wet a line?
@@indiathylane2158 We are talking about EATING fish, not those who get it out of the sea.
@@chriswatson1698 40-50% of Sandgropers are latecomers, from O.S. or eastern states. Chances are you are too. What's your cut-off date for labeling ppl ''latecomers"?
@@indiathylane2158 A person who was not born in WA.
@@chriswatson1698 Another parochial west Aussie! You have to take responsibility for falling fish stocks, too, as a consumer.
You'd be living in the dark ages if not for ppl coming to WA. The market for locally grown livestock and produce would be too small to be profitable. Almost everything you ate would be imported and expensive.
The mining royalties that give Sandgropers an easy ride in life would be bugger all. You'd still have petrol rosters and 2 commercial TV stations. No dining outside and no footy teams in the national league.
No big acts would perform at WA venues and Boans 'latest fashion' would still be what failed to sell over east 15 months ago.
Your superstars would still be John K Watts, Karen Pini and Rolf Harris...
Still drinking Swan Gold and cheering on spivs like Bond and Warren Anderson....
Slow down the intake, my local market is now looking like little india
Are they committing any crime? If not then shut the F up your mouth European migrants.
You don't want recent university graduated running companies. Getting a degree is only the beginning of a career. Once they go into the real workforce, they need to get most of the shit they learned at university and taught to them by idiot educators knocked out of them.
All sounds like rubbish - last week I heard from a white South African couple (one an engineer, the other a doctor) could not get visas to come to Australia - apparently their local taxi driver laughed at them saying "I already got my visa for Australia because my wife is skilled to work in hotels".
18 months labor .. 18 months ...will not forget the hardship you delibarately caused to Australians with your mass migration policy filling up the country with criminals, asylum seekers, spys and uber drivers.
We all need to stop the blame game as both parties got us here! When governments can show charts that show the increase in houses being build the number of homeless dropping, more money into our hospitals and all other areas. STOP BLAMING COVID you all did that, so that's on you all! STOP letting people inn on the short little lone long fix - you can't expect the system and tax payers to keep it all going without things becoming third world country right here! Take a leaf out of Germany, Sweden and America is now joining the movement of STOP BRINGING IMMIGRANTS INN - FIX THE COUNTRY FIRST and provide for the voting public of Australians now including those who are too young to vote WAKE UP POLITICIAN'S WAKE UP - NOT WOKE just WAKE THE HELL UP! NOT just LABOR ALL PARTIES!
Uber drivers are making a honest living by paying taxes ! Unlike you lot on the dole. Get out and get a job you mug!
Any doctorates of nuclear engineering in that core skills list.
That is where one change that could be made should be, degrees related to STEM should be made available for potential overseas students over useless ones like arts and law.
I used to be very open about immigration and equality, but I am understanding the foolishness of this thinking, would I leave the doors of my home open, no, so common sense needs to be applied at the macro level also.
I now see that only the race of people who were there at the start of a country's civilization which first developed government and infrastructure should be permitted into the government, this is to protect the interests of that country. The problem with multiculturalism in all levels of government is that it dilutes the country's management and direction and culture. A person from different heritage will potentially be inclined to push for laws and behaviours from their own country, this then will dilute the country they are now destroying. The evidence is quite clear. In science, if you have a bowl of molten gold, and you put lead in it, the gold loses value. If you have a bowl of good apples, and you place a rotten apple, others will also rot.
A method of protection for all countries and their individual cultures needs to be adopted quickly, this is to protect the world heritage of cultures.. This will require mass deportations, due to the over abundance of foreigners due to incompetent governments to date
We do not need more people, we need less. The problem is all governments have been complicit in our demise for at least 50 years, and this is throughout the West.
If a country is capped, let's say the population that we had in the 50's. How much housing shortage would there be, how much social insecurity would there be, a parent could afford to stay home and take care of the family, children could be raised in families. I am fully aware the 50's wasn't perfect, but it is possible to evolve positively, unfortunately we have evolved into a cesspit.
Another problem with governments is that they use GDP as the measure of the health of a country, this is false, and bringing in more and more people to increase GDP makes the situation worse and worse. Capping the populations, allow families to be able to live comfortably on one wage, then families will be able to grow sufficiently to replace each other, not rocket science, or maybe I'm a closet rocket scientist just coming out.
You're convinced of something. That's what I think. The USD is something like 2 to 1 ratio to the AUS Dollar. How do You think that the AUS Dollar will balance out with less trade enquiry over what term and from where it already is at and despite The United States' population; How do You explain The United States being so much farther ahead in terms of GDP and inflation than Australia given the widely Liberal Stance on Immigration and current involvement in 3 Wars?
