If God did not exist, it would be necessary to invent him - Voltaire (A story)

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 5 ноя 2024

Комментарии • 35

  • @mayito9100
    @mayito9100 13 дней назад +5

    The greatest challenge of this world is knowing enough about a subject to think you are right, but not knowing enough about the subject to know you are wrong…

    • @Paul-v8v4j
      @Paul-v8v4j 12 дней назад

      Always listen to people who say they are searching for truth, never those who say they have found it. Life is like stairs, each step is not the destination but necessary to finally get there.

    • @simonruszczak5563
      @simonruszczak5563 11 дней назад

      I don't like being subjected.

    • @EverydayPhilosophyy
      @EverydayPhilosophyy  8 часов назад

      That’s a profound observation! It highlights the importance of humility in our understanding. The more we learn, the more we often realize how much we don’t know. This can be especially true in discussions about complex topics like religion, philosophy, and existence. It’s a reminder to stay open-minded and continually seek knowledge. What strategies do you find helpful in navigating this challenge?

    • @Paul-v8v4j
      @Paul-v8v4j 42 минуты назад

      @@EverydayPhilosophyy Always listen to people who say they are searching for truth, never those who say they have found it.

  • @pierre10000
    @pierre10000 11 дней назад +3

    Born "François-Marie Arouet" and not "François Marie Arouais"

  • @FICTIONALCHARACTER2
    @FICTIONALCHARACTER2 11 дней назад +2

    I feel like it's not detailed enough yet.

  • @grayson1946
    @grayson1946 12 дней назад +1

    This narrative was one of the most succinct descriptions of the human condition that I have run across.

    • @EverydayPhilosophyy
      @EverydayPhilosophyy  9 часов назад

      Thank you for that! I'm glad you found it resonant. Voltaire’s insights often capture the complexities of human existence so well, and it's fascinating to see how his thoughts still apply today. What aspects of the narrative stood out to you the most?

  • @larry1824
    @larry1824 10 дней назад +2

    Same with Brian Griffin

    • @EverydayPhilosophyy
      @EverydayPhilosophyy  9 часов назад

      Haha, good catch! Brian Griffin definitely has his fair share of philosophical moments. Whether it's questioning religion, society, or even himself, he often brings a satirical take on these big questions-just like Voltaire, but with a bit more sarcasm and a martini in hand! Thanks for the laugh!

  • @Paul-v8v4j
    @Paul-v8v4j 12 дней назад +3

    Our conception of God is, to say the least, humorous. Us conceiving God is like expecting a dew worm to solve quadratic equations, again, humorous. I said that diddle I?

    • @EverydayPhilosophyy
      @EverydayPhilosophyy  8 часов назад

      That’s a fun analogy! It really does highlight the absurdity of trying to grasp something so vast and beyond our understanding. It’s fascinating how humans have tried to make sense of the divine in so many different ways-sometimes with humor, sometimes with reverence. Do you think there’s value in exploring these ideas, even if they seem out of reach? I’d love to hear more of your thoughts!

    • @Paul-v8v4j
      @Paul-v8v4j 38 минут назад

      @@EverydayPhilosophyy Always listen to people who say they are searching for truth, never those who say they have found it.

  • @msanguanini
    @msanguanini 12 дней назад +1

    All about creation and a creator were skillful described in various works for people susceptible for spirituality.

    • @EverydayPhilosophyy
      @EverydayPhilosophyy  8 часов назад

      Absolutely! Many works throughout history have explored creation and the idea of a creator in ways that resonate deeply with spiritual seekers. These narratives often reflect our desire to understand our origins and place in the universe. It's interesting how different cultures and philosophies approach these themes, each offering unique insights. What particular works or ideas do you find most compelling when it comes to the concept of creation?

    • @msanguanini
      @msanguanini 8 часов назад

      @ creation of live is an universal quality of the universe, and even common matter can evolve (Sara Imari Walker, Live as no one knows it)
      Apart from various differences of religions, as far as I know them, they mirror also mindset, interpretation of it and depend on history.

  • @mikev4621
    @mikev4621 11 дней назад +1

    None of these AI portraits really look like Voltaire

    • @EverydayPhilosophyy
      @EverydayPhilosophyy  9 часов назад

      Good point! It’s tough for AI to capture the unique character of historical figures like Voltaire, especially since we're working from old portraits rather than photos. AI-generated images can miss those little nuances in expression and style that make him instantly recognizable. If only we had a time machine to snap a quick photo of him!

    • @mikev4621
      @mikev4621 2 часа назад

      @@EverydayPhilosophyy The existing portraits of him give clear and consistent representations of what he looked like - these AI ones don't capture it

  • @EvGen1603
    @EvGen1603 13 дней назад +1

    Thank you from Russia! 🇷🇺

  • @simonruszczak5563
    @simonruszczak5563 7 дней назад +1

    No, it wouldn't be necessary to invent him because nothing would exist.

    • @EverydayPhilosophyy
      @EverydayPhilosophyy  9 часов назад

      That's an interesting perspective! I think Voltaire's point here isn't about the literal existence of everything, but rather the role of belief in shaping human society. Even if there were no deity, people might feel a need to 'invent' the idea of one to anchor morality, community, or purpose. The quote speaks more to the human tendency to seek meaning or guidance, especially in times of uncertainty. Do you think societies would create similar structures or values even without the idea of a god?

  • @PeterPotnoodle
    @PeterPotnoodle 12 дней назад +2

    Deism is just as crazy as organized religion, you just invent your own god instead of believing someone else's. You can't invent your own meaning or purpose, that is something that is forced upon you by circumstance. The person who seeks meaning is inherently lost and will stay that way. Meaning only comes when you stop looking.

    • @EverydayPhilosophyy
      @EverydayPhilosophyy  9 часов назад

      That's a really thought-provoking perspective! I get what you’re saying-when we’re too focused on finding meaning, it can feel elusive, almost like chasing a mirage. And it’s true that meaning can often arise unexpectedly from the circumstances and relationships in our lives, rather than from a search for something 'higher.'
      Still, some people find that exploring these ideas-whether through philosophy, spirituality, or personal reflection-can help them make sense of life in ways that resonate deeply. Do you think meaning naturally emerges from simply living fully, or does it come from accepting that life might not have a specific purpose? I’d love to hear more about how you see it.

  • @victorploscaru
    @victorploscaru 11 дней назад +2

    Bullshit. He was an outright atheist. Morals and meaning do not belong to mystical belief.

    • @michaelmccaffrey2731
      @michaelmccaffrey2731 7 дней назад

      Have you ever studied the bible and removed any indoctrination from your brain?

    • @EverydayPhilosophyy
      @EverydayPhilosophyy  9 часов назад

      Thanks for sharing your view! Voltaire’s stance on religion was indeed complex-while he was often critical of organized religion, he was also known for advocating for a 'watchmaker' type of deism, where a creator set the universe in motion but didn’t intervene directly. He challenged many religious institutions of his time but still saw value in certain moral frameworks.
      It’s interesting to consider how much of our moral thinking is influenced by secular philosophy versus spiritual belief. Do you think morals can evolve independently of any historical influence from religion, or do they tend to be shaped by cultural beliefs over time?