This is idealism. There isn't a perfect system but if You can convince people that things are so woefully inadequate that it demands imperial assessments the likes and demands of which never have been seen then people might just might root for their own demise in the form of running head first in to a wall of perfection to solve all of their problems and that's what I think.
The stuff about race and culture is your right to an opinion and so I won't touch that but this policy already is affecting people other than the bottom rung from Terrorist Watchlist Countries and that's sort of my point. You think that this Immigration policy will solve all of these problem(s) with no discussion or even consideration of even a marginal impact upon other classes or people from anywhere else other than the dregs of the Universe. It just doesn't add up and the capping and / or restricting of Student and Visitor / Tourist VISAs will hit Australia the hardest.
I'm a Registered Republican and a Trump Supporter but there's a time to put away your pride and prioritize progress and repair over "Alright. They won this one and We just gotta do better next time." and that's my real opinion. Let people in and things will resolve a lot faster than if You steamroller ahead with this "review of the Immigration System" that showed none of these signs prior to their declaration of it's disrepair and again there are flaw(s) in every system that rarely are taken apart like that and re-assessed and for good reason that this situation and this new policy I think will showcase and if I'm right; You will hand the baton back over to the Liberals once again and that just is my opinion.
What a bloody mess Thanks Albo
It would be fine, if They just left it alone.
Insane, our population should be decreasing
And what is your plan, afterward?
@@nickwolfe4591 Gee, I don’t know, endless advertising campaigns, tax incentives, change divorce settlements so men don’t get fucked over, change child support so it caps out, heavily subsidised child support/ daycare, the list goes on. Or we keep taking in people and pretend that they are interchangeable Lego blocks and see how that pans out.
What rubbish. A psychologist takes 4 years to train. Not 10 to 15 years.
6 years, to be exact. 4 years (hons) + 2 years of Master degree to be fully registered as a psychologist. Then another 2 years of clinical practice under supervision (if I'm not mistaken)
And they'll all be replaced by objectively superior AIs in two years.
Not all occupations can be replaced by AI. As long as human exists, they still need communication and connection with other human. We often call it emotional and mental connection. Lacking of those are the reasons why depression and other mental illnesses occur and slowly progressing, if not professionally treated.
In that case, no, psychologists, doctors, nurses, surgeons, social workers, and any human related occupations, will still be needed, because they are essential for human health, if that makes sense.
We needs trades people.
According to Clare, lack of trades is nothing to do with migration. It’s a failure of the current system.
You can't train Foreigners to Certification standards set by Australian Education Systems like TAFE in a field like Automotive, for instance, if You don't allow for the number of Student VISAs to be granted which now has been capped and even further reduced with additional taxes added to that cost of tuition in addition to that cost of the Immigration process to attain the VISAs *plural in some case(s)* to come in and train in any type of a Trade. PM Albanese recently announced "Fee-Free TAFE" for native Australians for a period of time and I wonder how They plan to pay for that with a total and sudden decrease in International intake for Student VISAs under the new Immigration plan and that's if those people even make that cut under the new reduction(s).
May of us know why students come to Australia. To bypass deliberately ineffective rules to get jobs and buy established homes. Its all by design.
Expect immigration and rental costs to skyrocket in 2024.
You cannot buy houses as a student holder....
But their family members back home, where ever that may be, can buy property in Australia no questions asked.@@katchreinberger679
wow what a strategy ! keep talking about reducing temporary residents who have stayed and contributed here for years while conveniently keeping quiet about swarms of Refugees and Asylum seekers who are highly likely to be standing in front of Centrelink the very next day.
Australia’s immigration strategy:
“Divide and conquer” is out
Now it’s “import and dilute”
They're severely reducing the number of people coming in to Australia. Are people seeing that?
I think that it's easy to see things that way out of an emotional reaction to panic and fear mongering that's been forced upon The Australian people for Years and would be different for You if You were being told that You don't make the cut for a Visitor VISA as an American Who lived in and educated in Australia for eight Years and even was engaged to an Australian Women for four of those Years. The refugee Immigration is a Red Herring. There's nothing there like You think and that Immigration is being used to set the model that now affecting other unrelated and genuine Immigration while gaslighting Australians to cheer it on under a false and misleading appearance.
Those private colleges looks like students visa producers
Now they have woken up lol
We don’t need more horde of Uber delivery drivers 😂